Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
DECLARATION
I, Ms. Aarti Anil Wankhede hereby declare that this project report
titled Commercial paper as a money market instrument
submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the
TYBECOM is my original work and it has not formed the basis
for the award of any other degree.
Date:
Summary
Commercial paper is available in a wide range of denominations, can
be either discounted or interest-bearing, and usually have a limited
or non-existent secondary market. Commercial paper, in the
global financial market, is an unsecured promissory note with a
fixed maturity of no more than 270 days.The study consists of
various graph of U.S. Commercial Paper types outstanding at
end of each year 2001 to 2007. And Total U.S. CP outstanding.
The study consists of various methods of issues. There are two
methods of issuing credit. The issuer can market the securities
directly to a buy and hold investor such as most money market
funds. Commercial paper is a lower-cost alternative to a line of
credit with a bank. Once a business becomes established, and
builds a high credit rating, it is often cheaper to draw on a
commercial paper than on a bank line of credit. This study also
consists of various advantages and disadvantages of commercial
paper.
There are various credit rating agencies listed in this study. The
types of commercial paper are also broadly classified into this
study. Various chacteristics and features of commercial paper are
finely described in this study.
Index
Pa
g
Sr
N
Particulars
N
o
Introduction
4-9
9-
History
1
2
13-
Object of Study
Bibliography &
References
3
2
323
8
INTRODUCTION:
ABSTRACT
COMMERCIAL PAPER
Commercial Paper (CP) is an unsecured money market instrument
issued in the form of a promissory note. It was introduced in India
in 1990 with a view to enabling highly rated corporate borrowers to
diversify their sources of short-term borrowings and to provide an
additional instrument to investors. Subsequently, primary dealers
and all-India financial institutions were also permitted to issue CP
to enable them to meet their short-term funding requirements for
their operations. Corporates, primary dealers (PDs) and the AllIndia Financial Institutions (FIs) are eligible to issue CP. The
largest and most creditworthy corporations use commercial paper
as a way to obtain short-term funds. Commercial paper is an
unsecured promissory note or an IOU issued by the corporation.
Corporations will sell commercial paper to finance such things as
short- term working capital or to meet their cash needs due to
seasonal business cycles. Commercial paper maturities range from
one day to a maximum of 270 days. It is issued at a discount to its
face value and has an interest rate that is below what a commercial
bank would typically charge for the funds. Commercial paper is
typically issued in book entry form. There are two types of
commercial paper: direct paper and dealer paper. With direct paper,
the issuer sells it directly to the public without the use of a dealer.
Dealer paper is sold to dealers who then resell the paper to
investors.
6
money market is relevant to the corporate world in terms of shortterm surplus or deficit of funds, which it experience. If a corporate
has a short-term surplus, it invests and if it faces deficit, then it
borrows. A corporate needs short-term funds to manage its working
capital requirements, pay taxes and meet other short-term
commitments. These needs are fulfilled, usually, by obtaining short
term finance from banks, trade credit from creditors, loans from
inter corporate deposits (ICDSs) market, bill discounting and
factoring, etc. corporate are always in search of new instruments to
raise funds that provides them with an optimal combination of low
cost, flexible and desired maturity. One such instrument allowed by
RBI in early 90s .
DEFINITION
COMMERCIAL PAPER
Commercial paper is a short term, unsecured license promissory
note issued at a discount to face value by well known or reputed
companies, who carry a high credit rating and have a strong
financial background. It is an unsecured obligation issued by a
bank or corporation to finance its short-term credit
requirements like accounts receivable and inventories and it
is usually issued at a discount reflecting the prevailing market
interest rates. An unsecured, short-term debt instrument issued by a
corporation, typically for the financing of accounts receivable,
inventories and meeting short-term liabilities. Maturities on
commercial paper rarely range any longer than 270days. The debt
is usually issued at a discount, reflecting prevailing market
interest rate
8
notes at a discount from their par value and then pass them on to
banks or other investors. The borrower would then repay the
investor an amount equal to the par value of the note. Marcus
Goldman of Goldman Sachs was the first dealer in the money
market to purchase commercial paper, and his company became
one of the biggest commercial paper dealers in America following
the Civil War. The Federal Reserve also began trading commercial
paper along with treasury bills from that time until World War II to
raise or lower the level of monetary reserves circulating among
banks. After the war, commercial paper began to be issued by a
growing number of companies, and eventually it became the
premier debt instrument in the money market.
depending on the quality of the issue, the credit rating and the
issuers current overdraft facility rate. It has been observed that
subscriptions to various commercial paper issues are high when the
treasury bill rates are high.(Dry and Specer,2004).It must however
be noted that when the Treasury Bill e and Central Bank Rates are
high, there are notably fewer issues of CP and available programs
are reluctant to get money through the facility.
