Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
COMPETITION
WIN A NAIM UNITIQUTE
SYSTEM WORTH
£1,350!
HI-FI WORLD AWARDS
MARTIN
LOGAN
INSPIRE ECLIPSE SE12
turntable
ETHOS
speakers
SIVE!
EXCLU
> FLETCHER AUDIO OMEGA
POINT 5 TURNTABLE
> DARTZEEL CTH-8550
AMPLIFIER
Blu-ray player
VOL. 20 No. 11
WorldMags
WE A WorldMags
R
G R O W E THE U K
I N G A 'S FAS
UDIO T
T I T L E EST
welcome !!!
EDITOR Writing this year’s Hi-Fi World Awards 2010 feature [see p17] has
David Price
tel/fax +44 (0) 1672 811882
caused me to reflect upon the various weird and wonderful designs
e-mail: editorial@hi-fiworld.co.uk that have come out in the past twelve months...
DESIGN EDITOR
Whilst this past year hasn't seen any fancy new formats or
Faiza Chunara technologies launched, the trickle-down of network music
tel: +44 (0) 20 7625 3129 continues apace. Played off computer hard drives often via a home
e-mail: adproduction@hi-fiworld.co.uk
Wi-Fi network, it's really catching on now, as more
PRODUCTION EDITOR and more audiophiles view it as a serious music
David Noble
tel: +44 (0) 20 7625 3134 source option. Hats off of course to Linn for starting the specialist
e-mail: classifieds@hi-fiworld.co.uk hi-fi computer audio ball rolling three years ago with their DS
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVE products, but now we see Naim in on the act and a number of
Debi Silver other big names poised to take the plunge...
tel: + 44 (0) 1723 500 435
mob: + 44 (0) 7966 84 35 36 As well as its convenience, computer-sourced audio offers
e-mail: debisilver@hi-fiworld.co.uk easy access to hi-res music. This, plus the emergence of Blu-ray
ADVERTISING EXECUTIVE has caused a renewed interest in something that was, after all, first
Brad Francis introduced a decade ago! Whilst no one's mourning the end of
tel: 01923 677 256
mob: 07715 421 569
DVD-Audio with its clunky navigation, its 24/96 (or 24/192) format
email: brad.francis@sky.com is now reappearing on high quality download sites, and taking on
skype: brad.francis.media
a new life. Meanwhile its old rival SACD is having something of an
ACCOUNTS Indian summer; second-hand prices of early discs are rising, there
tel: +44 (0) 20 8841 8892 are still many great titles available new and it’s possible to buy
fax: +44 (0) 20 8841 9144
e-mail: accounts@hi-fiworld.co.uk excellent sounding modern players from Marantz.
Amidst all this, vinyl continues to thrive. I’ve seen more than a
PUBLISHER
Noel Keywood few excellent turntables come out, and there’s no let up in the LP
e-mail: publisher@hi-fiworld.co.uk reissue market. It’s easier now to be a vinyl junkie than it was in
ASSOCIATE PUBLISHER 2000, and whilst the availability of black plastic might be lower than 1990, there’s
Sharon Mehlhorn certainly not the sense of impending obsolescence that the format had back then.
e-mail: sharonmehlhorn@hi-fiworld.co.uk
Who’d have thought that in 2010, analogue would rule the (sound) waves?
FREE READERS CLASSIFIEDS Finally, after a flourish of Class D transistor amplifiers over the past few years,
tel: +44 (0) 20 7625 3134
e-mail: classifieds@hi-fiworld.co.uk
valve amplifiers are back with a vengeance. There’s more choice than ever; from
affordable Icon Audios to new Quads and more. The trend is for ever bigger tubes;
SUBSCRIPTIONS I’ve seen more new 845-based amps this year than in the past ten!
tel: + 44 (0) 1442 879097
fax: + 44 (0) 1442 872279 Overall then, 2010 was a good year for hi-fi. Our Awards show that many strong,
e-mail: hifiworld@webscribe.co.uk thoughtfully designed and engineered hi-fi separates continue to be made, and that
PHOTOGRAPHY there probably hasn’t been a better time to buy! Enjoy.
David Noble David Price, editor
tel: +44 (0) 20 7625 3134
WRITERS
Tony Bolton, Steven Green, Tim Jarman,
testing
Paul Rigby, Adam Smith, Rafael Todes. To ensure the upmost accuracy in our product reviews, analyser, using pulsed and gated sinewaves, in a large
Hi-Fi World has extremely comprehensive in-house test room to eliminate the room’s influence. Pickup arm
facilities, and our test equipment - from big names like vibration is measured with a Bruel & Kjaer accelerometer.
hi-fi world Rohde & Schwarz and Hewlett Packard - is amongst the No other UK hi-fi magazine has in-house testing, and
SUITE G4, ARGO HOUSE most advanced in the world. none has access to such advanced tests across all types
KILBURN PARK ROAD Loudspeakers are measured using a calibrated Bruel of equipment. That's why you can depend on Hi-Fi World
LONDON NW6 5LF & Kjaer microphone feeding a Clio-based computer reviews.
www.hi-fiworld.co.uk
verdicts
OUTSTANDING simply the best
EXCELLENT extremely capable
GOOD worth auditioning
MEDIOCRE unremarkable
POOR seriously flawed
£ VALUE keenly priced
ELECTRONIC MAGAZINE
Go to our website www.hi-fiworld.co.uk to buy an electronic
version of this magazine, individual issues, back issues or a
subscription.
Distributed by Seymour Distribution Ltd 86 Newman Street London, W1T 3EX Tel: +44 (0) 20 7396 8000 Printed by St.Ives, Plymouth Tel: +44 (0) 1752 345 411
Our Agents in Malaysia Millennium Hi-Fi & AV Simon Chang Showroom & office, 500-1-3 First Floor Wisma Indah (Shen Court), Jalan Tun Razak 50400 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Tel: 603 9283 8171 Fax: 603 9281 3762 e-mail: info@millennium-audio.com
All unsolicited submissions and goods are at the owner’s risk. We accept no responsibility for such submissions, nor do we undertake to return them.
No material may be reproduced from this magazine without the publisher’s written permission. © Audio Publishing Ltd
54 Dartzeel CTH-8550
integrated amplifier
60
Advance Acoustic MAP-101
integrated amplifier
86 Olde Worlde:
Sony PS-8750 turntable
106
Inspire Eclipse SE12
turntable
hi-fi world
JANUARY 2011 VOLUME 20 : NO. 11
contents
FEATURES
HI-FI WORLD AWARDS 2010 17
David Price brings you our biggest and best awards extravaganza yet;
our favourite products reviewed in the past year!
DEFINITIVE ARTICLE 63
Noel Keywood tries out the Spears and Munsil Blu-ray set up disc.
63
LOUDSPEAKERS
MARTIN LOGAN ETHOS 12
Noel Keywood enjoys some superb hybrid electrostatics.
AUDIO ENGINE P4 80
Tony Bolton auditions these dinky bookshelf loudspeakers.
7 NEWS
words from the front...
AMPLIFICATION
DARTZEEL CTH-8550 54 35 MAIL
Twelve pages of your views; no small amount of controversy here...
David Price tries a fabulous piece of Swiss precision hi-fi!
69 COMPETITION
ADVANCE ACOUSTIC MAP-101 60 Your chance to win a superb Naim UnitiQute system worth £1,350!
Noel Keywood reviews this interesting French 'Class A' integrated.
71 SUBSCRIPTIONS PROMOTION
The perfect Christmas gift....
DIGITAL 73, 117 SOUNDBITES
OLYMPUS LS5 59 Paul Rigby reviews Origin Live’s Linear Flow 2 cable and Vertex AQ’s
Tim Jarman tries a fine new portable hi res digital recorder. Jaya power conditioner, then David Price reviews Roberts’ ColourStream
radio and Tony Bolton reviews Chord’s Indigo Plus digital cable.
PIONEER BDP-LX53 64 74 WORLD CLASSICS
Noel Keywood tries a reasonably priced new Blu-ray player. Brilliant designs that have stood the test of time...
82 SUBSCRIPTIONS
OLDE WORLDE Ensure your copy every month and save money too!
PRIME
SCAMP
DUAL
PEACH
WorldMags
NEWS WorldMags
news
news@hi-fiworld.co.uk
BROADCAST NEWS
Spendor has applied “a substantial number of carefully considered
refinements” to create their new Classic Series SP100R2 loudspeaker.
Many of the improvements are based on special technology developed
by Spendor for the SA1 mini monitor and the new Spendor ST,
the company says. At the heart of the SP100R2 is a new 18cm
Spendor mid/bass unit with an ep38 polymer cone. The midrange
driver incorporates phase correction technology, in the form of a
focusing magnet motor pole extension, to control spurious phase and
frequency response variations in the crossover region. With improved
phase matching, the result “is a very even and natural sound and a
more holographic soundstage”, Spendor says. A new 22mm tweeter
combines the extended frequency response of a small diaphragm with
the low frequency characteristics of a larger diaphragm to give stable
low distortion response over a very wide frequency range, it's claimed.
The new SP100R2 also has a redesigned and thicker front baffle, and
multi-layer elastomer damping is now applied to the rear of the woofer
cone. The crossover network has been re-engineered to improve
conductivity and signal routing and to eliminate magnetic interaction
between inductors. All internal cables are heavy gauge, high purity multi strand copper conductors, individually silver-plated, with
halogen free dielectrics. The SP100R2 is said to be an easy 8ohm load. Each pair of Spendor Classic Series loudspeakers is still
calibrated and matched to stringent broadcast reference standards, the company says. Retail price is £6,295 per pair, vital statistics
are 700x370x430mm and 36kg, and the new loudspeakers come in a choice of cherry or black ash natural veneers. For more
details, call +44 (0)1323 843474 or click on www.spendoraudio.com.
TAPE END
News comes from Japan that Sony is to cease production of the Walkman cassette
portable in its home country. Whilst the company will continue to manufacture a few
niche models in specialised markets where cassettes are still in demand, the cassette
Walkman is now to all intents and purposes discontinued. The Walkman (or
Stowaway as it was initially called) was emblematic of Sony’s golden age of
engineering-led consumer electronics; instead of following trends with products
designed by focus groups, Sony set the fashion with a host of original inventions.
Sony in its great period was headed by a gifted engineer, Akio Morita, who also
sported a sharp eye for marketing. Despite his obvious ability at popularising
consumer products, his designs were always superbly built for their time; indeed
the quality was such that NASA chose a Sony cassette deck to take to the Moon,
something of which Morita was justly proud.
The very first Walkman, the TPS-L2 [pictured left] was a seminal machine; a well
preserved example playing top notch tapes will outperform any iPod of today in the
sonic stakes. Ironically though it was by perfecting another manufacturer’s format -
Philips’ Compact Cassette - that Sony really made its name. Sony made the cassette
format ubiquitous with huge numbers of high quality, affordable recorders of all
sizes. They also made the original template for portable audio; without the Walkman,
the iPod may never have
happened. The interest
for cassette Walkmen
continues; there are many
millions in circulation
worldwide (in total, 220
million were made) and it
The 1979 Sony TPS-L2 was the will be a long time before all
very first 'Walkman', but early are gone. Such is the fine sound
examples such as this weren't afforded by most models, for
branded as such! Only slightly many people – including this
later did that iconic name magazine’s editor – the iPod will
never replace their Walkman! Hi-Fi World's Tim Jarman on BBC News
arrive...
Sony Walkman RIP; gone but not 24, paying a tribute to the world's favourite
forgotten. Cassette portable...
DESK TOP
Audioengine’s £169 N22 is described
as a “premium desktop audio amplifier”,
said to be easy to connect to a Mac
or PC with no software to install or
settings to change. There’s one simple
volume control with an integrated
on/off switch, and a USB power port
that’s perfect for powering Audioengine
wireless adapters to stream your music
wirelessly from your computer or iPod.
Paired with passive speakers, it makes
for “a compact and great-sounding
personal stereo system”. You can even
connect a subwoofer and charge your
iPod through the USB power port.
22W RMS per channel is offered, from
a Class AB amp, and there’s a built in
headphone amplifier too. Vital statistics
are 7x2.75x5.5”, and the finish is satin
black. For details, call +44 (0)845 004
5330 or click on www.ecodigital.co.uk.
TRI THIS
The new ET3 Enhanced Triode Preamplifier by conrad-johnson is said to be a “baby” version of the company’s flagship line-stage
preamplifier, the GAT. With voltage gain provided by a triode vacuum-tube, the zero-feedback line-stage circuit of the ET3, along
with its DC voltage regulators, closely replicates the circuit of the GAT. Finally, and especially noteworthy, the ET3 features a relay
operated discrete stepped attenuator level-control circuit of the type found in the GAT and CT5; absent only is the balance control
function found in those more costly models. Functionally, the ET3 provides highly flexible I/O facilities with six separate line-level
inputs, while premium quality component parts are specified inside to optimise performance, including precision metal-film resistors
and polypropylene capacitors. “It would be fair to say that the only thing entry-level about the ET3 is its price”, says conrad-johnson,
which is £2,450 in the UK. For further information, click on www.audiofreaks.co.uk.
WAVE BREAKS
L’Océan from Cabasse is the company’s very
first fully 'digital' loudspeaker system, and said
to be the result of a close Cabasse/Canon
collaboration in research and development.
The €80,000 L’Océan “combines elegant
aesthetic design with a performance that
is beyond expectations and guaranteed to
please music lovers”, the company says. It
uses the TC23 3-way coaxial drive unit from
the flagship La Sphére, together with a new
38cm honeycomb dome diaphragm woofer
and 2,250 Watts of digital amplification per
speaker. L’Océan can reach sound pressure
levels of 117dB with no distortion, it is
claimed. Mounted in the base of the speaker,
the digital amplification is connected via
optical S/PDIF to the preamplifier and CRCS
controller. This unit is fitted with 96kHz
digital and analogue inputs, with all analogue
signals being digitised before signal processing.
The CRCS (Cabasse Room Compensation
System) hardware and software enables easy
automatic adaptation of the loudspeakers’
response to the acoustics of the room
through parametric modules. To ensure
natural and minimum correction, the software takes into account
psychoacoustic parameters and the specific characters of the drive HI FIDELITY
units. Each loudspeaker is fitted with a phase linear digital filter and A new headphone stage from a new company; Fidelity Audio’s
an accurate time alignment to create a true point source system, it £350 HPA-100 is hand built in the UK, and sports a low noise
is claimed. Vital statistics are 1,200x51x610mm and 80kg. power supply, toroidal transformer and HexFred diodes. “All
For details, click on www.cabasse.com. components from the Blue Alps volume pot to the superb op-
amps are audio grade”, says the
manufacturer, and the signal
path “is also very simple and
clean”, with no capacitors. Size
STOCKFISCH is a compact 104x56x245mm,
Apologies for a misspelling in our Stockfisch Records article in and weight is 1.04kg. For details,
November 2010; the company owner’s name is Günther Pauler. If call +44(0)1302 739998 or
you missed the article, then check out the company’s fine range of click on www.fidelityaudio.co.uk.
audiophile discs at www.stockfisch-records.de/.
REL T5
SUB SONICS
REL Acoustics’ new £425 T5 ‘Sub-Bass
System’ is described as offering “the
traditional REL sonic and connectivity
strengths at an affordable cost”.
For all practical purposes, the T5 replaces
the Quake, but is said to “dramatically
outperform it”, thanks to a rigidly braced
cube-shaped enclosure. Finished in high-
gloss lacquer in black or white with
contrasting aluminium feet, the new T5 packs a 125 Watt Class A/B power
amplifier and custom-designed 8” down-firing woofer, with both high and REL G1
low level input options. REL’s new £2,999 G1 Sub-Bass System is housed in a
“sumptuous furniture-grade enclosure” finished in gloss piano black lacquer,
inside which resides a 12” long-throw carbon fibre driver and 600 Watt Class
AB MOSFET power amplifier. Employing an extensively braced enclosure, REL
describe the G1 as “massive, yet elegant”. The tight-wind carbon fibre 12” drive
unit is capable of a pistonic stroke of 1 3/4 inches. Adding to the overall user
experience is the G1’s IR remote control. The unique round disc-shaped remote
features three rotary encoder dials that control all adjustments. Located on
the bottom front of the G1’s enclosure is a large, bright LED readout providing
a visual indication of all the G1’s current settings. For further information, call
+44 (0)1656 768 777 or click on www.rel.net.
WorldMags
NEWS WorldMags
LOOK SHARP!
Yamaha’s new £299 BD-S667 Blu-ray player [pictured right] has
“magnificent audio performance”, the company says! It plays
all HD formats, giving direct bitstream and multichannel Linear
PCM output via HDMI, and analogue 2-channel down-mixed
audio output, via a 192kHz/24bit audio DAC. The company also
claims high picture quality via the 1080p/24Hz-compatible HDMI video output, with 1080p playback for DVDs, photos and personal
video data. Audio formats supported include AVCHD, WMV, JPEG (HD), MP3 and WMA. The unit comes in black, titanium and silver
finishes.
The company also has a new affordable integrated amplifier. The
£329.99 A-S500 [pictured left] sports the attractive design language of the
larger A-S2000, with classic nineteen seventies styling Yamaha touches.
Inside there are dual aluminium-extruded heatsinks, gold-plated speaker
terminals and RCA socketry. The 2x85W RMS amplifier has a Pure
Direct button which uses the shortest signal route, and there’s Yamaha’s
Continuously Variable Loudness Control for listening at low volumes. Vital
statistics are 435x151x387mm. There’s also the option of Yamaha’s YDS-
12 universal iPod dock which has an independent power supply for a high
signal to noise ratio. For details, click on http://uk.yamaha.com/.
MARSHALLING SUPPORT
“Nothing has been compromised when expanding
the Marshall heritage of big stage performance
to the individual enjoyment of good music”, says
Marshall about its new headphones. Design priorities
include ruggedness and the aesthetics, “making the
headphones ooze that iconic Marshall look”, the
company says. Click on www.marshallheadphones.
com for more information...
WORLD PARTY
Nevada’s new £59.95 Sinfonie II is described
PURE AND SIMPLE as a “future proof” radio with FM, DAB and
Pure Sound’s £2,447.95 L10 Line Stage Preamplifier uses "a sophisticated full valve rectified, twin DAB+ bands, plus the interesting long range
choke smoothed power supply". It also offers remote control of the volume via a separate handset, digital DMB-A system that works in the
while source selection is via "a high quality switch located near to the input sockets". The chosen majority of countries offering Digital Radio
source is routed to a "high quality motorised, film potentiometer" and from there on to the and VHF FM radio (see www.worlddab.
audio circuit. This consists of a single ended triode stage loaded by a custom wound wideband org/). Easy to use, it sports an alarm clock
output transformer which steps down the amplified signal allowing it to be coupled to the power and automatic time settings, plus “a large,
amplifier at a manageable level and as a low single full frequency range speaker” and
impedance source. The output stage is said to comes with a multinational UK/European
be impervious to long interconnecting cables or mains adaptor for travelling people. For
lower impedance power amplifier input stages. details call +44(0) 23 92 313090 or click
The company also has a new pair of monoblock on www.nevadaradio.co.uk.
power amplifiers out, the £6,854.95 Pure Sound
M845 Mono Amplifiers. This single ended design
is based around the 845 power triode. Operating in Class A and giving 27 Watts
of output power, it will complement a wide range of medium to high efficiency
loudspeakers, the company says. The 845 triode was originally developed by RCA
in 1931 as a radio transmitting
Puresound L10
and audio amplification valve.
The anode is machined from
solid graphite to allow high power dissipation. It has an extremely linear transfer
characteristic. In recent years, a renewed interest in this kind of valve has resulted in
them being manufactured again by various factories in China. Implementing the 845
in a sympathetic circuit which takes full advantage of its capabilities is not straight-
forward. The output transformer is an in-house design that underwent extensive
trials using a variety of core materials and winding techniques before the final
configuration was chosen, it is claimed. The M845 incorporates a driver stage based
on the 6SN7 triode coupled via a custom wound, wideband, interstage transformer.
The amplifier’s input stage is directly coupled to this driver meaning that there are
no coupling capacitors used in the circuit at all. The circuit also operates without
any negative feedback. “The end result is an amplifier capable of reproducing the
full measure of instrument tone with extraordinary dynamic contrast, energy and Puresound M845
colour”, says Puresound. For more details, click on www.puresound.info.
Ideal Type
Noel Keywood finds Martin Logan's new Ethos electro-
static hybrid loudspeaker another step closer to
perfection...
B
eing aficionados of the elec- stators to a high static voltage and to
trostatic loudspeaker at Hi-Fi drive the internal Class D 200W bass
World, we have tested and power amplifier. Mains power connection
used most of the Quads ever is through a normal IEC three pin
produced, plus a good num- socket and power consumption at idle
ber of Kingsounds and many is just 1 Watt. This model has a bass
Martin Logans too – and Martin Logans level control able to apply both boost
are as good as electrostatics get. So the and cut. It doesn’t simply cut signal level
announcement of the new Martin Logan to the woofer, but affects deep bass
Ethos had us scrabbling for the phone to output below 100Hz, offering substantial
get a pair for review. amounts of boost or cut when set to
There’s not been one Martin Logan maximum.
I have not enjoyed, so I had high hopes I should quickly mention that the
for the Ethos – and they weren’t dashed. Spire, sitting above the Ethos in Martin
It’s expensive, costing £6,498, but we’re Logan's premium Reserve ESL Series, has
looking here at a model quite a way up more bass control functions, whilst the
the Martin Logan range and for a top new and less expensive Theos below it
quality loudspeaker of its great and has a passive subwoofer and can be bi-
unusual abilities this is a reasonable price. wired or bi-amped, so is more flexible
If you’re wondering what an electro- in the bass department. The Ethos is a
static loudspeaker is all about, just quality model aimed at those who don’t
think ‘transparency’. As in transparency want to fiddle. It has just enough bass
of sound and with a Martin Logan control to allow easy adjustment with
panel, physical transparency too. a self evident outcome. The bass knob,
Here’s a loudspeaker that physically which has a centre zero detent, is turned
communicates its strengths: how many one way or t’other to suit both taste
loudspeakers can you see through? and room conditions. It’s zero position
Electrostatic loudspeakers produce will suit bigger rooms and a position far
sound from a sheet of 'Clingfilm' hung from walls. In our 28ft square listening
in the open air (well, sort of). There’s room -3 to -4 was about right, on a scale
no cone flapping around and no box to of +/-10, so there is plenty of leeway.
honk – so forget colouration! The only criticism I would make of
Notionally, an electrostatic a hybrid like this is that small
loudspeaker is perfect – and believe me, bass cabinets have limitations
they sound divine. What you get with the and putting a 200 Watt
Ethos is Martin Logan’s top quality XStat amplifier inside doesn’t solve
electrostatic panel, mated to a powered them. Quite the reverse.
subwoofer, in a room-friendly package. Martin Logan have taken
Although standing almost 5ft tall each the opportunity to force
unit weighs 19kgs, or 42lbs, so once in the bass unit to produce
place they are not immovable like some subsonics it would not
top quality monitors. A little under one otherwise have produced,
foot wide, they don’t dominate the resulting in very large cone
domestic landscape either and that’s excursions and a huge
how Martin Logan play it. Look at rivals amount of rear radiated
and you’ll find they are more visually energy that has to go
intrusive, including Quads of course. The somewhere; back out
main reason is that Martin Logan choose through the cones, making
not to produce bass from their electro- for a boxy sound. You can’t
static panel (except in the large CLX), trap an elephant in a small box
but from the small box that supports it, and hope it won’t be heard. Our
in which there is a conventional bass unit measurements confirm this and if
that works below 375Hz. That makes there is one criticism of Martin Logans
the Ethos a hybrid electrostatic, unlike it is that their bass tends to be not too
Quads and the bigger Kingsounds. well matched to the lithe electrostatic
Like all electrostatics each Ethos panel.
needs mains power, to charge the panel You have to accept that there is a
MEASURED PERFORMANCE
Our frequency analysis shows the Ethos shows. measuring 9% from the forward driver at 40Hz
possesses an unusually flat frequency Another interesting feature of the XStat and 2% from the passive radiator. Rock can
response, here with bass level set ‘flat’ to 0. electrostatic panel was that it measured flat at have massive levels at 30Hz and here distortion
However, electrostatic dipoles are complex any distance, including many metres away, and was above 20% (94dB SPL at the cone), mostly
beasts and one measurement says little. We across a wide forward angle. Sound into the bass doubling. This is a poor result.
took many forward response measurements, room will be very consistent, unlike lower cost The Martin Logan XStat electrostatic panel
at different mic heights and forward angles to models, where sound balance changed consid- measured very well and is quite exceptional
look at dispersion, consistency, phase cancel- erably with listening position. in many areas. The bass unit manages quite
lation effects, bass integration and bass power. Electrostatics are known for low well but has problems, running lower than is
The sine burst response shown is represen- colouration and the decay spectrum over sensible. NK
tative, but low frequency windowing pulls bass 200mS showed the Ethos is very impressive in
level down a bit. A third-octave pink noise this respect. Only below 150Hz does the bass FREQUENCY RESPONSE
steady state measurement suggests the Ethos bin get ‘hot’, hotter than most box speakers +20
will sound a little bass heavy at 0 and flat at -4. because it is so small, a lot of internal energy
+10
Users will find their preference lies somewhere coming out through the cones.
dB
between, according to room gain and tastes. Sensitivity was very high at 91dB Sound 0
Our pink noise response at -4 was almost Pressure Level for 2.8V (one nominal Watt)
perfectly flat from 20Hz to 20kHz and looked of input. Much of this is due to the powered -10
astonishing. However, running flat down to subwoofer and its strong deep bass output. -20
20Hz suggests large bass unit driver excursions However, the panel is quite sensitive too, it
and ‘slow’ bass quality. seems. Measured overall impedance was low -30
20 100 Hz 1k 20k
What our many measurements showed at 4 Ohms, in fact surprisingly low considering
Green - driver output
was that the Ethos is smoother and more the bass unit is powered. This is due to the
consistent on and off axis than the Purity and electrostatic panel that comes in hard at 400Hz Red - port output
Source. There was some lift below 800Hz our impedance analysis shows, careering down IMPEDANCE
down to 400Hz, below which the electrostatic to 1 Ohm at 20kHz – ouch! A valve amp will 50
panel rolls down to the box bass unit. The shrug this off; solid-state amps need Zobel
Ohms
crossover is not perfect and wherever the networks to cope. Most have them.
microphone was placed the dip at 200Hz seen Electrostatics produce little distortion and 30
in our analysis existed. This suggests less than the Ethos panel was no exception, around 0.2%
perfect integration between box and panel. up to 800Hz and down to a miniscule 0.05% or
The bass bin goes very low though, flat down so above this frequency, much lower than cone 10
to 30Hz our analysis here shows, helped by drive units. The bass bin worked well down
0
the passive ABR tuned to 33Hz our red trace to 60Hz but below this distortion rises quickly, 10 Hz 1k 20k
Aquarius replaced the companies GII Mini “The whole auditioning process took about 30
Sub and is the latest product in IsoTek’s
unique range of multi-award winning power
seconds. Play a piece of music on GII Mini
conditioners that are designed and hand Sub. Play it again on Aquarius and wonder
made in England using the finest materials why you were so attached to the GII Mini
and built to the highest of standards. Sub.” “Very highly recommended”
Formed in July 2001 IsoTek’s vision has been to Hi-Fi Plus. Issue 68,
create high-quality mains power conditioners that
stretch beyond current conventions. Through careful
market analysis and extensive research, IsoTek has
been able to launch products that dramatically
improve the performance of all components used
within an audio or visual environment, a fact that has
been proved by countless international reviews and
over 25 audio awards.
info@soundfowndations.co.uk
www.soundfowndations.co.uk www.isoteksystems.com
WorldMags
WORLD AWARDS WorldMags
WORLD
TURNTABLE: PALMER 3
TONEARM: FUNK FXR II
CARTRIDGE: BENZ WOOD SL
PHONO STAGE: EMILLE ALLURE
DIGITAL: MARANTZ KI PEARL CD
TUNER: MICROMEGA FM10
INTEGRATED: MUSICAL FIDELITY AMS35i
PREAMPLIFIER: MF AUDIO CLASSIC II
POWER AMPLIFIER: ICON AUDIO MB845/II DSS
FLOORSTANDER: TANNOY DEFINITION DC10T
STANDMOUNTER: ELAC BS243
SYSTEM: NAIM UNITIQUTE
CABLE: TELLURIUM Q BLACK
ACCESSORY: JAYS V-JAYS
TURNTABLE
WINNER: PALMER 3
A
t times last year it felt like when the deck reached us, he hadn’t ball. There’s a separate offboard power
someone had only just even thought of a price for it; he’d just supply with a matching wood fascia, and
invented the microgroove done what he thought was necessary a matching wood topped stainless steel
LP, such was the torrent to get the job done... record clamp.
of new turntables. We saw A low torque AC motor spins the The result is a deck with excellent
acres of shiny perspex 10kg alloy platter via a ‘loose touch’ measured performance, which sounds
on plinths and platters, carbon fibre peripheral rubber belt, and this sits neutral, open, dynamic and powerful, yet
this and cast alloy that, with so many on one 120x350mm sub-base unit, which plays music in a mellifluous and
promising better sound through ‘hi mounted in a stainless steel housing. beguiling way. This is not an analogue
tech’ design and build. Into this fray This sits next to the main 350x350mm player that secretly wants to be a digital
appeared, middle summer, the £3,750 plinth. These are separated by bonding one; it flows like wine at a good party
Palmer 3. Fascinatingly, it sported none resins and layers of natural wood. The and is no less enjoyable. It’s a truly
of the above; it wasn’t an obviously cut- platter and spindle locate on precision impressive first product from Palmer
ting edge deck. Indeed its design was machined conical surfaces ensuring Audio, and one that was so obviously
sober and conservative.Yet designer concentricity; much of the weight of the built with every concern for sonics and
Jonathan Palmer, we soon found out, heavy platter is magnetically supported little regard for commerce. One of the
had gone meticulously through every so it presents much less vertical mass real surprises of the year, here’s hoping
variable in the vinyl LP playback chain to the bearing, whilst maintaining a fixed that it goes on to succeed.
and attempted to get it right. So you reference to it. The main bearing is a
don’t see any whizz-bang technology, combination of brass and phosphor Palmer Audio
just a number of superbly engineered bronze custom matched bushings, the +44 (0)1604 686615
sub-systems working together. Tellingly, spindle supported by a tungsten carbide www.palmeraudio.co.uk
TONEARM
WINNER: FUNK FXR II
S
ince its inception in 1983, offering a package of mods expertly powerful and energetic sound that
the Rega RB300 tonearm researched and implemented, just lets the music’s flavour flood out.
has been a massive success. as Cosworth or AMG provide such Spatially the Funk is excellent, with
First came its almost uni- a service for performance cars. The something of a ‘stereo wide’ quality
versal adoption as ‘cheap original Rega arm has to be carefully to it that makes instruments appear
pick up arm of choice’ in dismantled from the original setup in the mix with boldness and power.
the eighties and nineties, and then as using special jigs and tools, and the The bottom is animated and tuneful,
the precious raw material for modifi- arm beam is then “parted off to a delivering lovely liquid basslines, and
ers and tweakers in the past decade. precise length” and the FXR tube treble is excellent too, proffering
We’ve now got to the stage where is then jigged and bonded to the crispness and silkiness in equal
some tonearms started life as Rega cut-down arm stub. The thin walled measure. This is an open, spacious
variants, but so much has changed aluminium tube gets a carbon fibre and animated sounding tonearm
that there are no longer any parts in cross section, tensioned within, that succeeds spectacularly in the
common! The Funk FXR II doesn’t which terminates in a custom extraction of music from the groove.
quite go this far, but what it does do headshell mount. The new bearing For the amount of performance it
is surgically cut out the compromises pillar is assembled with ABEC 7 provides at the price, it's a worthy
of the original Rega design, liberating bearings, adjusted and set. Once winner of our best 2010 tonearm
the arm’s real strengths and in the assembled, the chosen cabling and gong!
process improving its sound radically. connector system is added.
