Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
FACULTY OF ARTS
HISTORY DEPARTMENT
COURSE: DVS
QUESTION;
You reading list and the lecture nootes have provided an overview of civil society
theories and percipective of development so using the alternative development
paradigm.
2
clothing. Many modern lists emphasize the minimum level of consumption of 'basic
needs' of not just food, water, and shelter, but also sanitation, education, and healthcare.
Different agencies use different lists.
empowerment
is to enhance is active decision-making and influence over strategic life-choices and over
barriers to agency and well-being freedom. Almost all advocates of empowerment
share this conception of it, that priority goes to empowering the poor and other groups
whose agency and well-being freedom have been restricted
capabilities
human capabilities
capabilities, especially those included in the HDI (the capability to survive and be
healthy, to be knowledgeable, and to enjoy a decent standard of living the HDRs had to
focus simply on those capabilities that are universally valued and ‘‘basic’’
capabilities on which many choices in life depended), reflected in the three HDI
(i.e.,capabilities
capabilities: to be knowledge able, to survive, and to enjoy a decent standard of
capabilities
Capabilities to participate in social action have now become more important. In
living.Capabilities
the same way that economic entrepreneurship drives markets, social entrepreneu
participation
participation through democratic institutions within stronger democratic governance.
Indeed, collective action, especially in the form of social movements, has been the
essential motor behind progress in achieving major policy shifts necessary for human
progress
Women have demonstrated their ability to organise communities and build relations and
networks. Women must use these strengths and attributes to create their spaces for
participation and exert power over decision-making
Meaningful participation is dependent on the effective, articulation and communication
of thoughts which, in turn, is dependent on one’s confidence and self-esteem. A point of
departure towards the meaningful participation of women would be to focus on
building their confidence and self-esteem
citizen participation therefore allows:- for citizens to become governors of the
community; for representatives to coordinate the efforts of citizens instead of making
decisions for them; and for appointed officials to focus on assisting citizens in achieving
their goals rather than on controlling government departments
3
(ii) provide examples of how this paradigm has affected development
strategies in uganda
Part II
Mainstream development here refers to everyday development talk in developing
countries, international institutions and development co-operation. It now seems a long
time since development was defined as growth and simply measured by means of per
capita GNP. Gradually, starting with basic needs and other heterodox approaches in the
1970s, development has been redefined as enlargement of people's choices and human
capacitation(Sen, 1985) and as if people, basic needs, health, literacy, education, housing
matter. The Human Development Index (HDI) has become an influential standard.
Peoplecentred development is becoming a mainstream position.
This means that there is now considerable overlap between mainstream and alternative
development, which share much the same rhetoric, ideals and definition of development:
participation, work with the poor and vulnerable groups, local action. This overlap is not
always apparent from alternative development discourses. `Alternative' approaches often
stereotype and mainstream approaches.
The decision to involve the Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) in the formulation of the
PRSP came about as a result of continuous pressure and demands by CSOs to participate
in policy design, planning and formulation. In 1995, when the decision to develop a
Poverty Eradication Action Plan(PEAP) for Uganda was mooted, CSOs lobbied and were
included in the drafting committee and the various working groups to collect inputs
from their constituents, analyse them and present them to the technical committee of
the Ministry of Finance, Planning and Economic Development (MFEPD) that was
responsible for developing the PEAP.
4
system of governance. The main strength of the PEAP derives from powerful
im p le m e n t a t i o n me c h a n i s m s ti e d in t o th e nat io n a l bu d g e t pr o c e s s .
The main technical tool is the Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF), which
guarantees an increase in pro-poor allocations of public expenditure and creation of a
mechanism to assess whether funds are being used for pro-poor purposes .
As part of the process of creating people-centered public expenditure, the national
budget process has been opened up. The budget documents are made public, such as
“Budget at a Glance” budget summaries in newspapers, publication of financial releases
to Local Governments in newspapers and annual PAF monitoring reports are now
5
Access to information is basic right of civil society, in order for people to participate in
decision making they should have access to information and freedom to communicate
related to various topics vital to commmunity welbeing for example health, agriculture,
participation in decision making process.
The media has continued to be free, strong and independent. Uganda has over 75 radio
stations most of which are FM radio stations. There are also a number of TV stations and
many news papers and magazines. The government continues to do well in this field by
facilitating the growth of a diverse independent media. The passing of the access to
Information Act(2005) by Parliament will help in allowing all citizens access to public
information and encourage public broadcasting.
Civic Education
The Uganda Human Rights Commission continues to spearhead civic education efforts
aimed at empowering citizens with knowledge and information about their rights.
Through its national framework for civic education, the Uganda Human Rights
Commission has been able to successfully co-ordinate civic education programs with the
donors on one hand and other civic education providers especially Civil Society
Organizations on the other. Imperative to note is the fact that the role to provide civic
education is a preserve of neither the UHRC nor CSOs alone, in fact FM radio stations
6
have done tremendous work in providing civic education. Ugandans have greatly
benefited through the diverse media that exists in the country. The majority of Ugandans
can discuss social, political, economic and cultural developments at ease from an
informed point of view.
Ratification of Conventions
The Government of Uganda has been progressive in committing itself to the promotion
and respect of internationally recognized human rights through the ratification of
international human rights instruments. Uganda has up to date ratified the several major
international and regional human rights instruments. The biggest challenge has however
been making reports to the UN as required by the different treaties. There is lack of
enough manpower in key ministries to write reports and lack of coordination between
the key ministries where reports have been written. The challenge is to put in place a
clear framework to follow-up on UN recommendations.
Uganda has heeded to this global and national concern by fully participating in the
negotiations and preparations for the United Nations Convention Against Corruption
and the African Union Convention Against Corruption. In December 2003 Uganda signed
the UN Convention and in September 2004 Uganda ratified it. Similarly Uganda signed
7
the African Union Convention Against Corruption in December 2003. It was ratified by
Uganda in August 2004. To date Uganda is one of only ten African countries that have
fully met their obligations under the convention and as a result AU Convention has not
yet come into force.
Decentralization
The policy is participatory in nature ,such that it give an opportunity to the local
communities to decice upon thedistribution of resources at the their disposal and also
seek for accountability .
Decentralization is one of the key reforms adopted by the Government of Uganda to
promote good governance, improve service delivery and reduce poverty. This policy is
entrenched into the 1995 Constitution, and its basic structure is laid out in and
operationalised by the Local Governments Act. The policy has resulted in the
realignment of the relationship between central and local governments, both in terms of
fiscal and institutional arrangements. As a result, Local Governments play a key role in
implementing the PEAP, including the basic tenets of the Long-Term Perspective –Vision
2025. With the advent and implementation of decentralization, Local Governments
became and still are key service providers. Looking at the period of implementation of
the decentralization reform so far, there is compelling evidence that commendable gains
have been achieved as far as service delivery is concerned.
Education
A healthy and well-educated population is both a necessary condition for development
and one of the central objectives of development.education gives oppotunity to
individuals to become competitive in the job market. In Uganda, households’ economic
status is linked with their health and educational status as well as their social capital.
Uganda is therefore committed to achieving the MDGs on universal completion of
Secondary schooling by 2015 and eliminating gender disparity in both primary and post-
primary by 2005. Support to post primary education to increase access, quality and
relevance is being intensified to sustain the gains from UPE.
Water Provision
There is also a strong positive trend in rural water coverage, from around 20% at the
start of the 1990s to around 60% today. Time saved by the children from fetching water
from long distances permits them to attend to school. Shortage of water also affects the
quality of health care and education. The cost of investment in rural water supply makes
it almost prohibitive as an up-front investment for most rural communities.
There is however, more scope for private sector involvement in rural growth centres,
small towns and urban centres where population densities are higher, alternative options
are lacking and factors of privacy come into play. Government has assumed
responsibility for most of the costs of rural water supply. Access to rural water supplies
increased to an estimated 61.3% in 2004/5. This was achieved through the new water
facilities, which provided improved water supplies to an estimated additional 680,000
people. The new facilities include piped water schemes for 8 Rural Growth Centres(RGCs)
8
and for 7 Internally Displaced Peoples (IDP) camps in Northern Uganda.
Sanitation Observance
The observance of a sanitary environment is essential for good health and thus a
fundamental human right. The simple act of washing hands with soap and water can
reduce diarrhoeal disease by more than one-third. By implication, investing in sanitation
brings substantial economic returns, while reducing the cost of curative health, and
magnifying the benefits of education, by increasing attendance to schools with improved
hygiene and sanitation facilities. Over 75% of Uganda’s disease burden is considered to
be preventable as it is primarily caused by poor personal and domestic hygiene and
inadequate sanitation practices (failure to break the feacal-oral disease
transmissionroutes). Between 2002 and 2005, the latrine coverage changed from 55.7%
to 57%. In the last three years cholera outbreaks related to poor sanitation have
increased notably in the urban slums.
Road maintence
Improved access of ruraral and poor communities to markets and supply of basic needs
for life ,through road networks is an important factor in fighting against poverty. In
several sectors there have been improvements. There have been major improvements in
road conditions. Government created a National Roads Authority to implement the Road
Sector Development Plan. Uganda has increased funding for maintenance and use of
cheaper technologies. Community roads are also receiving increased attention. On
railways, Government has finalised the joint concessioning of the operations and explore
private sector incentives for rehabilitation of lines and regional links. On air transport,
Uganda is putting more investment in the international airport.
environment
Recent estimates of the cost of natural resource degradation in Uganda suggest that the
cost of natural resource degradation is as high as 17% of gross national income per year,
of which 6% consists of forest degradation and 11% soil degradation. Although the
estimate is highly approximate, it receives dramatic confirmation from households’ own
In light of the above challenges, Uganda is taking several actions to reverse this anomaly.
These include: improved wetlands management, control of illegal timber harvesting and
trade, control on the use of illegal fishing gear and enforcement of environmental impact
assessment regulations. Uganda put in place the National Environment Management
Authority to monitor, supervise and enforce regulations, standards and guidelines and to
coordinate all matters on the environment in Uganda. Capacity-building in local
governments and sectors levels is being provided, because the implementation of
9
environmental management rests with them.
The National Agricultural Advisory Services (NAADS) is one of the seven priority
areas under the Plan for Modernisation of Agriculture (PMA). It is a body corporate,
enacted by an Act of parliament in June 2001 with Board of Directors to guide policy
matters.
NAADS programme represents a fundamental paradigm shift from the traditional
supply-driven extension system to client oriented, farmer- led, decentralised and
privately delivered agricultural advisory services. Initially, agricultural advisory services
will benefit from public funding but responsibility will gradually shift to farmers
themselves.
agricultural transformation will occur through a gradual shift from subsistence to
commercial farming. It implies that related advice and information have to be
appropriate and focussed on market-led, farm specialisation as well as use of
productivity enhancing technologies and up-to date market information. Specific
activities under this component include: orientation and mobilisation of farmers to form
groups; farmer group and fora development, participatory planning; contracting
technical advisory services and implementing information and communication
strategy.( NAADS QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT APRIL – JUNE 2002 pg 5,6)
10
Through the privatisation and liberalisation of financial markets a large number of
banking and micro finance institutions have been established country wide, providing
credit and saving services. This has increased individual access to credit and the incentive
to save. Also since 1997 when the government first introduced entandikwa credit scheme
,other initiatives have been launched like rural farmers credit scheme, savings societies
and coopertives(SSACO) operating fom subcounty level ,and the most recent is the
bonabagagawale ( prosperity for all), with purpose to promote access to credit for the
poor and the disadvantaged
Efforts to increase financial assets relative to GDP are being promoted. Financial depth
as measured as the percentage of GDP has grown steadily over the past thirteen years,
from 8% in 1990/91 to 20% in 2002/03. It is expected to continue to rise over
themedium term, as the economy becomes increasingly monetised, and domestic
savings rates increase. The Long Term Expenditure Framework projection is for financial
depth to increase to 29% of GDP by 2013/14.( RoU (2005)PEAP
PEAP 2004/5-2008/9
2004/5-2008/9, MFPED, Kampala)
Part III
Combating malaria.
Government response in recent years has been promising in at least two different
aspects. First, Uganda was one of the first countries to abolish taxes and tariffs on
mosquito bednets in mid-2000, thereby making malaria protection better affordable to
poor people. Secondly, Government introduced home-based management of fever
which provides free, pre-packaged malaria treatment for children through community
distributors only. This supregnancy, promotion of the use of insecticide-treated nets, and
effective management of emergency and epidemic situations.pports existing
11
government interventions, such as prevention and control of malaria during
Progress in sanitation
According to UNHS (1999/00), 83 percent of the Ugandan population use a pit latrine
and 2 percent a flush toilet, while 14 percent do not have access to any toilet facility. The
2001 Poverty Status Report, however, observes that many of the pit latrines ‘may be
extremely rudimentary’ and cites that only 51 percent of the rural households can be
said to have access to safe excreta disposal. Performance monitoring of environmental
sanitation is also hampered by the existence of conflicting targets in various sector plans.
The Health Sector Strategic Plan 2000/01-2004/05 has a target of ‘increasing safe waste
disposal including human excreta in 60 percent of households and institutions in Uganda
by end of 2004’. The Water Sector Strategic Plan, on the other hand aims ‘to ensure
sustainable access to safe water and sanitation facilities of 65 percent by 2005 in rural
areas and 80 percent in urban areas’. The upcoming PEAP revision will address these
inconsistencies and set clear targets for rural
Influenced
nfluenced anti corruption legislations
To build the anti-corruption infrastructure in the country, Uganda has started developing
and updating anti –corruption related legislation. In the period under review a number of
important steps have been taken. As part of the Constitutional review process the
position of the Inspectorate of Government was clarified. The revision of the
Constitution made provision for the President or any local authority to report to
Parliament at least once every year on reports submitted to them by the Inspectorate of
Government. In line with the Constitutional Amendment Bill the Leadership Code Act
has been revised.
