Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Acknowledgement
We would like to extend our extreme gratitude to Dr. Jyoti Chandirimani, for supporting our activities throughout the year. We would also like to thank Ms. Ishita Ghosh and Dr. Sukalpa Chakrabarti for their unfailingly useful advice and Mr. Krishna Kant Roy for the readiness with which
he helped us out of the problems that we faced during the course of the year.
We would also like to thank Sourav Das for his expertise in making this magazine look like much
more than just a college magazine meant for 500 students. We would like to thank all the members
of the Editorial Board, the members of Arthniti, all the contributors to both, the newsletter and the
magazine, for consistently providing us with material and assistance to create material regularly.
Lastly, we would like to thank all the students of the Symbiosis School of Economics for gradually
building their faith in us and giving us another reason to keep on working.
Editors: Sanaya Chandar, Sarayu Nandakumar, Malavika Gode, Manasi Nikam, Nandita Ramesh,
Saakshi Puri, Tania Sharma
Contributors: Akshath Jitendranath, Soumyadeep Sen, Roshan Iyer, Shashank Pareek, Akarsh
Verma, Arnav Rawat, Krishna Betai, Arshaan Furniturewalla, Radha Karmarkar, Anmol Bhotika,
Sourav Das, Mugdha Gupta, Moritz Gundelach
Contents
Artha, Niti and Shastra:
by
by
by
Soumyadeep Sen
Krishna Beta
pg 5-6
pg 20-21
Gods among Us
by
Sourav Das
by
by
Akarsh Verma
Radha Karmakar
pg 11-12
pg 25
Anti-Humour
pg 13-14
pg 25
pg 15-16
pg 26-27
Arnav Rawat
pg 18-19
pg 22
It is for this reason that I feel honoured to have the opportunity to write to my juniors through the channel of a stuBut what is this discipline? And how does the word dents club named Arthniti. By invoking the word niti,
the club is dedicating itself to the use of reason and not
artha anticipate it?
divine or political authority, to justify an economic princiThe most famous use of the word is made in the great text, ple. Indeed, this is how I view Economics. It is this lesson
Arthashastra. The Arthashastra, as every Indian has been that I hope you will learn from Economics as well.
told, is a treatise on the means of consolidating and extending the authority of the State. It is the first text of its In what follows, I shall make a comment on economic
kind to be generated by human civilization. Indeed, the theory, through which I will introduce to you the work I
question must then be asked, why the name Arthniti for an do. It is important to pay special attention to this for two
Economics club? Surely, if we want to invoke an Indian reasons: first, all this might seem a little abstract in the
approach to Economics, we ought to use the word Arth- beginning, but I assure you, pay close attention and you
will understand what Im saying. Second, I am commentshastra for a journal or club concerning this discipline?
ing on the use of reason or more specifically, rationality
Here, I shall pursue this matter a little further, justifying in Economics. While we have seen rational argument to
the use of the word arthniti. A shastra is different from be central to Economics, I am afraid that I am reporting
a niti. A shastra is associated with divine or political au- on the discipline short-changing the idea of rationality
thority. It is by invoking the authority of divinity or the itself.
State that the means of living get justified in an arthashastra. A niti, on the other hand, is a just principle. The au- Reason, as we have already seen, is central to justifying
thority of a niti isnt derived from divinity, but relies on economic principles. Further, a central axiom from which
the reasoning involved in justifying the principle. It is most of economic theory has been constructed is the
true, of course, that words such as niti and shastra have axiom of the rational agent. This axiom states the followbeen used in many different senses in different philoso- ing: rationality entails a decision maker having a complete
phical discussions in ancient India, but there is still a basic and transitive ordering over a set of alternatives. I underdistinction between the respective concentrations stand that for some of you, the Sanskrit might have been
easier to translate than these abstract words. What is a
of niti and shastra.
complete and transitive ordering? I can hear some of you
Now, Economics is a set of principles that outlines the say. Fret not. Let me illustrate what I mean.
means of living for an individual, a firm, or a state and
thus, is also one constituent of the good life for an individ- Let A be a set of three alternatives x, y, z. Thus, A={x, y,
ual, firm, or society. These principles, then, have to be z}
justified by reasoning, not by invoking any spiritual or
political authority. Artha must be based on niti, not shas- Let i be an individual or institutional agent deliberating
over the alternatives in A.
4
Gods among Us
A look at the elemental processes behind the creation of the
concept of God
Sourav Das
What is a god? Is it an immortal being, the guardian to the
human race? Is it the supreme judge, jury and executioner? Or is it merely the fabled light at the end of the
tunnel? God is the cosmological constant, the part of the
equation of Einsteins general relativity that becomes
whatever the viewer of the problem needs it to become.
But to understand the true meaning of the concept which
has been the trigger for crusades and miracles alike, we
must delve into the creation of a god, by critically analyzing the gods among us.
The most curious factor driving psychosocial behaviour
patterns is our ability to empathise with our fellow human
beings. It is the phenomenon which leads to the dynamics
of the market and forms the cornerstone to most economic
theory, but that is a discussion for another time. The fact
which makes this psychosocial behaviour interesting to
our current discussion is that empathy is capable of nearly
un-resisted transfer between human minds. So even
though we are unique individuals, the deep layers of our
minds are connected to form the bare mesh of a hive
mind. This hive mind, on the basis of our very primal
instincts, amplifies certain elements which it perceives as
important (these elements are those having roots in the
early stages of evolution of our species), fear and reward
being two of them. But what does this have to do with
god?
Let us assume a scenario; there is a person who provides
food to the community, who protects the community from
substantial threats, rewards those who do good and severely punish those who do wrong. People are of the opinion that this person can control the weather in case the
crops are failing, rain fire from the sky on the enemies of
the community and in essence belong to a higher physiological class of Homo sapiens. It is thus safe to assume
that this entity is by strict definition, a god.
The description given above fits the image of Kim JongUn as told by the people of North Korea. It also fits the
description of the US government as given by a conspiracy nut. To some extent, it also fits the description of the
prime minister of India as given by an illiterate farmer
from the backward area of a certain state. Finally, it reminds one of a certain entity in Jerusalem some 2000
years ago performing daily miracles one of which was
walking on water.
God is a fantastic social concept. It is perhaps the best
example of how the amplifications of the hive mind act as
catalysts to promote an individual, an idea to the position
where they reach a supernatural status. Rationality acts as
a resilient barrier to this process, only to be dismissed by
Even during the time when Iran was under sanctions, India had sizeable if volatile trade relations with it. India is
the biggest consumer of Irani oil after China. The chart
below shows how despite heavy sanctions on Iran, the
value of Indian exports nearly mirrored the value of unsanctioned exports to Israel. Iran allowed India to purchase oil in rupees which in turn allowed Iran to easily
purchase Indian goods with those rupees. However, the
$15.7 billion bilateral trade must move beyond the oldstyle oil and fertiliser, cereals and chemicals export basket. Tehran is beginning to offer generous incentives to
foreign investors to formalise its economy: low taxes and
easy profit repatriation laws. Indias private sector can
offer consumer credit, factories for auto parts and electric
vehicles, and pharmaceutical and technology investments.
Fortunately for India, the only other big supplier of manuFor nearly half a decade Iran has been a victim of US ac- facturing goods in Western Asia is Israel, What Iran cantions, first with the coup in 1953 and then with the sanc- not buy from Israel, it can get from India.
tions imposed since the Islamic revolution in 1979. The
issue of Irans nuclear program merely provided the alibi Once the sanctions are removed, Iran is potentially a
New Delhi had a surprisingly lukewarm reaction to the
news of Irans landmark nuclear deal with the United
States in January 2016 and the lifting of sanctions that
came along with it. The deal would allow Iran to return to
the global economy after being placed under sanctions for
more than 35 years. It is obvious that the Iran issue went
much beyond the countrys nuclear program. If, in fact, it
was simply the nuclear issue that was the program, it is
Israel rather than Iran that should have been the prime
target in the region. In fact, other than from Iran, Israeli
nukes enjoy relatively less global attention that they deserve. India seems adamant in sticking to its pro-America,
pro-Israel policies even when logic dictates that we require a clear shift in foreign policy.
jor player in the Islamic region and has still stood by India
on vital issues such as the Kashmir problem where it used
its veto power in the Organisation for Islamic Cooperation
to support India on the issue of human rights violations in
the region. It is also reported that not a single Kalashnikov held by the insurgent groups in Kashmir was ever
ince.