With their new FXR II, For your £1,175 you get a The Funk Firm
effectively Funk Firm are acting tonearm that's unrecognisable +44(0)1273 585042
as a bespoke custom tuning shop, sonically; it gives a big hearted, www.thefunkfirm.co.uk
WorldMags
AWARDS WORLD AWARDS WorldMags
CARTRIDGE
WINNER: BENZ WOOD SL
T
here is no black magic who personally tests each unit whatever music you care to play
to moving coil cartridge before it leaves the factory, the with it, propelling the music along
design; MCs are relatively cartridge is hand built to faultless with an even-handed analysis of
simple in their concep- standards and sports some lovely the recorded acoustic; even on
tion. But that in itself design features which conspire to average condition discs it delivers
is no guarantor of uni- make a superb sound. As its name a degree of refinement and finesse
versally high standards; through suggests, the Benz comes clothed that amazes at the price. Massively
inexpert build and unimaginative in Bruyere wood, also found in the detailed, the levels of definition and
materials choice it’s perfectly pos- bowls of tobacco pipes. Encased energy in the sound, are hard to
sible to make a merely average inside is the generator, a crossed- beat at or anywhere near the price.
transducer, and indeed many do. coil design as found in other Benz The Benz Micro Wood SL seems
With that in mind, it’s more than Micro products. There's a solid unperturbed by record condition
mere coincidence that some of the Boron cantilever, with ‘side-bonded’ or musical genre, and is a master
world’s finest pick-ups come from stylus, grooved rear pole piece and of playing the tunes encased in the
countries that specialise in watches countersunk O-ring damper; the grooves in a particularly enjoyable
of superlative quality, such as Japan stylus is a Micro-ridge design with and engaging way. A fabulous piece
and Switzerland. In the case of the a 3 micron radius tip for excellent of precision engineering, this is a
Benz Wood SL, it hails from the tracking ability. worthy cartridge award winner.
latter, a land that’s established itself The Benz plays music with
for miniaturised precision engineer- riflebolt precision and times as Select Audio
ing. accurately as Swiss railways. It +44 (0)1900 813064
Designed by Albert Lukascheck, produces a magical rendition of www.selectaudio.co.uk
WorldMags
WORLD AWARDS WorldMags
PHONO STAGE
WINNER: EMILLE ALLURE
T
here’s a school of thought At just 318×330×170mm, it’s a is special even in this company. It’s
that says the worst thing refreshingly compact device as valve not quite as incisive or forensic
you can put in the way designs go, but is heavy at 15kg. The as some of the best solid-staters,
of that tiny fragile signal chassis and front panel is aluminium, sounding just a tad rounded and
issuing forth from your finely anodised, and the matching rich, but it’s not so much a listening
moving coil cartridge is metal knobs on the front panel offer tool and as a virtuoso performer
a transistor. Conversely, the small a moving magnet and moving coil in its own right when it comes to
signals phono stages deal with are switch and a variable gain control playing music. A massive soundstage,
very much in the tube comfort so the Allure can drive a power inside which you can almost pluck
zone. Serious valve phono stages can amplifier directly. Inside there’s a instruments out of the mix like fruit
sound quite stunning then, giving a Lundahl step-up transformer for off a tree, is what first greets you.
‘greater than the sum of the parts’ moving coils, gold-plated glass Yet it’s the Allure’s wonderfully fluid
listening experience; they can be epoxy printed circuit boards with midband, making music flow in an
sublime in all-tube systems yet still 2oz copper thickness. Passive effortless and organic way, that has
have a strangely restorative quality componentry is of a very high you riveted to your listening seat. By
in solid-state ones. And the Emille standard, with precision resistors, comparison, almost all other phono
Allure is precisely this; few phono Jantzen capacitors, silver plated stages sound forced and mechanical.
stages, tube or transistor, have made copper wiring and gold plated tube As such it’s a worthy winner of this
such an impression on us. Where we sockets for the four 6DJ8 or 6922 years phono stage Award.
might have originally baulked at its tubes. The transformers are designed
not inconsiderable price of £2,495, and hand wound in house. Angelsound Audio
setting ears upon it had us rethink- We’ve heard some fine phono +44 (0) 1923 352479
ing our stance. stages in our time, but the Emille www.angelsoundaudio.co.uk
AMPLIFICATION
Naim HICap 2. Mint, boxed with snaic (5-pin).
Manufactured in April 2009.(£1100) £645
Naim Supernait. Mint, boxed, one owner. Approx
12 mths old. (£2595) £1595
ATC SCA2 Pre-amp. One owner, supplied by us)
only 8mths old. Boxed, mint. (£4860) £3495
NuForce P-8 Pre-amp. Black with remote.
Excellent condition. (£1200) only £595. Music is our Passion
Ayre AX-7E integrated amp. Boxed, mint.
Just over a year old, one owner. (£2795) £1395
Icon Audio Stereo 40 mkII. One owner, KT88
model. Excellent, boxed, manual etc. (£1500) £595 t 01333 425 999
Bryston B4SST power amp. Excellent condition,
in silver, one owner. (£3450) only £1850
Chord CPA 2200 Pre-amp. Boxed in silver,
QUALITY
excellent condition. (£2917) £1250
Quad II Eighty Valve mono blocks. One owner,
unmarked, stunning performance, great reviews.
Original packing. 5yr warranty. (£6000) £3595
McIntosh MA6500 Integrated amp. Boxed,
excellent condition & reviews. (£4795) £2495.
Marantz PM-Ki Pearl integrated amp. Boxed,
mint. Only months old, one owner. (£2500) £1695
PRE-OWNED.
Luxman L-550A. Excellent condition, boxed, one
owner. Editors Choice HiFi News. (£3495) £2495
Boulder 865 integrated. Very rare. Regarded as
simply best integrated amp you can currently buy.
Mint, one owner original boxing. (£10000) £POA
Chord CPM-3300 integrated amp. One
owner, excellent condition, silver with gold badge.
Aluminium remote. 5yr warranty. (£6795) £2695 Benchmark DAC1 USB. One owner, unmarked, Linn LP12 Arm Board. Original and as new. £35.
Parasound 275 Power Amp. Only few months huge saving on new price, only £795. Linn Lingo PSU. MK1 For the Linn Sondek LP-12
old, one owner, mint, boxed. Bargain at £199. Cyrus DAB 8 Tuner. Quartz, mint, boxed, wonderful condition, complete with LP12 switch,
Chord SPM-1200B Power Amp. 250 wpc. Black only 4mths old. Bargain at only £395. circuit board & power lead. Recent service. £395.
with wooden side accents. Excellent condition, Accustic Arts Drive 1 mk2. Current spec, boxed, Eastern Electric Minimax Phono Stage.
recent service from Chord. Original packing. Rarely mint, one owner, great at this price. (£4500) £1949. Boxed, unmarked, one owner, only months old.
available used . (£3950) Great at only £1395. Simply sensational (£1495) £980.
Bel Canto Pre 3 Pre Amp. Black with aluminium
LOUDSPEAKERS Quad QC 24P Phono stage. Mint, one owner,
ATC SCM 50 ASL Active Classic. Black ash, one
face, original packing & manuals, immaculate. as new. Great reviews. (£1200) £795
owner, supplied by us, 8mhs old, boxed, mint with
(£1850) only £995.
stands. Balance of 6yr warranty. (£9470) £6495 MAINS CONDITIONING
Eastern Electric M520 Integrated Amp. One Kemp Electronics Power Source. Barely used,
owner, 8mths, perfect condition, original packing, Quad ESL 2805. Premium Classique, stunning, one
owner, few months old. (£6000) £POA as new, one of the best at any price. (£1395)
manual & remote. Just won Editors Choice in Hi-Fi bargain at £620.
News. (£1995) only £1195. ATC SCM 50 ASL Classic Actives. Walnut,
ex-demo, mint condition. (£9870) £POA Supra LoRad MD06-BS/SP. 6-way mains
ECA Technologies Vista Pre and Lectern filtering block. (£149) only £75.
Power Amps. Black with gold logos, immaculate. Celestion Kingston Speakers. Matching stands, one
Very musical combination. (£1700) only £650. owner, v rare, 32kg each with stands. (£3250) £995 Nordost Vishnu 1m mains cable.
Excellent condition. (£404) £249.
Quad 909 Power amp. One owner, silver, boxed, Klipsch P-39f Palladium series. Ex-demo, one of
mint, only few months old. (£1000) only £649. best speakers you’re likely to hear. Read Stereophile PurePower 700. Black, ex-demo. (£1595) £POA
Quad II Eighty Valve mono blocks. One owner, review to understand why! (£14750) £POA Vertex AQ Taga. 6-way distribution mains filter.
unmarked, stunning performance, great reviews. Sonus Faber Minima Amators. One owner, teak, Great reviews, one owner, unmarked. (£868) £595
Original packing, 5yr warranty. (£6000) £3595 boxed, excellent condition, with matching stands. CABLES
Chapter Audio Preface & Couplet pre/power 5yr warranty. (£2000) £895. Vertex Silver Solfon 1m. One owner, excellent
combo. Boxed, original flight cases, excellent Focal Electra 1037 Be Speakers. One owner, mint, condition. (£1092) £499
condition, less than half price, amazing value for boxed, manuals. (£7495) Be very quick at only £3595. Shunyata Research ‘Altair’ Cryo Interconnect
money. (£9000) £4295 (RCA-RCA). 1m. (£650) only £255
ADAM Audio A.R.T. Pencil Speakers. Cherry/
Art Audio VPI Pre Amp (with MM Phono Stage). dark silver combo, astonishing articulation, excellent Ecosse MS5.5 Bi-Wire Speaker Cable. With
Highly desirable chrome, spectacular condition condition, original packing. (£3600) only £1795. Monocrystal Spades, 2.9m. (£946) only £295.
original packing. (£2600) only £1295.
Audio Physic Virgo V. One owner, originally supplied Siltech Digital Signature Golden Ridge
Eastern Electric MiniMax Pre/power combo. by us, excellent condition, original packing, maple AES/EBU 1m XLR. (£995) £249.
One owner, supplied new by us, unmarked, as finish. (£5500) £3495
new, only 2mths old with 5yr warranty. Stunning Vertex Hi-Resolution Solfonn (rca-rca)
Amphion Argon 3L Speakers. Scandinavian Birch, Interconnect. 1m, ex-demo, sensational
performance, amazing reviews. (£2195) £1295.
original packing & accessories, only 8mths old. HiFi (£2047) only £1120.
DIGITAL Choice Best Buy Winner. (£2600) only £1495
Vertex Silver Solfonn (rca-rca) Interconnect.
MSB Platinum CDIII reference transport. Audio Physic Scorpio II. Latest model, cherry, 1m, ex-demo. (£1092) only £660.
Boxed, unmarked, 5yr warranty. (£4995) £1795 ex-demo, unmarked condition. (£3773) £2750
Vertex AQ Mini Moncayo Speaker Links.
Ayre CX-7e CD Player. One owner, mint, boxed, Quad ESL 2905 Speakers. One owner, mint, boxed, 4 links with 80x65x30mm accoustic absorption
manual. (£3000) £1595. very low hours, amazing reviews, 5yr warranty. module . Simply sensational. (£540) £395
MBL 1621 CD Transport & 1611F D/A (£7000) only £4990
Chord Signature speaker cable. One owner,
Converter (factory upgrade to F in 2008), original Audio Physic Tempo VI Speakers. Maple, one owner, boxed, as new, 2.5m, great reviews. (£775) £445
flight cases, packing, manuals and SFGB remote. 6mths old, unmarked, original packing and literature.
Arguably best combination available in the world (£2612) bargain at £1895. ACCESSORIES
today. Piano black & gold, some brassing & minor Grado PS1000 Headphones. As new, only few
marks only. (£35560) be quick at £12995. Audio Physic Scorpio. Boxed, cherry, one owner, weeks old. Huge saving. (£1800) £1095.
some very minor marks. (£3800) £1695
Naim CDX2 CD player. Excellent condition, MISCELLANEOUS
boxed, manual, remote. Huge saving. £1495. ANALOGUE Mission m7ds Surround Speakers. Black,
DCS Verdi Transport. (new laser and recent Whest TWO phono stage. One owner, months old, original packing & manual, perfect condition,
service within the last 4 months) £1895. mint, graphite. Great reviews. (£750) Only £495. fabulous bi-pole rear speakers with incredible
Accustic Arts DAC 1 mkIV. 66 BIT 1536kHz D, LFD MCT Phonostage. Mint, one owner, sensational dispersion. Only £60.
stunning spec, mint condition, boxed, one owner. performance, only 18mths old, very low hours.
Sensational value. (£4500) £1795. (£3400) So £2500 looks very tasty indeed!
WorldMags
WORLD AWARDS WorldMags
DIGITAL
WINNER: MARANTZ SA-KI PEARL CD
T
here are two ways of doing term robustness of their approach. only sounds sublime, with such
CD players. The tradi- Marantz on the other hand, have an easy, lyrical gait , but it’s also
tional Japanese way was had enduring success with expertly beautifully built and finished. Oh, and
to take a standard silver voiced machines, one after the other, it even plays SACD exceptionally
disc player, festoon it with year in, year out. The £2,500 SA-KI well; as any Super Audio Compact
bullet-pointed technologi- Pearl SACD player embodies this Disc fan knows, the format is capable
cal features (x times oversampling, y credo; it’s a well engineered machine of stratospheric sonic results, but
times upsampling, silver wired this, with no stone left unturned in the not all SACD players are capable of
special digital filtered that) and then pursuit of serious sound. It succeeds unlocking them. The KI Pearl most
plaster them all over the fascia in the not because of any specific techno definitely is – and veritably soars
hope it would walk off the shelves of trickery, but because it’s a beautifully with this special silver disc, producing
your local Laskys. The other way was rounded design, voiced by some of a massively musical and expansive
of course to make a well engineered the best ears in the business. This big sound, getting close to the best of
machine and apply careful fettling (440x419x127mm, 14.5kg) machine digital at any price. The KI Pearl
to critical parts of the digital and sports a nicely aligned disc loader was created to commemorate Ken
analogue stages, then listen to the with a damped Xyron disc tray, the Ishiwata’s thirtieth year at Marantz;
results, and then come back and do it large aluminium feet confer a sense if you were ever in any doubt about
again until everything sounds just as of solidity, as does the heavy copper the contribution he’s made to the
it should. plated chassis inside. An SACDM-10 company's house sound, then hear
The former approach proved mech drives a Cirrus Logic CS 4398 this.
successful in the short term, but DAC chip, with a variable position
many of those Japanese multinationals digital filter and Marantz’s HDAM-SA Marantz UK
have now left the specialist hi-fi and SA2 op-amp modules. +44 (0)1753 680868
market altogether, such was the long In action, the SA-KI Pearl not www.marantz.com
TUNER
WINNER: MICROMEGA FM10
2
010 was an important the breed has soldiered on, and metal box, that’s easy to use and
year for radio here in the somewhat ironically it now seems fuss-free.
UK; it began with FM fans that DAB is in more peril; it’s very Sonically it’s pure high end
feeling increasingly con- hard to make the case for a format European; a tidal wave of warm
cerned for the future of that offers few advantages over bass rolls out of the loudspeakers,
their beloved broadcast internet radio yet sounds inferior, bringing a toe tapping quality
standard. The previous government’s offers some 17,000 fewer stations to music that so many tuners
‘Digital Britain’ report outlined a and is non-upgradeable. It was nice completely fail to capture, while
proposed FM switch off, and even then to see Micromega launching treble is as creamy as the finest
named 2015 as the target date, even a new analogue tuner this year, French pâtisserie. Across the midband,
if few industry insiders ever thought and better still to find out what the FM10 is smooth and couth, and
it was possible. But the new govern- a star it was in the sonic stakes. simply lets you get on with hearing
ment that replaced it in May, argu- Aside from a few purists who’ll the music or speech being broadcast.
ably motivated by the massive cost lavish a couple of thousand on a It’s a fascinating and quirky little
of switching the whole country over Magnum Dynalab, the £715 FM10 product, but the Micromega FM10
to DAB, kicked things into the long is just about the maximum that justifies itself by offering excellent
grass, effectively signalling that there most people would ever spend on sound per pound, doubtless coming
was now no intention to switch off a tuner. But it’s superbly engineered from its designers’ determination to
analogue radio whatsoever. FM lives at the price; whereas most manufac- do things differently. As such it’s a
on to fight another day! turers fit an OEM receiver module, worthy Hi-Fi World Award winner.
As you might imagine, all this Micromega have their own bespoke
uncertainty has hardly worked intermediate frequency amplifier, Absolute Sounds
wonders for sales of analogue detector and stereo decoder +44 (0)20 8971 3909
tuners. But it’s fair to say that circuitry. This goes in a cleanly styled www.absolutesounds.com
INTEGRATED
WINNER: MUSICAL FIDELITY AMS35i
C
ontrary to the procla- get any better at this price, and most transistor power amplifiers;
mations of legions of are mortified to find that it can, it’s enough to make some people’s
hi-fi designers around providing you spend a bit more houses’ lights dim on switch on.
the world, it’s not easy still. Yet it’s still head and shoulders Indeed, in this respect it’s similar to
to make high end hi-fi. above most people’s conception of a big valve amp. Despite being full
They argue of course their ‘dream’ integrated amplifier, Class A, it doesn’t sound like one,
that cost-no-object designs let you such is its useable power, expansive however. Yet nor does it sound like
put in all the best components soundstaging, wonderful ‘hear a conventional Class AB solid-stater.
and do circuits as they should be through’ clarity and fine filigree The Musical Fidelity AMS35i treads
done, with ifs or buts. Yet when all detail. It’s the great, innate across a skilful path between to the two,
is said and done, if your high end the board strength of the AMS35i offering a good deal of the speed
hi-fi product is anything less than that makes it this year’s World and liquidity of tubes with the
perfect, it simply has no excuse for Award winner for integrateds. In insight and grip of a top transistor
its continued existence, end of. The solid-state terms, there are better design. It’s an infectious and at
failings of a £600 amplifier can be amps, but you have to spend a lot times totally arresting combination,
logically explained and excused, but more to hear them... and marks this machine out as
add a zero to that and the thing’s It’s not as compact as some; at having a most endearing character
got to pretty close to hi-fi heaven 483x148x475mm and 28.3kg you’ll all of its own. Simply put, once
to be worth so much as a men- need a larger hi-fi rack than normal, you’ve heard one of these, it’s hard
tion... and you’ll also need a commitment to justify spending more.
Not an easy life then, for to the idea of running hi-fi as a
Musical Fidelity’s AMS35i. At £6,000 household expense. The power Musical Fidelity
it’s at a curious price point; most consumption of the full Class A +44(0)20 8900 2866
will simply expect that hi-fi cannot AMS35i is obviously more than www.musicalfidelity.co.uk
PREAMPLIFIER
WINNER: MF AUDIO CLASSIC II
T
he lot of a preamplifier is our ears it is certainly the best. By The difference is clear to hear;
not a happy one; essen- using a transformer it attempts to the new MF Audio Classic II preamp
tially they’re damned if give the best of both worlds - gain has an even clearer, tighter, tauter
they do, and damned if without pain. There are no power sound which simply bolsters an
they don’t. If ever there supplies or powered amplifying already wide open and enveloping
was a hi-fi separate that devices inside, so it dispenses with character. Where the previous
people would love to dispense with, the audio equivalent of layers of one was ever so slightly opaque
eliminate entirely from the system bureaucracy and reams of red tape, across the mid and loose across
chain, it is this. Curiously though, yet the transformer does provide the bottom, the Mk II gains clarity
when people do move to ‘passive’ 6dB of gain if you want it. Unlike and grip. It’s a small difference, but
preamps - those with no active a simple resistive volume control, obvious all the same. Given that the
powered electronics - the results there are no impedance matching original was the equal or better of
can be genuinely disappointing. You issues. The major downside of this many £6,000 plus designs, we feel
look at all the circuitry in your approach is that everything depends the superior newer variant still
conventional active preamp and absolutely on the quality of the represents fine value at £3,642.50.
think surely this isn’t needed, and transformer, and it’s the excellence If you want a ‘fit and forget’
can only sully the sound. Yet move of the MF Audio’s inbuilt unit that preamplifier, with one of the best
to a conventional passive - which is has made it so successful. Now, the sounds around, this is a true high
effectively a volume potentiometer company has fitted a new version end audiophile bargain and a worthy
in a box - and things can sound of the original TX102 unit with a Hi-Fi World Award recipient.
leaden and lifeless. 25% larger core, claimed to possess
The MF Audio Passive lower saturation, improved level MF Audio
Preamplifier is not the first handling and better low frequency +44 (0)1825 890970
transformer based design, but to response and extension. www.mfaudio.co.uk
POWER AMPLIFIER
WINNER: ICON AUDIO MB845/II DSS
T
hanks to the vagaries of it came as a shock when the original this amplifier mines detail, exhibits
fashion, an entire genera- MB845 monoblocks came out. Here a richness of tonal colour and
tion of audiophiles grew up were stunning sounding, dramatically emphasises dynamic inflections is
believing that valve ampli- powerful and enthralling crowd amazing, giving a tremendous sense of
fiers were somehow pleasers, yet wonderfully creamy like fleshed out power and vast physical
hopelessly weak kneed, only an 845 triode based design can presence. Yet there’s a lovely silky
ridiculously rose-tinted and com- be. Any amp based on a monstrous treble, with a lustrously rich midband
pletely lacking in dynamics. This was 1931 directly heated power valve and strong resolution of instrumental
down to the gradual decay of clas- is a pretty seminal thing; unlike timbre, causing sounds to leap out of
sic valve amplifiers, which got ever transistors designed for general a darkness free of hash and muddle.
soggier sounding with age, allied to industrial use, possessing inadequacies And all music is so affected. This is
an ‘emperor’s new clothes’ attitude for audio amplification covered over a characteristic of the amplifier that
to transistor amplifiers in the main- with an electronic sticking plaster sets it apart. This is one of the most
stream hi-fi press. It wasn’t until the called feedback, the big 845s possess dramatic amplifiers you could wish
nineteen nineties that people started no intrinsic weaknesses as far as to hear, and its new higher priced
hearing excellent modern tube audio amplification is concerned. of £5,995 is more than justified by
designs, and it took longer still for Their drawbacks are the obvious sound which raises question marks
these to trickle down to the afford- ones of size, weight and heat; the about other super amps at two or
able end of the market. daily lived experience of being an three times the price. As such, it’s a
One company that played a MB845/II owner. deserved award winner.
huge part in all this, in the UK at Yet the upside is one of the most
least, is Icon Audio. They’ve made an weighty sounds around, with vivid Icon Audio
excellent range of ‘bread and butter’ dynamic swings extraordinary by +44(0)116 244 0593
valve amps of all shapes and sizes, so everyday audio standards. The way www.iconaudio.co.uk
FLOORSTANDING SPEAKER
WINNER: TANNOY DEFINITION DC10T
T
annoy is what Tannoy does. hide the fact. It carries a classic Tannoy Tannoys sound most unusual, and
One supposes that if you’ve Dual concentric drive unit, but in unlike anything else on the market,
been going since 1932 and domesticated 10in form, allowing a except other big Tannoys of course!
your name has become 339mm wide (13in) front baffle to be They’re wonderfully wide and open
both a noun and a verb in used, making for an elegantly shaped and deep and dimensional, instruments
common parlance in the Cherry veneered and gloss coated hovering in space like a hologram
English language, you’ve a right to go beauty that stands 1,125mm high and inside a soundstage which you can
your own way. Whilst the company weighs 34.5kgs. A monstrous 94dB practically walk around. They’re super
makes some fine, and distinct, lower sensitivity means around 5W into the fast too, bouncing along with zest
priced speakers, it’s their high end DC10s will set off neighbouring car and proffering an amazingly engaging
dual concentric ranges that define alarms or blow toddlers off their feet; rendition of the music that makes
the marque. Trouble is, they’ve almost these speakers go seriously loud and you want to keep listening late into
become a victim of their own success; are thus perfect partners for good the night. Although not the absolute
the styling remained defiantly antiquar- tube amps, such as 20W Single-Ended last word in refinement, these
ian throughout the thrusting eighties designs from the likes of Audionote loudspeakers do so much so well
and the cool, lifestyley nineties, and for example. This is down to the Dual that it was without hesitation that
the result was that if you wanted to Concentric driver, with a treble unit this magazine has awarded them the
experience the company's distinctive, firing out through the centre of a 10in accolade of our favourite floorstanding
nee unique, sound, you had to go with bass/midrange unit, loaded by hefty loudspeaker of the past year.
the styling that wasn’t to everyone’s rear ports.
tastes. Not so with the new Definition It’s hard to mask the innate Tannoy UK
DC10T... sound of a speaker; it’s a direct result +44 (0)1236 702503
Here’s a big Tannoy that tries to of their design. Which is why the www.tannoy.com
F
or those reviewers fluke either; Elac’s use of their JET and a decent front end, the Elacs
ensconced in their audio- ribbon tweeter is the hi-fi equivalent really take your breath away. They’re
phile ivory towers, a sub- of a turbo charger; it magically wipes far more sophisticated than is
£1,000 speaker can be a away so many of the pitfalls of small expected at the price, with none of
shocking thing. If you listen speakers by using a superb treble the squawking, screeching and boofing
to Martin Logan electro- transducer that wouldn’t disgrace a of many sub-£1,000 standmounters.
statics at ten times the price as a speaker at several times the price. It’s The BS243’s inherently transparent
matter of routine, putting up with the a great device and all it has to do is nature, allied to realistic three
vagaries of a budget box boofing and integrate well with a decent mid/bass dimensional imaging, rhythmic alacrity
booming is a pretty unsavoury expe- driver and a solid (285x170x232mm) and extended, delicate and sparkling
rience! With this in mind, it’s rare to cabinet for big audio dynamite. treble make them an essential
find a reasonably priced loudspeaker Fortunately, unlike certain other audition for those looking for grown-
that isn’t holed below the waterline, ribbon/moving coil drive unit pairings, up transducers that take up a small
so to speak, by variously poor cabi- Elac have got it right; the JET tweeter space. They proved an unexpectedly
netry, weak drive units or simply its integrates smoothly with the Elac pleasant surprise, and as such are
box-loudspeaker-with-moving coil- Crystal AS-XR aluminium sandwich worthy winners of an already hotly
drivers orientation... mid/bass unit and the cabinet doesn’t contested category.
It was with great relief then, that draw attention to itself either.
we auditioned the £1,000 Elac BS243, Hooked up to a beefy transistor Atacama Audio
only to find an exceptionally couth amplifier (if it’s valves you’re running +44 (0)1455 283251
sounding small standmounter. It’s no they’ve got to be particularly punchy) www.elac-audio.co.uk
SYSTEM
WINNER: NAIM UNITIQUTE
S
ome might see it as ironic ideal small system, then what is? ability, which lets you playout music
that one of the world’s Think of it as a serious separates from your Mac or PC via Wi-Fi or
foremost serious hi-fi system that’s been bundled into ethernet.
separates manufacturers one box, then shrunk in the wash. Considering its diminutive
has recently got very good Inside its dinky (87x207x314mm) dimensions, the UnitiQute has
at making dinky all in one case is a preamp with two analogue a surprisingly big sound. Bass is
systems. First came the superb Uniti inputs, five 24/192-capable digital breathtaking considering its modest
last year, and now it’s time for the inputs, FM and DAB tuners and the status in life, making for a gripping,
‘short wheelbase’ £1,350 UnitiQute ability to play music from an iPod bouncy rendition of any music
version to don its dinner jacket and or MP3 player via its front panel- you care to play. The built-in DAC
take a bow. By name and by nature, mounted USB socket (with digital sounds detailed, crisp and there’s a
the 'Qute does pretty much every- iPod playout); the USB socket also decently finessed treble; you’ll always
thing you could wish for in a mini plays (up to) 24/96 music files from hear plenty of depth and width to
system (for that’s what it is) and it a USB memory stick. The 30W the soundstage, letting you immerse
does it brilliantly, with sound quality power amplifier runs off a decent yourself in the music. Bristling with
that’s on another level from your 200VA toroidal transformer with enthusiasm, the Naim gets you
average compact all-in-one. But the three separate windings, and there closer to the original recording than
real beauty of it is the accessibil- are separate power supplies for any other small system, and does
ity; the wee Naim brings together digital, analogue, and power amplifier. so with such convenience too. A
a multiplicity of sources, digital All this goes into a beautifully neat worthy World Award winner.
and analogue, streamed, off air and metal case, fronted by a handsome
external, and serves them up to green OLED fine pitch dot-matrix Naim Audio Ltd.
you at the touch of a button with display. The pièce de résistance is the +44 (0) 1722 426600
the minimum of fuss. If that’s not an 'Qute’s excellent network streaming www.naimaudio.com
CABLE
WINNER: TELLURIUM Q BLACK £276/3m
C
olin Wonfor, famous bass is capacious and gener-
for his highly ously reproduced, moving up
acclaimed Incatech to a wide and airy midband.
Claymore amplifier Inside this, instrumental
of the nineteen timbre is extremely well
eighties, and lat- conveyed, Treble is smooth
terly a consultant for NASA, and as polished as you could
is Tellurium Q’s technical hope at the price. Overall, the
director, and responsible for cable is a deep, dark, velvety
the design of this new cable. performer that’s neverthe-
Patent pending, this “under- less highly musical, and it
stated, thin and unusually represents excellent value
flexible” cable proved one of as mid-price cables go. It’s a
the surprises of the year. The deserved recipient of the Hi-
company are understandably Fi World Awards 2010 cable
coy about its technical make- category.
up, but auditioning shows
how special it is. Smooth and Tellurium Q
beguiling to listen to, remark- +44 (0)1458 251 997
ably devoid of edge or grain, www.telluriumQ.com
ACCESSORY
WINNER: JAYS V-JAYS £49
J
ays is a Swedish headphone
maker that, commendably, hasn’t
gone down the route of making
garish products with the accent
on so-called ‘style’ rather than
sound. The £49 V-Jays are per-
fect exemplars of their approach; small,
soberly (but attractively) shaped, well
made yet light (59g), they feel like a
miniature high end product that could
have come from any one of the past
few decades. The design is semi-foldable
(with two folding joints), making them
ideal for portables, and the quality foam
earpads make them very comfortable
to wear with a nice firm but delicate fit.
The Jays’ 40mm Mylar drivers deliver an
extremely taut sound, yet with a natural
musicality along with an unexpectedly
refined and sophisticated tonality. Vocals
and instruments were expansive yet deli-
cately rendered, and treble was smooth
and crisp with a surprising amount of
atmosphere right up top. A worthy Hi-Fi
World Award winner.
Jays
+44 (0) 1244 458885
www.jaysearphones.co.uk
Zinc gives
great quotes...
am w o od
“Boreh w naim..”
has a ne
“LiInNnN
n h
found a ho as
on Manor w me
“Zinc is ay ”
the home of top Hi Fi
and that’s a fact !”!” R
New state of the art 4000 sq ft showroom with free on site parking M25 J23
STUDIO WAY
West East
A1m
Meteor House, Manor Way, Borehamwood, Hertfordshire, WD6 1QQ Zinc
South
info@zinc-ht.com
Technologies
Technologies
echnologies
www.zinc-ht.com
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
mail
LETTER OF THE MONTH PRIZE
CARTRIDGE CONFUSION!
You kindly printed my letter in the
January 2010 concerning a suitable
cartridge for my system which now
comprises a Townshend Rock Reference
turntable with Excalibur 2 tonearm
(Van den Hul silver wired), Reson
Mica cartridge, Gryphon Callisto 2100
amplifier (replacing the Sugden A21a)
and Castle Conway speakers.
My Trichord Diablo phono stage
has been sold and I intend to take
your advice and purchase an Icon
Audio PS1.2 phono stage. The Reson
Mica and the silver wired tonearm
are the problem and Noel suggested
a Shure M97XE (possibly too warm
and I wanted to try a moving coil) and
David an Ortofon Cadenza Bronze (too
expensive) or an AT OC9 MLII.
I was thinking along the lines of
the AT OC9 MLII, but in the September
2010 issue, in response to another letter,
it was suggested that the AT OC9 MLIII
(the replacement for the II) is fairly
bright and not a good match for silver A fine floorstander at a low price, the Q Acoustics 2050
wired tone arms. (see August 2010 issue).
I’m confused! I just want a moving
coil that is detailed, dynamic but not (five including the kitchen one) systems. is detailed, very clear, refined, lots of
overly bright or fatiguing. Any other I’ve got so many systems, partly as I like positives, but it is bright and could do
suggestions for a moving coil up to experimenting – though that inclination with more body.
£500? Would it be worthwhile getting has quietened down considerably with When I use my Sugden A21a
the Excalibur 2 rewired by Audio current economics – and because, as I amplifier, this goes very well with the
Origami with say Cardas OFC copper developed a fondness for some pieces Xeros, but as I leave the amp on
litz? of equipment, it became difficult to part constantly, I cannot in all conscience
Trevor Scull with them. leave the Sugden burning Class A
Surrey I know its anathema to you, but I electricity when I may be watching a
buy second hand without audition as a video as much as listening to music.
Yes, I have another suggestion that way of experiencing hi-fi equipment that Cables are reasonable enough, including
I am sure is right for you: get an would be too costly new. In discovering DNM reson biwire.
Ortofon Rondo Bronze moving coil hi-fi, I’ve been through a number of Fiddler that I am, I put my cheap
cartridge as reviewed in our May speakers in the budget to mid price Mission m71i 'speakers on, just to see
2010 issue. It is smooth and peak range, including Acoustic Energy Evo1s how they sounded. They serve as rear
free, performs well all round and is and 3s, Wharfedale Diamond 8.1 / speakers in a home cinema setup
suitably priced too. Sorry about the 8.3, Quad 11l and 12l, Monitor Audio normally. I was aware of less detail,
confusion. I hope this resolves the R852md, Triangle Titus Ex, Linn Keilidh, less precision, and a wallowy bass, at
issue for you. NK Monitor Audio Radius 1s, Mission m71i, times, but what I heard was musical,
Leema Xeros, Monitor Audio PMC 703s. more organic, warm, smooth and highly
I would say that, if you're going to Those I regularly use are the Leema enjoyable. Less hi-fi, in certain respects,
use a smooth sounding Icon Audio Xeros, the Monitor Audio PMC 703s but more musical. I listened to the setup
PS1.2 tube phono stage, you're not in my lounge, Monitor Audio Radius 1 for a week and really enjoyed it.
going to run into brightness problems in kitchen and Castle Isos in my study. Today, I’ve reconnected the Xeros
with an OC9. It's not the brightest of I like all of them, for different reasons, and once again, I can listen into
Audio Technica's range by far, and has but I haven’t hit the jackpot with any of the recording, hear a more precise
fine tracking. My feeling is that the them and I’m a bit lost. soundstage, but the sound has gone
Rondo Bronze would be softer and My computer set up is the one from emotionally engaging to intellec-
Reference 600
5 STAR AWARD
SEPT 09
Reference 600
5 GLOBES AWARD
SEPT 09
iPod dock compatible DAB, Internet and FM USB port - compatible Supports Reference 600:
with all iPods. radio - listen to hundreds with MP3 players and CD, CD-R/RW, 80+80W
*additional extra of new radio stations flash memory MP3,WMA disc CRH-500: 40W+40W
Reference 600 Reference 500/600 Reference 500 Reference 600 Reference 500/600
www.teac.co.uk
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
reputation and reliability of your journal,
that you take these comments on board.