MONEY MARKET:
The money market is used by a wide array of participants, from a
company raising money by selling commercial paper into the
market to an investor purchasing CDs as a safe place to park money
in the short term. The money market is typically seen as a safe
place to put money due the highly liquid nature of the securities
and short maturities, but there are risks in the market that any
investor needs to be aware of including the risk of default on
securities such as commercial paper.
Definition:
A segment of the financial market in which financial instruments
with high liquidity and very short maturities are traded. The money
market is used by participants as a means for borrowing and
lending in the short term, from several days to just under a year.
Money market securities consist of negotiable certificates of
deposit (CDs), bankers acceptances, U.S. Treasury bills,
commercial paper, municipal notes, federal funds and repurchase
agreements (repos).
13
14
16
COMMERCIAL PAPER
o Commercial paper refers to unsecured short-term promissory notes
issued by financial and nonfinancial corporations. Commercial
paper has maturities of up to 270 days (the maximum allowed
without SEC registration requirement). Dollar volume for
commercial paper exceeds the amount of any money market
instrument other than T-bills. It is typically issued by large, creditworthy corporations with unused lines of bank credit and therefore
carries low default risk.
o Standard and Poor's and Moody's provide ratings of commercial
paper. The highest ratings are A1 and P1, respectively. A2 and P2
paper is considered high quality, but usually indicates that the
issuing corporation is smaller or more debt burdened than A1 and
P1 companies. Issuers earning the lowest ratings find few willing
investor.
BANKERS' ACCEPTANCES
o A banker's acceptance is an instruments produced by a nonfinancial
corporation but in the name of a bank. It is document indicating
that such-and-such bank shall pay the face amount of the
instrument at some future time. The bank accepts this instrument,
in effect acting as a guarantor. To be sure the bank does so because
it considers the writer to be credit-worthy. Bankers' acceptances are
generally used to finance foreign trade, although they also arise
when companies purchase goods on credit or need to finance
inventory. The maturity of acceptances ranges from one to six
months.
REPURCHASE AGREEMENTS
o Repurchase agreementsalso known as repos or buybacksare
Treasury securities that are purchased from a dealer with the
17
agreement that they will be sold back at a future date for a higher
price. These agreements are the most liquid of all money market
investments, ranging from 24 hours to several months. In fact, they
are very similar to bank deposit accounts, and many corporations
arrange for their banks to transfer excess cash to such funds
automatically.
PURPOSE OF ISSUANCE
While creditworthy corporations can borrow from banks for the prime
rate of interest, they may be able to borrow at a lower rate by
selling commercial paper. Commercial paper is also sold to provide
seasonal and working capital for corporations, to provide bridge
financing until longer term securities are sold or until money is
expected to be received, such as tax receipts, and to finance the
purchase of other securities. CDOs and SIVs, for instance, use
commercial paper to finance the purchase of mortgage-backed
securities (MBS), profiting from the difference of receiving the
higher yield of MBS securities, and paying the lower yield of
commercial paper.
18
PARTICIPANTS
1.ISSUERS:
Any private sector companies, public sector units, non-banking
companies, primary dealers (PD), satellite dealers (SDs) etc, can
raise funds through the Commercial papers. But the companies
have to satisfy the eligibility criteria prescribed by RBI as
discussed later. The condition laid by RBI restrict the entry of
issuers into the CP market.
19
2.INVESTORS
CPs are generally open to all investors-individuals, banks,
corporates and also Non-resident Indians (NRIs). But NRIs can
only invest on a non-reportable and non transferable basis. SEBI
has permitted Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs) also to invest in
corporate debts instruments like CPs. FIIs were allowed to invest
their short-term funds in such instruments too. Within a ceiling of
the $ 1.5 billions of the total FIIs were inflows for debt funds set
down by the RBI. Though the market is open to the above
segments, usually, banks, large corporate bodies, public sector units
with investible funds functions in the market.
Source :- (http://www.indianmoney.com/)
Commercial papers favor both borrowers and investors. It is
considered as an optimal combination of liquidity and returns in the
short-term market. To borrowers it implies low cost of funds, and to
investors it implies liquidity, marketability and returns .I)
Commercial papers does not originate from a specific self
liquidating transaction like normal commercial bills, which
generally arise out of specific trade transaction. II) CPs is backed
by the liquidity and earning powers of the issuer, but is not backed
by any assets, and hence they are unsecured. III) The CP market
provides the borrower a cheaper source of funds witless paper work
and formalities when compared to bank finance. Corporate prefer
this mode of finance as they can determine the cost and maturity.
Similarly, CP involves less paper work formalities, as it an
unsecured liability, unlike bank finance, which is secured. IV)
Investors prefer to invest in CPs due to high liquidity, varied
20
21
Since call rates affect all the other short-term rates and banks are
the most important investors in CPs, its pricing is affected very
much by call rates. Also, as the lenders in the CPs market are
predominantly bank, call market affects the CP market rates; lower
call rates means cash surplus. Banks thus view CPs as an
alternative investment route
2. COMPETING MONEY MARKET INVESTMENT
PRODUCTS
Interests rate son CPs are determine by the demand and supply
factors in the money market and the interest rates on the other
competing money market instrument such as Certificate of
Deposits, Commercial Bills, Short term Forward premium and
Treasury Bills, the investment in CPs give comparably higher yield
than those obtained in banks deposits of similar maturity.
instrument to investors. Issue of CP is governed by the Nonbanking Companies (Acceptance of deposits through Commercial
Paper) Directions 1989. Acceptance of funds through issue of CP
has been exempted from the provisions of Section 58A of the
Companies Act 1956 and brought within the overall purview of the
Directions issued by the Reserve Bank of India under Section 45K
of the RBI Act, 1934. Under these Directions, CP can be issued
only for raising working capital finance. The aggregate amount to
be raised by issuance of CP cannot exceed the working capital
(fund-based) limit sanctioned by bank/s to an issuer company and
to the extent of CP issued, a corresponding reduction has to be
made in the working capital limit. It was felt that with the
introduction of CP, funds flowing through the inter-corporate
deposit market would shift to the CP market. The eligibility
conditions prescribed for issue of CP have been amended from time
to time and the present guidelines are set out in Annexure I.
Initially only corporates were permitted to issue CP. Subsequently,
primary dealers (PDs) were permitted to issue CP in September
1996 and satellite dealers (SDs) in June 1998.
26
(a) In October 1997, the stipulation that the request for restoration
of working capital (fund based) credit limit (on repayment of
Commercial Paper) should be considered by banks on the lines of
enhancement of limit was withdrawn and banks were given the
freedom to decide the manner of restoration of the working capital
limit.
(b) There had been sluggishness in the off-take of non-food credit
during this period and banks therefore, deployed their resources in
short-term instruments.
(c) Highly rated blue chip corporates have been issuing CP as an
effective instrument for reducing the funding cost of their working
capital during periods when money market interest rates have ruled
low.
Investors in CP have been banks, financial institutions and to some
extent other corporates. Except for the period when demand for
bank credit had been very high (such as 1995-96), an
overwhelming proportion (more than 80 per cent) of CP amount
has been subscribed to by commercial banks only.
Chart - 1
Demat Procedure For CP - Tentative Scheme
27
Steps :
1.
2.
8.
Chart 2
Dematerialisation of Physical CP Certificates
28
Request
Depository
Issuer
Confirmation
Request
Confirmation
Physical
Certificate
Depository
Participant
Certificate
Statement of
Holding
Investor
Steps :
1.
2.
3.
4.
33
INVESTMENT CHARACTERISTICS
Most commercial paper has a maturity of about 45 days, and most
are less than 90 days, although some commercial paper has a
maturity of up to 270 days. The terms of the commercial paper is
determined by a number of factors. One factor is the market.
