You are on page 1of 65





 
  :
 

    :


   ! 
http://samehar.wordpress.com

2008
! " &'() #$ %




5   3#, - /

3
8
12
15
19
24
32
40
45
49
52
54
58
61

5 #7   3/


"5 8   3/
;) 9 : %,1
!< <  9
#+< )(1
#+< )(2
 01A
" 0;BC
&)< < ,;+F ; EC <D#D
; EC <DG - #D
"&"F H3
*' 9
 33

+ 3 #O Q ) O L .J

 01/  #+,"-*"#

  . Just InTime 8 9:;


4:24  2008 ,3 3"3

:
<) #++ ,1%  9) G (G #5 *"-L 0 [!  ,F .Z  \]C
"5 L \3^ 9  3  #L) #F # Z  (#]"Z ) " !  40
( F `A -$  ."G ,F  #D3aa %F B% #F 
 \]C #[ -) #F "5 ,F c  & - #  #+& .-]C #H
f  d  % #+ ) H #++Q / *" <F 0 ;, .c
L d  3  # " / G )Z  #/ Z [! 3 -.H
!    <) #++ 3, # -- 9 9D D ,1%.-]C
 
<) #++,- ,1%  <) H % 0  ,1)Z #/ , -BF i #+
) H;) 9 : 9 G % ,1   ]Z  ! 5"3 GD  HE]j d1
,Z ) H k ^] Z)"  kZ l3Z c& i;) #]"F C ,Z 1
5 1 "< <) #++ . <) 9 ""D ,1%  % m) ,1 mA[ #) <Z/
 %DF , # H . ) #+"5( ,ZF + #n)F#3i)[/
Just In time /   d1" x+ y3 Z;i   d1" x+  9-L
 ;* JIT H
&< i;F ,A  #,A  ,1Q
Lean Production /  \L   
Lean Manufacturing *" 0\L
Toyota System Toyota Production System 5   3 5 /    3
] # B" H L  #+ . 3  #;* .TPS H
 9D<    % "Z #+,- ,- O )< ) (#Waste ,1%
Elimination,]3     # #FZF #ZA  9 <j #! O  -a
  <F .#+  <Z[ Just in Time # "53 93GD  - E- "Z #+ D3
" ;i ) Hm^/  BCQ] - .,- #+  E <) H;i ,- -"D
 <) H ,1%" k;i  9D3"n+ " .k  <Z[  c;i %8 -"D
, m F #    \]C .#+
[ <Z;i )1
,[ ,1 ] H) JIT 0 <Z3 yZi -  TPS 9 ,F ) Hi - Lean 9
.Manufacturing   ""Z3G  " <) #+ "1 ,3 9&" ,1% Z )H
<  <8%  + #+ TPS d+ JIT .Lean
3

 01/  #+,"-*"#

<) #++ ,1% 5 D3 , 9 ,- (8") #5 ) <) - .,1% <% #5a
 "CZ -jZF 0 7B"  <) #+ <) #+ .,1% ,1% [ d JIT )+
/ ;i ; EC/ @ 8 E:F ;9A9E C 
D  B >?@ A
@?>.
<) #"%+,1%
<) #++ -]C 3  ,1%3 C  &,& #5   3 C  F  ,ZF&
 #Z !  #G   93 0  <]1  H&  #Z .#GmQ 3 C
 -$ #+ & - # #5a;) -jZF <D #%] <) c"D3  mG .yZ;i
,F )< ] #"[  #]Z x&+ #++ \]C c"D3/ ,F )< E]j d1
,Z C ,Z.
*3 ] yZ <) #++ ,1% ,- JIT  <) H;i [ ;i #1 <G3
G  # <F .#"3i; #%)D "%)D3 a\  9 <) #++ .GDF c 5" ,1%H
;i ) H x]+ k  ++  ,1G ;i ) 9 HOn ")Z[3 ]D 
( 9 G< #)1 "F;i [ <! H) 9*3! ")Z < F;)9 :
 % .,1" G , -L 3  D%.

;< "[ , [  #"%+  kF A 9 GD Z <G \A*; ]D .<  0C
 #"%  mQ  [  Z  d  Z \A*;   <*  &FH
 #"%  -"D3 #"%  BF  d a %D3 F #  D  *;
 Z  \A  $  (7  + .#"%< *;    .Z<  .
< &"+ -   9&"  0]CF .m8
  EF% .  Cn*;  Z \A[  ")Z  ;i <Z[3 ]D
/ mF &]3  0  ,1G ] )*; (   ""D ;i -Cn3")Z[3
   F Z  Cn3 *; D3 ," . i; "3,  9F <A!< / " 
] " 9 #)! '1  ,!< / a 1F!<  + <Z"7 m8 !)#
4

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 #%1 F ZL  F  D3 #)D "C ,1 9&" %ZOi;F #)D ]D
#)DF ZL  !" -+"D 0.
 m
 D3 ," c i; c3, ]  9"[ " #A- 9   #*" 0 <
[  D  ]  , L <G  [".-F  3 #]Z;) -" : 
*" -Z  .;i  #%)DF ]  ")Z ]D"[  #]Z9 &]  ")Z
0" #)+ CQa . ,&3  D  ,& ," ,Q   x] #)D3
/ ) ( #+)& - &<  #)D]& -F]+; /  "0
D .;i  <Z[3 ]D 9 GD<  %( ,1  '1  H/ ) <G -
C  -mD  % .,1<  #Cn ,3<  ,3-
 <Z% <  F #  9[  <Z["  A*;  '1#"%
D+ #"%; 9  9 *; ,F .   <)F "1   &F m)1
yZFi *; ;)-" :  7 ,ZF  <)F c  " G i Q 9
*; ;) -" :D ! 9 :); H< *;  0C&F/ 9 <)1 F.
  !) <) #++ # "+ .,1%  <)F ;i , 0  [3!< ,F9 #3
 ;  ["F   #*" 0- ["F " #A-&"+ #3<
 % ,1 ,ZF .-  c <)F;i ,F ] " <  ,1Q  -)&F
 ,ZF .- <) c;i GD !a <* H  H  9;i  D "*); ,1
 9<   ,1*] n8 #)D $ #&O 3;)  k" :.

! yZF Z[  \A  D ,1 ] ] 9  - & d[ A


 9 :); ,"Z"] H]3[ & da "] d"]  Q . )" ;)9 :
 "]  9 ) 9 -Z .  " c!)"  <) #"%+,1%
9 :);"+  % ,1<  9 9 &]  .+ #&C+!)  DF
< 0 l3Z 9. % 9 -Z)"+.,1.
 9 GD Z[  \A  D ,1 Z  &F 0[) # .- ! 9 9%[<]3 0
  Z H) \Ai -  9& , <) #"%+ .,1%" , 9 ! \A ka \AZ
^] Z,&F <] 9 1"Q 1 5 ^ - #[ #)3  9 :);"+ .\AZ<
*; ! D3 H [  mF <) #++ .\A <]  ,1% % ,1  [-)] H) 0
 <G d1 ]D ,] kD)- #3/ ) Qf `" 9 na1 ]D   0j
5

 01/  #+,"-*"#

< "` D 9 Qf1 5  #)! 9 #)3 C Qa <) #++ ."Z ,1%
;) 9 :<  %.,1
 <) #"%& ,1% 9 :);) #5a *; "]  Z .\A< 0C3]C
 k3, )Z%3 c < 3 ]C  k3,<  Z\A < 3  < -%3]C
' 0)3<  "]  9 , -%3 k)Z ' 3 #"%+Z3  k"D *; #%
& -D3 Z3 "]  #% .-m1  - j 9 ,Fm ]C  0 k3,]&93
 9 #Z] #C + *;  -D3& 0C 0Cm1 "]  9.
[ 0 3 /Z #3 &< <  F c H 3 /9)n 9 #3
 .9DD 01a Z Z 9 ,Fm  9)n  9 9* # 9 9
) #,/   9 9] <& 0<.
 ')D 9D3  k c< &F F # ;8 ! ,Z 9 ,F 9D < ]& ," 93#
;8 <) #++ . H) ,Z ,1%  \3%, #Z <F .  <n #)! 9
 Z+ &<   #)D !) # Q ,&3 #"% .#)D -F dOZ
-m  i " - < ]& -[+ 93 m8/  [i   1  .Z," k c
 <) #++ \]C ,1%  #)! '1 ,-3 3F < !< a ;i  9"[
*' *" 9F #Z!< / ;i &, , .Z3+ ,%"+
 9D   ;) 9 : *; 1 7  ! [ F A ;)% k
Z 9 ,Fm  0 #"%( 9 9[  A 0" k ! 9 ;)%
*; <) #++ . H) iD ,1%Z 9F( #+ Z -3 i ,  .
])3 ^)] (  9 #+ Q )i  &  &F #A #F (%!m #+
i;F ]  9  . Z3  0( <!  #+< *" 0 F c,3
 #]+" G)  H . '1 3 ," a <F c 3  0( #+
 .-[" 3 C( #+ , c 3 C  93 -%, #5BF -]C  <Z
 - *! 9j D )3  H  9 #[ .

 " #3-  [+ #F <) #"%+mF ,1%  mF <) #++ .\A,- ,1%
a 3/ 3+ #+m+ <GF    [ " '5 ]&   #)! 9
 HQ  ]&   <) #"%+ .'1  mF #"% #Z3+ ]*+ ,1%1 )#]) H
6

 01/  #+,"-*"#

#]) H) 931 ")Z[+ ,1% )< #++ .#F  H) 1 #F ! 
.#F k &3  `""+ ""D" i; L H) - 9) #F mZ!
,1 % 9 :);) ,3, #5a &#%)%  .E] <DF ,1% )< #++ #%)) 
.J L #   - "#5 , 9 D ,1% )< #++ c .#%);
:5" - -%  3  #L L H) m^ c"D3
Production System Toyota
http://www.toyota.co.jp/en/vision/production_system/index.html

#"* #+,"- / 01 

8 9:   E:F; Culture of Toyota


Production System
7:10  2008 ,19 3"3

 d&O # <) #++ #%)) #F .E] <DF ,1%    #"- #F
, + - "5  9-L 5   3 system Totoyta Production /
k,;+ "Z  - <]1 .# Z  "5 " !  O  H,3,& G
) #G,A   D*  933, 9)Z- 9]C "5.
<) #++ #7) ,1%]" #(#++a
<]1 Z " 8   "5  )" Z #7 "5  ,F-
*]  f mF 7 (  F  , .  mG  9La [, ) 3,
ZF 9)Z) 3 D ) - 9D     cF 9(3  3, mF kF
0[3  &F!, ) H& c .kZ 3,! " ); :; C #++a  #)n)n
"5 O #%)% ]C -F lZ3 "5.
j ) H % :Waste Elimination ,1;) 9 : % ,1 - + #+  
 <Z]^ \]C3 9 <D 9  ! .#+% 9F ,1%%/  <) .#%)D"Z3 ,1%
;) 9 :)Z   ( ,A H .<)1 ,ZF -!"+ )< %/ :) "Z
) %/ ",  )[  k(+    " ,   :  # .#
)<  #%)D <) "Z #%)D"` # #%*F D3 ,1 <)F ,1% D3 ,1 k"D F "`
 <1  ! 9; ,&  .mG " k" )<  H"ZF ,1%  \]C  #+
<) "Z3%/  ,1 <F %/F G ) HL (+ )<   ,1%]<  c 
"5  \]C3  "` "[ Z+  # ,   O +
 + d  3 #*Q.9G
   %,1 " Z  % ,1 !, #]!8  3  - "5  -% -% D
 %  ,1 "5:
-1/ i :Over-Production ,A/ ii; k" `"3 ,A  9"[ ;i 9 ,A
"[ & d*" 0  x]33  1 5 ) 9F  <n D3  ]]+
 #Cn<  Z   <*%F d&O ##F
-21 5 :Waiting Time1 5  1 #ZAO c G 9
 x&3  933, 3  <Z3  '$ c  -) 9)n 3  / ynF
" 9 5! !< /  #!  .  #7 0 \%3 "5<) #7 .
 <)F - ,1%1 5   -F; "[ *' *"i <D #Z 5"31
^ F^  m3 ^ <]1 <3< !) ##  .k)) 9 ,F d1"  c1 5
 -j3 <n 5"3"i <n 9 -" # .