Do publish and reply to this letter if you
wish, but I suspect that you won’t.
yours sincerely
Ray Howgego
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
wave at the repetition rate and things that we
an associated extended harmonic now know we
structure. The shape of the square don’t know.
wave is altered by amplitude and But there are
phase changes of its harmonics. A also unknown
square wave will induce and show unknowns; there
ringing of a resonant system but this are things we
can usually be seen in the amplitude do not know we
response. I well recall the square don’t know".
wave tests you talk about and have The assertion
used them myself, but they reveal that some
no new information over and above engineers make
what we already publish. is that we can
Times have moved on and our know everything
instrumentation and understanding through present
of underlying phenomena have also knowledge; their
changed. I understand where you are contention is
coming from but there are plenty that science is
of highly skilled and experienced now 'finished'
engineers working in audio who have and what exists
heard cable differences and accept is measurable,
them. and thus if it isn't
We receive a regular trickle of measureable it
complaining letters about the cable doesn't exist.
sound issue, asking or demanding This of
we cease publishing ‘misleading’ course is a logical
information and, for the sake of fallacy; in the
openness we are happy to publish 15th century
them. But I’m afraid to say that most people could
people with any experience here not empirically
accept sound quality differences do 'prove' that the
exist. The following view, opposite to earth was a globe, Princesound Prince IIs, a full range electro-
yours, is from reader Rudy Deblieck. yet that did not static loudspeaker that is smooth and reveals
NK mean it was not. tonal colours.
Likewise, until
So, I get a bit angry with all these fairly recently we couldn't detect and Kingsound, as well as Quad are
people who keep on telling us that the existence of Pluto; that did not strong in this area. I also rather like
the importance of cable quality is mean it didn't exist until recently! Spendor’s ep38 polymer cones that
overrated, that burning in is nonsense So I think a degree of perspective is have a damped sound lacking zing,
and that it all comes down to ‘psycho- required; good scientists know that found for example is the S8e we use
acoustics’. They claim that ‘one simply there are known unknowns. One as benchmark loudspeakers.
cannot measure these so called ‘audible of the fascinating aspects of science Pure paper cones are good in
differences’...’ is finding those unknowns and then some areas but can have ragged
For crying out loud: I am a solid finding ways to know them. If ever upper treble when stiffened. These
state physicist myself and as a scientist they need any suggestions, they need days manufacturers like Dali use
I know very well how to conduct an look know further than hi-fi, which is pulp fibre cones that I’ve found
experiment, how to compare setups full of them! DP surprisingly neutral in themselves and
and finally, how to be careful about not good communicators of tonal colour,
drawing conclusions from what has not SEARCH FOR COLOUR but Dali unfortunately like raised
been measured in the test. Can you suggest any current treble too. Tannoy are a company
The fact is that no measuring loudspeakers that give good portrayal that steadfastly refuse to produce a
device actually measures what the ear- of tonal colour, or ‘good tone’ as it loudspeaker with raised treble and
brain combination hears and we should used to be called, and what are you their fibre / polymer cones are pretty
be humble enough to admit that we are looking to pay nowadays? There are good at conveying instrumental
not able to do so properly. plenty of sharp, detailed speakers out colour.
Rudy Deblieck there which can play 100bpm, but their Depressingly, both neutrality
monochrome presentation leaves me and the transmission of tonal colour
We often get letters from people cold. Are paper cones still the way to go are properties little considered in
who 'know' what constitutes a if you want a full, colourful sound? modern loudspeakers. NK
good cable/interconnect and what I would be delighted to hear your views
does not, reducing everything to a on this subject. Hi Jaswant - aside from the Q
question of resistance, capacitance cheers, Acoustics 2050 in the budget region,
and inductance. Whilst this undeniably Jaswant Gill the most obviously tonally varied
plays a vital part, I feel they'd do speaker I've heard recently is the
well to have an understanding of I see it as you see it Jas: too few MyAudio Design My Clapton Grand
philosophy too, at this point. loudspeakers reproduce a convincing MM. It's expensive at £3,500 or so,
There are, to quote the unlikely range of tonal colour and the but it has a great tonal palette, and
source of Donald Rumsfeld, "known drive toward an enhanced sense of this from paper drivers. The designer
knowns; there are things we know speed, clarity and detail, obtained pays meticulous attention to passive
that we know. There are known by boosting treble does not help. componentry, wiring and materials
unknowns; that is to say, there are Electrostatics from Martin Logan technology, and you can hear it! DP
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
opt for the Cadenza Black. Do you think particularly highlighted when you state
this is wise, for a solid state system? that a piece of kit is ruthless about the
Above all, my tastes are a truthful hi- quality of the source.
res. tonally neutral sound, with nothing If you only have high quality
added. recordings, no problem, but people
In case you were wondering about will generally have bought music they
my arm, I intend to upgrade my Silver enjoyed and not usually considered what
MkI to Mk3c when I change the studio/engineer recorded it and either
cartridge. not care, or just be disappointed. See
I would really appreciate any advice where I am going with this? I think most
you might be willing to give. Thanks a lot people will see a few pieces of kit that
for your time. get well reviewed, then decide which
best regards, one they like hopefully after hearing it
Chris Lloyd themselves. If there really was only one
excellent bit of kit in each category,
Ortofon Cadenza
We are talking about fine difference there would only be one hi-fi magazine.
Black cartridge offers here and where Ortofon wish to I personally, am glad it isn’t so. It’s one
a very smooth sound. go with their high end designs. The good reason I look forward each month
See April 2010 issue. Cadenza Black is a later design than to reading your mag.
the Per Windfeld and Ortofon have keep up the good work.
CADENZA QUERY honed it for a slightly darker delivery. Paul Clewlow.
I have been reading your reviews of the It really was very mild mannered but
various Ortofon Cadenza cartridges, you have to listen in to cartridges Thanks Paul – your point illustrates
Windfeld and A90, with great interest like this to appreciate what they are something I always end up agonising
and in great detail (!). I find them very capable of and the Black was pretty over around October time – that of
useful (some of the most comprehensive damn impressive in its sound staging, the Hi-Fi World Awards. It is so, so,
out there I feel). I find these reviews detailing yet good dynamic punch so hard sometimes to come up with
particularly useful in light of the fact that gives solid bass that’s tuneful. It’s 'one' winner, and so arbitrary, and
that it is so difficult to find dealers that a fantastic cartridge and more even yet it must be done otherwise we
carry stock and are willing to A/B demo handed than the Kontrapunkt b, but descend into a world of seemingly
most of these cartridges. whilst you will appreciate its qualities complete subjectivity where we can't
However, I wonder if you might be MCs like this need an Icon Audio PS3 make up our mind about anything! I
able to clarify something for me. I own to do them full justice in my view. don't like doing it, I must admit, but
a Michell Gyro (fully upgraded to near Then you’ll suddenly get a sound just when I dwell on this thought
Orbe status), with Origin Live Silver MkI stage that opens right up, displaying then a product that's so obviously
arm, Ortofon Kontrapunkt b cartridge cavernous depth. NK better in its category than any others
(all purchased 2002) and Tom Evans comes along! Ultimately, the best hi-
Microgroove Plus (later version using
newer Lithos design) phono stage. I use
AVI lab series pre-power and AVI Brio
loudspeakers. So it is well and truly
solid-state all the way. I do find the
Kontrapunkt b to be cool and emotion
free (via solid state amps), as you
suggest in one of your reviews. I am
therefore looking to soften the sound
with something easier on the ear, and
I am obviously now looking to update
my cartridge after 8 years of light to
moderate use.
I am aware that the b (whilst
Ayre 5xe amplifier is fully balanced
something of a benchmark) is not quite
state of the art. So I am looking for
something better than a straight swap DEALERS DO IT fi is the what you like most in your
for the Cadenza Blue. From what you I have just read Tim Jury’s letter in own system, in your own house, with
have written I feel as though I should your November issue re the different your favourite music. DP
also steer clear of the Bronze because conclusions arrived at in different
of its treble ‘populist’ presentation. This magazines about whether one piece of TRANSFORMER
means that I have been considering kit is the best at that price point etc, I particularly enjoyed the November
the Cadenza Black, Windfeld and A90. etc... 2010 edition of H-Fi World, especially
I have discounted the A90, largely for I too read other reviews and found its review of the Music First Audio
reasons of price, availability and it doing this, though it never troubled me as I Classic II preamp fitted with silver
so little more than the Cadenza Black am generally not in the market to buy. transformers. I own the Classic model
sonically (and sometimes less) for a lot However, I think I found one reason this fitted with larger copper transformers
more money. is so whilst reading blind tests by the and can vouch for the improvement the
Therefore I think it is between the public in What Hi Fi and Video. Their upgrade brings. It’s a fantastic piece of
Black and the Windfeld. What I can’t question usually is: do you like kit A over equipment and I take great pleasure
figure out from your review (no direct B or C. In this type of review, they are not just from its sound but also from
comparison is made) is which is ‘better’ deciding which setup makes the test its green credentials and bomb proof
generally speaking. From the frequency music sound the best. A reviewer will try nature.
response graph I feel as though I should for more objective assessments. This is However, I have a hi-fi dilemma
Truth.
From almost forty years of adventure and
innovation, a way to become more intimate with
music.
Platinum PL100
‘..the sense of space that those tweeters confer is
enrapturing, and a joy to behold...vocals were smooth,
delicately etched and superbly projected into the room’
Hi-Fi World - May 2008
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
I am sorry to say I have not
heard either of the power amplifiers
you mention and both look very
interesting. Fully balanced working
in solid-state amplifiers does usually
provide a great sound, very tidy and
clean, but it is quite different to the
presentation of a valve amplifier. I
suggest you try and get a few demos.
to see what you like, and don’t forget
Quad II-eighties either.
Most power amps have 1V input
sensitivity and 10k input impedance
and this is fine for the MF preamp.
NK
The MF Audio passive preamp with gain. Inside lies a step up DECISIONS
transformer with isolating primary and secondary windings. I’m hoping you can help clear my head
a bit. I’m looking for a new pair of
in that I am considering upgrading my transistor or valve based. Other models 'speakers, floor standers or bookshelf
current system and would appreciate I’ve considered are the Karan KAS 180 (can’t even make that decision!). My
your advice. I want to upgrade my and the Ayre mentioned above. I’ve not room is 5m x 9m with the usual soft
power amp to one in the £3k - £5k heard any of them, but they seem highly furnishings. The speakers would need
price range but my head is spinning respected. to fit into a space about 2.5mtr apart
faster than the discs I play because of Another issue I have concerns firing down the room. Unfortunately they
the complexity caused by connecting my matching power amp input sensitivity will be close to the side wall up to about
sub. via its high level speaker binding and impedance to the preamp. What 6” away from side and 12” from rear.
post connections, to a power amp used levels should I look at in a power amp I’m looking to spend around £1000
in conjunction with the MF preamp. fed from the MF? but can go £1400ish. My kit (which
I would prefer to buy a power amp Perhaps I’m exaggerating problems I’m perfectly happy with – no plans
with properly balanced xlr inputs; I’ve here but the proliferation of ‘exotic to change) consists of Icon Audio Mk
put together a DIY lead that take the designs’ in power amps within the I Stereo 40, Meridian G07 CD, CA
MF’s balanced xlr outputs to my Quad chosen price range does make things 640T and Project 5.1 rpm. Most of my
909’s Quadlink balanced input and the more complicated, not least of all when listening is on the turntable and FM
sound is significantly better then the using a passive preamp. radio for back ground listening. Music
unbalanced connection. Many thanks for your help. is varied Rock, Blues, Classical, Prog,
My system consists of the MF Best regards Acoustic and I want to get into Jazz (but
preamp, Quad 909 power amp, Sony Paul Wizonski that’s another letter!).
xa5400es SACD/CD (sounds great Having only got into valves about
with 2 channel SACD) , B&W 805s and Hi Paul. Most power amplifiers are 8 months ago I’ve since clogged my
a REL Storm 5 subwoofer. unbalanced in themselves (internally)
The problem is as follows: most and just use balanced-to-unbalanced
of the power amps in the specified input buffer chips. Their negative
price range are either monoblocks, fully loudspeaker terminal is usually
balanced throughout or Class D type. connected to ground. Very few are
These designs make it tricky to take a truly balanced throughout, although
high level subwoofer connection of the bridged amplifiers by nature must not
type favoured by REL from the power have either output terminal grounded
amp speaker binding posts. REL have and nor can most Class D amps.
supplied me with a de-coupled lead that You can connect the REL from
overcomes the danger of summing the the positive loudspeaker terminal to
outputs on monoblock amps, but I’ve amplifier ground (i.e. the casework)
no idea if the ground connection can and this should work, but in most
be taken to the chassis of the preamp, cases using the negative terminal will
given its passive design. be just the same. All amplifiers have
As for connecting power amps protection circuits, by the way, and
with fully balanced design such as they will kick in if things are not right,
the Ayre 5xe, how on earth is this providing you turn volume up slowly
possible without having to buy another (i.e. do not draw too much current
sub? There so many possibilities here, instantaneously).
most of which seem likely to blow up So your fears are largely
the equipment. Normally a line-level unfounded and nothing should blow
signal fed from the preamp would solve up. Do of course take a close look
the issue, but the MF preamp lacks a at manufacturer’s warnings on what
spare line-level output. can and cannot be done with their
I have considered the valve route amplifiers, before buying. Or e-mail
and am curious to try Icon Audio’s them to ask whether the loudspeaker
power amps. I’d appreciate your negative terminal can be grounded
The Mordaunt Short Mezzo 6
advice on running a sub from them. as this is a simple enough question
Any suggestions of power amps you to answer when a circuit diagram is offers a svelte sound and is
have would be of interest, whether available. worth hearing.
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
head with so much ‘speaker research I on your front end
shiver looking at any more and find my at a later date – or
self beginning to hate speaker reviews! even, perish the
I know I should audition what I can thought, music! DP
but living in the frozen wastes of North
East England my choices of suppliers is PILOT
fairly limited. My plan is once I’ve got a In reference to your
shortlist of three or four to try to listen MF Audio’s passive
to them. But getting to the elusive three preamp review in the
or four is proving to be very difficult. I’m Nov issue I use a tc
basing my initial idea on something of electronic levelpilot
at least 90dB sensitivity but the more I preamp (see http://
read the more I understand the ease of www.tcelectronic.
drive (cross over) is equally important? com/levelpilot.asp).
At the moment I’m using Mezzo 2s, I just wonder if
which I quite like. I borrowed some ATC anybody has used
10s a while ago on the understanding one and what they
they were a whole step up (at least) think? I use it in lots
from what I was using but to be honest of different systems
I wasn’t impressed. They certainly and think its a great
pushed the sound into the room (it was bit of kit, plus you
like David Bowie was sitting next to can pick one up for
me) but I felt as if they were ‘restrained’ about £50!
somehow. I guess they need more than Ian Park.
40Watts to really drive them. Surrey
My short list at present is
something by Living Voice (quite hard to Hi Ian. Their
find any info on these apart from their website say this is
web site, and I imagine quite hard to a Bourns potenti-
track down a pair I can listen to) and ometer, which is
PMC TB2i. slightly different,
Also, my first thoughts before I because it does not
started to get in too deep were Dali provide gain (i.e.
Ikons 6s. Oh yeah – almost forgot Icon will not make the
Try a Monitor Audio BX5 says David.
Audio also do speakers which I guess music louder). The
would fit the bill – can you get a sense idea of a ‘passive different. It uses an audio step-up
of the state of mind I’m in! pot’ (potentiometer) is an old one transformer and these things are
Can you recommend any more and it works nicely when there is more complex and more expensive
I should add to this list or give some enough spare gain in the system, than a potentiometer. The advantage
guide lines (am I being too optimistic lets say between a CD player (2V is that it provides +6dB of gain (x2),
aiming for 90dB?). output) and a power amplifier (1V as well as attenuation, just enough to
hoping you can help, input absolute maximum). Nearly all put between many external phono
Graham. CD players (and all other silver disc stages, tuners (etc) and a power
players) produce 2V or more, and amplifier. It also breaks ground loops,
Mordaunt Short Mezzo IIs (I presume nearly all power amps need 1V for providing complete isolation of
you do not mean Goodmans Mezzo full output so here a passive pot like source from power amplifier. There’s
IIs from the 1960s!) have quite an the Creek OBH-22 which I like to much praise for the MF Audio; it’s a
easy going sound and are very civil. use, works fine. The OBH-22 adds great product. NK
If that’s what you like – and why some twiddly bits by having switched
not – I would suggest you look inputs and remote control of volume, RUNAWAY
further up their range, at the Mezzo plus a mute function. That’s all a lot We have been experiencing the new
6 for example. ATC and PMC are of people need. Icon Audio MB845s for just over a
altogether different by nature and The MF Audio is altogether week. This is an amplifier that does
may jar a little. Triangle have a new
version of their fine Antal that
would likely suit, and Epos are to
introduce a new floorstander, the
Epic 5, priced at £750, that they say
will be accurate. I suspect that the
presentation of your Mezzos will
not be easily matched though. A
Tannoy DC8 would certainly suit, but
it is much more expensive. Modern
floorstanders manage 90dB from one
watt and it is a realistic target. NK
tannoy.com
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
Hi Matt. The main problem is a
square room that will boom strongly
at 35Hz. Look at the first mode of
your room as depicted by Cara;
there are high pressure zones at
the loudspeaker end and listener
end. There isn’t so much you can do
about this, other than move house!
KLS9 is a large loudspeaker with
powerful bass so it will provoke
your room’s main resonant mode by
putting a lot of energy into it.
A quick and dirty solution is to
put a foam bung in the port; some
even use an old sock. This will lower
bass output and lessen the boom.
Keep the loudspeakers as far away
from walls as possible too.
A square room resonates strongly, giving boomy bass. This is a Another aid is absorptive settees
Cara wave tracing analysis that illustrates Matt's problem. High with deep internal foam cushions. I
pressure points lie at the walls. have a three seater, two seater and
armchair stuffed into one room to
everything. It can make you tingle with My system consists of a Marantz 63 KI damp down bass and they do it very
Wagnerian delight, or cause tears to CD player, custom built turntable with effectively.
roll down your cheeks from nostalgia Rega RB250 arm and Denon DL304 Alternatively, you can try corner
driven Simon and Garfunkel. Its magic cartridge, a Separo p88i tube amp. absorbers from somewhere like
hits everything right between the eyes (fantastic piece of kit and don't know Studiospares (www.studiospares.com)
and expresses the miracles that sound why it hasn't been tested by a magazine where they have foam corner cubes
can imbue, inflict, and bestow upon the before) and your very own KLS9 for £12.90, as well as more expensive
emotions. The hooligan that was the first
MB845 has been sent to Eton, ran away
and joined the S.B.S., and has come
back transformed beyond our wildest
imaginings.
Thank you Noel for putting a
picture of it in H.F.W. and suggesting
that a reader should get it. The feeling
it gives me is like skippering an ocean-
going yacht in a Force Eight, close
hauled, crashing from wave to wave,
hitting the crest of one and down into
the trough, the bows hitting the bottom
like a shotgun blast: the whole boat
shudders and the sails regain the wind
and we’re off again, the salt-stained
magnificence of it all and the serene
calm that follows as the dawn comes up.
I know if that Keywood fella says
something is good it is, no question, and Icon Audio LA4 MkII preamp uses early 6SN7 triodes for a
this amp turns the page on all others. svelte delivery.
Owning the Icon audio MB845 Mark 2
is another thing you’ve got to do before loudspeakers. bass traps. Stacks of cubes in two
you die! The amp has no phono stage so I'm corners may work; in my experience
thanks again running the turntable through my Audio you need sheer volume to absorb
James Gould (toned down by Analogue Puccini se on board MC stage. bass energy and this may well add up
Cath Gould!) Mains cable (Russ Andrews Classics) to almost £100 or so (6 cubes) as a
interconnects (Russ Andrews Crystal) treatment. I have not tried it, I must
Well, thanks for that James. It is a bit loudspeaker cable is Russ Andrews 8vs. say, and can only speculate that it
special isn’t it? I’m glad it hits you the By the way, before I had the Separo should help.
way it hit me. Not many amplifiers amp I was running everything through I rather doubt you’ll cure the
sound like the MB845 MkII and David the Audio Analogue Puccini and the problem altogether, but you may
Shaw has done a great job. He’s got boomy bass was present then. well be able to lessen its subjective
the sort of dedication and determi- My room size is 5m x 5m with impact. I do hope this helps.
nation it takes to get a valve amp 2.4m ceiling height and all kit is spiked NK
right – and what a result. NK on to a concrete floor. Have I heard
somewhere before that adding a sub REPLACEMENT
TIGHTER BASS can tune the speakers? Simple question. I am looking to replace
I am desperately trying to get my hi-fi I'm sorry to throw all this info at valves (12AX7, 12AU7, 12FQ7 and
system to deliver a full and tighter bass. you and hope you can help. 5AR4). I am looking for the best of
At present it seems full but can seem a With best regards these types. Can you point me toward
bit boomy at times. Matt what manufacturers I should consider
a class above
Q Series
GP Acoustics (UK) Limited, Eccleston Road, Tovil, Maidstone, Kent, ME15 6QP, U.K.
Telephone: +44 (0)1622 672261 Fax: +44 (0)1622 750653 www.kef.com
WorldMags
MAIL WorldMags
as there seems to be quite a few in the Hi Keith - amazingly no, I
marketplace? haven't tried it yet. Let me
I am getting a “whispery” sound, assure you that I'm working
almost like a minor swirling wind coming to change this state of
through on one of my channels. When affairs ASAP! Still, I'd hazard
I swapped the preamp outputs, the a guess it will be superb.
noise changed to the opposite channel, But then again, I am, as you
implying that the preamp is at fault, state, a Lyra-phile! DP
and I would like to try new valves. I am
not sure what valve it is likely to be, IN A SPIN
and I don’t have a circuit diagram. The I’ve just retired, converted
servicer is in the USA and the preamp my garage into a dedicated
is obsolete. It is, however, astonishingly listening room and have
good to listen to and the most musical rediscovered the wonders of
piece of kit I have had so far. It left my listening to vinyl LPs.
old Audio Research stuff with a very It all began when my
sorry look on its face. architectural designer John
I can change these things out Chapman came to measure
myself as I have Electronic / Electrical up the garage and spotted New Old Stock valves like Mullards
skills, but alas, my education started too my old Luxman turntable reputedly sound best and fetch
late to grasp valve circuit topology. Your waiting to be shipped off to the highest prices.
advice would be greatly appreciated the local tip. Wiping a tear
and keep up the good work with the from his eye he ventured to ask about the Letters page in your August 2009
magazine. Having letters published in my interest in hi fi. edition where another reader had been
the magazine put a smile on my face, He, being a long standing audiophile on a similar path. I duly took your advice
but, my missus thought I was just weird. enthusiast, was quick to point out that and fitted the Goldring 1042 cartridge
She does however, like listening to the vinyl is not dead and is much more to the now rewired SME 3002S2 arm.
music. satisfying to listen to than CD. I was I installed the turntable on a purpose
Ewan Scott, somewhat sceptical at this stage so I made shelf screwed tightly to a granite
Aberdeen. took him into the lounge and gave him block wall and was duly rewarded by a
a demonstration of my system. I thought lovely well balanced sweet sound.
Heavens Ewan, you ask difficult my Rega Apollo, Rega Cursa and two So what’s the problem? Well, if a
questions! I cannot honestly suggest Rega Maia power amps bi-amped into 70’s turntable can achieve this what
the best tubes from personal my PMC FB1 + speakers would sort him more can I do to increase my listening
experience. As you must be aware out. pleasure?
some of those tubes like 12FQ7 and However, he was only moderately Though the Rega equipment
5AR4 rectifier likely won’t come in impressed and suggested I have a listen has served me well I am aware that
premium versions. For the 12AX7 to his Garrard 401, EAR Phono amp, it sounds a little cold and lacks the
(ECC83) and 12AU7 (ECC82) the Croft amp and Spendor BC1 speakers, emotional engagement I experienced
best are New Old Stock (NOS) from which I duly did and was gobsmacked listening to John’s system.
Philips and Mullard but these are now by what I heard. I listen increasingly to Classical
very expensive. You can pay £60 or By coincidence a short while later LPs (usually bought locally from charity
more per item. an old friend mentioned he had a shops) but also some jazz and rock. I
You obviously have an 70’s Transcriptor Hydraulic Reference would like to achieve the same wide
‘interesting’ mystery preamp. Audio turntable sleeping quietly under his bed soundstage I get from the Apollo but
Research inhabit a unusual world of – and would I like it? A good retirement with a richer, more subtle and articulate
their own with tubes and ‘are what project I thought, so with advice sound that is sympathetic to the likes of
they are’. from John and Michael Gammon at Sibelius, Mahler and Elgar.
I suggest you listen to an Icon Transcriptors I set about restoring it. It I’m in two minds, hence my letter.
Audio LA4 MkII preamp sometime, was also at this time I stumbled across Should I look to improve the phono
with its 6SN7 triodes. It is very easy
going and ultra smooth and is likely
what will appeal to you as a valve
head, NK
DELOS A DELIGHT?
Due to the fact I know your Editor
David Price is a bit partial to Lyra
pickup cartridges, then surely you have
had your mits on one by now I would
imagine? When are we likely to read
your thoughts in regards to the Delos.
I’ve never owned a Lyra but on what
bits of info I’ve gleaned so far in regards
to the Delos, let’s say I’m tempted to
try one. But..!
Sorry if this is the nth time that you Quad II-forty valve
have been asked this question. power amplifier is a
kind regards good base for a valve
Keith Burford system.
Swiss Kit
There aren’t many hi-fi separates that hail from
Switzerland, and those that do are generally
expensive, esoteric designs – just like
Dartzeel’s huge CTH-8550 integrated.
David Price enjoys the sound of music...
W
hilst I’m sure many reminding me of my old BMW F650 accessed by a row of buttons under a
readers imagine the motorbike with its Austrian army fluorescent dot-matrix display. There’s
editor of this maga- spec Rotax Type 804 engine. When a record output (thumbs up!) with
zine is permanently the bomb drops, I dare say that independent record source selection,
languishing in a state only cockroaches and Dartzeels will and all switching can be done via
of high end bliss, survive... the beautiful bespoke alloy cased full
impossibly expensive bits of kit stack- The CTH-8550 features newly featured remote control. The central
ing up from one end of the listening designed power output stages which volume knob is curiously labelled the
room, it’s not quite like that. Until include onboard regulated power ‘Pleasure Control’, and is custom-
recently I’d been relying on my old supplies for a compact global layout, made by Elma; the control electronics
Marantz CD273 (1984, bought on Dartzeel says, while the signal path are said to use high quality semicon-
eBay for £22) as a digital source, for has been carefully kept as simple as ductor devices for best reproduction
example; the trouble is that manu- possible. The use of two paralleled accuracy. Oh the Swiss!
facturers have an annoying habit of output transistor pairs was chosen Very quirky then, but it does
wanting their stuff back, whether I’m for hassle-free setup, whatever the work well and the whole amplifier
ready or not! Happily I’m well served kind of speaker used, the company certainly feels special to use, albeit it
with amplifiers though, with a Musical says. The additional power gain not in the sense of being transcen-
Fidelity AMS35i on loan along with provided by these two output dentally smooth to operate and
my gorgeous World Audio Design pairs allowed them to reduce the gorgeous to the touch, as with some
K5881 ‘Andy Grove Signature’ valve number of silicon junctions in driver Japanese high end. Each CTH-8550
power amp bought and paid for! So stages. So there are now only three is delivered with its own dedicated
how then, I mused, would the visit in the power section, resulting in USB key which contains all customer
of a £16,500 Dartzeel fit in with an a claimed 220 Watts per channel information including the owner’s
already very good thankyou-very- under 8 Ohms [see MEASURED name, the serial number and the
much amplifying team? What could PERFORMANCE]. firmware; I’m surprised there’s not a
it possibly bring to a system already All regulated power supplies remote control alarm with flashing
well served with serious sounding involved in the analogue section light in the dashboard!
power houses? are located on the audio circuits,
The first thing you notice about ensuring best possible ripple SOUND QUALITY
the Dartzeel is its sheer physical size rejection and low noise floor, I don’t know if it’s some covert
(440 x 335 x 170) and back-breaking the company claim. All DC drift puritanical streak in me, but I
29kg weight. It's an impressive bit is compensated by digital means, immediately took against this
of kit alright, with a striking gold allowing the compensation to be amplifier when I found out its vast
anodised 15mm aluminium fascia completely kept outside of the signal price. Sure, it’s an interesting and
and red painted hammer finished path, it is said. A huge toroidal power almost charming thing to look
2mm thick Swedish grade steel transformer feeds the dual mono at and to use, but can one really
casework. The four grab handles; power amp sections, while a second, justify the princely sum of £16,500
one at each corner; seem a stylistic smaller transformer caters for the for a largish integrated amplifier?
contrivance but soon prove essential low level signal. Optional phono On switch on, and several hours
when shifting it! It’s very well built, sections (£1,000 MC, £650 MM) are thereafter, my verdict was a firm no.
although it doesn’t have the silkiness implemented on same circuits for I was in no doubt that the Dartzeel,
of Japanese products; it feels more very short signal paths from the input lovely object that it was, was almost
like rugged military communications RCA connectors; these are a factory sadistically overpriced, such were
hardware than a soft, silky slice upgrade. the sounds issuing forth from my
of domestic high end, somehow The amp sports nine inputs, Yamaha NS1000M loudspeakers.
They were telling me that it’s a little edgy but it was getting creamier transient peaks didn’t knock the
powerful transistor amplifier, a bit by the minute and the more the song Dartzeel off its stride; it timed with
opaque across the midband and emoted (and the dynamics peaked), metronomic precision (I’ll avoid the
constrained in soundstaging terms, the more this amplifier seemed Swiss watch analogy) where most
which almost sounds less powerful to relish it. There wasn’t a hint of other solid-staters seem closer to a
than it really is. I cued up an original stress, thee CTH-8550 apparently worn out cuckoo clock.
pressing of Sade’s ‘Diamond Life’ completely unflustered and happy to Given its time to warm up (about
on CD and sat down to a rather spotlight dynamic peaks that almost two hours, all told), then tonally the
forced, harsh presentation of ‘Smooth every other integrated I’ve heard Dartzeel proved unexpectedly rich
Operator’, the Dartzeel sounding sits on. I can truthfully say I heard – sumptuous even. Indeed it’s richer
quite lacklustre. But then something ‘Diamond Life’ in a way I’ve not sounding that some KT88-based
strange happened, and as the album before, and I’ve played it more than a valve amplifiers; if it glowed in the
progressed, I began to find myself few times since 1984! dark it would have 300Bs sprouting
rather enjoying it. No longer pinned On to more contemporary fare, out of it like moss on a Morris Minor
to my sofa with the harshness of the and Mark Ronson’s ‘Bang Bang Bang’, Traveller side window. It’s quite
midband, the soundstage seemed to and I was now struck by just how dark and velvety, but yet somehow
be expanding in all directions and deep and dimensional the Dartzeel looped hi hats proved full
Ms Adu seemed no longer to have a was sounding. This is hardly a pinnacle of energy and not in
voice that sounded like she’d been of the pop album art in sonic terms, the least subdued.
on the fags the night before. The but the big Swiss amp didn’t dwell on I was most
Dartzeel began coming alive before the weaknesses and instead chose
my ears in a way I’ve not heard as to major on the track’s deep, dark
markedly before. bass, thumping out massive tracts of
By the time we’d reached low frequencies like it was going
Sade’s cover of ‘Why Can’t We Live out of fashion. Excellent as my
Together’, my system was singing in a £6,000 Musical Fidelity ‘35i is,
way that had me on edge of the sofa the Dartzeel showed what was
for a different reason. I’d really hit the possible with solid-state devices,
loud pedal (sorry ‘pleasure control’), sounding both tonally richer and
and whereas every other transistor far more commanding, especially at
integrated I’ve heard in this system volumes; there was just no fear for
has begun to sound strained in such the Yamaha’s extra large pizza sized
a predicament, the Dartzeel almost bass bins, which have most amplifiers
seemed to be relaxing in to the job doing a passable impression of a
of making my bass drivers take major asthmatic ant trying to blow up a
excursions forward and backward in damp paper bag.
time to the beat. Yes, it had been a Along with a rock solid bottom,
��������������������������������� Tuners
Arcam T31 silver £229.00 £50.00 D good
������������ Arcam T32 dab/fm tuner
Record Players, Tone Arms
silver £615.00 £379.00 D mint
���������������������� HiFi & Video Interconnects & speaker cables, Transparent Music Wave + Bi
Wire approx 2.5m £769.00 £299.00 D vgc
Transparent Music Link Super XLR 1m £989.00 £349.00 D vgc
Chord Epic speaker cable £512.00 £349.00 D mint
Chord Cadenza interconnect 1m £167.00 £99.00 D mint
����������������������
Mit AVT1 1.5M interconnect £239.00 £99.00 D vgc
And many more from Chord,VDH,Transparent, Qed, True colours etc
many half price or less. Phone for further information
WorldMags 56
����������������������
HI-FI WORLD JANUARY 2011 www.hi-fiworld.co.uk
������������������
REVIEW WorldMags
it just
plain REFERENCE SYSTEM:
nice to Sony CDP-X77ES/dCS Debussy DAC
listen to Musical Fidelity AMS35i integrated amplifier
music Yamaha NS1000M loudspeakers
of any
type. It’s rare that I say that about
any amplifier, let along a high power
transistor one.
