Sie sind auf Seite 1von 3

Impeachment of Andrew Jackson

Debate Form

Point

EvidencetoSupport

Jacksonwasjusttryingtohelpthe
Indianswithinhislegalpower

ItwillrelievethewholeStateofMississippiand
thewesternpartofAlabamaofIndianoccupancy,
andenablethoseStatestoadvancerapidlyin
population,wealth,andpower.Itwillseparate
theIndiansfromimmediatecontactwith
settlementsofwhitesfreethemfromthepower
oftheStatesenablethemtopursuehappinessin
theirownwayandundertheirownrude
institutionswillretardtheprogressofdecay,
whichislesseningtheirnumbers,andperhaps
causethemgradually,undertheprotectionofthe
Governmentandthroughtheinfluenceofgood
counsels,tocastofftheirsavagehabitsand
becomeaninteresting,civilized,andChristian
community.
TranscriptofPresidentAndrewJackson's
MessagetoCongress'OnIndianRemoval'(1830)

VanBurenputitintoactionwhile
Jacksonsuggestedit

FederalpolicyunderJacksonhadsought,through
theIndianRemovalActof1830,tomoveall
IndianpeoplestolandswestoftheMississippi
River.Continuingthispolicy,VanBuren
supportedfurtherremovalsafterhiselectionin

1836.Thefederalgovernmentsupervisedthe
removaloftheCherokeepeoplein1838,aforced
staggerwesttotheMississippiinwhichafull
quarteroftheCherokeenationdied.
3

ActionbasedonwhatJackson
believedwasfortheirownsafetyas
conflictswould'vearoseas
AmericansmovedWestward

Itputsanendtoallpossibledangerofcollision
betweentheauthoritiesoftheGeneralandState
GovernmentsonaccountoftheIndians.
TranscriptofPresidentAndrewJackson's
MessagetoCongress'OnIndianRemoval'(1830)

Jacksonsplanwasjustified.

WhiteswouldhavekilledtheIndiansanyways
andmorewarsprobablywouldvebeenfought
whichwouldhavedestroyedthenations
economy.

itwillincalculablystrengthenthe
southwesternfrontierandrendertheadjacent
statesstrongenoughtorepelfutureinvasions
withoutremoteaid
(AndrewJacksonssecond
annualmessagetocongress)

Nottechnicallyillegal

Whileitwasimmoral,everythinghedidhe
thoughtwasbestforthecountryandwaswithin
hislegaljurisdiction

Themovementultimatelybenefitted
Americanseconomicallyand
increasedaccesstorawmaterials

First,anexpandedsystemofcreditwas
necessarytohelpentrepreneurssecurethecapital
neededforlargescaleandriskynewventures.
Second,animprovedtransportationsystemwas
crucialfor
RAWMATERIALS
toreachthe
factoriesandmanufacturedgoodstoreach
consumers.Stategovernmentsplayedakeyrole
encouragingbothnewbankinginstitutionsanda
vastlyincreasedtransportationnetwork.
http://www.ushistory.org/us/22a.asp

Jacksonofferedtopayforthe
expenseoftheirnewhome

Rightlyconsidered,thepolicyoftheGeneral
Governmenttowardtheredmanisnotonly
liberal,butgenerous.Heisunwillingtosubmitto
thelawsoftheStatesandminglewiththeir
population.Tosavehimfromthisalternative,or
perhapsutterannihilation,theGeneral
Governmentkindlyoffershimanewhome,and

proposestopaythewholeexpenseofhisremoval
andsettlement.
TranscriptofPresidentAndrewJackson's
MessagetoCongress'OnIndianRemoval'(1830)
8

10

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen