Sie sind auf Seite 1von 558

MIROSLAV M A R C O V I C H

HIPPOLYTUS
REFUTATIO OMNIUM HAERESIUM

w
DE

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

PATRISTISCHE T E X T E UND STUDIEN


IM A U F T R A G D E R

PATRISTISCHEN

KOMMISSION

D E R A K A D E M I E N DER W I S S E N S C H A F T E N
IN D E R B U N D E S R E P U B L I K D E U T S C H L A N D

HERAUSGEGEBEN VON

K. ALAND UND E. MHLENBERG

BAND 25

WALTER DE GRUYTER BERLIN NEW YORK


1986

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

HIPPOLYTUS
REFUTATIO O M N I U M H A E R E S I U M

EDITED BY

MIROSLAV MARCOVICH

WALTER DE GRUYTER BERLIN NEW YORK


1986

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

Gedruckt mit Untersttzung der University of Illinois/USA

Printed on acid-free paper


(ageing-resistant pH 7, neutral)

Libraiy of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data


Hippolytus, Antipope, ca. 170235 or 6.
Refutatio omnium haeresium.
(Patristische Texte und Studien ; Bd. 25)
Preface in English.
Bibliography: p.
Includes index.
1. Heresies, Christian History Early church,
ca. 30600. 2. Heresies, Christian Controversial
literature Early works to 1800. I. Marcovich, Miroslav,
II. Title. III. Series.
BR65.H84R435 1986
273'.1
86-13593
ISBN 0-89925-211-7 (U.S.)

CIP-Kurztitelaufiiahme der Deutschen Bibliothek


Hippolytus (Papa, Antipapa):
Refutatio omnium haeresium / Hippolytus. Ed. by Miroslav
Marcovich. - Berlin ; New York : de Gruyter, 1986.
(Patristische Texte und Studien ; Bd. 25)
ISBN 3-11-008751-0
NE: Marcovich, Miroslav [Hrsg.]; GT

ISSN 0553-4003

1986 by Walter de Gruyter & Co, Berlin 30


Printed in Germany
Alle Rechte, insbesondere das der bersetzung in fremde Sprachen, vorbehalten.
Ohne ausdrckliche Genehmigung des Verlages ist es auch nicht gestattet, dieses Buch oder Teile
daraus auf photomechanischem Wege (Photokopie, Mikrokopie, Xerokopie) zu vervielfltigen.
Satz: Hagedorn, Berlin, Hubert & Co., Gttingen; Druck: Hildebrand, Berlin
Bindearbeiten: Lderitz & Bauer, Berlin

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

VXORI CARISSIMAE
DDD

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Preface

VII

Abbreviations, Editions, Literature


Introduction
Text
Book
Book
Book
Book
Book
Book
Book
Book

XIII
1

I
IV
V
VI
VII
VIII
IX
X

53
92
140
211
279
322
341
379

Indices
Index Locorum
Index Nominum
Index Verborum Potiorum

419
421
428
436

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

PREFACE
Apparently, history had shown little mercy to the Roman presbyter
Hippolytus, a prolific Christian writer and a staunch defender of orthodoxy
and Church. After a rather turbulent life in Rome - taking some four
decades, - he was deported to Sardinia, insula nociva, never to see Rome
again (in A.D. 235). His Roman admirers showed the poor taste of choosing
the statue of a Greek woman-philosopher - reinterpreted maybe as Sancta
Sophia - to honor the Martyr (that is the so called Vatican statue). What
is worse, the name of Hippolytus the author has been forgotten soon
enough to allow the posterity to ascribe his master-piece - Rrfutatio
omnium haeresium (along with its supplement De Universo) - to Origen,
or to a Roman presbyter called Gaius, or even to Josephus the Jew. Finally,
modern scholarship had cast doubts on the authenticity of Hippolytus'
accounts of the major Gnostic systems in the Refutatio, and recendy some
scholars have doubted even Hippolytus' authorship of the Refutatio.
But the discovery of the rich Nag Hammadi Coptic Gnostic library back in 1945 - has vindicated Hippolytus. For one thing, the very existence
of a Paraphrasis Stem (NH VII. 1), referred to by Hippolytus at V.22.1,
proves that Hippolytus' account of the Sethians (V. 19-22) cannot be
explained as a forgery. Hippolytus' Refutatio firmly stands today as one
of the best extant heresiological sources for the study of Gnosticism.
And the recent facsimile edition of the Nag Hammadi codices* makes
the need for a critical edition of Hippolytus' magnum opus even greater.
Paul Wendland's honest effort of 1915 - posthumously published by
others in G. C.S. 26 - looks inadequate today, in view of the rising standards
in modern palaeography and textual criticism. The point is that the text
of the Refutatio as transmitted is extremely lacunose and corrupt. The
bulk of the work is preserved in one single manuscript - Parisinus
suppl. gr. 464. In addition to having suffered considerable physical damage,
the Paris codex is plagued with huge textual gaps, countless word omissions, displacement of words and even entire clauses, intrusive marginal
glosses, tricky scribal errors accumulated during a transmission of eleven
centuries, etc.
*

The Facsimile Edition of the Nag Hammadi Codices (Leiden, E.J. Brill): Codex I (1977);
II (1974); III (1976); IV (1975); V (1975); VI (1972); VII (1972); VIII (1976); IX and
X (1977). XI, XII and XIII (1973). Cartonnage (1979).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

VIII

Preface

Both the Patristische Kommission and the Editors of the PTS-series have
kindly and appropriately drawn my attention to the fact that my apparatus
criticus includes orthographic variants and itacisms usually not recorded in
standard editions. After a long consideration, I have decided to report all the
differences between the adopted text and Parisinus - for the following
reasons.
First, Parisinus is the codex unicus of the Refutatio. It well deserves that all
the readings of its scribe, Michael, be recorded - for possible future palaeographical studies. Second, Parisinus is an exceptionally corrupt manuscript,
so that a complete and accurate reporting of its readings may be of great help
for future textual criticism of the Refutatio - in case the suggested solution is
not satisfactory. E.g., the same person is called in - (IV. 2.1),
(V. 13.9), (. 10.1). Or take 1
2 (VI. 35.7), () (VII. 31.1) (i.e., Bardaisan of Edessa). And
finally, Hippolytus often quotes poetry, where there is even more important
to know the exact reading of the manuscript. E.g., IV. 32.3 v. 9 f. ' . . .
' ... ' ... Miller: ' ... ... ' ; IV. 35.5 . 2 Meineke: - .
In conclusion, I beg the reader to bear with this rather generous apparatus
criticus - in view of the exceptional circumstances of the transmisssion of
the Refutatio.
The main objective of the present edition is to provide the reader
with a reasonably reliable text, not to produce an exhaustive running commentary as well. Hence the first apparatus has been deliberately limited
to a minimum. It is my hope that this edition will encourage scholars to
engage in a deeper Quellenforschung of the Refutatio than is presendy the
case.
The work on this edition had begun back in 1962, at the University
of Bonn, to be continued at Cambridge and Oxford, and to be completed
at the University of Illinois at Urbana: habent sua fata libei. Now, during
the past eighteen years, my obligations to others for generous help and
encouragement are many. I am indebted to the Bibliotheque Nationale
at Paris, and to the Vatican, Laurentian and Turin libraries, for letting me
study the manuscripts; to British Academy, the Research Board of the
University of Illinois, and its Center for Advanced Study, for generous
grants; finally, to the University Libraries at Bonn, Cambridge, Oxford and
Urbana.
I have greatly benefited from wisdom and insight of several scholars:
of F Marcel RICHARD, who possessed a superb knowledge of the entire
opus of Hippolytus; of Hans Herter and Wilhelm Schneemelcher at Bonn;

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

Preface

IX

of Henry Chadwick and G. C. Stead at Oxford and Cambridge; of Kurt


Aland at Mnster. Without their constant help this edition would not have
been possible. Needless to say, for any possible blunder the responsibility
is mine alone.
Last not least, it is a pleasant duty for me to express my sincere gratitude
to all members of the Patristische Kommission der Akademien der Wissenschaften in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland for the honor of including this
edition in the PTS-Series. My special appreciation goes to the Arbeitsstelle
Mnster of the Kommission for countless and invaluable improvements of
the book, above all to Kurt Aland and Hans-Udo Rosenbaum.
Urbana, Christmas 1980

. .

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

ABBREVIATIONS
Sigla
C O D I C E S REFUTATIONIS LIBRUM I C O N T I N E N T E S
L

Laurentianus IX 32
Ottobonianus 194
Barberinianus 496
Barberinianus 362
Taurinensis VI 25

ff. 307-318
ff. 135 r -166 v
ff. l r - 3 0 v
ff. 37 r -56 r
ff. quindecim

s. XIV
s. XVI vel XVII
s. XV vel XVI
s. XVI vel XVII
s. XVI (nunc deperditus)

C O D E X REFUTATIONIS LIBROS IV-X C O N T I N E N S

Parisinus suppl. gr. 464 saec. XIV, foil. 1-132, 137, 133-136.
P^, P^- codicis Parisini manus prima, secunda, tertia.

Breviata
()
*
( *)
f f
[ ]
( )
a. c.
add.
coniec.
conl.
corr.
damn.
def.
del.
em.

litterae in codice Parisino prorsus evanidae


textus periit: lacuna in codice Parisino
lacunam in textu coniecere viri docti
vox corrupta
vox delenda
vox addenda
ante correctionem
addidit
coniecit
conlato
correxit
damnavit
defendit
delevit
emendavit

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

XIV
in mg.
om.
p. c.
scr.
sscr.
suppl.
transp.
utv.

Abbreviations, Editions, Literature


in margine
omisit
post correctionem
scripsit
suprascripsit
supplevit
transposuit
ut videtur

EDITIONES
Refutationis libri I (, cf. IX. 8.2)
1701 Gronov Origenis Philosophoumencjn fragmentum: quod ex Bibliotheca Medicea
descripsit, ac notis illustravit Jacobus Gronovius, in Thesauri Graecarum
antiquitatum vol. X, coll. 257-292. Lugduni in Batavis (apud P. & B. van
der Aa).
1706 Wolf 1 Compendium historiae philosophicae antiquae, sive Philosophumena, quae sub
Origenis nomine circumferuntur (edita primum ex cod. Bibl. Mediceae
a Jacobo Gronovio)... recognita et notis uberioribus illustrate passimque
correcta a M. Jo. Christophoro Wolfio... Hamburg! (impensis Christiani
Liebezeit), pp. 1-186.
1713 Wolf 2 Compendium historiae philosophicae antiquae, h. e. Pseudorigenis Philosophumena, ex ipso ms. Mediceo denuo collato et alio Taurinensi repetita vice
emendata... auctore Christophoro Wolfio. Hamburgi (apud Christianum
Liebezeit).
1733 Delarue Pseudorigenis Philosophumena, in Origenis Operum omnium vol. I, pp. 872909. Ed. Carolus Delarue. Parisiis.
1879 Diels
Hippolyt! Philosophumena, in Hermann Diels, Doxographi Graeci, pp. 553576. Berolini.

Refutationis librorum I et IV-X


1851 Mi
1859 Go

1860 Cr

1916 We

Origenis Philosophumena sive Omnium haeresium refutatio, e codice Parisino


nunc primum edidit Emmanuel Miller. Oxonii (e typographeo academico).
S. Hippolyti episcopi et martyns Refutationis omnium haeresium librorum decern
quae supersunt. Recensuerunt, Latine verterunt, notas adiecerunt Lud. Duncker
et F. G. Schneidewin, professores Gottingenses. Opus Schneidewino defuncto
absolvit Ludovicus Duncker. Gottingae (sumptibus Dieterichianis).
Philosophumena sive Haeresium omnium confutatio, opus Origeni adscriptum,
e cod. Paris, productum recensuit, Latine vertit, notis variorum suisque instruxit, prolegomenis et indicibus auxit Patricius Cruice. Parisiis (Typogr.
Imper.).
Hippolytus Werke, dritter Band: Refutatio omnium haeresium, herausgegeben...
von Paul Wendland. (Die Griech. Christi. Schriftsteller der ersten drei Jahrhunderte, Bd. 26). Leipzig (J. C. Hinrichs). [Post Wendlandii mortem (a.
1915) opus edendum curaverunt H. Diels, C. Holl et A. ab Harnack].

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

Abbreviations, Editions, Literature

XV

COMMENTATIONES
ad rem criticam pertinentes
Roeper, G.,
Bernays, J.,
Marcovich, .,

'Emendationsversuche zu Hippolyti Philosophumena', Philologus 1 (1852),


pp.511-537; 606-637; 767 s.; et ap. Go.
Gesammelte Abhandlungen, ed. . Usener (Berolini, 1885), I, pp. 291-326.
'Textkritisches I zu Hippolyt Refutatio B.III-X', Rhein. Museum 107
(1964), pp. 139-158 et 305-315.
'Note on Hippolytus* Refutatio', J. T.S., N.S. 15 (1964), pp.69-74.
'Hippolytus and Heraclitus', Studia Patristica VII (T. U. 92, Berolini, 1966),
pp. 255-264.
'Textual Criticism on Hippolytus' Refutatio', J. T.S N.S. 19 (1968),
pp. 83-92.
'Textual Criticism on the Gospel of Thomas', / . T.S N.S. 20 (1969),
pp. 53-74.
'Displacement in Hippolytus' Elenchos', in Philomathes: Studies in Memoiy
of Philip Merlan (Hagae Comitis, Nijhoff, 1971), pp.240-244.
'Eighty Fresh Hippolytean Emendations', Antiquite Vivante 21 (1971),
pp. 635-658.
"Hippolytus, Refutatio X.33.9 Again',/. T.S., N.S. 24 (1973), p. 195 s.
'Fifty Hippolytean Emendations', in Serta Tutyniana: Festschrift Alexander
Turyn (Illinois U.P., Urbanae, 1974), pp. 374-393.
'One Hundred Hippolytean Emendations', in Festschrift Luitpold Wallach
(ed. Karl Bosl, Stutgardiae, A. Hiersemann, 1974), pp. 95-128.
'Phanes, Phicola and the Sethians',/ T.S., N.S. 25 (1974), pp.447-451.
'The Naassene Psalm in Hippolytus (Huer. 5.10.2)', in The Rediscovery of
Gnosticism, vol. II: Sethian Gnosticism, edited by Bentley Layton (Lugduni
Batav., E.J. Brill, 1981), pp. 770-778.
Studies in Graeco-Roman Religions and Gnosticism (Berolini, de Gruyter,
sub prelo).

in apparatu saepius laudatae


Bousset
Bunsen
Burkert
Foerster
Frickel

Ganschinietz

HenneckeSchneemelcher

Wilhelm Bousset, Hauptprobleme der Gnosis. Gttingen 1907.


Chr. K. J. Bunsen, Analecta Ante-Nicaena. I: London 1854.
Walter Burkert, Weisheit und Wissenschaft (Studien zu Pythagoras, Philolaos
und Plato). Nrnberg 1962.
Werner Foerster, Die Gnosis. I: Zeugnisse der Kirchenvter. II: Koptische und
Mandische Quellen. Artemis Verlag Zrich und Stuttgart, 1969; 1971.
Josef Frickel, Die Apophasis Megale" in Hippolyts Refutatio (VI 9-18): Eine
Paraphrase zur Apophasis Simons (Orientalia Christiana Analecta, 182),
Roma 1968.
R. Ganschinietz, Hippolytos' Capitelgegen die Magier (T.U. 39.2). Leipzig
1913.
Hippolytus alibi (e.g., in Refutationis libro X).
Edgar Hennecke f , Neutestamentliche Apokryphen in deutscher bersetzung. 3.,
vllig neubearbeitete Auflage herausgegeben von Wilhelm Schneemelcher. Tbingen. I (1959); II (1964).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

XVI
Hilgenfeld
Jonas

Koschorke
Lampe
Nautin
NH

PG
Reitzenstein
Resch
Resch, Agrapha2
Ropes
Sagnard
Staehelin
Wordsworth

Abbreviations, Editions, Literature


A. Hilgenfeld, Die Ketzergeschichte des Urchristentums. Leipzig 1884.
H.Jonas, Gnosis und sptantiker Geist, Teil I: Die mythologische Gnosis, Gttingen 1934; 1964 3 ; Teil II, 1. Hlfte: Von der Mythologie zur mythischen Philosophie, Gttingen 1954.
Klaus Koschorke, Hippolyts Ketzerbekmpfung und Polemik gegen die
Gnostiker (Gttinger Orientforschungen, 6), Wiesbaden 1975.
G. H. W. Lampe, A Patristic Greek Lexicon. Oxford 1968.
Pierre Nautin, Hippolyte et Josipe (Contribution a l'histoire de la litterature
chretienne du troisieme siecle). Paris 1947.
The Facsimile Edition of the Nag Hammadi Codices. Codd. IXIII & Cartonnage, E.J. Brill, Leiden, 1972-1979. - The Nag Hammadi Library in English,
ed. James M. Robinson. Leiden 1977.
J. P. Migne, Patrologia Graeca. Paris 1857-1866.
R. Reitzenstein, Poimandres. Leipzig 1904.
A. Resch, Auercanonische Paralleltexte zu den Evangelien (T.U. 10.1-4),
Leipzig 1893-1896.
A. Resch, Agrapha1 (T.U., N.F. 15.3-4), Leipzig 1906.
J. H. Ropes, Die Sprche Jesu (T.U. 14.2), Leipzig 1896.
Franfois-M.-M. Sagnard, La gnose valentinienne et le temoignage de Saint Irbiie
(Stdes de philosophie medievale, 36). Paris 1947.
Hans Staehelin, Die gnostischen Quellen Hippolyts in seiner Hauptschrift gegen
die Hretiker (T.U. 6.3), Leipzig 1890.
Chr. Wordsworth, St. Hippolytus and the Church of Rome. London 1853;
1880 2 .

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:39 PM

INTRODUCTION
I. THE TRANSMISSION OF ELENCHOS

I: THE

PHILOSOPHUMENA

Book I of the Refutation ofall Heresies ( ),


in ten books, comprises a Synopsis of Greek Philosophy} It begins with Thales
(1.1) and ends with the Sceptics (1.23), comprising twenty philosophers. To
them non-Greek philosophers (such as the Brahmans and the Druids, 1.2425) were added, as was the case in the last Book 13 of the lost Successions of
Philosophers by Sotion of Alexandria (ca. 200-175 B.C.). But already the literary genre of early Greek apologists had required that prose be mixed with
poetry: so this prose synopsis of philosophy is capped with a piece of relevant poetry (i.e., , 1.26.3),
namely, with some 30 lines from Hesiod's Theogony (108-113 and 115-139).
The same lines were quoted earlier, e. g., by Theophilus of Antioch (Ad
Autolycum II. 5-6).
The author of the Elenchos calls this Book I (IX. 8.2),
and it is not surprising that this succinct and handy Synopsis of Greek
Philosophy had been early separated from the rest of the Elenchos, most
probably to serve as a textbook in philosophy. As a consequence, Book I
has its own textual transmission, being preserved in these five MSS:
L Laurentianus IX 32 s. XIV. Chart., mixtus, foil. 336. Philosophumena:
ff. 307-318. 21 x 13.5 cm (15-17x9-9.5 cm; 30 versus).
Ottobonianus 194 s. XVI vel XVII. Chart., mixtus, foil. 275. Philosoph.:
ff. 135-166. 25 x 17 cm (16 x 10 cm; 24 versus).
Barherinianus 496 s. XV vel XVI. Chart., mixtus, foil. 139. Philosoph.:
l r -30 v . 28x21 cm (18.5x12.5 cm; 18 versus),
b Barherinianus 362 s. XVI vel XVII. Chart., mixtus, foil. 187. Philosoph.:
37r-56r. 20.5 14 cm (15 9.5 cm; 28 versus).
Taurinensis VI 25 s. XVI. Chart., mixtus, foil, fere 165. : foil, quindecim. Nunc deperditus.
While Barherinianus 362 (= b) is an apograph of Barberinianus 496 (= B)
and may well be dismissed, L O B and show many common scribal
errors. A few examples: Prooem. 7 , an obvious

See H. Diels, Doxographi Graeci (Berlin, 1879), 144-156, and J. Mejer, Diogenes Laertius
and His Hellenistic Background (Hermes Einzelschriften, 40, Wiesbaden, 1978), 83-86.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Introduction

dittography for Sancroft; 1.1.2 for


() Cedrenus; 1.3 for Roeper; 2.7
for () Wolf; 2.11 and 3.3 for <) Cedrenus; 2.18 for () Roeper; 15.2 for
Roeper; 20.5 for Stobaeus; 21.5
for ego, 22.4 for Cedrenus; 26.2
(= Hes. Theog. 110) for (); v. 112
for ' Rzach; . 127 for Gronov; . 137 '
for ' Gronov. Some of these errors are old,
going back to the uncial script; e.g., 1.1.2 for Cedrenus;
1.4 for Diogenes Laertius, Richter; 26.2 (= Hes. Theog. 129)
for () G. Hermann.
Doubtless the triad L O B form one single family as against T. Compare,
e.g., the title to Book I: L O B :
; Prooem. 7 L O B : ;
2.18 L O B : ; 24.2 rede, L O B
(a dittography). And in 1.21.2 sub fine displays a large paraphrase for
the correct text offered by L B.
Beyond this distinction between T, on the one hand, and the triad
L B, on the other - where the Laurentianus seems to offer the best text
most of the times, - one cannot go, since the transmission is contaminated.
For example, L O stand together against B T at Book I Recapitulatio 2
... against ...
of BT; at Prooem. 5 L O : BT; at 1.2.5 L O :
. On the other hand, L have at Prooem. 7
for the correct of , while at Recapit. 2, omit
{habent L T). Finally, when offers a correct reading (as against L ),
one cannot rule out the possibility that the reading is not a humanistic
emendation; for example, at Recapit. 6 ( Gronov,
Roeper): L O (T); or at Prooem. 6 :
LOT.
The Taurinensis deperditus. Fifteen folios of T, containing the Philosophumena, had been torn away from the codex and stolen before 1749,
when Pasini's Catalogue was published. The most likely culprit for this theft
seems to be Christopher Matthaeus Pfaff, who had worked in the Turin
Library from 1709 to 1712. For it was he who had provided Johann
Christopher Wolf with a list of variae lectiones of the Phibsophumena in
the Taurinensis, for Wolf s second edition of Compendium historiae pbibsophicae antiquae, which has appeared in 1713 in Hamburg. This was pointed
out already by Pasini (I, p. VIII), and clearly shown by A. Kiessling (in
a letter to Usener) and especially by Diels (Doxographi Graeci 155).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Transmission of Eknchos I: The Philosophumena

Consequently, the only editor of the Philosophumena to see anything of


the Taurinensis was Wolf, in his second edition, and we have no other choice
but to repeat Pfaffs report about the variae lectiones of T.
As a surprise, Paul Wendland described (in 1915) the Taurinensis as
existing: "Taurinensis C I 10 s. XVI. - Im Codex fehlen heute 15 Bltter,
dazu hat er bei dem Brand der Bibliothek schwer gelitten, vgl. Inventario
dei codici superstiti greci e latini antichi della biblioteca nazionale di
Torino (1904) unter cod. gr. LXXX."2
Wendland, however, was utterly mistaken about , since the codex
referred to by him (i. e., cod. LXXX of Pasini's Catalogue = C III 23
before 1904 = C I 10 after this year: Multorum patrum homiliae, ff. 142)3
neither contains the Phihsophumena, nor is from the sixteenth but from
the thirteenth century; its folios are of parchment, not of paper; and,
finally, 15 folios from it are not missing.
The codex which actually contained the Phihsophumena (i. e., = cod.
CCLVI of Pasini = C I 10 before 1904 = VI 25 after this year)4 had
been practically destroyed in the catastrophic fire of the Turin National
Library (between 25 and 26 January 1904): out of 165 folios of T, only
some 90 small pieces of burnt paper remained (13 13 cm in size),
which have since 1904 been kept in the Department called 'Cemetery'
as useless. But long before the fire has destroyed in 1904, the fifteen
folios with the Phihsophumena had been torn away from and stolen,
before 1749.5
Editions. Byzantine historian Georgius CEDRENUS (ca. 1100) made
excerpts from the Phihsophumena and included them in his
(I, p. 275 ff. Bekker). Then we do not hear of the Phihsophumena
until the seventeenth century, when the Laurentianus became known.
First, Lucas Holstenius (Holstein, 1596-1661) mentions the work as
extant in L (teste Gronov, in the Dedicatio to his editio princeps, written
in 1699). Next, Alexandre More (1616-1670) makes use of L in his

2
3

Hippolytus Werke III (G. C. S. 26; Leipzig, 1916), p. XI.


Jos. Pasinus, Codices MSS Bibliotbecae Regit Taurinensis Athenaei, I (Taurini, 1749),
pp. 174f. (cod. LXXX) = Inventario dei codici superstiti ... (Estratto dalla Rivista di
Filologia 32, pp. 385-588), Turin, 1904, p. 393 (No. 19) =- Albano Sorbelli, Inventari
dei MSS delle Biblioteche d'ltalia, vol. XXVIII (Florence, Olschki, 1924), No. R 288 =
C I 10 (Homiliae multorum patrum, membr. saec. XIII, ff. 142).
Pasini, I, p. 370 (cod. CCLVI = C I 10), chartaceus, ff. 165, s. XVI, olim Gabrielis
Philadelphiae metropolitae. Philocalia Origenis a ss. patribus Basilio et Gregorio Nazianzeno ex ejus operibus collecta... = Inventario, N o . 2 1 2 ("Restano parechi fogli, ma
ridotti a miseri frammenti," p. 421) = Sorbelli, No. 244 = VI 25.
Cf. M. Marcovich,/ T.S., N.S. 15 (1964), 73 f.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Introduction

Remarks on NT of 1661.6 In 1663, Gilles Menage (Aegidius Menagius,


1613-1692) quotes the Phihsophumena from L in his Commentary on
Diogenes Laertius.7 Ad D.L. 1.34 (I, p. 191 Hbner), Menage states that
he is using a transcript from L provided by Carolus Monchalius,
archiepiscopus Tolosanus . Finally, Pierre Daniel Huet, in
his Origeniana (Appendix, 11) of 1668,8 had correctly concluded from
the Prooem. 6 of the Phihsophumena that the author claims to be a bishop,
and thus could not be identical with Origen (who never was bishop).
Huefs own guess (Epiphanius) was far off the mark, but then Huet
could not read Eknchos IX. 7 and 11-12 to learn that the author was
a contemporary of the Popes Zephyrinus (198-217) and Callistus
(217-222), since the Parisinus has not been discovered until 1841.
Again it was the Laurentianus that served for the editio princeps of
Origenis Phihsophoumenu>n fragmentum: a certain Rulaeus provided Jacob
GRONOV with a transcript from L (careless enough), and Gronov included
it in Volume X of his Thesaurus Graecarum antiquitatum (Leiden, 1701),
coll. 257-292. In his first edition of the Phihsophumena (Compendium
historiae phihsophicae antiquae, Hamburg, 1706), Joh. Christopher W O L F
follows Gronov's text. For his second edition (Hamburg, 1713), however,
Wolf was able to acquire a good collation of L, made by A. M. Salvini,
the variae kctiones of T, provided by Christoph. Matthaeus Pfaff, and to
use the textual criticism on the Phihsophumena by Sancroft, La Croze,
and G. Richter.
In his edition of the works of Origen (Paris, I, 1733), Carolus DELARUE
was able to use the Ottobonianus and Barberinianus (in addition to L T),
as collated by his teacher B. de Montfaucon (compare Delarue's Preface,
p. XVII, and Montfaucon's Diarium Italiae, p. 210).
In the nineteenth century, G. Roeper had greatly improved the text
of the Phihsophumena (Phihhgus 7, 1852), but it is the merit of Hermann DIELS to have provided us with a first critical edition of the work,
in his Doxographi Graeci (Berlin, 1879), pp. 553-576. Diels used (as
transcribed for him by Fr. de Duhn), (as collated for him by A. Kiessling), L (apparently, in the collation of Salvini), and (in Pfaff s collation
of 1712); and Diels was the first scholar to recognize that Cedrenus
(Historiarum compendium, I. p. 275 ff. Bekker) had copied from the
6

Alex. Morus, Notae ad loca quaedam Novi Foederis (Londini, 1661); reprint Paris, 1668,
pp. 76; 180.
Observationes et emendationes in Diogenem Laertium (1663) ap. H. G. Huebner, Commentarii in Diogenem Laertium, 2 vols., Lipsiae, 1830; 1833.
Reprinted in P. G. XVII, col. 1282 f.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Transmission of Elenchos IV-X: The Parisinus

Phibsophumena (Doxogr. 156). Thus Diels was able to correct L in


many places by using Cedrenus.

II. THE TRANSMISSION OF ELENCHOS IV-X: THE

PARISINUS

The tripartite structure of the Elenchos is emphasized by the author


himself (X. 6.1): ' "
, ()
, , . That means, Books IIV comprise pagan (Greek and non-Greek) philosophy, mystery cults, astrology
and magic. Books V-IX deal at large with the doctrines of the heretic
schools, envisaged by the author as being inspired by Greek philosophy
or pagan beliefs and practices treated in Books I-IV. Finally, Book X
offers a brief Summary of Books V-IX (X. 9-29), preceded by an excerpt
taken from Sextus Empiricus {Adv. mathematicos X. 310-318) to serve as
kind of a Summary of Book I (X. 6-7), and capped with the exposition
of the priority of Jewish history (X. 30-31), and of the True Doctrine
(X. 32-34).
Now, Books II and III of the Eknchos are lost. Most probably, they
dealt with Hellenistic and Near Eastern mystery cults. Compare Prooent. 8:
' (sc. ) ()
,
(= Book I) (= Books II-III?)
(= Book IV). Or 1.26.4: Greek philosophers
(= Book I), (= Books II-III?)
(= Book IV). Or else, .5.1: ...
() (= Book I), ' ()
() (') ' ()
(= Books II-III?),
() (= Book IV),
' () () ... (=Books II-III or IV?). Cf.
also X.31.6 and X.34.1.
Books IV-X are preserved in one single manuscript, acquired in 1841 by
Constantinus Minoides Mynas (his codex ') from an Athos monastery
for the French Government.9 It is the Parisinus suppL gr. 464, saec. XIV,
9

Compare H. Omont, 'Mino'ide Mynas et ses missions en Orient (1840-1855),' Mentoires de


l'Academie des Inscriptions et Belks-Lettres 40 (1916), pp. 337-419. Entered the Library
18 November 1842 (Registre B, No. 8149).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Introduction

bombycinus, truncus, foil. 1-132, 137, 133-136. 215x145 mm (textus:


160x105-115 mm, 23-28 versus). The subscription on f. 135r reads:
f f 1 0 The monk Michael
has copied the whole of the Eknchos (= P1). There are two correctors,
one contemporary (= P2), the other, a later hand (in red ink, = P3).
The beginning of Book IV is missing in P, comprising at least Sextus
Empiricus, Adv. math. V. 5-11. In addition, one quire is missing between
folios 12 and 13. (The text on f. 13r from in IV. 28.1 to the end
of IV. 28.3 - is copied by Michael in the upper and right margins
of P). After this loss,11 two persons have tried to prevent further losses
by numbering the remaining quires (in the lower margin), the one in
Greek figures, the other in the Arabic ones. Here is what I could read
in P:
2
5
<>
3]
[ 7r
13
4

21
5
r
29

6
37
7

45
8

53
(ter)
9
61

10
69

11
IT

12
85

13 corr. in 12 (ut vid.)


93
()
14 corr. in 13
101
()
15 corr. in 14
109

16 corr. in 15
117
()
17 corr. in 16
125
f f
18 corr. in 17
133
19 corr. in 18
In addition to being mutilated, the Parisinus has suffered from moisture, worms, and other causes. The ink is blurred on the rough sides of
the folios because of the poor quality of the parchment. But apart from
physical damages, the codex is plagued with huge textual gaps, countless
word omissions, displacement of words and even entire clauses, intrusive
-

10

11

On the lower margin of f. 83 v Michael also wrote: ( ), ,


( = Ps. 5:2). Cf. also the inscription on the lower margin of f. 78r.
Cf. A. d'Ales, La theologie de Saint Hippolyte (Paris, 1906), 82 f.; Wendland (G. C. S. 26),
Preface, p. XII. f.; Marcovich, Rhein. Mus. 107 (1964), 143-145.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Transmission o f Elenchos IV-X: The Parisinus

marginal glosses, and above all many scribal errors. In brief, the text of
the Eknchos IV-X as transmitted is extremely corrupt. Evidendy, the scribe
Michael cannot be blamed for all this: the codex is the final product of
a long process of transmission and progressive deterioration, lasting
eleven centuries.
Editions. The editio prirtceps of the Eknchos IV-X (along with Book I)
was prepared by Emmanuel MILLER (Oxford, 1 8 5 1 ) , under the name of
Origen. The same year (1851) J.L. Jacobi 12 and especially L. Duncker 13
have recognized the Eknchos as a work of Hippolytus. In 1859, L . D U N C K E R
and F. G. SCHNEIDEWIN were able to publish the classical Gttingen-edition
of the Eknchos under the name of Hippolytus, accompanied by a Latin
translation and notes. Next year (1860), P. CRUICE has published his
Paris-edition of the work as Origeni adscriptum, again with a Latin translation and notes.
Long after these three pioneering editions (of 1851, 1859 and 1860),
Paul W E N D L A N D ' S edition in G.C.S. has appeared (Leipzig, 1916). Its value
consists primarily in the editors thorough Quellenforschung (visible in his first
apparatus). Its shortcomings, however, are due to two factors. First, apparently
the editor was unable to recognize that the Parisinus was that much lacunose
and corrupt; thus he prints the transmitted text at any price. The result is
that his textus receptus is too often neither Greek nor Hippolytus, being void
of sense.
And second, Wendland was a great scholar, but when working on his
edition of the Eknchos he was a dying man: the edition itself has been
published posthumously, by H. Diels, K. Holl and A. von Harnack.
Only so can one explain the fact that the codex had been often misread,
that Greek words are missing in the edition, that the editor was describing the wrong manuscript (the Taurinensis), that his own conjectures
were not lucky, etc.
The present edition starts from the conviction that the Parisinus is
damaged, lacunose and corrupt to a higher degree than the previous
editors were willing to admit. Consequently, first of all, greater attention
has been paid to the study of the original manuscript itself (which was
three times collated by the editor in Paris). Thus a lacuna (* * *), corruption (f f), illegible or blurred letters (printed in parenthesis),
etc., have been recorded in all instances, whether necessary or not.
Secondly, the editor has tried to restore the original text of the
Eknchos - wherever it was reasonably safe - by using the following
methods:
12
13

In Deutsche Zeitschrift fr christliches Leben und christliche Wissenschaft, June-July of 1851.


In Gttingische gelehrte Anzeigen, 1851, 1547-49.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Introduction

(a) The author of the Eknchos is highly repetitive. For example, in his
Summary (Book X. 9-29) he often verbatim repeats the entire passages
from the previous Books V-IX (only rarely bringing fresh material).
Thus a corrupt passage may be restored by simply collating it with
a correct and identical passage of the same Eknchos.
(b) In addition, the author copies - verbatim and extensively - from
other extant authors (such as Irenaeus, Adv. haereses, I; Flavius Josephus,
Sextus Empiricus). Thus a corrupt passage of the Eknchos may be helped
by collating it with its original.
(c) A corruption may also be cured by collating the passage with the
identical text in later authors copying from the Eknchos (such as Theodoretus, Cedrenus).
(d) Finally, a deeper Quellenforschung enables us sometimes to restore
the right reading. For example, in the case of the Gnostic and the heresiological literature, with their standard terminology, phraseology and
lexicon.
In brief, the editor is confident that the offered text of the Eknchos
is reasonably reliabk. Of course, when dealing with a highly corrupt text,
transmitted in one single manuscript, it is understood that many of the
suggested emendations or conjectures must remain a divinatio only:
May this edition serve as a basis for further textual criticism.

III. THE AUTHOR OF THE ELENCHOS

The tide of the work - - is provided


by the Tables of Contents {Recapitulationes, , ),
composed by the author himself and placed at the head of each book.
They begin so: (or , , ,
, , ) . Titles appearing in MSS are as follows:
Book I (initio): :
L (in mg.):
. 1.1.1 (ante ):
L O B .
Book IV (in fine): .
Book V: (in red).
Book VI: No title, but the Capitulatio begins with:
.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Author of the Eknchos

Book VII: f (in red).


Book VIII: (in red).
Book IX: No title, but after the Capitulatio (
), ante IX. 6.1: (in black).
Book : (in the margin, in red). Ante X. 32.1:
(in red).
Two comments seem to be in order here. First,
appears as a title of Books I, IV, and IX. Now, the author himself refers
to Book I as at IX. 8.2. However, in view of his
wording in X. 6.1 - (sc. )
' , - the possibility that
he himself had referred (in the lost parts of the Eknchos) to Books I-IV
as Phibsophumena cannot be ruled out. But it is highly unlikely that he
would refer to Book IX as Philosophumena. Thus the probability is that
the title Philosophumena was extended from Book I to the entire work
by the posterior tradition only.
Second, the attribution of Book I to Origen in L links this book with
Book X, where the name of Origen reappears (at X. 32.1). In addition,
Photius (Bibliotheca, cod. 48) found on the margin of his manuscript of
De Universe a scholium ( ) telling, among other
things, that The Labyrinth (= Eknchos?; cf. X. 5.1) had been attributed
by some to Origen ( ), in the same way in which the Small Labyrinth had been ascribed
to Origen (Theodoretus, Haeret. fabularum compendium II. 5).
Now, Origen was in Rome (Euseb. Hist. eccl. VI. 14.10) between A.D.
211 and 217 (or between 212 and 215), where he attended a churchsermon of Hippolytus (Hieronym. De viris illustr. 61): De
laude Domini salvatoris, in qua praesente Origene se loqui in eccksia significat
(sc. Hippolytus, cuiusdam eccksiae episcopus). This is the only known encounter of Hippolytus with Origen, and it may well have contributed
to ascribing the Eknchos to Origen. The alleged link between the two
authors was only enhanced by a mistake of St. Jerome {De viris ill 61):
he misunderstood the words of Eusebius (Hist. eccl. VI. 23)
(sc. ), taking them to mean (sc. ), thus implying that Origen was encouraged by Hippolytus (in huius aemulatione) to
write commentaries on Holy Scriptures. On their part, by further misunderstanding the text of St. Jerome, "Sophronius" (the translator of
De viris illustribus into Greek) and Photius (Bibl., cod. 121) had made
Hippolytus an imitator of Origen (... ,
... sc. Hippolytus;
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

10

Introduction

Photius).14
In brief, the Eknchos must have remained , if it could
be attributed to Origen, or to the presbyter Gaius, living in Rome
(Photius, cod. 48). As already said, P. D. Huet was the first scholar to see
that the Pbilosophumena could not be by Origen, back in 1668.
The author is Hippolytus of Rome. Since the name of Hippolytus does
not appear in the extant MSS of the Eknchos, the possibility that the
work is not by him - formally speaking - cannot be ruled out. However, the evidence in favor of Hippolytus, circumstantial as it may be,
seems to me to be overwhelming. Without entering here into the similarities of style, language and lexicon between the Eknchos and the works
preserved under the name of Hippolytus, the main reasons for attributing
the Eknchos to him are as follows.
1. The author claims to be a bishop; he lives in Rome and denies the orthodoxy to the Pope Callistus (217-222). In his Proem 6, the author speaks of
himself as a bishop in unmistakable terms: (sc. )
, , ...
(Compare Hippolytus' Apostolic Tradition, quoted in app. crit. ad locum).
As a bishop he felt authorized to excommunicate members of the Church,
and he did so:
' (IX. 12.21).
Furthermore, from the striking chapters 7, 11 and 12 of Book IX we
learn that the author was personally - and passionately - involved both
in the doctrinal struggle against the trinitarian modalism in Rome during
the Popes Zephyrinus (198-217) and Callistus (217-222) and in opposing
the Church reforms of Callistus. The congregation of Zephyrinus and
especially Callistus is repeatedly being called "a heretical school of
thought," , (IX. 7.3; 12.20; 12.21; 12.23; 12.26), while
being opposed to the orthodox Church (IX. 12.15; 12.20; 12.21) as represented by the author himself. In addition to openly accusing Zephyrinus and
Callistus of being heretics, the author blemishes them as being morally corrupt:
and (said of Zephyrinus, IX.
7.1; 11.1); (IX. 11.1),
(IX. 12.15) and (12.25), said of Callistus.15
14

15

The errors of St. Jerome, "Sophronius" and Photius have been explained long ago:
by G. Ficker, Studien zur Hippolytfrage (Leipzig, 1893), 83; by G. Wentzel, Die griechische
Uebenetzung der Viri inlustres des Hieronymus (T.U. XIII. 4, Leipzig, 1895), 51 f.; by
H. Achelis, Hippolytstudien (T.U. XVI.4, Leipzig, 1897), 11; 15.
On Eknchos IX. 11-12 compare J. Dllinger, Hippolytus und Kallistus (oder die Rmische
Kirche in der ersten Hlfte des dritten Jahrhunderts), Regensburg, 1853; G. Volkmar, Die

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Author of the Eknchos

11

Now, since the first reviews of the editio princeps of the Eknchos - by
Justus Ludwig Jacobi (1815-1888) and by Ludwig Duncker - back in
1851, and especially since the inspiring book of J. Dllinger (1853),
Hippolytus of Rome has been widely recognized as the best candidate
for the authorship of the Eknchos. First, there is an old evidence about
Hippolytus as being a bishop of a city (Euseb. Hist. eccl. VI. 20.2; Hieronym. De viris ill. 61; Theodoretus Haeret. fabul. compend. III. 1 sub fine,
et alibi), maybe in Rome (Apollinaris of Laodicea, Leontius of Byzantium, Eustratius of Constantinople). Second, the fact that Hippolytus
had been deported to Sardinia by the new emperor Maximinus Thrax
in A. D. 235 along with the Pope Pontianus (230-235): Eo tempore Pontianus
episcopus et Yppolitus presbiter exoks sunt deportati in Sardinia in insula nociva
Severn et Quintiano cons. (= A.D. 235; Catabgus Liberianus ap. Chronographum anni 354, p. 74 f. Mommsen), 16 is best explained by Maximinus5
general policy to persecute only the heads of the churches: Eusebius, Hist,
eccl. VI. 28, (sc. Maximinus),

.
Thus, both heads of the two churches in Rome, Pontianus and Hippolytus, are deported to Sardinia at the same time, and, accordingly, after
both had died there, their remains are brought back to Rome and buried on
the same day (13 August): those of the legitimate Pope {Pontianus episcopus),
in the Crypt of the Popes in S. Callisto; those of the illegitimate Pope
(Yppolitus presbyter), in a cemetery (?) on the Via Tiburtina, opposite the
Via Nomentana (S. Lorenzo Fuori): Idus Aug.: Ypolitiin Tiburtina, etPontiani
in Callisti (Chronographus anni 354, p. 72 Mommsen). 17

16
17

Quellen der Ketzergeschichte bis zum Nicnum, I: Hippolytus und die rmischen Zeitgenossen
(Zrich, 1855); G. Ficker, op. cit. (supra, note 14), 73 ff.; A. Hamel, Die Kirche bei
Hippolyt von Rom (Gtersloh, 1951); J.-M. Hanssens, La liturgie d'Hippolyte (Rome, 1959);
. Beyschlag, 'Kallist und Hippolyt,' Theol. Zeitschr. 20 (1964), 103-124, and others. On the claim on episcopacy by the author of the Eknchos (Proem 6), see John E. Stam,
Episcopacy in the Apostolic Tradition of Hippolytus (Diss. Basel, 1969), pp.33; 61 f.; 92;
esp. 110-113. For a different view cf. D.L. Powell, 'The Schism of Hippolytus,'
T. U. 115 (Studia Patristica XII, Berlin, 1975), 449-456. - Cf. K. Wegenast, in PWRE XA
(1972), 225-227.
Monum. Germ. Hist., Auctores Ant., IX.
Cf., e.g., H. Achelis, op. cit. (supra, note 14), 31 f. - O n Hippolytus in general compare,
e.g.: A. Harnack, Gesch. der altchristl. Litteratur bis Eusebius, I (Leipzig, 1893), 605-646;
II.2 (Leipzig, 1904), 209-256 (reprint 1958); O. Bardenhewer, Gesch. der altkirchlichen
Literatur, II2 (Freiburg im Breisgau, 1914; reprint 1962), 550-610; J. Quasten, Patrology,
II (Utrecht, 1953), 163-207; M. Richard, in Dictionnaire de Spiritualite, 44-45 (Paris, 1968),
531-571 (s.v. Hippolyte de Rome, Saint), P. Testini, 'Di alcune testimonianze relative

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

12

Introduction

2. The author of the Elenchos is identical with the author of the treatise On
the Universe, against the Greeks and Plato:' he is a presbyter living in Rome
between A.D. 189 and 217. The author of the Elenchos refers, at the end
of the work (X. 32.4), to a previous book of his under the title
. Now, the title No. 8 of a List of works engraved on
the Vatican statue, discovered back in 1551 between the Via Nomentana
and the Via Tiburtina and commonly ascribed to Hippolytus, reads:
, .18
Two remarks on the Vatican statue seem to be in order here. First,
the fact that the statue itself does not represent Hippolytus (nor was it
meant to) is irrelevant: all three Greek inscriptions carved on both sides of
the chair of the seated person are authentic, they belong to the third
century A.D., and were engraved after A.D. 222 and most probably
before A. D. 235, i. e., during the reign of the emperor Alexander Severus.
The List of the eleven visible titles refers to the works elsewhere attributed to
Hippolytus. They include:
() [ ] = De Psalmis (Hieronym. De viris i. 61); a Greek
fragment recently published by P. Nautin.19 The name of Hippolytus
had survived in the Syriac version, p. 127 Hans Achelis (G.C.S. 1.2
[1897]).
(b) [ ] = De Saul et pytonissa (Hieronym. ibid.).
(c) [] [] = De
Apocalypsi (Hieronym. ibid), compare the fragments De Apocafypsi
edited by H. Achelis (G. C. S. 1.2, pp. 231-238).20
(^ (sc. ) =
. The Chronicle, edited by A. Bauer

a Ippolito,' in Ricerche su Ippolito (Roma, 1977: Studia Ephemeridis "Augustinianum,"


13), 45-65. - A complete bibliography is not intended in this Introduction.
O n the history of the remains of St. Hippolytus posterior to the Depositio martyrum,
compare now: Maria Floriani Squarciapino, 1 recupero del sarcofago di S. Ippolito,'
BoUetino d'Arte (Ministero della Pubblica Istruzione, Roma), Serie V, 59 (1974), 180-186;
Pasquale Testini, 'Sondaggi a S. Ippolito all'Isola Sacra. I depositi reliquiari scoperti
sotto l'altare,' Rendiconti della Pontificia Aaademia Romana di Archeologia 46 (1973-1974),
165-177. The inscription (IX century) found in 1973 reads: f Hie requiescit beatus
Ypolitus marfyr).
18

19
20

The best text of the three inscriptions on the chair of the Vatican statue are to be
found now in Margherita Guarducci, Epigrafia Greco, IV: Epigraphi sacre pagane e Cristiane
(Roma, 1978), 535-547.
In Le dossier d'Hippolyte et de Meliton (Paris, 1953), 165-183.
Cf. P. Prigent, and P. Prigent-R. Stehly, in Theol Zeitschr. 28 (1972), 391-412; 29 (1973),
313-333; 30 (1974), 82-85.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Author of the Elenchos

13

and R. Helm (G. C. S. 46 [1955]), is most probably a work of Hippol y t s (compare Elenchos X. 30.1 and 5).21
(e) =
{Canon paschalis, Euseb. Hist. eccL VI. 22.1; et alii).22
() = De resunectione (Hieronym.
ibid.). Cf. Achelis (G. C.S. 1.2), 251-253, and M. Richard, in T.U. 115
{Studia Patristica XII; Berlin, 1975), p.69.
As Margherita Guarducci was able to demonstrate in 1975,23 the
Vatican statue itself represents a woman: it is a II century A.D. Roman
copy of a III century B. C. Greek statue, representing most probably the
Epicurean philosopher Themista of Lampsacus. Somewhere between
A.D. 222 and 235, when the inscriptions were made, the statue had
been "reinterpreted'' by the Christian adherents of Hippolytus to represent a female personification: or , according to
Guarducci, or rather (my guess).
Second remark on the Statue: The absence in the List of the major
works of Hippolytus - such as The Elenchos, The Syntagma, The Commentary on Daniel, The Antichrist - is surprising but not inexplicable. The
author of the three inscriptions wanted primarily to have The Canon
paschalis engraved: it takes the lion's share of the available space, covering both sides of the chair. The List of the works of the author of this
Canon paschalis was not his primary aim: it is an Appendix only, carved
on the narrow (right) back margin of the chair. Accordingly, the engraver
listed a few works of the author of the Easter Tables, namely those which
he knew were by this author (Hippolytus). Anyway, among the major
works The Chronicle is mentioned.
Back to the treatise De Universe: The reference at Elenchos X.32.4 links
the author of the Elenchos with the inscription on the Vatican statue listing the works of Hippolytus. But there is more to that: Doubtless this

21

22

23

Cf. M. Richard, 'Comput et Chronographie chez saint Hippolyte,' Mel. de Sc. ReL
7 (1950), 237-268; 8 (1951), 19-50; 10 (1953), 13-52 and 145-180; Idem, in Rech, de
Sc. Rel. 43 (1955), 379-394; H. Elfers, 'Neue Untersuchungen ber die Kirchenordnung
Hippolyts von Rom,' in Abhandl. ber Theologie u. Kirche (Festschrift Karl Adam),
Dsseldorf, 1952,169-211 (esp. pp. 189-192); G. Ogg, 'Hippolytus and the introduction
of the Christian era,' Vig. Christ. 16 (1962), 2-18, and others.
Cf. M. Richard, 'Notes sur le comput de cent-douze ans,' Revue des etudes byz. 24 (1966),
257-277.
See M. Guarducci, 'La statua di "Sant'Ippolito" in Vaticano,' Rendiconti della Pontificia
Accademia Romana di Archeologia 47 (1974-1975), 163-190; Eadem, in Ricerche su Ippolito (supra, note 17), 17-30 (esp. p. 29 f.), and in Epigrafia Greco, IV (supra, note 18),
p. 535 f.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

14

Introduction

book De Universe is identical with the treatise ()


, from which a solid fragment
has been preserved in the Sacra Paralkla (II. 801) ascribed to John
Damascene (= Fr. 353 Holl, . U. XX. 2). The similarities in imagery and
language between Eknchos X. 34.2 and Fr. 353 Holl are striking (and are
pointed out in app. ad loc.).24 The same seems to be true of the four
small fragments of De Universo, recently published by W.J. Malley from
the Coislinianus 305 (containing the Chronicle of George Hamartolus),
under the title ' . 25
Finally, Photius (Bibl. cod. 48) knows all three titles of De Universo:
(= the Vatican statue),
(= Fr. 353 Holl, and John Philoponus, De opif. mundi III. 16), and
(= Eknchos . 32.4). Photius had read the treatise
(consisting of two small books or treatises, ),
and he states that the author demonstrates Plato to be in contradiction
with himself, which explains the title of the treatise, (of
the Vatican statue), (Fr. 353 Holl), and squares with the
content of Fr. Ill Malley.
But the manuscript Photius read had the title
. The name of Josephus as the author of the De Universo reappears in the MSS of Fr. 353 (), in the Coislinianus 305 (), and in John Philoponus (De opif. mundi III. 16, ).
Now, Photius correctly doubted that Flavius Josephus could be the
author of a treatise speaking of Christ as Son of God (Cod. 48, p. 11 b
31-39 Bekker). Maybe the treatise was mistakenly attributed to Josephus
the Jew because the author of the De Universo demonstrates the Jewish
race to be much older than the Greek ( , . 11 b 21 Bekk.)?
Back in 1947, however, Pierre Nautin had suggested26 that this
obscure Josephus from the MSS of the De Universo is the actual author
of both the De Universo and the Eknchos. Nautin's theory is, however, self24

25
26

Cf. esp. D o m . Botte, 'Note sur l'auteur du De universo attribue Saint Hippolyte,'
Rech, de Thiol 18 (1951), 5-18; G. Bardy, 'L'enigme d'Hippolyte,' Mel. de Sc. Rel.
5 (1948), 63-88 (esp. pp. 78 ff.); B. Capelle, 'Hippolyte de Rome,' Rech, de Thiol 17
(1950), 145-174, esp. pp. 156-170, and others.
J.T.S., N.S. 16 (1965), 13-25.
Compare P. Nautin, Hippolyte et Josipe (Paris, 1947), esp. pp. 85-88; Idem, Hippolyte
Centre les heresies (Paris, 1949), 215-230; and in numerous articles: Rech, de Sc. Rel.
34 (1947), 99-107; 347-359; 42 (1954), 226-257; Revue des Sc. Rel. 25 (1951), 75-83;
Revue d'Hist. Eccl. 47 (1952), 5-43; Mel. de Sc. Rel. 11 (1954), 215-218; Idem, Lettres et
ecrivains chretiens des et 3e siecles (Paris, 1961), 177-190.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Author of the Eknchos

15

defeating. For, first, it has to attribute all the works listed on the Vatican statue to this Josephus, as it does: "... l'antipape Josipe, auteur de
1'Eknchos contre toutes ks heresies, de la Chronique, du traite Sur l'Univers
et des autres livres mentionnes sur la statue decouverte entre la via
Nomentana et la via Tiburtina." 27 But at least some of the works listed on
the statue - De Psalmis, De Resurrectione, Canon Paschalis, De Apocalypsi are firmly established as Hippolytean. And second, Nautin's theory has
to assume that Josephus and Hippolytus each had written a De Psalmis,
an Apostolic Tradition, etc. (Nautin, op. cit., p. 106 f.), which is highly
unlikely.
But the clue to the solution of the question about the authorship of
the De Universo and the Eknchos seems to be given by Photius himself
(Cod. 48). He found in the marginal notes ( ) of his
manuscript of the De Universo, among other things: First, that De Universo is not by Josephus but by a Gaius, who was a presbyter living in Rome
under the pontificates of Victor (189-198) and Zephyrinus (198-217), and
who later became "a bishop of the gentiles." And second, that the same
Gaius was also the author of the Labyrinth, ascribed by some to Origen. As
a matter of fact, continues Photius' Scholium, the author of the Labyrinth, at
the end of his work, attests himself to the fact that he is the author of the De
Universo as well: ... (sc. , )
(p. l i b 7-9 Bekk.).
Now, what this old Scholium of Photius says of Gaius (compare
Eusebius Hist. eccl. II. 25.6; VI. 20.3) squares reasonably well with what
we know about Hippolytus, presbyter (and even a self-proclaimed bishop) in Rome under Zephyrinus. Most probably, the Eknchos was called
in the posterior tradition also the Labyrinth - thanks to the opening words of
the last Book : (. 5.1), - in the same
way in which it also was called . And it is hardly
a coincidence that the author of the Eknchos refers to the De Universo as
his own work exactly at the end of his work (X. 32.4), as Photius' Scholium says that the author of the Labyrinth (called Gaius) does. It seems
safe, then, to conclude that the author of the De Universo and the author
of the Eknchos is the same person, namely a Roman presbyter (Photius),
and that this presbyter is Hippolytus of Rome (the Vatican statue, listing
De Universo as one of his works).

27

P. Nautin, Le dossier d'Hippolyte et de Meliton (Paris, 1953), p. 106.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

16

Introduction

3. Most probably, the author of the Elenchos is identical with the author of
the Syntagma, known as a work of Hippolytus. Right at the beginning of
his Proem (1), the author of the Elenchos refers to an earlier treatise of
his dealing with the doctrines of the heretical schools, a treatise less detailed and explicit in contents, and less ambitious in size than the present work, the Elenchos. (sc. )
, , ... Already Ludwig Duncker (in 1851) had recognized in these
words a reference to the lost Syntagma or Against All Heresies of Hippolytus: it is known as a work of Hippolytus thanks to Eusebius (Hist. eccl.
VI. 22), St. Jerome (De viris ill. 61), Chronicon paschak (p. 12.22 Dindorf),
and Photius (Bibl cod. 121), who briefly describes it in these terms:
- . ', , .
,
. As R. . Lipsius had proved, it is the same work of Hippolytus which later was used
by Pseudo-Tertullian (Adv. omnes haereses), by Epiphanius (in his Panarion), and by St. Filaster (in his Diversarum haereseon liber).26 As a matter
of fact, Epiphanius names Hippolytus as one of his sources (at Panarion
31.33.3; I, p. 435.23 Holl).
Now, Photius' description of Hippolytus' Syntagma as a small book
(), and as only a Synopsis of the voluminous work of Irenaeus,
perfectly matches the description of the work referred to at the beginning
of the Proem to the Elenchos: the author seems to be insisting on the
fact that his previous refutation of the heretical teachings was a rather
small book, and a Synopsis - , and .
Thus, the probability is that the author of the Elenchos is referring to the
Syntagma as his earlier work.
Finally, the author refers, at Eknchos X. 30.1 and 5, to a previous work
of his dealing with biblical chronology and similar in contents to the
Chronicle (completed probably between March 234 and March 235), which
is commonly attributed to Hippolytus (= , of the Vatican
statue). Thus it is tempting to see in X. 30.1 and 5 a reference to an
earlier version of the ascribed to Hippolytus.
One cannot, however, be sure enough.
In conclusion, each one of the three arguments adduced above points
at Hippolytus of Rome as the most likely author of the Elenchos. Now,
28

Richard Adelbert Lipsius, Zur Quellenkritik des Epiphanios (Wien, 1865), esp. pp.33 ff.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

17

the author seems to know the death of the Pope Callistus (in A. D. 222):
... () () (EL IX.
12.26). If so, then the Eknchos seems to have been composed between
A.D. 222 and 235.

IV. THE CONTENTS OF HIPPOLYTUS'

ELENCHOS

A. Hippolyti Refutations Capitum Conspectus


Signs
stands for Hippolytus.
= indicates that copies verbatim from his direct source.
(( means that either excerpts or summarizes his direct source.
( indicates Hippolytus' indirect source.
) means that a later author uses the respective passage of the Elencbos.
Finally, the phrase ; indicates the Greek philosopher
(or source) from which, in Hippolytus' opinion, the respective heresy had
plagiarized.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Introduction

18

'S ^
! I i
3i> t>

Ui Ui
T3
"O
u
u u

"Eb
v: m
IH Q
o <N
t i
U iS

c c c
y I
|yH l-l
H IHy
"O
u u "u u
U U U U

p4

D
5
>
<o t
O
1

on

OH C8
.o, a
S

t5

3
on

&
&
g
-C

c
1
6 '
3
J3
IS
cv

8 J8
J '' .
S

Ph OH PH

s
>I
I

bo

" 3
3
-
u

kH
-
C
C
1)

'3
g
rt
< < < < 1 &H
<
"3
J3
cS
c e - <-

sO t-^ 00 Os

so
OS

I
WS
D
U3 5 s
3
'S -S
Ol, 8"
"0
3 W
(U 2
J Q X
13

W t

f-H
rsi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Elenchos

c c

tH
na

isy
H
-

19

y y
- -
<

CO
NO
<

Ui
3
C
rt

-
Q
<
3
s
<

^
I
I'
tir

^S

^t
N

13

ju
-a

O g
ui b
^f
N

-
I3
ON
ro
X 00
II

C/)

JS
cm
. .
2 Q
Ou r 3
hS -G JT
cl, en eu

-G u

"-

<
'
& <

(
5
3 i - g -C
1 <->

2
< pq

(
3
rt 3
"2
3

Q

a
J2
"

U"1 NO ON 00 ON
I
"*

-H
(
I

<

m no

rt
-c

ON NO
2 on
^

00 1/
On On
<r>
.
I CO
r-> ON
eo I I
NO ON

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

20

Introduction

art

J3
p4

o
> 1
o ' S
-
C

<


on

IF
3
oo

-C2

fr

>
(y

-S C
<
(S
I
fr

S- I

S 8 I
^S g2
f rt <
C
Ii

r-l J2 _c
o\ ^

JS
ft<

u>

a
Q. --)
(

s
c
c
<3 ,
s

I
>

rr1
2

<;
0

U
-

a
^
4

CS

u-i
I
SO

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus'

Eknchos

21
(II -s
V
-

rtn( W> . J fS
ro
00 S II

I
U")
<N

"

-6 >
to

f P gg S S
>t
a a
- ^r I

^
>

3
(

)
J3

'

-aOJ
C
.y

f5

rt

U-)
so
CO
00

3
QJ
^

S
h
5

.a

1-1
2

(J
Pi
(J rt

rrt

(
-
I

.
>
^
UJ
(J
Ni-

3
U

Pi

ei
&

<

O i n

*
\
,-
2;

\
I -"

Vh

so

C -
3

t
Vh

.3 2

CS

a.

<
a

be
+- C
0
I
<
Os" -

u
1 <
G 00I
00 'S.
SO

ON

I *
I OS
G C

< rt >-> > CO

^ >
c
i*

" .

-s

<

C
W - UH
J3
" ( '
(

<

r^

S 1

.
*
os

/5 ^
> >

>
CO

Os
t in

-5
q
<

Os
I

SP
-fi

. ^
< w

"
I
I

-
-
/->

IS

-D

.-I

t/
u
<n
<
2

I
so
>

U
5

&

.
ja W
.
2 <
^(

..
so

00
-H
I

t-H

"S

S
c

f)

to

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Introduction

2 BQ
...
3

J*

II

s
"S
Irt
'5
U

1
in
I
^
(M
""

C i-i
^
c ^
0

> 95

_ "

Ii
-3

<

< 00
J a *
.

=>
U <(

.&<

I
U")

'S

<

- ^
*"<
-
Os , .
ro ; >

I n
a
Q_ <N

>
U
g

t-

t.

-S
)
eg

t"1

.m

1 0
J *

<N

( .

&

rt
S S

a
(
3
b

<3

I
' -

00

*I

<

^
3
-

b
S
a
S

7
r1
2

rfc SO
2

>3-

m
JJ

i-i

5
S*

"

3 ,5

I:
a:
CJ

CO

2<

<
<
I
Os

155
D
U
<

2
0

<

<

<
I

3
I

00

c -S
a

6B
D
.5

I
^
^
*

Q &
~ _ -S
1-1

S


_
< 2 . S

ei

<

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents o f Hippolytus'

23

Elenchos

<3
<1

00
I

a
Si

TO

s
*
) <

da <s
rt

Jg

W
^

I
<- (

c
(N

((-!

5
^

8
SO

CO
Os
C <

J>

>
I

>

<

y
C

e
2
CJ

a
a

"2

I
w

d,"
,'

w
<

S - S
oj

58

*
-s
<o

'S

5
C

3
u

00
fS
I
ro
<N

so
ro
I

Os
I

ro

SO
I
ro

00
ro

'

^
-S
3
t?

- s

S6

R ill

C N
.o .

ti

<N
<N
I

(N

PHI

e - J3
S Cu
8 . . (

00
w

vO

5
< T3
tC
o\
-3. -a

<

S3

/3 cd

ro
I
(

.2

S
S

ro
I

ro

it

NN

I7
<

. . 4

^.
V

UI-

t:

*
U U

"a
s

<N rn
CO

cr,

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

24

Introduction

<N
in
m

Oh

CO
OS

C
**

D
P"

o
w
" ' S

S 5

a
1H U5

<

rt

i f e

4-t
<
m

t
r>

H-t

Cl,
O.

00

1-
II
u-> I
es
e s CO t-H - -
-H
t-H U-)
1
I t-H
I
t-H ^
ro
es
Os e s e s

u->
C
a

oo

9o

un

Os

rr,

'S

Ji

<N

u>

u-> -O
fN
-

1-1

II

..

c
<

Os

<N

<

w m

00
(i

"-

><

es

m SO . . Cr
^f'
I
U
I,
12
a
<8
<o
1
8

u
13
-4-t

>

c
l>

"T3

Q
j
Co
<
PQ

<N
I

es

OO

S
y
0

00
es

2
-
U

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

25

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

hH

cx

<u
"u

"D

-
<
(

6
W

"rt
h
3

-C
ex

cx
<
<
h
1
er tr

-
II

< '

Ps| I 3
I G-
I


' 0- I
Os
OS
+-
(
(
(
C

00

"

PJ

SO
co (
<s

, &

w
"
CO CO CO

3
a
c
rt
C

2
03

<
3 3 %
-
~

< < . a

U")
CO \0
CO

c 2 >

g
- . 2
c 0
< 3
J<

co
^) CO
co

00

00

< ^
es

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

26

Introduction

u->

xi
l

<<

>u
<0
vO
C -

CS
><

" (
>-;
II I

D
ft
. y3

t/i

s i
1 .is
J<5

<-

J3 .a

0
t o ?fe

n-
<3

n-
'S

Ii


a
3

<
60

'
2

SO

9 2
-G

1
(N

d s

HC

Ui
ns
u

<
-4-J
C

-H
J-J*
S -i

ft

S2

V)

Vi

lH
<
J3

^^

><

os
Im
<
X

>
3

w
0

0
I-*
PiU
iL

1
I1 0
0
0
PQ

a 5 "0
C 3 <
2 C '
ofe
'S <,jf

Jj

i s l - S
g l

& 2

0 0 OS

ro
I

<N

<L)
"

rt

3 '3

ro

<N

0
p

</J
3
C

.SP
.

J
C

w
U

<& <N
f- 7
> < s

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

27

The Contents of Hippolytus' Elenchos

3
3

(
^
S
1
i
.

#
<u
3
C
X

NO
CS
I

*X
w - >

aV3 .

SP 2 8P
<s

%-a &

b
- s a
-S c
u

"o

t: s I
C b o^r
I
^
"o s - . a
rt

-
/3 ON

^ >


t
CO
0
<
c
"ss C
J3

U
2
rt

<N vi
a
w
^ .
.
cr>
2
I
I

C/3 Uh

&

C
rt
a ^-

I g d
J
U
^
W
U
<3

00

I
00

CS
-
I

<

a c
qj
t
w

00
^ <

I
rr>

>

rt

JS
NO

CQ
I
ON
S(1 VI ",(
c-oo a
B

II

I
,<s
3

a
;

3
C
rt
3 .
I
9*
rv
ON

i n >
I CN
en

(S

a
,
s
'c

U -c

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

28

Introduction

i s
>
t sS

i
(U t*

<2

D
vO

X

U

18

5
2
"
,

'S

II
r-H
so
m

<

SO C ^
; >

' tv
SO
>'
<

>
II

^ 00

!>

<

tv
I
so

>< t l

3,

<j

a
C/3

xi x

3

S 5

.3

rn
I
<N
OS
csi

so
I
ii
^ r

Tf <"H yI 3 Os os
I

y"5
S
J3

s
C w
<*>

J 2
&H

c
te

^H
-3
u
oo

2
a
S

wo

W
H
3

'3

"
C
'-
c

I
a

00

9
U

so

On
<
I
OS

Os
c

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Elenchos

29

CO
lH
U
rt
v
aj
2
s .

CQ

a
VI

V
S
_
5 .52
rnoI^

<N
I
S.
J4

CQ

'

Q.
y

S
8


C O
< u
3 C
cr <2
SiS

C
rt

-
l-H

u
S a

0
Ui
rt

so

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Introduction

U"> -<
CO r-1
<N
co

r"l i r
^
ro
so
CO oo
PQ
CO

w
-M
ro
CO

CO ' '
3

2
.13
fr-c
0 >-I <
W i
J
^
.
a
U U

(
I
CS
C

Os

U-) \0 os os

< ^ f
ro ro

I
Os

1
1
hin 4-4
h1
''

hlh

1
,

<

3 "< 3

5 2 -D
c

c . 2
1
U

^ tS)
< < <

>
-

( C

2 S Z

' t
( ( <

<
I
<)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

a
a

<

I
-4-i
QJ

-T3
_
t^

>

<j CQ
tu . s

SO

00

,-
rSO (
_ : hH
X l-pl

4
8
1-H
" 1-H 3

co co <"
X 2

CO

in
co
t-4
Uh
co

<N

3 S
S

o.

ro
X'

Id

'S- 00
I
CO

u
8

JS

OS
<N

' F o l

J3
U

^H CO
co co
I I
fS
CO CO

co

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

32

Introduction

. Hippolytus' Great Discovery and the Structure of the Elenchos


Long after (, Proem 1) having written his modest synopsis
(, Photius) Against all Heresies, Hippolytus had the good
fortune to get hold of a golden board: it comprised substantial treatises
belonging to no less than eight different Gnostic schools - the Naassenes,
Peratae, Sethians, Justin Gnostic, "Simon Magus," Basilides, the Docetists,
and Monoimus the Arab. Hippolytus' great predecessor and model,
Irenaeus of Lyons, did not know of these sources when writing his
heresiology (Adv. haereses I). In addition, Hippolytus was able to acquire
a ninth new source - an exposition of the Valentinian doctrine different
from the version known to Irenaeus in Adv. haer. I. 1-8.
Hippolytus was not slow in recognizing the importance of his great
discovery, of this "Nag Hammadi library" of his days. Not only that the
new sources would enable him to surpass both Irenaeus and his own
Syntagma: they presented him with an unexpected opportunity of his
life. Now he will be able to achieve three major objectives. They seem to
be as follows.
1. Hippolytus' Magnum Opus. Thanks to the new discovery, Hippolytus
felt that now he was able to produce, for the first time, a large-scale heresiology.
As a matter of fact, the new Gnostic material makes the bulk of the Elenchos:
Books V-VIII. And Hippolytus took good care to arrange the fresh material
in such a way as to stress its novelty and impress the reader. The opening
Book V comprises new material exclusively: the highly impressive Naassene
Predigt was put at the head of the book, followed by the reports on the Peratae, Sethians and Justin. In the remaining Books VI-VIII, the new material
was placed right at the head of each book - "Simon Magus" and Valentinus,
in VI; Basilides, in VII; the Docetists and Monoimus, in VIII. The rest of the
Books VI-VIII was filled with the material already known from Irenaeus
and from Hippolytus' own Syntagma.
In his earlier Refutatio, says Hippolytus in his Proem (1), he had chosen
not to disclose the secret teachings and mysteries of the heretics (
): he had preferred to
speak of their doctrines "in riddles only" ('
), thus giving them a chance to repent and reform.
We may well understand that he was not in a position to fully disclose
the secret doctrines of the heretics when writing his Syntagma - for the
simple reason that at that time he did not yet possess the rich hoard of
the substantial Gnostic tractates fully employed in his later Elenchos.
But now, when writing the Elenchos, he has changed his mind: he

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus'

Eknchos

33

feels that "enough is enough," and he has decided to expose the heretics
by fully disclosing their secret teachings and mysteries - '

' , ...
, Proem (2). That means that Hippolytus will now copy verbatim and extensively from the Naassene Predigt
and the rest of the newly discovered Gnostic treatises.
And what better way for the author to fulfil his promise of a full
disclosure - and, at the same time, to demonstrate the authenticity of
the new discovery - than to quote verbatim some key-documents from
those secret scriptures of the heretics. Again, Hippolytus takes good care
to place these testimonies () at strategically important points,
usually at the end of his report on a given Gnostic sect. Thanks to Hippolytus' intention to substantiate his accounts with Gnostic quotations
{haereticus verbis expressis), we have today such Gnostic original texts as,
for example, the precious Naassene psalm (Eknchos V. 10.2), the Peratic
List of the (V. 14.1-10), the Gnostic oath from Justin's
book Baruch (V. 24.1; 27.2), the Valentinian psalm (VI. 37.7),
passages from Monoimus' Letter to Theophrastus (VIII. 15.1-2; X. 17.5),
excerpts from an old Elkesaite scripture (IX. 15.1-6; 16.2-4; 17.1). In
addition, logia 4 and 1 l b of the Gospel of Thomas (Nag Hammadi II. 2),
at El. V. 7.20 and V. 8.32, and five quotations from the Apophasis Megaie
(at V. 9.5 = VI 9.4; 14.4; 17.2 & 3; 18.2-7) - among others - were
copied by Hippolytus within the texture of the Naassene Predigt and the
Simonian Paraphrase of the Apophasis Megaie, respectively.
Eknchos Book X. It is because of Hippolytus' design of the Eknchos
as a large-scale heresiological project - or, as he himself put it, a Labyrinth of Heresies (X. 5.1) - that he felt it necessary to add an Epitome
haereseon: Book X, chapters 9-29. This Epitome is meant to be an Ava (X. 6.1) of Books V-IX, and as a matter of fact the Epitome
- as a rule - does presuppose and summarize the teachings of the major
sects from Books V-IX. For this Epitome, Hippolytus had made a selection of the heresies to sum them up (thus reducing the original number
of 38 heretics to 22 only). Occasionally, he would change the original
sequence of the sects (notably, X. 15 Justin; X. 28 Hermogenes, and the
block X. 19-24, from Marcion to the Melchicedecians). Sometimes he
would use, for the Epitome, not exclusively his own Grundtext - the
respective chapters from Books V-IX - but also his source for preparing
those chapters. Such is the case with the Sethians in the Epitome (X. 11),
with Tatian (X. 18), with Marcion and Apelles (X. 19-20), and with Elkesai
(X. 29). This fact has been rightly recognized already by Wendland:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

34

Introduction

"Hipp(olyt). hat wohl hier und im Folgenden zum Teil seine Vorlage wieder eingesehen" (ad X. 11.5-11, the Sethians).
In general, however, Hippolytus does follow his own Grundtext from
Books V-IX, in his Epitome, and Frickel's recent suggestion - Book X
was originally an earlier separate heresiological work of Hippolytus ("eine
frhere Schrift gegen die Gnostiker"), later added to Elenchos Books I-IX
by Hippolytus himself,36 seems to me highly unlikely. First, it is not
difficult to see why Hippolytus was not happy with his rather poor
report on Marcion in VII. 30, thus deciding to write a new report in
X. 19; then X. 19 seems to presuppose the emptiness of VII. 30. Second,
the same mistake repeated twice - the misplacement of the Peratic phrase
at V. 12.2 and . 10.1-2 - is best explained by assuming
that Hippolytus in Book X was copying his own Book V. Finally, the
work referred to by Hippolytus in his Proem (1) cannot be our Epitome,
as Frickel (p. 55) believes it is. The Epitome engages in detailed reports partly by copying verbatim the Grundtext from V-IX - and thus does
not fit Hippolytus' description in Proem (1): a rather brief synopsis which
does not go into details ( ,
, ). In addition,
the Epitome does reveal the Gnostic "secret texts" (such as Monoimus'
Letter to Theophrastus X. 17.5 ~ VIII. 15.1-2), while the work referred
to by Hippolytus in the Proem does not:
.
In conclusion, the origin and presence of Book X in the Eknchos is
best explained by Hippolytus' tendency of being highly repetitive (and occasionally boring). The phrase from VI. 21.2 is typical of his methodology:
Ei '
,
' . . . And he seems to be repetitive because of his intention to produce,
at any price, a huge and "learned" book, a real Labyrinth.
(V. 6.3). The discovery of the new Gnostic
texts by Hippolytus had affected his heresiology in yet another way: it
made him change his mind about the origin of the Gnostic sects. For,
since Justin Martyr (I Apology 26.1-3; 56.1-4; probably in his lost Syntagma as well), the communis opinio considered Simon Magus (cf. Acts
8:9-24) to be the spiritual father of all the Gnostics, the source and root
of the subsequent heretical sects -fans et radix haereticorum, says Irenaeus
36

Op. cit., 52-56. Idem, in T.U. 125 (1981), 217-244 (dealing with an unpublished handout
of mine).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

35

of Simon (Adv. haer. I. 22.2-23.1-4). Hippolytus himself must have shared


this view in his Syntagma, which began the sequence of the Gnostic sects
with Simon Magus. Maybe the traces of this view are still detectable in
Eknchos V I 7.1, ' (sc. )
.
Now, however, after the discovery of the Naassene Predigt - exalting
the serpent, (Hebrew nabasti), - Hippolytus changes his mind and
decides to derive the rest of the Gnostic sects from the Naassenes, the
opening heretical school of his Elencbos (V. 6-11) - V. 6.3-4; 11.1; VI. 6.1.
Hippolytus had - quite correctly - detected Ophitic elements in the teachings
of the Naassenes, Peratae, and Sethians (cf., e.g., at
16.8). Now, since the Naassenes had got their name from the Hebrew
nabash, "serpent," he took them to be the original source of the rest of
the Gnostic sects. The additional fact that the Naassenes had considered
themselves to be Gnostics par excellence could only strengthen this conviction of Hippolytus: Oi (oi) ,
( - - -
, . () ,
,
(V. 6.3-4; cf. 11.1).
2. (or Medice, cura te ipsum). The link between
Gnostic writers and Greek philosophy and mythology was already present
in the Gnostic scriptures. In other words, the new and rich hoard of
such scriptures, discovered by Hippolytus and employed in the Eknchos, was
the most likely source of inspiration for the author to engage in a largescale exposition of the heretics as mere plagiarists ( and : the terms are neologisms created by Hippolytus) from Greek
philosophers, pagan mythology, mysteries, astrology and magic. Inspired
by this source, Hippolytus felt it necessary to expand his Eknchos (Books
V-VIII) by including a large survey of Greek philosophy (Book I), Hellenistic mysteries (the lost Books II and III), astrology, astronomy and
magic (Book IV), called Phihsophumena (Eknchos I-IV).
Thus Books I-IV are presented as the author's own research-work,
prepared for the benefit of the reader: he is now provided with a tool
for a "close comparison" ( , VI. 21.2)
of a plagiarizing Gnostic (e.g., Simon Magus) with his Greek source
(e.g., Plato and Pythagoras). Now, Platonism, Pythagoreanism, GraecoRoman mysteries etc. may well be taken into consideration as possible
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

36

Introduction

source of inspiration for some Gnostic schools of thought. But the point
is that Hippolytus in the Eknchos was not successful in pinpointing such
influences upon a concrete Gnostic sect, to the extent that the entire
enterprise of a Parathesis and the exposition of the Gnostics of the Eknchos
as mere plagiarists of Greek philosophers proves to be a gross failure.
Justin's Baruch (V. 23-27) simply did not borrow Gnostic wisdom from
Herodotus (IV. 8-10), Noetus (IX. 8-10) - and, by implication, Callistus
himself - did not plagiarize Heraclitus, Valentinus did not copy from
Plato's Second Epistle (VI. 37), Marcion has nothing to do with Empedocles (contrary to Hippolytus' own Antiparathesis in VII. 30), etc. The
column ; in the Conspectus capitum (printed above,
IV. A) clearly demonstrates Hippolytus' uncertainty and vacillation in
this respect, and that may be the reason why the whole idea of the
Gnostic plagiarism will be abandoned later on, in the Epitome haereseon
(Book X).
The main objective of the Philosophumena then seems to be to impress
the audience - to show its author as a knowledgeable and learned writer
of encyclopaedic education - in the eyes of his Roman congregation, of
the empress Iulia Mammaea, 37 of the matron Severina,38 and the posterity
in general, serving as a contrast to, for example, the Pope
Zephyrinus or the ex-slave Pope Callistus.
Most of this research-work and education, however, proves to be
a "paper-tiger:" for example, while in his Eknchos the author is plagiarizing from Book V of Sextus Empiricus (in IV. 1-7 and V. 13), in his
Epitome (X. 6-8) he is doing the same - from Book X of the same author.
In brief, Hippolytus as an unscrupulous and reckless plagiarist in the Eknchos has been recognized long ago. In addition to entire chapters copied
verbatim from Sextus Empiricus, he extensively copies from Irenaeus
(VI. 42-54; VII. 28; 32) and from Flavius Josephus (IX. 18-29). Some
modest credit has been given to Irenaeus (at VI. 42.1 and 55.2), but not
to the others. Apparently, Hippolytus believed that Si duo faciunt idem,
non est idem - that he himself was entitled to plagiarizing ()
as a bishop defending the orthodoxy and the Church, while the heretics
were not.
The sad truth is, however, that the Gnostic sects described in the
Eknchos could not be proven as plagiarizing, while its author could. As
a matter of fact, Gnostic scriptures deliberately and openly quote Greek

37

Cf. De resunectione ad Mammtuam ap. H. Achelis, G. C. S. 1.2 (1897), 249-253.

38

C f . title nr. 7 o f t h e inscription o n t h e Vatican statue: .

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

37

poets and philosophers to serve as witnesses to the universal validity and


primordiality of their doctrines. Doubtless we are dealing with an Interpretatio Gnostica, and in this respect there is no difference in the Gnostic
treatment of OT, NT or Greek philosophy and mythology:
..., , .
(follows Rom. 1:20-23 &
26-27) is one of their standard phrases (V. 7.16). According to the
Gnostic exegetes, Greek poets and philosophers were "spontaneous Gnostics," without being aware of that: If "correctly interpreted" (i. e., Gnostically reinterpreted), they all attest to the primordial truth of the Gnostic
doctrine.
That is why the Naassene Predigt quotes Homer (Odyssey XXIV. 1-12),
Hymn to Attis, or the poem nr. 985 of Poetae Melici Graeci (at V. 7.30-37;
V. 9.8-9; V. 7.3-6): they all "speak" of the Gnostic Archanthropos Adamas. That is why Heraclitus is quoted by the Naassenes (V. 8.42 & 44),
by the Peratae (by name, V.16.4), and by the Sethians (V.21.2; 19.4;
X. 11.2-3); or Empedocles - by an anonymous Gnostic writer (VII. 29.812 ~ VI. 25.1-4); or else Aristotle - by Basilides (cf. VII. 15.2 & 17; 19.7),
etc. And, mutatis mutandis, that is why, for example, Simon Magus as
(VI. 18.3) and Helen as his Epinoia could be worshiped,
during their among the Greeks, by the Simonians - as Zeus
and Athena (VI. 20.1 = Iren. 1.23.4). For a similar reason the Carpocratians could worship the image of the Gnostic Jesus along with those
of the Greek philosophers Pythagoras, Plato and Aristotle (Iren. 1.25.6,
omitted by Hippolytus at VII. 32.8 sub fine).
The most striking discovery, however, when dealing with the Quellenforschung of Hippolytus' Eknchos, is the fact that its author - in his
eagerness to discover "proof' of the Gnostics being mere plagiarists of
Greek philosophers - often finds such a "proof" not very far: in the same
Gnostic scriptures he is refuting. Gnostic exegeses quote Greek poets and
philosophers in order to reinterpret them and present them as their witnesses.
In his turn, Hippolytus copies the passages of the Gnostic exegeses dealing
with Greek philosophers, presents them as his own discovery, and uses them
as "proof' of the Gnostics plagiarizing Greek philosophy. A plagiarist accuses
a quoting writer ofplagiarizing.
Here are a few examples. For his report on Aratus (Philosophumena IV. 4650), Hippolytus uses a Gnostic (OphiticTj exegesis of Aratus (IV. 47.1-2
~ V. 8.34; V. 16.15). In order to prove the Sethians as stealing from the
Orphics (V. 20.4-8), Hippolytus uses a Sethian reinterpretation of the
mysteries at Phlya and the Orphic Phanes. That Hippolytus is copying
the whole passage from a Sethian exegesis, becomes clear from V.20.7,
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

38

Introduction

()
, ,
() , ()
, , . 39 Furthermore, for one of his several reports on Pythagoras (VI. 24-25), Hippolytus copies a Gnosticizing Pythagorean interpretation of Empedocles
(cf. VI. 24.4 & 25.1-4 ~ VII. 29.8-12; 29.15; 29.20-24). 40 And for his
account of Aristotle (VII. 15-19), he uses a Basilidean reinterpretation of
Aristotle (for , compare VII. 15.2 ~ VII.22.16; 23.3; 24.5; 25.6;
27.5; X. 14.5-6; for , compare VII. 17.1 & 19.7 ~ VII. 21.4;
. 14.1). Finally, Hippolytus brings excerpts from a Greek medical pneumatic treatise (IV. 51.10-14), but as found in a Peratic exegesis - compare
IV.51.11-13 ~ V. 17.11-12.
3. (IX. 6). So far we have seen: First, that the discovery of a new package of Gnostic scriptures had enabled Hippolytus
to produce a first large-scale heresiology (Eknchos, Books V-VIII, with
the corresponding Epitome haereseon, X.9-26). And second, that quotations from and references to Greek poets and philosophers found by
Hippolytus in those Gnostic scriptures (such as Homer, the Orphics,
Pythagoras, Heraclitus, Empedocles, Aristotle, etc.) were the most likely
source of inspiration for him to expand the scheme and produce his
own version of - by pairing each heretic with an earlier
Greek writer, in order to expose him as a plagiarist from that writer:
Justin-Herodotus, Basilides-Aristotle, Marcion-Empedocles, Simon-Heraclitus (VI. 9.3), Valentinus-Plato plus Pythagoras, Hermogenes-Socrates,
the Encratites-Cynics, etc. And to make this more convincing,
he felt it necessary to prefix Books I-IV (The Philosophumena) to his
Eknchos (with a brief Epitome pbilosophorum in X. 6-8).
But there is more to that. If the discovery of the Gnostic package
had led Hippolytus to producing the , this endeavour inspired
him to achieve yet a third goal - to expose his archenemy, the Pope
Callistus, as a heretic, as "one of them." In Hippolytus' opinion, Callistus
is only one of the successors () of Noetus, and Noetus had plagiarized the pagan philosopher Heraclitus. That is why Hippolytus felt

39
40

Cf. M. MarcovichJ. T.S. N . S . 25 (1974), 447-451.


Walter Burkert (supra, note 32), pp.141 and 145 n.25, was close to seeing the truth.
He took the word at VII. 29.9 and 24 to be a Zusatz des Hippolytos; as a matter
of fact. it belongs to the Gnostic commentator. - Cf. M. Marcovich, Studies in GraecoRoman Religions and Gnosticism (Berlin: de Gruyter, forthcoming), chapter 11.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Elenchos

39

that an additional book (IX) was needed, and that is why Book IX
makes the climax of the entire Elenchos. It is Hippolytus'
because two popes were involved in this heresy, and he felt that the very
existence of the Church was at stake: ,
' , '
(i.e., Zephyrinus and Callistus) ,
[] (IX. 6).
Now, the attack on Callistus - and on his followers and successors:
... (IX. 12.26) - is being led
on three fronts. First, Callistus is introduced as a Heraclitean, not a Christian (via Noetus: IX. 7.1-3; 10.9; 11.1). Second, allegedly Callistus' heretical theory and practice had encouraged Alcibiades (a late Elkesaite) to
create his own heresy: (sc. Alcibiades)
,
(IX. 13.4). According to Hippolytus, Alcibiades
had taken over from Callistus a too easy remission of sins and the
second baptism. Both Callistus and Alcibiades are rogues of the same
kind: (sc. Alcibiades) , ' ... (IX. 13.1).
Thus, Callistus appears in the Elenchos "sandwiched" between a
Christian heretic plagiarizing the pagan philosopher Heraclitus (Noetus of
Smyrna, IX. 7 and IX. 10.9-12), and a "Gnostic" from Apameia bringing
to Rome (IX. 4 and IX. 13-17). Now, Hippolytus is going out of his way to link Noetus-Callistus to Heraclitus:
he copies no less than nineteen different Heraclitean sayings (Frr. 1 and
50-67 Diels-Kranz; Frr. 51, 54 and 55 are quoted even twice) from
a chapter (, IX. 10.8) of a Hellenistic anthology with Stoic
comments ( , and , IX. 10.7). To
them Hippolytus had added his own comments - in a futile effort to
make out of Heraclitus a "Christian" who is saying the same things as
Noetus and Callistus. That is why Hippolytus ascribes to Heraclitus
such terms as (IX. 9.1), and (9.4), the
resurrection of the flesh ( , 10.6), and the
Last Judgement ( () , 10.7). According
to Hippolytus, the agreement between the teachings of Heraclitus and
Noetus is complete:
(sc. Heraclitus), , ()
'
(IX. 10.8).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

40

Introduction

The third attack on Callistus was a direct, frontal one: chapters 11


and 12 of Book IX, misrepresented as a Vita Cattisti (cf. IX. 11.4), is
a regrettable vitriolic "character assassination," written with a pen dipped
in gall, not in ink. If these chapters were written after Callistus' death
(in A.D. 222) - as, I think, the words of IX. 12.26, ... suggest, - Hippolytus' moral blemish for
writing them is even greater than that of plagiarism and false claims.
Important for the Church history as these chapters may be, they are,
at the same time, an Icherzhlung, a self-defense and self-justification of
Hippolytus. The first-person pronoun ( or ) occurs here no less
than ten times (IX.7.3; 11.2; 11.3 ter; 11.4; 12.15; 12.16; 12.21; 13.5).
But there is more to that. The "I" of the chapters addressed against
Callistus should be understood in the context of the "I" and the firstperson verbs throughout the Proem. They find their climax in the telltale
statement of Proem, 6-7:

, . , ,
, ,...

. (7) ()
' ,
, ... .
In my view, this is the most revealing passage in the entire Eknchos:
it gives us the clue for understanding Hippolytus' role and objectives in
his magnum opus. Hippolytus' is actually his only real
- to refute the contemporary Trinitarian modalists Cleomenes, Sabellius and, above all, Callistus. It is to Callistus (and Zephyrinus) that the
phrase at IX. 6 alludes in the first place:
, ' ,
'
...
In so doing - Hippolytus is trying to tell us in his Proem, - he is only
fulfilling his apostolic, pastoral duty as a bishop (), as such a successor of the apostles ( ), partaker in
the divine grace along with the apostles ( ),
defender of the true dogma ( ) - in accordance with the
Christian scriptural tradition (
and and also ), - and above all as the

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

41

Guardian of the Church ( ).


This purely Christian foundation and tradition would have done. But
Hippolytus combines it with pagan Greek platitudes, inherited from the
Cynic diatribe. So he likens himself, in his heresiological task, to a winning athlete, a successful sailor, a prospering farmer, a maltreated prophet
seeing his prophecies being fulfilled {Proem 10). He envisages himself
as a Christian Heracles, clearing the stables of Augeas (V. 27.6) or cutting
the many heads of the Gnostic Hydra of Lerna (V. 11.1: the image is
borrowed from Irenaeus 1.30.14). Or as a Christian Odysseus safely
sailing through a sea infested with heretical monsters (VII. 13.1-3); or
else as a new Theseus untwining the labyrinth of the heretics (X.5.1), etc.
In brief, the Eknchos seems to reveal - among many other facets also a lonely schismatic bishop crying out for recognition (compare the terms
) and as applied
to the main Church of Callistus, IX. 12.23 and 12.25). With this in
mind, we can understand why Hippolytus six times refers to his own
earlier writings (Proem 1; X.5.2; X. 30.1; 30.5; 30.7; 32.4) appending the
remark, ( )
,
, (. 30.5). Or why he shows
such a concern for posterity (Proem 5,
...):
He is the true Christian pastor, spiritual guide, educator and illuminator,
and not the illiterate, sordidly greedy of gain and morally corrupt Zephyrinus (IX. 7.1 ; 11.1
...
) or the villain and rogue Callistus (IX. 11.1
; 12.15
; 12.19-20 ... ).

C. Hippolytus' True Doctrine (. 32-34)


He calls it (or , , ), . 4;
5.1-2; 31.6; or simply or (Proem 6; . 34.1). Hippolytus' theology is elaborate and peculiar enough: it deserves greater attention than a brief Introduction to an edition may allow. Therefore, I shall
limit myself to making a few points only.
1. The Holy Ghost. It is usually assumed that Hippolytus wasforced to give a
brief statement about the True Creed or Dogma at the end of his Eknchos by
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

42

Introduction

the simple fact that Callistus had accused him of ditheism. Thus,
of IX. 11.3 and 12.16 is best answered by Hippolytus' own opening statement, (. 32.1). That is true, but it does not tell the whole story.
Scholars have been puzzled by the total absence of the Holy Ghost
in Hippolytus' True Doctrine (X. 32-34) - in sheer contrast to Callistus'
dogma (IX. 12.16-18; X.27.3-4). It is Logos who speaks to the prophets,
not Holy Ghost (X. 33.13-14). Marcel Richard, for example, wrote: "Le
Saint-Esprit est un des points les plus mysterieux de la doctrine d'Hippolyte. II est partout dans son oeuvre, aussi bien dans ses traites apologetiques que dans ses commentaires. Et, cependant, le seul expose systematique de sa theologie qui ait survecu, Refut. X, 32-34, l'ignre absolument" 41
Now, while it is true that a genuine Trinitarian dogma is absent in
Hippolytus' True Doctrine, I think it is equally true that the Holy Ghost
is not totally absent in it: Holy Ghost is to be understood by the word
of X.34.2 (and of 34.1). For Hippolytus Holy
Ghost is Conveyer of God's Truth to man, Spirit of Truth, and Truth
itself as expressed in the Holy Scriptures.
This assumption may be confirmed by Proem 6-7, where the expression and
(sc. ) is a synonym for the
phrase , i.e., Holy Ghost or Truth as expressed in the Holy
Scriptures.42
Accordingly, it is not Hippolytus but the Holy Ghost as Truth who
will refute the heretics in the Elenchos (
), states the author in his Proem 6.
And at the end of the Eknchos (X. 5), he says that the Canon of Truth
( ) is able to refute a heresy by simply appearing (
).
2. Logos. He is the most prominent agent in Hippolytus' theology.
Logos exists in Father as his immanent reasoning (X. 33.1
). When Logos was born by Father as His first-born
Son (33.2 ; 33.11 , ; cf. Col 1:15; Justin I Apol. 33.6; Tatian Oral. 5;
Theophil. Ad Autol. II. 22), He becomes the Agent of the Father's Creation
(33.2 ; 33.4 ; 33.6
41
42

In Dictionnaire de Spiritual,ite, 44-45 (Paris, 1968), 549.


Cf. G . W . H . Lampe, A Patristic Greek Lexicon (Oxford, 1961), s.v. , , 4, and
, 4.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

43

; 33.11 () ) - in
two ways: (1), He bears in himself the Father's will (33.2 ()
() and
); and (2), He bears in himself the Father's ideas as Voice
(33.2 () ()
). Thus, in addition to being the Father's immanent reasoning (33.1
; 33.2 ( )
), Logos becomes also uttered word or voice (i.e.,
).
Two remarks are in order here: (1), Hippolytus uses the word
as a synonym for (33.11 ...,
; 34.2 (); cf. Hippolyt. contra Noetum 10
; Psalm 109:3; 2 Petri 1:19;
. c.Noet. 16 s.f.). As such, Logos speaks to the prophets (33.13). And
(2), Hippolytus' Logoskhre follows a well-established and longstanding
tradition, shared by the Apologists, the Fourth Gospel, Philo: it goes
back to the basically Stoic distinction between and
, with possible antecedents in Plato {Sophist 263 e) and
Aristotle (e.g., Anal. Post. A 10, p.76 b 25).43
Finally, Hippolytus' Christology or incarnation of Logos (33.14-17
and 34.5) is based on the {recapitulatio; cf. Ephes. 1:10;
2 Cor. 5:17; Gal. 6:15; Ephes. 2:15; 4:24; Hippol. c. Noet. 17): Christ
recreates, reshapes and renews "the old man" Adam (33.15
; 34.5
; cf. Rom. 6 : 6 ; Ephes. 4:22; Col 3 : 9 ; Hippol. De

43

Cf. Sext. Emp. Pynbon. hypotyp. 1.65; 72; 76. Adv. math. VIII. 275; 287; Galen Protrept.
1.1; In Hippocr. de med. officina XVIII , p. 649 Khn; De plac. . et Plat. II. 5
(V, p. 241 .); Plut. Maxime cum principibus 111 C; Heraclitus AUeg. Homer. 72.15-16;
Porphyr. De abstin. III. 2; Jamblich. Vita Pyth. 218; Hesych., s.v. ; S.V. F.
I, Nr. 148; II, Nrr. 135; 223; 840. - Philo De Cherubim 127; De Abrahame 83; Leg.
alleg. III.96; De spec. legg. 1.81; IV.69; De vita Mosis 11.127 & 129. - Ignat. Ep. ad
Magnes. 8.2; Tatian Orat. 5.1; Justin Dial. 61.1; Athenag. Legat. 10.2; Theophil. Ad
Autol. ILIO & 11.22; Iren. Adv. haer. II. 12.5; Tert. Adv. Prax. 5; Apol. 17.1; 21.11;
Clem. Strom. V.6.3; VII.53.6; 55.4; Hippol. Contra Noetum 11; Origen Contra Celsum
VI. 65; Basil. Caes. Horn. 16.3 (P.G. 31, 477 A); Nemes. De nat. hom. 14 et alibi. Cf. M. Mhl, in Archiv fr Begriffigeschichte (Bonn, Bouvier), VII (1962), 7-56; Max
Pohlenz, Die Stoa2 I (Gttingen, 1959), pp.39; 185; 373 ff.; 412; 435; 451; II (Gttingen, 1955), Erluterungen; Max Heinze, Die Lehre vom Logos in dergriech. Philosophie
(Oldenburg, 1872); A. Aall, Geschichte der Logosidee in da griech. Philosophie, 2 vols.
(Leipzig, 1896; 1899).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

44

Introduction

Antichristo 26); He goes through all stages of the human life (33.15;
cf. Iren. Adv. baer. II. 22.4), endures passions and death, and finally resurrects (33.17) - in order to serve as ("first-fruit'') for the salvation
of man (33.17 ; cf. 1 Cor. 15 :20-23).
3. Platonic Influence. According to Hippolytus, prior to the Creation
through the agency of Logos, God first creates the ideas or forms of
things (33.2 () ); and prior to all
other things, God first creates the four basic elements or substances
(32.2 ; 33.4 ) - fire and spirit, water and earth.
Accordingly, things are made either of one single element (),
or of a combination of them. But every compound is perishable:
- () -
-, .
,
(32.3).
All these elements are Platonic in origin. For example, Hippolytus' last
sentence goes back to Plato Timaeus 41 a 7 to
. Furthermore, according to Hippolytus, man was created out of
all four elements (33.7 ). This too
is a Platonic idea: Timaeus 42 e - 43 a; Albinus Epitome 17 (ed. Hermann,
Plato vol. VI, p. 172)
.
Finally, Hippolytus closes the Elenchos (X. 34.4) with a reinterpretation
of the old Delphic and Socratic injunction (e. g., ap. Plato
Protag. 343 b 3; cf. Elenchos 1.18). While the meaning of the
was, "Man, recognize thy status of being only a mortal, not
a god" - hence, e.g., in Plato Charmides 164 d-e, or Akibiades I, 131 b,
, is interpreted as , practising moderation
or - , Hippolytus offers a directly opposite interpretation:
"Man, recognize that thou art godlike" - () '
, ( ) .
Now, doubtless Hippolytus is building upon Genesis 1:26: Man is
made in God's image and likeness (he refers to Gen. 1:26 in X. 34.5).
But the point is that the same interpretation of occurs
already in Plato Alcibiades I, 133 c 4: '
(sc. ), , [
,] . In this respect,
Hippolytus may well be found to be in agreement with the Gnostic
Monoimus (cf. his Epistk to Theophrastus, El. VIII. 15.1-2; X. 17.5).
Thus, Hippolytus had opened his Elenchos with a rejection of Greek

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

45

philosophy (Proem 1, '


), only to end up with a Christian theology showing clear
Platonic borrowings - which may well be compared to those to be found
in Athenagoras. Hippolytus must have had some knowledge of Plato,
since he criticizes Plato in his De Universo (referred to at X. 32.4), as the
title itself of the treatise attests: " ,
.

D. The Value of Hippolytus' Eknchos


1. Since the package of eight new Gnostic treatises - the Naassenes,
Peratae, Sethians, Justin's Bamch, the Apophasis Megak, Basilides, Docetae,
and Monoimus - makes the bulk of the Eknchos, the value of this package will in great degree determine the value of the entire work. Now,
with the exception of Basilides and probably Justin, the rest of these Gnostic
systems have in common the fact that they all operate with threeprincipks44
Moreover, in the doctrines of the Naassenes, Peratae, and Sethians the Snake
(Hebrew nhsh) plays a positive role (V. 9.11-14; V. 16.7-16; 17.2 & 8;
V. 19.18-20; cf. also V. 6.3; V. 11; VI. 6; not so in Justin: V. 26.22-26 & 31).
But in addition to these common characteristics, scholars - since
A. Hilgenfeld 45 - had pointed out striking similarities between some of
these systems - similarities in imagery and comparisons, in the use of
the Scriptures, and in phraseology. Here are a few examples 46

44

45

46

Cf. Werner Foerster, Gnosis I, cc. 14-19 (Zrich, 1969; English translation edited by
R. McL. Wilson, Oxford, 1972). Klaus Koschorke, Hippolyt's Ketzerbekmpfung und
Polemik gegen die Gnostiker (Gttinger Orientforschungen, VI. Reihe: Hellenistica, 4;
Wiesbaden, 1975), 10 f.; 95.
A. Hilgenfeld, 'Der Gnostizismus und die Philosophumena,' Zeitschr. f . miss. Theol.
5 (1862), 400-464, esp. 443-446; Idem, Die Ketzergeschichte des Urchristentums (Leipzig,
1884), 252-277. J. Frickel (supra, note 31), 11-25, offers an excellent summary of
scholarship - from W. Mller (in 1860) to W. Bousset (in 1907).
A full list of these similarities is to be found in G. Salmon, 'The Cross References in
the Philosophumena,' Hermathena 11 (1885), 389-402, and especially in Hans Staehelin,
Die gnostischen Quellen Hippolyts in seiner Hauptschrift gegen die Hretiker (. U. VI. 3,
Leipzig, 1890), 1-108. Koschorke (supra, note 44), 95-101, offers a summary from the
standpoint of the Sethians.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

46

Introduction

Hippolytus

1 Similes for
spontaneous
attraction taken
from Physics:
by

by

by

by

The Medical Simile:

Naassenes

5.17.9

5.21.8

5.9.19

5.17.10

5.21.8

5.9.19

5.17.10

5.21.8

4.51.10
-13

5.9.15

'

Biblical Parables

The Parable of
the Mustard Seed
(Mt. 13:31-32):
The biggest tree
out of the smallest
seed 47

47

C f . Eknchos

Apophasis

6.12.4;
6.16.5
two examples

Basilides

Docetae

7.21.3;
10.14.1

5.9.6
=

. 5.9.5

V I . 4 0 . 2 ( M a r c u s ) ; Ev.

Basilides

7.25.6

5.19.2
four
examples

Naassenes

Apophasis

5.17.9
5.17.11
-12
~

The Importance of
Teaching ()

Sethians

5.9.19

Peratae

Thomae

log. 2 0 ; Apocryph.

Jacobi

(Nag

Hammadi

cod. 1.2, p. 8.7); Clem. Exc. ex Theodoto 1.3.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

47

The Contents of Hippolytus' Eknchos

Biblical Parables

Naassenes

Apophasis

Basilides

Docetae


The Fig Tree
(Mt. 24:32)

8.8.3;
10.16.1


8.8.4-5 =

, ,

The Big Tree of


Nebuchadnezzar
(Daniel 4 : 7 - 9 )
opposed to
, ,
,
(Mt. 3 :10 & 12)

Scriptural
contamination

5 John 4 : 1 0
+ 4:14

6 Col. 1:19
+ 2:9
7 A phrase
for "all":

Naassenes

6.9.8-10

Peratae

5.9.18

Sethians

Justin

5.19.21

5.27.2

Apophasis

Basilides

Monoimus

8.13.2

5.12.5;
10.10.4

5.19.1

6.9.7

7.22.1

8.12.5

These similarities between the eight Gnostic systems had induced


some scholars to doubt the authenticity of the new material brought by
Hippolytus, while suggesting that the whole Gnostic package may well
be the work of a forger. Such was the case with G. Salmon and especially
with H. Staehelin. But this explanation was doomed from the beginning.
For one thing, a forger would not have limited himself to producing
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

48

Introduction

common images, similes and phrases, while leaving the essence of each
system so different in kind. And, as a matter of fact, the discovery of
the Nag Hammadi Coptic Gnostic Library - back in 1945 - has vindicated Hippolytus. First, the fifty-two Gnostic tractates of the Library
have demonstrated the full richness and variety of the Gnostic themes;
and second, the very existence of a Parapbrasis Seem (NH cod. VII. 1),
referred to by Hippolytus at V.22.1, proves that Hippolytus' account of
the Sethians cannot be explained as a forgery, although the concurrences
between Hippolytus and N H VII. 1 can be reduced to three principles Light, Darkness, and Spirit between them (NH VII. 1, p. 1.25 ff.) - and
although Ps. Tertullian {Adv. omn. haer. 2) and Epiphanius {Panarion
XXXIX. 1.1-5.3) offer different accounts. 48
E. de Faye had posited a common source for all eight Hippolytean
systems - such a one as the Ophitism. 49 This is not a likely solution
either, for the simple reason that our Gnostic systems are so different
one from another that they simply resist to be reduced to one single
known system.
The prevailing theory today seems to be that at least some of the
eight Gnostic tractates had undergone editing - prior to being used by
Hippolytus - by a single redactor. The question is now: what kind of
a redactor? Some scholars think of a Christian church-collector, who
wanted to use the treatises for polemical purposes: so, e.g., E. Peterson 50
and K. Beyschlag.51 I personally find it highly unlikely that a church
redactor would be so intimately versed and involved in Gnostic theories.
Recently K. Koschorke 52 had suggested that the redactor in question
may well have been a Gnostic group, for purposes of propaganda. But we
know of no "gnostische Gruppe" as an entity - as a rule, each Gnostic
sect preferred to go its own way. And then again, one would think that
a redactor would have intervened more drastically in the eight extant
treatises, in a Gnostic unifying effort.

48

49

50

51
52

Cf. Birger A. Pearson, 'The Figure of Seth in Gnostic Literature,' in The Rediscovery of
Gnosticism, vol. II: Sethian Gnosticism, edited by Bentley Layton (Leiden, E.J. Brill,
1981), 472-514, esp. p. 496; A.F.J. Klijn, Seth in Jewish, Christian and Gnostic Literature
(Leiden, Brill, 1977), pp.88 f.; Fr. Wisse, 'The Redeemer Figure in the Paraphrase of
Shem,' Novum Test. 12 (1970), 138.
E. de Faye, Introduction l'etude du gnosticisme au IIe et au IIIe siecle (Paris, 1903), 68 ff.;
Idem, Gnostiques et Gnosticisme^ (Paris, 1925), 189 f.
E. Peterson, Frhkirche, Christentum und Gnosis (Rom-Freiburg-Wien, 1959), pp.233;
271 n. 3.
Theol. Literaturzeitung 95 (1970), 670.
Op. cit. (supra, note 44), p. 100 f.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Elenchos

49

That is why I prefer to share an old view, expressed in 1897 by


W. Anz: 53 the similarities are due to mutual honowings between different
Gnostic sects. If a Naassene writer found it suitable to quote, in his
Exegesis, the Apophasis Megale (V. 9.5 ~ VI. 9.4), or the Gospel of Thomas
(logia 4 & l l b : V. 7.20 & 8.32), for example, he may have found it equally
suitable to use, say, a Peratic simile or image (see examples 1 and 2, from
the Table printed above).
Thus, a constant free exchange of ideas, images, similes, scriptural
parables and sayings, and phraseology between independent Gnostic
sects seems to be the most likely cause of similarities present in some
Gnostic treatises. I think this explanation is strongly supported by the
fact that one and the same common Gnostic motif is sometimes being
further developed by another sect. Take, for example, case 4 from the
Table above. The original idea (4a): present in the Parable of the mustard seed (Mt. 13 :3132; Mk.4:30-32;
Lk. 13:18-19) - is still visible in the way the parable is used by the
Naassenes, by Basilides, and by the Docetae. But, at the same time, the
Docetae (4b) had chosen to replace the mustard seed with the fig seed
(taken from Mt.24:32; Mk. 13:28; Lk.21:29-30), and, in addition to
the image of the seed, to use the image of the fig trunk, foliage, and fruits,
enabling them to introduce their three archons (VIII. 8.4-5). And that
brings them - possibly through some "missing link" or a lost Gnostic
treatise - closer to the image present in the Apophasis Megale (4C). Here
we find the image of tree trunk, branches, foliage etc. - valued as worthless in comparison with the treefruit (inspired by Mt. 3 :10 & 12; Lk. 3:17).
We can clearly see the variatio Gnostica at play here: one Gnostic sect
takes over a scriptural parable from another Gnostic sect, and reshapes
it or combines it with other scriptural parables as it best suits its own
purposes. Or take the "Medical Simile" (case 2): the Peratae used to liken
the human brain to the Father. But the Naassenes preferred to liken it
to Edem - only to satisfy a paretymological drive: '
,
(V. 9.15).
2. In conclusion, we may rest assured that the new material brought
by Hippolytus is reasonably reliable and genuinely Gnostic. And any
thought of Hippolytus' own doctoring is ruled out by his very methodology. He had a choice of three ways in which to use his sources: (1), to

53

W. Anz, Zur Frage nach dem Ursprung des Gnostizismus (T.U. XV. 4, Leipzig, 1897), 9.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

50

Introduction

copy them litteratim; (2), to make excerpts from them by omitting one
less important passage between two verbatim-copied blocks; and (3), to
summarize or paraphrase his source in his own words. Now, Hippolytus
by far prefers the first two methods. The second one seems to be his
most favored one - a combined sequence (ab ab ab) of the literally
copied (a) and altogether omitted (b) passages. This method seems to be
indicated by his standard phrase:
(V.7.1), or ' (V.6.5).54
That simply means that Hippolytus' passion for plagiarizing his sources is
a blessing for us, since we can be reasonably sure that he is, as a rule,
faithfully copying his source. Sometimes he would copy his source so
hastily or mechanically that he would not notice even a major error in
it; as, e.g., the misplaced phrase in his Peratic source,
an error which he repeats twice (V. 12.2 & X. 10.1-2). Or he would misunderstand his source and then write down a nonsense; e.g., at IV.3.6,
Sextus' simple clause (sc.
) , is reproduced by Hippolytus as,
, (Adv. math. V. 55).
We may also assume that Hippolytus is not strictly following the
sequence of the Gnostic themes in his source, but would rather cut the texture of his source into smaller pieces and place them in his Elenchos - in accordance with his general plan of exposing the
Gnostics as plagiarists, or as it best suited his heresiological purposes.
Nevertheless, the original usual sequence of events in a Gnostic system
is in general well preserved by Hippolytus. For example, the basic threestage Gnostic process is easily recognizible in the Elenchos: (1), the primal
cause(s) and the original state in the All; (2), the ensuing creation or fall,
deficiency, error, defection, deception or ignorance; (3), the ultimate
deliverance (redemption, salvation, rest) of the Gnostics (pneumatics),
usually through the agency of a redeemer or saviour, and the restoration
(apocatastasis) of the All. As already mentioned, Hippolytus would usually
place at the end of his account a verbatim copied sacred document of
the respective Gnostic sect, to serve as kind of testimony for the author's
faithfulness of the report.

54

Hippolytus' preference for either verbatim copying or excerpting his sources has been
long recognized by scholars. Recently, we have been eloquently reminded of this fact
by J. Frickel (supra, note 31), 82-83. I think, however, that Frickel goes too far when
assuming that Hippolytus was unable of producing a free paraphrase; a simple comparison of, e.g., Elenchos V.25.1-4 with Herodotus IV.8-10 proves that sometimes he
would do just that (which is only natural).

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

The Contents of Hippolytus' Elenchos

51

In brief, although highly repetitive and lacking a cogent organization,


Hippolytus' Elenchos remains a reasonably reliable, first-class heresiological
source for our study of Gnosticism. As one would expect, the bulk of
Hippolytus' sources belong to the authors and texts closest to his own
time - to I and II centuries A. D. Thus, Hippolytus prefers to copy from
Irenaeus, Sextus Empiricus and Flavius Josephus; he uses an Elkesaite
scripture from the age of Trajan (IX. 13.4 - A.D. 101; IX. 16.4 - A.D.
117?); or Antonius Diogenes (Vita Pythagorae, 1.2), or else Albinus' Epitome (1.19 Plato); and, above all, his own earlier Syntagma.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:33 PM

TEXT
(TOY >



5 .
, , , ,
, , , , ,
, , , , .
, .

. , .
.
,
is
, , .

1
2

4
5
6

LOBT
1 inscript. add. Mi
A addidi (cf. v. 2):
A' add. Mi: add. We
:
L, et in mg (cf. IV in fine
, ante IX. 6.1 et IX. 8.2 () ): :
L O B ante 1.1.1
3 superscr. L
om. O B
4 ... L
9/10 :
L
12 (- b)
14 Roeper, Gronov: : L :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

54

Prooemium

Hippolytus

'
() ,
.
, ,
- []
-, , ' ,
() , .
2 '
' ,
,
.
, , ,
3 . , , ,

.

4 . ,
,
(*) ,
.
^

is

20

25

1 - 6 8 ed. Bunsen, pp. 3 4 9 - 3 5 2


LOBT
1 praemittit
ante q u a e d a m excidisse susp. G o
L O T (cf. I. 10 ' ): o m . : . ( )
coniec. G o : Diels
2 addidi (cf. Aristot. Rhet. A 2.11, p. 1356
b 27)
3 G. Richter (Observat. crit., p. 76): codd.
L :

5 '
6
delevi (i.e. ): coniec.
Roeper: G o
8 addidi (cf. w . 7, 10, 11, 13)

9 del. Morus, Diels

10 G o : codd.
11 :
15 Wolf, Diels: codd., G r o n o v , W e
16 1 o m .
19
20
Sancroft, Roeper, Diels: codd., We
21 codd.: coniec. Gron o v : coniec. W o l f 2 , Roeper
L: :
22/23
24 post lac. signavit We, qui e.g.
add. suad.: m a l i m
25 : (sine lac.) Sancroft:
Roeper

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

55

Refutatio I, Prooemium 17

' -

, , . , ,
30

,
.

35

. ,
,
, ,
'
40

'

, ,

. ( ) ' -

, 34-40 cf. Trad, apostol. Fragm. Gr. = Epitomen Constit. apostol. 8. 5 2 - 7 Funk = Trad,
apost. vers. Lat. 6826 ss. ed. E. Tidner (T.U. 75, 1963) ... (cf. Act 20 :32), . . . ...
(cf. Ps 50:14),
,
... ( ) . . . ,
( ) ,
... et I. . Stam, Episcopacy in the Apostolic Tradition of
Hippolytus (Diss, theol. Basil. 1969), pp. 33; 61 s.; 92; praesertim 110-113
37 : cf. Martyr. Poly carpi 16 2. , '
et Lampe, s.v. , , 3, h
38 : cf. lust. Dial. 3.3; 2 Apol.
9.4; Clem. Paed. 1. 101.1; Eel. proph. 62; Orig. Horn. 9.4 in Jerem. (G.C.S., 3, p.6829);
Hegemon. Acta Archelai 6 (p.6.4 Beeson); Plat. Phaed. 73 a 8; 94 a 1; Polit. 310 c 4; Tim.
56 b 4; Leg. 2, 659 d 2; 3, 696 c 10; 5, 743 c 3; 10, 890 d 7, et al.
LOBT
27 , We
27/28 : vel Roeper
28 L
29
30 b
b
35 Huet (Origeniana, 3, p.277), Sancroft (
paraphr. in mg. L)
36 :
37
38 Richter: codd., def. Bunsen

: L O T : Roeper
40 '
41 () Morus, Sancroft
42 Delarue
43 addidi (post add.
suad. We)
43/44 L O B :
44 : Sancroft
: corr. ex L:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

56

10

11

Hippolytus

,
.
, ,
,
, 3 , , '
()
,
'
,
' (*) []
() .

, ' ,


. , '
-
,
-, .

60-62 cf. Ignat. . ad Polyc. 1.3; 2.3; 3.1; 2 Clem. 7.3; Clem. Strom. 1. 67.2; Cosm. Ind.
Topogr. Christ. 9; Theophil. Antioch. Ad Autol. 1. 8.3; Xenoph. Memorab. 3. 3.9 et al.
62 Gn 3: 19

LOBT
45-46 ... Sancroft: ...
codd.: ... ( Morus) Diels:
... Roeper
47 '

48 '3
:
50 - in mg.
: Salvini
51 addidi (cf. v. 57)
: Roeper
52
() Bunsen
55
56 post lac. susp. We, qui
, ' add. suad., ft. recte
56/57 Roeper: codd.
57 L (cf. v. 66):
del. Diels: coniec. Go
58 add. Diels
61 Diels:
codd.

64 Delarue
67 scripsi:
codd.
68 Wolf, Roeper: codd.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio I, Prooemium 7-c 2 1

57

, , .

, , '
5 () ().
,
. ' , .

,
,
, . .
,
, .

.


2
3

De cc. 1-25 cf. . Diels in Doxogr. Gr., pp. 144-156


1-5 excerpsit Georgius Cedrenus
in Historiarum compend. I, p. 275.9-13 Bekker
3 - 4 : Thaleti
opinio Anaximenea tribuitur: cf. Io. Philoponi In Phys. pp. 86.29; 116.20; 123.15 Vitelli;
Simplic. In Phys. pp. 150.1; 180.14; 1319.21 Diels; Aristot. De caelo 5, p. 303 b 13; H.
Diels, Dox. p. 145
4 ' - 5 : cf. Apul. Flor. 18, p. 37.13 Helm: maximas
res parvis lineis repperit... ventorum flatus, stellarum meatus
4 : Aet.
3. 15.1; Sen. Qu. nat. 3.14
5 - 7 : cf. Iliad. 14.201 ( V.
7.38; . 7.1) et Plat. Theaet. 152 e; Aristot. Metaph. A 3, p. 983 b 30
7 - :
Clem. Strom. 5. 96.4; Gnomol. Vatic. 321 Sternbach; Diog. Laert. 1. 36
8 s. Diog.
Laert. 1. 23; Plin. Nat. hist. 2. 53; Cie. De div. 1. 112; Aet. 2. 24.1
9 - 12
: Plat. Theaet. 174 a; Diog. Laert. 1. 34
12 Diog. Laert. 1. 38; Herodot. 1.
75
1-4 Aet. 1. 3.9; Diog. Laert. 1. 13; 8. 1; August. De civ. dei 8.2

LOBT
1 praemittunt L O B

1 , , L
2
4 :
5 (-)
Diels e Cedreno: codd.
Cedrenus, Roeper: codd. I
e Cedreno add. Diels
6 Roeper: codd.
7
codd.: Go (conl. Clem, et Diog. Laert.)
10 om. : coniec.
Gronov: (omisso ) Menage (ad D.L. 1.36)
v codd.: coniec Wolf,
agn. Diels: ' Roeper
12 Roeper ex Platone: codd., We
:

Richter e D.L.: codd.


1 tit.

3 Roeper: codd.

4 () conieci conl. v. 72

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

58

Hippolytus

2 ,

( ) ,

(') ,
3 ().
,

,
4 .
,
5 , ,
, , .
() () .
6 - , , -,
'
, '
5 - 7 Nicomach. Introd. arithm. 1. 3.7; Theolog. arithm. 4, p.21.5 de Falco; G. Roeper, Philol.
7 (1852), p.520
7 - : Theol. arithm. 1, p.3.21; Aet. 1. 7.18; Theon.
Smyrn. p. 100.5 Hiller; Macrob. In Cie. Somn. Scip. 1. 6.8; Athenag. Legat. 6.1
8 - 9 : v. 53; IV. 10.5; Diog. Laert. 8. 33; Sext. Emp. Adv. math. 4. 6;
7. 98; 10. 283; Pyrrh. hypot. 3. 155; Plat. Crat. 405 cd; Aristot. Metaph. A 5, p. 986 a 3;
Athen. 14, p. 632 be; Plut. De musica 1147 A; Theon. Smyrn. p. 139.11; Chalcid. In Plat.
Tim. 72; Censorin. De die nat. 13.5; Strab. X, p. 468 C.; Quintil. Inst. orat. 1. 10.12
9 - 10 <>: cf. Plat. Reip. 7, 530 d; Aristot. De caelo 9, p. 290 b 12 et
Burkert, p. 328 ss.
10-14 w . 75-78 et 84 s.; Iambi. V.P. 72; Hermiae Irris. gentil.
philos. 16 Diels
14-16 cf. Burkert, p. 187 ss.
17 Iambi. V.P. 71; 74; Porphyr.
V.P. 13; 54; Gell. 1. 9.2
18 - 43 = IV. 51.4-8; cf. VI. 23.1-5;
Diog. Laert. 8. 25 et A. Delatte, La vie de Pythagore de Diogene Laerce (Bruxellae 1922), pp.
124; 198 ss.; Aet. 1. 3.8; Sext. Emp. Adv. math. 10. 261; 276; Phot. Bibl. cod. 249, p.438
b Bekker; Iren. Adv. haer. 2. 14.6; Burkert, p. 46 ss., praesertim p. 54
LOBT
6
7 add. Wolf et Roeper (conl. test.)

coniec. Roeper
9 (') Roeper: codd.
10 () Roeper: codd.
11/12 : coniec. Usener:
coniec. Diels
15 ...
:
17 L
18 addidi
codd.: Usener, agn. Diels We
scripsi: codd.: Usener, agn. Diels We
19 ex add. Diels I
Go: codd.
om.
20 om.

om. , del. Roeper cett. (at cf. Simplic. In Phys. p. 181.27 Diels)
codd., ex corr. Go
22 corr. ex L

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.2.2-10

59

, ,
, , ,
, , 7
() .
, , ,
. - 8
- ' -, '
, , , ,
, '
, ,
9
[] '
,

. , , , , , , 10
, - ' ,
, (
,) , , - , ,
, , , , .

30 : .
, ,
, ' paraphr. in mg. L
33 IV. 51.7;
VI. 23.4; 34.1; Iren. I. 1.1; 2. 14.6; cf. A. Delatte, Etudes sur la litterature pythagoricienne
(Paris. 1915), p.249 ss.; Burkert, p. 170 ss.
37-41 de terminis (), ,
(2), ( 3 ), (*4), (x5) et (6) cf.
Diophanti De arithm. I, p.2 ss. Tannery; G. Roeper, o.e., p.532

LOBT
23
26 codd., corr. Wolf
27
29
codd., ex corr. Go
:
32 L O B
33
L (VI. 23.4; 34.1): om. (IV. 51.7)
L :

L , del. Wolf 2 , om.
codd.
36

38
39
coniec. Wolf 1 , ex ()
scripserunt Go: codd.
40

suppl. Gronov et Wolf, habet

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

60

Hippolytus

11


() , (), , '
12 , .
.
' ,
,
, , , , , ,
,
13 ,
.
,
,
- -, (
- ) - .
.
14

,
, ( ) -

44-47 : excerpsit Cedrenus, I, p. 275.4-8 Bekker


45-47 Diog. Laert. 8.
4 - 5 et A. Delatte ad loc.; Porphyr. V.P. 45; Tertull. De anima 28.3; Schol. in Soph. El. 62;
Suda, s.v. ; Schol. in Apoll. Rhod. I. 643; Burkert, p. 114 s.
47 ss. cf. I. Bidez et
Fr. Cumont, Les mages hellenises (Paris. 1938), II, p. 63 ss.; Aristoxeni Fr. 13 Wehrli; Gu.
Spoeni, R.E.A. 57 (1955), p. 267 ss.; Burkert, p. 177 n. 18
48 : cf. w . 5 5 ,
61; VI. 23.2; Porphyr. V.P. 12; Clem. Strom. I. 70.1; C. Clemen, Die gr. u. lat. Nachr. ber
die persische Religion ( R G W 17.1, 1920), pp.20; 36
49 s. - : cf. VI.
23.2; Plut. De animae procr. 1012
50-53 et 56-58 cf. IV. 43.8-10
61-71

LOBT
45 Cedrenus, La Croze et Wolf 2 : L, ,
46 Cedrenus, Wolf 1 : L (ut v.):

48 L: :
51
52 Roeper: codd.
53 scripsi: L O B T : Gronov (def.
Spoerri, . c., p. 271 n. 1): Go cett.: Roeper
57
scripsi: codd.
57-58 - supplevi: ,
suppl. R. Reitzenstein (Die Gttin Psyche etc., p.34 s.; Studien zum ant. Synkretismus, p. 117
n. 1)
58
Roeper
59 :
61 L
L: O B
62
63
supplevi post . S a u p p e ( )

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.2.11-18

61

. , - () -, .


' ,
() ,
.
. ' , , , ,

- ' , . , .
,
. '

15

16

17

18

Porphyr. V.PA4- Lyd. De mens. 4.42; . Marcovich, Philol. 108(1964),p.29ss.;Burkert,p. 165


n. 130
72 s. Iambi. V.P. 249; Diog. Laert. 8. 39; Porphyr. V.P. 55 et al.; Burkert,
p. 183 n. 53
73-78 Iambl. V.P. 30; 72; 168; Diog. Laert. 8. 10; Gell. I. 9.12 et
al.
75 w . 10-14; 84 s.; Iambl. V.P. 72; 74; 90; Gell. I. 9.3-4; Sen. Ep. 52.10;
Plut. De curios. 519 C; Diog. Laert. 8. 10 Delatte et al.
78 s. cf. w . 14-16;
Iambl. V.P. 72
79 s. Iambl. V.P. 249; Porphyr. V.P. 55; Diog. Laert. 8. 39
80-82 cf. I. 25.1; Herodot. 4. 95-96; Iambl. V.P. 173; Porphyr. V.P. 14; Diog. Laert.
8. 2; Suda, s.v. et al.
82 s. Iambl. V.P. 18-19; Porphyr. V.P. 7; 11-12;
Diodor. I. 98.2 et al.
LOBT
64 O B
65
65-66 ... codd., corr.
Diels
66 : L O B
67-68 del.
Sauppe
68
69


70 add. Cr
71 codd.:
Sauppe: Usener
72
73 Cr et Diels:
, L
73/74 : Go Diels
74 L
75

...
76 :
codd., corr. Wolf 1
.

77
77/78
79 L (in mg.):
L
80 : L:
: L

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

62

Hippolytus

,
( ) ( ) -

85

.
3

( )
, ( )
, , ,
,

, .
,

' .

( )
" , ,
.
85 : Iambi. V.P. 27; Porphyr. V.P. 9; 34; Burkert, p. 139 s. n.273
De c. 3 cf. I. P. Hershbell in Phronesis 18 (1973), pp. 101-104, et H. Diels, Doxogr. p. 145 s.
1-3 ft. cf. Empedoclis Frr. 112.4; 115.5; 122 DK et D. O'Brien, Empedocles'Cosmic Cycle (Cantabrigiae 1969), p. 330 ss.; G. Zuntz, Persephone (Oxonii 1971), passim
3-6 et 10
excerpsit Cedrenus, I, pp. 275.20-276.3
4 : cf. I. 2.2 (q.v.)
: Stoam redolet: cf. 1.4.2; IX. 10.7; S.V.F. II, nr. 1031; I, nr. 120 et G. S. Kirk, Heraclitus etc. (Cantabrigiae 1954), p. 352 s.
4 s. Heracliti doctrina Empedocli vindicatur:
cf. I. 4.2; Clem. Strom. 5. 103.6; G.S. Kirk, o.e., p.25
8 s. Empedoclis Fr. 117 DK
(= Fr.34 Zuntz); Diog. Laert. 8. 77; Athen. 8, p. 365 E; Clem. Strom. 6. 24.3; Cedren. I,
p. 276.4-5
10 s. : cf. Diog. Laert. 8. 54-56; Simplic.
In Phys. p.25.19 Diels; Iambi. V.P. 104; 135; 267; Empedocl. Fr. 129 DK; Burkert, p.204
n. 9
11 : cf. I. 2.11 et Burkert, p. 116 n. 120
12 : cf.
Diodor. 10. 6.2; Iambi. V.P. 63; Porphyr. V.P. 27; Schol. in Iliad. 17.28; Ovid. Metam.
15.163 s.; Hor. Carm. 1. 28.9 ss.; Tert. De anima 28.4; Burkert, p. 116 n. 121
LOBT
85 L (- corr. ex -): : Gronov cett.

Roeper: codd.
addidi
85/86 Go
1 tit. L O B
addidi (cf. I. 2.13 w . 55-58)
2
addidi
5
L Cedr., Delarue: b
8
codd.: ' D. L., Athen. Clem.
codd., corr. Gronov
9 1 codd.
L : : Clem.
codd., Athen.:
D. L.: Clem.: Cedr.
10
11
(i.e. Empedoclis et Heracliti, cf. Diels., Dox. p. 145) codd.: coniec. Wolf 1 :
Roeper
L O B T
12 : Roeper
om.
13 , om. L

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

63

Refutatio 1.2.18-5.1

, 1 4
,
,
. - 2
5 , ()
, ,
. ' ' 3

, ,
, .
, - 1 5
, . '

, ,
5 [] .
,
() ,
, .
1-3 cf. Luciani Vit. auct. 14; Sen. De ira 2. 10.5 et . Marcovich, RE Suppl.X (1965), pp.
254.61-255.25
3 - 4 : cf. Procl. In Tim. I, p. 351.6 Diehl; Diog. Laert.
9. 5 et Heracliti Frr. 1 et 101 DK (= Frr. 1 et 15 Marcovich, Florentiae 1978); RE Suppl.X,
p. 254.29 ss.; IX. 9.3
4 s. cf. Cedren. I, p. 276.7 s.
4 - 6 : cf. I.
3.1; Heracliti Frr.80 et 51 DK (= Frr.28 et 27 Marc.); Plat. Soph. 242 de; Aristot. De cculo
A 10,p.279 b 14; G. S. Kirk, Heraclitus etc., p. 25
6 : cf. Heracliti
Fr. 64 (= Fr. 79 .) ap. IX. 10.7; cf. ad I. 3.1 v. 4
6 :
cf. Luciani 1.1. et Heracliti Frr.51 et 10 (= Frr.27 et 25 M.)
7 : cf.
Heracliti Frr. 12, 49 a et 91 DK (= Fr.40 a, c2 et c3 Marc.); Plat. Crat. 401 d; 402 a; 411 bc;
439cd; 440a-d; Theaet. 152de; 160d; 182c; Aristot. Metaph.Y 5, p. 1010a 7; De caelo 1,
p.405a 28; G.S. Kirk, o.e., pp. 14 et 17 s. et al.
7-10 cf. I. 20.6; VII. 19.2; 24.3;
Diog. Laert. 9. 10; Porphyr. De antro 11; Plut. De facie 943 C - E ; 928 D; Cleomed. De motu
circ. corp. cael. 2. 3.99 et al.
1 s. cf. Cedren.I, p.276.12-14
5 s. : i.e. Pythagoras, Empedocles,
Heraclitus: cf. Diels., Dox., pp. 145 s.; 153 s.; at cf. J. Mejer, Diogenes Laertius and his Hellenistic Background (Hermes Einzelschr. 40, 1978), p. 83 s.
LOBT
1 tit. L O B
om.
om.
3 scrips!: codd.:
Roeper
L : , corr. Roeper
5 addidi
: :
Salvini
6 codd., corr. Roeper
om.
8 :
LOB
3
4 Usener: codd.

6 L
7

5 del. Diels
2 addidi

:
...

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

64

Hippolytus

. ,
,
, ,
() , .
2 ,
. ,
3 () . ,
, () .
, ,
, .
4
, ()
, ' . ' ,
, ' -

De c. 6 cf. C. . Kahn, Anaximander and the Origins of Greek Cosmology (Novi Eboraci 1960),
pp. 25-71
1 : cf. Euseb. Praep. ev. 10. 14.11; August. De civ. dei 8. 2; Diog.
Laert. 1.13; S i m p l i c . p . 24.13 Diels
2^4 et 8-10 excerpsit Cedrenus, I, p. 276.1521
2 et 6 : Theophr.Phys. opin. Fr. 2 Diels ap. Simplic. 1.1.; Ps. Plut. Strom. 2; Aet. I.
3.3; Diog. Laert. 2. 1
3 - 4 : Aristot. Phys. 4, p. 203 b 7-14; De caelo
5, p. 303 b 12 s.
4 - 5 : Simplic. 1.1. (Anaximandri Fr. 1 DK); Ps.
Plut. 1.1.
7 - 8 : Simplic. In Phys. pp.24.24; 41.18; 1121.9 D.;
Aristot. Phys. 1, p. 250 b 18-21; Hermiae Irris. 10
8 - 9 : Aristot. De caelo 13, p.295 b 10 ss.; Diog. Laert. 2.1; Suda, s.v. ; Cedr. I.
p.276.20 et al.
10 s. Aet. 3. 10.2; Ps. Plut. 1.1.
12-25 excerpsit Cedren. I,
p.277.1-14
12-19 Ps.Plut. 11; Aet. 2. 13.7; 15.6; 16.5; 20.1; 21.1; 24.2; 25.1; 29.1

LOBT
1 tit. L O B
L
3 ... .
Ritter {Gesch. der ion. Philos., p. 186): . . . codd., Cedr. (cf. v.23)
4
om. Cedr.
5 1 addidi
codd., transposui

scripsi (cf. w . 2 et 6): codd.
6 , om. L O B
6 - 7
() G.S. Kirk (The Presocratic Philosophers, Cantabrigiae 1957, p. 106) ex
Theophrasti Phys. opin. Fr.2 ( ): at cf. Simpl. In
Phys. p. 150.23 D.
7
8 codd., corr. Roeper
:
8 - 9 ,
Cedr.: ' L O B
9 ex Cedr. add. Diels: om. codd.
10 Roeper: codd., Cedr., def. C. H. Kahn (Anaximander, p. 56)
Gronov et Wolf
ex Aet. 3. 10.2 ( ) ): L, :
Cedr.: coniec. G. Teichmueller et Diels (Dox. p. 218 s.)
11 Gronov: L
: L
12 :
addidi ex Cedreni codd.
13 Diels
ex Cedreno (cf. v. 16): codd.
14 Diels: Cedr.:
codd.
Usener: codd., Cedr.
'

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.6.1-7

65

is . - 5
,
. (
), (*) , , (*)
( ) .
20
( ), , 6
- & -
' . () 7
(
) ' ,
25 . .

20-22 ' : Aet. 5.19.4; Censorin. De die nat. 4.7; Ps. Plut. 1.1.; Plut. Symp. 730
22 - 25 : Aet. 3. 3.1; 7.1; Sen. Qu. nat. 2. 18
25 s. i.e. anno 610/9:
cf. Diog. Laert. 2. 2 et F. Jacoby, Apollodors Chronik, p. 189

LOBT
16 L et Cedreni codd. (cf. Aet. 2. 25.1): et Cedreni ed. Bekketi
17 L O B
sine
lacuna Roeper conl. Diog. Laert I. 24 (de Thalete)
17-18 add. Diels conl.
Aet. 2. 21.1 et 2. 20.1
18 ante lac. sign. Diels, quam explet conl. Aet. 2. 25.1: post P. Tannery
{Science hell?, p. 119) suppl. E. Frank et . Becker, ft. recte
Roeper
post lac. susp. Diels, quam ex Aet. 2. 15.6 explet '
19 addidi post Dielsium conl. Aet. 2. 15.6
20 ( ), Diels ex Censorini De die nat. 4.7 (ex aqua terraque calefactis exortos esse sive
pisces seu piscibus simillima animalia) conl. Aet. 2. 19.4; Diog. Laert. 2. 9 s.f.: ( )
Cr ex Aetio: codd., Cedr.

21
L: : &
22 addidi ex Cedr.
23 :

Cedr.: codd.
23-24 ( ) '
Diels (KS) conl. Arii Didymi Fr. 11 (Dox., p. 451.20)
( addidi) :
' ( Par.) Cedr., agn. Kirk (Presocr.
Philos., p. 138): ( ) ' codd.
24 ' :
' Roeper et olim Diels, agn. Kahn (Anaximander, p. 63 s.)
25
Cedr. (cf. Aet. 3. 3.1): codd.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

66
1

4
5

Hippolytus

, , ,
, [ ()
] ,
, - ,
,
. () , . , ()
() ()
, ()
[] , , .
, '
[]
,
- ,
.
() .
1-12 Theophrasti Phys. op. Fr.2 Diels ap. Simplic In Phys. p.24.26 D.; Ps. Plut. Strom. 3;
Plut. De primo frig. 947 E; cf. I. Klowski, Hermes 100 (1972), pp. 131-142
1
- 3 exscripsit Cedren. I, p. 277.15-17
3 : August. De civ. dei 8. 2 non
tarnen ab ipsis (sc. deis) aerem factum, sed ipsos ex aere ortos credidit (sc. Anaximenes)
3 cf. Theophr. 1.1. ; Cie. Acad. 2. 118 gigni autem terram aquam
ignem, tum ex iis omnia; Ps. Plut. 1.1; cf. w . 15-16
6 s. Theophrast. 1.1.
, '
13 18 exscr. Cedren. I, .277.17-22
13-15 Ps.Plut. 1.1.; Aet. 3. 15.8; 2. 22.1;
Aristot. De caelo 13, p.294 b 13
15-17 Ps. Plut. 1.1.
17 s. Aet. 2. 13.10; I.
8.6
17-23 Aet. 2. 16.6; Diog. Laert. 2. 3; Aristot. Meteor. 1, p.354 a 28
LOBT
1 tit. L , om.
2
2 - 3
damn. Gu. . Heidel (Proc. Amer. Acad. 48, 1913, p. 629), vix recte
2
- 3 seclusi ut glossema ad v. 3
2 Cedr., om. codd.
3
4
5 L

, in mg. I
om.
6 :
add. Th. Gomperz
7 I
scripsi: codd.
7/8
8 Roeper: codd.

addidi ex Theophr.
9 Roeper et Diels: codd.

post 8 codd., transposui: pro Zeller


9 add. Diels
codd., corr. Roeper
10 L: : , corr.
Salvini
2 add. suad. Diels
11 ut gloss, sed. Diels et Heidel
14 - 15 om.
14 L O B , om. Cedr., del. Diels

15 Cedr.
18 () Diels ex Cedr.: codd.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.7.1-8.1

67

, , ,
.
, '
, . .
&, () 7
() ,
. ,
* , ', - 8

.
, .
.
. 1
,
, .
24-32 Aet. 3. 3.1-2; 4.1; 5.10; 15.3; Aristot. Meteor. 7, p. 365 b 6; Schol. in Arat.
p.515.27 Maass; Galen. In Hipp, de hum. 3: XVI, p.395 K.; Sen. Qu. nat. 6.10
2 - 4 exc. Cedren. I, p. 278.1-4
2 - 6 cf. Diog. Laert. 2. 6 et 8; Aet. I. 3.5; Theophr.
Phys. op. Fr.4 ap. Simplic. In Phys. p. 27.4 et 27.18 D.; Anaxagorae Frr. 1; 3; 4 et 6 DK
LOBT
20 L O B , , corr. Menage
21 paraphr. in mg. L: L :
om.
scripsi ex Aristot. Meteor. 1.1.: codd.
21-22
paraphr. in mg. L
24 () scripsi
(cf. .9 ): L O B , - :
coniec. Usener: coniec. Diels: ( ) coniec.
Heidel
coniec. Zeller (cf. Emped. Fr. 2.4; Galeni 1.1.): codd.:
coniec. Diels
25 ... Zeller

codd., corr. Salvini


L
28
codd., corr.
Go
32 : immo (i.e. anno 546/5): cf. . Diels, Rhein. Mus. 31 (1876),
p. 27 et F. Jacoby, Apollodors Chronik, p. 193
33
1 tit. L O B


codd.: Cedr.: Delarue
4
codd.: ( )
coniec. Go (conl. Simpl. In Phys. p. 155.27 D.):
coniec. Diels (VS, conl. Aristot. De gen. et con. A 8, p. 325 a
male intellexisse videtur

2
scripsi:

()
30): fontem

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

68

Hippolytus

2 , .
()
() ,
' , (
) ,
.
3


4 .
( ) , ()
() , 5 ,

.
() .
6 , () , '
,

6 s. cf. Anaxag. Fr. 12


7-11 Anaxag. Fr. 15; Diog. Laert. 2.8; Aet. I. 4.2
12 D. L. 1.1.
13 : Simplic. In Ar. De caelo p. 520.28 Heiberg
14-19 D.L. 11; Aet. 3. 16.2; Aristot. Meteor. 1, p. 353 b 6
19 s. Aet. 4. 1.3-4;
Diodor. I. 38.4; Aristot. Fr. 248 Rose; Sen. Qu. nat. 4a. 2.17; Schol. in Apoll. Rhod. 4.
269; Lyd. De mens. 4. 107 (p. 144 Wuensch) et al.
21 - 22 : Aet. 2.
20.6; 13.3; D.L. 2.8; Xenoph. Memor. 4. 7.7; Olympiod. In Ar. Meteor, p. 17.19 Stueve;
Suda, s.v. et al.
22 - 24 : I. 7.5; Aet. 2. 13.10 et Aristot.
De caeh 13, p. 293 b 21
LOBT
5
: Usener (deleto 6 )
7 2 et 8 1 addidi
8 :
coniec. Diels (conl. Aet. 1. 4.2)
et codd., corr. Salvini
9-10 suppl. C. Gu. Mueller (Gleiches zu Gleichem, 1965, p. 67 n. 124) ex
Anaxag. Fr. 15 ( ( add. Gu.
Schorn) ) et Fr. 12
10 (
) Usener
13 2 : () Usener, agn. We
15
supplevi et add. Diels
15-16 , () ()
Diels (conl. Diog. Laert. 2. 8):
codd.
18 paraphr. in mg. L, Roeper: codd.
20 ()
scripsi (Anaxagorae Democriti sententia tribuitur: cf. Aet. 4. 1.4 et Gu. Capelle, Neue Jahrb.
17, 1914, p.339 n.2): codd. ( coniec. Diels): ()() (et ) Roeper, agn. Diels, We: Aet. 4.1.3
22 add. Brandis
23 codd., corr. Roeper

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.82-12

69

,
[ ]
.
, .
. ,
. .
,
, .
.
.
,
( ) .
, . .

8
9

10

11
. () ,
. - 12
' .
,
,
, .
27 s. Aet. 2. 21.3; D.L. 2.8
28 s. Aet. 2. 28.5; Plat. Crat. 409a
29-31 Aet.
2. 29.6-7
31 s. Aet. 2. 23.1-2
34 s. Aet. 2. 25.9; 30.2; D.L. 2.8; Schol. in
Apoll. Rhod. 1. 498
36 s. D.L. 2.9; Suda, s.v.
37 s. D.L. 2.9; Aet.
3. 2.9
39 s. D.L. 1.1.
40-42 Aet. 3. 3.4; D.L. 1.1.
42 s. Aet. 3. 15.4;
D.L. 1.1.
44 - 46 : D.L. 1.1.; Aet. 5. 7.4; Aristot. De gen. anim. 1,
p. 763 b 30
LOBT
24 () Conti
L1: L2 : : (servatis ) coniec.
Roeper
25 del. Go (cf. I. 7.6 v. 23)
28 (- )
codd.
32 L ,
34 Gronov: codd.
35 L :
codd., corr. Diels
supplevi
ex
Aet. 2. 25.9
( )
36 :
Roeper:
codd.
36/37 codd., corr. Menage (ad D.L. 2.9)
37 :
38 codd. (- ): D. L.
40 L : : () Usener, agn. Diels
41 addidi
, . Schaubach: L (cf. I. 6.7)
44 codd. (cf. Aet. 5. 19.4): D.L.
L , Diog. codd. F 2 :
Diog. codd. B P 1 :
46

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

70

Hippolytus

13 , '
. .
1

, ,
, ,
2 () (). ()
() ' ,
, .
, []
3 , .
() ,
, , ( ) (*)
. '
, , ,
, .
4

, .
, ,
,
47 s. exscr. Cedren. I, p. 278.13-15
Rhein. Mus. 31 (1876), p. 28

47 i. e. anno 428/7: cf. D. L. 2.7; 3. 2 et . Diels,

1 - 3 et 17-21 exscripsit Cedren. I, p. 278.16-21


1-3 cf. Theophr. Phys. opiti. Fr.4 ap.
Simplic. In Phys. p. 27.23 D.
2 s. August. De civ. dei 8. 2
3-21 cf. Diog. Laert. 2.
16-17
22 s. cf. Isocrat. Nicocl. 6
LOBT
47 codd.: verum est (cf. D.L.): ( * ) ( )
Diels
1 tit. L
2 scripsi: codd.
3 scripsi conl.
Augustini 1.1. (... ut inesse [sc. particulis] etiam mentem diceret) et Anaxagorae Fr. 12 (
... ): codd.
:
( ) () scripsi:
codd.
iadd. Go
Roeper: codd.: (,
) Diels conl. D. L. 2.16
4 1 add. Ritter
6 post add.
D. L.
:
1 del. Roeper
7 ...
Roeper
8 addidi conl. w . 4 , 19 et Plut. De primo frig. 954 F (sc. )
,
9 post lac.
indie. Roeper, intercidisse ratus : '
suppl. Diels (KS): suppleverim conl. D. L. 2.17
(sc. ) ,
11
om.
13 L 2 ,-xpi- L 1
16

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.8.13-11.1

71

, . 5
,
,
20 () , , - .
() 6
,
( , )
25 [], , .
1 10
.
,
5 . , ' 2
, , , () ,
.
1 11
, ' ()
, ,

c. 11: 1-5 Theophr. Phys. opin. Fr. 6 ap. Alex. Aphrod. p. 31.7 Hayduck; Theodoreti
Graec. affect, cur. 4. 1 ( Aet. I. 3.13); Ps. Plut. Strom. 5
3 : Diog.
Laert. 9. 21; Aristot. Metapb. A 5, p.986 b 33; Simplic. In Phys. p.25.15 D. et al.
LOBT
17 - 18 in mg.
18 Cedr., Ritter: codd.
20 () , Diels ex Cedreno: codd.

21 Cedr.: codd.
: L : Cedr.
22 addidi conl. w . 17, 19, 24 et Isocrat Nicocl. 5
23
24 Zeller: L :
, supplevi
25
Ritter: codd.: ( Usener cett.
L : :
seclusi: Cr: Usener
1 :
L:
3 codd., corr. Roeper
4
6 post codd., transposuit Roeper
7 -
8 Wolf 1 : codd. We
1 tit. L
: seil, ut Xenophanes: cf. Theodoreti 1.1. et
Diels., Doxogr. p. 146
2 Diels: L O B We
addidi
scripsi: codd.: Roeper
3 scripsi: codd.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

72

Hippolytus

. () ,
2 , . 5
, ,
.
12 1

,
( ) , . () .
2 () - , - 5
, ( ' )
' , .

13 1


, ,
2 .
, , ,
. 5

4 s. cf. Parmen. Fr. 192
5-7 cf. Parmenid. Fr.8 w . 3 - 4 ; 6; 22; 25-26; 42-43; 49;
Plut. Adv. Colot. 1114 D et al.
1 ss. Theophr. Phys. opin. Fr.8 ap. Simplic. In Phys. p.28.8 D.; Diog. Laert. 9. 30 et al.
3 Aet. I. 3.15; D.L. 9. 31; Aristot. Metaph. A 4, p.985 b 4
4 - 7 : D.L. 9. 30-32; Aet. I. 4. 1-3; Euseb. Praep. ev. 14. 2 3 2 - 3 et al.
7 s. D.L. 9.33;
Leucippi Fr. 2
2 s. Diog. Laert. 9. 34-35; Suda, s.v.
3-5 cf. I. 12.1; Theophr. Phys.
op. Fr.8; Aristot. Metaph. A 4, p.985 b 4 et al.
6 : D.L. 9. 44; Simplic. In
Ar. De caelo p.202.16 Heiberg; Alex. Aphrod. ap. Simpl. o.e., pp.294.26; 310.5 ss.; Cie.
De fin. 1. 25 et al.
LOBT
4 2 add. Diels
5 in mg.
() Kranz: I. 142
(Comm. Ekat. p. 146)

codd., corr. C. Brandis

1 tit. L
2 supplevi conl. I. 13.2 et Aristot. De gen.
et con. A 8, p.325 a 25: add. Cr conl. D.L. 9.30
3 coniec. Diels
conl. Theophr. Fr.8
2 add. Wolf
4 add. Usener:
post add. Roeper conl. D.L. 9.31
Roeper ex D.L.: codd. I
Roeper: codd.
5
7 '
supplevi conl. D.L. 9.32
Diels conl. D.L. 1.1.: codd.

8 : Roeper conl. D. L. 9.33


1 tit. L
3
1 om.
transposui

2 codd., corr. Menage


I

codd.,

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

73

Refutatio 1.11.1-14.3

, ' .
, , 3
, , , ,
, () '
,
. ' 4
, , ,
' .
.
, () .
1
. ,
,
- ' .
2
,

. 3
' '

10 s. Aet. 2. 4.9
13 s. Aet. 2.15.3; Lucret. 5. 627-631
16 : cf.
Luciani Vit. auct. 13; Ps. Hippocr. Ep. 17 (IX, p.360 L.; II, p.226.15 ss. DK); Cie. De orat.
2. 235; Sotion. ap. Stob. 3. 20.53; Sen. De ira 2. 10.5 et al.; cf. S.I. Luriae Democritea
(Leninopoli 1970), p.21 s.
1 s. Apollodor. ap. Clem. Strom. I. 64.2
2 : at cf. I. 23.1 et Diels., Doxogr.
p. 148
3 s. Xenophanis Fr. 34.3-4
5 s. Ps. Plut. Strom. 4; Theodoret. Gr. f f . cur.
4.5; Aet. 2. 4.11 et al.
6 - 8 : Ps. Aristot. De Melisso Xenophane
Gorgia 3, p.977 a 36 - b 3; Simplic. In Phys. p.23.16 D.; Xenophanis Frr.23 et 24
8 s. Ps. Plut. Strom. 4; Theophr. Phys. op. Fr. 16 ap. Aet. 2.20.3
9 s. Ps. Plut. 1.1.; Aet. 3.9.4;
Xenoph. Fr. 28; Aristot. De caelo 13, p. 294 a 21; Simplic. In Ar. De caelo p. 522.8 Heiberg

LOBT
7 1 :
10 () Ritter: codd.
16 add. suad. We

14 L ,

1 tit. L

3 . . . codd.: . . .
Galen. VIII, .636 .: . . . Sext. Adv. math. 7. 49 et 110, Menage
4
LOB
7 () post Fabricium scr. Wolf 2
9 ()
coniec. Diels

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

74

Hippolytus

. ,
4 .
,
.
5

, ,

[ ],
, (
6 ) ,
, .
,
,
.
1


, () () (). ()
,
2 , ,
, ,

10 : Aet. 2. 24.9
10 - 11 : Aet. I. 3.12; Theodor, o.e., 4.5;
Ps.Plut.1.1.; Xenoph. Fr.27
11-13 Theophr. Phys. op. Fr.23; Aet. 3. 16.5; Aristot.
Meteor. 3, p. 357 a 15
16 : cf. Herodot. 2. 12; Strab. I. 3.4, p. 49 C.
21 s. Ps.Plut.1.1.
3 : Aet. I. 13.19

3 s. cf. Aet. I. 13.18

5-7 Aet. 2. 3.3

LOBT
12 : coniec. Diels
om.
14 : Roeper:
Cr
15 : Gronov, Roeper

16

1 , - 2 L: -
17 seclusi
(cf. v. 18): Th. Gomperz
18 Gronov: codd., def. Delarue,
Kirk
L , , corr. . Karsten (Xenoph. reliq. p. 178)

addidi (cf. v. 17)
20 L , - - :

22 L 2 : L 1
23 Diels: codd.: Karsten I
Roeper: codd.: Diels conl. Aristot. Meteor. A 14,
p. 325 a 14 ss.
1 tit. L
L O B
2 ( ) . . .
codd., corr. Diels (KS 1 )
add. suad. Wolf 2 (cf. paraphr. in mg. L '
)
addidi
5
coniec. G o (cf. Aet. I. 3.27): c o d d .

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.14.3-18.1

75

, ' ,
. () , '
.
.
() 1 16
. ()
. 2
, -
5 , .
1 17

, .
1 18

, ()
8 s. Aet. 3. 13.3
c. 16: 1 s. Sext. Emp. Pyrrb. hypot. 3. 30; Adv. math. 9. 361; Ps.Galeni Hist, philos. 18 et
al.
3 - 4 : Aet. 4. 3.9; Hermiae Irris. 2; Aristot. De anima A 2, p. 405
b24; Io. Philopon. In Ar. De anima p. 92.2 Hayduck
4 s. Theophr. Phys. op. Fr. 1;
Aristot. De anima A 2, p. 405 b 1-3
c. 18: 1-3 : exc. Cedren. I, pp.278.23-279.2
1 Diog. Laert. 1. 14; 2. 16;
19; 23; Porphyr. Hist, philos. Fr. 12 Nauck 2 ; August. De civ. dei 8.2 s. f. et al.
2
: . 34.4; Plat. Alab. I 130 e 7; 133 c 4; Charmid. 169 e 4; Phaedr. 229 e 6 230 a 6; Phikb. 48 d 2; Leg. 11, 923 a 4; Dicta septem sap. I, pp.62.8; 13; 14; 17; 63.25;
64.6 DK; Thalis dicta, I, pp.71.19; 72.21; 73.1 et 10 DK; Heracliti Fr. 116 DK (= Fr.23 e
Marc.); Iambi. V.P. 83; Plut. Adv. Colot. 1118 C; Cie. De fin. 3. 22.73 et al.
LOBT
7 () Roeper: codd.
Roeper: codd.: () () () . Gomperz
L
8 Go: codd.
9 codd., corr. Diels
( )
coniec. Zeller conl. Aet. 3. 13.3
1 tit. L
add. Wolf 1

2
.
L : Roeper
1 addidi

: L O B
3 corr. ex L
:
4 Zeller: codd.: Roeper
R.C. Bakhuizen v.d. Brink:
codd.
5 corr. ex
c. 17: 1
1 tit. L
codd., Cedr.
3 :
codd.

3
scripsi:
3-4 () Roeper:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

76

Hippolytus

2

. , .
[]
,
, ,
, ,
2 , , .
- , , ( ) .
3
()
- ,
- , 4 . ()
, -

5 : I. 4; I. 19.23; Diog. Laert. 3. 56; Aristot. Top. A 14, p. 105 b 19-25; Suda, s.v.

De c. 19 cf. C. Moreschini, Studi classici e orientali 21 (1972), pp. 254-260


1-5 et 6-10
excerpsit Cedren., I, p.279.2-10
1-8 cf. Albini Epit. 8.2; 9.1-2; 12.1-2 ed. Hermann;
Apul. De Plat. 1. 5-7; Aet. I. 3.21; 9.5; 19.1; Simplic. In Phys. p.26.14 D.; Hermiae Irris. 11;
Cyrill, c. Iul. 2, p. 48 (PG 76, p. 573 C); Iren. Adv. haer. 2. 14.3 et al.
3
: Plat. Tim. 49 a 6; 51 a 5; 52 d 5; 88 d 6
6 : cf. S.V.F. II,
nr. 413 (p. 136.31)
7 : Plat. Tim. 28 a 6 - b 1; Alb. 9.1; Apul. 1. 6
9 : Alb. 10.3-4 et 7-8; Cie. De nat. deor. 1. 30 ed. A.S. Pease; Diog. Laert. 3. 77; 5. 32;
Ps.Galeni Hist, philos. 16; Apul. 1. 5
10 : Alb. 8.3; Apul. 1. 5; Ocell. Luc. 24
Harder; Tert. Adv. Hermog. 35.2
11 - 12 : Alb. 8.2; cf. Plat. Tim.
50 d - 51 b
12-15 exc. Cedren. I, p. 279.17-19
12 s. Epiphan. Panar. 6.3 Holl

LOBT
6

, Roeper: codd.

I tit. L
seclusi
2 1 om.
3 Cedr.,
Roeper: codd.
codd., corr. Gronov
6
7 : Cedr.
Cedr., Gronov: codd.
( ) Roeper
7/8 L1 Cedr.: L 2
8 ex Cedr.
add. Diels
9 1 addidi ex Cedr.
post add. Cedr.
II
12
12 addidi (cf. v. 15)
13 Go (cf. v. 16):
codd.
13 et 23 codd.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.18.1-19.8

77

,
.
, .
,
- () ,
-,
, () .
, ,
, ,
-
() - '
, , ()
,
,
. ,
,
, - ,

7
8

14 s. .41; Philon. De aet. mundi 27; Alb. 5.5; Plat. Phaedr. 245 d 3; Aristot. De caelo A
12, p.282 a 30
18 - 22 : Ocell. Luc. 16; Philon. De aet. m. 143 s.
24 - 25 et 26 oi - 32 : exc Cedren. I, pp. 279.10-12 et 279.19-280.3
24 s. Plat. Leg. 715 e 7; Alb. 28.3
27 s. Plat. Tim. 41 a 7; Alb. 15.2; w . 32-33
28 s. Plat. Phaedr. 246 e 4
29 s. cf. Plat. Tim. 40 e 5

LOBT

14 Roeper: Cedr.: codd.


codd., Cedr.
16 L O B :
17
19 addidi
20-21
Go: codd.: () [] Usener, agn. Diels We
21
codd., corr. Gronov
add. Roeper
24 1 :
25
, Cedr. (Plato): om. L O B
26 addidi
scripsi:
codd.
27 codd., ex Cedr. corr. Diels
Cedr., ex Plat. scr. Roeper:
codd.
om. codd., ex Plat. add. Roeper (cf. v. 32), habet Cedr.
28 post
add. Plato: omittunt codd., Cedr., etiam Plut. Non posse suav. vivi 1102 E;
Ps. lust. Coh. ad Gr. 31
29
:
30 pro - habet
Cedr.
30 L2: L1 :
31

Cedr.
32 Roeper (cf. v. 27): codd.
:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

78

Hippolytus

, ,
9 , . ,
, .
10
,
-

, .
- ,
11 , .
() , ()
() ,
,
12 ,
'
(),
.
13 , ' (),
, ,
,
, .
34 - 50 : liberius excerpsit Cedren. I, pp.280.15-281.5
34 s. Aet. I. 8.2
36-38 : Plat. Phaedr. 245 c 5 ss.; Alb. 25.4
40 Plat. Tim. 41 d 4
: Tim. 44 d 3 ss.; 69 c 5
41 : Orig. c. Cels. 2. 60; Procl. In Tim. II,
pp.81.21; 85.3; III, p.355.16 Diehl; Suda, s.v. et al.
43 - 45 : Plat.
Phaed. 113 d ss.; 114 c; Gorg. 523 c ss.; 526 b ss.; Reip. 614 c ss.; Phaedr. 249 a
45-48 Plat. Phaed. 81 d ss.; Reip. 617 d ss.; 619 d ss.; Phaedr. 248 d ss.; Tim. 42 a ss.; Men.
81 be; Leg. 872 e; 903 d et al.
50-52 Phaedr. 250 b 7

LOBT

33
codd., Plat. codd. W , F A 2 , Philop., Procl. (cf. In Tim.
Ill, p . 2 0 8 2 3 D.), Themist., Cyrill., Chalcid. (me ita volente), Stob.: Plat,
cod. , Philo, Euseb., Athenag., Cie. (me invito)
34 Cedr.
36 Wolf 1 : codd.

37 Cedr.
41
om.
L O B (cf. v.31):
42-43 . . . codd., corr.
Roeper
42 add. Usener
43 . . . Cedr. (at cf. I. 22.5) I
Cedr., Roeper: codd.
Cedr.
44 Cedr.
46
':
47 () Diels (conl. Plat. Phaed. 113 e 1
): codd. et Cedreni codd. Par.: Gronov:
Cedreni ed. Bekk.
48 post 47 Cedr.
49 codd.,
corr. Diels
50 Wolf 1 : codd.
codd.: Cedr.:
Plato
52 L : : Mi cett.
om.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.19.8-17

79

, ,
, -

,
, ,
, -
.
-
[] -, .
, ()
' .
() , '
, , '
, , '
, , ' .

.

14

15

16

17

54 ss. cf. Divis. Aristot. p.65.24 ss. Mutschmann; Alex. In Ar. Metaph. p.257.31 Hayduck;
Simplic. In Ar. De caelo p. 332.1 ss. Heiberg et al.
57 - 60 : Plat. Leg.
697 b 2; Diog. Laert. 3. 80-81 = Div. Aristot. p. 1 Mutschm.; I. 20.3
61-63 Aristot. EN 6, p. 1107 a 6; Alb. Epit. 30.4; Apul. De Plat. 2. 5
63 s. Plat.
Phaed. 69 a 10;Reip. 433 b 7;442 b - d ; 504 a 5; Leg. 964 b 5; 965 d 2; D. L. 3.90 s.; 7.92 = S.V.F.
Ill, nr.265 et al.
64 : Aristot. EN 2, p. 1104 a 12; a 25; MM A 5, p. 1185
b 13
66 : Aristot. EE 3, p. 1221 a 12
67 : EE p. 1221
a 2; E N 2, p. 1104 a 22
68 : Hierac. ap. Stob. 3.
9.54; Aristot. MM A 34, p. 1193 b 25; EE p. 1221 a 4
69 : EN p. 1104 a 20;
EE 3, p. 1220 b 39; MM p. 1185 b 23; Apul. 2. 5
72-75 Plat. Theaet. 176 b 1-3;
Reip. 613 a 7; Tim. 90 d 4; Alb. 28.1; Stob. II, p.49.8 Wachsm.; D.L. 3. 78; Apul. 2. 7

LOBT
57 :
58
61 Wolf 1 : () codd.
61-62 - post codd., transp. Cr
62 del. Cr et Diels
2 scripsi: codd.
63 codd., corr. Roeper
64 addidi
66 Gronov: L O B
67 ( ) ,
' codd., transposui (cf. Aristot. EN 2, p. 1104 a 22
, ,
, et Demosth. 18. 120 )
68 - 69 om.
68 :
69 :
superscripto L:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

80

18

19

20

21

22

Hippolytus

,

.
, . () , '
, ' ' ,
,
' ' .

, , , () ,
, .
, '
() () ' ; , , .
, ;
() ,
(), ;
' - ' ,

75 s. Apul. 2. 6; Alb. 29.4; D.L. 7. 125 (= S.V.F. III, nr. 295); Plut. De Stoic,
rep. 1046 ( nr.299); Olympiod. In Akib. pr. p.214 Creuzer (= nr.302); Sext. Emp.
Pyrrh. hypot. 1. 68 et al.
76 : Aristot. MM A 25, p. 1192 a 12 s.; EE
5, p. 1239 b 11; Apul. 2. 5 (p. 108.5 Thomas): unimodam vero esse virtutem; Philon.
De sacrif. Abel 84
77 : Aristot. 1.1. 1.1.; Alb. 30.1
78 :
Aet. I. 27.3; Alb. 26.1; Cedr. I, p.281.5 s.
79 s. Plat. Reip. 617 e 4
80 Plat.
Phaedr. 248 c 2
81 ss. Alb. 31.1-2; cf. Plat. Prot. 345 d 9; 358 c 6; Leg. 731 c 2; Tim.
86 d 7
86-90 : immo in Clitophonte, p.407 d 4
92 : cf. Plat. Gorg. 477 a 7; 478 e 4

LOBT
74 : L
75/76
76
78 ex Cedr. add.
Diels
Cedr., Wolf 1 : codd.
79-80 . . .
80
Diels ex Piatone: codd.
81 Cr: codd.
84 addidi conl. Alb. Epit. 31.1
85 : coniec. We
86 Roeper ex Platone: codd.
87 scripsi ex Piatone: codd. I
:
et 88 addidi ex Plat.
88 Roeper ex Plat.:
codd.
89 scripsi ex Plat.: codd.
90 : I
ex Plat. add. Go
Mi ex Plat.: codd.
91 addidi (cf. v. 95)
92 om.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.19.17-20.4

81

- ()
, .
' 23
, '
' , .
, ,
.

, ,

. ,

, ,
, , , ,
, , ,
, ,
, .
, ,
,

3
4

94 : Ps.Plat. Defin. 416 a 33; Alb. 31.3; Plat. Gorg. 479 a 5


95 : cf.
Plat. Prot. 324 b 5; Leg. 934 b 2
97 : cf. S.V.F. II, nr. 1170 et
Plat. Tim. 86 e 1
99 s. Cedren. I, p.281.6-8
1-18 excerpsit Cedren. I, pp.281.11-282.5
1-2 Io. Philop. In Ar. Anal. pr. p.6.17
Wallies; Aristot. Vitae vulg. 26 (I. Duering, Aristotle in the Anc. Biogr. Trad., p. 135 s.);
Greg. Naz. Or. 28.10 et 32.25 (PG 36, pp. 24 C et 202 C; p. 365 Duering)
3-11 Aristot. Cat. 4, p. 1 b 25; Top. A 9, p. 103 b 22; cf. Metaph. 2, p. 1028 b 36 et al.; VI.
24.2
12 s. I. 19.14-16

LOBT
94 () Go: L ,
96

99 - om.
100 codd., Cedr., del. Usener
1 tit. L
3 2 : Cedr.
8 in mg.
9 Roeper: L (Cedr.)

10
post . 11 codd., transposui (cf. v. 5): in Cedreno
ordo est - , -
14 Cedr., Menage (ad D.L. 7.
157): codd.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

82

Hippolytus

, (*)
, []
- , .
5


,
.
, ,
, ,
6 . '
, , . ,
, ' , , .
7
,
.
, , ,

, ,
.

is

25

35

15 s. cf. .27-29; Aet. 4. 7.4 ap. Theodoret. Gr. ff cur. 5. 24; Arii Didymi Fr. 39.5-6 Diels
( - S.V.F. II, nrr. 821 et 809); Tert. De anima 54.2; 55.4; Ps.Galeni Hist, philos. 24 (p. 613.17
Diels)
15 : cf. Hermiae Irris. 3; M. Anton. 4. 21; Clem. Strom. 5. 105.1;
Olympiod. In Phaed. p.57 Norvin; Orig. c. Cels. 3. 22
16 : cf.
Aristot. De caelo A 3, p. 270 b 20; Meteor. A 3, p. 339 b 25; Ps. Aristot. De mundo 2, p.392
a 8; X. 7.4
20 : Aristot. EN A 8, p. 1098 b 12; EE 1, p. 1218 b 32;
MM A 3, p. 1184 b 1; Rhet. A 5, p. 1360 b 25; Diog. Laert. 5. 30; Stob. II, p. 124.15 ss.
Wachsm.; Divis. Aristot. 56 Mutschm.
23 cf. Stob. II, p. 129.14 W.
23-25 I.
19.16
26 : cf. I. 4.3; VII. 19.2; 24.3; Diog. Laert. 9.
10; Porphyr. De antro 11; Plut. De facie 943 C-E; 928 D et al.
27-29 exc. Cedr. I, p.
282.5-7; cf. w . 15-16
27 cf. Aristot. De anima A 4, p. 408 b 18 et 29; 2, p. 413 b
24; 5, p.430 a 17-25; Degen, anim. 3, p.736 b 27; EN 7, p. 1177 b 30 et al.
27 s. Aristot. De caelo A 3, p. 270 a 13
31-35 cf. Cedr. I, p. 282.9-12; Ammon. In Cat.
p. 3.8 Busse; Olympiod. In Cat. p. 5.18 .; David. In Porph. Isag. p. 121.8 B.; Diog. Laert. I.
17; Ps.Galeni Hist, philos. 4 et al.
LOBT
15 post lac. indicavi: ' suppleverim conl. .
28, Arii Did. Fr. 39.6 D. ' ; Hermiae Irris. 3

15-16 Cedr.
16
seclusi
19 : Roeper
22
23 Roeper e
Stobaeo: codd.
27 2 Roeper: codd.
33

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.20.4-21.5

83


, 6 () , ,
, .
' , ,
, , [ ]
, .
.
,
.
,
,
, , .
.

3-5 et 12-15 excerpsit Cedren. I, p.282.13-18


3 s. S.V.F. I, nr. 153; II, nrr.310; 1028;
1030; 1051-1054 et al.
6 - 11 : cf. Sen. Ep. 107.11
ducunt volentem fata, nolentem trahunt; S.V.F. I, nr. 527
12 Ps. Galeni Hist, philos.
24 (p.613.18 D.); Plut. Nonposse suav. vivi 1107
12 s. .: cf.
Diogen. Apollon. 64 A 28 DK; Plat. Crat. 399 d 10 - e 3; Aristot. De anima A 2, p.405
b 28 s.; Plut. De primo frig. 946 C; De Stoic, repugn. 1052 F; 1053 C; De comm. not. 1084
E; De def. orac. 433 A; Plot. 4. 7.8; Tert. De anima 25.2; S.V.F. II, nrr. 804-808; VIII.
10.1 et al.
14 : Epiphan. Panar. anacephal. I. 7.2 (I, p. 166.2 Holl);
Ps. Gal. 24 (p. 614.10 D.)
15 : Method. De resurr. mort. I. 47.3 (p.297.12
Bonwetsch)
18 - 20 : S.V.F. II, nrr. 463-481, praecipue nrr.479 et 480
LOBT
1 tit. L ,

3 addidi
I
scripsi ex Cedreno: codd.
4 :
5 : Cedr.: L O B
8 seel. Roeper
8-11 pro his habet , ,
- (1. Wolf 2 et Roeper) ,
(1. ) , -
,
8
11 coniec. Usener
12 : Cedr.

L : Cedr.
( ) Roeper conl. D.L. 7. 1561
, codd.: . , Cedr.:
. , , Diels
14
15
16 scripsi: codd.
18 codd., corr. Roeper

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

84

Hippolytus

,
, .
1

.
- ,
2 , -,
, [], ( , )
, ( (), ()
, . ' ,
, - .
3

, ,
. ' -
, -, ,
4 .

1-23 liberius excerpsit Cedren. I, .282.19-283.14


1 : cf. Ps.Galeni Hist,
philos. 3 (p. 601.15 D.)
4 : cf. . Useneri Epicureorum Fr. 354 ss.
6 - 8 cf. Aet. I. 3.18 (p.286.10 D.); Epicureorum Fr. 267 s.
9 : Diog. Laert.
10. 139; 123; Epicur. Fr.360 ss.
11 : Theophil. Ant. Ad Autolyc.
2.4; Epiphan. Panar. 8. 1.1; Lampe, s.v. , 2
13 : D.L.
10. 89; Cie. De nat. deor. I. 18 (et A.S. Pease ad loc.); De fin. 2. 75; De divin. 2. 40; Lucret.
3. 18-24; 5. 146-155
LOBT

19 Go: codd.
scripsi: codd.: Salvini cett.
(resistentiam Wolf 1 ): . Ritter: Usener: Diels (conl.
S.V.F. II, pp. 153.6 ss.; 154.22 ss.; D. L. 7. 151): ab Arnim
20
I tit. L
2 Cedr.
3 Cedr., Roeper:
codd.
4 om. , Cedr., del. Roeper: habent L O B
4 3 om.

add. Roeper (cf. I. 13.2-3)


5 () scripsi:
codd.
ex Cedr. add. Diels
5-6 ... Cedr.
6 :

6 - 7 ' (' Roeper) codd.: ' Cedr.: ', Usener, agn. Diels We
II L O B : : Cedr., Diels

12 Cedr., Gronov: codd.
14 ...
, Cedr. (D.L. 10. 139): . . . L O B

15 , Cedr.
(D. L.): L O B
(cf. . 21): L
om.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.21.5-23.3

85

, .
() () , .
, 5
- ,
.
,
, , .
- 1
. , ' , , , , 2
,
.
3
, ' ()
, ()
() , .

19 : cf. Epicureorum Frr. 336-341; D. L. 10. 65-67; 125; 139


Lucret. 3. 43; Empedocl. Fr. 105
21 s. cf. I. 19.11

20 :

1-6 : exc. Cedren. I, pp. 283.22-284.5


3 s. Diog. Laert. 9. 61; Sext. Emp. Adv.
math. 8. 408
4 : S. . Pyrrh. hypot. 2. 259
6 : S. . P.h. 3.
115; Adv. m. 8. 7; Plut. De 392 A - E ; De comm. not. 1083 ; M. Anton. 2. 17; 4. 43;
Philon. De poster. Caini 163; De spec. legg. I. 27; De somniis 2. 109; Plat. Tim. 42 a; 33 c; 43
a; 82 b; Phileb. 42 c et al.
9 - 11 S.E. P.h. I. 188-190; D.L. 9. 75; Phot. Bibl.
cod. 212, p. 170 a 1 Bekker

LOBT

16 L O B :
17 Diels ex Cedreno:
codd.
20 L ( - -):
codd.,
Cedr.: non sanum Diels
22 Roeper: codd.: ' Cedr.
1 tit. L

2 / 3 codd., corr.
Go
3 Cedr.
L , Cedr.:
5 post
add. Cedr.
6 scripsi: codd.
9 add. Roeper
10
Roeper: codd.
: coniec. Diels
2 add. Go
11 1 add. Roeper

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

86

Hippolytus

24 1

. ,
, -
, -,
2 () . , 5
.
, '
, ' , , '
, ' .
, ,

2 : Megasthen. ap. Strab. 15. 1.59 p. 712 C.; Clem. Strom. 3. 60.2; Bardesan. ap.
Porphyr. De abstin. 4. 17 (p.257.1 N. 2 ); Hierocl. ap. Steph. Byz. Ethri., s.v. ;
Pallad. De Brachman. 2. 24 et 45, pp. 122 et 130 I. Duncan . Derrett {Class, et Med. 21,
1960); Manu 6. 7; 13; 14; 21; 25 et al.
3 : Clem. Strom. 1. 71.5; Pallad.
2. 10, p. 116; cf. Strab. 15. 1.60 p. 713 C._et al.
4 : Manu 6. 21
5 : ft. fluvius Tuhgavena (cf. Mahabharata 3.14233; 6. 335), cf. I. Filliozat, Revue de
l'hist. des rel. 130 (1945), p. 64. Aliter Fr. Pfister, Hermes 76 (1941), p. 148n. 5; B. Puri, India
in Class. Gr. Writings (Ahmedabadi 1963), p. 30 s. (fluvius Tabra-Nala); cf. Pallad. 2. 4,
p. 114 ; 2. 15, p. 119
5 : i.e.
Clem. Strom. 1. 71.4; Strab. p. 713 C.; Pallad. 2. 7, p. 116; Manu 6. 6
et al.; cf. ap. Porphyr. De abst. 4. 17, p. 256.3; Clem. Strom. 1. 71.4-5;
3. 60.3-4; Ptolem. Geogr. 7. 1.51
5 s. : Sext. Sent. 449 Chadwick
... (cf. 346); Pallad. 2. 17, p. 120
(sc. ); . Anton. 10. 1 et 11; Plat. Crat. 403 b 5; I Cor.
6:19 et al.
7 : cf. Katha Upanishad 5. 15; Mundaka Up. 2. 2.10;
Svetsvatara Up. 6. 14; Chandogya Up. 3. 13.7; Bbagavadgita 15.6; 13.17; 11.12 et 17;
cf. IV. 43.3
8 : cf. Collat. Alexandri cum Dindimo p. 14.35 Pfister:
deus... per verbum exaudit orantem hominem, quia de verbo tantummodo homo simile
est deo, ut deus verbum est. et verbum istum mundum creavit, et per verbum vivunt
omnia, nos autem (sc. Bragmani) hoc verbum colimus et hoc adoramus et hoc amamus.

LOBT
1 tit. L
L O B , corr. Gronov
1-2 coniec. Usener
1/2
4

5 addidi
codd., cf. Tababenus Dindim. De Brachman.
p. 7.4 Pfister (Kl. Texte zum Alexandenoman, 1910), Tabobenus (Tababenus cod. Seit.) Anon.
Hist, de preliis [Hist. Alexandri versio J 1] p. 223.13 Zingerlt (Germanist. Abb. 4, 1885):
Roeper, Diels ap. We, vix recte
7
Roeper: codd.
L O B
': '
:
8 :
L O B
9 , Roeper: L O B

10
scripsi: codd.: ut ex v. 8 inlatum del. Diels We
codd., corr.
Delarue

W o l f * et R o e p e r : c o d d .

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.24.1-6

87

, ()
, , (
) , , .
' .
,
, .
,
,
.
, , (*)
-
- () , , .

() ,
, .
, , , , , ,

11 : Athen. 11, 507 D


; Fronton. . ad . Anton, . 138.9 V. d. Hout (p. 144 Naber); Philon.
Fr. Harris p.7 (Mangey II, 668); Tac. Hist. 4. 6.1; Niceph. Callist. Hist. eccl. 14. 50 (PG 146,
p. 1237 A); cf. Pallad. 2. 42, p. 129
12
: Clem. Strom. 3. 60.2; Porph. De abst. 4. 18; Strab. p. 713 C.; Pallad. 2. 18,
p. 120; 20, p. 121 et al.
13 : Porph. o.e., p.257.4 N.2; Manu 6. 8; 29; 30 et al.
14 : Clem. Strom. 1. 71.5; Strab. pp. 712; 713 et al.
17 : i.e. hi quoque vanaprasthas (i.q. ) sunt: cf. Porph. o.e., p.256.18 oi
oi , ; Pallad. 1. 13, . 112;
Manu 6. 3 et al.
20-23 de mayayoga agere videtur
24 - 30 :
Cynica Indicis mixta: cf. Pallad. 2. 6, p. 115 ' ...
... , , ; 2. 7
; 2. 21, . 121; 2.23, . 122; Bhagavadgita 3. 39 et 43 et al.

LOBT
11 Roeper: codd.
12 : Roeper
12-13 addidi et add.
Roeper
13 : Diels conl. Cedr. I, p. 268.2 , agn. We
14 : Diels
16
coniec. Diels
17 Gronov: codd.
20 post lac. indicavi: exspectes , , cf. . 22-23
22 () scripsi:
codd.
del. suad. Diels
25
seel. Roeper Go Diels
Roeper: codd.
28 L

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

88

Hippolytus


7 . , 3
,
,
' , ,
.
25 1

() '
,
,
2 .
5
,
,
. .

26 1


.
'
,
2 , ' . 5
, ',
30-33 Megasthen. ap. Strab. 15. 1.68 p. 718 C. et ap. Arrian. Anab. 1. 2.3-4; Pallad. 2. 4,
p. 114; 2. 11, p. 117; 2. 41, p. 128
33 s. cf. Fr.I. Doelger, , V, 1943, p. 321 s.
c. 25: 1-4 cf. I. 2.17
5 : Cie. De div. I. 90; Tac. Hist. 4. 54.2; Dionis
Chrysost. Or. 49 (32).8
8 : Plin. Nat. hist. 16. 249; cf. Diog. Laert. I. 1;
RE V (1905), p. 1731.49
c. 26: 1 s. cf. Hesiodi Theog. 22-25

2 - 5 Theog. 52-60

LOBT
29 :
30 L :
32 Diels
: L O T
om.

31 2 L: : om.

34

1 tit. L O B
addidi
2 :
coniec. Diels
: L.(et. paraphr. in mg.):
3 codd., We: coniec. Go, agn. Diels
4
5 :

6 : , Roeper Go
8
1 tit. L O B
corr. Wolf 2

3 : om. L O B

5 codd.,

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.24.6-26.2

89



()

108

' () ,
.

112

, , '
is

, ' ' .

115

[] '
,
, ',
' (),
' , ,

120

, '
.
' ()
' ' .

', ,

25

124
126

' ( ) ,
8-12 Theog. 108-113
13 cf. Theog. 114 ' '

14-37 Theog. 115-139


LOBT
9 codd., corr. Gronov
codd.: ( edd.)
Hesiodi Pap.3 et codd. (ed. M.L. West)
10 () Gronov ex Hes.: L ,
Theogoniae v. 111 (= 46) om. etiam Hesiodi Pap.3 B, Theophil. Ad Autol. 2. 5
11 ' ex Hes. codd. S V, Q 1 (ut v.) scripsi suadente
A. Rzach: codd. edd.: ' Hes.
codd., corr. Wolf 2
12
13 ' L : ' , corr. Diels
14 ' Roeper: codd.:
' (omisso ) Hes. Pap.3 et codd., Theophil.
15 del. Gronov, om. Hes.:
Sext. Emp. Pynb. bypot. 3. 121

16 codd., corr. Go
17 codd.: Gronov ex Hes.
18 codd. (cf. Theog. 742):
Hes.
L O B
codd. omn, corr. Salvini
19
L O B , corr. Gronov
( b)
20
' 2 om.
21 Gronov ex Hes.: codd. omn.: ' Salvini et G. Hermann, agn.
Diels We
L : : Hes.
22
L O B , corr. Gronov
23 v. 125 om. et. Theophil. 2. 6: habet Hes. Pap.3
24 scripsi ex Hes.: L B, Gronov: , Delarue cett.

: '
25 codd., corr. Gronov et Wolf1
Gronov ex Hes. codd. V 1 : codd.: Hes. codd. test. (cf.
Theog. v.462)
26 ' Diels ex Hes.: ' L : ' : Gronov
et Wolf1

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

90

Hippolytus

' , ()
no , ' (),
(),
,
'
' '
135 () '
() ' .
' ,
, ' .
139
' ,

' .

, , .
,
,
,
() .
38 : cf. Theog. 50 et M.L. West (Oxonii 1966) ad w . 5 0 ; 133; 139-153
38 s. Theog. 453 ss.
40-45 excerpsit Cedrenus I, p. 284.6-11
41s. . . . : cf. Luc. C. indoct. 1
42-45 cf. Rm 1:25; IV. 43.2;X. 32.5; De universe Fr.2
(ed. Gu. I. MalleyJ.rS., N.S. 16, 1965, pp. 13-25)
LOBT
27 () G. Hermann, Hes. Pap.3 et Theophil.: codd.: (sc. ) Usener, agn.
Diels We: Hes. codd., Go
28 L O B , corr. Go
L 1 1
': ' Hes.
L O B , corr. Gronov
29 L : , Diels We I

() scripsi ex Hes. Pap.3: codd. omn.: frCov Gronov ex Hes.
codd.
31
32
' L :
'
33 ' L b: ' , corr. Gronov et Go
34
ex Hes. add. Wolf 1


35 ' Gronov,
Roeper: ' codd.: ' Hes., Wolf 1 Diels We

Wolf 1 , Hes. Pap.3 et codd. : L O T ( b):


Hes. codd. et Laur. 91.10
36
37

39 \ 2
40pi:iCedr.
41 ()
Diels
scripsi: codd. (om. Cedr.)
42 codd.: Cedr.
44 in mg.
:
44-45
Cedr.
45 addidi conl. w . 43 et 44
( ), . 32.5 ( , ) et
Rm 1 :25

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

Refutatio 1.26.2-4

91

' 4
, '
' .

so -
-, () [']
.

LOBT
47
48 L 2
51 codd.: Roeper:
() Go, Diels
addidi
53 ' seclusi
post lac. susp.
Diels et We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:34 PM

< >
f.

11

* * ( ) ,
) ()() () ( )
() ( ) ( ) () ' ( ) ()
( ) (. )( ') , 5
( )() () () ( ) ()
[] ()( ) ( )( )( ),
( , ) (, )( )
2 () ' () , ( )
() () ( ) (
) ()(.) ( )
() () [] () () () ()
, ( ) . (
) ()
( ) , 15
, ()() () ,
.

() , ()) () , ()
2-17 e Sext. Emp. (= S.) Adv. math. V. 37-39 et 44 exscripsit (cf. V. 13.10-11)
1-5 V. 13.12
I - add. Mi
addidi ( Mi, We)
2 praeced.
S. V. 5-11 (cf. V. 13.3-9, praes. v. 41 s. . . .
)
2 - 3 supplevi e S. (cf. V. 13.10)
4 addidi e S.
6-7 <) [] Mi e S. ():
7 1 Mi: S. Go
2 Mi: S. Go
8 , e S. suppl. Mi ( S. Go)
10 et
II e S. et suppl. Go
11 scripsi ex :
12 e S. add. Go
del. Go
addidi ex et S. ( ): Go
cett.
13 : S.
1 : Mi: Go e S.
13 - 14 addidi conl. S. V. 44 ( .) et
14 , corr. Mi
15 Mi e S. et :
: S.
16 : e S. corr. Mi
1 : V. 13.9: . 10.1 et Theodoreti Haeret.fab. comp. I. 17
3 scripsi ex :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV. 1.1-3.4

93

,
5 ,
. , () 2
()(), ' ,
() . /
(), ' () () ( ) 3
() , ,
,
is ( ) . ' '
( ) ' ,
,
, .
() ( )
,
()
' ,
5 . '
( ) ,
()
, ,
(). ,
, ()
() ,
/ .

f.

1 3

f.

19 : (fem.) cf. Ael. De nat. anim. IV. 38 (codd.). : cf. Didym. De trin. 1.30
1-52 = S. V. 50-61
6
9 , corr. Mi
10 , con. Mi
scripsi:
12 scripsi:
15
17 scripsi:
Mi:

12

1 addidi e S. (cf. v. 7)
Mi e S. ( ):
3 2 e S. add. Go
5 ' S.:
6 Go e S.: PI
e S. add. Mi
7 , e S. corr. Go
Mi e S.
9 Mi ( ): S.
10 Mi e S.
11 , e S. corr. Go
Mi e S.
12 Go e S.: I
Go e S.:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

94

Hippolytus

() ' ( ) , ( )
( ) ( ) , is
, ' .

, ( ) , ,
.
5

f. 2

( ) , .

6 .
, ,
, 7 .
, , .
, ,
( ) 8 ( ) , /
. ( ) '
(,
, ' ) (
, ) ( )
,

25

35

13 Mi e S. (cf. IV. 4.1):


, corn Mi
13/14 Mi ( ): S.
14 Mi:
(
) scripsi:
: , () S. (V. 53)
15 () scripsi e S.:
(et Sexti codd. S 1 S 2 ): Go We

addidi e S.
18 , correxi e S.
20 , corr. Mi
, corr. Mi
20/21 Go e S.:
21-22 : S. (quam vocem male intellexisse videtur )
21 , corr. Go
24 - 25 male :
S.
24 scripsi:
25/26 coniec.
Go: : S.
28 : ( ) S.
31-32 : e S. corr. Go
34
35 - 36 et 36 - 37 e S. suppl. Go
36
37 scripsi: : om. Sexti codd. (praeter S 1 , qui praebet)
1 Go e S.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.3.4-4.2

95

() 40 . , 9
,
- -, ()
45 , 10

, , , . ,
, .
so ' () 11
,
.
- 1 4
. ' ' . / ()
()
( ,) () ,
5 (). () '
[ ] . 2
'
' ()
'

f. 3

1-37 - S. V. 64 sub fin. - 70


3 s. cf. Ps. Galeni
16.5 ed. Kalbfleisch (Abh. Berlin 1895, p. 57.12)
39 Mi e S.
Mi e S.:
40 : S.
Mi e S.:
We
41 Go e S.:
43 - e S. V. 57
addidit
Mi et Go e S.: We
45 : S.
48 : S.
, corr. Mi et Go
50 e S. add. Go
, e S. corr. Go
51 S.
S.
S.
2 ' Mi: : ' S.
3 S.
S.
4 (exterior) Diels: : Go e S.
. e S. suppl.
Go
5 , e S. corr. Go (cf. v. 10)
addidi e S.

, corr. Mi (' ' S.)
5-6 scripsi e S.:
6 , corr. Go
& seclusi
7 :
Sexti archetypus, R. Bury
8
9 Mi e S.:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

96

pf. 3

Hippolytus

, ' '
3 .
.
"
() , ,
, . is
4
,
,
, , 20
5 . ' () , '
- ( )
[] .
6 ( ) () / 25

, .

7 ' ,
( ) , 3
,
, () ()
,

11 et Sexti archet.: Go, Bekker


, corr. Mi

v Mi: : Sexti archet.

12 , corr. M i

14 , e S. corr. Mi

, corr. G o

16 scripsi e S. (cf. v. 31): I

: S.

17 scripsi e S. (cf. v. 32):

18 coniec. Mi: : S. (cf. v. 22)


Mi: : S.
(et Sexti archet.): Bekker
add. G o (om. Sexti codd. S 1 S 2 )
(et .) S.

20 We e S.:

21 Mi et G o e S.:
22 scripsi: : S.

23 1 Go e S.

19
e S.

2 G o e Sexti cod. (in mg):

24 reluctanter scripsi post R. Hackforth ap. R. Bury (ad S. V. 69):


et Sexti archet.
S.

del. Mi (om. S.)

26 M i et G o e S.:

S.

25 M i e S.
27 M i e S.:

30 : G o e S. (at cf. v. 34)

: S.
addidi: S.

32 , corr. Cr
S. Go

:
29 : addidi

e S. add. M i

34 : G o e S.

33 -

om. S.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

97

Refutatio IV.4.2-5.4

35 , () () ' .

is

20

() ,

[] , ()
,
' '
, ,
,
; '
, ' , , /
,
,
,
. ()
( )
, ()
.
'
() , '
, ' ,

1 - 8 cf. S. V. 86-87
= S. V. 88-89

9-14 cf. S. V. 74; 84-85

14-17 cf. S. V. 75; 77

1 5

2
f. 4r

18-28

35 : S.
35/36 Mi e Sexti codd. (praeter S 1 S 2 , qui
praebent): '
36 Mi ( S.):
36-37 () ' scripsi e S.:
'
1 scripsi (cf. S. V. 85 ):
2 post : hue transposui
3 , delevi: Mi

scripsi: : Diels
addidi e S. (V. 86): add.
suad. Diels
14 (vac. spat. litt. 3) , e S. suppl. Mi
15 Mil
post vac. spat. litt. 4 : suppl. We (cf. S. V. 24 ):
Cr
We e S.:
Cr ( S.):

16 Mi ( S.):
add. Diels
18 , e S. corr. Mi et Go
S.
19 addidi e S.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Hippolytus

98

5 . ,
,
.
() ( )
6
.
.
,
7 . () , , ,
/
' ;
8 ( ) . ( )
,
; )
9 . ' ,
, , '
() ;

pf. 4

25

35

' ,
,
,
2 , , , .
, , ' 5
30-41 - S. V. 92-93
1-5 S. V. 95-96

5 - 7 S. V. 102

22 S. (cf. . 23):
23 ' : S.
24 () et 25
() e S. add. Cr: () coniec. Diels
25
add. suad. Mi
2 Mi e S.
25-26 : Go e S.
26
scripsi e S.:
' , e S. corr. Mi
26-27 . S.
28 ov Mi:
30/31 , corr. Mi
32 : S.
33 om S.
34 scripsi e S.:
Mi e
S.:
add. Go (om. etiam Sexti codd., add. Hervet et Bekker)
35
oi Mi e S.:
:
S.
36/37 : S.
37 Go e S.:
38
39 S.
40-41 () Mi e S.:
41 Mi e S.:

4 . . S.
scripsi e S.:

Go e S.: (et Sexti codd. )

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

99

Refutatio IV.5.5-7.4

, ' , () () , , 3
( ) () ,
( ) ' ;
, , ( )
, ' , ' /
;
( )
,
( ) 5 , () .
, , ( )
'
.

, ( * * ) [ .] , *
, ' . ' '
is ,

7-13 S. V. 97-98

3
4

9 7777: Aet. II. 32.5: 9977 S. E.

6 scripsi e S.:

1 7

12 s. Arat. 56 s. ( = S. V. 98)

7-11 S. V. 105

M i e S.

f. 5

e S. (post ) add. Mi et Go

Mi:
11 () , corr. Mi

1 M i :
codd. cett. et M i

addidi e S.

3 : Cr

6 , corr. Mi

10 ( ) Mi et Go e S.: 13 M i : '
4 scripsi:

7 et Sexti codd. S1 S 2 : - Sexti

, om. S.

S.

8-9 '

10 S.

11 post lac. signif. M i

Go, quae e Sexto explenda est: ( ) , , ,


.

11-12 seel. suad. Go

Diels ( Go) et Mi G o : '


11/12

13/14 Mi:

15 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

100

Hippolytus

. ,
, ,

5 . , ' 2
.
8 1
f. 5

' -
, . * " /
- ,
( ) 5
, , , ,
, ." ,
- -, '
- -,
[ ] '

(). ()
, is
,
,
.
, , 2
, ()
, , ,
, ,

3 - 9 Plat. Tim. 36 c 7 - d 7
94-96 Hiller et al.

14 ss. Tim. 40 ab

23 ss. Tim. 35 be; Theon. Sm. pp.

2 Mi:
5 Mi ex Plat. (cf. v. 19):
ex
Plat. add. Go
7 et 8 , ex Plat. corr. Mi
8/9 ,
corr. Mi
11 , corr. Go
12 seel. suad. We
14 , corr. Go
, corr. Mi et Go
add. Go
17 , corr. Mi
20 , corr. Mi
21 Roeper:


addidi (cf. v. 23)
23 Roeper:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.7.4-9.1

101

() ,
25 ,
, ' ' ', 6
/ (- ' ' ') (* *
* *) ( ) () ' ' ,
() (') '.
30
() ', ()() ',
()() ' ,' 7
()() ,'
() ,' ()
35 ()() ,' ,' ()
()() ,', () ,'-
()() ,', ()
,' ()()
,', () ,' 40 ()() ,', () ,'
()() ,', () ,'.

f. 6

() ' 1 9
()() () .
() '

28 s. perimeter terrae 250,000 stadiorum: Eratosth. ap. Cleomed. De motu circ. 80, p. 146.27
Ziegler; 43, p. 78.24; 55, p. 100.22; 74, p. 134.4; Strab. pp. 113 et 132 Cas.; H. Berger,
Geograph. Fragm. d. Eratosth. (Lipsiae 1880), p. 101 ss.; Gesch. d. wiss. Erdkunde d. Griechen1
(Lips. 1903), p.408 ss.; F. Hultsch, ,Poseidonios ber die Grsse u. Entfernung der Sonne,'
Abh. Gott. Ges., Philol.-hist. Kl., N.F. I. 5 (1897), pp. 8 et 39 n.3
31 Apollonius:
cf. Cleomed. 81, p. 148.10 et P. Tannery, Memoires scientifiques, I (Paris. 1912), pp. 390;
393
32 ss. = Archimed. Op. II, pp. 552-554 Heiberg
2 : Macrob. In somn. Sc. II. 3.13
med. Arenar. 3.2 (II, p. 236.28 Heib.)

3 ( = ,2): Archi-

24 addidi
26 Go: '
' Mi: 5
27 ' ff
suppl. Mi
27-28 lac. ind. Go
28 supplevi suadentibus
Go et We
() ':
29 <'> Roeper: jl
31

': an '? (16 x 80,000 = 1,280,000: cf. F. Hultsch, . c. p. 8)



33 ,' : at ,' IV. 10 . 30
34 <> scripsi:
35 ,1
Go ex IV. 10 . 32: ,'
, corr. Mi
() scripsi:
37 ,' et 38 ,' Go ex IV. 10 . 35: , et ,
1 scripsi:
2 scripsi (cf. IV. 10, . 2): : Mi
scripsi:
3 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

102

f. 6

Hippolytus

()() ,'
5
'
( ) () [ ]
, () ( )
2 .
()
()() ,' () ,'
() () ()()
' '- ()
() ()() ,' / ()
,' ' () () () 15
()() ,' ,'
()() ,', ,' ()
()() ,', () ,'
.
10 1


, ) . () () '
- ' 5
.
2 ' ()
-,

5 : i. e. 3

18 s. : IV. 8 . 29-32

7 ss. Macrob. In somn. II. 3.14 quae tarnen Archimedis dimensio a Piatonicis repudiata est,
quasi dupla et tripla intervalla n o n servans

4 post add. . . Stein, agn. G o et Heiberg


5 del. Mi et
Go
6 G o :
7 addidi et add. Heiberg
G o :
seclusi ut dittographiam (cf. v. 5)
8 scripsi: :
() Heib.
addidi
9 , transposui
10 Mi:
12, 13, 15 et 17 addidi
12 :

: ]5
13 , corr. G o
15 add. Heiberg
18
3
4 scripsi:
8 1 , - - 2

5 , corr. Mi

7 2 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.9.1-10.6

103

10 , * . 3
,
,
( ) ,
is .
[
] . 4

()() ', ,', 20 , ( ,)
,
. /
" ' 5
() ,
25 () , () '
, .
, , ()() ',
,', , ()
30 , ()() ,', () ,', ( )()
() , ()()
,', () ,', ( - 6
, ()() ,', () ,',
) () ,
35 ()() ,', () ,', , ()() ,',
,', , ()() ,', ,', ()
.

f. 7

10 et 12 scripsi: et
11 Mi:
12
13-14 scripsi:
14 addidi
16 scripsi (cf. v. 19/20), We:
16-17
seclusi (cf. .20)
17
, corr. Go
20
addidi (cf. v. 16-17), crux in mg
24 addidi (post add. suad. Mi)
25 addidi
29 : 0,:
2 addidi
30 , corr. Mi
31 coniec. Go, agn. We:
32 - 34 suppl. Stem
ap. Go
34

35 scripsi:
35/36 :
36 ,' Mi et Go ex IV. 8 v. 39: , (ut vid.)
37 , corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

104

11 l

3
pf. 7

Hippolytus

oi () ( )

()
() , '

, ,
, .

,
() .
()() ', ()
,' , /
, ()() ,' () ,'
() ,' ()
,' ()()
,' ,', ()() ,',
,' ,',
,', ()() ,', ,'
()() ,^', ,',
', ,'
() ()() ,', ,',
() ()() ,^', ,'- ()
,^',
,', (') ,~^', ,'.

is

1
add. Go
2
3 Mi:
4 add. Mi
5 , corr. Go
10 scripsi (cf.H IV. 10 w . 16 et
19):
11 1 , - - 2
12 scripsi:
13
post 12 : hue transposui
,' Mi: ,
addidi
, , corr. Mi
14 :
add. Mi
addidi
15 , corr. Mi
16 , corr. Mi
17 scripsi:
,' Mi: ,
18 scripsi: (cf. .22): edd.
,
19 :
,5 , corr. Mi
, , corr. Mi
21 addidi
,' Go:
22 add. We
,) , corr.
Mi
:
addidi
23
Mi et Go: ,
24 '
add. Go
, , corr. Mi
,' Mi: , sed expunxit

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

105

Refutatio I V . l l . 1-14.1

1 12
; , , (), ,
5 , .
() ' ,
. , 2
,
[] ,
/ .

f. 8

, 1 13
,
, (), , ,
5 ,
' ,
, , - 2
, ' , ,
. , '
() () .
,
'
,
,
5 , ,

1 14

c. 14: 3 ss. Ps. Pythag. Epist. p. 249 ss. ed. P. Tannery (Notices et extraits des manuscrits de la
Bibl. Nat., 31.2, 1886) et p. 537 ss. ed. A. M. Desrousseaux (Melanges d'archeologie et d'histoire
6, 1886); F. Dornseiff, Das Alphabet in Mystik u. Magie (Lipsiae 1922), p. 117
3 We:
4 Mi:
6 coniec. Mi: : del. Go
9 1 del. Mi
3/4 , corr. Mi

5 () Diels
Mi:

7 Go (cf. v. 4): We

, corr. Mi
7/8
8 scripsi:
12
Go: : () We
We et Go:

c. 14: 2 Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

106

pf. 8

f. 9

Hippolytus

,
2 . ,
/
, (), ( , ) , () ( ) ,
, () , ()
3 .
, , .

() () (), ()
,
.
4
"
() ,
, < , ',
', ', , ', ' ' ' ' ' ' ' (') ' '- 5 '. ,
' ,
, .
6 .
, .
' ' ' ' '
'. , ,
() , /
7
, ()

15

25

33 et 38 ( = fundus 1) versus ( = fundus 7 s.9): p.250 Tannery, p. 538


Desrousseaux; Terentiani Mauri De litteris 272 {Gramm. Lat. VI, p. 333 Keil) sic Patroclon
(olim) Hectorea manu perisse
9-10 Mi:
10 - 11 supplevi post Mi
11 addidi
12 addidi
13 1 addidi
2 addidi
14 , corr. Go
17 Go:

Go: : Diels
add. G o
19 scripsi
(cf. v. 39):
20 , corr. Mi
Mi (cf. v. 53):
21 1 Go:
addidi
24 ' 3 add. Mi
' Mi:
29 Roeper: : ( ) Mi
32 addidi
33 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.14.1-12

107

,
35 ',
' , - '
' , - "
,
4 ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ', () '.
- ' , ' '
'.
()
45 ,
.
' ',
', () () . ', so ' - ' -
' .

' ' ' - ' '
55 - ' ,
()
- ' / () -

10

11
f. 9

,
' 60 ' ' -, () .
" () 12
() , , ()

35 " Diels:
36 scripsi:
37
Roeper (conl. IV.43 . 53): : We
40 addidi (cf. v. 65)
41 scripsi: : Go

, con. Go
43 add. Mi
45 scripsi:
46 scripsi:
48 addidi
scripsi (cf. v. 58):
addidi
50
scripsi:
52 , corr. Go
53 , corr. Mi
55
: Go
56 add. suad. Mi
57 scripsi:
58 , corr. Go
60 addidi
62 addidi

63 addidi computationis gratia: cf. v. 96 et fundos nominum '


(v. 88), (v. 93), (v. 77), (v. 82), (v. 86),
(v. 95)
scripsi ex coniectura: : ci. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

108

13

14

15

16
f.

17

18

Hippolytus

[]
. ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ', ',
, . ()
[],
0' ,
, , .
, - .
[ ] ,
. ; . ()
, - , ,
. ( ) ',

, ,
. ( - ) ()
', / 0'.
- , ,
, , , . -
, []
. ' -
', '
' ' ;
, ' ' .
()

65

70

75

so

85

68 : cf. . 73 ss.
87 Iliad. 23. 708 ss.
90 Iliad. 23. 778 s.
91 s. Terent.
Mauri De litt. 273 sic Hectora tradunt cecidisse mox Achilli; Petosirid. frr. 37-39 Riess
64 seclusi
66
67 , transp. Go
() , transp.
Mi
68 del. suad. Mi
72 Go:
seclusi
73
74 , corr. Mi
addidi
75
Diels:
77 addidi (cf. v. 87-88)
78 Mi:

scripsi: (sed expunxit)
79 , transposui
81 1 add. Mi
:
82 "
83 scripsi:
86
delevi
88
(recte, quia solae litterae vocales bis positae semel
computantur): Diels, We
89
91 addidi
91, 92, 93, 94
scripsi comput. gr. ( = 22): ubique

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

109

Refutatio IV.14.12-15.3

() , .
() ,
.
95 , .
, 19
, ,
,
, , () ,
. 20
, ' ()
() ', ', (', ) ', . , '
los , , , .
, ' 1 15
/ .
[]
5 (). 2
, () ,
() , ' ,
' (') .

;
' 3
' ,
() ' , -

f.

96 ss. Ps. Pythag. fr. II (cod. Par. 2426), p. 253 ss. Tannery
11 - IV. 27 v. 10 ed. R. Foerster in Script, physiognom. II, pp. 3 4 1 - 3 4 6

92 addidi
Mi

93 addidi

101 addidi (cf. . 102)

96

99 2 add.

102 add. Mi

103 ',

addidi (cf. v. 102)

4 del. Mi

5 - , corr. Mi

Mi
We

7 addidi
12 Go:

6 :

8 ' addidi

13

: '

' coniec. Mi: '

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

110

f.

Hippolytus

' - ( ) ,
4 -, . - is
,
() () ,
() ()
() () - ,
, , , 2
(), , , ,
5 , , . , ,
, , , , , , , , , , , 25
, / (), , , ,
, , , , , , , '
,
.
30
16 1

) - ,
, ,
, , ,

19 ss. cf. cod. Par. Gr. 2494 ff. 142 v -144 r (Catal. codd. astrobg. Gr. VIII. 3 [1912], p. 69);
CCAG VIII. 2 (1911), p.58 s.; VII (1908), p. 194 ss.; Vett. Val. I. 2, p.5.22 ss. Kroll;
Hephaest. Theb. Apotelesmat. I. 1; Manil. 4. 122 ss.; Ptolem. Apotelesmat. III. 12 et 14
(Hephaest. II. 12 et 15) et al.
14 addidi

16 Cr:
16-17
() () scripsi (cf. Sext. Emp. Adv. math. V. 103):
: () ()
coniec. We
18 add. Go
19 add. Mi
Foerster:

20-21 () Foerster (cf. IV. 18 . 3):
: () Diels: () (mobilibus) coniec. Mi:
. () (subloquacibus) coniec. Go: . () coniec. We ( Par. 2494 - Par.)
21
23 Mi Par.:
26 <&> (increduli) conieci:
- (hic et alibi) 2 : - 1
27 , : Go We
27/28 Mi:
We
28 : Go: Diels We
2 : 1
29
2
Go: : () coniec. We
(conl. Par. , )
2-3
, transposui post Go ( Par.)
3

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.15.3-18.2

111

, , ,
5 , , ( ,)
, , - 2
, , , , , , , ', , ,
, , , ,
, - [ ] ,
, , .
, , 1 17
, , , , - ,
() , , , , (
5 ) , (,) , , [ ] . 2
, , , iigc , , [
, ] , , , ,
, , () , , ,
, / .
f.
, , 1 18
, , , ,
, , . 2
4 , transposui (cf. IV. 19 . 2)
scripsi (cf.
IV. 24 . 2):
5 ex . 10 hue transtuli

6 , coniec. Mi (conl. Manil. 4.150 corpora
tarda / mole valent; cf. etiam v. 8 et Luciani De luctu 16 ):
, coniec. Foerster
6
10 Mi:
in . 5 transtuli: . Go
1, - - 3
2 (cf. IV. 19 . 4; IV. 24 . 3 et Plat. Leg. 795 e 4): Go et Foerster (
Par., s. . )
2 coniec. Mi: :
Roeper
2/3 scripsi: : Roeper
3 : Go
4 add. suad. We
( )
coniec. Mi, ( ) Cr

4-5 addidi
post Mi (in v. 8), cf. IV. 18 v. 5
5 (cf. IV. 19 . 7):
Mi (ex v.6)
addidi (cf. Par., s.v.
)
6 seel. Mi

post . 3 transtulit Diels, at cf. IV. 25


7
7 - 8 seel. Foerster
9 , corr. Mi
:
coniec. Foerster
c. 18: 1 scripsi: : Go: s. coniec. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

112

Hippolytus

, , , , , ,
, , , 5
, () .
19 1

, ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
2 , , ,
, , , 5
, , , , () ,
(), , () ,
, , , , , ,
, , , , .

20

, , , , , , ,
() , , () ,
2 , . , ,
, , , , , 5
, , , [,] , ,
, , , ,
, () () ()
, .

4 coniec. Foerster:

6 addidi

1

2 scripsi: :
Foerster
scripsi:
4
2 scripsi (cf. v. 4):

scripsi (cf. . 4 ):
6
7
coniec. We (cf. Vett. Val. p. 5.31 Kroll): litt, rubricatis add. 3 : coniec. Go
3 : 1
coniec. Go:
9
Mi:
3 () scripsi (cf. IV. 24 . 3), Diels (conl. CCAG
VII, p.202.8 , sed s.v. ): I
: Mi: Diels

5 scripsi:
6 scripsi (cf. IV. 23 . 3):
: Roeper
7 seclusi (cf. v. 4)
9 add. suad. We (conl.
Vett. Val. p. 10.14 Kr. ; cf. et. Ptolem. Apotelesmat. IV. 4.3, p. 180.1 BollBoer )
coniec. Mi:
2 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

113

Refutatio IV. 18.2-24.1

, / , , , 1 21
, , , , ,
, , , , .
, , , 2
, , , ,
( ), , , , ,
[,] , - ,
() , , , , ,
- .
- , , f , f 1
, ,
, , , , ,
(). - , , 2
, , , ,
, , , , .

f. 2

22

- , , 1 23
, , () , , . 2
- , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , , , , ,
, , , .
- , , , 1 24
, , ,
, , .

3 : coniec. Go
3 - 4 in mg 1
4 coniec. Mi: : coniec. We
6 () scripsi (cf.
Hephaest.1.1.70 Pingree ): coniec. Foerster: :
coniec. Mi
7 seclusi (cf. v. 5)
- seel. Mi
: Diels
8 addidi

()
coniec. Mi
1 1 , 3 : Mi: coniec. Foerster: coniec. Diels: ()() (cf. [leg. ] Par.) coniecerim
2 del. Foerster (at cf.
Par. )
4 & (cum signo ./.)
2 Mi: : corruptum We
scripsi (cf.
IV. 21 v. 1):
6 : coniec. We

post 5 : hue transposui
1 Go et Foerster: , Mi We

Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

114

f. 2

Hippolytus

2 oi - , ,
[,] , , , , / 5
, , , , , , ,
, , ( ,) .
25 1

( , ) , , , , , ( .) , , , ,
. () 2 (). - , , , 5
, , , , , ,
, [ ] ,
( ) ,
.

26 1
, , ,
2 , , ,
, , , () , '
, , , ,
, , , , . 5
27 1

' , '

5 seclusi (cf. v. 6)
7 - 2 , - 1
( Par.)

addidi

1 , supplevi (cf. IV. 18 . 1; 23 . 1)


scripsi:
1/2 Go:
2 ex . 7 hue transtuli
4 2 litt. rubr. sscr. 3 : locus sanus (cf. Par. , ;
Vett. Valens p. 10.23 Kr. ; IV. 21 . 5 ): post lac. indie. We
5 , corr. Mi
6
scripsi (cf. Firmic. Matern. Mathes. VIII. 29.10 perpetuis laboribus opprimentur):
: coniec. Mi: coniec. We
coniec. Mi:
7 seclusi (cf. v. 2); , corr. Mi
9 seel. Mi
8 (locus sanus: cf. Firmic. Matern. VIII. 29.14 erunt
equorum magistri): corruptum Go We
() Cr: : ' coniec. Foerster
c. 26: 3 add. suad. Go
c.27: 2 : coniec. Roeper: Diels We
3 Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.24.2-28.3

115

() ; 2
5 ' , () () ,

, () ,
, ( ) ,

( * *)

/ * * () 1 28 f. i3r
* , ,
, ' ()
, & 2
5
- (' )
, () , '
. ( ,) 3

4 ss. IV. 6.3; 50.2; Sext. Emp. Adv. math. V. 97-98; Achillis Isagog. exc. 40, p. 75 Maass;
Cie. De nat. deor. 2.104 ut ex notarum figurarum similitudine nomina invenerint
c. 28: 1 De cc. 28-42 cf. R. Ganschinietz, T. U. 39.2 (1913) - Ga.
2 : Apul.
pol. 42 ss. et . Abt, Die Apologie des Apuleius und die antike Zauberei, R G W 4.2 (1908),
p. 158 ss.; Origen. De prineip. III. 3.3 et al.
5 s. Lucian. Alex. 13; Ga. p. 33 s.
4 1 : 3 Mi
: coniec. Diels: s.
coniec. We
addidi
: coniec. We
5 () scripsi: 1 corr. in 3 : Mi: Roeper:
' Go
addidi (cf. Musaei Rhen. vol. 107 p. 151 s.)
8
addidi
9 addidi
2 scripsi: 1, expunxit 3
post
3 lac. indie. Mi
1 ante in litterae prorsus evanidae 10: . (s. ) . . . . . ut vid.: Cr,
Ga. p. 31: () ()() coniecerim
1 ab usque ad v. 15 in mg. a 1 scriptum
scripsi:
( ) We:
2 post in litt, evanidae 9: () () coniecerim: Mi, Roeper
Go, Cr, C. Graux (Revue de philologie 1880, p. 82), Ga., coniec. We
( corr. ex ) 1 : Go
4 Roeper Go: We
2 coniec. We:
5 scripsi:

6 Mi: : ' coniec. We
' addidi

scripsi: , Mi
7 Ga. . 34:
9 addidi
post Roeperum (ante )

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

116

Hippolytus

* () (*) (
) () . () , ,
()() () -
, - , .
4

( ) (,)
, ' ,
, ' . - ,
5 ' ,
, () () ()
, ,
. -
() , .

,
. -
, ,
' , . -

11 = Copt. ph-Re: R. Wuensch, Archiv f . Rel. 12 (1909), p.9; Ga. p.36 s.


16 ss. Philon. Byz. Mechan. syntax. V, p. 102.31 Schoene; C. Graux, o.e. p.82 ss.; Ga.
pp. 31 s. et 38 s.

10 post lacunam suspicor


ante () in litt, evanidae 5: (' )
conieci: ( ) coniec. Gu. Kroll ap. Ga. p. 35
post () novam lacunam
suspicor
10-11 post Cr supplevi ex v. 27
11 ( )
Mi (in Addendis) ex v. 28:
( ) : coniec. We
13 scripsi: ut vid.: coniec. Roeper: Cr: We
15 : Mi, Roeper
Cr: (in mg.)
(in textu)
16 addidi
scripsi: () ut vid.: Mi
addidi
17
19 Mi:
20
Mi:
. . . scripsi: . . .
22
addidi (cf. v. 4 2 )
2 addidi
, corr.
Mi
23 Mi:
Mi: We
25 add. Go
28 , corr. Mi
29 Go: , def. Ga. (p. 40 n. 1)
et We
: coniec. Mi, We
30 , corr. Mi
-

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.28.3-11

117

() . , 7
,
, .
35 ,
,
, , ' () 8
, , '
() , ()() , ,
() (),
40
.
/ ,

f. n v

.
, - 9
45 [ ] ,
(,) -
, ' .
,
so . , 10
()
, , ,
()
.
55
( ) ( ) , 11
, , ,
, (
) . ,

44 : Lucian. Alex. 26

56 : Ga. .43

31 , corr. Mi
31/32 coniec. Mi: We:
Go
32 Go
34 1 scripsi:
35 -
37
38 scripsi:
39 addidi: s. ex . 48 add. suad.
Mi
, coniec. Mi, We et Go: :
Go Ga. p.41
40 1 addidi
:
() coniec.
Mi: , Mi
45 seel. Diels
46 (,) Mi
(cf. v. 52):
51 add. Mi
53 addidi
55 Go:

56 scripsi:
57
Go:

57/58 addidi
58 Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

118

f. 4

Hippolytus

,
, 6
12 .
() () ,
.
[
] 65
, /
()

< 13 , 7
, .
() .
.
75
29 1

() -
,
,
, ' .

30 1


,
(), ,
64 Ga. . 43 s.
72 ss. Plin. Nat. hist. 37. 48; Ga. p. 44
23.26; 22.140; 19.23; Ga. p.45

c.30: 4 s. Plin. Nat. hist.

59 , corr. Roeper
Go:
62 ( )
() coniec. Mi:
63 :
Roeper Go
64-65 - seclusi
66
67 del.
suad. We
add. Diels
71 scripsi:
1
73 () Mi:
c.29: 1 addidi
Mi:
(at cf. Luciani Amor. 14)
3 . . . Cr: . . .
Mi
, corr. Mi
4 , corr. Mi

2 coniec. Go
, corr.

c. 30: 1 Mi:
2 & coniec. Mi: :
Go
3 Mi:
-
4 scripsi (cf. v. 1):
: Mi: G o

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

119

Refutatio IV.28.11-32.1

' (). 2
, , () , .
()
.

10

() , ' 1 31
,
' , / '
f. 4
().
,
() , 2
,
,
- ,
() , -
.
() 1 32
() ()
. , ,
,
, .

7 - 9 Ps.Democriti De sympath. et antipath. 31 Gemoll


c.31: 1-3 Aristot. Hist. anim. A 11, p.492 a 14; Varron. De re rust. II. 3,5; Plin. N.h.
8.202; Aelian. Hist. anim. 1.53
3 s. Antigoni De mirab. 60, p. 18 Keller; Ga. p. 46
5 s. Plin. 9.184; Ga. p.46
c.32: 1 ss. Schol. in Aristoph. Nub. 294 ( = Suda, s.v. ); Poll. 4.130; Fest., s.v.
Claudiana tonitrua; Ga. p.48 n.4
5 '
scripsi:
7 , corr. Mi
8

6 Mi:
scripsi:

addidi

c. 31: 1 , corr. Go
4 Ga.:
: Roeper
addidi
5 -
6 addidi
7
10 Diels:

11 Meineke (Zs. f . d.
Altertumswiss. 10, 1852, p. 375): : Cr
c.32: 1 addidi
2 addidi
3 Mi:
6 Go

3 Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

120

Hippolytus

, []
, . '
, , ,
,
,

, ,
3 . ,
( ) () - is
,

f. 5

, / ,
( )
,
()
2
5 ' ()
(, ) ,
,

' () , '
25
, ' ( ) ,
, , () ().

17-27 cf. Ud. ab Wilamowitz, Comment, gramm. III p. 39 s.; Ga. p. 54 ss.
17
: cf. I. Schwabl, RE A (1972), p.280 s.; Aristid. Or. 42.4; 47.45 et 78;
50.46 Keil; Ga. p. 56 s. et al.
7 del. Mi et Roeper
: coniec. Mi, def. Ga.
10 -
in mg. litt. rubr. P 3
11 : Mi

13 bis
14 scripsi: -
15 ( ) ()
scripsi: : coniec. Mi: . Gu. Benson:
Go: We
17 Mi: '
om. 1 , litt. rubr. sscr. 3
18 Mi, G. Butler, F.I.. Hort
et Roeper:
19
20
Roeper: : Meineke (cf. Verg. Aen. 6.132)
21 Meineke:
coniec. Mi:

Wilamowitz: : Meineke
22 suppl. Wilamowitz (cf. v. 23
) et addidi
: Wilamowitz
' ,
corr. Wilamowitz

23 : Mi
24
Mi:
Mi
25 ' 1 Mi: '
3 , 1 1
Meineke, Cr:
' 2 Mi:
26 '
: . Monro et F. Hort
Mi (- Diels):
27 add. Go
add. Meineke

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.32.2-33.4

is

20

25

121

, . ,
- ,
.
. () ,
,
,
.
, ' , . ()
, ' , ()
, , .
, , () - ,
, / , , ,
' () ,
, ,
. ' ,
, , ,
[] , ()
() , .

.
, ' ,
, -

7 ss. Ga . 49 s.

14 ss. Ga p. 51 s.

1 33

3
f. isv

25 ss. Ga. p. 53

1
2
4
6 : coniec. Kroll ap. Ga.
7 add. Go
9
10

11
addidi
12
coniec. We:

1.3/14 () , corr. Mi
14 , corr. Go
Diels:
15 addidi
16 bis
coniec.
Mi
18 1 add. suad. Mi
20 scripsi:
21
coniec. Go:

22 1 delevi
post lac.
susp. Mi et Go: gravius interp. Ga. (p. 51) et We, ad v. 23 referentesl
addidi conl. Galeni vol.13 p. 626 K.
23 scripsi:
, - p p - edd.: coniec. Mi
addidi post Mi
et v. 24

24 del. Ga. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

122

Hippolytus

' ,
' ,
.
3
34 1

f. 6

[] ' () ' , , ,

. ( ) , 5
, / , () ,
,
2 . ()
,
, ,
' []
3 , ()
is
() , ,
() [] ,
. ,
.
()() , 2
4
-
, .
-

5 ss. Lucian. Alex. 21; Ga. pp. 13 s. et 61 s.


28 Ga. p. 53:

30 coniec. Go

1 del. Go: Mi
2 () ' scripsi: ' : '
coniec. Mi: Go: ' coniec. We
5
addidi conl. v. 10 et Luciani Alex. 21

6

1 , - - 3 : Go
7 bis
10 , corr. Mi
[]
We
addidi
13 , corr. Mi
del. Go: () Diels
14 2 add. Go
16 1 add. Mi
17 2 seclusi
scripsi:
19 Mi:
20 Diels:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

123

Refutatio IV.33.4-35.4

25 ' * . ,
.

is

20

' .

, / , .
, (), . ,

.
,
' .
, (*)

, .

,
' , ,
, .
, '

8 s. cf. Apul. Apol.

1 35
f. 6
2

4 2 (. 49.16 Helm) puerum in aqua simulacrum Mercuri contem-

plantem; A. Abt, Die Apologie,

p. 171 ss.; Ga. p . 6 2 s.; 70 s.; RE XII, p.. 1879 ss.

12 ss. cf. IV. 32 . 14 ss.; Ga. p. 63 ss.


25 scripsi:

post in vac. spat. litt. 7: s. s.

coniec. Mi, Go, We


scripsi:
2 , corr. Mi
coniec. W e

3 Go:

4 Mi:

: coniec. Cr:
7 Ga. (. 62), We:

7 Mi: 1 , - 2 (ut vid.)

10 scripsi:
lac. susp. Mi

2 5 / 2 6

26 G o :

Go:

11 : coniec. W e

13 post

2 0 Mi: We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

124

f. 7

Hippolytus

, & , , , ,
, ,
/ ,
5 ' ,
, ,
' .

25

36 1

' ' ,
,
.
, (),
, ' () , 5
2 ,
- , ,
, , .

37 1


- ,
() ' ,
() ,
, s
2 '
, , ,

22-29 Ga. . 65 ss.

c. 37: 1 ss.: Ga. p. 69 ss.

22 (cf. Orph. hymn.


p. 682)
23 Mi:
1.8 ): -
26 Meineke et Go
- sscr. 3 : Mi
(cf. Ga. p. 68 s.):
c. 36: 4 addidi

51.9 ): coniec. Mi: ) Bergk (PLG4,



Meineke (cf. Orph. hymn.
24 1 , - - sscr. rubr. 3
1 , - - 2
(cf. Iliad. 10.298; Theocr. 2.13): () 1 , 2 ,

28 Mi:

Wilamowitz

c. 37: 1 Go:
3 addidi

4
, corr. Mi
6 ' Cr: ' : ' coniec. Mi, agn. We
scripsi: : () coniec. Mi, agn. We: coniec. Cr.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.35.5-39.1

is

20

25

125

() , / ,
() ,
() ,
() , 3
()
,
() (*) () '
,
, () () . 4

' ,
()
. ,
, .
[] , , .

f. 7

() , 1 38
()
.
, , ( 1 39
) '
(* *)

c. 38: 1 ss. Ga. . 73


8 addidi
9 addidi
9 - 1 0 coniec.
We:
11 : :
Ga. (. 71)
, corr. Mi
: coniec. Mi
11-12
() scripsi ex coniectura: :
coniec. Ga.
14 addidi
post lacunam suspicor
:
edd.
addidi
We:
15 Diels:
16 Mi:
19 addidi (cf. v. 21)
22
(cf. Plut. Mor. 696 ): Cr
22/23 , corr. Mi
23 del. Mi
24 : Diels
c. 38: 1 add. Mi

c. 39: 1 - 2 supplevi

3 post

lac. sign. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

126
40 1
F. 8

Hippolytus

() () (
) ,
/ ,
, ,
() .
5

41 1

( )
- , ( )
,
, , '
2 - () 5
,
, .
, ,
,
.

42 1

,
,
,
,
2 . , , 5
, ,
,
,
[] ().

c.41: 1 ss.: Abt . 142 ss.; Ga. p.73 ss.

5 ss.: IV. 28.9

1 () () scripsi: : Go
1-2 supplevi
2
3
1 , 3
5 scripsi:

c.41: 1 ( ) scripsi (cf. v.4): : Go
om. 1 , litt. rubr. add. 3
, corr. Mi
addidi
add. Mi
4 Mi:
5 addidi
10 in mg. 1
8 , corr. Mi
c.42: 2 , corr. Mi
4 scripsi:
Go:
7 scripsi:
9 1 del. Mi

2
post 7 usque ad

6 -

9-10 Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.40.1-43.5

127

, , , 3
/ , f. isv
, 15 .

is


,
, , ,
.
-
- ,
, ' . , (') ()
(), () , []
,
, .
,
,
() () -
, .
,
(*) , ()
/
, . , ,
' '
() ,
() , ( )
6 ss. I. 26.3
12 Mi:

1 43

4
f. 9
5

18 V. 7.22; Herodot. .2
14 Mi:

4 , corr. Mi
5 scripsi:
6 : Roeper
9 ' add.
Cr
post add. We
add. suad. Mi (post )
10 scripsi:
scripsi (cf. I. 26.3):
: Cr
del. suad. We
12 1 , - 2
16 Mi:

add. R. Scott
19 post lac. ind. Go
Mi:

Mi (cf. v. 54):
Go:
21
coniec. Mi:
23 , corr. Mi
24 2 addidi

addidi et add. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

128

f. 9

Hippolytus

, 25
, .
6 , ()
,

, , () 3
7 ' ' ' ['].
()
, ,
[] ' () '.
8 ( ) () 35
,
, . () ,
()
, ,
() , () , 4
9 - /
- - ,
, , ,
, .
45
10 ,
, - () ,
. ' ,
,
.
so
11
'
() , ,
().

31 cf. Theon. Sm. Math. p. 23.11 Hiller


27 scripsi:
: We
2 addidi
28 :
Roeper
Mi:
29 We:
post in vac. spat. litt. 22, sed nihil deest
31 5 P, del. suad. Cr
32 Mi:

34 1 delevi
2 addidi
35 coniec. Mi:
supplevi (cf. v. 37 )
scripsi:
2 addidi
36 scripsi:
Roeper:

37
addidi
40 add. Mi
addidi
42 scripsi:
47 add.
Cr
49 post lac. susp. Mi
51 Roeper:
52
, Go:
53
Go: : Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

129

Refutatio IV.43.5^14.3

,
55 ( ) ( ) () ( )
, ( )

12

, ,
- ( ) ,
,
6 , () . - -

13

' - ',
. ' ,
, . /
( ) []

1 44

f. 20'

( )
,
.
5 , "
, , , ,
, ( ) , ( )

, , ( )
.
,
. ( ) -

, . , , ( )

6 cf. Aristot. Metaph. A 5, p. 986 a 24

8 ss. cf. Serv. In Verg. Eel. 8.75 medendi

causa multarumque rerum impares numeros servari; : pro amuleto collo


appendentes
55 Roeper:
addidi
56 -
addidi
5 7 - 5 8 scripsi:
58 ' a d d . Go
61 , corr. Mi
1 addidi: add. suad. Mi, Cr, We

add. Mi
scripsi (- , , ):

2 , corr. Mi
coniec. Mi: -

add. suad. Mi
3 5 , corr. Mi
6 ,

transposui
7 Cr:
add. C r ( paraphr.
in mg. )
scripsi:
scripsi: : ()
Diels
8 , transp. G. Pasquali: del. Cr We
, con. C r
)
spat. litt. 7

11 addidi (medici nomen proprium computatur: cf. v. 9


1 , - 2

13 : () coniec. We

12 post in vac.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

130

Hippolytus

, oi .
, ' .
is
45 1

. '
,
.

, () 5
()
2 / .

() ,
,
, ' ' , '
, ' () .

pf. 2

46

f. 2

() ,
,
,

5
2 , ,
( )
, , , () ,
, ( ) ' 3 , ( ) /

15 Go:
c.45: 1 M i :
3 , 1

' : ' Go: We

3 scripsi:

5 Go:

10

post . 11 : hue transtuli


addidi (cf. VI. 20.2)

12-13 '... ' , corr. Go

c. 46: 1 addidi

2 scripsi: -

5 scripsi: -

Cr:

7 add. M i

11 scripsi:

4 scripsi:
: We
12 oi : G o

addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

131

Refutatio IV.44.3-47.2

,
, (
is , , 4
, ,
- ,
-
20
. () 5

, ().
6
25

()
'
- - ' ' , '
, '
, ' ().

30

- 1 47
-
, .
, ,
5 . ' ( ) - () ' , 2
() ,
/ , , f. 2

15 ss. Athen. 390 F - 391 A; Aristot. Hist. anim. 12, p. 597 b 25

25 ss. Arat.

19-23
1 ss. cf. V. 8.34-35

3-5 Arat. 45 s. et 57; V. 16.15

6 Job 1:7

' .
16 1, -- sscr. 2
19 -
, corr. Mi

25
1, -- 2
29 1, corr. 2

21 addidi

22 28 -

1 Mi:
2 post add. Mi
4-5 , ()
coniecerim
5 , transposui
: Go
add. We
5/6 Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

132

Hippolytus

,
3 .
, '
,
, , .

,

is

4 () ,
, ,
,
, . '
() ' - 2
,
5 . ,

,
, 25
, , , , , ,

.
48 1 () -
f. 22
- , / []

10 ss. cf. I. Gundel in RE IX A, p. 1040.66 ss.


14 s. Arat. 61 s.
19 ss. Arat.
63-67 et 73; Fr. Boll, Sphaera (Lipsiae 1903), p. 100 ss.; A. Rehm in RE V, p. 2563 ss.
25-28 Gn 3 : 1 5 ; cf. Gu. Gundel in RE III A, p.2423.1 ss.
29 Arat. 70; V. 16.16
1 s. Arat. 615; 71 et al.

2 s. Arat. 66-68

10 , corr. Mi
11
14 : Aratus
15


16 addidi
Go:
: ( ) coniec. Mi
18 : Diels
19
20
Mi:

24 post , transposui
28 1 ,
- 2
29 : Aratus et V. 16.16
: Arat.
1 scripsi:

Mi:

2 delevi

coniec. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.47.2-48.6

133

, .
,
5 . 2

' '
, ' () .
() ,
(*)
, . , , 3

, (*)
[ ],
is - ,
, , , 4
() , ()
[ ], '
,
20 ' (), () ,
() . , 5
()
() ()
() / ,

f. 22

25 ", .
, , ( ) , 6
,
, .

5 Schol. in Arat. 268 (p. 211.10 Martin)


7 s. Arat. 268 s.
9 s. cf. Lucian.
De astrol. 10
10 s. Gn 2 : 2 ; VI. 14.1
19 s. Arat. 82 s.; 86 s. et al.
21 ss.
Arat. 74-87 et al.
3 Mi:
5 R. Scott:
Diels:

6 scripsi:
7 ' om. Arat.
' Mi:
8
' : Arat.
9 add. suad. Mi
10 post lacuna: coniec. Roeper
13 post lacuna (exspectes
): add. Mi ( Go)
14 - seclusi (cf.
v. 18)
17
add. Go
18 seel.
Roeper
19 , corr. Go
20 addidi
21 Mi:
23 scripsi:
26 addidi et add. suad. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

134

pf. 23

10

11

Hippolytus

, , ,
, , , () []
, ( )
, ' ,
(),
, .
, , () ,
" - - ()

- -,
()
, . ()
, ,
- , , .
() () ,
().
() , , /
,
.
, , () , ,
, , ,
' ' () ,
() . ,
,
, , ()
, - . - , ,

35

45

so

55

29 ss. Arat. 26 ss.; I. Gundel in RE IX A, pp. 1038.10 ss.; 1047.25 ss.


35 s. Arat. 37 s.;
Schol. in Arat. 39 (p. 89.2 Martin); Ovid. Fast. 3.107 s.
37 ss. Schol. in Arat. 35 et
37; RE VII, p. 2859.21 ss.
41 s. cf. Eph 4 : 2 4
42 Mt 7:14
43 s. Arat.
44
48 Herodot. 1.1
29 Go:
coniec. Mi:
Roeper:

30 addidi
delevi
31 add. Cr
33 addidi
(cf. v. 31)
35 addidi
36 addidi
39 add. Cr
40 I
() scripsi:
43 Mi:
addidi (cf. v. 50)
45 addidi
46 , corr. Mi
48 - 1 , -- 2
49
addidi
50 3 del. suad. We
51 addidi
52 () scripsi:
: Go: () Cr
54 scripsi:
55 :
coniec. We
scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

135

Refutatio IV.48.7-49.1

60

65

70

75

-
. ()

, ()
() , 12
-
(). , , , ,
, () () ()
() ,
() , , () , ,
, () , 13
()() .
()(), /
, () - ()
() . 14
, , . , , (
) , .
() , ' , ,
,

f. 23

' .
, , () ()
,
. , ()
, ,

56 s. Arat. 332-335

60 s. cf. Mc. 4 : 1 7

64 Act 10:42

49

77 Arat. 179

57 Mi ex Arato: ()
addidi
60 addidi
61 scripsi:
( ) scripsi: : ' Mi
62 :
Cr
63 -
64 2 add. Mi
addidi (cf. v. 66)
64-65
Go: : () coniec. We
65 scripsi:

66 addidi
67 2 addidi
70 add. Cr
71
, corr. Roeper
1 add. Cr
72 addidi
73-74
addidi et add. suad. Cr
74 Mi:
75 () scripsi
(cf. VIII. 10.2): : Cr: del. suad. We
77 Mi ex Arato:
1 2 add. Cr

4 2 Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

136

f. 24r

Hippolytus

2 , , . ' ' 5
() '
, [] ,
, , , .
()() ,
3 .
, ( ) ", , ()
, , /
,
() , .
4 15
,
, , '
.
50

,
,
, .
, ,
2 , , 5
,
() , .

' - () ()() -
() -, ()
5 ss. Arat. 354 .
11 ": Arat.
272-281; Schol. in Arat. 275 (p. 216.1 Martin); Eratosth. Cataster. 25
13 Plat.
Phaed. 67 c 1
5 ss. IV. 6.3; IV. 27.2; Sext. Emp. Adv. math. V. 97 s.; Achill. Isagog. 40, p.75.7 Maass
9 Fr. Boll, Sphaera, p. 246 ss.
5 ' scripsi:
6 addidi
, corr. Mi
6 - 7 ,
scripsi:
7 del. suad. We
10
post . 11 , hue transtuli
11 addidi
12
Mi:
14
16 Go: : del.
Mi
18 1 , corr. 2
5 Mi: : Go
7 1 addidi
scripsi ex et
Sexto: : Mi
10 addidi
10/11 -
11 ( ) Cr
Cr:
12 Cr:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.49.2-51.5

137

, () () ()()
();

is

20

' / 1 51 f. 24
,
() -
, ' ' -, ,

. () () - 2
-,


. , , ,
() '
[ ] . 3
[ ],
, , ( ) ,
,
, () , ,
.

/ () 4
() - (), , -, '
, '
25 , ,
. , , 5

f. 25

13 ss. Sext. Emp. Adv. math. III. 19 s.; IV. 4 ss.; VII. 99 s.; Philon. De opif. mundi 49;
De decal. 24 ss.; Euclid. Elem. I d e f . l ; 3; 6; XI def.2 et Schol. V, p. 78.15 Heiberg
18 s. V. 9.5; VI. 14.6
21-^7 = I. 2.5-10
13 addidi

14 addidi (cf. v. 3)

2 , corr. Mi
7 addidi
, corr.
Mi
8 Mi:
9
12 v addidi
13
seclusi ut dittographiam
14 seclusi
16-17
supplevi
20 , corr. Go
21 scripsi ex :
22 addidi ex
addidi ex
25 et 27 :
26 bis

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

138

Hippolytus

, ,
. '
, , []
6 , . 3
[] - -, ' , ,
, , , ,
7 ' .
,
35
() '

pf. 25

, ()
.
, () () ,
8 , , , , ()
() () , - / ' ,
- ,
,
, ,
, , , , , , .
9
, .
() - , , , ,
, , ,
, , , , ,
( ) ()
() , '
.

50 s. VI. 12.2

45

so

55

51 s. VI. 29.6-7

29 delevi (om.H)
31 del. Go (om. )
34
Mi ex :
36 addidi ex

37 1 Go
ex :
2 addidi ex
38 scripsi ex :
40 scripsi
ex :
1 addidi ex
41 Go ex : ()()
41/42
42 , ex corr. Mi

44 Mi ex :
45 We ex : -
50 addidi
53 Roeper: '
add. Mi
54 () Mi
add. Go
54-55 ' scripsi: '

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio IV.51.5-14

60

65

70

75

139

,
,

&.
()() ,
. , ()
,
, / ,
, ,
,
,
, ,
.
. ()
, ()
, . ()
, ( )
, -
(*) , .
(*)
, ,
, () , (), ()
,
, ().

10

11

f. 26'
12

13

14

56 ss. V. 17.11-12
63 : cf. Galeni De usu part. VIII. 11 (I, p. 484.9
Helmreich)
66 : Gal. VIII. 14 (I, p.489.14 ss. H.)
71 s. cf. e.g. Gal.
IX. 4 (II, p. 12.20 H.)
73 1 Tm 6 : 2 0
58 Go
59 post signum ./. in
62 Mi:
65 . , corr. Mi
66 , corr. Mi
74
scripsi:
75-76 ( ) scripsi:

76 post lacuna: conieci (cf.
w . 6 6 ; 71; 74): coniec. Mi
78 post novam lacunam suspicor
: coniec. We
80 : Diels
81 scripsi:
addidi
83 post spatio relicto 5

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM


/
() , ,
, ' .
,
, ' .
, '

.
,
, '
.

1 ' in mg. sup. litt. rubr. 3


3

5 oi Go:
8
9
'
10-

13 , corr. Mi

14 post
add. 1

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V. 1.-6.4

is

20

141

() ' ()

(*) , , ()
,
()() () - ' ,
() ,
, /
.

,
()
,
() ,
- - -
, .
()
, ,
.

1 6

f.
3

12 - V. 11.1: cf. Foerster, I, pp.336-362


16 ss.: de Naassenis cf. R.P. Casey, J.T.S.
27 (1925-26), pp. 374-387; I. Schlier, 'Der Mensch im Gnostizismus': Anthoropologie
religieuse (Numinis Suppl.2, Lugduni Batav. 1955), 60-76; I.-M. Schenke, Der Gott
Mensch"in der Gnosis (Gottingae 1962), cap. 8; Gu. Foerster, 'Die Naassener', Studi di storia
religiosa della tarda antichit (Messanae 1968), pp.21-33; I. Bergman, Proceedings of the
Internat. Colloquium on Gnosticism (Stockholmiae 1977), pp. 74-100, et al.
17 =
Hebr. ah ash, serpens; cf. V. 9.11-13; 26.22-23
18 TO : 1 Cor 2 : 1 0 ; Rm
11:33; Clem. Strom.V. 88.5 ; VI. 30.7; Acta Thomae 143; G.
Kittel, Th. Wb. z. NT, I, p. 515 s.
1 addidi (cf. v. 8)
'
lac. sign. Mi, qui coniecit ()
coniec. We: pro
4/5 corr. in
addidi
8 coniec.

14 () Cr: '

2 add. Go
4 post
: (, ) sine lac. Go, agn. Cr We
7
Mi: Go I
Mi
9 ()
10
16 oi add. Mi
17 Roeper:

19 add. Mi
20 . Usener (Das Weihnachtsfest2, Bonnae 1911, p. 141
n. 30) conl. . V. 11 v. 6/7:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

142

pf. 27

Hippolytus

()
5 () , ' .
- , ' , ' 25
,
, , ,
6 , ,
, , , ,
, - 3
(, )
7 . , ,
( ) ,
, (), , /
, 35
' , , , -
, , , - ,
, .
7 1

(), , .
' () ,
, , -
-, , , 5

24 s. et 28-38: . 9.1-3
26 s.: VIII. 12.5; Synes. Hymn. 5 (2). 63 s. et
. Norden, Agnostos Theos (Lipsiae 1913), p.229 n. 1
28 : V. 8.4; cf.
N H II.1, p.5.7-9
31 s. V. 8.38
33 cf. V. 12.4
36 cf. e.g. Iren. I.
8.3
37 s. cf. Mt 2 2 : 1 4 ; Apc 17:14
1-2 X. 9.3
2 : cf. Orig. c. Cels. 5.62; N H III. 4, pp. 98.9 et 114.8; C.
Schmidt, Gnost. Sehr, in kopt. Sprache (TU VIII. 1-2, 1892), p.563 s.; I. Bergman, o.e. pp.
78-87
2 : cf. Gal 1:19; N H passim
4 usque ad V. 9.9
ed. R. Reitzenstein, Poimandres (Lipsiae 1904), pp. 83-98 ( Reitz.)
22 addidi (cf. p. 367.3)

scripsi post Mi.:
23
addidi
25 1 , - 2
26 Mi:
27 coniec.
Go
28
33 Mi: : Bernays
( )
34 scripsi: - -
38 Bernays ex :

1 scripsi ex :
2 : Go ex
, corr. Mi
5 : () coniec. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.6.4-7.4

143

()
,
() , 2

,

.
, , , - 3
, ,
is , , , 4
()
, , ()

10 Is 5 3 : 8
13-26 primum ed. F. Gu. Schneidewin, Philol. 1 (1846), p.421 ss.; cf.
Ud. ab Wilamowitz, Hermes 37 (1902), p.331 s. (= Kl. Sehr. IV, p. 167 s.); post Th.
Bergk hunc fere in modum refinxit D. L. Page (P.M. G. nr. 985)

15



() ,


' (')

'
'


,


()

quae sequuntur poeticae aliena


13-15 Plat. Menexen. 237 d et . Dieterich, Mutter Erde3 (Lipsiae 1925), pp.68 et 139
6 () scripsi (cf. ft. v. 11 ):
8 () scripsi:

scripsi:
11 coniec. Mi: - :
coniec. Go
Cr: : We
13 scripsi:

16 , corr. Schneidewin (p. 437) et Mi


17 Schneid,
(p. 426):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

144

f. 28

Hippolytus

,
/ , ()
,
5 , . ()
()
()
, , [
6 ] & *
, . , , () ,
, , , ,
, []
, () .
7
" ' - '
, ,
-, , '

- . -

25

35

18 ss. Clem. Protrept. 6.4; Origen. c. Cels. 4.36; R. Reitzenstein, Zwei religionsgeschichtliche
Fragen (Argentorati 1901), p. 62 n. 1
22 s. = Castanea vesca
(Diosc. Mat. med. I, p. 106.3 Wellm.; cf. Athen. II, 54 d)
23-25 Diod. I. 10 et Schol.
in codd. ABDEN ad I. 8.1; (Paus. VIII. 29.4)
25 : cf. I. Sturm in RE XVII,
p. 1677 ss.
26 : cf. Zosim. Aich. p. 230.21 ss. Berthelot
(= Reitz., p. 104.5 ss.); Olympiod. Aich. II. 4.32
27-29 cf. Gn 2 : 7 et 1:27; 1 Cor
15:47; Lampe, s.v.
28 : cf. ad VII.28.3
: cf.
Bousset, p. 34 s.
29 : V. 6.5
31-33 Eph 3:15; . 194
18 , corr. Schneid.
Schneid, ( Wilamowitz): 1 , - 2
sscr.
19 / , corr. Schneid, (p. 428) et Go I
, corr. G. Hermann (Philol. 1, p. 585)
Wilam. (cf. Schneid.,
p.429 s.):
' (i.e. ) Page
20 :
- Schneid.
Schneid.:
) Wilam.:
21
Bergk (Zs. f . Altertumswiss. 1847, p. 1 = P.L.G.\ III, p. 714), Wilam.:
, corr. Schneid.
22 Schneid, (p. 435) conl. Verg. A en. 4.198 ss.:
: Bergk, agn. Wilam., Reitz., We
, corr. Schneid.
23 Bergk:
G. Hermann:
addidi
24 , corr. Schneid, (p. 436)
24-25 seel. Wilam.
25 Schneid.:
27 add. Reitz. (cf. v. 25)
28
, corr. Schneid, (p. 437)
29 delevi
30 addidi
31 ad
v. 33 ref. Keil et Piasberg ap. Reitz.: () coniec. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.7.4-12

40

45

so

55

60

145


, '
()()
, ,
-
, , /
.
' .
- () -
() , ,

.
() , , , ,
- , ,
, - , ,
() . - , ,
*
- -
. - ,
, ,
-
, , , , ()
- ' -
- - , , ,

f. 2
9

10

11

12

37 : cf. Aristot. De an. A 2, p. 403 b 29, et al.


47 V. 6.6
49 V.
9.4; VII. 22.8
52 s. cf. Titi Bostr. c. Munich. 2.60 (p. 62.25 Lagarde)
(sc. ) ...
(et Fr. Cumont, Recherches sur k Manicheisme, Bruxellis 1908, I, p.46); Democr. 68 A
164 DK
55 s. Ph 2 : 1 0 ( = , = ,
= ); V. 8.22; 16.14
56 ss. cf. V. 9.8 (. 4)
; Bion. Epitaph. Adon. 58; Aristaen. Ep. 1.8; Theocr. 15.86
et Schol. 3.48; Apollod. Bibl. III. 14.4
36 Go: : coniec. Mi: del. Reitz.
44 addidi
45 1 add.
Mi
, corr. C. Bunsen (Hippel, and his Age, Lond. 1854, I, p. 346)
49 , corr. Go
scripsi:
Mi:
52 add.
Mi
scripsi:
() oi Reitz.
57
58
, corr. Mi
addidi: () coniec. Piasberg ap. Reitz.
60 ,
transp. Reitz.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

146

pf. 29
13

14
15

16

17

Hippolytus

- () - []
" /
, , , () .
, , -
() -, , ,

, , ,
, , () , , , -
() -,
, , , ,
, , () .
, .
',
, , .

,
,
, ' ( )
, ,

.

65

75

so

72 : cf. . Thomae copt. log. 22 ( .2, p. 37.29); Clem. Strom.


III. 92.2-93.1 = . ad Aegypt. fr./(Hennecke-Schneemelcher, I, p. 110 s.); Gal 3:28; Mt
22:30; Clem. Paed. I. 10.3; Corp. Herrn. IV fr. 24.8 et n. 23 ed. A. D. Nock; Philon. De opif.
m. 134; Tert. De an. 36 et I.H. Waszink ad loc. (p.420)
72 s. : 2 Cor
5:17; Gal 6:15; cf. X. 33.15
73 : Eph 2:15; 4:24; VI. 35.4;
c. Noet. 17 et al.
74 : V. 7.38-41
77-92 Rm 1:20-23 et 1:26-27
61 () Piasberg: : Keil, agn. Reitz. We I
delevi
63 : Go, agn. Cr
del. Cr
add. Mi
64
65 addidi
67 , corr. Mi
-
68
addidi
70
71 (post ) add. Reitz.
72 . . .
, corr. Go
73 Go:
75 Mi ( We):

77-78 et om. Paulus


78 om. Paul.
79 : Paul.
80-81 supplevi ex Paulo:
82 om. Paul.
83 Paul.
84 (cf. Rm 1:24): Paul.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.7.12-21

147

85 /
- ' 18
, - ,

, 90 '
, -
.
, , 19

95 '
'
() .
() 20
, ( )
, ()
() .
-
105 . , 21
/ ,
,
,
( ) , , .

f. 29

f. 3or

96 Jo 4:10 s.
96 s. V. 9.22
101 s. Lc 17:21; V. 8.8; . Tbomae log. 3
103-105 cf. seu Aet.V.23 et Ps. Galeni Hist, philos. 127 seu Aet.IV. 11.4 et SVF I nr. 149.
- Je II c.52, p.327.23 s. Schmidt-Till; Ev. Tbomae log.4. Mt 7 : 7 s.; 11:25; 18:3-5;
19:14; ft. 2 Cor 12:2. Ropes, p. 100 nr. 94; H.-C. Puech ap. Hennecke-Schneemelcher,
I, p.200 ss.; M. Marcovich, J.T.S., N.S. 20 (1969), pp.60-64
106 cf. Marcovich,
RE Suppl.X (1965), s.v. Herakleitos, pp.300.65 ss.; 310.49 ss.
87 scripsi ex Paulo:
94 scripsi:
97 , corr.
Mi
98 add. Mi
, corr. We
99 () Go I
suppl. Reitz. et We
101 scripsi:

add. Mi
102 addidi
104 -
109 add. Mi
(cf. v. 104)
Mi:
Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

148

Hippolytus

TL

() ,
,

' (
) ,
23 , '
() ,
( ) .
, aid ()
-
( ) () , (*) -,
(, )
24 . '
, , , , () ,
.

111-113 IV. 43.4; Herodot. .2


113-115 Lucian. De Syria dea 2
117
: cf. . ., 1931, p. 174 (Samos)
: cf. Epigr. 1023.3 Kaibel; Plut. De Is. 372 D; Orph. hymn. 42.9;
Hymn, in him 3.34 (Suppl. epigr. Gr. VIII, p. 100 nr. 550)
118 :
V. 7.27; Plut. De Is. 358 ; 365 BC; 371 F (et I.G. Griffiths, pp.342; 495); Diod.Sic.1.
22.6-7; I. Herter, RE XIX, p. 1717 ss.; E.R. Goodenough, Jewish Symbols 6 (1956), p. 99 ss.
" - : Plut. De Is. 364 A (et Griffiths, p. 424); 365 B; Origen. c.Cels. 5.38
(II, p.42.23 K.); Sallust. De diis et mund. 4; Ps.Clem. Horn. 6.9 Rehm; Pap. Gr. Mag. XII,
col. 234 Preisendanz " ; . Dieterich, Kl. Sehr. (Lips.
1911), p. 26; Th. Hopfner, Plutarch ber Isis u. Osiris, II (Pragae 1941), p. 154
119 : cf. VII. 23.7
122 s. cf. V. 16.6
123 : cf.
Plut. De Is. c. 53 (et Griffiths, p. 503)
124 s. Prv 24:16
111 addidi
112 Go
113 1 , - - 2

, corr. Mi
114 ' Keil ap. Reitz.: : ()
Go
114-115 2 add. Mi et addidi post Reitz. (post ), cf. IV.
43.4 et 44.3
117 addidi (cf. Plut. De Is. 358
)

118 addidi (cf.
v. 154)
Mi: : Go, agn. Cr et Reitz.
scripsi:

119 , corr. Cr
hic et in v. 121 , corr. Roeper
121 addidi
() Cr, . ( ) coniec.
Reitz.
: ' Go: coniec. We
post lac.
suspicor (exspectes ): []
Reitz.
122 , addidi
() Go, agn. Cr
2 corr. ex . 1
125 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.7.22-28

BO

135

HO

145

149

, ()
, ,
, .
,
, / , (')
,
; ,
()
-
,
. - ' ()
, . , , ()
,
() .
, - ()
, ' , () -

25

26 f. 3

27

28

127 : cf. . IV. 51.12; V. 7.35; 17.11-12; R.P. Casey, J.T.S. 27 (1925-26),
pp.381 n.4 et 382 n.2; et ft. j o 6:63; 1 Cor 15:45; 2 Cor 3:6; 1
; 3 : 1 8
129 ft.cf. Jo 3 : 8 et Ex 3:14
129 s. cf. Aristot. Phys. 5, p.256 b 24
et al.
132 : cf. . ad Diogn.
8.8; Clem. Strom. III. 43.2; . ad V. 26.1; L. Leloir, Le temoignage d'Ephraim sur le Diatessaron (CSCO 227, Subsid.19), p. 187; Plut. De Is. 368 AB (et
Griffiths, p.460 s.); Iambl. De myst. 6.7; 8.3; Th. Hopfner, o.e., II, p. 191
133 : Iren. Adv. haer. I. 20.1; Epiphan. Pan. 33.7.5; Ps.Clem.Horn. 18.3.4; lustin.
Dial, cum Tryph. 101.2; Clem. Paed.I. 74.1; Leloir, o.e., p. 188 (sect.48.2). - Mc 10:18;
Lc 18:19; (Mt 19:17). - VII. 31.6; Epiphan. Pan. 42.11.6 schol.50; Clem. Strom. II.
114.3 et al.
134 - 135 : Mt 5 :45; cf. lustin. I pol. 1.13; Dial. 96.3
et al.
137 : ft. cf. V. 7.34
139 ss. dubium, utrum de Osiride (cf.
Plut. De Is. 371 F) an de Priapo (cf. V. 26.32-33) agit Naassenus
141 cum acc. rei: cf. Ach. Tat. 1.5
143 s. Mt 5:15; Mc 4:21; Lc 8:16; 11:33;
Ev. Thomae log. 33
144 s. Mt 10:27; Lc 12:3; Ev. Thomae log. 33
127 : Go cett.
130 Reitz.:
131 '
addidi
134 , corr. Mi
137 3 , 1
3 add.
Mi
138 () Plasberg ap. Reitz.
139 ( ) (et ( ) )
Keil et Plasberg, agn. Reitz. We:
141 addidi (cf. V. 26.33) I
post , transp. Reitz.
Cr
143 add. Mi
144 add. Reitz.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

150

pf. 3

Hippolytus

' , () . - . -

29 (), , ' 5
. ( ) ()
( ) , () / '
,
, .
iss
30
- - , ,
,
,

60

() , , , ,

146 s. < . G. XVI. 86; 236; 237; 243; 260; 261; Epigr. 782 Kaibel et I. Herter, De Priapo
(RGW 23, 1932), p.246
147 s. : Pap.Gr.Mag. IV, col.3165 Preisendanz et Reitz., p. 30
148 cf. Lc 9:33
151 cf. Paus. VI. 26.5
, , et Rschen
Lex. I, p. 2342 s.; Gu. Fauth, Der kl. Pauly, II (1967), p. 1071
152 - :
cf. Artemid. Onirocrit. I. 45 Pack ,
..., , ,
,
; Cornut. De nat. deor. 16 (p. 23.16-22 Lang); Plut.
An seni sit resp. ger. 797 F; IV. 48.2; Reitzenstein, Zwei reltgionsgesch. Fragen, p. 96; S.
Eitrem, RE VIII, p. 791.28 ss.; C.F.H. Bruchmann, Epith. deor., p. 108
:
Orph. hymn. 28.6 Quandt; Orph. fr. 297 a I Kern; Philon. Legat, ad Gaium 99; Diod. I.
16.2; Macrob. Sat. I. 17.5; 19.9 et al.
155 s. - : ft. ad etymon
vocis Hermes alludit
159 s. Odyss. 24.1 s.
161 s. : cf. w .
177-179; V. 14.1; 17.8; N H 1.3, p.29.26 ss.; II. 1, p.31.5; V.5, p.66.1 ss.; Corp. Herrn. 1.27
(Poimandres); Acta Thomae 110; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 3.1 et al.; cf. G. MacRae in Numinis
Suppl. 12 (Lugd. Batav. 1967), p. 503 s.
146 addidi
150 corr. ex
, corr. Mi
151 post
lac. sign. Reitz.: supplevi conl. Paus. 1.1.
152 Go: I
addidi et add. Go
add. Go
155 : Mi

Mi
161 addidi
Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.7.28-34

151

() () ()
165 , ,
, ,
, - 31
. no


, , ' ,
, ' .

, , 32
, , , ,
175 , []
. - , , '
, ()
, , , , 33
( ), ,
8 () , , ,
() / - () , 34 f. 3

163 Emped.fr. 119 DK (ap. Plut. De exil. 607 ; Stob. III, p. 737 .; Clem. Strom. IV. 13.1)
165 s. cf. Rm 9:20 s. (Is 29:16; 45:9)
166 i.q. El-Shaddai\ cf. V.
26.3 ; N H III.2, p. 64.21; VIII. 1, pp. 6.16; 54.25; 126.20; Gnost. cod. Bruc. c.20
(p. 362.12 Schmidt-Till) Seldao; I. Doresse, NT 1 (1956), p. 66 s et al.
167
: cf. Ex 3 : 2 et 4; Dt 4:24; 9 : 3 ; VI. 9.3; 32.7-8; VII. 38.1; VIII. 9.7 et 10.1; X.
16.5 et 20.1; PapGr.Mag. 12.115 Preis.; Gu. Kroll, De oraculis Chdd. (Vratisl. 1894),
p.43, et al.
169-171 Odyss. 24.2-4
173 Ps 2 : 9 ; (Apc 2:27)
178 : i.e. , cf. . 161 s.
178 s. Eph 5:14. Cf. In
Daniel. IV. 56.4; De Antichr. 65, p. 45.11 ., et Resch, Agrapha2, p.32 ss.
180 s. cf. V 8.21
163 om. (Clem.): add. Mi (hab. Plut. Stob.)
Gesner: (Plut. Stob.):
Clem.
Mi:
164 addidi
165 &
: Roeper
167 , corr. Go
169 , corr. Mi
171 Mi:
175 Cr:
delevi
176
del. Mi
177 addidi
178 NT
179
addidi ex NT et
180 addidi
181 addidi

: coniec. Mi, agn. omnes


addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

152

Hippolytus

, () ,
. , , ,
() , , ,
[] []
'
() ,
, ' .
' , (),
.
35
(), , - (), ,
,
- ,
() , - - , ,
- ( ) - .
36 , , -
( , ) ,
() ', (), ,

182 = etiam (?): cf. . 180 et Plut. De Is. 364 D



182 s. , : cf. inscript. Athen, , Bull. con. hell.
20 (1896), p. 79; Procl. In Tim. Ill, p. 176.30 D.; A. Dieterich, Mutter Erde3, p. 45 s.;
G. Mylonas, Eleusis (Princeton. 1961), p. 270 s.
183 cf. 1 Cor 15:27
183 s. Odyss.
24.5
186-188 Odyss. 24.6-8
189 s. Rm 10:18
191 :
cf. Iren. Adv. haer. I. 29.3 hominem perfectum et verum, quern et Adamantem vocant,
quoniam neque ipse domatus est neque ii ex quibus erat; Thomae ps. 4.12 et A. Adam,
Zs. / d. NT-Wiss., Beiheft 24 (Berolini 1959), p. 42
192 et 194 s. Is 28:16
(: Luc.)

192 s. Ps 117:22 , , ; Mt 21:42; Mc 12:10;
Lc 20:17; Act 4:11; 1 Pt 2 : 7
194 Eph 3:15; .31 s.
197 et 199 Eph
3:16; Rm 7:22; 2 Cor 4:16
198 lliad. 4.350 et al.
182 addidi
183 scripsi: edd. ('ut illud'): Reitz.:
coniec. We
( Horn.) scripsi:
184 ex Horn,
add. Go
: Horn.
185 delevi
del. Reitz.
187
Mi:
188
189 ' - 190
post . 183 : hue transtuli
189 addidi
191
addidi
addidi
192 del. Reitz.
, transposui
193-194 Cr, agn. Reitz.
194 addidi (cf. IV. 51.10)
195 addidi
del. Reitz.
196 Reitz.:
197 post lac. sign. Go: - suppl. Reitz.
198 1 addidi
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.7.34-39

153

, , () ,
2 ( ) ,
, ,
. , (), - 37
() -, ( )
' , '
205 - '
- , , . , , ;
2

' ,
/ () ' .

, , ()

f. 32

38

' () , ' ,
, . ' , ,
', , ,
25 , () .
, , - 39
,
-
, ( )
22 - () -

200 D n 2 : 4 5
202 2 Cor 4 : 7 ; 2 Tm 2 : 2 0
204 et 206 Odyss. 24.9 s.
206 . . . intellexit Naassenus
209 s. Odyss. 24.11 s.
212 VIII. 12.1 et Orph. hymn. 83.2; Horn. Iliad. 14.246; cf. X. 7.1 et Iliad. 14.201;
Orph. fr. 57 K.
215 : cf. . Carcopino, De Pythagore aux aptres
(Paris. 1956), p.214 ss.
216 s. Ps 8 1 : 6 ; Iren. III. 6.1; 19.1; IV. 38.4; Clem. Strom.
II. 125.5-6; Tert. Adv. Marc. I. 7.1
218 : IV. 48.9; V. 16.4-5
219 s.
Gal 4 : 2 6 ; Gn 3 : 2 0 ; {Heb 12:22; Apc 3:12; 2 1 : 2 et 10); VI. 34.3; 2 A w 4 : 2 - 7 ; 3 : 1 ;
2 5 5 : 2 ; Iren. V. 35.2 et al.
199 2 addidi
Go, agn. Cr Reitz.
200 addidi (cf. v. 164) et add.
Reitz.
203 addidi
addidi
204 Mi ex Horn.:

, corr. Mi
205 del. Reitz.
207 ()
Reitz.
208 scripsi:
209 ' , corr. Mi
210 ( )
Mi:
211 add. suad. We
212 add. Go
215 <> Mi:

219 addidi et add. Reitz.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

154

Hippolytus

40 - , , , ,
() ,
(),
, ' , ,
, () 225
. (') '
41 () , , ,
' .
23
8 1

pf. 32

,
,

. / , () 5
2 - , ,
,
() - , ,
,
3 . - , ,
()
, ' .

221 8 1 : 7
223 Jo 3 :5; V. 8.37
225 s. Jo 3 : 6 ; VIII. 10.8; c. Noet. 16;
Clem. Strom. III. 84.3 et al.
229 - : V. 16.4-5; Philon. De migr.
Ahr. 23 ; 77; 202; De agric. 88 ,
; De congr. er. gr. 20; 83; Leg. alleg. II. 59; 77; De sacr. Ab. 48; Clem.
Strom. I. 30.4; II. 47.1; Apc 11:8
230 Jos 3 : 1 6

8 : cf. . 164 et Gnost. cod. Bruc. c.22, p. 352.11 Schmidt-Till


9
: cf. Ex 18:17-24
10 : cf. Philon. De mutat. nom.
120 [] ,
10 cf.
Ex 2 : 2 2 ; 18:3
13 Iliad. 15.189; V. 20.8
222 addidi
226 ' addidi

223 addidi (cf. V. 8.37): in ras. litt, quattuor ( = ,


227 addidi
228

2 , corr. Go
6 corr. ex

3 in mg.
8 2 addidi

4 scripsi:
12 addidi

5 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.7.39-8.6

155

, , ,
is , .
, , , .
, (,) - , , 4
, ,
() . ,
20 , ,
- () -,
" () ,
. , , ' , 5
. , ,
25 ,
() , ,
, (,) , () - () / ,

f. 33r

().
, , , () 6
30 , () , ,
. () , ,
' , ' , ,

15 cf. Mc 4:12; Lc 8:10; (Mt 13:13); Is 6 : 9


17 s. Cau-lacau, Sau-lasau, Ze'er
Sham (): Is 28:10; Epiphan. Pan.25. 4.4-5; Cau-lacau: Iren.I. 24.5-6; Theodoret.
Huer. fab. 1.4; Epiphan. 25. 3.6; Philastr. Haer. 33.3; Bousset, p.240
20 :
V. 6.6; cf. N H II. 1, p. 5.7-9
21 : Aeschyl. Agam. 870; V. 12.4; X.
10.3
22 V. 9.8 (v. 5 s.)
23 s. Jo 1:3-4; V. 9.2; 16.12; c. Noet. 12; Iren. I.
8.5 et al.; cf. Resch, p. 52 s.; C. Barth, Die Interpretation d. NT i. d. valentinianischen Gnosis
{TU 37.3, 1911), p.37
25 s. Eph 3 : 5 ; VI. 35.1; VII. 25.3; 26.7
28
(): cf. V. 7.30
29 = v. 22
29 s. Gn 4 4 : 5
30 s. cf. Gn 44:12
32 : fere i. q. : Iambi. De myst.
III. 8 p. 117.6 Parthey; Procl. In remp. I, pp. 140.16 et 166.20 Kroll; Plotin. II. 9 [33], 18.20
Henry et Schwyzer; Heracliti fr. 92 DK
33 cf. Anacreonteor. 52.10 Preisendanz
, ' , et 48.8 ,
34 cf. Anacr. 52.11

17 addidi
18 , Go:
19 1 add. Reitz.
20 - corr. ex -
corr. ex - -
21 addidi
23
26 <) scripsi ex NT:
27
addidi
post .26 , hue transtuli (post Go): del. Reitz. We
add. Reitz.
Mi: : Go
28 add. Reitz.
2 9 addidi
30 addidi
31 <> scripsi:
33 . . . I
sup. ras. scr. in

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

156

Hippolytus


,
5 ( KJ - ) .

f. 33

35

7 , ,
, () , ,
( ) [] , () , 4
() ,
, , , , , (,)
, , () ,
, , 45
,
8 , (), ,
,
.
9
' , , () , so
, , () ()
10 ' () .
()
, / 55
,

, ' .

35 s. A.G. XI.43
37 cf. Anacr. 17.25 s. /
: . G. VII. 641.2 ; VII. 193.4; Theogn. 1230
43 = . 3 3 '
46 Jo 2 : 1 1
47 s. V. 7.20; Lc 1 7 : 2 1 ; .
Thomae log. 3
48 : cf. Mt 13 :44; . Thomae logg. 76 et 109
48 s. Mt 1 3 : 3 3 ; Lc 1 3 : 2 1 ; . Thomae log.96
52 s. cf. V. 9.8 (.7)
55 s. V. 7.29
35 Reitz.:
37 suppl. Cr ex w . 4 1 et 43 (at cf.
v.210): suppleverim (cf. v . 4 1 et Aeschyli Choeph. 564; Pindari fr. 140 (a), 60 Snell)
39 addidi
39 usque ad v. 41 del.
Reitz.
40 addidi (cf. V. 24.2)
scripsi:
41 addidi
G o
addidi
addidi

del. G o
43 addidi

44

47 addidi
48 Go:
50 hic et saepius I
51 addidi
52 ( ) scripsi (cf. V. 9.8, v. 7):

53 addidi
sscr. litt. rubr. 3

54 ( ) Reitz.

addidi

55 - -

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.8.6-15

157

, ,
60 , , ,
, , . ,
, ()
, ,
65 , , '
, ,
() , , -
.
, ,
70 , ,
,
. ' , , - , .
75 , , ()
, , ,
, / ,
.
, , ()() ,
80 , () .

11

12

13

14

f. 34
15

59 - 60 : Jo 6 :53
60 - 61 : Mt 5 :20; 18 :3
61 - 62 : Mc 10:38; Mt 20:22
62 - : Jo 8:21; 13:33;
(7:34 et 7:36); cf. Resch, p. 110
64 ss. Mt 19:28; Lc 22 :30; Apc 21:12 et 14; Ev.
Ebionit. ap. Epiphan. Pan. 30. 13.3
et Hennecke-Schneemelcher, I, p. 102
69
: male intellexit vocem (i.q. Thessali) Naassenus: cf. V. 9.8 (. 8) et
A.D. Nock, Class. Quart. 20 (1926), p.41
69-72 : i.e.

71 V. 7.35; 17.11
73 : ft.
Naassenus (: ), cf. Rschen Lex. II, p. 1607.35 ss., et Reitz., p.92 n.3
74 = Clem. Strom. IV. 45.1; Adumbrat. in 1 Pt 3 :19 (pp. 81 et 94 s. ed. Th. Zahn, Forsch,
z. Gesch. d. NT-Kanons, III, 1884); cf. Dt 4 :12; Jo 5 :37
79 Ps 28 :10
80 Ps
28 :3; cf. V. 19.16; X. 11.9
60 , corr. Mi
63 ex corr. 3
68 scripsi:
3
1
69 , ..
75 : Go, agn. We

77 Cr, agn. Reitz.: , We
79
scripsi e LXX ( coniec. Go): ( coniec. Mi)
80 2 add. Mi I
: LXX, We (at cf. v. 82 et )

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

158

16

17

18

19

f. 34

20

Hippolytus

(), ,
, ' , (,)
, ,
, , , ,
, - - , ,
, , . ,
() ,
- , ,
- - ' , '
.
- - ,
, , , ,
, , , ,
- - ,
, ; , . (, ,)
,
(),
, , /
. (), ,
-
- (*)
, ,
, ,
, (,)
' ,

85

95

los

83 Ps 3 4 : 1 7 et 21:21 s.
84-88 Is 4 1 : 9 s. et 4 3 : 1 s.
87 - :
VI. 17.4
88-92 Is 4 9 : 1 5 s.
94-96 Ps 2 3 : 7 - 9
96 cf. . Thomae
log.29
96 s. Ps 2 3 : 8 = 10
97 s. Ps 2 1 : 7
99 Ps 2 3 : 1 0 et 8
101 s. Job 4 0 : 3 2
102 s. Gn 2 8 : 5 et 12 (cf. Hennecke-Schneemelcher, I, p. 201)
107-109 Gn 2 8 : 1 7
81 addidi

82 addidi
85 scripsi
e LXX: -
88 () Reitz.
et. LXX cod. :
cett.
89 addidi e LXX
91
92 LXX
96
scripsi:
98 , addidi
100 addidi (cf. v. 101)
: corr. in
102 addidi
104 post lac. sign. Reitz. I
: Reitz.
107 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.8.15-25

159

. , , -
no , , ,
, , ,
, ()
.
, , , ()
us ,
, ,
() ,
() - - 2 . () ,
, , ,
, ,
, , . , ( ) /
125 -
, , . - , ,
, '
, , .
, ,
no , , ,
. , ,
,

21

22

23

f. 35r
24

25

109 Jo 10:7 et 9 (ft. et. 14 :6); V. 9.21; 17.9; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 26; Resch, p. 126 ss.
114 : V. 9.8 (v.9)
116 s. Ph 2 : 1 0 ; V. 7.11; 16.14
118 et 119 /*&
2 : 1 7 ; Is 5 7 : 1 9
121 : V. 9.8 (v. 10)
121 s. cf. Dionys. Hal. Rhet. 6.5;
Iulian. Or. 6, 189 C; Philolai fr. 14 DK; Plat. Crat. 400 c; Gorg. 493 a; Clem. Strom. III.
16.3-17.1 et al.; Burkert, p.230 n.53; p.231 n.54
123 Mt 23:27
124 cf. I Cor
15:45; Gn 2 : 7
125 cf. Jo 5 :28; Mt 27 :52 s.; (Act 3 :8)
130 : V. 9.8
(v. 10)
133-135 1 Cor 12 :2-4; N H V.2, p. 19.23 ss.; Apoc. Mosis 4 0 : 2 ; 2 En 2 2 : 1 ;
Test. Levi 2 : 7 - 3 :8; cf. v. 171 s. et H.-C. Puech in Coptic Studies in Hon. o/W.E. Crum
112 ( ) Reitz.

114 , corr. Go
addidi (cf.
v. 118 )
116 () Cr
117 addidi post Reitz.
(post v. 116 )
117-118 1 , 3
120 ()
coniec. Mi: () . Reitz.
121 () Reitz.:
122 () Go
124 1 post . 123 , hue transtuli
1
2

132 ,
133 15

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

160

f. 35

Hippolytus

,
26 , , ,
, , ( )
, '
, .
- .
, , ,
27 , , ,
,
, . , ,
, , , '
28 (,
,) , ,
. / , ,
. , ,
, ,
, . , ,
,
29 ' ,
, ,
,
, ,
- , , ,
, , , , ,
, . , ,

35

45

iso

iss

(Boston. 1950), . 136; < VII. 26.7; Epiph. Pan. 38. 2.5
136-139 1 Cor 2 :13 s.;
VI. 34.8; VII. 26.3; In Dan. III. 2.4; In Prov. p.76.12 Richard (Le Museon 79, 1966);
Iren. I. 8.3; V. 8.3; Clem. Strom. I. 56.1; 87.4; V. 19.3; 25.5; VI. 166.3 et al.
141 s. Jo 6 : 4 4 ; NH II.6, p. 135.1; Ev. Thomat Gr. 6 : 1 2 Tischendorf; cf. Clem.
Strom. V. 7.3; 83.1; Epiphan. Pan. 69. 54.6; Resch, p.106
144-146 Mt 7 : 2 1 ;
II Ep. Clem. 4.2; lust. I Apol. 16.9
146-148 Je 1 : 2 2 ; cf. Mt 7 :24 et 26; Rm 2 : 1 3
148 s. Mt 2 1 : 3 1 ; In Gen. p.68.4 .; Iren. IV. 20.12
150 cf. Mt 17:25
151 1 Cor 10:11; In Dan. I. 16.4
154-159 Mt 1 3 : 3 - 9 ; Mc 4 : 3 - 9 ; Lc 8 : 5 - 8 ;
Ev. Tbomae log.9; I Clem. 24.5; lust. Dial. 125.1; Clem. Al. Fr. p.225.26 St.; Strom. I. 37.2;
VI. 114.3; Ps. Clem. Recogn. III. 6 1 2 ; VIII. 9.1; Mem. apostol. ap. Hennecke-Schneemelcher, I, pp. 180-190; I. Bergman, o.e., p.99 s. et al.
136 ex Paulo add. Go
146 () scripsi:
147 addidi
150 : Cr
156 in mg. litt. rubr. 3 (hab. Mt. Mc.): om. edd.
158 (ter) Mi: (ter)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.8.25-34

161

i6o () , ,
, , -
, , ,
, ,
, , ,
165 ' ()
.
-
.
, ,
no , , ,
, () , /
, , ,
, ;
( ) , 175 () () , () '
( ) , " ,
,
.
, , , ,
8 , , , '

30

31

f. '
32

33

34

161 s. Dt 3 1 : 2 0 ; VI. 30.9; Clem. Paed. I. 91.4


163 : < .
Bamabae 6 : 1 7 ; Tert. Adv. Marc. I. 14.3 meis et lactis societatem, qua suos infantat\ H.
Usener, Kl. Schriften, IV, p.406 s.; Kittel, Th. Wb. z. NT, I, p.645
167 :
V. 9.8 (v. 10)
168 Gal 5 :16; Clem. Strom. IV. 60.4
169 s. Mt 3 :10; 7 : 1 9 ;
Lc 3 : 9 ; VI. 9.9-10; 16.6
171 s. : cf. 2 Cor 12:2; v. 133 s.
172 s. Ev. Thomae log. 11; Ev. Philippi log. 93 (NH II. 3, p. 72.19); cf. R.M. Grant, Vig.
Christ. 13 (1959), p. 173 ss.; Gu. R. Schoedel, o.e., 14 (I960), p.225 ss.; E. Cornells,
o.e., 15 (1961), p. 83 ss.; B. Gaertner, The Theology of the Gospel of Thomas (Londin. 1961),
p. 164 ss.; M. Marcovich, J.T.S., N.S. 20 (1969), pp. 72-74, et al.
176 s. Mt 7 : 6 ;
IX. 17.1; Ev. Thomae log. 93; Epiphan. Pan. 24. 5.2; Didache 9.5; Clem. Strom. I. 53.3;
Ps. Clem. Recogn. II. 3.5; III. 1.5 et al.
179 : V. 9.8 (v. 11)
160 oi add. Go
163 (corr. ex ) : om. edd.
165 sscr. litt. rubr. P 3 j
Go:
167 Go:
170 scripsi:

Cr:
171 1 add. Go
173 , corr. Go
174
addidi
175 -
addidi
: Mi
addidi
176 addidi
180 an ?
180-181
, corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

162

Hippolytus

() , , () ,
35 ,
(), ,
, , ,
()
iss
,
,

f. 36

, , , []
, , (,) , 36 , [] , , , () 9
, ()
.
(), , , ,
, , (,) , 195
- , , ()
37 , () , , ,
() / , ,
' , , .
, (') , (,) 200
, , , '

181-183 cf. IV. 47.1-2; Plat. Crat. 408 cd


. . . ' ( )
184 :
cf. Etym. ., s.v.: , ;
Comm. in Aral., .331.5; 342.23 Maass
186 s. Odyss. 4.384 s.
189 s. :
cf. Etym. ., s.v.: ,
193 : V. 9.8 (. 12)
193 s. Is 54:1; Gal 4 : 2 7 ; Clem. Strom. II. 28.5;
Epist. apostol. 33 {NTApokr}, I, p. 145) et al.
197-199 Mt 2 :18; Jr 38 :15; lust. Did.
78.8
199 : cf. Lament. 1 : 1
181 Reitz.:
del. Reitz.
et 182 : corr. in
2
183
185 add. Reitz.
186 : ex 2
188 () Reitz.
delevi
189 1 () Keil ap. Reitz.
addidi
189/190 Roeper, agn. Reitz.: () Go, agn.Cr
190 1 del. Mi
del. Reitz.
2 scripsi: : Mi: () Reitz.
191 add. Go
193 : LXX, N T
195 addidi
196 addidi
197 add. Reitz.
in mg. inf. litt. rubr. 3 : in
textu 1
198 addidi e LXX
200 ' addidi
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.8.34-42

163

, ,
. , () , 38
; , , 205 . , ,
, .
, , ,
,

2 , . ,
(,)
, - ,
, (,) - ( )
25
, .
, , , ,
,
(), /, ,
220 , - , ,
- , () ( )
. , ,
() . () , (, )
() -

39

40

41

f. 37

42

202 Jo 3 : 5 ; V. 7.40
203 s. Jr 1 7 : 9
205 s. V. 6.6
207 V.
9.8 (. 11 s.)
208-210 cf. G. Mylonas, Eleusis, p. 275 s.
213 : cf. .
Kern, RE XVI, p. 1236.62
214 : cf. Plut. De prof. virt. 81
et Kern., o.e., p. 1243.44
215 s. cf. Hesych. - ,
, et Mylonas, Eleusis, pp. 306-310; Gu. Burkert, Homo necans
(RGW 32, 1972), p. 318 s.
219 - : cf. Etym. . =
et Cornut. De nat. deor. 28 (p. 54.10 Lang)
223 s. cf. Plat. Gorg. 497 c et Schol.
(VI, p. 319 Hermann)
224 s. Heracliti fr. 25 DK ( = 97 Marc.); . 234 s.
203 addidi
209 corr. in
211 addidi I
ante lac. susp. Go
213 : corr. in
addidi
213/214 Keil: : Piasberg
214
, corr. Go

216 (et ) Mi:
218 2
scripsi:
, transp. Go
219 addidi
221 coniec. We:
add. Reitz.
add.
Keil et addidi
223 add. Reitz.
Mi: :
Bernays (ex Piatone)
, addidi
224 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

164

Hippolytus

43 . (,) , [] 225
, () .
,
, , , ()
' ,
, '
.

no

44 ' , , , ,
()
, . , ,
.
235
, , ()
, ,
, , , , . ()
24
45 , , (,)
, , ,
, , ,

227 Mt 7:13; . 245 s.


228 : ft. Orpheus
229-231 cf. . Kern
ad Orph. fr.352 et Gu. Kranz ad Parmenid. 28 20
230 : cf. e.g. Plat.
Reip. II, 363 d 6; VII, 533 d 1
' = quae tarnen (male Reitz. p.96 n.4 'altera
semita')
233 : (i.e. a mense Anthesterionis usque ad mensem
Boedromionis): ad vitae spatium alludit Naassenus
236 s. Gn 28 :17; w . 107-109
237 cf. V. 7.26
239 cf. Mt 22:11 s. et Clem. Exc. ex Tbeodoto 61.8
. . . , ; 63.1
241 s. Is
7:14
242 : cf. Epiphan. Pan. 51. 22.10
( )
243 : cf. Pap. Gr. Mag.
4 col.2198 Preisendanz ; Synes. Hymn. 5(2).67; A.D. Nock, Essays on
Religion (Boston. 1972), I, pp.383; 388; et praesertim Gu. Bousset, 'Der Gott Aion':
Religionsgeschichtliche Studien (Supplements to NT, 50, Lugd. Batav. 1979), pp. 192-230
225 add. Go
1 delevi
226 addidi: add. E. Maass (Orpheus, p.79
n. 105)
228 post lac. susp. Go We
scripsi: P: del. Mi
addidi
229 , corr. Mi
Go:
230 ' Go: ' : ' Mi
233 Keil:
add. Keil
235 scripsi ex v.225:
236 scripsi:
add. Go
239 : Go
addidi ex testim.
241
scripsi:

addidi

243 : coniec. G o

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

165

Refutatio V.8.42-9.5


245 , / ,
,
' .

15

20


, , ' ,
,
,
() ), .
, (,) () (),
,
, [] , , ,
() , ' , ' ,
.
,
, (,) ,
, , , ,
, , ,
, , , , []
, , ,
, ,
, () , , / , , ,

f. 37

f. 38

2 4 4 - 2 4 7 Mt 7 : 1 4 - 1 3 ; IV. 48.9; Clem. Strom. V. 31.1 et al.


1 : cf. v. 51 s.

3 : cf. VII. 22.8 et 23.3

5 et 8 ad etymon vocis 9 alludunt


8.5; 16.12

4 ,

10 s. Jo 1 : 3 ; V.

12 : cf. v . 5 2 ; Orph. hymn. 8 : 1 1 ; Orph. fr. 297 b, v . 2 Kern;

Macrob. Sat. I. 21.9

1 3 - 1 6 Jo 4 : 2 4 ; 21; 23

19 s. V. 7.10; VII. 22.8

18 s. cf. VIII. 12.7

2 0 - 2 3 VI. 9.4

245 : N T

247 :

(et

) N T
2

3 , corr. G o

scripsi:
8 del. G o

5 add. G o

( ) Reitz.

4 , corr. Roeper
6 addidi

9 addidi: add. Reitz., agn. We


Mi:

: edd.

Reitz.

2 delevi

Reitz.

del. G o

addidi

Keil, agn. Reitz.


10 o m . N T

13 addidi

12

17 ( ) Cr, agn.

18 ( ) et Cr, agn.
19 G o :

20 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

166

Hippolytus

,
,
[ ] - ,
, , (), , -,
(), , (,) , (,) , ,
[ ], () 6 . , , ,
, , , ,
(') , , , , .
7
' ,
() (*)
( )
(') . , ,
,
, ,
,
8

, ,
', (), -

2 7 - 2 9 IV. 51.3; VI. 14.6


29 s. Mt 1 3 : 3 1 ; Mc 4 : 3 0 s.; Lc 1 3 : 1 8 s.; VI. 40.2;
VII. 21.3; X. 14.1; Ev. Thomae log.20 et al.
32 Ps 1 8 : 4
4 0 - 5 2 primum ed.
F. G. Schneidewin (Philol. 3, 1848, pp. 247-266), ad numeros revocavit Ud. ab Wilamowitz
(Hermes 37, 1902, pp. 328-331 = Kl. Schriften IV, pp. 164-167); cf. praesertim Th. Wolbergs,
Griech. religise Gedichte der ersten nachchristl. Jahrhunderte (Beitrge zur klass. Philol. 40,1971),
I, pp. 8 et 6 0 - 7 5
23 del. G o
24 : G o
24/25 scripsi
post Mi ( - W - ) :
25 . . , transposui
26
scripsi (cf. v. 28):
26 addidi (cf. v. 28)
, corr. Mi
addidi
scripsi:
27
scripsi: edd.
add. Reitz.
28 seclusi (cf. v. 26) I
. Usener (Das Weihnachtsfest!, p. 141 n.30)
Roeper:
: Mi (sine Usener)
31 ' addidi
32 LXX
34 addidi
post lac. sign. Reitz. (qui
supplevit approbante We)
Reitz.:
35 add. suad. Mi
36 'Schneidewin:
37 Wilamowitz:

Keil: : Wilam.
38 Wilam.
40 (coniec. Bergk, PLG III 4 , p.686): Mi Schneid.
41 :
Mi, W i l a m .
addidi: post Bergk. add. W i l a m .

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.9.5-9

167

' - 5 , ' , , / () , ,
,
' ()
' () , .
( ) () ,

',
() ,
' ()
() ,
5 '
,

42-44 : cf. Socrat. Hist. eccl. III. 23 , , ;


Porphyr, ap. Eus. Praep. ev. III. 11.12; H. Hepding, Attis (RGW 1, 1903), p.101
44 : cf. Mart. Cap. De nupt. Philol. et Mere. 2. 191 ss.
45 :
cf. Attin menotyrannum in CIL VI. 500.501; 508.511 s.; IGSI 913
48 :
Diod. III. 58.4 , ' ; CIL V. 766 (Atte Papa); Arrian.
ap. Eustath. ad Iliad. 5. 408 (= Fr. Gr. Hist. 156 F 22)
51 s. : Paus. VII.
17.11; Hepding, . c., p. 106 n. 1
52 : cf. ad v. 12 et Wolbergs, p. 75
55-62 primum ed. Schneidewin, o.e., pp.247 et 263 ss.; metrum restit. Wilamowitz,
o.e., p.330 s. (= 166 s.); cf. Wolbergs, o.e., pp.9 et 76-82
45/46 Diels: : Wilam.
46 , corr. Wilam.
Bergk (conl. Hesych. s.v. - .
), Wilam.: (cf. in .4 inscriptionis a C.A. Romaios,
Helknika 1 (1928), pp.233-243, editae)
47
49 ' Schneid.:

50/51
51 Wilam.:
scripsi (cf.
V. 8.36):
53 supplevi (cf. v. 63)
add.
Wilam.
56 () Schneid.:

57 ' : Wilam.
Wilam.:
et . 58 addidi metri
gr.: / / / / dimetris catalect. Wilam.
58 , corr. Wilam. (cf. Nonn. Dion. 3.237 et 44.4 )
59
Schneid.:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

168

Hippolytus

, , ,
.
10

11

12

f. 39
13

14

15


,
(). 65
, ,
() -
, () ,
- [],
, .
7
, () .
'
[ ], )
,
, / is
, ' .
,
() , , , [] , .
, , so
, , [ ], . (*) , () ( ) . , 85

61 : cf. Socrat. Hist. eccl. III. 23; Clem. Protr. 19.4; Schol. in Luc. Iup. trag. 8;
Etym. M s.v.
72 V. 6.3
81 cf. Dt 33 :17
83-85 et 89-92 Gn
2: 10-12; V. 16.9; 26.11; VI. 14.8; 15.1; Theoph. Ant. Autol. 2.24
85 : cf. IV. 51.11; V. 17.11 et e.g. Philon. Leg. alkg. I. 64 ,

61 , corr. Schneid.
65 , transposui
addidi (cf.
V. 7.19)
scripsi:
67 add. suad. Mi
68 () scripsi:

69 seclusi (cf. v.67)
71
72 scripsi:

73 secl. Cr
76 Go:
78
addidi
79 del. Cr
80 Diels:
81 , corr.
We
() Go
81/82 del. Go: Hilgenfeld (o.e.,
. 256 . 422)
83 post lacunam significavi
, corr. Go
83/84 addidi e LXX (cf. v. 88)
84 addidi e LXX
(cf. v. 87 )
85

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.9.9-19

90

95

los

169


, ()
. -
-


() , ,
() , ,

, , , .
() [] / , , ,
, , (,)
,
(),
, , () ,
() , '
- () .
, , ,
, , ,
' . ,
, ,
, ,

16

17

f. 39

18

19

86 : ad etymon vocis ' spectat


: i. q. , cf. IV. 51.11
89-104 cf. VI. 15.1-16.4
94 s. Gn 2 : 1 3
96 s. Gn 2:14
101s. Gn 2:14
103 : ad etymon vocis alludit: cf. Philon. Leg. alkg. I. 72; In Gen.
I. 12 s.f.
105 Gn 1:7; cf. V. 27.3; VII. 23.1 et 3; 25.3
106 s. Jo 4 : 1 0 et
4 : 1 4 ; cf. V. 7.19; 19.21; 27.2; . Thomas log. 13; Ev. Philippi log. 101; cod. Gnost.
Berol. 8502.2, p.26.20; Pistis Sophia 141, p.242.35 ss. Schmidt-Till; NH V. 5, p.84.8; XIII.
1, pp.37.3; 41.23; 46.17; 48.20; Acta Thomae Gr. 37; 39; 52; lust. Dial. 14.1; 69.6; 114.4;
Resch, p.88 et al.
87 coniec. Go
add. Mi
() coniec. Mi
91
(et. LXX codd. aliquot, Philon. Leg. alkg. I. 63; 66; 67 codd. AP): LXX, Go
92 2 addidi e LXX
93 add. Go
scripsi:
96 addidi e LXX
delevi (om. LXX)
97 Go:

98 addidi
99 Go:
100 () scripsi
(ad etymon vocis v.98 spectat, cf. ad. v. 103):
101 addidi
102 addidi
103 add. Diels
108 Go: We
109 , corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

170

f. 4

Hippolytus

() 20 . , ,
() ,
, ' , (,)


,

21 ./ , ,
, (*)
, (*) ,
, ,
, ()
22 () , ,
, (,) , ()

, ( ) , () , ,
, , ()
.
10 1

120

125

-
() , , '
() &,

110 s. V. 19.9-10; 21.8-9


112 Jo 9 : 1
112 s. Jo 1:9; VII. 22.4; Clem.
Exc. ex Theod. 41.3; Iren. I. 9.2; 10.2 et al.
118 s. cf. 1 ft 2 : 4
120 Is 40:15
121 Jo 4 :10
122 s. Jo 10:9; V. 8.20; 17.9
124 s. cf. V. 8.25 et 31 ;2 Cor 12 :2
125 s. 1 Rg 16:13
126 1 / ^ 1 0 : 1
127 1
16 :14
127 s. 1 2:11;
cf. H V . 8.31; VI. 9.2
110 1 addidi
111 , corr. Mi
112 I
1 addidi ex NT
113 addidi
114 (cf. Esth 7 : 7 et 7 : 8
Orig. ): Go, agn. We
119 post lac.
sign. Mi, qui , ( We) coniecit
120 , corr. Go
scripsi: : Go e LXX
post lacunam
suspicor
: ' Go, agn. Cr We
122 oi addidi
123
add. Usener
124 addidi
oi addidi
126 Go:

addidi
127 2 addidi
2 add. Swoboda

3 add. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.9.19-10.2

171

, ' []
[ ] () ,
,
() ' ' ()
'
, ,
() () ,
7
' () () .

6-29 de psalmo cf. . Harnack (SBBA 1902, pp. 542-545), A. Swoboda (Wien. St.
27, 1905, p. 300 s.), I. Kroll, Die christl. Hymnodik etc. (Ind. Iect. Acad. Braunsberg.
1921-1922 = Darmstadii 1968), p.94 ss.; Th. Wolbergs, o.e., pp.6 s. et 37-59; . Herzhoff, Zwei gnostische Psalmen (Diss. Bonn. 1973), pp.78-142; . Marcovich, The Rediscovery of Gnosticism, II (Numinis Suppl. 41, Lugduni Batav. 1981), pp. 770-778
6 - : cf. Cie. De legg. 2.8 ita prineipem legem ... mentem esse ... dei; Pap.
Gr. Mag. 5.465
: i. q.
, cf. Heracliti fr. 114 DK; Cleanth. Hymn. . w . 2 4 et 39; Diog. Laert. 7.88;
Diodor. Tars. fr. 20 In Deut. (PG 33, p. 1583 C) (opp. )
: cf. Theodoret. Haer. 1.4 ; Iren. Adv. haer. I. 24.3-4
(Basilides) innatum ... Patrem ... misisse primogenitum Nun suum; 1.1.1 (Ptolem.)
; 1.1,
38; V. 1, .9.7
7 : cf. V. 7.9 ; . 32.1;
Zenon. (SVF I nr. 103) aquam appellatum ; Iren. I. 30.1 (Ophitae)
, , , ; II. 5, pp. 99.27 s. et 98.31; 1.5, p. 89.26 s. et al.
8 : cf. Ps 14:2 = Act 10:35
9 : cf. Ps 4 1 : 2 ; I. Wilpert, Die Malereien der Katakomben Roms (1903), facs.
259 nr. 2; 150 nr. 3; Wolbergs, p. 45 s.; A. van Lantschoot in Coptic Studies in Honor ofW.
E. Crum (Boston. 1950), p. 347 s.
10 : cf. ft. Ev. Philippi log.39
( II.3, p.60.12)
11 s. cf. Iren. I. 4.1-2; II. 1, p.31.6
12 : cf.
Plotin. II.9.6.8 ; Plat. Reip. VII, 514 a 5; Mt 21:13 = Jr
7:11 et Th. Wolbergs, pp. 49-51
4 , corr. Mi
2 seclusi ut dittogr.: We
5 seclusi
ut glossema
Mi:
(pro )
Go cett.
6 () . Usener (Altgriech. Versbau, Bonnae 1887, p.94 s.),
cf. . 7: : coniec. Mi
7 Cr
8 () (sc.
seu ) scripsi: : Mi
' Mi: : Cr
(' Swoboda), at cf. Iliad. 23.275
() scripsi: :
(') Mi
9
Mi: : Gu. Harvey
(ad Iren. I, p.LXI), Gu. Christ (Anth. Gr. carm. Christ., Lipsiae 1871, p. 32 s.)
10 coniec. We (conl. Plat. Phaed. 81 a 1)
11 add. Mi

Swoboda: : Mi
12 () coniec. Wolbergs: :
Mi: ' Cr, agn. We
() Cr: , Mi

Christ:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

172

Hippolytus

7a
7b
7c

14

[( ) , ,
( ) , ,
, .]

() ()
.
/ ' (), ,
(')
()
( ) .
, ,
,
'
[]
.

14 cf. Mt 7 : 1 - 2 ; Lc 6:37; Sexti Sent. 183; Cod. Gnost. Berolin. 8502.1 p. 15.16 ss.
16 ... : A. G. XII. 93.1 (Rhianus); Theocrit. 12.19

: Eur. Med. 96
20 . . . : cf. Iliad. 13.591 s.; Odyss. 1.75
: cf. I Clem. 21.9 ; Horn. Clem. 16.16 ... )
; Gn. 2 : 7 ; 7 : 2 2
21 cf. : Gu. Peek, Gr. Vers-Inschr.
nr. 567.4; A. G. VII. 303.6
24 : cf. I Jeu 33-38 Schmidt-Till; II Jeu
45-48; I. Doelger, Sphragis, p. 160 ss.; G. Fitzer in Kittel, Th. Wb. z. NT, 1 (1964), p.953;
Wolbergs, p. 56
25 : cf. V. 7.20; 6.5; 8.45; 9.5
26
: ft. cf. Origen. c. Cels. 6.31; Cod. Copt. Berolin. 8502.1, p. 16.5; Ape 1:20; V. 9.22
27 ... : cf. Orig. c. Cels. 6.30 et 33; Pap. Gr. Mag. 13.997; V. 16.6
13-15 seel. Cr et Harnack (tres dochmios anapaestis immiscuit poeta quidam temporis
posterioris, verbis w . 11-12 , adhortatus)
13-15 scripsi ex coniectura: , ,
,
16 ' add. Cr et scr. Christ:
: We
Mi:
17 corr ex -
, corr. Mi
18 , corr. Mi
, corr. Mi
19 '
add. Mi: ' add. Cr
20 , corr. Cr
Cr:
22 , corr. Mi
26 , corr. Mi
27 Harvey et R.
Lipsius (Gnostieismus, 1860, p. 56):
28 del. Lipsius et Usener

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

173

Refutatio V.10.2.-12.3

, - 1 11
. '
() , ()
, ,
5 ,
() . ' [ ]
, , .
(, ) , ( - 1 12
,)
-
, ,
5 . ' [ 2
] () , ,
,
' ( ) ( )
, /
pf.4ir
, ()
. , 3
() [] () .
, , ,
, 15 ,
.

c. 11: 3 : cf. Iren. I. 30.14 (I, p.241 .) a quibus, velut Lernaea hydra, multiplex
capitibus fera de Valentini schola generata est
c. 12: 1 - V. 17.13: cf. Foerster, I, pp.363-374
: V. 6.6; 8.1-4

4-39 X. 10.1-5

2
2-3 ( ) Cr:

4 scripsi:
6 Cr:
Cr

3 () Mi:
7 1 seel.

1 , addidi
post lac. sign. Mi, quam ex IV. 2.1; V. 13.9 et X.
10.1 expl. I. Bernays (Ges. Abb. I, p. 300 s.)
5 2 Mi:
5-6
hie et Theodoret. Haer. I. 17 (error in Hippolyti fonte): in v. 8 transtul.
Go
6 scripsi ex :
7 Go, agn. Cr
8 ex
add. Go
( ) cf. v. 5-6
10 , corr. Bernays
addidi
12 addidi (cf. v. 9)
seclusi ut dittogr.
2 addidi
14/15 1 , sscr. - - 2

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

174

Hippolytus

f. 4

, () ()
, , ,
' ,
() , 2

5 ,

, () ,
, 25
,
6 ,
. ,
,
, , [] - 3
' ,
7 () () . , , /
, ' ' , ,
, . 35
, ,
,
, (), , .

13 1

()
,
,

17 ss. cf. V. 6.7


20 : cf. . 1, .6.19; II. 1, .5.8; Pistis Sophia 24,
p. 14.25; II Jeu 42, p. 303.25; Gnost. Anon. cod. Bruc. 8, p. 344.27 S.-T et al.
22-24 Col 1:19 et 2 : 9 ; VIII. 13.2; X. 10.4; Iren. I. 3.4; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 31.1
28 : V. 17.2 ss.
32 : dimittuntur sine stipendio (ft. cf. Gal
4:11)
33 s. Jo 3 : 1 7 ; 12:47; Resch, p.83 s.
36 1 Cor 11:32; VI. 14.6
17
2 ex add. Go
Bernays ex :
20 , ex corr. Go
24 addidi
25 : Bernays
30 delevi (om. )
32 Go: ,
addidi ex :
coniec. We
36 post , transtuli
37
, corr. Bernays
38 addidi ex
1 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.12.4-13.7

175


5 ,
- , ( '
, ) ,
() ,
, [] ,
,
, .
[] , .
is
/
() '
( ,)
. (
) , ,
20 - []
. , ,
, , , ,

( ) , ,
25 , , ,
' , , ( )
, , ,
[] .

3
pf.42r

4 - 8 cf. Ps. Aristot. De mundo 2, p. 392 a 9 - 3 4


7 s. VII. 19.2; Aet. II. 4.12
11 s. IV. 1.1 ss.
13 s. : V. 15.3
15-40 e Sexti Emp. Adv. math.
V. 5-11 excerpsit
4 scripsi (cf. v. 5):
6 - 7 ' ,
supplevi conl. w . 16-18; V. 15.2 et Ps. Aristot. 1.1.
7 : Go
8
() scripsi: : Go
9 del. We
11
13
del. Mi
13/14 : - - sscr. 1
16 , e Sexto corr. Mi I
e S. add. We
17 e S. suppl. Go
18
- 19 e S. suppl. Go
19 addidi e S.: add. Go
20 2
delevi (om. S.)
21 S.
22 2 . . . 3 : . . . S.

Go e S.:
23 : S.
24 e S. add. Mi
25 . . .
: . . . S.
26 add. We et add. Go (hab. S.)
28 Go e S.:

2 del. Mi (om. S.)
29 , e S. corr. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

176

f. 42

Hippolytus

- ( 3
) () ,
[] , () ,
8 [] ,
( ) ,
, , 35
()()
() , ,
9 , /
, , ,
.
4

-
, ,
, () ,
10 . 45
, , ( , ) ,
, .
()
11 ( , ) so

34 s. : cf. Ptolem. Tetrab. I. 12 et Schol.; Manil. 2.175-177;


660-663 et al.
45-48 cf. S.. V. 37 et 29
48-52 = IV. 12; S.. V. 39

30 - 31 e S. suppl. Go
31 e S. add. Go
32 del.
Go (om. S.)
2 e S. add. Go
33 del. Mi (om. S.): Go
34 e S. add. Go
Go e S.:
35 , corr. Mi (S.)
36 scripsi e S.:
Go e S.:

37 Go e S.:
Go e S.:
...
scripsi e S.: . . .
41 Go:
43
: an <>?: IV. 2.1: . 10.1 et Theodoret. Haer. I. 17
44 scripsi: : coniec. Mi
() scripsi (cf. v.64):

45 2 Go:
47 post lac. sign. , quam e S. (V. 29) expl. Mi
49 e S. add. Go

50 - e S. suppl. Go

Mi: S. Go
51 S.
51-52 . . . Go ex :
. . . : . . . S.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.13.7-14.1

177

, . ( )
() [] []
[ ] ,
55 , (), () .
, 12
, ( ) ,
.
60 () /
,
,
. ()
, 65 , (). 13

, ' () , .

f. 43

' , 1 14

.
, ,
5 , ()

52-56 = IV. 12; S.. V. 44


2 : cf. Jo 1:23

57-63 IV. 2.1


: cf. V. 7.30; 32-33; 17.8

52 Go e S.:
: Go e S.

addidi ( add. Go), cf. S. V. 44
,
, ,
, .
52-53 Go:
53 addidi e S.
() ,
corr. Go
S.: () Go
delevi (ora. S.)
del. Go
(om. S.)
54 et delevi (om. S.)
55 Go ex et S.:

55/56 ( ) Go e S.: P H
56 ex et S.
add. Go
58 addidi (cf. w . 42-43)
60 addidi
62
, corr. Mi
63 addidi
67 , corr. Mi
scripsi:

67/68 Go:
2 an ()? (cf. V. 7.30 et 32; V. 17.8)
5 2 addidi

4 Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

178

f. 43

Hippolytus

, , ,
, , ()
, () , () ' , ,
2 , ,
, ()
. ' , , /
3 . ,
is
() ()
() () ,
() ()
, .
' () 2
4 , , (), . (*)

8 ( p ? Cr), cf. Ex 15:27; Nu 33:9; Gnost. anon. cod. Bruc. 5,


p. 340.16 Schmidt-Till
10 : cf. Beros. Fr. 1.6 Jacoby (Fr. Gr. Hist. 680)
(i.q. Timat, Gu.R. Smith: cod.), '
11 : cf. V. 162; e.g. Pistis Sophia 136 (p.234.29
S.-T.); 137 (p.235.15) et Gu. Fauth in Der kl. Pauly, 3 (1969), pp.360-363
17
: cf. Herodot. IV. 50.3; VIII. 12.2; Polyb. XI. 24.9; Job 38:25; Prv 2 8 : 3
: cf. Ps. Iambi. Theol. arithm. 31, p.41.6 de Falco

17 s. cf. Pistis Sophia 75,
p. 10829 S.-T.: Und ich werde ferner die Oerter () des Adamas und seiner Archonten
() versiegeln (), damit niemand von ihnen imstande sei, mit Dir Krieg
zu fhren ( ) . . : cf. e.g. 1 Rg 6:16; 1 Esr 4 : 4 7
21 , , : cf. Nonn. Dionys. 10.103-105; 43.389 s. et RE VII,
p. 1410.57
: cf. Gn 10:8-9; \Chr\-. 10; Mch 5 : 5
6 conieci
7 scripsi: (cf. v. 6): coniec. Mi:
Cr: coniec. We
addidi
8 addidi
9
coniec. We
addidi
, corr. Mi
Cr:
10 () Cr
12 Mi:
addidi
14 - (at cf.
.51)
scripsi: : Mi
16 , corr. Mi
coniec.
We:
scripsi:
17 supplevi
17 scripsi:
18 scripsi post Diels. ():

() supplevi conl. V. 16.14 ( ): ' : '


(cum sequentibus) Diels
20 scripsi:
21 1 ( ) coniec. Mi:

scripsi, coniec. We conl. V. 16.11:
post
lacunam significavi: () . Cr

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.14.1-7

179

, ()
[] .
. , ,
25 , , f - f ( 0
,
. , 5
' .
( )
30 () - .
- ' , ()().
- 6
. ' , , ,
, -
35 () - ()
. - ' / 7
, , , ',
- '- ' ,

f. 44r

24 s. de stellis errantibus litteris vocalibus nominatis cf. Fr. Dornseiff, Das Alphabet in
Mystik u. Magie (Lipsiae 1922), pp.53 et 43 s. et ad VI. 48.2
29 cf. Eph 2 :2

30 : cf. ft. 2 Rg 23 :26
(cod. ) et (), () 1 Chr 9:15
31 : cf. Pistis Sophia
102, p. 165.7 S.-T. et al.; N H II. 5, p. 100.25 et I. Michl, in Reallex. f . Ant. u. Christ.,
5 (1962), p.204
32 : cf. Fr. Boll, Sphaera, p.309 s.; Reitzenstein,
p.257 s.
: cf. Sakla(s) in N H III.2, pp.57.16 et 58.24; V.5, p.74.3; Saklas =
Ialdabaoth in N H II. 1, p. 11.17; II.4, p.95.7; XIII. 1, p.39.27; Epiphan. Pan. 26. 10.1 et
C. Holl ad loc.; I. Doresse, The Secret Books of the Egyptian Gnostics (Lond. 1960), pp.51;
274; 433
33 : i.e. Orionem, cf. Boll, o.e., pp. 164 ss. et 310
34 s.
: , cf. inscr. Syr. 2426 b in Le Bas, Waddington,
Foucart, Voyage archeologique etc.
36 : i. q. , Sirium, cf. Diod. I. 27.4;
Boll, o.e., p.208 ss.; Gu. Drexler in Rschen Lex. II, p.434 s.
37 i.e. Ptolemaeus I
Soter
: hetaera Ptolemaei II Philadelphi, cf. Athen. XIII, p. 576
22 1 , - - 2
addidi
23
delevi
24 : Cr
24 et 25 (sine accentu)
25 ft. legendum , sim.
, corruptum
oi addidi
28 Mi:
: We
29 : coniec. Go

supplevi
, correxi
30 addidi

31 scripsi:
scripsi (cf. Et. ., s.v.): :
Mi
33 scripsi:
35 scripsi:
v Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

180

Hippolytus

, . () -
, (') . '
8 , , , ().
() () ,
' , , ,
(), , , , , .

' , , , ,
, (), , , , '.
9 , () - ,
'
, , , , , , , 10 , . ,
, , , , .
' , , ,
, , , , , , ,
(), , .
.

45

so

55

39 : cf. RE XVI, p. 997.33 ss.


41 : cf. in Eus. Praep. ev. I. 10.13
et RE XV, p.2051 (Dt 3:10; Jos 13:9; 16; 17; 21; 21:36; Jr 31:21)
:
uxor Celei, mater Triptolemi: cf. Apollod. I. 5.1 et Rschen Lex. III, p. 2932 nr. 4
43 : ant. Pers. Gau-mata, cf. I. Markwart, Orientalin 50 (1930), pp.23 n. 3; 29 n. 1 I
: cf. C. Preisendanz in RE XVIII, p. 1625.25 ss.
44 : non liquet I
: i.e. , Ea, Aquarius: cf. Fr. Hommel, Archiv f . Orientforsch., Beiband I
(Berol. 1933 Festschrift Oppenheim), p.41 ss.
47 ', : cf. I. Michl,
o. c., pp. 253 et 235 s.

39 scripsi, Go:
supplevi (cf. v. 37)
40 ' addidi
41 : an ? (cf. LXX los. 13 :21 Luc.)
scripsi: We:
coniec. Go, agn. Cr
42 addidi (cf. v.45)
:
Cr
43 : coniec. Mi
44 ( : coniec. I.
Bidez et Fr. Cumont (Les mages hellinises, II, p. 87) conl. CCAGI, p. 128

(cf. P. G.M. 8.1 ): Bidez et Cumont


46 scripsi:
Mi We: coniec. Go, agn. Cr
47 scripsi (cf. RE VII A,
p.77123), ( Mi, 1\) coniec. Go) et Go: . .
48 addidi

50
53
54 1 , - - 2
55 Go:
() coniec. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

181

Refutatio V.14.7-16.1

is

20

( ) /
, ()

, . , ,

, ' ()
' - -,
, ,
. ,
, , (
)
.
,
(,) , ()
() [] ,
()
, , '
.
' ,
() , ()

.

1 15 pf.44v

/ , () 1 16 pf.45r
- , , , ,

c. 15: 13-17 cf. Sext. Emp. Adv. math. V. 12-14


cf. S.E. V. 15-19

18 , 19 , 20 :

c. 16: 3 Orac. Sibyll. Fr. 3.1 et I. Geffcken ad loc.


1
addidi
2 addidi (cf. v. 9)
6

addidi
9 scripsi:
11-12
addidi (cf. v.4)
14 : S.E. V. 12; 13; 51;
V. 16
15 addidi
scripsi:

: Mi
16 addidi
17 addidi
seclusi ut
dittogr.: coniec. Go
18 addidi
19 Go:
22 , corr. Go
3 add. Go
: Mi
1 , corr. Mi

scripsi (cf. v. 10 ):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

182

Hippolytus

- , ,
, ' 5
,
2 , , , , , ,
. ,
, , , (,) ,
, , , - -
3 , , (,)
,
[] () . , ,
( ) ,
- -
() ,
() .

f. 45

is

4 , , , ' ', ,
, , , 2
()
5 , , , , ,
- ()
[] -, /
- , -, 25
- -,
- () ,
, (,)
. -

6 ad etymon vocis spectat


9 - 1 3 cf. V. 14.1-2
15-17 Iliad.
15.36-38; Odyss. 5.184-186; Hymn. ApoU. 8 4 - 8 6 ; V. 20.10
19 s. Heracliti
Fr.36 DK = Fr.66 Marcovich
20 s. Ex 1 4 : 2 8
2 3 - 2 5 V. 7.39-41; Acta
Thomae c. 108 (v. 12 s.); Jonas, p . 3 2 2 n . 4 ; Philon. De migrat. Abr. 2 0 (
) et al.
26 s. Ex 15 :22
7 , corr. Mi
9 addidi
11 addidi
13 delevi
addidi
14 supplevi conl. V. 20.10
coniec. Mi (conl.
. V. 20.10):
15 : Horn.
16 -
17
19 I. Bemays:
21 addidi
22 scripsi:

, Mi:
23 addidi
24
seclusi ut glossema (cf. Steph. Byz., s.v. , ( ) )
27 addidi
28 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.16.1-10

183

30

, , , 6
, , ,
,
, , 7
,
35 , , ()
- . - (,) ,
-, ,
. , , 8
40 - ()
-, () , , . , ,
,
. , ,
() - () 45 .
() , , .
(), (), () , (- 9
) , ,
() (). , , ()
so ()/ ,
- , (,)
(). , , 10
, () '
,
55 . , , () ' ,
, ,

pf.46 r

31-33 Nu 21:6s.
33 s s . N u 2 1 : 8 s .
4 2 E x 4 :2-3 et 1 7 ; 7 : 9 - 1 0 e t 15;HVIII. 14.3
43-45 Ex 7 : 1 1 s .
46 cf. Gn 3 :1 ss.
47 Gn 2 :8
47 s. Gn 2 :10; V.
9.14; VI. 14.8
48 s. Gn 4 :15
49-51 Gn 4 : 3 - 5
52 :
cf. Act 2 : 1 7 ; 2 Tm 3 : l ; / r 5 : 3
52 s. Mt 2 : 1
53 s. Gn 3 7 : 3 et 28
55 s. Gn 27 :15 et 27
56-58 cf. Gn 2 7 : 1
33-34 ... , corr. Mi
35 () scripsi:
36 Go:
addidi
39
40 addidi (cf. v.36)
41 addidi
44 add. Mi
addidi
46 addidi
47 addidi
47/48 add. suad. We
49 2 addidi e LXX I
addidi
51 addidi
52 , corr. Go
53 addidi
54
, corr. Go
55 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

184

11

12

13
f. 46
14

15

Hippolytus

, ' ,

. , , -
, , , ,
, '
() (),
. , ,
,
, (, ,) ' 65
() , .
, ,
() . , , , () , , - ,
, , 7
. ' ,
. , , ,
() . , ,
, / , ,
, , ( 75
), , , ,

, () ()
- so
, , , , , -,
' . ,

57 : cf. Gn 33:9
58 s. Gn 33:10
59 s. Gn 10:9
63-65 Jo 3 :14; Ps. Tert. Ado. Haer. 2.1
65 s. Nu 2 1 : 8 s.
67 s. IV. 47.2-4
69-72 Jo 1 :1-4; V. 8.5; 9.2; Iren. I. 8.5; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 6.1-4; 45.3; Ptol. Ep. ad
Flor. 3.6; Heracl. Fr. 1 ap. Orig. In . II. 14 et al.
73 s. Gn 3 :20; V. 7.39; VI. 34.3
76 Mt 13 :16; Lc 10:23
79 s. d . P h l : 10; V. 7.11; 8-22
58 : LXX
60 LXX
61 Cr: I
scripsi:
62
addidi
63
: NT
65 , addidi
66 add. We
68 addidi
1 , transposuit 2
69 1 addidi
72 scripsi:
1
73 addidi
74 , transposui
75 ,
transposui
2 : coniec. Mi: Cr
75-76
supplevi ex v. 82
79 add. Go

add. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V. 16.10-17.3

185

,
, , [] -
85 -
. ' , (,) -
(), . 16
, '
, (),
90 ,
.
() ",
, .
() , 17
,
. , '
. / () '
pf.47r
5 , . '
, , -
. , , 2


,

, (). - 3
, , , ()

83 et 87 Arat.46 , , ; IV. 47.1


84-86 Arat. 61 s.;
IV. 47.3
87 Arat. 57; IV. 47.1
87 s. Arat. 71 et 615; IV. 48.1
88-90 Arat. 63-67; 73; IV. 47.4-5
91 Arat. 70; . IV. 47.5
92-94 Arat. 82 s.;
IV. 48.4-6
c. 17: 14 s. Gn 30:37-39; lust. Dial. 86.2
84 scripsi:
2 del. We
86
addidi
87 () scripsi ex IV. 47.1: Aratus
89 supplevi
ex Arat. 66 et IV. 47.4
92 addidi
1 add. Mi
3
4 post in litt, evanidae tres: scripsi:
We
12 () scripsi:
14 addidi (cf. v. 31) I
coniec. We ( LXX):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

186

pf.47v

Hippolytus

4 . '

.

, ,
5 . , (, )

() , ()

6 , ,
, ,
/ () , [] ,
, ,
.
7
" , , ,
'
. - '
, ,
. () ()
, (,) '
8 () , , , '
( ) , , (,) ,
()

is

25

35

20-24 cf. VII. 25.6-7


26 s. Gn 30:39
30 Jon 4 :10; lust. Dial. 107.4
31 e.g. Mt 7 :11
33 s. Jo 8 :44; Epiphan. Pan. 40. 5.5; Heracl. Fr.46 ap. Orig. In Io.
20.24; . Philippi log.42; Clem. Strom. I. 85.2; Ps. Clem. Horn. 3. 25.2 et al.
40 : cf. V. 7.30; 32-33; 14.1
15 (sc. ) scripsi:
20 ,
addidi
: coniec. We
22 addidi
24
, transposui
() Cr
Cr:
25
, transposui
Go: : Mi
, corr. Go
26 addidi
26/27
27 , delevi
28 , corr. Go
Go:
31 1 , 2
34 , corr. Mi
35 scripsi:
scripsi:
addidi
36 addidi
37 () scripsi:
37-38
, transponere suad. Mi
38 addidi
: Go I
addidi
40 supplevi ex V. 7.32

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.17.3-13

187

, ,
' , , , 9
, ( ) () , ()
(,
45 ), , ()
, , 10
, (), ,
,
, , / ' ()
so .

pf.48r

() - 11
,
(), . 12
55
, ,
-
. 13
60 , -
, .

42 Jo 10:7 et 9; V. 8.20; 9.21; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 26; Ps. Clem. Horn. 3. 52.2 et al.
42 s. cf. V. 7.31-32 et Is 6 : 1 0
44 : VII. 25.6
4 5 ^ 7 V. 9.19;
21.8
51-58 IV. 51.10-13; V. 9.15
58 cf. 1 : 3

41
42 scripsi:
43 post lac. sign. Go:
supplevi conl. V. 7.31-32 et Mt 2 0 : 3 3 ; Jo 9 : 2 1
, corr. Mi
scripsi:
addidi
44 ,
corr. Go
44-45 , supplevi
45
2
add. Mi
47 Go:
addidi
49
addidi
51 scripsi:
addidi
53 addidi
55
Go:
57 et 60
58
:
Go
60 scripsi:
61 Mi: : Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

188
18 1

Hippolytus

'
, ( ) ()() ,
, ' .
5

19 1

f. 48

.
, . []
,
, () 5
2 - , , () []
, / , , ,
. , , ()
3 .
, , ,
, ,
, '
(),
4 () (). is
() () , ,
,

c. 19: 1 - V. 22.1: cf. Foerster, I, pp. 382-391


1-112 . 11.1-11
4 : VI. 9.7; VII. 22.1; VIII. 12.5
5-9 VI. 12.4 et 16.5
10 cf.
VII. 1 (Paraphrasis Seem = PS), p. 1.26-28; Iren. I. 30.1; Bousset, p. 122 s.; G. Widengren in The Origins of Gnosticism (Numinis suppl. 12, Lugd. Batav. 1967), p.57 s.; Bundebesh
1.4etal.
10 : cf. PS p. 1.19
17 s. : cf. PS p.4.5 s.
c. 18: 2 supplevi conl. V 11.1
: Go

2-3 scripsi:

c. 19: 1
3 Mi: '
seclusi
5 Go ex :
: Mi
(vac. spat. litt.2)
6

() Mi: : , Bernays
seclusi (om. )
7 -
7/8 , transposui
8
9 Cr: : coniec. We
addidi ex
12
(cf. Apoll. Rhod. 1.1016): Go
15 () () Go ex
: : Mi We
15-16 () Go: : :
Mi
16 2 add. Mi
17 v Cr: : Go
scripsi: : del. Mi
Bernays ex :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.18.1-19.10

189

, () , - () []
. -
() ,
.
, (,) ,
25 .
, , ,
, , / ,
, , , , ()
()
30 . , (,)
, ,
( ) , ( ) . ,
,
35 ,

.
, ' , ()
40 . () ,
() ' , ,
,
, [
] ,
20

20 s. V. 21.2-3
24 s. cf. Gn 1:2; w . 8 8 - 9 0
19-26
43 : cf. PS p.5.16 s. ()

6
pf.49r

10

26 : cf. ft. PS p.3.

19 Mi ex :
20 () scripsi ex : I
delevi ut dittogr.
22 () Bemays ex :
23 2
Mi ex :
24 addidi ( )
25
26 Mi
( ):
27 Roeper:
28 addidi ( )
29 , corr. Mi
ex add. Bernays
30 addidi conl.
32 addidi et ex add. suad. We
33 addidi ex
34

36 , corr. Bernays
scripsi:

39 2 Mi:
add. Go
40 add. Go
Go:

41 addidi
' scripsi: '
43/44
del. We ut dittogr.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

190

f. 49
11

12

13

14

Hippolytus

[ ], 45
[] ( )
. '
(), , /
,
. () so
[ ] ,
. ,
, , ,
, , 55
() .
()
(') () ()
.
() 6
, ( ) ,
[]
.
, 65
,
,
, ( )

52 : cf. PS p. 4.24 et passim


65 : cf. PS pp. 2.1; 7.3 et al.
: ad etymon vocis . 68 spectat

67 -

45 post , transposui: Go

seclusi ut dittogr.
46 delevi
( ) scripsi conl. :

48 addidi
50 addidi ex
51 ,
seclusi (om. )
Go ex :
51-52 Go
ex : , def. Bernays We
56

Go
scripsi:
58 (') Bernays:
2
, corr. Bernays
60 , corr. Mi
61
: Go: ' coniec. We
add. Cr
62 Mi:
62 et 63 Bernays: et
63 delevi

scripsi:
67 Go ex : We
68
post lac. sign. Go
add. Cr: add. suad. We
addidi ex w . 71, 76 ( ): add. Bernays, add. suad. We I
add. Cr
68-69 , corr. Bernays

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.19.10-17

191

,
70 ( ) .

[] ,
, / 15
, () . ()
75
, ,
- ()
- ,
, so , (), ( )- 16
( , ) ( )
( ) - , ( ) , , ,
, () ()
, ()
85 , ()
, () [] ()
,
' . , 17

f. sor

77 s. cf. Mt 5 : 1 3 et 5 : 1 4 ; Iren. I. 6.1; Clem. Quis div.


sah. 36.1
82 Ps 28 :3; V. 8.15; . 11.9
69 '
Bernays ex :
70
supplevi ex
post , transposui
72 Bernays:
1, - 2
delevi
Bernays:
73
74 1 scripsi:
2 add. Go
75
76
77 Go: : Bernays
( )
Bernays:
78
scripsi: : Mi
79 scripsi:
80 addidi
( ) scripsi
(possis et solum (): cf. spatium vacans in v. 91 ()): (vac. spat. litt.
11) : ( ) coniec. Mi
81 ( ) coniec.
We et () coniec. Mi (cf. w . 17, 88): (vac. spat. litt. 9)
( > We ex : (vac. spat. litt. 7)
82 ex
add. suad. We
ex et LXX addidi post I. Bernays () et We
( o )
83 scripsi:
addidi ex
83-84 ()
scripsi ex :
85 Bernays:

addidi
86 scripsi ex :
Cr:
delevi
Go ex : We
87 scripsi ex :

scripsi ex :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

192

18

19
f. 5
20

21

Hippolytus

() ,
() . 9
* * * *
* , ,
() , [] , , () - -
, 95
(' ) .
,
, , ,
, /, ,
,
, ,
,
, , () ,
, , , , , - 5
, ' ,
, , () ,

( ) -

90 Gn 1:2; VI. 14.4-5; 17.2; Iren. I. 30.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 47.3; Apocr. Io. (cod.
Gnost. Berol. 8502.2) p. 45.10; N H II. 4, p. 87.12 et al.
101-103 cf. PS p. 19.32 ss.
105 Ph 2 : 7 ; v. I l l ; V. 21.9; X. 11.11
105 s. ft. cf. Jo 1:1 et 14
108 Act 2 : 2 4 (. 1. )
89 Go: : Bernays

90
scripsi:
Bernays e LXX:
91 usque ad v.92
locus desperatus: exspectes ( )
( ) ( ) (, ) ( ) ( ,) (cf. w . 65-70 et
94-96)
91 post in vac. spat. litt. 14
: Cr
post
in vac. spat. litt. 10
post in vac. spat. litt. 13
post
in vac. spat. litt. 10
post in vac. spat. litt. 13
93
Go ex : We
delevi (om. )
: Go
scripsi ex :
94 addidi
() coniec. We
96 ' addidi
98 : Go
102 Bernays:
104 2 add. Bernays
107 2 addidi
109 add. We et add. Go
Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.19.17-20.3

193

no ,
.
, ' , 1 20
,
,
.
5 , - (
,) , - -
, , () , , , 2
- , , - , ,
- , ,
. / 3
,
.
, ()
is (), , ,
.
, ,
( ) .

110 Jo 4 : 1 0 et 14; V. 7.19; 9.18; 27.2

f. 511

111 s. cf. Mt 2 2 : 1 1 s.; V. 8.44; Clem.

Exc. ex Theod. 61.8; 63.1


c. 20: 5 Dt 5 -.22; (Ex 10:22); VIII. 8.5; Ps. Clem. Horn. 3. 45.3
7 Gk 4 : 2 5 ; cf.
Iren. I. 7.5; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 54.1; A.F.I. Klijn, Seth in Jewish, Christian and Gnostic
Lit. (NT Suppl.46, Lugd. Batav. 1977), p.89
8 Gn 6 : 1 0
9 Ex 6 : 3 ; 4 Mcc
7 : 1 9 ; VI. 3 6 2 ; VII. 25.4
9 s. Gn 1 : 5 - 1 3 ; VI. 14.2
11-13 Gn 2 : 1 6 s.;
V. 26.22; NH II.4, p.8827 ss.
13 s. Gn 1 2 : 1 ; Act 7 : 3 ; NH II.6, p. 133.29-31
16 s. Ex 2 0 : 1 3 - 1 5 ; Dt 5 : 1 7 - 1 9
110 scripsi:

111

1 scripsi:
Mi
-2
corr. Go
4 scripsi:
5-6 addidi
( Clem., cf. Iren.)
8
12 (et. L X X
Go e L X X
13 ( ): L X X
14
Act. 7 : 3 et L X X codd. aliquot: om. L X X
addidi e L X X
18 addidi

3 ,
7 addidi
cod. suppl.):
, et.
15 1 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

194

Hippolytus


,
5 .
() () - () - () .

,

6 ( ) () () , ,
[ ]
.
-
-, () ( )
, ,
7 , .

19-40 - Orph. fr. 243 Kem


22 : V. 19.11
23-34 = Plut.
Moral, fr. 24 Sandbach
25 s. : lapsu scripsit : immo
vel (i.e. Phlya, non Phleius)
27 (sc. ): cf. Paus. I. 31.4 et
RE XVI, p. 1265 s.; Suppl. X, p. 537
29-40 cf. M. Marcovich,/ T.S., N. S. 25 (1974),
pp. 447-451
30 s. cf. Lampriae catal. nr. 43 '
32 : cf. Orph. hymn. 6.2 et 7; Orph. frr. 54 et 78 .
32 s. :
cf. Orph. hymn. 6.3, 9 et 10; Pap. Gr. Mag. 4.1748 ss. Preisendanz
33 : ft. cf.
Pap. Gr. Mag. 4.2279 ; 2336 ; 2550 s. et sim.
19 Go:
21 post v. 20 , transposui
22 F. G.
Schneidewin (Goett. Gel. Nachr. 1852, p. 95):
addidi

scripsi: : I.D. Guigniaut et Cr


scripsi:
Schneidewin ex . 37:
23 scripsi:
addidi
25, 26 scripsi: , def. Kern: Mi
27 add. ten
Brink (Mnem. 2, 1853, p. 384)
add. Schneidewin

R. Scott et Schneidewin ex v. 40:
( ) ten
Brink
28, 30 et 32 -
28 del. Mi: coniec. We, agn. Kem
30 Mi:
: Lampriae cat.
31 addidi post Mi

: () coniec. Mi, agn. Cr: coniec. . Maass (Orpheus,


p. 302): coniec. We
addidi conl. V. 21.1 et Iliad. 9.639
32 , corr. Mi
33 : Go, agn. Cr, P. Tannery (Revue de
philoL 24, 1900, p. 99), F.H. Sandbach

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.20.4-10

195

, f f .
35 () ,
/ ,
() , ()
, , - 8
'
40 .

f. 5

, '
- . - 9
() , () ,
45
' , () '

so

- -
,

10

'
() ,
.

34 - : cf. Orph. hymn. 6.8; Orph. frr.2 et 86 .; RE XIX, p. 1763


: cf. v. 37 s.
34 et 36 : ft. cf. Iosephi Ant. lud. 12.160 ; 1.263
; Gn 21: 22 et 32; 2 6 : 2 6 ()
42 Iliad. 15.189; V. 8.3
48-50 Iliad. 15.36-38; Odyss. 5.184-186; Hymn. ApoU. 84-86; V. 16.3
34 et 35 scripsi: : ten Brink:
coniec. Maass (p. 303)
34 non sanum (an , i. q. , 'veneranda,
honoranda'?) et scripsi (cf. v. 36): : ten Brink:
coniec. Maass
35 addidi
- hic et in w . 39, 52
36 1 post , transp. Go
37 1 addidi
37-38 ( )
scripsi: : ten Brink
39 scripsi:
40 ( ego) R. Scott et . Meineke: :
( . Diels) Go
42 scripsi (cf. v. 43): : Horn.
44 2 addidi
( ) scripsi:
45 scripsi:
scripsi:

46<) scripsi:
48 |_ Horn.
52 addidi (cf. w . 44 et 49)
, corr. Go
53 , corr. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

196

21 1

3
pf. 52

Hippolytus

' ( )
, () ()
.

[]

[] , () () , , / ,

,
. ,
[] ,
. []
,
,
, , [] .
, , ()
.
, , ,
, [] .

- , (,)
, , ,
, (') , ,

is

25

8 s. cf. V. 19.4; . 11.3; IX. 10.8 = Heracliti fr. 67 DK = fr. 77 Marcovich


21 s. Mt 10:34; Iren. I. 3.5 = Epiphan. Pan. 31.15.3; . Thomaelog. 16; Ps. Clem. Recogn. 2.
26.6; 28.2; 6. 4.6
2 addidi
3 , corr. Mi
addidi
3-4 ()
scripsi post Cr ( ):
4 et 50 -
6 delevi (cf. w . 15,17)
8 delevi et scripsi:
() scripsi:
9 supplevi: ante in signum ./. (sed
nil in margine)
14 1 delevi ut dittogr.

15 delevi
17-18 Go:
18 scripsi (cf. w . 19, 21, 26, 31,
39, 48):
del. Go
del. We
18, 22, 23, 31 et 40 -
19 addidi

20 coniec. Cr: : We
bis
22 delevi
24 addidi
26 '
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.21.1-12

197

, . ( ) 7
,
( ) ,
30 , ( ) []
. , , , , 8
() , ( ) ()
()
. () / - 9
35 (, ,) ,
,
, , () .

f. 52

' , , ()
40 (, ) .
() 10
[] ' . ( )
,
45 - 11
, ( ) ,
, .
, , , ,
. , 12
so , ()
.

27 Ph 3 :20; , adDiogn. 5.9; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 54.3; Paed. 3.99.1; Strom. 3. 95.2; 4. 12.6
32-34 V. 9.19; 17.9-10
37 Ph 2 : 7 ; V. 19.20 et 21; . 11.11; Theodoret.
1.14
41 Herodot. 6.20
42-49 Herodot. 6.119.2-3
27 ( ) supplevi conl. Philumeni De venenatis animal. 4.1:
28
29 supplevi conl. VII. 19.9 et 30.1
30
addidi
scripsi:
, delevi: coniec. Mi
31 : G. Pasquali
, transposui
32 Go:
( ) scripsi:
add. Mi
33 1
addidi
33-34 coniec. We:
34 ()
Cr
addidi
35 add. Go et addidi
37-38 -
post .38 , transposui
38 addidi
39 2
addidi
39-40 post , transposui
40 ,
supplevi
41 Go ex Herodoto:
42 delevi
43 '
scripsi: '
addidi et add. suad. We
45

scripsi:
46 1 Go:
add. We et add. Go
48 Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

198
22 1

Hippolytus


' , ()
()
. '
, .
5

f. 53 23 1

/ ,
() [ ] (*)

- -, 5
, '
, ()
2 , .
,
() () ( -
- ,
-,
() , '
() . is
() , '

c.22: 3 : cf. VII. 1 (Paraphrasis Seem) et H.-C. Puech in Coptic Studies


in Honor ofW.E. Crum (Boston. 1950), p. 123 s.; I. Doresse, The Secret Books of the Egyptian
Gnostics (Londin. 1960), p. 150; Fr. Wisse, N.T. 12 (1970), p. 138 s.; I.-H. Severin, Le
Museon 88 (1975), p.75; A.F.I. Klijn, Seth etc. (Lugd. Batav. 1977), p. 105; praesertim M.
Krause, 'Die Paraphrase des Seem und der Bericht Hippolyts', Proceedings of the Internat.
Colloquium on Gnosticism (Stockholmiae 1977), pp. 101-110; B.A. Pearson, 'The Figure of
Seth in Gnostic Literature', The Rediscovery of Gnosticism, II (Numinis Suppl. 41, Lugd.
Batav. 1981), pp.472-504, praecipue p.496; Fr. Wisse, 'Stalking those elusive Sethians',
idem, pp. 563-576, praec. p. 570 s., et al.
c.23: 3 s. Mt 10:5
1

7 s. cf. v. 15 s.; V. 24.1; 27.2; I Proem. 3


1 et 4 -

2 addidi

3 ijf

2 Go:
, seclusi: ) Go
lacunam suspicor: exspectes e. g.

post

5 scripsi:
7 ( ) scripsi:
10 addidi I
0() scripsi:
11 , corr. Mi
13
addidi (cf. v. 11)
14 addidi
scripsi:
14-15 , corr. Mi
16 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.22.1-25.1

199

, , ,
, ,
( ) . 3
20 ()
, -
[ ] , () .
/ , , 1 24 f. 53
' ,
, () , [ ]
. ,
5 ' , ,
- . 2

,
() , (' ) ,
, , () , , 3
' ()
,
' () .
1 25
,

c. 24: 1 s. 1 Cor 2 : 9 ; V. 26.16; 27.2; VI. 24.4; In Dan. IV. 59.2; . Tbomae log. 17;
Acta Thomae 36; Acta Petri Gr. 39; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 10.5; Manich. Turfn fr. 789
et al.
2-6 V. 27.1-2
6 Ps 109:4; V. 27.1
c. 25: 1-18 Herodot. 4.8-10
19 supplevi
delevi ut dittogr. (cf. v. 19)
corr. Mi

20 supplevi (cf. v. 22)


22 ,
addidi ( Cr)
23 ,

c. 24: 2 : . . . NT
3 1 ex add. We
Go ex :

seclusi ut gloss.
4 1 ,
2
8 del. Cr
, corr. Mi
9 , corr. Go
' addidi
:
10 addidi
10/11 (ut .)
11 , con. Mi
12 () scripsi:
13 : Go
14
c. 25: 1 , corr. Go

Herodot.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

200

f. 54

Hippolytus

, '
. 5
2 , , / , . ,
,
3 , , , () -
,
.
,

4 , . - is
, .
, ()
. ,
,
, .
2
26 1

, ,
. () ,
, ,
, ( ) ,
() , , , (), 5
' () , ,

c. 26: 1 - V. 27.5: cf. Foerster, I, pp. 65-79


De cc. 26-27 cf. . Haenchen, Zs. f .
Theo!, u. Kirche 50 (1953), pp. 123-158; R. M. Grant, Church Hist. 23 (1954), pp. 36-45
1-30 . 15.1-3
2 : cf. Mc 10:18; Lc 18:19; Mt 19:17; V.7.26; VII.
31.6; Iren. 1.20.1. - : cf. V.7.26; 8.44; 9.14; VII.38.1 et 5; Iren. 1.27.1; Epiphan. Pan. 40. 7.1 et 3; 45. 1.3; Clem. Strom. II. 114.3; Ptol. Ep. ad Flor. 7.5; cod. Gnost.
Berol. 8502.2, p.25.18 s.; NH 1.3, pp.33.34; 36.35; 42.30; 43.19; II.6, p. 135.26; II.7,
p. 145.16; III.3, p.72.17 = III.4, p.95.10; VI.8, p.74.32; VII.2, p.62.11; 4 Esr 7.138 et al.
5 : cf. App. Verg. Cir. 67 (Haupt)
6 Go:
10 addidi ex . 15.2 et Herodoto
13 scripsi:

17 -
19 , corr. Mi
, corr. Mi
c. 26: 2 Mi:
addidi ex
3

3 Go ex : ()
4 ex suppl. Go
5 scripsi:
:
() scripsi ex :
6
addidi conl. v. 8 et V. 25.2 et 4

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.25.1-26.5

201

,
, , , () ,
' ,
, /
- , , - ()
,
.
,
is , , , ,
(*) , , - - , , , , ,
, , , , , , .
()

f. 54
3

7 : cf. Hesiod. Theog. 298 s.; Athenag. Leg. 20.4 = Orph. fr. 58 .;
contulit R. v.d. Broek, Vig. Christ. 27 (1973), pp. 35-45
: cf. V. 9.15;
16.9; VI. 14.8
8 : cf. N H II. 6, p. 137.11; II. 5, p. 105.24 ss.; Gn 35 :10
11 : cf. N H II. 1, p.24.18 ss.; VII.3, p.82.24
15 : cf. Iren. 1.30.9;
Orig. c.Cels. 6.30; N H II. 1, p. 17.30; Pistis Sophia 64, p.84.2 S.-T. et passim; I. Michl in
Realkx.f. Ant. u. Christ. 5 (1962), p.247
: cf. Is 65:16 Symmach. ;
Ape 3:14; N H II.l, p. 16.1; Pistis Sophia 1, p.2.18 et al.
: cf. N H IX. 1,
p.6.14 et Haenchen, pp. 136-138
: cf. N H III.2, pp.52.23; 53.6; 57.7;
64.26; VIII. 1, pp.57.9; 58.22; Pistis Sophia 7, p.7.28; 64, p.84.2 et passim; Orig. c.Cels.
6.30; Michl, p.241
: i.q. El-Shaddai; cf. V.7.30
17 : cf.
v. 93 et in Pap. demot. mag. Lond. et Lugd.-Batav. col. 5.9, p. 46 Griffith-Thompson et ft. Balbel in N H II. 1, p. 16.10; E. Peterson, Rhein. Mus. 75 (1926), p. 398 s.
: i.q. , cf. Iren. 1.4.1 et passim; N H II.3, p. 10-15; V.3, pp.34.3; 35.9 s.;
36.5
: i.q. , cf. V.6.3; 9.12
: i.q. Stella errans Iuppiter, cf.
Ginz Dext. 1.192, p.28.30; II. 126, p. 46.30 Lidzbarski
: cf. N H II. 1, p. 11.3;
III. 2, p. 58.21; Belial, Beliar (2 Cor 6:15) et Michl, p. 209
18 : cf. N H 1.2,
p.4.37 et 39; IX. 1, p.20.15, Iren. 1.24.2 = VII. 28.7; Epiph. Pan. 40. 5.3 s.; 45. 2.1;
, Michl, p. 232 s. et al.
: cf. in cod. Par. 2316 ff.433 r ;
436 , ap. Reitzenstein, pp.19 n.O et
297.8 s.
: cf. Iren. 1.30. 5 et 11; Epiphan. Pan. 26. 10.2; cod. Gnost. Berol.
8502.2, pp.40.9; 42.3; N H II. 1, p. 10.33; II.5, p. 101,31; III.2, p.58.14; V.3, p.39.11;
VII. 2, pp. 52.25 et 55.2 et 7; Michl, p.202 s. (Nr. 8 et 9)
: cf. E. Peterson,
p. 420 (nr. 121) et ft. Ez 31:18
: hapax; vocem karkum, (Cf
4:14) contulit Grant, p. 40
8 addidi ex
9 :
10 ,
transposui
11 2 add. Go
13 (cf. . 37): R. Scott
15 post
lacunam (septem angelorum nomina continentem) sign. Mi
17 , corr. Mi et Go
18 : coniec. Go: coniec. .
Haenchen (p. 136 n.5) conl. cod. Gnost. Berol. 8502.2 p.40.11
(et.
Iosephus): Go
19 addidi ( )

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

202

f. 55r
8

Hippolytus

, 2
.
, , ,
,
, - , () 25
, () , () ,
, .

.
30
, , ()
() ,
, ,
' /
, , , 35
.
,
, , ,

() , . 4
, , () ,
, ,
,
.
, 45

22 s. Gn 2 : 8
25 s. oi - : cf. Ps Sal 14 :3
26-28 Gn 2 : 9
31-38 X. 15.4
32 s. cf. Gn 2 :7; VI. 14.5; 34.5; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 50.1 et al.
35 (sc. ): cf. Iren. 1.24.1; 30.5; N H II. 1, p. 15.13 ss.; II.4, p.87.23 ss.
et al.
36 s. cf. VI.32.1
38 cf. Gn 2 : 7 ; N H II. 1, p. 19.23 ss.; II.4, p.88.12
ss.; V. 5, p. 6 6 2 0 ss. et al.
40 s. Gn 1 :26 s.
44 s. Gn 1:28
; Corp. Herrn. 1.18
(Poimandr), . 31.2
20 , corr. Mi
25 addidi
26 addidi
27 addidi I
: LXX
28 , corr. Go
scripsi: :
Go Cr: We conl. v. 46
29
31 2 et
1
32 addidi
34
, corr. Mi
36 ,
corr. Bernays
38 Mi:
39 scripsi:
40 1
addidi
41 scripsi (cf. v. 51):
addidi
42 , corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.26.5-13

so

55

60

65

203

. ,
, ' , ,

, ,
() () .
, ,
,
, , , ,
. () ()
() , /
.
, '
() ( ),
()
() .
, (,) , ,
- ,
() , ()
, () (),
() [ ] ()

.

10

11

f. ssv
12

13

4 7 - 5 0 cf. Pherecyd. Fr.2 DK ;


Clem. Strom. 3.1.1
51 s. cf. Gn. 2 : 1
52 et 54 Gn 2 : 1 0 - 1 4 ; V.9.15-17;
VI. 15.1
55 s. : cf. Ptolem. Tetrab. 1.19 ; Gu. et H.
Gundel in RE XX (1950), p.2125; Iren. 1.17.1 et al.
58 s. cf. Gn 2 : 1 1

63 : ad etymon vocis v. 62 alludit
65
et 67 : cf. et e.g. Fr. Boll, Sternglaube u. Stemdeutung3 (Lipsiae
1926), pp. 54 s.; 134 ss.
49 bis
50 et addidi
51
52 scripsi
conl. Gn 2 : 1 et Ps 145:6: : R. Scott
et v.55 :
et
:
55 addidi
hic et in
v. 59
scripsi:
56 addidi
57 , corr.
Mi
58 scripsi:
59 supplevi conl. v. 62 et
Gn 2 : 1 1 .
60 addidi
61 add.
suad. Cr
Mi: : We
scripsi:

62 addidi
64 addidi: pro 63 Mi

supplevi ex w . 53/54, 67
65 , corr. We
addidi (cf. v. 63)
66 addidi
seclusi ut gloss.
, corr. Mi
67
scripsi post Mi ( .) et Go ( .):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

204
14

15

16
pf. 56
17

18

19
20

Hippolytus

() , 70

,
' - - ()
-
(). - 75
,
,
, (')
, ' . , / () so
,
.
, , ,
-
, . 85
'

, ' .
,
, 9
.
[] ,
- -

6 9 - 1 6 6 cf. . 15.5-7
73 : cf. IV. 43.8; Ps. Aristot. Probl. 13.5, p. 908 a
25; Plut. De Stoic, repugn. 1053
76 s. Ps 1 1 7 : 1 9 ( ); cf. Clem.
Strom. 1.38.5; VI. 64.2; 1 Clem. 48.2; Orig. c.Cels. 6.36; Ps 2 3 : 7 ; V.8.18 et al.
77 : cf. Iren. 1.7.3; 30.5; VII.26.1 et al.;Jonas, p.230 s.
78 s. Ps 1 1 7 : 2 0
81 s. 1 Cor2:9;
V.24.1; 27.2; VI.24.4; Ev. Tbomae\o%. 17; 1 Clem. 3 4 . 8 ; 2 Clem. 11.7;
Clem. Strom. II. 15.3; IV. 114.1; 135.3; V.25.4; 40.1; VI.68.1 et al.
82 s. Ps 1 0 9 : 1 ;
VII.23.6; cf. Mt 2 2 : 4 4 ; Mc 1 2 : 3 6 ; Lc 2 0 : 4 2 ; Ep. Bam. 12.10; Clem. Exc. ex Theod.
62.1; 1 Clem. 36.5 et al.
83 : cf. Dt 9 :14
84 : cf. Gn 6 : 3 ;
Plat. Phaed. 81 e 2; 91 e 7 et al.
70 addidi
72 scripsi:
73 ' scripsi: ' I
addidi
74 , corr. G o

7 4 - 7 5
() scripsi (cf. w . 160, 162):
75 , transposui
78 ' add. Cr
79 LXX
80 addidi
90
, corr. Mi
92 del. M i

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.26.14-24

205

,
95 , ()

. 21
' , ,
/ , ,
.
( ) , ,
, (,) /
. 22
5 ' - -
, -
, ( )
,
, ,
n o ( .) ,
, 23
, (),
. ( ) ,
us ( ) ()
, , 24
,
[ ]
.

f. 56

98 : cf. Ape 1 3 : 2
106-108 Gn 2 : 1 6 s.; V. 20.3; NH II.4,
p.8827 ss.
I l l s. cf. Gn 3 :13; 2 Cor 1 1 : 3 ; 2 En 3 1 : 6 ; Apoc. Abrah, 23; Epiphan.
Pan. 40. 5.3
95 add. Go (cf. v. 99)
96
101 : Go Cr
102 addidi
103 1 , 2
addidi
104 :
Go Cr
105 2 , 1
107 sec. e L X X add. Go
110
supplevi
113 () coniec. Cr:
114 addidi
115 addidi
supplevi
118 seel. Go
118-119
Bernays et Mi (cf. v. 129): ()

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

206

pf. 57

Hippolytus

'
25 , . (
,) (), () ,
,
. ()

, ,
26 , . /
,

, . () [
]
,
,
() .
27
() ()
, ' ( )
, (')
,
() , .
28 ,
, (') , ' - , () - ,
- () , () - , -

124 s. cf. Gal 5:17; Clem. Strom. VI. 134.1; 136.2 et al.
ss.; Clem. Strom. V. 103.5

us

bo

35

145

141 : cf. v. 55

121-122 ' add. We


122 add. Cr
3 add. Cr
(cf. w . 129, 131): Mi
124 2 addidi
129
Bernays: ()
Go:
130 addidi
130-131
seel. Go (cf. v. 128)
131 Go:
132 hic et in w . 133,
155 -
133 scripsi (cf. v. 124):

: Mi cett.
134 addidi
135 addidi
I
addidi
137 ( ) scripsi:
138 ' addidi
140 addidi
141 , scripsi:
142 ' add. Go
143 2 : Go
addidi
144/145 addidi
145 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.26.24-33

iss

160

165

no

207

- ',
- , ()
.

- -
/ , ,
, '
, () (
, ) , -
, , , , ,

. - ,
, . (,
) .
, .

, -
- ,
, .
, (,) ,
() , , ,
, ,
, ,

29
f. 57

30

31

32

33

149 Mt 2 : 1 ; Lc 1:5; V. 16.10; Epiphan. Pan. 30. 13.6; 14.3 (. Ebionit)


150 s. cf. Lc 1:26
151 : cf. Jo 10:11
152 : cf. Lc 2 : 4 2 ;
Iren. 1.3.2; 20.2; Jonas, p.285 n . l
154 s. cf. Jo 10:8; VI.35.1
164 cf.
Jo 19:26
165 s. cf. Lc 23 :46
167 s. cf. I. Herter, De Priapo (RGW23,
1932),
p.44
169 s. cf. V. 7 2 8
147 2 addidi
152-153 ' , transposui
153
addidi
153-154 supplevi (cf. v. 157) et add. Mi
154 scripsi:
160-161 addidi post We ('
) conl. . 162 et : add. suad.
Mi
164 scripsi:
166 , transposui
167 addidi
168 addidi
169 post 170 ,
transposui
: coniec. Cr
170 We:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

208

pf. 5

Hippolytus

, 34 () . , , () ,
. /
, , m
35 .
, , ()
.
' ,
36 () , . ()
, , , ,
, , () ,
( )
37 , . , , (
,) () - iss
, - , (,)
, (),
.
27 1

() ,
[] . , ,
() -

181 Is 1:2; VI. 13.1; . Barn. 9.3; Clem. Strom. IV. 169.1 et al.
Iren. 1.19.1; lustin. 1 Apol. 37.1; 63.2 et 12; Clem. Strom. V.54.1 et al.

184 s. Is 1:3;

171/172 Go:
172 addidi (cf. v. 174-175)
175 hie et
in v. 176 -
177 addidi
179 () Cr
180 Mi:

Go:
addidi
181
(sc. Isaias) scripsi: , Mi
: , LXX
182 : We
( ) scripsi:
183 ' supplevi
184 - 185 1 post . 186 , hue transtuli
184 Go e LXX:
(cf. v. 186)
184-185 supplevi (cf. v. 187 )
185 2
addidi
186 : coniec. We
addidi
187 addidi
188 scripsi conl. v. 84 et Plat. Phaed. 91 e 7
, :
post lac. sign. Cr We
(post Mi)
1 addidi (cf. v. 24)
4 2 addidi

3 del. . Klostermann (cf. v. 4)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V.26.33-27.6

209

5 (),
. ,
, ,
.
,
/ ,
, ,
, . , ,
, ,
is , () ,
(), , ()
() .
, , , () -
20 -, , ,
, .
() ,
25 . ,
, . ,
() , []
() , ,
( ) 30 , ' .

f. ssv
3

5 s. Ps 109:4; V.24.1
6-8HV.24.1
9 s. 1 Cor 2:9; V. 24.1; 26.16
11 et 12 Jo 4:10 et 14; V.7.19; 9.18; 19.21
12 s. Gn 1:6; V.9.18
18 s. Hos 1:2; Clem. Ecl propb. 3.2; Iren. IV. 20.12
27 cf. V. 26.27
5 1, corr. 2

6 Go:
7 1,
2

15 addidi: pro coniec. We
, corr.
Mi
16 v addidi
() Cr
addidi
17 addidi
18-19 () scripsi e LXX:
22 () Go:
( ) coniec. We
22-23 addidi conl. Km 16 :26
23
scripsi: : Go cett.
25
27 (sc.
Iustinus) addidi
scripsi: : , Go:
coniec. We
delevi
28 addidi
29 : Go
addidi
29/30 - 1, - 2

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

210

28 1
f. 59

Hippolytus


,
/() , '
() , [] ' 5
, () () [] ,
.

2 scripsi:
3 scripsi:

4
Mi:
addidi (cf. v.5)
5 , delevi (cf. v.4)

: Mi cett.
, corr. Mi
6 addidi

oi delevi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

< )
,
( ) .
5
,
, .
) ,
()
(, ') .

,
().

1
2
3
4

1 ' suppl. Mi
4
addidi (cf. v. 5 s.)
8 () scripsi: : () coniec. We
'
coniec. We:
9 add. Diels et ' add. Go
11 () coniec. Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

212

6 l

Hippolytus

"
() ()
,
.
, ' , 5
-
()
, " . -

7 1

pf. 59

, ,
() , ' . ,

- -, 5
, , /
, .
2
,
, ,
, ,
.

C. 7: 1 De cc. 7 et 9 - 2 0 cf. Act 8 : 9 - 2 4 ; lust. I Apol. 26.1-3; 56.1-4; Iren. 1. 23.1-4; Tert.
De anima 34.2-4 et Waszink ad loc.; Ps. Clem. Horn. 2.22-25; Ree. 2.7-12; Act. Petri Gr.
31; Epiphan. Pan. 21; Ps. Tert. Adv. omn. haer. 1; Philastr. 29; Theodoret. Haer. 1.1 - E.
Haenchen, Zs.f. Theol. u. Kirche 49 (1952), pp.316-349; H. Schlier, Beiheft 21 zur Zs.f. d.
NT Wiss. (1954), pp.67-82; Gu. Foerster, Le origini deo gnosticismo (Numinis suppl.
12, Lugd. Batav. 1967), pp. 190-196; Frickel (1968); I. Frickel, Le Museon 85 (1972),
pp.425-450; Barb. Aland, Theologie u. Philosophie 48 (1973), pp.410-418; Salles-Dabadie
(1969); R. Bergmeier, Festschrift f . K.G. Kuhn (Gott. 1972), pp.200-220; E.M. Yamauchi,
Pre-Christian Gnosticism (Grand Rapids, Michig. 1973), pp. 5 8 - 6 5 ; C. Beyschlag, Simon
Magus und die christliche Gnosis (Tubingae 1974); G. Ldemann, Untersuchungen zur
simonianischen Gnosis (Gott. 1975) et al.
1 : () VI.20.3;
, , , ex vico Getthonum lust. Ps. Clem. Epiphan. = Karyet Jit
5 : IV.28-41
5 s. Act 8 :20-24; Iren. 1. 23.1; V I . 2 0 2
2 ( ) scripsi (cf. Ape 12:3 ,
...): : Bunsen cett.
addidi
3 :
Bunsen
- , corr. Go
3 - 4 , corr. Go
5 1 , - 2
7 addidi (cf. Rm 1:18 et al.)
1 1 , - 2 : Go

2 addidi ex coni.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.6.1-9.1

is

20

213


, .

() ,
.
()
. ) ()
() () .
[]
, .

.

() .
,
, ,
.

. /

1 8

f. 6

,
.
() 1 9
( ) [] .

,

c. 8: 1-22 cf. Max. Tyr. 29.4 b-d Hobein ( ); Arethae schol. in


Dion. Chrys. 1.14 ed. A. Sonny (Ad Dion. Cbrys. Anakcta, Kioviae 1896, p. 96)
,
. Aelian. Var. hist. 14.30 (
)
4 add. Go
del. Mi We (cf. Max. Tyr. 1.1.
)
5 scripsi:
8
10 del. Mi
post , transposui
15 -
18
scripsi:
1 addidi
2 : coniec. We
addidi: add. Mi I
... scripsi: ...
delevi
ut dittogr. (cf. v. 1): Mi Cr
4 Mi: -

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

214

f.60v

Hippolytus

2 , ' [],
,
() '
, .
3


, ,
, ,
,
, .
4
, .
() () ,
5 , .
, ,
, () .
, , ,
/
, []
,
6 ,
. -

is

25

5 : IV.51.9; VI. 12.3; 13.1; 17.1; 18.4; . 12.3 et 4;


: Ps. Clem. Horn. 2. 22.3-4; 18. 12.1; : VI. 13.1; 172; Ps. Clem.
Horn. 2. 24.6; Ree. 1. 72.3; 2. 7.1-3; 2. 11.3; 3. 47.3; Acta Petri Gr. 31 (p.80.37 Lipsius et
Bonnet); Clem. Strom. 2. 52.2; cf. Haenchen, p.330 s.; Ldemann, pp.97-100 et al.
6 s. cf. Jo 1:13 et 2 Pt 2 :11; V. 9.22; lust. Dial. 63.2; Clem. Strom. 2. 5 8 2 et al.
10 s. Dt 4 :24; 9 :3; Ex 24 :17; VI.32.8
14 : cf. IX. 10.7-8
15 - VI. 18.7: cf. Foerster, I, pp.326-335
15-16 et 21-27 . 12.1
16-19 V.9.5; cf. Frickel, pp. 166-188
16 : VI. 11; 14.4 et 6; 182-7;
Frickel, pp. 129-153; 189-202
20 cf. Jo 1:13; v.6 s.
24 : cf. VI.
32.8; Clem. Ecl. proph. 26.3
5 2 delevi (cf. 1 )
6 1, - w - 2
7 addidi
9 , con. Go
1, - 2
10-11 ...
1, - ... - 2
12 post , transposui
13 1, -
2


: ' coniec. We
14 -
16 coniec. Mi
18 bis addidi ex
21 :
23 5
24 om. , del. Mi
27 : Hilgenfeld

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.9.2-102

215

,
. -
30 ,
.
- ,
, , ()35 , () , () '
, ,
, ,
, , ,

40 ,
, , . ,
, , , , , ,
.

10

, , - 1 10
() ,
/ . f. ei1
, , , () '
5 . , , 2
,
,

30-32 V. 19.1; VII. 22.1; VIII. 12.5


35 s. Dn 4 : 7 - 9 (10-12)
37 s. cf.
VII.21.3; VIII.8.5; . 14.1; 16.1
38-40 Mt 3 :10; 7 :19; Lc 3 :9; V.8.31; VI. 16.6;
. Philippi log. 123
40 : V. 17.10; VI. 10.2; 12.3 et 4; 14.6 (bis);
16.5 et 6; 17.1; 18.1; X. 12.3 et 4; cf. Jonas, p.341; Haenchen, p.321 s.; Frickel,
pp. 189-193
41-44 cf. Mt 3 :12; Lc 3 :17; Ps. Clem. Ree. 3. 38.4; Iren. 1. 3.5 et al.
c. 10: 1 - 3 Is 5 : 7
6 : cf. V. 17.10
7-9 I Pt 1:24 =
Is 40 :6-8; VIII. 14.8; In Dan. 3. 6.7; Clem. Strom. 3. 103.2; 4. 163.5
28
30 Mi:
31
Go:
33 Mi:
34 , corr. Go
35 addidi
3 add. Mi
36 Mi:
38 Mi:
Go:
40 , transposui
41
43 scripsi:
44 1 , - - 2
4 add. We
LXX

7 LXX: NT

: NT:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

216

Hippolytus

,
, , ,
, ( ) .

11 1

, ' , , ( ,) ,
(), () , ( ) -
-, [ ]
() ( ) 5
() , ,
, ()
, ' ,
' (), ,
() , (') .

12 1

, , (), ( )
, .
,
, ,

c. 11: 4 : cf. V. 19.8


8-10 Empedoclis Fr. 109 DK (ap. Aristot. De
anima A 2, p. 404 b 13 et Metaph. 4, p. 1000 b 7)
c. 12: 1-19 = X. 12.2-4
2 Empedocl. Fr. 110.10 DK ap. Sext. Emp. Adv. math.
8.286; VII. 29.26
8 (et. vers. Sahidica et Syrohexaplaris): om. LXX NT
: () Go

10 Mi: '

c. 11: 1
2 supplevi ex VI. 12.1 et . 12.2
3 ()
Go:
, transp. Go
() Cr:
supplevi ex 11. 11.
post . 2 , hue transtuli:
Go
4 Go
secl. ut dittogr. Cr (cf. . 6)
5 scripsi:
supplevi
6 1 addidi
scripsi:
7 addidi
8
9 add. Mi
( Aristot. De anima cod. X et Sophoniae paraphr.: codd. C U E : Aristot.
Metaph. cod. A 1 )
10 add. Mi ( Aristot. De an. C U E ,
Metaph. J: De an. , Metaph. codd. cett.)
(') scripsi:
: Mi ex Emped.
c. 12: 1 (sc. Empedocles) : : Meineke ( Emped.)
ex add. Go
2 Go e Sexto: :
(cum signo corr. sup. )
4 scripsi ex :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.102-13.1

217

5 .
() () , 2
, / ",
.
, , 3
() () .
, , , , ,
,
() , [] 4
is , , , ,
()
(),
(), , , ,
.

f. 6

1 13
, ,
,

5 , , ,
-
- , , , , ()

7 s. cf. cod. Gnost. Berol. 8502.3, pp.86.16-87.1; 96.12-19; N H III.3, pp. 73.9-11; 78.5-9;
N H III.4, pp. 96.4-7; 102.20-103.1 ;
Acta Archelai 10
; Acta Thomae Gr. 27
; Iren. 1. 24.3 (Basilides)
; Bousset, .235 s.; Ldemann, p. 133 s. (n.62)
15-19 cf. V. 19.1-2; VI. 16.5
c. 13:2 et 11 s. , , : cf. Acta Archelai 13
, , , , et Bousset, p. 230 ss.
5
: cf. V. 8.31-32; VI. 9.10; 16.5
7 s. Is 1:2; V. 26.36
5 scripsi ex :
() coniec. Mi invito
6 scripsi ex :
addidi ex
scripsi ex :

7 om.
10 addidi ex
ex add. Mi I
Go ex :
11 (cf. w . 14-15): om. , del. Mi
13/14

14 in mg. , hab.
delevi (om. )
16 <> coniec. We:
: Go
17 () scripsi ex :
18 : Mi cett.
c. 13: 4

5 ante . 4 , hue transtuli

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

218

pf. 62r

Hippolytus

, / .
, , , ()
, " , .
, , , , .
14 1

pf.62
6

() ,
, ( )
,
, () ( )
, , (,)
- -
,
.
, , , []
(, ,) []
, ,
, ,
, , ,
, () ,
- , ,
, , , , , .
()
' , , , ,
/ '
' .

is

c. 13: 11 Gn 1 : 3 1
c. 14: 1 - 3 Ex 2 0 : 1 1 et Gn 2 : 2 ; cf. VI. 13.1; 32.8; VIII. 14.1
4 cf. Gn 1 : 5 - 1 3 ;
V. 20.2
8 s. cf. Prov. 8 : 2 3 et 25; cf. O. Betz in Festschrift Michel (Lugd. Batav. 1963),
p.38 s.
12 s. Gn 1 : 2 ; w . 16 et 21 s.; V. 19.17; VI. 17.1-2
19 s. Gn 2 : 7 ;
V. 26.7; VI. 34.5; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 50; N H II. 4, p. 87.25 ss.; V. 5, p. 64.7 s. et al.
20 s. Gn. 1 : 2 6 ; V.7.6; VII.28.2; X.34.5; Iren. 1. 5.5; 24.1; 30.6; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 50;
54.2; cod. Gnost. Berel. 8502.2, p . 4 8 . 8 - 1 4 ; N H II. 4, p. 87.31 ss. et al.
c. 13: 9 add. G o
c. 14: 1 1 addidi e LXX
coniec. We
2 addidi e LXX
4 addidi
supplevi (cf. v. 30 et V.8.1)
5 addidi
9 del. suad. We
10 scripsi:
, addidi
delevi
(cf. v. 11)
13 2 Mi:
14
addidi
19
21 , corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.13.1-14.10

25

30

35

40

45

219

- , ,
, - , ,
- . - , , (,)
, ,
(), () .
, , () ;
()- . , , , -
- . (), ,
, .
, , , , , ()
() , (), ,
-
, ,
(), , , , ' ()
()()
- / -,
, '
, -
-, () - ,
- ~

9
f. 63

10

24 I Cor 11:32; V. 12.7


25-27 cf. IV.51. 2 - 3 ; V.9.5; VI. 17.7; 23.3
30 s. cf. Is 4 4 : 2 et 24
35-37 Gn 2:10; V.9.14-15; 16.9; 26.11; VI. 15.1
37 ss. cf. e. g. Galen. De usu partium 15.5 (IV, p. 231 Kuehn; II, p. 351 s. Helmreich); IV. 51.14
23 , transposui
25 addidi
27
Hilgenfeld (conl. VI. 17.7):
28
30 scripsi:
32 addidi
35 Cr:
2 add. suad. We (hab. LXX)
36
addidi
36-37 , transposui
38 ! , corr. Go
39 : Chr. Petersen ap. Go
39 2 addidi (cf. v. 42)
40 hie et in v. 42 Cr:
:
Petersen
scripsi (cf. v. 43): () vel () ut v.
40-41 post lacunam signavit Mi, post v. 41 Go
41 Cr:

41-42 (sc. , cf. . 40)
44 addidi
45 Go: : Mi: R. Scott

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

220

Hippolytus

- -,
[]
11 . ()

so
. , ' ,
( ) , ,
.
15 1

f. 63

, , , () ,
: , [,] , .
. (), , (), 5
, ()
2 . () , ,
, , ,
, ()
3 - . ( ) () -
, () / , - () () ,
, - . , ,
,
4 , () , is
- -
, ' , ( , ,)

c. 15: 1 Gn 2:10
2 : cf. V. 9.15-18
15-17 Ex 15 :22-25 (Marah, ); cf. V. 7.39; 16.5

11-14 et

46 scripsi:
47 delevi
48 scripsi:

- (at cf. w . 2 8 , 33)
addidi
53
add. Cr (cf. v.46)
c. 15: 2 1 addidi
3 1, - - 2
seel. Mi (quattuor sensus
habet V. 9.15-18: , , , ): retinent Go, Frickel (Wien. St.
85,1972, p. 171 s.)
, transposui
secl. Salles-Dabadie
5 addidi
6 add. Go
7 addidi
9 addidi
10 add.
Go et addidi
12 2 addidi
addidi
13 1 coniec. Mi:

15 add. Cr (cf. V.9.14; 24.2)

17 ,
s u p p l e v i (cf. V I . 16.1)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.14.10-16.4

221


20

15

20

(),
'
.
, , ()
() () , ,
( ) ,
, ,
,
,
,
, . , ,
(,) () ,
,
()
() () (()). ()
, (,) , () () ()
( ) () (). ( , ,) , /
.
,
, ( ) ,

.

1 16

f. 64r
4

c. 15: 19-21 Odyss. 10.304-306


c. 16: 10 : cf. Eph 5 : 2 ; Ph 4 : 1 8 ; Gn 8:21; Ex 29:18; Ez 20:41; Didasc.
apostol. 28.5; Trad, apostol. 69.21 ed. Tidner (T.U. 75, 1963)
19 ex Horn. add. Mi

21 "

c. 16: 1 add. Mi
2 () () Mi: ( ) Go We
3 addidi
5 1, 2

6 scripsi:

scripsi:
9 addidi
1 addidi: add. Mi
11 addidi
12 addidi
scripsi ex coniectura (cf. . 18
et Longini De sublimitate 32.5 ): ()
ut v.: () Mi Go: ( ) Cr: () coniec. We (conl.
V.21.3): () (glossema) Diels
addidi
13 addidi
addidi
scripsi:
14 addidi
scripsi (i.e. in
rhythmo):
addidi
15 , supplevi
(cf. . 18-19)
16 : Go We
18
, transposui
add. Mi et Cr
18-19
19-20 ...

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

222

Hippolytus

, , , ,
() () , ()
, []
- , (,)
-, () , , 25
, ,
6 , () ,
, . , ,
, ,
.
3

17 1

pf.64 v


() , ,
,
, ,
2 , . , 5
, (),
, ' , '
(), () '
()(). / '
, (,) () ,

21-23 V. 19.1-2; VI. 12.4; . 12.4


29 s. cf. VI. 15.3-4
24 s. Is 2 : 4
25 VI.9.9-10
26 s. VI. 12.3
28-30 Mt 3:10; 7:19; Lc
V. 8.31; VI. 9.10; Ev. Pbilippi log. 123

3:9;

c. 17: 1 : cf. Epicuri Sent. 1; Ep. ad Menoec. 123; Ep. ad Herod.


78; 81; Diog. Oenoand. Fr. 52 col. 4.5 s. Chilton; Clem. Strom. 5. 83.1; 6.104.3; Constant.
Or. ad sanct. coetum 4; v.5 et VI. 14.4
2 s. : cf. ad
VI.9.1
4 et 7 Gn 1:2; VI. 14.4-6; V.19.7
4 Gn 9 : 6 ; Ps 3 8 : 7
7 s. Gn 1:26; VI. 14.5
10 : cf. Pap. Gr. Mag. 13.795 et 8.36
Preisendanz () ; 8.49 s. , , ()
22 addidi (conl. VI. 12.4; . 12.4)
<> coniec. We: : Go

addidi
23 2 delevi
24 addidi
25 1 addidi
post
add. We
28 () Go, at cf. w . 2 6 ;
29-30
: NT
29 NT
c. 17: 2 addidi
4 conieci (cf. v. 7)
6 addidi
7 scripsi (cf. VI. 14.4):
Go (cf. v. 9 ):
, retinent Salles-Dabadie, I. Frickel
8
addidi

9 scripsi: ()
9-10
10 addidi
1 addidi (cf. 2 )
2 Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.16.5-17.7

223

, , ( ) , (')
, , , , , , , , ,
, , [, ,] - .
, , , , ,
-
,
( ()) , , - ,

, . , ,

, , ,
, , . , ,
() , ,
( , ,) (), ( ,)
, () .
/ ,
.

is

20

25

30

7
pf.65 r

, , -

; Lib. mortuorum (Aegypt.) c. 64.4 ss. Lepsius 'ille est ego, ego sum ille'; Corp.
Hermet. 5.11 et A.I. Festugiere ad loc. (I, p.68 s.); Iren. 1. 13.3; Epiphan. Pan. 26. 3.1 (.
Evae)\ Pistis Sophia 96, p. 148.18 S.-T. 'ich bin sie und sie sind ich' et al.; A. Dieterich,
Mithrasliturgie3, pp. 97 et 240; R. Reitzenstein, p.242
13 s. cf. Mart. Petri 10 (p. 98.3
Lipsius-Bonnet) , , , , ,
.
17 : cf. 1 Cor 7:9; Sir
23:17
23 s. Gn 3:24; Orig. c.Cels. 6.33
28 VI. 13.1; 14.1-5

: cf. VI. 18.3; VIII. 12.5


32 : cf. VI. 10.2; 16.5
:
cf. Hebr. maqom; Ex 24:10; 33:21; Clem. Protrept. 56.4; Orig. c. Cels. 6.59 s. f.; Plat. Phaedr.
247 c 3; Gn 28:17; V. 8.20 et 44
11 addidi
' addidi
12-14 et ubique P, corr. Mi
14
seclusi (cf. v. 13)
, corr. Mi
15 1
16
1 , - - 2
17 et 18 1 , - - 2
18 ,
corr. Go
19 Go: ( ).
22
1, - - 2
25 , transposui (cf. v. 24 )
: male Mi: Go: coniec. Salles-Dabadie: coniec. Frickel
(W. St. 85, 1972, p. 176)
28 , addidi
, corr. We
supplevi (cf. VI. 18.3)
29 Cr:
31
32 Go (conl. VI. 16.5):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

224

Hippolytus

() , , ()
(), ( ) []
() (), () .
1


, [ ]
, ()(), (),

2 , . ()

, - ,
, ,
3 , , ,
, , ,
, , (,) , ().
, 4 , ,
,
() ,

33-36 IV.51.2-3; V.9.5; VI. 14.6; 23.3


c. 18: 3 : cf. lust. I pol. 25.2; Athenag. Leg. 8.2; 10.1;
IX. 10.10 et al.
9 , : cf. Athenag. Leg. 10.1; Acta Petri et Pauli
58; Passio P. et P. 37; Iren. 1. 1.1; 1. 2.1; IX. 10.10 et al.
9-11 cf. VI. 13.1; 14.2 I
10 : cf. Act 8 :10; Mt 2 6 : 6 4 ; Mc 14:62; Lc 2 2 : 6 9 ; Iren. 1.23.1; Epiphan.
Pan. 21.1.3 et 2.3; Ps. Clem. Horn. 2. 22.3; Ree. 2. 7.1; Tert. De an. 34.3; Ps. Tert. Adv.
haer. 1; Philastr. 29.1; V.9.5; VI.9.4-5; 12.2-3; 13.1; 14.2-3; 16.5; 17.1-3; 17.7; 19.4;
X. 12.4; VI.39.1; Iren. 1. 13.1; VII. 36.1; Philon. V. Mos. 1. I l l ; Hegesipp. ap. Eus. Hist,
eccl. 2. 23.13; Pap. Gr. Mag. 4. 1275 ss.; inscr. Lydiae nr.211 Keil-Premerstein (Denkschrift
Akad. Wien, phil.-hist. Kl. 54, 1911, p. 109 s.); Ldemann, pp. 40-49 et 120-125 et al.
33 addidi
Go:
Go:
34 3 addidi
35
supplevi ex VI. 14.6
35-36
[] () ( ) , () scripsi ex
VI. 14.6: : ( )
Go (conl. VI. 16.5), agn. We, qui (pro ) coniecit
c. 18: 2 2 sscr. 1
delevi
3
scripsi (cf. v. 4 et
VI. 12.3):
() scripsi: () : (
) Cr
9
11 (i. e. , cf. V. 20.5) addidi ex
coni.
14 Mi: ()
Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.17.7-19.2

225

I , '
, .
. 5
, ,
2 , ' ()
, 6
,
() ,
- -,
25 . ()
, , 7
. '
( ,) .
() ' ,
30 .

f. 65

- 1 19
,
,
, ( )
5 . () - 2

c. 19: 3-5 Epiphan. Pan. 21. 3.2-3; Iren. 1. 23.2; Tert. De an. 34.2; Ps. Clem. Hont.
2. 25.2; Ree. 2. 12.2; Verg. Aen. 6.515-519 (cum fatalis equus... venit..., illa... flammam
media ipsa tenebat / ingentem et summa Danaos ex arce vocabat); Ldemann, pp. 72-78 I
3 : cf. N H II.6, p. 136.35 ss.
5 s. cf. v. 19; Mt 18:12; Lc 15:4; Ir. 1. 23.2;
Epiphan. 21.3.5; Tert. 34.4 - VI. 52.4-5; Ir. 1. 8.4; 16.1; N H 1.3, p.31.35 ss.; Ev. Thomae
log. 107; Acta Thomae 57; Clem. Strom. 1. 169.2 et al.
16 -
17 Cr:
scripsi:
19 scripsi:

We: : Mi
20-21 ... Go: ...

22-23 () scripsi (cf. v. 29): : Mi: ()


coniec. We
27 : coniec. We
' Mi:
28 , corr. Hilgenfeld
addidi (cf. v. 15)
scripsi:

29 Go:
addidi
: Go
c. 19: 2 Mi:
4 ( ) scripsi: ..." ut vid.: ( ) Mi: ( ) Go: ( ) Cr: ( ) We
4 , corr. Mi
5 Roeper: : Cr I
( ) scripsi (et hanc esse perditam ovem Iren.; hanc igitur esse ovem
perditam Tert.): : (' ) Mi: We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

226
pf. 66'

Hippolytus

, / ()
,
' '
[ ] ,
3 . ()

, , . ( ) (*)
- , , -, 15
4 () .
()() , ()
, ,
, .
, , 2
,
5 . , ,

6 s. Epiphan. 21. 2.5 (et C. Holl ad loc.); 25. 2.4; 66. 27.1; Theodoret. Huer. fab.
comp. 1.1 (PG 83, p.345 A)
11-13 Ir. 1. 23.2; Tert. 34.4; Ps. Clem. Ree. 2. 122; Plat.
Phaedr. 243 ab; Reip. 586 c; Isocr. Hei. 64; P.M. G. Nr. 192 (et D. Page ad loc.); Ox. Pap.
2506, Fr. 26, col. 1 et al.
13-15 Ir. 1. 2 3 2 ; Epiphan. 23. 2.6; Tert. 34.3-4; Theodoret.
p.344 D
15 : lust. 1 Apol. 26.3; Theodoret. p.344 D ; cf. ,
in N H II.6, p. 128.1; VI.3, p.24.7 ss. et al.
16 : Ir. 1. 2 3 2 ;
Epiphan. 21. 2 2 ; Tert. 3 4 2
16-18 Ir. 1. 23.3; Theodoret. p.345 A
19 cf. ad
VI. 18.3 (v. 10)
20-22 Epiphan. 21. 2.2-3
22 s. cf. Ir. 1. 23.4; Epiphan. 21. 4.1;
Theodoret. p.345
22-27: Foerster, I, p.43 s.
6 addidi (cf. w . 15, 31, 44, 46)
7 scripsi:
8
Mi: : Cr We
, corr. Mi
9
, del. We: [] R. Scott, Go
11 addidi (et Ir.)
12-13 : ex Iren, (post deinde paenitentem et scribentem) corr. suad.
We
13 1 ( - - 2 ): eas quae vocantur palinodias Ir.
14
add. Roeper et addidi et lacunam signavi: exspectes seu (et
semper contumeliam sustinentem ir.) seu (haec detenta est ab ipsis Ir.;
Epiphan. 212.6; '
Theodoret. .344 D)
15 Go ex lust, et Theodor.:

16 : (ubi) We
17 scripsi (quapropter et ipsum venisse, uti
eam assumeret primam et liberaret earn a vineulis Ir.):
20 Roeper
(cf. Clem. Strom. 6. 18.6; Theophil. Ad AutoL 2. 12 v.25 Grant): : Bunsen:
coniec. Scott

22 scripsi:

, transp. suad. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.192-8

25

30

35

40

227

, ()
, () (), .
() ,
() - ()
/ ()
.

. - 6
,

,
, []
- () ,
, ()
, - 7

, ()
,
, () , 8
() - , ,

f. 66

29 s. Ir. 1. 23.3; Epiphan. 21. 3.3 (oi ); Theodoret. . 345 (


)
30-35 Ir. 1. 23.3; Epiphan. 21. 2.4; Theodoret. p. 345 A;
Tert. 34.4
35-38 Ir. 1. 23.1; Epiphan. 21. 1.3; Theodoret. p. 344 C D ; Tert. 34.4
38-46 Ir. 1. 23.3; Epiphan. 21. 4.5; Theodoret. p. 345 A
23 addidi
24 , corr. Mi
25 () : Go: Cr
26 addidi
() : Klostermann: Mi et
coniec. We
27 scripsi:
scripsi:
We:
32 We:
post ft. excidit
(ad emendationem venisse rerum, et descendisse eum transfiguratum et assimilatum
virtutibus et potestatibus et angelis Ir)
34 scripsi:
2 del. Bunsen
et Go
35 addidi
37 scripsi:
We:
() ut .
38 coniec. We:
40 () Cr

Go (et ut liberos agere quae velint Ir):
41 scripsi:
42 Bunsen:
scripsi:
Mi:

Bunsen:
43 add. Bunsen
Bunsen et Go (nec enim esse
naturaliter operationes iustas, sed ex accident! Ir):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

228

Hippolytus

,
. () 45
.
20 1
f. 67r

() (), ()
/
.
, 2 , ,
' ,
, ,

, ,
, , .
3
() (),
. , ,
-
,
4 , ' ( ) -
,

20

C. 20: 1 - 4 Ir. 1. 23.4; Theodoret. . 345 ; (cf. Ir. 1. 25.3; 24.5)


4 - 6 Ir. 1.1.; Theodoret.
1.1.; Epiphan. 21. 3.6; cf. Ldemann, pp.49-57
8 - 1 2 Act 8 : 9 - 2 4 ; cf. Ir. 1. 23.1;
Theodoret. p.344 AB; lust. 1 Apol. 26.2; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 2.14; VI. 7.1
12-18
Foerster, I, p.44
19-22 cf. IV. 51.9; VI. 12.2; 13.1
45 Bunsen (quapropter et solvi mundum et liberari eos qui sunt eius ab imperio
eorum qui mundum fecerunt repromisit Ir.): , retinent Go: Mi:
Harvey: We
: Bunsen
scripsi (repromisit Ir.):

46 : Go
c. 20: 1 : Go
1/2 addidi (magias autem perficiunt...
exorcismis et incantationibus utuntur Ir.; Theodoret.)
3 - 4 , transposui
8 - 9 post ,
transposui (cf. v. 12)
10 , transposui
11 Cr (&
Theodoret.):
'
Diels:
13 () () (ut v.), Hilgenfeld
19 addidi ex

VI. 7 v. 3 ( ): add. suad. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

229

Refutatio VI. 19.8-22.2

, () - ,
, , ", (). '
(),
.
/ 1 21 f. 67
.
-
. -
5 , 2
'
,
' , ((>) , ' - 3
, ,
() ' ()
, ,
, 15 , .
1 22
()
() () ,
, ,
5 / . ' - 2
f. 68
, c. 21: 3 s. cf. Plat. Tim. 19 e 8; Iambi. V.P. 267; Suda, s.v.; c.49 Diels-Kranz
5 - 7 1.2.1-18; 1.19.1-23; IV. 51.1-9
c. 22: 1-4 Plat. Tim. 21 c ss.

4 s. Tim 22 b 4

21 o i P
c. 21: 2 1, - 2 : coniec. We
3
4 Mi:
1, 2
10 scripsi (cf. Polyb. 16. 29.5):
: s. coniec. We
11 scripsi (cf. VI. 22.1):
12
add. Go: Cr
addidi
13 post lac. sign. Go,
agn. We
13-14 ... ... , corr. Cr
13 pro coniec. Go
scripsi:
14
scripsi:
c. 22: 1 () Mi
Mi
: Mi
5

2 Mi:
,

3 addidi I
transposui

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

230

Hippolytus


() , ' () ()

,
.
23

pf. 68

,
,
,
2 () , () , . ()- 5
,
, ( ),
, , ()
3 . ( ) ,

, () [ ], - ,
. () , , (
,) , , is
4 . /
- '

8 : 1.2.3, 16 et 18
c. 23: 1-12 cf. 1.2.6-8; IV.51.4-6; Burkert, p.51 ss.
4 : 1.2.12; Plut.
De an. proa. 1012
12-16 IV. 51.2-3; Sext. Emp. Adv. math. 3.19-21; 7.99-100;
Pyr. hyp. 3.154; Schol. in Euclid. Ekm. I (V. p.78.15 Heiberg) et al.; cf. Burkert, p.49

8 () Go:
() scripsi:
coniec. Mi: Roeper et Scott
10 ()

() We: :

c. 23: 4 addidi

addidi
6 scripsi:
7 add. Cr
8 addidi
9 addidi
11 scripsi
(cf. IV.51.7): : Mi
addidi: add. suad. We
11-12 seel, ut glossema We
12 Mi:
13
Go: ()
14-15 suppl. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.22.2-24.3

231

,
()' .
20 ,
, , , 5
, ( ), ,
, ,
, , []
25 - , , , () , ,
, , () ,
() .
, 1 24
, ( ) ,
, , .
, , ()
5 ( ) , ,
( ' ) , 2
()()
().
, , .

() , , / 3
f. 69r
, ,

19 1.2.9; IV. 51.7; VI. 34.1; cf. . Delatte, Etudes sur la litterature pytbagoricienne (Paris.
1915), p. 249 ss.; Burkert, p. 170 ss.; Iren. 1.1.1; II. 14.6
c. 24: 2 s. , : (4) = I (10): .>;.; cf. Burkert, p. 63 ss.
3 Mt 5 : 1 8 ; Lc 16:17; Iren. 1. 3.2 = Epiphan. Pan. 31. 14.8; cf. A. Delatte, 1.1.; Sagnard,
pp. 337-348; VIII. 12.6
18 vai (et. Carm. aur. 47 Diehl; David. Proleg. philos. 15, p. 48.24 Busse: auct. cett.) I
, corr. Mi ( Sext. . 7.94; Stob. 1.10.12 = Aet. 1.3.8; Theon.
Sm. p. 94.6 Hiller cod. A sscr.: Sext. 42; Theon. 1.1.; Ps. Plut. Plac. 877 A
Mau = Aet. 1.1.; Carm. aur. 47; Macrob. In Somn. 1. 6.41: Porphyr. V.P. 20; Iambl.
V.P. 162; Theol. arithm. 18, p . 2 2 2 1 de Falco)
19 (et. I et IV:
VI)
() (et. I, ' IV; Sext. . 7. 94; 4. 2; Theon.
codd. praeter A ; Porph.; Iambi. V.P. 150 et 162; Ps. Plut.; Stob.): VI,
' Theon. cod. A
20 scripsi:
22 add. Mi
24
delevi ut dittogr. (cf. . 23)
c. 24: 2 Go:
addidi (cf. VI.23 .20)
5 add. We
6 add. Mi et ' addidi (cf. w . 8 - 9 )
( ) Chr. Petersen

9 Roeper:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

232

Hippolytus

.
, , - , , , -,
[] , , , () ,
, . , ,
' .
' , , . ' , (,)
, ( ) ()
, () (), ()
- () , , ,
, () ,
.
, (,)
,
() ()
,
[]
,

is

25

f. 69 25 1 / ,
.

17 s. 1 Cor 2:9; V.24.1; 26.16; 27.2; . Thomae log. 17; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 10.5;
Manich. Turfn fr. 789 et al.
12
14 ev del. suad. We
coniec. We:
15 add.
Mi
19
addidi
20 addidi (cf. v. 17)

et 21 1,2 addidi (cf. v.22 )


21 scripsi: :
Go
23 post add. suad. We
24
scripsi (cf. v.22):
28 () : Mi cett.
30 delevi
31 Roeper:
c. 25: 3 : Go (conl. v.21)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.24.3-25.4

233

, (') (), ', ,


() .
; , 2
() , -
-,
. () - 3
,
,
, , , ,
, ' ' , , [ ,] ()
(
) ,
, . 4
, . ()
, (), .
() ,
().
, - []

5 s. Empedocl. Fr. 16 DK = VII. 29.10


7-10 et 13-20 cf. VII. 29.8-12
23 cf. Plat. Tim. 41 d 8; 42 b 4 (H VI.26.3); Cie. Somn. Scip. 3.15; Macrob. In Somn. Scip.
1. 14.16 ss.; Plin. Nat. hist. 2. 95 et al.
23-26 Philol. Fr. 14 DK; Plat. Crat. 400 c;
Gorg. 493 a; Dionys. Hal. Rhet. 6.5; Iulian. Or. 6, 189 C; Clem. Strom. 3. 16.3-17.1;
V. 822 et al.
5 coniec. Mi: : : Nauck
, (') scripsi (cf. Empedocl. Frr. 108.1;
128.4 DK): : () Go: Nauck: , Diels

, corr. Mi
6 Roeper: : :
coniec. Mi
Mi:
8 add. suad. We
10 Cr (conl. v. 20):
addidi: add. suad.
We
12 scripsi (cf. v. 11 ):
Roeper:

1 , - 2
13 , corr. Roeper et Harvey
14 '
14/15 scripsi conl. VII.29.9 ):

16 (1. ) , seclusi ut dittographiam (cf. v. 19)


add. Mi
17-18 supplevi conl. VII.29.9 et
11
18 scripsi ex : : Go
19
( We): : del. Diels
20 Cr:
21 scripsi (cf. v.3):
22 scripsi:
24 Mi:
delevi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

234

Hippolytus

-, , 25
. / ,
,

pf. 7

26 1 () ()
[] ' [ ]
, - , 2 , , . , ,
, , 5
, .
,
3 , , , ,
, () ,
() -
() ,
, , .
,
- -, ,
, () .
is
27 1

' ()
' () ,
,
' , , '

26 s. cf. Plat. Phaed. 64 c 4; 66 a 3


c. 26: 2 - 4 Iambi. Protrept. 21.14 (pp. 107.14 et 11429 ss. Pistelli) <)
' ; Porphyr. V.P. 42 (.39.14 Nauck 2 ); Diog. Laert.
8.18; Plut. De lib. ed. 12 F; Numa 14.6; Demetr. Byz. ap. Athen. 10, p.452 E; Olympiod.
In Phaed., p.8 s. Norvin
3 s. cf. Heracliti Fr. 94 DK (= Fr. 52 Marc.)
6 - 8 cf. Empedocl. Fr. 117 ss. DK
8 - 1 2 cf. Plat. Phaedr. 248 e - 249 b
11 s. Plat. Tim. 42 b 4
26 coniec. We:
c. 26: 1 Roeper:
1 addidi (cf. 2 )

scripsi: : We
2 addidi
2 1 del. Cr

del. ut dittographiam Cr
2 , - 1
9 addidi
10
addidi
, transposui
14 2 , - 1
15 del. suad. Diels, ft. recte
addidi
c. 27:2 et 4
: () Go

2 C. Goettling (Progr. Un. Ien. 1852) et Roeper:


4
'

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.25.4-27.5

235

5 ( ) , ()
/ ()
, ()(),
'
() ,
, .

, () ,
is ,
.
(), ,

20 , ()
, ' ,

2
f. 7

5-24 cf. C. Hoelk, De acusmatis sive symbolis Pythagoricis (Diss. Kil., 1894); Fr. Boehm,
De symbolis Pythagoreis (Diss. Berol., 1905); A. Delatte, Etudes sur la litt, pythag., p.269 ss.;
Burkert, pp. 150-175 et al.
6 Porphyr, ap. Stob. I. 49.59 W. (
.); Diog. Laert. 8.17. Cf. Iambi. Protrept. 21.29 (pp. 108.3 et
12222 ss. Pistelli); Plut. Qu. conv. 727 C; 728 B; Clem. Strom. 5. 27.8
13 Tryphon.
(Rhet. Gr. 3, p. 193 s. Spengel); Iambi. Protr. 21.8 (pp. 107.6 et 11224 ss.); V.P. 111 (et
Deubner. ad loc.); Diog. Laert. 8. 17 et 18 (et A. Delatte ad loc.); Dem. Byz. ap. Athen.
10, p.452 D; Plut. Qu. Rom. 281 A; De lib. ed. 12 E; De Is. 354 E; Numa 14.6; Fr. 93
Sandbach; Porphyr. V.P. 42; Luc. Verae hist. 2.28; Apostol. Prozi. 11.5a; Arsen. Prov.
35.16; Hor. Serm. 2. 3276; Suda s.v. Anaximander 2
14 s. Plut. Qu. Rom. 290 E;
Qu. conv. Ill C: ; Iambi. Protr. 21.13 (pp. 107.13 et 11420 ss.);
V.P. 186 (et Deubner. ad loc.); Diog. Laert. 8.17 et 18 (et A. Delatte ad loc.); Tryphon. 1.1.;
Athen. 452 D; Porphyr. V.P. 42; Plut. Fr. 93 Sandb.; Clem. Strom. 5. 30.1; Suda, s.v.
Anaximander 2 et al.
15 s. Plut. De Is. 354
17 Plut. Qu. Rom. 290 E;
De Is. 453
20 Suda s.v. Anaximander 2 ( )
5 addidi
, corr. Klostermann
6 addidi
7 scripsi:
8 Mi: : We
10
We:
11 , corr. Mi
14
addidi
(et. in gloss, in marg. f. 72 r ), corr. Roeper
16
, gloss, in marg. f. 71 r
16/17 Roeper:
17 (et. Plut. Mor. 290 : Plut. Mar. 354 )
19 , corr.
Mi
20 scripsi (conl. .22 et test.):
21

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

236

Hippolytus

.
- '
. 28 1

f. 7

, ,
() , ()
, () () , ( . 5
2 () , ( ) , .
, ,
, () /
().
, , ()
3 ,
' , ,
- , , , ,
, , , , , , ,
4 . , is

22 Iambi. Protr. 21.37 (pp. 108.13 et 125.9 ss.); Plut. De lib. ed. 12 F; Diog. Laert.
8.17 et 34 et al. plur.; cf. A. Delatte, Faba Pythagorae cognata, Serta Leodiensia (1930),
pp.33-57; I. 2.14-15 et . Marcovich, Philol. 108 (1964), pp.29-39 et al.
c. 28: 2 - 4 ... : cf. e.g. Corp. Herrn. 16.5 et A.-I. Festugiere ad loc.
4 s. cf. Cleanthis FIT. 499-500 (SVF I: - ); Hisdosi
Scholast. De anima mundi Plat, (ad Chalcid. In Plat. Tim. 34 b), cod. Par. Lat. 8624 f. 17v
v. 18: alii autem dicunt quod mundi medietas est sol, quem cor totius mundi esse volunt.
quemadmodum enim, inquiunt, anima hominis sedem et domicilium in corde habet...,
ita Vitalis calor a sole procedens omnibus quae vivunt vitam subministrat; Chrysipp., SVF
II, Fr. 879; Tert. De anima 15.4 (et Waszink. ad loc., pp.219 s.; 225 s.); Procl. In remp., II,
p.220.14 Kroll ( )
5 : ft. cf. Plat.
Phaed 94 d 8; Sympos. 218 a 3 ( ...); Orig. In . 6.38 (
... )
6 - 8 et 9 Plat. Tim. 31 b 5
8 s. Tim. 32 b 4
11-18 cf. V.' 13.3-4 = Sext. Emp. Adv. math. 5.5
23-24 , corr. Mi
c. 28: 3 Go:
4 addidi (cf. test.)
5
scripsi: ()
addidi
6 addidi
add. Roeper et
addidi
scripsi post Roeperum ( ):
Mi ex
Plat.:
8 ex Plat. add. suad. We
9 : Plato
12 |5
13

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI27.5-29.4

237

, []
, (
) [] , [] ,
' ()
20 (), ,
() .
, ,
, ' , ,
, , ()
, , .
5

, ,
() .
() , ,
, ,
' () ,
' () , - '
- ()
- / ()
()
is , , ,
[] . ,

1 29

2
3

f. 7

18 : i.q. , minutae secundae, cf. Gemin. Astron.


18.11.18
: cf. Solis epitheton (C. Bruchmann, Epith. deor.,
p. 144)
20 : cf. e.g. Plat. Reip. 516 b 5; Plut. Qu. Plat. 1007 DE
c. 29: cc. 29-37 ed. Bunsen, pp. 79-96. cc. 29.2 - VI. 36.4: cf. Foerster, I, pp. 243-253 I
5-7 cf. VI.28.1 et 3; 34.2-3; Iren. 1.1.1; II. 14.6; Philastr. 38.1; Theodoret. Haer. 1.7,
p.353 C
8: de cc. VI. 292-36.4 cf. Iren. 1.1.1-8.4 = Epiphan. Pan. 31. 10.5-26.7;
Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 432-652; Epiphan. 31. 5.1-7.11; Tert. Adv. Valentin., Ps. Tert.
Adv. omn. haer. 4; Theodoret. Haer. 1.7 et al.; Gu. Foerster, Von Valentin zu Herakkon
(Giessae 1928); Idem in NT Studies 6 (1959-60), pp. 16-31; G. Quispel in Vig. Christ.
1 (1947), pp.43-73; praecipue Sagnard, pp.31-50; 146-198; 224-227 et al.
8-10 et
21-34 cf. Ir. 1.1.1; X.13.1-2
10-20 cf. VI.38.5; X.13.1; Ir. 1.2.4; 11.5; Tert.
Adv. Vol. 34
16 Mi:
2 del. Mi
17-18 addidi
delevi
19
1 add. Go
21 addidi
: ... Roeper cett. (at cf. v. 10)

18 1 ' 3
...

c. 29: 3 add. suad. We


12 et 19
14 scripsi: : del.
suad. We: . 13.1
16 delevi (om. )

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

238

Hippolytus

,
, [] ,
, , (), ,
' .
() , , () , ,
, , , ,
' ,
, , , ,
,
() .
, , , , . () () ,
, , , ()

' .
, , ,

.
, ,
, ,
() , .
, ,

22 : cf. Ir. I; 1.1 (); 15.5; II. 1.2; IV.20.2 et al.; Philon. De confus.
ling. 136; Mand. past. Hermae 1.1; Cerygma Petri ap. Clem. Strom. 6. 39.3; lust. Dial. 127.2;
N H VII.4, pp.99.31 ss.; 100.32-34 et Gu.R. Schoedel in Essays on the NagHammaii
Texts
in Honour of A. Boehlig (Lugd. Batav. 1972), pp. 88-108
: ft. cf. Rm
11:34; Is 4 0 : 1 3
26 s. cf. 1 Jo 4 : 8 et 16
35-37 cf. Ir. 1.1.2
17 Mi:
18 delevi ut dittogr. (cf. v. 17): Mi
19 (cf. v.23; VI.24.1; Epiphan. Pan. 33. 7.7): Go
20 o' Cr:
20-21 . Go:
21 () scripsi:

24 scripsi (cf. w . 8 et 10):
25 v
26
'
2, - 1
Mi:
28
addidi
scripsi (ft.
cf. Bythi Patris epitheton ): : Mi
coniec. We:
29 scripsi (cf. w . 8 et 10):
() scripsi (cf. Ir. 1.1.1 ...
...): : coniec. Cr
30 -
35 , corr. We: del. Go
36
38
scripsi:
coniec. Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.29.4-30.5

239

40 ,
() , ,
, ()
/ .
()
(),
,
. () ,
5 , , ()
,
()
.
, ,
- ,
,
, ( ) , ()
, , ,
, . ,
is () ,
.
,
, ,

f. 72'
1 30

40 s. ft. cf. Theohgum. arithmet. 60, p. 81.9 de Falco ,


, , ,
c. 30: 1-20 cf. Ir. 1.1.2; Tert. Adv.
HaerAJ,

Vol. 8; Epiphan. 31. 2.10-11; 31. 5.8-9; Theodoret.

pp.353 C - 356 A

40 et 41 : et P. Boettlicher ap. C. Bunsen


addidi (cf. . 37)
42 scripsi (cf. w . 8 et 10):
transposui
1 addidi

41
,

c. 30: 4
5 Mi:
addidi (cf. v. 7)
6 1 Mi:

7 , corr. Bunsen

8 scripsi:
10 Bunsen:
12 suppl. Cr ( ,
Ir. I. 1.2)
, ex test. corr. Bunsen
13
Bunsen ex test.:

14 , ex test. corr. Bunsen I
Bunsen ex Iren.:
15 addidi: ex
Irenaeo add. suad. We
16 () Bunsen
18 et 19

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

240

7
f. 72
8

Hippolytus

, ,
, .
2
()
, (), ,
(,) () ,
() ,
() , 25
, ()
' , ' (,)
, () () / ,
, () 3
, .
(), , , ()
,
.
, (). 35
, , .
(') , , ( ) () , ,
(), () .

21-26 cf. Ir. I. 2.2-4


22 de Sophia cf. G.C. Stead in J.T.S., N.S. 20 (1969),
pp. 75-104; G. Gu. MacRae in . T. 12 (1970), pp. 86-101 et al.
27 ' : cf.
cod. Gnost. Berol. 8502.2, p. 36.16; NH II. 4, p. 94,7; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 32.1 et al.
35 : Ir. I. 2.3; I. 4.1a; I. 8.2 (1 Cor 15:8); VI. 31.1-2 et 4-5; 36.3; VII. 26.7 I
36 Gn 1:2a; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 47.4; Ir. I. 18.1
37 et 39 Dt 31:20; Ex 33:3 et
3:8; V.8.30
37 s. Heb 12:22; Gal 4:26; VI. 32.9; 34.3-4; V.7.39; Ir. 1.5.3
' ...
19 Bunsen ex test.:
20 Bunsen ex test.:
21 We:
23 addidi (cf. w . 32; 36; 37)
-
26
addidi: s. add. suad. Go
27 Roeper:
Mi:
28 addidi
29 1 addidi
addidi
30
32

34 scripsi:

35 () Mi Scott Bunsen Go (cf. v. 36):
37 ' addidi
addidi (cf. v. 39 et V. 8.30)
addidi
38
39

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.30.5-31.6

241

1 31
() , ( )
[ ],
,
5 , 2
,
() ' -
() -
() , () , , , () -
,
() , 3
()
,
is /
f. 73
()(). 4
(),
()
,
20 .
"' ' 5
, ,
- () -,
, "
25 ,
() . " , 6
() , ,

1 - 8 cf. Ir. I. 2.3


8-12 cf. Ir. I. 2.5
12-16 cf. VI. 30.3; Ir. I. 1.3
16-20 cf. Ir. I. 2.4; 2.5; 4.1 a
21-30 cf. Ir. I. 2.4; 3.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 22.4; 42.1;
Epiphan. 31. 4.3; Tert. Adv. Vol. 10; Theodoret. I. 7, p. 356 et al.
2
addidi conl. Ir. (
)
3 seel. Go (ut glossema ad v.
): ( ) coniec. Mi
:
Bunsen, agn. We
5 scripsi:
6
7
8 addidi (cf. v. 19)
9
11 :
Mi cett.
13 addidi
14 scripsi:
15
Bernays:
18 -
19 scripsi (cf. v.40):
22 -

23 addidi
26 () We:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

242

Hippolytus

, ,
,
.
3
7
", ,
' ',
()
, ()
8 () ()() , () 35
, (') (,
) ,
,
, (') " ,
.
4
f. 73 32 1

/()
() , () ()
()(), ()
.
, , ' () 5
2 ,
() ,
' , , ,
- -, .

31-35 cf. Ir. I. 3.4; 5 2 - 3 ; VI. 32.9; 33.1; 34.8; 36.1 et al.; Epiphan. 31. 6 2 ; 36. 2.1
35-40 cf. Ir. I. 4.1 a
c. 32: 1-10 cf. Ir. I. 2.6; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. I I I

10 Heb 4 :14

29 : Roeper: coniec. Go

Go:
31 2 bis
33 addidi
Go:
34 ( ) coniec. Go: : Cr
35 coniec. Mi: ()() , ut .
2 add. suad. Mi
36 ' addidi: ' add. Bernays

: del. Cr (i. e. )
36-37 add. Mi et addidi
37 scripsi:
39 'add. suad. Mi
Mi (s. delendum):
c. 32: 2 addidi
3 ( ) ( ) scripsi ( Ir.
I. 2.6): , def. Sagnard, p. 157 (i. q. Ir. I. 1.1):
Go: coniec. We
add. Mi
4
5
addidi post Go (cf. V. 26.8): add. Diels
6 Bernays: I
() coniec. Mi: () coniec. Go
7 addidi
8 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.31.6-32.6

is

20

25

30

243

,
() ,
.
, ,
, , ,
()

. ( )
( ) ,
()
.
( )
- []
( -, , /
, ()
, , ' () () - () () . - ,
,
' , .
() [], ,
()
() () []
(), .

11-18 cf. Ir. I. 4.1


Haer. I. 7, p. 356 s.

f. 74
6

18-33 cf. Ir. I. 4.5; I. 5.1 et 4; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 45; Theodoret.

12 addidi (cf. v. 13)


13 : coniec. We
C. Holl:

15 -
16 2 addidi

17
22 add. suad. Go (cf. v. 20)
23 2 del.
Bunsen
24
26 ' () scripsi: : coniec. We
27 2 ' 3 addidi
, transp. suad. We
29 We:
: Bunsen: () Go
30 addidi (cf. v. 33) I
delevi (cf. v. 31): Bernays ap. C. Bunsen, agn. cett.
31
() scripsi conl. Theodoreti Haer. I. 7, p. 356 s.
(sc. ) :

32 2 addidi
() scripsi (cf. Sir 17:24
; Nili ep. 3.171 (PC 79, p. 464 C) ): : Bunsen: . Go
4 delevi (i.e.
- )
33 addidi (cf. w . 2 7 , 29 et 30)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

244

Hippolytus

f. 74

( ) ,
' , , . 35
( ) ,
, , .
, , - '
, , , (
) , () (), 4
8 < . ( ) , ,
, , ,
, , ()
(*) [] 45
9 , - [ ]
',
, , ()
, () , ', / (0)

35 Ps 110:10; Prv 1:7; 9 :10; VII. 2 6 2


38 : Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 38.1;
V. 7.30 (q.v.); VII. 38.1; VIII. 9.7 et 10.1; . 16.5 et 20.1
38 : Clem. Exc.
ex Theod. 34.1-2; 37; 38.1 et 3; 39; 592; Heraclionis Fr. 35 s.f. ap. Orig. In Io. 4 : 3 7
(13.49); Ir. I. 5.3-4; 6.4 et al.
39 : Ir. I. 5 2 et 4
.:
Dn 7 : 9 ; 13 et 22; cf. In Dan. 4. 112
42 s. Dt 4 :24; 9 :3; Ex 24 :17; VI. 9.3;
cf. Dn 7 : 9 - 1 0 et Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 38.1
43 : cf. Clem. Ed. proph.
26.3-4
, , ,
. ,
, , . VI. 9.5
44 cf. Eurip. Med. 1187; VI. 9.9
45-52 cf. Ir. I. 5.3-4; 6.1; 6.4;
7.1; 7.5; Ptolem. Ep. ad. Floram ap. Epiphan. 33. 7.4; Heracleonis Fr. 40 ap. Orig. In Io.
4 : 4 6 (13.60); Clem. Strom. 4. 90.3; Epiphan. 31. 6.5 et al.
34 supplevi (cf. v. 35 et VI. 34.1
)
: (sine lacuna) Bunsen
35
36 addidi
38 (cf. Clem. 11.11.): () Go (conl. v.46 et Iren. I. 5.3; 6.4; Epiphan.
31. 6.5): () Cr (conl. Iren. I. 5.4)
39
39-40
addidi (cf. V. 8.1; VI. 14.7)
40 Bunsen:

addidi (cf. v. 43)


, corr. Mi
41 : Go
addidi I
scripsi:
45 post lacunam sign. Go
, del. Bunsen
46 , seclusi ut glossema ad v. 39 (cf. Gn
2:2-3)
47 R. Scott: : ( )
Cr
48 Go: : Bunsen: ,
, Ir. I.
5.3
49 add. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.32.7-33.1

245

so () , , , ,
, .
1 33
( , ) ( , ) , , - , ( .
5 ') '
, () , , , '
' ,
. ,
, '
, ,
.

50 s. Heb 12 :22; VI. 30.9; 34.3-4; Ir. I. 5.3


c. 33: 1-4 VI. 32.6-7; 34.1
2 : cf. Clem. Strom. 4. 89.6-902
,
... (= Valentini Fr. 5).
, ,
...; Exc. ex Theod. 4 7 2 - 3 (sc. )
, ' . . .
...; Strom. 4. 90.3 , ' (Gn 1:26) , '
. Cf. Ir. I. 5.1-2; Theodoret. Haer. I. 7, p.357
3 Jo 12 :31; 14 :30; 16 :11; cf. Anon. cod. Bruc. 2, p.258.15
S.-T.
4 Mt 12:24; Lc 11:15
5-11 VI. 34.8; 52.11; Ir. I. 5.1; I. 5.3-4; Clem.
Exc. ex Theod. 49.1
10 s. Is 45 :5 et 6; 46 :9; Dt 4 :35; 32 :39. Ir. I. 5.4 ,
. Cf. Ir. I. 29.4; 30.6; Epiphan. Pan. 25. 2.3; cod. Gnost. Berol. 85022,
p.44.15; N H II. 1, pp. 1120; 13.8; II.4, pp.86.30; 9422
50 () scripsi:

52 : Bunsen et Roeper

c. 33:1-3 ( , ) ( , ) supplevi ex test.: : post lac. sign. Mi: ,


(, , , ,)
suppl. Bernays ap. Bunsen.: ( ,
) suppl. Cr (conl. Ir. I. 5.1 s.f.)
4 ft.
delendum ut glossema (cf. VI. 32.6)
post lac. sign. Bunsen
4 - 5 supplevi ex VI. 34.1 et NT
5 ' add. Cr
6
add. suad. We
8 Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

246
34 l

Hippolytus

[] ,
[], ' ,

f. 75

, ' ' .
, ,
, () () . 5
2 . () ,
, , ()
() () ()'
(), ' 3 . ( ) ()
, ,
() , / ().
, ,
' ,
(), is
, ,
4 , (, ) ,
.

2 I. 2.9; IV. 51.7; VI. 23.4 (q.v.); Ir. I. 1.1


4 : VI. 35.3; 36.4;
Ir. 1.4.1
5 Jo 12:31; VI. 33.1 et Mt 12:24; Lc 11:15; VI. 33.1
6 s. VI.
29.1 et al.
10-12 VI. 28.3-4
12 cf. Ir. I. 2.6 s.f.; Epiphan. 31. 6.5; Theodoret. Haer. I. 7, p. 356 C; Ps. Tert. Adv. omn. haer. 4 (p.221.14 Kroymann) cum Valentinus Aeonas tantum triginta finxisset, isti (sc. Ptolemaeus et Secundus) addiderunt alios
complures...
13-18 cf. Ir. I. 4.5 s.f.; Theodoret., p.357 AB; w . 3 0 - 3 3
14 : .44; VI. 35.6; Ir. I. 5.3; I. 7.2-4 et al.
Gn 3:20; V. 7.39; 16.13; Ir.
I. 30.1; cod. Gnost. Berol. 8502.2, p. 60.15; N H II. 4, p. 89.15 et al.
15 :
cf. e.g. Gn 46:27; Ex 15:27; Nu 11:16; Lc 10:1; G. Kittel, Tbeol. Wb. zum NT, 2 (1935),
pp. 623-631; . Dreizehnter, Die rhetorische Zahl (Zetemata, 73, 1978), p. 18 n. 68 et al. I
16 : cf. Ph 3 : 2 0
16 Heb 12:22; Gal 4 : 2 6 ; V. 7.39; VI. 30.9; 32.9;
Ir. I. 5.3
17 : cf. Ir. I. 7.1; Apc 21:2; Jo. 3:29
1 del. suad. Go: post transp. Bunsen
2 delevi metri gr., om. H:
Go
' Mi ex I, IV, VI. 23:
5 add. Roeper
addidi ex NT
6 add. Mi
7 We:
8 , corr. Go
We: : Mi
() , ut .
9 addidi
10 et addidi ex VI. 28.3
11-12
- seel. Go ut glossema
12 add. suad. Go
14
Bernays et Go e LXX:
15 scripsi: : Go

Go:
17 addidi (cf. w . 3 4 , 41, 42) et 1 add. suad. We
' del. Bunsen

1 8 , corr. B u n s e n et G o

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.34.1-7

247

() ( )
2 , ' () ()
,
, , (,) 5
, ,

25 . ' , , , () , , .
' 6
, ,
30 ()
() ()
, () ,
.
, , 7
35
,
, ,
, / ,

pf.75v

19-27 cf. Ir. I. 5 2 ; I. 5.5; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 50.1-3; 51.1-2; Tert. Adv. Vol 24
20 s. cf. Jo 8 :39
23-25 Gn 2 : 7 ; Ir. I. 5.5; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 50: V. 26.7; VI.
14.5; VII. 28.3; N H II.4, p . 8 7 2 5 ss. et al.
25 s. : Eph 3 : 1 6 ;
Rm 1:22; 2 Cor 4 : 1 6 ; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 51.1; Ir. I. 5.5; 21.4; 2. 30.7; 5. 192; Clem.
Paed. 2. 45.3; V. 7.36; VI. 4 0 2 ; VII. 27.6; . 13.3; 19.3; Zosim. ap. Reitzenstein,
p. 104.14; Plat. Reip. 9, p.589 a 7; Plotin. V. 1.10; Philon. De congressu 97; De plantat. 42;
De fuga 71 et al.
2 8 - 3 3 cf. Ir. I. 4.6; 5.6; 7.5 s.f.; II. 19.3
28 s.
: cf. Valentini Fr. 2 ap. Clem. Strom. 2. 114.5-6; Democriti Fr. 171 DK;
Plat. Reip. 9, p. 580 a 4; Porphyr. Ad Marceil. 21; Mt 12:45; Apc 18:2; Ep. Barnabas 16.7;
VI. 9.5
3 4 - 4 0 Eph 3 : 1 4 et 16-18
19 add. Cr
addidi (cf. v. 42 et VI. 33.1)
20 I
scripsi:
22 addidi (cf. ad v. 17)
26 scripsi (cf. v.
23 et v. 32 ):
: coniec. We
26/27 addidi (cf.
.28): add. Go
27 scripsi post Mi (): : () Go:
coniec. We
28 ' , transposui
' del. Cr
31 scripsi ex Iren.:
35 - 36 :
N T codd. C: N T codd. x D
(cf. Eph 1:3)
36 Mi ex NT:
38 : N T
3 8 - 4 0 N T

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

248

Hippolytus

, , , "
, , .
8 , ,
- . , ,
- ,
, , , ',
.
1

,
, , , . , ,
,
, 2 0. , , ,
,
.
" , (,)
() - -,
( ,) , ,
, ()()
3 ()() () - ()
, ()
, (') -, -

41 s. 1 Cor 2:14; Ir. I. 8.3; . V. 8.26


42-45 VI. 33.1; 52.11; Ir. I. 5.3
44 : VI. 33.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 49.1; Heracleonis Fr. 1 ap. Orig. In Io. 1:3
(2.14) s.f.
c. 35: 1-7 cf. Ir. I. 7.3-4
1 cf. Mt 11:13
3 Jo 10:8; Clem. Strom. 1. 81.1;
84.6-7 et al.
4 : cf. VI. 36.2; Ir. I. 6.1 s.f.
4 s. Eph 3 :4-5; V.
8.5; VII. 25.3; 26.7; Clem. Strom. 5. 87.1
8-40 cf. Ir. I. 7.2; Clem. Exc. ex Theod.
23.3; 59.1-4; Epiphan. 31. 7.4; Theodoret. Haer. 1.7, p.357 BC; Ps. Tert. Adv. omn. haer.
4 (p.221.5 Kr.) et al.
9 Rm 8 :19; VII. 25.1 et 5; 27.1
11 s. 2 Cor 3 :15
14-17 Lc 1:35; v.37 s.; VII. 26.9; X. 23.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 60
40 coniec. We:
44 scripsi (cf. 43 et ):
45 scripsi (cf. v. 44 et Ir. I. 5.3):
c. 35: 2
3
4 : NT
6 post lac. sign. Go
8 addidi (cf. v. 11)
10 addidi
conl. w . 9 , 12 et 2 Cor 3 :14 et 18; supplevi conl. w . 2 2 - 2 3
et Ir. I. 62 s.f.; 11.1

12 addidi ex NT ()

13
15 et 16 ' addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.34.7-35.7

20

25

30

35

249

(') - /
. () ,
() [ ] - - ,
, [] ( ) -
-,
,
,
', () .
()
, ' ,
. () ,
, ,
, -,
, , ,
,
() [] , ( ).
- , , ( ) . '

f. 76r
4

19 s. Eph 2 :15 et 4 :24; V. 7.15; In Noet. 17; Acta Thomcu 132 et al.
25-28 cf. I.
Leisegang in RE VII A (1948), pp. 2268-2273; Tert. Adv. Vol. 1 1 2
27 cf. Clem. Exc.
ex Tbeod. tit. ...
29 s. Mt 3 : 1 6 ; Mc 1:10; Lc 3 :22; 0 1:32); Ir. I. 7 2 ; 14.6; 15.1 et 3; 26.1; VI. 47.2;
49.5; 5 1 2 et 4; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 16; 22.6; 61.6; Pistis Sophia 1; 61; 63; 141 (pp. 1.10;
7 8 2 ; 8 3 2 4 ; 2 4 2 2 4 S.-T.); Ev. Ebion. ap. Epiphan. Pan. 30. 13.7; Acta Thomae 50 et al.
31 : cf. Mt 3 :17; Mc 1:11; Lc 3 :22
33 Km 8 : 1 1 ; In Noet. 4 et al.
34 s. cf. Gal 3 :10
35 Gn 3 :19b
16 N T
17
Go:
18
addidi (cf. v. 20 )
19
del. Mi (cf.
w.20-21)
20 del. Go
suppl. Cr
21
24
25 et 28 addidi
31 Cr (cf. Mc 1:11; Lc 3 :22
): : () Roeper: () We (cf. Ir.
I. 7.2 )
34 addidi
1 delevi: pro Go
supplevi (cf.
v. 34 )
34-35

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

250

Hippolytus

, () () ,
- - () -, () .
4
36 1
f. 76

' /
() . ' ()
, ()
' - () -, ()
2 , 5
, ,
, ' . ()
'
, . ' , [] ,
( )
, ( ) []

, ' '
.
3
() is
,

36 : Tert. Adv. Vol. 4.3


: cf. VII. 31.1; Euseb. Hist. eccl.
4.30; Praep. ev. 6. 9.32; Epiphan. Pan. 56; H.I. Gu. Drijvers, Bardaisan of Edessa (Diss.
Groning. 1966), pp. 167-185
38 Lc 1:35; v. 15
c. 36: 3 : i.e.
5-9 cf. Ir. I. 7.4; 8.4
5-7 Is 45 :5 et 6;
46:9; VI. 33; Ir. I. 5.4 et al.
8 s. cf. Ir. I. 6.1 s.f.
10-12 Ex 6 :3; VII.
25.4; lust. Dial. 1261
15-21 cf. Ir. I. 6.1-2; Epiphan. 31. 7.5; X. 13.3
36/37 () (i.q. Bardaisan) Bunsen (cf. VII. 31.1): 1 , 2
39 addidi (cf. v. 38)

c. 36: 1
' coniec. We: '
2 ()
scripsi: : () coniec. We
scripsi (cf. VI. 342):
: - Mi: - Bunsen
addidi
3 et 4 add. Cr
4 addidi
7 , corr. Scott et Bunsen
8 scripsi:
9
delevi
10 addidi
11 addidi ex VII.
25.4
( LXX) delevi: Go
:
LXX
15 addidi
-

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.35.7-37.3

251

, () . ()
, ,
- -,
20 () () ()
, ()' ()() 4
- ( )
, () (),
() - ,
25 ( ) -,
' .
() 1 37
/ ' ()()
f. 1
.
,
5 ' , ' () 2
( ) , .
() ,
, () , 3
, ,

22 s. VI. 3 1 2 ; Ir. I. 2.5


VI. 32.2 et 4; Ir. I. 2.6; 7.1

23 s. , :
24 s. VI. 34.1; 35.3

c. 3 7 : 5 - 9 P s . Plat. Ep. 2, p . 3 1 2 d 7 - e 4
313 a 1

9 s. p. 313 a 1-2

10 s. pp.312 e 4 -

17 add. Roeper et Bunsen


addidi
20 addidi
,
transposui

addidi (cf. v. 18 et . 13.3)
21 Bunsen et Go (cf. v. 19):
21 : coniec. Mi (conl.
.26)
23-24 (), () scripsi:
24 , corr. Mi
25 addidi
c. 37: 1 add. suad. We
2 ()() (cf. v. 29): ' Mi cett.
5 (et. Clem. Strom. 5. 65.1; Euseb. Praep. ev. 11. 202 cod. I; Theodoreti
Gr. ff cur. 2.78): ' Plato, Eus. codd. praeter I
v ex PI. add. Mi (
Clem.)
habet
6 ex PI. add. Mi
7 - 8
(cf. Theodor, codd. MSCV ):
PI. et testes
8 addidi ex PI.
8 - 9 . . . 1 We ex PL: . . .
1
2
2
9 et PI.:
Mi ex PL:
ex PL add. Mi
10
Mi ex PL:
scripsi ex PL:
Mi ex PL:
: PL
: PL

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

252

pf. 77

Hippolytus

, , ' ,
, ,
,
4 , , (,) (). ()
( , ) ,
() , ,
, .

5 . ()() ()
(), [()],
() .
,
() , ( )
6 , ,
() " [ ] , / ( ,
) "
. ' ,
, ,

is

25

11-14 .313 a 3-6


14-17 .314 a 7 - b 2
17 s. cf. p.314 b 3-5
19 s. p.314 b 5-7
20-22 p.314 c 1-4
24 (): i.q. , ,; cf. Pap. Londin. 191.9 (A.D.II) et ap. V. 9.5; VI.
9.4
29-44: Foerster, I, . 314
11
12 bis
13 : PI.
-
13-14 PI.
15 , Mi ex PI. (' (> We):
Mi ex PI.:
: PI.
16 ex PI. suppl. We
17 Mi ex PL:

, ex PI. corr. Mi
19 Mi: : PI.
20 : PI.
21 1 addidi ex PI.
2 delevi (om. PI.)
24 addidi (cf. w . 2 7 , 30)
Hilgenfeld:
24 ( )
scripsi ex coniectura: : () R. Scott: [] Bernays et Roeper,
agn. We: coniec. Go: Hilgenfeld
25 et 27 We:
26 Roeper:
seel. Roeper
27-28 ,
supplevi

29 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.37.3-7

253

,
'
,
' ,
5 '
,
.

31-38 = Valentini Fr.8; de psalmo cf. Ud. ab Wilamowitz, Hermes 34 (1899), p.218 s.
(= Kl. Schriften 4, p.60); Gu. Foerster, Von Valentin zu Herakkon, p.96 s.; A.I. Festugiere,
Vig. Christ. 3 (1949), pp. 205-207; praesertim Th. Wolbergs, Griech. relig. Gedichte etc.
(Beitrge zur klass. Philol. 40, 1971), pp. 23-36, et . Herzhoff, Zwei gnost. Psalmen (Diss.
Bonn. 1973), pp. 35-77
31 : cf. seu () , seu (b) : (a)
cf. v.37 et v. 38 ; Ir. I. 1.1;
I. 2.6; VI. 32.1-2; (sc. ) '
Ir. . 8.5; I. 11.1 s.f.; I. 4.5 s.f.; 7.5;
, , ,
Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 54.3 et al.; (b) cf. Heracleonis Frr. 32-36 ap. Orig. In Io.
4:35-38 (13.41; 44; 46; 49; 50); Mt 13 :39 ; Orot.
Sib. 2.164; 14.356; Olympiod. In Arist. Meteor, pp. 111.30-112.8 Stueve ( ) et al.
32 : cf. Iliad. 8.19 et Orph. Fr. 166 Kem (P. Leveque, Aurea catena Homert,
Paris. 1959, pp.46-52); Corp. Herrn. 1.5 (sc. ) '
(sc. ); Pap. Gr. Mag. 4.1154 s.; 1172 s.; V. 14.9 et al.

: cf. Corp. Herrn. 3.2


33 : Corp. Herrn. 3.2 ;
10.13 ,
, ...
; Fr.24 et A.I. Festugiere ad loc.; Plat. Tim. 41 e 2; 4 e 2; Philon. De plantat.
3 ...
34-36 cf. Corp. Herrn. 11.2 , ,
, , ; 11.15 , , , , et al.
36
= : Orac. Chald. 61 d et e; 67; 223.1 des Places
37 : cf. Ir. I.
1.1; 11.1; VI. 30.7; 38.5; . 13.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 29; Theodoret. Haer. 1.7 in.; I.
14 in. (sc. ); Orac. Chald. Fr. 18 des
Places ; Pap. Gr. Mag. 12.229 ...
et al.
: i. q. , cf. Ir. I. 14.2; VI. 43.1
38 : Ir. I. 1.1; II. 1, p. 5.5
: cf. Valentini Fr. 7 ap. VI. 42.2;
cod. Gnost. Berol. 8502.2, p. 34.11; Acta Thomae 108, Hymn. 2 v. 1
31 : <) Go cett.
33 , corr. Mi
35 Bunsen ( Wilamowitz):

35 et 36

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

254

Hippolytus

8 ' ,
, () - ,
()
, " (), , ()
9 , - ( )
, .
1

() , , ,

, ' .
2
-
, , ,
()() , ( ) ().
, ( ,)
, () ,
3 , ,
. .

C. 38: 1-4 Iren. I. 112; Epiphan. Pan. 32. 1.5-6; Tert. Adv. Vol. 38
Epiph. 32. 5.4-6; Tert. 37

5-12 Ir. I. 11.3;

40 1 addidi
scripsi (cf. v.42):
41 2 add. We
42 : Go
: Go cett.
Mi:
43 addidi
addidi
44 post lac. susp. Go
45 post lac. sign. Bunsen et Go: supplevi: ( )
( ) (suppressis . 46 )
Cr
46 Scott et Go:
c. 38: 1 scripsi:
2 Go (cf. v.5):
3 scripsi ex
. et Ir.:
4
5 (qui et clarus est magister eorum Ir.;
insignioris apud eos magistri Tert): Go ex Ep.32
5-6
: Ir. . (Tert.)
6 (inexcogitabile Tert.):
Ir. .
Mi:
- (et. . cod.
V 1 ): - Go (et. . codd. V2 )
7 addidi ex Ir. . Tert. (cf. w .
10-11)
8 Mi:
addidi ex Ir. . Tert.
9
Go ex Ir. . Tert.:

10 scripsi ex Ir. . (huic
Tert.):
Harvey et Go ex Ir.:
Mi ex Ir.:
11 We (appellat Tert.): : Mi ex Ir. Ep.
12

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.37.8-38.7

is

20

25

30

255

/
( , , )
( , ) () .
,
) () ,
,
, .
() .
(' )
() , ,
, ()
. ,
, , , ,
, ,
()()
.
, [] ,
, .
() (),

f. 78
4

13-20 . I. 11.4; Epiph. 32. 7.1-3; Tert. 35


21-24 Ir. I. 11.5; Epiph. 32. 7.4-5; Tert.
34; VI. 29.3; X. 13.1
24-36 Ir. I. 12.1; Epiph. 33. 12-7; cf. Tert. 33; Sagnard,
pp.355-357
13 Bunsen, Harvey, Go ex Ir.:
14 , corr. Mi
( Ir.)
, , ex Ir. ap. . suppl. G.
Volkmar (Hippolytus etc., Turici 1855, p. 51) et Go
15 habet

, ex Ir. suppl. Volkmar et Go


17 ex Ir. add. Mi
18 - (et. Ep. cod. V): - Go (et. Ep. cod. )
post verba:
quarto et octavo loco ( ) add. Ir. Tert.: om. et Ep. (error in
Hippolyti fonte)
19 post add. hoc Ir.: om. et Ep.
20 ()
Bunsen et Go ex Ir.:
21 scripsi: , def. Cr: Go (cf. VI.
29.3): etenim Ir.: Ep.
Go ex Ir. Ep.: : Cr
' addidi ex Ir. Ep.
22 ex
Ir. Ep. add. suad. Go
23
addidi
25 Mi
ex Ir. .:
26 : .
27 , ex
Ir. . corr. Mi
1 Ir.: .
27-28 ()() Mi
et Go ex Ir. Ep.:
29 Go ex Ir. .:
30 coni. Go conl. Ep. et Ir. (egressas esse):
delevi (om. Ir.
Ep.)
32 (adventitiae voluntatis Jr.): () Mi: om. Ep.
addidi ex Ep. ( () Harvey)
Harvey et Go ex Ir. Ep.
Tert.:
addidi ex Ir. (est): Ep.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

256

Hippolytus

, .
() , () ' - 35
()()(), () .
39

pf. 78

, (,)
, , ,
,
2 . /
- 5
, ,

.
,
3
, ,
.
. (') ()
, is
.

c. 39: cc.39-42 et 55 ed. Bunsen .355-359


1 - 4 Iren. 1.13.1; Epiph. 3 4 . 1 2 - 3
4-8 Ir. I. 132; Ep. 34. 2.1
13 s. : IV. 28.13; cf. Ir. I. 13.1
33
34 Harvey ex Ep. (cogitabat Ir.): : Go (cf. w .
35, 36)
34/35 : Ep.
35 ' Mi ex Ep.:
()
Harvey ex Ep. (quae Ir.):
Harvey ex
Ep.:
36 Bunsen et Go ex Ep. (advenit Ir.): ()()
Mi ex Ep. Ir.
scripsi ex Ep.:
:
Harvey ex Ep. Ir. (emisit)
c. 39: 1 addidi (Marcus est autem illi nomen, Ir.)
2 Bunsen:
: Chr. Petersen (cf. VI. 41.1): Theodoret. Huer. 1.9
3
We:
4 - scripsi (= Ep. cod. V 1 ): - : - Mi (et.
Ep. codd. V 2 )
6 Ep.
: Harvey
7
: Harvey
10
11
12 Mi:
We: : Mi
14 coniec. We:
{') () scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.38.7-40.3

257

() 1
() , , ,
( ,)
,
- , () 2
, .
, [] ,
, .
() 3
,
, (') .
() () [] ()
()()(), , () ()
, ,
, .
, ( ) ,

1-10 Iren. I. 132; Epiph. 34. 2 2 - 4


5 - 7 cf. Sagnard, p.417
5 : cf.
VI. 392; Ir. I. 1.1; 8.6; 13.3; 2 9 2 ; Epiph. 31. 5.4; NH 1.4, p.45.13; II. 1, pp.4.8 et 8.4 ss.;
III.2, p.52.9 et al.
6 : cf. Eph 3 :16; Km 7 :22; 2 Cor 4 :16; Clem.
Exc. ex Theod. 51.1; Ir. I. 5.5; 21.4; V. 7.36; VI. 34.5; X. 13.3; 19.3 et al.
7
: Mt 13 :31; Mc 4 :31; Lc 13 :19; V. 9.6; VII. 21.3; . 14.1; .
Thomae log. 20; N H 1.2, p.8.7; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 1.3 et al.
:
cf. Lc 8 :8; Mt 13 :8; Mc 4 :8; V. 829; VIII. 9.1; . ThomM log. 9 et al.
1 () scripsi ( Ir.): '
: Go: ' Diels
2 addidi ex Ir.
3
addidi ( Ir.), cf. v. 10 I
4 We:
- om. Ir. .
5 2 addidi ex .
2 ,- 1
6/7-
8 .
9 del. suad. We (om. .), cf. v. 10
Mi:
11 scripsi: I
() Mi:
13 'addidi
Bunsen
14 ()
() (cf. . 19) scripsi:
delevi

scripsi:
() scripsi: . . . ut v.:
coniec. Mi, agn. We
15 ()() () : coniec. Mi:
We
() scripsi: . . '. . : coniec. Mi: coniec.
Go: Cr: () We
16 , corr. Roeper

scripsi:
18 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

258

pf.79r

Hippolytus

4 , , '
, 2
/ ,
,
.
41 1


, () ,
, ,
, . , []
(,) , , 5
,
() .
2
() , ,
' , ()
3 ( ) , ()
()
()
, ( ) , , [] (), is
4 , . ,
,
, ()

c. 41: 2 - 4 Iren. I. 13.3; Epiph. 34. 2.5; cf. VI. 39.1


4 - 7 Iren. I. 13.6; Epiph.
34. 3.4-5
4 : cf. Ir. I. 13.3; Ep. 34. 2.6 ss. ; Ir. I. 13.7; . 34. 3.10
8-11 Ir. I. 13.6 et 21.1-4; Ep. 34. 3.6 et 19.1-20.12;
VI. 42.1 - 2
16 : cf. Ir. 1.21.3; Ep. 34.20.1 '
19 , corn Mi

22 coniec. Cr:

c. 41: 1 scripsi:
2 add. Mi
4 : Mi
2
delevi
5 addidi
: Cr
6 ()
susp. Roeper (at cf. w . 21-22)
7 addidi
8 add. suad. We
(cf. v. 11 et VI. 42.1)
post , transposui (cf. v. 15)
10 add.
Bunsen et Roeper
11 Bunsen et addidi (cf. v. 6 et Ep.
34. 3.6 ): : ()
coniec. Mi
addidi
del. Roeper
13 addidi
14
addidi (cf. VI. 42.1)
scripsi:

15 delevi I

16 scripsi:
18 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.40.3-42.3

259

, () 5
2 ,
()(), ' , ' ()
. (), ()
, '
, .
/ , 1 42 pf.79v
() ,
, ( )
, .
5 , ()
, , . ' 2
,
.


, '
()
,
, 5 .
() 3
- , ,
-

c. 42: 1-3 Iren. I 21.1-4 - Epiph. 34. 19-20


7 s. : cf. . 34. 20.2-7;
Theodoret. Huer. 1.9
11-13 = Valentini Fr. 7; cf. Foerster, I, p. 314
12
: cf. Valentini Fr. 8 (v. 7) ap. VI. 37.7
14 : cf. Iren. I.
11.4 et 15.4
16 ab usque ad VI. 51.5 ex Irenaeo exscripsit H:
cf. Ir. I. 14.1-15.3 (I, pp. 127-152 Harvey) = Epiph. 34. 4.2-10.7 (II, pp. 10-21 Holl)
omissis solis Ep. 34. 8.1-2 et 34. 9.5-10
19
add. Cr
21 ' ( ) coniec. We
: Mi I
add. Mi
23 -
24 , transposui
Roeper:
c. 42: 2 addidi
3 Bunsen et Go:
6 addidi
12

scripsi:
13 Mi:

16 scripsi:
() scripsi ex . Ir. (descendisse):
18 scripsi ex . Ir. (semetipsam):
: .

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

260

pf. 8

Hippolytus

,
4 , , ()
, ( ,) [] () ,
,
() ,
,
5 ,
, ,
, /
() ,
- , []
6 , ()
, ,

, ,
( ' ),
, ' [ ]
() , , [] ()
7 []. , ,
, () ,
. () ,

25

35

26 ss. de Marci calculis cf. Fr. Dornseiff, Das Alphabet in Mystik u. Magie (Lipsiae 1922),
pp. 126-133 et Sagnard, pp. 358-386 et 429-438
20 : .
, ex . Ir. corr. Go
21
supplevi ex Ir. (cuius pater nemo est) et . (qui omittit et pro :
habet)
delevi (cf. v. 22)
-
24 : .
. Ir. (ei): susp. Holl
25
27
: coniunxit et Ir.: .
28
() Mi ex
. Ir.:
29 3 del. Diels (om. Ir.): habent ., sed del. Holl
. (ipsa Ir.): Diels
30 , transposui (
.)
ex . add. Mi
34 : .
( ' ), supplevi ex . Ir. (sed nec cognoscere eum):
.
) et v. 36 () sive i. q. (cf. VI. 43.6), sive
antiquus error pro
35 Mi: .
' Go ex . Ir.:
delevi (cf. v. 34)
36 addidi ex . Ir. (cf. v. 37): pro
Go
, ex . Ir. corr. Go
delevi (om. .)

ex Ep. Ir. add. Mi


37 delevi (om. Ep.), cf. v. 36
scripsi ex Ep. (pars
existens totius Ir.):
38 , ex . Ir. (cessare) corr. Mi
39 , ex Ep. Ir. corr. Go
We (deveniant Ir):
40 ex . Ir. add. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.42.3-43.3

261

,
-
, () 8
() - ,
45 ,
.
1 43
, ()
' () ()()
() () ().

5
2
- (')
, ()
(). ,
, /
f.
, -
, . , ' 3
,

, ' -
is ' , '
, ()
.

C. 42: 45 s. cf. Mt 18:10; Ir. I. 13.3 et 6; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 10.6; 11.1; 12.1; 23.4; Strom.
5. 91.3 et al.
42 post verba lapsu repetit
scripsi:
: .: cuius Ir.
Mi ex . Ir.:
43 ex . Ir. add.
Mi
44
45 : N T
c. 43: 1 Go ex . Ir.:
2 - 3 ( ) ' ( ) Mi ex . Ir.:
'
3
4
ex . Ir. add. Cr
5 Go ex . Ir.:
Mi ex Ir. (ultima littera): .
6 ' ex . Ir. add. Go
Go ex Ep. Ir.:
7
8 scripsi ex Ir. (generata): Ep. (corr. Holl)
9 Mi ex
Ir. (deorsum): Ep.
10 Mi ex Ep.:
12 Mi ex Ep.
Ir.: 1 , 2
13 post repetit
15
: .
16-17 () coniec. Mi:
: . Ir.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

262

Hippolytus

'
( )
- '
5 ( , ' ), ,
, ' () ;
(), ,
- 6 . ,
, - -
,
.

()
() ()() ()
,
,
2 . , , , ,

c. 44: 5-8 cf. : Manil. 4.701-705; Fr. Boll, Spbaera, pp.469-472; Sternglaube u. Sterndeutung3, p. 136 s. et facsim. 14-17; Reitzenstein, p.260 s.; Dornseiff, Das
Alphabet etc., p. 132 s.; Adam kadmon ap. E. Bischoff, Die Elemente der Kabbalah, II, pp. 38
ss. et 81 ss., et al.
5 = : cf. Ape 1:8; 21:6; 22:13; Iren. I. 14.6; 15.1 et
2; VI. 47.2; 49.5; 50.3; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 5; Pistis Sophia 62 et 136 (pp.81.9-12 et
232.23-26 S.-T.); Jeu II. 50, p.320.10-13; Gnost. cod. Bruc. 9, p.346.34; N H V.4, p.
58.10-14; Clem. Strom. 4. 157.1; Paed. 1. 36.1; O. Weinreich, Arch. f . Rel.-Wiss. 19(1918),
p. 181 ss.; Fr. Dornseiff, o.e., pp. 122-125 et al.
18 : ., disces Ir.
19 , ex . Ir. corr. Go

addidi ex . Ir. (et ipsum)
et . cod. V: Mi et . cod. , Holl
20 et . cod. V: . cod.
: ., hae
rursus Ir.
21 - ' ex . Ir. suppl. Go
24 ' Go:
(. Ir.)
Go: : . Ir.
25
. Ir.
Mi ex . Ir.:
Mi: : , vide Ir.
26-27 pro - . Ir. habent

27 , corr. Mi
28 We (suum Ir.): .
29
c. 44: 1 1, - 2
Mi ex .: : Go
2 Ir.
(autem): . Go
3
: ' ., ut circumspicias
Ir.
4 Mi (sapientiam Ir.): : .
5 (quid
(in) quit Ir.): om. ., del. Cr
, primum Ir.: om. ., del. Diels

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.43.4-45.3

263

[] , ( ) , , ()
( ) , , , / , , ,
, , '
, ,
, 3
( ) , ,
, , ( )
( ) ,
( ) ( ) ( )
is .

f. sir

, 1 45
,
() ,
. 2
5 , () [] ( ) ( ) ( )
[] ( ) -
[']
, . 3
, , ( ) [] , -

c. 44: 14 (): ft. cf. ,Vater aller Vaterschaft': Pistis Sophia 136, p.232.9 et 28;
Jeu II. 45, p. 309.1; Gnost. cod. Bruc. 17, p. 359.9 et saepius
c. 45: 9 : i.e. sex ( F), cf. Clem. Strom. 6. 140.4; Domseiff, p. 130 n.2; Sagnard,
p. 366 et al.
10 s. ft. cf. 1 Cor 1 : 2
c. 44: 6 om. Ep., del. We: () susp. Go: Cr
ex .
Ir. add. Go
() Go ex Ep. Ir.:
7 ex Ep. Ir. add. Go I
Go:
8 : Ep. Ir.
10 scripsi ex Ir. (autem): .
11 , corr. Mi
addidi ex .: eum Ir.
12 ex Ep. Ir. (quidem)
add. We
13 Mi: spat. vac. litt, duo
om. .
14 ()( ) Go ex . Ir.:
() scripsi: : Go ex . Ir.
c. 45: 4 (s. -)
6 scripsi ex . Ir. (tamquam):
edd.
delevi ut dittogr. () et ( ) ( ) ( ) scripsi: : ., contemptibile Ir.: Mi: R. Scott, agn. Go We, Cr
7 delevi (om. Ep. Ir.)
v ex Ep. Ir. add. Mi
, corr. Mi
8 Mi ex Ir. (olim): 1, 2 , ut v.: Ep.
' del. Cr
(om. Ep. Ir.):
8 - 9 . Ir.
9 .: autem Ir.
10 ex . add. Go
10/11 Go: :
., cognitum Ir.
11 del. Go (om. Ep. Ir.)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

264

Hippolytus

, , '
(), ' ().
46 1

pf. 8

() '
() [()] ()(),
[] . ()
,
, 5
2 , , ,
/
(), '
, , ,
-
3 .
[] [] ,
, .

, ' () is
, ' , () ()
4 , .

3 s. : , , (cf. e.g. Dionys. Thrac. Artis gramm. 6, p. 9


ss. Uhlig)
6 :
8 s. :
9 ; sc. (.4)
14 : et computatio et aeon Sophia (cf.
Sagnard., p.369 s.)
(sc. ): i.e. aeon (continens litteras
24) (= 888)
15 : sive (i.e. , cf. Iren. 1.11.1),
sive (i.e. ', cf. v. 18 s. oi )
c. 45: 13 scripsi ex Ir. (ab ipsis qui sunt cognati eius): iitterae evanidae quattuor P:
add. Cr: om. Ep.
c. 46: 1 addidi ex Ep. Ir. (igitur)
' Ep. (Tetras loquitur: v. 26 '
Marcus loquitur): ' Ir. (apud nos)
2 Ep. Ir.
dubium in P, delevi (om. Ep. Ir.)
() Go ex Ep. Ir.: () Mi We
3 Ep. (quae continent Ir)
Go ex Ep. Ir.: pov Mi

del. Go (om. Ep. Ir.): () Mi


6
7 Ep., recipere Ir.
8
10 Go ex Ep. Ir. (per):
12 1 et 2 del. Mi (om. Ep.)
15'.:1:1/;.

16-17 () ()
scripsi (cf. w . 18-20): : Ep., aequalitatem
habens Ir.
17

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.45.3-47.2

265

,
, '
20 .
, ()
, , ' ()
,
() , - 5
25 ,
[] ( ' )

.
1 47
() ,
,
5 , , 2
, / ,
f. 82

26 : cf. Dionys. Thrac. Art.gramm. 6 (p. 14 Uhlig)


- (at litteras bis computare Marcus videtur: ut litteras semivocales et ut duplices litteras); cf. VI. 47.4
28 : i.e.
(4 + 4 + 10 + 12), cf. Iren. I. 1.3; s. (= litt.24) + (
, litt. 6), cf. Ir. I. 15.2; VI. 49.5 et al.
c. 47: 1 s. Rm 1:23 (Gn 1:26)
2 s. i.e. Petrus, Iacobus, Ioannes, Iesus, Moyses,
Helias: Mt 17:1-3; Mc 9 : 2 - 4 ; Lc 9:28-30; Clem. Strom. 6. 140.3-4; Exc. ex Theod. 4.1;
Iren. 2. 24.4; Ev. Philippi log.26; N H 1.3, p.48.8 ss.; Acta Thomae 143; Acta Ioannis 90 et
al.; cf. Sagnard., pp.376-382
5 s. Mt 3 :16; Mc 1:10; Lc 3 :22; Ir. I. 7.2; 15.1 et 3;
26.1; VI. 35.6; 49.5; 51.2 et 4; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 16; 22.6; 61.6 et al.
18 Mi ex Ep. Ir.:
19 Holl ex Ir. (ter): Ep.
' Mi ex Ep. Ir. (in se): '
20 Mi ex Ep.:
21 ex Ep. Ir. (quae) add. Mi
Mi ex Ep. Ir.:
22
23 et Mi ex Ep. Ir.: et
24 () Mi ex Ep. Ir.: I
- et Ep. cod. V 1 : - Mi et Ep. codd. V 2
25 (= ) post
Harvey, scripsi ex Ep. Ir.: ( F)

26 , corr. Go
del. Mi (om. Ep. Ir.)
' supplevi ex Ep. Ir.
(= ) scripsi
(cf. test.): (= F) : om. Ep. Ir.: Cr
27 Mi (virtute quae est Ir):
: Ep.
28 We ex Ep.:
c. 47: 1 Go ex Ep. Ir.: (ex c.46 v. 28)
, transposui conl. Ep.
2 , 1

5 ante

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

266

Hippolytus

, ' () .
3
-
-, ()
.
4 , . ,
()
,
() [' ] .

.
1

, () , (
) , ,
, ( ) .
(')

7 + + + + + + + + - ' (801); Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 5; cf. : Ape


1:8; 2 1 : 6 ; 22:13; VI. 442 (q.v.); 49.5; 50.3 et al.
7 s. cf. Gn 1:26 et 31
10 s. cf. 1 Cor 15:45
l i s . Jo 19:14
14 cf. Lc 16 :8; Jo 12:36; Eph 5 :8; 1 Th
5:5
15-18 VI. 46.5
17 s. cf. VI. 42.6; 52.3 et 7 - 8 ; Iren. I. 1.3
c. 48: 4 : i.e. , cf. Iren. I. 4.1 et al.
5 : i.e. , cf. Ir. I. 5.1
7 Mi ex Ep. Ir.:
pro () - . Ir. habent

scripsi:
8 (die Ir.):
.
: ., dixisse Ir.
9 : om. . Ir. I
post intellege (cf. . 8): lacunam antiquam susp. Holl, qui supplet
( )
10 addidi (cf. w . 8, 9, 12),
om. Ep. Ir.
: om. . Ir., del. Mi
13 , corr. Mi

, ex . Ir. corr. Mi
15 Mi ex Ep. Ir.: I
() We ex .: : in eum numerum ( ) Ir.
' .: om. Ir., del. suad. We (cf. v. 14 )
coniec. We conl.
Ep. Ir. (quae facta est):
16 Mi ex Ep. Ir.:
c. 48: 2 ex Ep. Ir. add. Mi
2-3 addidi ex Ep. Ir.
3 2 Ep.: (ab) Ir.
4 Ep.: intelligi Ir.
addidi
ex Ep. Ir. (aut praecisus)
5 Ep.: Mi cett.
(') scripsi
ex Ep. Ir. (ab eo):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.47.2-48.3

267

() [ ]
,
() () ' 2
, () f , f ,
.
() ,
, , () () []
, , ,
. - 3
is ' ,
/. ()

() .

f. 82

8 s. cf. VI. 33.1; 34.8; Ir. I. 5.3


9 <>: cf. . ap. VI. 33.1; 34.8;
Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 49.1; Heracleonis Fr. 1 et Ir. I. 5.1
10 &
: ft. i.q. : cf. Ir. I. 2.4; 3.4; 4.1; 5.1 () et
I. 5.3; 7.2-4; VI. 34.8; 35.6 ( )
11-14 cf. Exc. ex Nicom. 6 (Mus. Scr. Gr.
p.276 C. Jan et p.228 n.3); Exc. Neapel. 24 (p.418 s. Jan); Alexandrum Lychnon ap.
Theon. Math. pp. 138-141 Hiller; Heraclit. Qu. Horn. 12; Chalcid. In Tim. 72; Plut. De an.
procr. in Tim. 1028 F-1029 (et H. Cherniss ad loc.); De mus. 1138 F-1139 B; De 389
; De def. orac. 430 A; Achill. Isag. exc. 17, p.43 s. Maass; Anecd. Gr. Bekker p.796; Io.
Lyd. De mens. 2.3 (p.20 Wuensch); Theolog. arithm. p.53 Ast; Schol. in Dionys. Thrac.
p. 198 Hilgard; Censorin. De die nat. 13.3-5; Plin. Nat. hist. 2.84; Hygin. Astron. 4.14
(p. 117 s. Bunte); Favon. Eulog. 25.2; Prob. In ViTg. Georg. 1.336; Mart. Cap. 2.196 ss. et
al.; cf. Domseiff., o.e., pp.35 ss.; 82 s.; Gu. Burkert, Philol. 105 (1961), pp.32-43; B.L.
van der Waerden in RE Suppl. X (1965), pp. 857-859 et al.
12 s.
. . . : cf. = I () (1 + 2 + 3 + 4 = 10);
ad VI. 24.1; Iren. I. 3 2 ; VIII. 12.6-7; Fr. I. Doelger, , . 356 ss.
6 ex . add. Go
ut glossema secl. Mi, om. Ep. Ir.
:
. Ir.
Cr ex . Ir.: We
8

addidi ex . Ir. (et ipse)


ex Ep. add. Mi
9 , ex
. Ir. corr. Go
ex Ep. Ir. (vero) add. Go
Go ex Ep. Ir. (reliqua
vero ministrant): , def. Harvey: corruptela in fonte Hippolyti, exspectes (
) ()
10 scripsi ex . Ir.:
11 Mi ex . Ir.:
12 : .
3 del. We (om. .):
Scott
13 post add. ., enarrat Ir.
: .
14 post addunt . Ir.
scripsi: : ., quae Ir. I
, , . Ir.
: . Ir.
16
: . (Ir.)
17 scripsi ex . Ir.
(factum):
18

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

268

Hippolytus

() () ,

4 . () , ,
, (
), () -
.
, [] , ' ,
, .
1

- ,
, , . -
, 2 ( ).
() ,
, -

19-21 cf. Clem. Strom. 5. 48.8; Dornseiff, p. 19


24 Ps 8 : 3 ; Mt 21:16; Ir. 4. 11.3;
In Psalm. 12 Nautin; Clem. Paed. 1. 13.1; Tert. De an. 19.9 et al.
25 Ps 18 :2; Clem.
Strom. 6. 141.6 ,
. '
; Ed. proph. 51.1; I Clem. 27.7; lust. Dial. 64.8 et al.
26 s. cf. NH
X. 1, p. 26.3 ss. et A. Boehlig, Zum Hellenismus in den Schriften von Nag Hammadi (Goettinger Orientforschungen, Hellenistica, 2, 1975), pp. 15-17
c. 49: 2 ss. = Iren. I. 15.1 ss. = Epiph. 34. 8.3 ss.
19 Mi ex Ep.:
ex Ep. Ir. add. We
-
20
, om. Ep. Ir.
21 Go ex Ep.: Ir. (hunc)
ex Ep. add. Mi
22-23 supplevi ex Ep. Ir.
23 2 Ep. Ir.: 1 1
, om. Ep. Ir.
24
25 pro usque ad v. 26
habent Ep. Ir. () ,
(lege )
26 del. Mi (cf. v.26 )
scripsi:
Mi: :
Ep. (ut Ir)
27
c. 49: 3 Mi ex Ep.:
4 1 : .
5

6 supplevi ex Ep. Ir. (generaverunt


figuras)
Go ex
Ep. Ir.:
7 ex Ep. Ir. add. Go
8 scripsi: (autem Ir.):
om. Ep., del. Go
: & Ep., quae Ir.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.48.3-49.5

269

() . - ( , ) () ' , -
, .
- 3
(), () () (),
, () .
is , , ,
, () 4
() , () - () '
() - [ ]
- () ()
20 , / () () ()
() , 5
() , , () () , () ()
, () , , () (*)

f. 83

19 i.e. + + + + + = Iitt.24 (cf. . Usener, Das Weihnachtsfest2 p. 23 n. 12)


9 () Mi ex Ep. Ir.:
ex Ep. Ir. add. We et ,
supplevi ex Ir., qui praebet: alia vero, quae cum gravitate et honore et fide nominantur: f f Ep. ( (
) . Holl)
9/10 () scripsi: : honore Ir.:
coniec. Go
13 :
Ep. Ir.
addidi ex Ep.
Go ex Ir.:
, Ep.
14 1 ex Ep. add. Mi
post addunt Ep. Ir.
( )
16 addidi ex Ep. Ir. (quoque)
17 addidi ex Ir. Ep. (IH):
ex v. 18 hue transtul. Go
() Mi ex Ep. Ir.:
2 addidi
17 - 18 , om. Ep. Ir.
18 Mi:

addidi (cf. v. 21)
seclusi
(cf. ad .24): in v. 17 transposuere Go
19 : Ep. Ir.
: om. Ep.: et Ir. cod. Vossianus
Go ex Ep.: Ir.
addidi ex Ep. Ir.
20 Mi:
21 usque ad v.26 om. Ep. Ir.
21 addidi (cf. v. 17)
scripsi: : () Go
22 Go:

Mi:
23 , supplevi
2 addidi
, supplevi
addidi
23 et 24 , supplevi
24 () Mi: : f We
post
(= ) lacunam signavi: exspectes (
,)
(cf. . 18), ( > (= F). Cf. Ir. I. 15.2 - Ep. 34. 9.8-9
, , ,
,

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

270

Hippolytus

() ()
. -
, , ,
.
1

[] , (,)
, ,
, ,
2 [ ] , , , ( )
, () ,
[] , .
3 . ()
() () ()
( ) ,

26 s. Ape 1:8; 21:6; 22:13; VI. 44.2 (q.v.); 47.2; 50.3


27 s. cf. Mt 3:16; Mc
1:10; Lc 3:22; VI. 35.6; 47.2; 51.2 et 4; Ir. I. 7.2; 15.1 et 3; 26.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod.
16; 22.6; 61.6 et al.
c. 50: 4 : IH, i.e. (), cf. Iren. I. 3 2 = Epiph. 31. 14.7; Ir. I. 30.14; Ep.
Barn. 9.8 (Gn 14:14); Clem. Strom. 6. 84.3
;.et.I + (litt. 8)ap.Ir. 1.15.2
9 5.: + + + + + = 888,..
tres ogdoades, cf. VI. 46.3-4

, ...,
, , , ()
25 addidi
addidi (cf. v. 19)
26 pro - 28
habent Ep. Ir. , ,

c. 50: 1 del. suad. We (om. Ep.)
addidi ex Ep. Ir.
2 scripsi ex
Ir. (in filiae locum), cf. VI. 51.1: Ep.
3 1 , corr. Mi
4 (1. ) del. Go (om. Ep. Ir.)
(XVIII Ir.):
Ep.
4/5 Mi ex Ep. Ir.:
6
ex Ep. Ir. suppl. Go
6/7 , ex Ep.
corr. Mi
7
8 () Mi ex Ep. Ir.:

9 del. Mi (om. Ep. Ir.), cf. v. 7



10 post addunt
Ep. Ir. '

addidi ex Ep. Ir.


11 1 , corr. Dindorf
, corr. We
12 ex Ep. Ir. add. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.49.5-51.3

271

, ,
, ( )
is , () .
() - 1 51
()()()
() () , ,
5 , ,
() ' '
, ( ). , 2
/ f. 83
,
. 3
()
, ,
.

14 s. Ape 1:8; VI. 442; 472; 49.5


c. 51: 1-25 Iren. I. 15.3 = Epiph. 34. 10.1-7
2 : cf. Ir. I. 1.1; 12.1; 14.5;
15.1; VI. 29.7; 462-3; 49.3
4 s. cf. L c l : 3 5
7 s. cf. Ir. I. 12.3 s.f.
8 s. Mt. 3:16; Mc 1:10; Lc 3:22; Ir. I. 7.2; 15.1; 26.1; VI. 35.6; 47.2; 49.5; Clem.
Exe. ex Theod, 16; 22.6; 61.6 et al.
9 : i.e. , cf. Ir. I.
4.1; 11.1; VI. 31.8; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 232 ; 322
9 s.
: i.e. : (undeeima littera et 30) + = (duodeeima littera),
cf. Ir. I. 162; VI. 52.9-10; Sagnard, p.383 s.
14 Go ex Ep.:
ex . Ir. add. Go
15 addidi ex Ir. (ex omnibus eius generationem): om. Ep.
c. 51: 2 ()() ut v., corr. Mi
: Ep.,
generaverunt Ir. (cf. v.6)
3 addidi ex Ep.
() Go ex Ep. Ir.:

6 addidi ex Ep. Ir. (et sic)
7 , corr. Go
7
usque ad v. 8 supplevi ex Ep. Ir. (cf. w . 12 s. et 16 s.)
9 Ep. Ir.: Mi cett.
10 Ep.: inerat ()
Ir., ft. recte
11 scripsi ex Ep.:
:
Ep., ipsam Ir.
12 : & .
om. .
Ir., ft. delendum (cf. v. 9)
ex Ep. Ir. add. Go
13 scripsi ex
Ep. Ir. (cf. Ir. 1.1.1):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

272

Hippolytus

[ ] () , Yiv
- . ()
, , () (5 ), [],
,
()
- , []
, () , () []
()
.
1



(),
, ,
2 ,
,
[] () (), ()
. () () []
.
c. 52: 4 s. cf. I. 2.5-10; IV. 43.4-44.3; 51.1-9; VI. 23-28
Epiph. 34. 12.1-14 exscripsit

9-63 ex Iren. I. 16.1-2 =

15 Go ex Ep.:
delevi (om. Ep. Ir., cf. v. 16 )
() Mi: : Ep. (qui locutus est Ir.)
16 scripsi ex
Ep. Ir. (coniec. Go):
Cr: Ep.
17 ex Ep. Ir. add. Go
18 scripsi ex Ep. Ir (cf. w . 1, 12, 20):
ex Ep. add. Go
18/19 addidi ex Ir. (cf. v. 19 ): om. Ep.
19 Ep. Ir.:
coniec. I.E. Grabe, ft. recte
del. Go (om. Ep. Ir.)
21 1 ex Ep. Ir. (in)
add. Cr
22
Cr ex Ep. (quem capientem habere
Ir.):
del. Cr (om. Ep. Ir.)
23 et 1 addidi ex
2
Ep. Ir.
delevi (om. Ep. Ir.)
24 ex Ep. add. Mi
c. 52: 3 addidi (cf. e.g. IV. 50.1)
4
6
() (non , ut Mi cett.)
7 delevi
() scripsi: : coniec. Cr
() scripsi ( i. q. Thes.
Gr. L.): , ut v.: ' coniec. Mi: ' s. coniec. Go: () Cr: () coniec. We

add. suad. We
, corr. Mi
9 : Ep. (constare Ir)
del. We (om. Ep.)
10 post addunt Ep. Ir.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio V1.51.4-52.5

2 73

' () (' ) , 3
, ,
() /(>
, . , 4
is () ,
(). ,
, , ( ). , , 5
20 . (
) , ()
,
,
.

f. 84r

16 : cf. Ir. I. 3.3; II. 20.1; Sagnard, p.382 s.


17 cf. Mt 18:12; Lc 15:4; de
Sophia Valentini cf. Ir. I. 8.4; de Helena Simonis cf. Ir. I. 23.2; Epiph. 21. 3.5; Tert. De an.
34.4; VI. 19.2; cf N H 1.3, p. 31.35 ss.; Ev. Thomae log. 107 et al.
19 s. cf. Lc
15:8; Ir. I. 8.4; N H 1.2, p.8.9 s.
20-24 i.e. ( 1 2 - 1 ) X ( 1 0 - 1 ) = 99 et + +
+ = 99. Cf. R. Reitzenstein, Zeitschr.f. NT Wiss. 15 (1914), p.78; de voce amen in
papyris et inscriptionibus ft (99) scripta cf. Dornseiff, pp. 112 et 131
11 ex Ep. add. Cr
' addidi (' Ep., ab ea Ir.)
12
scripsi ex Ep. (cf. app. ad v. 10):
Ep.: Mi Go
13 ex Ep. Ir. add. Cr
() Go: : I Mi
15 , ex Ep. Ir. corr. Mi
16 ex Ep. Ir. add. Cr
2 , 1
17 post lac. sign. Go, quam explevi ex Ep.
( ) et Ir. (quoniam apostasiam
a duodecade factam dicunt)
18-19 pro habent Ep.
Ir. []

19 scripsi:
19-20 pro -
habent Ep. Ir. ,

19 : coniec. Mi
.

20
20 pro usque
ad .24 habent Ep. Ir.
( , )
,
,
20 scripsi:
21 supplevi
post 22 ,
transposui
addidi
22 Go:
23 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

274

Hippolytus

()
, -

, () 7 . ( )
() , ()
( ), ( )
, (
.)
, ()
- -. ( '
8 .)
. - () ()
()
- ( ) () , (
) ,
[ ] ()
. 33 i. e. ex ogdoade, decade et duodecade, cf. v. 37 s.
25 pro habent . Ir.
.
post lac. susp. Go
addidi
ex .
26 post add. Ep., volunt Ir.
28 (componentes Ir.): .
(cf. .32):
. .
addidi
29 addidi ex . Ir.
scripsi ex
. Ir.:
30 addidi ex Ir. (per)
: per numeros
(/. numerum) litterarum Ir.: .
addidi ex Ep. Ir. (autem)

scripsi ex Ep.:
31 supplevi
ex . Ir.
add. Go et 2 add. Mi et Cr
32 post om. (Ep.
34. 12.9) ,
, , ,
32-33
supplevi ex . Ir. (cf. w . 3 6 s. et 44)
33
(tribus Ir)\ .
34 ex . et Ir. (ter) add. Mi
35
.: om. Ir.
35-36 -
ex . Ir. suppl. Cr
35 We: . Holl: in se Ir.
36 post
add. Ep., om. Ir.
37 post add. ' Ep., om. Ir.

addidi
ab () usque ad v. 43 om. . Ir.
(additamentum Hippolyti)
37 addidi
38 () ,
transposui
scripsi:
39 addidi
40 , transposui
40-41 supplevi
41
Mi:
scripsi (cf. v. 40):
scripsi:
42
seclusi (quia 11 9 = 99, cf. v. 22 s.)
add. suad. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.52.6-11

275

() 9
45 , -
,
, , () '
, / - () ()
so ()() () , , , 10
,
, ,
, ,
55 , ( )[] (),
, [
] , () 11
- -,
, ,
60 () (.

f. 84

57 : i.e. Marci discipulos


58 : VI. 31.6; 54.1; . 132; Ir. 1.14.1;
16.3; 172; 19.1; 21.4; Epiph. 31. 4.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. I l l et al.
58-60 cf. N H
1.3 {Ev. Verit), pp.31.35-32.16; Ir. II. 24.6; luven. Sat. 10.248 s. Felix nimirum, qui tot per
saecula mortem / distulit atque suos iam dextra conputat annos; Sidon. Apollin. Ep. 9.9
(Ad Faustum) s.f.: quandoquidem tuos annos iam dextera numeraverit; August. In ev. Io.
122.7 (C.C. 36, p. 672.50) quia in summa centenarii numerus ad dexteram transit; Cassian.
CoUat. 24. 26.7 (III, p. 202 E. Pichery, Sources ehret. 64) Centenarius enim numerus de
sinistra transfertur in dexteram, et licet eandem in supputatione digitorum figuram tenere
videatur, nimium tamen quantitatis magnitudine supercrescit; cf. ,
ap. Ir. I. 5.1; 6.1; VI. 32.6; cf. V. 15.4-5; Epiph. 32. 2.1-4 et al.
44 pro - 46 habent Ep. Ir.
,
(: Grabe)
44 Ep. (non , ut Mi cett.)
ex
Ep. Ir. add. Cr
47 ex Ep. Ir. add. Go
, om. Ep. Ir.
49
ex Ep. Ir. add. Go
50 2 ex Ep. add. suad. We
51 coniec. We:
Ep.
post ) addunt Ep. Ir.
52 bis
53 hie et in v. 55

(i.e. ) Ep. Ir. (eum), cf. v.55: antiquus error pro
Holl
54 scripsi ex Ep. Ir.:
55 2 ex Ep. Ir. add. Go et (
)[] () scripsi ex Ep. ( ) et Ir. (in semet
rapiens ipsum):
56
scripsi: : ex duobus lambdis
Ir.
56-57 om. Ep. Ir., del. Mi
57 om. Ep. Ir.
scripsi
ex Ep. Ir.:
58 Mi:
60 Cr ex Ir. (eos):
Ep.
() et v.62 () ex Ep. Ir. restituere Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

276

Hippolytus

' ,
, ) ()

[] - , , ,
, , , , ,
. ()
() , ,
, ,
.
, (). () ()
' .
(), , [],
, () (),
,
,
",
, , ()

61 ab usque ad VI. 542 = Ir. I. 17.1-2 = Epiph. 34.


14.1-12
61 s. cf. VI. 33.1; 34.8; Ir. I. 5.1 et 3-4
61 - v. 62 supplevi ex . Ir.

62 addidi

c. 53: 1 delevi (om. Ep. Ir.)


scripsi ex Ep. Ir.:
2 Ir:
Ep. (ft. cf. v. 1 , i. e. )
2 Mi ex Ep. Ir.:

3 : omisso . 3 .
Ir.
, . Ir.
4 .: Mi ex Ir.
(ex qua)
add. Go: om. Ep. Ir.
scripsi ex Ep. Ir.:iP
5 addidi
ex Ep. Ir. (quidem)
: Ep. Ir.
7 2 : om. Ep. Ir.
scripsi:
8/9 addidi ex Ep. Ir.
9 ex Ep. Ir. add. Mi I
ex Ep. Ir. add. Go
10 , transposui conl. . Ir. I
We ex Ep.:
11 Go: : ., quasi
per quandam umbram pinxisse Ir.
12 , ex Ep. Ir. corr. Go

Cr ex Ep. cod. V et Ir. (inquiunt): et Ep. cod.


Go ex . ()
et Ir. (oneri):
13 ()0 scripsi ex Ir. (quod superpositum est
caelum): : f f .
14 Cr ex . Ir.: I
: . (ita ut Ir)
ante add. Ep.: om. Ir.
17 addidi
ex Ep. Ir.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

Refutatio VI.52.11-54.1

277

() ,
() . / ,
20 () , ( ) . 6
, (),
,
- ()
25 - 7
() .
, '

( []
30 , () .

f. 85

, () 1 54
, [] ,
() , []
5 , [] (), .

18 Go: : .: circumeuntem Ir.


19 (i.e. ) addidi ex . Ir.
Go ex Ep. Ir. (significare):

20 Cr: : circumeuntem Ir.:
.
We: . (suum Ir)
21
supplevi ex . Ir.
, manifestare Ir.. .
22 scripsi ex . (non apparentis Ir): (i.e. corruptum ex ?)
23 post om. , ,
hab. Ir. . (34. 14.8)
24
ex . Ir. add. suad. Mi
25 2 Mi Holl: 1 .
We ex . Ir.:

26 ex . add. Go
Go ex . Ir. (custoditam):
, Mi
Mi ex . Ir.:
27 Mi ex . Ir.
(divisam):
28 Mi ex . Ir. (secundum demissionem):
'
29 1 : . (similes Ir.): 2 : (')
Go: Cr
del. Dindorf (om. . Ir.)
30 Go
ex Ir. (virtuti): .
ex . Ir. add. Go
om. Ep. Ir.
post addunt Ep. Ir.
c. 54: 1 ex . Ir. add. Cr
3 Go ex Ep. Ir. (perseverabile): I
2 delevi (om. Ep.)
4 om. Ep. Ir.
delevi (om. Ep. Ir.)
5
delevi (om. Ep. Ir.)
5/6 () scripsi ex Ep. Ir. (deposuisse):
6 Go ex Ep. Ir.:
scripsi (cf. v. 2):
: Go et Cr ex Ep. Ir. (interminatum)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

278

Hippolytus

2 , , , , ,
.
55 1

f. 85


, ()
, ()
2 ()() .
, 5
, ()
(, ) , [] . / ' ( )
( ,)
( ) ()()
[] .
3 ' ,
,
, is
.

1-16 ed. Bunsen, .359-361


1-4 cf. Iren. I. 18.1 = Epiph. 34. 15.1
, ' ,
, () (aliquid novi fr.)
' .
4-9 cf. Ir. I. 18.1-20.2 Epiph. 34. 15.1-18.7 I
14 : cf. IV. 13.1; VI. 5; Ir. I. 14.1; Epiph. 34.1 (anacephal.)
7 : Ep.: om. Ir.

c. 55: 2 () scripsi ex Ir. I. 18.1: : Bunsen


3
() scripsi ex Ep. Ir. (maxima mendacia): :
Bunsen: s. coniec. Go
6 -
7 () Mi:

8/9 2 , - 1
9 del. Mi
addidi et
add. Cr
10 addidi: add. Bunsen:
add. Go, agn. We: add. Cr
11 add. Cr: add. suad. We
12 -
del. Go
: (servato )

Bunsen

15

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:35 PM

is


, .
, () ().
()
.
, ()
, ' ().
,
.
" (), '
, () .
,
.
, () , ( ' ).
,
() .
, , [] .
" (), ( ) ,
,
.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

1 litt. rubr.
2
4 scripsi:
5

coniec. Mi et scr. Go:
6 scripsi:
Mi:

8 Mi:
12
addidi (cf. Prooem.8)
13 addidi

14 , corr. Mi
scripsi (cf. VII. 3 2 2 ; 34.1):
16
addidi
1 , - 2
17 suppl. Mi et addidi
(cf. VII. 35.1): suppl. Cr
18 Go:
20-21 [] scripsi conl. Ir. I. 272 impudorate blasphemans eum qui a lege
et prophetis annunciatus est deus; : :
Go
del. Cr
21 :
Mi cett.
22 : Mi

addidi (cf.
. 20.1): post add. . Klostermann, agn. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

280

Hippolytus

13 1

f. 86

[]
() , .
/ , (') , ()
() () ()() () - 5
, '
()() 0() 2 .
,
. () '
,
, () 3 . (),
() ' ,
() () - is
, () () ,
, , (), () .

14 1

() (), () ()

c. 13: 8 s. cf. Odyss. 12.44 et 183


10 s. Odyss. 12.47-49 et 173-177
11-13 Odyss.
12.49-52; 160-162; 178 s.; cf. P. Courcelle in Monographien zur Gesch. des Mittelalters, v. 11
(Festschrift L. Waach), ed. C. Bosl (Stutgardiae 1975), pp. 33-48
1 , seclusi (cf. .2): Mi cett.
2 addidi (cf. v. 1)
4 ' add. suad. We
2 addidi
5 ()() scripsi ex coniectura (cf.
Odyss. 23.326-328; Apollon. Arg. 4.922-924): . . . . , ut v.
4 addidi: ()
Mi
6 , transposui
7 Wordsworth et Go:
: coniec. Mi: Cr: Roeper
Go:
: Roeper
9 scripsi:
Go:
10 addidi
12 addidi
13 () coniec. Mi, agn. Go (cf.
Plat. Phaedr. 260 d 6): : Cr, agn. We
15 scripsi:

addidi: add. Cr
scripsi:
16
et addidi
17/18 scripsi: : Mi
18 , corr. Go
coniec. We (conl. Odyss. 12.51.; 162; 179):
c. 14: 1 , corr. Mi

2 addidi

1-2 () () scripsi:
Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.13.1-162

281

, , ' (' ) , ,
()
() .
1 15
, [], .
, ()
' . , 2
, / '
f. 86
().
() . ()(), , ' .
, 1 16
, , , [ ,]
, ' . ()
, 2
() () (),
(). , '

3 s. I. 20
c. 15: 2 : . q. Individuum, cf. Aristot. Cat. 2, p. 1 b 6; 5, p. 3 a 35 ss.;
b 12
4 - 6 cf. ap. VII. 22.16; 23.3; 24.5; 25.6;
27.5; . 14.5-6; Anaxagorae Fr. 1 ; I. 2.14
; ap. Aristot. Phys. 4, .203 a 21; De caeh 4, p.303 a 16;
De an. A 2, p. 404 a 4; Gu. Spoerri, Spthelknistische Berichte ber Weh, Kultur u. Gtter
(Basileae 1959) et al.
c. 14: 4 ' addidi (cf. VI. 21.2; IX. 8.2)
6 Go:

coniec. We (cf. VI. 2 1 2 ; IX. 8 2 ) : : Cr


del. suad. We
7 addidi ex coniectura: add. suad. Cr
c. 15: 2 delevi
3 post v.2 , hue transtuli
addidi
4
4 et 5
5 del. Diels
6 coniec.
Roeper:
7 () v (cf. VII. 18.3): <> Go
8 ,
corr. Go
c. 16: 2 seclusi
3
addidi
4 Mi: :
Go
5

add. suad. Mi (cf. w . 7 , 8, 10;
VII. 17 w . 4 et 7)
6 scripsi (cf. v. 10):
addidi
, transposui (cf. v. 7)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

282

Hippolytus

, , '
, ( )

, .

17 1

Ei , ()
' . ()
, ( ) ,
, .
() , , 5
.

18 1

f. 87

(') (), , () ,
, , , ,
, []
,
( ) () 5
, () ,
2 . ,
, , ,
() , / -
.

c. 17: 4 - 6 VII. 21.4; . 14.1


c. 16: 7 hic et v. 8 : Mi cett.
9 scripsi (cf. v. 1):

8 addidi

c. 17: 1 addidi
2
, transposui I
addidi (cf. VII. 16 . 7): add. Go
3 addidi
( ) We
3 - 4 ter in , corr. Go
4 , corr. Go
5 addidi

. Klostermann: : del. Cr
5 - 6 , ,
scripsi conl. VII. 22.16:
( 2 : 1 )
6 scripsi: Go:
We: del. Cr
c. 18: 1 ' add. Go
ubique
add. Go (cf. v. 35)

addidi
2 , transposui
3 1 del. Mi
4
Go
5 addidi (cf. v. 16 et VII. 16.1)
() scripsi:
: Cr
7 addidi
10 add. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.162-18.5

283

() ()
() ()() ()(), () '
' () . ' () 3
[ ] - () -, ()
- , , (,)
- .
, , [] ,
. ' ' , ,
() . () - 4
, ()
, , ,
() . ' , () , , , ()
.
, , , 5
. (' )
. (), ' , [,] , , , , (,)
. - ' [] () , .

12-14 Aristot. Cat. 5, p. 2 a 11


, ' '
14 ss. cf. Aristot. Cat. 2, p . l a 20 ss.; 5, p.2 a 14-27
23 s. cf. Aristot. Top. 5,
p. 135 a 18 ; De anirn. gen. 4, p. 738 b 19; De vita et
morte 3, p. 469 a 19 et al.
26 s. Aristot. Cat. 2, p. 1 a 24 s.
28-30 cf. Cat. 8, pp. 8 b 25
12 addidi ex Aristot.
Go ex Ar.: , .36

- , transposui conl. Ar. et v.36


Go ex Ar.:
()() , .36
13 ex Ar. et v. 36 add. Cr
() habent Ar.: om. Mi cett.
14
addidi ex Ar.
add.
Go
15 , delevi (cf. v. 16)
Roeper:
2 addidi
16 addidi
17 ... Go: ...
18 2 delevi
19 , corr. We
1 Mi:
20
Go:
21 Mi:
22 coniec. Mi et Roeper:

Roeper:
23 addidi
' scripsi:
24 : coniec. Mi, agn. Cr: coniec. We
addidi

, transposui
addidi
26
27 ' addidi
(cf. v. 19): add. Roeper
28 , transposui (cf. VI. 242)
29 seclusi (cf. Ar. Cat. 8, p. 10 b 14)
supplevi
30 scripsi:

del. Mi
30/31 () coniec. Mi, agn. Go We: ()
coniec. Mi, agn. Cr:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

284
6

19

pf. 87

Hippolytus

, ' ,
( ) , ,
() ' , ,
( ) , , 35
. ( )
, ( ) ,
().

( ) .
[] , , ,
( ) , ( ) ,
,
2 ' / , ' 5
()( ) ()
( ) ', (), , , -
( )
3 ( ) . ' (
), , () , ' , []
.
( )
4 . ,

is

c. 19: 6-8 cf. I. 4.3; 20.6; V. 13.1; VII. 24.3; Aet.II. 4.12; Epiphan. ap. Diels., Doxogr.
p.592.10-14; Ps. Aristot. De mundo 2, p.392 a 31-34
10-13 cf. e.g. Aet.I. 7.32;
Ps. Ar. De mundo 2, p.392 a 5-9; 3, p.392 b 35 - 393 a 5 et al.
33 add. Go
33-34 () scripsi:
35 add. Go
scripsi: : Go cett.: Mi
36 ex Ar. add. suad.
G. Pasquali
Go ex Ar.: , . 12
Go ex
Ar.: , . 12
37 addidi: add. Roeper

2 , 1
38 addidi (cf. VII. 19.1)
c. 19: 1 addidi
2 del. Mi
3 () Roeper
() Go:

() Cr
3 ( ) scripsi:
5 2
6 ()() Mi: () We
7 addidi
9 addidi
post . 10 , hue transtuli
1
in margine: 1 in textu
10 addidi
Mi: I

10-11 addidi
11 del. suad. We
addidi
12 , delevi
14 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.18.6-19.8

20

25

30

35

285


,
() , () () ,
. ()
, , () ' .
( ) ()
, ()
, () . ,
, - ' (
), ( ) , ,
, [
], () , .
, ,
( ), [] ' , ,
, / .
() ' , ,

,
() , '
.

7
pf.88r
8

19 s. cf. . Philopon. In Nicom. Isag. 1.1; Alexandri In Metaph. p.592.10 Hayduck; Aristot.
Vitae Marcianae c. 39 et I. Duering ad loc. (Aristotle in the Ancient Biogr. Tradition, Gothoburgi
1957, p. 105) et al.
25 s. Aristot. De anima 1, p.412 a 19-21; 27 s.
31 s. Aristot. Metaph. A 9, p. 1074 b 34
16 Go: , def. Cr
18 addidi
19 et addidi
20 2 addidi
21 scripsi (cf. w . 15, 19 bis, 22, 29, 36 bis):

addidi: add. Roeper



Roeper: ()
22/23
24 2 , 1
addidi (cf. v. 30)
25
add. Klostermann
26 , corr. Mi

27 addidi (cf. v. 25) I
Mi:
ex . 28-29 hue transtulit Roeper
28-29
cf. .27
29 addidi
30 scripsi:
31 addidi
(cf. .24)
seclusi (cf. v.31-32)

32 scripsi:
33 add. suad. We

34 Cr: , Mi
36
, transposui
37 () scripsi: : Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

286
9

Hippolytus

()

,
( ) .

,
, ,
' ,
() ,
.
2
, , () ' ,
()
. , , , , '
3 [, ], . ,
, , ( ) - , ,
, ' , ,
.

41 s. cf. Prooem. 11

43 Gal 5:2

c. 20: 1 - VII. 27.13 ed. Bunsen, pp. 57-75. Cf. Foerster, I, pp. 86-99. De Basilide eiusque
discipulis cf. Iren. I. 24; Epiphan. Pan. 24; Philastr. 32; Gu. Foerster in NT Studies 9
(1962-1963), pp.233-255 et al.
2 : cf. Clem. Strom. 7. 108.1 et H.-C. Puech
ap. E. Hennecke-Gu. Schneemelcher, I, p.226 s.
7 cf. Ps.Clem. Horn. 6. 3.1
; Plat. Protag. 320 c 8 .
13 s. Eph 1:21; Clem. Eel. proph. 57.4; cf. N H II. 1, p.3.15-17; VII. 22.13; 25.5
39 add. Mi
addidi

41 , corr. Mi
, corr. Mi

42 ( ) Cr

c. 20: 2 Mi: We
: Mi
5
scripsi:
Bunsen:
7 () scripsi
(cf. test.): : Mi cett.
8 2 addidi
9 scripsi (cf. v. 10): I
F. Jacobi (Bastlidis philosophi gnostici sententiae, Berolini 1852, p. 4):
10 seclusi (cf. v. 9)
scripsi:
11 , transposui
add. Bernays (ap. Bunsen.) et 2 addidi (cf. v. 13)
12 scripsi: I
1 scripsi:
2 scripsi:
2 : ' Bernays Go
13

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.19.9-212

287

is

, , - - 4
-, ' / ( ) , ,
() , () ,
() (), , (,) ()
20 .
() () 5
() ' .
(),

25 ,
() .

f. ssv

() , (, ,) , , , 1 21
, , , , ,
, , '
, ' 5 () , () -
, - ,
, (), , ,
. , , () 2

24 cf. Arist. Cat. 1, p. 1 a 1 ss.


c. 21: 5 : cf. cod. Gnost. Berol. 85022, p . 2 4 2 0 - 2 2 ; N H II. 1, p.3.27
15 Go:
16
( ) supplevi: : (
) coniec. Roeper
17 addidi (cf. v. 20)
() scripsi:
: Bernays
18 Bemays: () , ut v.: Mi
Mi
et Bernays: ()
19
addidi
,
corr. Mi
addidi
21 addidi
addidi
22 scripsi:


23 Go:
24
25 2
: Bunsen
: Mi
, corr. Bunsen
scripsi: : del. Bunsen
26 Go: :
- coniec. We
c. 21: 1 add. Go
addidi et add. Jacobi et Bernays
2
Mi:
, Jacobi: ,
: ( ), , ( ), G. Uhlhorn (Das Basiiidianische System etc., Gottingae 1855, p.7)
4/5 () Go:
: Roeper et Uhlhorn
5 add. Roeper
6 (cf. v. 19):
coniec. Mi
7 () scripsi:
8 2 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

288

pf. 89

Hippolytus

,
3 , , ()
, , , , []
() () ,
() [].
is
4
( ) () () /
, ( ) ,
5 () ()() ().
() , 2
, []
,
, ,
( ) , .
22 1

, (,) ,
,
, [] , ()
11-24 cf. . 14.1-2
11 s. Mt. 13:31 s.; Mc.4:30-32; Lc. 13:18-19; V. 9.6;
VI. 40.2; . Thomae log.20; NH 1.2, p.8.7; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 1.3 et al.
20
: cf. Ps. Clem. Horn. 6. 5.3
c. 22: 1 cf. V. 19.1; VI. 9.7; VIII. 12.5
9-10 scripsi:

12 Go:

ex . 15 hue transtuli
13 del. Go: () Diels,
agn. We
14 addidi (cf. X. 14.1 et )

Go:
() Go: ( ) Mi We
15 addidi I
transtuli in v. 12: coniec. Mi: Bernays
16
addidi et add. Roeper
() Jacobi et Go ex :
17 v addidi
ex (cf. v.23)
, corr. Go
, corr. Bunsen
19/20 () Bernays: : Go
21 delevi
(cf. .23): Mi: Go
24 addidi
add. Uhlhorn
(cf. . 18)
c. 22: 1 addidi
scripsi:
2 del. Bernays
post
, transposui
3 coniec. Mi, agn. Bernays: Go I
coniec. Mi, agn. Bernays (cf. VII. 27.4): : Go

Bernays: : coniec. Mi, agn. Go


del. We
4 () Bernays:
Bemays:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.21.2-22.5

289

5 , [] ( )
,

,
.

()
, ( )
() .
, (,) ,
() , , 15 () ; , , . , ()
, .
, , , ; . , ,
, ' ( ) .
20 , , , .
( ), , / ( )
, , , ,
() () ,
. ( ) 25 . - (')
, () ,
, ,
, , , (') . -

f. 89

16 Ps 32:9; 148:5; Clem. Strom. 5. 99.3; 6.136.3; Protr. 63.3; Paed. 1. 26.3; Iren. 2. 2.5;
3. 8.3 et al.
17 s. Gn 1:3; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 48.1; Ecl. proph. 38.1 et al.
23 s. Jo 1:9; V. 9.20; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 41.3; Iren. 1. 9.2; 10.2 et al.
5 del. Go: Bemays
supplevi ex
w . 32-33 et . 14.2
7 Bernays: : Go I
post , transposui
Bernays:
8 , corr. Mi
post v. 9 , transposui
10 addidi (cf. v. 21)
11
addidi
12 addidi
13
addidi
2 : coniec. We
Bernays
Bernays:

14 1 addidi
15 addidi
16 Go: : del. Bunsen
19 addidi
20 Roeper et Cr:
21
addidi
scripsi:
addidi
22 Mi:
24 supplevi conl. VII. 26.5 et 7-8; . 14.9
25 ' addidi
26 () scripsi: 2, 1
28 ' addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

290
6

9
10
pf. 9

11

Hippolytus

' ( )
, , , ,

(), [] () () . ()
() . (), ,
, ()
, () , ()
, (, ) .
, () , &
,
,
, , ' , .
, ,
() , ' ()() , . () / ,
() ()
, ,
. (
), ' ()

35

45

so

31-33 et 34-51 . 14.2-4


40 : cf. V. 9.1; VII. 23.3
42 Odyss.
7.36
43 s. cf. V. 7.10-11; 9.4
45 : sc. (cf. w . 3 5
et 37)
49 cf. Flat.Phaedr. 246 c 1; d 4 et 6; e 2; 248 b 3; c 1; 249 a 1 et 4; c4; d 6; 356 d 4
29 addidi
29-30 secl. Cr
31 scripsi
ex :
32 () Go ex :
del. Cr, om.
34 Go: : del. Bunsen
addidi ex
35 Uhlhorn et Bernays:

35-36 , ex corr. Mi et Bernays
36 We
ex :
2 om.
37 , ex suppl. Uhlhorn et
Bemays
40 ex add. Uhlhorn
41 , corr. Go
42 , corr. Mi
46 addidi
46/47
47
, corr. Uhlhorn
scripsi:
47/48 () scripsi ex :
48 Jacobi:
49 () Go:
: Mi
, transposui
() (ft. lapsus
Hippolyti): Bunsen et Go
51
51-52
supplevi (cf. v. 54 s.)
52 ' , corr. Mi
2 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

291

Refutatio VII.22.6-15

55

60

65

70

75

,
'
,
.
, , , ( ) , '
[] .
( ) ,
()
.
( ) []
, () . ,
,
, ,
() () , () , '
, ( ) . /
, (,)
()() ()

64 cf. Eph 1:21; VI. 20.3

69-74 cf. V. 19.3

12

13

14

15

f. 90

75 s. Ps 132:2

54 ( ) ' coniec. We
55 scripsi:
57
scripsi:
1 Jacobi et Go:
59 Jacobi:
59-60 supplevi conl. VII. 21.4; . 14.1
60 ' scripsi:

61
Jacobi:
delevi
(cf. v. 60 ): Bunsen
63 Jacobi:
64
scripsi conl. NT:
64-65
: () Mi et scripsi
66
addidi (cf. v. 58) et add. Bernays
Bernays:
67 2 del. Mi
68 addidi
69 , transposui
72 () Mi: : () Bunsen et Go
addidi
73 addidi

74 scripsi:
2 add. Diels et
suppl. Uhlhorn
75 addidi
75-76 ,
LXX
76 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

292

Hippolytus

' , , ()
16 , , ( ) . ,
, , ,
() , (, )
. , , ,
( ) , ( ) , , .
85
23

f. 9


,
2 -
,
' , - 5
( )
[],
3 - , () () , , () ,
, ()
, ,
.
4
() & /
[] [], is

78 s. Dt 32:11

82-84 . 14.5

c. 23: 2 : cf. Gn 1:8

85 : VII. 25.1 ss.

3-33 cf. . 14.5-7

78 addidi e LXX
79 scripsi:
81 :
Bunsen: coniec. We
add. Mi
del. Mi
,
addidi
83 ( ) Gu. Moeller ex : () Roeper

addidi ex
84 scripsi:
c. 23: 2 - 3 , corr. Go
4 coniec. Mi, agn. Go: We
6 supplevi ex v. 3 et . 14.5

7 delevi
8 () scripsi: : Bemays
addidi
9 ,
corr. Mi
11 scripsi:
scripsi:
() Bernays:
:
12 , corr. Mi
13
scripsi: : coniec. We
14
addidi
15 delevi (cf. v. 17)
del. Mi: ,
Bernays
scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.22.15-24.2

293

to
[ ] . ( ) - - , , , , () () ,

. 5
,
' ,
,
, . - - 6
, (). ,
() () . &
() () ' () 7
, ,
, , , () -
, .
- (') ' 1
(), ,
[ ],
(, )
' , 2

22 : ft. cf. Is 4 5 : 5 et 6; VI. 33 (v. 10)


: cf. 1 Cor 3 :10;
Is. 3 : 3 ; Tert. Adv. Marc. 5. 6.10; Clem. Strom. 5. 26.3
c. 24: 1 s. et 7-9 cf. Aristot. De anima 1, p.412 a 19-21; 27 s.; VII. 19.6
16 : Mi cett.
17 , delevi: () Mi cett.
del. Mi I
addidi
19 () coniec. We:
() scripsi (cf. v. 13):
: coniec. We
scripsi:
20
21 Mi ex :
, corr. Go
25 , corr. Mi
scripsi:
26 coniec. We:
28 () scripsi: : Bunsen cett.
addidi
29
addidi ex
addidi ex
Go ( ): : Mi
32 1 addidi: add. suad. We
c. 24: 1 'addidi

3 () Cr
3/4
1 delevi: Go We
5 , addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

294

pf. 9

25 1

Hippolytus

(),
( ) ,
. / ,
. 3
[ ]
- ()
. - , (,)
, []
, .
4 ' ,
. ( )
, [ ] , 5 () . ' , , .
, ()
( ).

, () () ()
.

is

25

' ,
, ,
() ( ) .

12 s. cf. I. 4.3; 20.6; V. 13.1; VII. 19.2; Aet. II. 4.12 et al.

13-21 cf. . 14.8-9

7 , corr. Mi
8 ( ) scripsi: : del. Bunsen
11
delevi (cf. v. 12): coniec. Mi, agn. Bunsen et Cr:
Go, agn. We
12 addidi
13 , corr. Go

14 addidi (cf. v. 22)
15 Bernays ex :
17
: Bunsen (conl. VII. 25.4)
18 supplevi ex
20 del. Cr: coniec. Mi
21 addidi (cf. v. 16)

scripsi:

23 () Uhlhorn: : Bunsen
: Roeper
24 Cr: : Bunsen:
Roeper
Bunsen:
, corr. Bunsen
supplevi ex
26 add. Jacobi
addidi
I
addidi
c. 25: 2 Mi:

3 addidi ex : add. Cr

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.24.2-25.5

295

() 5 () () ()
() , ,
- ( ),
(). (
), , , (
) /
.
(
), , () ,
() , ()
is (). , (,)
, , , ,
.
, , ,
.
20 ( ,) ,
. , ,

, -
-,
25 . , ,
.

2
f. 92

7 s. Rm 8 : 2 1 - 2 2 et 19; cf. . 2 8 s.; VI. 35.2; VII. 27.1


8-11 cf. . 14.10
12 s. Rm 5 . 14 et 13; Clem. Strom. 3. 64.2; 4. 9.6
14 s. cf. Is. 45 :5 et 6; 46 :9; Dt
4 : 3 5 ; 3 2 : 3 9 ; VI. 33; 36.2; Iren. I. 5.4; 29.4; 30.6; Epiph. Pan. 25. 2.3; N H II. 1, pp. 11.20;
13.8; II.4, pp.86.30; 94.22
16 s. Eph 3 : 4 - 5 ; V. 8.5; VI. 35.1; VII. 26.7; Clem.
Strom. 5. 87.1
22 s. Ex 6:3; VI. 36.2
25 s. cf. VI. 35.1; Mt 11:13
4 () Go (cf. v.27): : Bunsen
4/5
5
addidi
<)<> scripsi conl. VII. 22.8; . 14.3:
6 2 add. Cr
7
supplevi ex (VII. 27.1) et N T ()
8 () scripsi ex . 2 8 et NT:
8 - 9 addidi
ex w . 8 et 27
9 - 1 0 addidi ex : add. Cr
11 Bunsen:
: Go
12-13 addidi ex N T (cf. v. 29)
13 addidi
14 addidi
2 addidi
15 () scripsi:
addidi
20 supplevi (cf. . 14.8)
21 (sc. ) Bunsen:
23 : LXX

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

296

Hippolytus

, , , ,
, , ,
, ,
( ) () 3
6 . , ()
, '
. ,
; , , ,
, , (,) 35
7 .
() - () -
()
,
() 4
() ()
.
26
pf. 92

[] , ,
() ()
, / () ,
' ()
() 5
2 , , ,

28 s. Rm 8:22 et 19; cf. v. 7 s.

30 s. Eph 1:21; cf. VII. 20.3; 22.13

30 2 addidi ex NT (cf. w . 35, 40 et VII. 26.6) et 3 add. Mi


4
ex NT add. Bunsen
31 (cf. LSJ, s.v., IV, et v.34 ): Uhlhorn I
coniec. Mi, agn. Cr, Foerster (o.e., p.240 n.3)
35
addidi
35-36 , transp. Jacobi
37 , corr. Mi
() scripsi:
: Mi: ('captator') Go

38 addidi
40 addidi

41 addidi (cf. v. 38)

addidi (cf. w . 3 2 et 39)


c. 26: 1 transtuli in v. 2
2 addidi (cf. w . 18, 22, 32)
del.
Jacobi et Bunsen
ex v. 1 hue transtuli
3 addidi
4 ' I
() Roeper: : Uhlhorn:
() Go, agn. We
5 , corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Rtfutatio VTI.25.5-26.6

is

20

25

297

,
( ), ()
() , ,
, () () . , ,
, ,
' (), , ,
() ,
, . , ,
-
.
,
, ,
' .
() ()
, , ,
,
,
.

- () []
() ' /,

6
f. 93

7 Ps 110:10; Prv 1:7 et 9:10; Clem. Strom. 2. 35.5-36.1 (= Basilidis Fr. 15) ftev
.
()
, ' ,
,
(cf. Foerster, o.e., p.243 s.); VI. 32.7;
Clem. Strom. 2. 37.5-38.2 et al.
11 1 Cor 2 : 7
12 s. 1 Cor 2:13; V. 8.26
16 s. 31:5-6; 50:5 et 51:11
8 addidi
addidi (cf. v. 2)
9 scripsi (cf. v. 2): () edd. I
addidi
10 Mi:
addidi
: coniec. Bunsen
addidi
11 () Cr
:
NT
13 addidi (cf. v. 11): NT
14 addidi (cf.
w . 18, 22, 32)
-
17 LXX
20, 23, 24, 25,
27, 41, 42 et 46 -
21 , transposui
22
add. Go
23 , corr. Mi
26 -
28 coniec.
Cr:
del. Mi
29 supplevi conl. . 14.9
()

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

298

Hippolytus

' () ,
,
', ,
7 () - - '
, , ' , ()
' ,
,
, ,
,
.
8
() ,
( ) ,
, ,
9 . , ,
, ( )

, , ()
() , ( ) (
) () ,

31-34 Iren. I. 24.3; 24.5; 24.7; Epiph. Pan. 24.7.2 et 4; Ps.Tert. Adv. haer. 1.5; Theodoret.
Huer. 1.4 s.f.; Hieron. In Amos, P.L. 25, p. 1018 CD; c. Lucifer. 23, P.L. 23, p. 187 A; Pap.
Gr. Mag. 8.48 s.; 13.156 et 466; A. Dieterich, Abraxas (Lipsiae 1891), p.46; R. Reitzenstein,
Poimandres, p.272 s.; Fr. Domseiff, Das Alphabet etc., pp.42-44 et 105; I. Michl, in Reallexikon f . Ant. u. Christ. 5 (1962), p.201 s. et al.
37 ft. cf. 1 Cor 15 :8; cf. VI. 31.2;
36.3; Iren. I. 4.1; 8.2; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 68
37 s. Eph 3 : 4 - 5 ; V. 8.5; VI. 35.1;
VII. 25.3
38 s. Eph 3 :3
39 s. 2 Cor 12:4; V. 8.25; Epiph. Pan. 38. 2.5
41-44 et 50-55 cf. X. 14.9-10
44-45 et 47 Lc 1:35; VI. 35.3 et 7; X. 23.1;
Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 60
48 (): cf. V. 21.6; VI. 10.2;
VII. 27. 8-9 et 11-12; . 14.9; Clem. Strom. 2. 36.1 et 2. 38.2
30 ' scripsi: (cf. .29)
addidi
30-31
, transposui
32
33 : Go
34
1 Go: 2 Mi: Bunsen
() scripsi:

35 2 add. Roeper
39
40 : N T
41 add. Go
42 addidi (cf. w . 2 , 22, 24)
45
supplevi
47
addidi
48 () scripsi
conl. Clem. Strom. 2. 36.1 ... et VII. 27.8, 11, 12: We:
coniec. Go, agn. Cr: coniec. Roeper
2 add. Cr et
addidi
48-49 addidi (cf. v. 1)
49 add. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.26.6-27.3

299

so 1(). ' , 10
, ()
, ()
()
, ' ,
55 ().
.
" (), , () - 1 27
/ [] ,
f. 93
, ,
,
5 () , , ,
, ()
(). 2
, () ,
() ()

, , () () ()
- () , ,
, , , , 3

2 s.Rm 8 : 2 2 et 19; VI. 35.2; VII. 25.1 et 5


4 cf. . 14.10
12 s. de adynato
oi et sim. cf. Archil. Fr. 122.6-9 West (Fr. 74.6-9 D.); Herodot. 5. 92.1;
Lucret. 3.785; VII. 22.13 (et ft. I. 24.7)
50 () scripsi: () edd.

50-51
51
post . 52 , hue transtuli
addidi
52 ( ) scripsi:


53 ( ) scripsi:
scripsi: : Usener (Das Weihnachtsfest1, p. 139)
54 ,
corr. Mi
55 addidi
c. 27: 1 ( ) scripsi (cf. v.4):
addidi
2 delevi
5
add. G o
, corr. Mi
6 ( ) Bemays et Uhlhorn (cf. w . 9, 14): :
coniec. Mi
7 (in fine versus), suppl. Mi
8 addidi
9
Bunsen et Roeper:
, corr. Mi
, corr.
Bunsen
( ) Scott et Bunsen:
10 , corr. Mi
11/12
12 ( ) & () scripsi (cf. v. 13 ):

13 add. suad. Mi
14 scripsi (cf. w . 5, 9, 10, 16, 17,
18, 19, 22, 24):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

300

pf. 94r

Hippolytus

(),
()
, '

4 .
,
, ()
(). ,
,
() ( ) () ,
5
" , , / ,
() , ( )
( ) . , , (
) [] ()
6 .
' () , ()
. ( ) , ( ) , () , ()
() () ,
() -, .

is

25

18 Is 3 5 : 1 0 ; 5 1 : 1 1
24 : cf. VII. 22.1; 1 Tm 2 : 6 ; 6 : 1 5 ; Tt 1 : 3
26 J o 2 : 4 ; cf. Iren. 3. 16.7
27 cf. Mt 2 : 1 - 2
30 Eph 3 :16; Rm 7 : 2 2 ; 2 Cor
4 : 1 6 ; V. 7.36; VI. 34.5; 40.2; X. 13.3; 19.3; Iren. I. 5.5; 21.4; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 51.1
et al.
15 scripsi:
: (servato ) coniec. We

addidi (cf. v. 34)


16 () Mi:

() Cr
(servato v. 16 )
21 : Bunsen cett.
addidi (cf. v. 34) I
coniec. Mi:
22 () scripsi (cf. Menandri Fr. 276.16 Sandbach): : Mi cett.: coniec. We
24 (} Roeper:
supplevi conl. w . 34, 63 s. I
, corr. Mi
25 : Mi We: () Bunsen
26 add. suad. G o
2 addidi
27 et addidi ex N T
27-28 ( ) supplevi et scripsi: : Bunsen: Jacobi
28 seclusi ut dittogr. (cf.
v.27): (') Bunsen, (') Jacobi
addidi
Usener:

30 () scripsi:
2 addidi
31
addidi conl. v. 59
32 ( ) scripsi:
2 addidi
()
Jacobi: , ut v.: Mi: Go: C r
33 addidi
( ) scripsi: : Foerster
. . , transposui I
, corr. Mi
34 addidi
(sc. ) scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.27.3-10

35

45

so

55

301

' ' () , . ' , () , .


[]
, , , , ,
, (,) , () '
' .
'
, '
. ,
,
. -
, [ ]
( ) -, -
( , )
-, ' ,
, / ()
,
() ,
.
, ',
,
. () ( ) ,

f. 94
10

37 (): VII. 26.1


40 ... : cf. Mt 5 : 1 2 ;
Lc 1:14; Ape 19:7
40 s. - : fortasse Basilides
42 : VII. 26.8-9
45 : cf. VII.
26.9; Clem. Strom. 2. 36.1; 38.2
35 , corr. Go
37 () scripsi (cf. w . 4 2 , 43):

38 delevi (cf. v. 40)
40 addidi (cf. 45)
2 addidi I

43 scripsi:
44 scripsi:
45 , corr. Scott et Bernays

47-48
del. ut dittogr. et add. suad. Go
48, 49, 55 (bis) -
49 , supplevi conl. VII. 19.2 et 24.3
51 , corr. Mi
53 ( ) scripsi (cf. v. 54):
54 :
coniec. Jacobi
55 scripsi:
57 () scripsi:

, transposui
57-58 supplevi conl.
VII. 23.1-3

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

302

Hippolytus

11 . ' , ( ) , 6
, .
" () ()
()
12 (*). () ,
(' ) 65
, )
,
, () ,
13 . , ()
() () () ' 70
, .
28 1

f. 95

, ,
' ,
, ,
2 , , , - /
. 5

62 : cf. Clem. Strom. 2. 112.1 (= Basilidis Fr.6)

70 cf. Epiph. Pan. 23. 1.2; 24.1 ...


...
c. 28: 3-31 ex Iren. I. 24.1-2 exscripsit . De Saturnilo cf. et. Epiph. Pan. 23. 1.1-2.6;
Philastr. 31; Theodoret. Huer. 1.3; Tert. De an. 23.1; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 1, p.214.5-16
Kroymann
4 s. ... : cf. Iren. I. 30.3 s.f.; Orig. c. Cek. 6.27 et
30-31; Theodoret. I. 14 (p.365 B); Epiph. 26. 10.1-3; Gnost. Berol. 8502.2, pp.39.11;
48.7; II. 1, p. 11.23; I. Michl in R.L.A.C. 5 (1962), p. 102 s. et al.
60 supplevi conl. . 67; VII. 26.7 et al.
62 scripsi:
addidi
scripsi:
addidi
63 addidi
conl. VII. 15.2; 22.16; 23.3; 24.5; . 14.5
scripsi:

64 post lacunam signavi: exspectes
, ' vel. sim.
(cf. w . 69-71)
addidi
65 ' addidi et add. Mi
Cr: :
del. Jacobi et Roeper
67 , corr. Mi
scripsi:

68 () Go:
69
addidi
70 () () scripsi conl. Epiph.: :
Bernays
71 scripsi (cf. v. 71 ):
c. 28: 2
coniec. We:

3 scripsi:

4 Mi (qui Ir)\

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.27.10-28.6

303

, , ,
() . ,
, , ,
' ' . , 3
, ()
, ,
() ,
( ) . 4

, , , .
() ,
' . 5

() ,
.
() . 6
, ,
,
,
.

7 : cf. II. 1, . 14.28-34; II. 4, . 87.11-14; Gn 1:2; VI. 14.5-6


9 Gn 1:26 ' ' ; Epiph. 23.
1.6-7; VI. 14.5; Iren. I. 5.5; 30.6; II. 1, . 15.1 ss.; II.4, . 87.31 ss.; Clem. Exc. ex
Theod. 50 et al.
9-11 cf. V. 7.6; . II. 1, p. 19.14 s.; II. 4, p. 88.5 s.; Gnost. Berol.
8502.2, p. 50.15 ss.; Iren. I. 30.6; Tert. De an. 23.1 opus futtile et invalidum et instabile in
terra vermis instar palpitasse, quod consistendi vires deessent
13 cf. Gn 2 : 7 ; V.
26.8; VI. 34.5; II. 1, -p. 19.23 ss.; II.4, p.88.3 ss.; Gnost. Berol. 8502.2, p.51.15 ss.;
Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 50.2-3 et al.
17 : cf. X. 19.3; Fr. in Mt., p. 209 Achelis;
Clem. Strom. 6. 71.2; Orig. c. Cels. 2.16; Acta Ioannis 93; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 6, p.222.21-25
Kr.; Theodoret. Haer.l.lA (p.376 A) et al.
7 <) Go ex Epiph. 23.1.4:

8 Roeper (sursum Ir.):

10 ex Ir. . add. Mi
12 () Mi:
13 supplevi conl. v. 10 , . 23.1.8 et Tert. erexerit:
articulavit (i.e. ) Ir., correxit (i.e. ) Philaster
16
17
18 Harvey et Go:
19 addidi ex Ir. (eius omnes
principes)
21 ex Ir. (esse autem hos qui habent) et . 23.2.2 cod. V add. Go: om.
et . cod.
scrips!: : scintillam vitae eius (i.e. Patris) Ir.,
.
post add. ' Ir. (post v. 22
.)
22 ... , corr. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

304
7

f. 95

Hippolytus

To () ,
' ,
( ),
, -
, / , 3
() . () .

29 1

, () ,
() ,
, ()
. ,
2 () , , 5
'
, ,
3 , .
, ,

.

c. 29: 2 : cf. Iren. I. 27.2 non evangelium, sed particulam evangelii tradens eis (sc.
Marcion discipulis suis); Tert. Adv. Marc. 1.19 separatio legis et evangelii proprium et
principale opus est Marcionis; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 6, p.222.26 ss. Kr.: solum evangelium
Lucae nec tarnen totum recipit; apostoli Pauli neque omnes neque totas epistolas sumit;
acta apostolorum et apocalypsim quasi falsa reicit; A. ab Harnack, Marcion etc. (T. U. 45,
1921), pp.69 n. 1; 82-84
3 : cf. Iren. I. 27.1; VII. 30.2-3; 37.1; X. 19.1;
Tert. Adv. Marc. 1.2; Ps.Tert. Adv. haer.6.1- Epiph. Pan. 41. 1.6; 42. 3.1-2; Philastr. 44.1;
Theodoret. Haer. 1.24; Hamack., pp.28*-36*
9 : 1.3
26
27 Mi (autem Ir):
28
centes multos) add. suad. Go: . . .
23.2.5
30 2 (cf. .29), Ir. .: 1 Mi
30-31 () , ex Ir. . corr. Harvey et Go
31

ex Ir. (sedu .

addidi

c. 29: 1 addidi
2 addidi (cf. test.)
3 add. suad. Mi (cf. VII.
30.3; 38.1; Ps.Tert. Adv. haer. 6.1 hie (sc. Cerdon) introducit initia duo, id est duos deos,
unum bonum et alterum saevum; Philastr. 44.1 duo esse principia, id est unum deum
bonum et unum malum)
5 1, 2
(cf. VIII.
18.1): coniec. Mi, agn. Cr: coniec. Go
scripsi: : Mi
7 Cr:
Go:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.28.7-29.7

305

() , 4
, , ,
,
is , ,


() '
', .
20 , (,) , ' , 5
, , '
() , -
, , () , ()
, ' , 6
25 , , / ,
. () ,
, , 7
, ,
, () , ,
3 () , , ,
.

f. 96

12-144 de Empedoclis ap. fragmentis cf. I. P. Hershbell in Phronesis 18 (1973), pp. 97-114
et 187-203
13 : cf. Aristot. Degen, et con. A 1, p.314 a 16; Simpl. In Phys., p.25.21
ss. Diels; Sext. Adv. math. 10.317 = X. 7.4-5
17-19 Emped. Fr.6 - X. 7.3-4
20-22 cf. DK 31 A 33; Diog. Laert. 8.76; H. Diels, Poet, philos.frr., p. 108; Gu. K.C. Guthrie,
A History of Greek Philosophy, II (Cantabrigiae 1965), pp. 144-146
22 et 24 ad etyma vocum et spectant
23 : cf. Hippocrat. De alim. 55 ; Plut. Qu. conviv.
690 A; 698 D
29-31 cf. w . 13-15; X. 7.5
12 addidi
17 et. Aet. I. 3.20: Sext. Adv. math. 9.362; 10.315:
Prob, ad Verg. Ecl. p. 11.4 Keil
18 supplevi ex Ps.Plut. Plac. 878 et
aliis (cf. DK 31 A 33; Doxogr. p.287); cf v.20: (1. <>): ex Emped.
add. Mi
' Mi ex Emped.:
19 ' . . Krische et . Stein ex Emped.:
: : We
Krische, Stein, Cr ex Emped.:
: ()
20 addidi
22
23 addidi (cf. v. 27)
del. Gu. Kranz
24 '
scripsi (cf. v. 27 ): ()
26 addidi
28
, transposui
29 addidi
30 addidi
scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

306

Hippolytus

,
()
9 ,
- 35
, ,
-,
, '

10 , () () 40
() ()

, (') (), ', ,
() .

f. 96

() ; () 45
, ,
.
( )
11 . ,
() so
, , / 12 .
,

32-40 cf. w . 4 8 - 5 5 ; 125-130; VI. 25.2-4; Diog. Laert. 8.76; Clem. Strom. 5. 15.4
35 Emped. Fr. 17.19; X. 7.5
37 ad etymon vocis spectare videtur
(i.e. )
43 s. Emped. Fr. 16; VI. 25.1
33 add. Mi

34 scripsi (cf. w . 51, 52, 53, 62, 63,
122, 123, 130):
2 scripsi:
37 Go: : Cr I
Go:
38
39 . Sauppe (ap. Go) et Cr (cf.
v. 34): , def. Diels (sc. )
40 add. Cr
addidi
41 Go (cf. v. 124):
() scripsi: : Roeper:
Go: Diels: Kranz
43 Go: : : Nauck
' addidi
(cf. ad VI. 25 v. 5): om.
, corr. Mi
44 Roeper et Go: : : Mi
Mi:

45 addidi ex
, corr. Mi
48
add. Go (cf. v. 54)
49 We:
scripsi (cf. v. 53):
52
53 scripsi (cf. Plut. De superstit. 168 ): , - Mi: Roeper

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.29.8-15

307

, , , , , (')
55 .
, - 13
,

60

() ,
, ', (),
( ) [] ().
() () 14
- , []
, .

65

() , ,

[] ,
,
(). , , 15
( , ) ()
70 () .
, (,) ,

58-60 Emped. Fr. 29 (cf. Fr. 134.2-4)


65 Emped. Fr. 115.13 (Fr. 3.12 Zuntz)
68 s. Fr. 115.14
71 : cf. w . 120, 122 et Emped. Fr. 115.1
54 (') scripsi: () coniec. Sauppe
56/57
57
bis
58 Mi: : Stein ex Emped. Fr. 134.2
, corr. Mi
59 ' Mi et Schneidewin (Philol. 6, 1851, p. 161) ex Emped.
Fr. 134.3:
Sauppe: : coniec. Mi et Schneidewin ex Emped. Fr. 134.3
60 (et. Simplic. In Phys. p. 1124.2 Diels; cf. Emped.
Fr. 134.4 ): Schneidewin
( ) scripsi (cf. w . 62 ; 66
et Emped. Frr.27.4 = 28.2 ): : () Schneidewin conl. Emped. Fr. 28.1; Parmen. Fr. 8.49
() Schneidewin (cf. Hes. Theog. 126; Parmen. Fr. 8.49 et ft. Emped. Fr. 28.1): :
' coniec. Mi, agn. Cr
61 addidi
supplevi
(cf. . 32 et Plat. Tim. 34 b 2)
62 del. Sauppe
65 scripsi ex Plut. De
exil. 607 D: edd. (coniec. Scaliger)
ex Plut. add. Schneidewin

scripsi ex Plut. (cf. Philopon. In Ar. De anima, p. 73.32 Hayduck ' ;


Asclep. In Ar. Metaph., p. 197.20 Hayduck; Plot. IV. 8. 1.19 ):
66 del. suad. We (cf. v. 64)
68 addidi
Go ex Plotino:

69 , ex Plotino suppl. Go
1 del. Go I
Mi:
70 Roeper: : Mi
71
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

308

Hippolytus

() (),

16

( ') ' (),


75

- , (),
-,
17
f. 97


- ()
() / - so
[]
() ,
() () .

()
18 '
85
.

74 s. Fr. 115.4-5 (. 4 abrogant Empedocli Fr. Knatz, Wilamowitz, Zuntz, Persephone,


pp. 194-196)
78 Fr. 115.6
80 : cf. VI. 25.2; VII. 31.3; Simpl. In
Phys., p.31.30 D.; Gu. Guthrie, o.e., II, p.260 s.; D. O'Brien, Empedocks' Cosmic Cycle
(Cantabrigiae 1969), p. 99 s.
82 s. Fr. 115.7-8
72 scripsi:
addidi
73 : coniec.
Sauppe
74 ' supplevi conl. Aristoph. Ran. 150 ' :
ft' add. Diels: add. G. Zuntz (Persephone, Oxonii 1971, p. 195 n.4)
' Diels:
: Diels
Schneidewin
(cf. Hes. Theog. 793):
82 Diels ex Plut. De exil. 607 C
(cf. v. 76): : Heeren, Schneidewin, Zuntz
:
Klostermann ex Plut. et . 76
: Plut. (
Scaliger): coniec. Mi

76
addidi
78 Mullach, Schneidewin ex Plut.: et. Orig. c. Cels. 8.53 cod.

et. Plut.
79 Go: : Cr
Mi:

81 delevi
82 : Stein, Wilamowitz, Zuntz:
Karsten, Bergk ex Orig. paraphr. (sc. )

Bergk, Schneidewin: (et. Orig. cod. , . Bouhereau ap. C. Delarue) I


Mi: : Orig. cod. , Sturz
84 addidi
Mi:
85

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.29.15-21

309

, () .
() ,
, ( )
() [] [] 19
,
' () & , '
, '
' , .
() ( ) , 20
()
. , - ( ) ,
, ' . '
'
(), '
(') , .

21


,

, ()
' ,
, ' .

91-95 Fr. 115.9-12

107 Fr. 115.14; cf. v.68 s.

88 () scripsi (cf. v. 109):


89 addidi
89-90
secl. Cr (cf. w . 87-88)
90
supplevi (cf. w . 15 s., 119, 134)
91 addidi ex Plut. De vit. aere al. 830 F et Eus.
Praep. ev. 5. 5.2: om. et Plut. De Is. 361 C
scripsi ex Plut.:

scripsi ex Plut.:
delevi (om. Plut.)
1 ( - 2 ), del. Mi
(cf. . 93)
93 ' Mi ex Plut. 361 C: (una littera exesa) : Plut. 830 F (corr.
Meziriac), Eus.
, Plut. 361 C: Plut. 830 F

' , corr. Mi
, Plut. 830 F, Eus.: Plut. 361 C
94
: Plut. 361 C, 830 F
96 addidi
scripsi: : Mi
addidi (cf. w . 8 7 , 89, 99, 104, 113)
97 addidi
98
addidi
100

101 ' 2 , 1
102 I

103 ' add. Go
107 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

310
22
pf. 97

23

Hippolytus


( ) /
() -
.
( ' )
,
,
.

us

()
,
( ) , ,
, ( )

120


, ,
, , , , , , ,
24 , . 125

, ,
,
( ) .
3
25

( ) []
, ,
, ,

110-113 cf. Emped. Frr. 140, 141 (36, 37 Zuntz); Athen. I. 3 ; Iambi. V.P. 107 s. (et
Deubner. ad loc.); Sext. Adv. math. 9.128; I. Haussleiter, Der Vegetarismus in der Antike
( R G W 24, 1935), p. 109 ss.
120 s. Fr. 115.1-2
123 : cf. Aristot. De gen.
et corr. 6, p. 333 b 20
132 : cf. v.3 s.; VII. 30.2-4; 31.3;
Aristot. Metapb. A 4, p. 985 a 6 ,

111 Klostermann
add. suad. We
114 'addidi
115 , corr. Mi

118
addidi
120 Mi ex Simpl. In Phys. p. 1184. 9 Diels: (et. Plut. De exil.
607 C, corr. Reiske)
, ex Plut. corr. Mi
121 , corr. Mi
124 We
130 supplevi ex v. 51
Go: : coniec. Mi
131 addidi
1 del. suad.
We: 2 del. Cr
133 Mi:
:

scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

311

Refutatio VII.29.22-30.1

( ) ,
135

' ()
() () ,
' ,
' ' ()
' , / .
' , '
' ,
'
() ().

26

{. 98

1 30
,
, ()
- ()
5 () -, ()
()

135-144 Empcd. Fr. 110


Sext. Adv. math. 8.286

141 cf. Emped. Fr.2.2

144 VI. 12.1; X. 12.2;

c. 30: 2 : cf. Marcionis Antitheses, Harnack., o.e., pp.68-135; 71. n.l;


254*-256*
4 : cf. P. Corssen, Monarchianiscbe Prologe zu den vier
Evangelien (T. U. 15.1, Lipsiae 1896), p. 10.10: Denique amputasse sibi post fidem pollicem
dicitur, ut sacerdotio reprobus haberetur
134 supplevi conl. w . 67, 144 et Sext. Adv. math. 8.286 '
, ,
(sequ. . 144)
135 Mi:
' Schneidewin (Philol.
6, 1851, p. 166): ( coniec. Mi)

136 : coniec. Roeper
Schneidewin: :
Mi
137 Schneidewin: Cr
coniec. Diels (conl. Odyss.
2.306)

138 ' Diels (cf. Plat. Lach. 192 e 3):
: coniec. Stein: Ritsehl et Meineke

: coniec. Mi: Gu. . Heidel


139 coniec. Mi, Schneidewin: :
Heidel
140 ' Schneidewin: '
141 Schneidewin, Stein (cf. Emped. Fr.2.2):
:
Roeper, Cr
Diels: (et. Emped. Fr.2.2)
141-142 , 'Schneidewin et Meineke:
142
143 , ut .
144 Schneidewin e Sexto: (cum signo corr. supra ) :

c. 30: 2 Go (cf. v. 10):
4 scripsi: : Mi
5 add. Mi
Mi:
6 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

312

f. 98

Hippolytus

'
() .
2 , ,
, ,
, . ()
' () ;
3 ()
'
() ; , , , is
( )
. (' )
4 ; ,
() ,
, () / - 2
. ,
, () () ()
,
.
31 1

, ()
, ' ' ()
, () (), ()
(), 5

15-17 I Tm 4 : 3 ; VIII. 20.2


19-22 cf. VII. 28.7; VIII. 16; 20.1; . 18; 19.4;
Iren. I. 24.2; 28.1; Eus. Hist. eccl. 4. 29.2-3; Clem. Strom. 3. 12.1-2; 25.2; Tert. Adv. Marc.
1. 29.1; 4. 11.8; 34.5 et al.
20 : cf. Hegemon. Act. Arcbel. 8, p. 11.8
Beeson
c. 31: 4 : cf. Theodoret. Haer. 1.25; Harnack, Marcion1 p.255* s.; Marcion2 (1924),
pp.167; 333* s.
(): cf. VI. 35.7 (q.v.); Euseb. Hist. eccl. 4. 30.1;
Epiph. Pan. 56.1.2
8 addidi
9 scripsi:
10 scripsi:
11 addidi
12
, corr. Mi

13 addidi
14

15 addidi
16 : NT

supplevi ex N T et
17 ' addidi (cf. w . 12, 14)
20 : Cr: coniec We: VII. 29.22
addidi
20/21 2, - 1
22 addidi
c. 31: 3
, corr. Mi
4 Bunsen et Go:

addidi

5 :
R. Scott: coniec. We
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.30.1-31.5

313

. ( ) , 2
) , '
. 3
' (), ,
10 , ,
,
( ) , '
. [] 4
, ,
is ,

20

, ,
( ) ,
, ,
.

( ) 5
() ,
/
- - ( )
25 ()
, ,

f. 99

12 : cf. Sext. Adv. math. 7.122 et Gu. Guthrie, o.e., II, p.260 s.
17-20 Emped. Fr. 131 DK (Fr. 18 Zuntz)
21-33 ed. Bunsen, p. 99
25 s. Lc
3 : 1 ; de Marcionis evangelii principio cf. Iren. I. 27.2; Tert. Adv. Marc. 1. 19.2; 4. 7.1;
Epiph. Pan. 42. 11.5; Adamant. Dial. 2.3; Harnack, M} p. 165* ss.; M.2, p. 183* ss.
6 addidi
7 Go:
Mi:
7-8 . . .
scripsi: . . . : . . . Go
9 addidi
12
addidi
13 deievi (cf. v. 15)
14 et 24 -
15 scripsi:
scripsi:
, corr. Mi
17 Mi:
: Schneidewin (Philol.
6, 1851, p. 167)
18 () Cr: ()
Schneidewin
( ) Wilamowitz et . Maas: ( > Diels:
() cum lacuna unius versus post Bergk, Zuntz
19
Schneidewin:
20 Mi:
Schneidewin:
21 addidi (cf. v. 35)
23 Mi:
: . Klostermann
24 addidi
25 : Usener (Das Weibnachtsfest2, p. 93 n.22), agn. Harnack

addidi ex NT

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

314

Hippolytus

6 . , ,
, . - ' , ,
- ()
, , ' . -
, , , , , ,
(*) () ; ()
.
7
() , '
() '
, .
8 ' () , '
() , '
, ()
.
1


() ,
(), ()
, ,

27 Lc 4 : 1 5 ; Tert. Adv. Marc. 4. 7.5


27 et 31 : cf. Cyrill. Alex. De trinitate
dial. 1 (V. 1, p.410 D Aubert) , ,

31 : ft. cf. Gal 3 :20; Clem. Exc.
ex Tbeod. 53.2; De bened. Balaam, p.82 Achelis
32 s. Lc 18:19; Mc 10:18;
Mt 19:17; Epiph. Pan. 42. 11.6 schol. 50; Adamant. Dial. 1.1; 2.17; Orig. De princip.
2. 5.1; Harnack., M1 p.207* s.; M2, pp.225* s.; 304; cf. ad V. 7.26
c. 32: 1-44 ex Iren. I. 25.1-3; 4 et 6 hausit H. Cf. Epiphan. Pan. 27.1.1-6.11; Theodoret.
Haer. I. 5; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 3; Philastr. 35; August. Haer. 7. Cf. H. Liboron, Die karpokratianische Gnosis (Lipsiae, 1938)
1 s. cf. ad VII. 28 v. 4 s.
4 - 6 cf. Plat.
Phaedr. 247 d
27 Bunsen conl. Gal 3 :19: : Go
29 , corr.
Go
31 Mi:
Roeper et Bunsen: : G o
31-32 post lacunam signavi: exspectes
, (Gal 3 :20)
32 addidi
Mi:
34 addidi
35 addidi
37 Mi:

addidi
39 addidi
40 2 add. G o
c. 32: 2 Harvey (ingenito Ir.):
addidi ex Ir. (reliquis)
4 scripsi:

3 , corr. Cr

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.31.5-32.4

315

5 , () []
() ' () , ' ,
[] / () 2
, ( ) (),
, () ,
, , '
() .
3

is , () ,
() , '
() , ,
, 4
, ()
20
, []
. ,
.

f. 99

13-23 cf. Tert. De anima 23.2 et I.H. Waszink ad loc.


5 () scripsi ex Epiph. 27. 2.3-4 et delevi: : coniec.
Harvey, agn. Cr: coniec. We
6 Harvey:
8
delevi (om. Ir. Ep.): fjv Mi cett.
() scripsi (ascenderet Ir.; Ep.
27. 2.5): : Harvey et Go
9 et addidi ex
Ir. (et eas, quae similia ei amplecterentur, similiter): ( )
Go: ( ) Cr (conl. Ep.
27. 2.6)
Go ex Ir. Ep.:
Cr:
10 : . 27. 2.7, nutritam Ir.
11
(cf. . 28. 1.6 ; VII. 33.2 ):
Go ex . Ir. (accepisse), agn. omnes (cf. v. 14)
12 Go ex Ep. Ir.:
14 : . 27. 2.8; virtutes Ir.
15 coniec.
We (ad tantum elationis Ir., Theodoret. p. 352 ;
. 27. 2.9):
Harvey et Go:
16 addidi
(cf. . 27. 2.9-10): om. Ir.
Mi:
coniec. We:


, transposui: Cr: ( ) Go ex Ir.
(adhuc et secundum aliquid), agn. We
17 addidi ex Ir. (illo)
19
, corr. Go
scripsi ex Ir. (enim):
addidi ex Ir. et Ep. 27. 2.11
20 (de sublimi virtute Tert. De an. 23.2): Ir. Ep.
Harvey et Go ex Ir. (contemnentes):
21 del.
Harvey et Go (om. Ir., cf. v. 20): () Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

316

Hippolytus

f.

( ) ,
,
, ()
,
6 . -
( )
, '
,
, , ( ) () () . 7
/ () ,
()
(),
() () . ()
8 []
() , (
)() () ( )
, .
()
.
, ().

25

35

24-26 cf. VI. 20.1


34-41 Iren. I. 25.4; Epiph. 27. 5.6-7; Theodoret. I. 5 (p. 352 )
42 s. Ir. I. 25.6; Epiph. 27. 5.9 (et C. Holl ad loc.); Clem. Eel. proph. 25.1 = Heracleonis
Fr.49 Brooke
43 s. Ir. I. 25.6; Epiph. 27. 6.9
24 Go ex Ir. (operantur): , - Mi

addidi ex Ir. (et ipsi), cf. v.28
25
26 addidi ex Ir. (se)
29 supplevi ex Epiph. 27. 3.3 ,
' ; quemadmodum (Christiani addidi) ad (scripsi: et codi.) gentes a Satana praemissi sunt Ir.
33 ex Ir. (aut et) add. Bunsen et Harvey
Harvey ex Ir. (omnes):

, coir. Mi
34 addidi ex Ir. (semper)
35 () scripsi (cf. .34): : coniec. Sauppe: sic... quoadusque Ir.
36 (sc. ) addidi ex Ir. (ei)
coniec Mi
37
addidi (cf. v.43)
38 del. Go
scripsi:
: Bunsen (servato v. 38 )
39 addidi
39-44 (
)() supplevi conl. Ir. (sive de corpore in corpus transmigrantes),
cf. Theodoreti p.352 :
40 et supplevi ex Ir. (adimplentes et reddentes debita)
42 addidi ex Ir. (vero)
44 () scripsi
ex E p . 27. 6.9:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.32.5-34.1

317

, () , 1 33
() , '
()
() .
5 (), ,
,
(), [] () 2

() .
, ()
, ,
.
() 1 34
,
. ( )
( ) () , () / .

c. 33: 1-12 Iren. I. 26.1; . 21; cf. Epiph. Pan. 28.


Adv. haer. 3; Philastr. 36 et al.; A.F.I. Klijn et G.I.
Christian Sects (Suppl. to NT, vol.36, Lugduni Batav.
Mt 3 :16; Mc 1:10; Lc 3 :22; VI. 35.6; 47.2; 49.5;

f.

1.1-7; Theodoret. Haer. 2.3; Ps. Tert.


Reinink, Patristic Evidence for Jewish1973), pp.3-19; 74-77
7 s. cf.
51.2 et 4; VII. 35.2; 36.1

c. 34: 1-4 cf. Iren. I. 26.2; X. 22; Epiphan. Pan. 30.1.1-34.9; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 3.27; Ps.
Tert. Adv. haer. 3; Philastr. 37; August. Haer. 10; Theodoret. Haer. 2.1; Orig. De princip.
4. 3.8; In Matth. 11.12; Ser. 79; c. Cels. 2.1; 5.61; 5.66 et al.; cf. Klijn et Reinink, o.e.,
pp. 19-43; 73-77
c. 33: 1 add. Mi, om.
2 ex Ir. add. Bunsen et Harvey
3
addidi ex Ir.
post addunt Ir.
:
, principalitate Ir.
4 addidi, om. P H
5 scripsi ex
Theod. Ep.:
Bunsen et Harvey ex Ir.:
6 2, - - 1
7 addidi (ab omnibus Ir., )
del. Bunsen, om.
ex Ep. add. Bunsen: add. Harvey I
superscr. 2
9 , ex Ir. Ep. corr. Bunsen, Harvey et Go
9-10 post add. ( .;
Theodor.): om. Ir.
10 Bunsen ex ( .;
revolasse Ir): Theodor.
R. Scott et Bunsen ex Ir.: () :

addidi
12 Bunsen et Harvey ex Ir. (exsistentem
spiritalem): : ( . 28. 1.5)
c. 34: 1 addidi post Go. ( ) conl. Ir. (quidem)
supplevi ex VII. 8
4 addidi ex .
addidi ex

3
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

318

Hippolytus

2 ()
( ) [] [ ],
()
() , [] ,
( )
- ()
.
1

, ,

, ( ) ,
- []
2 - . []

,
(') () , ,
()
, -

5-7 cf. Epiph. 30. 18.5-6 (I, p.358 Holl) (scripsi: VM)
, (sc. )
(
), .
c. 35: 1-12 cf. . 23; c. Noet. 3; Epiph. Pan. 54.1.1-6.5; Theodoret. Haer.
Adv. haer. 8.2; Philastr. 50; August. Haer. 33; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5. 28.6
(cepisse): cf. VI. 51.5; IX. 12.18
9 cf. Mt 3 :16; Mc 1:10; Lc
35.6; 47.2; 49.5; 51.2 et 4; VII. 33.2; 36.1
10 Mt 14:2; Mc 6:14; cf.
33.2

2.5; Ps. Tert.


8 s. 3 :22; VI.
VII. 32.2;

5 addidi
scripsi:
6 addidi ex Epiph.
delevi
del. suad. We: coniec. C. Holl
7
addidi ex Epiph.: add. Bunsen: add. Scott: add. Go
8
addidi
delevi
9 addidi (cf. w . 4, 5, 7, 8)
10 addidi
ex VII. 35.2; X. 23
c. 35: 1 Go:
, corr. Mi
2 , transp. Cr
3
addidi
4 1 delevi
5 () coniec. We
del.
Sauppe, om.
7 scripsi:
8 ' addidi ex
9 addidi
10 addidi ex
Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.34.2-36.3

319

, , (
' ) ,
() .
() , 1 36
, ,
(),
, ' / .
f.
5 ()
, .
() () (), - 2
() , ()
' ' &. 3
, , '

12-14 de Theodoti schola cf. Theodoreti 1.1. (p. 352 C) (sc.


), , ,
; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5. 28. 9; 16-17; VII. 36.1
c. 36: 1-7 cf. . 24; Epiphan. Pan. 55.1.1-9.19; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5. 28.9; Theodoret.
Haer. 2.6; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 8.3; Philastr. 52; August. Haer. 34 et al.
3 :
cf. Gn 14:18-20; Ps. 109:4; Heb 5:6; 5:10; 6:20; 7 : 1 - 1 7 ; N H IX. 1
10 s. cf.
Prooem. 8 ' ...

11-16 cf. Act 6 : 5 ; Iren. I. 26.3; Clem. Strom. 3. 25.5-26.3
( - Euseb. Hist. eccl. 3. 29.2-4); Epiphan. Pan. 25.1.1-6; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 1.6; Theodoret.
Haer. 3.1; Philastr. 33.1; August. Haer. 5
13 s. cf. Iren. 1.1.: qui (sc. Nicolaitae)
indiscrete vivunt... nullam differentiam esse docentes in moechando et idolothyton
edere; Clem. Strom. 2. 118.3; 3. 25.7 et al.
12 1 ( ) coniec. We
: Cr

scripsi ex :
scripsi: : coniec. Mi, agn. Go Cr
scripsi ex :
12-13 ' supplevi ex coniectura
14 addidi
c. 36: 1
5 addidi
8 addidi
scripsi:

add. Cr: add. suad. Mi


9 addidi
: Roeper I
addidi
9/10 Roeper:
10 scripsi:
coniec. Mi
: Bunsen
11 We I
' : coniec. Sauppe
: Roeper
Bunsen
et Go:
12 1 , 2
14 Bunsen:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

320

Hippolytus

() is
( ) .
37 1

, (-)
, ,
,
2 , , - 5

. .

38 1
pf.

() , () () ,
- / , ()
() - ( ), - - , ( ) 5
2 , ,

16 Ape 2:14-15 et 2 : 6 ; Iren. 11; Ps. Tert. 11; Epiph. 25.3.1; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 3. 29.1
c. 37: 1-7 Iren. I. 27.1-2 = Euseb. Hist. eccl. 4. 11.2; Epiphan. Pan. 41.1.1-9; Theodoret.
Haer. 1.24; Ps.Tert. Adv. haer. 6; Philastr. 44; August. Huer. 21; VII. 10; 29.1; 30.2-3;
X. 19.1; Harnack, Marcion2, pp.31*-39* et al.
7 : VII. 11; Ps. Tert. 6.3;
Philastr. 46; Epiph. 43. 1.1; Harnack, Marcion2, pp. 172 et 401*-403*
c. 38: 1-26 cf. VII. 12; X. 20.1-2; Epiphan. Pan. 44.1.1-3.9; Rhodonem ap. Euseb.
Hist. eccl. 5. 13; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 6 (pp.223.11-224.8 Kroymann); Philastr. 47; Theodoret. 1.25; August. Haer. 23; Tert. et Orig. passim; cf. A. ab Harnack, De Apellis gnosi
monarchica (Lipsiae 1874), et Marcion2 pp. 177-196 et 404*-420*; Foerster, I, pp. 61 s.
4 s. cf. Theodoret. 1.1.
; differunt Rhodon; Epiph. 44.1.4-5; Ps. Tert. 1.1.; Philastr. 47.2-3;
Tert. De praescr. haeret. 34.4 Nemo alteram deum ausus est suspicari... donec... Apelles
creatorem angelum nescio quem gloriosum superioris dei faceret deum legis et Israelis,
illum igneum affirmans; De came Christi 8; De anima 23.3 ab igneo angelo, deo Israelis et
nostro (et I. H. Waszink ad loc.)
15

16 scripsi:

addidi

c. 37: 1 addidi ex Ir.


2-3 , transposui conl. Ir.
6
scripsi:
7 scripsi: :
eum qui a lege et prophetis annunciatus est Deus Ir.
Go:
c. 38: 1
3 1 addidi
addidi

scripsi:
addidi
addidi ex
4 addidi (cf. v. 5)
5 Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VII.36.3-38.6

321


.
( ) ().

() ,
(), . 3
, ' () ( )
, '
- ,
is - ,
( ) .
, 4
( )
20 () . () (), , 5
, () () ,
, ,
- () , ,
, -
25 ,
() .
() () - ' 6
/ () , () .

f. 2

8 : cf. . 20.2; Ps. Tert. p. 224.3 Habet praeterea privatas, sed extraordinarias
lectiones suas, quas appellant Phanerosis, Philumenes cuiusdam puellae, quam quasi prophetissam sequitur; Rhodon. ap. Eus. 5.13.2; Tert. De praescr. 30.6; De came 24; Theodoret. 1.1.
17-19 Jo. 2 0 : 2 0 et 25; Epiph. 44. 2.7
19 s. Lc. 2 4 : 3 9 ; cf. Ps. Tert.
6 (p. 223.20) Christum neque in phantasmate dicit fuisse, sicut Marcion, neque in substantia veri corporis, ut evangelium docet...
8 scripsi:
9 supplevi conl. et Ps. Tert. 1.1.
() G. Volkmar et Go ex :
10 addidi
11
addidi ex conl. Epiph. 44. 2.1 ...
12 ' () scripsi:
add. Go et supplevi (cf. v.20
et Apollinarii Laodiceni Fid. sec. partem 31, p. 179.1 Lietzmann:
(sc. ) )
16 addidi (cf. v. 25)
18 addidi
ex Epiph.
19 scripsi:
scripsi:
20 addidi
addidi
21 addidi

23
addidi (cf. w . 11, 14)
26 addidi
27 addidi
28 2 scripsi:

addidi
29 Mi:

addidi (cf. VIII. 2; 8.2; 11.1-2)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

< )
1
2
3
4

5
6
7

[] () ()
,
.
,
.
() ()
( ) , () ()
, .
()
.
,
.
,
, ' '
.

1 - suppl. Mi et scripsi (cf. v.2 et VIII. 8.2): litt,


rubr. 3
2 del. Mi, def. We
4
6 1 ,
3

, corr. Go
8 addidi (cf. v. 6)
coniec. Go
(conl. VII. 12): () , def. Cr: () coniec. Mi:
coniec. We

9 ( ) Roeper: I
, Mi: Roeper cett.
() scripsi: ()
addidi (cf.
v. 6)
11
15
16
post . 15 , hue transtulit Cr: del. suad. Mi
Cr: (cf. Iren.
I. 28.1 Euseb. Hist. eccl. 4. 29.3 ' et '
)
16-17 ' , seel. Go
We, at cf. Clem. Strom. 1. 71.5

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.1-8.4

is

20

323

[] , ,
( ) () , ,
' []
,
.
()
, () () ,
, ()
() ()
, .
,
, , / [] ,
(), (),
() - () , ' ,
, , - () , , ,
[ ].
, , ,
() , * , ,
, () ()
() , ( ),

1 8

3
f. 2

1-3 et 4-6 Mt 7 : 3 - 5 ; Lc 6:41-42


1 et v.9 ad etymon vocis
spectant
9 s. cf. Lc 1:4; (Xenoph. Memorab. 4. 6.15)
12 - VIII.
10.11: cf. Foerster, I, pp.393-399
12-47 cf. X. 16.1
14 s. ft. cf. Gn 3 : 7
15 s. Lc 13:6-7
16 s. Mt 21:19; Mc 11:13-14; 11:20-21
20 s. cf. Mt 24:32;
Mc 13:28
1 oi delevi
2 supplevi (cf. w . 5 - 6 et VIII. 11.1)

4 del. suad. Go
scripsi:
7
addidi (cf. v. 3)
8 addidi
() scripsi (cf. V. 28.1; VI. 6; VI. 7.1):
2, - 1
9 post add. Usener
addidi ex NT
10 addidi ex coni.: add. suad. Mi: add. suad. Diels
Mi:
: ' Go We
12
13 coniec. We: .
: Cr
delevi
14 et , corr.
Sauppe
15
scripsi post . Sauppe (.
), cf. . 17: ()
16 2 addidi
17 del. ut dittogr. Sauppe
18 , corr. Mi
19 () We: : ( ) Mi
bis
20 addidi ex NT
21
addidi
coniec. We et addidi: :
. Klostermann

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

324

f. 3

Hippolytus

() , []
5 .
,
, () , , ,
, , .
, , ,
, , (),
6 , , , '

' , .
(), , () ()
() , ' () 7 ,
- () ,
, ,
. () , (
) () , ()
, , , /
8 ,
, , () ,
, [] ,
(),
, () ( ),
.

25

35

45

28 Dt 5:22; V. 20.1
36 : cf. VI. 31.3; 52.7; VIII. 10.5 et al.
45 : cf. Plut. De Iside 370 []
, ; VIII. 9.4
22 delevi
23 : coniec. We
25 1 addidi

scripsi:
Mi: : coniec. R. Scott
26
28
32 addidi
addidi (cf. w . 2 6 , 28, 29, 38)
addidi
33 () Usener:
add. suad. Go (cf. v. 36)
35 , corr. Mi
addidi (cf. v. 38)
36
37 ( ) scripsi: : Mi
37-38 addidi ex coni.
38 () , ut .
addidi
41 addidi (cf. w . 4 3 , 44)
scripsi (cf.
w . 3 8 , 43, 44):
42 delevi
, corr. Mi
43 2 , - 1
44 , corr. G o
addidi (cf. v. 41)
45/46 addidi (cf. w . 42, 44)
46 supplevi (cf. w . 43, 44)
47
scripsi (cf. V. 26.8; VI. 32.1; VII. 9.2): : Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.8.4-9.3

325

1
() ()
() , ,
, , , , () [] 2
, ' (), .
()
( ), (
, ) ,
[ ] , , ()
[ ] () (), [] ,
, () , ,
, (). () 3
,
, -

-, ()
() .
- () (),
( )

2-4 Mt 13:3 et 8; Mc 4 : 3 et 8; Lc 8:5 et 8; V. 8.29; . Thomae log.9 et al.


4 s. Mt 13:9; Mc 4:9; Lc 8:8; V. 8.29
5-7 X. 16.1
11-13 cf. VI.
32.1-2; Iren. I. 2.6
11-15 X. 16.2
21-28 . 16.3
2 add. Go
3 addidi ex NT et
5 Mi:

addidi
delevi ut dittogr. (cf. . 7)
6 ' scripsi: '
6/7 supplevi ex
7 scripsi ex :
8 add. suad. Go (cf. VIII. 8.6)
9 oi addidi (cf. w . 6 - 7 )
9-10 supplevi conl. v. 14; VIII. 8 w . 12, 23, 25-26 et addidi conl. V. 26.8; VI. 32.1
11 del. suad. We

12 delevi ut dittogr. (cf. v. 9)

Cr:
13 del. Sauppe
14 , ex corr. Go
15 , ex
corr. Go

addidi
17 2, 1
19
addidi
scripsi:
20 addidi
21 scripsi ( ):
22 () scripsi ( ):
23 addidi
add. suad. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

326
p f. 3
4

8
f. 4

Hippolytus

/ ,
(. ) ()- 25
()
,
.
,
, 3

,
,
- - 35
- ( -
- ) . , ,
,
- ,
() .
() , ()
, - ,
(,) . - , , ,
, 45
. , (,)
,
, /
- - ,
so
.
24 s. cf. VII. 22.1; 21.5; 22.6; VIII. 8.4
29-41 . 16.4-5
34-36 Gn
1 : 4 - 5 (cf. 1 : 7 - 8 )
41 Gn 1:1
42 s. * 3 :2 et 4; cf. D i 4 : 2 4 ; 9 : 3 ; V. 7.31;
VI. 9.3; 32.8; VII. 38.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 38.1 et al.
47 cf.
: S.V.F. I nr.74 (Zeno); II nrr. 138; 139; 141; 384 (Chrysippus); III nrr.17;
19 (Diogen. Bab.); Aristot. De anima 8, p.420 b 27 ss.; Plat. Tim. 67 b 2 ss.; Origen.
c. Cek. 2.72; 6.62
24-25 , transposui
25 . 5 supplevi
ex
26-27 , transposui
28 , corr. Go
31
Bernays ex ():
33-34 Bernays: :
34
35
36-37
supplevi conl. Gn. 1 : 7 et v.35 s.
37 Go ex H:

42 addidi
addidi
43 (non liquet)
44 1 addidi
45 Go:
46 addidi (cf. v. 44)
49 -

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.9.3-10.3

327

(), , 1
, ,
()
.
() ()
(), , .
, () ( )
, ()
(). ' , , 2

(), ()
,
. .

.
() , 3
[ ] ,
& .
() () [ ] ,
,

1-9 cf. . 16.5-6


6 - 7 : cf. I. 21.3; Diogen. Apollon.
64 A 28 DK; Plat. Crat. 399 d 10-e 3; Aristot. De anima A 2, p. 405 b 28 s.; Plut. De
primo frig. 946 C; De Stoic, repugn. 1052 F; 1053 C; De comm. not. 1084 E; De def. orac.
433 A; Plot. 4. 7.8; Philon. De somn. 1.31; Porphyr, ap. Euseb. Praep. ev. 15. 11.4; Tert. De
anima 25.2 (et I.H. Waszink ad loc.); Orig. De {nine. 2. 8.3 (V, p. 161.2 Koetschau); S.V.F.
II nrr. 804-808 et al.
10 s. Job 2 : 9 d
12 s. Mt 11:14-15; cf. Pistis Sophia 7,
p.8.6; 135, p.230.12 S.-T.; Orig. In Io. 6.20 (Jo 1:23) - Heracleonis Fr.5 Brooke; Tert. De
anima 35.5 et al.
13 s. Mc 1:4; Lc 3 :3
3 addidi
, transposui
5 ()
post . 6 , hue transtuli
5 et 6 addidi
(cf. v. 1)
7 supplevi conl. locis a G. Gu. H. Lampe (s. v.
, 4) laudatis
8 addidi (cf. v. 3)
scripsi: I
scripsi: (cf. v. 11)
9 scripsi:
10 , corr. Mi
11 addidi e LXX
coniec. We conl.
LXX:
: LXX
addidi (cf. v. 10)
14 scripsi:
16 addidi (cf. VIII. 9.3)
, transp.
suad. We
17 del. suad. We
19 addidi (cf. v. 32)
scripsi:
seclusi ut glossema
:
Chr. Petersen ap. Go
20 Petersen:
Cr:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

328

f. 4

6
7

Hippolytus

( ) , ()
( ).
() () , () ,

/ (), 25

() , () () , , - () ,
, , ,
, , 3
, , ()
()
()
, , , ,
.
35
' , () , [ ], ()
, , , () ()
. ' [] ,
- 4
() [ ], ()

28-30 cf. Galeni Defin. med. 41 (XIX, p. 358 .)


8:12; 22:13; 25:30
37 s. Lc 1:26 ss.

34 cf. V. 9.21
39 cf. X. 16.6

36 s. cf. Mt

21 addidi
v addidi
22 supplevi conl. v. 34
23 1, et 2 addidi
24 Usener: : Mi Cr
25 We post . Usener:
27 supplevi ex coni. I
addidi
28 (cf. test.): coniec. Mi, agn. Go Cr I () Gu. Moeller
(Gesch. der Kosmologie in der griech. Kirche bis auf Orig., 1860, p. 330): : coniec.
Mi, agn. Go Cr
Mi: corr. in 1
31 (sc. ) scripsi:
2 addidi
32 ()
Cr
addidi
Cr: :
Go
33 scripsi:
33-34 Go: :
Cr
36 addidi

37 seclusi ut glossema: del. Cr
addidi
38 del. Cr
add. Cr

39
scripsi:
scripsi (cf.
() ):
41 addidi I
seclusi ut dittographiam
addidi (cf. v. 48)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.10.3-11

45

so

55

60

65

329

() ()
', []
, () , () , ()
() ' ,
, ' , ,
. , ,
,
, ()
.
/
, (,) ,
() . ()
() () () ()
, [ ] ,
.
() , (,)
, ,
(, ) ' , '
, , , ,
() , ()
() , () ().
- , ,

43 s. Ph 2 : 8
V. 7.40; 8.37

f. iosr

10

11

44-46 Col 2 : 1 4 - 1 5
46 s. 2 Cor 5 : 3
48-51 Jo 3 : 5 - 6 ;
52 s. Lc 3 :23; cf. Iren. I. 3.1; 16.2; VI. 52.7 et 9

42 scripsi:
addidi (cf. v. 47)

scripsi:
43 delevi
44 Klostermann ex NT:
1 add. Cr
Go:
2 addidi
45 addidi ex N T
46 , corr. Mi
50
53 addidi
54
addidi
Roeper:
, corr. Roeper
Go: I
scripsi:
55 add. suad. We
56 Go: I
seclusi ut dittogr.
58 addidi
addidi
59
, transposui
60 2, 1
, supplevi (cf.
v. 54)
Scott et Roeper:
61 coniec. Mi:
62 addidi
Mi: : coniec. Go
addidi (
add. suad. Petersen ap. Go)
63 Go et We:
addidi
63/64 addidi ex coni.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

330

Hippolytus

, ,
, () , '
() ,
.
11 1

.
() () . ( )
, () 5
, 2 , ' , () .
() , ()() .
, .

pf. 0 5

12

/ ()
(), () ,
,
' ' .
() () 5
() - () () - (), ,
, () ,

C. 11: 4 - 7 cf. VIII. 8.1

6 cf. Mt 7 : 3 - 5 ; Lc 6:41-42

c. 12: 1 - VIII. 15.2: cf. Foerster, I, pp.319-323


83.2; Orph. fr. 57 K.; Horn. Iliad. 14.201 et 246
66 (i.e. ) scripsi: (i.e. )

4 V. 7.38; X. 7.1; Orph. hymn.


5-9 cf. X. 17.1
67 addidi

68 1 addidi

c. 11: 2 , corn Mi
2-3 Chr. Petersen (cf. v. 5):
3 scripsi:
4
scripsi:
( ) scripsi:

Cr:
5 scripsi: :
coniec. Go
, corr. Mi
addidi
:
Sauppe
6 scripsi:
7 ' ,
R. Scott et Go, addidi:
Go: ,
def. Cr
8 Scott et Go:
addidi
c. 12: 1 () , ut v.: om. Mi cett.
4 2
5 addidi
5 - 6 ()
() scripsi ex ( () ):

6 addidi: add. suad. Mi
addidi
, corr. Go
7 , corr. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.10.11-12.7

331

, , (),
, , () ()
; .
, , .
[] , , ()
, ,
.
, () ,
, , , , ,
, , ,
, ' ()
, -
, , , ,
() , , ()
() , [ ] ,
, , ( )
, , , ,
(), , ,
, .

3
4

9 s. < VII. 21.1


11 ft. cf. C 1:3 et Jo 1 : 1 - 4 et 9; VII. 22.3
17 s. cf.
e.g. Ps. Aristot. De mundo 5, p.396 b 15 ,

18 s. cf. V. 19.1; VI. 9.7; VII. 22.1
19 s. cf. V. 6.5; Synes. Hymn. 5(2).63 s.
22 Mt 5 :18; Lc 16:17; VI. 24.1; Iren. I. 3.2
25 s. cf. V. 9.4
8 Mi (cf. v. 13):
addidi
9 () scripsi:

addidi
scripsi:
12 del. Roeper I
add. suad. Mi
15 addidi
16 , transposui
16-17 , transposui
17
18 ' Mi:

addidi ex
21 addidi
addidi
22 addidi
seclusi ut dittogr.
23 addidi
24 del. suad. We I
, corr. Sauppe
Go:
25 addidi (cf. v. 15)
26 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

332

Hippolytus

pf. io6r 13 l

, , () , , /
() , , (
)
() () - , ,
()
2 . , (,)

, ,
.
3
, , ,
(), , ()
() , . ()
, , , (,)
4 , () .
, (,) , () . , , ,
' , '
. , ,
, , , ,
, ,
.

is

1 - 6 . 17.2; cf. Theodoreti Haer. 1.18


7 s. Col
1:19 et 2 : 9 ; V. 12.5; . 10.4; Iren. I. 3.4; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 31.1
12 cf. Mt
11:27
14 s. cf. VIII. 14.8
18-23 X. 17.1 et 2
1 addidi (cf. VIII. 12 w . 15 et 24)
2 coniec. Sauppe: I
scripsi (cf. w . 6, 9, 21):
post Iacunam susp. Go, post We
2 - 3 supplevi ex (cf. w . 4 - 6 et 10):
add. suad. We
4 , corr. Mi
5 , corr. Go I
2 addidi
6
addidi
7 Mi ex NT:

: Cr ( NT): conieci conl. Orig. In . 20.1


8 coniec. We:
12 scripsi:
addidi
Go:

13 addidi (cf. v. 17)
addidi

Mi:
14
addidi
15 addidi
16 addidi
17
18 et 19 :
19

21 , , Go ex :

22 scripsi ex :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.13.1-14.5

is

20

333

( ) , , ,
, ()
( ) , ( ) , . ( * ) ,
().
( ) () (), / , (), , ,
()()
, , ( ) ,
" , ,
- , , ()() - ,
, , (, ) , ()
, (), ,
, .
() (), , ,
, ' . () ,
,
, (,) .
, ,
() ,
( ) , , (,)
.

1 14

2
f. 6

1-14 . 17.3-4
1 s. Ex 2 0 : 1 1 ; Gn 2 : 2 ; cf. VI. 13.1; 14.1
3 s. G 2 : 2 - 3 ;
VI. 32.8
5 s. cf. Plat. Tim. 55 a - 56 b; Tim. Locr. 98 d ( 35 Marg)
10-13 Ex 7 : 8 - 1 1 : 1 0 ; cf. V. 16.8
16 s. Democriti Fr. 32 DK; Clem. Paed. 2. 94.4
21 cf. VIII. 13.3-4
1 addidi
2 supplevi (cf. w . 8 , 23; X. 17.3)
3 et
addidi


3 / 4
4 post lac.
sign. Go (lac. in ): exspectes ' , , vel. sim.

, transposui (cf. v. 7 et . 17.2 et 3)
6 supplevi
( = , = , = , = )
add. Go
7
9 addidi ex
10
11/12 , corr. Mi
12 Bernays et Go: :

13
addidi et add. Cr
scripsi: : Go
scripsi (cf. v. 8):

addidi
14 addidi
15
16
addidi ex Democrito

17 Gu. Moeller (cf. v. 22):

18-19 , transp. Cr
19 addidi
scripsi (cf. w . 2 0 , 24, 37):
21 Mi:

22 addidi
addidi
23
, transposui

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

334

Hippolytus

f. 7

To , ,
, , 25
, , () (),
, ' , , .
( ) , (,)
(), , , , 3
, , (,) .
7
() [] ()
()
[] , () . ()
, , / 35
, () ,
; () () ()
8 () , (,) ,
, (,)
. 4
( ) ,
( , ) , .

25 : cf. 8:13
25 s. Ex 12:11; 12:14 et 12:17
26 s. cf. Ex 12:6
; 12:18 .
30 s. 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 = 10 (I):' cf. I. 2.8-9; IV. 51.6; VI. 23.5 et al.
32 s. cf. Ex
12:18
34 : cf. Ex 12:15; 12:18-20
36 s. cf. ad v.25 s.
41
: cf. Ex 3:20
42 4 : 6 et 7:17
24 Moeller et Cr (cf. w . 26-27):
26 :
LXX
27 addidi e LXX
() Cr e LXX: ,
Go We

28 scripsi (cf. v. 26 ):
28-29 ( ) scripsi (cf. w . 30-31):
29 addidi
30 add. Mi
31 addidi
32 addidi
, transposui
seclusi
addidi e LXX
33
addidi
34 delevi
addidi

scripsi:
Roeper:
add. suad. Sauppe
37 add.
Sauppe
38 () scripsi (cf. v.44):
addidi
39
addidi
Roeper:
40
41 scripsi: :
Petersen: Cr: coniec. We
Cr: , Petersen:
coniec. We
Petersen:
addidi e LXX I
Petersen:
42 addidi e LXX

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.14.6-15.3

335

() () - - ()
- ,
45 (,) , ().
9
, , ,
()
.
- 1 15
- ( ,)
, (),

5 [ ,] , , , 2
() ,
- () ,
. () , , ,
(), () ,
( ), ' .
' 3
, ' ()
is / () ,
()() ,
, ' , ,
() .

f. 7

43 : 10:4; 10:12-14 et 19
: cf. Lv\\:22
44 1 1:24;
Is 40:6; VI. 10.2
48 s. : i.e. Aristoteli et Pythagoricis, cf. I. 20.1; VI.
24.1-2
c. 15: 2-11 cf. . 17.5

14 cf. Theodoret. Haer. 1.18

43 addidi
addidi: add. Petersen
add. suad. Mi
45 et
supplevi
48 supplevi (cf. VI. 4; IX. 17.2)
, corr.
Mi
49 , transposui (cf. I. 20.1)
c. 15: 2 supplevi ex
3 scripsi:
: We
() Go ex :
5 seclusi
6 addidi (cf. . 4 )
7 addidi
9 addidi
10 (sc. ,
cf. . 2) : We
() coniec. Go (cf. v. 3):
addidi
11 addidi
: Roeper et Go
14 addidi: vel.
add. suad. Mi
: () Roeper
15 Mi:
17
Go:
18 scripsi:
19 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

336
16 l

Hippolytus

, ()
, , () , .
, 5
. ( ) .

17 1

, ,
() - .
() ,
2 () , 5
( ) ) . () () ,
, () .
() () ,
() . - ()

c. 16: 1 - 6 cf. . 18; Iren. I. 28.1 = Euseb. Hist. eccl. 4. 29.3; Epiph. Pan. 46.1.1-2.7; Ps.
Tert. Adv. haer. 7.1; Philastr. 48; Theodoret. 1.20; August. Haer. 25
c. 17: 1-3 X. 28
2 cf. Theodoret. Haer. 1.19; Tert. Adv. Hermogenem 1 (p. 127.5
Kroymann) ... materiam cum deo ponere, quae et ipsa semper fuerit, neque nata neque
facta nec initium habens omnino nec finem, ex qua deus omnia postea fecerit.
3-5 cf. Tert. 3 (p. 128.12) deum semper deum (semper) etiam dominum fuisse, numquam
non dominum; p. 130.7 itaque ex quo deus potestatem suam exercuit in earn, faciendo
ex materia, ex illo materia dominum deum passa demonstrat...
5-8 cf. Tert. 41
(p. 170.12) inconditus et confusus et turbulentus fuit materiae motus. sic enim et ollae
undique ebullientis similitudinem opponis; 43 (p. 172.21) de motu et illud notaverim.
nam secundum ollae similitudinem...
7 : cf. v.5 et Tert. 38 (p. 168.14)
unde, inquis, nec tota (sc. materia) fabricatur, sed partes eius.
c. 16: 1 addidi
3 addidi ex
Bunsen et Go ex Ir.:
:
4 Bunsen et Go ex Ir.: 1 I
post addunt Ir. . (46. 2.1)
5 scripsi:
6
addidi
c. 17: 2 : Go
addidi ex
3 scripsi ex :

4 addidi
5 1 addidi
scripsi conl. Tert.:

6 addidi
() scripsi (ollae Tert): . . . . , ut v.:
Mi Cr: Go: () coniec. Sauppe, agn. We
7 ,
corr. Go
8 addidi
9 addidi
addidi
scripsi:

10 addidi (cf. w . 5, 8)
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII.16.1-18.1

337

, ()
,
/ . () 3
is ()() () [ ]
.
()
,
. (), 4
20 ,

().
.

f. 8

, , , - 1 18
, ()
, (')
, () , []
5 () , , ,

12 : cf. Tert. 1 (p. 127.4) a Christianis enim ad philosophos conversus, de


ecclesia in academiam et porticum...
18 : cf.
Theodoret. 1.19; Clem. Eel. proph. 56.2
20-22 ft 18:5-6; Clem. Eel. proph. 56.1;
57.3; Tert. Adv. Mare. 4. 11.7; Cypr. Carthag. Test, ad Quirinum 2.19; Novat. De trin. 13.4;
lust. 1 Apol. 54.9; Dial. 69.3
c. 18: 1-12 cf. Epiph. Pan. 50.1.1-3.5; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5. 23.1; 5. 24.6; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer.
8.1; Philastr. 58; Theodoret. Haer. 3.4; August. Haer. 29
2 s. Ex 12:18; Lv 23:5;
Nu 9 : 4 - 5
4 s. Dt 27:26; Nu 9:13; Epiph. 50.1.4
11 Mi (cf. v. 1):
addidi
scripsi:
15 ()() : (et ) Mi: Go Cr: ()() We
scripsi:

seclusi (cf. v. 14): Mi
16 in
mg. 1
17 addidi (cf. v. 11)
18
19 Go:

addidi
22 addidi e LXX
c. 18: 1 tit. 1
2 , corr. Mi
3 ' addidi ex Eus. Epiph.
4 , corr. Mi
addidi

del. Sauppe (cf. . 5)


5 add. Mi
6 scripsi:
7 : coniec. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

338

f. 8

Hippolytus

2 . , ()
.
/ ()
.
19 1

, , ,
, () , , ,
. - 5
, ' ,
, ' , ' [] ()
2 .
,
( ) .

,
,
.
is
3
,
() ,
. ( )

8 - 1 0 cf. Epiph. 50.2.1-3

9 s. Gal 5:3;

cf. Ps. Tert. 8.1

c. 19: 1 - 1 5 de Montanistis cf. Epiph. Pan. 48.1.1-14.2; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5.3 et 5.16-19;
Philastr. 49; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 7.2; Theodoret. Haer. 3.2; August. Haer. 26; Didym. De
tun.. 3.41 (PG 39, p.984 ss.); Hieronym. />.41; X. 25; P. de Labriolle, Les sources de
Vhistoire du Montanisme et La crise Montaniste (Paris. 1913) et al.
9 - 1 1 cf. Ps. Tert. 7
(p.224.16-22 Kr.); Epiph. 48. 8.1; Didym. De trin. 3. 41.2; Hieron. Ep. 41.4
14 : cf. Tert. De ieiunio 1.2 et 4; 2.4; 5.4; 9.6; 12.1; 17.7
16-18 cf. X. 26; Ps.
Tert. 1.1. Christum ipsum esse filium et patrem; Theodoret. 3.2; Didym. De trin. 18
(p. 881 B); 41 (p. 984 B); Hieron. Ep. 41.3 et al.
8 Cr:
NT
10 : N T

9 post add.

c. 19: 1 tit. 1
2
6 scripsi:
8 del. Mi
addidi
10 post . 11 , hue
transtuli
11 supplevi (cf. w . 8 - 9 )
post v. 12 , transposui
13 Mi:
17 1 addidi ex
18 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio VIII. 18.1-20.3

339

() .
20 , ' / 4
() () () ,
.

f. 9

, , 1 20
[] , ()
, () , ,
5 , ,
() ,
, 2
,
, ,
, , ,
. , 15 .
3
() , ()
'.

C. 20: 1-6 de Encratitis cf. Iren. I. 28.1 = Euseb. Hist. eccl. 4. 29.2; Epiph. Pan. 47.1.1-3.5;
Clem. Strom. 1. 71.5; Theodoret. Haer. 1.20; Philastr. 72; August. Haer. 25; VIII. 7 I
4 : cf. Theodoret. 1.20 ,
, , , . Clem. Paed. 2. 32.1; 33.1; Strom. 1. 71.5
8-15 1 Tm 4 : 1 - 5 ; cf.
VII. 30.3
21 addidi

23 . . . , corr. Mi

c. 20: 1 tit. 1
2 2 delevi
addidi
3
scripsi: : Mi
3/4 addidi ex Ir. (cf. v. 12)
4 -
6 addidi
scripsi: (cf. . 5)
7/8
9 NT
9-10
(cf. 1 Tm. 1:10; 2 Tm. 4 : 3 ; Tit 1:9 et 2:1): NT
11 -
NT: - Mi cett.
15
16
17
addidi
2 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

340

f. 9

Hippolytus

Ei , () ,
/ , () () 2
' [ ] , () [] ()
4 [] . '
() ,
() () , ()
() iv () (- 25
), ()().

19 : cf. Iren. I. 31.1-2; Epiph. Pan. 38.1.1-3.5; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 2 (pp.217.11218.2 Kr.); Theodoret. Haer. 1.15; August. Haer. 18; Philastr. 2
: Iren.
1. 30.1-15; Epiph. Pan. 37.1.1-9.4; Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 2 (pp.216.3-217.11 Kr.); Theodoret.
Haer. 1.14; Philastr. 1; August. Haer. 17
20 : non liquet; ft. cf. Epiph.
Pan. 26.1.4 et 7-9; Iren. 1.30.9-10; cod. Gnost. Berol. 8502.2, p. 73.2 ss. - N H II. 1,
p.29.3 ss.; II.4, p.92.9; V.5, pp.70.17 ss.; 71.15 ss.; 72.15 ss.; 73.1 ss.; 74.17 ss.; 76.12;
VI. 4, pp. 38.22 ss.; 41.1
19 Mi Cr: : Go We
addidi
20 coniec. Bunsen, Volkmar et Go, agn. Cr: : Mi
We: (') coniec. Go
2 addidi
21 seclusi ut dittogr. I
dele vi et addidi
22 scripsi:
Sauppe: :
Bunsen
Mi:
del. Bunsen
Mi et Bunsen:
: Sauppe,
23 addidi
24 addidi conl. IX. 6
.6

addidi
25 Cr conl. IX. 11.3: : Go, agn. We
coniec. Mi et We:
25/26 addidi conl. IX. 13.6
26 ()^ scripsi:
26/27 coniec. Mi: Go
27 ' (in fine versus)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

< )
()
, ()
, .
5
, , () ,
() , () ,
.
, ()
() ,
.
() , .

1
2
3

2 usque ad IX. 13.5 et IX. 31.1-2 ed. Wordsworth, .224-276 (pp.62-100


sec. ed.)
6 : i.e. Montanistae: cf. IX. 12.19; . 27.4; Euseb. Hist. eccl.
5. 3.4; 5. 16.14-15
I - suppl. Mi
scripsi: ) tit. 1 (post v. 11 ): tf Mi cett.
2
3 addidi
5 addidi
6 addidi
scripsi:
8 Wordsworth: I
addidi
9 addidi
9-10 , corr. Wordsworth
10
II : Go: del. Cr
add. Sauppe
: (servato ) coniec. Mi
post add. tit. et 5 1
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

342
6 1

Hippolytus

,
, ,
() ' , '
()
, [] () 5
.
, ()
.

pf. 7 1

/ , () ()
().
, ' . ,
() , , ' 5
,
2 , ()
,
(),
-
3 ' . - ()
,
() , - is

c. 6: 1 usque ad IX. 13.6 ed. Bunsen, pp. 363-379


c. 7: 1 : de Noeto cf. IX. 10.9-12; . 27; c. Noet. 1 - 8 (pp.235-249 Nautin);
Epiph. Pan. 57.1.1-10.9; Theodoret. Haer. 3.3; Philastr. 53; August. Huer. 36
3 , ', : cf. . 27; differt Theodoret. 1.1.
10 s. IX.
11.1-12.26
c. 6: 1 , corr. Mi
scripsi:
2 Chr. Petersen: :
Roeper: Bunsen
3
4 , corr. Mi
5 del.
suad. Cr
Mi: 1 , 2
6 scripsi:
c. 7: 1 addidi ex
3
5 addidi
7 add. Mi
8
9 scripsi:
() scripsi: :
coniec. Wordsworth
1 , - 2
10 Mi:
11 addidi
12 , corr. Wordsworth
14 addidi

15 -

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.6.1-8.2

343


(), ' .
' , 1 8
() ,
() ) ,
( ) (.
5 ) /
f.
, - (') , 2
()' . '
' () , () ,
(), ()
, (), .

17 s. de proverbio cf. 2 Pt 2 : 2 2 ; Semonid. Fr. 7.2 ss. W.;


Heracliti Fr. 13 DK (36 Marcovich); Paroem. Gr. I, p.376; II, p.705; Anecd. Gr. IV, p. 172
ed. Boissonade; Epictet. 4.11; 29; 31; Aristid. Or. 33.31 Keil; Lucian. Anachars. 1; Horat.
Epist. 1. 2.26; A. G. 14. 106.3
c. 8: 4 : cf. IX. 10.8

8 : cf. I. 4

17 addidi (cf. v. 15)


c. 8: 2 addidi
3 () Sauppe
addidi
4 ()
Mi:
addidi
, transposui
del. suad.
Go
() scripsi:
5 ( ) scripsi (cf.
v. 6): : Cr

6 ' addidi
7 ()'
scripsi (post Wordsworth.): : Wordsworth: '
Diels
8
9 () scripsi (cf. v. 3 et VII.
29.3 ): : () Mi: ()()0 coniec. Go: () We
10

() scripsi:
addidi
11 : , coniec. Sauppe. agn. We
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

344
9 1

pf. in1"
5

Hippolytus

, , , , ,
, .
, - 5
- ,
. ,
' ()() ,


, ()
, '
, - ,
.
, , - is
, ,
, , / , . () (*) , .

1 usque ad IX. 10.12 ed. I. Bernays, Rhein. Mus. 9 (1854), pp.


242-246 = Gesamm. Abb. (ed. H. Usener, Berel. 1885), I, pp.75-78; de cc.9-10 cf.
M. Marcovich in Stud. Patrist. 7 (T.U. 92, Berel. 1966), pp. 255-264
1 = 2 s.
: 4 =
2 s. : ft. cf. Is 45:13
; c. Noet. 4
3 s. Heracliti Fr. 50 DK (26 Marcovich 2 , Flor. 1978)
5-7 Heracl. Fr. 51 (27 M.)
8-12 Heracl. Fr. 1 (1 M.)
13 s. Heracl. Fr. 52
(93 M.)
15-18 Heracl. Fr. 53 (29 M.)
18 Heracl. Fr. 51 (27 M.), cf. w . 5-7
1 () coniec. Bernays, Diels, agn. Cr
3 Bernays:
[cf. V. 6.4 Usener: ; IX. 11.1 Go: ; IX. 24.1
Fl. Iosephi versio Slavica: ]
4 Mi:
Mi:
[cf. I. 15.2 Roeper: codd.; IV. 48.1 Mi: ]

5
6 , corr. Mi
7 Mi: :
Bernays
8 , corr. Bernays
Mi ex Heraclito:

9 , corr. Mi
, corr. Mi
10 1,
2
Wordsworth e Sexti Emp. Adv. math. 7.132 cod. :
(2 corr. ex )
11 Mi (cf. v. 5): : Sext. 7.132


e Sexto ( ) add.
Bernays
12 Mi e Sexto (cf. v. 5):
13 scripsi ex Luciani
Vit. auct. 14:
14 Mi:
() coniec. Mi
15 Bernays:
Mi
18 post lac. sign. Mi:
exspectes , : , - add. suad. We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.9.1-10.3

345

() [] ,
()
,
, ,
, , (), ,
, ( )
, , 6
, , ,
' , .
() 1
,
() , , [] ,
() - -, ,
, , . 2
,
, . ,
() , , ,

, . 3

20 Heracl. Fr. 54 (9 .); IX. 10.1


23 Heracl. Fr. 55 (5 .); IX. 10.1
25-29 Heracl. Fr. 56 (21 .)
27-29 cf. Marcovich, Heraclitus1, p. 55
c. 10: 3 Heracl. Fr. 54 (9 .); IX. 9.5
4 s. Heracl. Fr. 55 (5 .); IX. 9.5
7 s. cf. Hesiodi Theog. 123 s.
9 s. Heracl. Fr. 57 (43 M.)
19 () , ut v., Mi: ( ) We
post add. Wordsworth et Cr I
del. Wordsworth et We
20 ( ) Diels
addidi: add. Cr
21 , transposui
22
23 Mi: I
, transposui (cf. IX. 10.1)
24 post lac. sign. Go:
add. suad. We
2 , 1
28 Bemays (cf.
.29):
Cr
c. 10: 1 addidi
2
3 <) Mi: : Bernays
1 ,
2
-
del. Mi
4 addidi
, corr. Mi
5 : coniec.
Wordsworth
8 corr. ex 1
add. suad. Go, add. Cr (cf. v. 10)
10 , corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

346

pf.

Hippolytus

() ( ) ,
(), , - ()
-, / '
- -, ,
4 , , , ( ) is
- , , - ()

() - ,
, . , (,)
5 , (,) . 2
,
[] , ,
, .
6
()
, is
, .
, () , ,
(),

11-15 Heracl. Fr. 58 (46 .)


12 , : cf. Aeschyl. Agam. 849; Diog.
Laert. 3.85; Plat. Gorg. 456 b; 479 a; 480 c; 521 e - 522 a; Reipubl. 406 d; 426 b; Protag.
354 a; Tim. 64 d; 65 b; Polit. 293 b et al.
14 s. [ ]
Heraclitum scripsisse viderunt Wilamowitz (Hermes 62, 1927, p. 278) et Cl.
Ramnoux (Heraclite, Paris. 1959, p. 354): sensum vocum ('eadem atque') male
intellexisse, inseruisse et scripsisse videtur fons Hippolyti (cf. Marcovich., Heraclitus2, p.165)
16-19 Heracl. Fr. 59 (32 M.)
20 Heracl. Fr. 60
(33 M.)
22 s. Heracl. Fr. 61 (35 M.)
25 s. Heracl. Fr. 62 (47 M.)
11 addidi (cf. v. 15)
addidi
12 addidi (cf. w . 4 , 34)
13 : Bernays, agn. Bunsen, Diels, We
' Wordsworth
et Sauppe: , Bemays, Diels, We
: Bernays, agn. Bunsen, Diels,
We
Wordsworth et Go: , Bernays
14 Sauppe:
15 addidi
16 scripsi (cf. v. 17): , Mi, def. G. S. Kirk
(Heraclitus, Cantabrig. 1954, p. 97): Bernays, agn. Diels, We: Go, agn.
Cr, Bywater: Mullach
addidi (cf. w . 4, 34)
17
Bernays omnium consensu:
18 Roeper: ( - corr. ex - - , ut .) 1 : Bernays
19 et 20 addidi
20 () Mi
Bernays et Go

21 scripsi:
22 seclusi ut dittogr. (cf. v. 21)
24 1 addidi
27 add.
Diels
28 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.10.3-9

347

'
30 , () 7
, ,
.
, - - , .
35 ' , , 8
() ,
, () ' / .
40 () () , ,
, - () , (), () , ' .
() () 9
45 ,
, -

f. m'

29 s. Heracl. Fr. 63 (73 .)


29 cf. Hesiodi Oper. 122 s. et 252 s.; Plat. Crat. 398 a;
Reipubl. 469 a; Clem. Protr. 41.1; 103.2
31 s. Heracl. Fr. 66 (82 M.)
33 s. Heracl.
Fr.64 (79 M.)
34 cf. Mt 18:8; 2 5 : 4 1 ; / ^ 7
35 Heracl. Fr.65 (55 M.)
40-43 Heracl. Fr. 67 (77 M.); cf. V. 19.4; 21.2-3; X. 11.2-3; Anecd. Paris. I, p. 167.17
Cramer
44 () : cf. c. Noet. 3 ,
, ; 8 ; Philastr. 53 insensati cuiusdam nomine Noeti
29 ' Mi: ' : ' Wordsworth, Bemays, Bunsen
, corr. Bemays
30 addidi
31 - 32 post
v. 36 , hue transtuli post . Fraenkel
33 - 34 post
. 31 , hue transtuli post . Fraenkel
33 coniec. . Sauppe et
. Boeder:
34 , , transposui
35
, corr. Mi
38 add. suad. Go, add. We
39 Bernays: ()
40 Mi:
41 addidi
42 :
. Davidson {A.J.P. 5, 1884, . 503) et . Nestle
add. Diels: add. Gu.
. Heidel: add. . Fraenkel, agn. . Snell
addidi
, corr.
Mi
() Bernays, agn. Bunsen, Go, Cr, Bywater
42/43 : Wordsworth: ( ) Cr
44 scripsi:
addidi
() Bernays:
45 Bernays:
: Mi We
46 coniec. Mi, Bernays:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

348

Hippolytus

.
() () , 10 , () . ,
, ( , ) so
, ( )
() , () ( ), , ()
; () , ()< () ;
55
11

pf. 2

12

" ,
() ,
( ) ,
()() () , ,
, 6
, , '
,
(. ) , , () - ()
, 65
() [] / () . ()
( ) ( ) ()
()

47-53 et 57-71 cf. . 27.1-2; IX. 12.16-19; . 27.3-4; c. Noet. 1; 3; 7; Epiph. Pan.
57. 1.2; 1.8; 3.2; 3.9; 4.8; Jo 10:30; 14:10 et 17:22-23; Theodoret. Haer. 3.3 et al.
47 Wordsworth:
48 1 2 addidi conl.
scripsi:

48/49
49 addidi
50 Cr ( ): I
, ex et Theodoreto add. Go et addidi
scripsi:
51 2 addidi
52 addidi
Bernays ( Wordsworth):
Go ex et Theodor.:
52-53
ex et Theodor, add. Go ( add. Bemays, add. Wordsworth)
53 add. suad. We
54 () Mi et scripsi:
:
( ) We
() () coniec. We:
57 scripsi:
() Mi:
58 : () Wordsworth
addidi conl. v. 63 et . 27.2
59 Mi: ()
add. suad. We (sive delendum)
60
scripsi:
61 scripsi: (cf. . 62)
63 .
addidi
, transposui
64
addidi
66 addidi
delevi (cf. v. 67)
2 addidi
67 addidi et
add. suad. We
: Wordsworth et Cr

addidi ex

W o r d s w o r t h et C r :

68 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.10.9-11.2

349


. ()
() ,
.
, 1
, povov. ()
, -
(), -, () ,

() [ ] '
() (), ' () , , () ' , 2
, '
, .
, , '
.

De cc. 11 et 12 cf. I. Doellinger, . und Kallistus etc. (Ratisbonae 1853); A. Hamel, Kirche
bei H. von Rom (Guterslohiae 1951), pp. 59-76 et 113-127; I.-M. Hanssens, La liturgie d'H.
(Romae 1959), pp. 302-318, et in Archivo hist, pontif. 3 (1965), pp. 7-29; C. Beyschlag,
'Kallist und H.', Theol. Zeitschr. 20 (1964), pp. 103-124; . Richard in Dictionnaire de Spirituals' 44-45 (1968), pp. 534-536 et 568-571, et al.
3 cf. Act 4:13
7 cf. Prv
26:22
14 : cf. IX. 12.15-16
70 addidi

71 addidi

2
addidi: add. suad. Roeper
4 Go: :
Bernays (Ges. Abh. I, p. 81 n.), Roeper et Cr
:
Bernays: coniec. We
5
6 scripsi:

7 scripsi e LXX: :
Mi cett.
Mi:
8 addidi
seel, ut dittogr. Bunsen
' coniec. Mi, Bunsen: ' : ' Wordsworth
9 add. Mi (post add. Bunsen)
addidi
Bunsen:

10 addidi (cf. v. 8)
Go: coniec.
Mi, agn. Bunsen Cr We
11 addidi
12 scripsi:
13
coniec. Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

350

Hippolytus

pf. 3

( )
,
() , ,
, () . /
(, ) 2
( ) ,
() , , , .
4
() , , , 25
,

.
() ',
.
3

12 1

,
, , ,
, -
. 5

. 2 , () ' . () -

23 : cf. IX. 12.16; Tert. Adv. Praxeam 13.1 duo dii praedicantur; 19.8 et al.;
C. Preysing in Zeitschr.f. kath. Theol. 50 (1926), p.604 ss.; A. Hamel, o.e., p. 114 ss.
16 scripsi (cf. v. 4 s.):
, transposui

addidi (cf. v. 18)


18 scripsi:
(sc. . 16 )
scripsi:
19 addidi
20 , addidi
()
scripsi ex IX. 7.3:
21 addidi ex IX. 7.3 et supplevi ex coniectura
22 addidi
23
23/24
25 addidi
scripsi:
27
scripsi: , ut. v.: Mi: Wordsworth: We (conl. . 8)
Mi: : Wordsworth
28
29 1 addidi
c. 12: 3 : Wordsworth, agn. We
5 Sauppe:

() Cr
6
7 Mi (cf. w . 12,
38, i.q. 'non defuit qui'):
8 () We: : ()
coniec. Wordsworth
2 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX. 11.3-12.9

351

,
-
, () ()
. '
/. () 3
() ()-
is . ,
,
, ()
, 4
, ,
2 '.
.
, ,
, , .
25 , , ,
-
- ,
. ,
,
30 , ,
. ()' ,
() ,
, ' ()
35 , -

40

f. 3

/ , ,
() ()
, . 9
, , ()

f. ii4r

11 Roeper:
v addidi
Wordsworth et Roeper:
14 add. Wordsworth
15 scripsi:
16
17 , corr. Wordsworth
addidi
19 Klostermann: : del.
Sauppe
20 Bunsen:
21 Sauppe:
27 Mi:
29 Mi:
30 Mi:

31 scripsi:
() coniec. Go
(cf. v. 13)
34 addidi
37
addidi (cf. w . 3 1 , 42)
38/39 , corr. Roeper
40 () Mi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

352

10

11

12

13
f. 4

14

Hippolytus

, , , ,
,
, ' ,
.
45
, , ,
() , ,
, ' , () ()
so
, () ' . ,
, () )
' , 55
,
( ),
() () ()
.
/, ' , 6
- ' -, ()(),
, .
' , () ()() ()
() , ( ) 65

46 : cf. Dion. Cass. 72. 4.6-7


48 : episcopus eccl. Romanae XIII
(A.D. 189-198); cf. Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5.22; 5. 28.3 et al.
64 : episcopus
eccl. Romanae XIV (A.D. 198-217); cf. Euseb. H. eccl. 5. 28.7; 6. 14.10; 6. 21.1; IX.
7.1-2; 11.1 et 3 et al.
42 2 Mi:
47 - post , transposui

(hic et in v. 52) coniec. Go
49 addidi
oi addidi
51 , corr. Mi
52 Go:
53 addidi
57 supplevi (cf. w . 5 5 , 56, 59): add. Bunsen
58
addidi
60 scripsi:
61 . . . : . . .
coniec. Go, agn. Cr
62 () , ut v.
63 coniec. Mi
coniec. Mi: 2 , 1 , ut v.: Go
64
(
addidi
() scripsi:
65
addidi (cf. IX. 7.2)
: () coniec. Roeper:
Wordsworth
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.12.9-17

70

75

so

85

353

, () . ( ) ,
, , , ,
() .
() 15
, ,

(' ) [] ()
, 16
() ,
() ,
,
,
, , ,
( ) , (),
() () () , , 17
() . , () .
, .

71 Callistus episcopus eccl. Romanae XV (A.D. 217-222); cf. Euseb. . eccl. 6. 21.2; IX.
7.2-3; . 27.3-4
72 : cf. w . 7 8 ; 97; IX. 11.1-2; Epiph. Pan. 62.1.1-2.3;
Philastr. 54; August. Haer. 41; Theodoret. Haer. 2.9; G. Bardy in Diet, de thiol, cath. 10,
pp.2201-2208 (s.v. Monarchianisme) et al.
78 : cf. v.87 s.; IX. 11.3;
Tert. Adv. Praxeam 13.1; 19.8; C. Andresen, Die Kirchen der cdten Christenheit (Stutgardiae
1971), p. 175 n. 122, et al.
80-93 cf. X. 27.3-4
80-83 cf. Epiph. Pan. 62. 1.4
' ,
, , ;
Theodoret. 2.9
83 s. cf. Ignat. . ad Magnesios 14; Clem. Horn. 6.1
66 scripsi:
addidi
67 addidi
68 , corr. Roeper
70 (i.e. Callistus) addidi (cf. IX. 11.1 et 3)

71 () (i.e. Callistus) scripsi:
73 scripsi:
74 ' addidi
seclusi
() scripsi:
75 coniec. We:
76 addidi
: coniec.
R. Scott
77 addidi
79 Bunsen et Wordsworth:
81 supplevi ex IX. 10.11: add. suad. Wordsworth
(),
scripsi: v : Bunsen
82 () ( ) () scripsi:
83 addidi ex

84 2 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

354

18
pf. 115

19

20

21

Hippolytus

-
; , ,
, () , () ,
, , / , , ' -
() ,
() ,
. , , () ,
.
() , ( )
()
,
, , .
() ,
- ()
() , ()
' () , '
[ ] , , ,
, , () , ()
,
' ,
.

95

86 s. Jo 14:10; c. Noet. 7; Epiph. Pan. 57. 4.8; 62. 2.3; 7.7; cf. Jo 10:30 et 38; 17:22-23;
Tert. Adv. Praxeam 20 et al.
90 : cf. Lampe, s.v. ,
93-95 cf. Tert. Adv. Praxeam 29 directam blasphemiam in patrem veriti, diminui earn
hoc modo sperant..., si filius quidem patitur, pater vero compatitur. stulti et in hoc:
quid est enim compati quam cum alio pati?... times dicere passibilem quem dicis compassibilem.
87 post add. NT (et c. Noet. 7)
89-90 () scripsi ex IX.
10.11:
91 addidi
93 -
94
supplevi: add. Bunsen et Cr: add. Volkmar: add. Go: '
add. We
95 () coniec. Go:
96 : Bunsen et Scott I
() Cr
scripsi:
97 2 , - 1
1
99 addidi
100 <> scripsi:
101 addidi (cf. w . 102, 103) I
, corr. Mi
addidi
102 scripsi:
addidi
103 seclusi ut dittogr.
: coniec. Mi, agn. Cr
scripsi:

105 add. . Schwartz
scripsi (i. q. 'duram conscientiam
habentes'):
oi addidi
106 , corr. Mi
107
coniec. We (cf. v. 102):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

355

Refutatio IX. 12.17-24

, () ,
no , . () 22
. , ( )
) , ()
;
u s () / ()

f. iis v

, () . 23
() () , ()
() () ,
2 () () . ()
, .
()
, ) 24
, () ,
125 , ( )
, . , [] ( )(), () , () []

109-121 cf. . Rolffs, Das Indulgenz-Edict des rm. Bischofs Kallist (T. U. 11.3, Lipsiae 1893);
C . G . Preysing, Zeitschr. f . kath. Tbeol. 43 (1919), pp. 3 5 8 - 3 6 2 ; C. Beyschlag, Theol. Zeitschr. 2 0 (1964), p. 115 ss. et al.
13:29-30

114 Km 1 4 : 4 ; Tert. De pudicitia 2.2

116 Mt

1 1 7 - 1 2 0 cf. Gn 6 : 1 9 - 2 0 et 7 : 2 - 3 ; August, c. Faustum 12.15; Tert. De

idolatria 24 s.f.; Didym. Alex. De trinit. 2.14; Ps. Athanas. Alex. Homil. in patres et proph. 1;
Ioann. Chrysost. In Lazarutn 6.7; Cyrill. Alex. Glaphyra in Gen. 2 (I, p. 36 C ed. Aubert)
124 d.Jdth

9:7

110 G. Pasquali: : Mi
112 Mi:
add. . Rolffs (o.e., p.68 n.3)

116

addidi

121 () conieci

1 1 1 / 1 1 2

coniec. Mi:

(cf. w . 113, 118):


118 addidi

addidi

addidi (cf. w . 110, 115, 118, 119)

124 -

Bunsen: : ' We

addidi (cf. v. 112)

120 1 et addidi

122

115

() scripsi
addidi

addidi (cf. v. 123)

123 125

()

126 coniec. Mi: : Bunsen

127 [] Bunsen Go: : We

addidi (cf. v. 130)

1 2 7 / 1 2 8 ( ) ( ) Bunsen Go: : (} coniec. Mi, agn. Wordsworth, Roeper, We


Mi: Wordsworth, Go

128 add. Mi

<> W e : :

del. Wordsworth, Go: coniec. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

356

pf. ii6r

Hippolytus

, () , ,
, , 3
25 () . () ()
( )
,
, , ()
. , 135
,
,
26 . ()
() ( ) / ,
- ()- 4
, () ,
() , () .
' () , ( )
() () .

140 s. : i. e. post A.D. 222

129
Go:

C. Neumann: : Go
131 addidi

, corr. Mi

()
addidi

Roeper et
132 -

( ) Bunsen Go: : ( ' ) (amuletis) Roeper:


We
v. 128 ):
138 addidi

142 add. Mi

134 addidi
136 , corr. Mi

139 post , transposui

scripsi (cf.
137 -
addidi

141 addidi (i.e. 'non custodiens traditionem apostolicam')


, corr. Go

143 addidi

144 -

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX. 12.24-13.2

357

() , 1
,
, ,
, '
, () 2
, , ()
' - ' -, ',
' ( - - ) .
() ' -
-, ,

CC. 13-17: de Elchasaitis cf. . 29; (Theodoret. Haer. 2.7); Orig. ap. Euseb. Hist. eccl.
6.38; Epiph. Pan. 19.1.4-6.4; 30. 3.2; 30. 17.4-7; 53. 1.1-9; cod. Manich. Colon. (Pap.
Colon. 4780), pp. 94.10-98.8 ed. A. Henrichs et L. Koenen (Zeitschr. f . Papyrol. u. Epigr.
32, 1978, pp. 114-118 et 182-195 nn.272-295) = CMC; an-Nadim Fihrist 9.1 (II, p.811
Dodge); Gu. Brandt, Elchasai etc. (Lipsiae 1912); H. Waitz, 'Das Buch des Elchasai' in
Hamack-Ehrung (Lipsiae 1921), pp. 87-104; I. Thomas, Le mouvement baptiste en Palestine et
Syrie (150 av. J.C. - 300 ap.J.C.), Diss. Univ. Cath. Lovan., ser.II vol. 28 (1935); H.I.
Schoeps, Theologie u. Geschichte des Judenchristentums (Tubingae 1949), p.325 ss.; G. Strecker
in Realkx.f. Ant. u. Christ. 4 (1959), pp. 1171-1186 (s.v. Elkasai)\ I. Irmscher in HenneckeSchneemelcher, II (1964), pp. 529-532; D. Flusser, Numen 16 (1969), p. 147 ss.; A.F.I. Klijn
et G.I. Reinink, Patristic Evidence for Jewish-Christian Sects (Suppl. to NT, vol.36, Lugd.
Batav. 1973), pp. 54-67; A. Henrichs, Harvard St. in Class. Philol. 11 (1973), p. 44 ss.;
L. Koenen, Illinois Class. St. 3 (1978), pp. 181-190 et al.
2 : cf. X. 29;
Theodor. Haer. 2.1
6 : cf. CMC p. 95.8 (sc. )
et . Henrichs-L. Koenen n.278
:
(Method. Symp. 8.10); (CMC), et (Epiph.); ,
, ; Helchi (Praedestinat. 1.32 Oehler); Syr. 'Iks' (Theodor, bar Konai
Lib. scholior. II, p. 307 ed. Scher); Parth. 'Ixs' (M 1344 + 5910 ap. Gu. Sundermann,
Acta Orient. 36, 1974, p. 130); Arab. 'Ibsyh et Thsh (an-Nadim Fihrist 9.1): cf. Aram, hyl
ksy (i.q. [scripsi: Epiph. Pan. 19.2.2] s. Aram.
'1(h) ksy (i. q. ) et Gu. Brandt, o. c., p. 8; Henrichs-Koenen, o. c., n. 272 et al. I
7 : cf. CMC p.97.18 () (), Aram, sb'(i.q. 'lavare, baptizare'),
Brandt, p.42 s.; Henrichs-Koenen, n.290
: cf. Orig. ap. Eus. H. eccl.
6.38 (sc. ), ; Epiph. Pan. 19. 1.4 (sc. ) , ( addidi), .
7-13 cf. Epiph. Pan. 19. 4.1-2;
30. 17.6-7; 53. 1.9
1 addidi
2
8 (bis) et 9 , corr. Roeper
Epiph. 19. 4.1
10 addidi

6 addidi
7 addidi
9 supplevi ex
scripsi (cf. v. 8):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

358

pf. 6

Hippolytus

3 . , ()
,
.
()
4
. () () -
-, () (
) , () , () () ()
[] () ( )
/.
5 () , () () , ()
( ) . () ,

, ()
, () .
6
' ( ),
, (
)

is

25

13 s. Epiph. 53. 1.9


; 19. 4.1-2; 30. 17.6-7
16 : sc.
(. 6); cf. Epiph. 19. 1.4 (sc. )
, ,
.
16 s. - : i.e. A.D. 101; cf. IX. 16.4
18 : IX. 15.1-3
18 s. cf. CMC p. 95.1
12 Roeper
15 addidi
bis (ut saepius, cf. v.22):
Mi Bunsen: R. Scott cett.
16 . Hilgenfeld (NT extra canon. 3,
p. 158):
17 addidi (i.e. ' ) conl. IX. 12.26; 15.1 et 3 I
addidi
18 , corr. Mi

18-19 addidi
19 scripsi:
Sauppe:
19/20 ,
corr. Mi
20 addidi ex
Bunsen ex :
21 seel. . Ritsehl (Zs.f. die hist. Theol. 23, 1853, p. 583), cf. v. 17
addidi I
supplevi
22 bis
24 :
Bunsen
25 addidi
26

supplevi
27
29 addidi
30 add. Mi
31
supplevi
32 Mi: : Sauppe We
32-33
addidi
33 , transp. Mi
, corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

359

Refutatio IX.13.2-14.3

, ( ) ( ) 35 , ,
.
( ) , 1 14
() . () ( )
( ) -
5 () (), ,
, ( ) , .
, , 2
()
( ) () . , () , ( ) .
() 3
is () /

f. 7

. ,
, () (), ' ()
.

1-3 cf. Epiph. 19. 3.5; VII. 34.1; . 22; Iren. I. 26.2; CMC p. 91.6-9 et . Henrichs,
HSCP 77 (1973), p p . 4 7 - 5 6
3 - 8 cf. . 29.2; Theodoret. Huer. 2.7; Epiph. 30.
3 . 1 - 6 ; 53.1.8; Gu. Brandt, Elchasai, p p . 7 9 - 8 5 ; H.I. Schoeps, Theol. u. Gesch. d. Judenchristentums, pp.327 s.; 335 ss.; A. Henrichs, o.e., p.54 s.
9 - 1 3 cf. IX. 16.1-4;
X. 29.3; Theodoreti 1.1.
13 : cf. Ps. lust. Cohort, ad Graecos 38

14-16 IX. 15.4-6
34 addidi
1 addidi

addidi
2 addidi

36
3 scripsi:

addidi I

addidi
4 scripsi:
addidi
5 scripsi:


addidi
7 scripsi: I
supplevi conl. . 29.2
10 , corr. Mi
11 addidi I
Mi: 1 , - 2
17 () , corr. Mi

13 add. suad. Mi
1 7 / 1 8 addidi

14 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

360

Hippolytus

To () ' () ()
, , ,
() , (), , ,
, , , '
,
() , ()
2 , () . ()
, ()
,( )
()
'.
() ,
, .
, '
3 , , [
], ,
() , '

1 - 7 cf. IX. 13.4; Orig. ap. Eus. . eccl. 6.38 (sc. )


, '
; Theodoret. 2.7; Epiph. Pan. 53. 1.4; 9. 3.6; 17. 1.2-3; 30. 2.3-5; 30. 15.3; 30. 21.1;
CMC pp. 80.1; 80.23 ss.; 82.23-83.13 et . Henrichs et L. Koenen nn. 180, 187 et 197;
G. Strecker in RLAC 4 (1959), p. 1180s. et al.
5 s. cf. / ? r f 2 : 3 8
6 s. cf. Epiph.
19. 3.4
7-11 cf. w . 28-33; Epiph. 19. 1.6;
19. 6.4; 30. 17.4; Ps. Clem. Horn. 2.1 et 4.1; Bousset, p.227 ss.; Gu. Brandt,
Elchasai, p. 14 ss.; A. Lumpe in RLAC 4 (1959), p. 1093 (s.v. elementum); A. Henrichs et
L. Koenen, ZPE 32 (1978), nn.299 et 273 et al.
12 . . . : cf. IX. 17.1;
CMC p. 80.8 et . Henrichs et L. Koenen n. 183
14 1 Tm 5 :19; 2 Cor 13 :1; Mt
18:16; Dt 1 9 : 1 5 ; 1 7 : 6
1 addidi ex w . 5 , 18, 33 (i.e. ' )
() , ut v. (coniec.
Go): Cr: coniec. We: ' R. Scott
2 (cf. Epiph. 19. 3.7): coniec. Mi et ) Cr (servato )
3 () Scott:
, corr. Mi
addidi
4-5 '
Roeper et Scott ex v. 17:
6 2 add. Diels
3 add. Go
7 1 add. Go
coniec. We:
addidi ex v. 27
8 , corr. Go
addidi ex v. 28
9 supplevi ex v. 28
10 , corr. Mi conl. v. 29
12 addidi
, corr. Mi
15-16 seclusi ut glossema
16 , corr. Mi
coniec. We: & : Hilgenfeld (o.e., p. 159)
17
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.15.1-16.1

361

, []
( ) (*).
2
' ( ) - 4
, ( ) . '
() - - () ,
()
25 , / , () 5
,
. () ()
, ,
()
30 () . 6
, ,
, , , ,
'. ()
.

f.

() , 1 16
,
, () .
()
5 ;

18 s. : cf. w . 2 5 s., 33 s.; Epiph. 9. 3.6; 30. 2.5 et al.


20-34 cf.
IX. 14.3; Epiph. 30. 17.4; E. Peterson in Frhkirche, Judentum und Gnosis (Romae 1959),
pp. 221-235
25 : cf. Epiph. 30. 2.4; Qutnrn: Zadokit. Damasc. (CD)
10.10 ss. et al.
30-33 cf. Plin. Epist. 10. 96.7 et R. Merkelbach, Zs.f. Pap. u. Epigr. 2
(1968), p. 22; 21 (1976), p. 73 s.
18 delevi
scripsi:
19
supplevi ex w . 5-6 et 34
post () lacunam signavi:
exspectes ,
. conl. w . 7-11 et 27-30
20 ( )
scripsi ex IX. 16.1:
21 addidi ex 1.1.
scripsi: I
' Scott et Go:
23 () 2, -() 1 :
Roeper
24 addidi ex w . 26 et 34
25 : Go
add. Go
27 addidi ex v. 8
33 addidi (cf. v. 25-26)
c. 16: 1 addidi
Roeper:
scripsi: :
Mi
3 1 addidi
: Go: Cr
scripsi:

4 coniec. Mi:
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

362

pf.

Hippolytus

' ,
2 .
, -
[] ,
() ( ) , -
. ()
3 () , ()
, ' ,
.
, () (). is
4 , /
, ()
() (), [ ]
()
.
2
17 1

() () () (),
,
,
, .
5

6 cf. IX. 14.2


11-14 cf. Cleomed. De motu circ. 95 et 107 (pp. 172.11 et 194.15
Ziegler)
15 : i.e. dies Saturni, cf. Gu. Rordorff, 'Der
Sonntag', Abhandl. zur Theol. des A. u. N.T. 43 (1962), pp.30-36 et al.
16-20 i.e.
A.D. 117?; cf. IX. 13.4; Bousset, p. 156; G. Widengren in Suppl. ad VT 4 (1957),
pp. 197-241, et in Iranica Antiqua I (1961), pp. 117-162
c. 17: 2 s. cf. Mt 7:6; V. 8.33; . Thomae log.93
c. 16: 8 coniec. Mi (cf. v. 14):
8-9 , transp.
Cr
9 del. Cr
Go:
10 addidi (cf. v. 14) I
addidi (cf. v. 9)
10/11 , corr. Mi
11 addidi
12 , corr. Mi
() scripsi: : () coniec. Go

scripsi:
() scripsi:
14 coniec. Go
16 Mi:
, corr. Mi
17-18 ()
Roeper: ()
et 18 , seel, ut glossema Go: pro his ,
Hilgenfeld (NT extra can. rec. 3, p. 164 s.)
19 (cf. Orig. Hexapl., Prv 15:18, II, p. 342 ed. Field: concitat:
LXX: Aquila: Symmachus): Mi: corruptum We

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.16.1-18.2

363

( ) , 2
, (
) ( ) ' ()
,

, ,
[] ^ ; 3
()
() ()
is , .
' , ' ,
, - () -
( ) . 4
2 - (),
, /
, () ,
()() .

f.

1 18
() () ,
() ()-
. ,
5 , ,
, () .
2
, , '
.

c. 17: 7 s. cf. IX. 14.1-2

23 cf. J o 1 4 : 1

6 addidi (cf. v. 1)
7 - 8 supplevi
8 addidi
addidi
9
11 Cr:
12 del. Mi: &() coniec. Go, agn. Cr
13 () , transposui
14 addidi
18 ( ) scripsi: ( ) Mi

19 add. We et add. G o
20 :
Mi
21 Mi:
22 add. Mi
23
c. 18: 1 tit. 1
2 addidi (cf. v. 1)

G o (cf. IX. 5; 28.3; Act 2 6 : 3 ) : , def. Cr


7 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

364

Hippolytus

' ,
, , ().
, , , () () , . ' , , ,
' . ,
, ,
.

11 usque ad IX. 29.4 ed. . Smith in Hebrew Union Coll. Ann. 29


(1958), pp.294-313; usque ad IX. 28.3 ed. A. Adam in Antike Berichte
ber die Essener (Kl. Texte 182, Berolini, 19722, ed. Chr. Burchard), pp. 41-51
11 - IX. 29.4 confer Fl. Iosephi De hello lud. II. 8.2-14 = 11.119-166 ed. B. Niese; Iosephi
versionem Slavicam (ed. N.A. Mescerskij, Moscoviae 1958), pp. 252.16-257.7; Iosephum
ap. Porphyrium (De abstinentia IV. 11-13, pp. 245.11-251.5 ed A. Nauck 2 ) et ap. Georgium
Monachum (Chronicon VIII. 5, pp. 329.10-331.21 ed. C. de Boor).
12 Quae ad
Essenos spectant, ex Fl. Iosephi compilatore quodam Christiano Hippolytum hausisse
vidit P. Cruice (p.460 s.), ex Hegesippo vero credidit S. Zeitlin (The Jewish Quarterly
Review 49, 1958-59, pp. 292-299). At Hippolytum ipsum Iosephi de Essenis capitula ad
usum Christianum redegisse iudicat Chr. Burchard, pp. 23-41. Alii aliter (cf. Burchard,
p.3 s.). Sed confer Essenos quasi Christianos in versione Slavica et ap. Georgium, qui
Hippolytum non legisse videntur: e.g., cf. IX. 21.1, versionis Slav. p.253.6-10, et
Georgii pp.329.22-330.2 versus los. II. 128; IX.22.1 (vs. los. II. 134 ) et Georgii p. 330.3 (vs. los. II. 129 ) et sim.
12 s. exscripsit Catena in Act 21:37-38 (ed. Cramer, Oxonii, 1844, III, p. 355):
, . Cf. Chr. Burchard ap.
. Betz et al., Josephus-Studien (Gottingae, 1974), p. 81 s.
14 - 15
om. los. II. 120
16 s. pro verbis habet los. (11.120) ; at cf. vers. Slav. (p. 252.21)
i ucasce ja knigam; Georg, (p. 329.15)
(= Suda, s.v. 3123 Adler)
17 : cf. 1 Tm 4:3
18-20 pro verbis habet los. (II. 121)
11 : los.: est' versio Slavica (p.252.16)
Iosepho:
hie ubique
14 add. Mi
(i.e. adoptant) : Go: los.

12 scripsi ex
16
17 coniec. We:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX. 18.2-20.2

365

1 19
(), ' '
. () ' / f. 9
( ) -
5 ( ) - () ' 2
. , () ().
, () () ()()()(). .
(), ' . 1 20
, ,
, .

5 , , 2
, . .
- , .
, '
, .

c. 19: 3 s. pro verbis - habet los. (II. 122)


. Cf. Act 2:44-45 et 4:34-35; I.
2.16. Philon. Quod omnis probus liber sit 85-87; Qumrn: Manuale disciplinae (= 1 QS, ed.
M. Burrows) 1.11-13; 6.17; 6.19 s. et al.
4 s. - om.
los.
5 () : cf. IX. 25.1 ; 20.2 (los. II. 125
); 22.1 (los. 11.129 et 134 ) et Mebaqqer: Qumrn
1 QS 6.19 s.; Frr. Damasc. Zadokit. (= CD, ed. C. Rabin2, Oxonii 1958) 14.14-16 et al. I
5 s. ' : cf. Act 2 : 3 4
8 : los. (11.123; 129-131; 137); Philon. De vita contempt. 66; Ex 28:38-43;
Ez 44:17-19; cf. Qumrn: Bellum (= 1 QM, ed. D. Barthelemy) 7.10 s.
c. 20: 6 s. ... : cf. 1 Tm 2 : 9
7 s. pro verbis
(cf. Mt 10:10) habet los. (11.126)
...
c. 19: 3 et 5-6 ' om. los.
4 supplevi conl. Act 4 : 3 7 et
1.2.16
5 add. Mi
6 ()
7 ex Iosepho add. We
c. 20: 3 , corr. Mi (ciuzi i neznaemii versio Slav. p.252.31): los., coniec. We
4 Go: : coniec. Mi: () Cr
7
(obraz vers. Slav, p.253.1): los. (II. 126)
9 (cf. Porphyr. De
abstin. IV. 11 p.247.3 . ' ): los.
10 los.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

366
21 1

3
pf. 9

Hippolytus

,
() , () () * , ,
. , - -, 5
.
- () () . '
/ , , , () () (), ()
, ()
[] . , () ()() () , () () () -
- ()
, is
.

1 s. pro verbis (cf. IX. 30.4) ,


(cf. IX. 21.3; Act 16 :25) habet
los. (II. 128) -
, , (Philon. De vita contempt 27; 89; 1 QS 9.26 ss.; 10.10 et 13 s.; Qumran Hymn.
( 1 QH) 12.3-9 et al.). At cf. Georgium (pp. 329.22-330.2)
,
' et versionem Slavicam
(p. 253.6-10) I k" bozestvu blagoc'stivi sut' pace vsix. Malo ze pocivajut noic'ju i v"stajut' na
plnie, slavjatfe i moljtrfce boga. Iprez s'ln'c'nago v"sxoda nicto ze ne glagoljut', no tokrno molitvy
ot'i'skia k nemu vosylajut', jako moljaScesja vosianii ego.
5 - om.
los. II. 129
9 s. - om. los. (II. 130)
12 post addit los.
(11.131) (: LVRC, victus vers. Lat.; pisci vers. Slav.):
om. Porph. Georg.
14 : cf. Ex 28:39; Lv 6 : 3 ; 16:4; Ez 44:17
16 post addit los. (II. 132) ,
: om. et versio Slav. (p. 253.23)
1 Mi:
2 (et Georg, p. 330.2): los.
(II. 129)
2/3 () scripsi:
6 : los.: " inoi
vers. Slav. (p.253.14)
7 addidi ex los.
(= los.):
Mi cett.
8 : s. coniec. We

9 scripsi
ex los. ( ):
10 () , ut v. (cf. w . 16-17): Mi cett. I
Mi:
11 scripsi ex los.:
Mi ex los.:

12 seclusi ut dittogr. (om. los.)

13
13-14 , om. los.
14 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.21.1-22.2

367

,
, . ,
.
' () 1
,
.
, ,
' , ' ,
- , (, ,) ( ). 2
, () , ,
, .

c. 22: 2 s. post omittit nonnulla (los. II. 134)


3 s. pro
verbis habet los. (II. 135) ,
4 om. los. (cf. e.g. Porphyr. De antro 34
)
7 s. pro verbis - habet
los. (II. 136) ' (: LVRC), (differt versio
Slavica, pp. 253.35-254.2)
8-10 pro verbis -
habet los.
, at vero versio Slavica (p.254.3-5) Im ze znaema im" sut' zelia,
i koreni, i kameni, cto s"dr"zaetsja i na kotoru strast'potrebuetsja i nekyi ein", vidomo im" est'
ot tex pisanii
17 coniec. Mi:
18 coniec. Mi: ( los.):
Ios. (vers. Slav., Porphyr.)
c. 22: 1 ' &<v) coniec. Mi (cf. v.5):
2 scripsi ex los.:

6
, addidi ex los.
7 ex los. (
) add. Cr We
Mi:
8 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

368

23
pf. 2

Hippolytus

()() , () ()/ '


() , ()
() , ()
2 () () . ( ) ()- 5
() , ()
, () ,
,
[] , ( ) .

3
,
,

, , ()
[] . () , ( ) is
4 ( ) .
, ( ) ,

1-5: cf. 1 QS 5.7-13; 6.13-23; 7.18-21; CD 13.11-13; 15.5 ss.


2 verba om. los. (II. 137), at cf. Georgium (p. 330.20)
et los. (II. 138) = . 8
3 s. pro verbis
() () habet los. , at cf. versionem
Slavicam (p. 254.7) no pervee povettvatt' emu ziti v" predvratnei xramine
11: cf. 1 QS
5.7 ss.; CD 15.5 ss.; 1 QH 14.17 ss.
13-15 pro verbis
(cf. Mt 5:45) (cf. Mt 5 : 4 4 ; Lc 6 : 2 7 et 35),
(cf. Mt 5:44; Lc 6:28) habet los. (11.139) ' (cf. 1 QS
1.4 et 10): 'plane mutavit Christianus quidam' recte Cr
1-2 : & los. (II. 137), Porphyr., versio
Slav.: Iosephi codd. PA
Mi:
2 scripsi:
3 addidi
5 addidi ex Iosepho
6 et Porph. De abst.
IV. 12 (p.248.13): los. et Porphyr, ap. Euseb. P.E. IX. 3.11
Go
ex los.:
7 Mi ex los.:
addidi
9 del.
Mi (om. los.)
9/10 () scripsi ex los.:
13 scripsi:
14 addidi ex los.
et Porphyr, (p. 248.22): los.
15 del. Cr (om. los.): We: Go
() scripsi ex Porph.
(p. 248.23): : los.
addidi ex los.
16 , corr. Go
17 addidi ex los.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.23.1-24.2

369

() 0() () () . () , ()()
20 . () , ,
. ()
.
() () . 1 24
() ( ), ,
/ ' , 2
f. 2
, ()
5 (). ' ()() ()
( ) () , (
) () .

20 pro verbis (cf. 1 Cor 8:7) habet los.


(II. 141)
21 : cf. 1 QS 4.6; 5.15 s.; 9.16 s. et 21 s.
23 post omittit nonnulla
(cf. los. II. 142)
c. 24: 1 (): cf. Prooem. 3: los. (11.142)
7 :
cf. 2 Cor 2 : 6 : los. (11.144):
Porph. De abst. IV. 13
(p. 249.18)
18 () () scripsi ex coniectura conlata versione Slavica (p. 254.23-24)
i ukrasitsja izlixa odezdeju svethju, ni inoju krasotoju: ( corr. ex , ut vid.):
s. cum adiectivo, quod latet in coniec. Go: in
v. 16 post transtulit Cr: ' () los. (11.140)
() scripsi ex los.: I
() scripsi (cf. Georg, p. 330.14 ):
19
scripsi:
addidi ex los.
20 addidi ex los.
c. 24: 2 ( ) scripsi ex coniectura ( ' '
los. II. 143): (litt, evanidae 8) : () We I
scripsi ex versione Slavica (p. 254.31 to izdenut' iz domu) (cf. IX. 11.1
Go: ): : Mi ex los.
5
: los.
6 addidi I
() , transposui (
los. II. 144)
6-7 addidi ex los.
7 Mi ex los.: : Cr
ex los. add. Cr

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

370
25

f. 2

Hippolytus

, ' .
(),
, ().
, , 5
2 , .
.
()
- - , ' () 3 - . -
, - ,
- , ( )
() () is
() () , () (),
/ , .

4 Christianum redolent (cf. Act 4 : 5 et 8):


(i.q. harbbim) los. (II. 146):
solum A startiny posluZajut' versio Slav. (p.255.4)
5 : 1 QS 6.3 s.; 6.6 s.; 1 QSa
2.21 s.; C D 13.1 s.; Pirque Abot 3.6; Misbnab Sanhedrin 1.6 et al.
6 :
1 QS 7.13; Berakbot 3.5
7 : C D 10.14-11.18; Philon. Quod omnis probus
liber sit 81-82
10 om. los. (11.147), cf. e.g.
Hieronymi Comm. in Esaiam XV ad 56: 2 (C. Chr. Ser. Lat. 73 A, p. 630.23 Adriaen):
neque mim prodest sedere in sabbato, sive dormire, et epulis inbiare (et Burchard p. 38)
10-15 : cf. Dt 23: 13-15; 1 Q M 7.6 s.
12 : cf. IX. 23.1 (los.
II. 137)
1 : los.
2 ' Mi ex los.: '
3
addidi ( Ios.), post add. Cr
4 () coniec. Mi,
agn. Cr ( los.)
addidi ex los.
5
Mi:
6 Mi: ft
: los.
scripsi ex los.:
7
: coniec. We
8 , corr. Mi
() Go
ex los. add. Cr
9 addidi ex los.
10 scripsi ( los.):
11
coniec. Mi:
14 addidi ex los. (11.148), Porph. (p.249.23),
Euseb., Vers. Slav. (p. 255.13)
15
16 prorsus ablatum in
, ex los. restit. Mi
() litt, evanidas restit. Mi
17 Mi ex
Ios.:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.25.1-26.3

371

() () - 1
, () . -
(), , ()
() - ()
, , ' ,
. , 2
,
, ( )
, , , ()
, , .
,
() . - () 3
(),
, , ()() .
, ()
() ()

1 s. pro verbis - habet los. (II. 150)



2 : i.e. fortasse sacerdotes, levitae, laid et novicii: cf. 1 QS 2.19-23; 5.2 s.; 5.23 s.; 6.8 s.; 1 QSa 2.11 ss.; C D
14.3-6
2 usque ad v. 13 om. los. (II. 150)
3 s. cf. Ex
20:4; los. Bell. lud. II. 169-174
6 - 11 ex exscripsit scholiasta
quidam ad Act 21:38: cf. Burchard ap. O. Betz et alios, Josephus-Studien (Gottingae 1974),
pp.81-83
12 cf. los. 11.118 . . . fteov
; 11.433; Ant. lud. XVIII. 23
14 s. pro verbis
habet los. (11.150)
17 - 24 :
pro his habet los. (II. 151-153) , , , , ,
, , , '
(LVRC: ), . (152) ' ,
, , ' , , ' .
5 Mi: : We
6 scripsi:
8 ()
Cr
addidi (cf. w . 4 , 13, 22)
9 Cr
scripsi: I
Mi:
10 2 addidi
13 addidi (cf. w . 4 , 22)

We
14
15
Sauppe:
17 addidi

18 : Cr
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

372

Hippolytus

() () ( ) ( ) (
4 , ) / ( ) . - 2
, () ()().
, ()
, (), (), .

f. 2

27

'
,
. ( ) []
( )
() 5
2 . - ( )
' ( )
,


3 ,

(153) .
21
: cf. 1 Tm 1:5 et 19
23 : cf. 1 Cor 8:4, 7 et 10
c. 27: 1 " - 6 : pro his praebet los. (II. 154-156)
' , ,
..., ,
, .
, ',
, '
... " , ,
...
1 s.
: cf. IX. 28.5; . 34.3; 1 Q H 6.34-35 et 11.12-14 (ed. Sukenik);
Dn 12:2; Is 26:19
6 usque ad 14 om. los.
(II. 156)
19 addidi
() , corr. Mi
addidi ex los. ( )
22 scripsi:

add. Cr
add. We

19-20
addidi

c. 27: 3 addidi ( [sc. ]


los. II. 155)
2 delevi: Go: () [ ] Diels
4
addidi ex coniectura ( los.)
5 addidi (cf. v. 6)
6 () scripsi:
7 addidi
9 , transp. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.26.3-28.2

373

' ( )
, ,
. - ()
is .
() () () 1 28
, () (), [()()]
() , ()() /
f. 22
() 5 () , , . 2
() ()
() , , (') , ' , .
, () , . ()
() ().

13 : cf. IX. 28.5; 30.8; . 34.2; 1 Q H 3.24 ss.;


1 QS 4.13 et al.
14 s. cf. los. II. 159
c. 28: 1 - 12 () () (): pro his habet los. (II. 160-161)
" ,
, -
, , , , ,
. (161) ,
, . '
, ' .
, .
.
3 : cf C D 7.6-7; 11.11-12; 12.1; 12.11; 13.17; 14.10;
14.16; 15.5-6; 16.10-12; 1 QSa 1.4 et 9-12
12 supplevi (cf. v. 10)
Sauppe

13 scripsi:

14 ex los. add.

c. 28: 1 et 12 -
addidi
2 : los.

: We
()
()() , ut v., delevi
3 I
() , ut v., suppl. Mi
scripsi:
4 addidi ex los.
5 : los.
6 , genus humanum versio Lat.,
celovec'skyi rod versio Slavica (p. 256.25): los. (II. 160)
7 () evanidum
in , ex los. restit. Mi
8 ' addidi ex los.
8/9
9 los.
10 () Mi ex los.: '
11 2 add. Go
12
addidi conl. los.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

374

Hippolytus

, ,
( ,) ,
, is
, 4 , ,
()
, , .
2
5
, ' ,
() , ' , - ()
. ,
(), , 25
(), ()
.

13 - 27 : pro his habet los. (II. 162-163) '


, (163)
,
,
, (cf. III. 374; Ant. lud.
XVIII. 14; C. Apionem II. 218)
14 ( ): cf. los. Vitae 191
; Epiph. Pan. 16. 1.7 , '
(i.e. perushim), Ps. Clem. Horn. 11.28; Ps. Tert. Adv. omn. baer. 1; Origen. In
Matth. 23:23: Ser. 20
17 : cf. Ios. Ant. lud. XIII. 297; Hieronym. In
Matth. 3. 22:23 {PL 26, p. 163 D) Pharisaei traditionum et observationum, quas illi
vocant, iustitiam praeferebant; unde et divisi vocabantur a populo.
21 : cf. Ios. Ant. lud. XIII. 172; XVIII. 13; Vitae 12 (sc. )
' ; Epiph. Pan. 16. 2.1; Const, apost.
6. 6.3 (p.313.31 Funk)
25 : cf. I. 3.1; 21.4; IX. 10.7; 27.3; 30.8; X. 34.2;
Dt 32:22; Is 33 :14; Dn 7:10; Enoch 18:11-16; 2 7 : 1 - 3 ; 90:26; Jdth 16:17; 2 Esr 7:36
ss. et al.

13 Mi:
14 supplevi ex test,
superscr. 1
Mi:
18 addidi (cf. v. 19)
Mi: : () ('litigise') Go
25 addidi

16

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.28.3-29.4

is

20

375

(). 1 29
() () () () (), () / ( )
f. 22
, ,
. ()() () () 2
(), ( )
(), []
. ( ) ()
,
, ' . ' 3
[] , ,
'
, () .
, , 4
.
, ( ) ,
. , ' , () , .
.

1-4 cf. los. Bell. lud. II. 164-165


4 - 13 : pro his habet los.
(II. 165) ' ; cf.
Ant. lud. XVIII. 16; Mt 22:23; Mc 12:18; Lc 20:27; Act 23 :8; Ps. Tert. Adv. omn. haer. 1
10-13 cf. I. 22.5 (Epicurea)
14 cf. los. Bell. lud. II. 166
14-19 cf. Orig.
c. Cels. I. 49; In Matth. 17. 35 et 36; Hieronym. In Matth. 3. 22: 23 et 31 s. (PL 26, pp.
163 D et 165 B)
2 los.
3 et scripsi: et : et Go: ' los.
3 addidi ex los.
4
, transposui
5 ()() ut v., R. Scott: Mi
addidi
6 scripsi:
scripsi:
() Scott et Go: : Mi,
agn. Cr
7 scripsi:
delevi (cf. v. 17)
8 ( ) scripsi:
11 2 secl. Cr
We ex :
: Mi
13 addidi

scripsi:
16 addidi
18-19 addidi (cf. e.g. Clem. Paed. 1. 60.1)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

376

30 1

2
f. 23

Hippolytus

,
.
, , , .
() , (), () 5
/ (),
, ()() .
() , ), . ()
.

,
() () -
' (), , () ,

.
is
' ,
, ,
, ,
'
, - 2
. ()
.
- ()
() ,
, () 25

6 : cf. I. 19.4; VIII. 17.1; . 28; 32.1


13 : cf. los. c. Apion.
2. 154 et 156
18 : i.e. Levitico
18-20 cf. 1 Tm 4:3; Trad, apostol.
versionis hat. 76.16-20 ed. E. Tidner (T. U. 75, Berolini, 1963, p. 139) = Euchologion to
mega (ed. I. Goar, Venetiae 1730, p. 522) , , ,
21 s. cf. Act. 23 :8
23 : i.e.
23 et 34 : cf. Gn 49:10-12; Nu 24:15-19 I
24 et 34 : cf. Is 7:10-17; 9:1-7; 11:1-9; Jr 2 3 : 5 - 6 et al.
1
2 , transposui
3 post , transposui
5 () Go: () , ut v.: coniec. Scott: Cr
7 scripsi:
9 . Go:
12 () scripsi:

addidi
13 ' () Sauppe:
add. Sauppe

: Cr
17 scripsi:
19
scripsi:
21 ()
23 addidi
24
addidi: add. Sauppe
25 addidi: add. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio IX.30.1-8

30

35

40

45

377

() ()() , () (), ()
(). / ()
,
(), , ()
' .
6
, , ( ) ,
[] , ,
(), . - 7
, '
, ' ,
() ,
' , ,
() , - ()
,
. 8
' ( ) (),
() . '
,

.

f. 23

28 s. cf. Mt 1 6 : 3
36 cf. Ps Sal 17:21 ss.; 4 Esra 12:3134; Apc 5 : 5
45-48 cf.
2 Bar 29-30 et 39-40; 4 Esra 7 : 2 6 - 3 0 et 31-44; Fr. Zadokit. 9 : 8 - 1 0 R . H . Charles;
Dn 9 : 2 4 - 2 7 et al.
27 scripsi:
scripsi:
() scripsi: , ut v.:
Mi cett.
add. suad. G o
28 addidi (cf. w . 2 7 , 33, 38)
29
scripsi:
30 () Mi: (
.)
, COIT. Mi
scripsi:
addidi (possis et ( ) )
31 scripsi:
33 ( ) scripsi: I
scripsi: : G o : Cr
34 delevi
post
add. suad. vel. sim. G o
35 supplevi (cf. w .
26/27, 47)
, corr. Mi
38
40 addidi
41 ' addidi (cf. v.40)
42-43 scripsi:

43 scripsi:
44 scripsi:
addidi (cf. v.40)
scripsi:

addidi
45 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

378

Hippolytus

31 l
f. 24

()
() () () /
() () () , () 5
2 . () () , ) ()
, (
)
, () ,

.
is

1-15 ed. Wordsworth, pp. 274-276 (p. 99 s. secundae ed.)


11
: cf. . 32-34
14 s. cf. Mt 9:22; Rm 1:16; 10:9; 1 C o r l : 2 1 et al.
I addidi
scripsi:
2
scripsi: I

3 scripsi:
4 addidi
5 addidi
() scripsi: () Cr
6 addidi
7 Mi (cf. v. 11):

8 add. Wordsworth (cf. v. 9)
9 Wordsworth et Roeper:


addidi (cf. v. 12 )
II add. Mi
12 addidi (cf. v. 14)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

< ) I

.
() .
, .

1 - suppl. Mi et I scripsi (cf. v. 2 et X.5 v. 15): in mg. litt, rubr


3
4
add. Mi
Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services
Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

380

Hippolytus

5 1

f. 24

() ,
() ,
. ( )
, ()
() , ' () - 5
() (') ' ()
, / () ,
' () () , ' , 2 , .
()
() ,

.
15

6 1

' , () ,
,
.
, , 5
2 , () .
() , .
() ,
, [] -
3 , , , . ()

c. 5: 1 : cf. Photii Bibl. cod.48


c. 6: 8 - . 7.6 e Sexti Emp. Adv. math. 10.310-318 (c.5
) exscripsit
c. 5: 2 addidi

3 addidi et add. We
addidi
5/6 , ut v., corr. Mi
6 (') scripsi: () Cr
Mi:

10 () Go
11 2 addidi
addidi
13-14 , transposui

4
9
12 -

c. 6: 2 1 : 2 edd.
scripsi:
:
Cr
addidi: add. suad. Mi
3 scripsi:
: Bernays: Mi
4 scripsi:
5
6
addidi
7 addidi ex coniectura
scripsi:
8 addidi e Sexto
9 del. Go, om. Sext.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.5.1-7.1

381

oi , ( ) (), oi () , ,
. () () / (),
[] () ()(),
is .
( ) 4
- '
' (), , ,
, .
20 ' . () " , , ,

f. us1

- - ' , [] .

(), , , 1 7
() ",
,

20 et 22 : immo

24 Xenophanis Fr.27

c. 7: 3 Iliad. 14.201; cf. V. 7.38; VIII. 12.2; . Diels, Doxogr. p. 91 ss.


11-12 oi - e Sexto suppl. Mi
12 () (cf. . 7.1): Mi
cett.: Sext.
scripsi e Sexto:
13 scripsi e Sexto: I
Go e Sexto (cf. X. 7.6): Cr
14 , del. Go Cr,
om. Sext.: retinent Mi We
Go Cr e Sexto: Mi We
15 Go e Sexto:
16 e Sexto add. Go
Sext.
18 : Sext.
Mi e Sexto:
scripsi e Sexto: I
Sext.
18-19 , Sext.

19
Mi e Sexto:
20 et Sext.: Meineke

om. Sext.
e Sexto add. suad. Go, add. We
21
om. Sext.
. Sext.
21/22 : Sext.
22 et Sext.: Meineke
23 . ' Sext.
24 (et. Theodoreti Gr. ff cur. 4.5): Mi Cr e Sexto et al.
, om.
Sext.
' scripsi: : Theodoreti 1.1.: Mi Cr
e Sexto et al.
del. Mi Go, om. Sext.
c. 7: 1 1 superscr. 1
, e Sexto corr. Mi
om. Sext.
2
3 Mi:

1-2 -

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

382

Hippolytus


' () .
2 () '
() () ()().
() ,

.
3 ,

() '
', () .
4 ( ) () () () ()() / , ( ) () .
.
,

5 Iliad. 7.99
7 Xenophanis Fr. 33
doclis Fr. 6; cf. v. 20 et VII. 29.4
(Neue Pbilol. Unters. 1, Berolini 1926)

10 Euripidis Fr. 1023 N. 2


12-14 Empe15 cf. Ocelli Luc. test. 4 et p. 32 s. R. Harder
20 Emped. Fr. 6; cf. v. 12

4 Cr e Sexto:
5 e Sexto et Horn. add. Mi
6
sic , e Sexto corr. Mi
' Sext.
7 et e Sexto add.
Mi
, e Sexto corr. Mi
8 () Go e Sexto:
: Sext.
11 Sext.
om. Sext.
12 (et. Sext. 10.317; Aet. 1. 3.20): Sext. 10.315 et 9.362
13 <)
scripsi ex Ps.Plut. Plac. 878 A (cf. v.8 et DK 31 A 33; Doxogr. p.287): : om. :
Cr e Sexto
14 ' scripsi e Sexto: : , ' Cr
, corr. Cr
Cr e Sexto et :
coniec Mi: : Cr We
e Sexto
() A.B. Krische, . Stein et Cr e Sexto: ()
:
15 " Mi: : et
Sexti codd., corr. Fabricius
16 Mi e Sexto:
17 ( )
Go e Sexto:
scripsi e Sexto:
18 (cf. . 20): om. Sext.
20 Cr e Sexto: : Mi
Sext. 10.317: Sext. 10.315
om. Sext.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.7.1-7

383

' , ,
(), ,
[] () ,
, , , , , .
,
- . - ' Ava- 6
,
- -,

(), - . () 7
, , ,
, , , ( ).

22 s. Emped. Fr. 17.19-20; cf. VII. 29.9


I. 8; I. 13; I. 22
33-36 cf. I. 19.1-2

24 s. cf. VII. 29.7

26-28 cf.

22 , e Sexto corr. Mi
23 Mi e Sexto (10.317) et Athenag. Legat. 22.2: : Sext. (9.10), Simplic.
Mi e Sexto: I
Simplic.: Sexti codd. (9.10; 10.317), corr. Hervetus et Bekker (et. Plut. A mat.
756 D)
24 del. Go, om. Sext.
: Sext.
scripsi
e Sexto:
2 addidi e Sexto (cf. v. 25)
25 , transposui conl.
Sexto
26 : Sext.
: Sext.
28 - om. Sext.
30 om. Sext.
32 e Sexto add. Go I
Go e Sexto:
33 add. Cr
36 addidi conl.
I. 19.2 0

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

384

8 l

f. 26

Hippolytus

, () , () , (), ()
( ) (),
/ ' () 5
.

9 1

' , . () ()
, () , [] , , , , .
2 [] 5
. () (),
, ,
3 ' .
() () (), , ,
, , , ,
, , , '
, , () , , , .

c. 8: 1 - 3 : pro his habet Sext. Adv. math. 10.319



, .
c. 9: 1-3 cf. V. 6.4

3-14 cf. V. 6.6-7.1

c. 8: 3 , corr. Mi
Go: add. Cr
) scripsi:

5 : cf. V. 6.5 et al.

2 addidi
4 addidi: add. suad.
add. suad. We

5 (sc.
6 () conieci (cf. v. 5)

c. 9: 2
addidi
3 1 addidi

4 1 dele vi,
om.
5 del. Bemays, om.
Bemays ex :

, transposui conl.
6
addidi
addidi ex
9 addidi ex
Go:
() R. Scott et Bemays ex :

addidi ex (cf. v. 10)
12 Mi:
addidi
( )
Mi:
13 :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.8.1-10.4

is

20

385

Oi , () () , - -,
() . () () ' ()
[ ] (), () ,
() ,
/ ' ( )
,
() () , ( ) . ,
(
.) , ,
, ,
, ( ) .
, ,
,
, ,
[ ] ,

().
, ,

1 10

2
f. 2 6

1-29 ex Hippolyt Theodoretum (Haer.fab. comp. I. 17) excerpsisse vidit I. Bernays (Ges.
Abb. I, p.303)
1-30 = V. 12.1-7
20 s. Col 2:9; V. 12.5; VIII. 13.2; Iren.
I. 3.4; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 31.1
1 et 30
et. Theodoret.: IV. 2.1: V. 13.9 I


2 add. Mi
2
1
om.
3
ex add. Mi
2 Mi:
4
hoc loco et Theodoret. (error in Hippolyti fonte): in v. 6 transtul. Go I
Mi Go: :

scripsi:
() , ut v.: edd.: Theodoret.
6 : Go, agn. Cr
cf. . 4
8
addidi ex
Bernays ex : Theodoret.
8-9
supplevi ex : om. Theodoret.
9 addidi ex et Theodor.
10 - 11 ex add. Bernays: om. Theodor.
13 addidi
ex
16 scripsi ex et Theodor, (cf. Mt 2:1; Lc 1:5): (cf. . 16)
17
19 , ex () corr. Go
del. Bernays
21 , corr. Bernays
scripsi ex :
22 : Theodoret.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

386

Hippolytus

qj ,
, () ,
5 , , 25
, ' , () () ,
, ()
(), () ,
() .
3
11 1

f. 27

() () , ( ,
, )
[()] (), ()- 5
/ , (, ) ()
() [] , (), ()
2 , , , () . ,
, , ,
, () ,
, '
,
3 .
, () u
()
e l l : 1-28 = V. 19.1-6

3 s. cf. V. 19.1; VI. 12.4 et 16.5

c. 10: 23 Bemays ex :

24 1 ex
add. suad. Go
25
27 addidi ex
Sauppe Go:
:
(om. ): coniec. We (conl. Theodor,
)
:
28 scripsi:
addidi
29
scripsi ex :
, COIT. Bernays
30
addidi
c. 11: 1
2 post lac. sign. Bernays, quam explevi ex
5 del. Bernays, om. (cf. . 7)
6
addidi conl.
()
ex add. Bemays
addidi ex
7 add. et
del. Bernays (cf. v. 5)
scripsi ex :
addidi ex
8 ( ): () Diels
11 1 addidi
om.
: Go cett.
12
13 , ex corr.
Bernays
Go ex :
14 Mi: (om. )
15 scripsi:
add. Bemays ( )
16 addidi ex I
scripsi ex : Cr: Bernays

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.10.4-11.6

20

25

30

35

40

387

, ,
(), ()
, ,

.
, () 4
() .
, '
, , , , , ,
, ()

.
() , 5
( ) ,
,
( ), ' ()
(), () .
- () () ,
( ) - 6
/ , '
, ()
, () , () ()
,
, , ()
, ()
, .

f. 127

29-42 cf. V. 19.7-12


17 post , transposui conl.
18 1 addidi ex

2
, transposui conl.
addidi ex
20
, transposui conl.
22 ex add. Mi
23 addidi ex
25 Roeper: P H
26 () Bemays: :
Bemays:
(om. )
29 addidi
30 addidi ex : add. Bernays
et We
32 supplevi conl.
33 addidi
34 () scripsi (cf. w . 4 1 , 42): Bernays: ()
35
supplevi
36 , corr. Mi

We:
: () Go
37 addidi
38 addidi
,
corr. Mi
addidi (cf. w . 2 9 , 43, 49 et al.)
39
40
: Bernays et Cr conl.

addidi
ex
41 addidi ex

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

388

7
8

10

11

Hippolytus

, ()
() ,
,
, , () ,
. ()
, () ()
( ) () , . () ,
() ,
, ( ) ,
. ,
, .
,
, () ,
( ) , ,
() , () () (). ()

, , ()
. () () , '

43-64 cf. V. 19.13-21


54 s. Ps 28:3; V. 8.15; 19.16
V. 19.20-21; 21.9; Theodoret. Haer. I. 14 (PG 83, p.365 D)

62-64 Ph 2 : 6 - 7 ;

43-44 Mi ex :
44 Mi ex :
46 scripsi:
Bernays ex :
We conl. (): : coniec. Go
coniec. Go:

Bernays:
46/47 () Bernays:
48
coniec. We:
() scripsi: : () coniec. We
49 Go:
post 48 , transposui
add. We I
del. We
addidi
50 2 addidi
51

add. suad. We
52 scripsi ex (V. 19.16):
scripsi ex :
: Bemays et Roeper
add. Bernays
53 Bernays:
add. Roeper et Cr
addidi
57 2 addidi
scripsi ex :
58 :
Hilgenfeld
ex add. Cr
: : Roeper
59 addidi
() () scripsi et addidi conl.
V. 19.16: : ( ) Go, agn. Cr We
addidi ex
post 60 , transposui conl. V. 19.20
60 , corr. Cr
60-61 : Bernays ex
62 addidi
63 Mi:
corr. ex ^

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.l 1.7-12.4

389

() / , ()
65 () .
.

is

20

() ,
() , []
, , ' ,
[] , ' ()
, ()
,
.
, , , ,
. , ,
, , ,

, ( )
, , ",
. ( )
(, ,
) . ( ) , () , , , ,
() ,
() ,

c. 12: 1-8 - VI. 9.4-6


VI. 12.1; VII. 29.26
64 ex add. Roeper

9-24 = VI. 12.1-4

f. 28

1 12

10 cf. Empedoclis Fr. 110.10;

65

c. 12: 1 addidi ex Theodoreto (Haer. I. 1, PG 83, p. 344 C)


2 1 addidi ex
Theod.
om. H, del. suad. We
3 ' , corr. Mi
4 (i. e.
) om. , del. Mi
5 addidi ex
6 , corr. Mi
2 addidi
ex
7 1 Scott ex :
10 Mi: : om. I
G. Volkmar et Go ex :
12 Go ex :
13 addidi ex
: Go Cr
14
: " Wordsworth ex Theodoreto
(p. 344 C)
15 addidi ex
16-17 - ex
suppl. Bernays: add. Go
17 Mi: : om.
ex add.
Mi et ex add. We
17-18
18 addidi ex
19
ex add. Go
Mi:
20/21
21
Go ex :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

390

Hippolytus

, , , ,
() ()
, .
() , 25
. () .
13
pf. 28

()
() , /
( ) ,
() ,
2 , . ( 5
, ) , , , ,
. ( ,) () "
() (
) () , ()
3 ", . ()
( ) (), ,
, ' .
is

c. 12: 25 s. cf. VI. 19.4; 18.3 et al.


c. 13: 1 - 5 cf. VI. 29.2-3; 38.5
5 : cf. VI. 30.7; 37.5 et 7-8; 38.4-5; Iren.
I. 1.1 et al.
5-8 cf. VI. 29.6-7; Iren. I. 1.1
8 : cf. Iren.
I. 1.1 , ; VI. 38.3 I
8-11 cf. VI. 31.5-7; differt VI. 37.5-6
10 : i.e. 8 + 10 + 12 - 30 aeones:
cf. Iren. I. 1.2; VI. 30.3-5; Sagnard, p. 145
: i.e. s. ,
,
: i.e. , ,
11 : cf. Iren. I. 2.4; 3.5; 4.1 et Sagnard, pp.250-252
11-15 cf. Iren. I. 5.1-2
- Epiphan. Pan. 31. 18.3-8
c. 12: 23 ( ) scripsi: : Mi
ex add. Mi
24 Go:
: om.
Roeper:
Go:
c. 13: 3 addidi ex VI. 29.3
4 addidi ex I
coniec. We ( ):
5 - 6 , addidi
scripsi:

8 addidi
() Mi:
9 add. suad. Mi
9-10 add. Cr
10 2 addidi
( ) Mi:
11 () scripsi:
11-12 post lacunam susp. Go, quam explevi conl. Iren.
I. 5.1
12 Go:
13 addidi (cf. v. 19)

corr. ex - 1
14

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

391

Refutatio X.12.4-14.3

(
) , ,
. , 4
() .
( ) , '
, .
, 1
, ,
( ,) , ,
, ,
.
, (- 2
) ,
.
, (), ,
() , ,
() , , () (). 3

c. 13: 16 s. cf. VI. 3 5 . 3 - 4

18 Eph3A6;Rm

7 : 2 2 ; 2 Cor 4 : 1 6 ; Iren. I. 5.5; 21.4;

2. 30.7; 5. 19.2; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 51.1; Paed. 2. 45.3; V. 7.36; VI. 34.5 (v.25, q.v.);
40.2; VII. 27.6; X. 19.3 et al.

20 Gn. 3 : 2 1 ; cf. Iren. I. 5.5; 3. 23.5; Clem. Exc. ex

Theod. 55.1; Strom. 3. 95.2; Tert. Adv. Vaknt. 24.3 s.f.; Adv. Marc. 2. 11.2; Pistis Sophia 69,
pp. 97.24 et 98.38 S.-T.; In Gen. Fr.6 Achelis et al.

2 0 Eph 4 : 2 2 ; Clem. Paed.

1. 32.4; 3. 17.2; Strom. 3. 28.2; 7. 14.2; Eel. proph. 24.1; Iren. 5. 12.4 et al.
c. 14: 1 - 8 cf. VII. 2 1 . 3 - 5 ; 22.6

9 - 2 1 cf. VII. 2 2 . 7 - 1 0 et 16

c. 13: 16 scripsi:
supplevi ex VI. 3 5 . 3 - 4
dum

1 6 - 1 7
19 scripsi:

20 addidi

c. 14: 1 tit. litt. rubr. 3

: () coniec. Go I

coniec. We:
, corr. Go

4 : coniec. We

7 Go ex :

coniec. Mi conl. :
Mi et Go ex :
Mi

2 v G. Uhlhorn:

addidi ex VII. 21.3

, corr. Mi

6 scripsi ex VII. 22.6:


supplevi ex

post ft. adden-

21 addidi

5 coniec. Mi:

6 / 7
( ) Go ex

Uhlhorn et Bernays: P H
11 addidi ex

9 ()
10

, ex corr.

, corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

392
f. 29

Hippolytus

, /
, (),
- ' () , is
, ,
, -
-, -
.
()) - 2
, .
( ) , ()
' ( ) ,
, ( ) . () 25
() ,
, .
,

() ( ), 3
.
()
, () , . ( ) . 35
() ,
, () ', '

22-42 cf. VII. 23.2-7 et 24.3-5


13 , transp. Go conl.
14


15 Go ex :
18 , corr. Cr
19 Go ex :
Go ex :
20 addidi ex VII. 22.16
21 Mi:
22 addidi
ex
2 addidi ex
Go ex :
23
ex add. Go
24 Mi:
24-25
addidi ex
25 addidi ex
26 1 addidi ex

30 addidi ex
addidi ex
32
Go ex :
33 , corr. Mi
addidi ex (cf. v. 37)
2 scripsi: : om.
34 : coniec. Sauppe
34/35
addidi ex
35
36 addidi ex
37
38 Go ex :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.14.3-15.2

393

, ()
40 . 9
() . ().
<> () (), ()
45 () () (),
/
. 10
( ) , () [] ()
(),
so , ()
. ,
. .

f. 29

() 1 15
, , () .
,
, ,
5 , - , , ( ). - () , , 2
, -
- () ()

c. 14: 41 s. cf. VII. 26.6

43-52 cf. VII. 26.8-10

47-49 cf. VII. 25.2

c. 15: 1-17 cf. V. 26.1-6


c. 14: 39 Go ex :
scripsi ex :

addidi ex
40 : conieci
41 addidi conl. v. 7
43 ex add. Go, agn. Cr
, transp. Cr
addidi
44 addidi ex
45 1 addidi ex VII. 26.1
add. Go
2 addidi ex VII. 26.5
47 scripsi:
48 Go ex
:
addidi ex VII. 25.1 et 5; Rm 8:19
addidi et
delevi (cf. . 50): pro Go
addidi (cf. v. 51)
49
addidi ex
50 () scripsi (cf. v. 48):
52 scripsi:
c. 15: 2 () Go ex : : Cr
4 Go We: Mi Cr

6 addidi ex V. 26.2
ex add. Go
7 :
8 add. suad. We

scripsi:
addidi ex

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

394

f. 3

Hippolytus

, ().
() , , '
.
, () ()
() (*) ( ) , . ( )
( ,)
.
,
( )
( ,) ( ), - , ( -
- ) .
(*)
. ' [] () ,
. ( )
, () , ()
, . /

18-23 cf. V. 26.7-8


26-28

24 s. cf. V. 26.14-16

is

25

25-32 cf. V. 26.19-21 et

9 Go ex : : () Cr
, corr. Mi
10 addidi ex
11 :
13 addidi
addidi ex
14 addidi
ex
post lacunam signavit Mi: exspectes , ,
, , (*) , '
, , , , , , , , ,
, , (cf. V. 26.3-4).
addidi ex et
ex add. Mi
14/15 , corr. Go
15
addidi ex
16 add. suad. Go conl. V. 26.6
19
scripsi ex (cf. v. 19 ):
addidi ex
20
addidi ex
20-21 addidi ex
21 1 Roeper:

coniec. Sauppe
:
22-23
- - supplevi: add.
Roeper Go
24 post lacunam signavi: exspectes sive (conl. V. 26.15 . 77 ) sive
(conl. V. 26.15 . 76)
25 , corr.
Go
2 del. suad. Mi
27 addidi ex V. 26.21
28
add. Cr (cf. v. 34)
29 Go ex : Cr

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

395

Refutatio X.15.2-16.3

,
' - , () . ' [] ,
, . 7
, ,
() ,
() ( )
, ,
.
1
, ,
. ,
() ,
( ) , ( ),
() ,
. , () 2

, [ ] ( ) , ( ) ,
() , , .
() , - 3
,

c. 15: 3 3 - 3 7 cf. V. 26.29 et 31

33 cf. Mt 2 : 1 ; Lc 1 : 5 ; V. 16.10; 26.29 et al. I

39 s. cf. V. 26.7
c. 16: 1-11 cf. VIII. 8.3; 5; 7; 9.2
c. 15: 31

addidi

37 , transposui
addidi (cf. v. 39)
c. 16: 1

1 2 - 2 6 cf. VIII. 9 . 3 - 7 et 10.1


33 2 del. Mi

38 addidi

39 scripsi (cf. v. 39):


3 scripsi ex : I

5 scripsi ex : : Go

4 addidi post Go ()

addidi

spatium litt. 6 : , add. suad. We


addidi ex

36 addidi ex

add. Go et

post vacat

6 addidi

8 coniec. Go conl. :

9 secl. Cr, om.

9 / 1 0 Mi:

ex

Mi ex :

posui

, Mi:

11 addidi ex

(> scripsi:

10 1 addidi
, trans-

Mi ex :
12 addidi ex VIII. 10.3

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

396

f. 3

Hippolytus

() ()
() ( )
4 . ,
, (),
() , ,
5 () ,

/ , () [ ] []
. ,
, .
( ) (),
() ().
6
() ,
' . ()

( ), ()
().
.

is

25

20 Gn 1:4; VIII. 9.5


23 s. cf. Ex 3 : 2 et 4; Dt 4:24; 9 : 3 ; V. 7.31; VI. 9.3;
32.8; VII. 38.1; VIII. 9.7; X. 20.1; Clem. Exc. ex Theod. 38.1 et al.
27-32 cf. VIII.
10.3; 5 et 7
14 addidi
addidi
15 () scripsi:

scripsi:
addidi ex
hic et v. 21
16 Mi:
() Go, agn. Cr We
, transp. Cr (cf.
v. 18)
superscr. 1
scripsi ex :
17 scripsi ex
:
18 :
21 post lacunam signavit Mi,
agn. cett. (quam ex VIII. 9.6 e. g. explendam esse censuit We): at cf. v. 21 s. ...
22
scripsi (cf. w . 1, 23, 27, 31):
add. suad. Go
secl. Cr I
Roeper et Go ex :
2 delevi (om. )
23 coniec. Go (
):
24 : coniec. We
25 addidi (cf. v. 13):
add. Cr
() coniec. Mi:
26 et supplevi
ex VIII. 10.1 ( )
27 Mi:
Mi:


28 addidi (cf. v. 31)
30
addidi ex VIII. 10.3
() scripsi ( ): : & Mi, agn. Go Cr: () We
, transposui
31 addidi
32 post fortassis excidit
( = VIII. 11.2)

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.16.3-17.4

397

Oi () 1
() ()
(), ,
, ' , (), '
() . - 2
, , [] ,
' , , ,
, - () , [] () (),
[ ] () [] , () [
] ( ) , .
, 3
, ( (*)
,)
. ( )
[ ],
, , , ,
,
, ( ), , , 4
() ( ) ,

1-11 cf. VIII. 12.2; 13.1; 13.4


12-22 = VIII. 14.1-3
15-17 cf. Plat. Tim.
55 a - 56 b; Tim. Locr. 98 d ( 35 Marg)
19-22 cf. Ex 7:8 - 11:10; V. 16.8;
VIII. 14.3
1 tit. litt. rubr. 3
scripsi:

2
addidi ex
addidi ex
3 addidi ex
Mi Go Cr I
scripsi ex :
4 ' scripsi ex :
addidi
5 addidi ex
scripsi ex :
6 delevi
8
scripsi:
scripsi:
scripsi: : coniec. We I
addidi (cf. v. 5)
scripsi:
delevi (om. )

scripsi:
9 seclusi (cf. w . 19 et 26)

scripsi:
seclusi ut dittogr.
scripsi:
9-10 del. suad. Go, del. Cr (cf. v. 10)
10 < ) Go Cr ex VIII. 13.4:

13 post lacunam signavi, cuius partem ex VIII. 14.1 explevi
(sed lacunam in lacuna habes)
15 addidi ex test.: om.
16 del. Mi, om. : coniec. Roeper, agn. Go
18 Mi ex :

19 addidi ex VIII. 14.2 (. 9), cf. . 9
,
corr. Mi
20 addidi ex
20-21 ( ) ,
supplevi ex : () , post R. Scott
et Roeperum coniec. Go

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

398

pf. 3

Hippolytus

, () ()
() () ( ) .
5
Ei , , ,
/ , , ( ) ()
() () - 25
(), , , [] , .
18 1


, ()
() .
() []
( ) .
5

19 1

()
, , .
( ) , ,

c. 17: 23-27 cf. VIII. 15.1-2 (Monoimi ep. ad Theophrastum)


c. 18: 1-5 cf. VIII. 16
c. 19: 1 : cf. VII. 10; 37.1; Iren. 1. 27.2; 3. 4.3; Epiph. Pan. 42. 1.1; 3.1;
Tert. Adv. Marc. 1. 2.3; 4. 17.11; Ps. Tert. Adv. omn. haer. 6; Philastr. 45.1 et 3; Theodoret.
Huer. 1. 24 (pp. 372 D; 373 B); A. ab Harnack, Marcion2 (Lipsiae 1924), pp.31*-39* I
2 ... : cf. VII. 31.2 (Prepon); Rhodon. ap. Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5. 13.4; Epiph.
42. 3.1-2 (et C. Holl ad loc.); 65. 8.6; August. Haer. 22; A. Harnack, o.e., p.333*
3 : cf. VII. 38.1; . 20.1; Theodoret. I. 24 (p.373 BC); I. 25 et al.
c. 17: 21 coniec. Mi et Bernays, agn. Cr: :
coniec. Mi et Bemays, agn. Cr: : om.
addidi ex
21-22 Mi et Bemays ex :
22 addidi ex
24 addidi (cf. .23)
() Cr ex VIII. 15.1 (
):
25 () scripsi: : We

addidi
25/26 () scripsi ( ):
26 , transposui
27 delevi (cf. v. 26)
c. 18: 1 tit. litt. rubr. 3
2 Bunsen et Go ex Iren. I. 28.1:
:
Go:
add. suad. Sauppe
3 addidi
Go:
4 add. Go
4-5 []
( ) scripsi conl. Philastr. 48.2 (qui etiam
generationem hominum execratur, et ius nuptiarum legitimum abicit, idque iuris a deo
sta(tu)tum non confitetur): ( Mi)
c. 19: 2 Mi:

3 addidi et add. Sauppe ()

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.17.4-19.4

399

, , . 2
, - () () [] ,
- []
. , '
. 3
,
,
(), ' .
() '
, () ,
() , , , () , () , ' . . 4
, ,
, '
.

9 s. Mt 7:18; cf. Lc 6:43 (. Marcionis pp. 194* s. et 25* Harnack 2 ); Tert. Adv. Marc.
1. 2.1; 4. 17.11; Ps. Tert. 6.2; Philastr. 45.2; Orig. De princ. 2. 5.4 et al.
12
: cf. Iren. 1. 27.2; Epiph. 42. 4.2; Ps. Tert. 6.1; VII. 37.1; 38.2; A. Harnack, o.e.,
p. 121 ss.
13 Eph 3:16; Rm 7:22; 2 Cor 4:16; V. 7.36; VI. 34.5 (v.25, q.v.);
40.2; VII. 27.6; X. 13.3 et al.
15 : cf. Ps. Tert. 6.1 superioris dei filium
Christum tractat, hunc in substantia carnis negat, in phantasmate solo fuisse pronuntiat,
nec omnino passum, sed quasi passum, nec ex virgine natum, sed omnino nec natum;
Philastr. 45.4; Theodoret. 1. 24 (p. 376 A); Clem. Strom. 6. 71.2; Orig. c. Cels. 2.16; VII.
28.4-5 (v. 17, q.v.); VII. 31.5; Fr. in Mt. p.209 Achelis et al.
16 : cf. Iren.
1. 27.2; Tert. Adv. Marc. 5. 10.5; De carnis resurr. 2; Ps. Tert. 1.1.; Epiph. 42. 3.5; Theodoret. 1. 24 (p. 376 AB); VII. 38.5 et al.
17 cf. VII. 28.7; 30.3-4; VIII. 16;
20.1-2; . 18; Clem. Strom. 3. 12.1-2; 25.2; Tert. Adv. Marc. 1. 29.1; 4. 11.8; 34.5 et al.
4 Mi:
Go:
5 addidi
add. Sauppe I
2 delevi
6 delevi (cf. v. 7)
7 scripsi:
9 ,
transposui
10 (sc. Marcion)
11 addidi

scripsi: : coniec. C. Holl


12 addidi (cf. v. 16)
13 add. suad. Go Cr
14 addidi
15 addidi (cf. v. 14)

addidi
16 ' Sauppe:
17 scripsi:

: Mi cett.
18 scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

400

Hippolytus

20 1
pf. 13

, (), , , )
, / () - ( ) () -,
- ( ) -, 5
- () -,
- .
2
() , () ,
(), ,
, '
. ,

. () .

21 1

, , ()
, '
, 2 () .
(), 5
, () , ()

c. 20: 1-13 cf. VII. 38.1-5


2 : cf. Theodoret. Haer. 1. 25; . 19.1 I
6 : cf. V. 7.31; VI. 9.3; 32.8; VII. 38.1; VIII. 9.7; 10.1; . 16.5
11-13 cf.
Ps. Tert. Adv. haer. 6.6; Rhodon. ap. Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5. 13.2; Orig. c. Cels. 5. 54; Ambros.
De paradise 5. 28; VII. 38.2 et al.
12 Mt 5:17; cf. In Gen. Fr.29 Achelis et al.
13 cf. Epiph. 44. 4.1; Ps. Teit. 1.1.; Tert. De carne Christi 8.2; De anima 23.3; 36.3; . 19.4
c. 21: 1-13 cf. VII. 33.1-2
c. 20: 1 tit. (sic) litt. rubr. 3
3 Go: I
ex add. Go
post lacunam signavit A. ab Harnack (Marcion2, p. 412),
quam explevi conl. VII. 38.2 et h. c. v. 11: add. suad. We
5
supplevi conl. Philastrii Heres. 47.1-2: Non mihi opus est dicere a Marcione,
ut duo principia adseram coaeterna: ego enim unum principium esse praedico, quem
deum cognosco, qui deus fecit angelos, fecit etiam alteram virtutem, quem deum scio esse
secundum, qui et virtus dei est, quae fecit mundum.
6 ex VTI. 38.1 add.
suad. We
8 , corr. Go conl.
addidi
fj(v) Mi:
9 addidi ex VII. 38.2
, corr. Mi
11 We:
13 coniec. Go
scripsi:

c. 21: 1 addidi
3 om. Iren. (I. 26.1)
om. ,
habet Iren.
3/4 (cf. . 8/9):
4 addidi (cf. v. 8): om.
PH
5 P H
6 Go ex :
addidi ex
Iren.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.20.1-23.2

401

, 3

. , ( )
- (
) , () , .

, ( ) . ( )
() , () .

1 22

() , 1 23
, ,
, .
() , ,
5 / ,
f. 32
( ) ) () 2
. ( ) .
, ( ) .
c. 21: 10 s. cf. Mt 26:18; 2 Tm 4 : 6
c. 22: 1-3 cf. VII. 34.1
c. 23: 1-9 cf. VII. 35.1-2
5 s. cf. Lc 1:35; Epiph. Pan. 54. 3.5 (sc.
) ,
; VI. 35.3 et 7; VII. 26.9
6-8 cf.
Mt 3:16; Mc 1:10; Lc 3:22; VI. 35.6; 47.2; 49.5; 51.2 et 4; VII. 33.2; 35.2; 36.1 et al.
8 Mt 14:2; Mc 6:14; VII. 32.2; 33.2; 35.2
c. 21: 10-11 ( ) supplevi ex Theodoreti Haer. 2. 3 (p. 389 )
(omissis ): om. Iren.
11 (revolasse Iren.; Epiph. Pan. 28. 1.6): Theodoret.
R. Scott ex Iren.: : ()
() I. Draeseke
11-12 supplevi conl. Iren. Epiph.
12/13 () scripsi ex Iren, (perseverasse):
13 scrips: ex Iren,
(exsistentem spiritalem): : : Epiph. 28. 1.5
c. 22: 1
Go ex :
2 ( ) scripsi ex
:
2 addidi
3 addidi
Go
c. 23: 1 Go: :
2 Go: : om.
4 scripsi ex : : coniec. We
scripsi ex :
() , transposui
: coniec. Go
6 ()
scripsi:
() Mi: () , ut .
8 scripsi: I
addidi ex et NT
9 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

402

Hippolytus

24 1

[] (
) (), () ( ) , ,
' [] .

25 1

,
,
. ()
[],
, () 5
- ,
() [] ( ) .

26 1

() , ,
() ,
() , ()
, , ,
, .
5

c. 24: 1-4 cf. VII. 36.1


c. 25: 1-7 cf. VIII. 19.1-2
c. 26: 1-5 cf. VIII. 19.3
c. 24: 1 delevi
(cf. ): Sauppe Go
1-2 addidi ex VII. 36.1 et ex add. Cr We
2 ()
( ) scripsi (cf. ' Theodoret. 2.6):
3 post add. suad. Go conl. et Theodoreti 1.1.
4 R. Scott ex H:

del. Scott, om.
c. 25: 2 scripsi ex :
3
addidi ex I
scripsi ex : : coniec. Go
4 scripsi ( ): :
del. We
delevi (cf. v. 2): coniec. Mi
5
scripsi: : We
: Sauppe Go

addidi
7 1 addidi et 2 delevi
G. Volkmar et Go ex : I
addidi conl. Theodoreti Haer. 3.2 (PG 83, p. 404 )
; Euseb. Hist. eccl. 5.16.7

:
Go cett.
c. 26: 1 addidi
. Sauppe

2 addidi

2 add. Volkmar

3 1 add. G. Volkmar et

5 coniec. W e :

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.24.1-27.4

is

20

403

' , , ()
, -

- , ( )
() [ ] ()
, ,
() ,
() , - / () , () () ,
, . () () () ,
.
-
- , . ()
( ), (
) , () , (
). , , (),
,
, . () , () []
, [] -

1 27

f. 3 2

1-12 cf. IX. 7.1; 10.9-11; Theodoret. Haer. 3.3


13-23 cf. IX. 12.16-18
13 s. cf. IX. 12.1-15
21 s. : cf. Clem. Exc. ex Theod.
59.3
1 2 addidi
3 scripsi:
4 addidi
ex et Theodoreto
2 scripsi:
5 addidi post We (
( ) ) conl. et Theodor.
seclusi
ut glossema
addidi
6 scripsi ( IX.
10.9):
7 addidi ex
1 We:
8 scripsi:
9 addidi
Sauppe:
coniec. We:
10
We (cf. IX. 10.12): : Mi
addidi
11 add. suad. Sauppe:
add. suad. We (conl. IX. 10.11)
scripsi ex Theodoreto (
, ) et IX.
10. 11 ( ), conl. . 16 s.:

14 addidi
15 scripsi:

, transposui
2 Sauppe:
16 addidi ex IX.
12.16 (. 80)
, transposui conl.
16-17 addidi
ex
17 ex add. Mi
scripsi ( ):
17-18
supplevi ex : add. Go
18 add. suad. C. Holl
20
addidi
addidi
delevi ut dittogr.
21 1 delevi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

404

Hippolytus

, () () , () ,
, () , ()
.
25
28 1

() , () ,
( )
() .

29 1

, ,
() , () (), ()
. ()
() , ( ) ,
2 , ' , 5
() () ()() ()
. () () ( ) ()
, , ()0,
. ()()
3 . () ()
c. 27: 23 s. cf. IX. 12.19 ,
.
c. 28: 1 - 4 cf. VIII. 17.1; Theodoret. Haer. 1.19
c. 29: 1-13 excerpsit Theodoretus, Haer. 2.7
2 s. cf. IX. 13.1
5-10 cf. IX.
14.1
8 : cf. Epiph. Pan. 30. 3.4 (Ebionaei) et A.F.I. Klijn et G.I. Reinink,
Patristic Evidence for Jewish-Christian Sects (Suppl. to NT, 36, Lugd. Batav. 1973), pp.59 s.;
78 s.
10 s. cf. IX. 14.3 et 15.4-6
c. 27: 22 , corr. Mi
scripsi ex IX. 12.18 (
, () ):
addidi
22-23
() scripsi conl. :
23 , corr. Mi
() scripsi ( ): () , - Go
24 addidi
addidi
c. 28: 1 addidi ex
Theodoretus)

2 addidi ex (

c. 29: 1 tit. litt. rubr. 3


2 addidi ex Theodoreto
( ) scripsi:
addidi
3 addidi ex Theodor,
... scripsi ex Theodor.: . . .
4 addidi ex Theodor,
supplevi conl. Theodoreto
6 scripsi (cf. v. 9):

addidi
scripsi:
7 addidi ex
Theodor.
addidi
8 scripsi: Theodor.
9-10
: , '
Theodorct.
10 1 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.27.4-30.4

405

( ) ,
() () ,
() () .
/ (* *) ()

, ,
.
5 ,
( ) , ( ) ,
(. ) () (
', ) (
) ' - '
'
( ') .

[] '.

C.

1 30 Pf.i37r

29: 12 s. cf. IX. 14.2

c. 30: 1 () : sc. Abraham: cf. Gn 12:1 et 4-6; Act 7 : 4 ;


Chronicon 620 ed. . Bauer et R. Helm (quando praecepit illi deus exire de domo
patris sui et venire in terram Chanaan); los. Ant. lud. I. 154
4 :
cf. v. 19 et . Bauer, Die Chronik des Hippolytos etc. (T.U. 29.1, Lipsiae 1905), pp. 158-162 I
6 1 Chr. 2 : 1 ; Gn 35:23
7 Gn 32:28-29; 4 9 : 2
9 ': Chron. 620; Gn 12:4 I
: Chron. 622; Gn 2 1 : 5
10 : Chron. 623; Gn 25:26
':
Lib. generationis I. 241 (Bauer-Helm)
11 ': Lib. gen. I. 242
c. 29: 11 supplevi ex Theodor, (cf. IX. 14.3)
coniec. Sauppe conl. Theodor.:
13 addidi

12 -

c. 30: 1 turbatum esse ordinem foliorum in codice vidit Mi (ff. 132 + 137 + 133-135) I
lac. sign. Mi
add. Cr
G. Volkmar et Go:
4 scripsi conl. v. 19: (cf. v.3 )
(i.e. Abraham) We:
6 suppl. Roeper: in spatium vacuum litt. 12
7 add. suad. Go: in spat. vac. litt. 15
8 . add.
Roeper et addidi: in spat. vac. litt. 14: . add. We
8-9 ', add. suad. Go: spat. vac. litt. 29
9
9 - 10 suppl. Go: spat. vac. litt. 25
10 ' Go ex Lib. gen.: ' , def.
. Bauer (. U. 29.1, . 159 n. 1)
11 1 ' 2 : Mi cett.
12 '
add. Go: spat. vac. litt. 9 : ' add. suad. Bauer
14 1 del. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

406

Hippolytus

() , , ,
( ', , ,)
( ,
5 ) ', ( ')
, , (
)
, , .
6
, ,
() () , . '
() ,
-
( ) . -
7 ( ) [] , '.
, ()
( ) , , ()

is

25

15 s. Gn 11:16-26
16 s. Chron. 172; (190.1; 200.1); los. Ant. lud. I. 146
17 s. Chron. 199; Gn 10:25; 9:19; Ios. 1.1.
18 X. 31.2; Chron. 198
19 : ft. cf. Chron. 56-198; cf. Gn 9:18-19; 10:1-32; Ios. Ant. lud. I. 122 ss.
23 s. et 27 s. Chron. 36-40; Gn 11:10-15
28 ' : i.e. Sala 130 annos + Cainan
130 annos + Arphaxad 135 annos + Sem 100 annos = 495
28 s. cf. Gn 6 : 8 - 9 ; 7 : 1
29-31 Gn 6:18; 7 : 7 et 13; 8:16
31 : cf. Gn 6:15
32 :
cf. Ios. Ant. lud. I. 92
: Gn 8 :4
15 add. Roeper et Bunsen: spat. vac. litt. 2
, corr. Go
16 - suppl. Roeper et Bunsen
et scripsi: et
edd.
17 , suppl. Bunsen ( scripsi) et
supplevi (: add. suad. We:
Bunsen): in spat. vac. litt. 28
18 '
add. Cr
19
Go:
19-20
addidi
20 : Go cett.
, corr. Mi
21 Go:
23 : " Go cett.
: Go cett.
24 ' 1 , ' 2 , corr. Mi
addidi
25 addidi
26
scripsi:
scripsi: : ( ) Mi cett.
27 addidi
28 " addidi
delevi
(i.e. Noe) . Bauer: I
scripsi:
29 addidi
30 addidi e LXX (cf. v. 30)
31 () scripsi: : R. Scott
31-32
, transposuit Scott
32 (ararad LXX versio Armeniaca):
et LXX

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.30.4-31.4

407

, / .
,
35 () , ,
',
() , []
;
' ()
,
( ) , () ,
5 , '
( ) . ( )
, , , ()
, '
. ()

' ', ', '.
' - ,
, (), , , , ,
, ( ) '
is ,
() .
[],
() , ()

f.

37

1 31

c. 31: 9 Gn 1:28; V. 26.9


11 Cbron. 198; 159; 73; 92-129 (et . BauerIi. Helm ad p. 20.8); Gn 10:1-32
12-14 Cbron. 94-97
17 ab Ei
usque ad finem opens ed. Bunsen, pp. 381-392
c. 30: 35 add. Sauppe

37 del. Go

c. 31: 1 () scripsi:
3 addidi
2 scripsi:
4 add. suad. Sauppe
Mi:
6 addidi
addidi
7 addidi
9 addidi
11
12 Go:
scripsi ex Chron. 97: : Mi cett.
13 . Bauer
ex Chron. 95; 110; 111: : Go e LXX ()

scripsi:
14 add. suad. We et addidi
16 coniec.
We:
17 ... coniec. We: ...
delevi
18 : We
Mi: We
addidi
addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

408

f. 33

Hippolytus

(), () - 2
-, () , , - ()
5 , () , ; -

() , 25
() ()
6 ( ) ;
, , ,
, / () , '
, ' 3
()
.
32 1

, , , , ,
, , , ' , (') .

c. 31: 22 s. Chrort. 60
27 ab usque ad finem opens ed. Wordsworth,
pp. 276-305 (pp. 100-129 secundae ed.)
28 , : cf. De universe
p. 139.50 C. Holl (T.U. 20.2, 1899)
c. 32: cc. 32-34 ed. Nautin, pp. 109-127; de Hippolyt! veritatis doctrina cf. M. Richard in
Dictionnaire de spiritualite, 44-45 (1968), pp. 545-571; L. Bertsch, Die Botschaft von Christus
und unserer Erlsung bei H. von Rom (Augustae Treverorum 1966)
1-5 cf. c. Noet.
10 ed. P. Nautin (Paris. 1949)
- ( )
c. 31: 19 , transposui
addidi
scripsi:
20 scripsi:
21 2, 1
add. Sauppe
22 : Bauer We
addidi
' 2, ' 1
23
addidi
24 We conl. v. 1-2: : coniec. Mi, agn. Go
25 addidi
Mi:
Bunsen:
26 addidi I
addidi
27 addidi
28 I. Hare ap. Chr. Bunsen:
29 add. Bunsen
30 coniec. Go (cf. . 34.2 ):
: coniec. Mi, agn. Bunsen We: ) R. Scott (conl.
. 32.5)
30-31 ' Sauppe: ' : Cr
c. 32: 1 tit. litt. rubr. 3
2 '
scripsi:

3 1 scripsi:
3 2 , 1
4 R. Scott (cf.
. . . Narrat. de rebus Pas. p. 12.19 . Bratke, T.U. 19.3): I
(') scripsi:

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.31.4-32.5

409

, () .
- -,
() , -,
, , , ,
. -
() -,
. -
, .
( ) -
()
, ()
- ()
,
, . (') , '
, .

6 : cf. Lampe, s.v.,


12 s. cf. e.g. Plat. Tim. 41 a 8
.
17 cf. De universe (Fr. 353 ed. C. Holl, T.U. 20.2, 1899,
pp. 137-143); Gu. I. Malley,/.7:S., N.S. 16 (1965), pp. 13-25; inscript. in statua Vaticana
; Photii Bibl. cod. 48; . Richard,
o.e., p.542 et al.
18 s. cf. I. 26.3 ,
() ; IV. 43.2; De universo Fr. 2
Malley ' ' () ,
' ...; Rm 1:25
5 : Go
addidi
6 Nautin:
7 () scripsi
(cf. w . 10, 12): : Go: del. Nautin
8 scripsi:
11 addidi
14 () Go: () coniec. Wordsworth, agn. Cr I
addidi (cf. v. 17-18)
15-16 () scripsi (cf. v. 17):
16 addidi
17 add. Wordsworth: add. Bunsen
18 :
Cr: del. We Nautin
2, 1
coniec. Go (cf. . 31.6;
34.2):
scripsi:
19 ' add. Wordsworth
20
(sc. , cf. . 18) : R. Scott
' 1, 2, corr. Mi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

410
33 1

f. 33
3
4

Hippolytus

() () , '
. () -
, . () , () (), ( ) 5
, ,
, ()
() , () , / .
() () ,
(), []
, ,
, () - , -,
, (' ) () () , , 15
. ( ) ,
,

1 : cf. c. Noet. 10
2 : cf. Theophil. Antioch. Ad Autolyc. 2. 10 et
22; lustin. Dial. 61.1; Tert. Adv. Praxeam 5; Iren. 2. 15.5; Orig. c. Cels. 6. 65; Basil. Caesar.
Horn. 16.3; Nemes. De nat. hom. 14; Sext. Emp. Pyrrh. hypot. 1. 65; 72; 76; Adv. math.
8. 275 et 287; Philon. De Abrahame 83; De vita Mosis 2. 127 et 129; De spec. kgg. 4. 69
et al.
6 cf. Col 1 : 1 5 ; Theophil. Autol. 2. 22
7 s. cf. c. Noet. 10 (p. 253.5 .)

10 cf. Gn 1:22
11 i.e. angeli (cf. Basil. Caes.
Adv. Eunomium 3.2 [I, p. 273 Garnier-Maran]
) et astra (cf. Clem. Eel. proph. 56.4-6; Orig. c. Cels. 5.11; Gn 1:16): cf.
w . 16-19
1 addidi
2 (cf. v.41): Nautin (cf. v.3)
addidi
3 addidi
4 . ( ) We: : . G o
4/5
Go (cf. v. 7): : We
5 , corr. Mi
addidi
6 Mi:
7 addidi
: Bunsen: () .
coniec. Nautin
Wordsworth: : Mi
7 - 8 ( )
scripsi: : Chr. Petersen
ap. Go: coniec. R. Scott
8 addidi
9
Wordsworth:
11 addidi
2 del. Mi
13 addidi
14 Mi: : coniec. Mi, agn. G o
' add. Cr, agn. We: ' add. Bunsen et Go
Bunsen et Go:

14/15 , corr. Mi Bunsen
16 2 , - 1

supplevi conl. Ps 103:4 et Greg. Naz. Orat. theol. 28.31 et 31.15


(pp. 70.5 et 164.7 Mason), cf. v. 18 .
17 1 superscr. 1

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.33.1-8

411

() . , 6
- () ,
- ()
(), -
. - ,
, . () 7
() , () ()
.
() , . ( ) () (),
() - - , ' ( ).
, () - (') , .
(), , '
() (). - 8
() , .
() ,

19 s. cf. Gn 1:20-21
20 s. cf. Aristot. Metapb. A 3, p. 983 b 26 ss. .
21-23 cf. Gn 1:24-25
24-26 cf. Ps 134.6
, ,
; c. Noet. 10 (pp.251.14 et 19; 253.1 .) ,
, (sc. )
27 s. :
cf. Albini Epit. 17.1 Hermann
; Plat. Tint. 42 e - 43 a
29 : cf. e.g.
De Antichr. 2 (p. 5.2 Achelis)
31 s. : cf. . 34.4
et 5 ; Clem. Protr. 114.4; Strom. 4. 149.8; 7. 3.6; 95.2; 101.4;
Lampe, s. w . () et (C)
32 s. cf. Mt 25 :21 et 23; Lc 19:17; 16:10;
Ps. De consummat. mundi 49 (Achelis); 2 Clem. Rom. 8.5; Iren. 2. 34.3; I.H. Ropes,
p. 16 nr. 5
19 addidi
Bunsen et Go: : Roeper
20 (cf.
. 22)
, transposui
21 addidi
22 addidi e LXX
23 scripsi:
Nautin:
: coniec. Nautin:
() coniecerim conl. c. Noet. 10 (.251.19 .) '
24-25 () () supplevi conl. c. Noet. 10 et LXX: : del. Mi: corruptum Nautin
25 scripsi:
addidi
27 addidi I
Roeper, Bunsen et Scott:
27/28 Nautin:

28 addidi et add. Cr
addidi ex w . 3 0 , 31
29
supplevi conl. . 31
31 ' add. Cr
33 et
33/34 : Roeper
34 addidi
35 addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

412

f. 34

Hippolytus

. ,
9 () () , () , ()
, ,
, 4
, [] ( ),
() . ()
, ' , ' .
10
() () , () .
() , - 45
; ()) ( ,
/ . ()
() () ,
, so
11 , () ,
, .
,
12 , (') ,
. () 55
() , , ()

36 s. cf. inscript. in statua Vaticana


38 s.
: cf. LSJ, s.v. , 2 a; Theophil. Ad Aulolyc. 2. 25; Iren. 4. 38.1 et . Marcovich, J.T.S., N.S. 24 (1973), p.195 s.
48 ss. cf. c. Noet. 11-12
52
: cf. Ps 109:3 (= c. Noet. 16 s.f.) et 2 Pt 1:18-19
53 s. cf. Euseb. Dem. ev. V, prooem. 28 ...
,
.
55-57 cf. De Antichristo 2 (p. 4.16-21 Achelis)
37 add. Roeper
addidi
38 addidi
()
scripsi: . : Bunsen, agn. Go Cr: , Wordsworth: , []
. Santer (J.T.S., N.S. 24, 1973, p. 194 s.)
39 , corr. Mi
40
Mi:
We:
41 delevi: coniec.
Mi: () Bunsen Go Cr
addidi: v (servato ) add. We
42 addidi
43 Bunsen:
44 addidi I
() scripsi:
45 Mi:
() , ut . (cf. .47): Mi cett.
46 '
47
48 addidi
49 addidi I
add. suad. We
2, - 1
51 () scripsi:

scripsi:
52 1, 2
: Nautin (vix
recte)
54 (') scripsi: '
55 scripsi (cf. v. 59):
addidi
56 et addidi

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.33.8-14

413

. , ,
( ) , ,
, () (),
, ().
() ' , , 13
() () , , ,
. ()
, ( ), ' () (), ' ' .
() () , 14
() , [], ' () [],
() ()
, ' , '

64 : cf. Plat. Axioch. 369 d 6


68 cf. Gal 5:13 ' ; Clem. Strom. 3. 41.3
69 ss. cf. c. Noet. 17-18 (p.263.1 ss. N.)
57 : Scott Go: Wordsworth
, transp. Roeper
59
addidi (cf. v. 60)
60 addidi
supplevi
61 ,
corr. Mi
supplevi
62 addidi
63 addidi (cf.
. 62)
65 , transposui
addidi
66 addidi
' : coniec. Go
post ' add.
Cr
67 addidi
68 addidi
' Mi ex NT:
: ' Scott cett.: () Nautin
69
addidi
ex c. Noet. 17 (p. 263.3 .) add. Nautin
scripsi
ex 1.1.:
70 scripsi (cf. w . 53, 66, 73): I
addidi
70-71 () conieci conl.
c. Noet. 17 (p. 263.4)

71 1 seclusi, 2 addidi et delevi: , ()


Bunsen et Scott, agn. Cr: coniec. Go: coniec. We
72 add. Cr
('ut mundus eum videns revereretu/): Nautin (conl.
c. Noet. 10, p. 253.7 . ), vix recte I
() scripsi (cf. v. 70):

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

414

f. 34

Hippolytus

15 .
. ( )
, "

, () ' , ()
()
16 , . ()
( ) '
( ) , . / ,
, () ,
17 ; (') ' , ()
, , ,
, , ,
, ,
() , ' ( ) .

75

so

85

74 s. Km 6 : 6 ; Eph 4 : 2 2 ; Col 3 : 9 ; . 34.5; c. Noet. 17 (p.263.8) ;


De Antichristo 26 (p. 19.1 Achelis) ' ; Iren. 3. 21.10;
22.2; 5. 1.2; Clem. Strom. 3. 75.3; 4. 51.1; Eel. proph. 24.1 et al.
75
: cf. 2 Cor 5 :17; Gal 6:15; V. 7.15; Eph 2 : 1 5 ;
4:24; V. 7.15; 6. 35.4; . Noet. 17 (.263.6) et al.
76 : cf. Iren.
2. 22.4 ideo per omnem venit aetatem (sc. Iesus) ... ut sit perfectus magister in omnibus
81 () ' : cf. Greg. Nyss. Horn, in 1 Cor. 15:28 (P.G. 44,
p. 1313 ) , '
; Leontii Byz. c. Nestor, et Eutych. 2 (P.G.
86, p. 1344 A); Ioann. Damasc. De fide ortbodoxa 3. 49 (P.G. 94, p. 985 et C)
85 ss.
cf. c. Noet. 18 (p.263.10 ss. N.)
86 cf. Mt 25:35; Orig. in Matth. 13.2; Ropes,
p. 35 nr. 25
88 : cf. 1 Cor 15 :20-23
75 (cf. 1 Cor 15:49; Col 3:9-10): Sauppe,
coniec. Wordsworth, agn. Cr (conl. 1 Cor 5 : 7 et v.81)
addidi (cf.
w . 74 et 80)
78 addidi
We:
79 addidi

scripsi: : coniec. Mi
80 () Mi:
Bunsen:

81 1 add. Bunsen
coniec. Bunsen (cf. w. 74, 75, 76):
82 supplevi (cf. w . 80-81)
coniec. Mi
84 () , ut v.
85 ' addidi
scripsi:
86 1,
- 2

89 addidi (cf. v. 90)
89/90 Mi:

90 () coniec. We, agn. Nautin: : ()
Bunsen, agn. Cr

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.33.14-34.2

415

, 1 34
, , ,
, ,
, .
5 , [] ,
' , () 2
,
, , '
,

' ,
) , (), ,
() , ,

. . . : cf. Orig. c. Cels. inscr.


.; Prooem. 4 s. f. et al.
1-3 cf. X. 31.6
5 : cf. Tt
3 : 4 ; Clem. Paed. 1. 3.3; 7.1; 58.2; 3. 43.2; Orig. c. Cels. 2. 25; 2. 38; 7. 42
6 s.
cf. X. 31.6; Tatian. Oral, ad Gr. 42 (sc. ego)
'
10 . Km 2 : 3 ; Mt 23:33; In Dan. 4. 12 (p.
214.17 Bonwetsch); 4. 60 (p.338.12)
11 :
cf. Hesiodi Tbeog. 814; 2 Pt 2 : 4 ; De universo (p. 137.3 Holl, T.U. 20.2)
, ,
.
l i s . : cf. 2 Pt 1:19
(sc. ); . 33.11 . . . ; c. Noet. 10 (p.253.5 .)
(sc. ),

12 - : cf. De Univ. p. 138.9 .
; 139.38 , (sc. )
; Ape 20:14-15; Is 33 :14; Dn 7:10 et al.
13
- : cf. In Dan. 2. 29 (p. 98.13 .) ; De univ.
p. 138.6 , '
, ;
. 139.33 ...
.
5 del. suad. We (cf. v. 31 s.)
6 2 addidi
11 Roeper: :
Mi
: Nautin (conl. De univ. p. 138.1 Holl),
vix recte
11/12
12 Roeper: (cum signo
corr.) : Mi: Bunsen, agn. cett.
13 addidi ex De
univ. p. 139.36 ( )

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

416

Hippolytus

, , ()
.
is
3
() ,
() . ( ) () , ()
, ,
4 () . 2
() , ()

14 - 15 : cf. De univ. p. 141.92


;
De Antichr. 65 (p.46.3 Achelis); Mc 9:48; Is 66:24; 2 ep. Clem. Rom. 7 : 6 ; 17:5; lust. 1
Apol. 52.8; Dial. 130.2; 140.3; Tert. De cam. resurr. 31.9 et al.
14 : i.q.
detrimentum: cf. Pap. Oxy. 1273.32
17
: cf. De univ. p. 139.49 , '
(sc. ), ;
. 140.56 , '
; 64 ' (sc. ) ...
, , ,
...; lustin. 1 Apol. 52.3 ... (sc. )
, ...; Tatian. Or.
ad Gr. 6
; Athenag. De resurr, mortuor. 11.1; Theophil. Antioch. Ad Autolyc. 1.7 s. f.

, et al.
19 Rm 8:17; De theophania 8 et 10 (pp.262.12 et 263.19 Achelis); Clem. Protr. 113.5; 115.4; Strom. 4. 45.6; Ecl.
proph. 20.3; Quis dives salvetur 36.2; Acta Petri et Artdr. 2 (II. 1, p. 117.21 Lipsius-Bonnet);
Constit. apostol. 2. 33.2; 3. 18.1 Funk; Ioann. Chrysost. Horn, in Rom. 5 : 3 (3, p. 145 ed.
Gaume) et al.
20 cf. De univ. p. 140.72 oi
, '
,
21 : cf. . 33 et
. 33.7
14 del. Bunsen
, def. Wordsworth: corruptum We: '
coniec. Go: Bunsen et Scott (conl. De univ. p. 141.93), agn. Nautin:
Roeper, agn. Cr ('corporis per illuviem'): coniec. We: Diels
addidi ex De univ. 1.1.
15 (i.q. supplicium, punitio) We:
: Bunsen
16 () scripsi (cf. e.g. Clem. Strom.
1. 91.3): : Nautin (conl. v. 6)
17 addidi
2 add. Mi et
addidi
18 addidi
addidi
19 scripsi:
20 ()
scripsi:
1 scripsi:
21 addidi
() Bunsen et Go:
: Roeper: Wordsworth: Cr

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Refutatio X.34.2-5

417

( ), , () , .
() ' , ( )
25
) ' . () , ,
() . 5
,
, ( )
30 ' , ()
. ,
, () ' / ,
() ().

f.

35

24 : cf. Plat. leib. 1, 133 c 4 ...


[ ], ; 130' e 7; Charmid.
169 e 4; Phaedr. 229 e 6 - 230 a 6; Phileb. 48 d 2; Leg. 11, 923 a 4; I. 18 (q.v.)
25 s. cf. Gal 4 : 9 ; 1 Cor 13 :12 et 8 : 3 ; Clem. Strom. 7. 82.7
26 :
cf. Pw 3 : 3 0
27 s. Rm 9 : 5 ; c. Noet. 2 et 6 (pp.239.1; 245.11 et 12 N.)
29 Rm 6 : 6 ; Eph 4:22; Col 3 : 9 ; X. 33.15 (. 74)
29-31 cf. Gn 1:26
' ' ; V. 7.6; VI. 14.5;
VII. 28.2
32 s. cf. Iren. 2. 33.5 () ,

33 cf. . 20 s. et . 33.7
22 addidi (cf. v. 33) et add. Nautin
: Nautin
23 addidi I
Bunsen (Hippolytus u. seine Zeit, Lipsiae 1852,1, p. 136): : Scott et Bunsen
(.Anaiecta)
<) Scott et Sauppe
Wordsworth:
24 addidi

supplevi (cf. )
25 1
2
Mi Cr: Go We Nautin
Nautin:
<>
Nautin
26 , corr. Bunsen
27 addidi
: Roeper I
(cf. . 33.1): Nautin ex NT et c. Noet. 2 et 6
29 addidi
ex Gn 1:26
30
addidi ex Gn 1:26
31 Mi:

32 addidi
Roeper et Go:
33 addidi: add. Cr
(servato )
Nautin:
subscriptio +
+

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:37 PM

INDEX LOCORUM
SCRIPTURA SACRA

Vetus Testamentum
Genesis
1:1
326.41
1:2 . . . 189.24-25; 192.90;
218 (14) 12-13 et 16;
218.21-219.22; 222.4 et 7;
240.36
1:3 . . .289.17-18; 331.11 (?)
1:4
396.20
1:4-5
326.34-36
1:5-13 . . . 193.9-10; 218
(14) 4-5
1:6-7
209.12-13
1:7
169.105
1:8
292.2
1:20-21
411.19-20
1:22
410.10
1:24-25
411.21-23
1:26 . . . 218.20-21; 222.78; 266.7-8; 303.9; 417.
29-31
1:26-27
202.40-41
1:27
144.27-29
1:28
202.44-45; 407.9
1:31 . . 218 (13) 11; 266.7-8
2:1
203.51-52
2:2 . . . 133.10-11; 218 (14)
1-3; 333.1-2
2:2-3
333.3-4
2:7 . . . 144.27-29; 202.3233 et 38; 218.19-20; 247.
23-25; 303.13
2:8
183.47; 202.22-23
2:9
202.26-28
2:10 . . . 183.47-48; 219.
35-37; 220.2
2:10-12 . . . 168.83-85; 169.
89-92
2.10-14
203.52 et 54
2:11
203.58-59
2:13
169.94-95
2:14 . 169.96-97 et 101-102

2:16-17

193.11-13;
205.106-108
3: Iss
183.46
3:13
205.111-112
3:15
132.25-28
3:19
56.62; 249.35
3:20 . . . 153.219-220; 184.
73-74; 246.14
3:21
391.20
3:24
223.23-24
4:3-5
183.49-51
4:15
183.48-49
4:25
193.7
6:10
193.8
6:15
406.31
6:19-20 et 7:2-3 . . . 355.
117-120
8:4
406.32
9:6
222.4
9:19
406.17-18
10:1-32
407.11
10:8-9
178.21
10:9
184.59-60
10:25
406.17-18
11:10-15 . . . 406.23-24 et
27-28
11:16-25
406.16-25
12:1 . . . 193.13-14; 405.1-2
12:4
405.9
12:4-6
405.1-2
14:18-20
319(36)3
21:5
405.9
25:26
405.10
27:1
183.56-58
27:15 et 27
183.55-56
28:5 et 12 . . . . 1 5 8 . 1 0 2 - 1 0 3
28:17
...
158.107-109;
164.236-237
30:37-39
185.14-15
30:39
186.26-27
32:28-29
405.7

33:9
33:10
35:23
37:3 et 28
44:5
44:12
49:2

184.57
184.58-59
.405.6
183.53-54
....155.29-30
155.30-31
405.7
Exodus

2:22
154.10
3:2 et 4 . . . 151.167; 320
(38) 4-5; 326.42-43; 396.
23-24; 400 (20) 5-6
3:8
240.37 et 39
3:14
149.129
3:20
334.41
4:2-3 et 17
183.42
4:6
334.42
6:3 . . . 193.9; 250.10-12;
295.22-23
7:8-11:10 . . . 333.10-13;
397.19-398.22
7:9-10 et 15
183.42
7:11-12
183.43-45
7:17
334.42
10:4; 10:12-14 et 19. 335.43
10:22
193.5
12:6
334.26-27
12:11; 12:14; 12:17 . . .
334.25-26
12:15; 12:18-20 . . . . 334.34
12:18 . . . 334.26-27 et 3233; 337.2-3
14:28
182.20-21
15:22
182.26-27
15:22-25 . . . 220.11-14 et
15-17
18:3
154.10
18:17-24
154.9
20:4
371.3-4

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

422

Indices

20:11 . . . 218 (14) 1-3; 333.


