After multiple middle-aged citizens of a small town are attacked in mysterious ways, a mystery-solving gang from Sugar Maple High School dusts off their magnifying glasses and gets back to work after time apart. Janet, their type-A leader, takes it upon herself to wrangle the rest of the gang — Cathy and Elaine, tennis-playing identical twins, and Darlene, rabble-rouser (and secret softie) — into an investigation just like old times.