Sie sind auf Seite 1von 444
Www.Negashteh.Com ,r-r;]6:6.-i g\ ! a.; 1,i^, *\ 9 - ,)-\>lPw\,1 ,.ti'2jTj' j g.t1 6\a '--$y,a6l,i
,r-r;]6:6.-i g\ ! a.; 1,i^, *\ 9 - ,)-\>lPw\,1 ,.ti'2jTj' j g.t1 6\a '--$y,a6l,i j
,r-r;]6:6.-i
g\ ! a.;
1,i^,
*\
9
-
,)-\>lPw\,1
,.ti'2jTj' j g.t1 6\a
'--$y,a6l,i
j
\ A&r-
6 /u,

i .i1,,

,,

l ,,i., iii,

r,;ii.i:l.

<<,4rSnjrr;S;rr*:tla;-61\)',,' r, t- o3Ao g;^r<r4 t*.rJ-\2.n\) r;)) .>sl6ta
<<,4rSnjrr;S;rr*:tla;-61\)',,'
r, t- o3Ao g;^r<r4
t*.rJ-\2.n\) r;))
.>sl6ta +io.ro\;\,-(:;\.r:=15a-t;tlr*t-e;to(ln#
a.ry\lJir6 r.,.Lrjs;,rr;t(l,lbo$p;f .a*\,*,-LfJEGi{ \-,
((.*r
r
,\rr.ir, L-: olJ!
.
J
L g-
J
i
-
rv
\
rrUl,!,,b rsiJa J-V i'l qr>,
lr$\-rr+Jla*r,r
((.&-\,9yi.r.,x6\,-.r b{ra;:, .t19!f Ui U*afi.9a.,r;:* tJ3\ ! r,r\,
;6eqs t 6fs;JL, bia,;r; t5; \,p\2
))
u- 2 2
;^;b - 6 ;b 6la a,b5s;5L-.rr<-,b5; \ .a*ta q liS 4*., ;ji,b -, "
((.c*\6-,KaB
\*\
$\
\L-.\
t!\\U\\\d\
2.--9\ 0.,,t u3-2V-t J*L e.fi 6*1J.-15,c,b5r,1-2r))
t,)-zraV)\try
e3 eW* eeai-t,f
-rAf",,4,dLJ"
-, 5 u -xS gu,/
o'u",-l\
;a, a4'5, 6,? 9' "
66 nuJj> 6 tv,a 6 o
ur. ;p
o & V\ y 2,>,lxl_e 7".7 Jst
;
t,
.*a
t *ft
j-.,
{,+
!
"y
a [
u[.lt" c?tl,r\.;$L;*^i ts\a,\;I.
!bF*,f45\r4* )*,1*4
ak aU or L to,I.,,l
{
aQy iJ\ii 6&*5b 6$rf ,,K-.'f.'
".o,rt
'3,.;n'll,Lr,.qt"i
rgl:-lt*b1\ 6\ 021;*fo;6t*7o.g.l
4)\\t,9\t
,N :ge!:11.>:*\j rSia2 t [*\v;:\ ],-tt-:2';1bt',!qh5r4'J U-
e}),tc 6laa
, : r:t,;.) rSi,aj 2.g;\x^
o rL 6* W
iZ-rt
l, ;;b;"
*
"
(.&--\.ue;
,l-"Ip .ei'-Ll o -l-l-i
.dJir o*iJ!,',L oa-li\-:.\ >
J
J
v2.
qa.
--:\
I
I
'Qs
qVA-qif -0tYf rYA-V,,5.rLl
(,j'
)il;-',)
(lo Li\c .dq
,-r,l!
ISBN:978-964-5633-25
-7
liil iiltlillll iilil I il
lillrl lll
ollTgoq.i g5ii5332 57 :l
Ju, ]€r.
')1,0
1i)

*'t(x{4-

{tlv.-IAULL, sl,3s t[\;4-1,]-.

.

Russell, Bertrand Russell

l-\ L,r'.)\ nv.'/ A,,1*l!r.!tS :,s-,ryIXq-:r Jlr,e

'd)'qlit'2';

.\f NY rl\,a .a\u$ i,;; ol7i;-

.ua tl A :621$ ola;it

97 8 -964-5633 -25-7 : sl,lI

t.i

:6p-, ,. , i^,-!,bs

l6l'al ,Lrrt :&brL

My philosophical development.

.&t),j\,:rLtbrL

.rr[j:oibrL

.1 tlv. - tAvY rJ-!,n\)r' tJ-D iAbJ,

Russell, Bertrand Russell :69ia1r

.f*

, - tf oA rqli r6a,:, io ri,il r-[*.

Btltt/, ttTr trAV :ouS;S €* ot2

l.\l :4,ir t94 oq,l

t11.11o :(51, 6-tr:"ht.rt.L

V.G-lil ^-eJ,c.a 0F6 dl*lti dt6ts3 J-D )t\;A Cr1^uV'*; blt-;-;14 ITAV
V.G-lil ^-eJ,c.a
0F6 dl*lti dt6ts3
J-D )t\;A
Cr1^uV'*;
blt-;-;14
ITAV
,(A. €-b Y'' b\u* oul2$\ ,d,r;Ult)' At F .a*.,J\ b\M .A\a* \\ tt>\' r;t;t-.iS,fl-.i,1 ,
,(A.
€-b
Y''
b\u* oul2$\
,d,r;Ult)' At F .a*.,J\ b\M .A\a*
\\ tt>\' r;t;t-.iS,fl-.i,1 , p Iar';[L].
AA'W1Yt'l , AAi.YIY:;)t
www.seraat.ir
}}({-
,.,sL'L
J't*
s\sa
,9\-t
6')'t\:i:g')
i\J:'r*.:+(*
AVlbdj
/Stl:-,,Vc'.i
eaiY-.:J6-)l.i
,lrJiof " :'a -*:
d-l }i'1riru aJi- LA
}}*1({-
4"ho 51., a;L; s: ?-P o,lJi,Gl-,.S+p;6-., Q "r-:;i^* )l ,:---; ,ti 11 a.5 ,.r-l^l*: +;*Jt
4"ho
51., a;L; s:
?-P o,lJi,Gl-,.S+p;6-., Q
"r-:;i^*
)l
,:---; ,ti
11 a.5 ,.r-l^l*: +;*Jt ,afl
glo;ti
a"iJi 3 ,r.l$ a.iJi :c--l
,rts.r
-6$;1 4i*L, q .r*JJrt a,i--L! oli,
r-
,t ;.:
"*L{;
,1;lf
J, f-n 3 a:-lil.:
, E t -b ;:U:"-)<;l* GU$;V
,,1*K:,;
*)
Jqu*-^K;l* .s61 -# i erl7 j;-l.r ,r1l-u,1
a./-,-(f &;\
.tl,-r,l Jqj#l
JUJ*li
;;a,;jyl
t"l .dtr
6to;y^5;:
.r{;
: L^VE ,*,5
JL r-r<,- ,-*
.SC gJt*, Ul;-l 3 bl.iS,JU*K;I
4,i---Lt ,d, &*li *)
rrtJ,
i--lj -,ilu'" 6Loa:^i; ;> g!)Jr.ir .:)LL
.Jjlo-t-i;r,-r -rG; d-.t,
;'--"i a,LJi,d),t il
a,lJ!,;-: a'l*E',-rtrj
J
,1-l i,r!*st:
,Jt-J.r-:1
-JJIS
61,;\1i"r:! oUl.:";t; 3 oUy'i
-L:
,o:-*.3r: rJil: 'S- ,J<--;,gall ,J7" ,o-9*1.;-"1 ,$y1 ,rylf
p-L,
.JjlliJi d; ,,-l o'.6L*
1
4i--Lt,Li t;
rrL.::K:,3 J:-?",,F\,03;,;d; +;* ;;tt"
1t^e
J-!r" j+5
i)
,,: -t-J+ ihb GSJlGl. ,6 -).-rilo.:f :lr'1-r .rlL;
q-e" u ojJ,>;r ,(*15 oYLL ,'c;Kpaa,-t5
;;t(;
s ut-,L-.tl
,
.l.J'U \,s_f
.r; ti,-l ,:l-l*i 4i.J-i ,t-_# -t cSr4tjtt(t ,,5 ,oL;
l. Begriffsschrift
2. Common sense
ir, "JJi ,J"lsi r: c5tt*r 5Jt^:- ,t ,it J-]^J ojf )) e-f .:lsl"ll ! ;r:
ir, "JJi ,J"lsi
r: c5tt*r 5Jt^:- ,t ,it
J-]^J ojf )) e-f
.:lsl"ll ! ;r: J-U
aJL*2 .>15 Fy
L .rr-b-:3i:,-j
ru;lr
u;)t ,r-L;,_,,l ,--L :.*":=l
{a)
,;l jl ;: ,' u;U - u;t
n: l: &-l-, ,_-;Lb f^"-.Jl .f:-* .JJ.,
lJ)
cr)4J LSjlrL* d--ft ,r*-fu o1[;r .51a,-rti #f
: -tiL; :3,- l--t-6J
,c-l
,-.,k5 ,,-l
a,--,lij
y: ,,l:;*:Ki- j
2Y;- (.f
6 ,Y lz. ,grr*;
La:
.4C
U- $U;;'"1 311:L* -,J"1 cJq" ,5.S; .glr, C:Q
'*,
s 6-,J*ly. f
.,J;r-P f$- !
U :yl: L ,_P:k J Ltf
a*j,,
,-.--j
;Ui
,J-:
.-t;-,(,. J^i*J 4i--Li d>: 6lra-i-ril t*
-'-ljl
s 7_r
4*,
;/
, ?ilA
,r1
Llbl*.r;lr ;lj u-jt
-rK )*-) )),rtJ*J JUJ-ij
r,q-; ?h e, \101 JL
*5 .:-l tS-:
4*l; *6
,lfi
,J-l) J'IJJ.
-r)
f:-.: orr *J*+
.c*l a-=b l" )F;l
Jdri,Jt-:-;J, t{5 nj
;l
C di .Jr*ii 5 .rrl5
-#
:Lill a, l;tK.-:i 5
.:-,1 ;UJ*+ jl .$1 +(! ,c-l
.L.tp -rl3-: i-gUi.c-l ,,i*ls .S
yS
J € ;l ,ll ,-zt -r-,,-,.1, ./5
a-rKU.-r:1.-r-;l:f a a:b.lqj
c 1_,:t5 +-l ,#
a,t*l; a=r"irilr
6sjF P
,7*2Y1fu 1
c.:-jl .rl
jl"t* 6 pli<J
,;/ .*b
"a:
a*jt
L
".i
oi ,-*l .gjl ar,Jtffi ,u-t*|u;*a os4 cbt;l J Lt>l;l
,c,--l !*.;
):e j:,AJh J S-p
a,i*Ii ,5t-a.; -ri e:t- ,_ly. tSlt )y,!
J: +5 ;t-J
*t
>:,f ;/ ,je
rp63
7:l:*l g;l: er*";r qg.r.L o1;
.trf els,$l.,IJ*; 4i*l; J];
,S-sV-lts 1S +S 6l)1U
F;:Sr
6Ui )l €d
rC"; ,a.-;t- r:
l-P
,'-.ss uel:.,:#
.-r,rl: pteJl l-)
! u+;
6)*l
f
"!LL y
.fr€ el,jl
tr-l *
SGls ,#
j.^.->J^.'
6Ui,btrc ',I;t-:j!
#t9, t c.iru *i
lst
7\: ,itr
\lAVoL.:lry
l. logical analysis
2. Tractatql Logico-Philosophicus
3. Picture Theory of Meaning
)J, dti -rJylJi fU o: tlK;y r* 11 r_,t .r-_5 NaJ.^ Jlii<fo, , -, r.,Sid_ti
)J, dti -rJylJi fU o:
tlK;y r*
11
r_,t .r-_5
NaJ.^ Jlii<fo,
,
-,
r.,Sid_ti 4
JLi
6lrl.:,\J-1, ft l*-, )J;)i -Ll;t;\;e cril.t J"lt
-rJ*J},oL:l
,jy
4s'
,S"IV tso$/. J Yqit:--r .+ur! ;:t*a;
J ,.}.Lj 6,-;)J,it<r^ql ;t j u)K;l S y oltiL:, 1
--a-),'t
,* EJ
V.J
LSP
: e -S
ot+! -,1
I I nu;,L- Jl-t-.il ;tjJa--L-
-;
"--<"
,-r.'tX:^; \ qOq JL- ;: (--*-J ,\ n;L- g*.-.r"\t t1 t jt-
1-*:*,-j-Xl
l. Bertrand Arthur William Russell (1872-1970)
2. O.M., F.R.S.
3. logical analysis
SW---*-ty
--:S.r:t--25 u- tl .q"1,;.-- i*-s".1:s:,4 l-, )f
.51.1! 1r el -r+:^ ,)y )l))t; j;r,.rK,jjli.r
.gl;.-,1-i dfqJ.;l
.K++ J*lJ dJl .f
Jr"-^ ;\,r.|'b-
,-. ,--1, ,*J
\)z; \ (*-r"-i.glaQ-ul ;/-irt+ jl .r(-
q J-U .,*,*
.ii1:3, -'iJL-
ri
u-_6 u- ll .rl-tLr .c--.il: .g;t(;L-U ,*
p"s.r" ,f;
l; .r-h;1
t6-" l" 4<!-l
6 ,=;l:.r"
crJ* O)J+i !l: )-l- C:
t J.- J"-! 6Sf ,.rn,
c,.^al ;,-1- 6ttl
J-l:6,-? t$t;
oL-Ll:;y,iJioUr*+ r
&k:.<rr,riJi.;WsE -::a.*1:,;.;q-; J*l*j t !iL" J-l^;
.;-.-il: "^l
.1L-(,_
.:.9-.r"
n/ ,.i^-l-i J*t<j Jl ;--l.9 rl rl .r-l .*"-, Vt+ q (:9 aJL AV J-lJ
n/ ,.i^-l-i J*t<j
Jl ;--l.9 rl
rl .r-l .*"-, Vt+ q (:9 aJL AV J-lJ 6
,,-ll-, *!l;
3 :rS ;*
6\9a
-l)t
;l -&-t ,.L,lr.ri _,1 ,-*l lral ,:ui yL-; e,
g+-U),rcL.^al s eV.5L".JL,
c.l3 o;t5- ls >F SF S:-*
.rf*, ,!y,
ari;
lU o: \ qPV Jt* ;: .r5- :c*l
L"q5-tJj a-$ j:
}'-11
t-i ,-fu,J- r.--l :Ll # q .r;u;r 6 (Autobiography) ./f:.tl
,-5 r;: * )**
)
c*l ol; 4.2;
*
+ ,ht-' 6<.$l;
Alj,c
"/.rf
:J+a-"b c*l .r,5 3 rjl.:rr
r:
J-b 6evzl -o-!- : Lra
J tL*
6l,sj
a- +J ,,- P
_hKfU q \qOq JL I
S-&)
* -,t Jl .riLb t **6La+;--.tJl ,JnK *r, L. oJ-r;oaa;
;L-; a, j e-* gi-\S-\) 5,y,t5;,11:.:;b
oplasljltr
clUL
l-, :3----
eF eV-r 6iti
) (f teiJ,;\*
r.
)*lt c)r)t!
,C*jl
?F
6bd-r
Gda^ oj*ar C-ie 6 ,6Fy:
,-i_:;
Ot* tt
_,, jru
r afi;,Ut ti ;tr5i_:^":. g-J q i
,Jt-q 1r _e J5 cl )J-f
;rr+ ; r;.1 J*"
Vt:5 ,-*l .-rjL_r"./ lfl
q lti tf
SF yA,
*U
tS$*, 6"-*" t lrtfui 6 lf-, ,J.aJ
.(,- r," .r-l;tQ 3 ri;l$ ,
lr J*lr ,g;y+i,
-l);l
.91o;js 45 dji<l-t>,_J^a;;Ei Jlid l, tairl
t) J*lt ;-Jl., l.:1;-! .t4
.--,15 ggc,Jt-L".:3^i e,.Jl-t" -r,-L;.f j!
4;lr- ,o-\; ,gl-.[a;- J ;;Lb I ei1-s d.*r J e<i:
JY*-l : -#
J d*l-! ,tL;,a.;.Jlr cSll. o1_y,olf-:-^1a9 ol-ru
6+; Je
eil-c
--_t-t*J
r)V./K:r
6-_rr" c;taai-rl f# .c*l ri.:3- rt * d.o 6aJJ 3
* J: ,c*lr,_jltil .rtK^," ,gly.3:.ai.r11: l*[s c*,k, 4_e.r,
jt+J"^:+ .:L.9t- a-- 6lo;l-Ul L J J,;)lr;.: tAl^e.i
p
-&,
-,1 Ai
.:*r:
"f-15 c;U*: ai c.--i,l: -hG + r,"tr.+ ,6.st--,a a,.r-i;l.:
r"1 .,1l .i:*31 JUI J-lr* et')lJ J 4rJtl" fiL- JJ-J.i J'a dLA4^L-$1 r- ai ;t-J
r"1 .,1l .i:*31 JUI J-lr* et')lJ J 4rJtl" fiL-
JJ-J.i J'a dLA4^L-$1
r- ai ;t-J
.fl;tt+ .r:*l
a:L^e j+ a.r. r;3-. -iy'i
i5otUr
,L!i 5:
-1r r.L-l pj) -r.l;q J:rai)\,
6Laa-:,--r,l ,:r"i: .t-LLLi,
JJ
'|-l;
.S ,-rr
r )-f i
rl ;;Lb ) p
aJ .:*1 ,-iQ1r Ji y be,L, esV to6 -.,t5 6taL"ai ;1 61';[-
lr Ldi J*lJ
6l.-aut!,1-ljl e:f
.c*,1 c-i;
\q0q JL jl
r+
SlS"_r.61e:;lrrL- dJe4^ ,ntf d j! -,y: -,lr t
,St^cj S y ,x-f t
\2 J*lJ 6 6.K3 ;*-,trr$ u,;L \AAA JL q
gtb 6
t+i "rrtK;
:-l
j--1 4-r".-1i ,1-llt i-fu
a5.:*"1 F;
or-9', aJL
6*-1" yl;l
), )f
:*
: :l;-r" ,-S x: JQL r*lr-
;: l; t4;;l>.rL-
,tK ;-t;
Jj ;f -Lrl&rL.e ;Lt p15.r.(,
U pj) .:Liil ,-ri;l g;n13 rll:
,;,Ai tW d37-r J-1, rfL
Lu y *:2
;tii ;l ,5r-r,:" eAg
il
;lp
Le 'e
j
J,:
sit-z I
7*4.; :15 ,*l J3 .,SJ ,5La1l:--.-7 j
J
J
J
vJ.
.
/
=
L
J*lr ,,.** ;Lii ;1 G,L- : l-:S €-r. : JV i S;; Gtlf &"
o;S y
"}-lr L^14 6:Q,;:.t; l