The Prevention of Corruption Act 1970 has been undergoing revision and this process
involved extensive consultation. The provisions of the revised Bill will bring Ugandan
legislation into line with the provisions of the UN Convention Against Corruption. The
scope of the legislation and definitions of corruption have been widened and penalties
increased. The Prevention of Corruption Act is a key piece of legislation in the fight
against corruption. The preparation of the Bill and Implementation Plan were completed
during 2005 and approved by the Inter Agency Forum (a voluntary co-ordinating forum
for anti-corruption agencies chaired by the Minister of State for Ethics and Integrity).
12
Decentralisation
There has been a tremendous increase in the levels of services delivered by local
government entities. Evidence of these service facilities across the country is available
for all to see. In addition, decentralisation of the responsibility for service delivery has
highlighted the need for increased civic responsibility of the recipient communities or
citizenry. The devolution of responsibility for service delivery had led to indirect creation
of employment opportunities through the procurement process (for example the labour
based approach to feeder road maintenance), which directly translated into increases in
household income.
Education
Total enrolment increased from 3 million in 1997 to the current 6.5 million. Enrolment of
children with special needs rose from 20,000 in 1997 to 218,286, of which 54% were
males. Recent survey evidence shows that the proportion of enrolled children from the
lowest income quintile increased from 50% in 1992 to 83.7% currently. The totalnumbers
of children accessing primary education in the country continued to rise although at a
decreasing rate. In addition, other indicators for the sub-sector that include teachers on
payroll, number of classrooms, pupil teacher ratio and pupil classroom ratio also
continued to improve. These have gone a long way in improving the quality of
education in the sub sector.
HIV/AIDS
On HIV/AIDS, Uganda has been one of the countries hardest hit by the AIDS epidemic.
However, significant progress has been made in reducing prevalence, which now stands
at about 6% nationally. While this partly reflects the deaths of many people infected by
HIV/AIDS, it also reflects a marked reduction in new transmissions. The reduction in
transmission has been achieved by a mixture of methods, including Abstinence, Being
faithful to one partner and Condom use (popularly known as the ABC strategy). The
consistent high-level political commitment to combating the AIDS epidemic has been
critical, as has been the support of religious groups and Civil Society Organizations.
Conclusion.
The alternative development paradigm has greatly influenced the main stream
development , which in the past was a trickle down approach to development .most of
the adopted approach by developing countries are people centred for example
participation in decision making ,decentralisation of power and service delivery among
others ,are inclusive in nature, allow the civil society to determine the course of
development and benefits more the society in terms of access to basic needs for life.
13
REFERENCES
Zie Gariyo december 2002.Participatory Poverty Reduction Strategy Papers (PRSPs)The PRSP
Process in Uganda. Discussion paper page 13,14
Ministry of finance ,planning and economic development Uganda National Report
For the ,Implementation of the Programme of Action for the Least Developed Countries for the
Decade 2001-2010
Levin, K., 2002, Options for Post Primary Education and Training in Uganda: Increasing
Access, Equity, and Efficiency within Sustainable Budgets, A commissioned Study for the
Ministry of Education and Sports for the Education Sector Review April 12, Kampala.
McGee, R., 2000, ‘Meeting the International Poverty Targets in Uganda: Halving Poverty
and Achieving Universal Primary Education’, Development Policy Review Vol. 18, pp. 85-
106.
Ministry of Education and Sports, 2002, Eight Education Sector Review – Final Aide
MemoirReport, October, Kampala.
Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning, 1995, 1991 Population and Housing Census
(Volume III) Household and Housing Characteristics, Entebbe.
Ministry of Finance, Planning and Economic Development, 2000, Learning from the Poor -
Uganda Participatory Poverty Assessment Report, Kampala.
Brohman, J. (1996) Popular Development: Rethinking the theory and practice of development.
Oxford:Blackwell
Korten D. (1990) Getting to the 21st Century: Voluntary action and the globa l agenda. West
Hartford:Kumarian Press.
Mander, J. and E. Goldsmith (eds) (1996) The Case Against the Global Economy: and for a turn
towardthe local. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books.
Edwards, M. (1989) ‘The Irrelevance of Development Studies’, Third World Quarterly 11 (1):
14
15