EndodonticTreatmentResultsRelatedtothe

ApicalExtentofRootCanalFillings

Year

Author(s)

JournalIssue

Sample
Number

1961

GrahnenH,HanssonL.

OdontRevy12:146
65

1,277roots

1963

SeltzerS,BenderIB,
TurkenkopfS.

JADA67(5):65162.

2,921teeth

1964

Engstrom,etal.

306teeth

1964

BenderIB,SeltzerS,
TurkenkopfS.

OdontRevy15:257
70.
OOO18(4):52740.

1964

BenderIB,SeltzerS,
TurkenkopfS.

OOO18(4):52740.

706teeth.

1965

EngstromB,LundbergM. OdontRevy16:193
203.

125roots

1969

StormsJL.

JCDA35(2):8397.

158teeth

1970

BritDentJ
128(1):6570.
OOO30(4):53336.

1,139teeth

1970

HartyFJ,ParkinsBJ,
WengrafAM.
HelingB,TamsheA.

1976

AdenubiJO,RuleDC.

1979

KerekesK,TronstadL.

BritDentJ
141(10)23741.
JEndod5(3):8390.

1979

BergenholtzG,etal.

2,335teeth

213teeth

870teeth
501roots

JEndod5(10):3104. 556
retreated
roots

ReviewPeriodor Favorable
ReviewType
Results
(I)inside
(O)outsideand(A)
attheradiographic
apex
45yrs.
I93%
O75%
A83%.
6mos.
I87%
O71%
A87%
4yrs.
I+A79%
O21%
5mos.
I87%
O71%
A87%
2yrs.
I81%
O69%
A87%
34yrs.
I90%
O(notreported)
A83%
1yr.
I100%
O82%
A90%
2yrs.
I+A91%
O87%
15yrs.
I68%
O57%
A71%
1yr.
I92%
O+A64%
15yrs.
I90%
O66%
A91%
2yrs.
I+A86%
O53%

Year

Author(s)

JournalIssue

Sample
Number

1979

HelingB,Kischinovsky
D.

JBrEndodSoc
12(2):839.

202roots

1981

BarbakowFH,Cleaton
JonesPE,FriedmanD.

OOO51(5):5529.

124teeth

1983

SwartzDB,SkidmoreAE, JEndod9(5):198
GriffinJA.
202.

1,770
canals

1983

MorseDR,etal.

OOO56(2):1907.

485canals

1987

MatsumotoT,etal.

JEndod13(5):239
42.

223teeth

1987

BystromA,etal.

EndodontDent
Traum3:5863.

79teeth

1990

SjogrenU,etal.

JEndod16(10):498
504.

849roots

1990

SjogrenU,etal.

JEndod16(10):498
504.

1990

SjogrenU,etal.

1990

SjogrenU,etal.

JEndod16(10):498
504.
JEndod16(10):498
504

1993

5yrs.

1995

SmithCS,SetchellDJ,
HartyFJ.
FriedmanS,etal.

551roots
without
PAR
204roots
withPAR
94
retreated
rootswith
PAR
821teeth
378teeth

618mos.

2000

DeMoorRJG,etal.

313teeth

Routineexams

2001

PeakJD,etal.

406teeth

1yr.

2002

HoskinsenSE,etal.

489roots

45yrs.

IEJ26:32133.
JEndod21(7):384
90.
IEJ33:11320.
BritDentJ
190(3):1404.
OOO93(6):70515.

ReviewPeriodor Favorable
ReviewType
Results
(I)inside
(O)outsideand(A)
attheradiographic
apex
116yrs.
I88%
O65%
A83%
1yr.
I82%
O91%
A92%
1yr.
I92%
O63%
A90%
1yr.
I71%
O100%
A100%
23yrs.
I90%
O40%
A62%
25yrs.
I95%
O90%
A100%
810yrs.
I+A93%
O75%
810yrs.

I+A97%
O93%

810yrs.

I+A90%
O76%
I+A94%
O50%

810yrs.

I+A85%
O75%
I+A78%
O57%
I+A61%
O25%
I+A81%
O89%
I81%
O76%
A70%

Year

Author(s)

JournalIssue

Sample
Number

2002

HommezGM,Coppens
CR,DeMoorRJ.
LupiPegurierL,etal.

IEJ35:6809.

745teeth

IEJ35:6907.

450teeth

BoltaczRzepkowskaE,
PawlickaH.
DugasNN,etal.

IEJ36:2732.

282teeth

IEJ36:18192.

383teeth

IEJ37:1218.

122roots

IEJ37:1218.

122roots

2004

FristadI,MolvenO,
HalseA.
FristadI,MolvenO,
HalseA.
AlleyBS,etal.

OOO98(1)11518.

350teeth

2004

FarzanehM,etal.

JEndod30(5):3029. 242teeth

2004

FarzanehM,AbitolS,
FriedmanS.

JEndod30(9):627
33.

2005

SiqueiraJF,etal.

OOO100(3):36974.

99
retreated
teeth
2,051teeth

2005

TsuneishiM,etal.

OOO100(5):5315.

3,320teeth

Routineexams

2005

StollR,BetkeK,Stachniss JEndod31(11):783
V.
90.

914teeth

10yrs.

2006

GesiA,etal.

OOO101(3):37988.

256teeth

13yrs.

2007

DoyleSL,etal.

JEndod33(4):399
402.

196teeth

1yr.

2007

ImuraN,etal.

JEndod
33(11):127882.

2,000teeth

1824mos.

2002
2003
2003
2004
2004

ReviewPeriodor Favorable
ReviewType
Results
(I)inside
(O)outsideand(A)
attheradiographic
apex
Routineexams
I+A95%
O47%
Routineexams
I+A87%
O33%
Recordsreview
I+A88%
O91%
Routineexams
I+A57%
O39%
1017yrs.
I85%
O+A86%
2027yrs.
I98%
O+A94%
5yrs.
I92%
O100%
A98%
46yrs.
I+A87%
I+O77%
46yrs.
I+A86%
I+O76%
Routineexams

Summary:
88%(37/42)ofthesestudiesreportedmorefavorableresultswithI,AandI+A.
12%(5/42)ofthesestudiesreportedlessfavorableresultswithOandO+A.

I+A50%
O45%
I+A61%
O20%
I74%
O74%
A94%
I+A94%
O91%
I94%
O60%
A81%
I92%
O89%
A87%