0 Bewertungen0% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (0 Abstimmungen)
3K Ansichten4 Seiten
Funder's narrative is held together by personal stories she recounts, either of the former Stasi men she interviews, or those gradually revealed by the women she befriends. "There is no peace for this woman who cries silently; fragile and broken." "the Wall cut a strange wound through the city. To remember or forget; which is healthier? to demolish or fence it off? to dig it up or leave it in the ground?"
Funder's narrative is held together by personal stories she recounts, either of the former Stasi men she interviews, or those gradually revealed by the women she befriends. "There is no peace for this woman who cries silently; fragile and broken." "the Wall cut a strange wound through the city. To remember or forget; which is healthier? to demolish or fence it off? to dig it up or leave it in the ground?"
Funder's narrative is held together by personal stories she recounts, either of the former Stasi men she interviews, or those gradually revealed by the women she befriends. "There is no peace for this woman who cries silently; fragile and broken." "the Wall cut a strange wound through the city. To remember or forget; which is healthier? to demolish or fence it off? to dig it up or leave it in the ground?"
Frau Paul is the most damaged character in the text. Discuss
1.) Key Words/Synonyms 2.) Turn topic into a question 3.) Your answer becomes your contention 4.) 3 supporting arguments/ideas to support your contention 5.) Find evidence and quotes to support your ideas
Introduction:
Author Title Place into context Narrative structure (p.12-13) Contention and 3 supporting reasons/arguments Consider including quotes that capture the essence of the text
As the Wall cut a strange wound through the city on a physical and psychological level, Funder unravels the painful memories of a land gone wrong. Stasiland offers a careful but powerful analysis of what went wrong in East Germany after 1945, and how it affected the people Funder interviews. Although the author offers no simple solutions, her underlying message reminds us both the dangers of forgetting and the horrors of remembering and as Funder reflects, To remember or forget; which is healthier? To demolish or fence it off? To dig it up or leave it in the ground? Creative non-fiction text; literary journalism; where factual material is shaped into engaging narrative; journalistic narrative non-fictional style; The world Funder enters as an investigative journalist is post 1989; Funders narrative is held together by personal stories she recounts, either of the former Stasi men she interview, or those gradually revealed by the women she befriends.
First Body Paragraph:
FOCUS: FRAU PAUL there is no peace for this woman who cries silently; fragile and broken..
TOPIC SENTENCE: As Funder discovers, many of those living in the new united Germany bear terrible scars from life under Communist dictatorship; Frau Paul is one of them.
Her clothes and hair are neat and she has the tapered plump fingers of a mournful Magdalene. She seems wobbly, a woman holding onto notes on her own life. The Wall Went Straight through My Heart. She starts to cry, so silently it is more like leaking. I look around for family photographs, but there are none on the walls, and none that I can see in the cabinet. She is weeping again, as if she is overflowing. Everything is silent here, theres not even traffic noise. The only sound is her breath. Memory, like so much else, is unreliable. Not only for what it hides and what it alters but also what it reveals I had decided against my son. At that time it was the right decision. There was no right answer here, no good outcome A lonely, teary guilt wracked wreck
I know there are places that I dont visit, some even that I prefer not to drive past, where bad things have happened. But here she is in the place that broke her, and she is telling me about it. Topic Sentence:
Key Character:
Key Ideas:
Evidence/Quotes:
Other ideas: (Hamburger)
Settings:
Funder: MUST be mentioned x3
Link sentence:
*Bridge words to acknowledge author intent. ZOOM AWAY *Link words Help connect ideas you might choose to examine the character before and after the Wall Some smells are hard to unravel.the smell of misery. This seems to me the sorriest thing; that the picture she has of herself is one that the Stasi made for her. She behaved with such great humanity. He does not seem surprised to see his mother has been crying. I have never looked at my parents and thought they made the wrong decision. I admire them for what they did. I ask Torsten whether he thinks of his life as having been shaped by the Wall. I find it hard to tell exactly, in what sense my life has been shaped by the Wall how it might have been different otherwise. He has learned not to play the if only game. There are no people that who are whole. Everyone has issues of their own to deal with. Mine might be a little harder, but the main thing is how one deals with them. People here talk of the Mauer im Kopf or the Wall in the head. But I see now a more literal meaning: the Wall and what it stood for do still exist. The Wall persists in Stasi mens minds as something they hope might one day come again, and in their victims minds too, as a terrifying possibility. Second Body Paragraph:
FOCUS: MIRIAM her story is one of bravery and sadness. This country created enemies of its own children
TOPIC SENTENCE: Funders guide through this grim Wonderland is Miriam Weber, who in 1968, at the age of 16 became an Enemy of the State.