 01/  #+,"-*"#

[" -3  3 ," :Defective Products #]Z "`  xZ  "Z3  k)n
m) k;) .(k" : O "Z3 xZ `" <n  d1  d1 <n
O #1 ^ # d1m )]])^ # mZ . "Z3 j3 !,Z # ] 9
 #Z  :&%"` " ,ZF A- .k<   %5  # ]  ,1 )< ,1%
 -4  ,1& :Motion #  9 \A1+  0j"7 ! #D 9 <Z ) Qf
BF  ,A " - 9D3"n+ "-  "5  BF -3  n <Z ^  d19D
5"3 H  BF  n k  `") #1 'j  &]3 ,"Z . 9 <n ,Z <n
\A1 " &]3* c% 9 # % ,  \A1  ) 0AO d1 dLa ]#
#&O 9 #]31  "%!   9 &]) \A1,a.
 -5  ,1 ^ :Processing <n ,Z  <Z < L )3  H  . D
5 )<  .,1%< <  ; C   -F,Z *" 0"` O#3 < 9D3
]-C < 9D3+- D ,1 " CQ 9D3[ - 9D3  d19 <1
^ \3,;+    "DQ  ) x .<n
 -6  ,1"< :Transportation* 0) #3, ; "[ *' *"#Z
*" -) 3 #Z ^ .#)3 < "Z3 G )"< 1 )"< "Z3&#
;i < 3 H! D3&" [,3,5  .  3  3 " 01  5 <Z )+ <Z
 < &F "< G < F % ,1]) H) # "<
 -7  ,1;i :Inventory;i C ) 9 GD Z <  #)Z
#/  d&O #[  a .#F  'D; 93i 9D a]  9.c
  ;i ]  9 HOn ")Z[3< [ < ,Z  % ,1GD Qa.
  -%  %5  ,1 )<  .,1%; #8m < ! # d1 ^ 9D3 #1"n+
"  ]Z - - ,1< ^ #1 9 ,F 0AO d1 kmn+ 3 9 9D3i kmn+  %,1
Qa.
!< <  9 ,Z3 :Root Cause Analysis "5 ) H" 5 H, ],Z
,-+ !< <  9 D% ." 9  ');3 )+ !< <   Z ,ZF
-L 93-L 9 ');3 )+  0 l3Z< ,[ c . )+ #+< i3
,;+F &,  ], #CF,- -"D  H D%  \Z]+ < <G
; EC <D FishBone Diagram #D*'  Brainstormin 9 D%[<F .
)+  A3 3 ,;3    3F  #)D <D O 3 - -F]+/ 
,! 0" ;+   .m] #)D ! , iA "5  x[3  D * )A
) 9)Z.933,
 015 :Visualization A   3&3 /  D La 9 0[) #&O
"5 a D ," .H  *" <) #++ \]C3 0 ,1% < L   01/ O
[F < <D  ) H" .5 "Z3 ) H"5 1 / [
C ,Z -  9 /  a 9. #"f Q H O  c
9

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 01"- .<Z  !  #<  -) 0O 3 01 + #F,  O1 /  3


F  n O[ Ca  ! d7," ,  O-  )< <D #
,  O- QB  .  #Z c"D3 01< L [F " ! .5 
C"3 ) Q L H ! # )Z )Z  E 9+,"-) #! d )  9)Z
 <F E 01Z -D  #O 3 <Z [ .0 c <  D  +  D
  # O 9 9)Z) 9D3 #&O 8 .# -F -
" 0;5 : Proof Mistake BC a 5 )< ) ,1%*" 0&3 (\L j )H
<  9  0" #++; BC ! 8" , ,! ,"Z .#G    #)D 9
 <   9D ' !, ;BC ' " .kZD% " [" * #)Z #-F
#)-+Z+ "  #Z]C #]+/ ) #+,"-]/ .(Ergonomics #3 kZ]^ 9
H"3 * ")Z C;3La  ]* &F ,Z kCQ ") .# " 0;9 C
&, 3 C ")Z c) m8"  #5,! 0"3 F <Z + BCQ  9/
" .# )+a .poka yoke #FF H3
; C  D3 ," :Standardise work <Z) #+ " ,  9  3 9"% %"F<Z
 ,[ , !, ,;3 ^ <) #3 9 ,1% d1 Q  9D 93Qf ,;3  F %
)+a c . CQ 0O <Z[3 <Z) #+1<  ,;3 9)n  <j )+  D
 ; C  #+ +a  3 C ")8  )D <Z #3^ H  " <j <3,ZF
; C  #+ 3 C 9 9D cF < .9)n
! ; C + #+  ,  9)n #8Q ;] .-" 93i
; C  <) H) , #+n  ) # H"ZF <n"  0C 9i <8
)Z) ]3 dF7 <) . n  9++ 5   3    - )Z F
" m] <*%F k1 L .J; C ,; #+  ,3,& c #Ca 9) #
  9j3 F 933, 03 ] <DF -1 \&3,  "5.
! 5 :Respect of Employees 9)Z   3 )<  9D3  ,1% <Z3  
 9!  #G]- # "5 ]"    ) H <Z[ ,F . D3 D
 933,  3 - ,F CQ H) 9Z /  Z3 -F ) H) 9)Z
CQ /  #1-  933,   H- H"ZF   (  9)Z
  .01 [ <Z) 9D3 ,]3 9D3&* ) H 9 3 C(  )Z3 93 0
) #/ L] <DF1 9D3 ;) #% Z
 01 <) #++ CZ :<Z ,1% #] 3i  933, 01  9+,"-<DF <Z
  3, C; D , / m^m ) H< ) H"- c .#Z]C 
G , 3   01 <Z .k" ]31" 3  #3   x
 01 Q ) H %8 &, ) #%) .<Z #3< ) H #Z]C, %
F 1  3 ) #5  #)8 )<  01  .,1%  <Z "5 D3 k3,
C)+ G  CQ H) 9)Z /   -j3 % 3 -) 9; 1 G
  H 3 -"D H)a3 EQ/ " ,   BCQ 01[ -"D3
 #+< 1 Da "%
10

 01/  #+,"-*"#

] :Simplification E] E L     EC;  -53 E] .#+/


 x&+ #++ \3^ 9/  x)^ \3^ 9!) # # ia &,  9!)#
 #F  \3^ 9 # O  #CQ \3^ 9 ; .EC] *  -53 E"[
D &F #)-+*" 0[ 0  Z3 ! F Design for Assembly Design for
.Manufacturing]  -53 E]&  9]+a &) #<  ] ]+ #CF
!)  .#CF -]  -53 E,;+ 01   #CF O  <Z 9La
F  #)Z .#/]  -53 E )+  3 +a], #C #+< 
]&  9< ] #C!) <]1 - &  H< ,Z.
Z  9D3  :i  <Z  #+    9Z 9F1a ;) #% 3
;)  .#% "5   <D x! ,Z3 <D ) 3 C)<   .,1%"5 ),
   CQ   "[ *' *"(3  #Z   H EQ/ ) k(
 CQa  [ 1" H #"Q+- ] 9F #1a ;) #% -" ,1 H
L .5  9D )<  ,1%  BCQ[ (+  EQ '1  H/  c <DF
- - ] 0 H  # "5 . - #! #]C "5 &
) H 1Z F 3 <D  !< mD + & 9 #)Z#/
 m; BC ]&  9;.C
 3 C)Z )<  <) #++ :,1% ,1% 5" A 3 C H)Z &)< )<) .-
 ,1%"   \3^ 9 H) Enj 9)n,! ," -]1Z BCQ5 9D  ,Z3  3
) H "  5 #)Z #/ / <& #3< )<  ,1%" 0; #G .BC
"5  " 5  A)Z / 3 C  D ,"Z  #)Z  D "`A
.
 ); <) #G : ,1%  # # L Z J  )< .,1%

11

 01/  #+,"-*"#

  8 9:; Tools of Lean Production


6:48  2008 ,26 3"3

,ZF #%) "OZ+5 #7 )< 5) ,1%   3Z (/   #
) #5aa( - #++a "5   9 k"D 8  H,.k
 W) TU(   8 9:;
<) #++ D ,1% , 9  #5 " .8  -OZ 8"Z" *QF -1" 7
  <*%F ! # L )) .k  8"Z #5a:
y%Q d1 : Reduced Set Up Time E]j ; y% d1m  E]j"
/ "` ;)' . d1 E]j  <3 C"O "Z3 #   ]  % 9"`
[! y%; 9 "Z"3 F #])C  y%; 9 F "Z"3;i *' *"0
x&+ #) 9 "Z"3/ .  y%; 9 ,Fm E]j d1" <DF #].
![  #])C* Small Lot size n ![  #])C !,  #Z/  !, . 
![ <   (#])^) <n]   H"Z c" "+ 93i;F 9 GD *' *"#Z
   ,3  <) ,3 "a k)Z%;i   #8;F;i *' *"0
y%Q;i & d*"i;) 0   *" Reduced Work in Process (0
;i  9 ia  #)!F/ a   QaF y%Q . ;i
 <) #++ #%)  ++ ,1%    <*%F k&O%  #F #
 9 k  #F #Cn  7< / ] k D  9  G
x&+ #++/ Pull Production "Z 3/ "F ) H! !) # #
 "F ) #CQ H &, #)! ./ a `"  H F !  #)! 9/
 #D ! EQ #3- H/ 3,D 3 m ./ 9F!< . Z F j3 Kanabn
#1CF  + -!L L   <*%F J 1#
!) E]O[ Quality Control Circles ]  9 <  9 9)n9"%
 ,F #+!< < [  <n* .# &) O, #3 #+< -m1
 9 L/ <  3  <!  <Z<)! . E]O[  !^ , 3 C
 Continuous Improvement  9++ 5  . 3
* # #/) Maintenance Total Productive # 5 (3 #8  H3
! #,Z )< Ca . "5 O  <) 9 9D D;i  9 *'
*" #Z x&+ #++ \]C/ <) 9 ,Fm .Ca  <DF #%]  \]C
+.

