Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
2014-2015
By Kevin, Yuki Zhong and Joel Yu for SIGHT at HKUST
Overview
In the summer of 2014, SIGHT students visited the NGO One-2-One Cambodia in Phnom
Penh (photos on below). They tagged along during their various assignments and looked for ways
to help them with their day-to-day functions with technology. Back they came with 2 ideas on how
to make One-2-Ones operation easier, the Electronic Medical Record System (EMRS), a software,
and the Pharmabox, a hardware. Student teams were assigned to each project, with the hardware
team named Cheesecake. Both teams came up with prototypes by the end of the semester, but
everything started all over again in the spring semester, with change in personnel in both teams, and
the Pharmabox was also renamed the Drug Dispensing Box (DDX). This case would focus on the
spring of 2015.
Team Cheesecake
Joel Yu
Year 4
Kenneth Cheung
Year 3
Molecular Biomedical
Sciences
Mechanical Engineering
Melody Chung
Year 2
Biochemistry (IRE)
Jisoo Lee
Year 3
Chemical & Byproduct
Engineering, General
Business Double Major
Chemistry
Mohamed Thalha
Year 2
Brian Wong
Year 3
SBM undeclared
Electronic Engineering
The Cheesecake Team, year of study are as of the 2014-2015 school year.
Nadiya Yudiana
Year 2
Background
The One-2-One Cambodia medical team takes weekly trips to the slums to provide mobile
clinic services to the inhabitants there. Part of this team is the mobile pharmacy, which the staff
would pack all medicines into a suitcase and chuck it to the slums. This was an inconvenient and
inefficient way of transporting, organizing and dispensing the medicine.
Outcome
Week 1
Week 2
Week 3
Week 4
Original
Team building
Unpack the
problem
Review existing
solutions
Set scope and
deliverables
Ideation and
brainstorming
workshop
Fast prototyping
workshop
Reality
The Cheesecake Team worked with One-2-One Cambodia to develop a new way of transporting
and organizing medicine during transport, one which not only allows the medical team greater ease
during transport, quicker setup times of the pharmacy station and more convenient inventory checks,
but also a solution that is attuned to the environment in which it operates. Two sets of DDXes were
made, brought over to Phnom Penh and handed over to One-2-One Cambodia, where the 2 DDXes
are now enjoying their field testing phase. One-2-One is now providing SIGHT with feedback, and
the Cheesecake Team is providing technical support. The Cheesecake Team is currently looking for
ways to manufacture more DDXes with less student-labour intensive methods, such as 3D-printing
or even engaging factories to produce DDX on a mass scale.
Team building
Unpack the
problem
Review existing
solutions
Set scope and
deliverables
Ideation and
brainstorming
workshop
Fast prototyping
workshop
Week 5
Week 6
Week 7
Week 8
Midterms
Midterms
Week 9
Week 10
Week 11
Week 12
WORK!!
Video submission .
WORK!!
Video submission
POSTPONED
Week 13
May
June
June 8
Final presentation
Finals
Prepare for
Cambodia trip
Flight to Cambodia
Final presentation
Video submission
Flight to Cambodia
Fall Recap
The fall of 2014 was rather frustrating for the
Cheesecakes. The team was ambitious upon return,
deciding that the Pharmabox should not be just a bag,
but also a table, bag, drawers, vaccine carrier all rolled
into one. The project was on the verge of overreaching
itself. Thankfully, Prof. Jim Patel of Stanford dropped by
and gave them the advice, focus on one thing only.
After much heated discussion, the one thing became
the drawers.
The many ideas for the Pharmabox.
The team started off by modifying suitcases,
but that did not work so they tried to make their own
suitcase with plastic, which was quite impossible
without heavy machinery. A plan to make a hi-tech
table as the selling point never materialised. In the end,
for the final presentation, they made in 3 days a box
on wheels with drawers from Japan Home City and
a table on top. The Cheesecakes themselves were not
satisfied, it was sad for them that the final product was
just drawers from Japan Home City. The Medbox was
just not ready for implementation, it was too simple
and bulky.
Choose one
function!!
-Prof. Jim Patell
Inspiration
The first generation of Cheesecakes went to
Phnom Penh and shadowed the One-2-One medical
team during their mobile clinic services at the slums.
From start till end, so starting with preparation,
different transportation phases, set-up, service and
pack-up of the mobile clinic. They visited 4 slums in
total, documented the conditions and the operations
of the medical team at each one with cameras and
also interviewed members of the One-2-One medical
team.
The conditions of the slums were simply dire.
There was trash everywhere, cramped living spaces.
The stink of rubbish permeated the air, and children
were often neglected, running around shirtless and
barefooted. Clean water was hard to come by in the
slums and personal hygiene is neglected. It was a
We understand how
and why slums develop,
have a glimpse on the
living conditions in
the slums.
stirring experience for the team, to see the conditions
in the slums, and also the dedication of the One-2One staff.
The Cheesecakes identified the major issue
for them to tackle was the way of transporting their
medicine to each slum, as the method used then was
too cumbersome in the following ways.
The One-2-One
medical team members
were very devoted
to their jobs,
professional and
humble.
First, the medicines were just in disarray
upon arrival at the slum, with the reasons below. The
medicines for each slum were packed into suitcases
before leaving the headquarters, and suitcases are not
known for having any organising tools inside them.
Upon arrival, the medicines inside would be in disarray
due to endless sloshing during transport. The staff then
had to sort and place the medicines orderly on a table
in order to begin pharmacy service. This whole process
takes around 30 minutes, eating into their servicing
time.
Second, when the medical team returns back
to the office, they would have to do an inventory
To design a drug
carrier that can
reduce the time
required for mobile
pharmacy setup.
Clockwise from top right: Transport of the mobile clinic via tuk-tuk; Disorganised medicines upon arrival; Settingup the pharmacy station; The mobile clinic in action.
Ideation
On paper, the Cheesecakes had one week
allocated for the ideation process (see Project
Schedule, page 3). But it must be understood that
the whole design process was not linear, and the
team often backtracked throughout the project.
Often some ideas would not work and the team
had to start all over again.
Before generating ideas, the Cheesecakes
had to come up with specifications that could
satisfy One-2-Ones needs. They grouped these
specifications into different categories, such as
medicine holder, interior, transportation, exterior
and material. The specifications are listed in the
table below,
The Cheesecake Team met and generated Post-its are a great way to generate ideas. Here are
many different ideas on how to tackle the above the specifications/needs came up by the team.
issues. They took care not to judge on each others
ideas at this stage, no matter how outlandish it
Criteria categories and their specifications.
Prototyping
Prototyping came in many different
stages. In early prototyping, the team often
made prototypes just for the proof of concept, so
prototypes were crude. The motto then was,
28 1
1st reality
check
1st prototype .
22
February
10
2nd reality
check
31 1
2nd prototype
20
1st expert
check
10
March
20
3rd prototype
10
30 1
May
Flight
31 1
June
20
April
Besides reality checks, known experts in the
field also dropped-in and paid the Cheesecakes
a visit. Prof. Vincent Li, adjunct faculty with the
MAE Department was one of them. Currently he
is in Afghanistan working with Mdecins Sans
Frontires at one of their clinics. Although brief
the encounter was, he gave a few important
pointers for the DDX. The first DDX prototype was
green in colour, which had military connotations.
Prof. Li remarked that such overtones should be
rd
avoided when a product is serving a humanitarian
mission. And as the DDX could be carried on the
shoulders with straps like a backpack, Prof. Li, an
avid hiker himself, suggested adding a waist belt
The 3rd prototype was the one showcased to stabilise the bag onto the persons body.
during the final presentation, the team had a little
more than 1 month to finish it. The most pressing
problem at this stage was space-saving, to
compress the DDX to a portable size yet allowing
organisation within, this theme would continue
to haunt the team all the way to Cambodia. The
team had limited information on medicine shape/
size/variety from Prof. Chau and based their
calculations on such data, but they were in no
way definitive. The number one dilemma during
the whole project was that organisation always
came in the cost of negative volume.
3 Prototype &
Expert Check
10
Implementation
Arriving at Cambodia!
The DDX was finally flew over to Cambodia
A total of 2 sets
in early June along with the rest of the team for
the first rounds of field tests. A total of 2 sets of
of DDXes were brought
DDXes were brought over to Phnom Penh, and
over to Phnom Penh,
they were finished practically the morning before
the flight. Extra materials, spare parts and tools
and they were finished
were also packed to Cambodia for last minute
practically the
modifications. The boys room of the Cheesecake
Team was converted to a temporary workshop,
morning before the
with simple tools such as glue guns, saws, sewing
flight.
kits, spanners and so forth.
At the One-2-One office, it was the first
time for the Cheesecakes to work first hand
with One-2-Ones medicine, leading to more Teaching the One-2-One staff on DDX usage.
modifications. New elastic bands were made to
contain small, round glass bottles. There was more
space left than anticipated so the railing system
was ditched for a stacking system (see next page).
The whole DDX system was easy and intuitive for
the Cheesecakes to use, as they were the ones
developing it, but it was another case for the One2-One staff, as everything was new to them. The
team had to spend some time teaching the staff
how to use the DDX. To facilitate DDXs usage,
the team also helped the local staff with inventory
(see next next page).
11
it was the
first time for the
Cheesecakes to work
first hand with One2-Ones medicine,
leading to more
modifications.
Testing new methods of storage.
12
Entering inventory.
All packed and set! The new way of storage freed up even more dead volume, and the staff is loving it!
Finally, the big day arrived, the Cheesecake
All medicines were
Team shadowed the One-2-One medical team to
the Banteay Sleak slum, while using the DDX to
still in order upon
carry their medicines. It was immediately clear
arrival and the trays
that the DDX had shortened the set-up and pack-
up time for the pharmacy station, from 30 minutes
just needed to be
to 3 minutes in set-up time. All medicines were
taken out to set up
still neatly packed upon arrival and the trays just
needed to be taken out to set up the whole station.
the whole station.
The trolley system also worked well, even at full
load the staff found it easy to tug the DDX into and
To this day, the DDX is being deployed
out of the slums. All in all, it could be said that by the One-2-One medical teams when bringing
both sides were satisfied with the DDX.
mobile clinic services to the slums, and this brings
the Cheesecakes real joy every time they see the
DDX in action!
It was immediately
clear that the DDX
had shortened the setup and pack-up time,
from 30 minutes to 3
minutes.
14
Multimedia
Throughout the whole semester, the whole
team had to document their progress using photos
and videos. Two video clips were produced to
introduce and showcase DDX, and often, part of
the team helped out with other SIGHT projects. For
example the team helped out during SIGHT week
by making displays and animations. Videos are a
great way to illustrate both work-in-progress and Displays for the DDX during SIGHT Week.
finished ideas, so their use is encouraged. Most
Videos are great
videos and photos were shot with smartphones,
picture quality is sufficient and their files are often
in showing both halfeasier to edit.
Software Team
Alton Lee
Year 3
Kevin
Year 2
Jenny Kang
Year 2
Computer Science
Computer Science
Samson Chan
Year 3
Lance Cheung
Year 3
Michelle Lee
Year 1
Sandra Sobaska
Year 1
Computer Science
Computer Engineering
Global Business
The Software Team, year of study are as of the 2014-2015 school year.
15
Background
Recording patient data in Cambodia remains a tremendous challenge, due to inadequate
supporting infrastructure, low coverage rate, as well as low literacy rate for the general populace,
particularly in low-income settings. The SIGHT team partnered with One-2-One, a New Zealandbased healthcare NGO offering free medical services in Cambodias poorest areas, in developing an
Electronic Medical Record System (EMRS) to increase coverage rate for the patients, as well as to
ensure that every patient record can be computerised, enabling better management and analysis by
the organisation.
Inspiration
While the World Bank estimates
approximately 40% of Cambodians earn less than
2 US$ a day. There also exists a major absence of
comprehensive healthcare system. Health-related
services are predominantly managed by the private
sector, including non-governmental organisations
(NGOs).
SIGHTs first collaborating partner, One-2One Charitable Trust Cambodia, is one illustration.
The organisation offers free dental services,
16
It is not unusual
that a patient comes
to the clinic with a
different name from
last visit.
