&+$37(5

 62/87,210$18$/
 
 )XQGDPHQWDOVRI7KHUPRG\QDPLFVWK(GLWLRQ
 6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ

 
 

FUNDAMENTALS

Thermodynamics
of


&217(17


 68%6(&7,21     352%12

&RUUHVSRQGHQFHWDEOH      
 &RQFHSW6WXG\*XLGH3UREOHPV   
0L[WXUHFRPSRVLWLRQDQGSURSHUWLHV     
 6LPSOHSURFHVVHV       
 (QWURS\JHQHUDWLRQ       
 $LUZDWHUYDSRUPL[WXUHV      
 7DEOHVDQGIRUPXODVRUSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW    
 3V\FKURPHWULFFKDUWRQO\    
 $YDLODELOLW\H[HUJ\LQPL[WXUHV   
 5HYLHZ3UREOHPV     
  

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ

&+$37(5  WKHGLWLRQ  6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNH:\OHQ


 7KHFRUUHVSRQGHQFHEHWZHHQWKLVSUREOHPVHWDQGWKHWKHGLWLRQFKDSWHU
SUREOHPVHW

1HZ WK 1HZ WK 1HZ WK 1HZ WK
       
 QHZ  QHZ    
       
 QHZ  QHZ    
       
       QHZ
 QHZ  PRG    QHZ
   PRG    QHZ
   QHZ    
 QHZ  PRG    
 PRG  PRG    
 QHZ  QHZ    
 QHZ    QHZ  
 PRG      
   QHZ    
 PRG  PRG  DF  
 QHZ  PRG    
 QHZ  PRG  QHZ  
 PRG  PRG    QHZ
 PRG      
   QHZ    
       
 QHZ      
 PRG    QHZ  
   QHZ    
 QHZ      
 QHZ      
 QHZ  QHZ    
       
 PRG  PRG    

 7KHSUREOHPVWKDWDUHODEHOHGSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUWRQO\FDQEHVROYHGZLWKRXWWKH
FKDUWXVLQJWKHIRUPXODVDQGWKHVWHDPWDEOHV0RVWRIWKHVROXWLRQVWKRXJK
EHFRPHOHQJWK\DQGWULDODQGHUURUW\SHGXHWRWKHLPSOLFLWFRQQHFWLRQVEHWZHHQ
WKHYDULDEOHVVKRZQLQWKHFKDUW$QDOWHUQDWLYHWRWKLVSURFHGXUHLVWKHXVHRIWKH
FRPSXWHUVRIWZDUHZKLFKFDQEHXVHGLQVWHDGRIWKHFKDUW

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


&RQFHSW6WXG\*XLGH3UREOHPV



 $UHWKHPDVVDQGPROHIUDFWLRQVIRUDPL[WXUHHYHUWKHVDPH"

 *HQHUDOO\QRW,IWKHFRPSRQHQWVDOOKDGWKHVDPHPROHFXODUZHLJKWWKHPDVVDQG
PROHIUDFWLRQVZRXOGEHWKHVDPH


 )RUDPL[WXUHKRZPDQ\FRPSRQHQWFRQFHQWUDWLRQVDUHQHHGHG"

  $WRWDORI1FRQFHQWUDWLRQVDUHQHHGHGZKHWKHUPDVVRUPROHIUDFWLRQV
 7KH\PXVWVXPXSWRRQHVRWKHODVWRQHLVE\GHIDXOW


 $UHDQ\RIWKHSURSHUWLHV37YIRUR[\JHQDQGQLWURJHQLQDLUWKHVDPH"

  ,QDQ\PL[WXUHXQGHUHTXLOLEULXP7LVWKHVDPHIRUDOOFRPSRQHQWV(DFK
VSHFLHVKDVLWVRZQSUHVVXUHHTXDOWRLWVSDUWLDOSUHVVXUH7KHSDUWLDOYROXPHIRUD
FRPSRQHQWLVYL 9PLDQG9LVWKHVDPHIRUDOOFRPSRQHQWVVRYLLVQRW


 ,IR[\JHQLVE\PROHRIDLUZKDWLVWKHR[\JHQVWDWH37YLQDURRPDW
.N3DRIWRWDOYROXPHP"

  7KHWHPSHUDWXUHLV.
  7KHSDUWLDOSUHVVXUHLV3 \3WRW × N3D
  $WWKLV73Y2 5732 × PNJ

  5HPDUN,IZHIRXQGWKHR[\JHQPDVVWKHQP2Y2 9 P

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $IORZRIR[\JHQDQGRQHRIQLWURJHQERWK.DUHPL[HGWRSURGXFHNJV
DLUDW.N3D:KDWDUHWKHPDVVDQGYROXPHIORZUDWHVRIHDFKOLQH"

  )RUWKHPL[WXUH0 ×× 
  )RU2 F ×  
  )RU1 F × 
 6LQFHWKHWRWDOIORZRXWLVNJVWKHVHDUHWKHFRPSRQHQWIORZVLQNJV
 9ROXPHIORZRI2LQLV
   57
   9 FPY FP 3  ×× PV
 9ROXPHIORZRI1LQLV
   57
   9 FPY FP 3  ×× PV



 $IORZRIJDV$DQGDIORZRIJDV%DUHPL[HGLQDPROHUDWLRZLWKVDPH7
:KDWLVWKHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQSHUNPROHIORZRXW"

  )RUWKLVHDFKFRPSRQHQWWKHPROHIUDFWLRQLVRQHKDOIVR
B B
  (T∆6 5OQOQ 5

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $ULJLGFRQWDLQHUKDVNJDUJRQDW.DQGNJDUJRQDW.ERWKDW
N3D1RZWKH\DUHDOORZHGWRPL[ZLWKRXWDQ\H[WHUQDOKHDWWUDQVIHU:KDWLV
ILQDO73",VDQ\VJHQHUDWHG"

(QHUJ\(T8±8  PXPXDPXE P&Y7±7D±7E
    7 7D7E .
3URFHVV(T9 FRQVWDQW !
   39 P57 P57D7E 39D39E 39
   3 3 N3D
∆6GXHWRWHPSHUDWXUHFKDQJHVRQO\QRW3LQWHUQDOO\ZHKDYHD4RYHUD∆7
 ∆6 PV±VDPV±VE P&S>OQ77DOQ77E@
 
  ×>OQOQ@ N-.
 
 

Ar Ar
cb



   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $ULJLGFRQWDLQHUKDVNJ&2DW.DQGNJDUJRQDW.ERWKDWN3D
1RZWKH\DUHDOORZHGWRPL[ZLWKRXWDQ\KHDWWUDQVIHU:KDWLVILQDO73"

1R41R:VRWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQJLYHVFRQVWDQW8
(QHUJ\(T8±8  P&2X±X&2P$UX±X$U
   P&2&Y&27±7&2P$U&Y$U7±7$U
   ×××7××××
  7 .
 9 9 9&29$U P&25&27&23P$U5$U7$U3
  ×××× P
3UHVVXUHIURPLGHDOJDVODZDQG(TIRU5
  3 ××× N3D

 

CO 2 Ar
cb



   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $IORZRINJVDUJRQDW.DQGDQRWKHUIORZRINJV&2DW.ERWKDW
N3DDUHPL[HGZLWKRXWDQ\KHDWWUDQVIHU:KDWLVWKHH[LW73"

  1RZRUNLPSOLHVQRSUHVVXUHFKDQJHIRUDVLPSOHIORZ7KHHQHUJ\
HTXDWLRQEHFRPHV
     
  PKL PKH PKL$UPKL&2 PKH$UPKH&2
 
 ⇒P&2&S&27H±7L&2P$U&S$U7H±7L$U 
   
 ⇒ P$U&S$U7LP&2&S&27L >P$U&S$UP&2&S&2@7H
 ×××× ×××7H
  7H .3H N3D

 
$U
0,;,1* 0L[
&2 
&+$0%(5
FE


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 :KDWLVWKHUDWHRIHQWURS\LQFUHDVHLQSUREOHP"

 8VLQJ(TWKHPROHIUDFWLRQRI&2LQWKHPL[WXUHLV
 )URP(TVDQGIURPWKHWZRLQOHWVWDWHVWRVWDWH
 ×
 ∆6 ×>OQ  ±OQ  @
 ×
 ×>OQ  ±OQ  @ N:.



 ,I,ZDQWWRKHDWDIORZRIDFRPSRQHQWPL[WXUHIURPWR.DWFRQVWDQW
3KRZPDQ\SURSHUWLHVDQGZKLFKRQHVGR,QHHGWRNQRZWRILQGWKHKHDW
WUDQVIHU"

  <RXQHHGWRNQRZWKHIORZUDWHWKHIRXUPDVVIUDFWLRQVDQGWKH
FRPSRQHQWVSHFLILFKHDWYDOXHV

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 )RUDJDVPL[WXUHLQDWDQNDUHWKHSDUWLDOSUHVVXUHVLPSRUWDQW"

 3DUWLDOSUHVVXUHVDUHQHFHVVDU\WRFDOFXODWHHQWURS\FKDQJHVLIWKHPL[WXUH
FRPSRVLWLRQFKDQJHV2WKHUZLVHWKH\DUHQRWQHHGHG



 :KDWKDSSHQVWRUHODWLYHDQGDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\ZKHQPRLVWDLULVKHDWHG"

 5HODWLYHKXPLGLW\GHFUHDVHVZKLOHDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\UHPDLQVFRQVWDQW
 6HH)LJVDQG



 ,FRROPRLVWDLUGR,UHDFKWKHGHZILUVWLQDFRQVWDQW3RUFRQVWDQW9SURFHVV"

 7KHFRQVWDQWYROXPHOLQHLVVWHHSHUWKDQWKHFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUHOLQH
 VHH)LJ6DWXUDWLRQLQWKHFRQVWDQW3SURFHVVLVDWDKLJKHU7

 7 

3 &

Y &
V




 :KDWKDSSHQVWRUHODWLYHDQGDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\ZKHQPRLVWDLULVFRROHG"

  5HODWLYHKXPLGLW\LQFUHDVHZKLOHDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\UHPDLQVFRQVWDQW
 6HH)LJVDQG

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 ,I,KDYHDLUDWN3DDQGD±R&ER&DQGFR&ZKDWLVWKH
PD[LPXPDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\,FDQKDYH"

 +XPLGLW\LVUHODWHGWRUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\PD[DQGWKHSUHVVXUHVDVLQ
(TZKHUHIURP(T3Y Φ3JDQG3D 3WRW3Y

3Y Φ3J
   ω 3   
D 3WRWΦ3J

D 3J N3Dω × 
E 3J N3Dω × 
F 3J N3DQRPD[ωIRU3WRW N3D

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &DQPRLVWDLUEHORZWKHIUHH]LQJSRLQWVD\±R&KDYHDGHZSRLQW"

  <HV$WWKHGHZSRLQWZDWHUZRXOGEHJLQWRDSSHDUDVDVROLG,WVQRZV



 ([SODLQLQZRUGVZKDWWKHDEVROXWHDQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\H[SUHVVHV"

 $EVROXWHKXPLGLW\LVWKHUDWLRRIWKHPDVVRIYDSRUWRWKHPDVVRIGU\DLU,WVD\V
KRZPXFKZDWHULVWKHUHSHUXQLWPDVVRIGU\DLU
 5HODWLYHKXPLGLW\LVWKHUDWLRRIWKHPROHIUDFWLRQRIYDSRUWRWKDWLQDVDWXUDWHG
PL[WXUHDWWKHVDPH7DQG3,WH[SUHVVHVKRZFORVHWRWKHVDWXUDWHGVWDWHWKH
ZDWHULV



 $QDGLDEDWLFVDWXUDWLRQSURFHVVFKDQJHVΦωDQG7,QZKLFKGLUHFWLRQ"
  
 5HODWLYHKXPLGLW\DQGDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\LQFUHDVHDQGWHPSHUDWXUHGHFUHDVHV



 ,ZDQWWREULQJDLUDWR&Φ WRDVWDWHRIR&ω GR,QHHGWRDGG
RUVXEWUDFWZDWHU"

 $VVXPLQJ3 N3D 
 $W°&ω ×× 
 7RJHWWRω LWLVQHFHVVDU\WRVXEWUDFWZDWHU
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


0L[WXUHFRPSRVLWLRQDQGSURSHUWLHV

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $JDVPL[WXUHDW°&N3DLV1+2DQG2RQDPROH
EDVLV)LQGWKHPDVVIUDFWLRQVWKHPL[WXUHJDVFRQVWDQWDQGWKHYROXPHIRUNJRI
PL[WXUH
6ROXWLRQ
7KHFRQYHUVLRQIROORZVWKHGHILQLWLRQVDQGLGHQWLWLHV
)URP(TFL \L0L∑\M0M
)URP(T
 0PL[ ∑\M0M ×××
     
 F1  F+2  
 F2  VXPVWR2.
)URP(T
−
 5PL[ 50PL[  N-NJ.
 9 P5PL[73 ×× P

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRI1$UDQG2RQDPDVVEDVLVLVLQDF\OLQGHUDW
N3D.DQGYROXPHP)LQGWKHPROHIUDFWLRQVDQGWKHPDVVRIDUJRQ
6ROXWLRQ
7RWDOPL[WXUH 39 P5PL[7
)URP(T
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
  N-NJ.
 P 395PL[7 ×× NJ
 PDU P NJ
)URP(T \L FL0L∑FM0M
  FL  0L  FL0L  \L
 1      
 $U     
 2      URXQGXS
      

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRI1$UDQG2RQDPROHEDVLVLVLQDF\OLQGHUDW
N3D.DQGYROXPHP)LQGWKHPDVVIUDFWLRQVDQGWKHPDVVRIDUJRQ
6ROXWLRQ
)URP(TFL \L0L∑\M0M
(T
 0PL[ ∑\M0M ××× 
 F1 × 
 F$U × 
 F2 × VXPVWR2.
)URP(T
−
 5PL[ 500,;  N-NJ.
 PPL[ 395PL[7 ×× NJ
 P$U F$U×PPL[ × NJ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QHZUHIULJHUDQW5LVDPL[WXUHRI55DQG5D
RQDPDVVEDVLV)LQGWKHPROHIUDFWLRQVWKHPL[WXUHJDVFRQVWDQWDQGWKHPL[WXUH
KHDWFDSDFLWLHVIRUWKLVQHZUHIULJHUDQW
6ROXWLRQ
)URPWKHFRQYHUVLRQLQ(TZHJHW
 FL  0L  FL0L  \L
5     
5     
5D     
      

(T
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
  N-NJ.
(T
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×××
  N-NJ.
(T
 &9PL[ ∑FL&9L ×××
  N-NJ. &30,;50,;

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $FDUEXUHWHGLQWHUQDOFRPEXVWLRQHQJLQHLVFRQYHUWHGWRUXQRQPHWKDQHJDV
QDWXUDOJDV7KHDLUIXHOUDWLRLQWKHF\OLQGHULVWREHWRRQDPDVVEDVLV
+RZPDQ\PROHVRIR[\JHQSHUPROHRIPHWKDQHDUHWKHUHLQWKHF\OLQGHU"
6ROXWLRQ
7KHPDVVUDWLRP$,5P&+ VRUHODWHPDVVDQGPROHQ P0


Q$,5
Q&+  P$,5

P&+ × 0&+0$,5 ×  

Q2 Q2 Q$,5

→Q  Q ×Q  × PROH2PROH&+
&+ $,5 &+

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 :HLJKLQJRIPDVVHVJLYHVDPL[WXUHDW°&N3DZLWKNJ2NJ1
DQGNJ&+)LQGWKHSDUWLDOSUHVVXUHVRIHDFKFRPSRQHQWWKHPL[WXUH
VSHFLILFYROXPHPDVVEDVLVPL[WXUHPROHFXODUZHLJKWDQGWKHWRWDOYROXPH
6ROXWLRQ
)URP(T\L PL0L∑PM0M
 QWRW ∑PM0M 
   
 \2  
 \1  
 \&+  
)URP(T
 32 \23WRW × N3D
 31 \13WRW × N3D
 3&+ \&+3WRW × N3D
−
 9WRW QWRW573 ×× P
 Y 9WRWPWRW  PNJ
)URP(T
 0PL[ ∑\M0M PWRWQWRW  

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $NJPL[WXUHRI12DQG&2E\PDVVLVDWN3DDQG
.)LQGWKHPL[WXUHJDVFRQVWDQWDQGWKHWRWDOYROXPH
6ROXWLRQ
)URP(T
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
  N-NJ.
,GHDOJDVODZ 39 P5PL[7
 9 P5PL[73 ×× P

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PVWRUDJHWDQNZLWKIXHOJDVHVLVDW°&N3DFRQWDLQLQJDPL[WXUHRI
DFHW\OHQH&+SURSDQH&+DQGEXWDQH&+$WHVWVKRZVWKHSDUWLDO
SUHVVXUHRIWKH&+LVN3DDQGWKDWRI&+LVN3D+RZPXFKPDVVLV
WKHUHRIHDFKFRPSRQHQW"
6ROXWLRQ
$VVXPHLGHDOJDVHVWKHQWKHUDWLRRISDUWLDOWRWRWDOSUHVVXUHLVWKHPROH
IUDFWLRQ\ 33WRW
\&+  \&+  \&+  
39 ×
QWRW  −    NPROHV
57 ×
P&+ Q0&+ \&+QWRW0&+
 ×× NJ
P&+ Q0&+ \&+QWRW0&+
 ×× NJ
P&+ Q0&+ \&+QWRW0&+
 ×× NJ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $SLSHFURVVVHFWLRQDODUHDPFDUULHVDIORZRI2DQG1E\
PROHZLWKDYHORFLW\RIPVDWN3D.7RLQVWDOODQGRSHUDWHDPDVV
IORZPHWHULWLVQHFHVVDU\WRNQRZWKHPL[WXUHGHQVLW\DQGWKHJDVFRQVWDQW:KDW
DUHWKH\":KDWPDVVIORZUDWHVKRXOGWKHPHWHUWKHQVKRZ"
 6ROXWLRQ
)URP(TFL \L0L∑\M0M
)URP(T
 0PL[ ∑\M0M ×× 
(T
−
 5PL[ 50PL[  N-NJ.
 Y 5PL[73 ×  PNJ
 ρ Y NJP

 P ρ$9 ×× NJV

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QHZUHIULJHUDQW5DLVDPL[WXUHRI5DQG5LQDPDVVUDWLR
:KDWDUHWKHRYHUDOOPROHFXODUZHLJKWWKHJDVFRQVWDQWDQGWKHUDWLRRIVSHFLILF
KHDWVIRUVXFKDPL[WXUH"

(T
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×× N-NJ.

(T
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×× N-NJ.

(T
 &9PL[ ∑FL&9L ×× N-NJ.
 &3PL[5PL[

 NPL[ &3PL[&9PL[  

 0 ∑\M0M  ∑FM0M     


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


6LPSOHSURFHVVHV


 $WDFHUWDLQSRLQWLQDFRDOJDVLILFDWLRQSURFHVVDVDPSOHRIWKHJDVLVWDNHQDQG
VWRUHGLQD/F\OLQGHU$QDQDO\VLVRIWKHPL[WXUH\LHOGVWKHIROORZLQJUHVXOWV
  &RPSRQHQW   + &2 &2 1
  3HUFHQWE\PDVV     
 'HWHUPLQHWKHPROHIUDFWLRQVDQGWRWDOPDVVLQWKHF\OLQGHUDWN3D°&
+RZPXFKKHDWWUDQVIHUPXVWEHWUDQVIHUUHGWRKHDWWKHVDPSOHDWFRQVWDQWYROXPH
IURPWKHLQLWLDOVWDWHWR°&"
6ROXWLRQ
'HWHUPLQHPROHIUDFWLRQVIURP(T\L FL0L∑FM0M

∑FM0M 
   
 0PL[ ∑FM0M  
)URP(T
\+ ×   \&2 ×  
\&2 ×   \1 ×  
−
5PL[ 50PL[  N-NJ.
 P 3957 ××  ×NJ
&90,; ∑FL&9L × × 
  × ×  N-NJ.

4 88 P&977 × × × N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KHPL[WXUHLQ3UREOHPLVKHDWHGWR.ZLWKFRQVWDQWYROXPH)LQGWKH
ILQDOSUHVVXUHDQGWKHWRWDOKHDWWUDQVIHUQHHGHGXVLQJ7DEOH$
6ROXWLRQ
&90L[WXUHRIFRQVWDQWYROXPH
3URFHVV 9 FRQVWDQW ! : ∫3G9 
(QHUJ\(T 4 PX−X≅P&9PL[7−7
,GHDOJDV 39 P57  ! 3 37799
 3 377 × N3D
)URP(T
 &9PL[ ∑FL&9L ×××
  N-NJ.
 4 × N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KHPL[WXUHLQ3UREOHPLVKHDWHGXSWR.LQDFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUH
SURFHVV)LQGWKHILQDOYROXPHDQGWKHWRWDOKHDWWUDQVIHUXVLQJ7DEOH$
6ROXWLRQ
&90L[WXUH
3URFHVV 3 FRQVWDQW ! : ∫3G9 39−9
(QHUJ\(T 4 PX−X: PX−X3PY−Y
    PK−K≅P&3PL[7−7
)URP(T
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
N-NJ.
)URP(T
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×××
  N-NJ.
 9 P5PL[73
  ×× P
 4 ×± N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $SLSHIORZVNJVRIDPL[WXUHZLWKPDVVIUDFWLRQVRI&2DQG1
DWN3D.+HDWLQJWDSHLVZUDSSHGDURXQGDVHFWLRQRISLSHZLWK
LQVXODWLRQDGGHGDQGN:HOHFWULFDOSRZHULVKHDWLQJWKHSLSHIORZ)LQGWKH
PL[WXUHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUH
6ROXWLRQ
&93LSHKHDWLQJVHFWLRQ$VVXPHQRKHDWORVVWRWKHRXWVLGHLGHDOJDVHV
  
(QHUJ\(T4 PKH−KL P&3PL[7H−7L
)URP(T
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×× N-NJ.
6XEVWLWXWHLQWRHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQDQGVROYHIRUH[LWWHPSHUDWXUH
 
 7H 7L4P&3PL[ × .

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $SLSHIORZVNPROHDVHFRQGPL[WXUHZLWKPROHIUDFWLRQVRI&2DQG
1DWN3D.+HDWLQJWDSHLVZUDSSHGDURXQGDVHFWLRQRISLSHZLWK
LQVXODWLRQDGGHGDQGN:HOHFWULFDOSRZHULVKHDWLQJWKHSLSHIORZ)LQGWKH
PL[WXUHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUH
 6ROXWLRQ
&93LSHKHDWLQJVHFWLRQ$VVXPHQRKHDWORVVWRWKHRXWVLGHLGHDOJDVHV
     −
(QHUJ\(T4 PKH−KL QKH−KL Q&3PL[7H−7L
)URP(TVRQSDJHWKHH[WHQVLRQRI(T
− −
&3PL[ ∑\L&L ××××
   N-NPRO
6XEVWLWXWHLQWRHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQDQGVROYHIRUH[LWWHPSHUDWXUH
 −
 7H 7L4Q&3PL[ × .


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $ULJLGLQVXODWHGYHVVHOFRQWDLQVNJRIR[\JHQDWN3D.VHSDUDWHGE\
DPHPEUDQHIURPNJFDUERQGLR[LGHDWN3D.7KHPHPEUDQHLV
UHPRYHGDQGWKHPL[WXUHFRPHVWRDXQLIRUPVWDWH)LQGWKHILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHDQG
SUHVVXUHRIWKHPL[WXUH
6ROXWLRQ
&97RWDOYHVVHO&RQWUROPDVVZLWKWZRGLIIHUHQWLQLWLDOVWDWHV
0DVVP P2P&2  NJ
3URFHVV9 FRQVWDQWULJLG !: LQVXODWHG !4 
(QHUJ\88  P2&92772P&2&9&277&2
,QLWLDOVWDWHIURPLGHDOJDV7DEOH$
 &92 N-NJ&9&2 N-NJ.
292 P573 ×× P
&29&2 P573 ×× P
)LQDOVWDWHPL[WXUH
 50,; ∑FL5L >××@ N-NJ.
7KHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQEHFRPHV
 P2&927P&2&9&27
   P2&9272P&2&9&27&2
 7  N-
     !7 .
)URPPL[WXUHJDVFRQVWDQWDQGWRWDOYROXPH
 3 P5PL[79 ×× N3D

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRIZDWHUDQGFDUERQGLR[LGHE\PDVVLVKHDWHGIURP.WR
.DWFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUHN3D)LQGWKHWRWDOFKDQJHLQHQWKDOS\DQG
HQWURS\XVLQJ7DEOH$YDOXHV
 6ROXWLRQ

)URP(T
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×× N-NJ.
)URP(T
 &3PL[ ×× N-NJ.
 K−K≅&3PL[7−7 ×± N-NJ
)URP(T
 V−V &3PL[OQ77−5PL[OQ33
  &3PL[OQ77 OQ N-NJ.
 $VWKHWZRWRWDOSUHVVXUHVDUHWKHVDPHWKHSUHVVXUHFRUUHFWLRQWHUPGURSVRXW

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 'R3UREOHPEXWZLWKYDULDEOHKHDWFDSDFLW\XVLQJYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$

$PL[WXUHRIZDWHUDQGFDUERQGLR[LGHE\PDVVLVKHDWHGIURP.WR
.DWFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUHN3D)LQGWKHWRWDOFKDQJHLQHQWKDOS\DQG
HQWURS\XVLQJ7DEOH$YDOXHV
6ROXWLRQ
)URP(T
 K−K F+2K−K+2F&2K−K&2
  ±±
  
  N-NJ
)URP(TDQG(T

 V−V V°7−V°7−50,;OQ33

  F+2V°7−V7° +2F&2V°7−V7° &2

  ±±
   N-NJ.
 $VWKHWZRWRWDOSUHVVXUHVDUHWKHVDPHWKHSUHVVXUHFRUUHFWLRQWHUPGURSVRXW
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QLQVXODWHGJDVWXUELQHUHFHLYHVDPL[WXUHRI&2+2DQG1
RQDPDVVEDVLVDW.N3D7KHYROXPHIORZUDWHLVPVDQGLWV
H[KDXVWLVDW.N3D)LQGWKHSRZHURXWSXWLQN:XVLQJFRQVWDQWVSHFLILF
KHDWIURP$DW.
6ROXWLRQ
&97XUELQH6WHDG\LQOHWH[LWIORZZLWKDQLGHDOJDVPL[WXUHT 
  
(QHUJ\(T :7 PKL−KH P&3PL[7L−7H
3URSHUWLHV)URP(TVDQG
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
N-NJ.
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×××
  N-NJ.
 
 39 P5PL[7 !P 395PL[7

  P ×× NJV

 :7 ×− N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 6ROYH3UREOHPXVLQJWKHYDOXHVRIHQWKDOS\IURP7DEOH$
$QLQVXODWHGJDVWXUELQHUHFHLYHVDPL[WXUHRI&2+2DQG1
RQDPDVVEDVLVDW.N3D7KHYROXPHIORZUDWHLVPVDQGLWV
H[KDXVWLVDW.N3D)LQGWKHSRZHURXWSXWLQN:XVLQJFRQVWDQWVSHFLILF
KHDWIURP$DW.
6ROXWLRQ
&97XUELQH6WHDG\LQOHWH[LWIORZZLWKDQLGHDOJDVPL[WXUHT 
  
(QHUJ\(T :7 PKL−KH P∑FMKL−KHM
3URSHUWLHV)URP(TVDQG
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
N-NJ.
 
 39 P5PL[7 !P 395PL[7

  P × ×  NJV
1RZJHWWKHKYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$DOOLQN-NJ

 :7 >
  @
  N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QLQVXODWHGJDVWXUELQHUHFHLYHVDPL[WXUHRI&2+2DQG1
RQDPROHEDVLVDW.N3D7KHYROXPHIORZUDWHLVPVDQGLWV
H[KDXVWLVDW.N3D)LQGWKHSRZHURXWSXWLQN:XVLQJFRQVWDQWVSHFLILF
KHDWIURP$DW.
&97XUELQH6WHDG\IORZLQOHWH[LWIORZZLWKDQLGHDOJDVPL[WXUHDQG
QRKHDWWUDQVIHUVRT 
      −
(QHUJ\(T :7 PKL−KH QKL−KH Q&3PL[7L−7H
−
,GHDOJDVODZ39 Q57 !

 39 × 
  Q  −    NPROHV
57 × 
7KHPL[WXUHKHDWFDSDFLW\EHFRPHV
− −
&3PL[ ∑\L&L ××××
   ×× N-NPRO.


:7 ×− N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 6ROYH3UREOHPXVLQJWKHYDOXHVRIHQWKDOS\IURP7DEOH$
&97XUELQH6WHDG\IORZLQOHWH[LWIORZZLWKDQLGHDOJDVPL[WXUHDQG
QRKHDWWUDQVIHUVRT 
       
(QHUJ\(T :7 PKL−KH QKL−KH Q>∑\MKL−KHM@
−
,GHDOJDVODZ39 Q57 !

 39 × 
  Q  −    NPROV
57 × 
5HDGWKHHQWKDOSLHVIURP7DEOH$WKH\DUHDOOLQN-NPRO

:7 >@
 N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $SLVWRQF\OLQGHUGHYLFHFRQWDLQVNJRIDPL[WXUHRIPHWKDQHDQG
SURSDQHJDVHVE\PDVVDW.DQGN3D7KHJDVLVQRZVORZO\FRPSUHVVHG
LQDQLVRWKHUPDO7 FRQVWDQWSURFHVVWRDILQDOSUHVVXUHRIN3D6KRZWKH
SURFHVVLQD39GLDJUDPDQGILQGERWKWKHZRUNDQGKHDWWUDQVIHULQWKHSURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
&90L[WXUHRIPHWKDQHDQGSURSDQHWKLVLVDFRQWUROPDVV
$VVXPHPHWKDQH SURSDQHDUHLGHDOJDVHVDWWKHVHFRQGLWLRQV
(QHUJ\(T PX−X 4:
3URSHUW\IURP(T
 5PL[ 5&+5&+
   ×× N-NJ.
3URFHVV 7 FRQVWDQW LGHDOJDV !
 : ∫3G9 P5PL[7∫9G9 P5PL[7OQ99
  P5PL[7OQ33
  ××OQ N-
1RZKHDWWUDQVIHUIURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQZKHUHZHQRWLFHWKDWXLVD
FRQVWDQWLGHDOJDVDQGFRQVWDQW7VR
 4 PX−X: : N-


  3 3 &Y  7
 7 &
 


Y V 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RQVLGHU3UREOHPDQGILQGWKHYDOXHIRUWKHPL[WXUHKHDWFDSDFLW\PDVV
EDVLVDQGWKHPL[WXUHUDWLRRIVSHFLILFKHDWVNPL[ERWKHVWLPDWHGDW.IURP
YDOXHVGLIIHUHQFHVRIKLQ7DEOH$:LWKWKHVHYDOXHVPDNHDQHVWLPDWHIRUWKH
UHYHUVLEOHDGLDEDWLFH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHRIWKHWXUELQHDWN3D
6ROXWLRQ
:HZLOOILQGWKHLQGLYLGXDOKHDWFDSDFLWLHVE\ILQLWHGLIIHUHQFHV
 &3L GKG7 ∆K∆7 KK
5HDGWKHKYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$
 &3&2  N-NJ.
 &3+2  N-NJ.
 &31  N-NJ.
3URSHUWLHV)URP(TVDQG
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
N-NJ.
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×××
  N-NJ.
 &9PL[ &3PL[5PL[  N-NJ.
 N &3PL[&9PL[ 
5HYHUVLEOHDGLDEDWLFWXUELQH !3URFHVVLVV FRQVWDQW
$VVXPHFRQVWDQWDYHUDJHKHDWFDSDFLWLHVVR(T
N 
7H 7L3H3L N    .

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RQVLGHU3UREOHPDQGILQGWKHYDOXHIRUWKHPL[WXUHKHDWFDSDFLW\PROH
EDVLVDQGWKHPL[WXUHUDWLRRIVSHFLILFKHDWVNPL[ERWKHVWLPDWHGDW.IURP
YDOXHVGLIIHUHQFHVRIKLQ7DEOH$:LWKWKHVHYDOXHVPDNHDQHVWLPDWHIRUWKH
UHYHUVLEOHDGLDEDWLFH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHRIWKHWXUELQHDWN3D
:HZLOOILQGWKHLQGLYLGXDOKHDWFDSDFLWLHVE\ILQLWHGLIIHUHQFHV
−    
&3L GKG7 ∆K∆7 KK
1RZUHDGWKHKYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$DOOLQN-NPRO
−
&3&2  N-NPRO. 
−
&3+2  N-NPRO.
−
&31  N-NPRO.
− −
&3PL[ ∑\L&3L ×××
N-NPRO.
− − −
&9PL[ &3PL[5  N-NPRO.
− −
N &3PL[&9PL[ 
5HYHUVLEOHDGLDEDWLFWXUELQH !3URFHVVLVV FRQVWDQW
$VVXPHFRQVWDQWDYHUDJHKHDWFDSDFLWLHV
N 
7H 7L3H3L N    .

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRINJQLWURJHQDQGNJR[\JHQLVDWN3D.LQDSLVWRQ
F\OLQGHUNHHSLQJFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUH1RZN-LVDGGHGE\KHDWLQJ)LQGWKH
ILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHLQFUHDVHLQHQWURS\RIWKHPL[WXUHXVLQJ7DEOH$
YDOXHV
6ROXWLRQ
&90L[WXUHLQWKHSLVWRQF\OLQGHU
(QHUJ\(T PX−X 4:
3URFHVV 3 FRQVWDQW ! : ∫3G9 39−9
 4 PX−X: PX−XP3Y−Y PK−K
 K−K 4P≅&3PL[7−7
)URP(TDQG7DEOH$
 &3PL[ ×× N-NJ.
 7 74P&3PL[
  × .
)URP(T
 PV−V P>&3PL[OQ77−5OQ33@
  ××OQ N-.

  

Mixture F=C



   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRINJQLWURJHQDQGNJR[\JHQLVDWN3D.LQDSLVWRQ
F\OLQGHUNHHSLQJFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUH1RZN-LVDGGHGE\KHDWLQJ)LQGWKH
ILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHLQFUHDVHLQHQWURS\RIWKHPL[WXUHXVLQJ7DEOH$
YDOXHV
6ROXWLRQ
&90L[WXUHLQWKHSLVWRQF\OLQGHU
(QHUJ\(T PX−X 4:
3URFHVV 3 FRQVWDQW ! : ∫3G9 39−9
 4 PX−X: PX−XP3Y−Y
  PK−K
 K−K 4P  N-NJ
6LQFH7LVVRKLJKZHXVH7DEOH$YDOXHVJXHVVLQJD7
 
 K−K. ±±

   N-NJ WRRKLJK
 
 K−K. ±±

   N-NJ WRRORZ
 7 >±±@ .
)URP(TVDQG
 
 V−V V°7V°71V°7V°72

 
  ±±

  N-NJ.

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 1HZUHIULJHUDQW5DLVDPL[WXUHRI5DQG5LQDPDVVUDWLR$
SURFHVVEULQJVNJ5DIURP.WR.DWDFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUHN3D
LQDSLVWRQF\OLQGHU)LQGWKHZRUNDQGKHDWWUDQVIHU
6ROXWLRQ
&95D
(QHUJ\(T PX−X 4−: 439−9
3URFHVV3 FRQVWDQW : 39−9 P57−7
   4 PX−X: PK−K
)URP(T
 
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×× N-NJ.

)URP(T
 
 &3PL[ ×× N-NJ.

)URPWKHSURFHVVHTXDWLRQ
 : ×± N-
)URPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 4 ×± N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $SLVWRQF\OLQGHUFRQWDLQVNJDUJRQDQGNJK\GURJHQDW.N3D
7KHPL[WXUHLVFRPSUHVVHGLQDQDGLDEDWLFSURFHVVWRN3DE\DQH[WHUQDOIRUFH
RQWKHSLVWRQ)LQGWKHILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHWKHZRUNDQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHULQWKH
SURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
&90L[WXUHLQF\OLQGHU&RQWUROPDVVZLWKDGLDEDWLFSURFHVV4 
&RQW(TP P P(QHUJ\(TPX−X −:
(QWURS\(TPV−V ∫G476JHQ 
3URFHVV DGLDEDWLFDQGDVVXPHGUHYHUVLEOHJLYHVLVHQWURSLF
 5PL[ ∑FL5L  ×  ×  N-NJ.
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L  ×  ×  N-NJ.
 &9 &35  N-NJ.
5DWLRRIVSHFLILFKHDWV N &3&9 
7KHFRQVWDQWVLVHQWURSLFSURFHVVIURP(T
 V V !7 733NN  .
7KHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQJLYHVWKHZRUNDV
  : PX−X P&97−7
   × N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 1DWXUDOJDVDVDPL[WXUHRIPHWKDQHDQGHWKDQHE\PDVVLVIORZLQJWRD
FRPSUHVVRUDW°&N3D7KHUHYHUVLEOHDGLDEDWLFFRPSUHVVRUEULQJVWKHIORZ
WRN3D)LQGWKHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHQHHGHGZRUNSHUNJIORZ
6ROXWLRQ
&9&RPSUHVVRU6WHDG\DGLDEDWLFT UHYHUVLEOHVJHQ 
(QHUJ\(TZ KH[KLQ(QWURS\(T VLVJHQ VH
3URFHVVUHYHUVLEOH !VJHQ  !VH VL
$VVXPHLGHDOJDVPL[WXUHDQGFRQVWDQWKHDWFDSDFLW\VRZHQHHGNDQG&3
)URP(TDQG
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×× N-NJ.
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×× N-NJ.
 &9 &3PL[5PL[  N-NJ.
5DWLRRIVSHFLILFKHDWV  N &S&Y 
7KHLVHQWURSLFSURFHVVJLYHV(T
 7H 7L3H3LNN  .
:RUNIURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 ZFLQ &37H7L ± N-NJ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRINJR[\JHQDQGNJRIDUJRQLVLQDQLQVXODWHGSLVWRQF\OLQGHU
DUUDQJHPHQWDWN3D.7KHSLVWRQQRZFRPSUHVVHVWKHPL[WXUHWRKDOILWV
LQLWLDOYROXPH)LQGWKHILQDOSUHVVXUHWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHSLVWRQZRUN
6ROXWLRQ
&90L[WXUH&RQWUROPDVVERXQGDU\ZRUNDQGQR4DVVXPHUHYHUVLEOH
(QHUJ\(TXX TZ Z
(QWURS\(TVV  
3URFHVVFRQVWDQWV !3YN FRQVWDQWY Y
$VVXPHLGHDOJDVHV7!!7&DQGXVHNPL[DQG&YPL[IRUSURSHUWLHV
(T 5PL[ ΣFL5L  ×  ×  N-NJ.
(T &3PL[ ΣFL&3L  ×  ×  N-NJ.
  &YPL[ &3PL[5PL[ N-NJ.
5DWLRRIVSHFLILFKHDWV  NPL[ &3PL[&YPL[ 
7KHUHODWLRQVIRUWKHSRO\WURSLFSURFHVV
(T 3 3YYN 3N  N3D
(T 7 7YYN 7N  .
:RUNIURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 : PWRWXX PWRW&Y77 × N-


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KHVXEVWDQFH5DVHH3UREOHPLVDWN3D.,WLVQRZEURXJKW
WRN3D.LQDUHYHUVLEOHSRO\WURSLFSURFHVV)LQGWKHFKDQJHLQVSHFLILF
YROXPHVSHFLILFHQWKDOS\DQGVSHFLILFHQWURS\IRUWKHSURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
 
(T 5PL[ ΣFL5L ×× N-NJ.

 
(T &3PL[ ΣFL&3L ×× N-NJ.

 Y 573 × PNJ

 Y 573 × PNJ
 YY ± PNJ
 K−K &3PL[7−7 ± N-NJ
)URP(T
 V−V &3PL[OQ77−5PL[OQ33
  OQ±OQ N-NJ.

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7ZRLQVXODWHGWDQNV$DQG%DUHFRQQHFWHGE\DYDOYH7DQN$KDVDYROXPHRI
PDQGLQLWLDOO\FRQWDLQVDUJRQDWN3D°&7DQN%KDVDYROXPHRIP
DQGLQLWLDOO\FRQWDLQVHWKDQHDWN3D°&7KHYDOYHLVRSHQHGDQGUHPDLQV
RSHQXQWLOWKHUHVXOWLQJJDVPL[WXUHFRPHVWRDXQLIRUPVWDWH'HWHUPLQHWKHILQDO
SUHVVXUHDQGWHPSHUDWXUH
6ROXWLRQ
&97DQNV$%&RQWUROPDVVQR:QR4
(QHUJ\(T88  P$U&977$P& + &9277%
 
 P$U 3$9$57$ ×× NJ
 P&+ 3%9%57% ×× NJ
&RQWLQXLW\(T P P$UP&+ NJ

(QHUJ\(T× 7

   × 7 
 6ROYLQJ7 .
 
 5PL[ ΣFL5L   ×  × N-NJ.

 3 P579$9% ××  N3D


  

cb A
B



   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $FRPSUHVVRUEULQJV5DVHHSUREOHPIURP±R&N3DXSWR
N3DLQDQDGLDEDWLFUHYHUVLEOHFRPSUHVVLRQ$VVXPHLGHDOJDVEHKDYLRUDQGILQG
WKHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHVSHFLILFZRUN
6ROXWLRQ
&9&RPSUHVVRU
3URFHVV T  DGLDEDWLFDQGUHYHUVLEOH
(QHUJ\(T Z KLKH
(QWURS\(T VH VLVJHQ∫GT7 VL VL
)URP(T
 
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×× N-NJ.

)URP(T
 
 &3PL[ ×× N-NJ.

  5PL[&3PL[  

)RUFRQVWDQWVLGHDOJDVDQGXVHFRQVWDQWVSHFLILFKHDWDVLQ(T
5&S
  7H7L 3H3L 

  7H ×  .
  Z≅&3PL[7L7H ±
   N-NJ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRIFDUERQGLR[LGHDQGZDWHUE\PDVVLVEURXJKWIURP
.03DWR.N3DLQDSRO\WURSLFSURFHVVWKURXJKDVWHDG\VWDWHGHYLFH
)LQGWKHQHFHVVDU\KHDWWUDQVIHUDQGZRUNLQYROYHGXVLQJYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$
6ROXWLRQ
3URFHVV3YQ FRQVWDQWOHDGLQJWR
 QOQYY OQ33Y 573
  × 
 Q OQ  OQ  
   × 
(T 5PL[ ΣFL5L  ×  ×  N-NJ.
(T &3PL[ ΣFL&3L  ×  ×  N-NJ.
:RUNLVIURP(T
Q Q5
 Z ⌠YG3
⌡ Q3HYH3LYL Q7H7L N-NJ

+HDWWUDQVIHUIURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 T KHKLZ &37H7LZ N-NJ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 6ROYH3UREOHPXVLQJVSHFLILFKHDWV&3 ∆K∆7IURP7DEOH$DW.
$PL[WXUHRIFDUERQGLR[LGHDQGZDWHUE\PDVVLVEURXJKWIURP
.03DWR.N3DLQDSRO\WURSLFSURFHVVWKURXJKDVWHDG\VWDWHGHYLFH
)LQGWKHQHFHVVDU\KHDWWUDQVIHUDQGZRUNLQYROYHGXVLQJYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$
6ROXWLRQ
8VLQJYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$ZHHVWLPDWHWKHKHDWFDSDFLWLHV

 &3&2     N-NJ.


 &3+2    N-NJ.
(T &3PL[ ΣFL&3L ×× N-NJ.
(T 5PL[ ΣFL5L ×× N-NJ.
3URFHVV3YQ & !Q OQ33OQYYDQGXVH3Y 57
  × 
 Q OQ  OQ  
   × 
:RUNLVIURP(T
Q Q5
 Z ⌠YG3
⌡ Q3HYH3LYL Q7H7L N-NJ

+HDWWUDQVIHUIURPHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 T KHKLZ  N-NJ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $E\PDVVJDVPL[WXUHRIPHWKDQH&+DQGHWK\OHQH&+LVFRQWDLQHG
LQDF\OLQGHUSLVWRQDWWKHLQLWLDOVWDWHN3D.P7KHSLVWRQLVQRZ
PRYHGFRPSUHVVLQJWKHPL[WXUHLQDUHYHUVLEOHSRO\WURSLFSURFHVVWRWKHILQDO
VWDWH.P&DOFXODWHWKHILQDOSUHVVXUHWKHSRO\WURSLFH[SRQHQWWKH
ZRUNDQGKHDWWUDQVIHUDQGHQWURS\FKDQJHIRUWKHPL[WXUH

6ROXWLRQ
,GHDOJDVPL[WXUH&+&+HDFKE\PDVV !F&+ F& + 


 5PL[ ΣFL5L ×× N-NJ.

 &YPL[ ∑FL&YL ×× N-NJ.
6WDWHP 395PL[7 ×× NJ
6WDWH7 .9 P,GHDOJDV39 P57VRWDNHUDWLR
9 7 
    !3 39 7  N3D
 
7 9Q
3URFHVV39Q FRQVWDQWDQG39 P57JLYHV7 9  
  
7 9
   OQ7  QOQ9  !Q 
 
DOVRIRUWKLVSURFHVVZHJHW(TRU(T

 !: ∫3G9 Q3939 N-

(QHUJ\(T4 88: P&YPL[77:

    × N-
&KDQJHRIHQWURS\IURP(T
 VV &YPL[OQ775PL[OQ99
  OQOQ
  N-NJ.
DQG
66 PVV  N-.
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KHJDVPL[WXUHIURP3UREOHPLVFRPSUHVVHGLQDUHYHUVLEOHDGLDEDWLF
SURFHVVIURPWKHLQLWLDOVWDWHLQWKHVDPSOHF\OLQGHUWRDYROXPHRI/
'HWHUPLQHWKHILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHRIWKHPL[WXUHDQGWKHZRUNGRQHGXULQJWKH
SURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
)URP(T
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×××
  × N-NJ.
 P 395PL[7 ××  ×NJ
&90,; ∑FL&9L × × 
  × ×  N-NJ.
 &30,; &90,;5PL[  N-NJ.
 →N &3&9  
7KHSURFHVVDGLDEDWLFDQGUHYHUVLEOHLVLVHQWURSLFH[SUHVVHGLQ(T

 →7 7 9 
9

N
  
    .

 : ∆8 P&977

  ×× ×  N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


(QWURS\JHQHUDWLRQ


 $IORZRINJVPL[WXUHRI&2DQG2E\PDVVLVKHDWHGLQDFRQVWDQW
SUHVVXUHKHDWH[FKDQJHUIURP.WR.E\DUDGLDWLRQVRXUFHDW.
)LQGWKHUDWHRIKHDWWUDQVIHUDQGWKHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQLQWKHSURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
&9+HDWH[FKDQJHU Z 
 
(QHUJ\(T 4LQ PKHKL
9DOXHVIURP7DEOH$GXHWRWKHKLJK7
  
 4LQ >×±×±@ N:
   
(QWURS\(T PHVH PLVL47V6JHQ
$VWKHSUHVVXUHLVFRQVWDQWWKHSUHVVXUHFRUUHFWLRQLQ(TGURSVRXWWRJLYH
WKHJHQHUDWLRQDV
  
 6JHQ PVHVL47V
 
  >×±×±@

  N:.


  .
5DGLDWLRQ

L H


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &DUERQGLR[LGHJDVDW.LVPL[HGZLWKQLWURJHQDW.LQDQLQVXODWHG
PL[LQJFKDPEHU%RWKIORZVDUHDWN3DDQGWKHPDVVUDWLRRIFDUERQGLR[LGH
WRQLWURJHQLV)LQGWKHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHWRWDOHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQSHU
NJRIWKHH[LWPL[WXUH
6ROXWLRQ
 
&9PL[LQJFKDPEHU7KHLQOHWUDWLRLVVRP&2  P1 DQGDVVXPHQR
 
H[WHUQDOKHDWWUDQVIHUQRZRUNLQYROYHG
   
&RQWLQXLW\(T P1P1 PH[ P1
 
(QHUJ\(T P1 K1 K&2  P1 KPL[H[
   
 7DNH.DVUHIHUHQFHDQGZULWHK K&3PL[7
 &317L1&3&27L&2 &3PL[7PL[H[
 
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×× N-NJ.

 &3PL[7PL[H[ &317L1&3&27L&2 N-NJ

 7PL[H[ .
7RILQGWKHHQWURSLHVZHQHHGWKHSDUWLDOSUHVVXUHVZKLFKDVVXPLQJLGHDOJDV
DUHHTXDOWRWKHPROHIUDFWLRQVWLPHVWKHWRWDOSUHVVXUH
  \L >FL0L@∑FM0M
 
 \1 >@>  @ 

 \&2 −\1 

     
 6JHQ PH[VH[PVL&2 PVL1  P1 VHVL1 P1 VHVL&2 
     

6JHQ  7  7
    >&31 OQ H[ ±51 OQ\1 @ >&3&2 OQ H[ ±5&2 OQ\&2 @
P1   7L1     7L&2  
 
 
  >OQ  ±OQ@

 
>OQ  ±OQ@

  
N-NJPL[.

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7DNH3UREOHPZLWKLQOHWWHPSHUDWXUHRI.IRUWKHFDUERQGLR[LGHDQG
.IRUWKHQLWURJHQ)LUVWHVWLPDWHWKHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHZLWKWKHVSHFLILFKHDWV
IURP7DEOH$DQGXVHWKLVWRVWDUWLWHUDWLRQVXVLQJ$WRILQGWKHH[LW
WHPSHUDWXUH
6ROXWLRQ
 
&9PL[LQJFKDPEHU7KHLQOHWUDWLRLVVRP&2  P1 DQGDVVXPHQR
 
H[WHUQDOKHDWWUDQVIHUQRZRUNLQYROYHG

   
&RQWLQXLW\(TP1P1 PH[ P1
 
(QHUJ\(TP1K1K&2 P1KPL[H[
 
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×× N-NJ.

 7DNH.DVUHIHUHQFHDQGZULWHK K&3PL[7

 &317L1&3&27L&2 &3PL[7PL[H[
 &3PL[7PL[H[ &317L1&3&27L&2

××× N-NJ
  7PL[H[ .
$PRUHDFFXUDWHDQVZHUUHVXOWVIURPXVLQJWKHLGHDOJDV7DEOHV
  
)URP7DEOH$ΣPLQKLQ P1>××@ P1×
  
#.ΣPH[KH[ P1>×@ P1×
  
#.ΣPH[KH[ P1>×@ P1×
1RZOLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQEHWZHHQ.DQG.

  7H[ × .

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



&DUERQGLR[LGHJDVDW.LVPL[HGZLWKQLWURJHQDW.LQDQLQVXODWHG
PL[LQJFKDPEHU%RWKIORZVDUHFRPLQJLQDWN3DDQGWKHPROHUDWLRRI
FDUERQGLR[LGHWRQLWURJHQLV)LQGWKHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHWRWDOHQWURS\
JHQHUDWLRQSHUNPROHRIWKHH[LWPL[WXUH

 
&9PL[LQJFKDPEHUVWHDG\IORZ7KHLQOHWUDWLRLVQ&2 Q1DQG
DVVXPHQRH[WHUQDOKHDWWUDQVIHUQRZRUNLQYROYHG
   
&RQWLQXLW\Q&2Q1 QH[ Q1
    
(QHUJ\(TQ1K1K&2 Q1KPL[H[
  
7DNH.DVUHIHUHQFHDQGZULWHK K&3PL[7
  
 &317L1&3&27L&2 &3PL[7PL[H[
)LQGWKHVSHFLILFKHDWVLQ7DEOH$WRJHW
 
 &3PL[ ∑\L&3L ××× 
N-NPRO.
  
 &3PL[7PL[H[ &317L1&3&27L&2 N-NPRO
  7PL[H[ .
3DUWLDOSUHVVXUHVDUHWRWDOSUHVVXUHWLPHVPROHIUDFWLRQ
3H[1 3WRW3H[&2 3WRW
          
 6JHQ QH[VH[QVL&2QVL1 Q1VHVL1Q1VHVL&2

   7H[ −  7H[ −
 6JHQQ1 >&31OQ7 5OQ\1&3&2OQ7 5OQ\&2@
L1 L&2

   >@ N-NPROPL[.



 
1 
0,;,1*
&+$0%(5 0L[
&2 
6 JHQ
FE


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7DNH3UREOHPZLWKLQOHWWHPSHUDWXUHRI.IRUWKHFDUERQGLR[LGHDQG
.IRUWKHQLWURJHQ)LUVWHVWLPDWHWKHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHZLWKWKHVSHFLILFKHDWV
IURP7DEOH$DQGXVHWKLVWRVWDUWLWHUDWLRQVXVLQJ$WRILQGWKHH[LW
WHPSHUDWXUH
 
&9PL[LQJFKDPEHUVWHDG\IORZ7KHLQOHWUDWLRLVQ&2 Q1DQG
DVVXPHQRH[WHUQDOKHDWWUDQVIHUQRZRUNLQYROYHG
 
&3&2 × &31 × N-NPRO.
 
&RQWLQXLW\(TXDWLRQ ΣQLQΣQH[
   
(QHUJ\(TXDWLRQ ΣQLQKLQΣQH[KH[
   
   Q1&3&27LQ7H[&2Q1&317LQ7H[1

   ××7H[×7H[

   ±7H[  7H[ .

   
)URP7DEOH$ΣQLQKLQ Q1>××@ Q1×
   
#.ΣQH[KH[ Q1>×@ Q1×
   
#.ΣQH[KH[ Q1>×@ Q1×
   
#.ΣQH[KH[ Q1>×@ Q1×
1RZOLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQEHWZHHQ.DQG.

  7H[ × .

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KHRQO\NQRZQVRXUFHVRIKHOLXPDUHWKHDWPRVSKHUHPROHIUDFWLRQDSSUR[LPDWHO\
×−DQGQDWXUDOJDV$ODUJHXQLWLVEHLQJFRQVWUXFWHGWRVHSDUDWHPVRI
QDWXUDOJDVDVVXPHGWREH+HPROHIUDFWLRQDQG&+7KHJDVHQWHUVWKH
XQLWDWN3D°&3XUHKHOLXPH[LWVDWN3D°&DQGSXUHPHWKDQHH[LWVDW
N3D°&$Q\KHDWWUDQVIHULVZLWKWKHVXUURXQGLQJVDW°&,VDQHOHFWULFDO
SRZHULQSXWRIN:VXIILFLHQWWRGULYHWKLVXQLW"

  1 2 3 N3D
&+ He 7 R&
+H 
CH4
DWN3DR& 3 N3D
 
3

9 PV :  N: 7  R&
&9 


 
 Q 3957 ×× NPROV
  
  !Q Q Q NPROV

 &3+H × N-NPRO.

&3&+ × N-NPRO.
            
4&9 QKQKQK:&9 Q&3+H77Q&3&+77:&9

  ×× N:

    
6JHQ QVQVQV4&97

 > 
  OQOQ

×
@

  > 
 OQOQ

×
@


  N:.!

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



$IORZRINJVFDUERQGLR[LGHDW.N3DLVPL[HGZLWKDIORZRINJV
ZDWHUDW.N3DDQGDIWHUWKHPL[LQJLWJRHVWKURXJKDKHDWH[FKDQJHU
ZKHUHLWLVFRROHGWR.E\D.DPELHQW+RZPXFKKHDWWUDQVIHULVWDNHQ
RXWLQWKHKHDWH[FKDQJHU":KDWLVWKHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQUDWHIRUWKHZKROH
SURFHVV"
 6ROXWLRQ
 1 
3 4
Mixing
chamber
2
Q cool


 &97RWDOPL[LQJVHFWLRQDQGKHDWH[FKDQJHU6WHDG\IORZDQGQRZRUN7RGR
WKHHQWURS\DWWKHSDUWLDOSUHVVXUHVZHQHHGWKHPROHIUDFWLRQV

 
  Q+2 P+20+2  NPROV
 
  Q&2 P&20&2  NPROV

  \+2  \&2 ±\+2 
    
(QHUJ\(T P+2KP&2K 4FRROP+2K+2P&2K&2

   4FRRO  
(QWURS\(TP+2VP&2V6JHQ 7 P+2V+2P&2V&2
DPE
 
$V7LVIDLUO\KLJKZHXVH7DEOH$IRUSURSHUWLHVRQDPDVVEDVLV
   +2 &2
K>N-NJ@    
R    
V >N-NJ.@
7

  
 4FRRO P+2K±K+2P&2K±K&2
  ±± N:

   4FRRO
 6JHQ P+2V+2±VP&2V&2±V7 
DPE
  >±±OQ@

  >±±OQ@  

  ± N:.
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PL[WXUHRIKHOLXPDQGQLWURJHQE\PDVVHQWHUVDWXUELQHDW03D
.DWDUDWHRINJV7KHDGLDEDWLFWXUELQHKDVDQH[LWSUHVVXUHRIN3D
DQGDQLVHQWURSLFHIILFLHQF\RI)LQGWKHWXUELQHZRUN
6ROXWLRQ
$VVXPHLGHDOJDVPL[WXUHDQGWDNH&9DVWXUELQH
(QHUJ\(T Z7V KLKHV
(QWURS\(T VHV VLDGLDEDWLFDQGUHYHUVLEOH

3URFHVV(T 7  7 3 3 NN

HV L H L
3URSHUWLHVIURP(TDQG
 &3PL[ × ×  N-NJ.
 5PL[ ××  N-NJ.
 NN 5&3PL[  
 7HV  .
 Z7V &37L7HV  N-NJ
 Z7DF ηZ7V N-NJ
 
 :7DF PZ7DF N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 5HSHDW3UREOHPIRUDQLVHQWURSLFFRPSUHVVRUHIILFLHQF\RI
6ROXWLRQ
&9&RPSUHVVRU6WHDG\DGLDEDWLFT UHYHUVLEOHVJHQ 
(QHUJ\(TZ KH[KLQ(QWURS\(T VLVJHQ VL VH
3URFHVVUHYHUVLEOH !VJHQ  !VH VL
$VVXPHLGHDOJDVPL[WXUHDQGFRQVWDQWKHDWFDSDFLW\VRZHQHHGNDQG&3
)URP(TDQG
 5PL[ ∑FL5L ×× N-NJ.
 &3PL[ ∑FL&3L ×× N-NJ.
 &9 &3PL[5PL[  N-NJ.
5DWLRRIVSHFLILFKHDWV  N &S&Y 
7KHLVHQWURSLFSURFHVVJLYHV(T
 7H 7L3H3LNN  .
:RUNIURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 ZFLQ &37H7L ± N-NJ
7KHDFWXDOFRPSUHVVRUUHTXLUHVPRUHZRUN
ZFDFWXDO ZFLQη  N-NJ &S7HDFWXDO7L
!7HDFWXDO 7ZFDFWXDO&3  .

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $ODUJHDLUVHSDUDWLRQSODQWWDNHVLQDPELHQWDLU12E\PROHDW
N3D°&DWDUDWHRINJV,WGLVFKDUJHVDVWUHDPRISXUH2JDVDW
N3D°&DQGDVWUHDPRISXUH1JDVDWN3D°&7KHSODQWRSHUDWHVRQ
DQHOHFWULFDOSRZHULQSXWRIN:&DOFXODWHWKHQHWUDWHRIHQWURS\FKDQJHIRU
WKHSURFHVV

 $LU1   3 N3D
SXUH2 
2 7 R&
3 N3D SXUH1  
R
7  &  3 N3D
  
P NJV :,1 N: 7 R&
 
6ROXWLRQ
 7RKDYHWKHIORZWHUPVRQDPDVVEDVLVOHWXVILQGWKHPDVVIUDFWLRQV
 )URP(TFL \L0L∑\M0M
 F2 ×>××@ 
 F1 F2 
   
 P F2P NJV P F1P NJV
7KHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ(TJLYHVWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUUDWHDV
     
 4&9 ΣP∆KL:&9 P2 &32 7−7P1 &31 7−7:&9
   
   ×  ×− −N:
7KHHQWURS\HTXDWLRQ(TJLYHVWKHJHQHUDWLRQUDWHVDV
      
 6JHQ ΣPL∆VL−4&97 PVPV−PV−4&97
8VH(TIRUWKHHQWURS\FKDQJH



>  
ΣPL∆VL  OQ−OQ   @
  >−OQ@ −N:.

 6JHQ − N:.

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $VWHDG\IORZRINJVRIFDUERQGLR[LGHDQGZDWHUE\PDVVDW
.DQGN3DLVXVHGLQDKHDWH[FKDQJHUZKHUHN:LVH[WUDFWHGIURP
WKHIORZ)LQGWKHIORZH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHUDWHRIFKDQJHRIHQWURS\XVLQJ
7DEOH$
6ROXWLRQ
&9+HDWH[FKDQJHU6WHDG\LQOHWH[LWQRZRUN
&RQWLQXLW\(T F&2 F+2 
   
(QHUJ\(T4 PKH−KL !KH KL4P
,QOHWVWDWH7DEOH$KL ×× N-NJ
 
([LWVWDWHKH KL4P  N-NJ
7ULDODQGHUURUIRU7ZLWKKYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$
 #.KH  N-NJ
 #.KH  N-NJ
 #.KH  N-NJ
  ,QWHUSRODWHWRKDYHWKHULJKWK7 .
   
(QWURS\(T PVH PVL476JHQ
7KHUDWHRIFKDQJHRIHQWURS\IRUWKHIORZLV3LVDVVXPHGFRQVWDQW
  R R
 PVHVL PV7HV7L
   >@
   N:.
7KHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQUDWHFDQQRWEHHVWLPDWHGXQOHVVWKHDYHUDJH7DWZKLFK
WKHKHDWWUDQVIHUOHDYHVWKHFRQWUROYROXPHLVNQRZQ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $VWHDG\IORZRINPROVRIFDUERQGLR[LGHDQGZDWHUDW.DQG
N3DLVXVHGLQDKHDWH[FKDQJHUZKHUHN:LVH[WUDFWHGIURPWKHIORZ
)LQGWKHIORZH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHUDWHRIFKDQJHRIHQWURS\XVLQJ7DEOH$
&9+HDWH[FKDQJHU6WHDG\IORZLQOHWH[LWQRZRUN
&RQWLQXLW\(T \&2 \+2 
        
(QHUJ\(T4 PKH−KL QKH−KL !KH KL4Q

,QOHWVWDWH7DEOH$KL ×× N-NPRO
   
([LWVWDWHKH KL4Q  N-NPRO
7ULDODQGHUURUIRU7ZLWKKYDOXHVIURP7DEOH$

#.KH  N-NPRO

#.KH  N-NPRO
  ,QWHUSRODWHWRKDYHWKHULJKWK7 .

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



$IORZRINJVVWHDPDWN3DR&LVPL[HGZLWKNJVR[\JHQDW
N3D.LQDVWHDG\IORZPL[LQJFKDPEHUZLWKRXWDQ\KHDWWUDQVIHU)LQGWKH
H[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHUDWHRIHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQ

 &90L[LQJFKDPEHUVWHDG\IORZQRZRUNQRKHDWWUDQVIHU7RGRWKHHQWURSLHV
ZHQHHGWKHPROHIUDFWLRQV

 
 P+2   P2 
 Q+2 0   NPROVQ2 0   NPROV
+2 2

  \+2 \2 

   
(QHUJ\(T P+2KP2K P+2K+2P2K2
    
(QWURS\(TP+2VP2V6JHQ P+2V+2P2V2
6ROYHIRU7IURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 
 P+2K+2±KP2K2±K 
 
 P+2&3+27±7P2&327±7 
 ×7±±× 7± 
   7 .
  
 6JHQ P+2V+2±VP2V2±V
 7  7
  P+2>&3+2OQ7 5OQ\+2@P2>&32OQ7 5OQ\2@
 


  >OQ±OQ@


   >OQ  ±OQ@

   N:.


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $WDQNKDVWZRVLGHVLQLWLDOO\VHSDUDWHGE\DGLDSKUDJP6LGH$FRQWDLQVNJRI
ZDWHUDQGVLGH%FRQWDLQVNJRIDLUERWKDW°&N3D7KHGLDSKUDJPLV
QRZEURNHQDQGWKHZKROHWDQNLVKHDWHGWR°&E\D°&UHVHUYRLU)LQGWKH
ILQDOWRWDOSUHVVXUHKHDWWUDQVIHUDQGWRWDOHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQ
&97RWDOWDQNRXWWRUHVHUYRLU
(QHUJ\(T 88 PDXXDPYXXY 4
(QWURS\(TDQG
   66 PDVVDPYVVY 47UHV6JHQ
9ROXPH9 9$9% PYYYPDYD  P
 YY 9PY 7 !3Y N3D
 YD 9PD 7 !3D P579 N3D
 3WRW 3Y3D N3D
:DWHUWDEOH%X N-NJX N-NJ
V N-NJ.V N-NJ.
$LUWDEOH$X N-NJX N-NJ
V7 N-NJ.V7 N-NJ.
)URPHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQZHKDYH
 4  N-
)URPWKHHQWURS\HTXDWLRQZHKDYH
 6JHQ >×OQ@
   N-.

 4 
 

$ % &



   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KUHHVWHDG\IORZVDUHPL[HGLQDQDGLDEDWLFFKDPEHUDWN3D)ORZRQHLV
NJVRI2DW.IORZWZRLVNJVRI1DW.DQGIORZWKUHHLVNJVRI
&2DW.$OOIORZVDUHDWN3DWKHVDPHDVWKHWRWDOH[LWSUHVVXUH)LQG
WKHH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHUDWHRIHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQLQWKHSURFHVV

 6ROXWLRQ
 &90L[LQJFKDPEHUQRKHDWWUDQVIHUQRZRUN 
    2
&RQWLQXLW\(TPPP P  
    1 0,;
(QHUJ\(TPKPKPK PK  PL[
&2 
     
(QWURS\(TPVPVPV6JHQ PV
$VVXPHLGHDOJDVHVDQGVLQFH7LVFORVHWR.XVHKHDWFDSDFLW\IURP$
LQWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQDV

  
 P&3277P&3177P&3&277 
 ××××××
   ×××7
   ! 7 !7 .
6WDWHLVDPL[WXUHVRWKHFRPSRQHQWH[LWSUHVVXUHLVWKHSDUWLDOSUHVVXUH)RU
HDFKFRPSRQHQWVH−VL &3OQ7H7L−5OQ3H3LDQGWKHSUHVVXUH
UDWLRLV3H3L \33L \IRUHDFK
P   
 Q ∑0   

  

\2  \1  \&2    

7KHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQEHFRPHV

   
 6JHQ PVVPVVPVV
  >OQOQ@
  >OQOQ@
  >OQOQ@
   N:.
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 5HFRQVLGHUWKH3UREOHPEXWOHWWKHWDQNVKDYHDVPDOODPRXQWRIKHDW
WUDQVIHUVRWKHILQDOPL[WXUHLVDW.)LQGWKHILQDOSUHVVXUHWKHKHDWWUDQVIHU
DQGWKHHQWURS\FKDQJHIRUWKHSURFHVV
&9%RWKWDQNV&RQWUROPDVVZLWKPL[LQJDQGKHDWLQJRIWZRLGHDOJDVHV
− ×
 Q$U 3$9$57$   NPRO
×
− ×
 Q&+ 3%9%57%   NPRO
×
&RQWLQXLW\(T Q Q$UQ&+ NPRO
 
(QHUJ\(T 88 Q$U&977$Q&+&9277% 4

−
 3 Q579$9% ×× N3D
 4 ××
  ×× N-
 
 ∆66855 476855∆66<6 Q$U∆6$UQ&+∆6&+
 \$U  

  7 − \$U3
 ∆6$U &3$UOQ7 5OQ 3 
$ $

 ×
  ×OQOQ  

  N-NPRO.

  7  − \ &  + 3 
 ∆6&+ &&+OQ7 5OQ 3 
% %

 ×
  ×OQOQ  

  N-NPRO.
$VVXPHWKHVXUURXQGLQJVDUHDW.LWKHDWVWKHJDV
 
 ∆61(7 Q$U∆6$UQ&+∆6&+∆66855

  ××
  N-.

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


$LUZDWHUYDSRUPL[WXUHV


 $WPRVSKHULFDLULVDWN3DR&DQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\)LQGWKHDEVROXWH
KXPLGLW\DQGWKHGHZSRLQWRIWKHPL[WXUH,IWKHPL[WXUHLVKHDWHGWRR&ZKDW
LVWKHQHZUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\"
6ROXWLRQ
(T 3Y φ3J × N3D
(T Z 3Y3WRW3Y ×± 
7GHZLVWKH7VXFKWKDW3J7 3Y N3D
% ! 7≅°&
+HDWLQJ ! ZLVFRQVWDQW !3YLVFRQVWDQW
)URP7DEOH%3J°& N3D
φ = 3Y3J  RU

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RQVLGHUPRIDWPRVSKHULFDLUZKLFKLVDQDLU±ZDWHUYDSRUPL[WXUHDW
N3D°&DQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\)LQGWKHPDVVRIZDWHUDQGWKHKXPLGLW\
UDWLR:KDWLVWKHGHZSRLQWRIWKHPL[WXUH"
6ROXWLRQ
 $LUYDSRU3 N3D7 R&φ 
8VH7DEOH%DQGWKHQ(T
 3J 3VDW N3D !3Y φ3J × N3D
3Y 9 ×
 PY 5 7   NJ
Y ×
 3D 3WRW3Y ± N3D
3D9 ×
 PD 5 7   NJ
D ×
PY 
 Z P   
D
 7GHZLV7ZKHQ3Y 3J N3D
 7DEOH%JLYHV7 R&

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KHSURGXFWVRIFRPEXVWLRQDUHIORZLQJWKURXJKDKHDWH[FKDQJHUZLWK&2
+2DQG1RQDYROXPHEDVLVDWWKHUDWHNJVDQGN3D:KDWLV
WKHGHZSRLQWWHPSHUDWXUH",IWKHPL[WXUHLVFRROHG°&EHORZWKHGHZSRLQW
WHPSHUDWXUHKRZORQJZLOOLWWDNHWRFROOHFWNJRIOLTXLGZDWHU"
6ROXWLRQ
9ROXPHEDVLVLVWKHVDPHDVPROHIUDFWLRQ
 \+2 3+2 × N3D

 7DEOH%7'(: R&
 &RROWRR&7'(:VRVDWXUDWHG→3* N3D
 \+2  Q+2YQ+2Y
 Q+2Y SHUNPROPL[LQ

 →Q/,4  

 00,;,1 ××× NJNPRO
 
 Q0,;,1 P727$/00,;,1  NPROV

 Q/,4&21' × NPROV

 RUP/,4&21' × NJV
 )RUNJWDNHV~PLQXWHV

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $IORZRINJVVDWXUDWHGPRLVWDLUUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DWN3DR&
JRHVWKURXJKDKHDWH[FKDQJHUDQGFRPHVRXWDWR&:KDWLVWKHH[LWUHODWLYH
KXPLGLW\DQGKRZPXFKSRZHULVQHHGHG"
6ROXWLRQ
6WDWH φ  3Y 3J 
(T Z 3Y3D ×± 
6WDWH 1RZDWHUDGGHG !Z Z !3Y 3Y
 φ 3Y3J  RU
(QHUJ\(T
    
 4 PKPK PDKKDLUZPDKKYDSRU
   
 PWRW PDPY PDZ
(QHUJ\HTXDWLRQZLWK&3DLUIURP$DQGK¶VIURP%
 
 PWRW PWRW
 4 Z &3DLU±Z ZKJKJ
 
 ×
  ×±  

   N:


   

.
4 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QHZKLJKHIILFLHQF\KRPHKHDWLQJV\VWHPLQFOXGHVDQDLUWRDLUKHDWH[FKDQJHU
ZKLFKXVHVHQHUJ\IURPRXWJRLQJVWDOHDLUWRKHDWWKHIUHVKLQFRPLQJDLU,IWKH
RXWVLGHDPELHQWWHPSHUDWXUHLV−°&DQGWKHUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LVKRZ
PXFKZDWHUZLOOKDYHWREHDGGHGWRWKHLQFRPLQJDLULILWIORZVLQDWWKHUDWHRI
PVDQGPXVWHYHQWXDOO\EHFRQGLWLRQHGWR°&DQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\"
6ROXWLRQ
2XWVLGHDPELHQWDLU39 φ3* × N3D
$VVXPLQJ3 3 N3D !3$  N3D

 3$9 ×
 P$  5 7    NJV
$  ×

)URP(T Z × 

 &RQGLWLRQHGWR7 R&φ 

(T 39 φ3* ×  !

(TZ × 

&RQWLQXLW\HTXDWLRQIRUZDWHU
 
 P/,4,1 P$ZZ 
   NJV NJK

 ,1 

2876,'(
6,'(



   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RQVLGHUDPVIORZRIDWPRVSKHULFDLUDWN3D°&DQGUHODWLYH
KXPLGLW\$VVXPHWKLVIORZVLQWRDEDVHPHQWURRPZKHUHLWFRROVWR°&
N3D+RZPXFKOLTXLGZDWHUZLOOFRQGHQVHRXW"

6ROXWLRQ
6WDWH 3J 3VDW N3D !3Y φ3J ×  N3D

 3Y 9 × 
 PY 5 7   NJV
Y ×

PY 3Y 
 Z    3   
P$ $

 PY  
 P$  Z   NJV P$FRQWLQXLW\IRUDLU


 &KHFNIRUVWDWH  
3J°& N3D3Y
VROLTXLGZDWHURXW .
4 /LTXLG 

6WDWHLVVDWXUDWHGφ 3Y 3J N3D
3Y 
 Z 3   
$
 
 PY ZP$ × NJV
  
 POLT PYPY ± NJV

1RWHWKDWWKHJLYHQYROXPHIORZUDWHDWWKHLQOHWLVQRWWKDWDWWKHH[LW7KH
PDVVIORZUDWHRIGU\DLULVWKHTXDQWLW\WKDWLVWKHVDPHDWWKHLQOHWDQGH[LW

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $IORZRINJVFRPSOHWHO\GU\DLUDW7N3DLVFRROHGGRZQWR°&E\
VSUD\LQJOLTXLGZDWHUDW°&N3DLQWRLWVRLWEHFRPHVVDWXUDWHGPRLVWDLUDW
°&7KHSURFHVVLVVWHDG\VWDWHZLWKQRH[WHUQDOKHDWWUDQVIHURUZRUN)LQGWKH
H[LWPRLVWDLUKXPLGLW\UDWLRDQGWKHIORZUDWHRIOLTXLGZDWHU)LQGDOVRWKHGU\DLU
LQOHWWHPSHUDWXUH7
6ROXWLRQ
VDWXUDWHG 3Y 3J N3DDQGKIJ°& N-NJ
(T  Z × 

  'U\DLU /LTXLGZDWHU
 



&9%R[
  
&RQWLQXLW\(T PDPOLT PDZ !
 