12

 01/  #+,"-*"#

   "D[  Group Technology # ^,- #3 *" 0"[ D  #-F
! <) , d1"< 5   Z3 3m;F*" .Cells Manufacturing 0 #3C
 <) H) ,1 <  D 9 Qf[ <Z< [  9 # 9 #  9)n!<
 ;) %" #%"`   -CZ  9  # 9 #)D"`.
 # " # H"ZF Multi Task Employees 'A$ D3 , <Z H) F ,ZF
- #- 9 ,F!, . )+a  CZ3- n  #  ," <Z& ! .# 
"5 ,-3 ) 8  #+ H])C #F[+ mZ x[3 F  D "  #
 #Z- n 9D3 &F c ])C x&F <Z  . )+a  #1m k]
  "DF[  <n 9D3 ! #! , 3 , <nF ".
/  ",-3 :Production leveling 5 5   3 <) Hn c
F  n8  9< "` < 3 D  &F " !/ #  ]  `" 9
 3  <) ., H) ,3 n !% i;F ] <Z[3 #)Z#)+mF  #/
5 ,F !, n ].
   d1" Just In Time Purchasing x+ "Z #D&* ) H;
 / " ,& # #++ .#F -   <) -" ,F;i  3 C/
)<  Z  "[ 8 ) .  H"- c  , <) <G -]C 3 G  93
Z  -Zi BF - &,  )+ ).-
& #F H) #5 5) <Z( :S5  x "Z" 5" '5 9 <Z <Z
D3 &F  8  Ha  )Z  3 Z3+ D3  , D 01 ) <Z"
  % H .d1 F #3C #] S5 H)D  #"F  5" "Zx
"D '5 .<Z
#F1[ ) :Total Quality Control #" m <) #++ 9F ,1% [
)mD # ,3 8 )) .Qf  x&+ #++ H/  9 ,F 8 3  H #
 9[  c .   3  \]CF d1 #F [ ) # #F1[
) 9 #    k]C 1  :&%F "%ia  H"ZF k%"F -["3 "` k*& 3
mQ < !) # \3^ 9 # 9)n .-% 9)C ; Z) # 3 EQ/
 ! #   #)D[ .
 + #5a   <*%F -OZ ,3, L .J
 <) #++ ,A,1%
d]7&Fa " - #5 `A( - #+ L( 9& H a :<G

)<  % x"F ,1]


%  "` ) ) -FC ! 9%8( ;% ] #"[ #]Z
;% d1, ) #]) d1 *"(0
13

 01/  #+,"-*"#

% ,Z ;i


, # #   n/ Qf `" 9
;% Ca ,Z) #%
;%  #%)DOverhead cost #O/
3  #1C#/
%  #])  #1,   ,3 d1&, ) ,3
#+n #F[+ 
& 9(L  H) #, ]  F ,Z c#&F
& 9& #9)Z) #3 "Z

<  \]C "5   Zm& FZ


 \]C "5   ,&3 # 9F&O &3 k"D [ - ]] ,1 . "yZF c
]Z  [5 \]C <Z  9 FO  3;  "  .FZ 9 GD ]Z 
! "  k]C 9D3  GD"  #)G 9 ,F .c #Z1Z+  ]Z "
" "] l1  \]C< "* 5 8" 9  ""D3 cF .#)*%" #  k!L ,"  3
" #1 #1,F a!"  0C    \]C "5   "D &.m
< \]C x[3<  8"Z
 ,1 c)Z d ,  yZF \]C 1  ")Z[3 8"Z  93" <) H) #3-;i
 x&+ #++ \]C/ "   D <) #++ "]^ ,1 ,1%H) <*&  F
 ,A . yZF \]C 9D (3 8"Z  yZF H %)! \]C .cLmF ,A E]O[ -
) <]+ HG ,!  - CZ3 k 9 GD" `A[, . *&) 9D ) H % ,A#CZ
 <) #+ 0 \]C 9 ,Fm ,1% .8"Z
 n3  \]C #+
 9; BC *  \]C ""D3 k   #+ i  "+ x)C3 a :); D
 9 % ,1 #7 n 0C( .#+ 9D, <DF 3 \]C [3&\  kZ %, ,A[3
.c

14

 01/  #+,"-*"#

Waste Elimination..  

 E  ;
C Y9Z
10:43  2008 ,11 

 < "*  l1 Just In Time /  3  5 #7 #F+ #  d1
.,1 % H) j ,1 % 9 :); "* BF " ,] .<*%F #G
/  3  5 #3,) #5a  ,1 %) #%); 5"
/  3  5" A +( Taiichi Ohno " 3  3
The basis of the Toyota Production system is the absolute elmination of
waste, page 4, Toyota Production System, Productivity Press, 1987.
#&%8 /  3  5 9 ,1 % 9 \)C :); /  3  5 +
.1988 4
#FZF H  x[  /  3  5 & ,1 % 9 :); O  # 
:,1 %F \)Z3  /  3  5 D ,) D% 9F " .,1% )< 5

TPS /  3  5


,1 % 9 GD"
<Z  ,1  9 &] x[3
,1 % 9 :); x[3
<Z i" #" &)< < ,F
,%  9 ,%
-" :);" ,1 % -5 ,F

,) 5"
,1"  3, 
#&F ") ,1"  3,  k F
-" &]) -[ ]
9& .-" :);" ,1"  3, 
G <DF <Z
) - < <Z #"
/  ,1"  3,
") 7(  ,1 %< Z[ ,F
]D i;F -Cn"

;#A-" "[ 9 i;


;#A-" "[ 9 i;
G ,1"   Z3 #Z"**'
#"BCF Z3 #Z"**'
<%F Z3
'j  # &9F \3% 9 ,F
`" - &3 <Z^
-    c) 9F )"` #1
 "` 0AO d1 ," , 3 
0AO d1 "<  5 1
D 9 k) 3 < n d&

#"* #+,"- / 01 

15

Qf 5"3 k)n 3


  "3,<  [ "`
 3 xZ *"kZ
] #"[  #]Z *< H
,Z  <Z %0.5 ]#
] #
 E]j"n3 # yZF d1
  ^] Z 9 ,Z3 %,1
* "` ])C \&3 <Z
  ^ <Z3 <Z  . k
0A
& <n 9"  Z ."
yZFCa  9D  Z

 d1   kD)- *" 0


% d1
 9 ,F 8 ] #"[  #]ZH
*%
 d1n   E]j" #
% d1  k)) 9 ,F H,1 H*1
9D
* "` ])C \&3 <Z
3 $ *" 0[0
  <Z3 <Z+ 0F  E&]3
 9a , 9+ 5"3"#
, .9+ k ('+
C ,Z    9 % ,1
n]"3;)-" :

  9 !m  #[, m  % ,1  # ] ]Z     #O


5   3 ./1 5 1 "< 1  E]j  9 a     ]Z,1
 #5a) .#3,  5   3 / <  9 ]Z3 % ,1 x[3;).-" :
 %F ,1-$
! , % ]D 9F #G) #3,5 #7   3Toyota Production System /
 % 3  ,1  -F #5a) ,[ .#3, 3 3,  c  % <* ,1 H*<F .%
D3 [ A mF l3Z  0 %  ,13 ;i  -5  D % ,1<
) H D3 ,"Z .C i; "3, ]  < [ * + #" - E+;i
 H"ZF ]D  k! Z+ , /  x]F QB  .#)D %,&3 D%  0,] #Z
 <) 9 d1  0Aj"< , a ]&  9 )Z m8  % 
D 3 k 3  - kBF #"BCF Z D #Z  d1 0Aj  D+ #Z
) # .<ZF
5 #7   3  #%); /,- -  H-$ <  % .-" :);) ,1-
  F  % ,1 [ 9 ,F --) -  .-Z l3Z "5  !;3 , 9
&,  9<  % #)D ,3,& H"Z ,1  ,1"   3 C) #8)< .,1%
;) 9 : % ,1  [3  5"F 9)Z   3 ./&3 - ;) 9 :<
 %,F - ,1 n8  - d Z  Z3 ZF  D3 F !H) 9*3
16

 01/  #+,"-*"#

]&   9 ,1Q ;) .-" : 3!, D%F ; y% 0[ d1"`  
)< #8 d1" # <]1 y%;  c d1 3 9 Ej m7 H + .D%3 -
 ; y%1 ]&  9 * #  <nD%3  ,! m ; BCD%3 
)< d1*" .0 %D3  - [F  <Z,33 -"D D3 < ) - .#j #1
 % ,1]#Z
" #Z]+  9 %,! ,1L -  3  #:
/ i :Over-Production ,A/ ii; k" `"3 ,A  9"[ ;i 9 ,A"[ & d*" 0  x]33  1 5 ) 9F  <n D3  ]]+
 #Cn<  Z   <*%F d&O ##F
-21 5 <) #7 :Time Waiting <)F - ,1%1 5   -F
; "[ *' *"i <D #Z 5"3 F^  m3 ^ 1 ^ <]1 <3< !)#
#  .k)) 9 ,F d1"  c1 5  -j3 <n 5"3"#
"i <n 9 - .
[" -3  3 ," :Products Defective #]Z "`  xZ  "Z3  k)n
m) k;) .(k" : O "Z3 xZ `" <n  d1  d1 <n
O #1 ^ # d1m )]])^ # mZ . "Z3 j3 !,Z # ] 9
 #Z  :&%"` " ,ZF A-.k
 -4  ,1& :Motion #  9 \A1+  0j"7 ! #D 9 <Z ) Qf
BF  ,A " - 9D3"n+ "-  "5  BF -3  n <Z ^  d19D
5"3 H  BF  n k  `") #1 'j .
 -5  ,1 ^ :Processing <n ,Z  <Z < L )3  H  . D
5 )<  .,1%< <  ; C   -F,Z *" 0"` O#3 < 9D3
]-C < 9D3+- D ,1 " CQ 9D3[ - 9D3  d19 <1
^ \3,;+    "DQ  ) x .<n
 -6  ,1"< :Transportation* 0) #3, ; "[ *' *"#Z
*" -) 3 #Z ^ .#)3 < "Z3 G )"< 1 )"< "Z3&#
;i < 3 H! D3&" [,3,5  .  3  3 " 01  5 <Z )+ <Z
 < &F "< G.
 -7  ,1;i :Inventory;i C ) 9 GD Z <  #)Z
#/  d&O #[  a .#F  'D; 93i 9D a]  9.c
  ;i ]  9 HOn ")Z[3< [ < ,Z  % ,1GD Qa.
*  \]+  % ,1] #Z 9D!]] d , " ;*  D3 D  O mD
17

 01/  #+,"-*"#

;) 9 : % ,1 "3 d 3d


5 #7   3 < /<  % + ,1   d*" 0  xD  0 #1mZ
 93 mZ <D . % -3, 9)Z <)FD  ,1% ) '$  .-
 <Z3 ] <)F -3 #3 -3 )G ,1% <Z 3 <nF"-3 )G #
 '$  <Z3]Z . 9 &]3 <D )< ,F - ,1% m)1! G .kD
)<  <) 9 ');3 ,1%%/
)<  <) 9 ');3 ,1%%/ <) ., "Z3 ,1% ,   )< % , "Z
%/ <) ,3 ," .m8 , ,1% ,Z ,3, " H) \%  x" #59D
  "(3 #3-  <) H .,1% )< %/ )[ B k " , # #AjF
)*  L - (# ;)%.
' 3;) 9 : %,1
  # #7 d&O;) 9 : % ,1   # L l1" J' 3<Z
 0  % ,1;) -" :Z yZFa % ;5  #,   3./

18

 01/  #+,"-*"#

` 8_] C 8Root Cause Analysis.


 6:42  2008 ,15

  <D 5 #7 8" #1" #   3Toyota Production System /
! Z )+ m1 <  9.
)+  9 #Cn  H,
  ,&3 ",! ,   #)D #5a)#3, & <! # #)D  0O H
 ) QB ka #3a H FQa ][   0O  H ) H+" k.#)D
D
,ZFD c  ,ZF #)D " ,Z 0O  H ) k" H+ #)DD . B
d    k)Z% 5 " ",! , 9 ; #)D
 #)D  ] .  9D
, <Z[3  F  H) %C  #)D  C Q ."  ",! 0  #)D &%
i;F ]  0C1 9n  ; "[  D mD  7( #)D H"ZF
 )Z mD ( #+ "  D cF .#)D "C ,1 9 #)D -+ H.-,1 :Q

  [ 3    -  *F/  ,! H #)D


%D3 + H) &F a  #]1Z; : ;La  c #[ .9-  3
a& H %Q <   0)C H) 933,< L H) x3 . c 3 933,
 :G c",! # -F )[i ,
&F <! #< "F ) )Z H  .#*1 O
  <G ! B #,"-  3, Fj3  +Q,+ ) D%3 

19

 01/  #+,"-*"#

]+  (#)D) # Z3 ] 0]CF .x "53 ! #3  H) <Z d
[B !, -F !  .<CZ G  D " F ) #)D x]+, O * <G
 d3i  ^Q d3iF d3i 9D <n  * ];3 9 #]Z+ -a 933,k
[ . 3 F ]+  # + x)n3 -F .95  D  )Z Cn #)D
Cn - )+  <!  #Cn<.
)+ m1  9[
  5  )  3 *" 0;  9 % (Production Lean ,1 . '); a
& #  0O  H ) ]"  k 0 x" H )+ &)< ] x[ ) .#)D
#7 9)Z"  ,! 0" ,3  #)D Q ."   #Cn ,3 #)D,3 9D
" <Z[ ," " -Z QB  x]  #)D 8 "`  H 0"  " <Z %,1
 #%)D    -7B ")Z ""D  . ,  5   3  ,3  " /,1
,3 9&" m8;) -" : 9 &] 9&" c] x[.

  3  #G ! 8 ) ,  H *3 x]+ k - <F  H) k)3< k 9
3 aF #1m   8  H] x[  \ . .D%   8 H
&<. D%. ) H& \]C.\A&< -" 7.  . #)D [
 %;3! ,& m \A! k]*3 , ",! , .#)D
&  D3  -;, Z BC , #))1  9DCQa  9 B]+ Q G " + -
* 5 & + D * D , <Z , x3 <Z  ,F , D  
,! 0" <A+ ; BC )Z  BCQ  <Z/ [ <Z) # ^ .#)3H
.Q!!  H  ,Z; ") x[3 k BC ]&  9] x[  '$  ,3
20

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 ,Z; BC D3 D   .m-  3 #G 0 <Z/ ) H k  9Z]C


C;3 ") 9D *  #)Z,  D3 D '$  9*, xZ .C;3i
) 3 C H #)Z) H]&  9]+a [.#3
 9F # D%),  <) D5) ,1%   3:(/
[,  3 9F )+  0 <Z %) ,1<(   D%), 5 D   3
./
"5 ),
& # 8  H]x
#F
] <C  <8 3 9H
]#F x

:  ,1 <ZBCQ
k]1 :] k) k C;3
 Q

 9 "3,;]  #)3 C Z


]+ <  \3^ 9) %
F 3
]+a  <8 3 -
]  !#
",! , ;;3 BC ;:

5   3TPS /


& # #+ \ZF #)D, [Z+
 8  H]x
 \3 D+ <Z ]<8 3 ," <C
 H] x[ \  D% ,ZF
: BCQ k<Z
: BCQ
ka :)Z   9D#&O
:  H) 9D3cF #3
: < k&\ G3,! <ZF
:  \)3, x3D
, H) , : ]3 O  "#C
k
) ,ZF" 0 #1 :(93Qf3 :
*& D+ )Z <Z
L 3 :7  <D #)D9)Z
3 :G7B  9 , , x3 
 <DZ [, , 3 H) -]3 
 ,3 F )-
L 3 :ZF ,) #)D 9]3
F  c` ,x3
,! 0" 3 :Q \3^ 9 #)D
 i  % #F -A+#F
&% d& 3 3 ,Z
3  01" #1 #)D"
]+a  <8 3 - $ d
 L #CF
",! , ; BC [ &)3 0

21

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 !#1m k 9D3  H


#)DF
]Z    :<Z
] ,"-  L k%33,
d  ,&+
 <L )1
 xCZL ,3 : ,
3i !^  ##-
D ," #)D
 ,3,& 9D3]+a &#
a ; : Z3 &#
;3 k% F3 F3)k
"1  #-%,Z )H
m 1   ]3 
a1 &\A
)+ ,  :#+ ,#+
a a, O
  , :#+]
 E
" :`A< D 3
 -Z <Z< 

) 8  H] Z"3 D x D


]Z    : 
 & #)Z  <3,Z<Z
&3 , [- &3 3 C
 xCZL ,3 :  < 
 3 C[- ^ #3,! 0" <Z
#)D
  9 0 & - # 0" #)+
 7 #)D ; #Z]^ 9 BC] )"
, ;D3 mD C ;BC
"1  -]!*3 -F 3&\A
 3a1  +
)+ , '* :#+ EC; 9<D
 #D A3 30[
 )Z
  , :#+< #1m k 9
n8 9 aF ] *<]1 n
 H"ZF ]D < 3 ,1 <n
 3,3  #
" :`A<  D  -)! 3 <F3

] <Z  <! #Z 9< 3 C


< <Z
<Z
CF ,Z3 <D < CQa -a
 9 GD< 3-) Z
(+  3 C H  <Z#]1Z H
! x1Z3  H!,
9)Z
/  )n   % - )Z
 )n  / 
<  )Z

#+<  5   3/


) 8 ) <! H<  9  " , ;,    - #]C
"5 9 . a EC; : <DF H"&" #D 3B+  5  '* 9
 3/ECQ 3/<Z/ ,D  Q . a + - :- #
22

 01/  #+,"-*"#

0C3 &F #CF ! , -,;3 D  F c "%  D )-


  \Z &F H) 0[ - D%< ]+a
 ) H& H) ,Z - \Aa1 &\A
! #& \A )Z )[ \3^ 9 0  3 #
 D%[   *' 9

23

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 _  E 8

  1 -
 2:39  2008 ,20

,ZF 5 #7 "OZ+   3 <!  Production system Toyota /< 9


 Z "  <! #%<  9   ,] .#G Z+F a #ZAL
Z+  !< < 5 #7  3 C  % .Manufacturing Lean  3 #
Z yZF a   # # L Z J #Fa ,ZF 7c
Z CQ !< <.
-1]
,]3 F + a  ""D + 9 #+ 5 #7   3 % ./  #G
[ H) 0 D%[ ) H #+<   D3 01 ,;+ ]   .-
;, ] ; #FD -,]+a &) #FD #)D) #1! +  #F[,
 O  "i yZF \)Z #)D +   .#&O  D  #G 
]  9 ] - 9 D <F ]  9 "F ".5
 ,&3     " .#)D  )! - l1 D%F B3  :;L -1" 7
,]3    <Q, 7 )*  - 0OQ % ,[ #+ '* ,ZF; 3 :  %&<
 Q &,F 9   k O  c&<  Q D .A  9D , "5
, [ H) 0 .D%;3 ,ZF 5Z c& 9CQ+ 93O " )+BF 9Z !<
.#)D
   ^ ""D #G < Da  H) -F] -1" 7!, !, !<* H
 )! # [ H ";" #]+  -)j ;  #3"-F .% D3  ",+ , 5
)^ H D ,3,  l1< Da  <F .d1 ) #Zj 9D3 9 G c < j! 9
 ;3 )! k " %&< L ka  0O&<   .  k39 -
D%F H  ")DL"  &<.
%! -2! # )Z
   %! 3 #G )Z ! <F .- ) < #;]  <DF  Qf < 90A
;] , 3 8  -"3 )Z < ,!a #FC    <8 k <DL]
& -F % ," k c .# 1  D3 #)D !m+ "3,:
a :;]  #F  !% -F)1 .Qf < 9 - 9F  #G #7 9F
,]3 < ,F ! 9 :;L  ! 9  k]+ 9 .H-! ]Q  aF d <Z9-
 F  ]Q .kj3 Z <-3  <Z ]Q ),"3 # [,   xD<F #)Z
 ]Q ) %"F #C] #( #+ %,Z  #F % %! .<Z;] &
9 "3 [ % #FDa  <]1 9 -) d"7 9 ,% ")Z[3Da "&.#

24

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 :G )Z .  )Z < L  <G #- 3F #)D /F
* # + )Z #"% "F <n [ .! # )Z  D  #]31
H"ZF  -   01 k% <Z 8 <-3 .-Z <Z    D3 01
 H"ZF A Z1  )Z  D Z  #O 01 * d ) ,; H& +.
 c ]  <n* D # ! 01   # <Z  d  ," \)n,"-
.3,
EC; -3 <DDiagram Fishbone #D
; EC <D Cause and Effect Diagram #D )+ , <-+ , ,%   % .d1
i3 ; H) ,3 kBF EC < ]+a &) %3 - #)D) # 9 <
]+a5 #7 0  H3 - c .    3]&  9]+a [ <DL .#3; EC
]  95 k]3 <D   .#D  3 #D #F d& #)D, #+ 
5Z ); C   (#)A #FLa  #A  O F #1m - . ) ] H< EQ
<  9(7 .#A
  <A #F]+a  D #%
G, 9& :  #)D !,  BCQ] [) # ! #  ] ,3
*". 0
xD -1  #)D #D
 -2 La  #A  <[F #1m - #&   #& ) "%<Z
 #F (<[3[<)Z  .<Z ,3,& #)+La  #A  Q H"ZF
]+a [  :<G #A #3^ #Z <Z #f;.
 -3 ]+a ) (#O 9 B" ,1  9La #A ! "    D%
 ]   x   xD ""D< ]+a  ,ZF .#"D "+ c F]+a ]]+ ]]+9D
" *< #)! 9F #F< ]+a &) #!)  #]+a .  H) , #3C
]+ G F3   #8% 8  H] x& [.

25

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 -4]+a &  ,3, ! " -  &3  9 ,3i, #+]&

; EC <D k]D ,1 #D!, 93QF #Z+F k]D ,1 k]D ,1"7 ) '* #.9
 3 ,;+ & + 9 <FZ 3 H) kF]   3 ,1kF
E;F ! .3  , 5 #7   3 H) ,Z /] EL  0 3
 & 9,;+ & +  &" .k   )+a 0C3 &F EF "
 <n .k,;3

26

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 9 ,3i O #)Ga  ) 9 9f)" 9 ; EC <D#D


; EC <D#D
 9 ,3i#)Ga

'* -49
*'  Brain Storming 9 )+ Z ,;3  !< <  3 C)Z
"[ i3 . )+a , CZ3 kBF  9 mADa  (  H 8  x]+ H
 #)D , , 3 C H )"[ )Z.
) '* # 9  ,-3 & ,3,]+  3 . #)D [) #! ,& 93O D
<[ k%$Da,] . [)F #  O ,] 7 ) '* #3 ! 9
&O ]+  #)D !) '* #)[ .- 1 9 <G , i-3 !BF , D -
,F #%;+ ["  .#"7 *'  [3  9  Da 3 <F1 [< Da E
,Z m+ 0C1 Da 9 . 9D QB3! ,& 93O1!  [) k,ZF .k) 'j3
- < Da   3 kDa ]+a ! H 8  H]+a &) # &)
".#]+
)+ *' 5  9  ,;3 ,1  3  EC; 0 <D 3 ! #D +; EC"7
) '* # .9 )+a "5 #G x+  a (Just In time)  3  0[ #G
) H D%[ ) HL <  .-))&  #)DF #1m k 9 c )+ *'
 9 ,Z]3 9& i  * \F+  9++ #+<  5 )<
.,1%
 L *'   <*%F 9  c"D3 .<]1 9 01 ) O ) H EF:
*' 9
F <)& -5Analysis Pareto 3
",ZF -" , ]+ ! ,3 " #)D) #  0j 3 )&< .< ], 9 :);F
] x F H"&" ]Z3 . 3 #CF #)+  #Z [F H"&" .7B [! 9]3 3
< 9 x]+]+a D3 F &O )"  H) x)n] xa7B G 7 .k)3
 + "&" H )" & 7B #] ,3,< ) x]+ ,   7B< x 7 (x]+]+a
! x "]) # !, x  .(7B

27

 01/  #+,"-*"#

-F Z ]+a  5 7B -, 'ZO 7B k -3 . D3 F 1 ,]F x]F
1 ]" ) #! H  x]3 k] ] 9 #CQa 9D3 . +"&" <DF H"x
 #3

  !m ] x !, ]]3  !  9 %80 #)D  9CQa,F .


 &)< ]" ,1 E BF  :;L ] x   x]+ ]x
 !m D .A #CF #)+ -"D .- 7B
 &)< "&" D3 ,1 H ; C  ,ZF # EC; + <D 7B ,3,& #D]+a 
 ")8 EC; 9 - <D.#D

28

 01/  #+,"-*"#

"&"F H  <*%F k!L \]+ 3  01 c"D3 ) 9 # EFH"&" :


F3

 -6A3 3
 9a ], #C   3  -,;+  3 3  d+ .A3 3 -F 3
5 +  H) -FD A3 [! yF #! 'ZO Z . xD3 3
ZF  D3 &F #1 ;* &3  H) 3<  )Z .#++a
  <!   3  D DZ3 3<L H) <3 3 . )L #)D ]+
&)L #    d   + )" <]1 `A ,ZF" %  F
, " )" #O/F % H O 3 + #)D  <]1 0O <! ,ZF #)D O 3
i " #,; ,1 *  #1  + * -F .Z  D   #1#
 #, #&O  c"D #3 O  k)DF #1!,  H) ,3 EF#)D
x]F".`A
 <D  O 3 .A3 3

29

 01/  #+,"-*"#

30

 01/  #+,"-*"#

",; ,  )+a   #F c 3!  n cBF %5 #- "7 #F
 3a c 0O&-F \A )<  "))& <Z[3 #C" G ) H&9 \A
& i ! .*;L   3 ^ H"ZF D% #3 [ ,;+ %D3  A3
) 8  H"[ #  9D %3 3 DZ3 )+  D% ,]3 ,F#+
 ,3,& 7 #)D]+a 71 &< 7" #ZF 7 %" .`A  DZ3 3 c )+
 ) H& \A + *Q   #F D D 3  %  # -%
 .d1
 L  #%,   <*%F A3 3  c"D3 .<]1 9 01 ) O ) HEF
 : 33
 yZFa ; <!  #,<  <) #7 Just In time ,1%#F <D
a   # # L .J

31

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 _  E 8

  2 -
 12:57  2008 ,26

  <D  #Z+ #+<  5 #7   3  ./#


 #F "OZ+a  :#] %! ! # )Z EC;  <D<)& #D
F 3 3  .3 Z # a  :#B+   Q
/ECQ/<Zm3,ZF 1/ m d EC; # + ;).#%
-7B+   Q -
 )+a ] E   0AL E,;+  5 #7   3 <F /  9Q 3
" Tiichic Ohono( +5" A   3 ./ )+a #^]F B
  Q ! <* H H] x&,& , . , <G #)D  #F 3  
 G) , B (O ) EF
  3 #F,   3
"3, 9D3  kad1
  D3, 9D3d1
"a"  ,ZF 
 "   ,ZF    % d1
a yZFa    n]"3 -F "1 aF -F
   aF
a ) #Z   9D3  (l
    9D3
" "a ;]   9) #Z  <]1 (l BF , 0F#+ 93
 9D3  ," '1   9D+ - ) 8  H] x[  ")Z
"Z #3-  #)D   " j! 5   ") .lf ]& ) H H! #)+
" H ;]   9  <]1 l 0F 9 #+ 93!" .k
 )+a ,-3  8  H]+a [ #3, % BF L - &C+ ,-
D 9 (  . )+a ,-3 ( c a  <G #)DF 9"Z
,F <n & i ]\ . )+a ,   3  D DZ3  ) 8  H"+.
G :Q

32

 01/  #+,"-*"#

  '1/
a ",! # -F%  &.
 !, %  &
a &<  ,A
  &< ,A
<&  ka ] [B
  &< ] A[ <DF
3  ka  ;  -)& <]1"#
  3  ; -)& <]1
a i  <Z3
 " ,1] x& . i  .<Z3 )"&<  #)Di  "$ %  '1
/ .  ,A  )+a ] E.-
3 ,1  :<A1 )+a  CF %D3 ( ,  1  :k 9 c%"F &F]+
< ,[+  k -5Z]+ #&O 9D3 8 [F - (+ ; :\8m
)", #  <F .  9 ""n3 Q,  O ]+a # ,Z   9
$.
 )+a &3:
H) 0[ <  -1&, #BF,F Q
, -2 & i]\ 
(+ -3  9 9 x31#)D
c"D3^m )L H - #3i)[/F )+a   H) EnjF -%  3  01 EF:
 L 01 3  #
#C3Q) d EC; -8[, ("i
; d EC O 3 +[,  %" "i  . ;D!  EC ) 3  #7 H
 0AL k"D,;+,;3 .  ; <! ," EC<  O 3 D[,  \]C "i&<
 \" <-3 D" % 9 ,] .kZF  " +  <Z%  "  0j 8  c
, " Z3 D < ^   k 9D3 DB 9 , ",[) ]^ 3 % ."i

33

 01/  #+,"-*"#

  !j  % l1"3 #)D  " " -1 ,  7 -L1 %


&<   F+  %"3 ! ,;+ H) ,3 d #C3Q H) x)n a #)D
, ",& % " .kZF3 9
G:

 ; O  #C3a )< "%  %" ,  H) ,3"\ 9F[-


;) #% <Z[3< Z3 aF #1m k 9   ," 9D3 .% ," c" % #1
"aF %1 ; ,3,& #CC]+  QB& 3,[, ."i
#C3Q[,   <*%F -!L \]+ "i  01 c"D3  c) HmQ 9 #
 EFd #C3Q :
.ECQ -9.<Zm3,ZF 1. Plan ..Do..checkAct #Am
 !, 5 )<  ,1% ^/ Z , #+!< < D3 .  ^/  90F
CQ #A:
,! :Plan ECQ  #)D ]+a
,! :Do <Z )+ &< %"F 1 <[+"`A
:Check !)< ", #Z `A [ &<
m3,ZF 1  :Act #Am  &<   \&3  )C )  Ai m3,Z
 #F )C , a; C a (ECQ) HD ! 3 H 8  H&< .<Ga ",1 d
^] d&<  <]+ H) Ai]Q  .kZF " , 8 ) )C  ]F &< #3C
<Z) #+1,F 1 k"3 9 &F Q ).3 C

34

 01/  #+,"-*"#

i3 )+a H) ,Z3 kBF; <]1 EC" m % %"F <]1# #+
) i3 .#)DF c H) i #+" `A*& / ! H 8  H )C.
 9 01   )+aPlan-Do-check-Act Cycle The :
Mind Tools

-10 + ;)#%
 9 GD + ] # ,; #&O  5   3 #^]F i3!#
 )Z  ) H& 9 .\A +  ,; ,1 ! #Z]^ x:#)D

; + EC)Z :Flow chart ;3 EC CQ  .E] +F #)Z"


yZF  #+ ,; ,1  + ; ECjF  9D ,;+-
 ! # #+< ka -Z3  F<  c #O/F 9)Z " mQ 
  c #+ G    ,;3 ) c .

35

 01/  #+,"-*"#

9 &] #)Z CQ #+ H ,-3 /  3  5  )Z + EC; ,;+


,3  ,1 % 9 ]F 5  O  3 ,1 .,1 % 9 &] #)D x]+
.-" :);
:# 01  9 H) m^ c"D3 )Z + EC; #+  #Z
analysis Process
Flowchart
Charting Symbols Process Flow
Diagram Scatter Q n 0 9i 0  n #1 n O  #F +
.<< G `F ,;+F  3,3 -+ 9D3 

#"* #+,"- / 01 

36

8 ) #1    O  (# #)D D  #)D  7B.#)D


 +; 01  CC Layout Diagram <Z D) &O  + ;EC
 O 3 01,Z CQ  +  9 .<Z + Z3 G ]E
,   O  ; .EC  + 3  9**; \3^ 9 -++
 D ! ," 0[) #& #) .- G  3  #%,   + O 3
 k D(#C] #A

  ,3,&  ,%3 + 9F,Z  9 <Z& ,3,a 9",Z 0O  #]+


 < 9#O
37

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 E] +  #% 1 ; E;F) BC  , 9 G!a(  3 ,1kO


) 3 3  #)D!)-
O 3 + <]1 0O <3,Z ,ZF .<3,Z ,;3 + G  O,- 9
 <3,Z ,F +3 ,1 .k%   CF ,;+F F` #Z]^ x! +
a . j3G  A3 3  0O 3    #.#F
 + ;** # +  m8  #F-D  + [ #Z ] 9i
"  + CQ  +  +  ] 9i-a CQ xF
Instrumentation Drawing & Piping   x&F .  3 k #)D
 H +  #"% -F #)Z[, L/  H5  k   3 TPS / <
 - -"D3 9)Z  + - F #Z) #"% 9)n" * (# 0]CF
 ,  #F Z8 , H) -]3.c

)+ #+<:
  CQ #+<  #7*" 0;  95),1%   3(/
Lean Manufacturing' ;, a  ", # 5 #+<.
,3,& -1#)D
-21 < ]+a ,;3 ,1) #"D   EC; c <D #D )+ B+  Q
 )+ *' (9
-3 #+]+a &) #& 9 # [ ,3,]+a & ,Z3) # H) c  H&\A
 )Z D+     " -,;3 ,1 "&"F H ,3,&  3a 3(
-41 x+&< ,;3 ,1) -"F #   '* c #O/F 9 H )Z
! #;] (#F
,3,& -5 )+ &< ",; ,1) x+ !F (#
-6 9) %") #CQ 0OZ 3 0O; 8  #C # - d #C3QZ
 #D(#ZF
-7"%
#ZF -8",;3) `A  c x+a;)) #% 3(
&* -9&< i a  \]C&< )  Ai %"  ,1
^ <3,Z -10  <Z \FC #+&<
)+ !< < i  <) # 5" 9,1%

38

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 a  iZ  <Z 5 #7 8" 1F 9   3  9  "5 <D .


La  mG .-jZF 0 <%!  9)Z x]+ ++ <!  -< .)<
;i  <& 0<  9 . D%[ ! , <! iA< . ,
  01  9++ ]&  9]+ < .D  #7 5 )< , ,1%
.jZF -jZF

39

 01/  #+,"-*"#

Visual Workplace.. dT 8?