Buyers of commercial paper generally buy the terms that they want
to coincide with their need for money.
The 270-day limit is dictated by the need to register the security
with the SEC if the maturity is longer. This greatly increases the
expense and time to issuehence, commercial paper will rarely
have terms longer than this. If the issuer needs the money longer, it
can usually rollover the issue by issuing new commercial paper to
pay off the maturing paper, which is often done.
There is also a 90-day barrier for the length of terms. When a bank
borrows from the Federal Reserve Bank discount window, it must
provide collateral. The Federal Reserve will only accept
commercial paper as collateral if it has a term of 90 days or less.
This increases the demand for commercial paper with terms of 90
days or less, and, therefore, lowers the interest rate that the issuer
would otherwise have to pay for the same term.
34
36
Interest Rate
Number of Terms
Per Term
per Year
Face Value -
Price Paid
Actual Number of
Days in Year
x
Term Length in
Price Paid
Days
37
40
COMMERCIAL PAPER-ADVANTAGES:
a) Cheaper than a short term business loan from a commercial bank
b) Large amounts may be borrowed conveniently
c) The ability to issue paper gives flexibility to pay for projects as you
go
d) A major benefit of commercial paper is that it does not need to be
registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as
long as it matures before nine months (270 days), making it a very
cost effective means of financing. These securities are actively
a.
e)
f)
g)
options.
h) It is quick and cost effective way of raising working capital.
i) Best way to the company to take the advantage of short term
interest fluctuations in the market
j) It provides the exit option to the investors to quit the investment.
k) . They are cheaper than a bank loan.
l) . As commercial papers are required to be rated, good rating
reduces the cost of capital for the company.
m) It is unsecured and thus does not create any liens on assets of the
company.
n) . It has a wide range of maturity
o) It is exempt from federal SEC and State securities registration
requirements.
41
42
The Federal Reserve Board posts the current rates being paid by
commercial paper on its website. The FRB also publishes the rates
of AA-rated financial and non-financial commercial paper in its
H.15 Statistical Release every Monday at 2:30pm. The data used
for this publication are taken from the Depository Trust & Clearing
Corporation (DTCC), and the rates are calculated based on the
estimated relationship between the coupon rates of new issues and
their maturities. Additional information on rates and trading
volumes is available each day for the previous days activity.
Figures for each outstanding commercial paper issue are also
available at the close of business every Wednesday and on the last
business day of every month.
43
All eligible participants shall obtain the credit rating for issuance of
Commercial Paper either from Credit Rating Information Services
of India Ltd. (CRISIL) or the Investment Information and Credit
Rating Agency of India Ltd. (ICRA) or the Credit Analysis and
Research Ltd. (CARE) or the FITCH Ratings India Pvt. Ltd. or
such other credit rating agency (CRA) as may be specified by the
Reserve Bank of India from time to time, for the purpose.
The minimum credit rating shall be A-2 [As per rating symbol and
definition prescribed by Securities and Exchange Board of India
(SEBI)].
The issuers shall ensure at the time of issuance of CP that the rating so
obtained is current and has not fallen due for review.
44
45
46
The commercial paper market is far from being fully restored. In fall
2009,the Federal Reserve is still in the process of unwinding its
purchases of commercial paper, the amount of commercial paper
outstanding is still quite low, and interest When Safe Proved Risky:
Commercial Paper during the Financial Crisis of 20072009 49
rate spreads on asset-backed commercial paper are still at their
historical highs. Issuers of commercial paper will remember for
some time that commercial paper was much riskier than they had
originally believed. And investors in commercial paper will
remember for some time that commercial paper turned out to be
much riskier than they had thought. The high level of skepticism on
both sides of the market for commercial paper suggests that the
market will probably diminish relative to its size before the
financial crisis.
