3D7C#) :3? K?3@ ) 3 7: 3@6K?7@#!3D77?

2014 IEEE 2nd International Symposium on Telecommunication Technologies (ISTT), Langkawi, Malaysia (24-26 Nov 2014)

*3D7C#):3?;K?3@>)3>7:3@6K?7@#!3D77?

35G>FKA8@9;@77D;@9#G>F;?76;3+@;H7DE;FK

K47D<3K3)7>3@9AD#3>3KE;3
F3D;CE:3?;
9?3;>5A?

5) F$%- ++!, .$! (%) %( %- .* *+.%(%4! .$!
+,*%'%.3*" !.!.%*)%)*#)%.%0!, %*)!.1*,&-3/-%)#
%""!,!). 0,%).- *" +,.%'! -1,( *+.%(%4.%*) %) %)#
.$! *+.%(' 1!%#$.%)# *!""%%!). 0!.*, %) -*". !%-%*) "/-%*)
-! **+!,.%0! -+!.,/( -!)-%)# %- $''!)#%)# .-& .$. %-
,/%''3 )!! ! .* %(+,*0! .$! !.!.%*) +!,"*,()! $!
+!,"*,()! *" -.) , ) "%0! *.$!,
0,%).- )(! - -!'"*,#)%4%)# $%!,,$%' 1%.$ .%(!
!'!,.%*) *!""%%!).- (! %)*,%!).!
!).,%+!.' !'!,.! #,0%..%*)'
+,.%'! -1,( ) **+!,.%0! #,0%.3 -!
%- )'34! 1$%'! -!,$%)# "*, .$! *+.%(' 1!%#$.%)#
*!""%%!). 0!.*, . 1$%$ .$! *0!,'' +,*%'%.3 *" !.!.%*) %-
(2%(%4! #%0!) "%2! +,*%'%.3 *" "'-! ',( $! !-.
$%!0'! "%.)!-- *)0!,#!)! -+!! ) -.%'%.3 *" .$!
0,%).- ,! *(+,! $! -%(/'.%*) ,!-/'.- -$*1 .$. %-
.$! !-. $*%! (*)# '' *.$!, 0,%).- .* %(+,*0! .$!
!.!.%*)+!,"*,()!%).$!#%0!))!.1*,& !+'*3(!).
5A788;5;7@F H75FAD ;@ 3 )43E76 5AAB7D3F;H7 EB75FDG?

E7@E;@9 E57@3D;A *:7 E:AIE E3F;E835FADK D7EG>FE 8AD F:7
ABF;?3> EA>GF;A@ A8 F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F 4GF ;FE
5A@H7D97@57 ;E E>AI 3E ;F D7CG;D7E 4;@3DK 7@5A6;@9 675A6;@9
BDA57EE7E @ F:;E IAD= 6;887D7@F H3D;3@FE A8 B3DF;5>7 EI3D?
ABF;?;L3F;A@ &)% 3D7 GE76 3@6 F:7;D B7D8AD?3@57E 3D7
5A?B3D76 +@>;=7 F:7 3@6 AF:7D 7HA>GF;A@3DK 3>9AD;F:?E
&)%D7CG;D7E87I7D5A@FDA>>;@9B3D3?7F7DE3@6;FD7FGD@E47FF7D
D7EG>FE I;F: E:ADF7D 5A?BGF3F;A@3> F;?7 %@7 A8 F:7 D757@F
IAD=EF:3FGE7E&)%FA;?BDAH7F:767F75F;A@B7D8AD?3@57I3E
BDABAE76;@12*:AG9:F:7IAD=;@127@:3@576F:767F75F;A@
B7D8AD?3@57 3E 5A?B3D76 FA F:7D7 3D7 EF;>> DAA?E 8AD
;?BDAH7?7@F F:3F 53@ 47 35:;7H76 4K 7JB>AD;@9 :;9:7D
B7D8AD?3@57&)%H3D;3@FE@12A@7E;@9>7>AIB7D8AD?3@57
H3D;3@F @3?7>K )&)% I3E GE76 ;@ 6;887D7@F ( @7FIAD=
67B>AK?7@FF:3@F:7A@7BD7E7@F76;@F:;EB3B7D

)/)*##%"
!

;9 E:AIE F:7 4>A5= 6;39D3? A8 )43E76 5AAB7D3F;H7

EB75FDG? E7@E;@9 ?A67> *:7D7 3D7 )+E 5A>>34AD3F;@9 FA
;67@F;8KF:7BD7E7@57 34E7@57A8F:7 E;9@3>A8&+E*:7)+E

E7@6F:7;DE7@E;@9;@8AD?3F;A@A8F:73H3;>34;>;FKA8F:7&+EFA
*:7 GE7 A8 @3FGD3> D36;A EB75FDG? ;E D7EFD;5F76 4K ?3@K 35A??A@675;E;A@57@FD753>>768GE;A@57@FD735:)+
835FADEEG5:3EF:7767D3>A??G@;53F;A@A??;EE;A@ E7@E7EI:7F:7DF:7&+E;9@3>;EBD7E7@FAD34E7@F3@6F:;E53@
D79G>3F;A@E3@6F:7;@F7D87D7@57F:3F?;9:FA55GD47FI77@FIA 477JBD7EE763E34;@3DK:KBAF:7E;EF7EF
6;887D7@F 67H;57E *:7D78AD7 GF;>;L;@9 F:7 D36;A EB75FDG?
4E7@F
$ / [ 4 ] = #/ [ 4 ]

788;5;7@F>K ;E 7JFD7?7>K ;?BADF3@F %@7 A8 F:7 D757@F
F75:@A>A9;7E F:3F ;E 53B34>7 A8 GF;>;L;@9 F:7 D36;A EB75FDG?