9:12  2008 ,1  3

A 01 
DF ,[  F k <n ) :;3  < Z c"D3 < Z D
 [ 3 <G #/ #)Z + O 3  kF ,[ 01  - .*] #+& c,;+< Z
,< Z D <Q 9f  D O  m ,Z + ,a &\ #]
<Z) #+ %8<  Z) Z a - O   !#F )C a O 
.c
:; )  Z < Z3 " 0 <ZF  3 < Z) 9D3 01  
) Z .k #&O < #F )C a` A"< D kD  #/ #)Z
.#+()  Z #D]L H) `A" 3  H)  3, H) D! d
]\ C "" Z3 <Z D  ) !yZF 0O ) [ #7 #%)  A 01 
D  #&O  <Z :; )  Z  < H) "8! "Z #G<  F .#%)%
  "Z #G - .) Z %Q , H) #G3,! ) Z  H) "&.<Z
m <Z --%3  ,Z EAQ ,"- 0j3 ,"Z .-- -5!m <-3 8  ) Z
," A Z1  D3  <Z 01   E <Z) Z 0j ," A Z1  c D3
#"%  + ,Z   D ," A 01  D3  <Z #[ <Z Z3 
01  D3   B <Z& 3 ," A 01  D3  ,"- 3, xD 
.A
Visual Management #3F / F j3 H3 Visual Workplace A 01 
.Visual controls
A 01 ) A G
A 01 ) A G :A 01  9 * i ,  EF ,;+
[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfEL6h7vlhI&feature=related
/  3  5 #7 8" 1F 0 A 01  #7 <%
 3  5"F j3 H  Just In Time ,1% )< #++ #7 ]< 1 9  
#)+  A 01  #G .yZ] -jZF 0 <% Toyota Production System /
D%F # -" ,3 9)Z & /)  Z   H"Z .Q 8" ,Z
.E #3%" B -,; 
<)3 A L << Z[ .Mistake proofing BC; 0" #GF 7 ]^ E]3 A 01 
 9 <  & 0"*F 9f  D O  m "D ,"Z .CQa 9
#"* #+,"- / 01 

40

]Q,F cF 9)Z m 0O  . 01 0C3 A[F k)Z k)  #Z <Z
1 yZF]1C D #3 ; 93i"`   .  ,[ 01 9 GDmZ 
 , x"[ H) <ZCQa L <D [F O ".5
L    3 dm+ *" 9 0 # #3 #F d #G,A  "3,  #G.#F
 "]^ c #"% ) 0O 9 GD) ! -+am "] .k ,1-$
 c) )G, # c)F -"1])C "])^ ," #8Q  #F EnO,Z 3+
 H) 0A<  EQ O  0 +[  .0A1 !,  :][Z   "- OZ
 +  O ]  <  EQ  k +  O 3  .0A mQ
#7 01 9 A #G) % .#3, 01 ,3 A  a D  :;L  <Z
Z3  :; # )Z <Z & # H  H 9Q . c 0O -+a
&  ,3, Z"3 0A ,! 9 CQ.
8 ,1  :; #)D ,3,& a !  d" n8 #L  *" 0] . 9D3
-F ,* #L ) -  nj1 .  "% 3Q -) EQ  nj F .#L
 Q  EQ 9 -) A ., ,ZF  j  ; E  EQ ^] Z -) CQ.
 ] x  )  H  +  #!  yF -    ! #n
 iZ]C )  3F , 9 9"+ 0jF ,ZFZ ) c"D3 .#Fa ;< ![
&   9D3 &, ."  #1 -5 H) #FD +  .-% c) H%;3
/   ^m  + ! ,]+a.
  01,; A <G #CF <A+* F -j3,! ," <Z F <C"k
Z <  cF 0"*F 93 x[m8/ 0  .<CZ cF  01 #7 ,3 A
 .<Z 01,F k& 9D3  A & #5 H) #5D x  <Z S5 #7
 ! , A 01.A
 01 D A  k< i; #&O 3 ]D  <Z `A/  #&Ok
,Z &  " 01  .k A  9 <A+-$ <   i  9iA
5   3./
 01,F <%3 A  x&+ #++ 0/ Production Pull  H) ,Z,;+
1CF  0O  #Z <Z #D x[3  -["3 d1&.
 ;i *n ![  #])C*mZ[3 n  9 i 9DLa 5") mQ 5"F
),  D3  [! k;i  9F!< / 0"3 &F ;O 9 <Z #3 L
.Q c ,;+ 3mQ*" 0  D < ] - #)Q , 9 !<  9/
[ <Z3 <Z EQ/ ),&3  DZF k  "5 ), !  D < !),ZF # 9
!< .#

41

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 01 A&i%
   "1 #F #]Q  k) #["F <Z #1m D3  '$  .i%&F c
&i% ! k" H%; 9 )Z%Q .  )Z  "Z <F \3  <Z3  k  ,3
5 .933,   3 <Z) 3 /<  )Z #F #CF #3CF  ) .k
"Z3  Z3 <Z < L  9 <Z3 [ k) #3 CQa  9 k"D3 F
#+CQa 1 &)  c . 5  5  3 &, i%  #ZF Z3 <Z <Z
 "5  -      \33 O3  \&  k3 0,- F 3'1
[ %Q.
+  <A+#A
  + -Z[3 <A+ !, :
-1 H) i #)Z#/
-2,  ",! 0 ;BC
-3! # )Z " .`A  ,- <A+ -$/ <  %Q.
-4]^+ 9 #+ - # 5   3 ,3 9&" /L --%3 [F ")D 5
 d La  #CF #A)  d.<j
-5 01   0[) #!/ .<Z[, L/  H  #5 )Z  9 m3,F d 01
a A * 01 F A! # 01   # )Za <Z <  5 9D )Z
   )Z  )[3 9 & + .E
-6& 3, )" `A ,&3 ,1 < #+ 9+  <Z  3 #FDF
![ /  %1 ) #!  H ]+ < #+ D &F 9+  `A #&O  <Z
!".k
-7 ) H 9)Z  -%,  ,[ , 9 GD + ] # [, #F D
E;F 3 m , #F< L ) & + a  Z3 ,1  0& 3, )Z) 03 0
]^ # #F )C # .9)Z  0"3 yZFLa ,Z ,;+F & +
#8Q  <G , E;F #F D) ! /L #3.#FG
-8 H) i[F 0C #3 " 5 , a " #*1 ;i i ,A
#)G
*! xZ*3mZ ) !  <A+ # #%*F #A ;,   [ .""D
Z <]+ H) -" jZFG:

42

 01/  #+,"-*"#

-1[,  0O 3 , Gantt Chart #"i[,  "i; 01  3 7 EC 9" %&
D3 cF  H) 9)Z,ZF #3 " %"7 <Z
`A -2! :<Z [! O  #F/  [ , Ca
, -3 * #-& x
8 -4 * #1  #)D <
EC; -5 <D O 3 #D]+ #)D
L -6 < a *"
,Z -7 ! <Z
- -8 <  ) :; #A1 <DL H< 
<[ -9"[! 8: )&m% 8 1m!
m -10  CQ:<G #&O a  <G 9CQ 0O,& 93%8  !  9f
 O H*1%   + 1 ,Z   A  <A
;i  iQ
 -11%8  <Z #+ D ,1 *1  [F xD D " %  D  # C
   )% &,;+F 3 , <DF #$ % -"7 <Z
-12 + ; : <G <Z +  #+,"-" #
, -13 & j a
D -14   , 9)Z ;,  #- O< <  D    , d1&
#Z) #]"F #8Q& <G #*#
1CF -15 / Kanban  O #/  #F )C ,&"+ " <*%F -
L #1" ," ! J )+ x&+/
-16,;+ ,& # &[ ;i) yZF 93i  <G <Z  3 &F
)( " ,,&  - 8 .#mZF ,;+ < 3 &F 9A !, ) .kF  ,%
-17!  ,& #!  - :*; ,1  1m!  9  # "5

43

 01/  #+,"-*"#

,;+ C; , O   - H) !a ) ,;+< G  a ,;+ -18


 %) i ,&  ,;+ +  CQ  0A  O  ,& 
F-D m+ i  a ,;+ ,!  O  :;
#%); La 93i; 9 O  i;) #CC; #!  0O -19
 % La O 3 -] < -3  -"3i; D  #*< DL + -20
%" d& 1 #F+ #)D A3 Report 3 3 -21

: O  0 9
Press, 2005 Creatin Lean Culture, David Mann, Productivity
Irwin McGraw-Hill, ,Competitive Manufacturing Management, J. Nicholas
1998
Gemba Research http://www.gemba.com/Tool-kit.cfm?id=637
MAMTC http://www.mamtc.com/lean/building_visControls.asp
Got Bondoggle http://gotboondoggle.blogspot.com/2005/10/visualmanagement-in-lean.html
The Visual Factory
http://books.google.com/books?id=SpFk6FJdtXQC&pg=PA289&dq=visual+pr
oblem+toyota+ohno&sig=exxZGf7b3PUQp0u4iNy-CC0RvsM#PPP1,M1
Visual Management and Self Reliance http://shmula.com/462/visualmanagement-and-self-reliance
Visual Tools
http://books.google.com/books?id=kdAMgsRoUE4C&pg=PA111&dq=visual+
management+toyota&sig=g5iYu4PEXhJL329wCUzSKjRwpSk#PPP1,M1
Visualizing Agile Projects http://www.infoq.com/articles/agile-kanban-boards

#"* #+,"- / 01 

44

 Poka-YokehiZ
8:49  2008 ,7  3

, "1 5 #7 8" 9   3 Toyota Production System /  #
"*" l1 ,3,  Z3 F " 0; BC Mistake Proofing  Poka- #F
.Yoke
 0" "Z3;BC
 )+a "Z3,;+ ,! 9 0" <A+ ; BC &  9 .k 1G  c ia
 -Z[ 9D3  &F * ,1 -Z[ 3   0O*& & <Z 3 , 
DL , E& H) #)7  #3A,A 9D3  &F[ + 0  0O! E ,
 0O*& . 9 #)Ga- ,  F \)nF   %F   9 0"3
 %  n ," -)Q - c&3 , ," #A j )\ F  ,
i! 0O  . 9 #)Ga] +&F #C 0j3& + CQ!  d& Z<
)3 # [  &8 \) <]1 cB3)' " %! ,3 d] .
  #G #7 9  #%); #7-  *F 9)Z, ] #7m8 ;BC
" , .k 1 Z #G BF ; BC] &, BCQ,Z &, c
" ;, ",! 0 ; BC & " <]1 kDF ,Z  9&" .k 1 ; BC,1"
)  H,! 0"F ,Z <F k- ; BC5 % .m8    3 1 "Z BCQ" -\3%
< 0j  - 9 3&) #)+ ; C ".kZ
 5  \]C 3  3 D% " 0;  BC ) #) #8Q / . 3]& 9
EF \& <A+ n  #++ 0 H3]  E "5.
 D% Q -]C , C  <Z[ H * "[ ,;) 9D3  &F
C;3[  -]C  c ;,   7B 9 -.F[3
] 0" #7;5"F BC   3/
 )+a 8" 1F 0 HL3  <! <G #G<  9 Root Cause
,! 0" 9&" Analysis  0" #7 .#)D; #7 0 ) BC 01a A ,;+
,-3 #A <A+  9 G!a " 0; -53 A BL 0j ,"Z BC; BC &3 "k
 0" c; .BC c !) E]O[ #7 <Z \3% #9)Z) #++a
<  *, Da ++a " 0;Da .BC  B
 0 9)Z,Z L] <DF
 9 3, ,"- <FG 9 0]"3 EQ H) 9)Z/ ,3 ,1 3,,"- 
3 C "%.
 D  " 8  #G &F #CF 5 \]C   3&3 / ) <D
 <n)n3 ! <DF 8" \]C D <Q.9)Z
45

 01/  #+,"-*"#

]C   01<Z

,;+ :& ," :& #A1,Z #A1 . :&% , -F #A1  9 a  3
B -" , 0j3 n8 0F  #m '$ <   .-*& ," #C"k"D3 #3-
L  9D3"  0FD . ],  #-7( -"D , 
B 9 , "3  k
<   %&3 <Z La 3 9 .L "  dL " #, # 
!c   cD.<Z

C 0O  !  %;C  % <G3/  0"* <D] .


