Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
STEM Series
March 2015
Credits:
Acknowledgements
Contents
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
First, I was born into a reading family. Books were everywhere in our home. My
mother, Maxine Robinson, and my father, Frank Robinson, were avid, enthusiastic
and completely open-minded readers. They modeled the intense curiosity that can
be satisfied by reading widely and thinking carefully about what one reads. Trips to
the Platte County Library were an almost daily event throughout my childhood and
adolescence.
Second, I had the good fortune to find myself in a doctoral program at Purdue
University. My major professor and lifelong mentor, John Feldhusen, was a
voracious reader of biographies. He introduced me to the joys of examining a life in
print, whether for scholarly investigation or for leisure.
Discussion Questions...........................................................................................16
P- Quad: Portrait Study.........................................................................................21
Ann Robinson
Little Rock, Arkansas
Experimentation...................................................................................................42
Additional Resources...........................................................................................50
Glossary..................................................................................................................52
References..............................................................................................................54
Feedback Form......................................................................................................55
Discussion Questions. The discussion questions for a Blueprint are divided into three
sections (Robinson, 2006). The first set of questions, BEFORE THE BOOK, focuses students
attention on the biography to be read and asks them to make predictions. The second
set of questions, BY THE BOOK, includes reading comprehension, vocabulary study, and
textual and graphic analysis. The third set of questions, BEYOND THE BOOK, emphasizes an
understanding of talent development and encourages connections to the readers life.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
STEM series. These experiments should not be thought of as stand-alone lessons. Rather,
they are intended to complement the reading of the biography by allowing students to step
into the shoes of the scientist aboutwhom they have learned. Whenever possible, the subject
of the experiment reflects a theme, concept, or invention presented in the book itself.
Teachers are encouraged to integrate the lessons communicated by the biography and the
other Blueprint sections into the teaching of the experiment as well.
...no species of writing seems more worthy of cultivation than biography, since none can be more
delightful or more useful, none can more certainly enchain the heart by irresistible interest, or
more widely diffuse instruction to every diversity of condition. Samuel Johnson, Rambler No. 60
Children selected their own biographies; however, Hollingworth noted that children did not
tend to choose outside the fields of warfare, government and mechanical invention when
left without guidance. Therefore, she provided a list of possible individuals for biographical
investigation and spent time and money to acquire a classroom library.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
Instruction was organized like a seminar with children reading or reporting orally on their
biographical figure and leading a discussion. Student questions were so numerous that the
class instituted a box for questions not addressed during the time allotted for the seminar.
After working with students for a year, Hollingworth decided that one hour per week for a
year should be devoted to the study of biography with high-ability learners.
intense interest can be guided toward specific biographies for reading outside the classroom
or as part of an independent reading program. The discussion questions of the Blueprint can
be provided to the student as he or she reads independently. The questions include three
sections: BEFORE THE BOOK, BY THE BOOK and BEYOND THE BOOK. Each section is separate
to allow teachers to pace individually guided instruction. Teachers can also schedule an
individual reading conference to follow up with students or can assign particular questions
to be answered in writing as part of a reading journal.
Learning Centers. Biographies enrich learning centers, and the discussion questions
and activities included in a Blueprint can be placed on task cards for a center. The P-Quad
extension activities found in a Blueprint focus on four general areas: PROMPTS FOR WRITING,
POINT-OF-VIEW ANALYSIS, PORTRAIT STUDY, and PRIMARY SOURCE ANALYSIS, including the
analysis of photographs. Lessons include reproducible prompts and facsimiles of primary
sources.
Reading buddies or reading dyads. Teachers can include biographies as part of the
reading buddy program in which pairs of students take turns reading aloud and asking
questions of one another. Again, the discussion sections, BEFORE THE BOOK, BY THE BOOK
and BEYOND THE BOOK, can be used to guide student questions and answers.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
classroom Silent Sustained Reading program (known also as Drop Everything and Read). The
biographies for which Blueprints are developed were selected for their merit and provide
choices for students casting about for something interesting to read. Busy teachers can use
the Blueprints series as a source for promising titles for their classroom libraries.