&D7E7@F $ / [ 4 ] = -/ [ 4 ] + #/ [ 4]

788;5;7@F>K;E5A9@;F;H7D36;A((;@F7>>;97@F>K67F75FEF:7
8D7CG7@5K 43@6E F:3F 3D7 @AF GE76 4K F:7 >;57@E76 EKEF7? AD
-:7D7 $ / [ 4] ;E F:7 E;9@3> F:3F ;E D757;H76 3F F:7 /9. )+
BD;?3DKGE7D&+3@63>>A53F7EF:7E743@6EFAF:7G@>;57@E76
EKEF7? AD E75A@63DK GE7D )+ @ 5AAB7D3F;H7 EB75FDG? D757;H7D / = 4 = ;EF:7FAF3>@G?47D
E7@E;@9&+E7@E;@9?73EGD7?7@FE3D75A?4;@764K?73@EA8
:3D6675;E;A@ 8GE;A@ 12 AD EA8F675;E;A@ 8GE;A@ ) A8 E3?B>7E 3@6 = !8 I:7D7 ;E F:7 43@6I;6F: A8 F:7
12I:7D7)E:AIE47FF7D67F75F;A@B7D8AD?3@576G7FAF:7 E;9@3> 3@6 !8 ;E F:7 E7@E;@9 B7D;A6 #/ [ 4 ] 3@6 -/ 3D7 F:7
675;E;A@ ?3=;@9 BDA57EE 47;@9 ?367 3F 3 8GE;A@ 57@FD7 EF397 366;F;H7 I:;F7 3GEE;3@ @A;E7 -$ I;F: L7DA ?73@ 3@6
D3F:7DF:3@3FF:7)+EF3973E;@E57@3D;A@1 2397@7F;5

3>9AD;F:? I3E GE76 FA 8;@6 F:7 ABF;?3> I7;9:F;@9 H3D;3@57 A8 #/ 3@6 F:7 5:3@@7> 93;@ 47FI77@ F:7 &+ 3@6

$(%+*%$
*:;E IAD= ;E 8;@3@5;3>>K EBA@EAD76 4K F:7 #3>3KE;3@ #;@;EFDK A8

6G53F;A@ G@67D F:7 G@63?7@F3> (7E73D5: D3@F )5:7?7 I;F: BDA<75F
D787D7@575A67()
*
##+

978-1-4799-5982-2/14/$31.00 2014 IEEE
110
!
/9. )+D7EB75F;H7>K [ 4 ] ;EF:7E;9@3>F:3F;EFD3@E?;FF764K
-:7D7 = [ ] ;E F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F
F:7 &+ I:7D7 F:;E E;9@3> ;E 3EEG?76 FA 47 ;@67B7@67@F 3@6

=
H75FAD 3@6 ! ;@6;53F7E F:3F F:7 H75FAD ;E FD3@EBAE76
/
@AD?3>>K 6;EFD;4GF76 I;F: L7DA ?73@ 3@6 H3D;3@57 A8 F

F:7 F:7 D757;H76 )+E E;9@3>E 3D7 ;@ F:7 / ./ #/ + / 3@6
= */'-
/ 3D7 F:7 H3D;3@57
8AD? %/ [ 4 ] = / ./ =/ [ 4 ] + / [ 4 ] I:7D7 / ;EF:7BAI7DF:3F 3@6 5AH3D;3@57 A8 % [ 4 ] G@67D I:;>7 =
/
/
;EFD3@E?;FF764K /9. )+ ./ ;EF:75:3@@7>93;@8ADF:7 /9. )+

-/ 8 +
/ 3@6 = */'-8
/ + / ./ -/
3@6>;@=3@6 / [ 4 ] ;E3@-$@A;E7;@F:7 / )+
>;@=I;F:F:73EEG?BF;A@F:3F;FE?73@;EL7DA3@6;FEH3D;3@57 3D7 F:7 H3D;3@57 3@6 5AH3D;3@57 A8 %/ [ 4 ] G@67D I:7D7
;E / 8F7DD757;H;@93>>F:7)+EE;9@3>E3@6478AD73675;E;A@ */'- () ;E36;39A@3>?3FD;J8F7D8;@6;@9F:7F7EFEF3F;EF;5E&
53@47?367F:753>5G>3F7EF:7FAF3>7@7D9K8AD3>>F:7)+E F:7 >;=7>;:AA6 D3F;A F7EF ;E GE76 FA 675;67 8AD A@7 A8 F:7
/ ./
9.
B3F:E 3@6 399D793F7E F:7? 4K & =
& I:7D7 ;E F:7

/ /
/ =
I7;9:F;@95A788;5;7@FA8F:7 / B3F:3@6 &/ =
:KBAF:7E7E
AD *:7 >;=7>;:AA6 D3F;A F7EF 53@ 47

7JBD7EE763E & <> I:7D7 ;EF:77@7D9KF:D7E:A>6E3
9.
% [ 4]
/
4 =
D7EG>FF:7BDA434;>;FKA867F75F;A@3@6F:7BDA434;>;FKA8 83>E7
;EF:7 3>3D?3D78AD?G>3F763E8A>>AIE
7@7D9K8DA?F:7 /9. )+E;9@3>*:7?73@3@6H3D;3@57A8F:7

53>5G>3F76F7EFEF3F;EF;5E & G@67D4AF::KBAF:7E;E
3@6
3D79;H7@4K12
( &
) =

/
"'7
( & ) =

/
(
/

/ =
/ =
/
/
+ /

(& )

, = ( & >

) =

"'7 ( & )
/
/ + /
/ =
/ =
( & ) =
"'7
( &
) =
/
(& )

* = ( & > ) =

"'7 ( & )

K EG4EF;FGF;@9 FA ;@FA 3@6 F:7 * 53@ 47
= *
ID;FF7@;@F7D?EA8 , 3E8A>>AIE
=
( )

,
* ( ) =

!

!

-:7D7
( =) =
9
7JB

8 / ./
*9 = [
]! /
=
-/
;H7@3BD7678;@76 , F:77CG3F;A@A8 * ( ) ;@:3E

/-25)1*/'-7'35, ('8+*)556+7'9/;+86+)97:38+48/4-
F:7 34;>;FK FA 9;H7 355GD3F7 67F75F;A@ D7EG>FE ;@ )43E76

5AAB7D3F;H7 E7@E;@9 F ;E 5>73D F:3F * ( ) 5D;F;53>>K 67B7@6E
A@ F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F H75FAD *:GE F:7 ABF;?3>
I7;9:F;@95A788;5;7@FH75FAD;E;@835FF:7ABF;?3>EA>GF;A@*:7
?3;@ A4<75F;H7 A8 F:;E IAD= ;E FA GE7 &)% FA 8;@6 3BBDABD;3F7
H3>G7E 8AD F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@FE F:3F ?3J;?;L7 * ( )
111
*:7H3>G7A8 / ;E;@F:7D3@97
< / < I;F:F:75A@6;F;A@

F:3F

*+)%&)%*%$*%&*#"
-*$%$*,*%(
&)% ;E 3@ 788;5;7@F 7HA>GF;A@3DK 3>9AD;F:? 12 F:3F :3E
BDAH76;FE78875F;H7@7EE;@EA>H;@95A?B>7J:;9:6;?7@E;A@3>
3@6 ?G>F;?A63> ABF;?;L3F;A@ 8G@5F;A@E )&)% EG887DE 8DA?
BD7?3FGD75A@H7D97@573@647;@9FD3BB76;@>A53>ABF;?3 12
@835F3>AFA83FF7?BFE;@F:7>;F7D3FGD7:3H7477@5A@6G5F76
;@AD67DFAAH7D5A?7F:7E76D3I435=E)&)%BDA57EEEF3DFE4K
;@;F;3>;L;@9F:7BABG>3F;A@3@6>7FF;@9735:B3DF;5>78>;7E;@F:7
EB357 FA 8;@6 3 47FF7D EA>GF;A@ I:7D7 735: B3DF;5>7 ;E 3FFD35F76
4K ;FE 47EF AI@ BAE;F;A@ 3E I7>> 3E F:7 >7367D BAE;F;A@ *:7@
735: B3DF;5>7 GB63F7E ;FE H7>A5;FK 3@6 BAE;F;A@ 43E76 A@
7CG3F;A@E
3@6 D7EB75F;H7>K *:7 8;F@7EE 8G@5F;A@ ;E
7H3>G3F76 43E76 A@ F:7 GB63F76 BAE;F;A@ 3@6 ;F ;E 5A?B3D76
I;F: F:7 B3DF;5>7 47EF BAE;F;A@ 3@6 F:7 9>A43> 47EF BAE;F;A@ 8
F:7 @7I BAE;F;A@ :3E 3 47FF7D 8;F@7EE F:7@ F:7 B3DF;5>7 47EF
BAE;F;A@I;>>GB63F76I;F:F:7@7IBAE;F;A@>EAF:7D7EG>F;@9
B3DF;5>747EFBAE;F;A@;E5A?B3D76I;F:F:79>A43>47EFBAE;F;A@
3@6F:7>3F7DI;>>47GB63F76;8F:7B3DF;5>747EFBAE;F;A@D7EG>FE
;@347FF7D8;F@7EE*:7BDA57EED7B73FEG@F;>3EFABB;@95D;F7D;3
EG5:3EF:7?3J;?G?@G?47DA8;F7D3F;A@E;E?7F%@573>>F:7
;F7D3F;A@E :3H7 477@ 5A?B>7F76 F:7 &)% IAG>6 :3H7
5A@H7D976 FA F:7 ABF;?3> EA>GF;A@ *:7 H7>A5;FKGB63F7
7CG3F;A@;EID;FF7@3E
;/0 ( 9 + ) = ;/0 ( 9 ) + )
7 (+89/0 ( 9 ) =/0 ( 9 ) + ) 7 (+89 0 ( 9 ) =/0 ( 9 )
B3DF;5>7 8AD F:7 0 F: )+ 3F F;?7 9 ;9 E:AIE F:7 &E7G6A
5A67 A8 F:7 )&)% 3>9AD;F:? FA ABF;?;L7 F:7 67F75F;A@
BDA434;>;FK ;@ (757@F>K F:7D7 :3H7 477@ ?3@K &)%
H3D;3@FE BDABAE76 FA 8;@6 3 9AA6 43>3@57 47FI77@ 7JB>AD3F;A@
3@6 7JB>A;F3F;A@ I:;5: D7EG>FE ;@ EA>H;@9 F:7 BD7?3FGD7
5A@H7D97@573EI7>>3EEA>H;@9F:7BDA4>7?A847;@9FD3BB76;@
>A53> ABF;?3 *:7 IAD= ;@ 12 BD7E7@F76 3 @7I H3D;3@F &)%
53>>76 E7>8AD93@;L;@9 :;7D3D5:3> &)% I;F: F;?7 H3DK;@9
3557>7D3F;A@5A788;5;7@FE&)%*,@&)%*,F:7
H7>A5;FK GB63F7 7CG3F;A@ 5A@E;EFE A@>K A8 F:7 5A9@;F;H7 3@6
EA5;3>B3DFEA8F:7B3DF;5>7EI3D??7F:A63@6F:7B3DF;5>7E3D7
D7;@;F;3>;L76 ;@ 53E7 A8 EF39@3F;A@ ?76;3@AD;7@F76 &)%
#&)% I3E ;@FDA6G576 ;@ 12 I:7D7 3 @7I H75FAD 53>>76
?76;3@ BAE;F;A@ ;E 5A@EFDG5F76 3@6 ;F ;E 36676 FA F:7 H7>A5;FK
GB63F7 7CG3F;A@ *:;E 3>9AD;F:? ?;@;?;L76 F:7 GE397 A8 F:7
5A@FDA>>;@9 B3D3?7F7DE 4K @AF GE;@9 F:7 ;@7DF;3 I7;9:F <
5A788;5;7@F ) 3@6EA5;3>5A788;5;7@F )
)

)F7B
78;@7 F:7 EI3? E;L7
)+E
;@F:7 0 F:6;?7@E;A@ ) ;E3@3557>7D3F;A@5A@EF3@F=@AI@3E

5A9@;F;H7 >73D@;@9 D3F7 I:7D73E ) ;E 3@AF:7D 3557>7D3F;A@
5A@EF3@F =@AI@ 3E EA5;3> >73D@;@9 D3F7 7 3@6 7 3D7 FIA
G@;8AD?D3@6A?H3>G7E;@F:7;@F7DH3>1
2 (+89/0 ( 9 ) ;EF:7
47EFBAE;F;A@F:3F:3E477@35:;7H76EA83D4KF:7 / F:B3DF;5>7
;@F:7 0 F:6;?7@E;A@ =/0 ( 9 ) ;EF:75GDD7@FBAE;F;A@A8F:7 /
F:B3DF;5>7;@F:7 0 F:6;?7@E;A@ (+89 0 ( 9 ) ;EF:7BAE;F;A@A8
F:7 B3DF;5>7 I:A :3E A4F3;@76 F:7 47EF EA>GF;A@ ;@ F:7 I:A>7
EI3D?*:7@7IH7>A5;FK ;/0 ( 9 + ) ;EGE76FAGB63F7F:7@7I
BAE;F;A@A8735:B3DF;5>743E76A@F:78A>>AI;@97CG3F;A@
=/0 ( 9 + ) = =/0 ( 9 ) + ;/0 ( 9 + )
;/0 ( 9 + ) = ;/0 ( 9 ) + )
7 (+89/0 ( 9 ) /0 ( 9 ) + ) 7 (+89 0 ( 9 ) /0 ( 9 )
"*,735:I7;9:F;@95A788;5;7@FH75FAD /
7@7D3F7;FEBAE;F;A@ /0 D3@6A?>K;@F:7
D3@971
2
)7F;FEH7>A5;FK ;/0 ( 9 ) FAL7DA

!) "*,
)7F (+89/ = / 3@6 * ( (+89/ ) = * (/ )

!) "*,
)7F (+89 = (+89
"*,735:B3DF;5>7 /
%" * ( (+89/ ) > * ( (+89 )
.$!) (+89 = (+89/
!) "*,
)F7B
,!+!.
"*,735:B3DF;5>7 /
"*,735:)+ 0
7H3>G3F7F:7H7>A5;FK ;/0 ( 9 + ) 3E;@
7H3>G3F7F:7BAE;F;A@ /0 ( 9 + ) 3E;@
@ F:;E B3B7D F:7 ?3;@ 3;? ;E FA ?3J;?;L7 * ( ) ;@
GE;@96;887D7@F&)%H3D;3@FE@F:7BDA57EEA8?3J;?;L;@9F:7
* ( ) 8G@5F;A@4KF:7EF3@63D6&)%3>9AD;F:?735:B3DF;5>7
A8 3 EI3D? D7BD7E7@FE 3 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F H75FAD I:AE7
6;?7@E;A@;EF:7@G?47DA8F:7)+E I:7D73EF:7BAE;F;A@
3@6H7>A5;FKGB63F77CG3F;A@E3D7F:7E3?77CG3F;A@E;@

3@6I;F:5:3@9;@9F:7@AF;8;53F;A@E3E8A>>AIE
3@6 F:7 @G?47D A8
"*,735:)+ 0
-:7D7 ;/0 ( 9 ) ;EF:7H7>A5;FK3FF;?7 9 A8F:7 / F:B3DF;5>7

I:7D7 /0 ( 9 ) ;E F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F A8 F:7 / F:
=
/ =
/0 ( 9 + ) = /0 ( 9 ) + ;/0 ( 9 + )
)
112
!) "*,
%" * (/ 9 + ) > * ( (+89/ )

.$!) (+89/ = / ( 9 + )
%" * ( (+89/ ) > * ( (+89 )
.$!) (+89 = (+89/

!) "*,
/).%''3EFABB;@95A@6;F;A@;EE3F;E8;76
/-8+:*5)5*+5, 95569/3/?+ * ( )
@ 1
2 3 57@FD;B7F3> 3557>7D3F76 &)% &)% 3>9AD;F:?
I3E BD7E7@F76 *:;E 3>9AD;F:? 3BB>;7E $7IFA@ME >3IE A8
?AF;A@FAF:7&)%3>9AD;F:?3@6366EFIA?AD7EB75;8;53F;A@E
FA 735: B3DF;5>7 =@AI@ 3E 3557>7D3F;A@ 3@6 57@FD;B7F3>
3557>7D3F;A@ 47E;67E H7>A5;FK 3@6 BAE;F;A@ 9D3H;FK43E76
&)%I;F::K4D;65AAB7D3F;H7EI3D?&)%I3EBDABAE76;@
12 @ &)% F:7 9D3H;FK 5A@57BF I3E 5A?4;@76 I;F: F:7
5AAB7D3F;H7 3BBDA35: ;@ 12 D7EG>F;@9 ;@ 3 @7I &)% H3D;3@F
*:7 &)% I3E :K4D;6;L76 I;F: 9D3H;F3F;A@3> E73D5: 3>9AD;F:?
) ;@ 12 FA BDA6G57 3 @7I &)% H3D;3@F 53>>76
9D3H;F3F;A@3> B3DF;5>7 EI3D? &) *:7 BAE;F;A@E ;@ &) 3D7
GB63F76 4K F:7 H7>A5;FK A8 &)% 3@6 3557>7D3F;A@ A8 )
*:7E7D757@F7J;EF;@9&)%H3D;3@FE3D7 GE7647E;67F:7 GE7A8
F:7 )&)% FA EA>H7 F:7 BDA4>7? ;@ *A F:7 3GF:ADEM
=@AI>7697&)%;EF:7A@>K&)%H3D;3@F3?A@9F:7E78;H7
H3D;3@FEF:3F:3E477@GE76FAEA>H7F:75A9@;F;H7D36;ABDA4>7?
;@@12F:7BDA434;>;FKA867F75F;A@:3E477@?3J;?;L76
4KF:7&)%3EI7>>3EEA?7AF:7DI7>>=@AI@&)%H3D;3@FE
EG5: 3E F:7 5AAB7D3F;H7 &)% &)% 12 3@6 F:7 8G>>K
;@8AD?76 B3DF;5>7 EI3D? &) 1 2 *:7 D7EG>FE E:AI F:3F
&)% AGFB7D8AD?E 3>> F:7 AF:7DE ;@ F7D?E A8 F:7 47EF E5AD7
5A@H7D97@57EB7763@6EF34;>;FK
,
IAD6E F:7 ABF;?3> I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F H75FAD ;E 8AG@6 4K

&) *:7 &)%*, 5A?7E @7JF 8A>>AI76 4K &)%
&)% )&)% 3@6 #&)% >F:AG9: F:7 &) A4F3;@E F:7
:;9:7EF8;F@7EEH3>G7;FE5A@H7D97@57EB776;EH7DKE>AIF;E
A4E7DH76F:3FF:783EF7EF5A@H7D97@57;EA4F3;@764K&)%3E
;F35:;7H7E3BDA434;>;FK67F75F;A@A8
3F;F7D3F;A@@G?47D
I:;>7 &) 35:;7H7E 3 BDA434;>;FK 67F75F;A@ A8
3F
;F7D3F;A@ @G?47D *:7 3H7D397 47EF EA>GF;A@ 3@6 EF3@63D6
67H;3F;A@ ) A8 F:7 )&)% 3@6 F:7 AF:7D &)% H3D;3@FE 3D7
D75AD676 ;@ *34>7 I:7D7 F:7 47EF D7EG>F ;E ;@6;53F76 ;@
4A>68357%@F:7AF:7D:3@6 F:7EF3@63D667H;3F;A@A8&);E
F:7 >AI7EF I:7@ 5A?B3D76 I;F: F:7 AF:7D &)% H3D;3@FE *:;E
?73@EF:3F&);EF:7?AEFEF34>7H3D;3@F*:GE;F;E5A@5>G676
F:3F &) ;E F:7 47EF 5:A;57 FA ?3J;?;L7 F:7 BDA4>7? ;@
7CG3F;A@ I:7@ F:7 EA>GF;A@ CG3>;FK ;E F3=7@ ;@FA
5A@E;67D3F;A@I:7D73EF:7&)%;EF:747EFABF;A@I:7@83EF
D7EBA@E7 AD 5A@H7D97@57 EB776 ;E D7CG;D76 AD 735: &)%
H3D;3@F F:7 D757;H7D AB7D3F;@9 5:3D35F7D;EF;5E (% I:;5:
E:AIE F:7 BDA434;>;FK A8 67F75F;A@ 8AD 3>> F:7 BAEE;4>7
BDA434;>;F;7E A8 83>E7 3>3D? ;E E:AI@ ;@ ;9 F ;E 5>73D F:3F
&)35:;7H7EF:7:;9:7EFBDA434;>;FKA867F75F;A@8AD3@K9;H7@
BDA434;>;FKA883>E73>3D?
)#+"*%$)*+&$()+"*)
#*" EA8FI3D7 :3E 477@ GE76 FA ;?B>7?7@F 3@6

5A?B3D7F:7EF3@63D6&)%3@6F:78;H7AF:7D&)%H3D;3@FE*:7
B3D3?7F7DE7FF;@9E8ADF:7($7@H;DA@?7@F3D7EG??3D;L76;@
*34>73E76A@F:7IAD=BD7E7@F76;@12F:75:3@@7>@A;E7E
#/ / 3@6 93;@E { -/ ./ } 3D7 97@7D3F76 D3@6A?>K *:7
*"&)%&(#*()**$)
++,*$
>>
FKB7A85:3@@7>;E3EEG?76FA473E>AI836;@95:3@@7>I:7D7
F:7 H3>G7E A8 { -/ }3@6 {./ }6A @AF 5:3@97 AH7D 735: E7@E;@9
F;?7B7D;A6*:7@A;E7E3@693;@EA8F:75:3@@7>3D7E7>75F76FA
D73>;L7 >AI )$( 5A@6;F;A@ ;@ AD67D FA E:AI F:3F F:7 &)%
H3D;3@FE B7D8AD? I7>> 7H7@ ;8 F:7 IADEF 53E7 ;E 7@5AG@F7D76
*:7B3D3?7F7DE7FF;@9EA8F:7&)%H3D;3@FE8ADF:;EBDA4>7?3D7
>;EF76;@*34>7AD83;D5A?B3D;EA@F:7EI3D?E;L73@6F:7
@G?47DA8;F7D3F;A@E3D7E7FFA
3@6
D7EB75F;H7>K
&)%
&)%
*,
#&)%
&)%
&)

&)%
,(!.!,

$G?47DA8;F7D3F;A@E
(G@E
) )
!..%)#-
)/ ) , )/ ) ,

) ) ) )
<
) ) <

0.95
*"(&(#*())**$)
&+FD3@E?;FBAI7D 8
)+FD3@E?;FBAI7D /
'/!
0.9

6?
0.85
0.8
Best Fitness
!!%0!,,(!.!,

&DA434;>;FKA883>E73>3D?
$G?47DA8)+E
6?
&+)+5:3@@7>@A;E7 #/

#/
6?
)+5:3@@7>@A;E7 /

/
6?
:3@@7>93;@E -/

-/
6?
:3@@7>93;@E ./
3@6I;6F:
)7@E;@9F;?7 !8

./
6?
#L
E75
0.75
0.7
PSO-gbest
CGPSO
MPSO
Gravitional PSO
CAPSO
HPSO-TVAC
0.65
0.6
0.55

*:7 D7EG>FE A4F3;@76 8DA? A@7 E;@9>7 DG@ 3D7 @AF D7>;34>7
E;@57 F:7 BDA57EE ;E D3@6A? *:GE FA 35:;7H7 ?73@;@98G>
D7EG>FE F:7 @G?47D A8 DG@E ;E E7F FA 47
3@6 F:7 D7EG>FE 3D7
F:7@ 3H7D3976 ?A@9 3>> F:7 &)% H3D;3@FE >;EF76 ;@ *34>7
&)35:;7H7EF:747EF8;F@7EEH3>G73EE:AI@;@;9 @AF:7D
113
100
200
300
400
500
600
Iteration Number
700
800
900
1000
/- +89,/94+88'4*)54;+7-+4)+86++*5, ;'7/'498

,
0.88
0.87
0.86
Best Fitness
0.85
0.84
0.83
0.82
PSO-gbest
CGPSO
MPSO
Gravitional PSO
CAPSO
HPSO-TVAC
0.81
0.8
0.79
985
990
995
1000
Iteration Number
%$"+)%$
;@6;@9F:73BBDABD;3F7I7;9:F;@95A788;5;7@FH75FAD;@(
@7FIAD=E ;E 3 5:3>>7@9;@9 F3E= 7@5AG@F7D76 ;@ )43E76
5AAB7D3F;H7 EB75FDG? E7@E;@9 E57@3D;A F ;E 5DG5;3> FA :3H7 3
F75:@;CG7 F:3F ;E 34>7 FA ABF;?;L7 F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F
H75FAD I:;5: B>3KE 3@ ;?BADF3@F DA>7 ;@ ;?BDAH;@9 D73>F;?7
67F75F;A@ B7D8AD?3@57 *:7 B7D8AD?3@57 A8 )&)% 3@6 8;H7
AF:7D &)% H3D;3@FE :3H7 477@ 7J3?;@76 I:;>7 8;@6;@9 F:7
ABF;?3>I7;9:F;@95A788;5;7@FH75FAD*:7B7D8AD?3@57A8F:7E7
&)% H3D;3@FE ;E <G6976 43E76 A@ F:7 47EF8AG@6 EA>GF;A@
5A@H7D97@57 EB776 3@6 EF34;>;FK *:7 D7EG>FE E:AI F:3F &)
AGFB7D8AD?E F:7 AF:7D &)% H3D;3@FE ;@ F7D?E A8 F:7 47EF
EA>GF;A@ 3@6 EF34;>;FK I:;>7 &)% 35:;7H7E F:7 83EF7EF
5A@H7D97@57 EB776 *:GE F:;E IAD= 53>>E 8AD 3@3>KL;@9 ?AD7
7J;EF;@9 &)% H3D;3@FE AD 67H7>AB;@9 @7I 47FF7D H3D;3@FE F:3F

E3F;E8K4AF:CG3>;FK3@6EB776D7CG;D7?7@FE
/-
&553/4,579.+2'89,+<-+4+7'9/5485,/-

(($)
0.8
P ro b a b ilit y o f d e t e c t io n , P d
12
SPSO
CGPSO
MPSO
GPS
CAPSO
HPSO-TVAC
0.9
0.7
12
0.6
0.5
1 2
0.4
0.3
12
0.2
0.1
0
12
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
Probability of False Aram,Pf
0.7
0.8
0.9

12
/-6+7,573'4)+

*"*,()*)%"+*%$$)% * ( )
,%).
&)%
0#!-.-*'/.%*)

&)%
*,

#&)%

&)%

&)

&)%

12

12
12
1
2

12
12
1 2

114
0 -7; ( ! #3>>;= 3@6 " !:3>76 AAB7D3F;H7 )B75FDG?
)7@E;@9 %BF;?;L3F;A@ ;@ A9@;F;H7 (36;A $7FIAD=E ;@
533:4/)'9/548 49+74'9/54'2 54,+7+4)+
54
BB
# G@0GA6A@93@6"/7)A8FA?4;@3F;A@3@67F75F;A@
8AD AAB7D3F;H7 )B75FDG? )7@E;@9 ;@ A9@;F;H7 (36;A $7FIAD=E
#/7+2+88533:4/)'9/548!7'48')9/54854HA>BB

>)3>7:# E?3;>3@6##>;7@7F;53>9AD;F:?
3EE;EF76 EA8F 8GE;A@43E76 >;@73D 5AAB7D3F;H7 EB75FDG? E7@E;@9
2+)9754/)8=67+88HA>BB

/ " "77 >)3>7: 3@6 # E?3;> D3H;FK43E76 B3DF;5>7
EI3D? ABF;?;L3F;A@ I;F: :K4D;6 5AAB7D3F;H7 EI3D? 3BBDA35: 8AD
9>A43>ABF;?;L3F;A@5:74'25,49+22/-+49'4*:??> >89+38HA>
BB

) 0:7@9 "AG 3@6 . /3@9 AAB7D3F;H7 EB75FDG? E7@E;@9
GE;@9B3DF;5>7EI3D?ABF;?;E3F;A@2+)9754/)8+99+78HA>BB

' 0:; ):G9G3@9 3@6 )3K76 %BF;?3> ";@73D
AAB7D3F;A@ 8AD )B75FDG? )7@E;@9 ;@ A9@;F;H7 (36;A $7FIAD=E
+2+)9+*!56/)8/4 /-4'275)+88/4-5:74'25,HA>BB

!7@@76K 3@6 ( 47D:3DF &3DF;5>7 EI3D? ABF;?;L3F;A@ ;@
+:7'2 +9<5718 75)++*/4-8 49+74'9/54'2
54,+7+4)+54BBHA>
(3F@3I77D3)3>93?G973@6-3FEA@)7>8AD93@;L;@9
:;7D3D5:;53> B3DF;5>7 EI3D? ABF;?;L7D I;F: F;?7H3DK;@9
3557>7D3F;A@ 5A788;5;7@FE ;52:9/54'7> 536:9'9/54
!7'48')9/54854HA>BB

07:7E:F;)#):3?EG66;@3@6)3E3@#&)%#76;3@
AD;7@F76 &3DF;5>7 )I3D? %BF;?;L3F;A@ 662/+* '9.+3'9/)8 '4*
536:9'9/54HA>BB

0 7:7E:F; 3@6 ) # < ):3?EG66;@ &)% 7@FD;B7F3>
3557>7D3F76 B3DF;5>7 EI3D? ABF;?;L3F;A@ 4,573'9/54 )/+4)+8
HA>BB

,3@67@7D9:3@6&@97>4D75:FAAB7D3F;H73BBDA35:
FA B3DF;5>7 EI3D? ABF;?;L3F;A@ ;52:9/54'7> 536:9'9/54
!7'48')9/54854HA>BB

*E3; // *K3@ /- -G 3@6 / ";@ D3H;F3F;A@3>
B3DF;5>7 EI3D? 662/+*'9.+3'9/)8 '4*536:9'9/54 HA>
BB

(#7@67E !7@@76K3@6 $7H7E*:78G>>K;@8AD?76B3DF;5>7
EI3D? E;?B>7D ?3K47 47FF7D ;52:9/54'7> 536:9'9/54
!7'48')9/54854HA>BB

3D7C#) :3? K?3@ ) 3 7: 3@6K?7@#!3D77?

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originaltitel

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

3D7C#) :3? K?3@ ) 3 7: 3@6K?7@#!3D77?

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

2014 IEEE 2nd International Symposium on Telecommunication Technologies (ISTT), Langkawi, Malaysia (24-26 Nov 2014)

    

5A788;5;7@F H75FAD ;@ 3 )43E76 5AAB7D3F;H7 EB75FDG?

!          

;67@F;8KF:7BD7E7@57 34E7@57A8F:7 E;9@3>A8&+E*:7)+E

*:;E IAD= ;E 8;@3@5;3>>K EBA@EAD76 4K F:7 #3>3KE;3@ #;@;EFDK A8

978-1-4799-5982-2/14/$31.00 2014 IEEE

;EFD3@E?;FF764K /9. )+ ./ ;EF:75:3@@7>93;@8ADF:7 /9. )+

B3F:E 3@6 399D793F7E F:7? 4K & =

& I:7D7 ;E F:7

I7;9:F;@95A788;5;7@FA8F:7 / B3F:3@6 &/ =

7JBD7EE763E & <> I:7D7 ;EF:77@7D9KF:D7E:A>6E3

7@7D9K8DA?F:7 /9. )+E;9@3>*:7?73@3@6H3D;3@57A8F:7

;H7@3BD7678;@76 , F:77CG3F;A@A8 * ( ) ;@:3E

F:7 34;>;FK FA 9;H7 355GD3F7 67F75F;A@ D7EG>FE ;@ )43E76

;@F:7 0 F:6;?7@E;A@ ) ;E3@3557>7D3F;A@5A@EF3@F=@AI@3E

F:B3DF;5>7;@F:7 0 F:6;?7@E;A@ (+89 0 ( 9 ) ;EF:7BAE;F;A@A8

)7F;FEH7>A5;FK ;/0 ( 9 ) FAL7DA

)7F (+89/ = / 3@6 * ( (+89/ ) = * (/ )

7H3>G3F7F:7BAE;F;A@ /0 ( 9 + ) 3E;@

3@6 F:7 @G?47D A8

-:7D7 ;/0 ( 9 ) ;EF:7H7>A5;FK3FF;?7 9 A8F:7 / F:B3DF;5>7

I:7D7 /0 ( 9 ) ;E F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F A8 F:7 / F:

%" * (/ 9 + ) > * ( (+89/ )

.$!) (+89 = (+89/

/-8+:*5)5*+5,  95569/3/?+ * ( )

IAD6E F:7 ABF;?3> I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F H75FAD ;E 8AG@6 4K

#*" EA8FI3D7 :3E 477@ GE76 FA ;?B>7?7@F 3@6

/- +89,/94+88'4*)54;+7-+4)+86++*5, ;'7/'498

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen

5A788;5;7@F H75FAD ;@ 3 )43E76 5AAB7D3F;H7 EB75FDG?

!

;67@F;8KF:7BD7E7@57 34E7@57A8F:7 E;9@3>A8&+E*:7)+E

;EFD3@E?;FF764K /9. )+ ./ ;EF:75:3@@7>93;@8ADF:7 /9. )+

7JBD7EE763E & <> I:7D7 ;EF:77@7D9KF:D7E:A>6E3

7@7D9K8DA?F:7 /9. )+E;9@3>*:7?73@3@6H3D;3@57A8F:7

;H7@3BD7678;@76 , F:77CG3F;A@A8 * ( ) ;@:3E

F:7 34;>;FK FA 9;H7 355GD3F7 67F75F;A@ D7EG>FE ;@ )43E76

;@F:7 0 F:6;?7@E;A@ ) ;E3@3557>7D3F;A@5A@EF3@F=@AI@3E

F:B3DF;5>7;@F:7 0 F:6;?7@E;A@ (+89 0 ( 9 ) ;EF:7BAE;F;A@A8

)7F (+89/ = / 3@6 * ( (+89/ ) = * (/ )

-:7D7 ;/0 ( 9 ) ;EF:7H7>A5;FK3FF;?7 9 A8F:7 / F:B3DF;5>7

I:7D7 /0 ( 9 ) ;E F:7 I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F A8 F:7 / F:

%" * (/ 9 + ) > * ( (+89/ )

.$!) (+89 = (+89/

/-8+:5)5+5, 95569/3/?+ * ( )

IAD6E F:7 ABF;?3> I7;9:F;@9 5A788;5;7@F H75FAD ;E 8AG@6 4K

#*" EA8FI3D7 :3E 477@ GE76 FA ;?B>7?7@F 3@6

/- +89,/94+88'4)54;+7-+4)+86++5, ;'7/'498