In 2014, China commenced massive oil drilling operations
in the region and began to reclaim and militarise the islands to consolidate its claim over them, including an airstrip capable of operating fighter aircrafts, docks for ships
and anti-aircraft missile systems. Other claimants have
also reclaimed land in the region in the past, but Chinas
reclamation has been alarming since it has reclaimed more
land than all the other nations combined in the history of
the contentious islands. China has also been expanding its
navy in terms of equipment and manpower.
Chinas actions sprung Washington into action and in
light of Chinas actions, President Obama urged China not
to use its military might to elbow out and undermine the
claims made by other nations over the disputed territory.
China however continued with its activities in the region.
Shashank Pareek
The Peoples Republic of China and the United States do In response, the US issued a series of warning to deter
not see eye to eye on a plethora of global subjects. One China from asserting its claim over the region.
such subject that has grabbed significant global attention
is the territorial claims of China over two archipelagos
located in the South China Sea, the Spratly islands and the
Paracel islands. The Spratly islands, also known as the
Spratlys, are a group of nearly 750 geological features
in the South China Sea which are claimed by the CHINA,
Malaysia, the Philippines, Vietnam, Taiwan and Brunei,
while the Paracel islands, a group of 130 geological features are claimed by China, Taiwan and Vietnam.
Chinas claim to the island dates back to the third century
during the reign of the Han Dynasty when the islands and
surrounding waters were used by Chinese fishermen who
inhabited the islands, while later claims are backed by the
nine-dash line. Vietnam, on the other hand, argues that it
officially documented the rights to the islands in 1771,
which is well before China legally staked its claim on the In 2015 and 2016, US aircrafts made a series of surveilislands in the nineteenth century. The Philippines claims lance flights near the disputed islands. This action of the
the islands to be a part of their sovereign territory based US met with some opposition at Beijing which summoned
on their proximity to the Filipino mainland, while Brunei the US ambassador and warned him against the potential
and Malaysia claim the islands because of the islands lie impact of US involvement in matters which are not its
in the Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZ) of the nations concern. The US has since deployed destroyers to patrol
based on the United Nations Convention on the Law of the region. In order to deter China, the US has tried to ally
the Seas (UNCLOS). Taiwan backs its claims on the fact itself with other claimants in the region and has used its
that the country originally occupied a part of the Chinese influence over Manila to curtail Chinese indiscretions.
mainland. Although China administers a majority of the The US has also tried to provoke China by scheduling a
region, all nations except Brunei have occupied features in joint naval exercise near the disputed region with India
the two archipelagos.
and Japan, the two other major powers in Asia. On March
Possession of the islands is instrumental in the economic 4, 2016, the US deployed a carrier group near the Spratly
and geopolitical welfare of the claimants, because control islands, which has been regarded as a major threat by Beiof the islands provides these nations with significant con- jing.
trol over the South China Sea. The South China Sea is the The growing tensions in the region have sparked a debate
second busiest sea route in the world and comprises of a over the implications of a potential engagement between
third of the global shipping traffic. The South China Sea is the US and China and another major war, however
also a centre for marine diversity and a massive fishing unlikely the situation may seem to be. There is also a
hub in South East Asia. Over and above, the South China growing concern of the US trying to use its influence over
Sea is estimated to hold about 28 billion barrels of oil and the other countries in the region to create a proxy war,
266 trillion cubic feet of natural gas and a plethora of which can be disastrous for the region and has the potenother natural resources.
tial to destabilise South East Asia in the same manner as
The official diplomatic claims to the islands date back to the Middle East. However, with North Korea proceeding
the 1950s, but major tensions arose between China and with its nuclear program, there is little hope that the US
Vietnam in the 70s and 80s when China fought Vietnam may stand down and stop asserting its influence in the
twice and in 1974 gained total control of the Paracel is- region since Washington considers it vital to deter Chilands. Recent tensions among the claimants have only nese and North Korean activities. With the estimated
arisen in the 2010s. In 2012 China took control of the global oil reserves in decline and an ever increasing deScarborough Shoal, a small group of geological features mand for oil, it is very unlikely that any of the countries
off the Filipino coast, form the Philippines and later took involved in the dispute will cede their claim in the near
over all the islands in the South China Sea in the adminis- future.
trative prefecture of Sansha City under the Hainan prov-
10
The Republicans
DONALD TRUMP
Who is he?
Donald Trump is an American billionaire, businessman, politician and a real
estate mogul. Currently, Trump is the Republican frontrunner.
MARCO RUBIO
Who is he?
A second-generation Cuban-American and former speaker of the Florida
House, Rubio was catapulted to national fame in the 2010 Senate election
after he unexpectedly upset Governor Charlie Crist to win the GOP nomination.
TED CRUZ
Who is he?
Cruz served as Deputy Assistant Attorney General in the George W. Bush
administration and was appointed Texas solicitor general in 2003. In 2012,
he ran an insurgent campaign to beat a heavily favoured establishment Republican for Senate.
The Democrats
HILORY CLINTON
Who is she?
We dont need to tell you, but shes a trained attorney, former secretary of
state in the Obama administration, former senator from New York, and former first lady.
BERNIE SANDERS
Who is he?
A self-professed socialist, Sanders represented Vermont in the U.S. House
from 1991 to 2007, when he won a seat in the Senate.
13
Pictured left:
Iconic picture from
the Ethnic Day
2013, featured in
the LF 2016 flex
Pictured right:
Swarnabhas high
voltage rock n roll
at the Social Fest,
Khwaishein
Pictured below:
Aindrilla Chakraborty at the LF
2016 opening ceremony
14
Bsc. Economics, Batch 13-16: Through the years, from 2013 to 2016
Pictured left:
Trek to Tikona,
2015
Pictured right:
Ajay Pawar eating a
crab c. 2013 (Yes, that
happened)
Pictured below:
Our first outbound to
Tamini Ghat
16
Above: Protests against the arrest of JNUSU leader, Kanhaiya Kumars on the charge of sedition
Sarayu Nandakumar
Anger and anguish was felt across universities throughout
the world as Kanhaiya Kumar, a PhD student from Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) was arrested in February
2016. Also the leader of All India Student Federation
(AISF), the youth wing of the Communist Party of India
(CPI), Kumar was charged with sedition due to the alleged raising of anti - India slogans by some people in a
student rally against the 2013 public hanging of Afzal
Guru.
The term sedition has caught the buzz since February 9
when slogans demanding azadi in Kashmir were reverberated. Soon, many Indian journalists were quick to brand
the protests as anti-national and circulated a doctored clip
from the protest which eventually led to a police crackdown. The protest was eventually squashed and the right
to dissent withheld. Consequently, public opinion on social media mirrored the muzzled-up newsfeeds passed by
the media and politicians of the government in power.
The fight has shifted the attention from the intent of the
protest and the Kashmir conflict to question of the validity
of the right to dissent. The right to dissent, according to
Articles 19 and 25 of the Constitution, allows liberty of
thought, expression, belief, faith and worship. The arrest
of Kanhaiya Kumar for seeking freedom from the ills that
plague the nation, especially among Dalits, has reverber-
ing for a free Kashmir at JNU, are nothing but manifestations of caste inequalities and communalism which are
resulting from a repressive Hindu authoritarian government, masked in the name of development.
There is hunger among the public for justice, there is hunger among the public for their rights. But if government
narratives forever mar the constitutional rights given to
the people, especially when it comes to narrating the story
of Kashmir or the Dalits, anything that falls under the
category of dissent will be anti-national.
The lands are so barren and dry, that only the best of
friends or the fiercest of enemies visit us
- Ladakh saying
Arnav Rawat
At 18,800 feet, up in the Karakoram Range in the Himalayas, lies the second coldest place on Earth and the highest
battlefield in the world. The 76 km long Siachen glacier is
a place like no other. Extremely beautiful and scenic, but
equally harsh. With temperatures that drop down to -60
C, just surviving there is a feat in itself and only one force
in the world operates in these conditions - the Indian
Army.
The barren heights of Siachen and its nearby regions have
been claimed by both India and Pakistan. This dispute has
its roots in the Karachi Agreement of 1949. The Indian
interpretation is that the current line of control (LoC)
should run north easterly from NJ 9842 along the Saltoro The yellow line shows the Actual Ground Position Line (India).
Range to the Chinese border. The Pakistani interpretation The Green line shows Pakistans claim.
18
your goggles as the reflection from the snow can permanently damage your eyes.