CONCLUSION
Perhaps I wouldn’t be so effusive if
impressed by its tonal palette too; Moving to beautifully recorded I’d come to this review expecting
here’s an amplifier that lets you hear classical piano music, and Gottlieb this amplifier to be amazing. Frankly,
the instrument (or sample’s) original Wallisch’s debut on Linn Records, I didn’t, even though I did think it
harmonic signature, rather than ‘Mozart in Vienna’, ‘Sonata in D would be good. As it turned out, it is
sucking out the colour or adding major, K.576 - I Allegro’ rang through more than this; the Dartzeel CTH- VERDICT
too much flavouring of its own. into my listening room like bells in 8550 is an excellent all rounder with Charismatic and quirky high end solid-
This is one of only a few solid-state the night. As you’d expect of this a charm of its very own. Combining state integrated amplifier with superb
amplifiers I’ve heard that take you to label, recording quality was beyond the intricate textural detail and sound and a charming visage.
a completely different world when reproach, letting the Dartzeel do its velvety tonality of a fine tube DARTZEEL
you switch discs; from early eighties stuff. The result was an admirably amplifier, with a take no prisoners CTH-8550 £16,500
Power Plant with ‘Diamond Life’ to wide recorded acoustic, with approach to supplying vast sums of Absolute Sounds
Dunham Studios, Brooklyn, last year, commendable depth too, and an power with grip and gusto, it makes
)
+44(0)208971 3909
different recordings come with a accuracy of imaging such that the for an interesting listen. Just be sure www.absolutesounds.com
totally different flavour, just as they concert hall’s boundaries seemed as to partner it with excellent ancillaries
should. real as those of one’s own listening - and warm it up thoroughly before FOR
Moving from Q-Tip’s recent room. The piano was sparkling taking the ‘Pleasure Control’ up too - neutrality, insight
rapping on Mark Ronson to with harmonics, about as good as high. - fine tonality and texturing
his contribution to Stanley it’s possible to get from Compact It’s hard to assess the value - engaging musicality
Clarke’s ‘1, 2, To the Bass’, Disc at least, and yet there was a for money of something so crazily - soundstaging
back in 2003, and the tremendous delicacy to the playing expensive as this, but if you’re lucky
Dartzeel was allowed to fly. too; rhythmically this amplifier enough to be contemplating such AGAINST
This album’s production proved superb. Once again, at high sums then frankly I don’t think they’d - styling not to all tastes?
values are superb, levels it showed absolutely no sign be wasted on this amplifier. - price!
rendering crystal clear whatsoever of stress, it
the contribution of Joe was as if it had barely
Satriani on guitar; I noticed the immense MEASURED PERFORMANCE
heard dazzling speed spread of sound it The Dartzeel CTH-8550 is massively will be amplified; there is no warp filter.
allied to wonderful was producing in the powerful, producing 210 Watts into 8 Hiss was low at -68dB.
rhythmic dexterity room. Those with Ohms and a massive 361 Watts into 4 The Dartzeel is very powerful and
and a delightful large listening rooms Ohms. Powers like this are for playing well engineered all round. It is likely to
very loud in large rooms and it takes a deliver good sonic results. NK
warmth and will want to try this
big loudspeaker to absorb such power
graunch to his amplifier cranked up
without damage, so the Dartzeel is Power 210 Watts
instrument. with its foot to the aimed at ambitious setups, or it must
Behind this we floor! be (under)used carefully. Distortion CD/tuner/aux.
had Stanley It’s normally at levels remain low and second harmonic Frequency response 3Hz-71kHz
Clarke’s this point that I add predominated at all frequencies and Separation 88dB
sublime bass my caveats, but if you levels, even up to full output, so the Noise -89dB
guitar and keyboard work remember this is a roughness of crossover distortion has Distortion 0.13%
and a pounding drum machine, high power solid state been avoided and the CTH-8550 should Sensitivity 160mV
making for a mesmerising track that device and not a 3W sound smooth in its treble. Damping
factor was surprisingly low at 16, Disc
fuses jazz and rap in a fulfilling way. parallel single ended
much like that of a Naim amplifier, and Frequency response 5Hz-32kHz
The following ‘Simply Said’ is a more tube amplifier, then
bass may well sound a little larger as Separation 63dB
traditional acoustic track, which it’s actually very hard a result. Noise -68dB
the Dartzeel carried with delicacy; to fault. You will find Input sensitivity is adjustable and Distortion 0.08%
oboes had a woody quality to them slightly sweeter, and/or reached a maximum of 160mV via the Sensitivity 0.3mV
but didn’t grate, the acoustic drum more incisive designs unbalanced line inputs, and 330mV via Overload 14mV
kit was a delight with a fantastically around, but you’ll pay the balanced input. DISTORTION
tight snare sound and smooth and the price for them in The phono stage was adjusted for
crisp treble, and the bass guitar either a concomitant MC use in our amplifier and had a high
sounded supple and insistent, yet not lack of power or ear- sensitivity of 0.3mV maximum, making
the amplifier able to cope with low
overpowering. achingly unpleasant
output designs. The overload ceiling
Overall, this amp delivered an tonality. The Dartzeel
was high at 14mV so overload will
engrossing performance, being both simply does so much not occur. Frequency response was
delicate and effortlessly powerful at so very well, and yet is flat from 5Hz up to 32kHz (-1dB) and
the same time. As before, if anything more than the sum of equalisation accuracy across this band
it was just a touch on the dark side its competencies; it has good, with just a mild treble lift of
tonally, yet had a speed and incision something intrinsically +0.5dB from the 75µS curve. Gain was
and bite that could only come from very endearing all of maintained down to 5Hz so disc warps
an amplifier of great transparency. its own which makes
ONLY
£899
WorldMags
REVIEW WorldMags
Trip Recorder
Tim Jarman is most impressed by Olympus’s go-anywhere
LS-5 portable digital recorder...
O
lympus, they make cam- include MP3 at up to 320kbps and
eras don’t they? Well yes, WMA at up to 160kbps but given the
but they have also been storage available it is possibly best to
a big force in portable record in PCM and then transcode
audio. The micro-cas- on a computer later if necessary.
sette, a format that even- For uploading the recordings the
tually became a world standard, was LS-5 connects to a host computer
originally part of their Pearlcorder via a USB cable where it appears as
system and though the Pearlcorder an extra drive from which files can
never really escaped the business- simply be added to or transferred
man’s briefcase in the UK it was a big elsewhere. There are five folders for
hit in Japan, where once you could recording and an extra one called
also buy micro-cassette hi-fi decks 'music' for downloaded content,
and Metal tapes to use in them! Windows Media Center, iTunes or
Like the Pearlcorder, the LS-5 is Olympus’s own Sonority software
really at heart a superior dictating (which is included on a CD and
machine, but those neat little tapes also performs track dividing and
are now gone, replaced by a built-in waveform editing) can all be used as
solid state memory of 2GB and the a basis for this function.
facility to plug in an SD card, giving Making a recording from an
extra storage and the benefit of analogue source is very easy. Once
easily exchangeable media. Olympus the folder and codec are selected all
don’t call it a dictating machine you have to do is press the Record
though, they refer to the LS-5 as key, set the rotary level control
a Linear PCM Recorder, which is (there are no fiddly up/down keys bit/44.1kHz
where things start to get interesting. here!) and then press the Record recordings
An obvious potential use is that of key again – and off it goes. The has
digitising analogue music sources input sensitivity does seem a little nevertheless
(LPs, cassettes, radio broadcasts low, if your preamp or phono stage proved itself
etc) for subsequent uploading onto has a low output then you may capable of
a computer and for this Olympus struggle to get the meters up to the making some
has thoughtfully provided a range recommended -12dB(fs) average level. really superb
of codecs and a stereo line input The volume control for playback recordings. The
connector. is also of the rotary type and once larger Olympus is in some ways
Recordings can also be made again the headphone stage is not easier to use but as it lacks the
from the built-in stereo microphones, the most powerful that I’ve ever Sony’s ability to divide the incoming
which are of excellent quality and encountered; sensitive headphones signal into tracks as it records and
offer a range of modes to suit most are a must if this machine is to be has no track marker function, it can
applications. It can also be used as used in noisy environments. be tedious to edit the long and large
VERDICT
a portable music player for MP3 Recording quality reached a files that it makes. Excellent all-round recording tool
and WAV files which may appeal to high standard; LPs copied at 16bit/ The Sony can also record from that’s ideal for LP to computer music
some; it is more Dragons Den and less 44.1kHz were nicely rendered with optical S/PDIF sources (which transfers.
Hollyoaks than the typical iPod! plenty of detail, the files making a the Olympus can’t), has a better OLYMPUS LS-5 £199.95
First impressions are good. creditable addition to any computer headphone stage and is more Olympus UK
Olympus do not mess about, as based music library. conveniently sized for use as a
)
+44(0) 800 111 4777
anyone who has ever owned or used Moving up to the maximum personal music player. The LS-5 on www.olympus.co.uk
an OM10 camera will tell you, and resolution of 24bit/96kHz added the other hand has a more useful
the LS-5 has a no-nonsense quality an enhanced sense of smoothness choice of codecs, clearer controls FOR
feel with large, simple controls and and slightly less digital grain, at the and a clearer display, far greater - hi res 24/96 recording
a very clear backlit LCD display. cost of larger file sizes and compat- storage capacity, a pair of decent - superb build quality
The range of codecs is sensible, the ibility restrictions with some other built-in mics and feels sturdier and - useful bundled software
default being 16bit PCM at 44.1kHz equipment of course. more rugged. - keenly priced
(CD standard) with up to 24bits In its role as a compact digital Priced at just under £200
at 96kHz being available for those PCM recorder the LS-5’s natural (including the Sonority editing AGAINST
who wish to experiment with higher competitor is the Sony MZ-RH1, software) it is also very good value - insensitive analogue input
quality recordings. Other choices which although limited to 16 and is therefore recommended. - weak headphone stage
Forward
Notion
Noel Keywood reviews Advance Acoustic's MAP-101 integrated amplifier...
T
he French constantly tell function, useful when the phone goes. Running transistors hot also stabilises
me that they do not have a Advance don't stop there though, them thermally and this may well be
hi-fi industry like Britain's, for this amplifier also has a phono important too, as short term thermal
and yet there is a small but stage so you can run a turntable from variation upsets their behaviour
growing flow of interesting the off, when setting up a system. It quite considerably. Valves avoid this
products arriving on our isn't any great audiophile stage but by running very hot all the time of
shores from France. And they remind it does a decent job I found, faced course. The baby Advance did not
me of Renault cars: good quality with an Goldring 1022GX cartridge quite fit this picture I was to find.
based on sound engineering, a little mounted on a Rega P3-24 turntable. The MAP-101 gets little more
chic, plus a low price. That's what There are Tuner, CD and two Aux than warm even with High bias
is on offer with this budget starter inputs too, plus a headphone output. switched on. In case you don't want
amplifier in the Advance Acoustic There is also a Pre-out and Amp- to run the amplifier like this Advance
range, the MAP-101. in split that allows processors or fit a small slide switch on the rear
These days 40 Watts is enough other power amplifiers to be used, that allows high bias to be switched
for most homes and loudspeakers; contributing to general flexibility. off. A blue warning light on the front
the MAP-101 produces 55 Watts Switch on is greeted by a few panel warns of status because if the
our measurements show, and that's blue lights shining eagerly from what amplifier heats up by being run at
a minimum. Into low impedance is a somewhat sombre fascia, since high volume, High bias automatically
loudspeakers this £280 amplifier Advance unfortunately use spindly switches off and the light goes out.
can manage 81 Watts so it isn't grey lettering on a black brushed Measurement showed that
challenged on the power front. aluminium finish, a low contrast High bias had most affect at low
There's sufficient for most listeners, combination that results in illegibility volume levels, halving high frequency
from an amplifier that is neither in low lighting. So whilst French distortion, from 0.18% to 0.07% at 1
heavy nor large, so it fits into the products usually have some visual Watt for example, when feeding a 4
domestic landscape easily enough, 'je ne sais quois' this one does not, Ohm loudspeaker. Run the amplifier
being 435mm wide at the fascia. falling into the same pot of visual hard though and bias change has no
Weight is a manageable 7kgs. mediocrity so thoughtlessly occupied affect; this is a subtle adjustment that
Build quality is on the lightweight by Far East products. Advance will affects only low level sound quality.
side, but the MAP-101 is well finished. have to try a little harder here, With an absolutely standard set
All the controls work smoothly, taking more notice of what their of inputs and outputs and no funny
the loudspeaker sockets are countrymen do and less notice of French ideas like SCART or SEACAM
sturdy gold plated types able what everyone else does. In an ever to get in the way, the MAP-101 was
to accept heavy cables, 4mm crowded market product differen- easy to connect up and use I found.
plugs and spades and there's tiation is important...
even remote control. This Switch on is also greeted with a SOUND QUALITY
is an unusual convenience little something else; heat. Advance As the amplifier warmed up its sound
on a budget amplifier and run this amplifier into Class A by coalesced into a solid, well wrought
it is supported by a bright using a high quiescent current sound stage with firm images set out
blue fluorescent display through the output stage and this clearly. The MAP-101 has a crisp and
showing volume level causes it to run warm, although it assertive midband; Jackie Leven sang
as a two digit number, does not stream heat like a full Class firmly planted centre stage with fine
with 63 representing full A amplifier. The benefit, in theory, resolution of his expressive delivery,
volume. It's easily seen is better sound quality. Class A vocal textures being nicely conveyed
at a distance so a user amplifiers have a slightly more solid, whilst hand drums beat out a steady
can guess whether they less edgy quality than Class Bs and rhythm. Like many modern amplifiers
are about to be blasted light A/Bs. They often sound a little the MAP-101 does not have sharp
or not when changing clearer too; a small veil of mush can or obvious upper treble; in fact at
inputs, for this function be cleared away to give sharper, more high frequencies it seemed quite
is under remote control definite outlines at low levels. The understated, yet cymbals rang clearly
too. Also available is gains are subtle, but they are usually and bells had convincing sonority.
a remote control mute there, all other things being equal. Faced with a wall of strummed guitar
VERDICT
Good budget amplifier with plenty of
useful facilities and respectable sound
quality.
chords it wasn’t as composed, clear enjoyable and liked the way in which I fancy it also had a little more slam
and fuss free as our Musical Fidelity this little amplifier cleanly resolved and dynamic life. ADVANCE MAP-101 £280
AMS50, but it is one thirtieth of its Gaga’s vocal antics, spreading her Advance Acoustic
price so it did pretty well! There’s a refrain in a wide arc across the room CONCLUSION )
+33(0) 160 185 900
vaguely industrial greyness about its between the loudspeakers as she The Advance MAP-101 is a fun listen www.advance-acoustic.com
tonal palette, but budget transistor crooned, “I’m a free bitch baby”. Mind and a fine all round budget amplifier
amplifiers are rarely sweet and I you, La Gaga over drove the output I feel. With a good range of useful FOR
don’t think this would be especially stage causing it to switch from High facilities and decent basic sound - phono stage
noticeable to most listeners; I spend bias down to normal bias to prevent quality especially strong in midrange - clear midband
most time with a specially tuned overheating; perhaps it was those resolution and absence of nasties this - remote control
valve amplifier, the Icon Audio MB845 lyrics that did it! A short spell muted is a well balanced package and worth
MkII and against this the poor MAP- brought the blue High bias light back considering if you are after a starter AGAINST
101 is a little disadvantaged, because on with a soft click. Turning Gaga amplifier. - dull styling
most amps are. right back up to spit - raucous at high volume
With orchestral works like out 'Monster' showed
Tchaikovsky’s Symphony No6 strings the MAP-101 hardened MEASURED PERFORMANCE
stood out clearly and sounded up when really pushed The MAP-101 produces a modest 55 available down to 12Hz. Sensitivity was
unmuddled, flute floating out clearly hard and took on an Watts into 8 Ohms and 81 Watts into very low at 8mV though, so high output
from centre stage, right a bit! edginess, a sharpness 4 Ohms. Since most loudspeakers MMs like Ortofons will best suit.
Where the MAP-101 was on the to its upper midrange, are nearer the latter it still manages As budget amplifiers go the MAP-
vague side of things was in its bass but if cranked down very useful power output from a small 101 produced an interesting set of
delivery. With both Rock music and to sensible levels it package. figures and is likely to sound good. NK
With low bias, distortion was
classical there was a gentle warmth recomposed itself back
reasonably benign in its harmonic Power 55 Watts
to bass and a nice, easy going gait, to a brisk, focused
structure and in the mild changes that CD/tuner/aux.
but not one temporally chiselled in sense of midrange occurred as signal level changed. Even Frequency response 13Hz-77kHz
stone. This amplifier for much of the clarity. at 10kHz there was little high order Separation 82dB
time has a gentle bottom end that With a simpler crossover distortion, second harmonic Noise -86dB
passes unnoticed. Here it is unlike composition like always dominating, as our analysis Distortion 0.18%
typical UK amps where a beefy Celine Dion’s 'A New shows. Levels were not low, but then Sensitivity 200mV
toroidal transformer and power Day Has Come' I this isn’t necessarily so bad, as valve
supply is used to provide solid low was again aware of a amps demonstrate. So whilst the MAP- Disc
end grunt, for the clear maintenance fine but brittle clarity 101 produces 0.2% distortion at 10kHz, Frequency response 13Hz-77kHz
it was mostly innocuous sounding 2nd Separation 62dB
of rhythm. That’s not to say the MAP- that had Celine Dion
harmonic. High bias reduced distortion Noise -84dB
101 did not do dynamics. At times it singing out clearly
level but increased third and higher Distortion 0.1%
pushed some strong dynamic changes centre stage, but with a harmonics, not a good sign as they are Sensitivity 8mV
through our Spendor S8es as horns presentation that was more audible than second harmonic. Overload 40mV
suddenly blared out and kettle drums less than couth, a tad Interestingly, damping factor
rolled in 'Pathetique'. raucous in a way. At DISTORTION (Bias Off)
was very low at 21, suggesting less
You’d be hard pressed to criticise this point I switched feedback than is common, and this
its rendition of the deep rumbling to Low bias and was tallies with higher distortion figures,
bass synth in Lady Gaga's 'Bad not surprised to find suggesting good sound quality and quite
Romance' or its driving beat, yet the that this ameliorated generous bass.
The MM phono stage was
MAP-101 was not tightly gripping the problem. Under
reasonably well equalised, just
our acoustically undamped Spendors, test the amplifier was
remaining within 1dB limits across the
so the fright of the AMS50 or the happier at low bias audio band, treble being prominent.
thunder of our MB845 MkII wasn’t and it sounded more There is no warp filter, full gain being
there. But I found the performance composed in use too.
WorldMags 62
forHIFIWorld.indd 1
HI-FI WORLD JANUARY 2011 www.hi-fiworld.co.uk
8/11/10 13:44:02
FEATURE WorldMags
Definitive
Article
Noel Keywood tries the Spears and Munsil High Definition
Blu-ray test disc for size...
M
odern Blu-ray players to show their impact and provide
like the Cambridge guidance on what is best.
650BD I use possess There are five test sections on
picture adjustment the disc. Setup & Evaluation carries
controls: brightness, no fewer than twenty one luminance
contrast, hue, satura- and chrominance tests, as well as
tion and sharpness, and colour TVs geometric patterns and it’s a good
commonly add to this with tint, noise way to judge both picture quality and
reduction, dynamic range enhance- setup accuracy. My disc came with
ment and colour temperature. This blue tint glasses for use with the
amounts to a bewildering array of colour bars.
adjustments and they disguise some The second section is a bit
peculiar goings on. TV sets in par- more arcane, with de-interlacing There
ticular come tweaked up as standard, tests and film to video pull down are bewildering
their pictures artificially enhanced cadence handling, with a wide variety time lapse sequences that look
to give a dramatic, rather than accu- of cadences provided to assess the like speeded up video, the point of
rate picture. Which is a pity, because ability of players and TVs to recognise which escapes me. I felt some of
modern HD TVs really are very good and handle the pull down process. the colours were suspiciously over
and offer a lovely picture that’s plenty This is a test section that acts as saturated for effect too; my own
good enough without enhancement. guidance for Blu-ray player 24p HD MPEG video on Blu-ray disc of
Where high fidelity never quite output settings amongst other things local park scenes are more naturally
accepted the artificial enhancement and can help with receiver video balanced, if not so silky smooth and
of audio as being desirable, keeping processing if it is enabled. hard outlined by the presence of
it as something you switch on rather The third section covers edge dense blacks.
than off, life is different with video. adaptive de-interlacing with tests for This is a fascinating test disc
It comes with enhancement on and, trailing edges, jaggies and such like. that’s well worth its £24 asking price
if you want a good picture, then it’s This carries both artificially generated I feel. It will give you hours of happy
time to switch it all off. patterns and outdoor video fiddling time trying to coax a better
And that’s what this disc helps sequences. Pressing Enter brings up picture from TV and Blu-ray player
you do. Of the many test discs I an explanation of what to look for, in and you will likely succeed with its
have and use when testing Blu- addition to the booklet liner notes guidance.
ray players, this one has the most and website help available.
comprehensive set of adjustments The fourth section has audio Available from Amazon.
and test sequences to aid in the demonstration tracks in basic PCM, www.spearsandmunsil.com
adjustment of brightness, contrast, DTS HD Master Audio and Dolby
colour balance and all else, and this is TrueHD coding, but there are no
especially useful when trying to find channel identification tones or pink
the optimal settings for modern TVs. noise bursts for tone matching
Having said that, the many geometric assessment, etc., so this is not an
patterns on this disc refer to older audio test disc.
CRT equipped sets that have issues The final section is a disc Setup
with corner geometry and colour menu where playback conditions can
alignment, as well as overshoot be changed.
and ringing on vertical black/white The disc has some beautifully
transitions that don’t affect LCD and sharp video sequences shot with
LED TVs. Today’s TVs need all picture an ultra high definition Red camera,
enhancement processes turned off, showing dense, noise free colour and
then progressively switched back on, detail that takes you breath away,
one by one, with a disc like this used even on a boggers high def screen.
Clear Blu Water Is Pioneer's new BDP-LX53 Blu-ray player sufficiently good to put it a fair
distance ahead of its competition? Noel Keywood finds out...
K
nown for some great UK, and Cambridge who jumped perhaps, but SACD still has a strong
audio products in the into the market gap using the same following around the world, especially
past, including some of formula to come up with the 650BD. for classical music.
the finest VHF/FM tun- This is my player of choice and the Pioneer miss out on SACD
ers ever in the TX-9500 benchmark used in this review. replay with the BDP-LX53, but they
and 9800, I was hoping For those new to Blu-ray, all are hardly alone as few players other
Pioneer’s illustrious audio past would players will spin CD, DVD and Blu-ray than recent Sonys, Oppos and the
feed through into this 2010 season discs, making them universal players. Cambridge will give the delicious
Blu-ray player, the BDP-LX53. The BDP-LX53 is no exception, sound of SACD in full surround
Priced at £299 and available for so it will play your old audio discs. sound glory.
around £250 it would seem, the Unfortunately, at this price it does The Pioneer does of course
Pioneer sits above the £160 jobbies not reproduce the high definition spin Blu-ray audio discs up to the
stacked in HMV but below audiophile DSD layer of an SACD, only the maximum resolution of 24bit at
specials like the superb Cambridge low resolution stereo track used 192kHz sample rate, in raw LPCM
Audio 650BD at £399. to ensure backward compatibility. form or losslessly compressed by
But as my group test of Blu- In their handbook Pioneer state Dolby TrueHD or DTS HD Master
ray players in our October 2010 otherwise, that SACDs are not Audio. That means it will replay
issue revealed, there are some nasty played, but they are – well, sort of! highest resolution surround sound
surprises out there for anyone Anyone with an SACD collection audio, both from movie discs and
wanting to swim in Blu waters. They needs to know that Sony’s excellent from dedicated Blu-ray audio discs
come from big fish like Samsung and BDP-S370, price just £120, plays from companies like 2L of Norway.
Sony who have very well engineered SACD in full, outputting high So you’ll get high fidelity cannon
products on offer at knockdown resolution DSD code via the digital balls recorded in DTS HD Master
prices. It’s a fierce market, but some HDMI line to a receiver and many Audio crashing through your lounge
minnows have done well, for example receivers can decode it into that from 'Master and Commander',
Swedish Oppo who marketed a lovely smooth sound SACD is known 'The Far Side of the World', or the
Mediatek based solution in the for, a real plus point if you have Trondheim Soloists playing all around
popular BDP-83, unavailable in the such a collection. It isn’t a big issue you in highest resolution digital audio,
The Diamond Revolution The new Usher Mini-2 Diamond DMD available now UK SRP £3700.
Oppo BD83SE NuForce Edition Graham Slee Novo NuForce V3 Amplifiers Analogue Nirvana
HIAudio - UK Distribution
WorldMags For your nearest stockists visit www.hiaudio.co.uk or call direct on 0845 0525259
REVIEW WorldMags
found the keypad would enter only temporal progress and muddle, managed better, but this is nit picking.
numerals. Great if you want to find or lack of it. Whilst stereo CDs Jaggies were absent. Picture quality
the 123 band, but no use otherwise. benefitted little when moving from was good, if not quite up with the best.
And no word in the Handbook analogue to S/PDIF digital to HDMI
of how to enter letters from the digital, surround sound recordings CONCLUSION
alphabet (you can download the of course opened out into the The BDP-LX53 justifies its modest VERDICT
Acceptable audio and video quality
manual from Pioneer's website). I was room. Playing high definition Rock price tag in terms of sound and video plus YouTube make this player fair
baffled. Much button pressing later I concerts in 24/96 like Elton John’s quality. In build quality and operational value, but it's too slow to load and
discovered an Enter button brought ‘Live at Madison Square Garden' and methodology it is behind the pack sometimes awkward to use.
up an on-screen keyboard and was at John Mayer’s well recorded ‘Where though. Load times were hopelessly PIONEER BDP-LX53 £299.95
last able to enter performer and band The Light Is’ the Pioneer was clean slow and operational methodology Pioneer GB Ltd.
)
names. enough, if not up to the pristine poor; I wrestled to use the BDP- +44 (0)1753 7897894
Only YouTube is available. The digital standards of our benchmark LX53 at times, even after learning its www.pioneer.co.uk
player will not access computer hard Cambridge 650BD or the Samsung foibles. So whilst you may enjoy what
drives via a home network. It will BD-C6900. the Pioneer does, getting it to do it FOR
however, play MP3s from a memory The BDP-LX53 played well can be a challenge. The brutal truth - decent sound
stick, but only MP3s and no other recorded top resolution 24/192 is Samsung make a better player at - fine picture quality
format. WMA and AAC are verboten! music Blu-rays like 2L’s impressive the same price in the BD-C6900 I - YouTube functionality
Rear panel connectors comprise and lovely Percy Grainger revival/ reviewed in our October 2010 issue,
an HDMI output, an optical S/PDIF tribute with aplomb and even if it and Sony make a less expensive player AGAINST
digital audio output, Component wasn’t fractionally the best it was in the BDP-S370 that offers more all - long load times
video outputs and a Composite plenty good enough to be thoroughly round. - awkward to use
video output, accompanied by stereo enjoyable. If I said it - lightweight build
analogue audio output sockets. sounded bad and you
heard it, you would MEASURED PERFORMANCE
SOUND QUALITY say I’m mad! So, in a
Frequency response with CD was flat Distortion % (CD)
Much as usual the stereo analogue nutshell, the Pioneer to 20.8kHz with no peaking, so the 0dB 0.002
audio output sounded a bit vague and played all discs and tonal balance was accurate and CD -6dB 0.0012
diffuse in its temporal progress and sounded good via will sound natural in this respect. With -60dB 0.19
its imaging. So some of the sharper its digital outputs, if 96kHz sample rate the upper response -80dB 4.2
timed Eagles tracks on their 'Long fractionally below the limit, -1dB, measured 45kHz, a good
Road Out of Eden' CD, like 'Last best. result that gets the best from modern Separation (1kHz) -101dB
Good Time in Town', were not quite Picture quality was 24/96 recordings. Noise (IEC A) -102dB
so tightly timed, leading edges being a good. My test BDMV Distortion levels were low too. At Dynamic range 99dB
-60dB CD (i.e. 16bit) measured 0.19% Output 1.97V
tad smoothed over. Blu-ray of an idling
and a higher resolution 24bit signal
The orchestra behind Percy Tiger Moth at Duxford
0.14%, both low values showing the FREQUENCY RESPONSE (24/96)
Grainger on 2L's Edvard Grieg airfield, shot in HD Pioneer’s DACs are linear and its
Blu-ray sounded a little messy too. with a Canon HV30, analogue output is of good quality.
Switching my Marantz SR8002 showed a pleasantly All other parameters measured
receiver over to read the player’s light colour balance; low normally for both CD (16/44.1) and
S/PDIF optical output immediately colour saturation made higher resolution 24/96 digital from
cleaned things up, as it often does. grass lightly green and Blu-ray. The player does not recognise
Rock music took on firmer timing, luminescent red airfield DVD-A discs nor the high resolution
with better accented rhythms. warning bollards not DSD layer of SACD.
The only area where results were
Complex classical orchestral too garish. Detail in
mediocre was jitter. Low rate clock
arrangements became more foreground grass and
drift resulted in a high 500pS peak
intelligible too. The Pioneer sounded background trees was below 300Hz and this degrades bass DISTORTION CD (16bit)
clean and tidy and was enjoyable, good, if not matching quality. At higher frequencies the
but to be pedantic it wasn’t as clean Philips players in result was better, a 1kHz tone at -60dB
as possible on digital and the quality particular whose noise inducing 40pS jitter, a low value. This
gap between analogue and digital was reduction best retain is a much poorer result than market
larger than the directly competitive detail and gave amazing leaders like Samsung.
Samsung BD-C6900, which sets an results with this video. Audio quality from the analogue
impressive standard at this price Blu-ray test discs outputs of this player reached a high
standard, if not up to the best from the
point. from HQV and Spears
likes of Samsung. NK
Switching again, but this time & Munsil backed up
to HDMI, showed the Pioneer was this assessment. The Frequency response (-1dB)
much the same in sound quality Pioneer’s handling of CD 4Hz-20.8kHz
between its two digital outputs, in film pull downs wasn’t
basic parameters such as cleanliness, great; our Cambridge
WorldMags
COMPETITION WorldMags
“T
he UnitiQute’s tal- work Ethernet socket and integrated dry, clean tonality, but isn’t harsh or
ent is that it brings Wi-Fi also comes as standard. The laced with distortion. Unsurprisingly
so many sources power amplifier claims 45W RMS given its DNA, there’s a strong, taut QUESTIONS
in one small place per channel into 4 Ohms, 30W into and punchy bass which doesn’t let
and offers sound 8 Ohms... it has a linear power sup- any type of music - drum’n’bass [1] What type of
DAC is fitted...?
quality that’s on ply with 200VA toroidal transformer included - get the wrong side of [a] Wolfson
another level from your average with three separate windings, and it. Sunday paper standfirst writers [b] Analogue Devices
[c] Burr Brown
PC World-bound ‘computer audio’ there are separate power supplies for will doubtless describe it as a
[d] Sanyo
gadget. It also sports a quality of digital, analogue, and power amplifier. “bantamweight belter”... With Mark
build and overall operating sophisti- All this goes into a neat non-reso- Ronson’s ‘Bang Bang Bang’, the size [2] Where is the
USB socket?
cation that is unknown to users of nant, non-magnetic case, fronted by of the soundstage, the punch of [a] front
Squeezeboxes and their ilk... Hidden a superb green OLED fine pitch the bass and the general speed and [b] back
deep within its chunky case, the unit’s dot-matrix display that’s exception- exuberance of the performance was [c] top
[d] side
preamplifier sports two analogue ally easy to read. Top marks for size breathtaking considering its modest
inputs, five 24bit/192kHz-capable (87x207x314mm) and weight (5.6kg). price and status in life. Playing via [3] Is integrated
Wi-Fi?
digital inputs (via a Wolfson DAC), In the great scheme of things, a home network the UnitiQute
[a] standard
FM and DAB tuners and the ability its sound is simply much better came close to CD on good AAC [b] optional
to play music from an iPod or MP3 than any other product of its type; files; no small feat! Here’s a brilliant [c] not available
[d] a pipe dream
player via its front panel-mounted the paradox is that it’s so good that little music box... a great crossover
USB socket (with digital iPod playout, you actually start treating it like a product that could just pull in [4] David described
Apple authenticated); the USB socket highish end bit of hi-fi! The little ‘civilians’ into the wonderful world of the Naim as what?
