PARTE MUESTRA

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

OPERADOR A
1
2
0.65
0.60
1.00
1.00
0.85
0.80
0.85
0.95
0.55
0.45
1.00
1.00
0.95
0.95
0.85
0.80
1.00
1.00
0.60
0.70

OPERADOR B
1
2
0.55
0.55
1.05
0.95
0.80
0.75
0.80
0.75
0.40
0.40
1.00
1.05
0.95
0.90
0.75
0.70
1.00
0.95
0.55
0.50

T
Tx2
Tc2
2
T1

48.45
41.37
41.33
39.17

N
MSA
MSB
MSAB

60
0.024
0.22874537
0.00575926

T22
SSA
SSB
SSAB
SSE
SST
a
b
n
T(tolerancia)

41.18
0.048
2.06
0.10
0.039
2.25

MSE
r
R
I
r&R
%r
3 %R
10 %I
2 %r&R
0.4

0.00129167
0.18508979
0.15552975
0.24340473
0.343065
46.2724467
38.8824368
60.8511823
85.7662498

0.00091204
0.0022338

OPERADOR C
1
2
0.50
0.55
1.05
1.00
0.80
0.80
0.80
0.80
0.45
0.50
1.00
1.05
0.95
0.95
0.80
0.80
1.05
1.05
0.85
0.80

Clculos auxiliares
T12
T22
273.9025
11.56
235.6225
36.60
273.9025
23.04
783.4275
24.50
39.171375
7.56
37.21
31.92
22.09
36.60
16.00
247.09
41.18

Tc2
3.875
12.203
7.685
8.203
2.543
12.405
10.643
7.385
12.213
5.515
82.668
41.334

ESTUDIO DE ANLISIS DE VARIANZA (ANOVA)

DENOMINACIN

CDIGO

DESCRIPCIN

HOJA CONTROL

OPERADOR B

ESPECIFICACIN

TOLERANCIA

OPERADOR C

N INSTRUMENTO

FECHA

SISTEMA DE
MEDICIN

UNIDAD DE
MEDIDA

OPERADOR

ESTUDIO REALIZADO POR

FERNANDO ACOSTA
METROLOGA

PIEZA
1

0.29

-0.56

1.34

0.47

0.41

-0.68

1.17

0.5

0.64

-0.58

1.27

0.64

XAjo

OPERADOR A

10

-0.8

0.02

0.59

-0.31

2.26

-1.36

-0.92

-0.11

0.75

-0.2

1.99

-1.25

-0.84

-0.21

0.66

-0.17

2.01

-1.31

Xioo

1.340

-1.820

3.780

1.610

-2.560

-0.300

2.000

-0.680

6.260

-3.920

0.08

-0.47

1.19

0.01

-0.56

-0.2

0.47

-0.63

1.8

-1.68

0.25

-1.22

0.94

1.03

-1.2

0.22

0.55

0.08

2.12

-1.62

0.07

-0.68

1.34

0.2

-1.28

0.06

0.83

-0.34

2.19

-1.5

0.400

-2.370

3.470

1.240

-3.040

0.080

1.850

-0.890

6.110

-4.800

0.04

-1.38

0.88

0.14

-1.46

-0.29

0.02

-0.46

1.77

-1.49

-0.11

-1.13

1.09

0.2

-1.07

-0.67

0.01

-0.56

1.45

-1.77

-0.15

-0.96

0.67

0.11

-1.45

-0.49

0.21

-0.49

1.87

-2.16

XCjo

-0.220

-3.470

2.640

0.450

-3.980

-1.450

0.240

-1.510

5.090

-5.420

-7.630

Xojo

1.520

-7.660

9.890

3.300

-9.580

-1.670

4.090

-3.080

17.460

-14.140

0.130

B
XBjo
C

5.710

2.050

Xooo

TABLA ANOVA
FUENTE
(SOURCE)

GRADOS DE
LIBERTAD (DF)

SUMA DE
MEDIA
CUADRADOS (SS) CUADRADOS (MS)

OPERADOR

3.1673

1.58363

PIEZAS

88.3619

9.81799

OPERADOR-PIEZA

18

0.3590

0.01994

EQUIPO

60

2.7589

0.04598

TOTAL

89

94.6471

PRUEBA (F)

0.434

ANLISIS ANOVA % VARIACIN Y CONTRIBUCIN

ESTIMACIN DE VARIANZA
0.03997
2 =
(REPETIBILIDAD)

DESVIO ESTANDAR ()

% VARIACIN
TOTAL

% CONTRIBUCIN

VE =

0.199933

18.4219

3.3937

0.0515
=
(REPRODUCIBILIDAD)

VO =

0.22684

20.9009

4.3685

0
2 =
(INTERACCIN)

INT =

GRR =

0.3024

27.8607

7.7622

VP =

1.0423

96.0405

92.2378

VT =

1.0853

100

GRR =

0.0914

(2 + 2 + 2)
2
1.0864
=
(PIEZA)
VARIACIN TOTAL

ESTADO DEL SISTEMA DE MEDICIN

MUY BUENO

0% < GRR < 10%

27.86065088

ACEPTABLE

10% GRR < 30%

27.86065088

RECHAZADO

GRR 30%

27.86065088

SS A

SUMA DE CUADRADOS DE LOS OPERADORES

k = nmero de operadores. n = nmero de piezas. r = nmero de repeticiones.
k=
3
nr =
30
k x2 2

x
ojo
n=
10
nkr =
90

ooo
nr
r=
3
x 2 0.017
j1
nkr

ooo

32.604

SUMA DE CUADRADOS DE LAS PIEZAS

kr =
9 2.3104
k=
3
nkr =
90
10.89
n=
10
r=
3
x 2 0.017 16.7281

SS P
kr nkr
i1

2
x ioo

3.1673

2
x ooo

ooo

4.20

58.22

58.6756

97.8121

91.7764

2.7889

9.4864

304.852

88.3619

199.940

SUMA DE CUADRADOS OPERADOR - PIEZAS

n x2
ioo

i1 j1 r
i1 kr
n

SS AP

2
x ijo

2
k x ojo

j1 nr

x2
ooo
nkr

0.3590

1.796

3.312

14.288

2.592

6.554

0.090

4.000

0.462

39.188

15.366

0.160

5.617

12.041

1.538

9.242

0.006

3.423

0.792

37.332

23.040

0.048

12.041

6.970

0.203

15.840

2.103

0.058

2.280

25.908

29.376

SUMA DE CUADRADOS EQUIPO

SSE TSS SS A SSP SS AP

2.7589

SUMA DE CUADRADOS TOTAL

TSS x ijm

nkr
i1 j1 m1

2
x ooo

94.6471

0.0841

0.3136

1.7956

0.2209

0.6400

0.0004

0.3481

0.0961

5.1076

1.8496

0.1681

0.4624

1.3689

0.2500

0.8464

0.0121

0.5625

0.0400

3.9601

1.5625

0.4096

0.3364

1.6129

0.4096

0.7056

0.0441

0.4356

0.0289

4.0401

1.7161

0.0064

0.2209

1.4161

0.0001

0.3136

0.0400

0.2209

0.3969

3.2400

2.8224

0.0625

1.4884

0.8836

1.0609

1.4400

0.0484

0.3025

0.0064

4.4944

2.6244

0.0049

0.4624

1.7956

0.0400

1.6384

0.0036

0.6889

0.1156

4.7961

2.2500

0.0016

1.9044

0.7744

0.0196

2.1316

0.0841

0.0004

0.2116

3.1329

2.2201

0.0121

1.2769

1.1881

0.0400

1.1449

0.4489

0.0001

0.3136

2.1025

3.1329

0.0225

0.9216

0.4489

0.0121

2.1025

0.2401

0.0441

0.2401

3.4969

4.6656

PRUEBA ESTADSTICA DE DECISIN

F=
0.434
F0,05 = 1.778

FF0,05

NO HAY INTERACCIN

F>F0,05

HAY INTERACCIN

CLCULO DEL MSpool

SS pool SS e SS AP

MS pool

3.1179

SS pool

nkr n k 1

0.0400

ESTIMACIN DE VARIANZA
FF0,05

2 MSpool
2 0

F>F0,05
0.0400

2 MS e
2

MS AP MS e
r

0.0460

2 0

MS A MS pool

s2

kr

MS P MS pool
nr

MS AP MS e
r

0.0515

MS A MS AP
kr

0.0521

1.0864

s2

MS P MS AP
nr

1.0887

DESVO ESTANDAR s
FF0,05

VE MS pool
VO

MS A MS pool

0.1999

VE MSe

0.2268

VO

MS A - MS AP
kr

0.2283

I AP

MS AP MS e
r

0.3024

GRR VE 2 VO 2 I2AP

0.3132

1.0423

VP

MS P MS AP
nr

1.0434

1.0853

VT GRR2 VP 2

1.0894

kr

GRR VE2 VO2

VP

F>F0,05

MS P MS pool
nr

VT GRR2 VP 2

0.2144

PORCENTAJE DE VARIACIN TOTAL

FF0,05

s
%VE 100 VE
s VT
s
%VO 100 VO
s VT

18.4219

20.9009

%GRR 100 GRR

s VT
s
%VP 100 VP
s VT
s
%VT 100 VT
s VT

F>F0,05

27.8607