   POLT ZPD NJV
  
(QHUJ\(T PDKDPOLTKI PDKDZKJ
 KDKD &SD77 ZKJZKI ZKIJ N-NJGU\DLU
     !7 °&

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $SLVWRQF\OLQGHUKDVNJRIVDWXUDWHGPRLVWDLUDWN3D°&,ILWLVKHDWHG
WR°&LQDQLVREDULFSURFHVVILQG4DQGWKHILQDOUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\,ILWLV
FRPSUHVVHGIURPWKHLQLWLDOVWDWHWRN3DLQDQLVRWKHUPDOSURFHVVILQGWKH
PDVVRIZDWHUFRQGHQVLQJ
6ROXWLRQ
(QHUJ\(T PXX 4:
,QLWLDOVWDWHφ 7DEOH%3Y N3DKY 
3Y 
 (T Z 3 3   
WRW Y
 (TZLWKPD PWRWPY PWRWZPDJLYHV
   PD PWRWZ NJ
 (T PY ZPD NJ

&DVHD3 FRQVWDQW !: P3YY !
4 PXX: PKK PD&S77PKYKY
6WDWHZ Z7 !3Y 3YDQG
  7DEOH%KY N-NJ3J N3D
3Y 
 (T φ 3     RUφ 
J
 )URPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 4 × N-

&DVHE7 FRQVWDQW φ  !3Y 3J N3D
3Y 3Y 
Z 3  3 3   
D WRW Y
PY ZPD NJPOLT PYPY NJ

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $VDWXUDWHGDLUZDWHUYDSRUPL[WXUHDWR&N3DLVFRQWDLQHGLQDP
FORVHGWDQNLQHTXLOLEULXPZLWKNJRIOLTXLGZDWHU7KHWDQNLVKHDWHGWRR&
,VWKHUHDQ\OLTXLGZDWHULQWKHILQDOVWDWH")LQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUIRUWKHSURFHVV

 $,5 D6LQFH9/,4 P/,4Y)≈P9*$6≈9
+
9$3 φ →3Y 3* N3D
4
/,4  Z ×  
3D9 ×
PD 5 7    NJ !PY ZPD NJ
D  ×
 
$WVWDWH3D × ×   N3D

  Z0$; × 


%XWZ$&78$/    Z0$;→1ROLTXLGDW
 4 PDXDXDPYXYPYXYPOLTXOLT
  ×× ××
   N-
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PELHQWPRLVWDLUHQWHUVDVWHDG\IORZDLUFRQGLWLRQLQJXQLWDWN3D°&
ZLWKDUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\7KHYROXPHIORZUDWHHQWHULQJWKHXQLWLV/V
7KHPRLVWDLUOHDYHVWKHXQLWDWN3D°&ZLWKDUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\RI
/LTXLGFRQGHQVDWHDOVROHDYHVWKHXQLWDW°&'HWHUPLQHWKHUDWHRIKHDWWUDQVIHU
IRUWKLVSURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
6WDWH 39 φ3* × 
 Z × 

 3$9 ×
 P$  5 7    NJV
$  ×
 39 3*  Z × 
     
(QHUJ\(T4&9P$K$P9K9 P$K$P9K$PK/
 
 4&9P$ &3$77ZK9ZK9ZZK/
   ××
  × N-NJDLU

 4&9  N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RQVLGHUD/ULJLGWDQNFRQWDLQLQJDQDLU±ZDWHUYDSRUPL[WXUHDWN3D
°&ZLWKDUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\7KHV\VWHPLVFRROHGXQWLOWKHZDWHUMXVW
EHJLQVWRFRQGHQVH'HWHUPLQHWKHILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHLQWKHWDQNDQGWKHKHDW
WUDQVIHUIRUWKHSURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
 3Y φ3* × N3D
 6LQFHPY FRQVW 9 FRQVW DOVR3Y 3*
 3* 3Y× 77 × 7 7
$VVXPH7 R&×    3*&
$VVXPH7 R&×    3*&
  LQWHUSRODWLQJ→7 R&

 Z Z  

 PD 3D95D7 ×× NJ

 VWODZ(T4 88 PDXDXDPYXYXY
   N-NJ
 →4  N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $LULQDSLVWRQF\OLQGHULVDW°&N3DDQGDUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\RI,WLV
QRZFRPSUHVVHGWRDSUHVVXUHRIN3DLQDFRQVWDQWWHPSHUDWXUHSURFHVV)LQG
WKHILQDOUHODWLYHDQGVSHFLILFKXPLGLW\DQGWKHYROXPHUDWLR99
6ROXWLRQ
&KHFNWRVHHLIWKHVHFRQGVWDWHLVVDWXUDWHGRUQRW)LUVWDVVXPHQRZDWHULV
FRQGHQVHG
 Z Z 3Y33Y
 Z Z !3Y !3J N3D
 &RQFOXVLRQLVVWDWHLVVDWXUDWHG
 φ Z 3J33J 
7RJHWWKHYROXPHUDWLRZULWHWKHLGHDOJDVODZIRUWKHYDSRUSKDVHV
 9 9D9Y9I PD5DPY5Y73POLTYI
 9 9D9Y PD5DPY5Y73
7DNHWKHUDWLRDQGGLYLGHWKURXJKZLWKPD5D73WRJHW
 99 33>ZZZ3YI5D7@>Z@
   
7KHOLTXLGFRQWULEXWLRQLVQHDUO\]HUR LQWKHQXPHUDWRU


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $/ULJLGYHVVHOLQLWLDOO\FRQWDLQVPRLVWDLUDWN3D°&ZLWKDUHODWLYH
KXPLGLW\RI$VXSSO\OLQHFRQQHFWHGWRWKLVYHVVHOE\DYDOYHFDUULHVVWHDP
DWN3D°&7KHYDOYHLVRSHQHGDQGVWHDPIORZVLQWRWKHYHVVHOXQWLOWKH
UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\RIWKHUHVXOWDQWPRLVWDLUPL[WXUHLV7KHQWKHYDOYHLV
FORVHG6XIILFLHQWKHDWLVWUDQVIHUUHGIURPWKHYHVVHOVRWKHWHPSHUDWXUHUHPDLQVDW
°&GXULQJWKHSURFHVV'HWHUPLQHWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUIRUWKHSURFHVVWKHPDVVRI
VWHDPHQWHULQJWKHYHVVHODQGWKHILQDOSUHVVXUHLQVLGHWKHYHVVHO

 6ROXWLRQ

 3  φ 3  × N3D
Y  *
+2
 L
3Y × N3D
3D 3D  N3D
$,5 
 Z ×  
+2

 
Z ×  

 PD ×× NJ

 3  N3D
 PYL  NJ
 XY XY≈X*DWR&DQGXD XD
(QHUJ\(T
 4&9 PDXDXDPYXYPYXYPYLKL
  PYLX*DW7KL  N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $ULJLGFRQWDLQHUPLQYROXPHFRQWDLQVPRLVWDLUDW°&N3Dφ=
7KHFRQWDLQHULVQRZFRROHGWR°&1HJOHFWWKHYROXPHRIDQ\OLTXLGWKDWPLJKWEH
SUHVHQWDQGILQGWKHILQDOPDVVRIZDWHUYDSRUILQDOWRWDOSUHVVXUHDQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHU
6ROXWLRQ
&9FRQWDLQHUP PPXPX 4
6WDWH°&φ  !Z 7GHZ °&
 )LQDOVWDWH77GHZVRFRQGHQVDWLRQφ 
 3Y 3J × N3D3D 3WRW3Y N3D
 PD 3D957 NJPY ZPD NJ
 3Y 3J N3D3D 3D77 N3D
 3 3D3Y N3D
 PY 3Y95Y7 NJ 9YJ VWHDPWDEOH
 PI PYPY NJ
7KHKHDWWUDQVIHUIURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQEHFRPHV
 4 PDXXDPYXJPIXIPYXJ
 PD&Y77PYPIPY
  N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $ZDWHUILOOHGUHDFWRURIPLVDW03D°&DQGORFDWHGLQVLGHDQLQVXODWHG
FRQWDLQPHQWURRPRIPWKDWFRQWDLQVDLUDWN3DDQG°&'XHWRD
IDLOXUHWKHUHDFWRUUXSWXUHVDQGWKHZDWHUILOOVWKHFRQWDLQPHQWURRP)LQGWKHILQDO
SUHVVXUH
&97RWDOFRQWDLQHU
PYXXPDXX 4: 
,QLWLDOZDWHUY X PY 9Y NJ
,QLWLDODLUPD 3957 ×× NJ
6XEVWLWXWHLQWRHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
X×7 
X7 N-NJ Y 9PY PNJ
7ULDODQGHUURUSKDVH7JXHVVY ![ !X !/+6
 7 /+6 7 /+6 
 7 /+6  !7 °&/+6 2.
[ 3VDW N3D
3D 3D9797 ××× N3D
   !3 3D3VDW N3D

 
100 m3

3
1m


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


7DEOHVDQGIRUPXODVRUSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW


 $IORZPRLVWDLUDWN3D°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LVFRROHGWR°&LQD
FRQVWDQWSUHVVXUHGHYLFH)LQGWKHKXPLGLW\UDWLRRIWKHLQOHWDQGWKHH[LWIORZ
DQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHULQWKHGHYLFHSHUNJGU\DLU
6ROXWLRQ
  
&9&RROHUPY POLTPY 
7DEOHV3J N3D 3Y N3Dω 
 3Y N3D 3J ! ω 
 KY N-NJKY N-NJKI N-NJ
TRXW &377ωKYωKYωωKI
 ×××
 N-NJGU\DLU
3V\FKURPHWULFFKDUW6WDWH77GHZ °& !φ 
  a  
PYPD ω K PYPD ω K× 
 
POLTPD ωω KI N-NJ
   
  PDTRXW PDK×POLTKIPDK× !
   TRXW K×ωωKIK× ±×±
    N-NJGU\DLU

 Z 
Φ = 

Φ = 

'HZSRLQW  Φ = 

Φ = 

7 GU\
7GHZ


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $IORZNJVGU\DLURIPRLVWDLUDW°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\IORZVIURP
WKHRXWVLGHVWDWHGRZQLQWRDEDVHPHQWZKHUHLWFRROVWR°&VWDWH7KHQLW
IORZVXSWRWKHOLYLQJURRPZKHUHLWLVKHDWHGWR°&VWDWH)LQGWKHGHZSRLQW
IRUVWDWHDQ\DPRXQWRIOLTXLGWKDWPD\DSSHDUWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUWKDWWDNHVSODFH
LQWKHEDVHPHQWDQGWKHUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LQWKHOLYLQJURRPDWVWDWH

6ROYHXVLQJSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
D7GHZ Z Zφ Z K× N-NJDLU
E77GHZVRZHKDYHφ OLTXLGZDWHUDSSHDULQWKHEDVHPHQW
  !Z  K×  DQGIURPVWHDPWEO KI 
 
 POLT PDLUZZ  NJV
  
F(QHUJ\HTXDWLRQPDLUK× POLTKIPDLUK×4RXW
  4RXW >×@ N:
GZ Z  °& !φ 

,I\RXVROYHE\WKHIRUPXODVDQGWKHWDEOHVWKHQXPEHUVDUH
 3J 3Y × N3D
 Z × 
 3Y 3J7GHZ !7GHZ °&
 φ 3Y 3J N3DZ × 
 
  POLT PDLUZZ × NJV
 Z Z !3Y 3Y  3J 
  φ 3Y3J  

 
Z Φ = 

Φ = 
'HZSRLQW 

Φ = 
 
Φ = 

7GHZ 7 GU\ 
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7ZRPRLVWDLUVWUHDPVZLWKUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\ERWKIORZLQJDWDUDWHRI
NJVRIGU\DLUDUHPL[HGLQDVWHDG\VHWXS2QHLQOHWIORZVWUHDPLVDW°&DQG
WKHRWKHUDW°&)LQGWKHH[LWUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\
6ROXWLRQ
&9PL[LQJFKDPEHU
  
 &RQWLQXLW\(TZDWHUPDLUZPDLUZ PDLUZH[
  
 (QHUJ\(TPDLUK×PDLUK× PDLUK×H[
3URSHUWLHVIURPWKHWDEOHVDQGIRUPXODV
 3J 3Y × N3D
 Z × 
 3J 3Y × N3D
 Z × 
&RQWLQXLW\(TZDWHUZH[ ZZ 
)RUWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQZHKDYHK× KDZKYVR
 K×H[K×K×  KDH[KDKDZH[KYH[ZKYZKY
ZHZLOOXVHFRQVWDQWKHDWFDSDFLW\WRDYRLGDQLWHUDWLRQRQ7H[
 &SDLU7H[77&S+2ZH[7H[Z7Z7 
 7H[ >&SDLU77&S+2Z7Z7@>&SDLUZH[&S+2@
  >××@
  °&
ZH[ 
 3YH[ Z 3WRW  N3D
H[
3JH[ N3D !φ  RU


3URSHUWLHVWDNHQIURPWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
6WDWHZ K× 6WDWHZ K× 
&RQWLQXLW\(TZDWHUZH[ ZZ 
(QHUJ\(TK×H[ K×K× N-NJGU\DLU
 H[LWZH[K×H[ !7H[ °&φ 


1RWLFHKRZWKHHQHUJ\LQWHUPVRIWHPSHUDWXUHLVFORVHWRWKHDYHUDJHRIWKH
WZRIORZVEXWWKHUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LVQRW
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



7KHGLVFKDUJHPRLVWDLUIURPDFORWKHVGU\HULVDWR&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\
7KHIORZLVJXLGHGWKURXJKDSLSHXSWKURXJKWKHURRIDQGDYHQWWRWKH
DWPRVSKHUH'XHWRKHDWWUDQVIHULQWKHSLSHWKHIORZLVFRROHGWRR&E\WKH
WLPHLWUHDFKHVWKHYHQW)LQGWKHKXPLGLW\UDWLRLQWKHIORZRXWRIWKHFORWKHV
GU\HUDQGDWWKHYHQW)LQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUDQGDQ\DPRXQWRIOLTXLGWKDWPD\EH
IRUPLQJSHUNJGU\DLUIRUWKHIORZ
 6ROXWLRQ

 6WDWHZ K× 7GHZ R&
6WDWHR&7GHZVRLWLVVDWXUDWHG 2
Z K× N-NJDLU
 
POLTPD ωω NJNJGU\DLU

(QHUJ\(T
  1
4PD K×K×±ωωKI
 ±±×
 N-NJGU\DLU 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $VWHDG\VXSSO\RIPVDLUDW°&N3DUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LVQHHGHG
WRKHDWDEXLOGLQJLQWKHZLQWHU7KHRXWGRRUDPELHQWLVDW°&N3D
UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\:KDWDUHWKHUHTXLUHGOLTXLGZDWHULQSXWDQGKHDWWUDQVIHUUDWHV
IRUWKLVSXUSRVH"
6ROXWLRQ
$LU5D N-NJ.&S N-NJ.
6WDWH7 °&φ 3 N3D
 3J N3D3Y φ3J N3D
 3D 33Y N3D !ω 3Y3D 

6WDWH7 °&3 N3Dφ 9 PV
 3J N3D3Y φ3J N3D
3D 33Y N3Dω 3Y3D 
 
 PD 3D95D7 ×× NJV
6WHDPWDEOHV%KY N-NJ KY N-NJ
6WDWH$VVXPH/LT:DWHUDW7 °&KI N-NJ
    
&RQVHUYDWLRQRI0DVVPD PDPI PYPY
 
 PI PDωω × NJV
     
VW/DZ4PDKDPYKYPIKI PDKDPYKY
 
4 PI 
   &S77ωKYωKY  KI ! 4 N:
PD PD

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $FRPELQDWLRQDLUFRROHUDQGGHKXPLGLILFDWLRQXQLWUHFHLYHVRXWVLGHDPELHQWDLU
DW°&N3DUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\7KHPRLVWDLULVILUVWFRROHGWRDORZ
WHPSHUDWXUH7WRFRQGHQVHWKHSURSHUDPRXQWRIZDWHUDVVXPHDOOWKHOLTXLG
OHDYHVDW77KHPRLVWDLULVWKHQKHDWHGDQGOHDYHVWKHXQLWDW°&N3D
UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\ZLWKYROXPHIORZUDWHRIPV)LQGWKHWHPSHUDWXUH
7WKHPDVVRIOLTXLGSHUNLORJUDPRIGU\DLUDQGWKHRYHUDOOKHDWWUDQVIHUUDWH

 6ROXWLRQ


0,; &22/  +($7 0,;
,1 287
'
&9
. .
4 & /,4 4+
287 

 D3Y φ3* × N3D

 Z ×  

 3Y φ3* × N3D


 Z Z ×  
 
 P/,4′PD ZZ  NJNJDLU
 3* 3Y N3D→ 7 R&
 E)RUD&9DURXQGWKHHQWLUHXQLW
  
 4&9 4+4&
 1HWKHDWWUDQVIHUVWODZ
   
 4&9PD KDKDZKYZKYP/′K/′PD
  ×××
  N-NJDLU

 3D9 ×
 PD  5 7    NJV
D  ×

 4&9  N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 8VHWKHIRUPXODVDQGWKHVWHDPWDEOHVWRILQGWKHPLVVLQJSURSHUW\RIφ, ωDQG
7GU\WRWDOSUHVVXUHLVN3DUHSHDWWKHDQVZHUVXVLQJWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
 Dφ ω E7GU\ ƒ&7ZHW ƒ&

6ROXWLRQ
D)URP(TZLWK3D 33YVROYHIRU3Y
   3Y 3ωω × N3D
)URP(T3J 3Yφ  N3D !7 °&


E$W°&3J  !ω × 
 )URPWKHVWHDPWDEOHV%
 KI DQGKIJ N-NJKY 
)URP(T
  ω >&S77ωKIJ@KYKI 
 )URP(TZLWK3D 33YVROYHIRU3Y
  3Y 3ωω 
 )URP(Tφ  

8VLQJWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW(
 D7GU\ °&Eω φ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QLQVXODWHGWDQNKDVDQDLULQOHWω=DQGDQRXWOHW7=°&φ 
ERWKDWN3D$WKLUGOLQHVSUD\VNJVRIZDWHUDW°&N3D)RU
VWHDG\RSHUDWLRQILQGWKHRXWOHWVSHFLILFKXPLGLW\WKHPDVVIORZUDWHRIDLUQHHGHG
DQGWKHUHTXLUHGDLULQOHWWHPSHUDWXUH7
6ROXWLRQ
7DNH&9WDQNLQVWHDG\VWDWH&RQWLQXLW\DQGHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQVDUH
  
&RQWLQXLW\(TZDWHUPPDZ PDZ
  
(QHUJ\(T PKIPDK× PDK×
$OOVWDWHSURSHUWLHVDUHNQRZQH[FHSW7
)URPWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUWZHJHW
6WDWHZ K× 6WDWHKI VWHDPWEO
 
PD PZZ  NJV
K× K×ZZKI × 
&KDUWZK× !7 °&

8VLQJWKHWDEOHVDQGIRUPXODVZHJHW
6WDWH 3J 3Y × N3D
  Z × 
 
PD PZZ  NJV
7RDYRLGLWHUDWLRQVRQ7ZHXVHVSHFLILFKHDWYDOXHVDOVRIRUZDWHUYDSRUE\
ZULWLQJKY KY&SKR77VRWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQLV
 &SD7Z&SKR77ZKY &SD7ZKYZZKI
7KHHTXDWLRQQRZEHFRPHV
 ×7 ×
    
  7 °&

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



$IORZRIPRLVWDLUIURPDGRPHVWLFIXUQDFHVWDWHLVDWR&UHODWLYH
KXPLGLW\ZLWKDIORZUDWHRINJVGU\DLU$VPDOOHOHFWULFKHDWHUDGGVVWHDP
DWR&N3DJHQHUDWHGIURPWDSZDWHUDWR&8SLQWKHOLYLQJURRPWKH
IORZFRPHVRXWDWVWDWHR&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\)LQGWKHSRZHUQHHGHG
IRUWKHHOHFWULFKHDWHUDQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUWRWKHIORZIURPVWDWHWRVWDWH

  Liquid 2
3 4
cb




6WDWHZ K× N-NJGU\DLU
6WDWHZ K× N-NJGU\DLU
 
POLT PDωω ± NJV

(QHUJ\(TIRUKHDWHU
 
 4KHDWHU POLTKRXW±KLQ ± N:
(QHUJ\(TIRUOLQH
  
4OLQH PDK×±K×±POLTKYDS
±±×
  ±N:
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $ZDWHUFRROLQJWRZHUIRUDSRZHUSODQWFRROV°&OLTXLGZDWHUE\HYDSRUDWLRQ
7KHWRZHUUHFHLYHVDLUDW°&φ=N3DWKDWLVEORZQWKURXJKRYHUWKH
ZDWHUVXFKWKDWLWOHDYHVWKHWRZHUDW°&φ=7KHUHPDLQLQJOLTXLGZDWHU
IORZVEDFNWRWKHFRQGHQVHUDW°&KDYLQJJLYHQRII0:)LQGWKHPDVVIORZ
UDWHRIDLUDQGWKHDPRXQWRIZDWHUWKDWHYDSRUDWHV
6ROXWLRQ
&97RWDOFRROLQJWRZHUVWHDG\VWDWH
 
&RQWLQXLW\(TIRUZDWHULQDLUZLQPHYDSPD ZH[
    
(QHUJ\(TPDK×LQPK PDK×H[PPHYDSK
,QOHW°&UHOKXP !ZLQ K×LQ 
([LW°&UHOKXP !ZH[ K×H[ 
7DNHWKHWZRZDWHUIORZGLIIHUHQFHWRPHDQWKH0:
   
  4 PKPPHYDSK 0:
  
PDK×H[K×LQ PD N: !PD NJV
 
PHYDS ZH[ZLQPD × NJV
7KHQHHGHGPDNHXSZDWHUIORZFRXOGEHDGGHGWRJLYHDVOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQW
PHDQLQJWRWKH0:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $IORZRIDLUDW°&φ=LVEURXJKWLQWRDKRXVHZKHUHLWLVFRQGLWLRQHGWR
°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\7KLVLVGRQHZLWKDFRPELQHGKHDWHUHYDSRUDWRU
ZKHUHDQ\OLTXLGZDWHULVDW°&)LQGDQ\IORZRIOLTXLGDQGWKHQHFHVVDU\KHDW
WUDQVIHUERWKSHUNLORJUDPGU\DLUIORZLQJ)LQGWKHGHZSRLQWIRUWKHILQDO
PL[WXUH
&9KHDWHUDQGHYDSRUDWRU8VHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
 ,QOHWZ K× N-NJGU\DLUKI N-NJ
 ([LWZ K× N-NJGU\DLU7GHZ °&
)URPWKHVHQXPEHUVZHVHHWKDWZDWHUDQGKHDWPXVWEHDGGHG&RQWLQXLW\HT
DQGHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQJLYH
 
 P/,4,1P$ ZZ NJNJGU\DLU
 T K×K×ZZKI N-NJGU\DLU


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 ,QDFDU¶VGHIURVWGHIRJV\VWHPDWPRVSKHULFDLU°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LV
WDNHQLQDQGFRROHGVXFKWKDWOLTXLGZDWHUGULSVRXW7KHQRZGU\HUDLULVKHDWHG
WR°&DQGWKHQEORZQRQWRWKHZLQGVKLHOGZKHUHLWVKRXOGKDYHDPD[LPXPRI
UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\WRUHPRYHZDWHUIURPWKHZLQGVKLHOG)LQGWKHGHZSRLQW
RIWKHDWPRVSKHULFDLUVSHFLILFKXPLGLW\RIDLURQWRWKHZLQGVKLHOGWKHORZHVW
WHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHVSHFLILFKHDWWUDQVIHULQWKHFRROHU
6ROXWLRQ
  4 FRRO 4 KHDW
  

/LTXLG 
6ROYHXVLQJWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW

 Z 
Φ = 
'HZSRLQW $LULQOHW°&φ 
Φ =   !Z 
IRU  7GHZ °&
 Φ =  K× 
$LUH[LW°&φ 
  !Z 
7GHZ °&
7 GHZ 7 GHZ 7 GU\  

7RUHPRYHHQRXJKZDWHUZHPXVWFRROWRWKHH[LW7GHZIROORZHGE\KHDWLQJ
WR7H[7KHHQWKDOS\IURPFKDUWK× DQGIURP%KI°& 
&9FRROHU
 
POLTPDLU ZZ  NJ OLTNJ DLU
 
T 4&9PDLU K×ZZKIK×
  × N-NJGU\DLU
,IWKHVWHDPDQGDLUWDEOHVDUHXVHGWKHQXPEHUVDUH
 6WDWH3J 3Y  !Z 
 KJ KD  !K× 
 6WDWH3J 3Y  !Z 
 6WDWHZJ Z !7 7GHZ °&KI 
  KJ KD  !K× 
 
POLTPDLU T ×  N-NJDLU
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $WPRVSKHULFDLUDW°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\RILVWRRZDUPDQGDOVRWRRGU\
$QDLUFRQGLWLRQHUVKRXOGGHOLYHUDLUDW°&DQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LQWKH
DPRXQWRIPSHUKRXU6NHWFKDVHWXSWRDFFRPSOLVKWKLVILQGDQ\DPRXQW
RIOLTXLGDW°&WKDWLVQHHGHGRUGLVFDUGHGDQGDQ\KHDWWUDQVIHU
6ROXWLRQ
&9DLUFRQGLWLRQHU)LUVWZHPXVWFKHFNLIZDWHUVKRXOGEHDGGHGRU
VXEWUDFWHG:HFDQNQRZWKLVIURPWKHDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\UDWLR
3URSHUWLHVIURPWKHWDEOHVDQGIRUPXODV
6WDWH 3J 3Y × N3D
  Z × 
6WDWH 3J 3Y × N3D
  Z × 
$VZJRHVXSZHPXVWDGGOLTXLGZDWHU1RZZHJHW
  
&RQWLQXLW\(T P$Z  POLT P$Z
   
(QHUJ\(T P$K×PL[POLTKI4&9 P$K×PL[
)RUWKHOLTXLGIORZZHQHHGWKHDLUPDVVIORZUDWHRXWPK PV
 
 P$ 3D957 × NJV
 
 POLT P$ZZ NJV NJK
  
 4&9 P$>&SD77ZKYZKY@POLTKI
  >××@
   × N:
,IIURPSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
 ,QOHWZ K×PL[ KI N-NJ
 ([LWZ K×PL[ N-NJGU\DLU
 
  3YDQGP$ 3D957VDPHDVDERYH
  
 4&9 P$K×PL[K×PL[POLTKI ×
  N:

 /LTXLGZDWHU 
&RROHU
([LW
,QOHW

  
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 2QHPHDQVRIDLUFRQGLWLRQLQJKRWVXPPHUDLULVE\HYDSRUDWLYHFRROLQJZKLFKLV
DSURFHVVVLPLODUWRWKHDGLDEDWLFVDWXUDWLRQSURFHVV&RQVLGHURXWGRRUDPELHQWDLU
DW°&N3DUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\:KDWLVWKHPD[LPXPDPRXQWRI
FRROLQJWKDWFDQEHDFKLHYHGE\VXFKDWHFKQLTXH":KDWGLVDGYDQWDJHLVWKHUHWR
WKLVDSSURDFK"6ROYHWKHSUREOHPXVLQJDILUVWODZDQDO\VLVDQGUHSHDWLWXVLQJWKH
SV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW)LJ(

 Ambient Cooled 3 3 N3D
Air
1 2 Air 7 R&φ 
3 3Y φ3J × 
Liquid  ω × 
)RUDGLDEDWLFVDWXUDWLRQ0D[FRROLQJLVIRUφ VWODZ(T
  ωKYKI &S77ωKIJ
  φ  ω ×3*33*
2QO\RQHXQNQRZQ77ULDODQGHUURURQHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
  &S7ωKIJωKI &S7ωKY
     ×× 
7 R&3* KI KIJ 
  !ω × 
 /+6 ××× 
7 R&3* KI KIJ 
  !ω × 
 /+6 ××× 
  OLQHDULQWHUSRODWLRQ7 R&

7KLVPHWKRGGRHVORZHUWKHWHPSHUDWXUHEXWWKHUHODWLYHDQGDEVROXWH
KXPLGLW\EHFRPHVYHU\KLJKDQGWKHVOLJKWHVWFRROLQJOLNHRQDZDOOZLOOUHVXOW
LQFRQGHQVDWLRQ

EFKDUW($GLDEDWLFVDWXUDWLRQ7≈:HW%XOE7HPSHUDWXUH≈R&

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



$IORZRIPRLVWDLUDWR&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\ZLWKDIORZUDWHRINJV
GU\DLULVPL[HGZLWKDIORZRIPRLVWDLUDWR&DQGDEVROXWHKXPLGLW\RIZ 
ZLWKDUDWHRINJVGU\DLU7KHPL[LQJWDNHVSODFHLQDQDLUGXFWDW
N3DDQGWKHUHLVQRVLJQLILFDQWKHDWWUDQVIHU$IWHUWKHPL[LQJWKHUHLVKHDWWUDQVIHU
WRDILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHRIR&)LQGWKHWHPSHUDWXUHDQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DIWHU
PL[LQJ)LQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUDQGWKHILQDOH[LWUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\

6ROXWLRQ
   4 KHDW
 FRRO
&97RWDO6HWXS 

VWDWHLVLQWHUQDOWR&9

 

     
&RQWLQXLW\(T PDZPDZ PDPDZ PDPDZ
   
(QHUJ\(T PDK×PDK× PDPDK×
6WDWH)URP3V\FKURPHWULFFKDUWZ K× N-NJGU\DLU
6WDWH)URP3V\FKURPHWULFFKDUWΦ K× N-NJGU\DLU
 
PDZPDZ  
  Z Z      
PDPD
 
PDK×PDK×  
  K×      N-NJGU\DLU
PDPD

6WDWH)URP3V\FKURPHWULFFKDUW7 R&Φ 

6WDWHR&Z 5HDGIURP3V\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
   K× Φ 
1RZGRWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQIRUWKHZKROHVHWXS
    
(QHUJ\(T PDK×PDK×4 PDPDK×
    
  4 PDPDK×PDK×PDK×
   ±± N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QLQGRRUSRROHYDSRUDWHVNJKRIZDWHUZKLFKLVUHPRYHGE\D
GHKXPLGLILHUWRPDLQWDLQ°&φ=LQWKHURRP7KHGHKXPLGLILHUVKRZQLQ
)LJ3LVDUHIULJHUDWLRQF\FOHLQZKLFKDLUIORZLQJRYHUWKHHYDSRUDWRU
FRROVVXFKWKDWOLTXLGZDWHUGURSVRXWDQGWKHDLUFRQWLQXHVIORZLQJRYHUWKH
FRQGHQVHU)RUDQDLUIORZUDWHRINJVWKHXQLWUHTXLUHVN:LQSXWWRD
PRWRUGULYLQJDIDQDQGWKHFRPSUHVVRUDQGLWKDVDFRHIILFLHQWRISHUIRUPDQFHβ=
4/:F=)LQGWKHVWDWHRIWKHDLUDVLWUHWXUQVWRWKHURRPDQGWKHFRPSUHVVRU
ZRUNLQSXW
6ROXWLRQ
7KHXQLWPXVWUHPRYHNJKOLTXLGWRNHHSVWHDG\VWDWHLQWKHURRP$V
ZDWHUFRQGHQVHVRXWVWDWHLVVDWXUDWHG
6WDWH°& !Z K× 
   
&9WRPOLT PDZZ !Z ZPOLTPD
T/ K×K×ZZKI
Z × 
6WDWHZ !7 °&K× KI 
T/ × N-NJGU\DLU
 
&97RWDOV\VWHPK× K×:HOPDZZKI
     N-NJGU\DLU
6WDWHZ ZK× !7 °&φ3 
 
:F PDT/β N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


3V\FKURPHWULFFKDUWRQO\


 8VHWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUWWRILQGWKHPLVVLQJSURSHUW\RIφ, ω, 7ZHW7GU\
  D7GU\ ƒ&φ   E7GU\ ƒ&φ 
  F7GU\ ƒ&DQGω  G7GU\ ƒ&7ZHW ƒ&

 6ROXWLRQ
D °&φ  !ω 7ZHW °&
E °&φ  !ω 7ZHW °&
F °&ω  !φ 7ZHW °&
G °&7ZHW °& !ω φ 

 Z 
Φ = 

Φ = 

G
E Φ = 
D
F
Φ = 

7 GU\ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 8VHWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUWWRILQGWKHPLVVLQJSURSHUW\RIφ, ω, 7ZHW7GU\
  Dφ ω   E7ZHW ƒ&φ 
  Fω DQG7ZHW ƒ& G7GU\ ƒ&ω 

 6ROXWLRQ
D φ ω  !7GU\ °&7ZHW °&
E 7ZHW °&φ  !7GU\ °&ω 
F ω 7ZHW °& !7GU\ °&φ 
G 7GU\ °&ω  !φ 7ZHW °&

 Z 
Φ = 

Φ = 

E D Φ = 
G F
Φ = 

7 GU\ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 8VHWKHIRUPXODVDQGWKHVWHDPWDEOHVWRILQGWKHPLVVLQJSURSHUW\RIφ, ω, DQG
7GU\WRWDOSUHVVXUHLVN3DUHSHDWWKHDQVZHUVXVLQJWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
 Dφ ω E7ZHW ƒ&φ F7GU\ ƒ&7ZHW ƒ&

D)URP(T3Y 3ωω × N3D
)URP(T3J 3Yφ  N3D !7 °&

E$VVXPH7ZHWLVDGLDEDWLFVDWXUDWLRQ7DQGXVHHQHUJ\(T
$W°&3J  !ω × 
 /+6 ωKYKI&S7 5+6 &S7ωKIJ
 5+6 ×× N-NJ
 ω φ3Jφ3JZKHUH3JLVDW77ULDODQGHUURU
/+6& /+6&  !7 °&ω 

F$W°&3J  !ω × 
 KI DQGKIJ N-NJKY 
)URP(Tω >&S77ωKIJ@KYKI 
3Y 3ωω φ  

8VLQJWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW(
 D7GU\ °&E7GU\ °&ω 
 Fω φ 


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 )RUHDFKRIWKHVWDWHVLQ3UREOHPILQGWKHGHZSRLQWWHPSHUDWXUH

6ROXWLRQ
7KHGHZSRLQWLVWKHVWDWHZLWKWKHVDPHKXPLGLW\UDWLRDEVKXPLGLW\ωDQG
FRPSOHWHO\VDWXUDWHGφ )URPSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW

 D 7GHZ °& F7GHZ °&
 E 7GHZ °&  G7GHZ °&
)LQGLQJWKHVROXWLRQIURPWKHWDEOHVLVGRQHIRUFDVHVDFDQGGDV
 (TVROYH3Y 3J ω3WRW>ω@ 3VDW7GHZLQ%
)RUFDVHEXVHHQHUJ\(TWRILQGωILUVWIURP7DGVDW 7ZHW

 Φ = 
Z

Φ = 

E D Φ = 
G F
Φ = 

7 GU\ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RPSDUHWKHZHDWKHUWZRSODFHVZKHUHLWLVFORXG\DQGEUHH]\$WEHDFK$LWLV
°&N3DUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DQGEHDFK%KDV°&N3DUHODWLYH
KXPLGLW\6XSSRVH\RXMXVWWRRNDVZLPDQGFDPHRXWRIWKHZDWHU:KHUH
ZRXOG\RXIHHOPRUHFRPIRUWDEOHDQGZK\"
6ROXWLRQ
<RXUVNLQEHLQJZHWDQGDLULVIORZLQJRYHULWZLOOIHHO7ZHW:LWKWKHVPDOO
GLIIHUHQFHLQSUHVVXUHIURPN3DXVHWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
$°&φ  !7ZHW °&
%°&φ  !7ZHW °&
 $WEHDFK$LWLVFRPIRUWDEOHDW%LWIHHOVFKLOO\


 Z 
Φ = 

Φ = 

$
Φ = 

Φ = 
%

7 GU\ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PELHQWDLUDWN3D°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\JRHVWKURXJKDFRQVWDQW
SUHVVXUHKHDWH[FKDQJHUDVDVWHDG\IORZ,QRQHFDVHLWLVKHDWHGWR°&DQGLQ
DQRWKHUFDVHLWLVFRROHGXQWLOLWUHDFKHVVDWXUDWLRQ)RUERWKFDVHVILQGWKHH[LW
UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DQGWKHDPRXQWRIKHDWWUDQVIHUSHUNLORJUDPGU\DLU
6ROXWLRQ
   
&9KHDWH[FKDQJHUP$L P$HPYL PYHZH ZL
   KDZKYLT KDZKYH K×HT K×HK×L
8VLQJWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUWLZL K×L 
 &DVH,H7H R&ZH ZL !K×H 
 φH T  N-NJGU\DLU
 &DVH,,HZH ZLφH  !K×H 7H R&
 T  N-NJGU\DLU

 Φ =  
Z
Φ = 

&$6(,, Φ = 
H L H
Φ = 
&$6(,
7GU\ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $IORZRIPRLVWDLUDW°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\VKRXOGEHSURGXFHGIURP
PL[LQJRIWZRGLIIHUHQWPRLVWDLUIORZV)ORZLVDW°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\
DQGIORZLVDW°&DQGKDV7ZHW °&7KHPL[LQJFKDPEHUFDQEHIROORZHG
E\DKHDWHURUDFRROHU1ROLTXLGZDWHULVDGGHGDQG3 N3D)LQGWKHWZR
 
FRQWUROVRQHLVWKHUDWLRRIWKHWZRPDVVIORZUDWHVPDPDDQGWKHRWKHULVWKH
KHDWWUDQVIHULQWKHKHDWHUFRROHUSHUNJGU\DLU

6ROXWLRQ
   4 KHDW
 FRRO
&97RWDO6HWXS 

VWDWHLVLQWHUQDOWR&9

 

   
&RQWLQXLW\(T  PDZPDZ PDPDZ
    
(QHUJ\(T PDK×PDK×4D PDPDK×
 
'HILQH[ PDPDDQGVXEVWLWXWHLQWRFRQWLQXLW\HTXDWLRQ
ZZ
 ![ZZ [Z ![ Z Z  
 

(QHUJ\HTXDWLRQVFDOHGWRWRWDOIORZRIGU\DLU
  
 T× 4DPDPD K×>[[@K×>[@K×
  ±× −  × 
  N-NJGU\DLU

 Z Φ =  6WDWH
Z K× 

 Φ =  6WDWH
Z K× 
Φ =  
 6WDWH

Z K× 
7GU\ 7GHZ °&
 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 ,QDKRWDQGGU\FOLPDWHDLUHQWHUVDQDLUFRQGLWLRQHUXQLWDWN3D°&DQG
UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DWWKHVWHDG\UDWHRIPV/LTXLGZDWHUDW°&LV
VSUD\HGLQWRWKHDLULQWKH$&XQLWDWWKHUDWHNJKRXUDQGKHDWLVUHMHFWHGIURP
WKHXQLWDWDWWKHUDWHN:7KHH[LWSUHVVXUHLVN3D:KDWDUHWKHH[LW
WHPSHUDWXUHDQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\"

6WDWH7 °&3 N3Dφ 9D PV
 3J N3D3Y φ3J N3D3D 33Y N3D

3Y  3D9D
 ω 3  PD  57  NJVKY N-NJ
D D

6WDWH/LT:DWHU°&PI NJKU NJVKI N-NJ
    
&RQVHUYDWLRQRI0DVVPD PDPYP PY
 
 ω PIPDω  
6WDWH3 N3DDQG3Y 3ωω N3D
      
VW/DZ4PDKDPYKYPIKI PDKDPYKY4 N:
  
KDKDωKY ωKYPIKI4PD
     
8QNQRZQVKDKYLPSOLFLWO\JLYHQEHDVLQJOHXQNQRZQ7
3Y
7ULDODQG(UURUIRU77 &3J N3Dφ 3  
J

,IZHVROYHGZLWKWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUWZHZRXOGJHW
  a
6WDWHPYPD ω K 
 
6WDWHω PIPDω  
1RZWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQEHFRPHV
a a   
K KPIKI4PD   
*LYHQωZHILQGWKHVWDWHDURXQG&DQGφ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RQVLGHUWZRVWDWHVRIDWPRVSKHULFDLU°&7ZHW=°&DQG°&φ 
6XJJHVWDV\VWHPRIGHYLFHVWKDWZLOODOORZDLULQDVWHDG\IORZSURFHVVWR
FKDQJHIURPWRDQGIURPWR+HDWHUVFRROHUVGHKXPLGLILHUVOLTXLG
WUDSVHWFDUHDYDLODEOHDQGDQ\OLTXLGVROLGIORZLQJLVDVVXPHGWREHDWWKHORZHVW
WHPSHUDWXUHVHHQLQWKHSURFHVV)LQGWKHVSHFLILFDQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\IRUVWDWH
GHZSRLQWIRUVWDWHDQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUSHUNLORJUDPGU\DLULQHDFK
FRPSRQHQWLQWKHV\VWHPV
8VHWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW(
 Z K× φ  7GHZ °&K×GHZ 


 Z K× φ 7GHZ °&K×GHZ 

6LQFHZ!ZZDWHUPXVWEHDGGHGLQSURFHVV,WR,,DQGUHPRYHGLQWKH
SURFHVV,,WR,:DWHUFDQRQO\EHUHPRYHGE\FRROLQJEHORZGHZSRLQW
WHPSHUDWXUHVR
 ,WR,,$GLDEVDW,WR'HZ,,WKHQKHDWHUIURP'HZ,,WR,,
 ,,WR,&RROWR'HZ,WKHQKHDW'HZ,WR,
7KHILUVWRQHFDQEHGRQHEHFDXVH7GHZ,, 7DGVDW,
 ,WR,,T K×,,K×GHZ,,  N-NJDLU
 ,,WR,TFRRO K×,,K×GHZ,ZZKIDW7GHZ,
   × N-NJDLU
 TKHDW K×,K×GHZ,  N-NJDLU

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7RUHIUHVKDLULQDURRPDFRXQWHUIORZKHDWH[FKDQJHUVHH)LJ3LVPRXQWHG
LQWKHZDOOGUDZLQJLQRXWVLGHDLUDW°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DQGSXVKLQJRXW
URRPDLU°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\$VVXPHDQH[FKDQJHRINJPLQGU\DLULQ
DVWHDG\IORZGHYLFHDQGDOVRWKDWWKHURRPDLUH[LWVWKHKHDWH[FKDQJHUWRWKH
DWPRVSKHUHDW°&)LQGWKHQHWDPRXQWRIZDWHUUHPRYHGIURPWKHURRPDQ\
OLTXLGIORZLQWKHKHDWH[FKDQJHUDQG7φIRUWKHIUHVKDLUHQWHULQJWKHURRP

6WDWHZ K× 7GHZ °&
7KHURRPDLULVFRROHGWR°&7GHZVROLTXLGZLOOIRUPLQWKHH[LWIORZ
FKDQQHODQGVWDWHLVVDWXUDWHG
°&φ  !Z K× KI N-NJ
°&φ  !Z K× N-NJGU\DLU
&9WR
 
  POLT PDZZ  NJPLQ
  
&9URRPPYRXW PDZZ PDZZ
     NJPLQ
&9+HDWH[FKDQJHUPDK×K× PDK×K×POLTKI
 K× K×K×K×ZZKI ×
  N-NJGU\DLU
Z ZK× !7 °&φ 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


$YDLODELOLW\H[HUJ\LQPL[WXUHV


&RQVLGHUWKHPL[LQJRIDVWHDPIORZZLWKDQR[\JHQIORZLQ3UREOHP)LQG
WKHUDWHRIWRWDOLQIORZLQJDYDLODELOLW\DQGWKHUDWHRIH[HUJ\GHVWUXFWLRQLQWKH
SURFHVV

$IORZRINJVVWHDPDWN3DR&LVPL[HGZLWKNJVR[\JHQDW
N3D.LQDVWHDG\IORZPL[LQJFKDPEHUZLWKRXWDQ\KHDWWUDQVIHU)LQGWKH
H[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHUDWHRIHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQ

   
([HUJ\)ORZΦLQ PψLQ P+2ψP2ψ
  ψ K±KR±7RV±VR
   &3+27±7R±7R>&3+2OQ77R±5OQ33R@
 
   ±±>OQOQ@

   ±± N-NJ

  ψ K±KR±7RV±VR
   &327±7R±7R>&32OQ77R±5OQ33R@
 
   ±±>OQOQ@

   ±± N-NJ

  
  ΦLQ P+2ψP2ψ  N:
 
&90L[LQJFKDPEHUVWHDG\IORZQRZRUNQRKHDWWUDQVIHU7RGRWKHHQWURSLHV
ZHQHHGWKHPROHIUDFWLRQV
 
 P+2   P2 
 Q+2 0   NPROVQ2 0   NPROV
+2 2

  \+2 \2 

   
(QHUJ\(T P+2KP2K P+2K+2P2K2
    
(QWURS\(TP+2VP2V6JHQ P+2V+2P2V2
6ROYHIRU7IURPWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 
 P+2K+2±KP2K2±K 
 
 P+2&3+27±7P2&327±7 
 ×7±±× 7± 
   7 .
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ

  
 6JHQ P+2V+2±VP2V2±V
 7  7
  P+2>&3+2OQ7 5OQ\+2@P2>&32OQ7 5OQ\2@
 


  >OQ±OQ@


   >OQ  ±OQ@

   N:.


 7KHH[HUJ\GHVWUXFWLRQLVSURSRUWLRQDOWRWKHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQ
  
  ΦLQ 7R6JHQ × N:
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



$PL[WXUHRIFDUERQGLR[LGHDQGZDWHUE\PDVVLVIORZLQJDW.
N3DLQWRDKHDWH[FKDQJHUZKHUHLWLVXVHGWRGHOLYHUHQHUJ\WRDKHDWHQJLQH
7KHPL[WXUHOHDYHWKHKHDWH[FKDQJHUDW.ZLWKDPDVVIORZUDWHRINJPLQ
)LQGWKHUDWHRIHQHUJ\DQGWKHUDWHRIH[HUJ\GHOLYHUHGWRWKHKHDWHQJLQH

 &9+HDWH[FKDQJHUVWHDG\IORZDQGQRZRUN

 )URP7DEOH$
R
   &2 KLQ N-NJV7LQ N-NJ.
R
   &2 KH[ N-NJV7H[ N-NJ.
R
   +2 KLQ N-NJV7LQ N-NJ.
R
   +2 KH[ N-NJV7H[ N-NJ.
 

  
(QHUJ\(T 4 PKLQ±KH[ P∑\LKLQKH[L

    >±±@

    >@ N:
 (QWURS\FKDQJH
VLQ±VH[ ±±
  N-NJ.
([HUJ\)OX[
   
 Φ PψLQ±ψH[ 4±7RPVLQ±VH[

  ±××

  N:
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 )LQGWKHVHFRQGODZHIILFLHQF\RIWKHKHDWH[FKDQJHULQ3UREOHP
 $IORZRINJVPL[WXUHRI&2DQG2E\PDVVLVKHDWHGLQDFRQVWDQW
SUHVVXUHKHDWH[FKDQJHUIURP.WR.E\DUDGLDWLRQVRXUFHDW.
)LQGWKHUDWHRIKHDWWUDQVIHUDQGWKHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQLQWKHSURFHVV
6ROXWLRQ
7KHVHFRQGODZHIILFLHQF\IROORZV(TZKHUHWKHZDQWHGWHUPLVWKHIORZ
LQFUHDVHRIH[HUJ\DQGWKHVRXUFHLVWKHUDGLDWLRQ
    7R
  ΦIORZ PψH[±ψLQ ΦVRXUFH 4LQ±7 
VRXUFH
 
+HDWH[FKDQJHU(QHUJ\(T  4LQ PKHKL
9DOXHVIURP7DEOH$GXHWRWKHKLJK7
  
 4LQ >×±×±@ N:

  7R 
 ΦVRXUFH 4LQ±7     N:
VRXUFH
   
(QWURS\(T PHVH PLVL47V6JHQ
$V3 &WKHSUHVVXUHFRUUHFWLRQLQ(TGURSVRXWWRJLYHJHQHUDWLRQDV
  
 6JHQ PVHVL47V
 >×±×±@
  N:.
     
   ΦIORZ ΦVRXUFH±ΦGHVWUXFWLRQ ΦVRXUFH±76JHQ
 ±× 
ΦIORZ 
η     
ΦVRXUFH

  .
5HPDUN:HFRXOGDOVR 5DGLDWLRQ
H[SOLFLWO\KDYHIRXQGWKH
IORZH[HUJ\LQFUHDVH L H


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ


5HYLHZ3UREOHPV



 $SLVWRQF\OLQGHUFRQWDLQVKHOLXPDWN3DDWDPELHQWWHPSHUDWXUH°&DQG
LQLWLDOYROXPHRI/DVVKRZQLQ)LJ37KHVWRSVDUHPRXQWHGWRJLYHD
PD[LPXPYROXPHRI/DQGWKHQLWURJHQOLQHFRQGLWLRQVDUHN3D°&
7KHYDOYHLVQRZRSHQHGZKLFKDOORZVQLWURJHQWRIORZLQDQGPL[ZLWKWKH
KHOLXP7KHYDOYHLVFORVHGZKHQWKHSUHVVXUHLQVLGHUHDFKHVN3DDWZKLFK
SRLQWWKHWHPSHUDWXUHLQVLGHLV°&,VWKLVSURFHVVFRQVLVWHQWZLWKWKHVHFRQG
ODZRIWKHUPRG\QDPLFV"
 3 N3D7 R&9 /9PD[ / 9
 3 N3D7 R&3L N3D7L R&
 &RQVWDQW3WRVWRSVWKHQFRQVWDQW9 9PD[ !:FY 399

 4FY 88:FYQLKL
  
  QKQKQLKL339
   
  Q$K$K$LQ%K%K%339

 Q% Q 3957 ×× NPRO

 Q Q$Q% 3957 ×× NPRO
 Q$ QQ% NPRO
 0ROHIUDFWLRQV\$  \% 
4FY ××××
 
   N-
  
 6JHQ QVQVQLVL4FY7
   
  Q$V$V$LQ%V%V%4FY7
     
 V$V$L OQ5OQ   

     

 V%V% OQ5OQ   

 6JHQ ××
  N-.! 6DWLVILHVQGODZ
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ




 $VSKHULFDOEDOORRQKDVDQLQLWLDOGLDPHWHURIPDQGFRQWDLQVDUJRQJDVDW
N3D°&7KHEDOORRQLVFRQQHFWHGE\DYDOYHWRD/ULJLGWDQNFRQWDLQLQJ
FDUERQGLR[LGHDWN3D°&7KHYDOYHLVRSHQHGDQGHYHQWXDOO\WKHEDOORRQ
DQGWDQNUHDFKDXQLIRUPVWDWHLQZKLFKWKHSUHVVXUHLVN3D7KHEDOORRQ
SUHVVXUHLVGLUHFWO\SURSRUWLRQDOWRLWVGLDPHWHU7DNHWKHEDOORRQDQGWDQNDVD
FRQWUROYROXPHDQGFDOFXODWHWKHILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHDQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUIRUWKH
SURFHVV
  π
 9$  
3$9$ ×
$ P$  57    NJ
$ ×
P% 3%9%57% ×× NJ
 
39$  3$9$ →
%
 CO 2  9$ 9$ 3 
3 
$
   
   P
8QLIRUPLGHDOJDVPL[WXUH
39$9% P$5$P%5%7

 7 ×× .
39$3$9$ ××
 :       N-

 4 P$&9$77$P%&9%77%:

  ××
   N-

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QLQVXODWHGYHUWLFDOF\OLQGHULVILWWHGZLWKDIULFWLRQOHVVFRQVWDQWORDGHGSLVWRQRI
FURVVVHFWLRQDODUHDPDQGWKHLQLWLDOF\OLQGHUKHLJKWRIP7KHF\OLQGHU
FRQWDLQVPHWKDQHJDVDW.N3DDQGDOVRLQVLGHLVD/FDSVXOH
FRQWDLQLQJQHRQJDVDW.N3D7KHFDSVXOHQRZEUHDNVDQGWKHWZR
JDVHVPL[WRJHWKHULQDFRQVWDQWSUHVVXUHSURFHVV:KDWLVWKHILQDOWHPSHUDWXUH
ILQDOF\OLQGHUKHLJKWDQGWKHQHWHQWURS\FKDQJHIRUWKHSURFHVV
$S PK P ! 9WRW 9D9E P
0HWKDQH0 NJNPRO&S N-NJ.5 N-NJ.
1HRQ0 NJNPRO&S N-NJ.5 N-NJ.
6WDWH0HWKDQH7DO .3D N3D9D 9WRW9E P
 1HRQ7EO .3E N3D9E /
3DO9DO PD
 PD  5 7  NJQD 0  NPRO
D DO D

3EO9EO PE
 PE  5 7  NJQE 0  NPRO
E EO E

6WDWH0L[3PL[ 3D N3D

(QHUJ\(T4 PDXDXDPEXEXE:4 
: ∫3G9 399WRW39 PWRW5PL[7 PD5DPE5E7
$VVXPH&RQVWDQW6SHFLILF+HDW
 PD&SD77DPE&SE77EPD5DPE5E739WRW
6ROYLQJIRU7 .
PD5DPE5E7 
9
9  3  P K  $  P
 
S

 4
(QWURS\(T∆6QHW PDVDVDPEVEVE 7 4 


QD
\D Q Q  \E \D 
D E

7 \ D 3
VDVD &SDOQ7 5DOQ 3  N-NJ.
D D

7 \ E 3
VEVE &SEOQ7 5EOQ 3  N-NJ.
E E

∆6QHW N-.
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QLQVXODWHGULJLGPWDQN$FRQWDLQV&2JDVDW°&03D$QXQLQVXODWHG
ULJLGPWDQN%FRQWDLQVHWKDQH&+JDVDWN3DURRPWHPSHUDWXUH°&
7KHWZRDUHFRQQHFWHGE\DRQHZD\FKHFNYDOYHWKDWZLOODOORZJDVIURP$WR%
EXWQRWIURP%WR$7KHYDOYHLVRSHQHGDQGJDVIORZVIURP$WR%XQWLOWKH
SUHVVXUHLQ%UHDFKHVN3DDQGWKHYDOYHLVFORVHG7KHPL[WXUHLQ%LVNHSWDW
URRPWHPSHUDWXUHGXHWRKHDWWUDQVIHU)LQGWKHWRWDOQXPEHURIPROHVDQGWKH
HWKDQHPROHIUDFWLRQDWWKHILQDOVWDWHLQ%)LQGWKHILQDOWHPSHUDWXUHDQG
SUHVVXUHLQWDQN$DQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUWRIURPWDQN%
 6ROXWLRQ
 
A B

C 2H 6
CO 2



7DQN$9$ PVWDWH$&27$ °& .3$ 03D
 
&Y&2 × &3&2 × N-NPRO.

7DQN%9% PVWDWH%&+7% °& .3% N3D

6ORZ)ORZ$WR%WR3% N3DDQGDVVXPH7% 7% 7
7RWDOPROHVVFDOHVWRSUHVVXUHVRZLWKVDPH9DQG7ZHKDYH
 
  3%9% Q%57% 3%9% Q%PL[57%
Q% 3% 
0ROHIUDFWLRQ \&+% Q  3   
% %

3%9% ×
Q%  57    NPRO
% 5×
3%9% ×
Q%PL[  57    NPRO
% 5×
Q&2% ± NPRO
1RZZHFDQZRUNEDFNZDUGVWRILQDOVWDWHLQ$
3$9$ ×
Q$  57    NPROQ$ Q$Q&2% NPRO
$ 5×

&9$$OO&27UDQVLHQWZLWKIORZRXWDQGDGLDEDWLF
(QHUJ\(T4&9$  Q$X$Q$X$QDYHKDYH
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ

  
 Q$&Y&27$Q$&Y&27$QDYH&3&27$7$

 ×7$××7$

   ! 7$ .
Q$57$ ×5×
  3$  9$     N3D

&9%7UDQVLHQWZLWKIORZLQDQGQRQDGLDEDWLF

4&9%Q%LK%LDYH QX%QX% QX&2%QX&+%QX&+%

4&9% ×× ±×

 N-
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PLQVXODWHGULJLGYHVVHOLVGLYLGHGLQWRWZRHTXDOSDUWV$DQG%E\DQ
LQVXODWHGSDUWLWLRQDVVKRZQLQ)LJ37KHSDUWLWLRQZLOOVXSSRUWDSUHVVXUH
GLIIHUHQFHRIN3DEHIRUHEUHDNLQJ6LGH$FRQWDLQVPHWKDQHDQGVLGH%
FRQWDLQVFDUERQGLR[LGH%RWKVLGHVDUHLQLWLDOO\DW03D°&$YDOYHRQVLGH
%LVRSHQHGDQGFDUERQGLR[LGHIORZVRXW7KHFDUERQGLR[LGHWKDWUHPDLQVLQ%
LVDVVXPHGWRXQGHUJRDUHYHUVLEOHDGLDEDWLFH[SDQVLRQZKLOHWKHUHLVIORZRXW
(YHQWXDOO\WKHSDUWLWLRQEUHDNVDQGWKHYDOYHLVFORVHG&DOFXODWHWKHQHWHQWURS\
FKDQJHIRUWKHSURFHVVWKDWEHJLQVZKHQWKHYDOYHLVFORVHG

 ∆30$; N3D3$ 3% 03D
$ % 9$ 9% P
&+  &2 
7$ 7% R& .

&2LQVLGH%V% V%WR3% N3D3$ N3D

 
)RU&2N  !7%   
 
 .