1-2

20:13-15
193.16-17
24:17 . . . 214.10-11; 244.
42-43
33:3
240.37 et 39
Leviticus
11:22

335.43

Numeri
21:6-7
183.31-33
21:8-9 . . . 183.33ss.; 184.
65-66
Deuteronomium
4:24 et 9:3 . . . 151.167;
214.10-11;
244.42-43;
396.23-24
4:35 et 32:39 . . . 245.10-11;
295.14-15
5:17-19
193.16-17
5:22
193.5; 324.28
27:26
337.4-5
31:20
...
161.161-162;
240.37 et 39
32:11
292.78
33:17
168.81
Josua
3:16

154.230
1 Samuel

Psalmi
2:9
151.173
8:3
268.14
18:2
268.25
18:4
166.32
18:5-6
337.20-22
21:7
158.97-98
21:21-22
158.83
23:7 = 9
158.94-96
23:8 = 10
158.96-97
23:10 et 18
158.99
28:3 . . . 157.80; 191.82;
388.54-55
28:10
157.79
31:5-6; 50:5; 51:11 . . .
297.16-17
32:9
289.16
34:17
158.83
38:7
222.4
41:2
171.9
81:6
153.216-217
81:7
154.221
109:1 . . . 204.82-83; 293.
28-29
109:3
412.52
109:4 . . 199 (24) 6; 209.5-6
110:10
244.35; 297.7
117:19
204.76-77
117:20
204.78-79
117:22
152.192-193
132:2
291.75-76
134:6
411.24-26
148:5
289.16

17:9
38:15

Jeremias
163.203-204
162.197-199
Lamentationes
162.199

1:1

Daniel
2:45
153.200
4:7-9
215.35-36
7:9; 7:13; 7:22
244.39
Hosea
1:2

209.18-19
Jonas

4:10

Proverbia
170.126
1:7 et 9 : 1 0 . . . 244.35; 297.7
170.125-126
3:30
417.26
170.127
8:23 et 25
218.8-9
24:16
148.124-125
1 Paraleipomenon
26:22
349.7
2:1
405.6
Isaias
1:2 . . . 208.181; 217(13) 7-8
Job
1:7
131.6 1:3
208.184-185
222.24-25
2:9d
327.10-11 2:4
40:32
158.101 5:7
215.1-3
10:1
16:13
16:14

6:9
155.15
6:10
187.42-43
7:14
164.214-242
28:10
155.17-18
28:16 . . 152.192 et 194-195
35:10
300.18
40:15
170.120
41:9-10
158.84-88
43:1-2
158.84-88
44:2 et 24
219.30-31
45:5-6 et 46:9 . . . 245.1011; 250.5-7; 295.14-15
49:15-16
158.88-92
51:11
300.18
53:8
143.10
54:1
162.193-194

186.30
Judith

9:7

355.124

14:3

31:6

23

Psalmi Salomonis
202.25-26
2 Enoch

205.112

Apocalypsis Abraham!
205.112

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Index Locorum

423

Novum Testamentum
Matthaeus
2:1 . . . 183.52-53; 207.149;
395.33
2:1-2
300.27
2:18
162.197-199
3:10 . . . 161.169-170; 215.
38-40; 222.28-30
3:12
215.41-44
3:16 . . . 249.29-30; 265.56; 271.8-9; 317.7-8; 318.
9; 401.6-8
3:17
249.31
5:12
301.40
5:13-14
191.77-78
5:15
149.143-144
5:17
400.12
5:18
231.3; 331.22
5:20
157.60-61
5:44
368.13-14
5:45 . . 149.134-135; 368.13
7:3-5 .323.1-3 et 4-6; 330.6
7:6 . . 161.176-177; 362.2-3
7:11
186.31
7:13
164.227
7:14-13
165.244-247
7:14
134.42
7:18
399.9-10
7:19 . . . 161.169-170; 215.
38-40; 222.28-30
7:21
160.144-146
8:12
328.36-37
9:22
378.14-15
10:5
198 (23) 3-4
10:10
365 (20) 7-8
10:27
149.144-145
10:34
196.21-22
11:13 . . . . 248.1; 295.25-26
11:14-15
327.12-13
11:27
332.12
12:24
245.4; 246.5
13:3 et 8
325.2-4
13:3-9
160.154-159
13:9
325.4-5
13:16
184.76
13:29-30
355.116
13:31 . . . . 166.29-30; 257.7
13:31-32
288.11-12
13:33
156.48-49
13:44
156.48
14:2 . . . 315.11; 317.9; 318
(35) 10; 401 (23) 8
17:1-3
265.2-3

160.150
157.60-61
347.34
261.45-46
...
225.5-226.6;
226.19; 273.17
18:16
360.14
19:17 . . 149.133; 314.32-33
19:28
157.64 ss.
20:22
157.61-62
21:19
323.16-17
21:31
160.148-149
22:11
164.239
22:11 -12
193.111-112
22:30
146.72
23:27
159.123
23:33
415.10
24:32
323.20-21
25:21 et 23
411.32-33
25:35
414.86
25:41
347.34
26:18
401.10-11
27:52 -53
159.125
Marcus
1:4
327.13-14
1:10 . . . 249.29-30; 265.56; 271.8-9; 317.7-8; 318.
9; 401.6-8
1:11
249.31
4:3-9
160.154-159
4:3 et 8
325.2-4
4:9
325.4-5
4:12
155.15
4:17
135.60-61
4:21
149.143-144
4:30-31
166.29-30
4:30-32
288.11-12
4:31
257.7
6:14
318.10; 401.8
9:2-4
265.2-3
9:48
416.14-15
10:18 . . 149.133; 314.32-33
10:38
157.61-62
11:13-14 et 20-21 . . . 323.
16-17
13:28
323.20-21

1:26
207.150-151
1:26 ss
328.37
1:35 . . . 248.14-17; 250.38;
271.4-5; 298.44-45 et 47;
401.5-6
2:42
207.152
3:1
313.25-26
3:3
327.13-14
3:9 . . . 161.169-170; 215.
38-40; 222.28-30
3:17
215.41-44
3:22 . . . 249.29-30 et 31;
265.5-6; 271.8-9; 317.78; 318.9; 401.6-8
3:23
329.52-53
4:15
314.27
6:41-42 . . . 323.1-3 et 4-6;
330.6
43
394.9-10
5-8
160.154-159
5 et 8
325.2-4
257.7; 325.4-5
0
155.15
6
149.143-144
28
265.2-3
33
150.148
23
184.76
15
245.4; 246.5
33
149.143-144
3
149.144-145
18-19 . . .
166.29-30;
288.11-12
13:19
257.7
13:21
156.48-49
15:4 . . . 225.5-226.6; 226.
19; 273.17
15:8
273.19-20
16:8
266.14
16:10
411.32-33
16:17
231.3; 331.22
17:21
...
147.101-102;
156.47-48
18:19 . . 149.133; 314.32-33
19:17
411.32-33
22:30
157.64 ss.
23:46
207.165-166
24:39
321.19-20

Joannes
184.69-72
323.9-10 1:1-4
331.11
207.149; 395.33 1:1-4 et 9(?)
165.10-11
301.40 1:3

Lucas
1:4
1:5
1:14

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

424
1:3-4
1:9 . . .

Indices

155.23-24
170.112-113; 289.
23-24
1:13
214.6-7; 214.20
1:23
177.2
2:4
300.26
2:9
156.43-44
2:11
156.45-46
3:5
154.223; 163.202
3:5-6
329.48-51
3:6
154.225-226
3:8 (?)
149.129
3:14
184.63-65
3:17
174.33-34
4:10
170.121
4:10-11
147.96
4:10 et 4:14 . . . 169.106107; 193.110; 209.11 et 12
4:24; 4:21; 4:23 . 165.13-16
5:28
159.125
6:44
160.141-142
6:53
157.59-60
8:21
157.62
8:39
247.20-21
8:44
186.33-34
9:1
170.112
10:7 e t 9 . . 159.109; 187.42
10:8 . . . 207.154-155; 248.3
10:9
170.122-123
10:11
207.151
12:31
245.3; 246.5
12:36
266.14
12:47
174.33-34
13:33
157.62
14:1
363.23
14:10
354.86-87
19:14
266.11-12
19:26
207.164
20:20 et 25
321.17-19

153.202
366.2 4:7
375.4; 376.21-22 4:16 . . . 152.197; 153.199;
247.25-26; 257.6; 300.30;
391.18; 399.13
Epistula ad Romanos
,...329.46-47
1:3
187.58 5:3
1:16
378.14-15 5:17 . . . . 146.72-73; 414.75
1:20-23 et 26-27 . . . 146. 12:2 . . . 161.171-172; 170.
124-125
77-147.92
298.39-40
1:23
265.1-2 12:4
360.14
1:25 . . . 90.42-45; 127.6-8; 13:1
409.18-19
2:3
415.10
Epistula ad Galatas
5:14 et 13
295.12-13
3:10
249.34-35
6:6
414.74-75; 417.29
3:28
146.72
7:22 . . . 152.197; 153.199;
4:9
417.25-26
247.25-26; 257.6; 300.30;
4:26 . . . 153.219-220; 240.
391.18; 399.13
37-38; 246.16
8:11
249.33
4:27
162.193-194
8:17
416.19
5:2
286.43
8:19
248.9
5:3
338 (18) 9-10
8:21-22 et 19 . . . 295.7-8;
5:13
413.68
296.28-29; 299.2-3
5:16
161.168
9:5
417.27-28
5:17
206.124-125
9:20-21
151.165-166
6:15 . . . . 146.72-73; 414.75
10:9
378.14-15
10:18
152.189-190
11:33
141.18
Epistula ad Ephesios
14:4
355.114 1:21 . . . 286.13-14; 291.64;
296.30-31
Epistula ad Corinthios 1
2:15 . . . 146.73; 249.19-20;
2:7
297.11
414.75
2:9 . . . 199 (24) 1-2; 204. 2:17
159.118 et 119
81-82; 209.9-10; 232.17- 3:3
298.38-39
18 3:4-5 . . . 248.4-5; 295.162:10
141.18
17; 298.37-38
2:13
297.12-13 3:5
155.25-26
2:13-14
160.136-139 3:14 et 3 : 1 6 - 1 8 . . 247.34-40
2:14
248.41-42 3:15 . . . 144.31-33; 152.194
3:10
293.22 3:16 . . . 152.197; 153.199;
7:9
223.17
247.25-26; 257.6; 300.30;
8:3
417.25-26
319.18; 399.13
8:4; 8:7; 8:10
372.23 4:22 . . . 391.20; 414.74-75;
8:7
369.20
417.29
10:11
160.151 4:24 . . . 134.41-42; 146.73;
11:32
174.36; 219.24
249.19-20; 414.75
12:2-4
159.133-135 5:8
266.14
13:12
417.25-26 5:14
151.178-179
15:20-23
414.88
15:27
152.183
Epistula ad Philippenses
15:45 . . 159.124; 266.10-11
2:6-7
388.62-389.64
2:7 . . . 192.105; 193.111;
Epistula ad Corinthios 2
197.37
2:6
369.7

16:25
23:8

Acta Apostolorum
2:17
183.52
2:24
192.108
2:34
365 (19) 5-6
2:38
360.5-6
2:44-45
365 (19) 3-4
4:5 et 8
370.4
4:13
349.3
4:34-35
365 (19) 3-4
6:5
319.11-13
7:3
193.13-14
8:9-24
228.8-12
8:20-24
212 (7) 5-6
10:42
135.64 3 : 1 5

248.11-12

2:8

329.43-44

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Index Locorum

425

2:10

. . . 145.55-56; 159. 4:3 . . . 312.15-17; 364.17;


Epistula Petri 1
116-117; 184.79-80
376.18-20 1:24 . . 215.7-216.9;335.44
3:20
197.27; 246.16 5:19
360.14 2:4
170.118-119
6:15
300.24 2:11
170.127-128
6:20
139.73
Epistula Petri 2
Epistula ad Colossenses
1:18-19
412.52
1:15
410.6
Epistula ad Timotheum 2
1:19
415.11-12
1:19 . . . 174.22-24; 332.7-8 2:20
153.202 2:4
415.11
2:9 . . . 174.22-24; 332.7-8; 4:6
401.10-11 2:11
214.6-7
385.20-21
2:22
343.17-18
2:14-15
329.44-46
3:9

414.74-75; 417.29
1:3
3:4

Epistula ad Titum
Epistula Joaonis 2
300.24
4:8 et 16
238.26-27
415.5

Epistula ad
Thessalomeenses 1
5:5
266.14

Apocalypsis Joannis
1:8 . . . 270.26-27; 271 (50)
Epistula ad Hebraeos
14-15
4:14
242.10
320.16
12:22 . . . 240.37-38; 245. 2:14-15 et 2:6
205.98
50-51; 246.16 13:2
Epistula ad Timotheum 1
19:7
301.40
2:6
300.24
20:14-15
415.12
2:9
365 (20) 6-7
Epistula Jacobi
21:2
246.17
4:1-5
339.8-15 1:22
160.146-148 21:12 et 14
157.64ss.

SCRIPTIS CHRISTIANIS
ET GNOSTICIS
Apophasis Megale Simonis
Magi 165.20-166.23; 214.
15-19; 216 (11) 4; 218.1415; 219.25-27; 222.9-223.
14; 224.5-225.30
Baruch Iustini
199.10-11;
208.1-209.8; 209.23-25
BasilidisApocrypha 286.1-3
Clemens Stromateis IV. 45.1:
157.74
Elchasaitarum liber 357.5-7;
360.2-11; 360.15-361.19;
361.21-34
Evangelium
ad Aegyptios
(Naassenorum)
145.4243
Evangelium Thomae (Nag
Hammadi II. 2)
Logion4 (?): 147.102-105
Logion l i b : 161.172-173
Logion 29(?): 158.96
Hippolytus
Chronicon libri (ed. A.
Bauer et R. Helm)

36-40: 406.23-24 et27-28


De Universe (Fr. 353 Holl,
60: 408.22-23
T.U.XX. 2)
94-97: 407.12-14
p. 137.3 ss.: 415.11
172: 406.16-17
138.6ss.; 139.33ss.: 415.
198: 406.18; 407.11
13
198,159,73 et 92-129: 407.
138.9ss.; 139.38ss.: 415.
11
12
199: 406.17-18
139.49ss.; 140.56ss. et
620: 405.1-2 et 9
64 ss.: 416.17
622: 405.9
140.72 ss.: 416.20
623: 405.10
141.92 ss.: 416.14-15
Chronicon (?) 405.4; 406.
De Universe (?) 409.17
18-19 et 31-32
Syntagma (?) 54.4-6
Liber generationis 1.241: Irenaeus Adv. Haereses (ed.
405.10-1.242: 405.11
Harvey)
Contra Noetum (ed. P.
1.14.1-15.3: 259.16-272.
Nautin)
25
10: 408.1-409.5; 410.7-8;
1.16.1-2: 272.9-276.63
411.24-26; 412.52; 415.
1.17.1-2: 276.1-278 (54)
3
11-12
1.24.1-2: 302.3-304.31
11-12: 412.48 ss.
1.25.1-3 et 25.6: 314.117-18: 413.69ss
316.44
18: 414.85ss.
1.26.1: 317 (33) 1-12
19: 411.24-26

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

426

Indices

et passim (cf. pp. 259.1-3 et Naassenorum hymnus 142. Peratarum 177.


1-180.56
24-28
278.8-10)
Marcionis Antitheses 311.2- Naassenorum psalmus 171. Philumenes
321.8-9; 400.8-9
6-172.29
3; 312.9-10
Monoimi Epistula ad Theo- Paraphrasis Seth (cf. Nag Valentinus
Fr.7: 259.11-13
Hammadi VII. 1 Paraphraphrastum 335.1-11; 398.
Fr. 8 (Psalmus): 253.31-38
sis Seem) 198 (22) 3
23-27

SCRIPTIS PROFANIS
3, pp. 1220b39 50 = 26: 344.3-4
1221 a 12: 79.66-70
51 = 27: 344.5-7 et 18
W B 6 , p . l l 0 7 a 6 : 79.61 52 = 93: 344.13-14
63
53 = 29: 344.15-18
54 = 9: 345.20;345(10)3
Metaph. A 9, 1074 b 34:
55 = 5: 345.23; 345 (10)
285.31-32
4-5
Top. 5, p. 135 a 18: 283.
56 = 21: 345.25-29
23-24
57 = 43: 345 (10) 9-10
Athenaeus IX, 390 F - 3 9 1 A:
58 = 46: 346.11-15
131.15-21
59 = 32: 346.16-19
Democritus 32 DK: 333.
60 = 33: 346.20
16-17
61 = 35: 346.22-23
Eleusinia dicta 152.182-183;
62 = 47: 346.25-26
163.215-216
63 = 73: 347.29-30
Empedocles
64 = 79: 347.33-34
6 DK: 305.17-19; 382.
65 = 55: 347.35
12-14 et 20
66 = 82: 347.31-32
16: 233.5-6; 306.43-44
67 = 77: 189.20-21; 196.
17.19: 306.35. - 17.198-9; 347.40-43; 387.18-19
20: 383.22-23
92 = 75: 155.32
29: 307.58-60
94 = 52: 234 (26) 3-4
109: 216 (11) 8-10
108 Marc.: 147.106 "
110.1-10: 311.135-144.
-110.10: 216(12)2;389.10 Herodotus
115.1-2: 310.120-121.I.1: 134.48
4-5: 308.74-75.-6: 308.
II.2: 127.18; 148.111-113
78. - 7-8: 308.82-83. IV.8-10: 199 (25) 1 - 2 0 0 .
9-12: 309.91-95. - 1018
12: 309.101-103. - 13:
VI.20: 197.41
307.65.-14: 307.68-69;
VI. 119.2-3: 197.42-49
309.107 Hesiodus, Theogonia
22-25: 88 (26) 1-2
117: 62.8-9
50: 90.38
119: 151.163
131: 313.17-20
52-60: 88 (26) 2-5
Euripides, Fr. 1023 . 2 : 382.
108-113: 89.8-12
114: 89.13
10
115-139: 89.14-90.37
6 - 8 Heraclitus
453 ss.: 90.38-39
5, p. 2 a 11: 283.12-14
1 DK = 1 Marcovich:
8, p. 8 b 25: 283.28-30
344.8-12 Hippocratis dictum: 147.106
De anima 1, p. 412 a 19 25 = 97: 163.224-225; Homerus
21 et 27-28: 285.25-26;
164.234-235
Ilias IV.350: 152.198
293.1-2; 294.7-9
36 = 66: 182.19-20
VII.99: 382.5

Anacreonteum

155.33-156.
37
Andronicus Peripateticus
196.2-4
Aratus
19-23: 131.25-30
26 ss.: 134.29 ss.
37-38: 134.35-36
44: 134.43-44
45-46: 131.3-5
46: 185.83 et 87
56-57: 99 (6) 12-13
57: 131.3-5; 185.87
61-62: 132.14-15; 185.8486
63-67: 132.19ss.; 185.8890
66-68: 132.2-133.3
70: 132.29; 185.91
71: 132.1-2; 185.87-88
73: 132.19 ss.; 185.88-90
74-87: 133.21 ss.
82-83: 133.19-20; 185.9294
86-87: 133.19-20
179: 135.77
268-269: 133.7-8
272-281: 136 (49) 11
332-335: 135.56-57
354: 136 (49) 5ss.
615: 132.1-2; 185.87-88
Aristoteles
Cat. 2, p. 1 a 24-25: 283.
26-27
4,p. 1 b25: 81.3-11; 231.

EE

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Index Locorum
XIV.201: 381.3
Plato
XV.36-38: 182.15-17;
Alcibiades
I,
130e7;
195.48-50
133c4: 417.24
Clitopho 407d4: 80.86-90
XV. 189: 154.13; 195.42
Epistula
II,
312 d 7 XXIII.708 ss.: 108.87
314c4: 251.5-252.22
XXIII.778-779: 108.90
Leges 697b2: 79.57-60. Odyssea IV.384-385: 162.
715e7: 77.24-25
186-187
Menexenus 237 d: 143.13V.184186: 182.15-27;
15
195.48-50
VII.36: 290.42
Phaedo 64 c 4; 66 a 3: 234.
X.304-306: 221(15)192 6 - 2 7 . - 6 7 c l : 136(49)
21
13.-69a 10: 79.63-64.XII.44: 280.8-9
81 d: 78.45-48. - 113 d:
XII.47-52: 280.10-13
78.43-45
Phaedrus 245 c5: 78.36-38.
XXIV. 1-2:
150.159- 246c 1: 290.49-50. 160.-2-4: 151.169-171.
246 e 4: 77.28-29.
- 5 : 152.183-184.-6-8:
248c2: 80.80. - 2 4 8 e 152.186-188. - 9-10:
249b:
234.8-12.
153: 204 et 206. - 11:
250b7: 78.50-52
153.209-210
Res publica 617 e 4: 80.79Hymnus in Attinem I 166.
80
40-167.52
Hymnus in Attinem II 167.
Theaetetus 176 b 1-3: 79.
55-168.62
72-75
Hymnus magicus in AesculaTimaeus 19e8: 229(21)3pium 120.17-27
4 . - 2 1 css.: 229(22) 1-4.
Hymnus magicus in Hecaten
- 2 2 b4: 229 ( 2 2 ) 4 - 5 . 124.22-29
31b 5: 236.6-8 et 9. Iosephus, De hello Iudaico
32b4: 236.8-9. - 3 5 b c :
II.8.2-14 (11.119-166 Nie100.23ss. - 3 6 c 7 - d 7 :
se) 364.11-375.14
100.3-9. - 40ab: 100.
Oracula Sibyllina, Fr. 3.1: 181
14ss. - 40e5: 77.29-30.
(16) 3
- 4 1 a7: 77.27-28 et 3233.-41 a8: 409.12-13.Orphicorum Fr. 243 Kern
41 d4: 78.40. - 42b4:
194.19-195.40. - Fr. 352
234.11-12. - 4 2 e - 4 3 a :
164.229-231
411.27-28. - 44d3: 78.
Orphicorum hymnus 83.1-2
40. - 55 a - 5 6 b : 333.5(cf. Fr. 57) 153.212; 330
6; 397.15-17
(12)4
Philolaus, 14 DK 233.23- Plutarchus, Moralia, Fr. 24
Sandbach 194.23-195.34
234.26

427
Poetae Melici Graeci 985
Page 143.13-144.23
Pythagoreorum Symbola 234
(26) 2-4; 235.6, 13, 14-15.
15-16, 17, 20; 236.22
Pythagoreorum
Tetractys
(cf. 58 15 Diels-Kranz):
59.33; 138.36; 231.18-19;
246.2
Sextus Empiricus, Adv. Mathematicos
III. 19-20: 137.13-18
V.5: 236.11-237.18. - 5 11: 175.15-176.40. 12-14: 181.13-17. - 37
et 29: 176.45-48.- 3739 et 44: 92.2-17.- 39:
176.48-177.52. - 44:
177.52-56. - 50-61: 93
(3) 1-95.52.-64-70: 95.
1-97.37. - 74 et 84-85:
97.9-14. - 75 et 77: 97.
14-17. - 86-87: 97.1-8.
- 88-89: 97.18-98.28.92-93: 98.30-41. - 9596: 9 8 . 1 - 5 . - 9 7 - 9 8 : 99
(6) 7-13; 115 (27) 4ss.;
136(50)5ss.-102: 98.57. 105: 99 (7) 7-11
X.310-318: 380(6)8-383.
32
Thrasymedes De magia 212
(7) 4-5 (cf. 115.1-126 (41)
10)
Xenophanes
27 DK: 381.24
33: 382.7
34.3-4: 73.3-4

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

INDEX NOMINUM
[ ] = voxdeleta;() = voxaddita; * = voxemendata.Bas. = Basilides; Doc. = Docetae; Elch.
= Elchasaitae; = Hippolytus; lust. = Iustinus Gnosticus; Marc. = Marcus; Mon. =
Monoi'mus; Naas. = Naasseni; Per. = Peratae; Seth. = Sethiani; Sim. = Simonis Magi
Apophasis Megale; Val. = Valentinus vel Valentiniani. - Nomina sacra etiam atque aeonas,
daemonas, potestates Gnosticorum in Indice verborum invenies.
' 291.76
' 72 (13) 2
" 183.51; 193.7
' 193.9; 295.22. 247.*20, 21; 250.10;
405 (30) (8), 13
298.32
' 200.16
' 106.21, 28
180.50
' 132.26; 133.12; 134.
31; 135.3; 144.26; 193.7;
202.40; 205.113; 208.176;
249.18; 295.12; 336 (16) 5
(Naas.)
142.24;
143.9; 144.29; 151.165;
152.191,192,195,197; 153.
200; 154.7; 155.18; 158.90;
163.220. 384
(9)5.' 156.*52;

145.43; 147.(99}; 148.112;


149.138; 150.149; 182.21,
22; 229 (21) 10; 229 (22)2;
279.12; 302.70; 317 (33) 1;
334.41; 363 (17) 6,10; 373.
12; 380 (5) 5; 406.25; 407
(30)35;407(31) 13; 408.22,
28; 415.2
72 (13) 3; 137.4;
153.217,220; 154.228,229;
154 (8) 10; 167.44; 182.
23 bis; 183.37, 44; 333.11;
397.20; 400 (21)1; 405 (30)
12
": ' 78.43; 85.
22; 136 (50) 9
305.18,21; 382.13
60.*45
169.95
99 (6) 6.
407.13; 415.3
179.34
167.47
157.69
179.31
' 85.1, 8
85.1
53.* 14
' 92(2)1; 173(12)(2)
311.6
14 3. * 16
' 88.

180.*54
' 156.38, 40, 41
53.7; 67.1; 70.
2; 383.26, 28
'
53.7; 64.
Ibis; 381.20, 22
53.7;66.1;67.32
' 135.2, 4; 136
(49) 6, 7; 136 (50) 8
' 196.4
" 352.63; 353.66
' 302.2
250.36
179.24
357.3
279.22; 320 (38) 1;

400 (20) 1
' 70.1
' 120.17
' 101.31; 102.2
406.32
167.*46
99 (6) 11; 130 (46) 7;
385.1.Cf.
131.24; 132.21,22,28; 133.
407.33
179.33
6,24; 134.43,45,55; 135.76
' 80.80
330 (12) 1; 397-1
201.18
" () 104.18, 20
145.57bis, 60; 167.
179.31
101.30
43
60.47
180.50
' 53.11; 63 (5) 8;
228.5
': 81.9
81.1; 82.15,20,33,35; 215.
' 70.1. '
28; 279.3; 281 (14) 3,4; 281
163.208, 211
30; 98.22
(15) 1; 282 (17) 2; 283.12;
108.77, 80, 87bis, 90; ' () 108.
284.37; 284 (19) 5,13; 285.
80 bis
109.8
21, 24, 30, 33, 35; 286.40;
113 (24) 1; 176. ' 357.2; 363.11
287 (20) 23; 287 (21)6; 289.
38, 39; 236.14 144.21
27; 290.49; 293.1,4; 294.8;
144.23; 162.187. ' 201.15
382.15
61.82; 115 (28) 197.*41
' 281 (14) 7
6; 127(43) 18; 130 (44) 14; " 108.85 bis
144.* 19

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

429

Index Nominum
" 131.4; 134.29; 136
(49) 10. "
134.35. "
134.41, 49
312.5
179.37
" 121.4
406. *24
53.7, 9; 70.1; 71
(10) 1; 75 (18) 1
101.32; 101 (9)2;
102(10) 1,7; 103.14,18,23;
104.8, 10
" 61.80
415.4
383.31
120.15; 121.1
312.4.
144.25; 145.46,47,57; 147.
98; 167.43; 169.97,98; 415.

161; 208.184; 208 (27) 2;


209.24; 394.28; 395.34
278.16; 279.3,5;
280 (14) 2; 281 (14) 6; 286.
39;286(20) Ibis,4;287.23;
289.12; 290.50; 292.4; 293.
5; 294.7, 10; 302.69; 302
(28) 1; 391.1; 393.52
245.4; 246.5
201.17
180.40
155.31
201.17
180.44
143.16
124.22
180.43
53.15; 86.*10;
87.17,24; 88.31,33.
86.1
2 179.*31
163.*216
109.93 bis
163.216
180.44
318 (35) 1; 401
194.26
(23) 1
" 146.64, *70; 163.213;
167.42, 53, 55; 179.38
209.28
201.15;271 (51)4
180.50
156.46
145.58, 59; 146.
180.53; 208.175,
61; 164.231. =
176
(lust.) 204.93; 206.
212 (7) 1
143; 395.31.
200.16
() 101.34; 102.17;
169.94; 203.54
104.15, 17 77.30; 143.13; 144.27.
201.* 17
89.16, 24
180.46. 142.28; 155.20,
108.*91 bis;
109.*92bis,
21; 199 (25) 2
*93, *94 90.38; 105 (12) 4;
" 212 (7) 8; 213 (8) 1,
144.21
9, ll,15bis, 19,20,22; 213 228.13
(9) 4; 224.2 178.21
201.17; 204.93; 206.
143; 395.31
72(13)3; 170.122
127 (43) 15; 380
(5)8
168.61
194.23
250.*36; 312.
4
199.11; 201.15; 202.
27; 205.102, 104; 206.120,
123,128,133,145; 207.150,

124.28
170.126; 268.23; 337.
20; 377.36
72 (13) 1
208.177, 178
180.50
88.30
406.27
60.47
194.25.
180.40

53.8; 72 (13)
1 bis; 383.27, 29
179.37
111 (17) 1; 176.32,
(34); 236.13
234 (26) 3
282 (18)6
60.47
(senior) 252.12.
(iunior) 251.4
194.25
321.29; 322.4; 323.
11; 328.36; 330 (11) 2,4,9;
395.1
131.4,8; 132.17,20,
27bis, 29; 133.28; 135.68;
185.87, 91
' 53.15; 61.81; 88 (25)
1,8
144.* 19
252.12
" 406. (16), 23, (28)
318(35)4
279.14, 16; 317
(34) 1; 401 (22) 1
406.16
115(28)5; 117.36
116.14; 141.
16

180.*47
322.15; 339.1
' (Naas.) 168.84, 85;
169.88. (Per.) 183.47, 48.
(lust.) 201.7,10,12,14,16;
202.21,23,24 bis, 32,33,38,
40,42,43,45; 203.47,50,57,
67; 204.73, 87, 88, 89, 92,
93; 205.97, 98, 105, 109,
118; 206.(122), 122, 126,

129,136; 207.146,153,163,
164; 208.174, 178, (183),
185 bis; 209.20; 394.10,18,
(20), 21, 25, 29; 395.35, 39.
(Sim.) 219.35, 36, 39, 42;
220.1
259.1; 278 (55) 8
' 123.15
179.30
" 106.29bis, 33; 107.
35,38; 108.78,91; 109.92
53.8; 74.1
' 225.3; 226.9,20; 227.
29, 40; 228.5, 7

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

430

Indices

144.20; 163.218,
219. ' 163.
*214; 194.25
' () 163.
208; 194.26
' 152.182; 163.22
134.35,39,50
116.14
" 179.33
54.1; 56.51,54,64;
57.8; 91.46; 98.33,36; 109.
12; 133.5; 134.36,46; 137.
4; 140.4,9; 141.1; 143.13;
150.148; 155.22, 31; 182.
19; 198.6; 211.8; 213.16;
229 (21) 11; 229 (22) 4; 230
(22) 8; 280.6; 314.38; 319
(36) 11; 330(11) 8; 335 (14)
48; 335 (15) 12,17; 345.26;
363 (17)2,10; 372.5,7; 378.
1,5; 380 (5) 5,13; 380 (6) 1,
4; 406.26; 407.36; 408.22,
23, 28; 409.18; 415.1.
" 213.19
' 142.5; 199.18;
213.13; 229.14; 270.11;
407.15
167.*45
' (lust.) 201.11,12;
202.32 bis, 38, 40, 44; 203.
47, 50; 204.70, 75, 89, 91,
92; 205.95 bis, 99,100,102;
206.126,130,134,135,145;
207.150,153,159; 208.174,
177, 182, 186; 208 (27) 4;
209.17, 20; 393.5; 394.12,
18,(22),26,(27),29; 395.(38)
' 53.6; 62.1,13;
63 (4) 4,7; 194.31; 216 (11)
7; 234.7; 279.9,18; 304.7,9;
306.40; 307.64, 70; 309.
105;310.111,118,131;311.
5; 312(30) 12,14,17,21,23;
312(31)2; 313.8,9,14; 314.
35; 382.11, 18
' 132.22, 25;
132(48) 1; 133.16,21; 134.
31; 135.71; 185.89,92
' 145.*57; 146.62;
180.54
' 342 (7) 3; 403.2
' 120.26
' 53.13; 84.1; 85.
23; 383.27, 30

" 89.22
' 60.47
234(26)3,4,14,15
' 180.46
' 133.5; 150.(151), 152,
156, 159; 152.184; 156.56.
' 133.8; 153.206.
150.150. '
() 101.36; 104.17,
19. '
180.43
' 322.9; 336 (17)
1; 337.13, 23; 404 (28) 1
60.46
199 (25) 1
' 134.46
47; 153.218; 182.21,24-25,
26; 183.33; 220.11,(12), 14
180.53. " 89.* 19
' 180.54
364.12; 373.1, 12
135.4; 183.46; 184.72,
73 bis; 193.7; 202.41, 43;
205.111
Eoia 98.36
169.91
179.34
382.8
66.1
415.4
60 *46; 62.*11;
109.94, 95
169.102; 170.122;
203.54
92
(2) 1; 173 (12) (2); 176.43;
385.* 1
63 (4) 1; 381.21

5 3.12; 8 2.
31 bis; 83.3
113(21) 1; 176.38,39;
236.14
180.44
180.44

67.1
' 327.12
" 153.210
341.8; 357.6; 358.
(31); 360.12; 363 (17) (2), 9,
12; 404 (29) 2
89.23
170.110;
187.45; 197.33, 37-38
' 383.31
' 343.4; 349.72
' 53.6; 63 (4)1,
10; 182.19; 214.14; 341.4;
342 (7) 2; 343.3,8; 344.1,4;
345.1, 7; 346.12; 347.38,
45; 348.53; 381.21

211.7; 237.5;
249.28
' 199(25) 1; 200.10,
12; 206.136, 139bis, 144;
207.147; 209.27; 395.30
" 305.18, 20; 382.13
' 134.48; 140.13;
197.48; 199 (24) 13; 199
(25) 1; 200.10,18; 200 (26)
6
' 180.55
'
174.19; 183.53;
207.149; 385.17; 395.33
201.15. 151.166
183.55
& 123.14 ' 53.15; 88 (26) 1;
61.80; 88 (25) 2
345.7, 9
60.48, 55, 61; 230 " 180.45
(23)4
155.18, 19
178.10, 14
77.29; 78.50; 88 (26) 2, 53.6;57(1)1;63(5)6;
4; 90.39; 136 (49) 5; 144.23;
64.1; 71 (10)1; 168.78; 363
166.40; 228.5; 305.18, 20;
(17) 9; 381.20, 22
382.13. 120.17. 406.15
() 101.38; 102.11; 90.*33
104.20, 23 90.33
342 (7) 6,13; 349. 319 (36) 5; 402
3; 350.16; 352.64; 353.71
(24) (1)
371.11
279.
6 72 (12) 1
16; 318 (35) 1; 401 (23) 1,9

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

431

Index Nominum
319
(36)2
Montanista 341.
6; 354.97; 404.24
335.1
180.54
157.69, 70
88 (25) 3
212 (7) 4
57.11
147.102.. 109
' 158.103; 184.58; 193.
9; 250.11; 295.23; 405 (30)
6, lObis, 12
' 142.2, 4; 384.13
120.*26
90.32; 178.14
144.*22
135.*77
' 180.*55
193.8; 407.7,11; 408.
22

143.* 17; 167.57


' 162.200,201; 163.
203
' 165.15; 377.
40. '
153.219; 240.37; 245.50;
246.16,17. '
162.200
(Naas.) 142.33; 156.
44,46; 159.109; 161.(176);
170.123; 172.18; 384 (9) 7.
(lust.) 207.151, 155, 159;
395.33. (Val.) =
248.13; 249.19,
29; 250.16. = aeon
242.10; 251.23.
(Marc.) 263 (45) 3; 263.9;
269.(17), [18]; 270.1, 9bis;
271 (50) 13; 271 (51)3; 272.
16,17,(18),[19],20.(Bas.)
298.43; 299.*50, 53; 301.
42,46, 52; 302.64, 68; 393.
43. (Marcion) 314.30.
(Carpocrates) 314 (32) 2;
315.10, 16,19. (Cerinthus)
317(33) 4,*10,10; 400(21)
4; 401.11, 12. (Ebionaei)
318 (34) 5, [6], (Theodot.
Byz.) 318 (35) 6; 401 (23)
*4, 7. (Theodot. trapez.)
319.6. (Cerdon) 320 (37)3.

(Doc.) 329.56, 59; 330.67;


396.29. (Callistus) 350.17.
(Elch.) 404.7, (7).
247.36; 320 (37)
3. 263
(45) 3; 350.17
filius Nun 154.230
180.54
62.12
296.33,37.
118.71
' 53.15; 72 (13) 2; 86.1;
322.16; 415.3
178.*21; 180.50
154.9
' 154.227; 155.19;
318 (35) 8; 328.41; 363.4
227.34; 405.2, 5
279.14; 315.10;
317 (34) 3; 372.11
'vel' 227.
35; 303.17,20; 304.31; 321.
17; 337.6; 341.11; 351.31,
37; 352.42; 363.19; 363
(18) 1; 370.8; 374.13, 15;
376.1, 3, 25; 377.40, (41);
406.(17)
215.2, 3; 405.6
336
(16) 1

140.
12; 198 (22) 5; 198 (23) 1;
199 (24) 1; 200.19; 201.7;
210.1; 393.1; 395.40
" 102.2
" 381.20 bis
' 147.108
147.106
" 53.8; 75 (16) 1
193.9; 250.10; 295.
22; 405.(9), (10), 14
286.1, 4
148.116, *118; 179.36

154.228; 158.84;
183.34; 184.61; 206.121;
208.185 bis, 186; 215.2;
240.38; 405.(7). (lust.) = 201.8; 394.
10

' 57(2)4;61.72;249.28
' 57 (2) 2
249.28
114 (26) 1; 176.35;
236.15

' 320.16
131.5; 327.10
408.23
' 183.54
207.151; 314.3; 317.
5; 395.34; 400 (21) 5
408.23
405 (30) 11 bis
144.20
183.48, 49; 193.7
406.23
340.1
313.26; 350.2; 362.
17
88.32
313.19
356.144
341.5; 342.10,
13; 349.1,12; 351.9,16,27,
38; 352.50,55,59; 353.(67),
69; 354.104; 356.140, 144;
357.4; 358.24, 30; 403.13;
404.25
156.46
180.46
201.18
111 (18) 1; 115
(27) 9; 176.38, 39; 236.13
279.10; 314.
41; 314 (32) 1; 317 (34) 3
350.1,2,6,7;
351.13, 23, 25, 39, 43; 352.
62

92(2) 1; 173(12)
(2); 176.43; 385.1
179.29
135.1, 3
201.18
155.17, 18
176.43. .'
180.4; 194.24
53.15; 61.81; 88 (25)
1, 5; 415.3
279.18; 320 (37) 1;
398 (19)1
279.12, (17); 317
(33) 1; 317 (34) 2; 318 (35)
4; 400 (21) 1; 401 (22) 2
136 (49) 5
135.77; 135(49) 1,3;
136 (50) 8; 178.13
143.16

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

432

Indices

221.3
67.1; 383.27
341.5; 342 (7) 4,
8; 349 (10) 71; 349 (11) 13;
403.2
179.37
90.32

105 (13) 3;
211.10; 278.14
73.1; 382.6
352.47,52
179.24. = 145.60. filia
Cereris 194.25

157.69; 167.47.
144.18
143.17; 167.58;
179.30
180.44
90.32
121.15
110.19; 175.24; 176.
30, (31), 37, 38; 236.13

57.12
90.35, 38; 166.40;
178.11; 182.9,10,12,13,25.
() 101.39;
102 (9) 9; 104.22

61.72

180.54; 208.173, 174


144.20
212(7) 8; 213(8) 1;213
(9) 1; 224.2. 144.
*21; 213 (8) 4, 14,21; 407.
14; 415.2
212.9; 213.7,12; 415.4
140.10; 194.20
279.20; 320 (37)
7
82.30, 34
132.2; 133.4, 6, 8, 13,
17; 185.88
61.79
154.11
88.30; 98.22
322.14; 338.2;
402 (25) 1
98.33
142.34;207.151;248.
13; 249.24; 250.38,40; 251.
17, 20, 25; 271 (51)6; 298.
43, 47; 317.5; 325.*12,
[13]; 393.43; 395 (15) 34;
395(16)8; 400 (21)5. 328.38
154.9
142.2, 3. 384.13
352.46, 52, 58
279.8,19,20,(22);
304.1; 311.1,(6); 312(30)9;
312 (31)1; 313.21; 314.34;
320 (37) 5; 320 (38) 2; 322.
8; 336 (16) 4; 398 (18) 4;
398 (19) 1; 400.13
312.*4
(evangelista) 311.4,
5

280.5.
90.37
136 (49) 11
156.56
150.151, 159
339.6
134.49; 135.67
134.43
73.1
135.56bis, 58, 61 bis,
63, 65; 179.36
120.(22)
(gnosticus) 211.10;
256.1, 15; 259.10, 16; 262.
201.18
26; 263 (44) 8; 263 (45) 5;
180.50
278.14
123.14
286.2, 5; 287.25
415.3
194.27; 195.
180.55
40
405 (30) 11 bis
: 81.*9
382.15
180.47
153.209,215 178.21
53.8;72(12) 1;72 74.* 18
(13) 1,4 319 (36) 3; 402
(24)2
98.3; 112 (19) 1; 115
(27) 8; 236.14

279.*6; 302.3

108.80, 82; 109.


94 bis, 95

158.103,
105bis; 405.1, 8
407.* 13
381.21
311.*5
179.33
155.22; 167.45; 180.42
124.*28
( = ')
146.64.
168.64
74.12
57 (1) 1; 64.2; 66.
1; 168.78; 381.20
(?) 180.41
201.15
88 (26) 4bis;
90.33
180.49
322.6; 330 (11)
10; 330 (11) 1; 335.1, 17;
397.* 1; 398.27
322.13; 338.4;
402 (25) 1, 3; 402 (26) 2
124.28
313.14,16.
88 (26) 2bis, 6; 89.13
140.10; 194.20
180.*39
132.26; 154.10; 183.
41,42,43,45; 193.4; 202.22,
29, 41; 206.120, 123; 214.
10,11,14; 218 (13) 10; 218
(14) 1, 12; 219.32; 220.5,
16; 225.1; 266.8; 278 (55) 5;
289.17; 295.12,22; 320(37)
2; 320 (38) 4; 334.40, 42;
363.2; 375.18; 394.16; 397.
3; 400 (20) (6).
161.161; 183.32, 34; 184.
63,64,66; 185.14; 202.29;
203.51, 55; 214.9; 240.36;
244.42; 250.10; 324.27;
326.42,44; 327.2; 331.1,10,
18; 396.24; 397.12,19; 401
(22) 3; 412.49
201.17; 202.28; 205.
98, 108, (110), 111; 206.
(122), 131; 207.160, 161;
208.175; 209.21
140.3; 141.16;
168.71; 173(11) 1; 3 8 4 ( 9 ) 2

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Index Nominum

215.36
207.151
180.53
406.15
184.59.
178.*21
68.19; 144.23
305.19, 22, 26; 382.
14
319 (36) 12
340.*2
338.16; 340.24;
402 (26) 1
341.3, 5; 342 (7) 1;
343.*10; 347.37,44,46; 402
(26) 5; 403.1; 404.23
90.28
89.22,23
355.117; 406.(18), 24;
407(30)36; 407(31)6,18

53.8; 73.1; 74.


14; 381.23; 382.6

' 108.87,88,89,90;
109.8; 280.6, 10
180.39
382.* 15
' 179.37
88(26)6;89.12,17

152.198; 154.2;
195.46, 51; 345.26; 381.2
' 180.47; 206.143;
395.31
73.1
" 136 (49) 11
140.10; 194.21, 23
148.118 bis; 167.44;
179.33
180.43
179.24

138.48, 51;
139.78; 211.5; 228.18; 229.
21,24; 229 (21) 1,5,9; 229
(22) 6; 230 (22) 9; 237 (29)
2,5,12; 239.8; 246.1; 251.1;
252.23,26,29; 254.44; 259.
8,11; 278 (55) 1,15; 322.8;
336 (16) 3; 390.1; 391.22;
398 (18) 1
352.48,59
77.29; 89.25; 90.31
179.25
179.25

133.24; 134.33;
135.73; 185.93
133.23,25; 185.92,94
340.19
180.*47
405.2
168.61
159.114,116; 167.48
98.3; 99 (6) 6; 112
(20) 1; 115 (27) 9; 176.34;
236.14
357.5
362.* 18
108.(81), 81; 180.53
53.7; 71 (11)1
74.18
(?) 107.*63
107.39, 42, 46,
48; 10 8.69 bis
147.93; 159.132;
311.3; 314.31; 315.18; 339.
7, 16
144.19
180.51
144.*21
69.*28
140.7; 177.(58); 181
(15) 1; 181 (16) 1; 385.1;
386.30
92 (2) 1; 93 (2)
*12,19; 173 (12) 1,(2); 176.
42, 43; 177.66, *67; 185.1;
188 (18) 1; 385.1
120.26
82.34; 196.4
281 (15) 8;287.21
127 (43) 14; 197.41,
49
135.2, 4; 136 (49)
8 bis

145.60; 164.
226, 228.
120.24
180.44
228.12; 315.18
150.161
88 (26) 6
316.44
350.5
280.*5
53.9, 11; 70.48; 75
(17) 3; 75 (18) 3; 76(18) 4,
6; 76 (19) [1]; 81.99; 81

433
(20) 13 bis, 14; 82.19, 24;
98.24; 102(10) 9; 103.[17],
(20); 215.28; 229 (21) 2,7;
229 (22) 1, 4; 230 (22) 9;
234.26; 234 (26) 8; 236.5;
237(29) 2,6; 251.3; 252.21,
24,25, (27), 30; 290.49; 337.
12; 363 (17) 10; 383.33
77.17; 102.3;
103.16; 211.6; 229 (21)2,4;
237 (29) 4
194.30
82.31
108.85, 86, 87
57 (2) 3
304.1; 383.31; 398
(19) 1
90.30
351.11
178.20
64.1
180.*41
312.4; 313.7
180.50
207.167, 168
322.13; 338.2;
402 (25) 1
180.50
178.13
162.187
(astronomus)
105 (12) 2, 10
'
179.37
(gnosticus)
211.7; 237.5; 249.29; 254.
1; 255.24
53.6; 57 (2) 2,3;
59.32; 60.47,48; 61.75, 80,
82; 62.11; 63 (5) 5; 88 (25)
3 bis; 137.4, 8; 138.35; 229
(21)3,6; 230 (22) 7,9; 230
(23) 1, 4, 6, 8, 9; 231.1;
233,21,22; 234 (26) 1; 234
(27)1; 235.5; 237 (29) 1,6;
272.6; 335.15; 363 (17)2,9;
372.11
61.78, 81; 88
(25) 1; 105 (13) 5; 211.11;
229 (21) 4bis; 235.5, 11;
236.1, 3; 238.18; 251.2;
272.4; 278.11; 359.8, 10
88(25)6; 175.
26; 211.6; 229 (21) 1; 230.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Indices

434

180.54
229 (21) 2, 3; 229
(22) 1
98.30; 113 (23) 1;
176.34; 236.14
358.17; 362.17
120.*25
180.41; 194.24
cf. '
98.35
60,45 bis; 226.7
226.16
118.67;
122.15; 126 (41) 3
389.1; 390.26
178.19
363.3
118(29)3
352.53, 57
152.195,(197)
113(22) 1; 236.14 98.35, 38; 114
(25) 1; 236.14
200.16
90.32
199 (25) 2

16; 231.4; 232.4; 237 (29)4, 357.5


12; 246.10 182.4
134.44 bis
61.78
() 101.37; 371.11
102.13 312.8
280.4
60.46
137.18; 138.48, 50;
53.14; 85.2
139.78; 210.7; 211.3; 212
85.2
(7) 1,3,10; 213 (9) 1,4; 214.
5,9,15,22; 216 (11) 1; 218.
' 406.(16)
4,14; 222.1; 224.2,5; 225.1;
' 144.*19
226.22; 227.40; 228.4, 7, 8,
' 180.47
18; 229.21,23; 320 (37) 2;
' 162.198
' 90.39; 146.75; 166.41;
167.42; 179.38. ' 90.
33; 167,55
' 75 (16) 1
' 351.34
' 228.11; 342 (7) 3; 350.
29; 351.20; 357.4

280.5
290.49
342(7) 1; 403.1
215.2
400.(16), (17)

357.7
349.9; 353.72,78;
(i.q. ) 195.34,
354.97 179.32
35, 37
364.12; 375.1, 229(22)*2; 363(17)9 201.18
14, 19; 376.21 180.47
364.12; 374.14;
281 (14) 3
201.18
375.1, 14

132.2;
133.14,18,
406.23
169.90; 203.54, 62
19,
23,
24,
25,
27;
134.34;
98.33
cf. 212(7) 1; 227.36;
185.88, 94

228.9; 375.15 226.11


195.*34, 36
57 (2) 2,3; 60,46; 101. () 102.16
321.8; 400.8
30; 230 (22) 7 372.11
144.21
156.50,52,54; 182.16; 195.49
180.*46
167.46 53.12; 62.5; 82.32; 195.40
170.127
83.1; 84.20; 381.17 194.*25, *26
352.45, 49, 54
74.16
167.59
108.68, 73
74.1
90.34
201.18
302.2; 357.3
134.45 bis, 46
304.26,29; 316.30 53.9bis; 63 (5) 8; 162.200; 226.16
279.5; 302.1;
71 (10) 2; 75 (17) 3; 75 (18) 407.13
1; 252.22; 282(18)6; 322.9 350.29; 351.33,
304.31
337.12
155.17, 18
37, 40
280.5, 8, 12, 16
116.11,28
211.7; 254.1
86.5

147.99; 148.112;
146.62
120.20; 178.13;
157.70; 159.114, 121, 129;
154.10
415.11. 89.18
161.167,179; 162.190,193;
406.15
322.8; 336 (16) 1,
163.207, 208; 165.1, 9, 12;
193.7; 198 (22) 3
6; 398 (18) 1
167.48. (gnostici)
140.9; 188 (19) 1; 110.1; 175.24; 176.
322.13; 338.1; 402 (25) 1
193.2; 195.35, 39, 46, 52;
31; 236.13 143.17
196.4; 197.50; 198 (22) 1,4; 90.34; 381.*3
386.1; 389.65 313.25
93 (3) (1), 7; 99
(7) 12; 177.57, 66
193.8; 406.24; 407.7,11 169.96; 197.41;203.54

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Index Nominum
vel 60.
48; 93 (2) 8, 13; 94.14, 20,
33; 95.52; 96.12,14,17,28;
97.1,7; 98.25,29; 99.2; 144.
26; 175.15; 380 (5) 7; 406.
26;407.35;408.21,28;415.2
193.8; 407.7, 11, 12
405.3,14
407.* 12
407.13
89.15,22 (Hesiodus).Cf.
405.2
280.5
178.19
407.13
130 (45) 7; 170.
124; 237 (29) 4; 316.(29);
339.6; 351.36; 352.41; 354.
103
() 143.7,12; 147.
105; 173(12)3; 174(13)20;
177.59, 68; 214.5; 228.18;

229.15; 230 (22) 10 bis;


272.6; 278.12; 280.16; 281
(14) 3; 286.43; 304.6; 314.
38; 322.10; 339.2; 341.4;
343.6, 11; 347.38; 350.17;
355.125; 377.32; 416.19;
417.27. (Gnosticus anonymus) 134.32. (Naas.) 151.
179,180. (Per.) 174.20,28;
385.18; 386.24. (Val.) 247.
36, 37; 249.33; 251.(20);
391.16. (Aeon) 241.10, 13,
16; 242.33, 36, 38; 243.11,
18,21; 251.18. (Marc.) 263
(45) 3; 269.20; 270.25; 272.
19. (Saturnilus) 303.19.
(Carpocrates) 315.13; 316.
44. (Cerinthus) 317.8, 10,
11; 401 (21) 9, 11, 12.
(Ebionaei) 317 (34) 2; 318
(34) 6, 8; 401 (22) 2.
(Theodot. Byz.) 318 (35) 4,
9,11; 319 (35) 12; 401 (23)

435
2, 7, 9. (Theodot. trapez.)
319 (36) 4bis,6; 402 (24)4.
(Cerdon) 320 (37) 3, 4.
(Apelles) 321.10; 400 (20)
4, 7, 9. (Hermogenes) 337.
14. (Phryges) 338 (19) 11,
13; 402 (25) 4. (Elch.) 359.
4; 404 (29) 5. (Marcion)
399.12. (Marc.)
269.*19, *22.

(Val.) 251.22. (Ebionaei)


318 (34) 9. =
Messias 376.23; 377.45.
263 (45)
3; 350.17. 247.36; 320 (37) 3
53.12; 83.2
144.*25
406.27
'
90.31; 153.209,
212,214; 158.106; 330(12)
3, 4; 381.3

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

INDEX VERBORUM
A

POTIORUM

149.142; 156.54,57
351.38; 377.*30
192.100;215.3;221.
6; 238.27; 293.27; 335.7
227.26; 238.26,27bis.
- (Val.) 240.19

136.4; 209.26;
350.*25
139.66, 70bis; 291.
71, 72
142.36,37; 384.9,
10; 400 (21) 3

159.133; 205.98,
103; 206.(121); 207.159;
271.4; 287.3; 304.30; 328.
37; 357.7; 411.29; 413.73.
- 166.24; 184.74;
201.14, 15, 16, 19; 202.21,
24, 25, 27, 28, 32; 203.53,
55,63; 204.73,80,90; 205.
104, 106, 109; 206,136,
138, 142; 226.14; 227.30,
33, 38,43; 246.15; 261.45;
279.6, 10; 302.4, 5; 303.6,
11, 18, 22; 304.29; 314.1;
316.37; 320 (38) 6; 360.10;
361.29; 362.19; 376.6, 22;
394.13, (14), (15); 400 (20)
6; 410.16; 415.13
291.69
362.19
131.16
71(11)*2;76.*13;
77.*14, *23; 78.36; 166.
*24; 336 (17) 2; 344.2,15;

154.8; 161.164
330 (11)3
287.*7; 331.8,
13
177.3
150.147
176.47
111 (16) 10; 113
(21)6; 113(23)3; 114(24)
5; 128.40; 129.59; 129 (44)
1, 2; 176.48
78.35,44bis, 51; 80.
93; 92 (2) 3; 93.4; 136.13;
161.161; 168.80; 177.60,
61; 257.7; 303.23,25; 309.
105; 310.127; 352.47; 372.
21; 3 7 5 . 9 . - 80.
84; 81.97; 150.147; 345.6;
346.11; 375.3; 412.37.
(Per.) 173 (12) 8,11, [12];
385.7, (10). (Empedocles)
310.132; 313.11. (Marcion) 311.2; 312 (30) 9; 312
(31) 1; 313.24, 26; 314.31.
(Prepon) 313.7. - 79.56,57,58,59; 82.19,
20,22,26; 205.116.-' (): (Naas.) 149.
132; 164.237. (lust.) 199
(23), 23; 199 (24) *3, *4,
*8; 200.2; 204.81, 82, 83,
86, 92; 205.117; 206.121;
207.(154), 157, 158, 163,
166,167; 208.187; 208 (27)
404 (28) (2)
3,4; 209.7, 8,9,15; 393.3;
174.*17,29; 239.
394.24; 395.37. (Marcion)
5; 306.46; 385.15; 386.
304.3; 312.13, 15; 314.32,
24
33; 398 (19) 2,3; 399.4,12.
(Cerdon) 320 (37) 5. 127.22; 161.165;
173.11; 174.25, 35; 181.5;
(Apelles) 320 (38) 2; 321.
191.74; 200.1; 216 (12) 3;
11, 25; 400 (20) <3). ()
217.12,13;
222.21,27; 222
412.37; 414.84; 417.31
(17) 3, 9; 224.*3; 230.1;
110.29
237.8; 238.22; 239.42;
301.40
240.28, 31, *32; 254.*9;

255.32; 261.*44; 303.*16;


306.*41; 310.124; 314.
*29; 314 (32) *2; 315.*6;
325.*15; 330 (12) *6; 348.
*52; 385.9, 22; 389.11, 19,
20; 393.2; 395.11; 402 (26)
4; 403.8. -
(Val.) 255.19
180.51.- (Val.) 239.* 13
64.4
227.27
& 56.50; 149.142; 172.
28.

227.26. -
268.7. - 56.49; 140.7, 12; 154.
3; 198 (23) 1; 279.9; 322.
1 5 . - : ()
55.34, 42; 320.15; 323.9;
377.37. (Sim.) 227.36.
(Val.) 241.11, 13, 16; 242.
*36, 38; 243.12, 15; 248.
14; 249.20, 23; 250.37;
251.23,
24;
391.(16).
(Marc.) 271.4. (Bas.) 290.
50; 291.55,63,72; 292.77;
292 (23) 2,7; 296.39; 297.
9; 298.44; 300.33; 301.38;
392.18,24. (Elch.) 358.14;
360.10; 361.29. (Theodot.
Byz.) 401 (23) 5
369.(18)
360.7
366.6
94.32; 95.39; 105
(12) 4; 117.58; 155.20;
182.22; 228.8; 240.28;
245.8; 248.44; 248 (35) 6;
263 (45) 9; 276.(62); 293.
20; 317(33)3; 326.31; 332.
13; 348.56; 392.31; 396.
18; 400 (21) 4; 409.19
63 (4) 2; 80.84; 208.
188; 241.1; 287.*22; 296.
6; 299.6; 300.17, 20

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Index Verborum
178.11,20; 179.23,
27, 30, 32, 35, 38; 180.40,
42, 45, 49, 52; 185.86

94.37; 138.54;
149.138; 170.3; 328.34;
345.19, 21; 408.26. 200 (26)
(4>; 302.3; 317.*9; 320 (37)
4; 393.5; 401 (21) 9
365.9
131.19
349.3
118.62
131.15
336 (17) 5, 9
111(16)7
149.145
118.72
54.7; 55.45; 81.2; 109.3;
121.4; 134.38,50; 164.227;
173(12)3; 187.47,48; 190.
53; 199 (24) 8; 199 (25) 2;
258.14; 309.109; 340.(25);
349.4; 358.32; 364.16;
373.8
228.2
238.18; 342 (6) 1, 2;
363.21
98.32; 109.104
119(30)5
223.13; 360.3
183.54; 323.6; 324.
45; 329.63. - = Iacobus
142.2; 384.13. - = Christiani 349.6; 350.6; 351.22
66.5; 178.12

74.3; 127.20;
128.30; 312.23; 324.*37;
331.16; 344.1; 353.82;
403.(18)
88(26)3;203.67
120.21
232.3
319 (36) 14
310.125; 361.32; 368.
13 bis
193.18; 197.30
80.84; 129.59
78.52; 113 (21) 7; 283.
29; 373.13; 374.26
406.21
328.34
91.51; 303.10; 395.
38

54.6; 259.3
189.28; 387.25
103.27; 117.33;
237.13; 283.*30; 299.11;
300.18. - 336
(17) 2; 390.4; 404 (28) 3
62.85; 363 (17) 6
$ 136.13; 166.38; 171.*5;
280.9
66.6; 72 (12) 2; 72 (13) 5;
77.18, 20; 87.12; 137.9;
162.181,195; 180.51; 181.
16; 185.8; 188(18)2; 203.
58, [66]; 226.6; 232.2; 237.
18; 256.34; 259.4,20; 262.
22; 305.26; 306.33,46,51;
310.116, 127; 316.34; 327.
3, (8); 336 (17) 4ter, (5), 5;
344.7, 8; 349.5; 353.67;
365 (19) 8; 369.(19); 373.
14; 374.26; 376.9; 396.25;
404.9; 415.13. - 153.
213
122.28
177.5
120.*20
(Val.) 240.* 19
162.181

59.*33; 138.*36;
231.* 19; 246.2. -
415.12
113 (24) 2; 131.14;
208.175 bis; 292.79
237.13; 238.19; 240.
26; 255.22
334.34
232.22
60.58; 64.13; 65.22; 66.
1,4,9 bis, 13,15; 67.24,30;
68.13; 69.32, 39, 42; 70.
6,(9), 14; 73(14)9; 76(19)
5; 82.17; 83.13; 88.34;
95(4); 123.16, 18, 19; 124
(36)1; 127(43) 15; 169.99;
178.8 ( ); 179.
29, (29); 180.48, 55; 218
(13) 12; 224.13; 253.35,
36; 254.40,41; 276.1; 291.
62; 294.13; 305.14, 21;
306.48; 307.54; 309.100;
310.124; 326.43,44,46,47,
49,50; 333.4,7; 380 (6) 10;
381.18,22; 383.25,35; 397.
7, (14), 17; 408.3

437

77.32; 142.27;
154.222; 162.195; 168.78;
184.74; 237.21; 306.40;
308.76; 310.124; 331.20;
344.2; 346.24, 25; 348.53;
372.2; 402 (26) 5; 403.9;
409.10; 416.17; 417.23. 60.44; 78.
42; 82.15, 27; 83.12; 234.
25; 234 (26) 14; 244.49;
299.8; 372.3; 374.25
288.9
54.9; 371.6
54.8; 56.47; 314.36;
342 (7) 4; 343.7; 359.18
361.32
237.*12; 238.*19
56.60
206.139
65.23; 72 (12) 5; 73
(14) 8; 107.44; 232.29,30;
237.19
107.47
326.29; 327.[19]
414.89
54.12; 105 (13) 9;
226.21; 323.4; 343.16;
353.77; 354.98; 377.29
64.4, 7; 71 (11) 1; 72
(11) 5; 73 (14) 6; 77.22; 82.
28; 84.9; 233.8; 285.33;
330 (12) 7. - 277.
3
87.28; 263 (44) 7

148.*119, * 121;
179.35; 293.31; 294.12,14;
309.91
68.11,22; 128.42; 180.
55; 216 (11) 9 bis; 294.* 13;
309.94, 98, * 102; 382.*8,
10. - 89.23
253.36; 254.41
371.13; 372.22
85.20; 124.25,27; 219.
39,43; 220.13; 223.19,21,
24; 334.42. - 183.
51; 214.6, 20
183.50

110.3; 118.70,
72; 256.7
54.7; 234 (26) 2
218.5
376.9
'' 119(31)1; 136.15; 161.180

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

438

Indices

161.179; 162.191;
167.50
56.68; 109.9;
126(42)3; 127(42)12; 130
(46) 4; 136 (50) 12; 141.8;
234 (27) 3; 380 (6) 2; 384
(8) 4; 409.20
53.(1), 2; 56.56, 57,
66; 57 (2)4; 85.1; 86.1; 88
(25) 7; 92.(1); 93 (2) 6,15;
105 (13) 2; 130 (45) 4, 11;
130 (46) 3; 137.1; 138.55;
140.1,2,6; 141.7, 19; 173
(11)5; 173(12)(1); 176.43;
181 (15)2; 185.1; 188(18)
1; 199.19; 209.25; 211.(1),
2; 212 (6) 4; 229 (21) 1,14;
237.3; 251.1; 259.15; 279.
1,2,4; 304.10; 312(30) 7;
312(31) 1,5; 314 (34) 36;
318 (55) 1; 322.(1), 2; 329.
58; 330 (11) 2; 338.16; 339
(19) 19; 339 (20) 18; 340.
19, *24; 341.(1), 2, 6bis;
342 (6) 1,3; 342 (7) 2,11;
343.5; 347.38, 45; 349.1;
350.28; 353.80; 354.106;
359(13) 36; 359(14) 3; 363
(17) 22; 363 (18) 7; 365
(19) 3; 368.1; 375.15; 378.
13; 379.(1), 2,4; 380 (5) 1;
401 (23) 1; 402 (25)2; 402
(26) 1; 403.2, 13, 14; 404
(29) 1; 409.21
375.20
54.3; 91.47; 99.
* 15; 109.12; 132.24; 136
(50) 12; 139.80; 210.*2;
236.2; 280 (13) 2, 14; 321.
(28); 378.3; 380.13; 415.8.
- 338.1
364.11; 365 (20)
2

193.15,16; 321.8; 347.


46; 356.129; 375.3
67.*24; 189.35; 248.12
216 (12) *2
69.24
96.24; 215.31; 220.
2, 4; 221 (16) 17; 232.12,
17, 18; 287.3; 376.10
73(14) 8; 283.24
74.4; 85.5; 215.29,
33; 231.2, (5), 10; 232.14,

15, 20; 236.11; 287.*2. 231.5


342 (7) 7
( = ) 61.70;
148.* 118; 150.155; 156.
56; 194.33; 323.15; 366.5
54.8; 122.24;
393.53
114 (25) 5
116.29
112(19)8
60.61; 95.47; 121.15;
128.53; 135.67; 145.50;
147.91; 149.128; 174.19;
175.16; 180.48,51; 204.69;
237.9; 340.24; 359.16;
396.14; 409.15, 18
57.9; 60.49; 88 (25) 2,
4; 127.9; 141.13; 150.157;
181.5, 8; 182.12; 190.66;
208.171; 218 (13) 10; 227.
42; 285.28; 301.39; 319
(36) 12; 320 (38) 5; 346.28;
347.33; 374.23; 388.*44. 72 (11) 4; 304.8;
305.23,27; 306.35; 307.63;
371.18; 410.4
87.27; 142.38;
384.11
= aevum 99(7) 10; 177.
2; 202.42; 218 (14) 8, 11;
278 (55) 7; 306.36; 308.77;
344.2 (?), 12.- = aeon ()
92 (2) 3; 137.2; 177.60.
(. Thomae) 147.105.
(Naas.) 142.27; 164.243
( ); 166.23;
172.25. (Sim.) 219.27; 222.
(6>, 6; 224 (17) 35, [35]; 224
(18) 7. (Val.) 229.21; 238.
31, 37; 239.(41); 239 (30)
*7, 9, 14; 240.22, 23, 25;
241.[3], 4, 5 bis, 9, 13, 14,
16, 19, 20, 21, 22, 24, 25;
242(31)30,34,40;242(32)
2,4,5,7; 243.19,28; 246.8,
9; 248.40; 250.3,9; 252.25,
27; 254 (37) 44; 254 (38) 4,
12; 278 (55) 7; 390.12.
(Marc.) 261.1,44; 262.28;
263 (45) 11; 271 (51) 14;
274.(33); 275.44; 277.19.
(Doc.) 324.26, 29, 31, 32,
35, 36; 325.6, 7, (9), 11, 16,

18,19, (23); 326.28,29,33,


37, 39; 327.16, 19, [19];
328.*32, *33, 33; 329.52,
54, 55; 395.2, 3, 6, *8, 12;
396.16, 21, (30). (Tatian.)
336 (16) 3; 398 (18) 2
78.52; 146.65, 71;
153.207; 202.39; 243.25;
324.47; 325.21; 327.4,(19);
328.32; 329.53,57 bis; 347.
34; 396.16. - '
344.12. - 277.2, 5
124(37)*6; 179.*28
192.104
164.238; 192.97,
100, 102; 355.119
111 (17) *9
380 (5) 9
161.167, 168; 167.
49
93 (3) 7
58.*20; 137.
22; 165.19; 166.25, 28;
224.9, 13; 237.9; 324.44;
330 (11) 3; 332.16.- (Val.) 255.17
53.14; 73 (14)
2; 85.3
240.*35,
36
165.5; 296.
*5. -
256.*4
120.13; 122.30
188.10; 386.9
258.6. - 280.12
72 (11) 6; 139.60;
144.28; 149.130; 185.8;
187.52; 370.2. - 352.58. -
(Val.) 239.13
242.28
67.32; 70.47; 73 (13)
9, 15
180.52
169.95; 220.[3]; 232.
13; 299.10. - 119
(31) 1; 221.2; 280.11; 316.
32
79.67
77.14; 83.10; 85.
21; 153.202; 237.6; 312.22

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

439

Index Verborum
250.15

78.44; 84.15;
141.11; 210.2; 212 (6) 4;
212 (7) 2; 323.*8. - 91.51
415.9
336.10. 117.31
80.82.-
80.91
167.42; 325.5
1 1 3 ( 2 1 ) 8
81.95; 88 (26) 1; 117.
43; 124(36)4; 133.*5; 147.
108; 156.42; 157.67, 75;
160.147; 188 (19) 3; 206.
124, 128, * 133; 208.172;
209.21; 213.20; 221 (15)
18; 228.45; 232.22, *24;
250.13; 262.4; 263.*7, 15;
286.3; 316.31; 344.*15;
358.*20; 360.5; 361.18;
364.14; 367.*17; 371.7;
372.5; 386.(3)
348.52
376.12
93(3) 12; 94.19; 95.
40, 50
97.6,12; 259.5; 370.
1 . - 96.11; 97.7;
98.25; 182.6; 213 (8) 16;
213 (9) 3; 276.3; 335.9
335.43
403.2
338.7; 356.142
197.28; 198.6;
280.10; 285.38; 287.20;
310.114; 312.14
64.1; 71 (10)2; 75
(18) 1; 81.1; 161.160; 199.
13; 258.12; 280(13)2; 347.
46; 355.122
206.* 135
86.3
80.74; 84.14; 185.84,
89; 371.18. - 376.
16.-'88(25) 1
79.61
96.17,24,32; 298.
48; 301.56
188.* 17; 191.(81), 88;
196.5; 197.(35); 332.*13;
386.16
284.8

272.2
93.19
342.15; 351.19
213.18
147.*97; 156.(37),39,
41; 170.125; 199.*9. 156.39; 185.13;
187.*57, *60
189.28; 387.25
308.78, 80
.
111 (17) 2; 365 (19)
*6

92 (2) 2; 96.29; 127


(43) 13; 202.30; 278 (54) 7.
- De recta fide Christiana:
130(45)9; 130(46)5; 131.
23; 136 (50) 5; 141.6; 173
(11) 4; 177.59; 316.32;
342.15; 343.16; 349.8;
350.21; 354.*96; 363.21;
378.11, 14; 379.5; 380 (5)
2,3,4,11; 380 (6) 3; 384 (8)
2, 6; 406.22; 4 0 8 . 3 1 . - D e
Spiritu sancto: 55.44; 415.
8 . - ' : (Val.) 138.
52; 228.20; 238.29,31,35,
38; 239 (29) 43; 239 (30) 1,
4 bis, 8,9,10,15; 241.9,17;
242.33, 37, 39; 251.18,22;
390.6. (Ptolemaeus) 255.
29,31. (Marc.) 262.2; 263
(44) 9,14; 263 (45) 1,7; 264
(46)4,13;269.11,14;272.24
154.6
85.5; 113(21)6; 139.
(81); 219.30; 283.17; 359.
1 2 . - D e recta fide: 353.77;
363.23; 380(5) * 9 ; 4 1 5 . 1 . 318.2.
- 97.8; 121.11;
173 (11) 2; 209.26; 213 (8)
3; 312.18
74.1; 156.45; 159.
110; 170.123; 183.34; 337.
6
94.24
131.13, 15
114 (26) 5; 203.59;
359.7
130 (46) 9; 148.
120; 152.196; 181.17; 219.
32; 225.3; 333.* 11, 19. 398.21

202.25; 278.6;
394.16
120.23
67.31
in anaphora: 181.* 15,
16; 213.11; 262.22; 288.
15; 316.30.-
63 (5) 4; 85.16; 100(7) 16;
137.*2; 145.49; 165.19;
199.21; 254.46; 290.44;
363 (18) 5-6; 392.*15-16.
- 329.59-60
167.48; 181.*15, 16

55.44; 110.30;
111 (17) (5); 112(18)5; 112
(20) *9; 286.42; 321.21;
342 (7) 5; 364.15.- 353.74; 402 (25) 5
371.16
1 1 9 ( 3 1 ) 6 ; 121.11,13,
27 bis
74.11,13
319.*9
54.9; 380 (5) 8 . 227.23
54.25; 103.11; 143.
14; 184.75; 362.1; 380.13;
407.1; 412.46. -
126 (42) 7; 229.7; 399.7
118.66, 6 9 . - 118.
68; 191.*77; 197.46; 360.
11; 361.30
164.231
266.*7; 270.26; 271
(50) *14; 274.26, 29; 275.
48
270.11
60.(63); 61.72,77; 70.16;
85.19; 121.4,8; 125(39)2;
225.3; 226.18; 235.10;
254.1; 258.23; 263 (44) (6);
268.20; 287.22; 290.39;
331.14; 347.37; 353.77;
354.105; 392.13; 393.49,
52; 394.19; 406.29; 410.6;
416.17
113 (21) 6; 130 (45)
13; 342 (6) 4
77.18
199.20; 209.28
147.96

80.91; 81.94;
258.6, (11); 354.103; 355.
109,113,117,125; 361.31

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

440

Indices

80.82; 316.35;
369.2, (7)
54.18; 133.3; 297.
15; 316.39; 327.14; 354.
(101), 102,104; 358.16,22;
360.4, 17; 417.28
149.136
124(37)4; 125.(19),
21
167.50
184.57
183.56
120.* 17
55.41
120.*24
133.15
111 (16) 11; 112(20)
8; 113(21)7; 1 1 3 ( 2 3 ) 5 . 405.4
120.19
137.11; 175.21; 230.
14; 331.24
166.*26,[28],30;
219.25
79.54, 55; 81.12
242.29
185.13
324.43; 325.19;
408.2

105 (13) 2. 372.19


261.42; 273.23.-'
201.15
285.31
267.9; 361.3
1 1 2 ( 1 8 ) 5
220.52 ()
118(30)1
377.47
291.73
: (Val.) 241.2, 20,
22. (Bas.) 292.77; 296.35;
298.35,36; 299.51; 301.51,
53, 54; 302.(60), 67
148.123; 240.35;
241.3, 18; 325.21
170.117; 333.15
165.1, 2, 9; 167.
51
332.14
154.3
165.5
165.8
328.29

117.58
166.37; 366.13
77.17; 108.72bis,
76, 84 bis; 133.3; 135.4;
156.55; 185.92; 349.6;
384.14; 414.80
204.71; 205.116,
117; 207.157, 163; 265.3;
294.15; 351.11; 392.36
177.4
306.49
144.18
170.114; 184.76;
226.13
207.152, 156;
311.4
134.32; 156.58;
159.112, 126; 162.195;
163.202; 196.26
158.93;266.10,
*13, 15
351.35; 362.4
55.27; 83.9, 10;
116.18; 130 (46) 3; 198.16;
213.20
54.20; 63 (5) 1;
96.34; 100 (7) 21; 117.38;
122.3; 126 (42) 8; 301.51;
340.20. - 190.
48; 288.*3
72 (12) 8 bis; 77.31;
78.41; 83.8; 93 (3) 5; 98.31;
157.64; 182.4; 183.31;
186.29; 192.105; 204.69;
235.10; 237.16; 307.71;
335.12; 363 (17) 9; 399.7;
413.67. - ' 310.
*120, 122
367.7
198.12
101.31
58.* 10; 163.(221)
351.11
141.4 (); 148.123; 265.
*20; 269.16; 273.14; 318
(35) 11; 331.19
264.7; 281 (15)
3; 326.27

373.4
60.59; 74.21; 126
(40) 4; 173 (11) 5; 337.7;
351.19; 371.13; 375.2

143.14. 287.7; 288.9


146.66; 221.6;
310.129

61.69; 149.
138; 248.(10)
209.8
168.74
221.17;
380 (6) 3
221.19
69.36
119(31)4
189.36; 195.
45
84.*19
54.15
131.16
163.219,221
156.54
134.40
343.17
88.34; 209.30
18 5.9,10; 186.
34; 197.45; 261.10; 364.

15; 366.14; 388.61; 414.74


112(19)8
365 (20) 6

175.25; 246.8;
265.28
110.17
62.5; 128.*51; 237.
20; 257.* 16; 303.15

118.72; 256.
12; 316.38; 388.52
256.11
150.162
355.127
188.18

179.26; 198.12;
238.24; 241.6; 372.4
78.47; 87.13; 136.
14; 267.16
118.69
177.62; 221.*5;
65.24; 137.68;
222.8; 259.10
143.13; 144.25,27; 352.50 118.63
292.1; 292.15
105 (13) *12
144.22
271.3; 275.52,
112 (19) 8; 304.2
56

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

441

Index Verborum
261.10
119 (31) 2; 220.49,
50
119 (31) 3; 169.99,
101; 221.9
378.3
232.*31
126 (41) 3
290.*47; 392.18
340.25
121.20; 124 (36) 5;
215.39
170.1; 189.40;
198.* 10
216 (11) *3
129.*8
349.12
370.15
321.17
159.127; 319(35)
14; 346.27,28; 371.1; 374.
24; 375.4,7; 377.47; 414.87
154.230

62.2; 87.16;
258.9; 339.3; 348.*64
350.27
169.*100
123.3
70.16; 135.56
139.62 165.8
113 (22) 5; 230
(22) 9
75.9; 100.12, 13;
131.2, 3; 132.17, 19; 135.
56,58,61; 179.29; 185.85;
250.36
179.35; 249.27
139.57; 187.51
130 (45) 10
364.16
178.15; 181.21;
303.14. - 63
(5) 6; 75 (17) 2; 240.24;
242.38; 271.9; 281 (15) 9;
290.41,46,47;299.53;,54;
303.8; 392.17
378.12
221.5
124 (36) 3
71.19
347.46

110.15; 186.40;
190.46; 197.43; 291.57bis;
292.*79; 301.57; 372.(4)

93 (3) 12; 94.13,


15; 178.17; 264.8; 276.
[12]
190.61
79.64, 69; 82.25
144.*28; 371.5
76.9; 281 (16) *5;
303.16
60.56; 387.33
363.18
264.5; 392.27
210.3; 212 (6) 5;
314.(37); 321.28
112(18)5
65.22, 24; 66.(8); 67.
24; 69.39; 179.31; 188.12;
190.65; 191.70,76,86; 192.
92,94,99,105; 280 (13) 1;
386.11; 388.43, *49, 57
325.* 19
148.122; 254.6;
257.5; 258.7; 260.21; 324.
(46). - (Val.)
255.(14), 17
148.115
288.13; 324.
22

148.122
342 (6) 2
143.*11; 345.
*22

172.16
56.46
287.7
188.14; 386.13
178.8
163.221; 174.30;
186.28, 38; 207.166; 234.
12; 245.*50; 290.40; 292.
78; 295 *5; 299 (26) *53;
299 (27) *1,4; 302.61; 315.
*8; 337.17; 386.26; 392.
14; 393.50; 394.24; 395.36
232.2
222.6; 274.27; 374.23;
390.4
85.23
259.5
143.16; 209.29
229.15
146.69; 158.104; 161.
178; 221.6; 223.19; 342 (7)
6; 349.1, 3; 350.1; 355.
(127); 356.130; 357.2, 6;

361.22; 362 (16) 11; 377.


37,39; 403.1; 408.19; 412.
50. - 167.52. - 76.10; 78.51; 84.15;
120.22; 203.49; 289.17;
335.46; 362 (17) 5; 373.11;
408.20; 412.48, 52
323.13
216 (11) *3
61.67
183.43; 358.26
61.68; 122.13
115 (28) 8; 118.69,
73, 75; 120.8, 10, 13; 121.
18,26; 125(39)3; 126 (41)
8

61.66; 99 (7)
10; 188 (19) *5; 191.75;
213.7; 234.10; 321.7; 326.
48; 386.5
202.34; 394.
(20)
186.33,36
60.(63); 65.21; 79.
71; 81.5; 85.21; 133.26;
147.101; 150.155; 152.
196; 154.(223); 182.5; 189.
31; 192.99; 202.35, 36;
205.106; 206.132; 207.
155,165; 208.182,183; 212
(7) 6; 213 (8) 18; 213 (9)
*2; 214.5, 20; 215.2, 3, 4;
217.16,19; 219.28,34; 222.
(2); 227.33, 34; 234.9; 235.
13; 247.25bis, (26), 28;
248.11; 257.6; 266.8, 10,
11; 281 (16) 2,6; 282 (16)
(8); 282 (18) 2, 5, 7; 283.
(16), 17,18,24; 287.2; 289.
8, 14, 28; 303.6, 13; 333.
16bis (Democritus); 367.
4; 375.6, 10, 11, [11], (16);
376.15; 390.23; 394.20,27;
411.29, 31 bis; 412.38, 45,
47; 413.67; 414.79, 89;
416.21; 417.22. - 54.23, 24; 55.30;
56.45; 63 (4) 2, 4; 71.*20,
22; 73 (13) 16; 74.21; 80.
(91); 81.95; 83.9; 85.6,
19; 87.27; 93.14; 110.16;
115 (27) 4; 135.66; 136
(50) 6,11; 143.17; 145.44;
148.112, 113; 153.214;

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

442

Indices

155.25; 156.38,54; 158.82,


91; 159.120; 161.171,174;
164.233; 166.33; 170.124;
173.14,15; 194.24; 204.85;
205.94, 96, 99, 104, 115,
119; 206.123, 127, *129;
207.156; 208.172, 175,
187; 209.15, 16; 214.(7);
227.29, 38; 228.46; 249.
(18); 260.19; 294.4; 303.22,
24; 314.3; 315.12; 316.31;
317.6; 318 (35) 7; 332.17;
345.19, 22; 348.64; 354.
101; 358.16; 362.4; 368.
12; 373.6; 375.3, 12; 376.
20; 378.8; 385.12, 13; 400
(21) 6; 403.*6; 407.7, 18;
408.29; 413.62; 414.77;
415.1; 417.27, 28. " (Naas.) 142.
23 ter, 28,31,35; 143.9,11,
13; 144.26,29,31,35; 145.
37,38,47; 146.67; 151.164,
180; 154.7; 155.20; 156.58,
83,106; 159.111,112,124;
163.202,205, 206; 169.88,
104; 170.118; 384 (9) 2,3.
(Seth.) 191.69; 192.107.
(Val.) 138.52; 228.20; 238.
33; 239.10, 16; 390.7.
(Marc.) 263 (44) 10; 264
(46) 9,10,12; 269.15; 271.
5; 272.22, 23; 276.10.
(Mon.) 330 (12) 2, 5, 7;
331.9,12,15,21,26; 332.7,
11, 16, 18, 20, 21, 22, 23;
333.9; 397.2 bis, 3, 4, 5,
10 bis, 19.-" =
Adam: 202.40. " = Iesus: (Naas.) 142.
33. (Per.) 174.20; 183.52;
385.17. (Marc.) 271.7;
272.16, 20. (Saturnilus)
303.17. (Marcion) 399.
13, 14 bis. (Ebionaei) 318
(34) 10. (Theodot. Byz.)
318. (35) 6; 401 (23) 4.
(Theodot. trapez.) 319.5.
(Noet.) 348.64. (Callistus)
354.87. (Elch.) 359.4. ()
414.75,77, 80,83, 88; 417.
29. - " =
: 132.20; 133.21;
134.34; 185.89

413.58
121.24; 268.*26
73(13)8; 100(8)5,19
377.40. - 66.16; 159.130; 228.
15; 234.25; 301.54, *55;
349.69; 372.2; 399.16
158.93
213 (8) 4; 224.1;
292.81; 347.*44; 354.95. 214.9; 287.6;
288.9
110.21; 113 (24) 3;
172.*26; 187.(43); 204.79;
213.11; 260.23; 263.2
65.17
54.23, 25; 198.14;
358.* 19
331.17; 381.14;
383.30, 31
186.18; 189.42

356.135; 360.14;
369.20
.
303.10,(13)
245.7; 248.43
260.21; 261.44;
287.1
134.33; 350.
(21)

80.75, 77
123.4; 124
(37)5
125.22
77.21
55.40
414.87
276.*12
257.4
329.(42), 47; 356.130
411.32
64.11

228.12;
342.*14; 350.21
68.9
119(31)*4
61.65; 121.8;
126 (41) 9
181.14
184.60
281(14)6.(Marcion) 311.2; 312.9;
320 (37) 5

177.65;
304.10; 312.10
87.15
228.11; 352.*62

189.33, 34;
234.5, 6; 376.11; 387.31
304.30
224.12; 225.25
276.14
80.90
69.30, 31
197.43,44
226.7
286.8
187.41; 327.2
57.10; 70.7; 128.38,45;
132.11; 139.(75); 144.28;
146.65, 71, 73; 149.140;
150.155; 153.214; 154.
222,230; 154 (8) 7,8; 155.
*18, 19; 156.55, 56; 163.
217, 222; 181.11; 188.12,
16; 191.*84; 195.*45; 197.
27, [42]; 200.10; 204.74,
75; 222.3, 4; 223.11; 225.
26; 244.49; 250.15; 261.
10; 262.5; 264.3; 268.27;
271.9; 275.(44), 48; 276.2;
277 (53) 30; 277 (54) 1;
290.41; 292.15, 80; 295.5;
296.35; 300.33; 301.57;
303.*8, 11; 327.7; 346.18,
19,20; 353.84; 386.11, 14;
388.(53), 56; 392.14; 393
(14) 50; 393 (15) 8; 404.5. 109.5; 153.213;
354.95-96. -
103.31, 33, 34, 36, 37. 65.18
69.42; 108.77; 144.
31; 151.164; 153.200; 157.
71, 76; 159.111; 163.220;
174.17,28,30,31; 185.88;
186.26,39; 188.18; 190.64;
191.72,75,81,88; 192.101;
195.38; 196.6; 197.36; 212
(7) 5; 213 (8) 4; 217.3; 224.
9; 245.5; 247.30 249.31;
251.18; 252.30; 292.77;
296.32; 297.23; 298.42,49;
299.56; 303.6; 313.26; 318
(35) 9; 326.25, 27, 28, 32,
45; 327.3, 16, [17]; 328.
31, 37, 39; 329.65; 330.

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

Index Verborum
68; 332.21; 385.15; 386.
16, 24, 25, (27); 388.51,
59; 393.(44}; 394.20; 396.
15; 397.9
112 (19)* 7
254.6; 265.
24,- (Val.)
255.18. -
271.14
112 (18) 5; 112
(19)9

128.40; 129.2;
204.73
55.40; 78.47, 49; 355.
* 1 2 8 , 128

368.4; 370.12
112(19)9
54.14; 380 (5)6
61.83. - 126 (42) *2
54.6,24; 55.39; 73 (13)
16; 98.5; 99 (7) 1; 105(13)
2; 116.29; 127(42) 14;212.
11; 319,8; 339.22; 340.22;
360.13; 368.9. - 55.
39; 378.14. -
55.39
58.11; 103.[16], (20);
115.1; 117.43; 131.21;
293.23; 315.21; 352.57
352.51
136 (49) 9
384 (8) 3
69.24; 165.4, 10;
178.10; 200 (26) 4; 216
(11) 2; 216 (12) 2; 224.9;
254.9; 255.30; 256.3; 260.
23, 24; 265.25; 276 (52)
(61); 276 (53) 8; 331.27;
336 (16) *3; 345.19,21,24;
348.49, 50; 389.9; 393.5;
398 (18) *2; 402 (26) 4;
403.7. - ' (Val.)
255.15, 18
372.20
58.*20;59.*29;77.
27; 96.19; 137.22; 138.31.
- 277.2, 6
220.46, (53)
350.7; 351.13,
*38
193.10, 11
364.15; 376.21
198(23)*5;340.*26

224.3; 317.11; 381.


14; 383.30; 401.12; 403.9.
- 287.7
272 *7
189.27; 387.24
112(18)6; 120.* 15;
125.24; 350.*8
349.4
80.92; 136.14;
153.207; 174.38; 200.17;
284.11; 291.53,68,73; 314.
27, 30bis; 316.36; 386.28
232.24; 323.20
99(7) 11; 107.63; 108.
64 bis; 258.11
335.4
217.13; 219.
27; 224.35, *36; 389.20. 190.56
110.27; 400 (20) 1
164.240
163.*213
107.52,54,56,59;
128.29; 170.125; 179.23.
142.31; 163.206
301.*45; 302.64
144.23; 376.*19;
414.88
: 63 (4) 5;
337.11
408.*24
136.1; 256.2,7; 257.
3, 8; 258.2; 280.9; 287.22;
338.2; 349.9; 360.2; 395.
35

350.19.
131.3; 416.(14)
413.65
2 1 3 ( 9 ) 1
130 (46) 8; 187.
52
371.9
408.21; 415.10, 13
351.30
: 349.
4
189.38;
216(11)5; 325.6, 23; 387.
33; 395.6
190.*63
323.13
= infinitus: 66.2;
67.4; 72 (12) 2; 72 (13) 6;

443
73 (14) 9; 74 (14) 10; 74
(15) 5; 95.4; 105 (13) 2;
137.12; 173(12)6,10; 185.
6; 188(19) 2; 189.39; 190.
47, 48 bis, 49, 59, 61, 62;
196.1; 216(11) *5; 219.27;
262.25; 289.27; 297.29;
324.22, 45; 325.6, 18, 23;
326.24,37; 338.5; 381.(11),
13; 383.26; 385.5, *8; 386.
(2); 387.34, 38; 393.42;
395.6; 408.2.-
99 (7) 6; 137.9; 261.16;
262.22. ' 58.21;
137.23. - 64.2,
6; 68.5
= imperitus: 130
(45) 12; 349.3; 410.5
87.22; 329.44
139.64
63 (5) 2; 131.14;
136.3; 173 (11) 5; 212.10;
272.(3); 398 (18) 4
. ) 137.19.-
: 214.
15,17,21,22; 217.9 bis, 12,
14; 218 (13) 13; 218 (14) 7,
11, 14; 222 (16) 27; 222
(17) 5; 224.34; 225.16;
389.1,2,16,(16), 19,21.-6
224.35. (Marc.)
277.2
79.71; 118.70;
119(32)6; 186.*37; 233.7,
21;242.34; 306.34; 307.62,
63; 308.*72; 387.38
131.18
237.9; 296.32.
- 151.174
371.8
:
356.137. 279.
*20

243.15
228.10
364.14
207.164; 212 (6) 7;
367.3. - 86.3;
168.68; 304.27; 310.112;
312.15; 339.4; 364.18;
370.7; 399.19
116.10

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

444

Indices

98.36; 139.61; 263


(45) *6
105 (12) 7; 328.35
105 (12) 8, 9; 110.
*26; 185.85
65.19; 73 (13) 14;
93 (3) (11); 100.15; 175.*4,
5, 6, 18
112(18)4
415.9
113 (23) 3; 114 (26)
2; 214.22, 23, 24; 218.20;
287.2; 331.23; 332.5, 8;
333.8, *13; 389.3bis, 4;
397.* 18. - 85.9;
146.75; 281 (16) 1, 3; 282
(16) *9; 286.5, 11; 287.5
144.27
56.63

61.77; 110.29;
329.63; 354.106; 369.2, 3
57.9; 217.5
228.7
403.14; 410.2
66.4
235.20
78.38;274.(32);
312.24; 352.42; 406.32
74.15; 105(12)8;
137.6; 154.6; 187.51; 197.
50; 268.19; 363.20; 380 (5)
3, 11, 14; 408.31
77.34; 236.23
234 (26) 3; 365
(20)4
351.10,29
193.111; 206.
144

56.67; 101.2;
102.2; 112(18) 5; 114(25)
9; 122.5; 130 (46) 3; 285.
24,30; 286.42; 293.4; 316.
40; 321.20, 22; 351.28;
352.54; 377.48
215.41,42
221.3
110.30; 217.19;
306.49; 348.68; 350.18
76.11; 185.11; 380(6)
9; 381.16, 17
302.59
299.53
290.37; 292.

129.63; 295.
4; 297.10; 300.*24; 301.53,
55; 377.42
70.10

140.3; 199.22;
307.70; 323.11; 339.1;
350.23; 356.137; 391.20
141.4; 260.20;
295.4; 296.27; 298.37
320.15
99 (7) 8;
260.40; 277.20; 300.22,29;
302.*63; 306.39
351.24
351.26
93.3; 97.10; 181.
16, 19, 22
168.170
146.64,69.- 163.212; 168.
66, 67, 68
64.12; 65.23; 69.
45; 70.4; 116.25; 191.(80);
259.13; 351.34; 409.14;
412,56
117.(57); 118.63
54.3; 114(27)2;
188 (18) 3; 348.66; 369.20
110.24; 126(42)
3; 210.5; 250.13; 286.2;
295.16
136(49)7;183.49
268.(6); 274.37
61.77; 204.85;
215.41; 326.38; 416.18
376.20
56.62; 178.9
174.32
243.18; 290.47;
300.31; 315.19; 378.*2
117.47
85.21; 114(25) *5
(); 116.30;
164.228; 217.15; 219.22;
223.30; 226.19; 243.13,25;
245.52; 273.19; 386.29;
390.22; 400.13
192.109; 366.6;
368.6; 370.17; 371.15;
373.10
352.52
352.56
258.9, 10, 17;

82; 391.12; 392.20

259.2, 7

124 (36) 6; 178.6;


191.*85; 234.*26; 291.54;
352.55, (57), 59
76 (18) 5; 229
(21) *3; 396.*16
228.17
141.19
212 (6) 6
388.60
128.43
121.12
212 (7) 7; 279.8;
304.5; 350.22; 357.2
370.* 10, * 11
115.3; 386.27
317.* 10; 401.11
153.199
172.*20
105 (13) 7; 358.
30; 391.17
332.21
209.29; 417.28
373.*3
145.43;244.37;350.7
243.14, 24, 27, 31;
245.4
95.4; 289.10; 384 (8).
- 9 8 . 2 9 ; 109.6

187.55; 265.22;
271.*2
54.13; 117.*31;
122.1; 126 (42) 7; 143.6;
148.11; 173(12) 4; 212 (6)
6; 360.12; 362.1. -
198 (22) 3
87.11

175.13; 181.*6,
11, 12; 264.1, *8; 277.29
233.*22
276.*11
273.17
191.*80

117.51; 133.19;
233.17; 307.54,63,67,71;
310.126, 128; 318 (35) 5;
333.16; 359.*3
92 (2) *3; 177.
60; 273.(17)
64.9; 67.22, 23;
69.25; 100 (8) 18, 23; 103.
14, 23
88.32
166.24; 377.32;
394.27; 4 1 3 . * 6 9

Brought to you by | New York University Bobst Library Technical Services


Authenticated
Download Date | 1/7/15 5:38 PM

445

Index Verborum
101.29; 102 (9)
(8); 102(10) 1,6,8; 103.12,
17; 104.8, 11
:
55.35; 212 (7) 7; 228.9,11;
315.18; 319 (36) 13; 338
(18) 12; 338 (19)9. ( = ) 159.
132; 248.4; 311.3; 321.8;
338(18)9; 339.7; 355.114
110.27; 316.32;
364.14; 365 (19) 2
157.75
97.19; 217.12;
294.7; 389.19
59.39; 66.9; 119
(32) *3; 124(37)5; 175.14;
266.18; 388.*46; 410.*9;
412.41; 417.29
118(30)1,*40
99(7)6; 105(13)
9

88.33; 258.19;
366.13
346.21
353.73
195.51
99(7)4; 109.6;
213 (8) 2
416.14
58.7; 77.26;
85.4,9, 11; 118.59; 127.8;
130 (45) 7; 230.1; 232.4;
381.21
111 (17) 7; 112
(19) 5. - (Sim.)
166.21; 214.16; 216(11)4;
219.26; 224.6
69.40; 126 (42)
7
194.33
117.50
123.14
118 (29) 3
139.*74
339.(3)
197.28
241.19
327.7
189.28; 387.25
287.7
200 (26) 4, 5;
201.10; 393.5, 6. - 394.12

284.7. - 166.36
331.8, 13
223.26; 238.19;
323.14
273.19; 296.36; 297.
23; 370.9
69.32; 353.72
182.28; 183.30,44;
273.20
66.8.- 68.
(10)

66.7, 17
289.14
308.83, 84, 86
325.22
61.74
196.15
111 (16)6; 112(19)
5; 229.8; 321.8; 354.104;
410.*9
79.61, 62, 64, 71; 80.
75 bis; 81.98; 85.18

128.26; 231.23;
236.9; 269.*21; 272.10;
273.13; 324.34; 334.*28
236.4
216 (11) 3; 381
(6) 11,(11); 382 (7) *1
59.25,*26; 109.
1; 137.*7; 138.27, 28, 53;
232.1; 236.12; 237.7; 246.
6; 272.3; 322.6. -
58.(7), 18;
137.1,21; 335.14. - 232.27, 31; 233.
10

58.8,18,20,21,22;
59.24 bis, 25,27,28,29,30,
31,34 bis, 36,37,38,41,42;
61.82; 88 (25) 6; 101.25;
102(9)5,7; 102(10)7; 103.
17,19,22,23,28,29,31,33,
34,36,38; 104.12; 105(13)
3,6; 105 (14) 1,3; 106.17;
107.39, 44, 52, 56; 108.72,
90; 109 (14) 101; 109 (15)
2; 117.47; 127.22; 128.25,
31,32, 34 bis, 52; 129 (43)
59; 129 (44) 2,3, lObis, 12;
130 (44) 14; 137.5, 9, 22,
24 bis, 26bis; 138.27, 29,
30,31,32,34,37,39,40,41,
45, 46; 151 .* 167; 175.7,

28; 189.38; 190.47; 211.


11; 229.13; 230 (23) 2,8,9,
11; 231 (23) 22,25,27; 231
(24) 3, 9; 232.29bis; 238.
37, *38,39; 239.2,6; 246.9;
264.3, *16; 265(46) 19,20,
24,28; 265 (47) 5; 266 (47)
7, *13, 16, 17; 266 (48) 1,
(3); 268.5; 269.12, 15, 18;
270 (49) 27; 270 (50) (6), 7,
8,10; 271 (50) 14; 271(51)
10; 273.16, 21, *23, 24;
274.25, 27, 28, 30, 32, 34,
37, 39, 42; 275.47, 49, 51,
53; 276.7; 277 (53) 18; 277
(54) 5; 278.5; 324.*35;
332.(2), 5,8; 333.8; 334.30;
359.10; 397.6 bis, 7, 17.

(=10,000 2 ) 101.3; 102.10,


12, 14, 15. -
(= rhythmus) 221.* 14. 221.12
126(40)2,4; 129.
6; 180.39; 181.19,21; 254.
2; 275.*58