Topic Sentence:
Key Character:
Key Ideas:
Evidence/Quotes:
Other ideas: (Hamburger)
Settings:
Funder: MUST be mentioned x3
Link sentence: *Bridge words to acknowledge author intent. ZOOM AWAY *Link words Help connect ideas - you might choose to examine the character before and after the Wall The Wall controlled travel; the Stasi controlled people and for Miriam Weber, her ordeal As Funder discovers, many of those living in the new united Germany bear terrible scars from life under Communist dictatorship, and whilst there is freedom, many of the Stasi survivors suffered; Miriam Weber was one of them. At the age of sixteen, Miriam Weber became an Enemy of the State. As the puzzlers try to piece back the lives of the wounded and scarred victims of the former GDR, it becomes apparent o Funder that Miriams . Miriams story is one of compassion and courage, and as Funder acknowledges perhaps they beat something out of her she didnt get back. Funder chooses to bookend Stasiland with Miriams story and is able to do so by contrasting the fragile and vulnerable woman she first met, to a woman who has begun to make peace with her past. Miriam is brave and strong and broken all at once
Third Body Paragraph:
FOCUS: STASI though the damage may be less obvious, each of these men are irrevocably destroyed.
TOPIC SENTENCE: Many of the Stasi became imprisoned by the identities they created for themselves.
Topic Sentence:
Key Character:
Key Ideas:
Evidence/Quotes:
Other ideas: (Hamburger)
Settings:
Funder: MUST be mentioned x3
Link sentence:
*Bridge words to acknowledge author intent. ZOOM AWAY *Link words Help connect ideas - you might choose to examine the character before and after the Wall.
Hagen Koch unable to move forward; lives his life in the shadow of the vanished Wall; devoted and fixated on the Wall; will not, cannot let go; he is consumed and defined by his past; a past created by the Stasi. Herr Winz is a man still playing spy games seven years after the fall of the Wall; he uses disguises and insists that Funder show him her identity card; out of touch with the world. Herr Bock interrogates Funder, as though she is being interviewed by the Stasi; continues to wield his power; out of touch with the world. Herr Bohnsack socially isolated and friendless.
Fourth Body Paragraph: *Optional* FOCUS: The former GDR consider the land as a character; Funder acutely observes the monstrous grey of expanse concrete designed to make people feel small.
Revisit Chapter One The former GDR is described by Funder as the dream of a better world the German Communists wanted to build out of the ashes of their Nazi past. It is a land of pure nightmare; a place of surveillance, suppression and brutality. The oxymoronic title for a country with little freedom.
Fourth Body Paragraph: *Optional* FOCUS: Consider Julia Behrend Anna Funders landlady. A woman only part attached to the world.
Chapters 9 11, 14 Conclusion:
*Refer to pages 54-60 of Booklet for other ideas on language, structure, symbolism and author intent. Bridge words incorporate these words when using author intent Highlights, symbolises, signifies, illustrates, reflects, emphasizes, epitomises, reveals, exposes, evokes, implies, represents, proves, exaggerates, reinforces, acknowledges, conjures, unveils illuminates, embodies, demonstrates, exemplifies, parallels, suggests, engenders, encapsulates
Linking words help make connections between ideas within your paragraphs. They can also be useful in introductions to connect your supporting arguments. Furthermore, however, similarly, in a similar vein, contrary to, in contrast, on the other hand, moreover, paralleling this.. , equally, compounding this/ compounded, while
Claudia Durst Johnson Understanding To Kill A Mockingbird - A Student Casebook To Issues, Sources, and Historic Documents (The Greenwood Press ''Literature in Context'' Series) PDF