Krishna Betai
*DISCLAIMER: The characters depicted in this
20
Right:
Mugdha Gupta,
Urban Poverty
Malavika Gode
Think of the uncovering of explosive news stories and you
think of a glossy, powerful million-dollar corporation like
WikiLeaks, for whom even the CIA is no match. You
picture John Oliver and his team at HBO, taking on Donald Drumpf, backed by the power and reach of the internet. However, before the internet was the powerhouse it is
now, journalists dug up important stories the old fashioned way rummaging through libraries, knocking on
doors, and usually, having doors slammed shut in their
faces. The more important the story, the deeper it was
buried.
The movie Spotlight, directed by Tom McCarthy, with a
talented cast including Mark Ruffalo, Michael Keaton,
Rachel McAdams and Stanley Tucci, explores one such
story. The movie follows the investigation of an elite team
of Boston Globe reporters into the systemic abuse of
young children in the Catholic Church, by priests, often
high ranking ones, and the casual air with which this
chronic molestation was brushed under the rug. It documents how the team fought a long, hard battle over the
course of a year, to uncover truths that no one seemed to
want to hear, about one of the most powerful organisations in the world. With the initial aim of exploring the
story of one Boston priest allegedly abusing a child, the
team uncovers a mountain of shameful cover-ups that
begins to tumble down, involving over 200 priests and
brothers in the Boston diocese and then several more all
over the world.
Conflict
Radha Karmarkar
Radha Karmarkar
Anti-Humour
25
Sarayu and I had started thinking about our plans for Arthniti before our third year began. We decided to contest the elections together as co-club heads, probably the best decision that we have
taken as members of Arthniti.
Considering that Economics students arent expected to know
their way around the details of printing, editing and formatting,
our activities form a unique blend of extra and co-curricular work.
People who are now active members approached us to help with
web design, editing, formatting, digital design, and fundraising,
besides contributing as writers. Realising that each newsletter and
magazine is a hugely collaborative activity is my most distinctive
experience of working with the club.
The one event that perfectly encapsulated the cocktail of emotions
that has been the last year with Arthniti was the student-faculty
mixer. From the frustration of dealing with the implication that an
Arthniti party just didnt sound cool enough to the immense
relief that enough students eventually turned up, we were taken
through the entire spectrum of human emotion in the space of a
few hours. Two weeks later, we fulfilled our promises and distributed the third and final edition of the newsletter.
While I did take the internal decision of never organising a party
ever again, the support that we witnessed that day from our college-mates and teachers made me realise that despite all the challenges, all that time and effort was worth it.
26
I was always involved with writing clubs; from school magazine to the
French society (I understood very little here, but it was nevertheless fun).
This was the best year of all the three years that I spent in Arthniti (Yay
to SanSar!).
Working with like-minded persons is always rewarding; the nerdy talks,
the obsession with grammar and punctuation, appreciation for different
kinds of cinema and our common objective of producing good work. The
article Nandita and I wrote for NCC canteen was by far the most amusing
experience. We got to ask curious questions of the elusive NCC boss.
Who knew that there would actually be a story behind our adda?
Working on the blog, I realised how difficult it is to get other people to
collaborate to produce something. However, I am glad that I got the opportunity to see the blog grow and of course the opportunity to see the
club grow.
P.S: The student-teacher mixer was a brilliant idea. Our club could organise it every year for the college as a whole and make a tradition of it.
Arthniti as a club managed to do a lot of things this year, but its biggest
achievement, in my opinion, is that it was able to bring people together.
Sitting in one of the fifth floor classrooms on a Wednesday, discussing
ideas for the next issue of the newsletter is what I will remember about
the club. We got a lot of work done, but we had a lot of fun too. The club
was a safe place, but it also was a voice, especially for enthusiastic juniors who would always come up with great topics to write on. I hope
when the editors sit together to write for the magazine next year, they
will be able to say the same thing.
Working with Arthniti this past year has been an incredibly enjoyable, enriching
journey for me. Right from the onset, I've learnt a lot, not just by constantly
working to improve the quality of my own work, but through the example of others. Working on the newsletter month after month while juggling deadlines was
always an exciting experience. Working with our club heads, Sanaya and Sarayu,
has helped me improve not just as a writer and an editor, but has also taught the
kind of work and effort that goes into making a good magazine as a whole. Our
work on Oeconomica Scriptis wasn't the easiest thing, but was a new and interesting experience nevertheless.
For all the efforts we have all put in and the work we have collectively done,
working with Arthniti has been one of the most satisfying experiences of this
year.
28
29