Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
0WFSWJFX
FZW WV[fad[S^ fWS_ [e dWeba`e[T^W Xad SUUWbf[`Y S^^ fab[Ue fZSf dWWUf dWS^iad^V WhW`fe IW
bdah[VW Ua`fWjf fa ZW^b bWab^W g`VWdefS`V fZW fdW`V S`V _WfSVSfS fa [`Xad_ fZW S^Yad[fZ_e
fZSf fSdYWf fdW`Ve
FZW fab[U VWfWUf[a` fWS_ [e dWeba`e[T^W Xad egdXSU[`Y bW`V[`Y fab[Ue S`V dS`][`Y fZW_ SXfWd
fZWkdW SUUWbfWV
FZW Ua`fW`f dS`][`Y fWS_ [e dWeba`e[T^W Xad VW^[hWd[`Y Z[YZcgS^[fk dW^WhS`f fab[U XWWVe
a`UW fZW fab[U [e SUUWbfWV
* "446.& &7&3: 501*$ */ 1&/%*/( *4 " 3&"-803-% &7&/5
6/5*- 1307&/ 05)
&38*4&
3 dWS^iad^V WhW`f [e ea_WfZ[`Y fZSf ZSbbW`WV dWUW`f^k [e ZSbbW`[`Y `ai ad i[^^ ZSbbW` [` fZW
XgfgdW ;fe [`fW`f[a`S^^k TdaSV ea fZSf iW US` TW [`U^ge[hW aX S i[VW dS`YW aX [`fWdWefe
AhWd f[_W iWhW efdWS_^[`WV agd iad]ai fa W`egdW iWdW SUUWbf[`Y S^^ aX fZW fab[Ue fZSf _WWf
agd dWS^iad^V WhW`f Ud[fWd[S IW T[Se faiSdV SUUWbf[`Y S fab[U g`^Wee [f _WWfe a`W aX fZWeW Ud[fWd[S
Xad T^SU]^[ef[`Y,
6gb^[USfW fab[U FZW fab[U dWbdWeW`fe S dWS^iad^V WhW`f fZSf [e S^dWSVk ^[hW W[fZWd [` fZW
eS_W eUabW ad S`afZWd eUabW
IZW` fZWdW SdW _g^f[b^W fab[Ue fZSf dWbdWeW`f S` WhW`f UZaaeW fZW _aef ^aY[US^ fab[U fa TW fZW bd[
_Sdk fab[U GeW S Ugefa_ fab[U `S_W [X fZW Wj[ef[`Y fab[U `S_W [e faa YW`Wd[U ad Ua`Xge[`Y
;fe A= fa SUUWbf eWUa`VSdk fab[Ue Se ^a`Y Se fZWk _WWf fZW[d ai` dWS^iad^V WhW`f Ud[fWd[S
Fa_ :S`]e 3Ufad 5S^^e Xad 7cgS^[fk [` AeUSde DWV 5SdbWf ;`fWdh[Wi
>W4da` <S_We 5ShS^[Wde 8adiSdV EUadWe &" Ba[`fe [` 9S_W $ aX @43 8[`S^e
** "446.& 5)& 501*$ '&&%4 26"-*5: 8*-- *.1307& "'5&3 5)& 501*$ *4 "$
$&15&%
;X kagdW Ua`UWd`WV STagf fZW cgS^[fk aX fZW XWWV SUUWbf fZW fab[U S`V S^Wdf kagd Uabk WV[fad
fa eWf S dW_[`VWd fa UZWU] TSU] a` fZW XWWV [` %" _[`gfWe
;X [f ZSe`f [_bdahWV SXfWd %" _[`gfWe dWbadf fZW [eegW h[S fZW TgY `gT [Ua`
3FWJFX 1SPDFTT
$! <a g[X eXi\Xj gbb_ fgTeg Ul V[XV^\aZ T__ ?\iX gbc\Vf \a g[X fVbcX gb j[\V[ lbhiX UXXa Tff\ZaXW Ul
g[X Vbcl XW\gbe _XTW\aZ g[X f[\Yg g[XfX jXeX TVVXcgXW Tg fb`X cb\ag Ul T cTfg eXi\XjXe!
:Xg T ZbbW haWXefgTaW\aZ bY j[Tgf geXaW\aZ \aV_hW\aZ Tal _\iX XiXagf g[Tg `Tl aXXW Ta \``XW\TgX
hcWTgX fcbegf TjTeWf f[bjf GI f[bjf XgV!
8iXagf g[Tg TeX _\^X_l gb aXXW Ta hcWTgX j\__ T_fb UX _\fgXW ba g[X HcWTgX JTgV[ fXVg\ba bY bhe Dh\c _bZ
Uhg g[\f fXVg\ba \f abg T_jTlf Xk[Thfg\iX UXVThfX \gf [TeW gb ceXW\Vg T__ g[X gbc\Vf g[Tg j\__ aXXW gb UX
hcWTgXW
%! 6[XV^ g[X GeXaW\aZ 7X`b gbb_ gb fXX \Y g[XeX TeX Tal aXjfjbeg[l gbc\Vf g[Tg TeXag f[bj\aZ hc
\a g[X eXi\Xj gbb_ X\g[Xe UXVThfX g[Xl jXeX ceXi\bhf_l U_TV^_\fgXW be UXVThfX bY T UhZ!
&! :b g[ebhZ[ T__ fVbcXf \a CXaW\aZ TVVXcg\aZ TaW U_TV^_\fg\aZ gbc\Vf!
Jbe^ Yeb` g[X gbc Wbja! CXaW\aZ beZTa\V gbc\Vf TeX ce\be\g\mXW Thgb`Tg\VT__l j\g[ g[X [\Z[Xfg fVbeXW
gbc\Vf Tg g[X gbc bY g[X dhXhX \a ZeXXa!
BeZTa\V gbc\Vf TeX WXgXVgXW Ul 9TVXUbb^f GeXaW\aZ T_Zbe\g[` j[Xa g[X gbc\V [Tf UXXa `Xag\baXW
ba 9TVXUbb^ f\Za\VTag_l `beX g[Ta \gf abe`T_ _XiX_ bY Uhmm!
Gbc\Vf `Te^XW 8kgXeaT_ TeX WXgXVgXW Ul VeTj_\aZ EFF YXXWf bY [XTW_\aXf Yeb` gbc aXjf f\gXf!