This Blueprint aligns to the following Next Generation Science Standards and Common Core
State Standards. The information in parentheses lists which activity in the Blueprint fulfills
that standard.
instruction in reading or in social studies. The questions can be used by the teacher as he
or she leads a discussion of a book all students have read. Prompts can be used to develop
childrens writing skills, particularly in the area of persuasive writing which is often included
on state accountability exams. Blueprint PROMPTS FOR WRITING provides students with
opportunities to develop expertise in organizing their thoughts and using evidence to
support their arguments.
paperback for reasonable prices as well as for hard cover texts. The reasonably-priced
biographies can be used as class sets just as easily as fictional paperbacks in a whole-class
setting. In addition, the P-Quads focused on point-of-view analysis and primary sources can
be implemented in small groups or with the whole class.
10
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
11
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
13
Title:
Author:
Michael Dooling
40 pages
Annotation:
Young Thomas Edison focuses on the inventors childhood in the Midwest. In touching on
the best known episodes from Edisons early life, this biography explores the aspects of its
subjects character that would grow to define his legendary career: his passion for science
and self-education, his entrepreneurship, and his indomitable persistence in the face of
setbacks along the way. Although the book concentrates on Edison as a boy, it also provides
brief descriptions of the groundbreaking inventions that made him a household name. The
story is illustrated with realistic, beautifully-rendered paintings in oil.
14
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
15
1.
Most of Thomas Edisons inventions were related to electricity. In his time, people were
just beginning to discover how to use this powerful force. Do you use electricity in your
daily life? List at least five things in your home that use electric power and try to include
something from each room in your house.
Yes, we use electricity in our daily lives today. Answers will vary.
2.
As a boy, Edison was fascinated with performing experiments. What is an experiment?
Why do people perform experiments?
An experiment is a series of scientific tests that a person performs so that he
or she can learn something about the world. Experiments tell us whether our
ideas about the world are correct or not.
3.
This book is called Young Thomas Edison because it focuses on Edison as a boy and a
young man. Why might a biography focus on a persons early life?
A biography might focus on a persons childhood because understanding
the experiences and personality of a person as a child can teach us about the
person when they are grown.
4.
The text on the inside front sleeve describes Edison as Americas greatest inventor and
entrepreneur. What is an entrepreneur? How might being an inventor help someone to also
become an entrepreneur?
An entrepreneur is someone who starts their own business. An inventor might
start a business to sell the things he or she invents.
5.
One of Edisons most famous quotes is that genius is one percent inspiration, ninetynine percent perspiration. Explain this quote. Do you agree with it?
This quote means that much hard work and persistence is required to create
extraordinary new things. Genius is more about dedication and hard work
than it is about having a single brilliant idea. Answers will vary.
16
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
By the Book
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
1.
As a boy, Al did not do well in school. What were two reasons why? What happened as
a result of his poor schoolwork? Do you think Al was happy with this outcome? Why or why
not?
Al did poorly in school because he had hearing problems, because he tended
to daydream, and because school moved too slowly for him. As a result, his
teacher considered him addled, or not very bright. This led Als mother to
teach him lessons at home instead. Al very much enjoyed reading and learning
on his own, so it is likely he was happy to stay home from school.
2.
What was Als first business, and where did it operate? How did he later expand this
business?
Als first business was selling newspapers on the train that ran from Port Huron
(where his family lived) to Detroit, Michigan, the Grand Trunk Railway. He later
began selling fruits and candies to passengers on the train and eventually
began printing his own paper, which he called The Weekly Herald.
3.
Even though Al began working at an early age, he continued to educate himself. How
did he use his business to further his self-education? What accident put a stop to his job?
Al used the money he earned to continue his experiments. Because he worked
on a train that traveled to Detroit, he also spent hours each day reading at the
city library and performing experiments in a laboratory that he installed in
a train car. His job ended when a bottle of phosphorus a chemical that will
easily catch on fire exploded and started a fire on the train.
4.
As a teenager, Al worked as a telegraph operator and learned Morse code, a type of
alphabet made of long and short taps. The telegraph was the first device that allowed people
to send messages over long distances, and in Als time it had become extremely popular.
Why do you think people found it to be so important?
The telegraph was extremely important because it allowed people to
communicate over long distances.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
17
By the Book
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
5.
Towards the end of the book, the author stops calling the main character Al and
begins calling him Thomas instead. Why does the author do this? What changes happen in
Als life around this time? What does the name change suggest about Al at this point in his
life?
The author begins referring to Edison by his first name at the point in the plot
when he moves to Boston, Massachusetts to begin his career as an inventor.
The book tells us that Edison himself began using his first name at that point in
his life. The name change suggests that the character is growing up and is no
longer a child.
6.
According to the book, who was the most influential person in Thomas Edisons early
life? How did this person encourage him? Do you think he would have become an inventor
without this person? Why or why not?
Edisons mother was probably the biggest influence on his early life. She taught
him to ask questions constantly, such as What is this? Why does that happen?
How does it happen? Answers to the last questions will vary.
7.
Read about the inventions described on the last several pages of the book. Do any
of the devices shown look like things you use in your everyday life? Pick one invention and
describe how the modern-day version of the device is different from Edisons version.
Answers will vary.
1.
Considering his interests as a child, do you think Edison was happy as an adult? Why or
why not?
Because he loved to experiment and learn, it is likely that Edison was happy as
an adult. He was able to turn his passion for science into a career as an inventor.
2.
Edisons experiments usually did not work right at first. How did he respond to his own
failures? Do you think it is common for scientists to try many different solutions to a problem
before they find one that works?
When his experiments went poorly, Edison would always keep trying. He never
gave up, even when faced with disappointments. Scientists almost always have
to try many different solutions before they solve a problem.
3.
Edison began losing his hearing as a young boy and was almost deaf by the time he
reached his mid-twenties. How did this affect his life? In what ways can a disability in one
area encourage a person to improve in another area? Give at least one example.
Edison said that his hearing loss let him tune out the world, which helped
him to concentrate. This may have made him an even better scientist. People
with other disabilities often compensate by learning new skills for example,
people who are blind may learn to hear extremely well, and people without the
use of their legs may develop greater upper-body strength. Answers will vary.
4.
The telegraph is no longer used anywhere in the US because it has become obsolete,
meaning that it has been replaced by better technology. What do we use today for longdistance communication? Why are these methods better than the telegraph? Does the fact
that the telegraph is now obsolete mean that it was not actually an important invention?
Why or why not?
Today, we use the telephone and the internet for most of our long-distance
communication. These methods allow spoken or written language to be sent
directly from person to person, rather than requiring Morse code. However,
the telegraph was still a very important invention because it greatly affected
history during the period when it was widely used. It also helped better
technologies (such as the telephone and internet) to be later developed.
18
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
19
5.
If Thomas Edison were a young boy today, how do you think his life would be
different? Do you think he would be experimenting with telegraphs and chemicals, or would
he instead be experimenting with something different? What sort of things might he be
interested in? Why?
If he were a boy in our world, Edison would probably be more interested in
newer, cutting edge sciences. He might be interested in studying computers
and other digital devices, robotics, biotechnology, nanotechnology, or green
energy.
Portrait Study
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
This famous photograph of Thomas Edison appeared in the New York Times in 1888 while
the inventor was working on improving the phonograph. Edison had been working without
sleep for three days straight when the picture was taken! Analyze this portrait by answering
the prompts on the following page.
6.
When electric lights were introduced, many people thought that electricity was too
dangerous to be used in their homes and other buildings. Edison helped to create a system
of wiring that made electricity safe for home use. However, today we have other concerns
about electricity specifically, we are worried about how our use of energy may be harming
the planet. What are these concerns? What are scientists today doing to improve the way we
use energy?
Today, we are concerned that our use of energy is polluting the air and causing
global warming. Scientists are working on ways of creating energy that cause
less pollution and are less harmful to the earth.
7.
Think again about what it means to be an entrepreneur and what it means to be an
inventor. Edison was both, but not all inventors are also entrepreneurs. Likewise, not all
entrepreneurs are inventors. Create a Venn diagram listing qualities you would expect to find
in an inventor and those you would expect to find in an entrepreneur.
Answers for inventor may include: curiosity, science ability, math skills, a love
of reading, being good with tools. Answers for entrepreneur may include:
ambition, willfulness, being good with people. Answers for both may include:
creativity, persistence, intelligence.
CCSS alignment: This activity fulfills guidelines of the CCSS. See pages 1112.
Courtesy of U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Edison National Historic Site. Image
retrieved July 9, 2009 from http://www.nal.usda.gov/exhibits/speccoll/items/show/1070
Portrait Study, designed at the Jodie MahonCenter for Gifted Education is adapted from Morris, S., Teachers Guide to
Using Portraits, English Heritage, 1989.
20
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
21
Portrait Study
FACE
Explain the persons
facial expression
or mood.
CLUES
The act of studying portraiture encourages students to think of the subject of a biography as
a real human being. Students should first be introduced to the idea of a portrait as a study
of a particular person. A person who poses for a portrait is called the sitter. But a portrait
is more than a picture of the sitter it is about that person and who he or she really is. A
portrait should capture something special about the sitter and his or her life. One could
think of a biography as a kind of portrait in words (or, one could think of a portrait as a kind
of biography in picture form).
It should be explained to students that studying the portrait of the subject of a biography
can give us a better understanding of the person. Sometimes, a picture can express
something about a person that words cannot. Also, taking a long and thoughtful look
at a picture can provide us with information that we might miss otherwise. Encourage
students to draw connections between the book they have read and the portrait they are
investigating.
The FACE portrait analysis tool on the preceding page is intended to be used as part of a
classroom discussion. If possible, project the image onto a screen for the entire class to see.
Instruct students to stand up and assume the pose of the sitter for fifteen seconds (including
his or her facial expression, perhaps). Then, use the FACE method to discuss the portrait.
Think about the biography you just read. In what ways does the
information in the portrait add to your understanding of the person?
EXCITING NEWS!
What did you learn from studying this portrait?
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
23
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
A.
Today, Thomas Edisons home and laboratory in New Jersey have been turned into
a museum. Imagine the museum is trying to pick one of Edisons inventions to highlight
as the single most important of his career. Write a letter to the directors of the museum
persuading them to pick the invention of your choice. You may choose the electric light, the
phonograph, the movie studio, or research a different invention at http://edison.rutgers.edu/
inventions.htm
B.
Imagine you are Thomas Edison living in the 1880s. You are touring the country to
show off your new electric light and you are trying to convince a group of citizens that
their town needs electricity. Some of the people are very skeptical of your ideas and think
electricity is too dangerous to have in their homes. Persuade them by describing the benefits
of electricity, especially electric lighting.
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
24
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
25
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
26
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
27
Students responses to the first prompt may take either position. Responses to the second
prompt should give specific details about traits, activities, or accomplishments of the
person the student chooses. The teacher may wish to require students to choose someone
who embodies a positive quality. The following rubric may also assist in evaluating writing
responses.
Category
4: Above Standards
3: Meets
Standards
2: Approaching 1: Below
Standards
Standards
Position
The student shows a
and
clear understanding of
Perspective both sides of the issue
and demonstrates
some sympathy
towards both.
The student
shows general
understanding
of both sides of
the issue.
The student
shows some
understanding
of both sides of
the issue.
Point-ofView
The response is
consistently written
in character for both
points-of-view.
The student
shows
understanding
of only one
side of the
issue or of
neither side.
The student
does not
adopt a
characters
point-of-view
for either
position.
Category
Support
for
Arguments
4: Above Standards
3: Meets
Standards
The student provides The student
provides at
at least one clear
and compelling
least one
argument or piece of argument
supporting evidence or piece of
for both positions.
evidence for
both positions.
One or both of the
positions directly
address points that
are raised by the
opposing position.
2: Approaching
Standards
The student
provides
arguments or
evidence for only
one position.
1: Below
Standards
The student
does not
include
compelling
arguments for
either position.
Sentence
Structure
Grammar
&
Spelling
The student
makes 2-3
distracting
errors in
grammar or
spelling.
The student
makes 4-5
distracting errors
in grammar or
spelling.
The student
makes 5 or
more distracting
errors in
grammar or
spelling.
The student
makes 2-3
distracting
errors in
capitalization
or punctuation
.
The student
makes 4-5
distracting errors
in capitalization
or punctuation
The student
makes
more than 5
distracting
errors in
capitalization or
punctuation
CCSS alignment: This activity fulfills guidelines of the CCSS. See pages 1112.
28
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
29
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
The book mentions that Edison was nicknamed the Wizard for the inventions produced
in his laboratory, because people found them so incredible. The phonograph particularly
amazed the public. The announcement that Edison had created a talking machine made
him famous across the world.
Step 1. Pre-listening
The National Park Service has preserved some of the earliest recordings of the phonograph.
The audio clips found at the links below are from early phonograph recordings created
by Edison and his staff. Read the information on the website about both clips. Then, listen
carefully to the recordings.
Choose one of these clips below and answer the questions on the
following page.
A.
After Dinner Toast at Little Menlo this is one of the earliest sound recordings ever
made! http://www.nps.gov/edis/photosmultimedia/very-early-recorded-sound.htm
B.
Electricity and Progress this clip contains Thomas Edison himself giving a speech on
technology and its role in the United States at the turn of the century. http://www.nps.gov/
edis/photosmultimedia/documentary-recordings-and-political-speeches.htm
Step 2. Listening
A. How would you describe the quality of this recording?
B. Both of these recordings express opinions about technology. What does the speaker
think of the new inventions made during Edisons time?