State Bank of India said a further cut in base rate by the lenders will
be possible only if there is a substantial pick up in loan growth,
which it expect from the fourth quarter. SBI Chairman Arundhati
Bhattacharya said although the rates in the commercial papers are
lower, banks can only match those rates once credit growth picks
up. "If we are going to compete on the commercial paper market
front, we have to lower base rate by more than 100 basis points,
which, looking at the credit growth in the market, is something that
cannot be done," she told reporters here after addressing the
shareholders at the 60th AGM here this evening. "I see credit
47
49
(Investment in commercial)
banking system, corporates are reducing their interest costs further by raising
short-term funds through the commercial paper (CP) route. As of August 15, the
total amount invested in commercial paper stood at Rs 9,148 crore.
COMMERCIAL PAPER
October 30, 2006
Money market rates remained steady but with a downward bias tracking the call
rates. Due to the festive season holiday, activities remained thin. Companies
borrowed funds through commercial papers in the range of 7.51-7.75%. Banks
raised short-term funds to meet up festive demand by issuing CDs. At the 91day treasury bills auction, RBI maintained the cut-off price at Rs 98.37 (yield
6.6462%). CREDENCE ANALYTICS INDIA PVT LTD.
51
CONCLUSION
Short-term interest rate environment, credit rating and market
liquidity condition play an influential role in the Indian CP market
activity The empirical finding shows that CP issuance yield
depends on varying credit quality across the CPs issuers and
prevailing market liquidity. The short term risk premia also affect
CP issuances activity depending on spread between T-Bill yield and
CPs issuance rates. A rise in risk premia limits debt-paying capacity
of the company and hence compresses the market growth in CP
segment on account of rise in default probability. Credit rating and
market liquidity condition are the most persuading factors in CPs
market dynamics. Comfortable market liquidity makes availability
of funds easy in the open market at lower borrowing costs and
hence corporates prefer CPs route for borrowing their working
capital and vice versa. At present, Indian commercial paper market
is still in its nascent stage of evolution in terms of borrowing
activity.
52
4
38
96
Non Financial
Financial
11
20
89
63
22
78
15
42
85
58
80
45
55
63
38
76
73
24
27
cut in policy rate along with huge liquidity injection by the RBI led
to surplus mode of liquidity in the market which prompted CP
issuers to borrow directly from the market due to easy accessibility
of funds at lower costs compared to higher bank lending rate. On
other end, investors were getting better shortterm return by parking
their funds in the CP market than LAF reverse repo window with
the RBI. This was the first time when the CPs issuers in India
tasted the benefits of taking the CP issuance route for meeting their
financing requirements. The average mid-issuance rate for CPs
during last six years hovered around the upper band of policy rate
corridor signaling natural preference of corporate borrowers for
CPs over bank credit which costs them additional 2% - 4% over the
bank rate depending on their credit rating.
There is need for further studies to carry out similar study for a
longer time period. This would allow better generalizations across
the board for similar CP issues. A similar study should also be
carried out on relationship between firms performance and
Treasury bills and commercial paper performance in India.
Comparable studies should also be carried-out to establish the
effect on commercial paper yield by other short term debt
instruments like bank overdrafts or even long term debt instruments
like corporate bonds in India.
Equivalently, studies on how other key factors bear effect on
commercial paper should be conducted to establish their extent, for
instance there is need to establish how Central Bank Rate, bank
interest rates and inflation levels influence commercial paper yield.
The commercial paper market has long been viewed as a bastion of
high liquidity and low risk. But twice during the financial crisis of
54
I CONCLUDE
Commercial paper is an important money market security. By making
this project I learn about the features, advantages and disadvantages
of the commercial paper. The main point is that
55
References:
Acharya, Viral, and Philipp Schnabl.
Downing,2009.
Chris, and Stephen Oliner. 2007.The
Term Structure of Commercial Paper Rates.
http://imf.org/external/np/res/seminars/2009/arc/pdf/acharya.pdf.
Acharya, Viral ,
Philipp Schnabl,
Gustav o Suarez.
Securitization
without Risk
Books:Advance financial
arrangement By Dr. M.A.
Kohok (Page No. 40 to
46)Financial Market &
Instruments Journal:Source : (http://www.scribd.com/)
http://www.scribd.com/doc/95
823767/Commercial-Papers
56
and
2009.
Transfer.http://www.richmondfed.org/conferences_and_events/research/2
009/pdf/suarez_paper.pdf.
Akerlof, George. 1970. The Market for Lemons Quality
Uncertainty and the Market
. 1995
57