QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.

2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES
Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB
Ahmedabad Zone
1 (Central Excise) Ahmedabad-I 14 0 0 14 4 0 1 3 638.73 0 0 638.73 334.64 0 12.74 321.9
Ahmedabad-II 14 0 0 14 3 0 1 2 4793.92 0 0 4793.92 43.13 0 20 23.13
Ahmedabad-III 7 0 0 7 1 0 0 1 2216 0 0 2216 17.05 0 0 17.05
Rajkot 12 0 0 12 4 0 1 3 1991.77 0 0 1991.77 72.68 0 0 72.68
Bhavnagar 14 2 0 16 16 0 0 16 671.05 224.3 0 895.35 356.7 0 0 356.7
Service Tax 1 2 0 3 0 0 0 0 49.37 81.48 0 130.85 0 0 0 0
Total 62 4 0 66 28 0 3 25 10360.84 305.78 0 10666.62 824.2 0 32.74 791.46

Bangalore Zone
2 (Central Excise) Bangalore-I 16 0 2 14 0 0 0 0 6868.49 0 12.82 6855.67 0 0 0 0
Bangalore-II 15 0 0 15 1 0 0 1 3722.26 0 0 3722.26 77.21 0 0 77.21
Bangalore-III 15 2 3 14 3 0 0 3 11025.48 0.97 9.78 11016.67 596.72 0 0 596.72
Service Tax 1 3 0 4 6 0 3 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 47 5 5 47 10 0 3 7 21616.23 0.97 22.6 21594.6 673.93 0 0 673.93

Chief Commissioner Large Tax Payers

3 Bangalore Unit 9 0 1 8 3 0 0 3 460.13 0 2.18 457.95 68.55 0 0 68.55
Total 9 0 1 8 3 0 0 3 460.13 0 2.18 457.95 68.55 0 0 68.55

Bhopal Zone (Central

4 Excise) Indore 25 25 23 23 1678.41 1678.41 4022.06 4022.06
Bhopal 26 26 7 7 4609.26 4609.26 33.31 33.31
Raipur 7 7 13 13 355.23 355.23 604.25 604.25
Total 58 0 0 58 43 0 0 43 6642.9 0 0 6642.9 4659.62 0 0 4659.62

5 Bhubneshwar Zone Bhubneswar-I 3 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 1503.06 0 0 1503.06 0 0 0 0

Bhubneswar-II 2 0 0 2 2 0 0 2 2135.93 0 0 2135.93 71.25 0 0 71.25
Total 5 0 0 5 2 0 0 2 3638.99 0 0 3638.99 71.25 0 0 71.25

Chandigarh Zone.
6 (Central Excise) Chandigarh 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ludhinana 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Jalandhar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
J&K 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 159 0 0 159 45 0 0 45 10389.96 0 0 10389.96 1470.54 0 0 1470.54

Chennai Zone
7 (Central Excise) Chennai-I 16 1 0 17 3 0 0 3 16579.04 8.09 0 16587.13 105.52 0 0 105.52
Chennai-II 11 1 0 12 4 0 0 4 3141.3 866.51 0 4007.81 9.06 0 0 9.06

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 1/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB
Chennai-III 15 0 1 14 2 0 2 0 207.09 0 5.33 201.76 123.18 0 123.18 0
Chennai-IV 8 0 0 8 0 0 0 0 777.46 0 0 777.46 0 0 0 0
Pondicherry. 15 0 1 14 3 0 0 3 4289.48 0 1590 2699.48 308.31 0 0 308.31
Service Tax 13 0 0 13 7 0 0 7 2002.73 0 0 2002.73 0 0 0 0
Total 78 2 2 78 19 0 2 17 26997.1 874.6 1595.33 26276.37 546.07 0 123.18 422.89

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 2/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB

Cochin Zone (Central

8 Excise) Thiruvananthapuram 8 8 0 0 292.64 292.64 0 0
Calicut 36 36 5 5 525.83 525.83 62 62
Cochin 10 10 5 5 844.31 844.31 101.45 101.45
Cochin Cus 8 8 3 3 169.6 169.6 0.33 0.33
Cochin (Preventive) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 62 0 0 62 13 0 0 13 1832.38 0 0 1832.38 163.78 0 0 163.78

Coimbatore Zone
9 (Central Excise) Coimbatore 58 0 39 19 2 0 0 2 1301.69 0 27.41 1274.28 282.78 0 0 282.78
Salem 6 0 1 5 2 0 0 2 776.48 0 85.72 690.76 483.52 0 199.91 283.61
Thiruchirappali 6 4 2 8 10 0 0 10 3894.47 651.83 4.99 4541.31 603.14 0 0 603.14
Madurai 16 4 0 20 7 0 0 7 1108.27 2.4 0 1110.67 715.21 0 0 715.21
Thirunelveli 2 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0.68 0 0 0.68 0 0 0 0
Total 88 8 42 54 21 0 0 21 7081.59 654.23 118.12 7617.7 2084.65 0 199.91 1884.74

Delhi Zone (Central

10 Excise) Delhi-I 8 8 6 6 3377.64 3377.64 141.29 141.29
Delhi-II 8 8 6 6 364.35 364.35 3.82 3.82
Gurgaon 25 25 17 17 985.78 985.78 586.25 586.25
Faridabad 9 9 2 2 372.06 372.06 498.13 498.13
Rohtak 6 6 7 7 15302.9 15302.9 161.79 161.79
Panchkula 6 6 4 4 888.65 888.65 0 0
Service Tax 4 4 2 2 1331.83 1331.83 0 0
Total 66 0 0 66 44 0 0 44 22623.21 0 0 22623.21 1391.28 0 0 1391.28

Hyderabad Zone
11 (Central Excise) Hyderabad-I 1 1 0 0 28 28 0 0
Hyderabad-II 31 31 5 5 3920.86 3920.86 376.25 376.25
Hyderabad-III 20 20 9 9 2147.01 2147.01 1042.56 1042.56
Hyderabad-IV 14 14 2 2 6485.79 6485.79 140.37 140.37
Total 66 0 0 66 16 0 0 16 12581.66 0 0 12581.66 1559.18 0 0 1559.18

Jaipur Zone. (Central

12 Excise) Jaipur-I 24 0 0 24 21 0 0 21 3105.95 0 0 3105.95 601.36 0 0 601.36
Jaipur-II 83 0 0 83 16 0 0 16 2271.76 0 0 2271.76 243.28 0 0 243.28
Total 107 0 0 107 37 0 0 37 5377.71 0 0 5377.71 844.64 0 0 844.64

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 3/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES
Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB

Kolkata Zone (Central

13 Excise) Kolkata-I 3 3 2 2 7.77 7.77 66.43 66.43
Kolkata-II 10 10 2 2 33.27 33.27 0.1 0.1
Kolkata-III 2 2 1 1 493.83 493.83 72.33 72.33
Kolkata-IV 2 2 2 2 1791.17 1791.17 1359.79 1359.79
Kolkata-V 1 1 1 1 12.47 12.47 12.37 12.37
Kolkata-VI 1 1 0 0 626.74 626.74 0 0
Kolkata-VII 1 1 0 0 410 410 0 0
Haldia 6 6 3 3 55834.52 55834.52 118.56 118.56
Bolpur 1 1 1 1 115.11 115.11 0 0
Sillguri 1 1 0 0 3494 3494 0 0
Service Tax 1 1 1 1 92 92 0 0
Total 29 0 0 29 13 0 0 13 62910.88 0 0 62910.88 1629.58 0 0 1629.58

Lucknow Zone
14 (Central Excise) Allahabad 20 20 1 1 433.55 433.55 5 5
Kanpur 5 5 3 3 654.55 654.55 3.05 3.05
Lucknow 12 12 4 4 236 236 20.46 20.46
Total 37 0 0 37 8 0 0 8 1324.1 0 0 1324.1 28.51 0 0 28.51

Mysore Zone (Central

15 Excise) Belgum 4 0 0 4 3 0 0 3 1628.1 0 0 1628.1 283.37 0 0 283.37
Mangalore 5 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 239.52 0 0 239.52 0 0 0 0
Mysore 2 0 0 2 1 0 0 1 68.64 0 0 68.64 11.07 0 0 11.07
Total 11 0 0 11 4 0 0 4 1936.26 0 0 1936.26 294.44 0 0 294.44

Meerut Zone (Central

16 Excise) Meerut-I 22 22 12 12 1328.84 1328.84 185.02 185.02
Meerut-II 18 18 1 1 608.3 608.3 0.38 0.38
Ghaziabad 18 18 3 3 788.59 788.59 76.24 76.24
Noida 32 32 10 10 7261.62 7261.62 1670.16 1670.16
Total 90 0 0 90 26 0 0 26 9987.35 0 0 9987.35 1931.8 0 0 1931.8

Mumbai-I Zone
17 (Central Excise) Mumbai-I 9 0 0 9 2 0 1 1 425.3 0 0 425.3 48.16 0 48.16 0

Mumbai-IV 12 0 0 12 4 0 0 4 1907 55 0 1962 311 0 0 311

Mumbai-V 18 0 2 16 7 1 0 8 2434.74 0 318.81 2115.93 2718.14 9583 0 12301.14
Thane-I 19 0 0 19 9 0 0 9 3869.07 0 0 3869.07 435.39 0 0 435.39
Thane-II 22 4 2 24 1 0 0 1 1462.49 55.92 308.86 1209.55 16.18 0 0 16.18

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 4/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB
Service Tax 4 0 1 3 2 0 0 2 11.04 0 9.02 2.02 64.58 0 0 64.58
Total 84 4 5 83 25 1 1 25 10109.64 110.92 636.69 9583.87 3593.45 9583 48.16 13128.29

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 5/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES
Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB

Mumbai-II Zone
18 (Central Excise) Mumbai-II 19 19 1 1 44495.46 44495.46 11.59 11.59
Mumbai-III 34 34 8 8 8724.71 8724.71 191.44 191.44
Belapur 13 13 4 4 6887.9 6887.9 192.47 192.47
Raigarh 21 21 0 0 11564 11564 0 0
Total 87 0 0 87 13 0 0 13 71672.07 0 0 71672.07 395.5 0 0 395.5

Nagpur Zone (Central

19 Excise) Aurangabad 9 9 15 15 1081.59 1081.59 19268.17 19268.17
Nagpur 36 36 7 7 3483 3483 5315 5315
Nasik 5 5 6 6 497.17 497.17 12640.72 12640.72
Total 50 0 0 50 28 0 0 28 5061.76 0 0 5061.76 37223.89 0 0 37223.89

Pune Zone (Central

20 Excise) Pune-I 23 23 3 3 1202.64 1202.64 0 0
Pune-II 8 8 3 3 3514 3514 412 412
Pune-III 20 20 3 3 5241.06 5241.06 14.54 14.54
Goa C.Ex. 11 11 0 0 8531.89 8531.89 0 0
Goa Customs 3 3 1 1 234 234 0 0
Pune Customs 30 30 0 0 18197.44 18197.44 0 0
Total 95 0 0 95 10 0 0 10 36921.03 0 0 36921.03 426.54 0 0 426.54

Ranchi Zone (Central

21 Excise) Ranchi 10 10 7 7 2109.77 2109.77 668.45 668.45
Patna 2 2 8 8 87.14 87.14 246.68 246.68
Jamshedpur 13 13 6 6 26459.31 26459.31 107.58 107.58
Total 25 0 0 25 21 0 0 21 28656.22 0 0 28656.22 1022.71 0 0 1022.71

Shillong Zone
22 (Central Excise) Shillong-CE 2 2 6 6 1884.22 1884.22 16.1 16.1
Dibrugarh 0 0 2 2 0 0 220.18 220.18
Guwahati CX 3 3 3 3 4894.28 4894.28 0 0
Shillong-CC(Prev) 2 2 1 1 0 0 0 0
Total 7 0 0 7 12 0 0 12 6778.5 0 0 6778.5 236.28 0 0 236.28

Vadodara Zone
23 (Central Excise) Vadodara-I 24 24 6 6 10053.47 10053.47 518.91 518.91
Vadodara-II 30 30 1 1 16104.25 16104.25 1931 1931
Surat-I 24 24 4 4 19277.68 19277.68 7.87 7.87
Surat-II 24 24 1 1 1636.92 1636.92 455.08 455.08

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 6/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB
Daman 26 26 9 9 12472.51 12472.51 1243.09 1243.09
Vapi 51 51 4 4 43166.33 43166.33 383.89 383.89
Total 179 0 0 179 25 0 0 25 102711.2 0 0 102711.2 4539.84 0 0 4539.84

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 7/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES
Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB

Visakapatnam Zone
24 (Central Excise) Visakapatnam-I 7 7 1 1 4810.88 4810.88 45.38 45.38
Visakapatnam-II 23 23 2 2 5199.6 5199.6 1531.68 1531.68
Visakapatnam-Cus. 16 16 4 4 944.38 944.38 366.86 366.86
Guntur 13 13 0 0 210.77 210.77 0 0
Tirupati 7 7 4 4 1090.37 1090.37 493.51 493.51
Total 66 0 0 66 11 0 0 11 12256 0 0 12256 2437.43 2437.43

Ahmedabad Zone
25 (Customs.) Ahemadabad 9 1 0 10 1 0 0 1 4580 1449 0 6029 32 0 0 32
Jamnagar(Preventive
) 26 0 0 26 11 0 0 11 2316.13 0 0 2316.13 926.74 0 0 926.74
Kandla(Preventive) 10 0 0 10 4 0 0 4 4038 0 0 4038 365.98 0 0 365.98
Total 45 1 0 46 16 0 0 16 10934.13 1449 0 12383.13 1324.72 0 0 1324.72

Bangalore Zone
26 (Customs.) Bangalore 13 1 0 14 5 6 0 11 951 0 0 951 591 0 0 591
Mangalore 7 1 0 8 3 0 0 3 1141.64 0 0 1141.64 1720 0 0 1720
Total 20 2 0 22 8 6 0 14 2092.64 0 0 2092.64 2311 0 0 2311

Chennai Zone Chennai (Airport &

27 (Customs.) Aircargo) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Chennai Port
(Import) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Chennai Port
(Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 42 0 0 42 16 0 0 16 1982.97 0 0 1982.97 1005.5 0 0 1005.5

Chennai Zone
28 (Customs-Prev) Thiruhirapalli(Prev) 3 0 0 3 1 1 0 2 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1
Tuticorin(Prev) 3 0 0 3 1 0 0 1 44.52 0 0 44.52 0 0 0 0
Total 6 0 0 6 2 1 0 3 44.52 0 0 44.52 1 0 0 1

29 Delhi Zone (Customs) Delhi Aircargo Import 7 7 7 7 12 12 85 85

Delhi Aircargo Export 0 0 1 1 0 0 46 46

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 8/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB
Delhi (ICD) 13 13 4 4 5834 5834 42 42
Total 20 0 0 20 12 0 0 12 5846 0 0 5846 173 0 0 173

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 9/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES
Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Chief RECEIVE DECIDE DECIDE
Sl. No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED D CB
Delhi Zone (Customs
30 Prev.) Delhi (Prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Amristar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Jodhpur (prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 6 0 0 6 4 0 0 4 1305.49 0 0 1305.49 8 0 0 8

Kolkata Zone
31 (Customs) Kolkata(Port) 33 0 1 32 8 0 0 8 640 0 132 508 197 0 0 197
Kolkata(Airport) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
West Bengal (Prev) 17 0 0 17 2 0 0 2 9 0 0 9 75 0 3 72
Total 50 0 1 49 10 0 0 10 649 0 132 517 272 0 3 269

Mumbai-I Zone Mumbai(Mulund CFS

32 (Customs) & Gen) 5 5 2 2 17443.11 17443.11 13.32 13.32
Mumbai(Export) 8 8 6 6 487 487 3 3
Mumbai(Import) 69 69 41 41 11741 11741 6357 6357
Total 82 0 0 82 49 0 0 49 29671.11 0 0 29671.11 6373.32 0 0 6373.32

Mumbai-II Zone Aircargo(Import &

33 (Customs) Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
JNCH(Import &
Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 5 0 0 5 8 0 0 8 508 0 0 508 415 0 0 415

Mumbai-III Zone
34 (Customs Prev) CC Mumbai(P) 10 10 4 4 19490.97 19490.97 91.64 91.64
Mumbai(Airport) 6 6 0 0 390.02 390.02 0 0
CCPune(P) 7 7 14 14 307 307 4394.5 4394.5
Total 23 0 0 23 18 0 0 18 20187.99 0 0 20187.99 4486.14 0 0 4486.14

Patna Zone
35 (Customs) CC Patna(Prev) 32 32 3 3 209.64 209.64 217 217
CC Lucknow(Prev) 0 0 1 1 0 0 23 23
Total 32 0 0 32 4 0 0 4 209.64 0 0 209.64 240 0 0 240

GRAND TOTAL 1898 26 56 1868 624 8 9 623 553359.2 3395.5 2506.92 554247.7 84727.34 9583 406.99 93903.35

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 10/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

REMARKS

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 11/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

REMARKS

Commissio
nerate-
wise break-
up not
given

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 12/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
SUPREME COURT CASES

REMARKS

Commissio
nerate-
wise break-
up not
given

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 13/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
1 Ahmedabad Zone
(Central Excise) Ahmedabad-I 72 14 23 63 38 1 0 39 2069.86 57.3 65.3 2061.86 232.93 157 0 389.93
Ahmedabad-II 62 21 5 78 43 1 2 42 4549.82 2712.07 1534.49 5727.4 835.04 0.68 33.65 802.07
Ahmedabad-III 18 7 0 25 34 2 1 35 627.47 165.12 0 792.59 2098.59 271.58 0 2370.17
Rajkot 59 13 0 72 39 3 10 32 12873.64 14075.39 0 26949.03 2833.22 8.85 0 2842.07
Bhavnagar 54 6 1 59 37 0 0 37 906.19 12.04 1.55 916.68 707.87 0 0 707.87
Service Tax 0 2 0 2 24 0 1 23 0 62.84 0 62.84 86.09 0 0 86.09
Total 265 63 29 299 215 7 14 208 21026.98 17084.76 1601.34 36510.4 6793.74 438.11 33.65 7198.2

2 Bangalore Zone
(Central Excise) Bangalore-I 38 2 7 33 5 0 1 4 1351.23 584.28 372.48 1563.03 96.87 0 91.52 5.35
Bangalore-II 40 5 1 44 1 0 0 1 3677.03 233.78 0.43 3910.38 0 0 0 0
Bangalore-III 51 13 2 62 6 2 1 7 1849.33 81.43 5.77 1924.99 98.59 71 0 169.59
Service Tax 171 6 5 172 15 3 4 14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 300 26 15 311 27 5 6 26 6877.59 899.49 378.68 7398.4 195.46 71 91.52 174.94

