Name: _______________________________________

Name of Peer: _________________________________

Rate your partners paper from 1-5 (5 as the highest) based on the following questions
REVISING CHECKLIST
5
4
3
2
1
1. Did I select and develop a conflict that can hold
my readers' attention?
2. Did I present background events and details that
explain the basis of the conflict?
3. Do my characters believably resolve the conflict?
4. Does my narration present a clear and consistent
point of view?
5. Does the order in which I presented the events in
the narrative make sense?
6. Did I use dialogues, anecdotes, and other narrative
techniques correctly?
AVERAGE (Total points divided by 6)
EDITING CHECKLIST
1. Have I capitalized all proper nouns?
2. Have I avoided sentence fragments?
3. Have I correctly punctuated direct quotations?
4. Have I avoided pronoun shifts?
5. Have I used vivid/active verbs and strong adverbs?
6. Have I checked spellings of any words I am unsure
of?

TOTAL

TOTAL

AVERAGE (Total points divided by 6)

GENERAL COMMENT/S: _______________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________________
Name: _______________________________________
Name of Peer: _________________________________
Rate your partners paper from 1-5 (5 as the highest) based on the following questions
REVISING CHECKLIST
5
4
3
2
1
1. Did I select and develop a conflict that can hold
my readers' attention?
2. Did I present background events and details that
explain the basis of the conflict?
3. Do my characters believably resolve the conflict?
4. Does my narration present a clear and consistent
point of view?
5. Does the order in which I presented the events in
the narrative make sense?
6. Did I use dialogues, anecdotes, and other narrative
techniques correctly?
AVERAGE (Total points divided by 6)
EDITING CHECKLIST
1. Have I capitalized all proper nouns?
2. Have I avoided sentence fragments?
3. Have I correctly punctuated direct quotations?
4. Have I avoided pronoun shifts?
5. Have I used vivid/active verbs and strong adverbs?
6. Have I checked spellings of any words I am unsure
of?

TOTAL

TOTAL

AVERAGE (Total points divided by 6)

GENERAL COMMENT/S: _________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________