Baseball America

POWER UP

BT19

MAKING THE GRADE

AUGUST 2019

As the spring of 2010 unfolded, Tim McDonnell formed an opinion firmly outside the scouting mainstream.

McDonnell, the Marlins’ area scout for greater Los Angeles, believed Christian Yelich had the potential to hit 25-home run power.

Few others shared that opinion. The overall consensus was Yelich, a skinny first baseman with a sweet lefthanded swing from Westlake High, would primarily hit for average and might approach 15 home runs in his best years, a la Casey Kotchman or James Loney.

McDonnell felt otherwise.

“You go back to his junior year and we saw him against Tyler Skaggs (of Santa Monica High), myself and our national crosschecker at the time, and he homered to dead center off of Skaggs that day and we were both looking at

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Baseball America

Baseball America3 min read
Breakout Players
While we haven’t yet seen an uninterrupted Lewis season, he is capable of crazy numbers if he can stay on the field. In his brief MLB career, he has hit .307 with home run and RBI totals that scale to 35 and 100 at 150 games. Lewis hits the ball hard
Baseball America2 min read
Hall Of Famers Were Almost Always Top 100 Prospects
We believe our Top 100 Prospects rankings stand the test of time. We’re not perfect prognosticators, but baseball is a game that often defies prediction. Just look at the top free agent signings in any offseason for examples of how MLB teams will mis
Baseball America5 min read
15 Players Who Just Missed The Top 100
The Top 100 Prospects list is the product of lengthy discussions by the BA prospect team and industry feedback from scouts, executives and analysts. The Top 100 will change throughout the season, and the process that led to its creation included far

Related Books & Audiobooks