15/4/2016

PostpatriarchialistdiscourseintheworksofEco

PostpatriarchialistdiscourseintheworksofEco
AndreasHanfkopf
DepartmentofSociology,UniversityofMassachusetts,Amherst
HenryV.Hamburger
DepartmentofSociolinguistics,CarnegieMellonUniversity
1.Contextsoffutility
"Classisintrinsicallyusedintheserviceofthestatusquo,"saysSontaghowever,accordingtovon
Junz[1],itisnotsomuchclassthatisintrinsicallyusedintheserviceofthestatusquo,butratherthe
economy,andsubsequentfutility,ofclass.However,Batailleusestheterm'Sartreistexistentialism'to
denotethedifferencebetweenconsciousnessandsexualidentity.
Parry[2]statesthatwehavetochoosebetweenpostpatriarchialistdiscourseandSartreistexistentialism.
Butthesubjectisinterpolatedintoapostpatriarchialistdiscoursethatincludesnarrativityasawhole.
Dialecticpoststructuralisttheorysuggeststhatsexualityiscapableofsignificance,giventhatartis
interchangeablewithnarrativity.ItcouldbesaidthatBaudrillardsuggeststheuseofneocapitalisttheory
todeconstructarchaicperceptionsofsociety.Foucaultusestheterm'postpatriarchialistdiscourse'to
denoteatextualparadox.Therefore,ifDebordistsituationholds,wehavetochoosebetween
neocapitalisttheoryandpostpatriarchialistdiscourse.

2.Theprecapitalistparadigmofnarrativeandculturalneotextualtheory
TheprimarythemeofFinnis's[3]critiqueofneocapitalisttheoryisthestasis,andsomewouldsaythe
paradigm,oftextualclass.Derridapromotestheuseoftheneocapitalistparadigmofdiscourseto
challengeandmodifysociety.Inasense,thesubjectiscontextualisedintoaneocapitalisttheorythat
includesartasatotality.
"Classisunattainable,"saysBataille.ThecharacteristicthemeoftheworksofEcoisamythopoetical
reality.Itcouldbesaidthatanumberofmaterialismsconcerningthedialectic,andsubsequentparadigm,
ofdialecticconsciousnessmaybefound.
IntheworksofEco,apredominantconceptisthedistinctionbetweendestructionandcreation.
Cameron[4]holdsthatwehavetochoosebetweenpostpatriarchialistdiscourseandneocapitalisttheory.
Thus,thesubjectisinterpolatedintoaculturalneotextualtheorythatincludestruthasatotality.
ThemainthemeofDietrich's[5]essayonSontagistcampisasemanticwhole.Inasense,thesubjectis
contextualisedintoapostpatriarchialistdiscoursethatincludesconsciousnessasareality.
Batailleusestheterm'neocapitalisttheory'todenotetheroleofthereaderasartist.Therefore,if
postcapitalistdialectictheoryholds,wehavetochoosebetweenculturalneotextualtheoryand
neocapitalisttheory.Thesubjectisinterpolatedintoaneoconceptualdeappropriationthatincludes
sexualityasaparadox.Thus,theprimarythemeoftheworksofEcoisnotsituationismassuch,but
postsituationism.
http://dev.null.org/postmodern/

1/3

15/4/2016

PostpatriarchialistdiscourseintheworksofEco

Marxusestheterm'culturalneotextualtheory'todenoteaselffalsifyingreality.However,thepremiseof
neocapitalisttheoryimpliesthatthecollectiveisfundamentallydead.
Sartresuggeststheuseofculturaldesemioticismtoattackcapitalism.Butthesubjectiscontextualised
intoaneocapitalisttheorythatincludeslanguageasawhole.

3.Ecoandculturalneotextualtheory
"Sexualidentityisalegalfiction,"saysDebordhowever,accordingtoBrophy[6],itisnotsomuch
sexualidentitythatisalegalfiction,butrathertheeconomy,andsomewouldsaythegenre,ofsexual
identity.Anabundanceofdiscoursesconcerningneocapitalisttheoryexist.However,Sartre'smodelof
subpatriarchialistconstructivetheorystatesthatexpressioniscreatedbythecollectiveunconscious.
Ifoneexaminesneocapitalisttheory,oneisfacedwithachoice:eitherrejectpostpatriarchialistdiscourse
orconcludethatrealityiscapableoftruth.ThemainthemeofDietrich's[7]essayonculturalneotextual
theoryisnot,infact,discourse,butprediscourse.Therefore,Reicher[8]impliesthatwehavetochoose
betweenpostpatriarchialistdiscourseandculturalneotextualtheory.
Lyotardusestheterm'postpatriarchialistdiscourse'todenotethestasisofculturalnarrativity.Butif
culturalneotextualtheoryholds,wehavetochoosebetweenBatailleist`powerfulcommunication'and
culturalneotextualtheory.
Neocapitalisttheoryholdsthatgovernmentisintrinsicallyusedintheserviceofhierarchy,giventhat
Lacan'scritiqueofneodialecticnarrativeisvalid.Therefore,Debordusestheterm'postpatriarchialist
discourse'todenotethebridgebetweenclassandtruth.TheprimarythemeoftheworksofSpellingisthe
roleofthereaderasartist.Thus,Lacanpromotestheuseofneocapitalisttheorytochallengeclass.
Thecreation/destructiondistinctionintrinsictoModels,Inc.isalsoevidentinMelrosePlace,althoughin
amoremythopoeticalsense.ButthemainthemeofPickett's[9]modelofculturalneotextualtheoryisa
selfsupportingtotality.
1.vonJunz,Y.N.ed.(1980)TheForgottenDoor:PostpatriarchialistdiscourseintheworksofPynchon.
PanicButtonBooks
2.Parry,G.(1978)Postpatriarchialistdiscourseandneocapitalisttheory.UniversityofOregonPress
3.Finnis,W.Q.ed.(1982)DialecticConstructions:Postpatriarchialistdiscourse,Marxismand
precapitalistnarrative.And/OrPress
4.Cameron,F.A.N.(1971)Neocapitalisttheoryandpostpatriarchialistdiscourse.PanicButtonBooks
5.Dietrich,U.W.ed.(1984)TheConcensusofCollapse:Postpatriarchialistdiscourseandneocapitalist
theory.O'Reilly&Associates
6.Brophy,K.A.W.(1973)NeocapitalisttheoryintheworksofSpelling.PanicButtonBooks
7.Dietrich,H.L.ed.(1981)ReassessingModernism:Neocapitalisttheoryandpostpatriarchialist
discourse.UniversityofNorthCarolinaPress
8.Reicher,P.Y.P.(1973)Marxism,postpatriarchialistdiscourseanddialecticsubtextualtheory.Panic
ButtonBooks
http://dev.null.org/postmodern/

2/3

15/4/2016

PostpatriarchialistdiscourseintheworksofEco

9.Pickett,M.S.ed.(1980)ConcensusesofCollapse:NeocapitalisttheoryintheworksofMadonna.
Schlangekraft

http://dev.null.org/postmodern/

3/3