Week 1
Week 2
Week 3
Week 4
Team building
Project Handover
Review existing
solutions
Set scope and
deliverables
Ideation and
brainstorming
workshop
Fast prototyping
workshop
Week 5
Week 6
Week 7
Week 8
Set future
implementation
plan
Midterm break
Finalising user
interface
Week 9
Week 10
Week 11
Week 12
Prototype public
showcase
Fundraising &
laptop donation
Week 13
May
Late May-June
June 8
Final presentation
Finals
Final pre-trip
testing
Flight to Cambodia
2nd
reality check
17
Fall Recap
In the fall semester of 2014, although the
team managed to lay the groundwork and make
the first version of EMRS to test the concept, the
progress was not very satisfactory. The momentum
was not as strong when the team came back from
a long summer. While user needs are the center
of any design process and must be continuously
explored, especially for software engineering,
proactive communication with partner was
missing during the semester. Although there was
some communication with the partner, it was
far from comprehensive and frequent enough to
support project development.
Estimation of project workload might be
another issue. We found the coding power was
not enough for a project of this scale. Moreover,
the coding task was not divided methodically in
the beginning, this affected the team performance
more and more later in the semester.
18
However the
technical handover
was not very smooth
due to the absence of
good documentation. It
took the team quite
some time and effort
to understand the
existing codes.
This is to observe
the performance of
the EMRS in settings
that were made as
Cambodian as
possible.
19
Many considerations were taken into
account throughout the tests: compatability with
different operation systems of different versions,
distance between one computer and another in
transmitting the information, user-friendliness,
comprehensibility of medical terms, and also
impact on workflow.
When the team and their software were
ready to meet the first users, a workshop for
high school students was organised in April.
Over 25 students from 7 local high schools were
invited to HKUST to learn about global health
technology and participate in a role-playing
scenario as doctors and patients to test the system
in action. Observations were made to see how the
participants responded to the software, whether
the workflow became faster, and whether some
Implementation
Preparation
Mid-April awareness campaign, Left: the counter of the campaign, the screen set-up on the right is
playing a promotional animation for SIGHT, the team also collected old laptops at the counter; Middle:
donations for fingerprint scanners; Right: Kevin of Software team explaining the workings of an early
prototype of the DDX
Beyond the software itself, the team also
the team also
worked on lots of other non-technical activities
surrounding and supporting the EMRS, such as
worked on lots of
awareness campaigns about ongoing health issues
other non-technical
in Cambodia, displaying the initial prototypes
on campus, fundraising for fingerprint scanners
activities surrounding
and a laptop donation drive during the twoand supporting the
day exhibition in mid-April, as well as outreach
to HKUST staff and computer manufacturers,
EMRS,
chiefly Lenovo, to secure further support for
laptop donations. The team also made occasional interested in endorsing the ideas of integrating
visits to social entrepreneurs and businesspeople technologies with healthcare and social needs.
20
The final preparation for implementation in
Cambodia took a meticulous mind. The power
supply for laptops was one example. It did not
take any programing skills, but could devastate
the implementation if not properly planned. The
team came up with several plans including the
Implementation
Meeting for
sustainable
implementation
Day
1
Flight to
Phnom Penh
Observation in House
Above Water
slum
Day
2
Day
3
Basic EMRS
training for
One-2-One
Set-up &
test by
students in
Canal Side slum
Day
6
City Tour
Day
7
City tour
Project
scouting:
Helen Keller
International (HKI)
Day
9
Day
4
Wrap-up
meeting with
One-2-One
Return to
Hong Kong
Left & middle: Kevin, Lance and Alton studying paper patient records and discussing how to incorporate
them into the software; Right: Education of One-2-One staff on the EMRS at their office.
Left: First field test at the Canal Side slum, 20-30% time reduction was recorded for both the triage and
pharmacy stations; Right: The fingerprint scanner in action.
22
Realising that
transition from paper
to computer was hardly
easy, tutelage was
provided step by
step;
were guided to run simulations in office and later
field tests in slums. More rounds of simulation
were made, with software team members doing
their very best to guide and support the medical
team. Furthermore, the team also discussed further
with One-2-One in regard to potential ideas for
future expansion of EMRS roles.
Upon implementation, the software team
observed that the staff in One-2-One, in general,
were very committed to improving public health
for Cambodian communities, particularly among
the poor, and to making use of EMRS to accelerate
the flow of medical services, which can help
widen the scope of patients within their reach.
There were times of excitement, especially
for team members who visited Cambodia for
the first time. Being involved in a technologydisseminating project, and not simply volunteering,
especially in a developing country like Cambodia,
gave both SIGHT teams big hopes of how simple
technologies, created through direct humancentered approach, can solve major problems
there. The teams also observed such spirit in the
eyes of many Cambodians, especially those who
could barely afford basic healthcare services.
Because such was the eventual expectation
Charts the software team prepared overnight for One-2-Ones long-term implemention of the EMRS.
Left: Implementation and transition timeline; Right: Transition diagram.
23
24
Team Dynamics
Cambodia
2014
Fall
2015
Spring
2015
Cambodia
2015
Cheesecake
Swapped
Stayed
New
members
Didnt go
Software
Team
Left the
team
Didnt go
New members
New members
Old members
How the teams evolved over the 2 semesters and the trip.
25
Software Team
The two SIGHT teams went through quite
different changes throughout the year, one team
was practically reconstituted while another just
In a software project, hardcore coders
expanded. These differences shaped how the
make
the
foundation of the technology. Among
teams developed. (See diagram in previous page.)
the four CSE students, Lance and Alton, despite
their hectic schedule due to final-year projects,
contributed predominantly in developing the
software, all the while coaching and supporting
the other two younger coding members, Jenny and
For the Cheesecakes, the team just Michelle. Lance also took up the role of project
expanded after the fall semester, it was an manager. Jenny contributed to the development
amalgamation of old and new members. New of web portal connected to the EMRS. Michelle
members brought new enthusiasm, expertise is the most junior, but she later became an
and energy to the team, while the old members intermediary, an important role who can look
provided the foundation to build on with their past at the implementation from the technical aspect
experiences. It took around 1 month for the team and vice versa. Samson is another key peron who
to really gel and work together, to get warmed up. tied the two divisions. Majoring in busines and
And since the semester actually isnt that long, this with understanding in programing, Samson knew
kind of ate into the working time of the team. One what information the coders needed exactly from
the users then proactively approached One-2One to look for answers. He is also a meticulous
It took around 1
member who looked after many details such as
hardware purchase, event planning and graphic
month for the team
design. Sandra provided a major boost for the
to really gel and
software project with her strong communication
work together, to get and management skills with other parties in many
occasions, such as the fundraising campaign,
warmed up.
outreaching for corporate partners, and making
transition plans. Kevin, originating from the
thing of mention is that it could be demanding to social sciences, possessed strong writing skills,
have the old members to focus and work at the and also related knowledge about global health,
same level of intensity as they had last semester. developing countries, and their socio-economic
This is why the injection of new blood is always conditions, especially for Cambodia.
The combination of all the people from
welcomed. Workmate and commitment could
also be affected by the course registration status, different majors and backgrounds themselves can
the majority of the team were fully enrolled in the be a powerful impetus in ensuring the success of
project, when the team dynamics are functioning
course, while 1 was auditing.
well.
Open communication is the golden rule. In
general, the team members could voice out what
they needed from teammates and suppportively
responded to others, which was key to building
and maintaining a team. While this was not
properly done in the first semester, poor allocation
of manpower and underperformance of the team
followed.
In an interdisciplinary team, it is also
important to be patient in sharing what you are
good at, and be humble in learning what you
are not. While this was not fully appreciated in
the very beginning, the team members have held
much more appreciation in seeing each others
The Cheesecakes with cheesecakes, treat by Yuki! strength and specialities after all the ups and
Team Cheesecake
26
In an
interdisciplinary
team, it is also
important to be
patient in sharing
what you are good at,
Project C
Project C came into being when the
software team wanted to provide their computers
some pack-up time when it starts to rain during
One-2-Ones mobile clinic services. They wanted
some kind of rain cover for the laptops, and
hoped that the covers can also double as paddings
to protect the laptops during transport. They
approached the Cheesecakes with this idea and
the Cheesecakes immediately said yes and started
the development of Project C, the laptop cover
project. Project C aimed to provide: temporary
protection from rain to give more time to pack, air
vents for laptop ventilation and cooling, padding
for laptop during transport, screen hood to block
off sunlight from the screen, reflect sunlight away
to prevent overheating, laptop platform for better
ergonomics. A crude prototype was made and
presented to team Saturday and One-2-One. All
this happened during the trip in Phnom Penh.
27