.t-lql 5Laa-;--ll V ttj'rr
)!
45ju-: -r5 J)-r:-t Q,i ou: q L- :r
!
: J5 v)'-- l: )f
-,,
:L5 F-, Gy. :\ .ras oy.a *\
cK
: .}1*; : afr Vi ;: s)
6jl--.,,-l_rt+ s,]-,,l-t
#
-6_& -ts:li;l ,.;.1 .-f
r*V
U-Frf
:t5,*1:, J*lt.,:*l a,LJi iJot!;> -rl rsta ot5.l: i:-,1-l
!-
) ,p)+'&-_* ,sA; rl c"-rl;r 1; ;3.-- P
3"r c-rl
,)-a3 J, -r)./6 c1o,6-t> 6+;-- 11.-t'-Li-,! L4JJ
'#stoi;;tii
3l 6t'o 6bl13-\ r
r,L-r.r
aln e,:\-:: ).zt:ra.:,rr ctLJ-J l; r3'-
.x-\e (U ;F
c#k-)
;l 6r.a:* C-t ;:i JU. q 4L2u)'t" 45
lUt:
pt,
J L-64-x--J,1 ;l .L;35 €-*
L 1; r3'-- 6;Ar;1"t5;
a.,. !j--Li J*t<j rl ;Lpl g,f;t x-_$.l tr st .S r; ,Gi Gtr:,6o;3: 6t-oof I
a.,. !j--Li J*t<j
rl ;Lpl g,f;t
x-_$.l
tr
st .S r; ,Gi
Gtr:,6o;3: 6t-oof I
S$.t J ,_*.s gLn-,-r! J.:_'E _,, ;LaJ, .J^:5 F" 4L$ | r5+!)[c ;:
\
y
,AVi,-r(J:n
::jt jz>.,,.:t-;t_-, ;r cg:!* .gL-L.r! .:L!l
4i-*l-, U-i eS
.,L,1r
p:3, JU:"
.3- .(
;:,
0
+i-*lg
-
.
_J
----
-J-
1l
.--.
\-
J.
,
\ p _i)_;l *.r"
\
-
--_
+*bre ry' oJ.,.U
rt)
;ytr $l_l.f 6 o?Ji -r*'tj _,,
f-g"
J."J^ dtA;;
e5 prL JrU:" lJ )_i 6 pr3, .ti _,|-lf
,-fi, ,S- ;l 3 :a, t- -r:S.f
c-rt- fr
6L^t-;r 6 :y' a=[:;
.r,ly.f g;r7 ]>-a c,!rL-_r _r:
15U ,j-;
p;.
J)
J*lt 4-S L-€
-);
*. &,d^{!-lq n.:3^:;,r;
gL;-,ytr J+.L -,, fg-
qr^
ab-,t $li,r.i k.;
n: l:rj ,
:-l
or]L
.it";tr_, )J3-. J)
t--:- 6 r5 l+
C): SlL. y _,1*;l ,l.u or,"=-.-o ;r
c: "L;> YL c-*: [- ,r*"_, .llycr- tt 5* \ 6 L-:€ a5"! yl a,,.3
d:i
*it--FL^ C"-:lf y) f
J
4
GR .r=,-, oi a,. tslyg aS
4=(JU-
c*;l: -hV *
+! 4l
.nc-*l .l;t2 :V
p>.il
+J orhilL
r,
.f-lt
6Ylj r- ,*"1 J:
,n"r.Jlgt5[ ,r<-a oG;#l +-S e 'r_,, J1
L
!-5 .:*1 6;1';c*:Kt ,JUJ*.ttri .li;l ,rf*n Jl 6 .-.-,1 4ll# ,/l J,l
3 o.-Li;;l ,546 ,t1 a>t*t c.+- J) J t$J--L.6a lJ .,,t5U ft"j c.;U.z
ollG\qt
oJJ) 6L-ae^i--t,l 1l
Ci
Jt- r-a 1r
:;l:,_rr
,1 6J^!
'l-1,
3l .5.:tJlcrl! ;l*y
: dt_f
,5y 61r,. j c*.lrS y .tjF _,1".t
l_ ;-tr;
P
+ .l-U e*6q.-,[;5
c-*-;j J-oJ J, +,1
--!.r,
.>15 a->t y rril;J1il Jl"a
a-, ai
\AqV [
tSosJ)
\Aqf Jt- jl "U_f 6a_^J.(-_;:,_[-l;
6+i*J)t o+ t!rt,
,'o-fi
&;'U
d^-.i )rl) a*;
j-r1 "Jual
1. Alan Wood
2. Mc Taggart
3. Bradlev
6J; ,.-d 6 r;+1"i 31 .t.:3Ll s u-& 6".:yji dlr gftJ-l-l .tss\ 6s-s;3* .--<* e*
6J;
,.-d 6 r;+1"i 31 .t.:3Ll s u-& 6".:yji dlr gftJ-l-l
.tss\ 6s-s;3* .--<* e* .ll ,Shr-9 r-,L& a>.*j r lE 1r .r-UQrt
d, ,,F;L
c-;
r ,Jt cits;'ti r=; ar o;3': Yl ;' J-lr
e
lJ J*<^:=Jt+ ui.l.i--t
,-r"Ul ,lL;i,5Ln.t5"r,-.r.rt" aS 6,1<5
t
jl .,(1 sl .*f
15 r-=J 9 rJ-a Ltl3; gio;L;))) lU
l-,
C
',+t64JtL
.&u.rje J-tt, Ft
aU o;./
s;t- x f,v
-:ts ;t
-"JU+l;tl;;r .iJt:. J-lJ \AqA JL ,)t-ti )3J> ;)
-fu.tr+
5 .*
-;S
,ltz
J:-hr
;,1 +, 61.;L- .>l> ,-rl;l ;;SIJ
-rl,-S o-llf
a-K .>l;b
6otL:t: oJ:+-3,, u+i a5 -LLJ 4+J ,-*l q l-, Jl Jfu
v ,1G,
e,-J
,-,*1 q gl.tL,3 c*l ,f^al
,*.1
- -1r ^-S 6rg$ 6.*
L:-:J
cr-:Jl j:rt'-Y d4i*L, do;b: o-*
&
8 ;'-1-,4+.j J",-l \ r;d
J:
.Uei 4t - J.ilcr,Jl9ti t-F-."J 4<i-l ,a ylr .rJrlrr tSt+Lo;t
r-l C"ly
)J-> o,J) -:-,
oJtl, a
4
ef,
-ll "*
4+j d.rl t: J-ll 5 '.-l
,'l
ylj;a-JL.i> 16 q lK
c J: rl
lK&
ol; ,",1 ;) litt)::3r \1j,0 .:;lerl
-* 5,r;.r,--, JJ! d./-l \
J-b .\\'
u-sl3 d)to f.p +i
p -f )y J
)-f
C'-,!'i 'r:*l .rJl3 tr*lu'
J J*lJ e"-'
,
t)Jr C;o)Jt r'Ft
ar ,r1L-au-:y ;r4*"a J[-lJ .$$1J
,-:- q ,-J+ jl
tt-t lJ 1*;UJ
"r-r
*i
;l u+ 4jUii,J, 6 .r1l: .;<^
SStU": 6os*;
.ga:--t-x l, L#i
t+;irl Js .:;t-n d-$ -&t l-t tf
;i-l d
6+;-,-b -l-
sl-r -'lq
JL.ii li J*lJ ,ri--J., ,51-aa:--.rll F
J -t;b ,r;-1E ,r:.^,ol Lae*:ij
.5d4-A o-5 .r+-,r ,.:-l o:;ji *V :5-l.: l1 la;i jl ,Sl.:! 9l ,J;-a:,r,
;yKlu, J"<" .r!(t j c*;:lJ l1 ta;i
s oW\-t ), ;;Lb 6ta<$ q J-1, -rV :6
15rr 6\J.'a-i ;>
l. Stout
2. George Edward Moore
j" , ei--i.i JFt<i 6L--E,L+l J- ol; j .:3 > )*,gQ-J3:11! r qAb &1 L.
j" , ei--i.i JFt<i
6L--E,L+l J- ol; j .:3
>
)*,gQ-J3:11! r qAb &1
L. w- :jl)JJ!.,-.
.:J)r 6.1"t* J eC eW:
(Sr.--b s Wy
,*L^.t5.u-) J ,,b:i<i- J )_* ,GtX 6t6-a 6o.t,a-,-,
-,lyi,
6.4;,
,Jr-p ,4-f
-r L<JS G*J)6.JL
,c.rL; rc>tJ (SL--)^ do:Ll;:
613,,L:S.,r,Lar1[i eU::-l *3t- HVSl-a S*--);;l :lc;l J jJe
ar pta.,l- S .b:e.:Ft--,
r5otlt: 6-tyl*
ot5-r,-.: ;l >f
uV- ,fi
* tJa,,
:'o *sl.;.|
,Y.5url, ,'o3-1i +t"-7 ;1 :3r ol.tri ;l 61.;!
- ,L--; a- '\J e o:
\)- '.1.' :(J!-
)
,)Ji*Si
'J s
-
Ols-*,
Jr-* J -rr----
oGJ.-l*l
;t .(a
"-r<"
.sr /
*-i.r
.r-.*-q
J*l; 5 C*l o.:jr oi -.,5 J,-lJLUI;l eira o;ra aii Jn- otjJS
j"t(
s fl$l e_f
,*Jl :,JF
x1s 6sLu-,
J a/. \ )f
L. Ju, tS O# -h c.*;rli 6ta:.i;lry ,, t+r"<r;S i3_,lr.-t ;l .l; ;-.r, E
tf
p
s> *
Cly ,, Jl 4<i,_l ,*n
6o1\;r e5 c*,: q;) U:_, 6*
u-4Ktt .€.&;*-
;-l jl .r:ii -u"-& c*lr;a q s .:;lss-t*t
;1 qL;U d: .Sx.Jlf
.,L"q ;r .ti :.ll3rr; ,-rt5-r-:,tr;
'?r; ,[5
Ji # q l;
-,sJ<;l )Jp.r* J*tr -rrr
J*U !j*!
.gtoe.r,t
f-Jli<i J ,.3$i
63,G 6 .:*l ;l
+ilJue.:r-- 6tr\-l)l.J:5 &JLL"
\l: ttf
6+L*Js.J.K .5".-
) ,Ji,Jqj ,
lJ u.:ld-:,-J,l )f
J-lt
r t; e
.t-_6 :\ G.&r-.l
F-l Gq;
.jl
,Fly rlr;:
,,1 6qJ
r3o_r!;r i
d-15 r-
;
JL-IJ Jt-ii y.L
a- ai ,rlL5 .ga^-a 6\p;1
6 ;1.:r5
"i)Ai il
tS_r. -sl5 J-t, ;Lii ;l .g1"1! t)_f )) J,
fS o:Li:-l -rilo:;[J
c^.-o
1. Urmson
2. Warnock
3. Strawson
4. Ryle
ar t-+6-.;; a5 c*-tru. $lorii *t 5;( -6:y ta-5- 6ltl cSLrc-ry 3 r:-l o-r*:_l orl>
ar t-+6-.;; a5
c*-tru. $lorii *t
5;(
-6:y
ta-5- 6ltl
cSLrc-ry 3 r:-l
o-r*:_l orl> ,.i-
Lt+Jl -#t-t
6Ei 6Loa
--1
,3
;V
jl
q- ,i,43 )t oi3,, .d*l d-S ott*
,*t
e
e
-:l L:,.y
J
J
\J
a
L_r,t ,Flt Clfy
r---.-1
,ga-^>; )l t_#,f
Go:Jt 6t-aa;"-ril a,
glr->l .(*xJ- .r-.--l :L*1 Cl-;,6 t+l jl J_: .1t.r; orLi:-l ,-fur-
5 t+l ;l x
;
-ly-r yl _:l *,
elqt
pf u.;,Jt.(
.J tr olyt,.i
q 6.,1t^ta;) e)l) c*.l"
rn+ lLl
or; o>b 1V:,t,l-t-,,5u6J,
):-f
st.;1.:;3i lJ.ftJ-:t-l
;lU*.*,-:l
:k-*l 6*;
.5a7ri
1 a-trj\; Jq^- i ;ttL-
,-,-:l rk-,| 6Laa
.J:5.," of ,&
--ri
#
J Lip) J!--.: 4jLU-: u:41 14jLU^i o!-, gk*
-,;
a,. *y
[ 3 il;r,
".>
r;1.r Jt*:-l3 c*l Cr^i ;1 JJ) dLL-l gtdrL, *S t+i ;l )j
.slry^e
ji t+i .-t5
./l5
jl
--ir-,;.
9 J--or 6r lt oJ\:.il;,- 6
Ln,
',1.zl
J )-d G oi gb
a,. xl3eun Je)*1 oJi.:i|3,- 6 plorT -,[.(1 l-, clkJrL,
.*,-:l 1gLii t:13 tgo-# ! a*1 -u"jLi e5.r-Urt . d:;a;ti;l
d----*j otKi 1: 5 QrL. ;l 61";L )s_f )).p1
:r5
;.ar1 ,tJlo>3,, ;ltL
.c*l o.u o:l:1j)
d*iiq -,: Ju,-U.f .!rLU J ?--P -b \
Wy
ol; .---l :t lt'
45 ;t-J
6a.",o yl 5 ,,1:,_r" :j;
,5a-fa3 ;r .gL-i;lr-l l; :j- ,g;l;S*!- ,rr C*
6aA-S ot-! ;r
3 -r,rJL; 6;[-
q
./l-5 jl ).*
c^Lt-t" 1S 6 plfut* -^+ .-L F, il c--iJ
;.ol:
: M-S oW J.l-: -eV
-,1" -t -,1-l-: .:rt* ;l ,gl.;! ;.: ot^l;tg1l
eyl t ly .ry t;(ol;
,--1, -,i--," 3i-o ,1L: dJr
-f , SGi .f
) o?l-) +y
t1 ,ol--,-l 6aLJJ
slS-t, ,5a**j,'
;: a-llr.L;.uJ, I
a-.-7a;-,.1 ;L;-Il ,3a13 ,;-15 aa .rgflgl;t
Www.Negashteh.Com J. !.i.-J.i J.t<j ;13-^,o )f J.l: ,f:6 d ttlts r5.> ,5tri ,t7 e) 6
Www.Negashteh.Com
J. !.i.-J.i J.t<j
;13-^,o )f
J.l: ,f:6 d
ttlts
r5.> ,5tri ,t7
e) 6 'eWt€
-rtS .r--l1i{>.;4 J a#J-? C<-
4*
fL- -tSy S $r-S
"pq
,Ll'-," c;lrt;;1 (p
bbt"u .5t{.irU
ft,J
o_r-_tt s .t'V
e)l
J gr)-; 8
€,r
r:i .rl d,r--lF ,slt.ls 6i:- ;)*J,,
-
6lri
3 ctlllJ:-3r J Jlu"r-iyr,;+
y ol:t:-l J{l J}4. ol; ;,1 ;r -::*135
-t5 rl-
,_l
,f#
;JS f t ,>*l
f
t , ,sSt d-Jr 4!,7-ttr
T,3j
.)r3l
++ bF _,, ;L1.i, ,.5 .*:
s! rr.9.l.l
d
P
?lt
\lAP ;,*g
.l-lt -.,Lil 64-J\t nlt 6t!.c ie; 6Lo.:eL ., ;!9 r,,\:-Ity go-,r!-r) -;-7 6 ;*'.rlo"r;l-1if .r-I
.l-lt -.,Lil 64-J\t nlt 6t!.c ie; 6Lo.:eL
.,
;!9
r,,\:-Ity go-,r!-r) -;-7 6 ;*'.rlo"r;l-1if
.r-I
,JJq) :+\.u,r^ll 6o.lu*,-9J 6p 6oJU)
flt,rJ
\-4 .-;\
at;al s,lT
l."Remarks on Bertrand Russel's Theory of Knowledge",P.A. Schillp(ed.)
Philosophy of Bertand Russell, Library of Living philosophers, Vol.5, Evanston,
rfi.1944).
., h.JGn C".ilccl, lj.*: y ot.;S,r:--tr- sl'rFa ,stK*r./t5 6 ,1r,93 Ji .5Gi u)j,'l*-j*.;- 6i-Ji :l
., h.JGn C".ilccl,
lj.*: y ot.;S,r:--tr- sl'rFa
,stK*r./t5 6 ,1r,93 Ji .5Gi
u)j,'l*-j*.;-
6i-Ji :l Std
&3t,6:y
.li J,)U ^s*K,;\,
;--l .:l
oJ:--r pt+l t
-i^-l; -,,-l ;l ,_r(.ar5 -;;1 t-€i Jl S,u
lg:a
y a.si. y-l 3 :y noJit,l* ,J.tj .<"-f .r:+
lJ Ji 45 ;L*5 -#
if-l o+.C*1 or-,i yt4 .ga:--V,61;-l;1 3 JU*i11l .11.:15 +,Jtt"
14)6-o *LA o-r .:t5 ir.^ clL-! ;: ,rSi ,:^,o3; .$:
F-l ;l
d)ut.IL?".< -tf
:6
lLoi;.: ,)t Ll t_f,
, ;)il.rAJ;4
€.1crtJ
.-u:U J(-. J"l -el 6 -r."-, L c*l,
oi ,1 ;y-: -,Q. J:
6
Jt*i J-jlJr,i ;Lbi;: l;:yy;Ji e}i ,r^:X,ot5-r;lr; ;l
.>12.,o:'-l *
;t a5 lJ "r,,t"oJL -,1 g-,lrt 6 l-r-) <:y ralj> +Jl.u,
rr.-
,;-i,
jE-J(;t
t.r--.!j=-.uftpU
Ut;t j-r:- ol(:;t: jl ttt
Wood.t
Ji,Alan
J t+-l;*
.:l:
r-l:l
:.,,/-Ji ot(-:ll: ;.: ,,; ,Li crc.jt y l1 t3> c,)l"e;
,.g*-7,;i
.r,-U--.iT
JL-
;: r5 *5r,
.K- .-,s-, .rK; ol-L ultt
r
$
c*,1 .r,tS ,F_ J"t, ! .9l 4r_,
j,rli
c-l
Il
lU o--.r rl-l;.gLau--Jl
Jl
Jis
r-,3o_s\-s> ffu
,56
C-&-t J
lqOA
jS;l4L-:
r, J-lr 6,
.c---Jr3;: ,r(U-
rr j-
,
ttr ji
:.1-t.1 ,guiJ;
.li 1Lt* ,-
.J-jL
Jl .5Lrr:--Il iu-
.r:t;:
:.ej Ji
J iIt"
.91!i .gu:
fL;U
rbl-
-15
-;)K
.-ru:5 ell
1,ti
,rL-\ e1
-r,-^
.li:ilr- .l-l-r J.;U: t3j Ji 6rri;t .rrtfi .gly .rtS-u;lr;
2. Bertrand Russell the Passionate Skeptic: A Biography, by Alan Wood; Simon
and Schuster, 1958.

J/ , i-Jj J"Ki

\Y

aJ.----.j o[-L; ,51. q.*i *. tt;

c*;.:Li 6k:-ilr7 *_f

r;l: JL-:-l

.J-JLi oJi; dh:- )33 .5tri S (L.l d-J*tl .5qL .:;,

;)l-u,. slJ)

.SL_r ot_t" q lt >r; ;l

6

,A :\ \ ,e[*3lf ! J_t-,t l:* goJL-, s ai)s ol-; -11 l1 l"j ,/
,A :\ \ ,e[*3lf !
J_t-,t l:*
goJL-,
s ai)s ol-; -11 l1 l"j ,/
t
3;;
6*
U -rteij
t.sL(,;,r^L;
:\Y-\Y:\ ,,.r# * Jys g,,Je,.SaJL,.r
.;l-:3- jU^ jt 6r."! \-- .;Ul ,+ jl ,(1
J;^:Jat c,-i.i-c)) 2K.;3y 4J"^a 9\;f,
'cif
t
i-l
--\-2 g\(;rl
.<slolL^(.;
l. EPISTLE TO THE CLOSSIANS 1.12-13 : II.8
2. EPISTLE TO TITUS
&,)*3 . h.tgn C gla:--i,lr sS s y. t+i q 6 rUol't- ,* t oly€
&,)*3
.
h.tgn C
gla:--i,lr sS s y. t+i q 6 rUol't- ,*
t
oly€ lr/ ,_j-*J., Jrtt
a- c*l
6o)-r" H"t:1
.:rr rt-r5;'U ,J tS-s,s -g r-rtJ;t5 6 ull*S J
1: ::-l*ji"r: c-!L_ Ltyr tr*Jr 4 t6J "
.jl;i"
d.-lli.:3*;
,
*a
4-.7 t-13 o;l.Ul 4+ t-
fi[::
pl
:,
GU:b ,Af
u-i--t-t J.tt r-ll"
oa^e,, i Lc,g+ti;.a11:,_r" L S .JS bli.S qr-/ t_ a,.-- jl 6lqs>
1*"dl d4i*U \1
Li \utll 6Qt-;: a5 ry+
t;t*
.rl pl.r,iJ;;[5;.:
c--"E \
fl.-,*l .lrf rt-.;l l;
<5
,t ;t
'*L-: jLb ,
*, Ly.y *5 n+i ,5L::-L ,lr.:
.1-i rJbtt5 4<jLa 13, .--,)\-i.il e(-
:t G-6-5t.(iL Ltyl prl:1t+,1 -*
6 qi-* [ ,:3,.:l*iL_1
.rJ:3,, ,--,)'Gil U
G4 ,sW-F f t tt-r.r,xil 4 t<JL ,-r-l
)l i
r-it:; , ,,- 4
;l
:.:3" C;
3r ;l
c+r a,iJi a, U A)Gi,r<J.:
JJll.,-. 6 4i
J.:L -,, ffi"
4i--J., t"1 5
J+ _r^
tb-,t
,qU;.: ;r31
-*:1.: d*3) ,rS-t rgj- rl 3 :+i t".rs.f &-f t_t- o-r,uli;-r;3L
l. logical atomism
.gr-!Lr-l jl"t ;L-: ,y\ *.tr.(\qfY-lA0A)
Giuseppe Peano .Y
j/ , i-l"i J.l.'i 6 Grt + Ol_f .* LPM.il=iL--, ;: g;L .t-oU.:,. l; :3--
j/
, i-l"i J.l.'i
6
Grt + Ol_f .* LPM.il=iL--, ;:
g;L .t-oU.:,. l; :3--
,,5l:-:
e5.u7 -p ,;.i-el- c;U^:
G;t*X J+^^ 4 ,tt$lf : .Jt^t-;.:
1l .(J
dtJ-i !
I ,.;-t<s ;: ,u1l1a tSo)J)
r!
:r
t*:!
c^jil-lJ :y+-t
a+ l: :y- ;3L C- -;.i r.;-) );3r ;: .1-p--tll
La4!
-
;l
,5.;[;>
[4,L5
trlli.5o:l;l
,r.l-ti a:1t+,lr* ,,'Ur,JQ.+
u,-::- r;rlr *:;l
'LSJ;\7
t+ 6* q tipq-, ,;tV t-:f
q r,_S.l ti f",1.lr
t
Gl}>l f1-"J
"(1
n:-r:.r- ;t<a 1l) y -9r) 6 ;.5 -,:! f-l_l.5;
6#4,.4 U-l 6_r*.i 1r 5 na;i y' dor!-rr )j ,.>-l *d
)l kf
y
.;IL -r,-r;
r_y
urL"l"r*
,rJ3 ,-ui.:b,r, G)-fi cr, t l-l o;<^ r ta;ts.gt^.iJ 6r-,t-J -rr
r; l; L-aari-Ji ,,,-l ::
j,-l C .jUjq ;t
S's-f 6I.A
y' 6 ,,,--r::--r 4+j
)f
ds
,iry. r-rL:-l"r o
Gs-r;r L 3r -,^ J-" t
€C JLJ ,q5
1: 6 e{i
q .rr
17 }
dLrq. i
fK
s? J .:-*^.al .gl;1.: .r,-ta-i)tJl
rl C"l: /l
caa;i
5
J),1.4-l jl r:-
t^djJi" )'&
o-:V t-5 -r:,+!)\p l; -l3,0 u-a 1l ,i;Di
6[a:3a.:, y'tS.1K;.: fl-
,r i
c.;[:*i;
Jl L 4jt.*.-'a :;y+ ;s-l 1.: .fi;t*r-
er:* l; ,L/JX dL-e- 4j JJ
;l .51";L ,-.)j,at l1 :,9,.-- "f- ,l jl .J:;* ,y
.):
rgr-1; clk*l.I*a
;r +5 ,--;Lb eW-*y
f"l .-.*;.<r pf
,:A-- uia- 6@2ey
6,;j-,it lJ Ji 4J :ja gfi
C*l orJ+ t'f
,-lr-
fl.Sro 6+i')c
1. free will
2. immortalitv
J. emplflclsm
.;u1 .i-.*.Q ,cjts Jiit.il .(\A.Y-lVYf ) Immanuel
Kant .f
.-r,.*U .J<^ .;:-r).p deL-_r 5rr;5 .{tlrt-tw. ) Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel .0
.,ui
giol3J-ra 6*4kl -rJ-l+ .,1;r. :;13:l 6-r-f .( I 10zr- \,'\t) George Edward Moore .2
. u:
7. a priori intuitions
\q Gu& r-h c-*i +-5 -Ll:3,1 j3ti j,,-l l-'4-roUJ-+ .l{,Lj n' Csx AW -lr C-.JIJ
\q
Gu& r-h
c-*i +-5 -Ll:3,1 j3ti j,,-l l-'4-roUJ-+
.l{,Lj n' Csx AW
-lr
C-.JIJ ;) +^l=o-a -t- f:
3 a-i6l-t-- J-> 3) 6Laa-z-.a> -,1 :S:"
Ot"l
;) rL- c-l-:-a.:.r" J"(,;_; J> 3) oi aS c*t o
ry
6t^^ nr,
:l -J -t
a.ril d *-:r-l
f+
\.c*r.-l ,r; U_l;l 4y
t6,;
:!:.:"-t4;
aJ
p-t*
l, gLjL
r 4->.-.i.1
'rl a, .: iL
-.
.iLi*.i;
, otiJ,.
'
\
e'
e
/-
:
(_-
J
'
t-b.e no-rlL-.;
6
dt,o-l- -t, 6-bbttsr,*
*2"'
;{s;U-
-L:-a:.-n Jtrfu +:.rt{cJ 6L"J- 6
ai ,t 6h**;6*
J:t*
.:)S
q, ';;*-Y 6alJs Jot!;r F5;,
l, ot-(-l_: -r-l 4<jl ;l _- c-.;r
;i
.(-
otii )L
, Ja.:* ,: .iL ,15 tl .r:l:
i
I
,ol '.1 , ,u
*.rJv-J\9rr-ar'yv-)-t
"-
-o
',
l. the doctrine of extemal relations
2.
monists
J,_l .(Jr,)) 6((-i')) dL* | terminum
;Y
rl .term
a-5 .:tl: _,1.----: .SLoL- Crlrl
6ojlJ .f
er-+"o
.[rr.:,t-),1.L*h t+ n.r-U O\Lei)
terminology] .:-l rfl-Lalu :3- ta;i ;t
,i-
a + b orLr
r)
.d;f;
l1 (expression) cr-.,!" &-
:oLj!;
.glr,
u1,
term
,r"
.gG,;>
;:
a-.rg,-;l!))terml.9--6o;r-il .*:-.-aetJl"r'.gbri1;rr.-2cd j b3a.gLodL:J.- 2cd
mon6me
{-Jl} ol11 1: .c-l ou oril:f,, tderr
.r-_:LS -.
1J4-
.t-l ,S\t *
ay-Lpl
+l
jl=, ! .rr-: .-r.e-i go ! 5
*a
[_ -j:
t- ,_;.A
L_
_9: ;l ,51 ,t:;h-
rr -.)Jr
"rl.re .q
-.,-tlf ,S-- 1: ;3
l-r-:-,c;r
;
6ly.t;.\u.
<l>l l, term
.t;
lsp
,11r.64-
C_l
(middle term) (J<jl :^ -r-) J (minor term) ir;=45 "r-r (major
term) n;.6, J>)
J.:+4^
,rg;je.rt*
.L-i .r- -,1-l-,,.i-,a.n-li-ir, 3 ns$ 6utLl ,<j4. ,3o.lj,ll ;6
f-:,
:i3;61r,
tJtJll j*<iL -r- I [aG] ;r-,&^ r- 6\j> ,3=s 6a'r]'
.c-l jU crL*;l
ta,Lill ,J?<L s j lL\r;-)
1bt/*].rxs -i- I
"6
.l>
.gl;l: ,;"45 ur;."
I;u1 ."*
-E grrl5.-sl,
.c-l oL;l !l ,i.-
.c-l .r.;ti Ll/- ,nt
1*l
etz: y^:t.S.-,!-,) J-lr ot5-r,-: ;l
ori
ij>
t,itJll JSjt " J-)
";+
,r^t<i .glra (
.J,-!l,J-"-r )4 ,;Ai-,
,_:l .gaeri ,.rL-b 6l4l:--
J-;lir,
.J-l) :r,_; utS a, -r;5
.\Vf up i\YiY ,Jl; .rJr-l ulrL;.il 6e*jy
4. property
5. whole
6. relatedness
7. complexity
8. related terms
9. Russell, B.A.W. (1900) A Critical Exposition of the Philosophy of Leibniz.
j. !i--Ij J"K; .r yl .rl-rrl, JK r-i ,JJ*:.A\ J- s-"L) Gi.i)3 (13 ; "<;S;
j.
!i--Ij J"K;
.r yl .rl-rrl, JK
r-i
,JJ*:.A\ J- s-"L) Gi.i)3
(13
;
"<;S;
,)tJl .i-
oS *?Ji -f
,-# -,_b s o.:L 3 ctLj j
Lri r-r:,i,, aF.U n.:Liln
gt-g,b-,r ;r*i .l=U:
45 .,"t(i" .x:y a;s;S 3> :;l: JJ! di t
1-9)te
6i)r
J-LL da-Lii a-, i-Lilc-1rt t^r.A aJ-fu|q c.iJt;" ;r .rlfu
,)\.L -:y;
JtJ,l;-*;liq*
*t-i
q5il3 t
,^
_,:tr ; prX;!
F
.ef
r-,t l,
-r;;,.t>'\-rl .st<Js 3 rbo;! 1r tLnnL*J ,, 'Lnnta
l;:j-) olL,
r,"tK"n
,\q\. JL;l
cgb-,6 6a-.,a 6
.r*, ,a.,4,_lL
lr F";., ,-rtg 6o;L-r.: ,(;
,p-r,L: gta=,| |
,p.:t*"pL--,
c5o:!:r
o: o.r-<l_t; ;'U c-.,; -*
6,ri
rl 61.;Ll
.r.p:f ;L;i
"gLar,,;K
d3-#t c)3r o)15 -fi+i)\p
lr,.
.:L
--
.54,iJi ;r 9i .g-rc
oS .t,Si
r3-
g-t" t dyd 6 t-F scllzly.&.,-l:.fs
^-*,16a,.---l:r, "(--;p
go:L
)Jei r4:-l; .>-# ,-f
p,-rL6.7 v
;l u.:,r-; lJ La4E*J J La4taj
,6-*
r.rt6; 6
aS-p*-r Gl-t' * -rl lr
:L
,!
.rl :) jf
,t J -r;,1
-t*;-r;l .r,aLi .gl";l.l,t 6-,^ 6 rrli
a;rt-r-=Sy tliC
";to:1.13;;l
,r- ,15i 6.r--l ry;[5:113* 6+ra
J-iL".J:5.,,
l*
Jti;l lJ dLj
4l! ,J-5 Jtljl J:5"," _Eu-e ta:i 1l 6 t, n;t(,u-*^
,.:,.,o 6 :3*i
t. ooints
2. instants
3. particles
4. platonic universals
oh:-;L-, ,r *-r*-l=;
,J &.;lr j)J-:
-ili .(tqtv-lrf t ) Alfred North Whitehead .0
'"*J<l
;:)
William of Ockham
,"si
gt I-r g"t"-.r d ,- -
t
.gto-rrt! .plSi .g.r:t Occam's razor .?
fc*l oJ-i dL*.,**Jt+r rU-(l* ,**-;<t u;V.1
,tsS.rr^-Lr .(\Yfq-\yAO .:jJ>
.r*L;r :Entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter
necessitatem :;;Y a_l qL5i
6oJ-[!
o)_:- cgal=_"l J Ci, .rU* ! gr";U oL) ;r or:-l .n:r5 ,.:Sl; ;.9! o.9+ l_, tk_:lSl oL(-u:-
'.'-l
7. stuff
8. entities
ju& r* Y\ eJ:9-1 ai yl r,,l .go-r,l.i .:_s,s-l ts:l>>_t' si or-5 6;r-.;l5:y;:G Sp l:
ju& r*
Y\
eJ:9-1 ai yl r,,l .go-r,l.i .:_s,s-l ts:l>>_t' si or-5 6;r-.;l5:y;:G
Sp l: \-.-=., )j-po
;iti
;l a.-t-; p
ri
s> 6sS-* 6Wt
)-f,s ti4-E*J -aL;; 45 yl ,;_l .iqi .,,(1;p JW >s-r;: .,.:*5.rr
e-l Sl-*,"!: i3Q-a 6-,* fb +*,_l .:Lil J_, -.-* .,,J; J"Jl$
.c*l ,,.t^i -ti;l: :_g--3
3a",o 6 J-o:.r.J i4+ oef
;_b;ra
4i L6:; 4j \q\f L; \q\. duL OL" c;+t"uJ).'o_,t-rL; Oka-r.>
crli
,.,iKa +5.JL
lL;,_t
"r_l c n<Ji c^-:" ,_&* Jt6; of
c*--J.fri -r.:.dy, } f"JL-./ *,
,5laJ'L- -L-r* ,.-t" t{ 5l;:l
oi
a:*ilr J_9,i,:- )J> q lr* ga5-$1 olK .
olK o;,5U ;t ; ai 1l 6 c*l
! $*l;r.c*l
;-#,1t ,**ll:
,-r*t
fl4i*ir d c--l olL;t
\ ,t'
,f
,S.-J-y: C*J
t^i
--la.i ;:
S
,ttJ.;'ry l1 51;:l
6;rQ
"r-!
;l .rly;.rr ,;j<--
5\r1a5lr d(i a.rl f# otf-u_: ;,_l 6 tr_) \r,
e.5
;'U c-; J: .r-Se JL1't:.'^i -LA.) c-d-L c.iL-i ;r^i
f
6rt
-,1
q t;-
+
JL--.-a ;r t I .;--,tE YL ot5-r.-r 6 ;{-;
ei-rjl ;r-l
ft=L-l
,q>,gLa5l;rl 15 .-r 6 *-:,_S fr- ! .c*ta'1[ ,51L .>L "(
k=
.r1_* -p_J -t:,-uJl6;lu-: L- 611-t--: a-S 61u,
--,gQJl;rl *.r--
a, 5 ,,t(," f--&. ^5.:--i 'r-l p:3,a;,."+ll .-E+
,-Ur'r,-r.
alL:;---* tli". 1-fie jl+ 6 4i 3 -n it*.r-r- f F,-t S*
eJ c-*-i ;l ;c-*lr-U -,t -: c-*j ",r-l f"& 6.*-l ;-l fJai,
4Klcr- ,>Fc/ Lj,t' oll;LLb _,EL ! 45 t+l tj ,$liu" sr /
l. subject and object
:-r<" ;triKt+;l .r5- 3-t(-r"i ;r-L=; .;.ra- 1t"t-: .(]q\.-l^f Y) william James .Y
'n"-oKl'l
3. relational occurrences
Jr' .?i--Li J"t<j YY ;:i a- +5 ;rj,L +:;l: )trJ ,J tSJ: er*, ) U
Jr' .?i--Li J"t<j
YY
;:i a- +5 ;rj,L +:;l: )trJ ,J tSJ: er*, ) U )l o1y ;: 6;-
7$.
6L-,"01't* 6;1-*i: J-,5[_aol.i-c -tt C_6f ,;,1 .rar tSs: ei-,t*
.rr5 ctl-ta s>l_s Gs*ok? q t.*"j r-r:l: x:*", Lf-r
Jt- :j.L-- J) c+- ,,fLj ilL-a :3J->;r a5 r3,, ,S-&t 6aL*
al .r_5 *."+i)\p lt
*:
{.iJ,\q\V
Cjl:.SL-r"l t-.:,JLij c;dL
\-
J )y.
.l5jl: y L_yy;--;j r;;.1 :ry".iio y:.gl;l: aJL."" _,,-l .).t
'A,
.5r"J.-u;),1
ot-F
,.*:J G_61_6 rtit pr r.,dyr,ti a, +ii
,i!
di ;"^,al ,
n+-^ t-Jj
o.1.6-.Jl 3 slt ae;jt 6i
,50;L1r
.r,t5
rf- .f)3-1 d;
-b;r o-iti; 6rrl orr*-a l-, otrj
.tp6.
C J:
);J- J) .rF
+i
JU, 4<ji,r, r_9J o:; ;t5 a, i-.*ll3l u, 6 6laL-lj
,- l; otf.r-r ;-.1 ,,-L;1.; -r:-r,i -r,4 e\-:
,JL
; +i .,tg ;;g; ,-r;
r".,J 6
fl
,y-l ,_*s-t pt3+^,;t :i;ls ::_f ;r.,uJ.:r5,J=.;' .f
alt
.SL-oJ"t* t-,c*rr4ot-(,l l-> a-- U c;L-l; ;17 .;t-t|Srt;u,
i5lri
.tLnj i5L-^{n- J -;',.* ,*
J1, ,#) J.: ;/-l t .l*
s:ts:
dLij q
^-5 .,JtJ .11 L pl.r3*i :rG
f .e J, .fS -r5t ,-U:;;U^:
r-Ll
dr.jt fS J*-^ .,-t-,^--l l_&,_luao_ir- t*rAa iJg.-a
L .f
)l *
6*
: .:_,lt t -r;1.: [:* oU 5 c*,1 ;,1 ,;!; g;o;L1:
l. vocabulary
2. syntax
,,St-#f
L--.,r.,(---r.(\qlY-\AlV) Victoria Welby-Gregory, Lady Welby .Y
--$
r*J<l
6c-.zl cr*J=e t,rJ:
cs!
.J]j .:l(-l
K-5 J-:q:y .(lqrv-\Atf ) Ferdinand Canning Scott Schiller .f
.c
;u5tr
r*tK,t -;ui -*+
5. transparent
6. behaviouristic
7. autonomos province
;I"JL - L ^!r o)r-.i'.rb-rr :--:;' # :i :r:;- "t'" *y 6 tr-f i*-#i C
;I"JL - L
^!r o)r-.i'.rb-rr
:--:;'
# :i :r:;-
"t'"
*y
6 tr-f
i*-#i
C ff
iUr*-fol
g--! r: eU::-l +"t,
,-5 cru ol;,r" ,cui,L .a';13*l li*l
.r:L*: t c*
6l.i;-l5
l.}; a- lJ L .;:.*
i.:3*: ory;$ t,JrL-, g+ ea.I;>\" G j<\,$l-
r-i r-l,i aSi ;1 ;*, kt
&- ;l
u4Ktt.$y- q tj s.r
d_r"J-r
6 c^-+ -Vl Ly a\ f-"t,.t^i,L 6:te g4, J-jtr ry' or;1ti dl+"ll
-u-r-- 1; .ll't'cb 't'l-r!
: S
,F et4
t
€lrrs fl J,-ll[-
:;L
Gt-{ts 6 til ti,l;6:t-c ,.+i
S-$t ,Fl c,-,) r-! trr'"+,Jr-.r
q=t G*
U 6V)l; i.''l $ j'.3 rt '* dL
d.rl 'f*q lj*l
;l |2
bly.t'
6,-
-i/
oi :l-r :'.1 1: a5 plo.:l: gl; : lJ .,,-L-a,-.:, L;
1,-l jl
.:f ja*a'b ;l-,l)
,gL".J't* Jo ol, ,frf Ln-, lJ J<^ y sit5 dtA4i-J-i aS ,lU1 oi1t
J+r+ 6k *--lf el"r_,. t'l
L4.; $-;:+. ,3
J,gl.rrS -*tJ'J-
"l; ;l l; ;iJi
g!
:f
,/
'l;;l
1;Jj
-r:! ;-l;1 r.rl.^2."-o ,.-,iJti"
:+il .5111.: .5a-Jl 6- ilyo a,.-*yj!1("1 J"l*J
4-?.;J j-,-l a; ii
l; ort:3 ;+i *;.j.JL.5l;rl
3 .i-.r* d,
-iJi.l;;l
6 gl.-r-;
c*l; .rF
J- .;[5- ,.rlr;r"
J
-
.lJ fr-
q oS t, o;i 6*5 ^S;-l
.r*:t oi #.
prl: ;-r! Js ,.>-l cr:r-{ b:,-/
t rl
c-l6 q:l;.\:l -r
.JJld.iU r) i r:n I , pla, J"l e5
1. non-linsuistic
2. non-deffionstrati
ve inference
3. common sense
4. analysis
lr': ;|ej dr".dgf u#Okt c-1:Li Lt* d-t o:i-, 5 oo.6 qlo-ui oJ-;5 ,si e-y. \
lr': ;|ej
dr".dgf u#Okt
c-1:Li Lt*
d-t o:i-, 5
oo.6 qlo-ui oJ-;5 ,si e-y. \
"*t(-r,-,
c;by
;r1: olr 1: a5 t+.jl U €,g
;;;
esAl;l 3 .:-l ou
Ges i9:Sl f-
1;
t1
e--
qkl sl 6sV.glo-q*a, s u$tU
+5
c*l, +l c-l ot(-r,r;l ep-r
J erra Q! r*,--*^
"4L+Ur,J)l)
;rl +"rL
.Jlo$L:S ii e-r \
ly
S 66,;.;l-r"l
-i Jt- -,4 -r>
"[.*
,.(--;; LG*--tj;,ue az$
JJ<UJ< &
rka
=S; :t 1y1- ol3l-->
,:
iL,
:L'"^ )L,
-Jeu
(.,- -LA,t:;L-:t-l
o
0,.,<iJ-*!
L>
-J
v
(2
-J
v
J
tj,
-U:l
Jr
vrJ
J-J-
6
,rz\-t i)l-P s 6tJ
aS Alara:,c.;l .r.i;l.: J=v g\u4.e
zy.-ls ot5ti cjtS ul,j jl aS l;,gl'j;.f
.)r;c/;[(1 "t.i;b i5r:5 ;t.-
'-
c-
t1 C--;;
ai .:*l o:_9, 6l; lJUJ*l-.t dk;r
a.i3;13 C*l o.:3r
fs.f
,1+ ,sJKa ri;l:r-
n-llr.r" 4?) t
sr?* -9 -r5;Lci rr.-ll:,.rr .1K-7t
c-t
trlb.rr ,jSqt
1rr; ,c-*tt-
,r<-f
,;1
+fi-l ;,*lr
ri- ;-l
;-l :-11:.r- tl, l; O\ i -&-t .,.tJ, C.rr-;b.r" a-7n aS;-l ,J;ilr;1
\ciL^:
g+:--L; GJ) eJ t 5 ,.it-d.r-.rt
e,5 r.l>,i,-Li r-r,
l. knowing
Www.Negashteh.Com \? j. "i--13 J"t<j 4J .l-:5 oJ--.r-c rrl q1;orLl l1 a,iJi.5o-unJ; dL;,-+ J ra+
Www.Negashteh.Com
\?
j. "i--13 J"t<j
4J .l-:5 oJ--.r-c rrl q1;orLl l1 a,iJi.5o-unJ; dL;,-+ J ra+ .c*4 ji
it-6.7 d.5 o.U-o ;-l
t-b- L- ,>11: ,g;r. GllJ,r<\r'
[
oka ;
,_r^)
,gLa+-t-.J J) a.ri) 4_( crtt*a: c5L-_i-r _3 -*+
6R;^iLj
! .r-K- ot(-r,> ;,1 .c-l oJ,-: d;ljJitj
oLaf ,1 a.r"
i-p
"+!
J-1p.4 +i,;t
e-*,y:
s aVJl;l;l
15l1 ,r*.,f
.c*l ct(
-,1 ,gl-J 6-a )jt*.5" f,*
,+> 6r*
a5 L/*
,lJ-+d Lr. ,
LSLAJ-;3;|i 4-(i-l J cqrLr-l ;; )l &-f
6a.Li :t -fu rlr.r^; $L-
j-or e5 Ls:d,-r"=l c*t#_rb ,*tu,tK-,L,9 ta;t-.- Jy; &
.J:5.,- 6jt t+1 ;: u;ii aJr(=p
c-*;t-(;i.p-r--!1 l, ;-;lLi c-sr-rl-rQ ,y-l;l
ga ,gly.,-5
q*,i
6+
,-*-q.," Rt
)l
Jt€- g-;[i d;or--o 6la-r:3;li
"r+
t f.:
6h q*,4jU-L .tr':S t*t
43 6^r<j \ ef
ayr.ri
l-#
.t-"-S
-,L+t l-t UA
6- F-
:j; 1i,:;3>y,ti jl .-r,i,o ,:S ;:
,JtlrS,-j* It f*
-,V -*' .rt ,,orL .sL; ,Vit :,:,5 u, -,t5 drt*:
.*L^;t oLj ; l)-s ,34 _b ::.-tilorr* dyl;
i.9dr !
-r,--r+
5 ,(-l
aJ'*X ,Jtrj 3 Las 6la }
dt j -1 ;; .5rr
tt --lrr; ,'rJb
,;5U L"rt.r,;; .gaLI-.c-te^;;1 .ratK*r -<! c-+ Sf-S e rl
ei rll
6 qi
ol;.rU;s(tr
,-F-t-"; l-#
,1*^*j.i
rSV l
c-l
,k:
+-a3,i .5r-,o a5 6la:;L
U
;l 6;,.1 -9 :i+l
et:; 6;yl
.-L; t.aj
J<-j 6 ,gr .:1c p;+" .c-ly"{U_,rL; $L.f cglt;q orL;l e5 c*l
.c*l o-t-.i a"-:45 ,-Li-t.-V.; S*ltt,l.t-(,"; 15 .:*l CR P
6l-a1y o_f )l Al,-rU € gJ3 ,.:*l ":re 1jai, U_l e& f^lf.r-
.;;l-r, jlc^-;J
l. non-mental
2. force
3. solid
4. independent
Www.Negashteh.Com
;f ;js.;,rt-g? a:i-)\ ,g;t-e J-"J* r-!.f -r,--ra- ,51j* 6 o",i Q!J, ;1 1966 a c-.1;lr
;f ;js.;,rt-g?
a:i-)\ ,g;t-e J-"J* r-!.f -r,--ra- ,51j* 6 o",i Q!J, ;1 1966 a
c-.1;lr t:L
d
;rl;l*
,-ri o:
t J,-J+
L ,a-.g,-lL .c-l
f.:.-^;r f;.1" 3 y
,r-J.rr:;
l, -t--t-7 5-r*,JL^q.b i6.l-"-f ;!L- .rcla*"l-- ft
A\
;r t, .,1(;-.Liloli
.u.jL<;,t5 a, -"aJt-,,-J3: ,.--*'-1, 4t;UlJ<,-j*
c*l
;1:1y,-,- J ,AF jl -t-J- jlK-jp -u;l;l
.-tJJ,-)!re ;i ;>l"r,l
U OLJa ;1
3 ,r--La;, dlij-f
-,) .r:ni o:;t
6lJ, jl .r-* -,t"*r
gI
4i 4-
:;f1
L l;31 ,5t-or.b -,Wl 6:;l:.r, ,si tl:
u.r
dl;-l
e4-$ f t rt [il -u,-! -af
1.6 E;l-r.i G-\,-)r, ()Jp f-€r ! J/ .trs
icil:.(,"e fb -,, l-, .;!
^-.;9-.:j'U=f
/-
Fr*
,gl-o
";j.i
or-:5,,n-:
ik? do;!;: iJ5lf^ 6
-#r.gla.;r"i [ -r::.*.o j;;>-
o )L"<.J i;.-Lr
J I .*^--+ J.-;r
o;t^(.- g;l4EJ ai
.:.: ,*Le .}il"-Lj
rag--
d)y l:+;,) JL:-l ,.r^leu (JL^qF;l ,:--1 dr.+-s-,3 ,c*l c-;:Li
'fi/-+ t *'t
c+J, -tt!6J-.i"j*
oUyt l; d'
6 '-*1 ;-l +ilJ';':r'- .-ll-tQ ':;l: l;
6,
ib :
6 rFcs- a:sL-;r a-;.^.-a fl
,t-l
:r"*" J a?l;.\ o;[il a2 rar
1; .,-_rL.l .5Loa-J:t- 6h
6*.c*l
crjlr,+ La:l.t-y; ;;Lb )lsl
y tly.ll4,i C$-l)" 6 sSg ;-p
Y- ';l:
cL4j
4-S ))IJS r- a:;L-:,U.r*-K- lJ 4-j<j
4-*l Jl-
,-l
Q: l; La:l*3; .rrl! .^La;.&--- ri;lr 6;kiL ;.+ oS 3-Grl-t,y;
U S#
4,=r r, 6rt €.-La:rr i:b,Sl,t 45 c-Lj.r".r"K:^
;li
6 :1L.-r- -r>G U
F_, .JL^t? ;r l-a:l,t j;
c^L4, 6o;!:: ;;-
L, elt oS I^j,! r,-La:1-t-31
rlL c-1: t-orl-t-3;,rl :;1.:.tt<"t .9.*6
4S 4
:yd :> r.-rl 6 6\"1r- J 6ti a, r;1r Jt<"l [- .sr.r" ?
-l-arr: L a I 5--;-p or;.i .9"., .-ru.;L -,;'Li:. LarlJ,-r. -,,-l L oiL<-
1. hypothetically
2. intrinsic character
ar. !i--l-i J.Kj .,L:-a:,y r*J, l; V;-S _5 t :r>,a 6laa-a--a; a5 c*l .l- .gbaJ:L.
ar. !i--l-i J.Kj
.,L:-a:,y r*J, l; V;-S _5 t :r>,a 6laa-a--a; a5 c*l
.l-
.gbaJ:L.
jly ,.-*, ,T )j-:,us A-Sf , qJi ^<ll d3q^a
Ab_,.t
6o;L;: .5J:
ry-e A-6 -S t q , ) q
.c*l ,.r,1.- &-t
jl .pr -,,1, dJ+ Jl
.c,*l 5l;rl ,gal:- q o-t
i;
4r;,
.S,l+ lK
_,lp
2l 6la.Li JIJ :> 6 .gl.r-t(e L'*JJ) .4;+ yr"l,
=*,)L*i
J ,s-.|{o
dk*-r-:: -St t-S ,g u-Ss- ;:tK t*,-<j.<i jl r-!
o-L.i o:l.r
;l aJ;
jL*A , LUi
6$*.t(;i
,**.t,[ a{:- 6y
Jlrl J t)Jl
a:-i;lr :-9--y 6;C
-r--!.f ,rel-ttt .rila,L;, ,r,-)L .'tl;
t,,
,)L*i
1l a5 (p;3i -L) 9
',ly,r
d fr.rrL{
l; 6l.jl3 .-r-yrg.) -r;u
.:s-ius tF;
-ii;
cr"t(.o .5t*::r
6_t-, \.jL;"
ot(_,L
r- ,,J-, oytcl J-*
Vy
-:|r.,'U ,-r-l 6 x:rSu,,Jt^( Jtju<,-j*
)l &-;
dL-oa:*i _,l t-#,l
J5.jJ ,j'U .xt d r,Ss" oL.( JJ:SI
JSa" r. ,_*-/ 4. q dir,-<1 6 Jib.r, oUi'.14r, fU q.gjyl
eS;.
F-l a5 o,l3$ )y.d
,-r.* f
)l ,olK43 ,J;
g
*. s
6:Jl )l C-fut 6,J-r< q -r:5.,,. ))f J 6-l9e erjrJr 6a";i ! o_ry
1l j oj)u-
rl
61,>.,,*-{.-o e15l-p o;t:.- ,-a 6 hj1 ,l .:4
J-tt"
J -L-:U -,V s A :l 6_sG 6 ., i ,tt--i;l G-q )^;) o;[:- dr,l a5l+i
,)r
6lr-;L- --a rr *!
61l'>r*.9.s tlig
t$.: t, -r,_: .5;[
,r-L
Jt-- ;: 6fr
oi "t*:ti ,trl: i,
)_r 61'>r^.,,5.-e *li.l
ta.-_l-,1 .:;l: -[i3,- o;l;
";ti
;1 5
)) _ff ft<r^ .=-.i S +i,_l J *
,,1 !
"]-r
6 jl-- $-*:: .5;lr,--lp riUr.,r 4-S Gg )U--:ll-; a- t+ o--^
Cl^;_6 -r,-[ Ct(1.4 qg[arl,r,j; ;l;l
.(_ y' y ,c*1 CKI-r-- 6t-a:l-r,3;
r-iy^, c*l
r-"i
ol
1_, _rl oS ri,! a;;l: 6ri
oi;l e5 61.;k--
i-;1,
l. photons
;J ;is -+jk- "<-- J-IJ, ;: 6 uilt;* 6-15& GW.-1S: d+E-y" ;l a.-a ;,_l .fa:,r"
;J ;is -+jk-
"<-- J-IJ, ;: 6 uilt;* 6-15& GW.-1S: d+E-y" ;l a.-a ;,_l .fa:,r"
.t-- cl 4++j $lol; orl:;lr.i :J
.)t*i
r -S )fil:
F ,t l: A-&, Jl:" 4rtj(
t
.r^*-r: ,lny .t6
,lJ .,i--Lj aJ ::l; L.23 J ,s.i &; c, ait-Li[^i J^l 6j<b]G )l 6
a- ,.5;lrr*Ji 6L+n*t_l: 1l 6lac_9^a. JIJ :, a5 ori;
1:y
)y
s> i
JL-1,- t+i .S"*n rK 4<ji et
,-,g11:rJ 6t+tl;-:r .r;ji;r lr--l
yV e4ttj
J;-t t
a-S J;5,, {_l l-, s#L:. 1t.- ,gtg-l.i -rit
,tt.:-: f
: -,! Jl.i;-l .-r.J;l: c:jl;
a:>,-a;l 6LL-+LaG J'[-lr, J -bt'
.g;l:r^Ji eriiJ) ,.A ;) +5
r-L(e
&))) -[iLa ,lal-
^JA y;:
;; 5.41r:l Jt11 ga-ejaq-t !'W, 5 far,r, i;
to:l-r,-9; ;l ,gltr-j.-,,
,Jt-;'ti q ;,1+ )J-.,r dJ*$a j.; t+r-l 1:
:;1.:
a;2,p
Ji3r -La.:,r,.
C
;
.r-31
:V $-S c *r
b-6v_6 6W;l
6 ,5liL(l"r--
,SS-t ^*i Jt- nlorlu cu- cr+)) ,-r5 .:L-i e F-:\ ,u* 6l&,4
6j." J,-ti GJ-t'-l;l 3 ,,r^i -L"lJ, L*b j> r,n r,!r;<,.:i !"(5rr .*i; rl:
.*,
& ,5;lry'i
l+i 3: y' t
a:al3
(-r.iJJ) -,^ :,
Glp"-.<{ 45 4
f
p
,L--5. F ,, l: e -&-t JU" ,,r jtt
6, eJ o-. ,:*-fl-S 6l-o,4^;4 ,tt; L;
o-*-rlf J-t rS4-r
,-*[i
-,t5tjt* (.-- ti ,"-{j,-lti 3 iJ.:*i ;tal GIF.- J.!t ^ lJt<-:i
4i
,Ss-*-l;l .r;l: .:^F
lJ e *
,-ri q -,t-t 4t J:5 /:*
El_t',_t
6lsa>.;ta 4i
,-)t.-u*:rL a;*il: 5r:;-. j\;il
! l; rS;:t -r,-tt
.+l;;l di*L"S dlj q tli.t
t4,;,rill: 6;:.
GIF"-\ b_*-rl-S
ls G*,
U- JU" 3,rl; ;l 6lt" ,fu.rJ^; i.Jl* _,|.:;L cjorU:
"i_lJl
-t-a:.,o G-S :t a,.6 u
) "*_6 ,Jt*, J$l +7,;i."r"o:"r" r:-Jr rijl
S
-o: l=;l J[.i" s!5 ;-:l tSo\-_t:l a:;L; 6 .:-l .r.! L-l/ J ]U.
pJr .perspective.\
.(:-,;ljJl uil
:l Vi r. t .?; ,-.*
;l) . u ,l F
ir" "/iJ' J.tsr ,^G ;: .-rJl.r, cUll "=-i L- y-_F e "-c".-rS.oi qJ Ss: 6?
ir" "/iJ' J.tsr
,^G
;: .-rJl.r, cUll
"=-i L- y-_F e
"-c".-rS.oi qJ Ss: 6? q
-t-L,o ;;t.ai oS --;t, ek y.liJJ--,i t-*i-l -r: .-*-* ty€
"rFji
L-r.y txrl;t: dt4+f ai a5 t-j1 U.;t. gtod1- J:,.:-l ;lJt"q
r;_9-a dy'.2<+a :;y" a.*l ;s .J-a1u* h
* &,
dy
)l or-S--,:3,;u"
)yd
u *- ,*
6n-L*L C-l rly
,> 6 4;*
,o_*-rl-5 j.A>.La
.c*1 ,:*- 'uro" ,-,1; 6la.f
.5l#*-r-r: L .-ri;b ;t- 4r* ,.bro ,5-"^ lfu:<,5t-a-i;3; ;l
L-> grr-Sr-^i l-: ,f P;"1 j ,p*s,r+, et
,y).51;11 1; 6;l:r^*L!
.tK-t- ;: a5
Jt-4;;::
,L-ali .-5"$;L- ,S_r. :l Jt5il .,t'u;l L. ,;l
s u1#.5ta+1;J a, 6 -rJu.r" a:;L
r[a
rill: ;lr-i .;3 o[aUL-
6k-tp F-l d 6*.tr;5
otXl .r*:.;
! .fb cJk"*r-:: c,.-
,=J
,L+Lj ,-*
J Wt<" ,":.: ;r 6 c*l ;1 ra.:.r" 6L:J 5l;rl ! .'Fr*
6t-a:l-t--_3, ;t u--Ls A;a-sJaH,t4JL; 6r
-a
_, k,K ,ga^s g
* ,Sl
urLj :
jt<" ,.K1 ;:
,LarlJ,3y ,*t ;l
4(,-l J r.!ar.7 ? Ft-u"
,Stt*--i
ol;;l ,a5,uila:*l3;rt-:l-t,3; e" y ,*.gLo+Ll- 6aL-ly ,:*.
c)j: j )\1 t" $l-ss 6li-F
.tl-Ujl -iLr=" 6t+t<" Jl dJq^-i rtr,
.c-l or;31 s-* .rrf
a*,.: d,
C
r*
!J-!lJrF, ll
jl{-
)l
6J--ya, Ly \;;;L
!
l_, L
k
:_r
,.-,*l
*
i
-r,_! ,-,*-4 Ul f yt" fS.f oX
,Jljr" .,".^*- Jr 45 s,-Ladl-- t
.-5 4L
,f tS .5Q.r-a tSlt .>:s "fu ri;l: .:.,3U; a:iL- gt+t $U;
1.
constancy of structure
L-,
alKo
.g.;L;l
,r_l ;).+1 J-1, #
.r<-:-"- ;b ;l 6luj;,J+"i iJ,_l .Y
"f-l;
'|":;
o!;":-"
LAdtiL^:Li L:-
;-_l;:.c,-l
.i-<r.9+iL1 ;: (Globe Theatre)
-: +-=:a/U j!.LiLj
Ki.jt'
.u:^--:;.r, tr"
u^K_t 1: Ju^t;j Jt" jq"{-
:_# tV *
L cna;
.ri:l--",.-lr/ "r--t^;6L-L; a1 aY u*
Glq ;t .r"G
;f ;js.r+jL6? p 6,--l Ul)rJ .€ ,t't 619.,5e3au- l; rr\:l.t-3;l;3g,i, ,,1 j 6Larl-t-3; ;: 3
;f ;js.r+jL6?
p 6,--l
Ul)rJ .€ ,t't
619.,5e3au- l; rr\:l.t-3;l;3g,i,
,,1 j
6Larl-t-3; ;: 3 J:5
r- Jti:t 1; ,t1"1 -Lj; -,1 ,,oLr 61.;lll :l-t,j;
-Lil;1 L.,., dL-a,">t-S i ):|Vf
6 S,;
);lx
6f-:
-,1
;o
r5 1L5 b4E*J - ti.j t -rnlf.f aS ;l+)V.-tilo:rS JlJl lJ JLi
j;ru"
lJ t+i J,li.j"
.glarl-t--;. ,gLaa-o3 *
;l u-\:
S*y
-b
pt+.,I a-1 )J-> ,;r d$-ua glr L+. 1;15;l dl+;tr J-: ,rjl-t
oJ--:Li
ijslr, a5 -rJL;y
;r a.5 ,1to:l-l--.0. f-A
l, oi ;t;.,,
6L^t-;: a5.r1la:l-t-3; L -ua: € O oL-,-E )l ;z-f
G^'L3
J-\i6r.s*lG
ve,)i) 3t, -So, q
a;-:r::Ll -l:.4:.rr t:
6-,
;.,-l (.:Jl.:rJ lJ ;*
1: .grl-t-,-3; a-5 c-*1 oi :--r*-+ fl
6.;V* 1y-a.
a;\ gaL-ly 6 rar.r, 3 :;l: o-l<e rriJJ)
c-;l;J 1, ,r1 -t;.,,
ft,tf
,SL.-1, l
J-K,
-!:JjJ) .r;l: -t-iy- s^ftJ ),\J+. do-rli t f*Q
t-# 6 ,'sc\-:4;* r, .c-l
6-l ,:;lr a-i)\-a r;lrr-.-" ii
.gl.;l; o1.r,;1 .t-*.-E o1) ,g1l>r--5.-o
6
ut-W_roy )F
Jq--n 6lo+l.+ C
Lii -,, Cj;l
6 s$e
JL-t"i u,-La.l5 rS ,slx i-6t-S dLo$-r-r
a-5 c,*l :r-"=" rJLt go\:,4jt, 5 c.-l ,-ri ?a-
C-| .5'l
fl
r,
,)j.-u.1u" )^ yU Go),1: -* ,-5s: oka -,1 .>sUtr;1,q,-ri,lk=
4-Jtt lJ c**^-- rt i l5
.f;
.,-5"\: l,; c*l GJIV r*.1 .:3U; ;,1
;r +5;i jl .r+-i J-r-^)crr J<;: l;;Li ,,1 5lq"* 6 ,gty ,Sc
uS.S l-e;\ 1\ gll p:r" 6La+aa; ,5""^ V-p $Jr c+ 6;l^)r*
J,-Fi J,JJ Ki
ori
ur?i ojl-Lil jl
* ,>:-f ,ll -:t Js.c*l
"i11
=.
jlq
,-.1-f
6nJi-*;: l1 oi ot:l:f 2 c^-ij .-Jt- t c*l 4:ri
eJ )r-ft,. ;l c:J;L ;u- ,4\-t &p t-,_f -t, Js.g*L-g*, ;l-ry:
1. event
J/ !i.--u J*t<i 6 SC u,J 1, L -r,.r; ;* - y c*l g-. J
J/ !i.--u J*t<i
6 SC
u,J
1, L -r,.r; ;*
-
y c*l g-. J Ci I
s:l:> d_r^L
tiU, '." ," -r-L c^-.rl3 a3 l; 6J--V, L-.i J f*_t-t* ol; ;L5;:
.,-5 Utl ,)l+ r5 -^ll;ulr;;
,K.: La:l*;-, oi -,, e5 .:;lr )_fJ i
j.J,;
;f e-&-, da-l--l ,Jt<,|
uL-y ,t-l ,-r-:l *. ;J-S C*>u 1: ,-J; .*^-^+ clL# ;t- 6.:L
.pjl:r
.
t+t<" 1s t,-ir.a
cSL<!: a, .t-a:1J,3; 6 a,1":r5 orakr t-a1t,
'&*
-tJ_# or;3i rrS r-1".:tyV oye
q -\:.jly,.f Jtf;{.jl:i,
eW::
;.: o;t:-- .<-- JF 4SJUrF.a ,il-$ r_l t-4f
U
4
-,1 6
:) ,r1;) .i
dkl*i .sy,! oJ5ly ;i .5ta;a2 ,5t*a;l 'Al : ,:i tfl:;
LG:t *
t.jl:;"
15Lnaa;r a, ,gl":lll> i,,." jl
.r--13 .ga,-L; e(
a: o;L*, .!
;l _:i *.
a5 .,r1la:1.r,31 .-ti;l: c.a[J
.'(r*"q Jfl
s
;-,-l .-ru;S.r- r:*
1.*i J dJ:! -r":a:., JS.:j l; L .50;L* _ff tS_t -
q5ldt.<i oK.l:-^ 6,-l;-3 *.l_t La >l-r,y, ,t-l olie
a<:i c-t" c.*t
*
1.: rt(-r;L *.lig
+5 .,,t<-lr*a ,*yt./.,r:"U qt1, e5 c'*:Kl
;l ,5la.l*L tl--1ut t- .r
,L-
_tr , )_9, 6 6rl<$ J: .S_y *-5
.:;l:,Jt<"| .sr
r"
V bl 6|
Jn-y-,-; *--p J H
(l)tc,5
CE,
:;l: dtl,l .*-1g ,gr*t J:f
q t_ -r:*-ri _,tl [
+, \ ,_:f l.jl
1: 6
"<-" q r;lr 6t(,1 .:y' c-.K
f;
L- :3* o.qb;! y -rS ))F1
/i
C!
t,
a-73" 6.*t
t:f
"(--
. 15+( q
,y- J.r." s S
/. rgj:r*.So ,)*.
,)lJl .il- a;4
t- ,)fJ
:;b
ot<"1 ,pta.;l;*" .tyKt, lJ d*l.joJtj*,
.-Lilo,J-.+.- :1. -: 63_L- c,-Lar,r-r ?
dtil
F-l d
,s,g&.-u!l cgtijl
J1 L6*-"jr, *
a-t -ti;l: .:3.-3 yr J
f<oty
ta:1.13, 1l 6lao1^.,.
c*l
a-5 .jl-Ll d[^a Vi--s tr t+i c-t-
l:
3 -r.:-a.:.rr Jlj 4,Jt-t" ,U
;t u!;;;i,oL-L- ;: .-r>l-: 4.oJ;.--S Jt-:L* ti ,_t1,)ls SV-r c-!;
6
j" ;jS.r+jl{i 6a-;Lr. ar cc-l o:r5 ,r1L-:; U oi c*_j! _y-_p 6 (u^@ 6t-oa:.i;; .*e
j" ;jS.r+jl{i
6a-;Lr. ar cc-l o:r5 ,r1L-:; U oi c*_j! _y-_p 6 (u^@ 6t-oa:.i;;
.*e
l; o;t:^. ,lri
*
fFlr
ffu
;-l ;s 3 t:,-a ,ut f
,,--Li
,t r- t5:,-l ,.
;l .:3Li:" tlr*: ott:-", tJ-r--.: lr--, X-*; rf
frr,
J o);
c-*.-1)y-* 6 b:,g F t ,rr_t^*;r,
, L: < u1Ua.7-as ;t
J-al3-J l1 o;[l- briy-, "rl
S s*ll-
,*l-*L+ .-lJ-)
oy+ u.ti
"-(j.-ltl
J-X
4-ih-6<j oJ:-:-fi.glo;l-ljl
l;6
dr"i jf
6;1; J c,
e
,S*
,;-6
a-5,)i )l;)J
.gjl; 6-a O fi ,.,)J> f#
!
"7.>;lr s1>j osle 1
)_f,s c.*l a:ii 3r-.:l; ol; ;l olj.cl e, **-tL; ,]tt
AV-r.-[.rn ,.
3 c+;rl-i .F"r", ,_*:k- .(,- 11 o:L J ir"! o! jl_, 55f oLJ .r;t-r;
{--it<l d-*, ,Jt-& 6+-f t ;pi oQ.7 sr;ji,*-! -,t 'drL
'/l-f
.c*l o.t;3i J,-J1 o:L ,5o.u
jl ./*K- ai c-*l GW *t^t;< ;F- Ji do_r!,r: JJ:5 U 6 ;W
ta,i _,1 .(-X 6
;--
l1
c*-r, 6h.-l ol;
;15-r:*a ^:rK,ti L -r,-i
r"
?-*5j ;tK.r::*a iE-" jl
JW ft:
,p5"r- St;:t *-iS u,
'&*
f-
l_, .,1t+ ,--.oc
J .-.3 f^ lrlj .J,-> a-al_g.J
L d"
.t<1 riti ":rt-
,l -t :;rLr c:3j o)r+j C*;),9 c*l; ,fl-ti";*
3*
ft
,ut-Q .-
"c
.:;L L*ii tei tr t, L, u-f ,_t uP,tt,r<-; 6 e-_e gS oK*;*.a
b t6; ,-u.*"o eL:.:*l bp-r l-, )F d)3, d-r"* ot(-u:*" C-l o-* J_t
,-iJ"l :;l> aljri,Jt+-k-l
,J,r,o ;;;L
ot1.siJ. elt 6 ,gl";|.t]l
pi,51;l: *
J,|i-f
,l+y* ,{sr-r,t+ti(l 6 ,r.t C-| .$y"C
:;lr ;;J*; ?-p tst*-* ,gta;X* e- a-( ;u-*a
rlorL
+rl) C;
+- a-5 J:;*A "r"*lj r;t?,:i 6l;b c-Jt-- ,J--k -s> t+i.c*+ 6)J-r2
jj
,r-
ly
;: ully-l [dualist] tf :: :r"\Manichaus .rrL *:-r-
Manichean .\
.:)1.";l
j. J--ij J*ti u-ilJ -rl -* ,):,.1-l ,-*[:, -,L^t ,.S"jl-, ,-(- rr,l-uJn .>;l: ;fi n6-uJn
j. J--ij J*ti
u-ilJ -rl -* ,):,.1-l ,-*[:, -,L^t ,.S"jl-, ,-(- rr,l-uJn .>;l: ;fi n6-uJn
d3J:,;L.t,+- ti oarSt ,c;tyC ry-g ot1.j13;l ry;tS L a5
: o-uJ J+
&"
f" ,i,
.c-**a dJ.e .*.-F-1! .:a- ot* f'^ ,Ji
,('.6a di
.J--: J*<-- t-+i ,t j.r:J 6 t, ;-$u_6 6[.a f*lr.r t" :te3r5Jl
,{-J JS t, *jr".f a;;l;"; L. e};aL-lt-. t-h:; J,l Cl; r, J ,"-il
ai\6";t-,4 6 l: 6* L J dd,-SlJ)l lJ ,ti c ,ijr5Jl >;y f
6lo;L 6 f*E.f u); 6o*:-a 6- fU f L$; l-, cr3;"(Jl .f-*.r.
Ly.-t 6+
5--*
4- 4J t+j1 ti
.J-56, os
j\y.l:
,S-E d$"t^
{-^l;lJ.l oJr-(Jl *li,-.;:;L ":;3iy
l-, t+r^
6 en
ot-'/
C-l
-P
;l -r,13;.r, r;,q orr!"-a ft
,
rx:t
tt;L*^ L o:L xli.l cr3r5ll .>-
J--eV -,lr-L, .-u,-a)sr.1t-11 t5:-9*i a5L-,.-4b-iJ-L --6-e
4J jt+* ,-rL+a +* t+:j 4-i 4-<j d,-l .I:L +::l: l; ;;) 6t"a-o
4--
.:-rg.!)!t;
,,,- s ,W* ,u-.-- 6lAl*l -3-, t ,.^.; q ;E-?-A
a5 -ui;l: :ji-7j .4La.i- .q
lke
.,aU::-l ,-K- Syl t"
J-l
oti:r- a- f j
u-- ft.f*lr.f
dJr"; d:*
lJ t#i "L^-Il> 4ioJ*itl-
lJ Jlr{j*
4joJ-is 4-(i,r, ,L--r€.tfl gt, -r"l ,*l;l ,rr;.r,:j"!
.r*.f
lt $r,-rLr-,, 6o-& dS 6,1<$.-r*,4 br s 1,15 6"1L1>
+.F
p-\
)s ,rf
*-rr; ,-l1 ;r ol;;
tSs-t 6? a, a5 -t,;b Sly*
;*-- ta:1 r5o:t1tr 6.*lif JUU<,-j., 5 c*ai ,-,1b;*A ,-rJ,-: ;l -,-lLo
.+-6 g
t*i a.o tai 6 4r1: -r-l! -r -ri*,y l-, -&-r,-rLr-,^ oL*:a t;
o13"r a1 [*i:3.-,JL-:-.4.r,. l,
1(o-Lj7tr-ul ,;*i . Gy
6t
ll
v(:-v
9='1 etL-l A.-l qfl,r,Jl) JL; ,Jt-&-
u^\J ; t-6.*-ft ,Lne-i-i
l. constituent
(Jrl)
J ((-t*J)) "r--,U crkJ:L. complex -9 simple ,SA-z; i
tclL-ar -9 to-:Ltt -Y
Jr
."U:^.4 grf
,,rl.1
;f ;-f "r+jl&- s\-:-o o-. L-; ry,- ,JL*:-- CU:-l .tt-5,_l ,J* .gl.;l.r,l 1-l ot:jl;:; ,tl.t-i-,"r
;f ;-f
"r+jl&-
s\-:-o o-. L-; ry,- ,JL*:-- CU:-l .tt-5,_l ,J* .gl.;l.r,l 1-l ot:jl;:;
,tl.t-i-,"r cSalt--_t o)-* J U+;Fl ek::-l -rulL-,a :1"; ;)
6l.il
",,y
l-, .f-l -L,-! ,-U5 .r-c, 1; ol.ti-;p .gta;h:-l .r;r: -ualr;- fl
j::*l
y --t,;1-: .:-"_i_, .!G
.J-+&1 4<iU- ,;l
.rq
45 J"5 ,-* f^
-r*1
r"
\.c-t
,_!.+. 6fl ,+_& i;li,,
.Ki ql rl
lU f-r-.r-
6b*l d-:* +5 .*bj.t rrd- -a 4J r*l-l.r
;: l; L glo-L-j o-LaL;- g*
GWI-t:l .gu-a t-a":l: .a^a-t, 1; \nlao:brr
a5 -L5.-" J!-u-l 6)1, € . os-.e t.r*J ,,_r* ,614 -i-S gt
g-Cr .-u;la:-13 L .:ye- )l os4. d_W , G 6*,gta5l;:l jl dJl--i
;r a-5,_r!Ll :3; :lf
y t- r-r+1_, oiQ
fl
aS JSrr; _,_,!,Jrt
o;;L- .-Jl-i;;; J ,.^^.-a 6 ,5.f
:s\ sl .sy-d ry,,Li c*l 4:-*-f oi
1'+ q g*lf"f
:;ly* ;l
.'544,a J) .l;:--a Jl J-i=j 'tr-a ,-9a:;l:1 s
a5 c*"1 ;l
;: ::;.;/ U, q d.l.c €
d.t-t-
J;
tf.s c
"ily*
.g:t-c
-t-"+ !-;l F-l d .41a51;:l ! ,;U4t: ,9Q;;f -E ,,1 J_, ottg; r_5f.J;l
642.;-o +J c-l
a,-!3 o;[:l ,-r[^a :U;-c.l ;l
.:;l-rq.r" *l:-" xsjlu"
6 e *
.,_Jt<+ o,L:u :yiu,,I,_+ oS el,*-y \\-, jgGlf
n^<-I,-lq
t ,;_*
iL-6.: j+
osLi fS rJU i1 Ss-:, t"-a jl .-i*
r^tr,g
c---Al ,51;l: 1; gi j:;t* rt<;i +S 6p ,.)k,.q
Lao:l> ,:Q--.
d)! t: .i_r.s f-l; ^(f ,l -;r=!: ;L-*r .*l ./-t6:^!; JK"l fJt<I.r"
-U5.r" :l+;* r,"1
glr.i
L o5 t, n;i,r :trK n
cr
1.--r r" f-*.
6 ,r-t$l q ?Jlr
.r---r! .91+le .\
.rr"5;t(l
<4-L*
o
L-l ,
:_q,.i, .r"L; .('what I see with the eye, I can not deny'.)
-l
",1;l
JJ
r;! =r*
2. daLa

a"" ,J^*1" ,J"tSi

*'*-)

6l;i tr ry-

6tj 6**-w ! -r,-Ll o5; gs,r,",rtJ

;l c*-l ;-,L:p dL6. +5 :f

u, oVS

,)L-6a Ui;l 11.157 3 c-*l q-5 ip!

"r^+_) . yr-,l, t4;i -lrq

4.

!p111 gt.r5 r^ o5 ,tt^rur,

;l- .'-;.e:".t )l 6iL;

gt_aa--;r

t- l; oLaa

L--a:1i3,.

.-r,tb,r" j!

1;

.-uJ11: o1-4; 1l :_r; J-_ft;r l1 qta,l U"-# G:li-y ;-re S!U.f

loy

o.:Eil [.Li u. 1b-;l' Sr -- -dy-f

.;t" :=-l 5

"-.",-Y

;1

;r La.:1i3,;lr;-l J"l n<!"1 J JScr-

;--l .r-ri a"-

* ;V.l;;l

LrrtJ_9" 6 .:3,;yL

,

r,t-.r -,.J+ ,rfut^ A^bt "5f^; -t-! 9k- {

.-r-uL[;L

t-4:;.c.*l ,r:gr!U.t!1:.-r+.t-) S{-ri rl ,:1

aS 61,--)) ! 6.u*a jl rg";jr\;l ,,^ Uf-, .5Lon-- J: .g+!U.r"

,f-l C--*+;t

r-(,"

.-uJ;l: ,g.,:.:-.: ;lF*A d

LG,

ti;l

a,.lr-.r"

",--l t: 3l ot-(-u.: J+ J^)

rt6;

"r^+.-,_) 4;oLi-e a, .c*l gt-(, ,go;L;: t-au-

L, 3: (:.9,.J lJt<-ii

.rLK.

_F *

"r\

;: a5 ,r;t.(." .r;b :.e,-3 jK

y .l.=H ! uly,.r:[i3,. 5 c-*1 ;15'. cr;l: :3>3 rtj-r -,^ e_f

ii

6 +-6.l t q

c;L;

+- -t:5 ,-f p

"r;.r-Y

l: Lao:l: t. ostl e *

.c-*a i

&i,_s. t-a

JJ

:b

ti;

c*:

f

,-,tK" _,1 e -&t )f

r,U-

L-not(*: .:3UJ ,-riLti.r"

j! ,-*)f "154>;l

l_, oka LarLi3r tl 4

Lr ts"K-rt ) da-+a C;a-e JA>j.,;--lri. c--t allsl g-; .:J[,i; J.it

,lly" _r^ ct'_tr Ot4;;r 5 ;t<" L 5 ra:,r" L q l_, ,-rti;1 S-&t

,Jt- --n;r rL ,Li "i- r[i3" Ja ,srK-a ,-,ti .rl ;r

:11:

.!i

c--*^

y *_r*-l1j

r+,_)

y-+L-: .t--* F .( ,\ v \ r- I 2f 2 ) Gottfried

2. monad

3. subjecrpredicate logic

4. pr.'-establ ished harmony

Wilhelm teibniz .l

.;tJi jlr:";t_r

U ;-#,r+ok4- -/ 6ete oL6-a;r q_Sl .sc JlJl tr q-f ,!"t,5db,! .c-*l -!.a rt 3,
U ;-#,r+ok4-
-/ 6ete
oL6-a;r q_Sl .sc
JlJl tr q-f
,!"t,5db,!
.c-*l -!.a rt 3, oi d-tr
ot(-r,r ;l 6 c-"^a d_tr
.,,ti :t3"
t-J
SQ fr,gt-.:tf3" dL, tr rLi3*;1 6 ,r,l<b c*.Ee;,1 gaa
dL<+ -r: 45 lJ ;tl"
e*ly-.*
.)J),/ J; )-f )V*. 6$;;,-(,- ;:
;l c*l o-,\" 5l-,aK
n6l4t*;) jl(." c-*o rli:r y 6Lao:l:
3
oJ t+ji U .fr"Q n,F;*, JIS* Jr<ur< 6t-a:l.J_y. J-$V-6,gboK-u:
6?_ff ot(" ,r--r:a 6la*a
a>,.nLlfrrj!
Lf-)t
l-, o16.7 t-a:LJ_9,"
.)3l $lJ, ,&*,-rli
.r-;u,o ,5taa-=^^e-- -u,La
,3 6la--p Cr-;:
.r :-:l3,.rr j_S -5r,-f-tl q !q +U" .;^:*
6LaJl;rl dka -,>
;t<" .-Uli.r_,ut5: fS LC, oi ;l aalr-.r"
-"+.,")
4;o.Li-e q J*:q.*.a ,U 6oLis, t .*i-;* ;,) J----a .rK J _*
t+.
JU-il lr F.1* ,Jt<" ;r Q-F ,gla;L:*
.f ,gta5l1:1 Jt<, J-lr-
aJ,' -^.-r+l-)
6il-.b J ,y 64,"P,)ti. ,4, di 4
J:.5,t
.# +.r;l: $3- -=*. SL-F.rb-t"! : -_b 1l -,-.Li:" ,;;lrr, L
{^--1l: }yL* t ,*
Co\l-: q,tsj#.rQ.7-lr u1l,;-al*s &.-r"
tF
F"rp ,Jb!:-, t57"-qUc*JJ a)
Gly \,.J+lr ,-rl 3 r:--l
-p t_yt. fl
.r_y J"+CSJ ;.? +^,a 4*yS 4r+ _,r .rrl: ,r(:.-13
,l-;3i;r
c--S )-
\
q*
c.(- J^: ,-,r+- crJr jL,
!
l; o:L 1go;:
,U"i q*.tf
ej!
c.(-J) ls )r:V*
oV g:L ,-l-
"r-(r
-,: L<.; d l) GS;-,-t
.\"<--U,- )rt
;l ,Jl
3--:l; .gt-6*jl .c-*l ":r5 t-a; i
ps> oyt-i 1l ,t:rJ;L;i L
-S-, dL^ti;> a5 "(-L:y,;
olaa 6Lor-: stl; ,'F .:-r!t .-t!t!39
rs
.r-i!"f
f^ C -,tiF_, -,
f^
JJ-l- 3 cJo oL-r i*-
j
c-.6; ;l
-ti;l.: p
Jg ;r-t
;*p
.<-- ;t"t -[ .9.;,r-;l) 4-:r-\ t--_S C oS ;it,
Second Law of Thermodynamics.l
.+L-"r-.r^15
f * : +L-e,;-lil .;l_*a (.i,-p "t(-,
-/.JJi,rt"K' oX .r_it .a_E .{-),\5.{aL,: & ;. S t4.f 6iT* C 45 fS f a-,
-/.JJi,rt"K'
oX .r_it .a_E .{-),\5.{aL,: & ;. S t4.f 6iT*
C
45 fS
f
a-, aJ .*1
$:
r_E
a,.*a
t .c*1 ;l*1-- c.lc ;,,-l J*z-:A.rL"J
:+ti g -:si.-+; l; ,ti .r(.*a Jti1*L! F-, ^S p;1, ;-r! ggl"_r^r-o
"i-_
)lP
o)L-.<,-;;r, .*l
f
3L;-La+5 Jgss ;:;Lri
JL.ro-;-il 4<-l
d
ae
)) 6\;*,;ii
) )y-./;F;
S.7 .:$11 .;.U* t-
Sloo
'sV
rl-r--,r_r ;i-l oS .-*l ;l
lJ3li .-r"t+ls" f
'S-- 6y'
)) d)l{J)
!
LA4-:-II
jl
JKjJ
n
a5 p;b "-U, .eilJ ;> .c-*l ,g ra,. u-t-ol
lj[-
-,L!l-, gi r-r15,
.gi dL-:,* t-t'-t-=-t 4-i
4;---Li1 -)-?-r-/
;-1 -er--y
a-z| +' ;< -L3l3'> e-L"1.+ o-Uic;,,1 !
.)J€
lrJ,
L-Ad--$l;l e5 g-a.1 g,lf.f J f*i:i ./F-:f* *t \: f-
o:L;l 4iiti J-('; i L-aJ-u-"a _, L-_,." r:-iL c-;r 4<L o-u:i
1l;a
"|5-:.i
^-::-fu:-S- J}o ;l 4t .r"t<.a .;-l ,;,- 6U;
;;-
;-l
.nc*l
.(*f
o-; .rete- Jk? jl .i-c J;*.r" 6 S*
-r{.f
"t(
;-
.<-
;\*
r1---: .,.! -uj_r_, .(- J_i* : L+^; ey;: J:"*rr L.*:
6.grg
6F
)-y€ )V\ 6 €.K
ui ! t-,lr *-$ ,g 6 Sr;l
5 c*l
F"r* JL4+ jl #,,lL^K.r-
.+5.r"
6
-r,--rl: +
6.f
f"
a[.c*kl; ,-a! ;) g!lo:1) oJ i-"a
"t(, ;i !
.-gF ",i
]-
;,,-l Jr :c*l
,-rL-67;: La:l-t-.3; -=.eJ, ft
j .c*l
*:
*5,
#
F
)J, JJS*
.6_*
5l;rl .LKli "Lj!.-1" gbolqlt U,o.-,p_,lr;_r! J./
^(U"
_t'u as;:l d
aL+ g
:
;-<
;:
45 ,L--:
;: ,-4G:l-t-,3 s fl
il9-tr
J.
.J;L +;;l: .5t- L*.: f
), c,-_t .r" .*_i.f -r,_-r. -uLr.;1.r.
u .:y5: l; (,Jr^:--$b .S:*l
;.-iy'!
;;5:
.j-; .(\ 20.-\Oqr) Ren6 Descartes .Y
,L-6li ,
t.5
.i:: 6 c-l
.5;"7 -r-aIl.r" 6 S;* x_f -f .tlrl
_,l5 !
_,!t ,.Et*
"r,"-:
r5
":l;l ,'r5 )) ,-u-<
-,, 6Lt ",:f
,,L*1 llj
--rS r-L*l ,-r-5 JF
J,-J-a ,rS ))a
(cJl
"t--! 6:-,
rri
i-L:---t l (s; c>\: JjF-7
*l
,JJa:_ll ;t ,rf<^: ,ra:., c-:
L_j;
.:r*
.rrlf
;: [:-* .-u:L ;-ti_J-ll J[- 1: +:*"a
;f ,r-F r+jk? .t2t" G.-r.;, 1;*rt^.61 6Gi;l .glaltL rlily,-s \qOP JL j::\ cC-l jr-l a,-)1"
;f ,r-F r+jk?
.t2t" G.-r.;, 1;*rt^.61 6Gi;l .glaltL
rlily,-s \qOP JL j::\
cC-l jr-l a,-)1" 6nb ,:\_t:o.:;L y'-9t ,Jtr-j*F -&
! lre -,3U;
r"
6.91 ttolr-D;r 6 g-t-a;*- ! ftli.,-
lFl
.:rt-6 ; $r
L" --.
L a5 ;*l
i) 4J .7-b;< y F|r'.t"
ap-t -'. ;3L .'t,*5 "-LaL:. lJ tdi
4li_l J .p-5
o.taLi lJ t-di t- a.rr .:.:ta; l^r./
t;s-s o\f
o--l q
.p5 "r"Ui lr Ji t- a-a: r::ta; S-&"t .fr ,
€l-f €- 6J)
a.-;;;;**a I g*lrcf t
^S 6"Lga.nr).(-.r7
-&"t.-r^l; jl
l; o;h-,r,,)t*-i
Lr-)J. l;6lalle L,:JrJ)
1l .gl.;L 6 f-rFe
;r fa:1-t-3; tl .+:rl Jt*-l j,*:t" -rl C-l 6 ,,--r,-: o; d gg;l:)--<-e
:lJ--:; .(,- .,5c-> rj*-:;*l
aS 6l,u-;,-i,Jljti
.r-K' e*)J)
Sa-6 1l**'. 6e;h:- y' ;: a5 f F ,S 4+ (1-.; J;* .J-<e -lr -r,l3i,r"
,-i- f
6 t:.-,_/ c*rt"
pl,r:.
.5La:l-t,3; rl;L,J"y .r^yll ot; -lb :l
{-tK,Jt j J) ,51+^-;2-- r,*
Gort.) "(,-
,Sal*"f
-rJl+:-lj
c*K At;4 (--:;
:V. e*S
dt J J),lJ
*. ,q-51
"<-- 4J
,-LiL ol; o:lr;li 6 ,;Q r-^;r,*-t-(a tX)J) J:jt .e,-L^2- oK-:-,,
u;<f
L- 4
t-+i -,t
u)s 6ll,,A-j
;-l
1
q
e5 b G;JJ* g1
C)i;- ,.-,-,r--,L! l-, t.Sl-r:ln.5.jli L .Js6, rr.5l;rlrr x-5,-l
.:*l
c,eu .:1y oK.;,
;,-l #+ r"t ,ll J:.uL
ori-l ua;t ,K" *
;-[-arl-t-3; L. t-l--€;-rt- l+i i) o-t]j uel;)l *
6.r,-tAdLr" ii 6
;-l
.Ju:.*a A.
61;lr -ua:.r, 3 t+i aS
Opl-; dk#
"f;^+.
rij-i
:*l
,r
d-rt" ,-eV eW;
tJt-- L6^';
^-s g-F
&l t- ,+
l; n;.a!n.:;lr 13-7-9 61"-t551;.:l
[a:l.t;; ;l 6la-oj*--- dtjJ?
Fjli.,"
-5,"q
o,-u:,-i;> J dS
;:
l)itV ,5lars.; e^ .-y.45 f*:5 i"J;
ti
6 rgl+o3 *,.r:*--11 t-arl-rr;; ll r5la-oy r,u ;a*ac(-.J,14i-*
l. H.Hudson. 'why we cannot witness or observe what goes on "in our heads"'
Jr !.iJi J*Kj oL4; 11 65, fr -p tl ju+Va J ;o)J,e-er./ J-fu lJ t"
Jr !.iJi J*Kj
oL4; 11 65,
fr -p tl ju+Va
J ;o)J,e-er./ J-fu lJ t"
t- ry- Slf.61; 3la:l-t,y; ,fi, ;;Lb _,t;>L L# d L" .f-*.1
1l ps.aJ,-1'-L;;.,";+ l; k,i cJk* :< .,*+-*A +(! -r :^>,r, 3
.J-Sc- _,rL*";- )ll: yj
t- ,l4KJr;l ly Glr*, ai .:*1 Crt
W
iLe+ L{ t-'5;: fr:l+ r*lrd
6 c*l .,1l^r.a ^,jS;\ ;l .,<1J"l dl
.e>*l Lt'r" ,&*
;-1 c.",;; 64-<j .t_r-,f c-L- .S.rJS ,ga;9- a* Y!.ga,-rE;:
gio:L;l ,r4
t_r-d ah ,r--\) 6-j+ r, eS ;t(*-*a +i ,.:*l
alj:-o a :3 La:l-ly;;l c.st-sJ; *;*a .,,ba:-f_* nflr ,-,-.j dt"
;1 q-l:,5+(;.-r,r-,r" ,J-S -E 1: dlr;L; -,t5 cJy+- .sll .;k,li-
dL-64 4n 6e
5l;rl 6h--l ,r_r-r: a5 l;,_r1tt;>.5a
a
e5,-,",1
jl.*-i.ptl: c--a!lr.',rtr'- !
t1,
er--l :r.-r,;lr ,;L; U gra;
o;k-y ,-rL--i .C-,t d;t) fr*c/ )f
G)4 U.t----l ;: e5 6lo;lir,
f:- cSa:(, .c*l o-t"i c-*,r, 6[:l;.-l ol; ;l ,.,,;l: -,Jli di * 6 g;ls;s-*
-t .5:i^-y-L;l rr;L-.-r" "[-li U t 6 Cl& 6la.rpy e5 c-,1 ;l
J^" y' ,f:1, .t<i lrl ;L^AU
c*it- t+ r--a J) (.r,-Laora.n:, it
c^-lc .-t-;r1, d-l-i: J-a. a
Ot-a+:t--:3, J.i[-a ,$Jjs,
"[ti;lF;:
.c*l j=-a
5l;:l l; j.> d&a
,*S--
$L; .5+^a;: +(i
5 crtj
jli6,b Y! .S."F ai g5.r*, ta:l
,ei c-l ;,1 f)"u-"|
64---b 4-Ki_l J crrS t-r[ oli,J t: ,l.rl o>l.h ,.<,,j., ,.5[aa,rL r.;1.-a
! )!
e*q Jula:rt- "J:5d< ;-ai ol;lry *-,8 6 cr,_t^4lL- jl
grq-*
):-f
:s,;--l
s;*
eL5 .r^:,r,
-,1 t*
u^Gi rr- e^ O d;
.r5 Jl fl.-r;
s-rJ7l
o,.Ii
d,",1 .(\VOf-\2A0) GeorgeBerkeley .l
uF.lq pr,
Www.Negashteh.Com lrF kiigl- OS",rE .p:rS1Gi ,rflU "riq ,-,- ;) U j--L, SW-t, iJotlr: dJ:i-$l ll4^:.--Jjl
Www.Negashteh.Com
lrF
kiigl- OS",rE
.p:rS1Gi ,rflU "riq ,-,- ;) U j--L, SW-t, iJotlr: dJ:i-$l
ll4^:.--Jjl ,-r* JL* a-, 6:s-,g:-l-, 5r::.5 *.6 urlK;a !; ,ti;l ,-
U .f r-
o-LilJ;
l/_j .), dU*"-t"t
dl,.c*-l-,
,rl
s +llr *.:*
Gn^
"-6-
.l-Ljl-r, lr t.!=" jJ:"'#-;
,s\
o(:i
o: -.--, jl ,;-i
or. -;:
.:t ;t--, ,-r1#
c:l:.r* opLa-;l tF ,lt
C-i,S 4jo-V.e .:FL-_,
Ga- ,|:,rJi
p
dt-
,*),t 6-& dt#)t -r R r" jl
"r-.:
6wol
c5ottr-r: J--rJ Fc\:
-l-;.-.-a_9r lr:.5a;_*Jl aS 616;Lle
t.fj+
.
.6-:l;,-.-j u,-f l: )J= .-i-) 6t-a-t-:,j .)3r.1 -t-) gr[.l
C k.lJ
d
.r-l al ;,.-^"= A .4
.fr-9'1 4.:-iL- .J,-yi cri) t) 5 p:
;l
"lJ,
-t')))
d4--t .;;L* ;t(-;i r, t-a:i ,5t .t-n.r--:; .r-l gr-5./ -.,L-"--l
o:L.!l l.t7 -r .*
-,!t
,,-f_l-rt-t J "t*i rlAlJ, i*;
i:.et, ,
:j, lu.al_r;
.e-J:tt olK^:J|", ;: ,r#K ft TrinitY .l
**f<l
-r,"*-l+ .(vY-\4.2) John Stuart Mill J* o;l-j:-l oL+ -K
j-\; ;ya;- .\
:S-; ,:\ic L
+l
.!a- .go;L;:
.r*, :h
r
\AfY JL ;
6 System of Logic: Ratiocinative and Inductive
3. dogmas
Www.Negashteh.Com
Www.Negashteh.Com J/ .i--Li &Ki fY .,-,1 jl ,_,*, '# : fl.r(JU-.:iLi -rJ3, -:s_: )l e*,
Www.Negashteh.Com
J/ .i--Li &Ki
fY
.,-,1 jl ,_,*, '#
: fl.r(JU-.:iLi -rJ3, -:s_: )l e*, .,J.fris" L# J
LaJ a
rr!
,-rl q d
--1-t
l_, ,_,,-bj.t : g*;b _,y! ol q 61_, .,1l^;.t
-e) :> 4J .r,-La+"lr! .frf g -;b:L
.,,U-9,_ 6)\,1 y tJl ! .S;I.(k+
.,rui*atlg:-r;t
-i;j .l-l -,1 .,,-b.t-$ *-i.f
*-lr l-, el4iy, j isl 6 drp_f J;-7 .go;L;: ;," .\AAA .-r;L \"n
6
yt.+
a
1:.c*l;1: f^U- ;tl"
-r.Jl":r5
6
;,
;-6a-6 Jlr.--l r La)j
fl4jrt G:s-*,3i r,
,S[^rtt )F l;,.
.:-l "r"i ,+
"i-,
))y;r
goJ-i-o -r-_; gl":;yl c-.t, 5
.;loJ5lil
.,"=,-ta ot.(.i ;l eJ
6p
))_f )) 4lji
o- ,3-> oLL; 64
Jt-"- c-LJlo:J--i f-i-
rlr -ualr; ,-,t* lr" |t^5 kJ +J 5 ;1ol^-; ,-f."t i o[" a,7-qli,---3li"
a: r3-l:c ts::l-f ;: .C*1 .)F;L*t
g-c>j -,1t, f^ lr" r_g.- a(L
t-:-- ,l-L-Li, l,l ,ll4it- .-r
C-Ji
,.r-J"i ,)t-^+1 o-t oJ G-qi;r
ol-*.J-lloJ-i "qri
i.*y
oti
,-l4;U*
.,*;-,;: ,$lorut-x.Li
.Strtq e, rii- ,)lri 6
#
,,",'( ftJ
! ;rlr:
.f^, o|;i 11 l"u r p:l
j3;,.1 .g*;L \1
,,lr-.f
i:rl
.r*Ll 6 .',l ,
4_5 -L:L "iY
5l q .nJi:ro
l-g
a, 5
.iS
e c *:,,c1
\
"lo-L.i-p
-
r. -
t
-.-(
- \
\'-J
-
l.t
--l
.glr- /-):
o>r5 I ' ,, ,.: t-l .g-t*: Cl$lr, l: )f
{!
;-,14 .rU
./Lri .,---l .:l: f^lP
Jlr-j u.L-l \ GAe gt+U;t Li-i l.t; a, :Li:el
rL:S lr .iLL---l --$ *
J "t-it, f^lf
-t:.1_q Jl+ J flo:-n 6 c.*l
l.r.; 4i:Li;el 6lr- .,,*Lr gL"n+j a,:lL_ )_fu \ r*-.c-i;l-r5 a,rlr-
;-rS e\*
:.g"*n't
e5 a!l:,r- .frf
:L. La;
-
!;Ei
q.l-t1
a-S ,glQrtl) a--L;t5 3 o:L ,i -.!: 1[L .-tJlo:3r;t5 1.: oll3 a .]J
-il+ l.:l cJ-iL o:3, c^il: >l+J e^:1'.a
r;1r r3,-j t-rQ;;: O3;51
"r--!
o)y t" elts.-
6r,1 6o:L jl ,Jt6; rlr
6 eU) )l["tl C*r;
l. reflections
k-::_f ;--; eS 4s-* 3 o:L e5 c-l dJ-<^.'>i"S 3;t;t .r;Su*.grL;.:.r, c.*l oJJ*i rf ,.-;.--,ji
k-::_f ;--;
eS 4s-* 3 o:L e5 c-l dJ-<^.'>i"S 3;t;t .r;Su*.grL;.:.r, c.*l
oJJ*i rf
,.-;.--,ji J--l i^l-
J ,-Li!
r-;
".r,r.ii :;b r3>y oy,l5l
oi.r- -l.ilor3,
erb _r: 4j*-A l+i d trr*
Ll .:y t;li .,Jl
e ;l
€e
oL.( !-r.;l.-r."i t*S _it J:"5., FEi 1r ">V J si
r;5 ^t ,_*l_*
.rJi 45 rl: c^--.j 6;1oJ:5,-r;l 1^l .,,U -r;-i! +, L;; l, t4.;i .tlr-i oS
(V,g l.u 1;,ti U bA
c5l!U;* r --+ .,=lr(- t Kil q f""+ *+5J ;r .g*;L yy
\
6.*b r-r;61 .p:r- .rL:l 1, ls; :3-3,--,"L, fEr;l
;*u ily!
1*a/oJ'5I 4J.tL4z 6
c:ai.a)14 JY.r;,-t o:;a Jr"c-
f;5
tr.-u;L ".r-i )frA
--ir,.a -irL^ei ,1tl ,rj;l-r:.-r^ 6;*. rS;V
",--1
"r-t" fu,pr tf J-p L-lr -,r .*,l f
oS *-! o::b ;U";.;l -r,-11 \\ u,,y
)r+s Jr
-,.-":!,)t"": k^;l ;l aS is-/ Jt.( f-u5.," J*r F", fl
o;-yc 6-;5 6tb Ssi:fs
o-r* t+i ^5 frt
a;b:l,t:jl e5:;l-r.J
a,,l-r- :1;i dorl;l c--aJi .51;l: l; L4i .t;'; -3., S--
rl Ll
.-u-a:
,j;*
d4*"t-;r rJt4> dk",l ,5u-a
e5 f";*+ U a+i al g1fL
oi f
*
L+i ,t &"ef
; Jl"-r"i ,,5 r^ f,
a5 -rjlo: 5 3.:
"tQu_rG
p*
J-*-l)lj c*l 6-l l;Kli ,set,k.J:Ss^j ,";;\lrlt
Jt- ,.-r;:
1.t-; .,r;*.a .:t r:l e,:(*l Ul .C*;;! c;lr rli:3,l l.u a, aj
;l l1 Lgi ,Jt<"1 ir5.J .J:Su" &
l: ,S>;-l
6)t
_&r.:l*la; 3 Laor,,.-
j+
jl l-, t-e,i x|r€ )jL./
"t*t-
tr;,:y,r^i ;-
l-, ,_rrl, 6 6*5
lt) .j*t
ts ft
Laor
*
G&: ol; ;l .r;l-:y ;=:
,,l f f.-l,r d t'
.r--a: r-.iJ l-, L+1 dtjl ,.:*--r,.r"alr-1 -5f ,-u:,! t4,;S,g,tSges
,-.a;; j-b- f*lrcr*i L 3 ,c*1 o)J; .r"a;; ta;i 1: 6 *i'll
-\
,r<
l, l-l;
,l
J .,*-a.: J^* .,4Jl -rl: a, -;*l
"-t"i _-Ii, .715 ;r 5 'lLt
.r_rK' .-rtt^i j.:r
s$;
ar" !i--li J*t<; LFy P )t ,*+ J,-t-x 4J ey-f C ji5l .-f,-ryi r -)€
ar" !i--li J*t<;
LFy
P
)t ,*+ J,-t-x 4J
ey-f
C ji5l .-f,-ryi r
-)€
.gal't- pP.rjq;t-l
ot<q t-,5a-i)tr \y (S-&t
g;o;L-2.1
tuf
gi,y Fij -i d 6 o-l uer;r;,l
:*l
.Slttq
"/--,:*
.l;;l ,r5- ,.>*-f; Lyy;,l
a, ol9r,r" ol; 3r jl .;lo-L- 6,r ) ,-fL-
.1
t;
J ,J\il+ tr ,-rt
ti ,-rtari 6a--[i" {
;l
f-:
rI
Ge*.-W J ,J"Si
a--n r-ll;_:pt-- dot!:: 6 lr) ,.>-l ;uA-o c-*jJ ol:
l_: rt
-,-lr.r-,
l; rl;i
ep
i*
*-S F:t
6":l;l Jsl ,?f
.dj lr, 6o1L;: gJ-r
:-t-;L c.;lrl )3.-J t^45[- .* 3 itlri
Jrj .fttr YV b
6 d,-l
;tl=t-.*
gl-r 1; ;i *-tr ,--q.l,ti :l;i,5or1;l q,J!.ri Slt -51 ,-r.,
.-,1y., Q*.:-l
,5;t5 ;al : rg;+dr f^
.(; 61r, f*l9#
ft
1,-tr.tt.
Loo';L-
f5
lr-,
l; o1 aol;;
g^ ,-rt ":i Ul.t g--** L5)Ui 6':l;l
ei c-l
:l-*, G:_ro 9 G2yat Ll .c-*1 fu
S*;*
J^" JA
p
Lij.J--L;.r- J-t-" y -E r: 6 cfL*a .(g-\r-.-,i) .-L*
_, L ,-r- t-t-iL o-t-j; J-(
u*.C
J .*,+
iJ
ull
6tG r-
'eV
-t .+-*.J e o-r1:l ,rr-S Gbs-* gd*Jt Li-i o$j .ib3ry3,' 6a--a
rl;i ,5.r1;l ^i
e-lt, .#
4t ,fi-+ c.-;: ;l ;f;lc^;K; 6V
"l,ti
,J-::S.r- ;l
,-# J CU):A
;: 6 ,S.6st r5o;tr;: -Sl U- -: ,g**
.t-(i,nt-:,l:,r-.rr5 '.!)*
s ,*
:l
f.:J,
3 aJ ,gto"fl
;r L
6t-c.:l e
",.1, 6^2 ;1.:r5 ral3,- n" oS fril+ U.;: O;t3;.r"
e5 l;,--j ,,-*l 4jtt[:*J;!-
d.:j
|
*;:
rlli 6orl;1 :;3r
-a
t-
JL^rl .5L+a jl 6:G G\-f *,
of #,