,; % 3 ,! ," %  BCQ 9D F BCQ!mF -) Enj ,
.x]+ Cn kF  %F-D  & ,1%^a.
* ia -Z[ 9D3  &F 0O F! ,  0O*&
 %F-D & Limit switches #3,   )" #  <Z  [i 
 O &8 0O F  "& #F 0 )[ 9 xj1 H  EQ ) c
 '1" # !, ,C8 BCQ i  -F % D
,;+  %j #AF- *]!  <8  iQ  <A  H
"; y%  0%
,;+ , D )B 9 , ,Z *& ) 9  xG d ,1 0C
,;+  %8  <Z #+D  -ZO  .<Z  9 0"3 CQ
 "%
 3 <G 3 Enj &  C   3,;+BC; k]) -
 3/ " # <8 #]+"  #
H) # ) #m 0O *  0C3 D -Z[ ," # <Z ,3
5"F  " ! -"F #] # ,F #3&m ) (c* #
m 0O )  c ," #ia  %"F -Z[ 3 D #1, 0O
 , O   , H) kF  ,;+F a

46

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 O #"f 9; D  Exit  <DF <ZO


,;+  #31 9a*"  <G; ! a ! #ia !#Z]^ x
<Z
0O,Z  )C 9 -E- [ 0< i [F   <Z &F n8
] H  ,ZF[ 0  "Z3    3] .kD  i
n8  9D3 ]-
) #B Validation ,    #5 )Z H"ZF CZ3"5  ",
Q ,]3 1  &8  k  <]3Q 1  9( ,.#&&8  -
; 93i"[ *' *"iQ  #Z !   + 0 , &,  9"`
# ) #m 0O  )iQ H ,"8 ; &F 93i <8;i -
Z3 #mZ  <Z ) k ^) x  a

]C  [ Q

!  HD) C1 9 ]  kF " "+  C 900 3)  9D3
)+ 9&L x  kZ kC . 3  0CF x & 9 3 7D x
9&L  + 0 < k   % k  <*3 ," .C a & #C
9D3 ,&3 a BCQ  a'   #C& H) #m 8   \A+
<3i" #)+C 0 <3i"F ) Ha'    - ) c& .#C \]C
] H) L <A+ 0" #A; BC   D% ,;3 #CF <A+
  #%)D   % #& d1#1
" * f *, 33&  8  c1CF d   "#
CQ +  H) #ZFO !'  9;, & ,3, "<Z) x+
iA
,;+ ; 3m  #A j*& 0" , * ,Z  " !x31 ,
 9& EA ]

 yZF #)Ga c"D3^m ) H 9 ,3i 01  ,3  9 GD 0" #)G; BC
"[Mistake Proofing Center :
'  \]Cc
< "+ <"F #)Ga-]C < 0j"+ 9 GD) !  *" 0;, 9 GD
a
0" #7; BC 01,] A #"F cF 3, 9)Z) k"1 .9 ,ZF,]3 c
[  0]&  9CQa 0O ",! 0 .-7 /  ,F   #^]F
 9D "] 0 9 ++ \]C .9)Z 8 <DF a 9 Q*, 7 (3 9.
   k]C 9 , " <F , ,ZF , -Z] #7 & .-"3  3 C

47

 01/  #+,"-*"#

H x .<CZ m8[ F %  A1  / 9 &F <Z  #)D  ,"


9)Z l1 .,& 9D3  ,&  CQa< B #+ '* ' "1< Z 01 
.Z k]C ,[ , ) +a   .CQa  0" <A+ 1 -" x)^

: O  0 9
Times Pitman Publishing, Operations Management, Slack et al., Finanancial
2nd edition, 1998
Irwin McGraw-Hill, ,Competitive Manufacturing Management, J. Nicholas
1998
The Toyota way, J. Liker, McGraw Hill, 2004
:#)8 01
Prevent mistakes by poka-yoke http://www.school-forchampions.com/tqm/poka-yoke.htm
Poke-yoke http://www.poka-yoke.org.uk/
Poka-Yoka ,Presentation
http://mgtclass.mgt.unm.edu/Stewart/MGT%20462%20%20TQM/Lecture%20Files/07%20Poka-Yoke.ppt#1
Architectures of Control http://architectures.danlockton.co.uk/category/pokayoke/
Poke-yoke, presentation ,Scribd http://www.scribd.com/doc/70149/poka-yoke

#"* #+,"- / 01 

48

 8 9_Z@ 8  liZ 8kkA


 8:29  2006 ,4 3

; EC] x 7B ! , <A+[, ) 8  H]+  . #)D 9D3,;+ 


; <)&  EC  ynF #)D" H"ZF -Z]^ 9 5 9D3 c ;#)D <)& k,
#*;L  #"8  #)D  #]Z  #)D ) .# ;#3i)[/F H3 EC
FishBone Diagram .Diagram Cause and EffectZ+ " )+ ,;+ 
;.EC
 *! 9
 ;,-3 EC  0 *! H]+a  ( ,1  H #)D !) ,] .-
  D%]+a Z   ; H) ,3 EC  D%< ]+a  #"DF
 8  H] x ]+a & # D ,1   .#Z1 ;EC
<-3 j3  #)D O )+a  ]  0 8  H&<  9 . ,A j3k
][3[ H) 0  D%,F \ZF #)D  9  1 &) CQ . ,;+
f
:n +[i a  9; EC '8 #)D !)  - ! .#D #F
 <DF #)D \1;* . " ` L  #"  9 ZG D   9 "`

: F  ,- #F 8"Z #++a # D (7 ) H"` ;<G #,


 #)D :#,Z #F <Z;  #Z+
 \3 < #)D , :,  9]m/ D , x3& i%Fm
, #)1 #)D  #  :ZCZC  ZC  * 9)Z ZCa
 ;#,

49

 01/  #+,"-*"#

:pF x< La (7 ) H< 9 x]+]+a  ! .#A xD c<  ( 7
 ] x  *"Z ] ,Z  L   !) <-  .# ynF x]+"9 5
 #)DF k1mZ cZ1#)8a

@? <)& 3 :< ]+a ,  #; yZF .EC]+a 9D3Z]+ [   #
 )Z !( # ,  ]    x  ."3,] yZ&3 ,1 Qf < & 8
 )B 9 ,  ] .! x yZ]F -"" F]+a &) # ,ZF:&%
+ *<  x]+ H ]+ !#

50

 01/  #+,"-*"#

9D3 + ;  EC j&3<  #)DF #1m k 9 !) - )+a
<ja 3 :;L k+F!  ,  <! 9  H3 .#)D ;5 EC;F EC
 #D  <D #D ; ECD3 .  - )+a <-+,;+ H) ,3
 8  H]+a &  # . .*1 d1 5"  ,%3 k c ! D% < ]+a
, # 3Z]+  3 ,&3 )G k  "1 ! .#-% [
; #F Z H!  #)D <& k, )+a.

51

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 liZ 8kp -kA


 5:47  2006 ,9 3

! x EC; O <DGF #D .Q "  ,3 , ]+  'ZO


  , )F  )Z ,]" . # "3, #FDF 0 7 #)D]+a  .#A   #
 xD 9&" #F<  9D3 ,! H) 7(3  ynF #)D" 9 5  ]   x
 !"  H"ZF )  #]+a    d1 +; EC  ,ZF 9D- , 993
< ]+a &) .#; C  #GG  #F< ]+a  %"F #% )+a .; C Qa 
 ]+a -m 9 # [F]+a  & , #+ .3 C

52

 01/  #+,"-*"#

c"D3 0]CF  'j F]+Q ,-  9 G  D O ; EC <D#D

53

 01/  #+,"-*"#

@ r 
Pareto Chart
6:29  2007 ,11 <3F

"& , !<  - #)D 9 GD]+a "   ,3,& #)D k]+a &) aG
 <]+ H)Z .#G "  , #)D k Z D  "` " [ , " 9 GD
]+a ""D3 H) x)n< 9 # [F x]+&) . 9D,] 93 " !) G 0]CF
)& - [ -  ; <- #3 yZF&)  #3CF #A x[3  \]C< &)
!,  (  F H"&" k" x[3Pareto Chart 3


@ r 

"&" x 3 F H]+a 7B [! ! 9   <& #)D, % .#+G ,1 \F
D3 " ,3, F]+  + <G ! #" 'ZO-  9)Z) #"%   
; CQ  , "` CQ   ')n"`   *F H"&" + .3
)" & #] ,3, Z  9< 9 x]+ ]+a B  QB " #]+" #&, ,  Z
 9<  7 .x]+ #] ,3,&F Z " 9 #L< x]+ H,Z  Z) )D H"ZF &,
"] # Z) #3 " 9 #L< ,ZF .x]+  c xF]+a  ! 9" x #3
) Z ,F aF]  <1aD .Q  H"&" + O

54

 01/  #+,"-*"#

5"F H) Z \% H"&") #Z3+" x[3 ], #[ZFCQ  #Zx] -a #/
!,   9 %60<  "` 9 . O c" #Q 9& B[) ,1"
#/; C  .#7 ""`  9 c "&"H  *   ;
 d  # 1]F #]+a mG 3 - 9 E %3 Z
 9"  ,;+ "&"F H 3 "&" Ha   ,% , ,3,& H) ,3 ka
a 3 d 9 ,F[ ,-   H) x)n]+  d ! .7B 
 "1  ! -j- #)7  O .<  & ,3,a 3 -F #3C
& )$ 93O 7,&3  9]+ ,3,   - 7B    )Z  #1
[,   0 c  3 9,! , :   x"` + #[ aF *
 0 3 Qf    :   ;  +a  3 :mA1 <Z%"3 Q 0+ '
"   0 "`  0 CQ D   x[3 ')n ], .')nF "#1
 G ]" H) #; 9 -"3%F a ) H], x]F ]" ) Hja
 8 m "*].
_@ r h 

D "&"F HB" 3 ], F 3 1 20 - 80 "Z3  k) x!a  %20
 9]+a ] 9 %80  x"3  .`A &\ ,   0 !a %80 #]"F
%20 m)1 '); ,1 9D 5Z  9D!a ,[+ i 9 <)1]+a ]  xD
a]  9" .`A c "&"F H ,% 3 " 9]3 ka]+a  ] 5Z  x"`A

55

 01/  #+,"-*"#

Z @ r 

"&"F HF 8Q  3<  "`   ,% - E #+  - #)D]+ ,Z


& ,3,]+a [" #A L  mG . "  ,3 , x]+;% 3   ZC
 ZC "  ,3, F]+ & ""D  #Z]+a a   , c (F mZ
 9F& 9 9 < ,[3  - ZC  ]  #[ 9 *L +
"&"F H 3 'D]+a #A
" ,3 ,3 ]1 mZ ) B[) ,1 " "[" H H3 * '3 \3  9D <j
"1  \3 <  3 * H) '3 #" F )" , #)+
 \3a7B G  ]) ."Z ") cF B mZ  9 #)+ \3 -
"["F"F )F H"&" + k 3Z ) "1 H  \3a7B G ) c  -
 ] 7B]
@ r 
 liZ 8kkA
 9", x+ 3,;+ "&"F H EC; 0 3 <DBone Diagram Fish #D
mD ,;3 &<  #  %< a  a   -]+ G  9D3
&,3,  .#F! #3CF & D3  9" x+,;+ ; EC <D 8 ) #D H
< ]+a &) 7 #)D) #,;+ ;F EC ,3,& 3]+a a ) c  - 7B
 u ?  t
n]"3QF #3"Z " d& #)D) #)G  #, #+ x[3 c 5 ) H] )H
nF QB  mG .  [  -L! ,  " C G   -51
 ,& +  <G *'   3 /  mG . #+  #% #-
%^a  *3 m F QB  , a -L " ,& <*  " O  9"<G #
 i )%a   "3 .  "Z3 n]"3 k  D  #"Z " #)G A )#
, D , -L "n8 # ]Z ^  < -< ]+a  D3 x]+ , 3 <DF
 G1 Q !,  #"Z;  #,,#+
 u v :
,;+  3" 7B #]+Ca , <G Ca  .-%)D! " H,-  9,#+
]Z  d 3 H) ,Z ," mG .,Z #)D #+  "  #%)D H) iCa
 '1 -]!*3 , +  .'1  ^ H) ,Z  9m8 ,! ," <CZk7
-  a ]Z yZFCa D3 ,1  !,  Z n3  + "F k!m8
 <CZD3 ,1 Qf 7m7  &3 #+!, k!m8/<  cL  ." n]"3 ],
<CZF 9 #+ 97m7 "%)D3  3 "+ '1
x A:tB 
D r

56

 01/  #+,"-*"#

"F H"&" + , B[) ,1 " 3 0[ H]+a  [   *1 :<G  -
 9)n) #"% + #8,Z #/ x]F cG ]+a n]"3 . ," #3"Z
]+a  [ H  D3  D " & ] x [  #]+yZF    mG .
]+a  Hi G  0[3]+ Q  [  #!, x[3 <F D3 " 
 9 0[F "1 ) .<7< ,Z ] x! , F "1<  ;  H-F]+
 #% (3 ,1 c  -$ H < ,Z ] x  9!  5 7B"  "1
< ,Z   <7 <DF<  ;  '); ,"[. #
 n]"3 c] , H D ] x,&3 ,1 c F Q x]+  !x]) #[ k
a D3 ,1 mG . "    #)D 0  x3,Z ,&3 F   d3i) A
(3  H< D  . & D3 # ;%    #[ d3i !  # 0x3
*3  F  xD;%   d3i],! ,1 9D3   <*%" x ]Q x

57

 01/  #+,"-*"#

! y] C ;Brainstorming..T
 8:52  2006 ,17 3

! y] C ; T )+ ,;3 ) 8  HD ,3, &<  #A1 #)D `" 3 C


 ) 8  HD ,3, ,;+ L  '*Z . ,  H) ,3 9D ,3, c
,;+,3, k . )+a 0+ <-+" i3 .% )+a fF

H) ,Z3 D%[ D3 F , Da :;L D   GDF G! ,
!< #)D
 #) <B 3Da  0 ,  ,ZF  HDa  m+ H) ,3 9
 8  HD G
[L/ # , ] **; 9 ;)  #%  #)Z  H) -Z[3
 &< "A-

;  | ti

 " L `" 3 C ,3" ),;+m #D+mF x "  i FCmG.
' ""D3 8  HD G ,3,  "]3! ,- +  ,ZF j&3
-F #1m k 9 ,3,Z "`  9 \3*" 0]& 1  :;L H 3 .kmQ
 3 F ,-  9 !"  3 C H x)Z]3i #D+m ,1" ".#
,3 7& 93O H1 D  3 C x)Z] #D+m #1 O 3L [ 0#
 O  #5!m 0f

58

 01/  #+,"-*"#

1 D ynF" 9 5-]C #D


1 D ,F  #) B - ,ZF-  *! 9Da
! x[ 0Da  ) #3,  ,] ,1 O  9["
  ! ,!a y3 1 , l1"3 #) B - ,ZF- 9
!* Da
,!a 9D3& 93O 3 D ]"D H) # Q -!1 -!1  k%
 %[) <F # 0[3 )+a
   9& #3  #)D1 Da
x[3 3
&3 ,A1 ) HL & 93O) H  C3 ! H) ,
&3 ,A1 ) 0[ H& H) 93O D%1 D G
3 ,A1 ) <[F (Q :;LDa ,F "L H) -1 0[) A
 ]+ <G F D #D/ -1 3 -
-" ,1-F #)Z  9 D3 ,1 *' #+ #+ ^ ,ZF
 D ,3, 9 # [ , 3 ,1 .[)  3 ,Z   ,D G

 3Da !   %   !\ <]1 3 ,1 . [ 0Da #-F
 Da  [ H -"3DaF #AF a [,  .\]C) #)F;  "A-
D3 ,1  #C)+ 9& 93O  & x! H) 93O O  / )&93O
) #C;  #-

T }D 

5 a ) '* # H) ,Z 9^m  9&  1 9  <j%3 k D%
D3 &   93O  %$ .  %$3  0 0 <1
<Z[3 ,1 GDFa #)L #)Z 9 G& + 93O Z]3 D   0,1
D3 " ;  9 ,"3D
n]"3 D3 ,A1[)&"  # [  9Z D% #"Z
, <j%3 ;  #) 9 D%1 Da <j% c . D3 " #D
&, F #)[) 0C1 ) %) H  kFL
 &]Q -3,  93O ^ '*  #)3 9 ,Fm 9 F -m ,#)Z
]  , 3  kDa "7 ^! - !3 ,1 - D ,  9D  1!-
<]1 9 1 Q H '* , .9 O  H) #F[ < 3 ,1 c  , Q
B) \A1 9 , & ,1 93O ] +  ,
 9 ,F 3m  '* #)  9 C;F 9 "B3 H! #3%, 9
[ -   k 7!3 H  #3,[F *'  9])#
, & 93O;**mQF '); -  O ,F . D3 , & 93O
 Z   " mQ  ,Z  G D3 ,1  #Q 9 H . "7 , k
! #]  #L , ] , , 3 ) BF ;)9%
 ! #F Z8 # )D3&O #3&F;  9 -,F   9D,;+ *'
 9 \3^ 9 9D,3 &F #FD < " 0 -Da    kBxD3  #1
) - 0[ 3 7 k+Da #1") -O

59

 01/  #+,"-*"#

" )+ '*Z Q 9 "3&O  ", #3 7 -! 93


[ -Z -&" 3 7 -O Q , 93D Q -Z[ 3 7-O
1 ]  yZ )+a  \F 0[ 3Da ,ZF -%L 9 --F&93O
H"ZF 3 -" x)C3 k1! 3 7 -+ ) xF - ) - Q D.
 !, #  1 , ,3, ;  :  H .k)3 )+a ,1
0[3[ H) 0L . 9D  , #Z]^ H) '1 3 a& 93OF
,)F 9 ')Q x]3 , -,)F H )+a  ! :;) ,3,L % D 
x"[3 k)Z[3L    #)Z Q
*' ,;3 9  a  & 1 D ,;  -  !< < 
,& <! - 3 8 F&F k + &)< )Z
 !Z # < *'  x] # [  9 c"D Qf ;,  % )+a
 kF!, a *< !) #  #)! 91 Da D3 H) , 7B -
 % [
9D3,;+ *'  0 9 <A+Q 3i , ) H,F/ <]+ H)Z .G
G  ,;3 *'  <& 9< ,;+F ; EC <D#D

E t d
Q ) '* # <Z[ 9 5 G[ D% <Z& 93O.] G
 <]+ H)ZG:

)+  #F! 9 <Z[3 - 7&<  Z " #11!  #O


 Q  ,ZF 0jF\A1
 )+a 0"3m  &<   #)D   `" 3 C HO  Hx;8
*'  "Z[3 9 ")Z3  0]  -3,, ) H D% Da ,1 #5Z
  9 B , 'ZO %$
) #]" ) HD " 93Qf Z 9 ,F ,Z #",
!< ) '* # <Z[ 9 " 5!) # )Z k #")Z k3#&O
G  & j Da - 0 *" 7 #5  ;3 1  9D
)+a <Z[3Q  <j! i  9 #8 < F; ,F
1
*' 7B k 9 ) H <G 9)Z3 , ,F/ i%& # 0[ 9)Z
]

60

 01/  #+,"-*"#

T T: Report A33
1:17  2007 ,23 3"3

5  # d1 <Z ,1" ) <8  H )Z <DF O;* 03+ 9
- [, ""D3 . ;*   3 91 m7  9D F ,F D #CF
 -"D #1  #F 3;*  [! 9 #1 3    D !k
'ZO Z  . * 3 #]CZ H3 4   H ]D 3 D3
ZF ^  297   420.
 3 D3 4 ^   <D


_ :
 8  _T
 2006]]+: 6
 :C 
D

..4

  3 D 3  'ZjF O! # ]  9 <D




_ :
 8  _T
 2006]]+: 6
 :C 
D

..3

 \]C 3"*' ,"- 93a -#3i)[/F #FD ,"- 3a&F 9 -#FZF #FD
9D3 0O%)  3 ![ "D3 0]CF .4 % #F 3, kD
61

 01/  #+,"-*"#

 \]C 3"*' ,"- 93a -#3i)[/F #FD ,"- 3a&F 9 -#FZF #FD
9D3 0O%)  3 ![ "D3 0]CF .4 % #F 3, kD

,]3 F  k]C ," 3 <DF

  #1 #F  3 9 ,F 3 Z


c"D3 - #FL ,3,   k]D  #3 9 91 Z
9D3 -  93 & #3  ]" 3 x" H & x) #a & #EF
&`A"F \A
c"D3 - 8 0O O 3 +    3) 9D3 x[F k3&\A
" - H) ,3  `A O # -F
' xD3 33
 3 3  H,F 93 & EC; # Z  3 7 .93<   9 H
0O 3 ,1 .#7m7 <DL 9]3 +[-  &, " k [,  xD .%") "i )Z
5" <DF;*
* ] yZ  3 3 )+ &< < .  k"D 01 )+ %"F 3 #F
)+a , F #+< . c"D c H) 3 #F 3 -% H) ,3#)D
!) .- n]"3 9D #F )+BF 3 DZ3 D%" <!  C< . ,"Z c#F
  #)D O 3 3 )+ !) 3 , - 3H

62

 01/  #+,"-*"#

L - #)D
L - ]+a &)#)D) #
x]+ ,3,& -#)D
- #%"%
, - "%
" <&F "1 ,1 #)D  D3 , Ai  
L - #)D
k)Z  -
x]+ ,3,& -#)D
- "D 0 #)D
<j% ,1  :;) 0O], #3kZj  ,1
 x?   Z> :  Tt x #+/xZD - 120
 2006]]+: 6
?  CA` :T T:`  k k   U -
 n : YZ91 l #]  -
[ k #%  "i 
 ? 9  
x 
 ]D  ; #, d&]8i
  Z]C
yU_9k
 D
 !m%  i  9 H
 i ) 1 #C H  H 
 " ," #C 1 1 H) #&O+

 U

yU ! 
 #+i  & : l#
3 <) #+ :& 9D#"+ 9 l
#+ # ! \  Dl
 #+ H-L
, #+ 0 #;j 
3 9 , #+ #;j 1 
n  FD l #+
B #m+ 9 , l#
 0 #;j 
n+  #+ <Z*' ,F 7B
)Z #/

63

 01/  #+,"-*"#

  Q


_ :
 8  _T
 2006]]+: 6
 :C 
D

 ? 9  
x


yU_9k

 }t_9k

tB 9

8

D ; ]

ZA x E T T:3
,;3  "  9  #)D O  3 )+ !) - 1  #) 3 C
5!m
-  * Z ) 3 3 c"D3 9D& " F m)1 -0 x+"3 F 3
^] #Z O  0  n]"3 9D!a O  35 ]+a 1! ,
" % " .`A  *;  3 #F  &3  La <Z[3 9 #++a3
,
9D3 - D3  3 3 " m*% D3 *Q  3 <3 ^ 3k1
9D3 - #F,3 3 3 ) H&x+
 3 ,1 -* #&% #7m7 H, 9 ,F 9"7 3 ,1,;+ i ZF * <DF #&%
Z k5ZF 8 CC; +
3 ,1 - ! 0F 0O < 1  3 ia ,F ;ZF EC
! - 0O O 3 CC; + O F + , " )"%
64

 01/  #+,"-*"#

c%"F k,A H) Z 3 3 ,;+  -



v;@ :9? 

http://www.gembapantarei.com/2007/04/a3_report_title_pick_up_your_t.html
http://www.coe.montana.edu/IE/faculty/sobek/A3/report.htm
http://leanhealthcarewest.com/a3_problemsolving.html
http://www.leanhealthcareperformance.com/lean/a3.html
http://www.matthewemay.com/elegant_solutions/2008/10/the-art-of-thea3.html

#"* #+,"- / 01 

65