Sie sind auf Seite 1von 2

Jashan-Debate Presentation

Criteria

Achievement Level
Achievement Achievement
Below Level
Level 1
1
50-59
0 to 49

Understanding
topic and
presenting
information
(25%
Weighting)

Did not
show an
adequate
understanding
of
the topic.

Achievement
Level 2
60 - 69

Seemed
Seemed to
to understand the understand the
main points of the main points
topic, but didnt
of the topic and
present with ease. presented
those with ease.

Critical thinking
Uses critical
skills:

Uses critical
thinking skills thinking
appropriate
When choosing in choosing
rhetorical tools

Rhetorical appropriate
rhetorical tools and persuasive
devices
and persuasive techniques with

Persuasive techniques with limited


effectiveness.
Technique very limited
effectiveness.
s

Achievement
Level 3
70 - 79

Clearly
understood the
topic in depth
and presented
information with
ease.

Achievement
Level 4
80 to 100

Clearly
understood the
topic in depth
and presented
information
forcefully and
convincingly.

Total

19

Uses critical
thinking skills in
choosing
appropriate
rhetorical tools
and persuasive
techniques with
some
effectiveness.

Uses critical
Uses critical
thinking skills in
thinking skills in
choosing
choosing
appropriate
appropriate
rhetorical tools and rhetorical tools and
persuasive
persuasive
techniques with
techniques with
considerable
high degree of
effectiveness.
effectiveness.

Refutes ideas
with some
effectiveness

Refutes ideas with


considerable
Refutes ideas with
effectiveness
a high degree of
effectiveness
Communicates
Communicates
information & ideas information & ideas
with considerable with high degree of
clarity &
clarity &
organization.
organization.

19.5

organization.

Communicates
information &
ideas with some
clarity &
organization.

Varies vocal
strategies with
limited
effectiveness.

Varies vocal
strategies with
some of
effectiveness.

Varies vocal
strategies with
considerable
effectiveness.

18.5

20

Refutes ideas

When refuting with very


ideas
limited
(25% Weighting)

effectiveness

Refutes ideas
with limited
effectiveness

Communication
of information Communicates Communicates
information & information &
& ideas with
ideas with very ideas with limited
clarity and
limited clarity & clarity &
organization
organization.

(25% Weighting)
Application of
vocal strategies Varies vocal
strategies with
(tone, pace,
pitch, silence, very limited
and volume) to effectiveness
or vocal
enhance
(25% Weighting)

Varies vocal
strategies with a
high degree of
effectiveness.

strategies are
not or used/
varied at all.

For the rebuttal, refer to specifically what your opponent says,


rather than stating that you said the death penalty does not
deter crime. However, you have good evidence to support
your refutation especially after the speeches were complete.
Good effort to vary your tone and volume, but slow down and
pace your self.
Effective rhetorical devices, but what other persuasive
techniques can you include to make your message more
engaging?
Excellent, you specifically name the source that youve used to
defend your point.
Under time

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen