Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Book Illumination
Kurt Weitzmann
Late Antique
Book
Illumination
Late Antique
and Early Christian
Book
Illumination
Kurt Weitzmann
Qeorge Braziller
New York
Published
in
L977.
George
One
Braziller, Inc.
Park Avenue,
New
And
Early Christian
Book Illumination
Bibliography: p. 25
1.
Early Christian.
ND2930.W42
I.
Title.
745.6'7'09495
ISBN 0-8076-0830-0
ISBN 0-8076-0831-9 pbk.
First Printing
76-16444
Acknowledgements
the publisher
would
like to
who kindly
Color Plates
BERLIN, Deutsche
CAMBRIDGE,
FLORENCE,
Biblioteca Mediceo Laurenziana, Plates 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 48 (Photo,
LONDON,
University College,
London).
MILAN,
Paris).
ROME,
1,
VIENNA,
OsterreichischeNationalbibliothek, Plates 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 23, 24,
WASHINGTON,
W.
Black-and-White Figures
FLORENCE,
LONDON,
ROME,
IX,
VIENNA,
III,
WASHINGTON,
XVI.
W.
Contents
Introduction
Selected Bibliography
25
Descriptions of Manuscripts
27
32
Introduction
One
of the most important events in the history of the book, comparable in im-
the
form
in
which
is
it
still
used today)
at
first
century A.D.
poet Martial wrote several epigrams (XIV, 186, 192, etc.) in praise of the
papyrus
had
rolls,
in
on an average 3035
to be written
it
on
as
many
scrolls.
The
new
whole of
form of
the
in
(in
peted with each other, and not before the fourth century did the codex become
the predominant form.
written their
Book
of the
conquest of Egypt and the foundation of Alexandria did papyrus become widespread in the Greek, and later in the Roman, world.
famous
library of Alexandria,
700,000
scrolls,
illustrated,
we
if
and the
burned
at the
loss
When
Many
it
possessed
must be considered
equally tragic.
What,
then,
is
scrolls
were
illustrated?
There
XXXV.II.ll) recounting
that
is
famous
Varro
(first
that these
were spread
all
and an
all
active
kinds
of natural science texts were illustrated by explanatory pictures. Here again, Pliny
is
our best witness (N. H. XXV.IV.8), telling us that the herbals of Crateuas,
Dionysius, and Metrodorus were "most attractively" illustrated with colored like-
<*J
.>
'
%
<h^~*
AT?
ji i-^-r
'/-*-*
fc^lp^p^
II
nesses of the plants. Illustrated herbals in particular have survived in later copies
(Plates 15-20).
Among
it
Alex-
little
is
ciple survived in
many
strip.
induced to
codices
(Figure
possibilities.
X) and
Flat
to the next.
is
still
parchment
in quick succession
sheets, not
having to be
fresco
a single
scene and thus the imitation of the general effect of an actual panel, fresco, or
result,
became
held until the miniature was replaced by the woodcut and engraving.
It
must, however, be emphasized that, since so few Late Antique and Early
century) have
come down
in
lost,
datable models
what might
justifiably
Figures
be called
u
[::AM5VAiAV\:Ao:vMLAAVMCv,\u\.vrvA\.,\
X\AiOM30A KAOVN!lAUl5DtAlONIl6V^V.U'BL\J
,
t^UvON5V\VVa\UOOK-rAHOA-AK6Ah\ilXlhi
in
medallion
papyrus
of illustration in
roll,
Such a medallion
portrait.
types of texts
all
is
in the
made
Vatican Terence manuscript (Figure VIII), where the codex format has
possible
its
actors.
In the codex, the seated author became the most widely accepted form of author
portrait.
In
initial
stages, as in the
solution
17),
filled
came
who
strip
Vergilius
Romanus (Figure
III),
he
scrolls.
The
sits in
still
is
final
(Plate
authors in the long history of book illumination (Plates 33, 35, 42), and here
colonnaded buildings,
Roman
The
in
some
,
are a
common
feature.
only in seventeenth-century
is,
unfortunately, preserved
The Calendar
tinus, reveals
made
is
a subject
and the
series of the
is
characteristic of Late
high
artistic level as
famed
is
like
Roma
II,
silver plates;
most familiar
in
scientific texts,
literary texts.
illustrators of
found on
contemporary
and some
first
of Valen-
name
Some
were
floor mosaics.
texts
of practical
illustrated
on the same
we
it
.
x,
v
>
4
I
II II
'
II
I\
\j\
III
ik Vii
'
<
i'M
'
i>
>
III
I*
j'
;,
'
U<nf<l|.j
(i
..,,-
.-.I'
\
>
vrn.'i
Ml
miii'm
,
KM,
I
if IT' ><|.\
ltl\Mi l|i
U V Vi
n-MlX/.t-y it'll.:''' vj'\ipy{|i!inin
:
\. iv
i,
I'M
'
"
<
M'triMliil
|>
I'VKIfll
>
IC
'
ii
\J'i :\
tr'--
v'*
oh'fT.\
MXUOlCTfS
.U.Ui.WOnah'i'MJW/ACMA
VI
VII
in
an
miniatures (Plates 15-17), has not only delicately painted plant pic-
tuous
title
tures
of great verisimilitude
appended
one
treatises:
to a
(Plate
poem on
sump-
on the poisonous
Among
bites
we have
greatest popularity,
Iliad
an Iliad
now
in
thus had a
Odyssey nor any of the other Greek epic poems has survived.
From the
down to us,
West two
illustrated
early,
Not
Latin
style,
in
Rome and
the
other in an undetermined province, but they are also different in their iconography,
suggesting that illustration of the Aeneid began in more than one place.
Next
in popularity
among
illustrated
literary texts
The
new
first
char-
the catalogue of the masks in their exact shapes and proper colors (Figure IX),
still
scripts of Euripides
classical
dramatists,
must
Vergilius
pastoral
Rom an us
life
first
art.
An
To
lore
(Plate
illustrated Theocritus
(Plates
1,
The
scenes
texts
and animal
Georgics, with a
influenced Christian
the
mind
made from
branch of
tion,
art,
but
in
not only by following the technical aspects of classical books, but also by
style, their
13
k
:,
riKfM
.V'
a*..
ii
VIII
"
jglltlfptT*
-I
>
'i
'
"i jurfikbriiivillicul
ftdeccu tpfu
IX
In the center of Early Christian book illumination stands the Bible, assuming
a position comparable to that of
Homer
in ancient
book illumination.
It is
most
books of the Bible, for the obvious reason that the scenes follow in such quick
succession and are so
Bible
Our
from the
on
that,
a practical impossibility.
miniatures
Biblical
earliest
illustrated
numerous
four
Plate 5
had perhaps
in
number
are
from
Several scenes
scenes.
Itala
fill
luxuriously
Quedlinburg
As
it
illustrations
they are without parallel, and yet the fact that narrative illustrations
would have
from Kings
from Kings
comprise a major part of the wall decoration in the fresco cycle of the synagogue
of
Dura from
The
Book
of Genesis,
which, judging from the fact that there existed several picture recensions, must
The
its
many dramatic
London from
is
episodes, so attractive to
best revealed by the so-
its
mentality of the
who
The ark
many
suc-
remain of the
original
artist,
still
of
Ui
'
m.vi duduc|Ud7t)fnii30
16
J
one birth scene after another. The manuscript was highly appreciated
nously,
throughout
a
its
hundred of
hall of
its
San Marco; and in the seventeenth century, one of the greatest scholars of
materialized,
it
only two preparatory drawings for the engravings are left of this project, one of
To
Figure XI)
now
and known
the original
as the
in
its
(i.e.,
It
in the
Vienna
text,
(perhaps a
member
of
in order to adjust
it
to
the balance of text and miniatures on each page. Manuscripts of this kind were a
rarity at all times
artists,
and appreciated
as such.
who
illus-
XI
Larger groups of illustrated biblical books were the Octateuch in the Greek
East, of
which only
down
have come
later copies
to us,
in the
Latin West, of which one early, luxuriously illustrated copy has survived, the
Ashburnham Pentateuch
seventh-century
extensiveness of
at the
Paris
in
The
illustration.
its
(Plates
original
number of
left,
many
cases
was able
to collect
40
(ca.
more individual
the Ashburnham
Pentateuch also must be counted by the hundreds. Typically, more* than half of
them
title
economy,
its
St.
faced the
Julian in Tours.
artist
now
in Paris.
full Bible
There are
standing author figures, like Sirach in front of a colonnade (Figure XII) or the
scene of Joshua at Gibeon turned into a
title
figure
in a
few
cases,
as
for
illustration
began
is
manner
in a
was omitted.
Two
is
evidence that
Old Testament
with
its
exten-
no event of Christ's
century, one
now
in Paris
system of illustration. Apparently not very long after the firm establishment of the
Christian Church, Gospel Books were produced not to be kept on the library shelf,
but to be deposited on the altar table, as the focal point of the service. Such Gospel
have
when
at the
it
was
and
all
title
at
taken out of the writing column and placed either in the margin or collected
all
Among
at the
the
few
thew's Gospel and written in huge golden uncial script on purple parchment, has
all five
who
remaining
hold
withering
scrolls
fig tree
illustrations in the
with typological
(Figure
texts.
XIV), which
from
Such a scene
is
as
Book
Gospel scenes.
ten in silver uncial on purple parchment and likewise belonging to the sixth century, all illustrations are
The
sub-
17
tCAft
XIII
jects
were chosen
monumental
to the
huge
Communion
(Plates
both fresco
art,
XV-XVI),
com-
bination with the Prophets underneath, reflect the organization of a wall decoration such as that of the church of Sant'
different system
written by the
cycle
was used
monk Rabbula
Angelo
in the Syriac
in
in Formis.
Mesopotamia
in
586
a.d.
Here
a narrative
Gospel
placed in the
is
XII),
fill
But then,
iatures
as in the
Canon Tables
characteristics of
monumental
art
(Plates 36-38).
the impression that in the Early Christian period the various media
frescoes
The
and perhaps
West
(Plate 35).
also icons
One
has
miniatures,
q'de on
from
the
Cambridge
separate pages, as in the Corpus Christi College Gospels
end of the sixth century. Heading at least three of the Gospels were collective
Latin
IV... <7i
M XI
XJ.l /'XC
.v--:K
-?f
VY"Ylfe
xv t H K* 1 ^#"1
"A\MH%Km
'
fgg/f0H$
XIV
miniatures, one of which remains (Plate 41). Essentially, the scenes in this miniature are of a narrative character, illustrating the first half of the Passion.
For
additional scenes the artists placed very condensed double scenes left and right
New
Testament scenes flanking the Canon Tables of the Rabbula Gospels (Plate 34).
a rich
ornamental decoration.
It
book
must almost be
a surprise, seen
later
those produced in the Mediterranean, are rather bare of the ornament such as
and
that
is
full set of
(Plate 34),
where an
filled
its
is
one excep-
prived of
There
in the
the concordance of
Eusebius.
art.
architectural function
is
in
arch,
which occurs
and often,
floral decorations,
as in the
also as a
It is
largely de-
London show
frame
is
birds. Frag-
and exuberance (Plate 43). In the Rossano Gospels there is, in addition,
a frontispiece to the Canon Tables with a wreath composed of rainbow-colored
richness
disks
Moreover, in some Gospel Books, the Canon Tables are followed by a picture of
20
XV
the so-called Fountain of Life of which, however, only ninth-century and later
copies are preserved.
Book
is
It is
Gospel
the only, and in the West, the principal, book decorated with golden, jewel,
and pearl-studded covers, sometimes with the addition of ivory and enamel, thus
enhancing
To
its
try to write a
coherent
stylistic history
futile,
is
left is
main
comparable to a few
priori one can
assume
luxury codices were the great traditional metropolitan centers which had become
the seats of the early patriarchates:
To
one should
these centers
and
their orbits
Yet some
try to attribute as
many
as possible
and
With
we
are,
fortunately,
is
general agreement that the Vergilius Vaticanus (Plates 1-4) and the Quedlinburg
Itala (Plate 5)
were produced
in
in the
same scriptorium,
tradition,
ently adapted
quality.
To Alexandria
in the
appar-
much
is
left in the
set into
Roman
the impact of the Egyptian hinterland where art forms of the older Egyptian
tradition
had survived
after
from
in
when
Constantinople.
closely
related
papyrus fragment
found
at
has also been proposed as a place of origin. Yet the style of the figures with their
straight outlines (Plate 8) has
much
in
common
21
XVI
whereas Constantinople in the sixth century had preserved a much more
classical
style.
To
Vienna Dioscurides,
roughly contemporary with the Milan Iliad and the Cotton Genesis. In particular,
the miniature with the author portrait (Plate 17) shows a purity of the classical
tradition that occurs in
and
To
been ascribed the fragments of the Greek Canon Tables (Plate 43), demonstrating
that, at least in
and able
The
to
Gospels (Plates 23-33, Figure XIV), form a coherent group which, because of
the purple which
to Constantinople.
in the
Yet the
from
and
often swaying, the backs of the heads exaggerated (e.g. Plate 29), and the faces
oriental-looking.
There
is
a deviation
from the
where, in their
late
We
which points
transformations of the classical style under the impact of a local tradition. This
would be
typical Syrian
humped ox
occurs in
some Genesis
scenes,
that
the pictures of the Rossano Gospels reflect a liturgical order familiar in Antioch.
Yet
this
mean
were made
in
Antioch. Another center within the Syrian orbit must also be taken into consideration: that
is
fifth patriarchate.
connection to Jerusalem
Apostles (Figures
(Plates
XV-XVI),
is
which,
if
we
Communion
of the
monu-
Apparently some miniatures of the Rabbula Gospels from 586 a.d. also reflect
monumental compositions in Jerusalem (Plates 36-38), although we know for
sure that this manuscript was made in Zagba in Mesopotamia. The figure style of
22
this Syriac
we
of the three purple manuscripts, and this indicates that, at least in the sixth century,
the Syrian style did not differ essentially in
Greek and
Syriac manuscripts.
Even
the pictures of the seventh-century Syriac Bible (Plates 39-40, Figures XII-XIII),
reflect a
still
speaking of Syro-Palestinian
justified in
One
is
homogeneous
area.
we
began, there
made
there
either in
is
Rome
no reason
to
West
to a linear style
it
was sent
good
What
Greek and
is
much
most striking
is
succumbing
by Pope Gregory
as a gift
Archbishop of Canterbury.
its
is
41-42), was
(Plates
better preserved
rhythmic quality in the linear design which must be seen as the beginning of a
process of intentional abstraction.
One
into a
thing
more
is
clear:
abstract
mode proceeded
at a faster
Romania
is
from the
century (Plates 11-
quite obvious
14), where this transformation has gone further than in the undoubtedly later Saint
this
Vergil manuscript
is
still
an open
opinion, carries no conviction. True, in Eastern art also, especially in floor mosaics,
there occurs a far-reaching simplification in the design of the
works of respectable
at least in
human
figure but,
typical of
itself.
Western
The
face
shown
in strong,
where
a "barbaric" style
exaggerated profile
is
began
to assert
more frequent in Western art. This feature is, for example, very
strongly marked in the ivory plaques from Kranenburg in the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York which have been ascribed to fifth-century Gaul.
Although this does not prove that the Vergil manuscript originated in Gaul, it is
in the East but
nevertheless one of the provinces that, in any future discussion of the localization
is
The
Ashburnham
exotic dress, the exuberance of the fantastic architectural settings, the sensitivity
to a rich decorative color scheme, all
stylistically or iconographically.
Old
Roman
cycles,
Saint Peter's.
as that of the
Its
Genesis cycle
is
quite inde-
However
it
O Q 5
XVII
&
i>
t>
& o
rl
"
24
ham
Pentateuch can be
felt in later
narrow somewhat the problem of whether the Pentateuch might have been produced
in
North
Africa.
No
in the
museum
at
when
Saint Augustine
is
was bishop
some
whose
in
reliefs
nearby
showing
figures display an
figures in the
With the Codex Amiatinus in Florence, a Bible which was produced at JarrowWearmouth in Northumbria around 700 a.d. and copied there from Cassiodorus'
Codex Grandior, executed at Vivarium in Calabria, we have reached the point
where the Early Christian tradition clashes with the emerging Middle Ages. The
miniature, with Ezra rewriting the various books of the
title
48 )
is
Old Testament
(Plate
the faithful copy of an early Byzantine evangelist portrait, while with the
New
new
tradition be-
gins in which the composition no longer adheres to the concept of natural space.
new and
it
From
Italian or a native
Anglo-Saxon
artist.
narrowed down
periods.
accidental
character
is
and
a specific
lost the
mon-
ecumenical
which distinguished the products of the Late Antique and Early Christian
Selected Bibliography
General Bibliography
Plate 6
S.
E. Bethe.
zig 1907.
A.
M.
Friend,
"The
Jr.
Evangelists
Manuscripts,"
115ff.
Art
and 1929,
and
Latin
Studies
1927,
H.
Gerstinger.
A.
XCIII (1973),
from
192ff.
M.
Ceriani,
Mai.
A.
XXVIII)
ani
Vienna 1926.
A.
Calderini,
Ilias
Buch-
griecbische
Olten 1943.
Turner.
ies
malerei.
Iff.
"The Charioteers
Plates 7-10
3ff.
S. J.
Die
XVII (1931),
Portraits of the
Greek
in
G.
aeology
E.
of
Illustrated
tinoe,"
"A Fragment
Gasiorowski.
J.
Greek
ed.
Olten
1955.
Plates 11-14
ton 1970.
Picturae
Studies in Classical
Manuscript
tine
H.
L. Kessler.
and Byzan-
Illumination,
Specimina
ed.
(Codices e Vaticanis
Chicago 1971.
(facsimile).
E.
Rome
1902.
The Illuminations of
Rosenthal.
the
Bibliography to Individual
Manuscripts
Plates 15-20
ManJ.
Codex Aniciae
Frag?nenta
tuani.
et
Vaticanis
Latini
3225
selecti,
(facsimile).
J.
Vaticani
Rome
vol.
(Codices
I).
2nd
ed.
vol.
P.
Graeci
1930.
Amsterdam 1959.
Dioscurides,
X)
Buberl.
linburger
Italafragmente
(facsim-
depicti,
Die
Byzantinischen
vol.
Hand-
(Beschreibendes
pt.
photogr.
schriften,
schriften
Plate 5
Latini
et
in
Osterreich,
vol.
VIII,
iff.
Graz 1970.
gr.
(facsimile).
26
Plates 21-22
J. J.
Marco
S.
Venedig und
in
Acta
tonbibel,"
Scien-
Societatis
XVII.
Fennicae
tiarum
ihr Ver-
haltnis zu
J.
F.
Helsinki
Honor
on
"Observations
the
Late
Fragments,"
Genesis
Classical
M.
A.
of
Friend,
in
Plate 43
H.
Shaw and
F.
Ornaments
Jr.
London 1833,
von Hartel and F. Wickhoff, Die
Wiener Genesis (facsimile). Vi-
Die
schriften,
(fac-
Hand-
Byzantiniscben
vol.
schrifcen
(Beschreibendes
in
Osterreich,
vol.
Ashburnham Pentateuch
/'/<?). London 1883.
B. Narkiss.
the
A. Munoz.
sano (facsimile).
W.
C.
Rome
di Ros-
1907.
"The Miniatures of
Loerke.
XLIII (1961),
T.
the
XIX
(1969),
XLIV
(1953),
55ff.
Plate 48
M.
Salmi.
The
R. L.
S.
tinus,"
in
Codex
Lindisfarnensis.
K.
Study of
171ff.
Plates 34-38
C. Cecchelli, G. Furlani,
J.
a Further
(facsim-
45ff.
Bulletin
"Towards
hiers Archeologiques
//
lift.
44-47
Plates
VIII,
ed.
29-33
Plates
feln.
pt.
I-IV
pis.
enna 1895.
P.
Madden. Illuminated
from Manu-
selected
scripts
Plates 23-28
W.
Gos-
in the
Augustine (facsimile).
pels of St.
Cambridge 1954.
Weitzmann,
Cotton
41-42
Plates
1889, 99ff.
K.
85ff.
Weitzmann.
Sancta
D. Kendrick
Lausanne I960,
1964, 139ff.
"Loca
T.
and
the
P.
Nordhagen.
J.
et
al.
Olten and
l43ff.
"An
Italo-Byzantine
frith,"
(1974),
31ff.
Studio.
Romano
in
honorem
Plates 39-40
Figure
VIP
au
VHP
siecle,"
Monu-
tion,
Figure II
Codices
and Plate
'85ff.
L.
W.
Vaticanis
XI.
Chronographen
vom
354,"
Jahre
I.
Erganzungsheft,
H.
Berlin,
"Fragments du Manuscrit
Genese de R. Cotton, conserves parmi les papiers de Peiresc,"
la
Memoires de
des
IV.
Handlinger,
terhets-Samhdlles
A. 5,2, 1936,
Miniatures
des
2nd
28ff.
ed., Paris,
siecle,
Paris,
et ses illustrations,
XIV
and Plates
Iff.
A-B.
VIII-X
canus
XlV
anciens
Plate.
Figure
Jachmann,
plus
Nationale du VI e an
Ser.
1953.
Figures
(1895),
son texte
LIII
I63ff.
Gote-
Jahrhunderts,"
la
de France,
quaires
Stern,
Omont,
de
Insti-
XI
Figure
1888.
H.
1931.
IV-VI
Figures
J.
vol.
Selecti,
Codex
Terentius.
Latinus
3868
Vati-
de Sinope,
(facsimile).
Paris, 1948.
Descriptions
of Manuscripts
Color Plates and
Black-and-white Figures
List of
II.
Quedlinburg
Deutsche
DDR,
I.
Vergilius Vaticanus
X 196
lat.
mm
six
Berlin/
Staatsbibliothek,
Cod.
5 fols.
The
3225
Itala
theol.
lat. fol.
approx. 305
leaves
485
205
mm
terial
collectors,
Pietro
given
sini,
Library.
1875/76
Plate 5. Saul
the
to
and Samuel
fol.
Royal
2r
4v
Plate
1.
Georgics
Plate
2.
Sack of Troy
Plate
3.
Death of Dido
fol.
in
fol.
19r
40r
fol.
fol.
73v
III.
The
Egypt
Exploration
27
28
fragment 120
Found
mm
75
1914 by Johnson
rubbish mound.
in
tinoe in a
An-
in
Plate 6. Charioteers
5v
I48v
391v
483v
fol.
41 lr
Ambrosian
Milan,
205
F.
Cod.
Library,
London, The
Inf.
Middle Ages
the later
in
when
the
were
added.
1608
In
it
at
century
XXXIV
Sir
XLVII
Peiresc
XX-XXI
pict. XXXVII
ings
309
the
it
came
3867
lat.
about
mm
in
then the
X 323
332
(in
Denis
at Saint
to the Vatican
who lent it to
who intended
with engrav-
facsimile
XI).
burned
It
in
Ashburnham House,
British Museum, and only
the
150
fragments
charred
re-
main.
Plate 21.
When
century.
fifteenth
(approx.)
in the possession of
1618),
(Figure
1731
V. Vergilius Romanus
was
it
make
to
fols.
mm
222
Robert Cotton,
273
fols.
gift from
two bishops of Philippi to King
Henry VIII. In the seventeenth
Cardinal
Borromeo acquired
Federico
294
miniatures
the
in
tituli
Cotton Otho B. VI
Constan-
in
not quite
is
&
Angels
fol.
House
Bristol
IVv
Abraham
26v
Plate 22. Lot's
clear.
Plate
11.
Eclogues
Plate
12.
Georgics
vium
fol.
lOOv
Plate
14.
Aeneas
fol.
VIII.
fol.
lr
fol.
44v
&
Vienna,
Dido: Convi-
& Dido
in
Cave
fols.
Vergil
3v
fol.
335
mm
X 250
was
in
med.
491
In
Nationalbibliothek,
380
fols.
mm
X 330
fourteenth
used by the
through
sold,
it
was
monk Neophytus
of
Prodromus of
Constantinople.
1569
In
the
offices
it
II
mon, physician
pict.
pict.
Suleiman
Manass eh
pict.
of
Ephraim
&
Duomo
di
45
Rossano (Calabria),
188
3v
II
Rossano
An
fol.
Joseph
Seven Physicians
of
31
II.
16.
Departure
of
Maximilian
Plate
Eliezer pict. 13
century
&
1664.
3
30
gr. 1
the
was
cod.
cod.
III.
Nationalbibliothek,
theol. gr. 31
279
106r
Figure
Vienna Genesis
fols.
307
X 260
mm
Rossano,
it
was
first
mentioned by
alist, in
286
265
+V
29
mm
250 X 190
fols.
Formerly owned by
fol. lr
cod.
Augustine's,
St.
fol.
8r
Christ Before Pilate fol.
Plate 31.
terbury,
Sv
in 1575.
Plate 41.
Plate 32.
New
Testament
Scenes
125r
Plate 42.
St.
Luke
129v
fol.
3v
tles fol.
Communion
Figure XVI.
tles fol.
fol.
to
of Apos-
4r
XIII.
fol.
5r
add. 5111
2 fols.
X. Rabbula Gospels
Laurentian Library, cod.
Florence,
Bound
220 X 158
mm
into a
292
56
I.
mm
336 X 266
fols.
of
St.
at the
mon-
then
Maria of Mai-
S.
monaster)-
the
in
Kanubin, and
1497
in
it
of
entered
the Laurenziana.
Plate 34.
Plate 35.
13v
The
l4v
it
Entered
pro-
Bibliotheque
the
142
fols.
Moses
2334
371
Pharaoh
8r
fol.
it
of
St.
when
Ashburnham
in
Duke
Bibliotheque
Nationale
&
Plate 44.
Cain
Plate 45.
Deluge
of
Abel
&
1888.
in
fol.
6r
9r
fol.
Rebecca
fol.
21
fol.
76r
Amiat.
fols.
500
X 340
mm
218v
fol.
52v
Castello
Nuovo
The Gospels
Tours from
at
Before
XII.
mm
321
1029
Nationale in 1909.
fol.
n. acq. lat.
Plate 47.
341
place where
XI.
11
fol.
Canon Table
Plate 43.
the monastery of
phuc.
said to
is
Augustine
at
786v
Florence.
Vr
in
Majesty
30
Additional
Figures
85ff.
Figure
IV], Berlin
Bd.
turen,
and
1971,
pp.
28-61).
pis.
Terence
fol. 2r
Figure
1294
suppl. gr.
mm
340 X 115
fol.
60v
Acquired 1900.
Romance Papyrus
XI
Figure
Figure
franc.
II
The
London,
Egypt
Exploration
X 106
235
325
One
Society
Found
mm
Daniel
Oxyrhynchos
at
9530
250 X 380 mm
of the two watercolors
fols.
(Pap.
Rabel
made
Nicholas-Claude
1622
in
Fabri
de
by
for
Peiresc
2331).
Heracles Papyrus
Genesis
fol.
32r
Figure IV
Vatican Library, cod. Barb.
55
276 X 206
fols.
The
2154
lat.
mm
on an intermediary Caro-
are based
Cal-
A.D.
the
in
Rome
name of
Constans II
Figure
for a Christian by
VI
Month
2r
fol.
Figure
of
March
18r
fol.
Figure VIII
Vatican Library, cod.
fols. 343 X 293
The manuscript was
92
lat.
Adelricus
the
in
written by the
vestigation.
painted by
third
ninth century
according to
the
in
most
Already
3868
mm
decennium
Lorraine,
recent
in-
in
the
listed
Bartholomaeus
Platina
in
1475
43
1286
200 X 180
fols.
mm
Jean de
bought
it
Fig Tree
13r
Roma
suppl. gr.
la Taille,
French
who had
(Black Sea).
Valentinus.
fol.
XIV
Paris,
drawings
seventeenth-century
lingian
Figure
fol.
30v
Color Plates
and Commentaries
32
PLATE
Vergilius Vaticanus
Ge orgies
5v
fol.
In his didactic
cow
in Sila in the
tells
the story of
Apennines
two jealous
(III, 209fT.).
bulls
Against a
sky that turns from pink to light blue, two enraged bulls charge each other,
about to lock horns in front of a tree with a gold-striated trunk and feathery
leaves.
The
new
is
is
to
an
exercise to build
Vergil did not invent this story, a familiar tale which occurs in several
ancient writers including Pseudo-Oppian, Aelian, and Pliny. In an eleventh-
is
illustrated in
this
episode
{Cynegetica
II,
in the
fashion of papyrus illustration (Figures I-II), faithfully reflecting a secondthird century archetype. Here, the scene of the fighting bulls
assumed.
The
common, and
illustrator of the
Vatican codex,
who worked
two
so similar to that
them
is
in
must be
Rome
in the
5.1
"I
34
PLATE
Vergilius Vaticanus
fol.
In
Sack of Troy
19r
Books
II
and
III
among
upon
tells
depicts the
moment when
in
cycle recounting
its
Troy
The miniature
Wooden
is
"sliding
Vergil speaks only of attacking the guards, and the killing of the banqueters
is
text.
source,
most probably an
from the
first
century in the
Museo
composition of an encompassing
city
Most important,
in the
the
first
codex.
common
more
opening of the horse by a trap door and the letting down of Odysseus
lar that a
we
is
so simi-
;Li-iXMKRCL
*
V <t
J
-*
<*
LUC JfeS N
|XTMLi
J I \:i
(&H AT ISC
IMC lu f'v
\< C I AV
.-
Df&
XXav SJ
N lx! L
56
PLATE
Vergilius Vaticanus
Death of Dido
40r
fol.
Dido's dramatic death, one of the most important events of the Aeneid,
resented by two miniatures, one of the
moment
illustrator
plunging
see
Dido
ladder,
made
has
it
it.
Dido
its
Vergil
made
under the
it
sword before
raises the
sky,
to
We
climb up by a
but the
significance, the
perspectively,
emphasize
lying
was erected
just before,
rep-
is
artist
is
an entrance door
with a drawn curtain. This very conspicuous door does not take into consideration the foreshortening of the side wall.
way
to a
more
Whereas
in the
or less literally
earlier
illustrator
was able
in this case
full visibil-
from
which
classical
to
copy more
he adapts a
from an
illus-
^HH^^fe
HHN^^flH
i\
MA
10k
^HhMU
Mi
39
PLATE
Vergilius Vaticanus
73v
fol.
When
Trojan Council
encamped
at the
mouth of
According
whom
to
send to Aeneas.
miniature, however, they are not depicted in lively dispute but appear
imperial bodyguards,
on
all
One
is
Two men
like
whose cinnabar-colored
who
shields provide a
not
more
in the
Vergil's text.
He
according to
The
other
is
is
picture.
In his intention to create a hieratic composition the artist obviously has taken
liberties
with the text and, instead of a simple strip-like composition, such as one
Milan
camping
scene,
fills
ideas
tribunal scene.
when
city wall,
iconographic tradition
he seems to be influenced by a
not called
The
Iliad,
(Plate 2).
new
compositional
40
PLATE
QUEDLINBURG ITALA
fol.
2r
Samuel
Samuel
I.
spoils,
like.
The
first
sacrifice, the
air
of an impe-
all
the
runs away with Saul following, clutching the end of the prophet's
Agag)
it.
(we
believe he
wrongly
is
Roman
fully illustrated
rial
is
Samuel himself
kills
While iconographically
walled
city
of
the picture
is
the illustrator has tried to unify the scenes within each register by adding a
rises
rative buildings, a sky not unlike that in the illustration to Vergil's Georgics
(Plate 1)
striations.
The
Both
figures, as well,
artists
show
the
same elegant
in the
style,
same scriptorium
in
Rome,
42
PLATE
the pitifully
design and color depicts a group of charioteers; five figures are easily recognizable,
dress: each
belt
is left.
They
to protect
ing, suggested
and one
This fragment
is
on both
and while
Roman
circus.
body by
sides of the
fourth such
we
it
may be tempting
is
from an
found
in
epic
1914
poem
at
and
is
to think of
games of
Book
Achilles,
we
or prose.
its
tendency
faces,
and low
Antinoe, with
typically Egyptian
more
The
foreheads,
build-
letters
The
emerge from a
XXIII of
in falls, a
is all
fifth century,
stately size.
to
him
of the
round
Milan
Iliad (Plate
21-22).
v>
v
ls:
2a
44
PLATE
Ambrosiana
XXXIV Capture of
Ilias
pict.
The
story of
Book X,
the Achaeans,
is
in
told in
Dolon
two consecutive
Odysseus,
who
is
hands of
to the other.
is
Dolon has
billows out in the wind, increasing the dramatic effect of the very agitated
group. Diomedes, dressed in full armour and rendered in a swaying pose, looks
on. In the next scene
Diomedes
is
drawing
it is
after having
erties
his
sword
Odysseus
is
who
Dolon,
decapitates
him
which he
in order to kill
pilos, the
pointed cap by
should wear caps of hide. Here too the wide stride and vivid action of the two
heroes add to the turbulent effect of the scene.
The hovering
bust of Night
is
from pinkish
visibility,
The
placed at either
dawn
much
illustration.
is,
or sunset.
preserved
to that
fifth century,
have
of the papyrus
roll
47
PLATE
I
LIAS
AMBROSIANA
XLVII
pict.
Achilles
and
upon
bowl
He
in his right
is
hand and
lean-
who
offers a liba-
He
is
praying to Zeus,
who
protect Patroclus,
outgrown the
it
is
quite signifi-
cant that he should have done so in this one case for the leading hero of the
Iliad.
This suggests the influence of monumental painting and yet does not
him
in a
this subject
was
enlarg-
Despite
this
monumental
effect,
lacks
corporeality,
because the traditional firm stance has been abandoned in favour of a swaying
pose,
and the outlines of the figure have been straightened and the body thereby
flattened. In this
we
see a deviation
from the
classical
norm and
a similar reap-
49
PLATE
Ambrosiana
XX-XXI Battle Scene
Ilias
pict.
To
special
crowded
we
this
see two.
The
combatants
as
is
on the
no
single
The two
over-
wrongly
text
hand
later
other, while in the miniature the latter attacks with a sword. This interpretation
is
text can
wounded Sarpedon
most
easily be explained
most
somewhat
isolated
don. This
would
The
general lack of
from the
combat scene
rest of the
in the center,
Iliad
which appears
wounded
Sarpe-
undeterminable.
probably belongs to
is
whose
illus-
superficially to
Dolon adventure
The crowded
the only
Whether
tree.
is
left the
this period.
10
51
PLATE
I
LI
AS
10
AMBROSIANA
XXXVII
pict
Three scenes from Book XI are squeezed into the picture frame not
sequence but as they best
"Achilles
fit
we
Next follows
mark
who
it
as
where the
felt
been
in scale, in
is
To
the right
is
Achilles,
who
dwarfed
artist
two protagonists and the orange of Patroclus' mantle and the cushion are
fully
see
standing by the stern of his ship, huge of hull, gazing upon the
sits
At
in logical
to the
by an arrow (842ff.).
text,
similarly
The
composed
tent
skill-
scene,
which, as a whole,
who
is
looks like
followed very
While
could easily be
7), reflects
Whereas
models, show a homogeneity in their figure treatment, with vivid actions often
exaggerated, the
artist
style will
be based.
52
PLATE
11
Vergilius
Eclogues
lr
fol.
Romanus
Whereas
Iliad (Plates
7-10) are
still
Milan
Romanus show
abandonment of natural
the
spatial relationships.
The
very
first
cowherd
sits at
in
shows remnants of a
still
text, leads
tree;
horns. Other goats peep out from behind a tree at the right, showing the art-
ist's
same
papyrus
On
still
shows adherence
to the tradition of
illustration.
frame
normal
weakness
is
size,
and on the
other,
it is
illustrated
by
human body by an
is
artists
who
try
unusually large
somewhat
in contrast
The
human
ture,
artist
who
another
artist,
With
"S
V4\
*-
rilTinVUIVvfAtCV&ANS^VMl^MiNIE-fA^
MS-.V
V
|> hi
'
rO'
"!
"
"
'.
tt
V
*'*
t
*'
> /*t
*
>*
r. :
,'
1*1
v
\
"
11
55
PLATE
12
Rom anus
Vergilius
fol.
44v
Georgics
Beginning with the second miniature to the Eclogues and consistent throughout
the Georgics and the Aeneid,
we
is
first
miniature. In a full-page illustration to the third book of the Georgics there are
and
listening.
They
flute
to
which
this
and
his
found on
on the opposite
There
no groundline: the figures and the animals are suspended and evenly
is
and
a hut, a
elements
is
very
common
in Late
floor mosaics,
and
Compared with
is
Antique
and patternized
it
seems quite
who was
striving
surface.
in a
more
linear
and
abstract manner,
somewhat
stylized profile.
the classical tradition, the expressive linear design reflects the mentality of an
artist
who
is
13
57
PLATE
13
Romanus
Vergilius
fol.
Aeneas
lOOv
&
Dido Conv'wium
In order to hear more about the Sack of Ilium from Aeneas, the love-stricken
is
charged with the emotions of unhappy Dido, the miniature depicts the banqueters in
stiff,
center,
The
body: he
seems
artist
to
in Plate
what he
garments.
zation.
He
One
Plate 3)
is
is
not an unskilled
artist,
but he
is
patterni-
(in contrast to
figures.
The
is
The
three rest
tightly fitted,
on
its
top
Also abstract are the colors and their separation into three
floor,
human
sition is
Aeneas
apparently added
sections, each of
set in the
like
of the
is
in the exact
utterly unable to
is
matching Aletes
is
left,
is
in strict profile.
strips,
purple for the drapery of the couch, and green for the wall. Beginning
artist
has
made
steady
PLATE
14
Romanus
Vergilius
&
Aeneas
Dido
Cave
fol.
108r
One
of the most dramatic episodes in the Aeneid, in which Dido and Aeneas
in
treated in a
manner
dividing
it
impression.
At
is
more
like a
to a tree
is
the
their hooves.
uneven shape
more
fall
suggestively rendered.
The
in such a
Thick raindrops
(IV, l60ff.)
fourth section
is
artist
is
head
filled
way
that
what looks
on a small
scale, tied
as space-fillers beneath
soldier in the
upper
left
to
and seemingly
in a cave
no doubt who
there
He
sits
on top
show every
beholder.
The
figures
lies in
and the decorative design of the draperies, which have the quality
any other,
its
or sixth century.
to the
On
paleographical evidence,
fifth century.
it
more
it
14
Ai-e fS*>
<re+Vfc*
<fizo^Hc1<r'.
YJ*
G~& -_b
I^JT
wmum
61
PLATE
15
Vienna Dioscurides
6v
fol.
Anicia Juliana
This luxurious herbal contains the oldest dedication miniature in existence, representing the princess Anicia Juliana within an eight-pointed star enclosed by a
circle,
stiff
sits
on
a cush-
ioned throne distributing coins and holding the codicillus, which distinguishes
her as a
member
nanimity, carrying
on her
more gold
is
Mag-
third personification,
and a putto
holding the dedication copy allude to Anicia as the founder of a church in the
suburbs of Constantinople, whose citizens show their gratitude by the gift of
this
manuscript.
show
Vetii
putti
The
working
Pompeii,
in
as
likewise
to those in the
patronage.
The miniature
is
Casa di
A.D.,
The
and the
this date.
reflects the
most refined
style
of
with the
putto holding the book and the putti active in crafts, notwithstanding that the
princess
was
a pious Christian.
V |>.VI
16
63
PLATE
16
Vienna Dioscurides
Seven Physicians
fol.
3v
The
set of
is
Galen,
who
sits in
The
sit
on snake
latter's treatise
bottom
left,
is
second picture
He
is
flanked by
paraphrase of the
in the
bites
Mys and
Nicander.
is
a plant to a serpent.
At
the
(Plate 19).
The
Seven Wise
Men
as they
is
appear on
whose
it is
clearly
chairs there
composed of
thus the figures are rendered sitting on slabs or rocks. For most
if
There
is
to
in
which
who was
of
treatises. It
way toward
(e.g., Plate
artist
who
ical style.
all
modes depending on
not
space;
we know
no reason
individual,
more
like
17
65
PLATE
17
Vienna Dioscurides
5v
fol.
Dioscurides
The second of
may
painter in
status
work
from the
clothes
scholar.
parchment sheet
a root in
human
behind
life portrait
it.
Before him
sits
and there
a youthful
on a low bench
thus
On
his easel
is
He
copies
it
and on
it
sensitive
shape.
The
to a root held in
in a
and a deep blue shawl, the strongest color accent, over her
The background,
is
remi-
in
accordance with the concept of a studio, but added apparently for mere decorative splendor.
In the
first
drake
is
There was a
ics,
is
tradition in
it
up.
Greco-Roman
art, in
marble
reliefs, frescoes,
mosa-
and other media, of poets and writers inspired by a muse, and from some
.#
\
wsi?
iov -tv>r^>vf/ufi
"V
^s*.
/".-.
18
67
PLATE
18
Vienna Dioscurides
I48v
fol.
The few
Violet
show
that their
normal
system of illustration, surviving also in later codices, was the depiction of the
plant on top of the writing column with the explanatory text underneath.
It is
exceptional that in the luxurious Vienna codex, a full page of considerable size
(37 x 30 cm.)
is
which
two
groups: one quite naturalistic, surely copying an earlier, classical model very
faithfully,
The
of
abstract.
its
design. Since
its
it
belongs to the
first
a copy, this
is
the
all
XXV.
group and
and elegance
more remarkable,
view of
in
Moreover, one must be reminded that such plant pictures were neither made
solely for aesthetic pleasure nor for a scientific record per se, but for the utili-
ulty
The
violet, as
Dioscurides
administered
"has a cooling
upon
states,
who
children."
fac-
and
'
isy> <-<-A*-'
-^
\S
:>:
19
69
PLATE
19
Vienna Dioscurides
fol.
39 lv
Coral
is
Ephesus, the pharmacologist placed at the lower right of the second collected
Of
one
is
illustrated in a
oak or sea
tree,
Instead of depicting
bility, lets
the coral
at the
it
cobweb or
a fine net,
brown
The pond
cal imagery.
and
in her hair.
its
is
may be an
a
its
filled like
pond with
few rocks
in
illustra-
From another
With
and patternization
classified as a plant.
bottom of the
grow out of
still
deeply steeped in
classi-
knowledge of
a specialized treatise
on
fishes.
She points
treatise.
The
may
close association
between science
and poetry
is
pictorially,
by mythological additions.
20
71
PLATE
20
Vienna Dioscurides
483v
fol.
Birds
Another addition
tise
to the
Vienna codex
is
is
the
oldest treatise of
its
faithful in design
In the
artistic merit.
first
two books of
the treatise, the birds are intercalated without frame or background into the
text columns, while those of the third
full
page and
hunting
treatise dealing
snare, net,
and
trap.
Most of the
birds
on
this
page are
moor
etc.
However some
of them are not even mentioned in the paraphrase, and thus one
must conclude
some
go back
to
an older, fuller
One
this
collective
this decorative
pictures originated
is,
Myndos.
system
in
which
is
mosaics
particularly fitting.
a manuscript and
were
Dioscurides
on
treatise,
is
hard to
say.
No
21
73
PLATE
21
Cotton Genesis
fol.
Abraham
26v
Among
&
manu-
ham
Angels
is
one which
garment although he
patriarch in a long
illustrates
is
and
Abra-
destruc-
white-haired,
Abraham
approaches the angels with a wide stride and vivid gestures suggesting the
urgency of his argument. The nimbed angels stride forward to meet him but
with measured
is
steps, in a
more
hieratic pose.
Only the
first
and red-purple
shoes,
and
compa-
rable to the archangels in mosaic at San Vitale in Ravenna. Their straight outlines
line
and
flat
and
forms
is
the blue
plastic treatment of
The miniature
at
Abraham's
Mamre and
is
is
from each
other.
Abraham meeting
the angels
Thus
it
forms a link
of more abstract
The mastery
figure.
Mamre
San Marco
scenes,
who
74
PLATE
22
Cotton Genesis
IVv
Bristol
While normally
column
House
Lot's
five lines
page or near
The miniature
where there
are only
which the Sodomites assault Lot with threatening gestures, demanding that he
hand over
to
19:41
The
artist
to
whom
Sodomites, and pulls him back into the house, whose open door
grasping arm
is all
that
is
left
what
depicted by two
is
ground. By
artist
formula the
is
The
is visible.
fallen to the
same colors
figures,
white
whereas
the
Sodomite, seen from the back, wears brown and green garments. Most garments
show
striation of
script, in a
heavy gold
lines,
which
is
Quedlinburg
in
in the
The tendency
to flatten
their
low
fore-
heads and burning eyes, remind one of the charioteers in the papyrus (Plate 6)
In both features one recognizes Egyptian elements.
22
76
PLATE
23
Vienna Genesis
pict.
Deluge
relates to impressionism.
Deluge (Genesis
that area of each
7:17ff.),
This
is
later in date
mode
which completely
fills
illustration.
The upper
The
down from
is
narrow
ashen.
illustrator delights in
is
Two
victims
all
still
above sea
in different,
alive
and
sometimes
on
his
headfirst.
To
another
of sky.
The
strip
lies
who embraces
woman
at the
is
icono-
graphically unrelated.
In this manuscript there are three distinct illuminators at work, each with a
pupil; the
first
"miniaturist."
painter,
who
is
77
PLATE
24
Vienna Genesis
13
pict.
The
most
Rebecca
&
Eliezer
chapter 24,
illustrated in
is
cycle, is
scenes distributed over three miniatures, each having two superimposed zones.
In the
and
first
miniature, Eliezer
is
sent off by
Nahor;
in the
second, Rebecca
appears and offers water to him; and in the third Eliezer gazes at Rebecca, gives
her a ring and then she talks to her parents in their house.
Whereas
second the
the
first
artist tries to
Nahor, a
in the
in a
pink
and walks
downhill along a colonnaded street which makes a hairpin turn. At the bend a
half-naked nymph, her legs covered by a purple garment,
fashion on a water urn.
eager Eliezer
is
jar
leaning in antique
filling a trough. In a
is
who
The
23
24
80
PLATE
25
Vienna Genesis
As
Joseph's Departure
30
pict.
in literature the
legendary detail, so too has the illustrator of the Vienna Genesis enriched the
extensive Joseph cycle by extraneous elements which are not contained in the
Bible text.
Many
made
illu-
sent to
Shechem (Genesis
farewell
is
in
is
an easy
is
depicted
first,
Joseph's
37: l4ff.)
down
tenderly touches
chair,
like a
is
"Bilhah, Rachel's
is
led off by an angel. This angel, not explained by the Bible, can be identi-
the
way
scale
to
Dothan where
his brothers
against him."
At
the
Christian feature.
orist."
Then
Eliezer.
follows a scene
finally,
man
Rabbi
who
we
see Joseph
more by a
little
him by
artist,
inciting
is
dogs
hill is a distinctly
^i?v
X jR0t^*i
-\
*?.t*?*:
ray. jm$
lif^niCv'6^
*^
K4JT0J
3CH' r f
yn
25
^^
<
'
^3K
HMHUHMIVHPIHHSI
83
PLATE
26
Vienna Genesis
pict.
Temptation of Joseph
31
many
folios,
scenes, the Joseph story continues with the episode of his tempta-
Dressed
the temptress
sits
in a transparent
garment,
suggesting a stately palace chamber; she grasps the edge of Joseph's purple
mantle, which he
tries to slip
but the
rest in the
is
To
all
The
more
holding a
as Potiphar's wife,
woman
rattle
whom
Joseph
is
later to marry.
women
woman
daughter
( Asenath
Even
in
Greek) an adopted
,
spinning, the one at the right clad like Potiphar's wife in the
in a transparent garment.
is
work of
trees
first
the "colorist,"
who
scene
fillers."
The swaying
>se
of the
woman
'3
*
>rt
i$fc^%&*
.'o3
WD&
i&jS&i^^^^
^*a
..
27
85
PLATE
27
Vienna Genesis
Joseph in Prison
33
pict.
we
preting the dreams of the baker and the butler (Genesis 40:9ff.)
makes
it.
Joseph
sits in
artist
a scene
bad news
to the baker,
towards heaven
impending
liberation.
The
prison
is
who
arms
ren-
dered like an open court, into which one looks in bird's-eye view. Outside the
prison and before a sundial
sits
the guard,
who
turns around to a
named
text,
but in a Midrash
is
we
paenula,
is
is
easily
phar's wife
woman who
was
kill
in prison.
brown
tunic
Joseph
That
Poti-
and purplish
to look inconspicuous
during
these escapades.
This miniature
termed the
is
"illusionist,"
who
has been
-,-ie.
:\
t*v\
,1
'
IN
28
87
PLATE
28
Vienna Genesis
The
Blessing of Ephraim
45
pict.
&
Manasseh
depicted as the
is
only scene on this page, in a monumental figure scale, showing the nearly blind
Ephraim and
his left
in a tunic
and the
imperial purple chlamys with golden tablion and wearing the golden torque
remove
his left
which quite
Joseph
we have
likely
his
moment
many legendary
is
now
lost.
story.
was depicted
by trying to
is
attributed,
One would
Genesis cycles
fit,
whom
legs,
this
"colorist."
The
over-sized
in
swaying
artist,
how-
green to brown, and the pink sky turning to light and dark blue, show his mastery of
an impressionistic technique.
89
PLATE
29
Rossano Gospels
Raising of Lazarus
fol.
lr
The
first
who
up
sis-
surrounded by
is
The
mummy
(John 11:39).
Underneath stand two pairs of prophets, David and Hosea and David and
Isaiah,
holding open
scrolls
must be viewed
as a
by liturgical usage, according to which a passage from the Psalter precedes the
lesson of the day, in this case the reading for the Saturday before
Palm Sunday.
Such a composition was surely not invented for a Gospel Book but
umental wall painting
ment
is
in
which a
from the
reflects
New
mon-
Testa-
aligned in an upper row and prophets with their open scrolls in the
is
also
due
to the influence of
would be more
The
artist delights in
Among
its
most
monumental painting
It
movement
the vividly colored dresses, the golden mantle of Christ stands out
hieratic
and dematerialized
quality.
92
PLATE
30
Rossano Gospels
Christ Before Pilate
fol.
8r
Two
manner
sits
dux
group of court
high
who
officials
standing
stiffly
at the left
The
at the right.
balanced by a
is
blame
is
priests.
Not
is
in a hieratic
befitting the dignity of the imperial court the trial before Pilate. In the
high on a throne,
center,
ture
in a semicircle. Simi-
larly
they are
all others:
two high
priests as
Annas, the older one, makes a spontaneous gesture of abhorrence. Then Judas
hangs himself.
The
Pilate scene
is
The circumscribed
arc suggests a
and adjusted
to
dependence on a niche
The
artist
was
of a miniaturist.
The
soft
modeling of the
monumental model
figures of Pilate
officials
flat
Christ.
into the
mode
priests,
style
of the Rossano Gospels are the orientalizing heads of some figures that one
associates with the Greco-Syrian style of this period.
PLATE
31
Rossano Gospels
8v
fol.
The second
two
pose,
with
is
this
man and
release unto
'is
who
Barabbas."
'Away
clad only
in a loincloth
in a
and
fettered,
is
is
officials,
The manner
in
model was
cular line, the farther ones suspended, suggests that in this case the
It
torium, the hall in which the actual judgment of Pilate took place, and which
Jerusalem
by the pilgrim of Bordeaux (333 a.d.), had monumental scenes of the Pilate
story.
If
the
we
it
in
seems
likely that
guard looking upward would be placed more to the right to meet the eyes of
The previous
Pilate.
miniature, then,
was most
ing another niche to the right, whose most logical subject would have been
Pilate
washing
PLATE
his hands.
32
Rossano Gospels
Good
fol.
7v
One
parable of the
in
Samaritan
Good
Samaritan.
artist
From
is
the passage
more extensive
Luke
man who
It is
peculiar to the
wounds,
assisted by an angel
who
man and
tends to his
Baptism angels reverently hold Christ's garments. The inspiration may well
come from
the liturgical.
The second
scene, in
which
two
is
city
wounded man
of Jericho at the
left.
Once more we
see
Sira<~h.
The
story of the
Good Samaritan
is
de picted in the
Ros-
Virgins,
32
96
PLATE
33
Rossano Gospels
fol.
It is
121r
Mark
Saint
The
one single
to us
Mark
that of
in the
Rossano Gospels.
woman
in a
veil, dictat-
The composition
in this
a background
draperies flow
down
This
is
a highly abstract
Pompeian
frescoes,
form of
with a pro-
from which such draperies sprawl. The color formula behind the
correlated.
Roman
is
is
to be derived
outer
The
marble
col-
ture.
In this Greco-Syrian miniature, very markedly different from the Constantinopolitan miniature of the Dioscurides portrait (Plate 17),
the figurative scenes the distance
a
more
from the
classical past
more than
in
any of
97
PLATE
34
Rabbula Gospels
Canon Table
fol.
4v
The
Canon Tables
lunette
first
from
Canon with
in this case
Tatian's Diatesseron.
The
form of a block
child
altar
sanctuary as
it
is
manger
in the
we
is
see under-
neath the Nativity, distributed over both margins, the Massacre of the Innocents in
which Herod
is
left
as a
yellow flame emanating from the Jordan, an allusion to Luke 3:16, "I shall
baptize you with the Holy Ghost and with fire." In the upper spandrels, appropriate to the Nativity, are
in the
>rate
Christ,
is
lyre,
and Solomon
-ated
on a very
!<**&
34
35
100
PLATE
35
Rabbula Gospels
Matthew & John
fol. 9v
After Canon V, the
New
Tables.
tures,
They
interrupted
into
is
and the
artist
settings
are a mixture of
two
types:
struc-
and two are standing holding codices under very simple architectural
frames.
The
elderly
his right
hand
Matthew
is
lap rests his Gospel, not firmly held and seeming to slide down, indicating that
it
scroll, a
sits
Mark
more
still reflect
the copyist,
in the
in writing,
it.
The
vertically
light. It will
be
they are ultimately derived. Statues of seated poets were often connected in
ancient art with the scenae frons of the theater, and this explains the architectural setting in our miniature: the structure
around Matthew
is
reminiscent of
the tempietto in the center of the scenae frons, and the conch above John, as
the
Mark
source.
is
from
i<i
this
101
PLATE
36
Rabbula Gospels
13v
fol.
Ascension
Like the Rossano Gospels, the Rabbula manuscript has several full-page miniatures which, because of their complexity, are not simple narrative illustrations,
of the
biblical narrative,
is
Not
The
Virgin,
present in the
Christ,
human
nature of Christ are the two angels offering crowns with veiled hands,
to earth
little
thou crownest him with glory and honour." Paul himself, whose presence in
this picture is also unjustified
by the
text,
seems to explain
this
passage by hold-
ing a codex slightly opened with one finger and pointing to the ascending
The
Christ.
dogma
cedon
of the
in 451.
the church
Two
One
The
picture
the tetramorph
must be understood
as a glorification of
may
place.
The
much
is
earlier period,
with an impressionistic
landscape comparable to those in the Vienna Genesis (Plate 28). Only in the
himan
figures,
seem
<: lines,
the vivid
to h; ve penetrated the
powerful Greek
tradition.
37
104
PLATE
37
Rabbula Gospels
I4r
fol.
Christ Enthroned
apse,
a blue
an
whom
grouping similar
to that of the
well-known mosaic of
men to Christ, in a
Cosma and Damiano in
all
title saints to
associates with
monk's
is
not partic-
dress.
is
is,
sites in Jerusa-
lem, this raises the question whether the apse reflected in the miniature goes
monk
Only the
they
five figures
to the special
Canon Tables
more
trees,
pic-
to those u;
sla
105
PLATE
38
Rabbula Gospels
I4v
fol.
The next
Pentecost
is
the Apostles not seated in a circle or semicircle, but standing flanking the
being
less
corporeal and
more
abstract.
is
different, the
This
one
may be due
in the Pentecost
in part to different
hands, but even more to models from two different periods, that of the Pentecost seemingly the later one.
The iconography
who
is
is
To her right
who must be
by
the
Bishop of Jerusalem.
There was
in
chapel of the Holy Spirit thought to be the place of the actual event. This
chapel had, at least as early as the crusader period, a mosaic of the Pentecost,
and
it
seems quite
Stylistica''y the
away from
ion,
likely that
ve.e (
tH
with a tubular
ie for
our miniature
effect,
and
The
mosaic.
style,
in this a Syrian
element asserts
already
moving
summary
i.
fash-
The same
is
atures such as
--.
m~J&^j
m
38
4JPi**
39
108
PLATE
39
46r
In a
few
Job
head of an individual
one of these
that
is
often illustrated
two
as
the
the most
is
prolific illustration
of the
first
who,
to give
around
chapters. Such a
much
not by chance
in the East.
It is
illustrator,
despondent wife
sits at
Then one of
upon seeing
finally
we
First,
him before
his
his
from
see
sitting
and
beginning the conversations which form the core of the book (Job 2:13). At
the upper left
before his
It is
is
many
still
an earlier scene
misfortunes.
tance of the
remnant from
Book of Job
illustrated
Job manu-
is
that
it
Pentateuch.
ments with no
>ng,
rifts
resulting
conflation.
The
Jscap..
n.
elev-
109
PLATE
40
8r
The miniature
to the
ning of Exodus.
is
lost;
Why
the
first
hardly understandable, since other subjects from Exodus were more popu-
is
lar.
Moses approaches
hastily
seetr
Dr
gonis;
il
pov
rigl v
:
1st to
hand
accus-
left
hand,
the excited
.is
stiff
110
PLATE
40 (Continued)
is
quite
Syrian art; in the scene of the Massacre of the Innocents in the Rabbula Gospels
we saw Herod
Rabbula Gospels
thut
Is,
may
eems that
a cylindrical body,
particularly be
this Bible
may belong
The
and the
fluffy
cannot be dated
to the sixth or
much
perhaps the
later
er.rly
n?r
'
y
^j4?
rt*v? <^&s
Abas,
40
112
PLATE
41
is
ing the early phase of Christ's Passion, from the Entry into Jerusalem to
from
all
just as in the
four Gospels.
have similarly
scenes
similar
illustrated the
from the
all
Symon
with
harmonized cycle
now
lost,
must
we
it;
Mark's Gospels.
In collecting scenes originally strewn into the Gospel text, the illustrator was
obviously hard pressed for space and resorted to omissions (showing only eight
Apostles at the Last Supper), and occasionally to cutting figures off at the
margin.
The
and expressionless
tive distribution
hilly
is
more
this
he
Roman
Although
in the
Washing
touch.
upper center
hursday.
compo:
for
in
^ndy
<
115
PLATE
42
Luke
129v
Luke's Gospel
is
arm
is
one of the
is
surely based
in
it
is
rarest.
While
it
has not
is
with a portal, a reminder of the Porta Regia of the scenae frons. The four
umns of
like
col-
are, as in the
Canon
frame. Differently stylized and abstracted, this type of setting ultimately goes
Mark
in the
itself in
the Evangelist's
The
scenes which, unlike the collective page (Plate 41), are not
cycle but all
left
illustrator
off
by frame or
~.p!?:ing organic
^^
tii
lower
at the
right.
upper
Here, the
The
from a harmonized
making
more
hills.
gone quite
Romanus
to
th
and
in
iting a pleas-
lines
figure
iassical tradition
artist
has a greater
PLATE
43
llr
fol.
Perhaps the most precious fragments of any Early Christian manuscript are the
set
of
fit
into a twelfth-century
Gospel Book of smaller format. Even rarer than purple-stained leaves, these are
stained gold, forming a background for a lunette supported originally by three
ornament consisting of
sides.
The
tural sense.
The
textile borders,
face
allions
and
Because of
its
the
two arches
is
correctly
found
letter,
it
its
real-
in
inspiration.
is
Under each of
istic
with an abstract
tectural
filled
Canons
graphical origin, harking back to a set of imagines clipeatae that decorated the
interior of Constantine's
stantinople. Since
we
mausoleum attached
to the
ecommend
ely.
it.
An
car
6-.K1JJ
oc
I.
118
PLATE
44
ASHBURNHAM PENTATEUCH
Cain
&
Abel
fol.
6r
The
thirteen verses
one miniature
by no fewer than nine scenes which the illustrator distributed over the surface in
a purely decorative
manner with
upper
with
Adam
The
ends at the right of the second row, with the Lord questioning Cain. The nursing of Cain and Abel are separated and placed in two different registers, and
the scene of the brothers' sacrifices and their reception by the Lord are in
is
which the
some
bottom.
is
of grain
The
is
gloomy purple
and Cain
tills
orange at
and
is
at the
reserved for
in spandrel-like
space-filler.
is
is
found also
in the
iconographically based on
this
not
belong to
this
ite
cetv'
44
I
45
121
PLATE
45
ASHBURNHAM PENTATEUCH
fol.
Deluge
9r
to the
The blue
fills
brown
page with
a full
stripes
is
of a very
unusual shape, resembling more a chest resting on feet than a ship. In the water
below, naturalistically colored a murky dark green, float two large and two
small
human
effect.
made an end
of them,"
indeed very
it is
Jewish tradition.
The macabre
ish
BeatusApocalypse manuscripts.
This
it
The Deluge
23), but here
victims,
is
On
Span-
some
Ashburnham Pentateuch
is still
Spain proper,
some of the
it is
its
the
prominent place
if
not
made
in
art.
in the
very different.
more noteworthy
be a Spanish prod-
undeniable that,
The Deluge
itself to
sub
1
"-
since, in the
were noticed.
;
is
iture in
Among
the
the Early
is
-iations to the
man
representa-
o -V p \liiuci)opeRuiT?e* sen
busAuTfpi^-i^CTA uAeqes
i
fi
tp^NARRA'-MT -ISAAC'
/nicr$rJ^rc^cV>LoK
oouio
050RTerr)ArRjsAcc.'^t:>: *r
rempeRARer
v <iB
u*
,"**
PLATE
46
ASHBURNHAM PENTATEUCH
&
Rebecca
fol.
21r
The
Isaac
more
distrib-
uted over the surface out of order, beginning with Eliezer, Abraham's servant,
seated contemplatively at the well at the right of the middle register. Rebecca
him by
a scene in
jar
At the same
rate scenes
proof
just
originally
finger.
were rendered
was used
on her
as a model.
the well
in
Here,
two sepa-
How
different
are these scenes, the surface densely filled with disregard of spatial relationships,
from the
ical figures
move
freely in
Compared with
landowner such
as
class-
form
fantastic
is
The
subsequent
reception of Eli-
is
is
is
particularly placed
some black
ones. Luxuriousness
is
on the com-
and on a group of
biblical
narrative
is
almost hidden in these extraneous addenda, which are colorful and lively and
xhibit a quality peculiar to the
ly
other
known
unparalleled
manuscript.
125
PLATE
47
ASHBURNHAM PENTATEUCH
Moses Receiving Law
76r
fol.
Some of
The upper
for Genesis.
Moses
He
is
From
at Sinai
still
has a
the
in a cloud, a feature
is
it
is
in
increased
by their breaking through the upper frame. Below, Moses reads from the tablets to
a large
behind an
sacrificial
crowd of
altar
men and
Israelites,
festively dressed
women, standing
offering.
But instead of
oxen, one notices on the altar a chalice and breads, clearly a prefigur-
The lower
at the left
The
may
juxtaposition of
to
Bibles
made
It is fitting
at Tours,
that
we
Moses climbing
static
and there
is
also
found
last biblical
scene
we
more
in the Carolingian
is
havf
The exchange of
way
The
archetype.
ascribed with a
evidence, which
all
us He
Vs.'
PLATE
48
Codex Amiatinus
fol.
Vr
was
It
Ezra
Bibles copied at
scribe
The
who
in Calabria,
the
rewrote the Holy Scripture after the end of the Babylonian captivity.
choice
ity as a
all
Vivarium
is
own
Cassiodorus'
activ-
Codex Amiatinus
ing busily in a large codex held on his knees, was used as a model and adjusted
by placing a
tallith
on
his
when
still
his breast.
its
shelves,
with
filled
scrolls.
About 700
a.d. the
was made by an
Italian artist
in the
first
Jarrow-Wearmouth
It is still
working
at
Northumbrian monastery or by a
alternative
is
Byzantine Evangelist type, his pose, drapery, the furniture and the writing paraphernalia, and the miniature's stylistic affinity to
Among
the factors
the tunic,
\\
ii
frescoes
hereby th^
Roman
*
mantle bec v
from
is
tl
'
end
the dc na-
2? in its
ESPRA
CK>
:..
pUCYSltff
48
$9.95
And from
as in
modern cartoon
such fragments
how
possible to see
still
strips.
in existence,
it is
worked out
lines.
their
Among
new
Gospels,
and
Kurt Weitz-
mann
from "the
first
Late Antique
Book Illumination
This volume
is
new
series
of
Mug-
XIVth Century
GEORGE BRAZILLER
ftinted
inWest
Cmanf
ISBN: 0-8076-0830-0
One
Park Avenue,
New York
10016
0-8076-0831-9
P bt