[a] “a brilliant little music
also plays (up to) 24/96 music files Naim tries and largely succeeds to separates hi-fi at a later date.” box”
from a USB memory stick. A net- get you closer to the music. It has a If you’d like to win this superb [b] “not bad if you really
must”
system then all you have to do
[c] “okay if you like that
RULES AND CONDITIONS OF ENTRY is answer the following four easy sort of thing”
questions. Send your entries by [d] “not as good as an
- ONLY ONE ENTRY PER HOUSEHOLD iPod”
postcard only by 31st December
- MULTIPLE ENTRIES WILL BE AUTOMATICALLY DISQUALIFIED 2010 to: January Competition
January Competition, Hi-Fi World Magazine
- PURCHASE OF THE MAGAZINE IS NOT A PRE-CONDITION OF ENTRY Unit G4 Argo House
Hi-Fi World magazine, The Park Business Centre
- NO CORRESPONDENCE WILL BE ENTERED INTO Unit G4, Argo House, Kilburn Park Rd.
London NW6 5LF
- THE EDITOR'S DECISION IS FINAL The Park Business Centre,
Kilburn Park Road,
- NO EMPLOYEES OF AUDIO PUBLISHING LIMITED, OR OF ANY COMPANIES
ASSOCIATED WITH THE PRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION OF THE PRIZES, London NW6 5LF.
MAY ENTER
HI-FI WORLD
✹ F RE E ! THE PERFECT
CHRISTMAS GIFT!
Subscribe to Hi-Fi World and choose either
a Chord SuperScreen mains cable
(1m), or a Chord CobraPlus
interconnect (1m) FREE - for yourself or
those nearest and dearest to you.
Chord SuperScreen
mains cable
Dual foil high frequency effective shielding -
Vibration damping external casing -
High purity multi-strand copper conductors -
Performance optimised internal wiring geometry -
Chord CobraPlus
interconnect cable
- Multi strand, oxygen-free copper signal/return conductors
- Twisted pair configuration
- Low density polyethylene dielectric
- High quality gold-plated RCA plugs
TERMS & CONDITIONS FOR THIS OFFER: You will receive twelve issues per annum. Minimum subscription term is one year. This offer is only
available to new subscribers. Your subscription will start with the next available issue, at the annual subscription rate of £46.80. Offer ends 14th
January 2011. Quote REF: HFW - XMAS2010 . To avail of this fantastic offer, go to pages 82 & 83 and complete the subscriptions form and tick
the RED BOX i.e. XMAS OFFER BOX and send to the address shown. Due to high demand on promotiional offers, gifts are subject to
WorldMags availability. We reserve the right to send you an alternative gift if the above-mentioned gift(s) run out.
WorldMags
soundbites
ORIGIN LIVE LINEAR FLOW 2 earth lead for each interconnect) tation, giving the soundstage a less
‘SHIELDED’ £380 superior in that they target RF constricted feel. In fact, listening to
Origin Live is best known for its fine interference promising further detail the Linear Flow 2s felt like a box lid
turntables, tonearms and upgrade enhancements had been lifted, allowing the sound
kits, but did you know the company During sound tests, I hung the to soar forth. Do audition this when
also produces cables? The Linear cable off my Icon Audio PS3 phono next you consider upgrading your
Flow 2 ‘Shielded’ interconnects amp which, in turn, connected to interconnects; its an excellent cable.
reviewed here are based upon a an Avid Acutus deck with SME IV PR
balanced design that aims to reduce arm and Benz Glider cartridge.
the amount of inductance present This high resolution source would [Contact: +44(0)2380 578877,
within the cables by twisting the highlight any obvious and subtle www.originlive.com]
leads. It’s interesting to see that the changes found when compared to
Linear Flow 2s utilise high purity the reference Chord Anthem 2s. In
copper as the principal component sound terms, over varying musical
instead of silver or even a silver genres, the Origin cable exhibited
coating. Many users see copper as an obvious firming of the bass
more tonally balanced, which should which became more solid and well
provide a more neutral flavour. sculptured. The effect was to give
The addition of over five dielectric the lower frequency regions an
insulators promise to enhance that obvious character as well as power.
balanced sonic aim by providing an This extra layer of aural detail was
even response. also transferred to the midrange
The samples sent to me by frequencies. Here, tonal information
Origin Live featured good quality was enhanced, sometimes with a fine
Eichman Bullet plugs. The Linear etching that linked into the Origin
Flow 2s arrive in both shielded Linear Flow 2’s admirable transparent
and unshielded forms. I listened to qualities. It’s also the latter that
the former, coated with 95% nickel helped the cables to offer a more
plated copper braid (plus an attached open presen-
WORLD Here is our list of the great and good from audio’s
glorious past, products that have earned their
place in hi-fi history. You’ll also see some oddities
CLASSICS
which aren’t classic as such, but are great used
buys. The year of introduction is given, alongside
the original UK launch price.
We do not sell these products.
It is for your information only.
AUDIO TECHNICA
AT 1120 1978 £75
Fine finish can't compensate for this ultra low
mass arm's limited sonics - a good starter
arm if you've only got a few quid to spend.
POWER AMPLIFIERS
HH ELECTRONICS TPA-50D
AMPLIFIERS 1973 £110
Simple design with easily available compo-
nents, solid build quality and fine sound make
for a surprisingly overlooked bargain. Not
exactly stylish, however.
ROTEL RA-820BX 1983 £139
Lively and clean budget integrated that argu- LEAK STEREO 20 1958 £31
ably started the move to minimalism. Excellent workaday classic valve amplifier
CREEK CAS4040 1983 £150 with decent power and drive. Surprisingly
More musical than any budget amp before it; modern sounding if rebuilt sympathetically.
CAS4140 loses tone controls, gains grip. CHAPMAN 305 1960 £40
Irrepressibly musical and fluid.
Smooth pre/power combo with a sweet and
AUDIOLAB 8000A 1985 £495 open sound. Not quite up to Leak/Quad
Smooth integrated with clean MM/MC phono standards but considerably cheaper second-
stage and huge feature count. Extremely reli- hand.
able, too. Post '93 versions a top used buy.
PREAMPLIFIERS
AUDIOLAB 8000C 1991 £499
Tonally grey but fine phono input and great
facilities make it an excellent general purpose
tool.
PHONO STAGES
CREEK OBH-8 SE 1996 £180
MUSICAL FIDELITY
Punchy, rhythmic character with oodles of
XA200 1996 £1000PR
detail makes this a great budget audiophile
200W of sweet smooth transistor stomp in a
classic. Partner with a Goldring G1042 for an
grooved tube! Under-rated oddity.
unbeatable budget combination. REVOX B760 1975 £520
More of a semi-pro machine than a domestic
bit of kit, the Revox offers superlative measured
performance although the sound isn’t quite as
staggering as the numbers. Fine nonetheless,
and surely the most durable tuner here?
HH ELECTRONICS TPA-50D
AMPLIFIERS 1973 £110
Simple design with easily available compo-
nents, solid build quality and fine sound make
for a surprisingly overlooked bargain. Not
exactly stylish, however.
CLASSIC CONTACTS
When a classic goes 'pooof' your troubles have just started, but there may be a good ending. Replacing failing parts can
improve the sound, so here is a short listing of all these companies who specialise in getting a classic up and running again
after its deposited a small ring of soot on your ceiling!
GT AUDIO QUAD ELECTROACOUSTICS EXPERT STYLUS COMPANY CLASSIC NAKAMICHI
(Graham Tricker, Bucks) (Cambs) Quad's service department, (Wyndham Hodgson, Surrey) Stylus (Paul Wilkins, Worthing. West Sussex).
Leak Troughline specialists. Also Quad able to repair almost all Quad replacement service for all types of Restore, Repair & Service Nakamichi
and most classic tuners, radios and products, from the very first. (Also cartridge. Including precise profiling Cassette Decks.
Audiolab, Mission & Wharfedale). for 78s. Tel: 01372 276604
amplifiers restored, repaired. Tel: 01903 695695
Tel: 0845 4580011 Email: w.hodgson@btclick.com
Tel: 01895 833099 www.quad-hifi.co.uk Email: paul@bowersandwilkins.co.uk
Mob: 07960 962579 ONE THING www.bowersandwilkins.co.uk
www.gtaudio.com Dr MARTIN BASTIN (Coventry) Specialist in electrostatic
(Shropshire) Garrard 301/401 panel manufacture and repair. Can OCTAVE AUDIO
TECHNICAL AND GENERAL restoration, renovation and service. refurbish ESL 57s and 63s as well as WOODWORKING
(East Sussex) Special plinths; rumble cures, etc. Leak Troughlines and Quad lls. (Bristol)
Tel: 01584 823446 Email: one.thing@ntlworld.com
Turntable parts - wide range of Unit 2, 16 Midland Street, St Phillips.
www.onethingaudio.com
spares and accessories, plus arms and ARKLESS ELECTRONICS Bristol.
cartridges. (Northumberland) LORICRAFT AUDIO Tel: 0117 925 6015
Tel: 01892 654534 Specialist in repairs, restoration and (Terry O'Sullivan, Bucks) www.octave-aw.co.uk
modifications to all amplifiers, valve or Garrard 301/401 and their own 501
CARTRIDGE MAN solid state, ancient and modern. repair, spares and service.: REVOX
(Len Gregory, London) Tel: 01670 829891 Tel: 01488 72267 (Brian Reeves, Cheshire)
Specialist cartridge re-tipping service Email: www.garrard501.com Revox tape recorder spares, service
arklesselectronics@btinternet.com
and repairs. High quality special and repair. Accessories also available.
HADEN BOARDMAN
cartridges. SOWTER TRANSFORMERS Repair, service & modifications; Tel: 0161 499 2349
Tel: 020 8688 6565 (Brian Sowter, Ipswich) classic & modern. Collection available. Email: brian@revoxservice.co.uk
Email: thecartridgeman@talktalk.net Large range of audio transformers Redundant / faulty equipment www.revox.freeuk.com
www.thecartridgeman.com for valve amps, cartridges, line drive, purchased, selected new equipment
interstage plus all associated services. available. Tel 01942 790600 CLASSIQUE SOUNDS
AUDIO LABORATORIES Tel: 01473 252794 www.sowter.co.uk www.audioclassics.co.uk (Paul Greenfield, Leicester)
(LEEDS) ESL-57s restored, rebuilt, fully
(Phil Pimblott, Leeds) Renovation, WEMBLEY LOUDSPEAKER LOCKWOOD AUDIO renovated or improved. Leak, Quad
(Paul MacCallam, London) (London)
repair and restoration. Specialist in valves amps etc.
Comprehensive loudspeaker servicing. Tannoy loudspeaker parts, restoration
valve hi-fi, radio transmitters, cinema Tel: 020 8 743 4567 Tel: 0845 123 5137/
and repair. Also Epos and TDL
amps, kit building. Email: loudspeakers. Mob: 0116 2835821
Tel: 0113 244 0378 paul@wembleyloudspeaker.co.uk Tel: 020 8 864 8008 Email: classique_sounds@yahoo.co.uk
www.audiolabs.co.uk www.wembleyloudspeaker.com www.lockwoodaudio.co.uk www.flashbacksales.co.uk/classique
Motor Head
Tony Bolton finds Audio Engine’s P4 to be a zesty little loudspeaker...
A
s the variety of audio measuring just 228x140x165mm which uses neodymium magnets.
sources expands from (h x w x d) and weigh in at 2.75kg Below the cones is a narrow bass
conventional audio equip- each. The cabinets are made of reflex port. At the back are a pair of
ment to include comput- 20mm thick, high-resin MDF and quite substantial binding posts which
ers and portable digital internally braced to provide a rigid, will take the usual range of 4mm
devices such as iPods, so low resonance case. Rapping them banana plugs, spades and bare wire
the need for a variety of speakers for with my knuckles certainly seemed to connections.
different listening environments has confirm this with a dull thud being all
developed. American company Audio that I heard... SOUND QUALITY
Engine have recently introduced a The cabinets are well finished After about fifty hours of running in
passive version of its active P2 and with a chamfered edge around the on the usual diet of classical music
P5 models. This, the P4, is available front panel, and curved corners. and burn-in discs, I set the P4s up in
in either black or white, as pictured The underside is thoughtfully my front room on sand filled Atacama
here, for £179 or in bamboo finish protected by a soft rubbery material stands powered by the Leema
for £235. This latter model is made of and mounting holes for brackets Acoustics Tucana ll amplifier. Sources
carbonised bamboo and is claimed to are provided at the back and included a Clearaudio Master
be voiced to give the same sound as underneath. The front contains a Solution turntable and Leema’s Antilla
the other two versions. 101mm diameter bass/mid driver CD player.
The speakers are compact, and a 20mm silk dome tweeter I started off listening with a
compilation of Mozart, Tchaikovsky, noise on the record was added to by of furniture is recommended and
Pachelbel and Debussy pieces played that present in the recording, insuffi- I would feel these units will be
by the New Cologne Philharmonic ciently muted during the transfer better suited to small listening
Chamber Orchestra on CD. from 78. environments.
First impressions were good. Moving the speakers from
The sound was very open and, with stands onto a solid oak desk seemed
a small ensemble like this, detailed. to calm things down somewhat,
I was very aware of the different confirming (to my mind at
tonalities and characteristics of least) that these speakers
each of the nine instruments in the are at their best on solid
orchestra. This was aided by quite furniture, at close quarters
precise imaging which seemed to and relatively low volumes.
place each player in their relative Since they are descended
space in the classic horseshoe from active units designed for
arrangement. The bass notes from use with computers this did
cello, double bass and piano were not surprise me.
quite well shaped, especially given
the size of the speaker cabinets, but CONCLUSION
unsurprisingly lacked really deep When powered by a reserved
extension. However the sound was sounding amplifier and
sprightly and quite melodic. The source, particularly a valve
treble was at least as accurately amplifier which appreciates
defined, with each breath of the two these loudspeakers' fine
flautists clearly displayed, along with sensitivity, I think Audio
odd little noises from the instru- Engine’s P4 is capable of very
ment’s mechanism. reasonable results. But the
At civilised listening levels this design emphatically does
was acceptable, but when I turned need careful pairing to avoid
the volume up only a bit, the ‘uber’ sounding a bit overblown.
definition of the high frequencies Placement on a solid piece
ceased to be as pleasant and
caused me to back off the
volume control somewhat. MEASURED PERFORMANCE
Midrange seemed a little The small Audio Engine P4 stands The P4 is dominated by raised
reserved when compared to out in a few ways. It is enormously treble output. This apart it measures
the vividness of the higher and sensitive, delivering 89dB sound well. NK
pressure level from just one nominal
lower frequencies, almost as
Watt of input, outstanding for such a
though there was a slight dip FREQUENCY RESPONSE
small loudspeaker. It will go loud from
in output around the octave 20 Watts or so and will suit small
centred on middle C. computer audio systems and such like.
This was confirmed when It also has a substantial +6dB step up
playing Blondie’s track ‘Denis’. in output above 1kHz our frequency
The rather forward nature of response analysis shows, an effect that VERDICT £
the higher midrange and treble will give it a bright or even fierce sound Engaging and enjoyable small
sounds gave Debbie Harry’s balance. So the P4 is not an accurate bookshelf speaker that faces stiff
loudspeaker by any means and there competition at the price.
voice a slightly lighter sound
appears to be little attempt to make it AUDIO ENGINE P4 £179
than I would normally expect Green - driver output
so.
to hear, making it seem a little Red - port output EcoDigital Ltd.
The narrow slot port applies broad )
two dimensional. The bright damping to the bass unit, extending +44(0) 845 0045330
production values of recordings output down to 50Hz. However, port IMPEDANCE www.ecodigital.com
from this period aggravated output was not high so although bass
FOR
the forwardness of the treble, appears to go deep for such a small
cabinet in practice this small Audio - vivid sound
letting me hear the detail of
- fine timing
tambourine and cymbal, but not Engine will only manage ‘bass’ if placed
close to a rear wall. - decent bass
integrating it with the sounds
happening below very well. Impedance was low and this is
really a 4 Ohm loudspeaker, even AGAINST
A brief foray into pre-war
though the peaks lift measured overall - treble a little sharp
jazz via LP proved a slight
impedance up to 6 Ohms. - slightly recessed midrange
disappointment. Any surface
UK SUBSCRIPTION
SAVE UP TO
12.5%
12.5
�
�
�
���
�
��
���
�
���
���
�������
�
��
���
��
���
��
��
���
������
����
�� ��
������
�������
�����
���
����
���
������
�����
���
������
�����
��
����
�
��
��������������������
���
����� ��������
�� �������
����
���
��������
�����
�����
����
�����
��
�
� ��
������
������
�����������
�����
������
�����
�����
�����
� ��
� ������ ��������������������
���� ������ ��
������
���
�����
����� ���������� �����
������
�����
��
������ ��� �����
������� �������
��
�����
���� �����
���
����
����
�����
�����
���
���������
������ ����
��� ����
���� ����
���� ���� ��������
�����
2:26
13:2
�����������
�� 1/10
����������
16/1
���������������������������������
����
���� �������
�
���������������������������
�
���� �������
�����
��
����
����
1
dd
������������� ���������� �������������������� bed
J$.in
11 sub
er JAN
FREE READER CLASSIFIED ADS IN THIS ISSUE! Fron
t Cov
��������������������������������������������������������������������������
�����������
������������������������
� ��������������������
����������� ���������
���������
������������
�����������
���������������������������������
����������������������������
��� �
������
�������������������
�������������������� �������
��������
�������������� ����������
FREE READER CLASSIFIED ADS IN THIS ISSUE!
��������������������
������������
������������
�������������� �����������
������������������
��������� ��������������������
�������������
�����������
01442 879097
���������
����������������������������������������������
�������������������������������� �����������
����������
�����������
Front Cover Oct 10 subbed.indd 1 16/8/10 14:27:43
���������������������������������
�����������������������������
������������
���������������������������������������
��������������������������������������
��������������������������������������
����������������������������������
�������������������������
�
���������
��������
�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������
����������������������
���������������������
�����������
��������� ���
�������������
������������
�������������
PLEASE CALL FOR OUR LATEST PRICES
TO WINTER BLUES
❑ XMAS OFFER BOX ❑ I would like a years subscription to
Hi-Fi World and receive a discount off the
I would like to avail of the Christmas promotional
cover price (I have read and accept the terms
offer see p59 quoting ref HFW - XMAS2010. At the
and conditions).
full subscription rate of £46.80 is applicable.
❑ Chord CobraPlus interconnect cable. ❑ 6 monthly Direct Debit: Pay £20.47 every 6
months saving 12.5% off the yearly subscription
rate of £46.80
WHY SUBSCRIBE TO HI-FI WORLD?
■ 12 issues a year delivered straight to your door. ❑ Annual Direct Debit: Pay £40.95 every 12
■ Be first to grab a bargain in our "Free Reader months saving 12.5% off the yearly subscription
Classified Ads" section. rate of £46.80
■ Run by dedicated hi-fi engineers and enthusiasts.
■ Subscribers receive a minimum 10% Discount
❑ Annual cheque/credit card: Pay £42.12
annually. saving 10% off the yearly subscription rate of
■ Hi-Fi World has become famous for its informative £46.80
reviews and radical kit designs.
■ PLUS! Subscribe by Direct Debit and receive a Cheques made payable to Audio Publishing Ltd.
12.5% discount (UK only).
Your Details
Instruction to your Bank or Building Title ____________ Forename ____________________________
Society to pay by Direct Debit
Please fill in this form and send to: Originator’s Identification Number
Surname ________________________________________
Hi-Fi World, Webscribe Ltd, PO Box
4 2 7 0 4 9
464, Berkhamsted, Herts., HP4 2UR Address ________________________________________
Name and full Postal Address of your Bank/Building Society
To: The Manager Bank/Building Society
________________________________________
Address
Postcode ________________________________________
Name(s) of Account Holder(s)
Post Code ________________________________________
Branch Sort Code
Daytime Tel: ________________________________________
Bank/Building Society Account Number
Email: _______________________________________________
Reference
HF
Instruction to your Bank or Building Society
Please pay Webscribe Ltd Direct Debits from the account in this Instruction subject to
the safeguards assured by the Direct Debit Guarantee. I understand that this Please debit my ❑ VISA ❑ MASTER ❑ MAESTRO ❑ AMEX
instruction may remain with Webscribe Ltd and, if so, details will be passed (SWITCH)
electronically to my Bank/Building Society.
Signature(s) Security No: (last three digits printed on the signature strip)
Date
Bank and Building Societies may not accept Direct Debits Instructions for some types of accounts
The guarantee should be detached and retained by the Payer
Valid from Date:_______/________ Expiry Date:_______/________
TheThe
Direct Debit
Direct DebitGuarantee
Guarantee
• �ThisThis Guarantee
Guarantee is offeredisby offered by building
all banks and all Banks and
societies that Building
accept
Societiestothat
instructions take Debits
pay Direct part in the Direct Debit scheme. The Switch card issue No:
• efficiency
If there are any changes to the amount, date or
and security of the Scheme is monitoredfrequency of your Direct
and
Debit Webscribe Ltd will notify you 10 working days in advance of your ac-
protected by your own bank or Building Society
count being debited or as otherwise agreed. If you request Webscribe Ltd to collect a payment, confirmation
� If the amounts paid or the payments dates change
of the amount and date will be given to you at the time of the request Webscribe Ltd will notify you Cardholder Signature: ___________________________________
• 10
If anworkings days
error is made in payment
in the advance of your
of your Directaccount
Debit bybeing
Webscribedebited
Ltd oror asbank
your otherwise agreed
or building society
you
� Ifareanentitled
errortoisa made
full and immediate
by Webscriberefund ofLtd
the or
amount
yourpaid fromor
Bank your bank or building
Building Society, society
you are
• guaranteed
If you receive aarefund you are not entitled to, you must pay it back when Webscribe
full and immediately refund from your branch of the amount paid Ltd asks
• You can cancel a Direct Debit at any time by simply contacting your bank or building society. Written
you to
Outside UK:-
� You
confi canmay
rmation cancel a Direct
be required. Please Debit at us.
also notify any time by writing to your Bank or Building
Society. Please send a copy of your letter to us. EUROPE Airmail £50.00
TERMS & CONDITIONS: You will receive 12 issues per year. OVERSEAS Airmail £70.00
Minimum subscription term is 12 months. Prices include P&P and are
correct at the time of going to press. All prices are quoted in sterling. Offer
available for UK subscribers, only. For enquiries relating to overseas pricing
call + 44 (0) 1442 879 097.
SUN DIAL needs to pick up a guitar. This album ‘81⁄2’ (in which a director, suffering
Sun Dial introduces a barrel load of desolate from writer's block, experiences
Headspin riffs that move from darkness to the dreams and flashbacks) and the late
Formed in 1990 and with several intense and then, bouncing between period, seventies works including the
album releases under their belt, this the pair, creates a sort of sonic rock vulgar comedy, ‘Amarcord’.
self-titled vinyl LP precedes a planned pendulum. All these films featured
CD reissue campaign of their back Check out the CD reissues via soundtracks by the composer Nino
catalogue via the Shrunken Head the group; ‘Reflector’, the band’s Rota and all are now presented in
label, so keep a look out. This album second album which here arrives this magnificent box set. Contained
reveals the band’s dirty, grungy, messy with bonus tracks plus an extra disc in a pizza-style container, the trio
rock ethics that resemble a Nirvana- of outtakes and live cuts; ‘Return of soundtracks are presented as
like vibe. Lead singer Gary Ramon Journey’ was supposed to be the individual albums within their own
provides gritty vocals to front the band’s second album but the project sleeves and incorporating their
band’s no-nonsense approach. In fact, was abandoned (these are the lost own artwork while the records
Ramon himself is an interesting figure, sessions in full plus the deluxe edition themselves are included in the
especially with his extra-curricular of the debut) and ‘Other Way Out’ national colours of Italy: one record
works with the likes of Coil and with outtakes and unreleased tracks. in white, another in red and a third
Current 93. His eclectic tastes mean in green. Like many vinyl productions
that his delivery is always interesting NINO ROTA in coloured vinyl however, this does
while his take on a lyric is imaginative. Music For Federico Fellini result in a rather noisy playback, I
To that extent, his interpretative Get Back hasten to add.
abilities of the lyrics are interesting. Federico Fellini was an iconic film Rota’s works plug directly into
Yes, they are simple but Ramon gives maker who became a friend and the contemporary culture. They can
them more legroom. ally, during the sixties in the UK, be deceptively inoffensive as in ‘La
That sense of space is not of the alternative culture, a symbol Dolce Vita’ because, despite their
provided by the music – no, the of intellectual cool and a hero for often upbeat and pastoral nature,
music itself constructs a wall of noise the aspirational film goer. His work there is often depth to be had for
– the space is only created by the spanned his neo-realist period of the the patient with disturbing angularity
lyrical constructions which are short forties and fifties in which real people inserted to keep things interesting.
and sparse, relying on repetition to were portrayed in works showing Variety is another Rota weapon
get the message across. Something poverty and harsh living conditions to with, on ‘81⁄2’, a sprawling array of
our own ex-Prime Minister, Gordon his late period neorealism including styles from European brass bands to
Brown, was a major advocate of, the then shocking ‘La Dolce Vita’ waltz-time orchestras and rock’n’roll.
incidentally. Which means that either (a journalist’s search for love and ‘Amarcord’ is wholly more intimate
Ramon has a media savvy approach happiness), his examination of dreams with solo work or small ensembles
to his song creations or Brown really during the sixties with films such as dominating. A significant box set.
THE TREE PEOPLE you immediately with a delicious perfect hair. And, of course, there
It’s My Story selection of hooks while the next were the songs. The king for the
Guerssen track on the side, ‘Sunday’, takes King just has to be ‘Viva Las Vegas’
I have to hold my hands up and you on an organic ambient journey which tends to be the hook that
admit that I’d never heard of this of flute, double bass and acoustic just about every Elvis impersonator
outfit before who hail from Oregon, guitar. And so it goes on, mixing latches themselves upon sooner or
USA. After some investigations instrumentals and vocal tracks, later.
I found that they released their throughout, in a wonderfully dreamy The principal feature of this
first album (self-titled) in 1979 manner. For those wondering what release (and the other two albums
and then followed that up with the band was up to during its listed below exhibit the same
another (‘Human Voices’) five years earlier days, you can get a flavour characteristic) is the quality of
later. I knew that teachers had by checking out the track, ‘Space the pressing. For example, playing
long holidays but this is ridiculous Heater’, which sits on Side Two the first track of this album, a
because this album is the band’s and is a remake of the track that particularly toe-tapping case of
third release – was it worth the appeared on their debut release. A the movie-derived ditties within
wait? The current incarnation series of complicated ideas simply the Elvis soundtrack fraternity, I
consists of Stephen Cohen (acoustic executed to form a magical album. heard the left-hand channel spring
guitar), Jeff Stier (flute) and Rich to life. Thinking that I’d lost the
Hinrichsen (double bass) with the ELVIS PRESLEY right speaker channel because of a
added occasional voices of Maeve Viva Las Vegas pulled speaker cable or somesuch,
Stier and Nicole Campbell. Their Music On Vinyl I began to get up from my seat
music is basically folk but it’s not Ah, the Elvis films, eh? I spent half to investigate when the King’s
as simple as that. There’s too many my life watching those things during warblings sprang from the same
tweaks in their work for them to summer holidays as a kid where right channel. Of course, there
be labelled with such a simple word. Elvis would always be called Johnny was no problem, I was, in fact,
Which is why you will see the or somesuch, take part in a few facing an example of early stereo
words ‘freak folk’, ‘psych folk’ and Bond-like action moments (racing programming which offered the star
‘alt-folk’ tagged, rather uncertainly, in a car, etc.), get into trouble, vocal performance in one speaker
to them. get out of trouble and then break and the backing track in the next.
Whatever you call them, ‘It’s My out into song during inopportune What struck me, though, was the
Story’ is a wholly engaging album moments while dreamy eyed girls total silence from this ‘dead’ channel
that, right from the off, pulls you would swoon. Then he’d get into a that lead me to believe that it was
into their head space. Beautifully bit more trouble from which he and faulty. High praise indeed! Also look
melodic, the album is both busy and his chums would have to extricate out for two additional Elvis LPs
calming in its presentation. The title themselves. He was Norman from Music On Vinyl: ‘Girls! Girls!
track, the first on Side One, grabs Wisdom with shiny teeth and Girls!’ and ‘G.I. Blues’. PR
Crystal Ball
David Price remembers Sony’s PS-8750 turntable
from 1975, one of the very first quartz locked
direct drive designs made...
I
t’s hard to overstate the signifi- evolved into what we’d recognise it
cance of turntables back in the as being today. The first
nineteen seventies. In today’s Technics SL1200 appeared
multi format world, realis- in 1972, offering direct
ing just how important the drive in a package far
humble vinyl LP was back then more affordable than
requires real contortions of the mind. the broadcast standard
We were ten years into the 1969 model SP-10,
widespread use of stereo LP in this which is where the
country, and vinyl was living through technology
in its harvest years. Sales records first appeared.
were constantly being broken (if you The race
pardon the pun), as the likes of Mike was on,
Oldfield, Pink Floyd and Electric Light during
Orchestra produced mega-selling this decade,
albums with lavish packaging, whilst for Japanese
Queen and Wings shifted hitherto manufacturers
unseen amounts of 7” singles. There to offer the technology
was a sense that vinyl had no rival; in ever more affordable products.
open reel was for studio use and By 1975, only budget Japanese
police surveillance, cassettes were turntables, such as Pioneer’s PL12, used in the
for cars and Radio 3 FM aside, radio were belt driven; quite a contrast to servo control system
wasn’t able to touch vinyl’s soaring the UK audiophile market which was of the turntable; one was the
sonics. dominated by belt driven Thorens- conventional servo and the other,
That’s why every new high end type models. switchable, was the quartz lock. The
turntable release had real significance; Sony’s 1975 range offered a latter wasn’t affected by voltage and
here perhaps was a product that twist, however. As expected, the mid temperature variations during use,
just might take us even closer to the priced PS-4750 and higher end PS- making for breathtaking wow and
original sound than anything else yet 6750 were direct driven, but sitting flutter measurements of 0.025%
devised? Because vinyl was limited right at the very top was the breath- WRMS, when generally it was said
only by the engineering precision and taking PS-8750, sporting direct drive that the ear couldn’t detect beyond
innovation of the products built to augmented by a ‘X-tal Lock’. This 0.1%.
play it, rather than some notional line was Sony-speak for what came to be The system worked by the use
of a ‘tape head’ mounted just inside
"an essay in the way the the rim of the 320mm diecast alloy
platter, with the platter’s inside rim
and precision
proved both an and finish
instant (albeit subtle) jewelled to put almost
improvement in sound and trunnion mount and every British
a great showroom sales feature. carbon fibre arm and headshell gave deck to shame.
Ironically, Sony’s implementation of it the feel of Japan’s finest cameras, Sonically, the Sony is extremely
the direct drive system in its high end when hand cueing; the lift-lower clean and open, with little in the
decks was so good that the ‘X-tal mechanism even had its own silent way of coloration right across the
Lock’ was of marginal effectiveness; motor! There was a photo-electric frequency band. It has the feel of a
the cheaper PS-6750 also gave an activated end of side auto stop, to very delicate, finessed performer,
extremely solid and pitch-accurate save the (surely very expensive) stylus with an unerringly strong and grippy
sound, but all the same the quartz on your phono cartridge, should you bass, a lovely silky high treble, and a
crystal was the crowning glory be unable to wrest it from its run out neutral, open and expansive midband.
to a turntable which - until the groove. Most PS-8750s came supplied Indeed, it’s surely one of the best
arrival of the later (and arguably with optional Sony XL55 moving coils. sounding integrated turntables, giving
inferior sounding) Biotracers, was Such finery didn’t just stop with way only to even more expensive and
the Sony Corporation’s biggest, the direct system and tonearm; the advanced machines that followed in
most expensive and best integrated deck is beautifully built from a mix its wake later, such as Kenwood’s Lo-
turntable ever. of materials; polished aluminium 7D.
The deck is an essay in the way surrounds a frame made from Sony’s It’s certainly true to say that
the Japanese could manufacture a Bulk Mold Compound material. Even the PS-8750 is a rare turntable; it’s
domestic hi-fi product like a military- the dustcover was a thing of beauty; unlikely to turn up in your local free-
grade precision instrument. The heavily smoked acrylic complete ads paper for £15. But despite its vast
torquey direct drive motor spun with an ‘anti-static’ metal grid inset £800 (in 1977) price when new, they
the platter up to speed within half – somewhat reminiscent of a heated do turn up every now and again for
a revolution, with a built-in brake rear window in a mid seventies less than the cost of a new Technics
circuit to stop the turntable quickly limousine! It’s a largish beast too, at SL1200. Due to its pedigree and
when the stop or reject buttons 458x184x395mm and heavy at 14.2kg. position in life, the PS-8750 can be
were activated. The 237mm statically All of which made for an impossibly seen as one of the true aristocrats of
balanced PUA-160S tonearm’s expensive turntable, with levels of Japanese turntables.
WorldMags
OPINION WorldMags
david
price
F
or many years, it was my computer. I found that running a USB and didn’t want to buy one until
deepest, darkest secret. I’d soundcard out into my hi-fi system, there was something I really wanted
try not to mention it in sitting with my laptop PC fairly close to watch on this much-vaunted new
polite company; I’d agonise up and in-between my Quad ESL989 format. And so it was that one of my
about when - or even loudspeakers, I could enjoy amazing all time favourite TV shows appeared
whether - to tell girls I was audio-visual sensations. By 2005, I was on Blu-ray recently. Gerry Anderson’s
dating at all. It was, you see, awfully getting seriously into DVDs, helped by Space 1999, shot on glorious 35mm
difficult to come out of the closet new Mac PowerBook with its super film, was the most expensive-to-
and confess to people who’d regard screen and glitch free video playback... make science fiction show ever
my lifestyle as bizarre. What on earth Finally I succumbed. A Sharp and a veritable visual feast, even if
would they think of me, when I men- Aquos 32” LCD telly arrived, and the slightly meandering plotlines
tioned at a party or in a pub? “Hi, my in conjunction with any number of interspersed with psychedelic dream
name’s David and I don’t have a TV”... review DVD players, I got more and sequences aren’t your thing! The
Auntie Beeb certainly found it more into the viewing experience. I’d model making was brilliant, the sets
hard to understand; she kept sending gone fifteen years without a 'box', and superb, the special effects on another
me letters telling me she was going now I was like a kid on Christmas day. level from previous Gerry Anderson
to come round and check I wasn't Repeated visits to Fopp made for a pictures.
hiding my (non-existent) television. If rapidly expanding video library, and Watching Space 1999 on Blu-ray,
I was, she said tersely, I'd get a huge a fine time was had by all. Piping my I am finally seeing the show in all its
fine from the BBC Witchfinder (or DVD sound through my hi-fi was a glory; the already impressive DVD
was that Director?) General. When I transformational experience, making version bought four years previously
simply told the TV Licensing people I the video all the more enjoyable. now seems mushy and washed out.
didn’t have a telly, they looked at me Yet still there was something Indeed, it's now strangely reminiscent
like I was Keith Richards launching a wrong; I couldn’t help thinking that of viewing the show on a quality
healthy living video... the old picture I used to get on my cathode ray tube TV like the Profeel,
The funny thing was that my eighties 14” Sony Trinitron was better. broadcast live, with sparkling colours
quality of life was really rather good. Somehow the blacks were blacker, the and amazing definition to actors
I didn’t have a TV not as a political colours more colourful, the definition faces and planet surfaces. Now I can
statement, or to dodge the licence more striking, the contrast more vivid. see that DVD via LCD TV covers
fee; instead I didn’t have a TV because This LCD panel just didn’t quite do its tracks well, not explicitly drawing
I’d moved back to the UK, set up my the business. attention to its faults, but somehow it
hi-fi and just not got round to getting Warp forward five years and I’ve just doesn’t do it like it should.
a TV. Life was nice; whereas otherwise lived with DVD for seemingly an age, This strikes me as having a
I’d be watching some twaddle on the and do like it. I now have a current fascinating parallel with listening to
goggle box, now I’d simply cue my Sony Bravia 40’ LCD TV, and this is music on hi-fi. Most folk are happy
GyroDec, pour a glass of vino, spark fed via HDMI from any number of to watch DVD on modern LCD flat
up the occasional Silk Cut and sit DVD players. I was very happy with screens having completely forgotten
back with my system, enjoying the this, until a friend of mine kindly just how good tube TVs used to
finest of times. What on earth was the donated a Sony Profeel; this is a classic be. It's only when you move to Blu-
point of forsaking an evening with my eighties cathode ray tube monitor ray that you realise what you were
original Japanese pressing of Crosby, with a brilliantly aligned Trinitron missing, as it spookily reminds you
Stills Nash and Young’s ‘Deju Vu’ for tube. It absolutely hammered my new on how fine your original viewing
the tri-weekly fix of Brookside? Well, Bravia LCD; it’s so diverting to watch, experience once was. Ditto people
quite... such is the richness of its colours, the thinking CD sounds good simply
Still, things changed. In 2003 I precision of its outlines, the stability of because they've forgotten how
clocked 24 at a friend’s house, and its motion. I suddenly realised that my sublime vinyl could sound. Only when
adored it. Whereas I’d previously beloved DVDs via LCD flat panel TVs they hear 24/96 and/or SACD do
listened to radio late into the night, weren’t quite as good as I thought... they feel some of the magic of their
now I would sometimes sit back and Just recently, I’ve gone Blu-ray. own vinyl discs again. Despite what
watch Jack Bauer blasting baddies, Yes, I know it’s a bit late in the day, the song says, things don’t always
from a DVD spinning inside my but to be honest I’m not a TV geek necessarily get better!
Inspire Hi-Fi
Presenting high class, award winning
UK built analogue equipment
And with direct sales from the manufacturer to customers there’s no retail markup saving you £££’s
Our prices are inspiring - so are our turntables!
NE
W
eclipse TURNTABLE
HI-FI WORLD £1,
999
Apollo
*
349
£2,
SE
HI-FI WORLD £94
9**
Our latest release. The Eclipse se12 for 12” arms. Offering 27%
TURNTABLE ** with 700 Arm
better tracking, delivering sound reproduction beyond compare
AND at a fraction of the cost you would pay elsewhere.
9
Example: * with 12” SME M2 Total £3149. Audio Origami PU7 £69
12” Total £4349 (dependant on arm choice). for Linn LP12 Turntables
Unit 11 / Markham Vale Environment Centre / Markham Vale / Chesterfield S44 5HY
Tel: 01246 827272 / 01246 568770 Mobile: 07932 367555 Email: robert@inspirehifi.co.uk DemoSuite
Listen to our award winning
www.inspirehifi.co.uk equipment at our Demo Suite.
Situated 1 minute from M1 J29A
Part Exchange available.
paul
rigby
M
usically, there are titles from the likes of Country Joe songs were released in Nashville and
no real surprises And The Fish (Country Joe McDonald were quickly recorded and pressed,
anymore, right? New supplies the forward to the included normally in numbers of around 100
music is trotting out book), Joan Baez and Donovan, which each. “These records were far more
well oiled and prac- are all included, but the gamut of immediate than books of the time,
ticed formulas and obscure songs from unknown artists which would often be affected by
familiar reissues merely remind us of that are sometimes disturbingly corrections and changes. Songs could
what was once exciting. Yet there are direct: ‘Claymore Polka’, ‘Khe San’, be recorded in a matter of hours
gems to be found if you – or, rather ‘Grunt’, ‘The War Keeps Draggin producing unfiltered sentiments.”
some dedicated passionate music On’, ‘Dear Mr President’ and more, Instant history, in fact.
enthusiast – takes the time and the “That has been the exciting part of This music gives you a much
effort to dig deep enough. this” said Kessing, “That there has better idea of the degree of polari-
And gems there are in one of been so much new material and so sation in the country at the time
the most impressive box sets I have many new artists. Apart from the few than many textual histories out
had the pleasure to clap my eyes commercial recordings, this body of there. Further interest is supplied
upon in many a long year. And it’s a music has been completely unknown.” on disc seven, the ‘In Country’ disc
compilation. Not the usual genre to Interestingly, the majority of which was written and recorded by
get the blood flowing. Out now via this content, the obscure songs, are the US military while they were in
Germany’s Bear Family record label studio-produced country creations Vietnam, plus two discs created by
(www.bear-family.de), ‘...Next Stop with strong emotions flowing through Vietnam veterans: non-commercial
Vietnam - The War On Record: 1961- them. With many – you might be sources that have previously been
2008’ is quite simply magnificent. surprised to hear – raging against the largely ignored. They deal with their
Arriving in a large slip case is a multi- anti-war protestors. So many of these part in the war and how they have
folding gatefold containing 13 CDs songs celebrate the American flag, been treated since they returned
plus a CD-ROM of lyrics. You also motherhood and anti-communism; back home. So, here, you’ll find songs
receive an LP-sized, hardback book a right-wing presence that is dealing with post-traumatic stress
that deserves plaudits all of its own. unexpected. In fact, this area of studio disorder, the long-term impact of the
The aim of the box is to track recording also produced ‘answer biological warfare chemical product,
the history of the Vietnam war and songs’ to well known anti-war hits. Agent Orange (e.g. grandchildren
to record the songs that were being Remember Barry McGuire’s ‘Eve born with birth defects) that are, “...
released year on year. As you can see Of Destruction’? Often seen as an both personal and completely unique.
by the dates covered, those songs anti-war ditty, there appeared, within I’m reasonably knowledgeable of
include later works that dwell on weeks, an answer song called, ‘The war-related music from WW2 but I
memories of the conflict and for Dawn of Correction’. “These records cannot find any music, and I have an
those who have fallen. represented a right-wing backlash. archive of 10,000 sheet music copies,
Hugo Keesing, the reissue Similarly, Buffy Saint-Marie’s ‘The where veterans wrote music and
producer on the project, explained Universal Soldier’, which was also a recorded them about their wartime
how he undertook his research. hit for Donovan, triggered an answer experiences.”
“By 2006, I had listened to 800-900 song called ‘The Universal Coward’ So what we have here is not just
Vietnam-related songs. As this project by Jan Berry of the popular surf guitar a jolly selection of gallows humour
has come to fruition, I have finally duo, Jan & Dean. "His partner, Dean music and doom-mongering from the
heard over 3,000. I thought that I was Torrence, thought it so right-wing likes of The Doors and Pete Seeger
pretty knowledgeable on the music of that he even refused to have his but a complete cultural record of
the Vietnam War but found that that name on the label,” said Kessing. This the ordinary people who put their
was not the case.” all appeared around 1966, when the thoughts into song; direct, affective,
The most exciting element of this support for the war was fairly high. often devastating but always riveting.
box set is not the famous, commercial The majority of the most obscure An incredible production.
steven
green
O
ver the last couple of the UK Internet (consumer ISPs only) argument’s sake, let’s say that digital
years, the DAB industry currently has a capacity of approxi- radio switchover will take place at the
heavily lobbied politicians mately 1 Tbps (equivalent to 1 million end of 2019 (I can’t see it happening
to make sure that DAB Mbps), and the BBC assumes that the before then). This would mean that
would become the ‘prima- UK Internet capacity grows at 40% the capacity of the Internet would
ry digital platform’ in the per annum (which tallies with some have increased by a factor of 1.49 =
plans for digital radio switchover. Just reports on the growth of Internet 20.7 relative to today. The current
as important to the DAB industry’s capacity I’ve read). capacity is 1Tbps, so the capacity
plans however, was that Internet radio In order to make a like-for- of the Internet at the end of 2019
be excluded from these plans as far like comparison between DAB and should be 20.7Tbps. Looking at it
as possible, because the popularity of Internet radio, it’s necessary to take another way, the peak radio audience
services such as the BBC iPlayer, last. into account the relative efficiencies of 17 million people at breakfast time
fm and Spotify indicate that Internet of the audio codecs used on each would consume just 3% of the total
audio services will pose the greatest platform. The WorldDMB Forum Internet capacity by the end of 2019.
threat to traditional radio listening in (the organisation in charge of DAB) And Digital Radio UK’s estimate
the future. has carried out a listening test which of Internet capacity would now be
The DAB industry’s method of showed that the AAC+ codec, which incorrect by a factor of 129. That’s
attacking Internet radio – on the can be and often is used for Internet one seriously dodgy calculator they’re
basis of its inability to handle mass radio streams, provides the same level using!
audiences, and its high distribution of audio quality at a bit rate of 40kbps The above figures are for fixed-
costs – is perfectly summed up in as the MP2 codec provides at 128kbps line broadband only, so they ignore
the following quote, which is taken (98% of stereo stations on DAB in the mobile reception of radio. However,
from a speech by Lisa Kerr of Digital UK use 128kbps MP2). On Internet fixed-line broadband is a good
Radio UK (an organisation set up by radio, one stream is sent per listener, platform for digital radio anyway,
the BBC and commercial radio to so the maximum number of listeners irrespective of the Internet’s mobile
promote DAB), at the ‘Radio at the that could be handled is simply the reception capabilities – 60% of all
Edge’ conference in November 2009. total capacity divided by the bit rate of radio listening takes place in the home,
“As a primary platform, [Internet each stream. Using the figure obtained and a high percentage of homes now
radio] would be hopeless. It simply from the BBC: 1Tbps/ 40kbps = 25 have Wi-Fi. It could also be argued
can’t cope with the simultaneous million listeners (this assumes the that mobile broadband technologies
levels of listening that radio demands. audio quality is the same as that used due to be rolled out over the next
For example, at 8 o’clock on a typical on DAB, which is purely to allow a five to ten years could deliver radio to
morning, there are about 17m people like-for-like comparison to be made mobile receivers anyway, but that’s a
listening to the radio. But the entire – I don’t suggest that Internet radio separate story altogether...
UK broadband infrastructure could should be degraded to DAB-quality!). Ultimately, the above calculations
only support simultaneous listening Digital Radio UK claimed that the are intended to highlight the
for about 4m of them – even if maximum number of listeners that the discrepancy between the claims
no-one was using the internet for Internet could currently handle is only made by the DAB industry about
anything else, anywhere in the country. 4 million, whereas the correct figure Internet radio when they were
And the costs would be enormous – is 25 million. Maybe they were using a lobbying politicians and the reality of
hundreds of millions of pounds a year faulty calculator? the situation once certain important
for the radio industry – and more for However, Digital Radio UK’s factors are taken into consideration.
the ISPs.” figures become even more inaccurate The only conclusion you can come
I contacted Digital Radio UK when you take the 40% per annum to is that the politicians have made
in 2009 to ask them for the figures growth in Internet capacity into important and very costly (to the tune
they’d used in their calculations, but consideration – it’s reasonable to of hundreds of millions of pounds)
I received no reply. In the last few include future growth in calculations, long-term decisions based on flawed
weeks however, I’ve obtained relevant because people will migrate to digital information. Now why doesn’t that
figures from the BBC. These are that radio over a long period of time. For surprise me?
“One of the truly special products I,ve reviewed in the past 18 years”
STEREOPHILE
SOVEREIGN DECK
“The LP12 remains a classic ...but ..upgrade kits by Origin Live can bring
“How does the Carmen perform? In a word, magnificently.......The
most musical, clean, focused and fast sounding cartridge I’ve ever a vast improvement to it’s performance” HI FI NEWS
used!......nothing but thorough musical pleasure and frequent
amazement.” “ Firmly recommended” Martin Colloms - HI FI CRITIC MAGAZINE
THE AUDIOPHILE VOICE No one would blame you for being sceptical of an easy to fit,
inexpensive dc motor upgrade. Especially one that improves on the best
“About as clean and articulate a tracker as you’re likely to experience of other power supplies costing over 4 times as much or your money
for any price—the kind of cartridge that made me forget about back. It is simply impossible to imagine the level of improvement
audiophile performance checklists and just kick back and listen for attained by eliminating the motor vibration that your stylus amplifies
pure musical enjoyment.” STEREOPHILE (on the Carmen) over 8,000 times! Our DC motor kit offers massive improvements to all
versions of Linn Lingo / Valhulla, Rega, Systemdeck, Roksan, Rock etc.
The cartridge exhibits a lower EFFECTIVE moving mass than The kits consist of a drop in replacement high grade DC motor and off-
almost all MC cartridges. Far lower. Why is that good? Because it’s board 2 speed control box. Why not order now? - see web site or phone.
easier to control. The stylus can stay in better contact with the groove
walls. If you stay in contact with the groove walls, you can hear Complete motor kits Options you can add
what’s on the record. Standard dc Motor Kit - £250 Upgrade Transformer - £185
Advanced dc Motor Kit - £339 Upgrade DC 200 motor - £129
Aladdin moving iron cartridge (mm input) £495 Ultra dc Motor Kit - £570
ORIGIN LIVE LTD
For FREE brochure on “upgrading and system Tel/Fax: +44 02380 578877
E-mail: originlive@originlive.com
philosophy” visit www.originlive.com. www.originlive.com
WorldMags
OPINION WorldMags
noel
keywood
I
love the science of nothing: went wrong of course. It's too inside and that's the amplifier I choose
it's a fiendishly counter-clever involved in the science of everything. to use today. That's what Icon Audio
approach that works deliciously, Apple engineers must get terrible have done with their MB845 amplifier:
a joke on us all in our belief headaches designing in that lot and you it's a medley of transformers, each
in complexity. I sell you the get something potentially able to reach one a fundamental design job. They are
world's most brilliant amplifier out across the universe, if only it had so difficult to build there are fewer
for £4,999.99 based on a design phi- an aerial socket, for just £400 or so I factories on this planet able to do
losophy that the less that's inside the believe. the job than there are able to make
better it is. So when David Shaw lifted I think I prefer the contrary iPhones.
the bottom plate off one of his MB845 approach adopted by enlightened And that's the beauty yet the
power amplifiers the other day there audio manufacturers that the less you difficulty in Martin Logan's XStat panel.
were few components to be seen. I use the better it will sound, because The fact that there's almost nothing
laughed. each and every component introduces there, little to see, is testament to
And just look at those lovely degradation. Then when designing the effort this company has put
Martin Logan Ethos loudspeakers in said product as you throw out yet into perfecting the electrostatic
this issue. What perfection – there's another component, sound quality transducer. Their electrostatic panels
nothing there – you can see right improves and the price can be put up! rely on unusual proprietary processes
through them for heaven's sake! And This is one of the delightful ironies developed by the company and from
that'll be £6,498 please. built into audio design, one that eludes what I have been told in the past,
By way of contrast I've just got modern day engineers – now known by Quad in particular, about the
one of those i-thingies that takes as traditional engineers – who reach difficulties of designing and building
calls from outer space, or would do for yet another silicon chip to solve electrostatics I have nothing but the
if the aerial worked properly. But it a problem. That isn't the way to do greatest admiration for Martin Logan
doesn't. No problem I thought; I know it. Just look at my shiny new iPhone: and their solution.
all about aerials and a bit of wire or stuffed with chips and it doesn't work You don't have to take my word
perhaps a longer headphone cable will well. for its sound quality. Rafael Todes,
allow me to receive telephone calls The truth is a little more who plays a Strad. in the Allegri String
in Central London. Typing "i-phone 4 complicated of course. We contributed Quartet, ran off with our review pair
tear down" into Google to find where to the valve amplifier design lexicon directly I switched them off and he
Apple have hidden the aerial socket back in the early 1990s with our confirms their rendition of violin and
brought up http://www.ifixit.com/ first 300B World Audio Design kit viola is unsurpassed and that they are
Teardown/iPhone-4-Teardown/3130/4, amplifier. The idea behind it was to use a very special loudspeaker.
plus some even more complex as few amplifying or 'active' devices The truth is a little more
descriptions on other websites, of the as possible. The place for electronic complicated with the iPhone too.
'phones internal workings... components was on the floor, not People in my area – a lot of them
All of a sudden I was glad to in the amplifier. But what actually – recently objected to a proposal for a
be working in high fidelity. I nearly happened was that we substituted phone mast to improve signal strength.
swooned at the complexity of the simplicity with complexity, it's just that The iPhone isn't as sensitive as my
thing, and that's just the bits you can it doesn't look that way. outgoing Samsung and drops calls
'see' like a gyroscope and motion You don't design anything with earlier as I walk into a steel reinforced
detectors using MEMs technology. silicon chips; all the work is done for concrete building, but at least I can play
There's a complete computer onboard you by boffins at Texas Instruments Tiddlywinks on it using an App. when
made by Samsung we are told, a and National Semiconductor; they it's impossible to reach the cosmos.
proprietary Apple design based on an even tell you how to use their bits The science of nothing runs
ARM core that first popped up in the in helpful Application Notes. What exactly counter to a lot of what we
BBC Acorn I believe. And – I knew we had to do with 300B was design grapple with today, especially mobile
it – an FM radio. But it isn't used, and build ever more complicated phones. Its simplicity is deceptive; in
probably because there's no space left transformers, including inter-stage my experience though it gives the best
for an aerial socket. driver transformers. The result was an sound quality, as Martin Logan and
This is where the modern world amplifier with almost no components Icon Audio demonstrate.
������������������������������������������������������������������
OctWld:Oct.qxd 07/10/2010 18:27 Page 1 ����������������������������������������� ���� ������������
������������������������������������������������������
���������������������������������������
������������������������� ������������������
New Naim - UnitiQute DAC & HDX HD Player A selection of Pre-owned & Ex-Dem available at www.billyvee.co.uk
Linn Unidisk SC Universal CD Player E/D (1Yr G/tee) . . . . .(3145.00) £995.00
UnitiQute Compact streamer
Linn Unidisk 1.1 Universal Player E/D (1Yr G/tee) . . . . . . .(8470.00) £1895.00
now available Linn Majik-I Integrated amplifier E/D (2Yr G/tee) . . . . . . .(1595.00) £945.00
Creek Destiny CD Player E/D (2Yr G/tee) . . . . . . . . . . . . .(1430.00) £695.00
Linn Linto Phono preamp Silver S/H (1Yr G/tee) . . . . . . . .(1180.00) £549.00
Linn Akurate 2200 Power Amp Sil. E/D (2Yr G/tee) . . . . . .(3000.00) £1550.00
Linn C5100 5 Ch Chakra Power Amp S/H (1Yr G/tee) . . . .(2200.00) £995.00
The Naim DAC - NaimUniti series and the HDX marked a turning point in Naim
Linn Artikulat 320 Speakers Dk Cherry E/D (2Yr G/tee) . . .(8250.00) £2950.00
history and delivered a stunning product line-up for the future of quality music. You
Quad 99 Preamplifier E/D (2Yr G/tee) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(799.00) £475.00
now have multi source delivery options of up to 24bit studio quality even with the
new baby UnitiQute. Splendid! Visit billyvee.co.uk for more info or come and listen.
Quad 99 Power Amplifier E/D (2Yr G/tee) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .(599.00) £349.00
adam
smith
S
o, as the spherical stylus (well, at least until your hard drive you are sat watching something on
of destiny approaches the conks out and you lose the lot!). television and a lovely song crops
runout groove in the LP of Heck, you don’t even have to buy up in the background or during
time that is ‘2010’, and the them if you don’t want to – pay £10 a title sequence. The chances of
autochanger of fate gets per month to the likes of Spotify and the programme makers telling you
ready to whip the arm off you have an almost infinite jukebox of what it is in the credits are as slim
and drop the 2011 disc on, I can’t songs at your disposal whenever and as they ever were and often the
help but wonder what the next year, wherever you want them, the latter internet draws a blank, especially
and indeed the next decade, have in thanks to the various smartphones if the music is buried somewhere
store for us in sonic and technology and digital music players with their in the programme. May I therefore
terms. In his live show that I enjoyed appropriate ‘Apps’. recommend the App that I have
recently, comedian Dara O’ Briain The story is the same when purchased that is only beaten in
made the observation that we are it comes to films and live music frequency of use on my phone
overloaded with technology and the concerts. You can buy them on video, by eBay? It’s called Shazam and it
means by which to enjoy music, films DVD or Blu-ray, you can rent them couldn’t be simpler to use – you
and entertainment generally. I have to in all of those formats, or you can simply hold the microphone up to
say, he has a point... digitally download or stream them the music playing, hit the ‘Go’ button
After all, consider for a moment over the interweb. Add in the radio and the phone records a short
the hobby that all Hi-Fi World stations available in their dozens sample and sends it off to a database
readers undoubtedly enjoy the (analogue), hundreds (DAB; well if that is probably hidden somewhere
most, namely music. If you want to you can manage to pick up a signal, on Tracey Island or one of Captain
listen to an album or track, there anyway...) or thousands (the internet) Kirk’s favourite Starbases. In a matter
are a huge number of ways that one and frankly, it’s a wonder that any of of seconds it tells you artist, title,
can go about this. If you prefer a us manage to get anything done with album and even gives you a direct
physical format, you can buy it on all these distractions at our beck and link to the iTunes store so you can
CD, certainly, but there is an ever- call. buy it there and then. Frankly, this is
increasing chance that you will be Now, as many readers how I want my technology to work
able to buy the LP; a limited edition undoubtedly realise, I am something for me and despite throwing some
one that is rather pricey possibly, but of a traditionalist. I like a physical seriously weird stuff at it, I can count
the option is there nonetheless. The format, I remain dubious over the on the fingers of one hand the times
pre-recorded cassette option seems reliability of hard drives, having it has drawn a blank. It’s brilliant and I
to have largely fallen by the wayside lost more than one load of files cannot recommend it highly enough!
but the cassette in general seems due to their failure and I still think So there we have it. Regardless
to be staging a slight comeback, so that quality can tend to take a of what you think of it all and
recording one yourself is as easy as back seat to convenience, which is what your preferred methods of
it ever was. In fact, it would appear a compromise that I am still not acquisition and reproduction are, I
that home taping didn’t actually “kill willing to make. That said, though, the don’t think there is any doubt that
music” after all – who’d have thought situation is steadily improving and it has never been easier to access
it? I can feel that it is only a matter of musical entertainment, whether
Moving further afield, if you’re time before I finally dip my toes into that be a physical album, a virtual
one of these people who aren’t all the murky water of digital music. track or even just an artist’s name.
that fussed by a physical format, Heck, you might even see some Goodness knows what 2011 and the
then there are a myriad of further musical content on my iPhone one years following it will be bringing us,
options open. Digital downloads day [I thought you didn’t approve of but all of us here at Hi-Fi World are
are becoming cheaper, more easily Apple products, Adam? Ed.]! very keen to see what materialises.
available and in increasingly higher Talking of that infuriatingly That’s for next year, though - in the
quality. It doesn’t take too much effort addictive portable device, I have meantime, I suggest you sit back, pop
to quickly develop a whole hard to say that there is one piece of on your favourite tune, maybe pour
drive full of music that offers a better music-related technology on it that a wee dram to go with it and simply
selection of tunes than most people I would find very difficult to live enjoy, because that is what it’s all
who stick to the ‘proper’ formats without. Imagine if you will that about. Merry Christmas!
vinyl section
contents
JANUARY 2011 www.hi-fiworld.co.uk
news
DOXY HALF-DOZEN
Six new releases from Doxy span blues, country and jazz.
Beginning with Ornette Coleman’s ‘Tomorrow Is The
Question’ (1959), featuring Don Cherry, Percy Heath, Red
Mitchell and Shelly Manne, this LP removed rhythm and
relied on textures to promote his own version of free jazz.
Thelonious Monk’s ‘Brilliant Corners’ (1957) is, in fact, a
brilliant album and an essential purchase for any jazz fan: it
evokes an energy and strength fused, even today, with an
unsullied approach to Monk-flavoured jazz.
ELEVATOR BATH The Angola Prisoners’ Blues – via a prison in Louisiana
Featuring left-field music which explores soundscapes, textured ambience – features detainees Robert Pete Williams, Hogman Maxey
and the downright weird, Elevator Bath (www.elevatorbath.com) has an and Guitar Welch. Recorded in 1959, the album features
interesting suite of limited edition vinyl picture discs on offer. Each, supplied in songs like ‘Electric Chair Blues’ and ‘I’m Gonna Leave You
a plastic cover, features artwork created by the LP’s own creator, giving you a Mamma’. Also look out for a Hank Williams trio: ‘Nashville
sense of the visual as well as the aural. They include Dale Lloyd’s ‘Akasha For Sessions’ (1949-1952; demos plus rare radio cuts);
Record’ a drone-based field of ambience that incorporates found sounds; Matt ‘Shrevport Sessions’ (1948-1949, Louisiana Hayride radio
Shoemaker’s ‘Isolated Agent/Stranding Behaviour’ which investigates a feedback recordings) and ‘Montgomery’ (1939-1949; demos and
world of noise set within a fractured setting, plus Keith Berry’s ‘The Cartesian radio recordings).
Plane’, a haunting emptiness, a void on wax.
CHERRY PICKINGS
Three LPs from the Cherry Red stable. Judging by the sleeve art,
you might be fooled in thinking that this first album features a
late-sixties psychedelic band musing groovy thoughts when it is,
in fact, the post-punk indie outfit from the eighties and nineties,
Teenage Filmstars. Their 1992 debut, ‘Star’, on Creation will be
welcomed by any My Bloody Valentine fan.
Next? The Times’ ‘Pop Goes Art’ (1981). An album that was,
in fact, a release from an earlier incarnation of the Teenage Filmstars: a glorious pop frenzy. Finally, Teenage Jesus And The
Jerks’ ‘Shut Up And Bleed’ were a no wave, post-punk outfit from New York, featuring the legendary Lydia Lunch. Noise was
their friend and this collection (the band never released a full length album) is packed with 7” rarities, EP tracks and live works.
ECLECTICISM
Taking the word ‘variety’ and skipping through the daisies with it, Music On
Vinyl’s (www.musiconvinyl.com) latest releases include the Manic Street
Preachers’ ‘Know Your Enemy’ (1991), an LP that attempted to re-create their
political and dissenting personality. The Afghan Whigs’ ‘1965’ (2001) proved to
be their first release on the Columbia label but the last album for this soul-
infused indie band – it was a cracking way to exit, though.
SPV DUO
Two new vinyl releases from
the German-based SPV label
Gov’t Mule’s ‘Déjà Voodoo’ (2004) gave new life to this rocking roots-based includes the incomparable
band with their effective blues crunching guitars and power riffs and more Zodiac Mindwarp & The Love
mature lyrics while extreme rockers, ‘Alice In Chains’ (1996), and neo-soul Reaction’s rocking ‘We Are
man, Maxwell (1997), both offer ‘MTV Unplugged’ fare. Then there’s Jay-Z’s Volsung’ which is scornful of
‘Reasonable Doubt’, a special edition that also includes a limited bonus 10” life in general, dark and heavy.
disc featuring the track, ‘I Can’t Knock The Hustle (Fool’s Paradise Remixes)’.
...AND FINALLY
This issue’s end piece includes The Gipsy Kings’ self-titled masterpiece (Audio Fidelity; www.audiofi-
delity.net) which is notable for the best rendition of ‘A Mi Manera’ – or ‘My Way’ – this side of Frank
Sinatra. An excellently mastered edition. Next is Ray Charles’ ‘The Great Ray Charles’ (Atlantic), an
instrumental selection that sees Charles as a jazz pianist. This is a welcome change from the usual soul-
man explorations. The Sword’s new album, ‘Warp Riders’ (Kemado; www.kemado.com, which includes a
download MP3 card) is gracious, a stoner rocking concept album! It’s all rather SF and epic and, despite
it not being the best release of the year, shows ongoing progress for this relatively new band. Kohoutek’s
‘Losslessloss’ (Prophase; www.myspace.com/prophasemusic) offers improv rock with guitar heroics and
electronic weirdness with vocals that often seem part of the instrumentation. Mastered by Ray Staff,
who handles the Pure Pleasure audiophile albums, Jim Guthrie’s album from 2003, ‘Now, More Than Ever’
(3 Syllables; www.myspace.com/3syllablesrecords) takes a sweeping pop ethic with string attachments,
surrounded with a downbeat vibe but a thread of genius that runs through the entire project. Finally,
Erland And The Carnival’s self-titled album (Static Caravan; www.staticcaravan.org) brings a modern twist
to folk rock with a English eccentricity that resembles The Kink’s Ray Davies with a straw hat and a
further strand hanging from the corner of his mouth.
Point Source
Rafael Todes reports on the legacy left by the late
Tom Fletcher, in the striking shape of the
Fletcher Audio Omega Point 5...
I
f this sounds more like an maintain momentum, nothing more.
obituary than a review, I apolo- It has the same eccentric lack of an
gise, but the Fletcher Audio on and off switch. To switch on, you
Omega is the product of Tom give the platter a ‘push’, to switch off,
Fletcher’s (formerly the design- you manually brake it. A similar set
er and owner of Nottingham of bands circumnavigate the platter
Analogue) final few years of work, as with the Hyperspace to damp
and is as such the crowning legacy of the ‘ringing’. A small felt mat sits on
a highly innovative career. Tom died top of the platter – the Hyperspace lesser known
earlier in October from cancer aged sees the record touching the platter one) on Philips
72, following a fight of several years. directly. There is a curious piece of (6707 020), I was
Having left Nottingham Analogue, he rubber which looks like a rat’s tail, immediately aware of
forged a partnership with his former which brushes the underside of the soundstage opening
Danish distributor to form Fletcher the platter during rotation, which up massively. It was always fairly
Audio, and to realise the fruits of the according to the designer assists with grand with the Hyperspace, but this
work he had begun around the time phase issues. The three adjustable took the performance space to epic
when his illness started. feet and armboard are made with dimensions. The separation between
As you might expect considering Acetal (Polyoxymethylene - POM). instruments was more clearly defined,
his previous work, the Omega Point A secondary armboard can also be creating a believable sonic image that
5 has visually as well as aurally fitted. turned my living room into a concert
Nottingham Analogue DNA. Tom The deck was supplied with the hall. After sampling this spacial feat, it
Fletcher had a fascination with how Fletcher Zero arm, which is a hybrid may be difficult to return to a more
different materials sounded. In the design said to “combine the sonic compact space I fear!