96.0405

100

s
%VE 100 VE
s VT
s
%VO 100 VO
s VT

19.6839

20.9570

%INT 100 INT

s VT
s

%GRR 100 GRR

s VT
s
%VP 100 VP
s VT

s
%VT 100 VT
s VT

28.7516

95.7776

100

PORCENTAJE DE CONTRIBUCIN
FF0,05

s2
%C VE 100 2VE
s VT
s2

%C VO 100 VO
s2
VT

F>F0,05
3.3937

4.3685

s2
%C VE 100 2VE
s VT
s2

%C VO 100 VO
s2
VT
s2

%CINT 100 INT

2
s
VT

3.8745

4.3920

 s2

%C GRR 100 GRR

s2
VT
s 2VP
%C VP 100 2
s VT

7.7622

92.2378

s2

%CINT 100 INT

2
s
VT

2
s GRR

%C GRR 100 2
s

VT
s2
%C VP 100 2VP
s VT

8.2665

91.7335

0.0400

ESTUDIO DE ANLISIS DE VARIANZA (ANOVA)

DENOMINACIN

CDIGO

DESCRIPCIN

HOJA CONTROL

OPERADOR B

ESPECIFICACIN

TOLERANCIA

OPERADOR C

N INSTRUMENTO

FECHA

SISTEMA DE MEDICIN

UNIDAD DE
MEDIDA

OPERADOR

OPERADOR A

ESTUDIO REALIZADO POR

FERNANDO ACOSTA
METROLOGA

PIEZA

10

0.29

-0.56

1.34

0.47

0.41

-0.68

1.17

0.5

-0.8

0.02

0.59

-0.31

2.26

-1.36

-0.92

-0.11

0.75

-0.2

1.99

0.64

-0.58

1.27

0.64

-1.25

-0.84

-0.21

0.66

-0.17

2.01

1.340

-1.820

3.780

-1.31

1.610

-2.560

-0.300

2.000

-0.680

6.260

-3.920

0.08

-0.47

1.19

0.01

-0.56

-0.2

0.47

-0.63

1.8

-1.68

0.25

0.07

-1.22

0.94

1.03

-1.2

0.22

0.55

0.08

2.12

-1.62

-0.68

1.34

0.2

-1.28

0.06

0.83

-0.34

2.19

-1.5

0.400

-2.370

3.470

1.240

-3.040

0.080

1.850

-0.890

6.110

-4.800

0.04

-1.38

0.88

0.14

-1.46

-0.29

0.02

-0.46

1.77

-1.49

-0.11

-1.13

1.09

0.2

-1.07

-0.67

0.01

-0.56

1.45

-1.77

-0.15

-0.96

0.67

0.11

-1.45

-0.49

0.21

-0.49

1.87

-2.16

XCjo

-0.220

-3.470

2.640

0.450

-3.980

-1.450

0.240

-1.510

5.090

-5.420

-7.630

Xojo

1.520

-7.660

9.890

3.300

-9.580

-1.670

4.090

-3.080

17.460

-14.140

0.130

XAjo
B
XBjo
C

Xioo

5.710

2.050

Xooo

TABLA ANOVA
FUENTES DE VARIACIN
(SOURCE)

GRADOS DE
LIBERTAD
(DF)

SUMA DE
CUADRADOS
(SS)

MEDIA DE
CUADRADOS
(MS)

OPERADOR

3.1673

1.58363

PIEZAS

88.3619

9.81799

OPERADOR-PIEZA

18

0.3590

0.01994

EQUIPO

60

2.7589

0.04598

TOTAL

89

94.6471

PRUEBA
(F)

0.434

ANLISIS DE RESULTADOS
ESTIMACIN DE
VARIANZA

DESVIACIN ESTNDAR
(s)

0.039973
2 =
(REPETIBILIDAD)

0.199933

EV =

0.051455
=
(REPRODUCIBILIDAD)

0.226838

0
2 =
(INTERACCIN)

% VARIACIN
TOTAL

%
CONTRIBUCIN

1.199599

18.42

3.39

AV =

1.361025

20.90

4.37

INT =

0.00

0.00

6s

GRR=

0.09143

0.302372

GRR =

1.814229

27.86

7.76

1.086447
(PIEZA)

1.042327

PV =

6.253965

96.04

92.24

VARIACIN TOTAL

1.085300

100.00

(2 + 2 + 2)
2

CLCULO ndc

PV
ndc 1.41

GRR
4.86

EMITI: METROLOGA
APROB: CALIDAD

6.5118

ESTADO DEL SISTEMA DE MEDICIN

MUY BUENO

0% <GRR< 10%

27.86

ACEPTABLE

10% GRR< 30%

27.86

RECHAZADO

GRR 30%

27.86

REFERENCIA: MSA 4 EDICIN

OBSERVACIONES
Validacin planilla de clculo segn
ejemplo MSA 4 edicin.