Topicality: in means in the US

Merriam Webster Online Dictionary, 06 (http://www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary? book=Dictionary&va=in)

A. in means within the limits of

Main Entry: 1in Pronunciation: 'in, &n, &n Function: preposition Etymology: Middle English, from Old English; akin to Old High German in in, Latin in, Greek en 1 a -- used as a function word to indicate inclusion, location, or position within limits <in the lake> <wounded in the leg> <in the summer>

B. Violation the Affirmative sends Solar powered Satellites into space outside of the USs jurisdiction C. Standards 1) Limits: Their interpretation allows affs that create renewable energy

outside of the United States such as give Iran Nuke power aff and the solar military aff this explodes neg research because an aff could be written to send alternative energy to any number of countries. Additionally, for each one of these affs 40 different positive incentive mechanisms could be applied not to mention negative incentives.

2) Ground: This interpretation severs out of key neg arguments for this years topic such as the states CP and grants the Aff advantage ground unrelated to alternative energy such as space weaponization and colonization. 3) vagueness: Currently not even one SPS system has been built, which means all the arguments for both sides are just allegations of what could happen with out any substantial evidence. this destroys any case specific turns or das like the bats DA for wind or the earthquakes da for geothermal. This also means we cant run our fossil fuel Das because the links dont exist destroying reseprocity

B. Voting issue T should be judged on a matter of competing interpretations its not what you do, but what you justify vote neg to preserve limits.