C. Write a question.
30
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
31
A patent is a document that proves a particular device was invented by a particular person. It tells
us who owns an invention. Without a patent, another person could steal an inventors idea. So,
when an inventor creates a new device, he or she asks the government for a patent so that he or she
can prove that the invention was really his or her idea. Examine the original patent application for
Thomas Edisons light bulb on the following pages and answer the questions below. A larger image
of the patents can be found at http://www.ourdocuments.gov/doc_large_image.php?doc=46;
Records of the Patent and Trademark Office; Record Group 241; National Archives. Retrieved from
http://www.ourdocuments.gov on May 20, 2009
32
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
Records of the Patent and Trademark Office; Record Group 241; National Archives. Retrieved from
http://www.ourdocuments.gov on May 20, 2009
May be reproduced for classroom use only
33
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
Step 1. Observation
A. Study the document for two minutes to gather as many details about the patent as
possible.
B. On what date was this invention patented? In which state was the patent granted?
C. Is the patent typed, handwritten, or both? Describe the appearance of the writing.
C. Write at least one question that this document brings to mind. Where could you find an
answer to this question?
34
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
Primary sources are valuable instructional tools for many reasons. Historical artifacts
whether written documents, videos, photographs, or some other objects or pieces of media
allow students to connect with the past in an immediate way. When used to supplement a
biography, primary sources can breathe life into the subject of the biography, transforming
him or her from simply another character in a book into a real person. Focusing on a primary
source also encourages observation and inference on the part of students.
The worksheets on the preceding pages are intended to be used as part of a classroom
discussion. Words on the worksheets such as infer may need to be defined for students
beforehand. If using the sound recording(s), the teacher should play the recording(s) for the
entire class. If using the patent of Edisons light bulb, the teacher should project the image
onto a screen for the class to view.
Students should be encouraged to think as historians in order to gather information from
the primary-source document and answer the questions as a group. (The attention of the
classroom should not be limited to the source document itself, as the documents captions
may also include relevant information.)
Finally, if teachers are interested in including more primary-source material to further
supplement the biography, many other photographs and documents about Thomas Edison
are available online at the sources listed under the Additional Resources section at the end
of this Blueprint. Further information about teaching with primary source documents can be
found at the National Archives at http://www.archives.gov/education
CCSS alignment: This activity fulfills guidelines of the CCSS. See pages 1112.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
35
Audio Clip B
The following was transcribed by the Center for Gifted Education from Electricity and
Progress. The speaker is Thomas Edison. Edison references Samuel Morse, inventor of the
telegraph, and Cyrus W. Field, the businessman responsible for laying the first transatlantic
telegraph cable in 1858. Fields endeavor would have been well known to the audience that
Edison is here addressing.
News of Fields successful transatlantic telegraph brought great public celebration in 1858
(the jubilee Edison mentions) and, only a few weeks later, great public disappointment
upon the cables rapid deterioration and failure. A durable, practical transatlantic line was
not installed until 1866. Edison references these events because they were seen as ranking
among the most significant technological milestones of the 19th century.
Ladies and gentlementhose of us who began our love labors at the operators key
50 years ago have been permitted to see and assist in the whole modern industrial
development of electricity. Since the remarkable experiments of Morse in 1844 and
the unsuccessful efforts of Field in 1858, there have come with incredible rapidity one
electrical art after anotherso that in practically every respect, civilization has been
revolutionized.
It is still too early to stand outside these events and pronounce final judgment on their
lasting value. But we may surely entertain the belief that the last half of the 19th century
was as distinct in its electrical inventions and its result as the first half was in relation to
steam. The lesson of the jubilee of the Atlantic cable of 1858 is one of encouragement
36
37
Point-of-View Analysis
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
Many people think that Edison invented the light bulb, but this is incorrect other inventors
had created light bulbs before him. The special thing about Edisons bulb is that it could glow
for days, while earlier versions could last for only a few minutes before burning out. Edisons
light bulb worked well enough to be sold commercially, which means that it was something
many people wanted to buy. (This is one way in which Edison showed his genius as both an
inventor and an entrepreneur.)
However, Edison might never have created his improved light bulb if earlier inventors had
not done their important work. Some people believe that these earlier inventors should get
more credit for their work. Is it more important to create something entirely new, or to create
something that is practical? First, imagine you are an inventor who created an early version
of the light bulb. Write a paragraph arguing that you should be given credit for the light bulb
rather than Edison. Then, imagine you are Thomas Edison. Write another paragraph arguing
that you should continue to be given credit for the light bulb.
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
38
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
Point-of-View Analysis
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
NAME:_______________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
39
Students should use evidence from the book to argue for both sides of their issue in turn and
may or may not favor one position over the other. In the first prompt, both responses should
reference the same event of Albert frightening his tutor. In the second prompt, Alberts letter
may mention his great talents in math and the fact that he finds it hard to learn a subject he
does not love. The teachers letter should warn Albert that he may fail to get into college if he
neglects his studies. Responses may also include different arguments entirely. The following
rubric may assist in evaluating writing responses.
Category
4: Above Standards
3: Meets
Standards
2: Approaching 1: Below
Standards
Standards
Position
The student shows a
and
clear understanding of
Perspective both sides of the issue
and demonstrates
some sympathy
towards both.
The student
shows general
understanding
of both sides of
the issue.
The student
shows some
understanding
of both sides of
the issue.
Point-ofView
The response is
consistently written
in character for both
points-of-view.
The student
shows
understanding
of only one
side of the
issue or of
neither side.
The student
does not
adopt a
characters
point-of-view
for either
position.
CCSS alignment: This activity fulfills guidelines of the CCSS. See pages 1112.
40
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
Category
Support
for
Arguments
4: Above Standards
3: Meets
Standards
The student provides The student
provides at
at least one clear
and compelling
least one
argument or piece of argument
supporting evidence or piece of
for both positions.
evidence for
both positions.
One or both of the
positions directly
address points that
are raised by the
opposing position.
2: Approaching
Standards
The student
provides
arguments or
evidence for only
one position.
1: Below
Standards
The student
does not
include
compelling
arguments for
either position.
Sentence
Structure
Grammar
&
Spelling
The student
makes 2-3
distracting
errors in
grammar or
spelling.
The student
makes 4-5
distracting errors
in grammar or
spelling.
The student
makes 5 or
more distracting
errors in
grammar or
spelling.
The student
makes 2-3
distracting
errors in
capitalization
or punctuation.
The student
makes 4-5
distracting errors
in capitalization
or punctuation
The student
makes
more than 5
distracting
errors in
capitalization or
punctuation
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
41
Experiment 1
Experiment 1
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
Before Thomas Edison and his amazing inventions, most ordinary people never used
electricity at all. Today, we use electricity for thousands of different purposes in our daily
lives. When we plug a computer into the wall or turn on a light switch, we expect that the
electricity will do its job and make the device work. But how? What exactly happens when
we turn on a computer or a light?
(1) This experiment must be done with an adult present and supervising!
Electric current flows through the device. Current is the word we use to describe the
movement of electricity. Do the words current and flow make you think of anything else
besides electricity?
Such words might make you think of a river or stream. In some ways, current acts very much
like water. Just as water flows through your plumbing, electricity flows through the wires in
the walls of your house. When you turn the knob on a sink, water flows from the faucet. In a
similar way, flipping a light switch causes electricity (current) to flow through a light bulb.
Whenever you finish using the sink, you have to turn the knob to make the water stop
flowing. However, when you unplug a laptop from the wall, you dont have to turn off the
electricity in the wall afterwards. Why not? For that matter, why doesnt the current flow out
of the wall and fill the room with electricity?
One reason is that current can only flow through some materials. Some materials conduct
electricity, which means current will flow through them easily. These materials are called
conductors. Materials that do not conduct electricity are called insulators. One example of
an insulator is the air around us. Because air does not conduct electricity, the current inside a
wall socket cannot flow out into the room.
Another fact about electricity is that current must follow an unbroken path. The path
taken by an electric current is called a circuit. If we were to open up a computer, a lamp, a
washing machine, a toaster, or any other kind of electrical device, we would see the circuits
inside. Sometimes circuits are very complicated, with many loops and twists and turns, and
sometimes they are very simple. For a circuit to work, though, its path cannot have any gaps
or holes.
In this experiment, you will build your own circuit and test which kind of materials are
insulators and which are conductors.
42
(2) Always wear safety glasses and gloves when doing experiments!
(3) NEVER play with wall sockets or household electric currents!
Procedure
1. Tape the two batteries together, with the negative end of one to the positive end of the
other. Take two pieces of insulated wire and tape one end of one wire to the positive
terminal. Tape one end of the other piece of wire to the negative terminal. You should
now have two loose, exposed ends of wire.
2. Screw the bulb into the socket
3. Touch the wire to the screws on the bottom of the bulb socket. What happens? Does it
matter which wire touches which screw? What happens if both wires touch the same
screw?
4. Keeping the wires on the screws, carefully cut one of the pieces of wire in two. What
happens to the bulb? Why?
5. Your teacher will come by your table to strip away the insulation from the two new tips
you have just created and tape them to the table.
6. Without removing the tape from the wires, light the bulb. You may use one item from the
box of materials.
7. What other items would also help you to light the bulb? Make predictions.
8. Now, try each item. Record your results. Were your predictions correct?
9. The items that allowed you to light the bulb are called __________________. The items
that did not light the bulb are called _________________. Do you notice any similarities
between the items that allowed you to light the bulb?
Congratulations, you have built a circuit! The electric current is following a path from the
batteries to the wire to the light bulb. It then flows through the second piece of wire back to
the batteries.
May be reproduced for classroom use only
43
Experiment 1
Draw a picture of your circuit. Then, draw arrows to show how the electricity is moving
through the different parts of your circuit.
NOTE: The current generated by the batteries in this experiment is too small to cause injury,
but, children should be given a safety talk beforehand about the dangers of household
electricity. Batteries are fine to experiment with, but wall sockets are not!
Materials
Teacher only: Wire strippers (scissors can be used as wire strippers if necessary)
Two lengths of insulated copper wire with about a half inch of insulation stripped from
both ends. Speaker wire works well.
Two D batteries
Masking tape
Scissors
Box of various metal and nonmetal materials a paper clip, aluminum foil, cardboard,
chalk, a nail, coins, a slice of lemon, and/or any other small objects
Procedure
This is an experiment for small groups or individuals. Divide students into groups and
distribute materials. See student section on previous page for step-by-step instructions.
Guide students as necessary to secure their batteries together and attach the wires to their
bulb sockets. After students have cut their lengths of wire in step 4, go around the room and
strip off another half-inch of insulation from the two new loose ends.
Conclusions
Students should observe that some objects conduct electricity and some do not. They may
have an intuitive sense beforehand that objects made of metal make better conductors
although they should also observe that some metals seem to work better than others.
Also, some nonmetal materials make good conductors: a lemon slice, for example, should
complete the circuit.
NGSS/CCSS alignment: This activity fulfills guidelines of the NGSS and CCSS. See pages 11-12.
44
45
Experiment 2
Experiment 2
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
Results
Edisons light bulb was an incandescent light, which means that it glowed with heat. As
electricity passes through the small wire in an incandescent light bulb, the electricity heats
the wire to very high temperatures. This wire is called the filament. As the filament heats up,
it begins to give off light. (Today, we also have ways of creating light that do not produce
heat, such as the fluorescent tubes that probably light your school. These light bulbs work
differently than Edisons invention.)
Thomas Edison tried hundreds of times to make filaments that would glow and not burn
up. He used many different materials, from metal to cardboard to bamboo. Edison was
persistenthe never gave up trying until his project worked!
Light and heat often go together. Some electrical devices such as toasters or electric stoves
will glow as they heat up. A campfire also gives off both light and heat.
Test #
1
3
4
Part of the answer is that different materials burn in different ways. A piece of paper burns
much more quickly than a piece of wood, for example. Edison designed his light bulb so that
it gave off a great deal of light yet did not burn up for a very long time.
However, think about the difference between a campfire and a light bulb. A fire will only give
off light as long as there is plenty of wood or other fuel to burn, but an incandescent light
bulb will glow for hundreds of hours before the filament burns out. If a light bulb is so hot,
why doesnt it burn up like the wood in a campfire?
In this experiment, you will copy Edisons work on the incandescent light.
5
6
How does the number of strands that you use affect the amount of time the filament stays lit
before burning out?
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
Examine the filament of a commercially sold incandescent light bulb. Is it thick or thin? Do
you notice anything interesting about the shape? Try out different filament shapes with the
iron wire and note which one seems to work best.
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
46
47
Materials
Conclusions
Students should draw a connection between the thickness of the filament that is, how
many strands of iron wire are used and how long it takes for it to burn up.
1-inch nail
NGSS/CCSS alignment: This activity fulfills guidelines of the NGSS/CCSS. See pages 1112.
Procedure
1. Cut the copper wire in half and strip off an inch of insulation from both ends of each
length of wire.