3 Chief
Commissioner
Bangalore Large Tax Payers Unit 30 2 0 32 3 1 2 2 1740.7 553.42 0 2294.12 289.78 106.64 106.64 289.78
Total 30 2 0 32 3 1 2 2 1740.7 553.42 0 2294.12 289.78 106.64 106.64 289.78

4 Bhopal Zone
(Central Excise) Indore 119 119 141 141 4279.22 4279.22 9426.46 9426.46
Bhopal 44 44 87 87 1408.75 1408.75 14065.62 14065.62
Raipur 119 119 96 96 5654.68 5654.68 2300.13 2300.13
Total 282 0 0 282 324 0 0 324 11342.65 0 0 11342.65 25792.21 0 0 25792.21

5
Bhubneshwar Zone Bhubneswar-I 93 3 0 96 151 7 14 144 8247.74 11.51 0 8259.25 10450.57 260.59 254.24 10456.92
Bhubneswar-II 80 2 0 82 47 10 4 53 3251.47 1.27 0 3252.74 1756.17 0 0 1756.17
Total 173 5 0 178 198 17 18 197 11499.21 12.78 0 11511.99 12206.74 260.59 254.24 12213.09

6 Chandigarh Zone.
(Central Excise) Chandigarh 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ludhinana 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Jalandhar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
J&K 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 434 0 0 434 347 0 0 347 7809.59 0 0 7809.59 2681.91 0 0 2681.91

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 14/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
7 Chennai Zone
(Central Excise) Chennai-I 76 2 2 76 28 0 3 25 3387.37 0.57 71.22 3316.72 1749.2 0 57.37 1691.83
Chennai-II 76 7 0 83 66 0 0 66 8866.2 43.8 0 8910 4630.14 0 0 4630.14
Chennai-III 47 3 2 48 105 10 8 107 1484.17 7.45 5.26 1486.36 5123.18 38.02 74.43 5086.77
Chennai-IV 43 5 1 47 15 2 2 15 3501.71 18.55 12.2 3508.06 3677.05 24.48 396 3305.53
Pondicherry. 169 2 0 171 14 3 1 16 7155.71 24.35 0 7180.06 449.46 682.43 30 1101.89
Service Tax 22 4 0 26 196 25 4 217 1692.36 3 0 1695.36 13186.02 406.04 10.2 13581.86
Total 433 23 5 451 424 40 18 446 26087.52 97.72 88.68 26096.56 28815.05 1150.97 568 29398.02

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 15/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB

8 Cochin Zone
(Central Excise) Thiruvananthapuram 14 14 26 26 857.3 857.3 4959.77 4959.77
Calicut 56 56 84 84 686.92 686.92 2188.58 2188.58
Cochin 43 43 17 17 6118.25 6118.25 453.07 453.07
Cochin Cus. 42 42 214 214 76.8 76.8 928.43 928.43
Cochin (Preventive) 4 4 16 16 0 0 0 0
Total 159 0 0 159 357 0 0 357 7739.27 0 0 7739.27 8529.85 0 0 8529.85

9 Coimbatore Zone
(Central Excise) Coimbatore 107 3 1 109 155 6 2 159 3180.27 9.04 4.3 3185.01 5594.52 42.98 0 5637.5
Salem 68 13 0 81 214 12 8 218 1534.6 18.13 0 1552.73 6487.55 15.95 636.12 5867.38
Thiruchirappali 42 5 0 47 60 0 1 59 1962.46 601.6 0 2564.06 1404.44 0 24.04 1380.4
Madurai 62 13 0 75 15 0 0 15 655.14 613.6 0 1268.74 612.43 0 0 612.43
Thirunelveli 81 0 0 81 66 2 4 64 2778.71 16.29 0 2795 980.87 0 1.38 979.49
Total 360 34 1 393 510 20 15 515 10111.18 1258.66 4.3 11365.54 15079.81 58.93 661.54 14477.2

10 Delhi Zone (Central

Excise) Delhi-I 21 21 38 38 1173.78 1173.78 1706.42 1706.42
Delhi-II 15 15 14 14 8.33 8.33 1222.75 1222.75
Gurgaon 56 56 7 7 1017.39 1017.39 6731.07 6731.07
Faridabad 35 35 16 16 1175.11 1175.11 151.04 151.04
Rohtak 21 21 17 17 1893.71 1893.71 285.43 285.43
Panchkula 6 6 4 4 338.92 338.92 22.56 22.56
Service Tax 9 9 119 119 3.75 3.75 21766.55 21766.55
Total 163 0 0 163 215 0 0 215 5610.99 0 0 5610.99 31885.82 0 0 31885.82

11 Hyderabad Zone
(Central Excise) Hyderabad-I 98 98 69 69 12657.28 12657.28 3582.11 3582.11
Hyderabad-II 68 68 106 106 4459.31 4459.31 2300.03 2300.03
Hyderabad-III 71 71 34 34 6134.46 6134.46 561.35 561.35
Hyderabad-IV 88 88 39 39 2494.76 2494.76 723.27 723.27
Total 325 0 0 325 248 0 0 248 25745.81 0 0 25745.81 7166.76 0 0 7166.76

12 Jaipur Zone.
(Central Excise) Jaipur-I 241 5 1 245 183 4 11 176 7267.53 35.73 0 7303.26 3056.61 606.59 33.63 3629.57
Jaipur-II 91 9 4 96 104 61 0 165 2234.89 17.24 15.79 2236.34 2205.32 841.42 0 3046.74
Total 332 14 5 341 287 65 11 341 9502.42 52.97 15.79 9539.6 5261.93 1448.01 33.63 6676.31

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 16/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
13 Kolkata Zone
(Central Excise) Kolkata-I 8 8 19 19 121.77 121.77 387.54 387.54
Kolkata-II 39 39 47 47 13557.31 13557.31 789.38 789.38
Kolkata-III 20 20 59 59 5374.06 5374.06 6162.33 6162.33
Kolkata-IV 34 34 63 63 2491.63 2491.63 3843.04 3843.04
Kolkata-V 17 17 50 50 959.65 959.65 1099.22 1099.22
Kolkata-VI 12 12 9 9 301.1 301.1 2992.62 2992.62
Kolkata-VII 12 12 10 10 451.22 451.22 200.72 200.72
Haldia 17 17 33 33 8835.87 8835.87 1178.34 1178.34
Bolpur 13 13 49 49 1100.45 1100.45 1099.79 1099.79
Sillguri 6 6 27 27 600.45 600.45 507.2 507.2
Service Tax 5 5 38 38 101.6 101.6 15439 15439
Total 183 0 0 183 404 0 0 404 33895.11 0 0 33895.11 33699.18 0 0 33699.18

14 Lucknow Zone
(Central Excise) Allahabad 140 140 85 85 754.58 754.58 1253.5 1253.5
Kanpur 59 59 157 157 350.09 350.09 10674.02 10674.02
Lucknow 73 73 51 51 37376.01 37376.01 1350.19 1350.19
Total 272 0 0 272 293 0 0 293 38480.68 0 0 38480.68 13277.71 0 0 13277.71

15 Mysore Zone
(Central Excise) Belgaum 75 7 4 78 6 2 2 6 15432.16 407.1 6.34 15832.92 96.61 1024.28 0 1120.89
Mangalore 17 9 0 26 10 0 0 10 11179.58 3334.95 0 14514.53 236.79 0 0 236.79
Mysore 14 2 1 15 9 0 2 7 219.6 136.4 75.4 280.6 85.2 0 0.33 84.87
Total 106 18 5 119 25 2 4 23 26831.34 3878.45 81.74 30628.05 418.6 1024.28 0.33 1442.55

16 Meerut Zone
(Central Excise) Meerut-I 96 96 73 73 4442.3 4442.3 9466.61 9466.61
Meerut-II 86 86 61 61 1641.1 1641.1 931.7 931.7
Ghaziabad 66 66 56 56 1048.99 1048.99 2277.41 2277.41
Noida 65 65 41 41 3508.88 3508.88 986.61 986.61
Total 313 0 0 313 231 0 0 231 10641.27 0 0 10641.27 13662.33 0 0 13662.33

17 Mumbai-I Zone
(Central Excise) Mumbai-I 27 3 0 30 27 1 1 27 1593.23 29.6 0 1622.83 149.72 13.57 0 163.29

Mumbai-IV 12 0 0 12 18 0 0 18 178 0 0 178 1207 1048 0 2255

Mumbai-V 71 0 13 58 18 1 1 18 6488.62 0 68.25 6420.37 4893.64 1.5 1.01 4894.13
Thane-I 59 1 3 57 17 4 2 19 1453.57 7.02 4.5 1456.09 1095.5 3423.19 87.69 4431

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 17/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
Thane-II 77 0 8 69 26 1 1 26 4154.93 0 59.42 4095.51 714.61 7.75 415 307.36
Service Tax 16 2 8 10 45 0 7 38 2591.49 0.58 553.28 2038.79 15707.12 0 14.01 15693.11
Total 262 6 32 236 151 7 12 146 16459.84 37.2 685.45 15811.59 23767.59 4494.01 517.71 27743.89

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 18/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
18 Mumbai-II Zone
(Central Excise) Mumbai-II 30 30 13 13 2465.45 2465.45 1035.69 1035.69
Mumbai-III 43 43 18 18 1422.44 1422.44 1215.09 1215.09
Belapur 24 24 22 22 1094 1094 11680.57 11680.57
Raigarh 35 35 17 17 3381 3381 4955 4955
Total 132 0 0 132 70 0 0 70 8362.89 0 0 8362.89 18886.35 0 0 18886.35

19 Nagpur Zone
(Central Excise) Aurangabad 136 136 60 60 2505.24 2505.24 5003.82 5003.82
Nagpur 145 145 100 100 7259 7259 4829 4829
Nasik 85 85 18 18 8261.62 8261.62 12296.02 12296.02
Total 366 0 0 366 178 0 0 178 18025.86 0 0 18025.86 22128.84 0 0 22128.84

20 Pune Zone (Central

Excise) Pune-I 40 40 16 16 3087.44 3087.44 306.02 306.02
Pune-II 118 118 11 11 7319 7319 1299 1299
Pune-III 38 38 22 22 18879.22 18879.22 4887.12 4887.12
Goa C.Ex. 46 46 7 7 1909.69 1909.69 322.42 322.42
Goa Customs 3 3 7 7 108 108 161.45 161.45
Pune Customs 26 26 10 10 103.05 103.05 66.22 66.22
Total 271 0 0 271 73 0 0 73 31406.4 0 0 31406.4 7042.23 0 0 7042.23

21 Ranchi Zone
(Central Excise) Ranchi 24 24 38 38 23460.36 23460.36 1077.11 1077.11
Patna 32 32 34 34 1733.01 1733.01 2490.35 2490.35
Jamshedpur 41 41 38 38 16657.57 16657.57 1884.06 1884.06
Total 97 0 0 97 110 0 0 110 41850.94 0 0 41850.94 5451.52 0 0 5451.52

22 Shillong Zone
(Central Excise) Shillong-CE 2 2 49 49 341.6 341.6 6382.58 6382.58
Dibrugarh 14 14 34 34 1893.41 1893.41 1065.55 1065.55
Guwahati CX 23 23 7 7 7511.91 7511.91 2762 2762
Shillong-CC(Prev) 9 9 20 20 23.45 23.45 18.84 18.84
Total 48 0 0 48 110 0 0 110 9770.37 0 0 9770.37 10228.97 0 0 10228.97

23 Vadodara Zone
(Central Excise) Vadodara-I 45 45 16 16 1852.44 1852.44 724.16 724.16
Vadodara-II 64 64 23 23 10072.94 10072.94 1966.69 1966.69
Surat-I 342 342 53 53 5758.22 5758.22 20382.93 20382.93

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 19/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
Surat-II 141 141 35 35 4842.78 4842.78 3862.39 3862.39
Daman 142 142 25 25 7482.13 7482.13 758.55 758.55
Vapi 91 91 18 18 3881.91 3881.91 1045.21 1045.21
Total 825 0 0 825 170 0 0 170 33890.42 0 0 33890.42 28739.93 0 0 28739.93

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 20/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
24
Visakapatnam Zone
(Central Excise) Visakapatnam-I 56 56 11 11 12722.87 12722.87 952.32 952.32
Visakapatnam-II 115 115 50 50 7424.94 7424.94 945.2 945.2
Visakapatnam-Cus. 22 22 16 16 7013.61 7013.61 246.14 246.14
Guntur 58 58 26 26 8729.56 8729.56 3413.57 3413.57
Tirupati 60 60 14 14 5978.33 5978.33 576.89 576.89
Total 311 0 0 311 117 0 0 117 41869.31 0 0 41869.31 6134.12 0 0 6134.12

25 Ahmedabad Zone
(Customs.) Ahemadabad 30 0 5 25 30 1 1 30 3573 0 2932 641 225 0 107 118

Jamnagar(Preventive) 61 2 1 62 31 1 1 31 6008.5 87 1.19 6094.31 2873.3 68.74 37 2905.04

Kandla(Preventive) 69 4 6 67 122 7 24 105 3350.98 197 348 3199.98 1565 0 635 930
Total 160 6 12 154 183 9 26 166 12932.48 284 3281.19 9935.29 4663.3 68.74 779 3953.04

26 Bangalore Zone
(Customs.) Bangalore 89 2 3 88 28 4 1 31 3186 236 5 3417 1621.51 79 922 778.51
Mangalore 15 0 0 15 9 3 1 11 519.5 0 0 519.5 993.37 131.19 0 1124.56
Total 104 2 3 103 37 7 2 42 3705.5 236 5 3936.5 2614.88 210.19 922 1903.07

27 Chennai Zone Chennai (Airport &

(Customs.) Aircargo) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Chennai Port (Import) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Chennai Port (Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 246 0 0 246 970 0 0 970 10763.52 0 0 10763.52 58856.22 0 0 58856.22

28
Chennai Zone
(Customs-Prev) Thiruhirapalli(Prev) 9 2 1 10 35 2 7 30 547.37 4.17 292.52 259.02 302.17 0.5 53.92 248.75
Tuticorin(Prev) 40 2 2 40 95 29 21 103 5530.59 15 0 5545.59 548.58 196 0 744.58
Total 49 4 3 50 130 31 28 133 6077.96 19.17 292.52 5804.61 850.75 196.5 53.92 993.33

29 Delhi Zone
(Customs) Delhi Aircargo Import 15 15 89 89 2087 2087 13007 13007
Delhi Aircargo Export 5 5 30 30 16 16 195 195

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 21/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB
Delhi (ICD) 3 3 76 76 0 0 5322 5322
Total 23 0 0 23 195 0 0 195 2103 0 0 2103 18524 0 0 18524

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 22/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB

30 Delhi Zone
(Customs Prev.) Delhi (Prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Amristar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Jodhpur (prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 103 0 0 103 78 0 0 78 216.25 0 0 216.25 6596.04 0 0 6596.04

31 Kolkata Zone
(Customs) Kolkata(Port) 18 1 0 19 8 0 0 8 1121 132 0 1253 53 0 0 53
Kolkata(Airport) 2 0 0 2 1 0 0 1 57 0 0 57 174 0 0 174
West Bengal (Prev) 5 2 1 6 156 9 47 118 32 0 5 27 3446 0 394 3052
Total 25 3 1 27 165 9 47 127 1210 132 5 1337 3673 0 394 3279

32 Mumbai-I Zone Mumbai(Mulund CFS &

(Customs) Gen) 19 19 13 13 198.48 198.48 3287.26 3287.26
Mumbai(Export) 20 20 51 51 452 452 1348 1348
Mumbai(Import) 89 89 138 138 4852 4852 5022.32 5022.32
Total 128 0 0 128 202 0 0 202 5502.48 0 0 5502.48 9657.58 0 0 9657.58

33 Mumbai-II Zone Aircargo(Import &

(Customs) Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

JNCH(Import & Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total 20 0 0 20 63 0 0 63 557 0 0 557 1255 0 0 1255

34 Mumbai-III Zone
(Customs Prev) CC Mumbai(P) 38 38 41 41 3718.48 3718.48 12892.27 12892.27
Mumbai(Airport) 18 18 26 26 1603.39 1603.39 27171.8 27171.8
CCPune(P) 28 28 20 20 1404 1404 2042 2042
Total 84 0 0 84 87 0 0 87 6725.87 0 0 6725.87 42106.07 0 0 42106.07

35 Patna Zone
(Customs) CC Patna(Prev) 103 103 161 161 311.54 311.54 326.6 326.6
CC Lucknow(Prev) 59 59 47 47 324 324 207.24 207.24
Total 162 0 0 162 208 0 0 208 635.54 0 0 635.54 533.84 0 0 533.84

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 23/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

Nos. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. No
Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D DECIDED CB

GRAND TOTAL 7546 206 111 7641 7405 220 203 7422 507008 24546.62 6439.69 525115 477467.11 9527.97 4416.18 482578.9

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 24/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

REMARKS

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 25/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

REMARKS

Commissio
nerate-wise
break-up
not given

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 26/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
HIGH COURTS CASES

REMARKS

Commissio
nerate-wise
break-up
not given

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 27/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED
1 Ahmedabad Zone
(Central Excise) Ahmedabad-I 213 10 1 222 145 8 5 148 2941.62 129.42 8 3063.04 6163.67 1346.57 1211.98
Ahmedabad-II 128 16 10 134 239 37 16 260 4986.65 629.08 145.61 5470.12 27086.41 1675.71 342.89
Ahmedabad-III 78 14 7 85 135 15 31 119 4131.98 3375.16 43.09 7464.05 24127.28 325.68 1807.75
Rajkot 168 4 8 164 0 0 0 0 15245.73 31.3 10385.47 4891.56 0 0 0
Bhavnagar 59 0 0 59 128 8 3 133 1166.14 0 0 1166.14 3247.17 624.56 9.39
Service Tax 33 4 2 35 139 36 12 163 1155.49 9.7 45.01 1120.18 5326.08 535.46 43.14
Total 679 48 28 699 786 104 67 823 29627.61 4174.66 10627.18 23175.09 65950.61 4507.98 3415.15

2 Bangalore Zone
(Central Excise) Bangalore-I 111 4 1 114 188 27 8 207 6385.68 3.46 0.26 6388.88 25522.77 2526.03 2025.09
Bangalore-II 63 2 0 65 190 18 5 203 1338.34 1.91 0 1340.25 7723.37 1227.2 80.26
Bangalore-III 24 2 0 26 59 4 1 62 137.4 20.86 0 158.26 2069.67 395.54 52
Service Tax 62 31 7 86 179 37 13 203 4286.92 10069.18 802.6 13553.5 62504.45 6765.32 1690.75
Total 260 39 8 291 616 86 27 675 12148.34 10095.41 802.86 21440.89 97820.26 10914.09 3848.1

3
Chief Commissioner, Large Tax Payers
Bangalore Unit 54 4 1 57 102 5 8 99 1908.6 24.7 3.64 1929.66 30333.52 1220.33 779.58
Total 54 4 1 57 102 5 8 99 1908.6 24.7 3.64 1929.66 30333.52 1220.33 779.58

4 Bhopal Zone
(Central Excise) Indore 374 374 377 377 4830.72 4830.72 29311.63
Bhopal 203 203 328 328 7092.36 7092.36 26985.42
Raipur 372 372 394 394 11746.46 11746.46 95736.8
Total 949 0 0 949 1099 0 0 1099 23669.54 0 0 23669.54 152033.85 0 0

5
Bhubneshwar Zone Bhubneswar-I 42 5 0 47 115 15 7 123 864.83 161.6 0 1026.43 8545.06 7319.45 3.83
Bhubneswar-II 48 5 3 50 129 12 7 134 4300.07 170.2 34.84 4435.43 27099.07 594.55 2324.86
Total 90 10 3 97 244 27 14 257 5164.9 331.8 34.84 5461.86 35644.13 7914 2328.69

6 Chandigarh Zone.
(Central Excise) Chandigarh 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ludhinana 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Jalandhar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
J&K 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 2218 0 0 2218 935 0 0 935 30326.62 0 0 30326.62 61422.11 0 0

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
28/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED

7 Chennai Zone
(Central Excise) Chennai-I 93 9 3 99 106 1 3 104 7755 0 5055.34 2699.66 9540.45 957.2 14.68
Chennai-II 113 5 7 111 123 8 10 121 2998.35 560.61 20.1 3538.86 4052.64 911.75 23.42
Chennai-III 97 4 10 91 149 10 9 150 3627.38 57.91 12.59 3672.7 5555.51 17370.2 191.04
Chennai-IV 79 3 3 79 133 6 2 137 1702.83 37.73 25.69 1714.87 2128.36 496.79 4.19
Pondicherry. 118 18 8 128 113 10 12 111 3202.37 1546.28 7.72 4740.93 7888.75 1673.85 115.36
Service Tax 37 41 0 78 210 37 15 232 2207.71 655.77 0 2863.48 31332.52 3837.79 689.22
Total 537 80 31 586 834 72 51 855 21493.64 2858.3 5121.44 19230.5 60498.23 25247.58 1037.91

8 Cochin Zone
(Central Excise) Thiruvananthapuram 29 29 51 51 40318 40318 9682.23
Calicut 57 57 150 150 2190.83 2190.83 4772.07
Cochin 43 43 122 122 60376.98 60376.98 8060.64
Cochin Cus. 63 63 330 330 452 452 6777.5
Cochin (Prev.) 6 6 7 7 10.48 10.48 28.32
Total 198 0 0 198 660 0 0 660 103348.29 0 0 103348 29320.76 0 0

9 Coimbatore Zone
(Central Excise) Coimbatore 165 0 0 165 407 34 22 419 4749.66 0 0 4749.66 20796.38 612.56 172.74
Salem 41 7 8 40 309 12 15 306 665.36 54.76 14.32 705.8 7649.82 1269.5 174.51
Thiruchirappali 75 4 1 78 224 7 15 216 269.39 51.71 1.48 319.62 18120.58 68.24 166.91
Madurai 124 3 15 112 226 11 15 222 1156.27 23.71 65.36 1114.62 3876.44 836.87 169.99
Thirunelveli 147 12 17 142 136 4 3 137 4395.36 245.73 39.84 4601.25 26362.85 103.87 1.51
Total 552 26 41 537 1302 68 70 1300 11236.04 375.91 121 11490.95 76806.07 2891.04 685.66

10 Delhi Zone (Central

Excise) Delhi-I 46 46 120 120 981.87 981.87 51358.56
Delhi-II 20 20 154 154 1456.77 1456.77 19835.91
Gurgaon 87 87 185 185 12601.15 12601.15 18940.43
Faridabad 51 51 149 149 817.28 817.28 16641.29
Rohtak 36 36 145 145 260.29 260.29 3105.91
Panchkula 36 36 130 130 695.88 695.88 5967.97
Service Tax 30 30 103 103 8208.44 8208.44 70979.89
Total 306 0 0 306 986 0 0 986 25021.68 0 0 25021.68 186829.96 0 0

11 Hyderabad Zone
(Central Excise) Hyderabad-I 145 145 118 118 8410.82 8410.82 5285.02
Hyderabad-II 197 197 237 237 3540.74 3540.74 28856.98

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
29/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED
Hyderabad-III 125 125 135 135 12921.82 12921.82 5353.7
Hyderabad-IV 81 81 148 148 13744.82 13744.82 12222.58
Total 548 0 0 548 638 0 0 638 38618.2 0 0 38618.2 51718.28 0 0

12 Jaipur Zone. (Central

Excise) Jaipur-I 196 24 2 218 519 49 21 547 1427.4 90.82 4.35 1513.87 28336.92 888.31 105.03
Jaipur-II 210 0 0 210 251 51 16 286 2215.87 0 0 2215.87 6154.88 480.31 120.17
Total 406 24 2 428 770 100 37 833 3643.27 90.82 4.35 3729.74 34491.8 1368.62 225.2

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
30/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED

13 Kolkata Zone
(Central Excise) Kolkata-I 15 15 32 32 984.89 984.89 2237.11
Kolkata-II 17 17 99 99 495.61 495.61 6463.49
Kolkata-III 34 34 61 61 1104.52 1104.52 2044.32
Kolkata-IV 44 44 40 40 2786.11 2786.11 3946.31
Kolkata-V 34 34 45 45 2529.87 2529.87 5969.96
Kolkata-VI 8 8 21 21 8125.79 8125.79 3388.54
Kolkata-VII 11 11 36 36 786.03 786.03 10694.21
Haldia 33 33 32 32 15310 15310 5595
Bolpur 36 36 137 137 6694.24 6694.24 56421.6
Sillguri 54 54 48 48 2348.7 2348.7 14390.49
Service Tax 57 57 50 50 10933.29 10933.29 30216.56
Total 343 0 0 343 601 0 0 601 52099.05 0 0 52099.05 141367.59 0 0

14 Lucknow Zone
(Central Excise) Allahabad 167 167 192 192 3780.38 3780.38 17937.06
Kanpur 328 328 333 333 4149.9 4149.9 12643.17
Lucknow 220 220 345 345 6790.75 6790.75 39012.41
Total 715 0 0 715 870 0 0 870 14721.03 0 0 14721.03 69592.64 0 0

15 Mysore Zone
(Central Excise) Belgaum 154 9 0 163 152 8 14 146 13903.79 512.08 0 14415.87 18717.57 70.17 6401.32
Mangalore 110 8 4 114 123 9 5 127 13177.87 72.64 79.99 13170.52 23056.83 437.11 903.08
Mysore 102 19 2 119 109 13 10 112 1622.22 119.42 127.88 1613.76 5814.73 1770.69 976.59
Total 366 36 6 396 384 30 29 385 28703.88 704.14 207.87 29200.15 47589.13 2277.97 8280.99

16 Meerut Zone (Central

Excise) Meerut-I 204 204 285 285 8157.33 8157.33 46609.85
Meerut-II 76 76 193 193 2300.58 2300.58 12864.67
Ghaziabad 112 112 116 116 1281 1281 16613
Noida 38 38 218 218 1037.25 1037.25 66524.12
Total 430 0 0 430 812 0 0 812 12776.16 0 0 12776.16 142611.64 0 0

17 Mumbai-I Zone
(Central Excise) Mumbai-I 71 0 0 71 136 1 5 132 8141.56 0 0 8141.56 2551.9 15.05 71.15

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
31/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED

Mumbai-IV 96 0 0 96 68 0 0 68 18719.7 0 0 18719.7 1898.95 0 0

Mumbai-V 74 4 5 73 135 18 5 148 4369.64 24.83 167.11 4227.36 29102.69 3999.21 9852.7
Thane-I 97 4 2 99 194 23 2 215 4724.61 208.58 0.15 4933.04 31159.46 10659.06 228.89
Thane-II 98 3 6 95 188 35 7 216 4013.09 47.11 512.11 3548.09 9757.03 1658.76 1347.61
Service Tax 52 8 26 34 96 30 49 77 25762.49 937.54 18148.47 8551.56 20411.87 3.31 13034.33
Total 488 19 39 468 817 107 68 856 65731.09 1218.06 18827.84 48121.31 94881.9 16335.39 24534.68

18 Mumbai-II Zone
(Central Excise) Mumbai-II 53 53 197 197 47086.77 47086.77 25570.33
Mumbai-III 151 151 259 259 5516.85 5516.85 14585.49
Belapur 137 137 306 306 6324.46 6324.46 15177.55
Raigarh 122 122 352 352 28533 28533 29212
Total 463 0 0 463 1114 0 0 1114 87461.08 0 0 87461.08 84545.37 0 0

19 Nagpur Zone
(Central Excise) Aurangabad 404 404 318 318 14582.58 14582.58 23175.18
Nagpur 545 545 204 204 264.6 264.6 3
Nasik 220 220 506 506 8919.53 8919.53 14036.69
Total 1169 0 0 1169 1028 0 0 1028 23766.71 0 0 23766.71 37214.87 0 0

20 Pune Zone (Central

Excise) Pune-I 111 111 621 621 5608.94 5608.94 45998.03
Pune-II 438 438 164 164 8232 8232 9522
Pune-III 117 117 329 329 6597.93 6597.93 32981.44
Goa C.Ex. 69 69 193 193 3431.41 3431.41 7928.81
Goa Customs 29 29 84 84 467 467 4870
Pune Customs 24 24 40 40 181.31 181.31 1034.88
Total 788 0 0 788 1431 0 0 1431 24518.59 0 0 24518.59 102335.16 0 0

21 Ranchi Zone Patna+Patna Service

(Central Excise) Tax 34 34 139 139 434.59 434.59 56851.48
Ranchi 30 30 69 69 1661.52 1661.52 11725.7
Jamshedpur 47 47 134 134 5485.02 5485.02 73028.52
Total 111 0 0 111 342 0 0 342 7581.13 0 0 7581.13 141605.7 0 0

22 Shillong Zone
(Central Excise) Shillong-CE 14 14 34 34 3472.43 3472.43 30816.82
Dibrugarh 26 26 34 34 2473.87 2473.87 2383.23
Guwahati CX 27 52 52 4123.31 4123.31 18078.04

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
32/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED
Shillong-CC(Prev) 12 12 7 7 33.62 33.62 423.47
Total 79 0 0 52 127 0 0 127 10103.23 0 0 10103.23 51701.56 0 0

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
33/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED
23 Vadodara Zone
(Central Excise) Vadodara-I 39 39 82 82 21236.89 21236.89 14674.24
Vadodara-II 45 45 27 27 8662.54 8662.54 42949.18
Surat-I 96 96 217 217 1214.91 1214.91 17754.83
Surat-II 41 41 118 118 764.87 764.87 22645.56
Daman 126 126 158 158 16653.02 16653.02 11464.61
Vapi 126 126 98 98 3935.64 3935.64 8653.82
Total 473 0 0 473 700 0 0 700 52467.87 52467.87 118142.24 0 0

24
Visakapatnam Zone
(Central Excise) Visakapatnam-I 183 183 218 218 13279.21 13279.21 23832.93
Visakapatnam-II 127 127 169 169 2948 2948 16947
Visakapatnam-Cus. 43 43 71 71 2222.22 2222.22 1355.16
Guntur 106 106 61 61 3670.98 3670.98 8102.77
Tirupati 54 54 135 135 839 839 18975
Total 513 0 0 513 654 0 0 654 22959.41 0 0 22959.41 69212.86 0 0

25 Ahmedabad Zone
(Customs.) Ahemadabad 9 1 0 10 180 3 4 179 119 346 0 465 840 10 30

Jamnagar(Preventive) 82 12 1 93 131 12 0 143 973.19 716.32 0 1689.51 4334.41 322.23 0

Kandla(Preventive) 27 1 0 28 323 13 4 332 1082.2 389 0 1471.2 16679.44 195 5
Total 118 14 1 131 634 28 8 654 2174.39 1451.32 0 3625.71 21853.85 527.23 35

26 Bangalore Zone
(Customs.) Bangalore 82 14 1 95 480 15 11 484 461 264 0 725 60109 2718 767
Mangalore 14 2 0 16 177 8 136 49 1252.73 55 0 1307.73 8043.55 502.74 3663.8
Total 96 16 1 111 657 23 147 533 1713.73 319 0 2032.73 68152.55 3220.74 4430.8

27 Chennai Zone Chennai (Airport &

(Customs.) Aircargo) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Chennai Port (Import) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Chennai Port (Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Total 404 0 0 404 1223 0 0 1223 13378.95 0 0 13378.95 36500.56 0 0

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
34/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED
28
Chennai Zone
(Customs-Prev) Thiruhirapalli(Prev) 15 0 3 12 18 1 3 16 204.54 0 1.67 202.87 145.02 0 46.32
Tuticorin(Prev) 49 1 0 50 166 5 19 152 842 16 0 858 7540.48 75 56
Total 64 1 3 62 184 6 22 168 1046.54 16 1.67 1060.87 7685.5 75 102.32

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
35/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED
29 Delhi Zone
(Customs) Delhi Aircargo Import 59 59 71 71 6312 6312 1168

Delhi Aircargo Export 41 41 65 65 696 696 6455

Delhi (ICD) 111 111 289 289 982 982 8389
Total 211 0 0 211 425 0 0 425 7990 0 0 7990 16012 0 0

30 Delhi Zone (Customs

Prev.) Delhi (Prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Amristar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Jodhpur (prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 70 0 0 70 120 0 0 120 35 0 0 35 10137.46 0 0

31 Kolkata Zone
(Customs) Kolkata(Port) 88 9 19 78 271 16 39 248 1493 21 900 614 91045 42 2062
Kolkata(Airport) 23 2 0 25 77 5 6 76 459.8 62.79 0 522.59 1331 77.3 506.27
West Bengal (Prev) 77 7 32 52 201 13 11 203 1163.1 0 34.1 1129 2589.09 23.91 142
Total 188 18 51 155 549 34 56 527 3115.9 83.79 934.1 2265.59 94965.09 143.21 2710.27

32 Mumbai-I Zone Mumbai(Mulund CFS

(Customs) & Gen) 118 118 145 145 752.12 752.12 1084.18
Mumbai(Export) 128 128 120 120 10313 10313 29080
Mumbai(Import) 186 186 413 413 6316.07 6316.07 30331.15
Total 432 0 0 432 678 0 0 678 17381.19 0 0 17381.19 60495.33 0 0

33 Mumbai-II Zone Aircargo(Import &

(Customs) Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
JNCH(Import &
Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 123 0 0 123 496 0 0 496 1473.3 0 0 1473.3 18721.7 0 0

34 Mumbai-III Zone
(Customs Prev) CC Mumbai(P) 17 17 76 76 104.53 104.53 4697.91
Mumbai(Airport) 19 19 138 138 353.1 353.1 4361.14
CCPune(P) 26 26 181 181 826 826 10578
Total 62 0 0 62 395 0 0 395 1283.63 0 0 1283.63 19637.05 0 0

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
36/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl. Chief RECEIVE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE
No. Commissionerates Commissionerates OB D DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB RECEIVED DECIDED
35 Patna Zone
(Customs) CC Patna(Prev) 35 35 38 38 300 300 430
CC Lucknow(Prev) 25 25 43 43 19.9 19.9 292.94
Total 60 0 0 60 81 0 0 81 319.9 0 0 319.9 722.94 0 0

GRAND TOTAL 14563 335 215 14656 23294 690 604 23380 759008.49 21743.91 36686.79 744066 2338554.27 76643.18 52414.35

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
37/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

6298.26
28419.23
22645.21
0
3862.34
5818.4
67043.44

26023.71
8870.31
2413.21
67579.02
104886.25

30774.27
30774.27

29311.63
26985.42
95736.8
152033.85

15860.68
25368.76
41229.44

0
0
0
0
61422.11

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
38/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

10482.97
4940.97
22734.67
2620.96
9447.24
34481.09
84707.9

9682.23
4772.07
8060.64
6777.5
28.32
29320.76

21236.2
8744.81
18021.91
4543.32
26465.21
79011.45

51358.56
19835.91
18940.43
16641.29
3105.91
5967.97
70979.89
186829.96

5285.02
28856.98

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
39/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS
5353.7
12222.58
51718.28

29120.2
6515.02
35635.22

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
40/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

2237.11
6463.49
2044.32
3946.31
5969.96
3388.54
10694.21
5595
56421.6
14390.49
30216.56
141367.59

17937.06
12643.17
39012.41
69592.64

12386.42
22590.86
6608.83
41586.11

46609.85
12864.67
16613
66524.12
142611.64

2495.8

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
41/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

1898.95
23249.2
41589.63
10068.18
7380.85
86682.61

25570.33
14585.49
15177.55
29212
84545.37

23175.18
3
14036.69
37214.87

45998.03
9522
32981.44
7928.81
4870
1034.88
102335.16

56851.48
11725.7
73028.52
141605.7

30816.82
2383.23
18078.04

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
42/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS
423.47
51701.56

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
43/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

14674.24
42949.18
17754.83
22645.56
11464.61
8653.82
118142.24

23832.93
16947
1355.16
8102.77
18975
69212.86

820

4656.64
16869.44
22346.08

62060
4882.49
66942.49

0
Commission
erate-wise
break-up not
0 given

0
36500.56

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
44/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

98.7
7559.48
7658.18

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
45/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES
Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )
PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

1168

6455
8389
16012

0
0
Commission
erate-wise
break-up not
0 given
10137.46

89025
902.03
2471
92398.03

1084.18
29080
30331.15
60495.33

0
18721.7

4697.91
4361.14
10578
19637.05

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
46/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
CESTAT CASES

Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

PARTY'S APPEALS

CB REMARKS

430
292.94
722.94

2362783.1

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECEIVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL
47/60
EXCISE.
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB
1 Ahmedabad Zone
(Central Excise) Ahmedabad-I 92 3 0 95 153 30 70 113 674.13 823.27 0 1497.4 1242.58 144.84 459.57 927.85
Ahmedabad-II 46 25 7 64 79 43 86 36 715.99 38.57 41.81 712.75 1502.26 670.07 768.39 1403.94
Ahmedabad-III 20 16 3 33 0 0 0 0 56.37 50.31 1.33 105.35 0 0 0 0
Rajkot 6 15 18 3 143 133 150 126 346 1014 759 601 7818.53 4528 9427.53 2919
Bhavnagar 2 0 2 0 25 49 35 39 275.05 0 275.05 0 469.94 592.92 710.4 352.46
Service Tax 10 6 13 3 78 90 115 53 95 74 120 49 1291 1363 1913 741
Total 176 65 43 198 478 345 456 367 2162.54 2000.15 1197.19 2965.5 12324.3 7298.83 13278.89 6344.25

2 Bangalore Zone
(Central Excise) Bangalore-I 49 6 3 52 97 51 26 122 269.98 12.05 2.3 279.73 1188.99 416.46 873.16 732.29
Bangalore-II 146 15 96 65 22 13 6 29 1231.37 275.25 635.92 870.7 434.17 156.07 43.88 546.36
Bangalore-III 49 13 19 43 114 62 31 145 672.64 113.07 63.92 721.79 1208.32 767.47 122.43 1853.36
Service Tax 12 17 0 29 510 171 117 564 581.17 558.49 0 1139.66 28688 7278.08 5464.21 30501.84
Total 256 51 118 189 743 297 180 860 2755.16 958.86 702.14 3011.88 31519.5 8618.08 6503.68 33633.85

3
Chief Commissioner Large Tax Payers
Bangalore Unit 2 1 0 3 35 6 9 32 10.41 0 0 10.41 619.85 62.24 172.34 509.75
Total 2 1 0 3 35 6 9 32 10.41 0 0 10.41 619.85 62.24 172.34 509.75

4 Bhopal Zone
(Central Excise) Indore 25 25 61 61 187 187 1232.01 1232.01
Bhopal 6 6 33 33 644.55 644.55 952.22 952.22
Raipur 43 43 173 173 76.38 76.38 3432.38 3432.38
Total 74 0 0 74 267 0 0 267 907.93 0 0 907.93 5616.61 0 0 5616.61

5
Bhubneshwar Zone Bhubneswar-I 0 0 0 0 13 52 36 29 0 0 0 0 82.77 464.45 317.21 230.01
Bhubneswar-II 0 6 6 0 12 27 28 11 0 0.63 0 0.63 96.18 572.55 581.97 86.76
Total 0 6 6 0 25 79 64 40 0 0.63 0 0.63 178.95 1037 899.18 316.77

6 Chandigarh Zone.
(Central Excise)
Chandigarh 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Ludhinana 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Jalandhar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
J&K 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 276 0 0 276 1276 0 0 1276 1105.01 0 0 1105.01 14790.6 0 0 14790.61

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 48/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB
7 Chennai Zone
(Central Excise) Chennai-I 10 8 0 18 81 22 15 88 56.44 65.69 0 122.13 723.56 80.4 12.72 791.24
Chennai-II 7 0 1 6 196 22 27 191 41.24 0 33.45 7.79 1782.69 284.1 280.45 1786.34
Chennai-III 40 2 1 41 251 22 46 227 916.11 79.11 26.41 968.81 3846.43 0 826.19 3020.24
Chennai-IV 35 4 0 39 96 31 23 104 448.2 20.7 0 468.9 5201.38 735.19 145.67 5790.9
Pondicherry. 19 0 5 14 0 73 73 0 357.48 0 53.14 304.34 0 758.71 758.71 0
Service Tax 0 14 0 14 253 114 56 311 0 24.9 0 24.9 3421.38 2998.76 618.69 5801.45
Total 111 28 7 132 877 284 240 921 1819.47 190.4 113 1896.87 14975.4 4857.16 2642.43 17190.17

8 Cochin Zone
(Central Excise) Thiruvananthapuram 9 9 147 147 111.19 111.19 1487.34 1487.34
Calicut 8 8 496 496 86.24 86.24 5222.65 5222.65
Cochin 25 25 1196 1196 457.64 457.64 14146.8 14146.78
Cochin Cus. 4 4 372 372 401 401 9589 9589
Cochin Prev. 0 0 12 12 0 0 23.31 23.31
Total 46 0 0 46 2223 0 0 2223 1056.07 0 0 1056.07 30469.1 0 0 30469.08

9 Coimbatore Zone
(Central Excise) Coimbatore 5 3 3 5 127 78 99 106 139.61 0.87 25.85 114.63 676.92 797.8 378.5 1096.22
Salem 9 0 0 9 409 23 21 411 62.12 0 0 62.12 2983.02 692.52 225.92 3449.62
Thiruchirappali 16 0 2 14 60 23 15 68 880.45 0 13.63 866.82 778.34 526.76 90.55 1214.55
Madurai 29 34 0 63 105 406 125 386 86.41 105.58 0 191.99 4937.35 687.72 2395.47 3229.6
Thirunelveli 3 0 3 0 8 36 25 19 14.93 0 14.93 0 275.89 86.47 228.78 133.58
Total 62 37 8 91 709 566 285 990 1183.52 106.45 54.41 1235.56 9651.52 2791.27 3319.22 9123.57

10 Delhi Zone (Central

Excise) Delhi-I 2 2 163 163 1.47 1.47 3454.48 3454.48
Delhi-II 14 14 336 336 140.73 140.73 10770.1 10770.14
Gurgaon 17 17 383 383 390.06 390.06 3367.52 3367.52
Faridabad 0 0 64 64 0 0 690.95 690.95
Rohtak 9 9 48 48 181.66 181.66 897.61 897.61
Panchkula 6 6 30 30 14.17 14.17 241.2 241.2
Service Tax 3 3 40 40 101.73 0 0 101.73 345.78 345.78
Total 51 0 0 51 1064 0 0 1064 829.82 0 0 829.82 19767.7 0 0 19767.68

11 Hyderabad Zone
(Central Excise) Hyderabad-I 10 10 13 13 36.78 36.78 246.67 246.67
Hyderabad-II 7 7 33 33 40.61 40.61 925.15 925.15

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 49/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB
Hyderabad-III 5 5 17 17 62.19 62.19 342.99 342.99
Hyderabad-IV 0 0 3 3 0 0 47.11 47.11
Total 22 0 0 22 66 0 0 66 139.58 0 0 139.58 1561.92 0 0 1561.92

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 50/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB
12 Jaipur Zone.
(Central Excise) Jaipur-I 54 28 12 70 577 374 405 546 836.15 715.03 272.45 1278.73 9671.8 1211.01 1862.1 9020.71
Jaipur-II 70 1 1 70 311 212 194 329 989.36 30.9 0.24 1020.02 2004.48 154.91 215.37 1944.02
Total 124 29 13 140 888 586 599 875 1825.51 745.93 272.69 2298.75 11676.3 1365.92 2077.47 10964.73

13 Kolkata Zone
(Central Excise) Kolkata-I 0 0 38 38 0 0 1132.79 1132.79
Kolkata-II 15 15 170 170 70.36 70.36 1713.02 1713.02
Kolkata-III 18 18 295 295 74.49 74.49 3206.52 3206.52
Kolkata-IV 18 18 168 168 127.28 127.28 2824.97 2824.97
Kolkata-V 12 12 85 85 96.06 96.06 910.92 910.92
Kolkata-VI 3 3 41 41 7.19 7.19 1825.12 1825.12
Kolkata-VII 30 30 90 90 619.22 619.22 736.81 736.81
Haldia 15 15 54 54 169.42 169.42 8706.86 8706.86
Bolpur 0 0 289 289 74.84 74.84 5560.65 5560.65
Sillguri 7 7 55 55 6.86 6.86 437.29 437.29
Service Tax 0 0 244 244 0 0 2715.48 2715.48
Total 118 0 0 118 1529 0 0 1529 1245.72 0 0 1245.72 29770.4 0 0 29770.43

14 Lucknow Zone
(Central Excise) Allahabad 12 12 205 205 8.49 8.49 2276.8 2276.8
Kanpur 11 11 162 162 109.99 109.99 1176.78 1176.78
Lucknow 8 8 89 89 107.68 107.68 757.82 757.82
Total 31 0 0 31 456 0 0 456 226.16 0 0 226.16 4211.4 0 0 4211.4

15 Mysore Zone
(Central Excise) Belgaum 13 1 0 14 172 30 52 150 211.6 2.61 0 214.21 1161.02 124.41 251.22 1034.21
Mangalore 2 4 0 6 125 36 47 114 6.29 28.56 0 34.85 1302.04 405.04 796.82 910.26
Mysore 12 18 9 21 112 36 60 88 372.31 353.03 12.35 712.99 1406.63 1254.38 571.46 2089.55
Total 27 23 9 41 409 102 159 352 590.2 384.2 12.35 962.05 3869.69 1783.83 1619.5 4034.02

16 Meerut Zone
(Central Excise) Meerut-I 42 42 88 88 372.44 372.44 1085.91 1085.91
Meerut-II 13 13 91 91 76.08 76.08 2023.93 2023.93
Ghaziabad 32 32 40 40 742 742 680 680
Noida 10 10 63 63 465.56 465.56 1358.62 1358.62
Total 97 0 0 97 282 0 0 282 1656.08 0 0 1656.08 5148.46 0 0 5148.46

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 51/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB
17 Mumbai-I Zone
(Central Excise) Mumbai-I 5 4 3 6 18 5 17 6 96.06 54.92 57.54 93.44 725.85 56.98 327.93 454.9

Mumbai-IV 41 1 1 41 26 15 11 30 1701.91 2.56 2.56 1701.91 390.4 1429.01 1326.95 492.46

Mumbai-V 28 0 0 28 93 10 12 91 146.46 0 0 146.46 1071.55 139.55 141.02 1070.08
Thane-I 84 15 5 94 489 16 90 415 286.39 251.32 37.93 499.78 4756.4 166.95 277.71 4645.64
Thane-II 40 1 5 36 521 13 68 466 130.94 0 6.99 123.95 4948.33 138.57 553.12 4533.78
Service Tax 2 2 0 4 344 135 40 439 16.58 28.45 0 45.03 7145.66 6187.05 959.43 12373.28
Total 200 23 14 209 1491 194 238 1447 2378.34 337.25 105.02 2610.57 19038.2 8118.11 3586.16 23570.14

18 Mumbai-II Zone
(Central Excise) Mumbai-II 13 13 162 162 883.22 883.22 5784.49 5784.49
Mumbai-III 29 29 111 111 215.89 215.89 3143.9 3143.9
Belapur 98 98 89 89 3770.38 3770.38 1315.82 1315.82
Raigarh 52 52 94 94 7361.55 7361.55 7871.28 7871.28
Total 192 0 0 192 456 0 0 456 12231 0 0 12231.04 18115.5 0 0 18115.49

19 Nagpur Zone
(Central Excise) Aurangabad 3 3 17 17 54 54 363 363
Nagpur 30 30 17 17 10.07 10.07 112.89 112.89
Nasik 1 1 93 93 13.14 13.14 1232.58 1232.58
Total 34 0 0 34 127 0 0 127 77.21 0 0 77.21 1708.47 0 0 1708.47

20 Pune Zone (Central

Excise) Pune-I 3 3 16 16 27.55 27.55 216.68 216.68
Pune-II 1 1 45 45 0.51 0.51 382.23 382.23
Pune-III 4 4 65 65 22.69 22.69 1109.32 1109.32
Goa C.Ex. 1 1 17 17 45.26 45.26 1469.19 1469.19
Goa Customs 1 1 21 21 3164.82 3164.82 131.11 131.11
Pune Customs 0 0 5 5 0 0 24.67 24.67
Total 10 0 0 10 169 0 0 169 3260.83 0 0 3260.83 3333.2 0 0 3333.2

21 Ranchi Zone
(Central Excise) Ranchi 0 0 70 70 0 0 748.72 748.72
Patna 29 29 121 121 356.93 356.93 1455.71 1455.71
Jamshedpur 15 15 34 34 1153.01 1153.01 272.99 272.99
Total 44 0 0 44 225 0 0 225 1509.94 0 0 1509.94 2477.42 0 0 2477.42

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 52/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB
22 Shillong Zone
(Central Excise) Shillong-CE 7 7 18 18 99.76 99.76 513.16 513.16
Dibrugarh 20 20 51 51 3141.45 3141.45 766.15 766.15
Guwahati CX 7 7 43 43 99.03 99.03 528.24 528.24
Shillong-CC(Prev) 1 1 14 14 0 0 41.59 41.59
Total 35 0 0 35 126 0 0 126 3340.24 0 0 3340.24 1849.14 0 0 1849.14

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 53/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB
23 Vadodara Zone
(Central Excise) Vadodara-I 21 21 232 232 498 498 1276 1276
Vadodara-II 20 20 142 142 172 172 1344 1344
Surat-I 2 2 145 145 3.39 3.39 3132.26 3132.26
Surat-II 45 45 143 143 1329.95 1329.95 1885.52 1885.52
Daman 10 10 119 119 37.61 37.61 3640.62 3640.62
Vapi 19 19 13 13 370.18 370.18 3227.54 3227.54
Total 117 0 0 117 794 0 0 794 2411.13 0 0 2411.13 14505.9 0 0 14505.94

24
Visakapatnam Zone
(Central Excise) Visakapatnam-I 2 2 77 77 12.66 12.66 907.08 907.08
Visakapatnam-II 27 27 37 37 73.94 73.94 804.23 804.23
Visakapatnam-Cus. 0 0 19 19 0 0 66.6 66.6
Guntur 4 4 25 25 22.17 22.17 642.66 642.66
Tirupati 4 4 71 71 0 0 525.54 525.54
Total 37 0 0 37 229 0 0 229 108.77 0 0 108.77 2946.11 0 0 2946.11

25 Ahmedabad Zone
(Customs.) Ahemadabad 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Jamnagar(Preventive
) 29 7 0 36 134 30 79 85 403.55 34.73 82.97 355.31 1638.68 83.95 874.87 847.76
Kandla(Preventive) 24 297 2 319 169 17 39 147 46.57 996 37 1005.57 5805.13 11 143 5673.13
Total 53 304 2 355 303 47 118 232 450.12 1030.73 119.97 1360.88 7443.81 94.95 1017.87 6520.89

26 Bangalore Zone
(Customs.) Bangalore 98 57 6 149 163 84 144 103 590.14 616 216 990.14 2049.35 1453 1166 2336.35
Mangalore 8 0 8 0 11 1 6 6 496 0 496 0 744.5 15 168 591.5
Total 106 57 14 149 174 85 150 109 1086.14 616 712 990.14 2793.85 1468 1334 2927.85

27 Chennai Zone Chennai (Airport &

(Customs.) Aircargo) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Chennai Port (Import) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Chennai Port
(Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 35 0 0 35 845 0 0 845 21116.6 0 0 21116.6 39456 0 0 39456

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 54/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB

28
Chennai Zone
(Customs-Prev) Thiruhirapalli(Prev) 0 0 0 0 0 8 5 3 0 0 0 0 0 11.15 11 0.15
Tuticorin(Prev) 4 1 1 4 27 17 13 31 2329 9 1177 1161 169 452 78 543
Total 4 1 1 4 27 25 18 34 2329 9 1177 1161 169 463.15 89 543.15

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 55/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB

29 Delhi Zone
(Customs) Delhi Aircargo Import 1 1 27 27 5 5 122 122

Delhi Aircargo Export 2 2 39 39 16 16 1224 1224

Delhi (ICD) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 3 0 0 3 66 0 0 66 21 0 0 21 1346 0 0 1346

30 Delhi Zone
(Customs Prev.) Delhi (Prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Amristar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Jodhpur (prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 1 0 0 1 51 0 0 51 0 0 0 0 401.07 0 0 401.07

31 Kolkata Zone Kolkata(Port)

(Customs) +Kolkata (Airport) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
West Bengal (Prev) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 1 0 1 0 50 119 156 13 24.67 0 24.67 0 95.12 398.51 418.62 75.01

32 Mumbai-I Zone Mumbai(Mulund CFS

(Customs) & Gen) 2 2 35 35 41.32 41.32 733.04 733.04
Mumbai(Export) 3 3 41 41 203 203 959 959
Mumbai(Import) 50 50 107 107 182.79 182.79 9333.12 9333.12
Total 55 0 0 55 183 0 0 183 427.11 0 0 427.11 11025.2 0 0 11025.16

33 Mumbai-II Zone Aircargo(Import &

(Customs) Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
JNCH(Import &
Export) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 2 0 0 2 208 0 0 208 0 0 0 0 1842.9 0 0 1842.9

34 Mumbai-III Zone
(Customs Prev) CC Mumbai(P) 4 4 10 10 0 0 3.82 3.82
Mumbai(Airport) 10 10 60 60 2.55 2.55 26.35 26.35
CCPune(P) 8 8 70 70 0 0 5.85 5.85
Total 22 0 0 22 140 0 0 140 2.55 0 0 2.55 36.02 36.02

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 56/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

No. of Appeals Amount involved ( Rs. In lakhs )

DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS DEPARTMENTAL APPEALS PARTY'S APPEALS
Sl.
No. Chief RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE DECIDE RECEIVE
Commissionerates Commissionerates OB RECEIVED DECIDED CB OB D D CB OB D D CB OB D DECIDED CB

35 Patna Zone
(Customs) CC Patna(Prev) 1 1 94 94 5 5 91.86 91.86
CC Lucknow(Prev) 81 81 40 40 10.6 10.6 20.9 20.9
Total 82 0 0 82 134 0 0 134 15.6 0 0 15.6 112.76 0 0 112.76

GRAND TOTAL 2506 625 236 2895 17125 2735 2672 17188 68303 6379.6 4490.44 70192.63 324847 38357.05 36958.36 326246

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 57/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

REMARKS

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 58/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

REMARKS

Commissionerat
e-wise break-up
not given

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 59/60
 QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORT FOR THE QUARTER ENDING 31.03.2010
(MINISTRY'S LETTER F. NO. 390/74/2003-JC DATED 03/06/2003 REFERS)
COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)

REMARKS

Commissionerat
e-wise break-up
not given

COMPILED BY THE DIRECTORATE OF LEGAL AFFAIRS ON THE BASIS OF QUARTERLY LEGAL REPORTS RECIEVED FROM ALL THE CHIEF COMMISSIONERS OF CUSTOMS AND CENTRAL EXCISE. 60/60