Hyperspace he used a combination of attributes of a unipivot and a gimbal Next up was the early Bernstein
alloy and graphite for the platter and bearing arm” and retails at around recording of ‘Rhapsody in Blue’, with
MDF for the plinth. In the Omega two thousand pounds. It has a highly the Columbia Symphony Orchestra,
Point 5, there is less mass, but the original anti-skate mechanism, which conducted from the Piano by
chosen material is a hardwood of works like a rubber band on a balsa Bernstein (CBS60135). The piano had
some description for the plinth and wood plane propeller and is operated a rock-steadiness to it; it made me
the same material for the body of by rotating a screw at the highest think that Steinways have changed
the turntable, which looks like a half- point of the arm, to add compen- since the nineteen fifties, the sound
moon. The platter is weighty (10.5kg satory rotational force. There's an was more mellow, less brittle than
and 59mm thick) and made of an SME V-like screw for adjusting VTA today, but utterly convincing. The
aluminium alloy. It has a sacrificial on the fly. There is a “lite” version brass was more extremely located
bearing made of this, the Point 3 which has a less to the right than I am used to on
of phosphor substantial platter and retails at the Hyperspace, there was more
bronze with £2,599. In the New Year, the entry- interplay between the orchestral
a stainless level Point 1 is scheduled for release sections, and seemingly greater
steel pin at around £1,500. distances between the instrumental
– the soft sections too. How convincingly this
material will SOUND QUALITY turntable creates space is almost like
‘wear’ into One of the attractions that drew me a magician’s trick.
shape – and to the Hyperspace is the sense of air I did notice on the downside
should last an and space it creates for the music. that the ‘weight’ of the string
estimated twenty It is a sound that appears as if from section is more substantial with
years. a cloud. How would this new opus the Hyperspace; in its quest to
The motor is a similar type fare by comparison? Well, the Omega achieve ultimate airiness, there are
to the Hyperspace, and is Point 5 took less than a couple of inevitably casualties. The Omega 0.5
connected by a substantial seconds to declare its hand. Listening does, however, have its half-brother’s
silicone band. Fletcher believed to the opening of the Mozart ability not to make heavy weather
that it should be powerful enough to Sinfonia Concertante for Winds, (the of anything, it never gets bogged
down in rhythms and is never leaden- Coleman Hawkins and Red Allen, I to tell this melancholic tale. Isn’t that
footed; it bounces and springs along was instantly struck by how amazing the point of it all, to get to the heart
and often I found myself smiling at its this recording is. The instruments are of the music, and open the window
jollity! humongous in the room, the energy, to the performer’s communing with
Tom Fletcher was a great music communication and spontaneity the the composer?
lover, and the two areas he was most musicians generate stopped me in my Raymond Leppard’s recording
interested in were classical and jazz. tracks. You have the illusion of being (Philips 6747 166) of the Bach
Turning to the 1958 recording of bathed in their sound. The piano Brandenburg Concertos provide
‘High Standards’ (JASS Records), sounded, like the previous recording, for some interesting insight. In
utterly solid, not at all honky-tonk, the 3rd concerto, there are some
and mellow. The double bass just beautifully sculpted spacial effects
sounded right; not exaggerated, not written by Bach; you hear a cellular
showing off or sticking out, it was unit being passed through the band,
integrated to the correct degree like a decanter of port being passed
– taut and tight, never bloated. clockwise with every
Listening to Sir Clifford solo instrument
Curzon’s recording of the Schubert having his or her say,
Impromptus (Decca Jubilee JB140, virtually locatable
the Ab op 142 No2), a recording I in space. There is
had previously written off for its odd an evenness and
timbre, suddenly made perfect sense. excitement created
It is Schubert at his most tender, by its precision. It’s
soul-searching and poignant; the an old-fashioned way
Omega expounds the microdynamics of playing Bach which
perfectly, showing the extraordinary you don’t hear these
range of colours that Curzon uses days since the period/
VITAL STATISTICS
Thickness of platter: 59mm
Diameter of platter: 300mm
Weight of platter: 10.5kg
Width of plinth : 525mm
Depth of plinth: 370mm
Overall height of TT and plinth: 185mm
Height of TT without plinth: 145mm
original instruments took over, but is massive, highly creative and original more ‘organic’ nature the sound has
not without its charms! collection of orchestral colour, I miss over the Hyperspace, and so many
In the same set, there is a the incision that I remember from other turntables I’ve heard.
recording of Brandenburg no 5, with the combination of the Hyperspace
solo harpsichord, violin and flute, I and the SME V, or even better Len VERDICT
had a feeling that the turntable was Gregory’s Conductor, an air-bearing CONCLUSION Superb high end turntable with a
lifetime’s design expertise contained
really 'on song', as it documents parallel tracking tonearm. With both This turntable represents the final within. A fitting testament to the late
the interaction between the solo of these arms on the Hyperspace chapter in a life’s quest for the Tom Fletcher.
trio and the orchestra. When you there is more grunt to the bass designer Tom Fletcher. Right from his FLETCHER AUDIO OMEGA
go to a live concert, you don’t just section, the bite of the beginning work on the Dias decks of the late POINT 5 £3,699
hear instruments playing, the most of the attack of the sound when nineteen seventies, he was obsessed
Fletcher Audio
compelling thing is to feel the forces the fugue starts. It’s almost as if the with the quest for a transparent, )
+45 60 45 28 90
airy sound, and finding the heart
"it bounces and springs along, and soul of the music he loved. He
was not a marketing man and didn’t
www.fletcheraudio.co.uk
FOR
and often I found myself play the game necessary for market
domination. Instead, his success was
- naturally musical
- organic tonality
Swing-ometer
Tony Bolton gets down to the beat with Origin Live’s
Aladdin moving coil cartridge...
O
ver its twenty-four year SOUND QUALITY
existence Origin Live I did the running in
has introduced products and most of the
that encompass most of listening using
the audio replay system, the Hadcock
from arms and turntables 242 Cryo
through to loudspeakers and cables. arm on the
One of the few missing links in the Sondek,
chain has been the lack of an in- which
house pickup cartridge – until now. sports an
Founder Mark Baker commissioned Origin
Peter Lederman of Soundsmith in Live DC
the USA to create a special model power
purely for Origin Live. The result is supply. The
the Aladdin, a Moving Iron design that Aladdin’s signal was
combines design elements from two fed into a Luxman
of Soundsmith’s own range. E200 phono stage
Based around the Carmen model and through the
but using an energy management Bent Audio TAP-X
system, found on the range topping and bi-amped Quad
Sussurro cartridge, which controls 303s to my Kelly
the dissipation of energy travelling up KT3s. The MusicMaker
the cantilever, the Aladdin is housed lll (£725) is usually resident
in a blue body made of a material here, so I felt this was the ideal
that Peter described as “a Dupont place to start listening. One of the
material - similar to Corian”. There things that I have always loved about
is a gold coloured bar that runs the MusicMaker lll is its ability to
across the front and leading edges of transmit not just an accurate rhythm, this
the body just below the mounting but to do it with a certain subliminal propulsive
block. This both helps to damp energy that makes the sound foundation the midrange had an
resonances in the already pretty inert quite invigorating. Moving magnets equally well shaped framework
body, add a little mass and provide generally do a similar thing, but, for in which to hang the rasp of
a secure location point for the me, in a somehow slightly less sophis- saxophones or the reserved sound of
mounting screws. ticated way. The moving iron designs muted trumpets. A joyous few hours,
Internally the Aladdin utilises that I have tried tend to have a more in which I played and enjoyed the
the moving iron principle for its sinuous nature when required, and tunes for the music’s sake without
generator. In this design both the seem to delight in sonic fireworks. worrying about the high fidelity
magnet and coils are stationary, The Aladdin proved no exception aspects of the sound.
whilst a small piece of ferrous to this, and I found myself working The following night I was still
metal, usually iron, attached to the my way through quite an acreage playing dance music, but of the
cantilever, moves within the magnetic of jazz LPs and thoroughly enjoying
field and produces a signal within the the drive, pace and snap to the beat
coils. This has the advantage of being imparted by this device. The records
able to be engineered with a very varied in age from the nineteen fifties
low moving mass - in this case the onwards, although the majority of the
moving mass is claimed to be lower recordings were from that decade
than that of a lot of moving coils - and earlier. The Aladdin seemed
which should help tracking ability and unphased by such old material,
reduce record wear. Output is high producing a smooth and tonally rich
enough to drive any moving magnet sound from both mono and stereo
phono stage easily. In this case it grooves alike.
was adequate, seeming to output Along with its ‘romp along’
less power than my MusicMaker lll nature, I found the bass had a
Moving Iron unit, so requiring a small pleasingly full bodied and slightly
rotation of the volume control to round sound that proved easy to
compensate. listen to and very satisfying. Above
MEASURED PERFORMANCE
There was a large 1.7dB difference in twice as much.
output level between the channels of The Origin Live Aladdin from
this cartridge, suggesting a difference Soundsmith did not measure especially
left or right before moving in coil turns. Supporting this, the well by today's standards. NK
it around the area like a lower output channel (yellow) had
demented, electronically a flatter frequency response due to Tracking force 1.4gms
synthesised bee. reduced generator loss than the high Weight 6.8gms
Subsequent listening output channel (green), differences Vertical tracking angle 27degrees
erred more towards the being equalised in our analysis so the Frequency response 20Hz - 6kHz
classical and culminated in channels can be easily compared. Both Channel separation 24dB
Mahler’s epic Symphony No.2 channels exhibit falling high frequency Tracking ability (300Hz)
‘The Resurrection’. The 4th output, sufficient to soften the sound lateral 63µm
and give a warm tonal balance. Inner vertical 45µm
movement of this is probably
groove tracing loss (red) was not great. lateral (1kHz) 16cms/sec.
the best known, having been Tracking was good at 300Hz Distortion (45µm)
used as one of the major but fair at 1kHz. Tracking force was lateral 2%
themes in Visconti’s film, ‘Death set to 1.5gms for this result, as the vertical 3.4%
In Venice’, however I love the recommended 1.4gms is too low for Output (5cms/sec rms) 3.5mV
5th movement, starting with its a low-ish compliance hinge. There
growling basses, incorporating, was visible triangulation of sine wave
to start with very quietly, the test tones, caused by third harmonic FREQUENCY RESPONSE
chorus, and gradually building distortion, and lateral distortion
up and down again until it measured 2%, double the usual 1% or
so from second harmonic, not a good
finishes with full orchestra
result. Distortion on vertical modulation
and chorus combined. It is was fair, being determined by a vertical
a complex piece and can tracking angle of 27degrees, a little high
be demanding on both the but this is not unusual.
tracking and staging abilities of Output was low at 3.5mV at 5cms/
a cartridge. This one made a sec rms; modern Ortofons manage
good job of it. The MusicMaker
Supersize Me
The twelve inch supporters club will cheer the arrival of Inspire Hi-
Fi’s Eclipse SEv2 12 turntable, fitted with matching extra long Audio
Origami PU7 tonearm. Tony Bolton stretches out in front of it...
A
lthough only in existence into SEv2 format. These include the Master
for twenty months, bearing, spindle shaft and subplatter Solution,
Inspire Hi-Fi have estab- now being machined from one billet swapped
lished themselves as of stainless steel (previously the the decks
a producer of highly subplatter was of aluminium with the over on the wall shelf,
regarded and finely engi- spindle bonded in) and further use of plugged the pickup lead into the
neered turntables. Adam Smith stainless steel in the mass loading to Leema Acoustics Agena phonostage
favourably reviewed the Eclipse deck the acrylic platter. and settled down to listen.
in the September 2009 issue of Hi-Fi Some other features have been
World. This model was equipped with carried over from the previous SOUND QUALITY
Inspire’s own take on the 9 inch Rega model, notably the Sorbothane feet Although the phrase, “from the
RB1000 tonearm. Since that review, under the lower plinth, and the moment the needle hit the groove....”
Robert Isherwood, founder and cone feet supporting the upper has been done to death in magazines
managing director of the company, plinth, with their built in Sorbothane over the years, for once I’m tempted
has been busy developing the Eclipse ‘shock absorbers’. The points of the to repeat it. Playing a 1950s HMV
SEv2 12 you see here. cones rest in little recesses in the copy of ‘Ella Fitzgerald Sings the
As the name suggests, the SEv2 lower plinth and seem very effective Rogers and Hart Song Book’ (let’s
12 is designed to take 12 inch long in isolating the unit from external just say although it looks to be in
tonearms, and Inspire offer a range of disturbances. I briefly tested this, by quite good condition the inner tracks
choices, including the SME V12, SME placing the turntable on a lightweight can get a little edgy in a couple of
M212 and the Audio Origami PU7 table, with the needle resting in the places), I was immediately impressed
fitted to this example (armboards groove of a stationary record, and with the lack of grain and general
to fit any other suitable length arm even with the volume turned up spaciousness of the sound. Although
can be made on request.) The other quite a lot, there was no sound of a couple of noises did catch it out in
main option included in this package disturbance through the speakers the inner grooves, even here there
was the outboard power supply unit. despite some moderately heavy was a sense of separation and clarity
This costs £350 if bought separately, footfalls quite near to the deck. that I am not used to hearing on this
but only £250 if ordered with the As well as paying a great deal of particular pressing. The instructions
turntable. An optional lid is available attention to the engineering of this advise at least twenty hours of use
for £150. record player, the same level of care to run the SEv2 12 in properly, so
Since Adam’s review various has obviously gone into the fit and this I did, and returned to the Ella
‘under the bonnet’ changes have also finish of the various components. recording as a reference point...
been made to develop the Eclipse From the precisely machined detailing The second time around, I
of the alloy armboard to the mirror felt that the essential character of
finish polish on all of the black acrylic, a smooth, spacious, detailed and
and the exquisitely finished record well balanced sound had remained
weight, I found the deck difficult to unaltered, but the subtle detailing
fault. The overall effect was topped that separates the good from the
off with the superbly presented, very good had begun to show
and equally well engineered Audio through.
Origami PU7 tonearm; the mixture I think subtle is an appropriate
of chrome, polished to the point that word for this deck and arm
it looked almost liquid, gleaming gloss combination. Some players try to
black, and some deceptively simple impress with cavernous bass upon
looking designs in both arm and deck, which the higher frequencies teeter
complementing each other perfectly. in an ungainly manner, whilst at the
Assembly and setup were very other extreme there are those that
easy. The deck arrived semi complete, are more focused on midrange and
needing just the two plinths placing treble detail, often at the expense of
together and the belt and platters rhythmic drive.
putting on – with two drops of the The Eclipse seemed to do
supplied oil added to the bearing neither. Bass was deep, agile and well
housing. I transferred the Benz formed, and although not the fastest
Micro Wood SL from the Clearaudio that I have heard, possessed enough
bounce
to get the
feet moving, and
enough unforced depth to be
satisfying. Twenty hours in, and the
timing seemed a little tighter, adding
a certain snap to the gently swinging
dance rhythms of ‘Manhattan’ that
moved its sense of rhythm from
being something that left
the listener static, to one
that made dancing a consid-
eration.
Keeping the sounds a I find
little jazz influenced, I next played myself left with
‘Mack The Knife’ on a 1964 Atlantic keyboards, one slight dilemma, which is
pressing of ‘The Bobby Darin Story’. bass and where to attribute this impressive
In better condition than the Ella drums were easily and accurately performance. The cleanliness of the
record, but still not in the first flush described in front of me. The stereo sound, especially when playing the
of youth, this forty six year old spread was both wide and deep, inner grooves of a record, owes a
piece of vinyl belied its age with extending well beyond the speakers, lot to the superior arm geometry
minimal extraneous noises and a and seemingly through the wall and inherent in the 12 inch design.
soundstage that seemed to be just into the driveway. The performers Tracking error is hugely reduced,
there, occupying a believable amount appeared to be realistically spaced and here the example was very
of space in front of me. Although and sized and the whole effect obvious. However, any arm, no matter
a mono pressing, the openness was quite convincing. Playing a how good, will fail to perform well
and depth of the soundstage was mint condition record, the music
impressive, but again without seeming emerged from an impressively dark
to be overblown and towering over background, instruments and voices
the listener. flowing with a convincing conviviality.
Moving to stereo and modern The last record that I played
recordings, I played the Fleet Foxes' before writing this was the 1959
eponymous LP from 2008. This was stereo Decca recording of Curzon
the Seattle based folk band’s debut playing Greig’s Piano Concerto. This
LP, and caught my attention when is one of my favourite performances
I first heard it at a friend’s house of this piece and I found myself
with its combination of late sixties immersed in it from the first distant
West Coast styling and harmonies. rumble of the kettle drums, through
Imagine the vocal blending of the to the final hard struck chords.
Beach Boys or the Vogues, combined The sound felt natural and easy,
with the more balladic sides of impressive and intimate by turns,
Jefferson Airplane and you get the leaving me to resist the urge to play
idea. The combination of electric and yet one more track before sitting
acoustic guitars, occasional mandolin, down at the keyboard.
WorldMags
Revox , vgc boxed 99 Unison Research Unico hybrid Integrated, vgc 499 PS Audio Quintessence, as new boxed 499 Rega Saturn, Cursa 3, Exon 3s, excellent Call
VINYL SECTION WorldMags
if mounted on a poorly optional power supply.
designed or unsympathet- I found reaching behind
ically chosen deck, and here either annoying and
I think the combination of occasionally awkward and
the two are both mechan- would prefer to see this
ically and aesthetically very rather essential control at
well matched. the front.
Both are subtle self
effacing performers, that CONCLUSION
don’t try to impress but I would recommend this
reward the listener with 12" turntable and tonearm
a flowing, natural sound. combination to anyone
Part of this is the effortless wanting a simple to set
depiction of scale in the up record playing system
music, whether it is a solo that doesn’t need constant
voice with a mandolin, or a tweaking, sounds lovely, and
full orchestra and piano. At looks beautiful. The optional
no time was there a feeling power supply is worth
AUDIO ORIGAMI PU7-12 of showing off in the sound, having, bringing a little
This 12 inch tonearm is the long version of
rather a well balanced perkiness to the timing.
Audio Origami’s PU7 which won Best Arm
presentation that seemed Overall, a well thought out
in our 2007 Awards (Hi-Fi World January
to spread its favours evenly and executed design from VERDICT £
2008). There is a price differential of £350 Finely engineered, smooth and
over the frequency range Inspire Hi-Fi that can hold detailed sounding deck offering great
between the two arms, meaning the 12inch
in a smooth and detailed its head high even in the twelve inch tonearm compatibility.
model costs £1,999 with the standard bead
manner. The only real super competitive world of
blasted and anodised finish. This is avail- INSPIRE ECLIPSE
quibble is over the practi- £2,000-plus turntables.
able in pretty much any colour that you can SEV2 12 £2,349
calities of siting the power
think of - the company’s website shows, Inspire Hi-Fi
switch at )
amongst others, a pink example, and they +44(0) 1246 827272
the back of
have also made arms in the colours of both www.inspirehifi.co.uk
both the
Watford and Sunderland Football Clubs no
turntable FOR
less! The internal wiring is Cardas 33GA
and the - well timed & detailed bass
although there is the option of a Kondo
- three dimensional imaging
loom for an extra £350, as fitted to this
- 12” tonearm capability
example. The chrome plated finish cost an
- fit and finish
extra £1,000 (gold is also available for the
same price) resulting in this particular arm
AGAINST
costing £3,349. It's expensive, but the fin-
- power switch location
ish is stunning by any standards.
- faces stiff competition
The acoustic-foam filled arm tube
itself is made of aircraft grade aluminium
or brass, as is the bell housing in which
the bearings sit. The chosen arm mass
MEASURED PERFORMANCE
and, occasionally, finish dictate material The first bending mode of the
choice. The bespoke nature of these arms supplied 12in Audio Origami arm was Speed accuracy no error
surprisingly well damped; it is hardly Wow & flutter 0.285%
is demonstrated by the fact that the mass
visible in our accelerometer vibration Wow & flutter (IEC weighted) 0.088%
of the arm can, if required, be fine tuned analysis. The high (0.2g) but narrow
to match a certain cartridge. Designer and peak at 900Hz is likely the common
maker John Nilsen tells me that each arm ARM VIBRATION
third order bending mode but there is
takes about one hundred and sixty hours little energy in it, so colouration will be 12in Audio Origami
to make, and that certain other tweaks are minimal. The basic excellent stiffness Arm vibration behaviour
0.3
available dependent on the purchaser’s and good damping of the arm at low
choice of cartridge and deck. The head- frequencies and across the midband Accel.
suggests firm bass, good dynamics (g)
shell, also of aircraft grade aluminium, is
and excellent stereo staging. The small 0.2
described as a push fit into the arm tube
energy plateau from 900Hz up to 2kHz
- using approximately half a ton of pres-
may add a tad of character, but it may Main arm
sure on a 10 ton press in the factory! The well be undetectable. Above 2kHz the 0.1 tube mode
arm sits in four, 7 ball-race bearings that arm is again remarkably clean and will
I
are mounted within a twisted cage rather likely have smooth, stable treble.
than the more conventional crown mount- The turntable span at exactly 0
ing. These are very finely toleranced to the right speed; there was no error. 15Hz frequency (Hz) 6kHz
within a few microns. On the other side of All the same, there was some low
this sits the counterweight – brass for the rate cyclic wow at the rotational WOW & FLUTTER
plated arms, stainless steel for the ano- frequency of 0.55Hz even though the
dised models, on a stub connected to the disc was centred, giving the 0.285%
IEC Lin (unwtd) wow value seen in
armtube by a sleeve. Mounting is by either
our analysis. This resulted in an IEC
a 23mm Rega mount or a 30mm Linn one. weighted value of 0.88% which is good,
but not exceptional.
The Inspire Eclipse se12 with Audio
Origami 12in arm should give a fine
sound. It measures well. NK
R E P R O D U C T I O N
Q U A L I T Y H I G H F I D E L I T Y & V I N TA G E
AMPLIFIERS TURNTABLES
Audio Research M300 MKII monoblocs boxed £2295 Acos Lustre GST1 tonearm boxed mint £125
Audiolab 8000Q british built mint boxed £395 Ariston RD11 turntable with Audio Technica tonearm £195
Audiolab 8000M (x2) british built mint boxed Each £395 Audio Synthesis moving coil phono stage
AMR 77 integrated ampTitanium finish flightcased x dem £3995 with 2 box PSU £595
Anatek monoblocs £2400 new £995 Clearaudio Victory cartridge £1000 new £445
Ayre K-1 XE pre amplifier £3395 Clearaudio Master Reference with parallel
Ayre K-5 XE pre amplifier £1295 tracking tonearm £POA
Conrad Johnson Premier Eleven 6550 valves Cyrus EQ7 phonostage £345
(re-valved with 6550 valves boxed £1495 EAR 834P mm/mc with volume £695
Croft integrated valve amp EL34 with valve phonostage £495 EAR 324 phonostage £2295
Croft micro25 valve pre amplifier with phonostage 6mths old £495 Garrard 301 £695
Cyrus 7 integrated amp £345 Graham silver tonearm lead new £750 £395
Cyrus PSXR boxed £295 Linn Lingo power supply £445
Cambridge Audio P50 mint condition £95 Linn LP12 variious from £445
Golden Tube SEP2 valve pre amplifer £495 Linn Ittok tonearm mint condition £295
Hoveland pre amp with phono stage & EL34 power amp £POA Linn Sondek various from £495
Leema Pulse intergrated amp xdem with warranty £595 Leema Agena Hi-End phonostage with USB &
Leak TL12+ rare hammered paint finish 1961 £POA DAC various cartridge setup option as
Leak Stereo 20 mint condition £495 new £3000 3mths old £2250
Leak Stereo 70 integrated amp £95 Leak early 60's tonearm £95
Lyra Dorian Cartridge £345
Linn Aktive amp module £65 Michell Odyssey No.39 of the Limited Edition of
Linn Classik all in one CD, radio, amp boxed mint £495 the 100 made with Techno Arm N/C PSU mint boxed £POA
Marantz PM8200 integrated amp, £395 new boxed mint £275 Michell Mycro £295
Meridian 100 series pre amp £95 Michell Hydraulic Transcriptor from £495
Mission 776/777 pre and power amplifier 100w cast Michell Focus 1 £295
case work a real classic £795 Mission 774 tonearm £175
Musical Fidelity A1001 Class A super integrated Moon LP3 phonostage £375
amp seriously powerful amplifier £895 Nottingham Analogue Horizon with Origin Live
Musical Fidelity A1 MKII excellent condition £245 motor and speed control fitted with latest model £495
Musical Fidelity A100 50watt Class A amp with Project Tube Box II £195
superb phono stage £395 Rega Planner 2 no tonearm £85
NAD model 60 integrated with VU power meters classic £175 Rega turntables various from £245
Naim 90.3 power amp boxed £225 Rega P5 turntable no arm with outboard PSU £245
Naim Flatcap mint boxed £275 Revox B790 direct drive turntable with linear
Naim 62 pre amp £195 tracking tonearm excellent condition various from £245
Naim 250 power various from £445 SME IIII tonearm £895
Naim Snaps PSU £145 SME 10 with tonearm with V £3295
Naim NAC 145 £145 SME 3009 tonearm series II improved with
PS Audio IV pre amp with separate PSU £195 phonoplugs boxed £225
Quad 2 mono blocs mint original valves £795 SME series 3 tonearms various from £175
Quad 303 power amp last version with IEC sockets £225 System Deck electronic £245
Quad 50E mono bloc excellent condition (pair) £295 System Deck II biscuit tin model (SME mount) £245
Radford ST25 MKIII power amp £1195 Technics SL1200 MKII £195
Ranaissance music re-performance moving coil Thorens TD166 MKII £95
phono stage with external PSU (new £1795) £895 Thorens 125 MKII Turntable £195
Rega Mira integrated amp remote boxed mint £350 Trichord Dino phonostage 6mths old £295
Rogue Audio Atlas EL34 power amplifer 40w per channel £795
Roksan Kandy 3 integrated amp black boxed as new £395 CD PLAYERS, DACs
Sugden Audition -P power amp £345 AKAI 93 Hi-End old school 16bit CD player £395
Sugden Optima 140 integrated amp £245 CEC 3300R CD player £375
Sugden Masterclass remote pre amp with Chord DAC 64 boxed mint £895
balanced facilities mint boxed £995 Cyrus DAC Master £195
Sonneteer Sedley adjustable MM/MC phonostage £275 Cyrus 8 CD player £295
Technics SU9600 top of the range stereo control Consanance CD120 £295
centre & also SE9600 stereo power amplifier a pair £595 DCS upsampler great upgrade for plugging
into external dac boxed £695
Yamaha natural sound stereo receiver model Leema Stream CD player £695
CR420 mint condition £175 Linn Mimik £245
Linn Numeric DAC £295
SPEAKERS Marantz 63 MKII KI Signature £195
Aurum Cantus black orchid speakers piano black £495 Marantz CD10 heavy weight player mint boxed £495
Acoustic Energy AE1 stands £195 MicroMega Drive transport £195
Alphason Artemis 100 £245 MicroMega Drive DAC 1 balanced outputs AES input £175
ATC SCM19 £995 MicroMega CD132 cd player silver finish £395
ATC Active 50 £POA Moon CD player Equinox RS boxed as new £2000 £1195
ATC Active 10 £1195 MHZS model 66 top loading valve output cd
AVI Active Pro 9 speakers Rosewood finish x dem £795 player Sony mechanism and laser £395
Castle Howard 2 Oak finish £495 Nakamichi CD player 2 £175
Celestion DL4 £95 Quad 99 CDP CD player £495
Beauhorn Virtuoso reference lowther £2995 Rotel RA965 BX classic old school cd player
Cyrus CLS50 £245 boxed mint condition £195
JBL century 100s £195 Roksan Kandy 3 CD player boxed as new £345
JBL 2500 bookshelf speakers USA built £125 Rega Planet CD player new style £345
JM Lab Electra SR30 walmounted speakers £250 Shanling SCD-T200 SACD player £645
JM Lab Chorus speakers £225 Sony CDP X-B920E £125
Kenwood KL-888X speakers 15" drive unit £195 Sony XE680 SACD player £195
KEF Celest 3 £95 Sony SCD XE680 SACD player £225
Leema floorstanding speakers rosewood
finish £2000 new £895 MISCELLANEOUS
Leema Zen speakers ex-dem £795 Aiwa AD6400 old school VU meters and piano keys £95
Martin Logan Aerius £945 Abbey Road 1.5mtr power cord £195
Martin Logan Vantage mint boxed rrp £5195 £2995 Abbey Road reference interconnect 1mtr £345
Meridian DSP 3100 Active speakers latest model Audio Technica OC9 original £225
boxed mint £4000 new £2195 Infinity Black Widow tonearm SME mount great with
Mission 753 black £295 high compliance cartridges £195
Mission 775s boxed large floorstander with Manticore Magician piano black Linn mount £295
Aerogel drive units £295 Magnum Dynalab MD106 T valve tuner silver
Mono Pulse 32A 8 months old ex dem. £495 finish boxed mint £4600 new £1995
Mono Pulse 32S ex dem. £645 PS Audio statement biwire speaker cable
Musical Stones Italian Solid Marble floorstanding boxed as new £695
PS Audio power plant 300 with multiwave MKII upgrade £595
speaker with Dynaudio drive units £495 Marantz superscope portable tape recorder superb
Musical Fidelity Reference 2 excellent condition £195 build quality mint condition £195
Nagoka Swan high efficiency speaker cult item £195 Nakamichi receiver 2 £195
Neat Petite SX £POA Nakamichi cassette deck 2 £195
ProAc Tablett 2 £295 Nordost cable various phone for details
Quad ESL 988 Electrostatic speakers MAD My sweetie silver interconnect £345
new neovo version £1995 Transparent Reference 3 metre music link £495
Quad 10L piano black finish £225 Transparent Ultra bi-wire XL cable 25 ft. length £1495
Reference 3A DiCapo i fantastic spks with low valve amps £1795 Transparent Ultra interconnect 1 metre £795
Sentorian early 60s corner speaker pair £375 Revox B77 four track boxed with service manual and
Single ATC SCM 10 active speaker was used accessories £795
as a centre speaker £295 Sony TCK611S 3 head dolby S cassette deck £145
Snell Type K bookshelf loudspeak oak finish sealed Sony TCD5M portable professional cassette deck
box great against rear walls £395 superb qualty mint condition £295
Spendor S5E maple finish boxed as new
condition new £1500 £795 DUE IN....
SF1 FF1 open baffle speaker with Fuji mid range unit £595 Leak Varislope/point 1 stereo pre amp various
Tannoy Autograph Mini £845 Quad 2 pre valve & radio various
Wharfedale W3 omni directional speakers £195 Leak Troughline with one thing audio decoder
W E N O W H AV E O N D E M O N S T R AT I O N T H E S U P E R B L E E M A P U L S E + S T R E A M
W I T H X E R O S P E A K E R + A G E N A H I - E N D P H O N O S TA G E W I T H U S B
G E N E R O U S PA R T- E X . O N A L L E Q U I P M E N T, N E W O R U S E D . W I L L B U Y G O O D
Q U A L I T Y E Q U I P M E N T A S A B O V E . N E X T D AY M A I L O R D E R & U P L I F T FA C I L I T I E S
O p e n i n g t i m e s : 1 0 . 3 0 - 5 . 3 0 Tu e s . t o S a t .
28a Haddington Place, Edinburgh EH7 4AF
Te l / F a x : 0 1 3 1 5 5 8 9 9 8 9
Email: retro.reproduction@virgin.net
We b s i t e : w w w. r e t r o r e p r o d u c t i o n . c o . u k
All Mixed Up
For the first time in a long time, the vinyl-based compilation
has begun to make a mark in terms of numbers and sales.
Paul Rigby reflects on the continued maturity of the vinyl
industry...
I
n the physical format world classic albums to fill their catalogue.
of Compact Disc, the music Even newly released albums
compilation genre is notori- tended to focus on classic artists.
ous. Often viewed as the That was an essential ‘level one’
creative dustbin of the musi- stage of development for just
cal retail sector, the image of about every vinyl label on the
these products is poor. CD-based market.
compilation music has been seen as Then, things began to move. volumes of
throwaway and of little or no value: Level Two has seen an examination the Northern soul
a judgement normally associated of contemporary artists. A variety compilation have all sold
with downloads. Yes, there are good of reissue labels have looked out while the newly
compilations out there, but they are towards releasing new albums released third volume
rare, which has meant that the entire from indie and rock bands. Level has already sold more
genre has become suspect... Three includes soundtracks which copies than either of the
The last time vinyl compilations have sometimes acted as bridging previous two volumes.
had any sort of meaningful presence ‘pseudo-compilations’. “The Bob Other record labels are finding Vinyl
was sometime in the seventies but, Dylan soundtrack album we did, ‘I’m similar success in a variety of other labels are put-
incredibly, the vinyl-based compilation Not Here’ is a good example,” said genres. For example, Doxy has ting more care
is making a comeback! Is this Gething, ”which features covers of released a new blues-based album and attention into
important? Definitely. In fact, vinyl his songs via different people.” featuring Willie Dixon called ‘Walkin’ new compilation
may, single-handedly, be about to save The fact that this record sold the Blues’ which features cover projects because
the compilation as a musical sub- well made Music On Vinyl take versions of his work sung by a variety of vinyl's inherently
genre. notice. The company decided that of artists and it is reportedly selling high costs...
