Indianapolis Monthly

RIPPED from the HEADLINES

TO BEGIN THE STORY of a podcast, let’s introduce a voice:

I keep hearing that you love stories of true crime. You love all things true crime. But hearing about it once a week isn’t enough for you. You guys are just like me—you’re true Crime Junkies, and you need to hear stories more than once a week to get your fix.

Actually, those are borrowed from a podcast, someone else’s work. But don’t worry about that. Just keep reading. Someone’s about to stalk, kidnap, and kill a little girl.

Full. Body. Chills.

Go on. Someone’s about to commit a crime. That’s what we’re here for, right? A fix?

THE ADDICTS have arrived at Clowes Hall on the campus of Butler University. In droves. Hours early. Standing in line. Eager to part with $120 for the good stuff: VIP tickets to the live show of the No. 1 true-crime podcast on iTunes, Crime Junkie. Produced in Broad Ripple, the podcast is downloaded 22 million times each month, adored by a growing audience that includes 370,000 Instagram followers. The hosts, Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat, pose with fans in front of a branded Crime Junkie backdrop as an assistant hands out Crime Junkie swag bags. Britney Spears’s “Oops!… I Did It Again” plays: I’m not that innocent.

Nearby, there’s a merch table hawking $25 T-shirts: “Crime Junkie Podcast Tour,” the front reads; on the back, there’s a list of 15 cities, from Phoenix to Austin. Hoodies cost $50. One of the Junkie junkies near the merch table says, “I think I was supposed to be a detective in real life.” The 43-year-old southside woman wearing a pink Crime Junkie T-shirt works at a nearby college instead, but lives vicariously through her $5-per-month Crime Junkie subscription (packages run up to $20), which she pays via Patreon, a crowdfunding site. “Ashley’s voice is, like, the best.”

Two years and more than 100 episodes into the project that launched in December 2017, Flowers’s voice has made Crime Junkie a seven-figure franchise that’s been hailed by tastemakers like Rolling Stone and shortlisted by networks for a television project. In an upcoming venture, the duo is expected to release Red Ball, a podcast miniseries documenting the work of a young Indiana State Police detective taking over the case of the unsolved 1978 Burger Chef murders.

Now, a little past 8 p.m., more than 2,000 people—a sold-out audience—settle into their seats inside Clowes for a live version of Crime Junkie, where the hosts lead

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Indianapolis Monthly

Indianapolis Monthly2 min read
The Rest Is History
AN ICONIC Irvington home has changed owners after remaining in the same family for three generations. The Hibben House is a classic, charming Tudor built in 1926 for Helene Hibben, an accomplished artist who was well known for her sculptures (bas-rel
Indianapolis Monthly1 min read
Ensemble Cast
IF ROD JUAREZ has picked up on anything during his six years as part owner and general manager of New Albany’s live dining show, Mesa, it is that chefs crave feedback. “Just like an actor or musician,” he says. But chefs rarely get to see the look on
Indianapolis Monthly2 min read
Hidden Talents
IMAGINE IF your employer decided to showcase the artwork of its staff. The resul might be no more remarkable than the work on your neighbor’s refrigerator. That’s far from the case at Newfields, though, where Artists Among Us, its first all-staff exh

Related Books & Audiobooks