8kgXeaT_ gbc\Vf TeX T_jTlf _\fgXW Tg g[X Ubggb` bY g[X cXaW\aZ dhXhXf \a XTV[ fVbcX!
Gbc\Vf `Te^XW FbV\T_ TeX WXgXVgXW g[ebhZ[ eXfcbafX _\^Xf Vb``Xagf TaW f[TeXf gb 9TVXUbb^
cbfgf TUbhg be Ul g[X gbc\V! FbV\T_ gbc\Vf j\__ UX _\fgXW T`baZ beZTa\V gbc\Vf!
BcXa g[X gbc\V YXXW \a g[X eXi\Xj gbb_ TaW XiT_hTgX j[Xg[Xe g[X gbc\V \f g\XW gb T eXT_ jbe_W XiXag!
6ebff eXYXeXaVX :bbZ_X AXjf TaW bg[Xe aXjf fbheVXf j[Xa aXVXffTel! G[X cXaW\aZ gbc\V YXXW WbXf
abg [TiX gb eXXVg g[X eXT_ jbe_W XiXag UXYbeX TVVXcgTaVX!
<Y g[X gbc\V WbXf abg eXXVg T eXT_ jbe_W XiXag U_TV^_\fg \g Ul [biXe\aZ biXe g[X gbc\V aT`X TaW
V_\V^\aZ eX`biX! G[X gbc\V j\__ UX fXag gb g[X U_TV^_\fg [\fgbel TaW VTa UX eXge\XiXW \Y aXVXffTel
fXX 5_TV^_\fg\aZ <gX`f UX_bj!
Id[fW VWeUd[bf[a`
Id[fW eg__Sdk
5ZaaeW 9Wffk [_SYW S`V 8SUWTaa] `Sf[hW h[VWa ad `Sf[hW [_SYW [X ShS[^ST^W
EgT_[f fa Uabk WV[fad Xad SbbdahS^ S`V _S]W S`k `WUWeeSdk ad egYYWefWV WV[fe
3UUWbf fab[U
4UFQCZ4UFQ 1SPDFTT
# 5a`e[VWd iZWfZWd fZW fab[U iag^V TW WSe[Wd fa g`VWdefS`V i[fZ S Ugefa_ fab[U `S_W
IW i[^^ id[fW S Ugefa_ fab[U `S_W Xad SUUWbfST^W fab[Ue iZW` Va[`Y ea i[^^,
FkbW fZW `Wi `S_W [`fa fZW 5gefa_ Fab[U @S_W W^V
5gefa_ fab[U `S_We eZag^V TW gbefk^W USb[fS^[l[`Y fZW def ^WffWd aX S^^ _S\ad iadVe
FZWdW [e `a UZSdSUfWd ^[_[f Tgf fZWk eZag^V TW iadVe ad f[YZf bZdSeWe `af Xg^^ eW`
fW`UWe
EWW fZW SVVW`Vg_ Sf fZW W`V aX fZ[e VaUg_W`f Xad _adW a` Ugefa_ fab[Ue
$ Id[fW S Ugefa_ VWeUd[bf[a` TWfiWW` *"+" UZSdSUfWde fZSf SVZWdWe fa fZW Xa^^ai[`Y Yg[VW
^[`We,
Id[fW fZW VWeUd[bf[a` gb efk^W USb[fS^[l[`Y fZW def ^WffWd aX S^^ _S\ad iadVe bWd 8SUWTaa]
5a`fW`f EfS`VSdVe
6a`f USb[fS^[lW bdWbae[f[a`e fa a` Tk eZadfWd fZS` Xagd ^WffWde ^a`Y
6a`f USb[fS^[lW Sdf[U^We S S` fZW aX ad UaadV[`Sf[`Y Ua`\g`Uf[a`e S`V ad fa g`^Wee
fZWeW SdW fZW def ad ^Sef iadVe
3^iSke USb[fS^[lW S^^ Xad_e aX fa 4W WhW` [X fZWkdW XWiWd fZS` & ^WffWde ;e 3dW ISe
IWdW 3_
5Sb[fS^[lW, @a @ad @af A Agf Ea Gb ;e 4W BWd
5Sb[fS^[lW ^[ff^W bdWbae[f[a`e fZSf fgd` [`fa SVhWdTe, ?Skad 6dabe ;` ?WWf[`Y 6da`We
A`
6a`f USb[fS^[lW, S Se S`V Sf Tgf Tk Xad [X [` aX a` ad fZW fa he h[S W` W`
DagfWh ^WYS^ Ua`fWjf
3[_ fa id[fW [` fZW SUf[hW ha[UW S`V bdWeW`f fW`eW iZW`WhWd baee[T^W
Id[fW Xad S YW`WdS^ B9#% SgV[W`UW 6a`f Seeg_W XS_[^[Sd[fk i[fZ egT\WUf _SffWd
6a `af Uabk S`afZWd agf^Wfe ZWSV^[`W 8ad ^WYS^ dWSea`e S^^ aX agd VWeUd[bf[a`e `WWV fa TW
ad[Y[`S^
Fa fZW TWef aX agd ST[^[fk XSUf UZWU] fa _S]W egdW fZSf agd VWeUd[bf[a`e SdW SUUgdSfW S`V `af
ebWUg^Sf[hW 3ha[V VWXS_Sfadk S^^WYSf[a`e
Eba[^Wde, 3ha[V S^^ eba[^Wde [` VWeUd[bf[a`e Xad eUd[bfWV eWd[We S`V e[_[^Sd eZaie 3ha[V eba[^
Wde [` VWeUd[bf[a`e Xad ^[hW eZaie g`f[^ fZWkhW `[eZWV S[d[`Y [` S^^ _Sd]Wfe GE S`V ahWdeWSe
Bda IdWef^[`Y [e Ua`e[VWdWV W`fWdfS[`_W`f S`V Se egUZ Xa^^aie eba[^Wd dg^We S`V `af
ebadfe Yg[VW^[`We
8ad dWS^[fk FH Ua_bWf[f[a`e W^[_[`Sf[a`e S`V i[``Wde US` TW SVVWV fa eg__Sd[We Tgf
`af VWeUd[bf[a`e SXfWd fZW eZai ZSe `[eZWV S[d[`Y
% Id[fW S Ugefa_ eg__Sdk TWfiWW` #)" S`V $"" UZSdSUfWde fZSf Ua_b^W_W`fe fZW VWeUd[b
f[a` S`V SVZWdWe fa fZW Xa^^ai[`Y Yg[VW^[`We,
Id[fW S eg__Sdk [` eW`fW`UW efk^W fZSf U^WSd^k S`V egUU[`Uf^k Wjb^S[`e iZk S fab[U [e fdW`V
[`Y
6a`f dWbWSf [`Xad_Sf[a` [`U^gVWV [` fZW VWeUd[bf[a` Fdk fa Sha[V dWbWSf[`Y fZW fab[U `S_W
faa
8a^^ai agd efk^W Yg[VW^[`We i[fZ 8SUWTaa] fZW` 3B efk^W Se S TSU]gb Tgf Va`f geW
VWeUd[bf[a`WjUWbf[a`e Xad bg`UfgSf[a` STTdWh[Sf[a`e WfU
7j GE [` VWeUd[bf[a`e- G E [` eg__Sd[We
GeW YgdWe Xad #" ad STahW S`V iZW`WhWd bdWUWV[`Y S g`[f aX _WSegdW ad dWXWdd[`Y fa
SYWe aX bWab^W S`[_S^e WhW`fe ad fZ[`Ye EbW^^ agf iZW` fZWk efSdf S eW`fW`UW
EbW^^ agf [` [`VW`[fW S`V USegS^ geWe Wj FZS`]e S _[^^[a` :W iS^]WV S cgSdfWd aX S
_[^W
3FFD;4GF;A@, FZWeW eg__Sd[We eZag^V dWWUf iZSf [e ]`ai` fa TW XSUf iZW`WhWd bae
e[T^W FZW [`Xad_Sf[a` kag id[fW `WWVe fa TW UaddaTadSfWV Tk dWbadf[`Y Xda_ Sf ^WSef fZdWW
?WV[S #= agf^Wfe IZW`WhWd baee[T^W Sha[V [`Xad_Sf[a` fZSfe a` fZW bWd[bZWdk aX S efadk
Ef[U] fa fZW UadW Y[ef
8a^^ai fZWeW Sffd[Tgf[a` Yg[VW^[`We,
7j # Ba^[UW B^SlS FZW @KB6 `Wfiad] iSe geWV fa WV[f I[][bWV[S W`fd[We a`
7d[U 9Sd`Wd S`V afZWde 5Sb[fS^ @Wi Kad] dWbadfWV FgWeVSk
7j 5Zd[e 5g^^[hWd FZW ISeZ[`Yfa` DWVe][`e i[^^ e[Y` fZW Uad`WdTSU] fa S &kWSd
Ua`fdSUf @8> ?WV[S dWbadfe
;VW`f[Xk fZW UaddWUf S`Y^W Xad fZW FdW`V[`Y fab[U TSeWV a` XWWV dWh[Wi S`V YW`WdS^ `Wie
eWSdUZ Yg[VW^[`We
3XfWd [VW`f[Xk[`Y fZW UaddWUf S`Y^W Xad S fab[U U^[U] [`fa fZW VdabVai` _W`g g`VWd`WSfZ fZW
G`[cgW =WkiadV W^V S`V eW^WUf fZW G`[cgW =WkiadV fZSf TWef fe fZW fab[U eWW Yg[VW^[`We
TW^ai
;X `a g`[cgW ]WkiadV SVWcgSfW^k fe fZW S`Y^W ad agd Yg[VW^[`We eW^WUf afZWd S`V id[fW S
Ugefa_ G`[cgW =WkiadV
&
;_badfS`f, FZW egYYWefWV g`[cgW ]WkiadV XWSfgdW eZag^V fS]W bd[ad[fk ahWd fZW egYYWefWV
XWSfgdWV GD> W^V [ W iW eZag^V b[U] fZW TWef g`[cgW ]WkiadV TWXadW eW^WUf[`Y fZW TWef
GD> ;X fZW TWef egYYWefWVg`[cgW ]WkiadV VaWe `af fd[YYWd S geST^W egYYWefWV GD> iW
eZag^V ef[U] i[fZ fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV S`V [`bgf S GD>
IW eZag^V `af [`U^gVW bg`UfgSf[a` [` g`[cgW ]WkiadVe FZW a`^k WjUWbf[a` [e SUUW`f _Sd]e
IW eZag^V [`U^gVW SUUW`f _Sd]e iZW` Sbbdabd[SfW
FZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V Ua`fS[` fZW _aef [_badfS`f bWdea` b^SUW ad fZ[`Y SeeaU[SfWV
i[fZ fZW fab[U @WSd^k S^^ aX fZW f[_W fZ[e _WS`e fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V Ua`fS[` fZW fab[U
`S_W [feW^X
FZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V `af Ua`fS[` SUf[hW hWdTe ;X S` S^Yad[fZ_[U egYYWef[a` Ua`fS[`e
S` SUf[hW hWdT Tgf [e afZWdi[eW YaaV kag US` geW [f [X fZWdW [e`f S` abf[a` i[fZagf S` SUf[hW
hWdT
FZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V TW ebWU[U fa fZW e[fgSf[a` ;X fZW S^Yad[fZ_[US^^k egYYWefWV
g`[cgW ]WkiadV [e`f [` ^[`W i[fZ fZW fab[Ue FdW`V[`Y S`Y^W fZW` UZaaeW S`afZWd egYYWef[a`
fZSfe _adW ebWU[XU
8ad ebadfe YS_We fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V Ua`fS[` TafZ fWS_ `S_We
8ad ZSeZfSY fab[Ue Xad iZ[UZ fZW ZSeZfSY [e dWbdWeW`f[`Y S` WhW`f iW eZag^V `af geW fZW
ZSeZfSY Se fZW ]WkiadV
8ad ZSeZfSY fab[Ue Xad iZ[UZ fZW ZSeZfSY [feW^X [e fZW fab[U fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V TW fZW
WjSUf ZSeZfSY Tgf i[fZagf USb[fS^[lSf[a`
FZW iadV adVWd VaWe`f `WUWeeSd[^k _SffWd Tgf ]WWb [` _[`V fZSf fZW ]WkiadV i[^^ TW h[e[
T^W [` fkbWSZWSV S`V fZW eWSdUZ Taj ;X kagdW UZaae[`Y TWfiWW` fia fZSf TafZ XWfUZ YaaV
dWeg^fe b[U] fZW a`W fZSf ^aa]e _adW ^[]W S `SfgdS^ eWSdUZ bZdSeW
3XfWd id[f[`Y S g`[cgW ]WkiadV Xad S fab[U U^[U] 9Wf GD> EgYYWef[a`e fa babg^SfW ^[`]e [`
fZW XWSfgdWV GD> W^V
5^[U] BdWh[Wi fa YW`WdSfW S bdWh[Wi aX fZW ZWSV^[`W Xad fZW def ^[`]
S ;X fZW Sdf[U^W eagdUW _WWfe fZW Ud[fWd[S agf^[`WV TW^ai Ua`f[`gW i[fZ UgdSf[a` Se `ad_S^
T ;X fZW Sdf[U^W eagdUW VaWe `af _WWf fZW Ud[fWd[S Xad UgdSf[a` bdWh[Wi fZW `Wjf egYYWefWV
GD>
5a`f[`gW fZ[e bdaUWee g`f[^ kag `V S eg[fST^W GD> ;X `a egYYWefWV GD>e _WWf fZW UgdSf[a` Yg[VW
^[`We _S`gS^^k W`fWd fZW TWef GD>
GeW fZW Xa^^ai[`Y Ud[fWd[S fa WhS^gSfW fZW GD>,
;X kag Va `af eW^WUf fZW fab egYYWefWV GD> fZW faa^ i[^^ Se] kag fa bdah[VW S dWSea` TSeWV a` fZW
Xa^^ai[`Y abf[a`e,
Fab egYYWef[a` [e [ddW^WhS`f, EW^WUf fZ[e abf[a` [X fZW egYYWefWV GD> [e `af dW^WhS`f fa fZW
FdW`V[`Y fab[U
@af fZW ad[Y[`S^ eagdUW, EW^WUf fZ[e abf[a` [X fZW FdW`V[`Y fab[U ad[Y[`SfWV Xda_ S` WjU^ge[hW
dWbadf fZSf iSe `af fZW fab egYYWef[a`
?W`f[a`e S` a^VWd WhW`f, EW^WUf fZ[e abf[a` fZW fab egYYWef[a` [e dW^WhS`f fa fZW fab[U Tgf
agfVSfWV
Baad cgS^[fk ad `af S` SgfZad[fSf[hW eagdUW, EW^WUf fZ[e abf[a` [X fZW fab egYYWef[a` [e `af S`
Sbbdabd[SfW eagdUW Xad fZW fab[U 8ad WjS_b^W [X fZW fab GD> [e Xda_ S Yaee[b e[fW Xad S ZSdV
`Wie efadk ad [X fZW fab GD> [e Xda_ S`kfZ[`Y afZWd fZS` S `Wie iWTe[fW egUZ Se ^[`]e fa S
US_bS[Y` bSYW ad bdWee dW^WSeW
5^[U]TS[f ad aT\WUf[a`ST^W Ua`fW`f, EW^WUf fZ[e abf[a` [X fZW fab egYYWef[a` VW^[TWdSfW^k
i[fZZa^Ve UdgU[S^ [`Xad_Sf[a` ad W_b^ake afZWd fSUf[Ue YWSdWV Sf XadU[`Y geWde fa U^[U]
fZdagYZ fa fZW Sdf[U^W
;ddW^WhS`f ^S`YgSYW, EW^WUf fZ[e abf[a` [X fZW ZWSV^[`W Xad fZW fab GD> egYYWef[a` [e id[ffW`
[` S ^S`YgSYW fZSf [e`f Sbbdabd[SfW fa fZW eUabW [` iZ[UZ kagdW iad][`Y
EUS` fZW XWWV [` fZW dWh[Wi faa^, @Sf[hW h[VWa i[^^ ea_Wf[_We TW W_TWVVWV [` baefe egdXSUWV
[` fZW fab[U XWWV i[fZ[` fZW faa^
EWSdUZ SUUag`fe [`ha^hWV [` fZW efadk, IZW` baee[T^W iW eZag^V geW bd[_Sdk eagdUW h[VWa
Cg[U]^k eWSdUZ fZW SUUag`fe [`ha^hWV [` fZW efadk Xad dW^SfWV h[VWa
EWSdUZ Xad dW^SfWV h[VWa h[S baef eWSdUZ, Cg[U]^k eWSdUZ dW^SfWV ]WkiadVe Xad `Sf[hW h[VWa
Xda_ afZWd SUUag`fe
&
Agd bdWXWdW`UW [e fa eZaiUSeW >[hW h[VWa iZW`WhWd baee[T^W FZW adVWd aX [`U^ge[a` Seeg_[`Y S^^
h[VWa [e dW^WhS`f,
#
@Sf[hW h[VWa
5gdSfWV ^[hW h[VWa eZag^V SVZWdW fa fZWeW SVV[f[a`S^ Yg[VW^[`We Xad d[e]k Ua`fW`f
9g[VW^[`We Xad h[VWa [`U^ge[a`,
;X `a bd[_Sdk eagdUW h[VWa [e ShS[^ST^W [f [e SUUWbfST^W fa geW `Sf[hW h[VWa Xda_ S `Wie adYS
`[lSf[a` ad S`afZWd SUUag`f Se ^a`Y Se fZW h[VWa VaWe `af Ua`fS[` Uabkd[YZfWV _SfWd[S^
IZW` UgdSf[`Y h[VWa Xda_ `Wie adYS`[lSf[a`e agd bdWXWdW`UW [e fa geW h[VWa aX fZW `Wie
WhW`f [feW^X dSfZWd fZS` UahWdSYW ad Ua__W`fSdk aX fZW `Wie WhW`f
IZW` `a h[VWa aX fZW `Wie WhW`f Wj[efe [f [e SUUWbfST^W fa geW h[VWa UahWdSYW Xda_ `Wie
agf^Wfe GeW fZW Xa^^ai[`Y Yg[VW^[`We fa eW^WUf fZW _aef h[fS^ h[VWa,
IZW`WhWd baee[T^W geW h[VWa Xda_ agf^Wfe iZa aWd WjU^ge[hW!ad[Y[`S^ dWbadf[`Y dSfZWd
fZS` SYYdWYSf[a`
;X _g^f[b^W h[VWae cgS^[Xk TSeWV a` fZW STahW Yg[VW^[`We geW fZW h[VWa i[fZ fZW Z[YZWef h[Wi
Uag`f Se S f[WTdWS]Wd
5gdSfW S `Sf[hW bZafa ad h[VWa Xda_ S bWdea`S^ bda^W iZW`,
3 fab[U [e fdW`V[`Y TWUSgeW S h[VWa iSe eZSdWV a` 8SUWTaa] 3@6 S`afZWd b^SfXad_ W Y
KagFgTW H[_Wa-
FZW fab[U fZSf [e fdW`V[`Y dWXWdW`UWe S h[VWa 3@6 fZW bd[_Sdk eagdUW eZSdWe fZW h[VWa
`Sf[hW^k a` fZW[d 8SUWTaa] bda^W
<a TWW\g\ba gb hf\aZ g[X aTg\iX i\WXb \a g[X VbagXkg `bWh_X T_fb VheTgX g[X i\WXb cbfg Ybe <aib_iXW \a g[X
Fgbel gb XafheX \g \f i\f\U_X TaW [\Z[_l eTa^XW ba g[X F8EC!
@Sf[hW 8SUWTaa] h[VWae [` fZW Ua`fWjf _aVg^W SdW ^[_[fWV fa baefe Xda_ bSYWe S`V bgT^[U
bda^We W Y bda^We i[fZ 8a^^ai fgd`WV a` 8ad bgT^[U bda^We iW `WWV fa Ua`d_ fZW
[`V[h[VgS^ `Sf[hW h[VWa baef ZSe TWW` eZSdWV bgT^[U^k
7jS_b^We, 9g`_W` ][^^ #$ Sf BSd[e eSf[d[US^ `WiebSbWd- 8WdYgea` ba^[UW aUWd `af UZSdYWV Tk
YdS`V \gdk
@gU^WSd Fab[Ue,
DWeWdhWV Xad fZW fdg^k :a^k Ef efad[We fZSf ZSbbW` _SkTW #% f[_We S kWSd >WSV[`Y S^^ #" iWT
e[fWe 3@6 dWcg[dWe 8SUWTaa] WV[fade SbbdahS^ TWXadW _Sd][`Y Se `gU^WSd 7jfdW_W WjS_b^We SdW
+!##- _S\ad Uag`fdke bdWe[VW`f [e eZaf- Dgee[S VWU^SdWe iSd i[fZ G]dS[`W WfU 3 fWS_ ^WSV _gef
SbbdahW TWXadW S fab[U US` TW _Sd]WV @gU^WSd
FZagYZ a`^k 8SUWTaa] bdaVgUf ^WSVe US` SgfZad[lW S @G5>73D Taaef iW i[^^ Xa^^ai fZWeW Yg[VW
^[`We fa VWfWd_[`W iZW` iW eZag^V WeUS^SfW fab[Ue fa 8SUWTaa] ^WSVe Xad @G5>73D Ua`e[VWdSf[a`
#"4*$ $3*5&3*"
#
Fab[Ue _gef TW fZW _aef bda_[`W`f efadk a` Sf ^WSef * aX fZaeW e[fWe 3 dWVWe[Y`WV Xda`f
bSYW TdWS]agf TajWe i[fZ _g^f[b^W dW^SfWV efad[We ad S fab^[efWV efadk i[fZ Ua`efS`f gbVSf[`Y
SdW S^^ YaaV _Sd]Wde ;VWS^^k fZ[e eZag^V TW fZW fab efadk a` S^^ #" e[fWe Tgf iW^^ SUUag`f Xad
efdSYY^Wde WebWU[S^^k ahWd`[YZf
Fab[Ue _gef `af TW aX S bdWh[age^k eUZWVg^WV WhW`f ;` fZW dSdW e[fgSf[a` fZSf S eUZWVg^WV
WhW`f iag^V WhWd TW _Sd]WV @G5>73D fZSf i[^^ TW iad]WV agf iW^^ [` SVhS`UW S`V Ua_
_g`[USfWV fa fZW fWS_
&
Efadk XaUge _gef TW U^WSd ZSdV `Wie SUdaee fZW #" e[fWe ;X e[fWe SdW S^dWSVk TdWS][`Y [`fa
ebWUg^Sf[a` S`V S`S^ke[e aX iZSf ZSbbW`WV S`V dWb^SU[`Y ZSdV `Wie [fe ^[]W^k faa ^SfW fa TW
@G5>73D
'
7hW`fe Xad iZ[UZ 8SUWTaa]e ESXWfk 5ZWU] [e SUf[hSfWV US` TW Tgf SdW `af S^iSke bafW`f[S^
US`V[VSfWe Xad S @G5>73D Taaef ;X ESXWfk 5ZWU] [e WhWd SUf[hSfWV Sf ^WSef Ua`fSUf S fWS_
^WSV Xad V[eUgee[a`
5gdSfade S`V 57e eZag^V XWW^ W_baiWdWV fa efSdf fZW WeUS^Sf[a` V[eUgee[a` [X S` WhW`f eWW_e
fdg^k _See[hW
&4$"-"5*0/ 803,'-08
#
5gdSfade eZag^V V[eUgee i[fZ fZW Uabk WV[fad a` Vgfk Iad] faYWfZWd Td[Wk fZdagYZ fZW Ud[fW
d[S S`V VWU[VW faYWfZWd iZWfZWd fa _ahW fa EfWb $
5a`fSUf TafZ fWS_ ^WSVe ;X SXfWd Zagde US^^ fZW_ Sf Za_W [X `WUWeeSdk FZW ^WSVe _Sk `af
TafZ efSk Xad fZW a`Ya[`Y UahWdSYW Tgf fZWk eZag^V _WWf S`V V[eUgee fZW `WWV Xad @G5>73D
dS`][`Y
FZW fWS_ ^WSVe US` Ua`fSUf ad US^^ fZW 8SUWTaa] WV[fad Xad XgdfZWd Yg[VS`UW [X fZWk VWU[VW
@G5>73D [e \gef[WV
S ;X fZW 8SUWTaa] WV[fad US``af TW dWSUZWV
T ;X `W[fZWd US` TW dWSUZWV Va `af _Sd] @G5>73D g`f[^ a`W aX fZW_ US` Y[hW U^WSdS`UW
&
FZWeW efWbe eZag^V S[_ Xad S Ua_b^Wf[a` f[_W aX #" _[`gfWe ad ^Wee
7jS_b^W, 7^_a`f @K ebWU[U b^SUW @SeeSg 5ag`fk @K Uag`fk @Wi Kad] efSfW
;X fZWdW SdW _g^f[b^W ^aUSf[a`e [`U^gVWV [` S fab[U `S_W!VWeUd[bf[a`!eg__Sdk [`U^gVW fZW_ S^^
7jUWbf[a`e, 6a`f [`U^gVW S ^aUSf[a` Xad fab[Ue ^[]W ebadfe fWS_e fZSf [`U^gVW S ^aUSf[a` [` fZW[d
`S_W g`^Wee S _adW YdS`g^Sd ^aUSf[a` [e S^ea [`U^gVWV [` fZW VWeUd[bf[a` ad eg__Sdk 6a`f [`
U^gVW S ^aUSf[a` Xad fab[Ue iZW` fZW ^aUSf[a` [e fS`YW`f[S^ fa fZW efadk ad [`U^gVWV Xad TSU]Ydag`V
bgdbaeWe
@Wi Kad] KS`]WWe, FWS_e 4da`j @K EfSV[g_ 5^aeWV Xad % 6Ske 6gW fa DaVW`fe ;`XWe
fSf[a`
@Wi Kad] KS`]WWe, FWS_ >aeWe EWSea` AbW`Wd fa Fada`fa 4^gW <Ske (#
:Sbbk 8SfZWde 6Sk, Eg__Sdk ?S`k Uag`fd[We Sdag`V fZW iad^V UW^WTdSfW fZW VSk a`
fZW fZ[dV Eg`VSk [` <g`W FZW def ]`ai` aTeWdhS`UW aX fZW VSk iSe <g^k ' #+"* [`
8S[d_a`f I HS
IW a`^k iS`f fa Ua``WUf fab[Ue fZSf SdW V[dWUf^k dW^SfWV IW US` Ua``WUf fZW_ S^^ dWYSdV^Wee aX
bSdW`fUZ[^V dW^Sf[a`eZ[b :WdW SdW ea_W WjS_b^We,
7% EfSd ISde 4Sff^WXda`f S`V EfSd AUWS` SdW S^^ fdW`V[`Y FZWk eZag^V S^^ TW _Sd]WV
Se dW^SfWV fab[Ue Xad WSUZ afZWd TWUSgeW fZWkdW S^^ bSdf aX fZW eS_W WhW`f 7%
6a`S^V Fdg_b S`V FZW 3bbdW`f[UW eZag^V TW _Sd]WV Se dW^SfWV fab[Ue TWUSgeW fZWkdW
S^^ Ua``WUfWV fa Z[e bdWe[VW`f[S^ US`V[VSUk S``ag`UW_W`f
9a^VW` EfSfW ISdd[ade 5^WhW^S`V 5ShS^[Wde S`V 3`VdW ;YgaVS^S eZag^V S^^ TW _Sd]WV
Se dW^SfWV fab[Ue
9a^VW` EfSfW ISdd[ade eZag^V @AF TW _Sd]WV Se S dW^SfWV fab[U fa @Wi Kad] =`[U]e
iZ[UZ [e STagf fZW[d UaSUZ TW[`Y dWV
;VW`f[Xk fZW UaddWUf S`Y^W Xad fZW FdW`V[`Y fab[U TSeWV a` XWWV dWh[Wi S`V YW`WdS^ `Wie
eWSdUZ Yg[VW^[`We
$
3XfWd [VW`f[Xk[`Y fZW UaddWUf S`Y^W Xad S fab[U U^[U] [`fa fZW VdabVai` _W`g g`VWd`WSfZ fZW
G`[cgW =WkiadV W^V S`V eW^WUf fZW G`[cgW =WkiadV fZSf TWef fe fZW fab[U eWW Yg[VW^[`We
TW^ai
;X `a g`[cgW ]WkiadV SVWcgSfW^k fe fZW S`Y^W ad agd Yg[VW^[`We eW^WUf afZWd S`V id[fW S
Ugefa_ G`[cgW =WkiadV
IW eZag^V `af [`U^gVW bg`UfgSf[a` [` g`[cgW ]WkiadVe FZW a`^k WjUWbf[a` [e SUUW`f _Sd]e
IW eZag^V [`U^gVW SUUW`f _Sd]e iZW` Sbbdabd[SfW
FZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V Ua`fS[` fZW _aef [_badfS`f bWdea` b^SUW ad fZ[`Y SeeaU[SfWV
i[fZ fZW fab[U @WSd^k S^^ aX fZW f[_W fZ[e _WS`e fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V Ua`fS[` fZW fab[U
`S_W [feW^X
FZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V `af Ua`fS[` SUf[hW hWdTe ;X S` S^Yad[fZ_[U egYYWef[a` Ua`fS[`e
S` SUf[hW hWdT Tgf [e afZWdi[eW YaaV kag US` geW [f [X fZWdW [e`f S` abf[a` i[fZagf S` SUf[hW
hWdT
FZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V ebWU[U fa fZW e[fgSf[a` ;X fZW S^Yad[fZ_[US^^k egYYWefWV g`[cgW
]WkiadV [e`f [` ^[`W i[fZ fZW dWSea` fZW fab[Ue FdW`V[`Y S`Y^W fZW` dWid[fW [f fa _S]W [f
_adW ebWU[U
8ad ebadfe YS_We fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V Ua`fS[` TafZ fWS_ `S_We
8ad ZSeZfSY fab[Ue Xad iZ[UZ fZW ZSeZfSY [e dWbdWeW`f[`Y S` WhW`f iW eZag^V `af geW fZW
ZSeZfSY Se fZW ]WkiadV
8ad ZSeZfSY fab[Ue Xad iZ[UZ fZW ZSeZfSY [feW^X [e fZW fab[U fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV eZag^V TW fZW
WjSUf ZSeZfSY Tgf i[fZagf USb[fS^[lSf[a`
FZW iadV adVWd VaWe`f `WUWeeSd[^k _SffWd Tgf ]WWb [` _[`V fZSf fZW ]WkiadV i[^^ TW h[e[
T^W [` fkbWSZWSV S`V fZW eWSdUZ Taj ;X kagdW UZaae[`Y TWfiWW` fia fZSf TafZ XWfUZ YaaV
dWeg^fe b[U] fZW a`W fZSf ^aa]e _adW ^[]W S `SfgdS^ eWSdUZ bZdSeW
DW^SfWV =WkiadVe
DW^SfWV ]WkiadVe SdW eWSdUZ bZdSeWe kag iag^V WjbWUf fa Td[`Y gb fZ[e `Wie efadk `ai Tgf
fZWk SdW `af g`[cgW Xad fZ[e ebWU[U fdW`V
3[_ Xad #% dW^SfWV ]WkiadVe bWd fab[U S`V Va efSk a` fab[U Kag Va `af `WWV fa dWbWSf fZW
fab[U `S_W S`V fZWdWe `a `WWV fa SVV bSdW`f ]WkiadVe
8ad fZ[e kWSde 3USVW_k 3iSdVe fZWk iag^V TW aeUSde S`V SUSVW_k SiSdVe IW
iag^V`f geW W`fWdfS[`_W`f ad _ah[We
:WdW SdW ea_W WjS_b^We fa ZabWXg^^k U^Sd[Xk fZW V[WdW`UW TWfiWW` fZW g`[cgW ]WkiadV S`V fZW
dW^SfWV ]WkiadVe,
>aY [` fa 9Wffk ;_SYWe Zffb,!!iii YWffk[_SYWe Ua_! EWSdUZ dW^SfWV ]Wk iadVe fa eWW [X
fZWdWe S bZafa
5ZaaeW S bZafa fZSf TWef [^^gefdSfWe fZW fdW`V ;X fZWdW SdW UZa[UWe UZaaeW fZW bZafa i[fZ fZW
e[_b^Wef Ua_bae[f[a`
S GeW Zad[la`fS^ [_SYWe iZW` baee[T^W FZWk i[^^ TW WSe[Wd fa Udab
T ;fe SUUWbfST^W fa geW S ^W!efaU] bZafa Se ^a`Y Se [f VaWe`f _[edWbdWeW`f fZW UgddW`f
fdW`V
[ 7jS_b^W aX _[edWbdWeW`f[`Y fZW UgddW`f fdW`V, 4SdSU] ATS_S [e fdW`V[`Y TWUSgeW
aX Ua__W`fe ZW _SVW STagf bdafWefe [` 8WdYgea` IW SffSUZ S ^W bZafa i[fZagf S
USbf[a` fa Wjb^S[` fZW Ua`fWjf fZSf eZaie Z[_ SffW`V[`Y S bdafWef [` AS]^S`V fia
kWSde SYa
5abk fZW 7V[fad[S^ aX fZW bZafa S`V bSefW [f [`fa fZW 9Wffk BZafa eWSdUZ Tk ;6 W^V [`
fZW dWh[Wi faa^ S`V U^[U] fZW EWSdUZ Tgffa` 3 bdWh[Wi aX fZW [_SYW eZag^V Sgfa_Sf[US^^k
dW`VWd S`V fZW bZafa UdWV[f W^V eZag^V Sgfa^^
&
6dSY fZW dWV Taj gb S`V Vai` fa Udab!UW`fWd fZW [_SYW BdWh[Wi fZW 5a`fWjf ?aVg^W fa
_S]W egdW fZW Udab ^aa]e YaaV Tgf bd[ad[f[lW fZW Ua_bae[f[a` [` fZW UW`fWd Taj FZ[e i[^^ TW
fZW [_SYW V[eb^SkWV [` fZW _aT[^W @g^^ EfSfW
(VJEFMJOFT
#
IZW` S fab[U [e fdW`V[`Y TWUSgeW aX fZW bZafa fZW bWdea`!adYS`[lSf[a` baefWV a` 8SUW
Taa]-
IZW` S fab[U [e fdW`V[`Y TWUSgeW S bZafa iSe eZSdWV a` 8SUWTaa] 3@6 S`afZWd b^Sf
Xad_ W Y ;`efSYdS_ Fi[ffWd-
IZW` fZW fab[U [e fdW`V[`Y fZSf dWXWdW`UWe S` [_SYW 3@6 fZW bd[_Sdk eagdUW eZSdWe fZW
[_SYW `Sf[hW^k a` fZW[d 8SUWTaa] bSYW!bgT^[U bda^W
;` SVV[f[a` fa ge[`Y fZW `Sf[hW bZafa [` fZW Ua`fWjf _aVg^W S^ea UgdSfW fZW `Sf[hW bZafa baef
Xad ;`ha^hWV [` fZW Efadk fa W`egdW [f [e h[e[T^W S`V Z[YZ^k dS`]WV a` fZW E7DB
@Sf[hW 8SUWTaa] bZafae [` fZW Ua`fWjf _aVg^W SdW ^[_[fWV fa baefe Xda_ bSYWe S`V bgT^[U
bda^We W Y bda^We i[fZ 8a^^ai fgd`WV a` 8ad bgT^[U bda^We iW `WWV fa Ua`d_ fZW
[`V[h[VgS^ `Sf[hW bZafa baef ZSe TWW` eZSdWV bgT^[U^k
8PSLPX
#
AbW` fZW `Sf[hW bZafa ea fZW [_SYW [e ^SdYW gegS^^k fZWSfWd h[Wi D[YZfU^[U] a` fZW [_
BSefW fZW [_SYW GD> [`fa fZW dWh[Wi faa^ [` fZW ;_SYW GD> W^V S`V U^[U] bdWh[Wi 3V\gef
fZW Udab S`V bdWh[Wi fZW Ua`fWjf _aVg^W
@AF7, IW iS`f fa XShad ge[`Y fZW `Sf[hW bZafa WhW` [X [f VaWe`f Xg^^k ^^ agf fZW V[
_W`e[a`e aX fZW Ua`fWjf _aVg^W B^WSeW SY S`k WjS_b^We aX fZ[e fa kagd fWS_ ^WSV ea
iW US` WeUS^SfW i[fZ W`Y Se `WWVWV
Id[fW fZW Sffd[Tgf[a` [` fZW BZafa UdWV[f W^V,8SUWTaa] Ua_!geWd`S_W 8a^^ai fZW USb[fS^
[lSf[a` aX fZW geWd`S_W [` fZW GD> W^V
5gdSfW fZW `Sf[hW bZafa baef Xad ;`ha^hWV [` fZW Efadk Baef [` ;FE 7V[fad[S^ ! ED3 J8@
Ydagb fa S^Wdf fZW ED3e fZSf fZW `Sf[hW bZafa baef `WWVe fa efSk [` ;FE g`f[^ fZW fab[U XS^^e
agf
EU[W`UW Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa ebSUW iWSfZWd W`h[da`_W`f U^[_SfW UZS`YW eU[W`f[U dWeWSdUZ!