Mike Gething, boss of the UK the sales were not derived from well and, on a jazz theme, UK-outfit,
office of the audiophile vinyl label, soundtrack fans but, “...because it Pure Pleasure, has recently released
Music On Vinyl (www.musiconvinyl. was a compilation of Dylan songs. It a variation on the compilation theme
com), agreed and reflected on how was from that point that we asked with a jazz-flavoured compilation
the industry has changed from a ourselves: what compilation ideas fit based upon the work of Billie
tentative beginning. “I did a stint at both the format and the label? Holiday. The selling point is not so
the Simply Vinyl record label, about The answer was a new Northern much the various Billie Holiday tracks
five years ago, and it didn’t work at soul series which took a basic CD that are bundled upon the LP but the
all. We did a Steve Marriot tribute concept via Sony but then went a star side-men that played with her.
concert with the likes of Oasis step further by offering the series This release was carefully considered.
appearing on it. It featured interesting as a double album limited edition, And this is the point. Not
cover versions and so on but didn’t coloured vinyl for the first 500 only does the resurgence of the
sell a bean.” copies with further copies pressed in vinyl-based compilation reflect the
At that time, when most reissue standard black.” maturity and confidence of the vinyl
labels were still within The records flew out of the door market and, hence its health, but it
Compilations are their early stages of as it was bought by collectors but, also shows you that you can trust the
enjoying a new development, many more interestingly, the compilation compilation genre once more, at least
lease of life on concen- series has continued to sell to within the vinyl sector..
vinyl... trated general Why? Because a vinyl album, any
on the music fans vinyl album, is expensive to make:
in its black unlike CD compilations which cost
vinyl pennies. So, if a vinyl label is going
guise. In to release a compilation, it will have
fact, the to make sure that the LP will sell.
first Hence, that company will carefully
two craft and hone it. Real thought will be
put into it.
So welcome the compilation back
into the fold. It may be a previously
derided concept but, under the vinyl
wing, it may have found a natural
home...
SALE
remain separate legal entities.
SEVENOAKS STARTS
SATU
RDAY
STORES 4TH DECEM
BER
ABERDEEN 01224 252797
BRIGHTON HOVE 01273 733338
BRISTOL 0117 974 3727
BROMLEY 020 8290 1988
CAMBRIDGE 01223 304770
CHELSEA 020 7352 9466
30
CHELTENHAM 01242 241171
EPSOM 01372 720720
%
EXETER 01392 218895
GLASGOW 0141 332 9655 CLAIM UP TO
GUILDFORD 01483 536666
HOLBORN 020 7837 7540
The RRP of a wide range of hi-fi
KINGSTON 020 8547 0717 and A/V speakers.
LEEDS WETHERBY 01937 586886 Visit www.SSAV.com or contact
LINCOLN 01522 527397
LOUGHTON 020 8532 0770
your local store for full details.
MAIDSTONE 01622 686366 MOST, BUT NOT ALL, BRANDS INCLUDED.
NORWICH 01603 767605 NB - 30% DISCOUNT RESERVED FOR EX-DISPLAY AND END OF LINE SPEAKERS.
OFF
NOTTINGHAM 0115 911 2121
OXFORD 01865 241773
PLYMOUTH 01752 226011
POOLE 01202 671677
READING 0118 959 7768
SEVENOAKS 01732 459555
SHEFFIELD 0114 255 5861
SOUTHAMPTON 023 8033 7770
TUNBRIDGE WELLS 01892 531543
WATFORD CHORLEYWOOD 0845 5046364
NEW WEYBRIDGE 01932 840859
WITHAM ESSEX 01376 501733 Unbelievable value on these systems and more!
YEOVIL 01935 700078 Prices may be even LOWER on our website - which is updated daily - please check
IRELAND DUBLIN 01 275 1100
PRICING IN IRELAND MAY VARY FROM THE UK
SYSTEM OPTION
NEW WATFORD STORE change amplifier to
£649 £1199
RELOCATED TO YAMAHA A-S500
CHORLEYWOOD £699
0845 5046364
AUDIO T STORES
BASINGSTOKE 01256 324311
BLACKPOOL 01253 300599 MARANTZ ARCAM FMJ
BOLTON 01204 395789 CD6003 CD Player & PM6003 Amplifier CD17 CD Player & A18 Amplifier
BRENTWOOD 01277 264730 MONITOR AUDIO BOWERS & WILKINS
CAMBERLEY 01276 685597
CARDIFF 029 2022 8565
BRONZE BX2 Speakers Save £198 685 Speakers Save £410
ENFIELD 020 8367 3132
LANCASTER 01524 39657
MANCHESTER 0161 839 8869
PORTSMOUTH 023 9266 3604
PRESTON 01772 883958
SWANSEA 01792 474608
£1699 £1999
SWINDON 01793 538222
WARRINGTON 01925 632179
WORCESTER 01905 619059
AUDIOLAB CYRUS
# Christmas Hours 8200CD CD Player CD6SE CD Player
. and Sunday Opening . 8200A Amplifier 6XP Amplifier
Many stores are open additional hours and days throughout KEF DYNAUDIO
December and January. For the latest information visit
www.ssav.com or call before travelling. Q300 Speakers Save £148 DM 2/6 Speakers Save £386
WorldMags
SALE
WorldMags
STARTS
SATU RDAY
4TH DECEM
Sevenoaks Sound & Vision | Audio T BER
FREE
WORTH £10
M
ONITOR £499
AUDIO
RRP £535 Also: B&W Zeppelin & Zeppelin Mini £SSAV.com
SILVER RX1
SPEAKERS REGA RP1 LEEMA STREAM II
WORTH £399
£599
OR LESS!
£2999
£1349 Claim QED
CABLE
Save WORTH £300 Save
Also: NEW Caspian M2 CD & Amplifier £SSAV.com Also: Audiolab 8200 Amplifier £SSAV.com
£146 Also: Arcam rDAC £SSAV.com
£556
30
CLAIM UP TO The RRP of a wide range of hi-fi and
%
A/V speakers.
Visit www.SSAV.com or contact your local
store for full details.
£185
OR LESS!
OFF
Most, but not all, brands included.
NB - 30% DISCOUNT RESERVED FOR EX-DISPLAY AND END OF LINE SPEAKERS.
£325
OR LESS!
Save Save
£74 £44
Also: Marantz M-CR603 £SSAV.com Also: Yamaha CRX-550 £SSAV.com
LESS THAN
PIONEER HALF
BDP-LX52 £249 PRICE
OR LESS!
PLEASE NOTE: SOME BRANDS/PRODUCTS ARE NOT AVAILABLE AT ALL STORES. SALE/ADDED VALUE OFFERS ARE NOT IN CONJUNCTION WITH ANY OTHER OFFER (NICWAOO)
R E A L S TO R E S R E A L P E O P L E R E A L P R O D U C T S R E A L VA LU E
£595 £799
SPENDOR
OR LESS! OR LESS! A5 Speakers
Save
£170
Save
£126 £SSAV
Also: Denon CEOL RCD-N7 £SSAV.com
CYRUS 6XP
Also: Cyrus CD8SE £SSAV.com
£799
OR LESS!
Also Available
B&W 600 Series ..£SSAV.com
B&W CM Series...£SSAV.com
KEF Q Series .......£SSAV.com
Save
£SSAV Spendor A6 .........£SSAV.com
.com
£126 Spendor A9 .........£SSAV.com
Also: Cyrus 8XPd £SSAV.com RRP £249
ARCAM FMJ
CD17 Save
£469
OR LESS! PEACHTREE AUDIO
£146 Also: Arcam FMJ CD37 £SSAV.com NOVA
Save
DENON £70
TU-1800DAB £229
OR LESS!
PLEASE NOTE: PRICING IN IRELAND MAY VARY FROM THE UK. ADVERT VALID UNTIL 24/12/2010, E&OE
VALVE AMPLIFIER
SERVICING
AND REPAIRS
We have over 40 years’ experience in the design, construction, repair
and servicing of all types of valve (tube) amplifiers.
These include: stereo, hi-fi, guitar, cine projector, pre and power amps.
Prices start from:
£25 – initial investigation, testing and diagnosis
£35 – first hour’s work, including PAT electrical saftey testing
£33 – per hour thereafter, excluding cost of parts required
We will always advise the total cost before proceeding.
Valve testing is offered as a separate service at £2 to £5 per valve.
We also offer a standard service package for £75 which includes:
PAT electrical safety testing
Cleaning valve bases
Cleaning potentiometers
Cleaning all connectors
Re-soldering dry joints
Testing all valves
We provide a fully detailed report on the repair carried out.
All test equipment is regularly calibrated and traceable to
National Standards.
Please note: We do not undertake work on any solid state equipment.
All prices are subject to VAT. T: 01444 881968
Bolney, West Sussex
david@pannellandpartners.co.uk
Power Systems Services www.pannellandpartners.co.uk
ROBERTS the 17,000-plus stations available on decent quality speakers the Roberts
COLOURSTREAM £200 the ‘net than your average button- fills the room well. It doesn’t go as
Roberts’ range of analogue, digital festooned radio. Indeed, it provides loud as you’d expect given its size,
and internet radios is frankly baffling, surprisingly quick and easy access and isn’t as good as Vita Audio’s
so vast is its size. But it’s worth to loads of features, including partic- R2i in terms of clarity when playing
looking at, as there are some really ularly well implemented Podcast music, but it is of course a far more
impressive products hidden within! functionality. versatile device at the price. For
The Colourstream is a case in point. Of course this doesn’t attempt smooth, easy background listening
It’s bang up to date in design, with to be a hi-fi product, but with twin across all sources, it makes a nice
FM, DAB (DAB+) and Internet radio noise and does the job ably. Overall,
capability, plus an iPod dock and an it’s an easy to use, decently well
auxiliary input. Then there’s a little made and feature-packed design,
hinged flap under the fascia controls, that should find its way into
hiding a USB socket for playing MP3, many Christmas – or New Year
AAC, WMA or FLAC music files – a – stockings! DP
nice touch. Indeed it’s bristling with
features, leaving no stone unturned. www.robertsradio.co.uk
Despite this, it proved
surprisingly easy
to use thanks
to its excellent
touchscreen
control panel,
which is a far
less fussy way of
navigating around
soundbites
CHORD INDIGO frequency shielding system, Teflon at this price. A fine product then
PLUS DIGITAL £425 insulation is used both internally and and audiophiles with top-notch CD
The digital output of a CD transport externally. transports and DACs will find this a
is a totally unprotected square wave Via a tweaked Marantz CD16 CD worthwhile purchase, but they will
signal which represents the basic player feeding my Marantz Project have to get the rest of the system
binary data, and is sent in a series of D1 balanced multi-bit DAC, I found sorted before it makes any useful
numeric blocks. Digital cables, due to the results surprisingly pronounced. difference. TB
the effects of capacitance, inductance There was a sense of the soundstage
and resistance, can ‘round off’ the enlarging, slightly superior detailing [Contact: +44 (0)1980 625700,
hard corners of the square wave, being heard, although there was www.chord.co.uk]
which can create ambiguity over no sense of the tonal
the original start and stop points of balance being affected of
the square wave, mildly delaying the course. In fact the cable
data. This can have real sonic effects, seemed to have an inbuilt
not dissimilar to that of digital clock sibilance filter, removing
jitter. Chord’s Indigo Plus digital cable ‘spit’ and edginess from
is designed to protect this signal as the sound, but preserving,
much as is possible. It uses solid core almost enhancing, the
oxygen-free conductors, precision smallest nuance. At this
cast with multi-strand silver-plated price level, value for
signal conductors with two lots of money does not really
silver-plated return signal paths. On enter the conversation; a
top of that the whole lot is shrouded serious commitment to
in a fully floating (and again silver music replay is needed to
plated – the same High Tech wire is even consider purchasing
used through out construction) high a digital interconnect
SPEAKERS Audio Note M1 Line pre amp £350 Esoteric PO-3/DO-3 CD transport and DAC, MINT.
Tannoy Stirlings Ex demo AS NEW (£2800) offered for only £2250 Audio Note Zero R pre amp, new £395 (£20,500) Offered for £10,950
Vienna Acoustics MOZART speakers in rose wood Audio Note Zero pre amp, new £295 Mark Levinson ML 31.5 Reference CD transport £3495
(£2200) offered for £995 Audio Note Zero ONE-R pre amp, new £495 Audio Note Zero DAC, new £399
Hansen Elixir speakers finished in Mercedes Boulder MS-11 phono stage with PSU, balance and Tri CD player new £1895
black, MINT/CRATED (£14,850) only £7995 single ended outputs, £995
TURNTABLES, CARTRIDGES & TONEARMS MISCELLANEOUS
AMPLIFIERS 1 metre balanced pair Madrigal CZ Gel interconnect (£449) only £195
Audionote P1 power amplifier £795 Simon York “ZARATHUSTRA” turntable and PSU with Graham arm,
Lindley Tyson (Quad 11’s) KT88 valve monoblocks £3250 Black/Gold on slate base with glass hinged cover £3250 Arcam DT-26 DAB tuner, ex’ cond. Boxed with remote control £125.
Audio Note SORO SE integrated amp. 6 weeks old, very Yamamoto Mono cartridge, NEW, rrp £1023 offered for £749 Ayre L5-xe distribution unit £660
low hours, as NEW, full warranty (£3480) only £2695 Shun Mook record clamp, boxed with papers £495 MIT Shotgun S2 15’ speaker cable £795
Audio Note P-Zero mono blocks, new £495 Callas record clamp (£500) only £225 MIT Shotgun S2, 1 metre pair balanced interconnects £300
Wavac MD-805M monos (£16,500) as new £7995 Ayre Signature 1.5 metre power cord £350
CD PLAYERS & TRANSPORTS Various equipment stands from £50 please call
Almarro 318B (new) £2250 CEC TL-1N CD transport, as new, £5795
TRI TRV-M300SE amplifier new £4495 Mark Levinson ML 39 CD player with variable Selection OYAIDE plugs and power strips POA
o/p (£6500) superb/boxed offered for £1695 Winds ALM-01 Stylus Gage new £425
PRE-AMPS Esoteric P-05 transport with D-05 DAC, ex demo, 2 metre Madrigal CZ gel bal’ interconnect (£695) £295
Audio Note M1 pre amp with phono £495 full man’ warranty, rrp £9590 offered for £7595
Luxman C-03 pre amp £325 Boulder 2020 DAC with PSU superb cond, cost new Main dealer for Esoteric
Ayre P-5X phonostage £1195 £30,000 offered for only £14,250
VISA - SWITCH - MASTER CARD - AMEX - DINERS CLUB WELCOME.
ALL USED CARTRIDGES ARE CHECKED UNDER A MICROSCOPE BEFORE BEING OFFERED FOR SALE. WE TAKE PART EXCHANGE ON NEW & USED STOCK and buy in for cash
HI-FI WORLD
ELECTRONIC EDITION
VISIT OUR WEBSITE: www.hi-fiworld.co.uk
Queries to - esubs@hi-fiworld.co.uk
Subscribe to our
eco-friendly e-edition of
Hi-Fi World and receive a
50% discount!!!
• Receive your issue a week before on-sale dates.
• Be the first to grab a bargain in our Free Reader
Classified Ads.
• In-house lab. tests to AES and IEC standards
• Run by dedicated hi-fi engineers & enthusiasts.
• No missed issues, or postal delays.
• Access your issues from anywhere in the World.
• PC and Mac friendly.
• Eco-friendly.
WorldMags
DIAL A DEALER WorldMags
DIAL A DEALER
This is a comprehensive directory of Hi-Fi Dealers throughout the UK and Ireland.
DIAL A DEALER
This is a comprehensive directory of Hi-Fi Dealers throughout the UK and Ireland.
Midland Audio X-change are looking for Audio Research, Krell , Mark Levinson , Naim Audio, SME, Wadia.
WorldMags
FREE READER CLASSIFIEDS WorldMags
FREE READER
CLASSIFIEDS
TERMS AND CONDITIONS: Only one advert per reader. No Trade adverts. This section is strictly for readers selling secondhand hi-fi
equipment only. Maximum length per advert is 30 words, Adverts over 30 words will not be accepted. Telephone numbers and E-mail addresses
are treated as one word. Model numbers are treated as one word i.e. Quad 303 = two words. Email your advert to; classifieds@hi-fiworld.co.uk
or fill in the form on page 129 and post it to Hi-Fi World Free Readers Ads, Suite G4, Argo House, Kilburn Park Road, London NW6 5LF. Sorry, we
cannot accept adverts over the telephone. The Publisher reserves the right to judge submissions.
ACOUSTIC ZEN Hologram 2 PROJECT X-PACK. Fitted CYRUS 8VS2, black, remote, 1 METRE PAIR Madrigal CZ
speaker cable, 2x 8 feet, excel- Ortofon Rondo Red cartridge. manual, original package, very Gel balanced interconnect.
lent condition, (£950) £350 Speed box, manual. Boxed. good condition, £300. Tel: 0797 Boxed. £110. Tel: 01772 315
nearest offer. 90 watt valve Mint condition. Buyer collects 024 8050 723
mono’s, guaranteed, Graaf from Slough, Berkshire. £450
WFB2 valve pre, RDS valve ono. Tel: 07941 174804 after GALE 401 speakers, profes- UNIVERSAL DVD SACD
tuner, remote, S.E. valve inte- 6pm sionally reconditioned by player Arcam 137. Mint condi-
grated, etc. High end, all very Wilmslow Audio. Original tion. Box, instructions. Colour
cheap, pristine, boxed, offers DENON DCD 920 CD player. boxes and paperwork with black. Upscaling 1080 HDMI
welcome. Tel: Shalom 07951 Excellent condition. £55 ovno. custom made stands. £590 socket on back. £300. Tel: 0789
553 091 (London) Rotel RT840L tuner. Good ono. V.D.H. Teatrak speaker 161 2918 (Mobile)
condition. Nice sounding cable, 11 metre pair, £200. Tel:
ORACLE ALEXANDER turn- 01825 722 936 UNWANTED PRIZE: Kimber
tuner. £40 ovno. Creek 40-40
table, Rega arm, Goldring 1042 Hero cable, 1 metre Ultraplate
amplifier. Excellent condition.
cartridge. Fifteen years old. CONTEMPORARY STYLE phono plugs, unopened. £110.
New volume pot and serviced.
Offers. Tel: Allan 01323 520 black glass & chrome 9 shelf Tel: 01772 315 723
£75 ovno. Tel: 0161 865 9607
205 (Eastbourne area) hi-fi unit. Top shelf adjustable
for levelling record deck. Size: LOWTHER SPEAKERS
WANTED: BATTERY/Mains
HARBETH SUPER HL5, new H-98cm x W-60cm x D- 36x25x81 cms high, folded
£1200. Icon Audio PSI-2 reel to reel tape recorder. 45cm. £95. Tel: 0151 677 3521 horn design with front and
phonostage £30. Cambridge Sony T.C. 800 Fi-Cord or (Wirral) rear PM6 drivers. Rear drivers
DacMagic £100. Creek OBH- Telefunken in good condition. not working. Teak veneered
12 passive pre-amp £100. Tel: 07847 573 031 SME IV tonearm, 6 months cabinets with dark mahogany
Shure V15MR, under 10 hours old, as new condition, still finish. £195. Tel: 020 8361 3435
use. Tel: 07879 463 060 KIMBER DIGITAL and ana- under warranty, boxed,
logue interconnects. Russ instructions, tools, £995. 1/3 WHARFEDALE PASSIVE
MARANTZ CD12 CDA12 Andrews filters and Yello off new price. Tel: Mike 01246 sub-woofer twin 6” speak-
transport DAC owned from mains cables. Genelec active 209 578 or 07780 888 686 ers in push-pull with vents at
new, boxes, all accessories, studio monitors. Other items rear. Twin 4mm terminals for
£1500. Amateur tape recorder many less than half price. DAB REVEL SALON 1 speak- stereo or mono. £30. Also
magazines 1959 binder tuner, RRP £350. Offers. Tel: ers with original packaging Cambridge 70 watt amplifier
complete Volume One £50. 07813 953 874 (£15,000) £5250 ono. Shanling to suit. £30. Good condition.
Technics SL5 turntable, vgc, Omega CD with Cryovac Tel: 020 8979 1484 (Hampton
£60. Tel: 01708 457 691 AUDIOLAB 8000DAX HiDef valves (£4,000+) £2150 ono. Court area)
DAC for sale in very good with original metal case
MELODY SP3 Mk2 valve condition including manual and complete. All in immaculate HITACHI MUSIC centre SDT-
integrated amplifier.38 watts recent service by Audiolab. condition. Tel: 01594 822 597 7820R with Garrard deck
RMS. 5881 x4, sweet, detailed, £345. Tel: 01924 272 104 or email: includes speakers. Genuine
punchy. 19 kilos. Only 6 (West Yorks) clivej634@btinternet.com offers only. Miniumum £100.
months old, mint, boxed. Have Tel: 024 76370528
upgraded. £450. Tel: 01273 541 CAMBRIDGE AUDIO 540c 60’s-80’s Hi-Fi. Some
462 (Brighton) Version 2 CD player for sale. need attention. Leak 30+, ICON AUDIO MB845
Armstrong 521, Garrard Signature monoblocks. £1400.
Silver finish. Absolutely mint
FOR SALE: Isotek Orion 2way DD75, Technics HD M253 Icon Audio LA4 MkII preamp
condition. Sale due to upgrade.
mains filter £100. Also wanted: + remote, tech gear 4 chan, £350. Icon Audio CDXI valve
£80 ono plus P+P. Tel: Peter
Troy Ambisonic Decoder. Tel: downsizing, ill health. Tel: John CD player £450. Tel: 0787 946
01729 822 480 after 3pm
Peter 01642 559 078 0161 442 5449 (Stockport) 3060 South London
�����������
�����������
To advertise in this space please call
�� ��
�� � � �� ��
���� �� � ��
���������
�� �� �� ��
�� � � �� � �
�� �� �� ��
�� � ��
�����
�� ����
���� �� � �
���������
��
���������
����
������
�������
����������
���������
�����
���������� �����
Debi Silver
����� ����������
��������
��������
�����
���������
�������
������
���������� ����
��
��������� ����
����������
���������
�����������������
��� ���������
�������
����
������� �������
�
���������
����������
����������
��������� ����
���������
������� ����
email: debisilver@hi-fiworld.co.uk
��
�������
���������
���������
��� � ������
�����
����������
���������
������� ���������
�������
���
���������
��
���������
�����
�����
���������
�������
�
���
���������
�� ����
���� ����������
����������
�������� �����������
���
Brad Francis
���� ��
���������
���������
�������� ��������� �� ����������
����������
������ �����
��������� ���������
�������������������
���
���������
���
�������� ��������
����������
�����
��������
���� ����
�������� �����������
���������
��
��������
� �
���������
�����
���������
���������
���
�����
������
���
����������
email: brad.francis@sky.com
�����
����� ��� ������� �����������
������
���������
������
�
1
J$.indd
subbed 16/11/1
JAN11 0 13:22:2
Front Cover 6
Winter Sale
h
h
STARTS 4TH DECEMBER
Please visit our stores and check our website for
the very latest special offers, deals and huge
discounts we have on offer.
www.audio-t.co.uk
WorldMags
FREE READER CLASSIFIEDS WorldMags
ARCAM ALPHA 10 for sale. WANTED A faulty or non DENON DCD1500 mk11 AYRE CX7 silver CD player,
Excellent condition, fully working Quad 44 preamp, CD player immaculate hardly very lightly used, mint condi-
working, 100 British watts Quad 44 c.d input module used since new very good tion, boxed, looks and sounds
per channel, includes remote, 500mv 500k, Quad 405-2 sound and built to last £125 wonderful, genuine sale. Latest
no phono stage. £220 plus modules, Quad 33 preamp. or £200 if bought with my rtl3 version costs over £2,400,
£10 postage, tel Peter 0116 Contact Mike 01758 613790. transmission line speakers rich bargain at £1,200 tel: 07851
2249282. 07751537148 715446 (Watford, Herts)
SHANLING CDT 100 cd play-
MICROMEGA STAGE 2 CD er. Valve or solid-state output, FOR SALE TDL transmission BORDER PATROL MB
player in excellent condi- also valve headphone output. line speakers absolutely mint psu coupled with Audio
tion visually and mechani- Onboard preamp if required. no scuffs or scratches whatso- Innovations L 1 Valve Preamp
cally. Original price £700 Mint condition, boxed with ever not been used for a long + 2 x Lavardin p.s. cables ST
Supplied with owners manual, manual. New £1,650, £550. time with all packaging £125 600 Derek 0035 318210896
remote control and power Can email photos. 01424 contact rich 07751537148
lead. £250 onoPlease phone: 446282 oxon PROFESSIONAL TRANSMIS-
07952257335 SION line high end monitor
LINN FOR sale: Kremlin I'M SELLING My B&W CDM7 speakers Kef & TDL units,
QUAD 606 Power Amp. Tuner £550 Kudos Tuner floorstanding Loudspeakers bi-wired, light oak, condition
Perfect working order and £200 Majik Amp (LK style) in cherry wood finish.in good as brand new space required
cosmetically very good. £200 Trikan centre speaker condition as i had them from hence only £1250 , no better
Slight paintwork damage (black) £225 Call 07500 new original rrp £1000. selling sound, demo Tel: 020 8951
to some edges, visible only 220726 (Chris) £375 Waliat 07523 289766 3178
close up. Pictures on request. Lancs;
£285. Carriage (UK) £16. NAIM DAC, almost new WANTED: TOWNSHEND
gavin@grete.wanadoo.co.uk (July 2010), fully boxed and QUAD II FORTY Monoblocks Audio super tweeters. 01909
01683 221002 unmarked £1600. Chord in unmarked, as new condition. 730 681 or 07783 327 689
Prodac digital interconnect, Svetlana Cryogenically rayspink@supanet.com
PURESOUND A30 amplfier, BNC plugs £60. 07967- treated KT88’s Valve Upgrade.
very good condition, boxed, 031286. Absolutely fantastic cond- WANTED: SONY ES DAT
instructions included. £750 tion. Boxed with Manuals cost recorder. Must be in full work-
01638668299(suffolk) TUBE BOX 2 (Project) MM/ £4000 accept £l,850 Tel Tony ing order and in excellent
02380 224003 Southampton
MC phono valve pre amp. As condition. Willing to travel up
QUAD 33/303 amplifier and
new condition, boxed, man- to 200 miiles by train from my
FM3 tuner £200, SME 3009 4m PAIR DNM bi-wire speak-
ual. Great sound £210 ono home in Portsmouth. Tel: 0750
tone arm £200. Telephone er cables c/w 4mm banana
Hertford 01992 589315. 495 3555 or Email
01189 413708. plugs £135. 1.0M Chord Sig-
k-allen@hotmail.co.uk
nature digital co- axial inter-
GARRARD 401 £1000ono,
REVOX B77 Qtr Track connect £165 4M pair Chord
Turntable power supply FREE TO good home! Pair
3.75/7.5 Speed Ex. Condition Epic twin speaker cables c/w
£300ono, Technics Equaliser Hacker speakers, mint condi-
Only 2 Owners From Signature jumper cables £250.
£150, Class A Amplifier power tion on stands. 20" x 13". Also
New, Iconic Tape Recorder 01483 271669 ( Surrey)
supply £300ono, Arcam 9 pair B&W Model DM3 teak
Full Working Order Can
Power amplifier £250ono, on castors. Lovely condition.
Demonstrate. Buyer Collects AVID DIVA II turntable
Maplin 50W board £25. Tel Person to collect. Tel: Terry
Peterborough £355 Ray with Avid flat cover (no
0207 499 8729 0793 939 4380 (South Yorks)
01733347308 tone-arm). Less than two
years old; boxed; excellent
SIMAUDIO MOON MFIDELITY A1 Mk3. £180.
PAIR ROGERS AB1 condition. Buyer collects.
Subwoofers Black Good con- i-5 amplifier £1250 (not £700 ono. Contact Stephen MFidelity A1 Mk1. £140.
dition. Also pair Wilmslow boxed), Dynaudio Contour Morley, phone 01253 859257 Audiolab 8000P uk . £275.
Audio LS3/5a clones fully 1.3 mk2 £650 (not boxed). (Blackpool), email Linn Intek. £180 Linn Basik ,
assembled and tested. All North London. Jonathan stephen.morley1913@virgin.net. Akito , K5. £180 Rogers LS4a
original KEF units. Will split 07751529070. £80 Mike 0161 291 9331 /
Sensible offers please 07870 LEAK TL12 Plus blank chas- 07743442821
411604 SW London SME MODEL 10 preci- sis, £45. ‘Sound Organisation’
sion turntable with Series V TV/AV/Hi Fi stand, steel frame REGA P3 ‘Super Bias’ turn-
AUDIOLAB 8000 Dax Tonearm (£5700) £3200. One in silver, three opaque glass table incl arm & catridge
HiDef Dac F SN for sale owner. Superb condition. Will shelves, on castors. W90cm, mint condition £110 Pro-ject
in very good condition. Inc demonstrate. Photos avail- H61cm, D40cm. Cost £200, pre-amp mint condition £20
manual and recent service able. Original packaging. Buyer £42. Eastbourne 01323 garry1963@talktalk.net
by Audiolab. £345.00 Tel collects. Tel 01604 410726 or 500174.
01924272104 WYorks. 07711 702836 (Northants) WANTED: TOP quality Hi
WANTED: QUALITY head- Fi seperates and complete
EASTERN ELECTRIC Minimax HI, I’M looking for a good phones and or headphone systems,Naim,Linn,Cyrus,Me
valve phono stage. Only 6 used Graham Slee Reflex gold amp ridian,Arcam etc,fast,friendly
months old. As new. All pack- MC,phono stage at a reason- rayspink@supanet.com response and willing to travel/
aging. £950. Tel: Martin 01268 able price.Thanks Marco 01909 730 681 or 07783 327 pay cash Please call me on
764 542 (Essex) mamuze@alice.it 689 0781 5892458
NEXT MONTH
As the chill winds of winter cause a shiver, what could be better to defrost your extremities than February’s Hi-Fi World
magazine? We’ve a bumper treat of high end delights, such as the stunning EAR V12 tube amplifier [pictured], B&W’s
thumping great 804D loudspeakers and the exotic Dr Feikert Woodpecker turntable. But we haven’t forgotten those seeking
less esoteric pleasures, as our reviews of Creek’s brand new Destiny 2 integrated and Yamaha’s BDS-667 Blu ray player
attest! There’s much, much more too; here’s some of what we hope to bring you:
S
omething a little bit dif-
ferent for you this month.
This album isn’t so much
believes, has produced almost a
a classic as a future classic.
Alternatively, if you disagree
different album..."
with that premise, Eno him-
self is a classic. Co-founder of Roxy the three of us improvising together don’t like people who cross over,”
Music, inventor of an entire genre of formed, then later the idea for this said Abrahams.
music, ambient, collaborator with a record.” A word about the extra CD
string of influential artists on often The album is available in a in this box set. The content of this
ground-breaking productions such number of formats, including a basic disc includes a track to be found
as Germany’s electronica legends, CD. What I looked at however, was in a Japanese edition, a couple of
Cluster, David Bowie, King Crimson’s the limited edition box set which download-only tracks plus a release
Robert Fripp, Talking Heads’ David will set you back around £85 and is that was available, for a limited time,
Byrne and avant garde artist Laurie magnificently designed and presented via Rough Trade. This CD features
Anderson, producer for such groups in a Birch paper-covered slipcase them all.
as U2 and ex-Velvet Underground with printed and foil-blocked cover “The LP itself is long and
man John Cale, plus soundtrack artist and spine. Inside you receive digital spacious and sounds open-ended, in
for influential film creators such as and analogue copies of the album fact it sounds almost like the central
Derek Jarman, Brian Eno has lead a plus extras. More specifically, you snippets of a longer soundtrack. You
startlingly significant career. get the full CD album plus an extra can put the CD on shuffle, in fact.
This new album sees the man disc featuring four extra tracks, two The additional musical entries, on
issuing his debut release on the 180gm vinyl discs of the full album the second CD, are not to be classed
respected Warp label (warp.net) with plus 24bit WAV files and 320kbps as outtakes but genuine pieces of
an improvised work of ambience MP3 files. The physical formats are work that were not approached with
that sees Eno back to his very best. contained in separate full colour different attitudes to the pieces that
In fact, the last time he hit these case-bound hard covers that both can be found on the main album.”
creative heights was back in the late slide into the slipcase cover. You also Abrahams made a point of
seventies. receive a third hard cover which noting the vinyl discs available in
Leo Abrahams, guitar maestro features a square lithographic print this set. The analogue interpretation,
and one of the contributors who also of a new Brian Eno artwork, printed he believes, has produced almost
acted as a co-editor and co-producer on 352gsm Mohawk Superfine stock. a different album, with a wholly
for the LP, described how the project This receives additional tissue-paper different bass approach due to the
came about. “I met Brian in a guitar protection. analogue warming. As such, because
shop ten years ago, I introduced John “Brian Eno studied visual art at of the nature of this music, the vinyl
(an electronica artist with classical University. Increasingly, his projects version almost creates a remix of the
training) to Brian five years ago. have been outside of the UK which CD version!
Brian likes to get together and just is why he is not known quite so A superb box set release that
play music. Projects then tend to well in this country as a visual artist. not only offers packaging quality that
overlap where music, intended for His last solo work did feature his can be viewed as a piece of complex
one project, will end up as part of photography and his art and the one art in itself, but a total of three sound
another. Last year we did a series before that featured a print of his on formats that offer audiophile sources
of improvised concerts around the the cover but, generally, England has and, when comparing digital and
world called ‘Pure Senius’. That was a an unwillingness to let someone who analogue, a production process that
larger group. However, it was such a is perceived as a rock musician be actually impacts on the music itself as
positive experience that the idea of involved in art. The media over here a creative entity. PR
WorldMags
WorldMags
���������������
����������������������������������������
�������������������������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������������������������������
������������������������������������������������������������������
��������������
www.electrocompaniet.no
WorldMags