 Q% 3%9%57% ×× 
 Q$ Q$ ×× NPRO
 
 4  QX QLXL Q$&9$77$Q%&9%77% 
∑

L
××7××7 
  6ROYH7 .
 3 ×× N3D
 3$ × N3D 3% 33$ N3D
 
V$V$ ×OQOQ   N-NPRO.

 
V%V% ×OQOQ   N-NPRO.

 ∆61(7 ×× N-.

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $QDLUZDWHUYDSRUPL[WXUHHQWHUVDVWHDG\IORZKHDWHUKXPLGLILHUXQLWDWVWDWH
°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DWWKHUDWHRIPV$VHFRQGDLUYDSRUVWUHDP
HQWHUVWKHXQLWDWVWDWH°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DWWKHUDWHRIPV
/LTXLGZDWHUHQWHUVDWVWDWH°&DWWKHUDWHRINJSHUKRXU$VLQJOHDLU
YDSRUIORZH[LWVWKHXQLWDWVWDWH°&&DOFXODWHWKHUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\RIWKH
H[LWIORZDQGWKHUDWHRIKHDWWUDQVIHUWRWKHXQLW

$VVXPH3 N3D

6WDWH7 °&φ 9D PV
 3J N3D3Y φ3J N3D
3D 33Y N3D

3Y  3D9D
 ω 3  PD  57  NJV
  D D
 PY ωPD NJVKY KJ N-NJ

6WDWH7 °&φ 9D PV
 3J N3D3Y φ3J N3D3D 33Y N3D

3Y  3D9D
 ω 3  PD  57  NJV
D D
 
 PY ωPD NJVKY KJ N-NJ

6WDWH/LTXLG7 °&PI NJKU NJVKI N-NJ
6WDWH7 °&
  
&RQWLQXLW\(TDLUPD PDPD NJV
   
&RQWLQXLW\(TZDWHUPY PYPYPI NJV

PY 3Y
 ω     33 → 3Y N3D
PD Y

3Y
 3J N3Dφ 3  KY KJ N-NJ
J
       
VW/DZ4PDKDPYKYPDKDPYKYPIKI PDKDPYKY

 4 ××××
  ×××
  N:

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 <RXKDYHMXVWZDVKHG\RXUKDLUDQGQRZEORZGU\LWLQDURRPZLWK°&φ 
7KHGU\HU:KHDWVWKHDLUWR°&EORZVLWWKURXJK\RXUKDLU
ZKHUHWKHDLUEHFRPHVVDWXUDWHGDQGWKHQIORZVRQWRKLWDZLQGRZZKHUHLW
FRROVWR°&)LQGWKHUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DWVWDWHWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUSHU
NLORJUDPRIGU\DLULQWKHGU\HUWKHDLUIORZUDWHDQGWKHDPRXQWRIZDWHU
FRQGHQVHGRQWKHZLQGRZLIDQ\
7KHEORZGU\HUKHDWVWKHDLUDWFRQVWDQWVSHFLILFKXPLGLW\WRDQGLWWKHQJRHV
WKURXJKDQDGLDEDWLFVDWXUDWLRQSURFHVVWRVWDWHILQDOO\FRROLQJWR
 °&UHOKXP !Z K× N-NJGU\DLU
 Z Z7 !φ2 K× N-NJGU\DLU
&9WR
 Z ZT K×K×  N-NJGU\DLU

   PD 4T  NJV
    
&9WRZZ POLTPDPDK×POLTKI PDK×
 φ  !7 7ZHW °&Z 
 φ 7 !Z 
 
 POLT ZZPD × JV
,IWKHVWHDPWDEOHVDQGIRUPXOD
VDUHXVHGWKHQZHJHW
 KJ KJ 3J 3Y 
 3J Z Z Z3Y 3Y
 φ 3Y3J KI 
7ULDODQGHUURUIRUDGLDEDWLFVDWXUDWLRQWHPSHUDWXUH
 7 °&Z 3Y 3J N3D
 Z × 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 6WHDPSRZHUSODQWVRIWHQXWLOL]HODUJHFRROLQJWRZHUVWRFRROWKHFRQGHQVHU
FRROLQJZDWHUVRLWFDQEHUHFLUFXODWHGVHH)LJ37KHSURFHVVLV
HVVHQWLDOO\HYDSRUDWLYHDGLDEDWLFFRROLQJLQZKLFKSDUWRIWKHZDWHULVORVWDQG
PXVWWKHUHIRUHEHUHSOHQLVKHG&RQVLGHUWKHVHWXSVKRZQLQ)LJ3LQ
ZKLFKNJVRIZDUPZDWHUDW°&IURPWKHFRQGHQVHUHQWHUVWKHWRSRIWKH
FRROLQJWRZHUDQGWKHFRROHGZDWHUOHDYHVWKHERWWRPDW°&7KHPRLVWDPELHQW
DLUHQWHUVWKHERWWRPDWN3DGU\EXOEWHPSHUDWXUHRI°&DQGDZHWEXOE
WHPSHUDWXUHRI°&7KHPRLVWDLUOHDYHVWKHWRZHUDWN3D°&DQGUHODWLYH
KXPLGLW\RI'HWHUPLQHWKHUHTXLUHGPDVVIORZUDWHRIGU\DLUDQGWKH
IUDFWLRQRIWKHLQFRPLQJZDWHUWKDWHYDSRUDWHVDQGLVORVW

 3 N3D $LUYDS 
R
7  & 4 1 7 R&

φ  P NJV
3 N3D LIQ H 2O

7 R& 7 R&
3
:%7 R& 2
$LUYDS 
  2 2' 7′ R&φ′ 
R& 
Z′ × 

/,4,1
KD′KDZ′K)*′ ×
Z   KYK)′     


 3Y × Z ×  
      
 &RQVPDVVPD PD PDPPY PPY
    
 RUP PPDZZDQGVHWU PPD
     
 VWODZPKPDKDPYKY PKPDKDPYKY
 RUU KKDKDZKY UZZKZKY
 UKK KDKDZKYZKYZZK
 U ×
   ××
  
 U PPD →PD NJV
  
 P PPDZZ × 
 
∆PP 

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $PELHQWDLULVDWDFRQGLWLRQRIN3D°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\$VWHDG\
VWUHDPRIDLUDWN3D°&UHODWLYHKXPLGLW\LVWREHSURGXFHGE\ILUVW
FRROLQJRQHVWUHDPWRDQDSSURSULDWHWHPSHUDWXUHWRFRQGHQVHRXWWKHSURSHU
DPRXQWRIZDWHUDQGWKHQPL[WKLVVWUHDPDGLDEDWLFDOO\ZLWKWKHVHFRQGRQHDW
DPELHQWFRQGLWLRQV:KDWLVWKHUDWLRRIWKHWZRIORZUDWHV"7RZKDWWHPSHUDWXUH
PXVWWKHILUVWVWUHDPEHFRROHG"
 1 3 3 N3D
5
2 7 7 R&
MIX
COOL φ φ φ 
4 .
. 3 -Q MIX= 0 3 7 R&
-Q COOL
LIQ H 2O
 φ 

3Y 3Y × N3D !Z Z × 


 3Y × N3D !Z × 

&90L[LQJFKDPEHU&DOOWKHPDVVIORZUDWLRU PDPD
 FRQVPDVVZUZ UZ
 (QHUJ\(T KDZKYUKDUZKY UKDUZKY
 →UZ U
PD  3*
 RUU P   Z ZLWKZ ×3 
D  *

 ××U××7UZKY
   U××U××

 > @
RUU ×7ZK*  

 $VVXPH7 R&→3* K* 

 Z × 

  U PDPD  

 >××@ ≈2.
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $VHPLSHUPHDEOHPHPEUDQHLVXVHGIRUWKHSDUWLDOUHPRYDORIR[\JHQIURPDLU
WKDWLVEORZQWKURXJKDJUDLQHOHYDWRUVWRUDJHIDFLOLW\$PELHQWDLUQLWURJHQ
R[\JHQRQDPROHEDVLVLVFRPSUHVVHGWRDQDSSURSULDWHSUHVVXUHFRROHGWR
DPELHQWWHPSHUDWXUH°&DQGWKHQIHGWKURXJKDEXQGOHRIKROORZSRO\PHU
ILEHUVWKDWVHOHFWLYHO\DEVRUER[\JHQVRWKHPL[WXUHOHDYLQJDWN3D°&
FRQWDLQVRQO\R[\JHQ7KHDEVRUEHGR[\JHQLVEOHGRIIWKURXJKWKHILEHUZDOOV
DWN3D°&WRDYDFXXPSXPS$VVXPHWKHSURFHVVWREHUHYHUVLEOHDQG
DGLDEDWLFDQGGHWHUPLQHWKHPLQLPXPLQOHWDLUSUHVVXUHWRWKHILEHUEXQGOH

 $ 1% 2 
 0.79 A 1 2 0.79 A MIX
3 N3D
+ + 5 % 3 N3D
0.21 B 0.0416 B
3
O2 $OO7 R&
P1 = ? (0.79/0.95)
0.1684 B 
 /HWV$ V% DW7 R& 3
 
  V0,; \$5OQ\$\%5OQ\%
  
  V0,; 5OQ33\$5OQ\$\%5OQ\%

 3XUH%V 5OQ33
  
 )RUQ V  Q V Q V 
     

 

>
5 OQ33OQOQ

   OQ33OQOQ @ 

 OQ33OQ33 OQ3 
 3PLQ N3D

 )RU3!3PLQZHZRXOGKDYHHQWURS\JHQHUDWLRQ∆6!

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



$GHKXPLGLILHUUHFHLYHVDIORZRINJVGU\DLUDWR&UHODWLYH
KXPLGLW\DVVKRZQLQILJXUH3,WLVFRROHGGRZQWRR&DVLWIORZVRYHU
WKHHYDSRUDWRUDQGWKHQKHDWHGXSDJDLQDVLWIORZVRYHUWKHFRQGHQVHU7KH
VWDQGDUGUHIULJHUDWLRQF\FOHXVHV5ZLWKDQHYDSRUDWRUWHPSHUDWXUHRIR&DQG
DFRQGHQVDWLRQSUHVVXUHRIN3D)LQGWKHDPRXQWRIOLTXLGZDWHUUHPRYHG
DQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHULQWKHFRROLQJSURFHVV+RZPXFKFRPSUHVVRUZRUNLV
QHHGHG":KDWLVWKHILQDODLUH[LWWHPSHUDWXUHDQGUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\"

 6ROXWLRQ
 7KLVVHWXSKDVDVWDQGDUGUHIULJHUDWLRQF\FOHZLWK57KLVF\FOHDQGWKHDLU
IORZLQWHUDFWVWKURXJKWKHWZRKHDWWUDQVIHUSURFHVVHV7KHFRROLQJRIWKHDLULV
SURYLGHGE\WKHUHIULJHUDWLRQF\FOHDQGWKXVUHTXLUHVDQDPRXQWRIZRUNWKDW
GHSHQGVRQWKHF\FOH&23

5HIULJHUDWLRQF\FOH
 6WDWH[ K N-NJV N-NJ.
 6WDWHV VK N-NJ7 R&
 6WDWH[ K KI N-NJ7 °&
 6WDWHK KDQG3 3

 R-22 R-22 7
Evaporator 4 3 Condenser 

Air o Air
Air sat. 20 C
in ex  
1 2 V

C 
WC
R
 7  &3 N3D

1RZZHJHW
 Z& K±K ± N-NJ
 T+ K±K ± N-NJ
 T/ K±K ± N-NJ

)RUWKHDLUSURFHVVHVOHWXVXVHWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ

 $LULQOHWZLQ K×LQ N-NJGU\DLU7GHZ R&!R&

 $LUφ Z K× KI %
1RZGRWKHFRQWLQXLW\IRUZDWHUDQGHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQVIRUWKHFRROLQJSURFHVV
 
 POLT PDLUZLQZ ± NJV
  
 4FRRO PDLUK×LQK×POLTKI ±±
  N:
1RZWKHKHDWHUIURPWKH5F\FOHKDV
 
 4KHDW 4FRROT+T/  N:
VRWKHFRPSUHVVRUZRUNLVWKHEDODQFHRIWKHWZR
  
 :& 4KHDW4FRRO ± N:
(QHUJ\HTIRUWKHDLUIORZEHLQJKHDWHG
   
 4KHDW PDLUK×H[K×⇒K×H[ K×4KHDWPDLU
 K×H[  N-NJGU\DLUDQGZH[ Z
/RFDWHVWDWHLQWKHSV\FKURPHWULFFKDUW
  7 R&DQGφ 

 Z 
Φ =  

Φ =

7GU\

   

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $/LQVXODWHGWDQNFRQWDLQV1JDVDWN3DDQGDPELHQWWHPSHUDWXUH
°&7KHWDQNLVFRQQHFWHGE\DYDOYHWRDVXSSO\OLQHIORZLQJ&2DW03D
°&$PL[WXUHRI1&2E\PROHVKRXOGEHREWDLQHGE\RSHQLQJ
WKHYDOYHDQGDOORZLQJ&2IORZLQWRDQDSSURSULDWHSUHVVXUHLVUHDFKHGDQG
FORVHWKHYDOYH:KDWLVWKHSUHVVXUH"7KHWDQNHYHQWXDOO\FRROVWRDPELHQW
WHPSHUDWXUH)LQGWKHQHWHQWURS\FKDQJHIRUWKHRYHUDOOSURFHVV
 CO2 i 9 /3 N3D7 7 R&
3L 03D7L R&
$WVWDWH\1 \&2 

Q&2 Q1 Q1 3957
N2
    NPRO
Q NPRO


 VWODZQLKL QXQXIRUFRQVWVSHFLILFKHDWV
   
 QL&3RL7L QL&9RLQ&9R7Q&9R7
  
 %XWQL Q →&3RL7L &9RL7&9R77
 ×× ×7×7
 7 .

 3 Q579 ×× N3D
 &RROWR7 7 .
 3 3× 77 ×  N3D

 4 Q&9R77 ××
    ×× N-
 ∆61(7 QVQVQLVL47
 

  QL>V&2VL@Q>V1V@47

 ×
  ×OQOQ  

× 
  ×OQ  

   N-.


   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 $F\OLQGHUSLVWRQORDGHGZLWKDOLQHDUVSULQJFRQWDLQVVDWXUDWHGPRLVWDLUDW
N3DPYROXPHDQGDOVRNJRIOLTXLGZDWHUDOODWDPELHQWWHPSHUDWXUH
°&7KHSLVWRQDUHDLVPDQGWKHVSULQJFRQVWDQWLVN1P7KLVF\OLQGHU
LVDWWDFKHGE\DYDOYHWRDOLQHIORZLQJGU\DLUDWN3D°&7KHYDOYHLV
RSHQHGDQGDLUIORZVLQWRWKHF\OLQGHUXQWLOWKHSUHVVXUHUHDFKHVN3DDW
ZKLFKSRLQWWKHWHPSHUDWXUHLV°&'HWHUPLQHWKHUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\DWWKHILQDO
VWDWHWKHPDVVRIDLUHQWHULQJWKHF\OLQGHUDQGWKHZRUNGRQHGXULQJWKHSURFHVV

 3 N3D7 R& 79 P
P/,4 NJ$3 PNV N1P
3L N3D3 N3D
A+V 7L R&7 R&

i 3 3NV$S99
DRY AIR  9→9 P

 φ RUZ × 
3Y9 ×
 PY  5 7     ZP$
Y  ×
 $VVXPHQROLTXLGDWVWDWH
 PY PYP/ NJ
PY5Y7 ××
 →3Y  9     N3D


 Dφ  

3$9 ×
 EP$  5 7    
$  ×
×
 P$  
×
 P$L P$P$ NJ
 
 F:&9 ⌠
⌡3G9 3399  N-
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 &RQVLGHUWKHSUHYLRXVSUREOHPDQGDGGLWLRQDOO\GHWHUPLQHWKHKHDWWUDQVIHU6KRZ
WKDWWKHSURFHVVGRHVQRWYLRODWHWKHVHFRQGODZ
 D4&9 P$K$ P$K$  P$LK$L  PYKYPYKYP/K/39
 39  :&9
   ××××
×××
  ×±×××
   N-
 E∆6&9 66 P$V$P$V$PYVYPYVYP/V/
 ∆66855 4&97P$LV$L
 ∆61(7 P$V$P$V$P$LV$LPYVYPYVYP/V/4&97
  P$V$V$LP$V$LV$PYVYPYVYP/V/4&97
 
 V$V$L OQOQ  

 
 V$LV$ OQOQ 

 VY V*5YOQφ OQ 

 VY V*5YOQφ ± 
 V/ V) 
→∆61(7 ×±
 ×±×
  N-.

   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ



 7KHDLUFRQGLWLRQLQJE\HYDSRUDWLYHFRROLQJLQ3UREOHPLVPRGLILHGE\
DGGLQJDGHKXPLGLILFDWLRQSURFHVVEHIRUHWKHZDWHUVSUD\FRROLQJSURFHVV7KLV
GHKXPLGLILFDWLRQLVDFKLHYHGDVVKRZQLQ)LJ3E\XVLQJDGHVLFFDQW
PDWHULDOZKLFKDEVRUEVZDWHURQRQHVLGHRIDURWDWLQJGUXPKHDWH[FKDQJHU7KH
GHVLFFDQWLVUHJHQHUDWHGE\KHDWLQJRQWKHRWKHUVLGHRIWKHGUXPWRGULYHWKH
ZDWHURXW7KHSUHVVXUHLVN3DHYHU\ZKHUHDQGRWKHUSURSHUWLHVDUHRQWKH
GLDJUDP&DOFXODWHWKHUHODWLYHKXPLGLW\RIWKHFRRODLUVXSSOLHGWRWKHURRPDW
VWDWHDQGWKHKHDWWUDQVIHUSHUXQLWPDVVRIDLUWKDWQHHGVWREHVXSSOLHGWRWKH
KHDWHUXQLW
6WDWHVDVQRWHGRQ)LJ3WH[WSDJH
 $WVWDWHR&39 φ3* × 
 Z × 
 $W7 R&Z Z Z 
(YDSRUDWLYHFRROLQJSURFHVVWRVWDWHZKHUH7 R&
$VLQ(TZKYKI &3$77ZKIJ
  Z× 
 Z  × 3Y3Y
 39 N3Dφ  
)ROORZLQJQRZWKHIORZEDFNZHKDYH
 $W7 R&Z Z 
(YDSRUDWLYHFRROLQJSURFHVVWRVWDWHZKHUH7 R&
 ZKYKI &3$77ZKIJ
  Z× 
 !Z 
)RUDGLDEDWLFKHDWH[FKDQJHU
    
 P$ P$ P$ P$ P$ $OVRZ ZZ Z
6RQRZRQO\7LVXQNQRZQLQWKHHQHUJ\HTXDWLRQ
 K$ZKYK$ZKY K$ZKYK$ZKY
 RU
 &3$7ZKYKY &3$777ZKYKY
 7KY 
      
   6RQQWDJ%RUJQDNNHDQGYDQ:\OHQ

%\WULDODQGHUURU7 R&KY N-NJ

)RUWKHKHDWHUZ Z
 
4P$ &3$77ZKYKY
   N-NJGU\DLU