2. With a nail, drill two holes into the lid or stopper of the jar. Push the wire through the
holes so that about 2 inches of wire can be seen in the jar.
3. Bend the exposed copper ends into hooks. Twist one or more strands of iron wire
together and stretch them between the two copper hooks to form the filament.
4. Secure the lid or cork stopper (with the filament) onto the jar.
5. Carefully hook up the other ends of the copper wire to the battery and watch your
filament glow! (Note: the filament will become very hot. Do not touch!)
6. Students should use a stopwatch to time how long the filament glows, and use the
Results Form to record the time.
7. Try the experiment again with a different number of iron wire strands twisted together.
Record your times in the Results Form.
48
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
49
Additional Resources
Additional Resources
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
Published Resources
Baldwin, N. (1995) Edison: Inventing the Century. New York: Hyperion.
A biography of the inventor that focuses on placing him within the cultural and
economic context of his time. Biography. Reading level: Adult.
Brown, D. (2010) A Wizard from the Start: The Incredible Boyhood & Amazing Inventions of
Thomas Edison. New York: Houghton Mifflin Books.
Recommended as a supplemental source for this Blueprint. A biography focusing on
the childhood and young adult life of Edison. Biography. Reading level: Ages 6 and up.
Internet Resources
Edison National Historical Site, National Park Service http://home.nps.gov/edis/
Excellent educational site with biographies of Edison and others, hundreds of photos
and sound recordings, resources for teachers, and kids activities.
The Thomas A. Edison Papers, Rutgers University http://edison.rutgers.edu/
Contains thousands of pages of primary-source documents from Edisons life and work
and readable, illustrated descriptions of many of his inventions.
Edisons Miracle of Light, PBS. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/edison/index.html
A companion to the PBS American Experience documentary.
Instructional Resources
College Board Pre-AP. (2002). The AP vertical teams guide for English (2nd ed.). New York:
College Board.
The definitive source on literary analysis, close reading, rhetoric, and writing tactics.
50
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
51
Glossary
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
Glossary
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
Bias is a personal and often unreasoned preference or an inclination, especially one that
inhibits impartial judgment.
Secondary sources are works that record an event which are removed from that event by
time or place.
Setting is the time and place of the action in a story, novel, play, or poem; also, surroundings
or environment.
Historical fiction is a story set in a specific time period, having characters, setting and plot
which are both imaginary and historically documented. Where fictional, the characters,
settings and plot events are portrayed authentically as if they actually could have happened.
Imagery is the written representation of people, objects, actions, feelings or ideas through
works or phrases which appeal to the senses.
Letter is a written message addressed to a person or organization.
Memoir is a written account of the personal experiences of an individual.
Milieu is an environment or setting.
Glossary terms adapted from the following sources: AP Vertical Teams Guide for English (College
Board, 2002), www.dictionary.com, http://www.wwnorton.com/college/english/litweb/glossary,
http://www.gale.com/warehouse/glossary/
52
Glossary terms adapted from the following sources: AP Vertical Teams Guide for English (College
Board, 2002), www.dictionary.com, http://www.wwnorton.com/college/english/litweb/glossary,
http://www.gale.com/warehouse/glossary/
May be reproduced for classroom use only
53
References
Feedback Form
Cox, C. (1926). The early mental traits of three hundred geniuses. Stanford, CA: Stanford
University Press.
Hollingworth, L.S. (1925). Introduction to biography for young children who test above 150
Please provide us with feedback about this Blueprint! If you have any comments about
Blueprints, copy this page and send it to the address below. Please be specific about the
items to which your comments apply.
Robinson, A. (2009). Blueprints for biography: Differentiating the curriculum for talented
readers. Teaching for High Potential, Fall, THP-78.
Robinson, A. & Cotabish, A. (2005). Biography and young gifted learners: Connecting to
commercially available curriculum. Understanding Our Gifted, Winter, 36.
_____I would like to recommend a childrens or young adult readers biography as a subject
for a Blueprint. My recommendation(s) follows:
Robinson, A. & Schatz, A. (2002). Biography for talented learners: Enriching the curriculum
across the disciplines. Gifted Education Communicator, Fall, 1215, 3839.
_____I have comments about the questions and/or activities in this Blueprint:
54
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
55
Feedback Form
Blueprints for Biography Young Thomas Edison
56
@Jodie Mahony Center for Gifted Education, UALR. May be reproduced for classroom use only.
58