;,-l r ,c*l.u ,J$iti
)Vr*l -r--tr.f g;o
l-*ic
a-.,Lllor; )p .J*jl oL*i JI<JU- JIt"
JS6-,r:*
1; t" Jt-rl s x-; ,* g
f *.5
l-,.1-k-rlJ gqJ;l
a-a a-ll:yt-- Jt;:
g*tl-u; rl;i,5.r1;l Loy-; s.1
l.r; 4-.i
:l3ls
.c*:b a.113;.r-
t0 k-:r-6,-,# l-r-j,p-! -r.ci" 6J,l .Ss: y 1 fj*jli.,,,-,j,6 |rryt !' i'3: L;i +Ji .:-l
t0
k-:r-6,-,#
l-r-j,p-! -r.ci" 6J,l .Ss: y
1
fj*jli.,,,-,j,6
|rryt
!'
i'3:
L;i
+Ji
.:-l
-tl ,i>F ,.L;;1 ifuL
,6
,#t"
aSa-l tr*:
,r
:i
Jl .:y\u-, JJ-+ .,:r
J -r*- \ .*6i
1+
u.t---l i-/ ;: c*l
slt1 f
ot-( C ,fte 6l.u ,f"6 ,ga;JL^ c,-,-ri ! a5 c-+ e-&, 6,.")^ ef
t-_ -r--!
.J*i! ,K tt* c.rjL-,r:
",*i
Jt-fui t_, 'e-SUf .:ur.i ,;*
,,-;l:.r-.
c-r,l-u
n<-"U lt J:l .)J" .f<j ::l,r l-r
t- fti
'Slttq
,F
-# ,y-t
6 €g *
6fr e
v r lJ-*,t
ts ,-/s'
r--f e
tl 6$;lof
2p tt.iL
oJ::SJ*y f-
-:L], p,gL:1 ,5o;L;r
t-.i 6 J:5 .!,Jt- aU-rE )Vi -,t c-*"1 a;*;l; 6 ra:.r, L a, l"p d^^1,
;r a5 .r3r 6rjlb-e +S 6 ,J.(; ,5rrl 6o:L;1 ,51"13; ;t t+i Jt"rt
t+i
n; 5 +rr! V i_* CGre crt*l o:3r oJSl; oka -,1 d+ J,-1
+(!
I \-. dtjjlr tS6:) \ G-v U f.rli.f
,.-:l:
uolSi ,3-
C
"#
j
.-r-;L a:-;lr Jt-,
ei.,1 ,-*.A d4-6 ta-l .prr csi
L+i -,, $':
rl;i,5.r1;l lb
C--P L-i ^J p.r: J f.--.r+.r:St
jl "+.* g-,5 '*lt L- -ul;r
\l-: cg* -rrlf./
! lJ .-i-t" gl ft
.*'t
6t1 7-1lS oF -r) ,/
6lr)
r5 ,*1j- .!lJ: e {tl
.J:5.," ,-FC-l
+5 t_tsir-/ el;
el"6l
tL,
c-l;Q 3 -riLy .:L!l
-,t5 ol+ c-:
-,"1
a5 5;l: dl-6.j31
.^:**^ f-A)cr.
pta.,l eS C-tS -f J) .-r-,.$,1
s _re.\ or-f
t" r
-fu,
ot* ;*
;tpl3 E.JlS.," lf
l: b*f
JUi ar, 5l-L-.,^ ,+" t l .:;[i :3--3 Ulr-l ,Stl-l! J-al ,r.:,-J ,Si
.iJ,*. s ,-s.leL,;-, +5;*l i3Uj;-r,! oLr 3-lyaL- oi j
d
,_5 t;:
6-)i 6 ,Lic a,,1l JJ+ ol; ;.: 1;;-a Jt- a,,1 I ! ."},-rli I f
F
4
6fr
r-.p)\, e-,ail
a,3 :l;i g;o:l;l n^i 3 >;b +!l:-9t-7
1. Papua
Www.Negashteh.Com
j /^-! \? J"t<j ,Jtt,5ta,-;13*:;r ,,*Gi c,*j ;l j>;j--13 tu*i;,a ,Fb ey ;L.; gL-- 6o:t-
j
/^-!
\?
J"t<j
,Jtt,5ta,-;13*:;r ,,*Gi c,*j ;l j>;j--13 tu*i;,a ,Fb ey
;L.;
gL-- 6o:t- ;l 1; ot a:i a5 c--l G# 6^l<i tJ3q .r;1: .:_py
1J--- ,1. -iU a;-:l: iJL-?d g;o^:L L .>jti:^ 16 .i- ,tty:i Jl J i)a€
;-l
:l;i 6orl;111 pye;
S-r:-j[ {^:l$ -:i;i ,gorl;l e--e_&t *
'yi
,gL-.1;
I 1 ,J:<; d-.+i 5J"- J3l ojG;f
,tUi d c-*l
.S!j ,-f;l- "5l-*: llr
*. a;-t3 Lt ; c-l tai;: e5 .'gla,L;l5 J)Lil Jt<,
,o:J;e L. ,3 yl
JL*;l ,J1"" ll
a5 -r--t-,r- JS^"U 1y,.ai ;l "j)\*
!
.-,Ut ,:;lr .l*;rU 3 iu;)
;l 6
ra, _l .dk+ r3o_r!;r Pf
:-5,
j+
-'*iLJ tS*
iLil i-l .g;i ";\
.r;-, J .r:a5 j 4" ,u;ibly
4i )LS J L A /-
J f
))_f :)
j 1l o;.6
grr-*tr .4[.*;
"ir"U
S;r-
;*. gU_rA -r )\ ,soV .-Sr-
il>7, .5d-+a J J*i:[ L_r.f
_rl
JtS-r a. J6-r,JL:--l ;) a-5 rllor3a 3 y.,,aa O*."lsro oV
a-i .t-#,-" a-sF -'(1, ,t ri;r 6 .tS.r, ))FJoI ;l ;-a f-:
J-;L a-Jlj,: -Ltj du;.: L_i 3 -u-r.r- -);r. el+U
,J<, ,r?t ;*
GL--E n5 ir-l !c.*1 gl.r5 ,K, r .ii .-'i f"r5 _,_r! l, .,L.r ini" ti
k-r.* dg
.lre 6-- ,Fr+
ol*,
6 f5
.:Lil q ),1,", 6 lJ Jl"t<i
:-,l:,-j, )l .J.1" a. 6lo1* ti JkSU l-r- 3
-,"
I {.i1, , il
.}l e :&
r-o-> L 4- -:;5,5 .); 5F-
oJ ,f tL-ot t; 6.-*lci<-: Ji, ji
*j*
-,l(^Lj,3 ;U3.l;" .-s;l .p1 5 ,,1 ,.r">i t-i .-f"
c--l 6;1,
J-t<j )La-el a-*a ;,-_l p
) t)-- 6 c-*l
,o.u; o-Lull u--;i
l_j6r
*
a-1 lu
Ll ,r!l:.r*; fr3"i :3,t1 .r*(,-
er-
6t
1,, F
,r_l .r.
.:3.-- Jl-
: C*l o:J i
ar 1; _ll itsl
r:.rl- JtJl u;:,",i goTst
r:i
ralr,-.r" ,.+ji U {.-:U<lJ
l: ,--E ,J_l -Sl Jt- ."[3i trf
,go:1;l -u!G s lr*
r-ri
o-S ,,_l-+
L-ar.; ^--F ,.t--l da-A-a l-.it" {.Jl J (ca---j ,r*. S\r-i!i eS -c*l
rl;i
l"Fi_6,,"r^-; jl zu-;l.: C*1:Li 3 C*;: llJJ.,r tS-s_* 4-? -g-l G>* fJ; dJ[n gf.-li ytjc
l"Fi_6,,"r^-;
jl
zu-;l.: C*1:Li 3 C*;:
llJJ.,r tS-s_* 4-? -g-l G>* fJ;
dJ[n gf.-li
ytjc ,sj-- &y"
C."-b !
L*i fl
S +-6,;JtJ
jL:-15 J.z ra -o,_-r,-r \-' +5 :3, ralr; ,JL.a ;L _il++j 5 ,1;5 6lo;L;l
I r--- il-i
4;o-\-)s a- aJ ,slJ->3 .j-Kj
*
-*
P
.11 tt
"*l,r
p
J-#\
r_;
J^lJ; a* rc*l o.:1.: 6E ,r":i
:ta,;, i.;r"-
,f-l f
giL-'" llf
6 ,.:-l
"|.t* 6a-+* J3l 6da3 ;: L ,Jlq3 4t fl.J-,@
.a*l ,J
:
6*;::
eidaf ;:3 .sl-l o))Ji )Fy
l; .:li
L*l
or JLi:. 6lj:o -.i q.r:*l
o.:r5
l-, .:l! $t
1
.e 6a;--tll 5
; ,LU -,t
,ri rl g-,t--: .f#
,r
-b -t: c*l ,r1l"ril Jyrl ,K;-L; 4t lJ Jt"i
P
4--* *l: Ly 6 *-rd'rrt'^'71;: ;l;i 5n: *.9-tal"S
s t_id
o:rui jl-.
"L5 r,r;c*l;j
^f-,1 ?*Jr!d+ .JSG, L;>
6,c*l ,F ,rtie
Ly #o:r5,**;
-,! q l-, ;t+.
,-Hrr.i
,f
o-1.-ie;,,1
oL-:* oF ;: .,.,=ilr,r, 6 jU- .;"i 3 .-r,-i.r" tL;:
e-l;
a, ri;l$
$t
6 GaS J c-l l-t; c*a>J d.t;; )t"j J,jJe ;-ul: 5
JL.( J cJ-i:3,, -ry::. oLlj o--.- H
otyl-, o! 9 .*11:sf l-s cJ
lr.-a Jt- .rr
;-l
L*;-r-;L
,a-J,-i JL
"(-
;l .-r-* 6
€,g
.>Vy*br" aj--l d ,3- oi Glr .z t-1 f"b-i.r" J,-+ .rt-
,gtoa-:,-ril
G.-*. SJ,J*iF .;t; .r,ty:i ,:-r.i -rtl *-f
-r:,-L;pt, U" $;tgi
;"G1 ,t!,:i 5 .rirrS -r-.x; 6^l<$ ta4*i-$l *_S c-l 5 .:.![-;: ,:li,g
.-U J1 r-t6- 6--1; qgla-l"j 9 ;3:f
i51r,,; ,r-u
L- J.$ ;l
-^*J G)L ) rtu ,
n;,1 ya,l;
JLrl ;l
45 6*5 J-Al )l s >61,_lt
J\
."rJl.rr5 ,*,i .g1.;l.ll tr t-64*L-$l aril
45*ai Clyr ot* _,, uJl .t-5,-S
.6
t't-
-fi"t
-,\ ', fr-
4io,Li-o
;1 a---".-a .r-lql ciy-tl d
fs.f
F
:+;
.'|1;3i Y.
r-r:
a-5.:--^^-a,<lo-tc[! '-l Li t"l .r S
- 4+*]> * * i,<lLL L;-,<a-:.$l
v-
-
J-
I
1J
j. , J-J.i J.Kj g!oJ.eL! .a, 6 'Sr: oL( l; rli jl o,r-: bl{ y>
j.
, J-J.i J.Kj
g!oJ.eL! .a, 6
'Sr:
oL(
l; rli jl o,r-:
bl{
y> j ,{
q SJ:5 6J-* oi;l .l_L o"x" d4*"t- 4
u- ri-l-r-a ,)i
y l; ;;br5 a.5 .;.
",-Ll
C-_S:t;l rU:cl e,5,--l ,*--b
\ G;;.if
*.,t:rS
"l.c.gl:.r"
:l.tJ c.^.- jl e J Gi-i;f
jllr
c-f ;l g A-5:j
,t;-;,d
*y
lt ,5n: gioJeG a-l Ss-t;rL 6 flr.r .x_r.r/ ce.*:J, aS 6:l;l
a-7 a5.t-+l+.rr:l_rs- f *;:
b* 6 +-5,;3 $1:,r
,r\t
*
ci3rJ 6lJ-l a, 5 c*,1 .rl r-.e ,ssirl JL lJ .,d1; f
A-S:t GA
*;5*
;;*,-rl.r=l
6,:!L;r bly€;Ll
t l .4
Ly
,-*-$ tr
j
.J:JlrF x lt 5;K e:t
yj" 6 ,.JU-? ,:;l) c.i/j
-tJy-i ,lV pf
,-ib bl-rl.t+y
r:3r
fl
6^2 6 c*l
rst5
U tSoLis q _,"1 ;,r*n
:-+
"tSi
J4l-
L A dU-J ,;J-ei, i/
6 dU" cdJt 3 .)jL
J J
,P
:t c^*.j jl -,-.r*tl ji ;l 6t,
e5 c.-l Uls d,.c*,l c.3;
.-*l
-,+ 6 +-F ,_l ,f \ e $r a .c.*l
;Sl"t-- 4-5 dS J^t A*
6 l*
ga.1 gl.:r5 p
.-S-t ,*--h * i s Itsi t7y
ls G;;r:;r
Hr
4-.flur! 6rt r
q
fjL:r,_#t*.
rt: A-&t fr
fr.rg ,-* ,;t
o-u.J,G1:; .-6,
F
-*,Sl;t
dir ,7:j; ua-*; 6lrt
f,
rl
ar-,-l silJ
,_5 -:
_,s .dL(o '>t S ,t;t J 6k-3: s yb*r
s
1r--1 ,;u*ili u-, 6,J-ie J ol-St d :;[i .rU^" oS C Slt Cb)
6 c*l J+ -L"ti c^j;lr ::rty r.1-r dJ; oJil3; JLi-l e5 1-" Ja i.l-
ir-
#, t"l .rJt<,lcr" c+;) t;,ti r:;tJ 5 ra: gt+,l U 6;15 ua:*)
tl)-p 6l1,-:,6t* glr"r* C-&-t.li 4<ji c--; ,-*:-b c-l ,Slt
,5;,-u.--"ul.,- J-K do_rt:tr e+:*
*6 e&.r
,if
-u;t,
y
a5.f-l p,t, : ,p1ll3 Ju lJ ur[-a-l a 1a-aly 6---Li
-#;r
,,1 :-p;t5 olrb t.:3, ,:^l!;r .l,-! 5.:-l tS* C-.$:t Hf
5;-l
.-Se* r.Jq 6 6ry;:
,-r-1 .r 6;.
,)*o 'Sst tt ,"-b
fq l-#-6 ""r^-; -51 s ,fiV d!+ :r ;f )f d- ,)_dL, st5rl 6:;-2. *
fq
l-#-6 ""r^-;
-51 s ,fiV d!+ :r ;f )f
d- ,)_dL, st5rl 6:;-2. *
elt,
?
66t JLt,:) fS J-" f),.- .t:,-UJr 6ly. L& dlJ:*1:j> y"tS +!
;u*iL a:-i;l: >_f s 3 f
)l .#
,J:l) Ot+ ,Jl-<"| d.," elt. 6 d
.l;+ :i;r
.;+ .lkt;r Fr-r ".;
6
3l ;t-7-i .917 +fu-l el-t C
:*1
6l*,
ot f|
t
5
JSr 4"1,, q)r ,-#3,.- J,-! 6 c--l g)13
jt
fi;
c-:
t ,rt+-sU- ;i
,glr-. 61a:*-U -,t.* olr .fi*
;l ls sf
,si t
,=j
.:t+, 1-r -sl dt?
Gb 6 l-rS
-,lt: rJ
.5-:iaJJ jr
jl e,
;: dl+a t-.1 ,pl.-t-_; ,_* Sl-s 1_, _,t.;r d.ryr d-S.i J gl"ry ,-rLl
,'-
. S-s.; 1ga--:i
:: .a:b 45
5$l
.u"l
v
(.)
,
, t^t .3 3l gJ; 'i1i .gea.1
L>
-
J.
\.
.t-S tf
L.6J+. g;0r4.7 -r;t;
,-
a-l
l-i.p o-,<'5
^-;L
': a-5 alo: 3
s--2r
L'oi Yq
JJ-1
JJ-1vJ
-a
J
U
J
J
D
I)-JJ
\.
\
-v1;li:-l -rr .L- plory i-,1 q ,.,t<L; jl l, t-6,i;l 6a*.45 ;--6")t-p
G4-?.* , \ r-<.,) c;J4 3 ,plorrS sJ ,)Ui ;l 6p.t.:1 ,',+,.,t*.il
j t:-r;: + L_r.f Jit-;r
6 c*l it+U ne.pl.:;3i,-*-L i:*i
C-l jl o:y c-;:Li
.Jl*il _;' .i 4.5 dt-:+^A ,lr--1 .:s; 6J-*";lf
q 6 rili J-*l
d-t- e;*
L;; c*l ;(-.
u;s:r c**;
.qlo:rS
.J-.:, J.-"rt-- C--dJ,, .l-r-ll a5,j*i
3 ,I,t*Jl.r, ;;l: .;Lj gi e, ;,
6
6
.{ t" c-*l ./;r
t" 6:S ,:ay L! *;
Gltf _r t" tl
c--l
lglorl:l.u dll--3 Sl ,u1s::.glrf ,,1 ;l .t-L g-rlr-l f
J ,P i:.i
;l
ir-l ;-" .S e:X,.)Jbl3 l+t-:y; rl-r.ilj-y*, ,.lr\ rly;r; 6-f 6
,g -r p,l:a U.iitrr tr r.b
fr! J"" j2;- --laril.45.t-t+ ti if
)l ,r-- 6,,.*:ji
d,-::l r;:.(100A-\0\?) :s:i 4;rt *.c,-l .gl.1Lil
Bloody Mary .\
ir"--irt .1too,,tLj\oor;l):f
.-:tL-r:Jr_i-e,tu*r(t
,Jrrr[;:11 3y
;:9.i;:;13:l
,Ll-
s )f
.r-5 fl-rot t-., .r.:i ,r-l ollx jl .r l''
l.l' l; -rhJ3;a
-ts
0. ;r, , J--Li J*t<i ,-.1 .:--!,g ;r +5 t>*l 6;-.> JI .rJ-ll" JL^5 ;r.
0.
;r, , J--Li J*t<i
,-.1 .:--!,g ;r +5 t>*l 6;-.> JI .rJ-ll" JL^5 ;r. -E -:t
"fJ+ aJ
r,'JgL,g1
,,J,!,,-l .J5,',.a"Url.u;,',,r*,51 rll
.5,;i
uJ9-vJ.-.9!U.V-J-.vJ.re
-^l
)1f 1) ;#
,g. f;c jl r,t-=+ l-.a). 6'-l o"
ltt'
,H
f#
f)-f
?_f
i-*J, JJ-"-,* 6 ,-:5 i-rii
,Jl-t>J jl ,i*L.5 1',ly.f
l; dL;;.rr .5L-n.fl 6 $;1.:.r^l ia3: f)y 6.:-l
,-=.n-c t"l .J-iL
.-t-+l; ,-l- ,S!;,
,-*t:,
dt+ t: lJ Ji
4J
e -S.t J i"Ji
tL*l ,-rL"r, .a, Y
,j:U ,l.r-- ,<ld
J S ar J-
J b*
e ) asrl
7
'-g ,plolit-^l-:.i
,,,
i
.
1. t
J-
t
LJ-
v
.
JU
.
-
Lt
-
U
--
l_-.
\
o-i Ji ti
tst-,J, -,;1,q
.ti tr .-rJ!.f d+ U .c*1 .r*ij! r-r-,u er d->.*"
:r;
Gil J J tilLl ?lF
rt
p;l
c--r-r er j :;lK u, iV
f
'\
r
C-lu .1--
t
z'
.
.
t
t
tt
-
.tlv*_l
J-
6.
.:;3;>;3 4;Lao;'L-il
;V *;r
;t-.:*,1!
qt-.f ,J"K, J!.1 .'t+ olr^a a, ail 6 c*Jt-*i lrr; *>-l u;^.
.c-+ J.t51Ui oL*^;l :;l: r3! oJJj)Jt o(Lt y
GQf \ J:*t:lr-;
c*l € th
4S li<J."r:j f
u- ,3
,-* C &L -,:*U.r,-:j ril.u:u 6 f*.f lr,*t;t
t4ri a, gla*;l3i
J,-r7 3y'i o,.6f1> tl u=
"rf;
-r,:; ,gleEAuo f
-*\U.xrry
L-l
:: *-: ,-+-q ji
5
q -r,-! .;ly*-a d
<-l
,_r*-f ci-;
'r-l ;: g:y,
li;>
p;--->.plo-t;
;LU
', S s; Jq) ojti ',,1 ;: )t-
r r -t,r
i
vJ. s
(->-
J
u-J
\
-
-
4J ,)i Jt-- ,ll4-ii ir
,,1;r ei .:*1 oJ.i ct-*:.at ,_r*,-L; ;*-"o a, lr,.
jL
;-|,i,:
p.
\
j,-"U.:Sl
jl*-*,(o:J) ;L$
pl
et"+ y
ft
ts
,l)
r
J
J
q,
vJ.
\QJ.J
c,*1 c--fu .r t: l,,. 6a:$ tglayq F*
J4;> 6ffi.fSL.f
.r,-Kl ,rL: .(1A0.-\VV. ) .:,t.rj:t-r gtL-: WilliamWordsworth
.\
,fl3rL- "lr-"r n- d
olr-t|,- ,l
,i*
,|,_l-jl
.r(l:_9t-
.:-2 .rk-J"(;l ;,
,.lt *SS
Lrt-aoJL-l .gul(;
f*i-+;LJJ
Ode: Intimations of Immortality
from Recollections of
Early J>13 ,5,13:
.vl
3\ 6r;
:yV-: S-;K;S ,$A,Y) Childhood
o\ l(,:;JS j-:-"; Jt-,ri9i o:r*; ot-5 -lLl;5 c*l +:^:lrl;.ab_,S:Ktl yly s fs.r- F glt".,, -,5
o\
l(,:;JS j-:-";
Jt-,ri9i
o:r*; ot-5 -lLl;5 c*l +:^:lrl;.ab_,S:Ktl yly s
fs.r- F
glt".,, -,5 1 k i t
:t5;r1 ;t -r,-tl ,-,sra:^,_l ,i, ;:
^S;i
rr- 4--l "rJl riq .rr5 ;c-;;
f
6_p a, lrr c^.i";^. ol; ;r 3,t-(i 6
.;-l +*L 1;l;* -u-L;- o.;-a j Jj:- oa.i ;l -,q ol"-:; -*:i u;:"
l: J"r(- urL!;) r-r:;yi
c--r, J ot; JJ) d)31 :LX 11 lr, Jt-- ;-a ;> Ll
L :l;i
yt
a
-a
;l 3 ,c.*l
":,9 ; jl3^:r
.*,LJ
.50r31r, ,l rr" +ii
,,ly
dq
,-rl.:'z ,c-l .r-5
)l gt
L 1,
j[i 3 aul.:;L
f_La4;-Il ;_W
J>.;u; r;J,
J)
-*G l-, La4-;-$l ,:i :l dt
l)
fjL
+ +
)l fl
45
c;*
t r t,J-i[-;
f^ a!f|:
,- :l q_1l.rt5 .,r_l J ,l)-€ elr
;llt o5 f-3-& f.lp-r- ?)J> e.;--; )))u ;) ,--, r--i- ;t,5
>t; o-:K C*l ;(-" Ll :_r- ti c-l o)-91 * ,;^:* C^i-i- 6yq
^4-ft l; ;=:-l; c;\;->- -S\ t,a*;;;n>-
l4-l."d j, aS G;.;> aS
);.-l )1 .-,f---t -L-;rr ;3>;: c*l .r^S-- ;l
Ll sy, a-al-9',- y;u;rL-
.pl":rJ \4 3:S dJ,_)rr c-;J>- ,ro : kC d*.)r
;: ;* 6 l-l
i r;1.: ":lr-ri ;l ua;; 6 l; ,g13.a
-r-L;,:*-,
;: --.e,L^. a:Jl
".rLl
eK.1 l,.1-r-!,tl;L- c--r-j-,- ,u$;tr
l;L
.llir;; +tr,_rl J o)Jict
.C*l -t- ixi F-l 3 ,:;lr.r- j!
_,1 l; u":i J ))L-rl
"pL_
!
.jl.i ,lt:.,:)
a^-a;l 1, u,ti
6
r:ti,;i c*;:.r,L;
"<lr-:,rrSi,g;tSi-ti ffi
,-(: oLJ -,V-. Slt. c*l
;K
t.i
-r,L- e-:
,:i a, u-S 6 ;4+
cSffi
.sl:F G\J il J ri:ti *:;-s; a;"
'-i.5 1-i r- J.
eGJ-)r1
3 ci*l
:t qft,a-o: ul:l ci.;
"-r."i;, ;1 ;: +5 r.:t .,:ij-
Ly
;i+
-<ir r-rU- ,;
a-S p;l-ul "l+
6*,riq
,r-\r. "*i ^a,i ft
)n4- g$
jlq.;i ,.: ,l +5 p;l: (+y:
Aukrbiography (\ltq-\qtv) ,, .rfu
-J-1,
.rru Yl cAn--.L! 6Ll--L ,)L .5Ga"-lz; .l
j" !i--Li J.Ki OY ;l .-r-"iy C<ui,-;i;-l : rl 4:Ui s:Jt- 1, ;L(, ,-,,1 ;)
j" !i--Li J.Ki
OY
;l .-r-"iy C<ui,-;i;-l : rl
4:Ui s:Jt- 1,
;L(, ,-,,1 ;) ,-* cra)
i-i-J;i" ,l;
a-. q 5rl
XrS;:\ 3 [-aotK-u_; orr5ut5.i-
cit{--t-
-l
ii
G)f
C fl{:-$l c-Lar,rr jl
J lG
)t dLA4,lri 4<iti- .c*ilr
";Li
L-P;r
.Jl ;: .O;[5) ci4;--$l J-!La _,L^-: ,y-
3 r;,, +:;=1li
L;i .:;t5.:
6 :3, ',,1 *jlr,/
.l ,l 4i 6rt
W J.l .frr 'F
U\
f
{<a
+;)s
;
c5otlrt:31 a5;:y"r;lrra> 3 ,-*l tOrU, ,>la;^, ps".
1;1 "i ,Jl, .i-,-ri ! 6 #,
q ,-* 6-y :l:l;i
:-l
c^i;;
*l
.g.r1;l :1
.r-:L o$L;-5
I
l;y+l dli**U q +"; dld--l-i q lJ" J,-tl r;l: ,r;ti
;-,-l ;L;i;> a-5 r3r dL,a -r;tS ,r^.o,r,ta gri ot(-r,-r ,-cl q l-," 6 ;Ae
.St+;U t .,,"Si r.r:r- :)3r o.:;3i l,l, l; ot5.l-r
oJ-i-e 1.( ,'b_: *
jl .ri .n-<.,-lL .,r:.r:,r
-r l; 6:L -).;-7 ,.35 ,a talyl.! ;r-l +(i-l q
ef
o-5;r;yi tSil epy
a-r:6rl: c*r;l
t"r; q l: )f
oLql ,6-r:-a
---l l+.)3-1 r^)P ip'6*-lt
iFiL-r,
(y
l.(,-.:;.1 ;t-1
e-
U:-;lr
6J;rf \ 6)-r*J
:Li:rl
lr-; ;:3a Olalr*a JlrSiiJJ
oJ-j
a-si
j,l .ri]is"
.,--t[i ,ttrj o .3r-
.t.el .9Ul; #
q ;rt _,1 .r*
:K
giL_ -)
u
e L-l ,
v , ,*V3 s; ./l5
J! r-
r
-r-:l
J i r'
"
jl r-.,j
,r5$l t )t
6taa
L!
;-l
o-Li ':i,f ,,rl-*q
csaa-;, 9il;l .c-l
6'o*;a ;:3>
1. cartesian co-ordinates
-rJ--$.1;,4r*l o: r.j:K,_JL:, 1-r_,!.(VV-ttl"Y) Baruch Benedictus de Spinoza.Y
.cSr{a
:je;"
t2;-l ;: J3 r:*l .r-y.-b .5L- !
o*;l-p iL) ), -;rA;
French Philosophes .Y
.5o;3: ;-l.i-
;: JLi-l^a;_Jl 6 +l
,a:j,o
o-C e _s*'lt,JUJ*]+ J du:.-:ejl ;l 4:-S
o[:"-:---[l ;--l ,l .51";L .ry. -r? rl=.t !r:l
(enlightenment)r-:*$l .rs-: l- 6_fus;
jl .rrL'-1 .f::! .-d .r-U .*fu-1" .rJr
=*l
fl.l .rl-,
.5lj olj .j;.L-: .J*i: :11 -$rL-
ai-Ji ;:
,J
t-6a
i-.it_ i
s,-LAL:-l ,tt +-l _:: J:t y' ,-*.t<t s SS-I; oL;_ll ;r,
j lrl.rr r .:*L*
f-
! e*-rai .!
;: .$:.ir
L- c-!UJ*lJ
J J^U
1: t s.S
t,S tf
.r::3r -iJE- {lU-l)ljj J u1) a-z; ,at;
;rK y
L 3 .-r::;l> :r!
3.L;
4. ratitrnalism
tt.':.JS J;--; c*rlJi arlf 44;i r^ jl tf.-il)crl c*3) lr t"f\l 6+.d, ot'(.i: ,r,l-l.f .r"ri
tt.':.JS J;--;
c*rlJi arlf
44;i r^ jl tf.-il)crl c*3) lr t"f\l
6+.d, ot'(.i:
,r,l-l.f .r"ri
oS a-lr ei;j :lcrl3
fi'l
J:;-i
fi
-r: !
Py.P
)a:,r JJ*i e(-- jl t+."1 u-a .l*/
JL.5 a, ,#1." 6Laiyl 1 >;
;L5;: .--.(i,-lt.: .:-q-i .iLt-
--l
,l .-rrir, LSJ) e? * )j
l-Valt
6\s );c 6c14.:1 e^ 6 )-f. d ), e 6ibG rl$1- cJt-- .(" t6-1l
c*:;t
l: )t';:::L-i:cl
ii
6 pr1,l urpl.eLr 6-f;.r-
tg:
:lr,r"
C+3)
f
Gy S :-y- \l:
c-,*t c+U :11'11:
U t, ror^*;; ,
'f t;-)rS J 6>)
,J:J)>:) u*t.-l J .f;^i- 6Laa--cG: 3
r
tl J+
,+l)-t-a u"'L-l
.e.J'.il
q--,
L,'€t
s ,a;;.-,
;)tie
-,til
JA
J
(.)
Jw
9-
\
,:l.5
r
\: k
--a a-
iJ,
aS./t j ti tJt'r O,*,, SLJrit
p-Lil
(->.
(j_-
.\
J
,u)1 .-L-;, J;e {S*;-J .gl;b lP \:t5,_r-l dl+*a 6 lttfit
e-rr .g;:k 1, i1
o;
6 >, os=*t,lyd 6161i;*,^--6:,-l!
";tr;
pP -,> .!,-)rS z,gncl:3[ 61i,, 3 trdlr3l-
t r rr3*i.r: .J.<--xt
,t^r
jU, rr.":;t(1.r, U-.,, lJ k1,Lr;: n(i
qtK:^ oi ,> oS
"713s;.-i
1-^* t<,; 4i
.r-* -t-* t-t' &)l- q .r-i- u,-ru .a=t*.,r
F
.)y::*;r-
e4
&1* L u.!ta)J*.S
.-,i:+.$ <!
"*t+<.-"t-:
j
,JL*<.1 3:re j
rt-.Jl
Jt-Jb"rt
pt3;.^ ;i ;r .J-i:y,, ;r- .J*j g;qL
l. Laplace's calculator
,Jl-r;rt t .r--y )-2,^,r--J-,.JU".J--Y)IS o-Lr.(\AAl-\V10) Thomas Carlyle 'Y
.q9.t:1;l(-l
.'*;<t 6+J
,i3''-i:pi rtrlt-tl't)
;v
Alfred Tennyson 'Y
6oJ;*-'r .6)<\
el-r.;-;l.;.(\A2Y-\A\\) ,tS! "-"U.9;s J{enry Thomas Buckle 'f
.',rr-l 61;tl ul:S
5. rhetoric
4-i Lf--)rt5 .r,oL5; 6IJLL r .rJ .lK; o;L ;,-l ;:'Everlasting
Yea' ; 'Everlasting No' '2
.Sartor Resartus (183 l) gU
.r-l<:t yv ,,); G* .g-t.(\AYY-\vq\) Percy Bysshe Shelley Y
j. i-li J.t<j J )y J eri-^ j; +lU,a-aria cr; ,il.: +fu-l ,l pry, ,tl;[i
j.
i-li
J.t<j
J )y
J eri-^ j;
+lU,a-aria cr;
,il.:
+fu-l ,l pry, ,tl;[i
"r**(,.
.fS *S4
K^t-. JS.i ;: l;
j;.jr
aar;ei
.t-t^-L--)r, f-^ .)!jt";
6 -,LJl :;.2";: Qi a-i
do-ll_1tr J.+
-,L! l-, t u',1^,t cf J -t a-S L+i .,,-y-.,.r- J-J;l .Slet^;r ; I
.6i;l:
.5i";L_
c5o-r!-r: ir- ! f.L^l- jl .r(- .)J-€ JJ;- ,Vn
flj
;, ,,),sr,ue
o-Je
-,l .r=Ll; t6,+a ^zft ;;<.-+-.r-r"f,lU 5a^.-ua
Ly;l
;i
!
,r;l: )J.) G)-j+"-a 4<j,_l F ,f;jl$
.ur UL .5 .rrt<;.a
"Jy
Gr*
-,\ us.j-)3t
aS
-tt-J tl _, -,_:iltL+="^ -
f)i
.i
fJ_j U_ji
a-S ;LJ
-
*-r; "U:
".1 .gl".r-5 olr_(:
)_i
6
.r--ua
r;".:-rl
-rr;r.i.f ! l_: tk+-f.--k+
d)1.; crL"C *;:
6tgla r;
.-,L-_
It d*r.5t-,t+-tlL. 4-5 r:5 *V. lr.r,-r.-F,y 3 -r::;:l:O; l, ,ti
pt--r d-"+j j,l I .q-r.* r;l-r.i --,t^il t j[f 45 jl.:l ,_glorj-o rJ3q.a^
't-"! l;a a5 gL;-: p*-ln,r^j J: S.l
45 frt".r" .tJ .Jtt" ,ro ,54:W 6;l;;r
JIS J""., ;) i---,L.o
Ly
,r-l S
,+^4:,-lL .S -,[5 "i^r;r
[, ,La-i,--:; 3,-l ,u$;lj .pf ,_l .f J"l] l-s )f
dL^-t,.)J, Cl:^ -r*
;,
;;s_ ,$-r-ir o,-r-" :, ;K:tJ, Fl;t tl-* d
6aL_\r,,.glo;lril
'tK
.trrr4lt .J _rl, r 54ri: 1r/o ,g-:Lo
,a
e s)-ti
q UL- .-,--l ;r c)3r c-i>u ;l ""rSi TlGl:<t.go;j. e(;i I
d
jtr+^-^ crF &J^-i 3 .:;L*i +, };
f'rJ
r-
oLS .ya .,;
"rt
J-_! --*5 y' ,,_rlrQ 4(:_l J
)-,r oF ;l l, ,rlLL,rU j
;kili
dl* .!-q
L suoemosition
2. infi nitesimal Catculas
3. Common Sense in the Exad Scienc:es (lBB5).
4J .r**Kl ,:l4,!_, .:;yi^ls ;l.rKs
!: .(trrvl-r,a,fo) William Kingdon Cliffbrd .f
1t
.;;Ls -4t uL5 ;: sl isf-,St^ol"a tl .r51 .c;r,
r"b ,o *iJi 6";L;: .,*-r
.tt-:-, o-t J-jl3r ;l
,,,ii
+;"*a Lr :+l
g
l_j",.
.pl oq,
LS C-5 LSJI o-r.cl! ,r-l {
f*
(.c-l
).a ,:y;.^af
r,j*
C.,L d)Lo 1-6j ,, .r=.L .r-"t(t
k-jj-6 ,+-'; -,L<rl-r gj3, -Jl,r.a j J:orrr gt+,l l; t6;t5 L€.+L 6 i$;r cril3.:1 .:!
k-jj-6 ,+-';
-,L<rl-r gj3, -Jl,r.a j J:orrr gt+,l l; t6;t5 L€.+L 6 i$;r
cril3.:1
.:! ;t--,4
q r-rj
L- r,-: a5 f)f ;lyJ*l .S 6U: i;;f
'5./
.5J,il 5.-Ul 1:)jK
gl-->r 'gla
tit-,J"lSJ
^,$q-'^ 6 €,
"p!
p y
csti 3/r
e;t: cly .,+-rr ,-);*S -&", f *
q .:trrL--, ;1 l;
;+;>.tb;.r- 4 !-s'-5 F:;
oLdl q fl4'y.c 'JL
a-- r'-1
.fJ5jl::*lr
cr:1) c-;, dt-Q ,r.-,1-l
Pv,F ,t"{6.rr_l Og.rcq Sgsf u'-l*l 6lar- iUJ-Jy ! d J.4 .:-lly;l Jl- dti- ! a-
Pv,F
,t"{6.rr_l Og.rcq Sgsf
u'-l*l 6lar- iUJ-Jy ! d J.4 .:-lly;l Jl- dti- !
a- 3 --l;lr
olK-:*;l, a, \At' ;a-51 ;r n(i U p:r, 6rllJ, lJ it.i-t#t5 4<ji
6*5
l1 :1;oL;,5or^-e c---!.r" c*-; 6iL o* ;:,
*-Sl .fL-.l-l
C;L**.: #
'.hE 6 lS &y J: ';:br" fLzsl;LiL--,
C
.tnsir* rJ-,f .fS er
J ,:-* N
a;Q)"r*l;: C^i-: flv-
t;-l;"
:: ,J)J. )t,
dj ;:lr-
y >y t-rLa,-L^n
J\ G-f 6+iJi >L-l
I sl s f:rh< .rt-";: €iO t ,.iJi lls )-f ;*-Jt.-u g-:r-r
J* JL.S
3> ,sl3:-o L-6:,; .rl: ef t p,l3- +q 6 U .,1krt5 )\ P)e
;-l;r 1; .-'15
€\-* 6 ,y.tJr, 'fu ,&:ps\6t rL- a, .:-l
.r*;<;t;r-L; .-si- e P tJ.tt.(\qf^-lA2A) Harold Henry Joachim 'l
2. Merton
3. Haslemere
c**-lL:.r-l -r,--l+ ,):11 c;r-1y ,rr-'\;.(lqYf-lAfi)
Francis Herbert Bradley .f
The Principles of lttgic :c--l ,--; aA
&
J-ts ol3, r,r-- t(l
cio-rt:t: :l .:5
'(1883)
j/ , i-J-i J.l* tc-<;l1 y. ,fu e -&t c-;3 ^-S ,- i.-.",;ty': J: =r
j/ , i-J-i J.l*
tc-<;l1 y. ,fu e -&t
c-;3 ^-S ,-
i.-.",;ty': J: =r
;,ts .JS
n-5 J*ili oJ-.i 3l Gr*
;,;
64-_L .r,_L:;
:l-yt ds -t'f
u,t5
,5laa-Jtl" 64:-r) )3
.,.t; a.Jtt" r3,, o.:r5 ,*r4i Jl e5 lJ .r-L6it,5
Jt-;L;i J) .c.,!*J F^ jl ;J" elt JVt
rl-u; .(,_ lr
lt,;*!
3,r13;L;.r*4 lr-. oL d,/_J+ d lS ai+;; 6ljJ,;)i.<, rq, trftf
ti 5 t+i _tl s )_t -ri-l--;,.-t,
dtJ di 1: ;;K .c-.-L j.> d4^ q niXr,-t
p:3-, eiK J;.
Ji g;oJS qJuil.; dLaJ,Q I l;,yl;i ,J-,L::
";L;:
"rJ
j-r?.c41 .rr5.t{1_," ,*\:
Jt-t 4,i*J-i guJlUn,. aS J;tf 6" JS<
fl+, pr- o:r5 er;,u;g Jl L .-lJ-+ J"-ti q *5;_l ,50;L;r a5 Y.:;13
aS jj<
;l .c*;h., ,-t'\:.5,9-7-:;l:tjl * rrt-r.g3,n-:Jll
J rt:^,J.e
t;"*r-'
;l a5 :;lr F-i dJ* 6
-J;
a=
":i
:;ly
r;;rti igc;n ;,1
f-r
,1t-.:"1 Jqq U 5
JJI),, r-{-l
f{tf
-t
&-:4 ,-t'\:
o[*;,1 ,9.-r.6_o
5oU+ ,iLd."l ji s> 6
tSosi 6:3, .li -rl a-l.ga3":,.dlJri 4i*1,
')-r {
:rS u" ,:t3 r-r. t
t-rll: ;;-r,l ;tK:,o r;13
ot-fu:l: tr .:!o[--, G)_fi f)y .-r"LJ 6o:J),g3,n-Xb d s"t<.^
il*L,y?," i,g1.11"r-il L: ol ,r--;:Li.r.:'l i
*;rLi lJt<_ji 63
^15
re-_U
,-;-+: h.;
.r-i E! .r* ;$l
6
fJ!
ty. ,-*\s dt*:.| 1r o
nLaaJL*n 6ss J r:+
,JUl 6 fi.l
g.rti,Jt<-llarok l 6k_ll*jli
6L^A*i.:t-31 ;r a5 ,rlntaJtoy) .(.,.bJ;1 ;Sl 611l tj t:5 JJ'U
olr,= rr--$11 c---!l-:-r"-l oA;
c5l;r, :;tlr, .(\l,tf-\AfA) Bernard Bosanquet .l
:.:*l ,,, Ci:l
-15.f"lS
. I-ogic, or the Morphology of Knowledge( I 888)
*7<;t
u.L.:lrJ: -;r-lj.:11-e r*
.('\ qyO -\Afy)James Ward .y
3. Wrangler
4. identity
5. order of merit
f*JU.,,-t i s -: : \,.5 s -t f ,-l ,- ,3-!l 9 ;: .,.;Lb,r"-3'a
f*JU.,,-t i s -: : \,.5 s -t f
,-l
,- ,3-!l
9 ;: .,.;Lb,r"-3'a ! $rf
.r+_i, IS.r"
;ro\:
J
J
e
":tg ;
a--
6lr-. a.lS1;,Jl^-rlj ;l 6la-oj *,ltyA
.:fp\:
ot;si tj
(f
f
.:ttoL--, 6 r-2 ,li d
6il,
t.a ;-l jl
.:-9, o's; a*bre Ot--:'l ;r o,^j
d/-A-A -f-"; ol*! 4: g,-Ut^;"l ^S 6,K:.^.r-5 ryiJy";l.r;-Il ;r l;
.JL+I:S .- ,!-&, f -* S frf
-r<, r t'st
l: tF e\:.Jt-eUj
,51jL:L:; L,ot(,;il: lrt6" JL r) dL;,-+.1-<j .t<
€;l
'ro\t
.1fr ;soLf 4;).t G-\, rtQ*;r
J
,:r--i .(-- 6L:r-t ,-Lir3, jS
4S;L5
1\; t-t' Gil t
,ga-*a
rL,l
.:-r ,,Jft u-
;ls
,;Ui
dL^l-, ;: ,tl:l'tj
d,.-:A
,*l
r!trr,-r
; 9-.
oL; ,Ji;, .rJ- t;k r e;U-t-l ol3r- ,5o-r'JL-,tr ir*ll-.1 '4r**
l
,
.,-irLi.,-
l) Jl e)l ry jla:--Li 4*U" Gss 6? a, 41.;13,a f-r
a-S orh!l;3 ,r" ci- dJeE4a : e*J*,U.f
,ildi*-! J-:
n1 6-1
1; :1
5
)) .€f
olK 31 a, c*l o-u 6r*"
ir" tr!. ! n-^ -,1
u.:*
6tJA
.l
.r-iry t.irL-l
)ji
.J1.,-f j >1\1 fi
-u;;tr ;t5 3 ,*
J
,,.1.5 :113
s
*--s VLa ar jLj d.,*A -s, Jrf.'rt*,
s-y ?6.,J<^ JJL-I
:i
1.ll6 t-;i U -rt5 j'-l ,S ii1
.-'y[il
:;1r dL-<,l orl;-
;i ,5";L;r
L
)-/ J) ir-.1 yl .!+-a .".-d"-lq .c-l oriL; Jt.5 q l; ,r-L*:;,r:---a
.**;<;t '-ir*li "!re'.- dP '(\C"-\AfA) Henry Sidgwick '\
Ge-qt JX-rl r.e--li .: i\t-3.t;,f4,rr.('\AfY-\vfA)
Jeremy Bentham -Y
.Utilitarianism urssf ts-l- e-s-o*
-("rr
1ljK;!:, :uS:t
George Frederick Stout (G. F. Stout) -l
.-!y'i,oyk-l &-:>i e:ss+.(lqYf-\^2')
Lj
\Aq\
JL- ;lMind u-L.s"-Ia=" v.tr- 'u*)*t
o)*-)1.,'--"c-l
J,lqY'
"-+i
olK-:-;1.;: ct3l;-l 6e:*l dlrriLx.\q'f u \Aqq JL;l Aristotelian Society
er-.5
-r]r-
Ll , c,-
4. Appearance andReality (l 893, I 897).
j" ui^-JJ JFKJ ?, ,-iJL.S f--*"i \ J.&.(" .-r,lf, iy- ;," ,, t-r,-C -C 6o;l-t-ll
j"
ui^-JJ JFKJ
?,
,-iJL.S f--*"i \
J.&.("
.-r,lf, iy- ;," ,, t-r,-C -C 6o;l-t-ll
t-J -* tc:l 3l .rl:,r" ;<- Ot**"! .:;,, .:r5 -lr.l;blJ, _j;,a- a5
.,"tt
-,--l .*lr.ut
At t.<-; jl,+- 4J Ji
.:,[i -;L, ol; ;l ril-j.,, e5
:l3;., s .,,fJt :r5,-r" otr:l t
,-sU: ^S uS .:y
Jl )r
+(t-e oL^y
JL^J, Ji g iL--,r +- e;13;,r- :3, o:fi o-f
J )J; aL)ot: Jt
.i.t^:r ;1 cis d-s 6 ,S-s* \ oF.<"
:F tlJ ::.-ui[ +:-ib .9.r*.1
Y '
',.!)t;l
f-/r.rt-u"t jl -+ .r5$l 4<ji E fr.s.rS:k-_r -uy +;t5 si
ett
&
"*I ;t5
4-.i dd-,*-t.qt" .il- q "-,1t! \A1f JL;:
d)y
'f ':Yi
u. Ly.-tt5lalt-; G-tK,5-r* ,^t(;l: gL( .ol*il jl ,-*:
o'L, C s e*-S
p {{4*-lJ.A.5tort
ls
)f
-J
J'
v
;:
lrr
J-I
9---JLJ-J'-r6=-.JdL; ? *o+,.:e,,J.-.a>.i
J).f)f
,,ilot-s 4?i cit5 .,,-)\,j-l o[,."- tSs-t t,_r""J.lrlU d{JJa
Jt1-."r
3 :L^e:!l tSs-s t
-,t5 !
aJL*; ;--l c9s-s t
gtl,-S 1tK^^ ;_t
ge--! r
,:i ;ttk
3:-e- r,t-S j,1**;
Lyy
6,oUi e-l-|_r,
\ p
J Jb."."^j J) d.Hl .r-5 l+ pl-u ,.:3, ,|-r, ,t oh*,; y: eril;jf
jt lr" (\Aqt) oi _,1 .ri JL t)
o""t_; 6;;k
rr-*.A ! .tr^a ti-r,i
.J--tjl o:.-. oJ b
ri-,, ,-t'\--: 64--*);r ;lJi
rGi, -r^;Lo, uo,.^5
,)Ji J:*:.-i *
€f
$L-U-i
e'" t f)31 "+:5 t+i 6o;L1s 6,-
.i, L^J-i 45iU" L+t;S Ul_,1 cS_,t-* -l$l:;
15;L* .*L-: dkt:5
. -HJ: 6ta--L- 6qp:-Liryr by.fU fl.r.rl :s.a;" ! "-,l"(; fr,t
:c,r3; S- "4t o_fi.<" jt- .(\qyO-\Arp) John Mc Taggart Ellis Mc Taggart .\
."-=t<t c-!U-r,-l o-.*.1*
+5 .:*l .fl-; ,):a-;.gn:-t; r(-- gU 6-:--.5 olK-:_:l: ;, (the moral sciences) .y
+:iL-;: rri.-Lir 6.)l)
)l ostt-l o-S "+,i r-
Ttts _:: S:L^--;l .:*L*.jytl
r-U-:_;lJJ
.t#.s t s: l1 sj;,u'
3. Darboux's Theory ofsurfaces
7\ -*=lU"r,-t a s -: t \ 6 s -: f ,G-r;lt';!Ui 6"rr., l4 3
7\
-*=lU"r,-t a s -: t \
6
s -: f
,G-r;lt';!Ui 6"rr., l4 3 ,r,5--r k
**
6t-*0 Oe.b
cJ; ;;3,gr-];;
dre 6t-b
1l 63-3 .ri2,:. ,gta
L--
o
:
I;
d *;r
a, 1r,. -f4i-13 oS f t:t*tf
-, Oi e -f-
"-UO,,-; a
-t-.-, VE q UL"j &l ;l "r:
u.d)l
lre ,Lc;+S .tp-lj
.fSl _, :rS
a-5 p:
a- ,
qL
,'r1
,, ,+-4!.lL
.t-y L-f.f tJL*lf o6.i, L oL-e t-h. S
J
JJ
,U-
J.
\
l-,--j ,c*l ;*
r:[iL-J ;l ;u*-l*: 6tt:6 -L;t--, .,*JU,
-P'5 ,-s ,-f -P *
-g'r-ttlS st oL--,
ll.*t--,r^i-: ,#r;Q
S )S u*LL; -, ,sl .r)L J;H \
r!r.:i
;.:t* 5 :;l: JL"i-l r:;*
r-5 !i
,JlilJ
eVy t
&-r "rr^ 5 6,1<s gr.i oL:L:;
l1
6;ei u=^7*^.rri ?-ii lr-, '>;nrrr*.U q
q,Sf<-:,-t-,i
3 t.-5rr
rUi.r.iU.r.;r"i;, jS ;l;Lyy
fl.ri^rl :**aia t 6 fJ,lr
J* W-L" l-; .l5.<-J J-. , r*;-;\J;€a
dlr " St''.r*S
.n:-U^::.;
j.J
7
,"
.-,t5
4-S
,'';^-;
--
,Sta:* ,So;t:-,: G.,l+.pl.
--L^
'
e'-
l_J
\e
\
JJ:SI.^ :;a ql.rJg,; d)_y,, Lyy 6lL_: L-*
6_s.:-3, f+
l. Dini's Theory of Functions of a Real Variable
2- Cours d'Anahtse
3. Gauss's Geniral Theorv of Cuned Surfaces
4. Grassman's Ausde hnuigslehre
5. Universal Alg,ebra
6. Clerck Maxwell's Electricity and Magnetism
7. Hertz's Principles of Mechanics
4l.i-i-i ,rjr^1rti
rla
-ijra-
r- .(\qf .-'\AA2) Sir Joseph John "J.J." Thompson "A
.oJFl -i5,p:a, 11.2 .i-rp ji, 4;oy-V 6or.1 3 u*:t
.cr:,S)) :rL+,: ,_k!: ,rt)r.(l
q \ t- \AYl ) Julius Wilhelm Richard Dedekind .q
.julJu:;L-)
- ut- s: pl-rrrL-1,, t
S 3 t -# .(\ q \ A- I Af o) Georg Cantor
.\'
. ;l)i
.rl ,=.:t,, -r ir-li
r,LJT
.6; :*_F .(\qYo-'\AfA) Gottlob Frege .l \
12. An Essay on the Foundations ofGeometry (1897).