V[eUahWd[We Z[efadk SdUZSWa^aYk S`[_S^e
&
'
:WS^fZ Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa bZSd_SUWgf[US^e ZWS^fZ USdW [`Vgefdk ZWS^fZ ba^[Uk S ] S ATS
_SUSdW bgT^[U ZWS^fZ Ua`UWd`e S ] S L[]S h[dge agfTdWS] `gfd[f[a` f`Wee
`aWe i[^VdWe!dWe fZSf dWeg^f [` _g^f[b^W VWSfZe S`V!ad SdW aX `Sf[a`S^ ad [`fWd`Sf[a`S^
[_badf Fgbe\Xf gTZZXW _bVT_ TUbhg _bVT_ be eXZ\baT_ \aV\WXagf XfcXV\T__l baXf g[Tg eXfh_g \a ab VT
fhT_g\Xf f[bh_W abg T_fb UX gTZZXW W\fTfgXe!
)
5d[_W Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa S^^WYWV Ua`h[UfWV Wja`WdSfWV Ud[_We Ud[_[`S^ fd[S^e SbbWS^e
VWSfZ bW`S^fk Fgbe\Xf gTZZXW jTe"gXeebe\f` f[bh_W abg UX gTZZXW Ve\`X! @\ff\aZ cXefbaf f[bh_W
abg UX gTZZXW Ve\`X ha_Xff cb_\VX [TiX Vbae`XW T eX_TgXW Ve\`X ^\WaTcc\aZ ebUUXel XgV!
>[XWefk^W Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa XSeZ[a` Za_W VWUad Ug^fgdS^ fdW`Ve S`V [eegWe S ] S XW_
[`[e_ >94F d[YZfe dW^[Y[a` bSdW`f[`Y iWVV[`Ye Za^[VSke @Sf[a`S^ 6Sk UW^WTdSf[a`e
S ] S @Sf[a`S^ 5aWW 6Sk
5W^WTd[fk Fab[Ue STagf XS_age W`fWdfS[`_W`f YgdWe eaU[S^[fWe dakS^e 7bXf abg \aV_hWX
Tg[_XgXf!
#"
EfdS`YW Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa g`gegS^ dWUadVe S`V aVV `Wie efad[We fZSf SdW dWUW[h[`Y SffW`
f[a` Xad fZW eS]W aX fZW[d efdS`YW`Wee
##
7VgUSf[a` Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa S^^ ^WhW^e aX WVgUSf[a` WVgUSf[a` ba^[Uk fWSUZWd efd[]We efg
VW`f iS^]agfe Ua^^WYW dS`][`Ye
#$
#%
ESV!V[efgdT[`Y Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa fdSYWV[We h[a^W`f Ud[_We Ud[_We fZSf fSdYWf UZ[^VdW`
VWSfZe aX UZ[^VdW` ad S`[_S^e
#&
AfZWd 5ZaaeW fZ[e [` fZW dSdW U[dUg_efS`UW iZW` S fab[U VaWe`f XS^^ [`fa S`k aX fZW afZWd
USfWYad[We Fgbe\Xf gTZZXW _bVT_ f[bh_W aXiXe VTeel Ta bg[Xe gTZ UXVThfX _bVT_ \f T VTgXZbel!
#'
>aUS^ Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa `Wie efad[We!WhW`fe fZSf a`^k [_bSUf bWab^W ^aUS^^k ad dWY[a`S^^k ;X
S efadk [e dWUW[h[`Y e[Y`[US`f SffW`f[a` Tk `Sf[a`S^ S`V!ad [`fWd`Sf[a`S^ _WV[S [f eZag^V `af
TW fSYYWV ^aUS^
#(
9aee[b FST^a[V[eZ fab[Ue fZSf _Sk S^ea ZShW ^aiUdWV[T[^[fk eagdUWe ;`U^gVWe fab[Ue dW^SfWV
fa XS_age bWab^We T[dfZVSke VWSfZe S``[hWdeSd[We aX W`fWdfS[`_W`f S`V ^[XWefk^W WhW`fe
?gef TW UdaeefSYYWV fa a`W ad _adW dW^SfWV USfWYad[We
#)
D[ecg Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa eWj bad`aYdSbZk `gV[fk YdSbZ[U h[a^W`UW WfU Efad[We fZSf US` TW
bWdUW[hWV Se DdSfWV ad iadeW eZag^V TW fSYYWV d[ecg S ] S 5Zd[e :W_eiadfZe VSgYZfWd
V[eUgee[`Y Z[e bW`[e
EgTUSfWYad[We,
Ebadfe!AfZWd Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa ebadfe fZSf Va`f XS^^ [`fa afZWd egTUSfWYad[We
7`fWdfS[`_W`f!AfZWd Fab[Ue dW^SfWV fa W`fWdfS[`_W`f fZSf Va`f XS^^ [`fa afZWd egT
USfWYad[We
#MBDLMJTUJOH *UFNT
IW T^SU]^[ef fab[Ue Xda_ fZW dWh[Wi faa^ Xad fia dWSea`e,
#
6gb^[USfW fab[U FZW fab[U dWbdWeW`fe S dWS^iad^V WhW`f fZSf [e S^dWSVk ^[hW W[fZWd [` fZW
eS_W eUabW ad S`afZWd eUabW
S 7j IW SUUWbfWV @43 8[`S^e S`V iW T^SU]^[efWV @438[`S^e S`V @43 5ZS_b[
a`eZ[be
IZW` S fab[U [e T^SU]^[efWV [f [e TS``WV Xda_ SbbWSd[`Y [` fZW dWh[Wi faa^ Xad fZW ^W`YfZ aX f[_W
fZW f[_Wd iSe eWf
9g[VW^[`We Xad T^SU]^[ef f[_Wde
Agd T[Se [e fa T^SU]^[ef fab[Ue Xad fZW _Sj[_g_ aX $& Zagde [` S^_aef S^^ USeWe FZ[e W`egdWe fZSf
fZW cgWgWe efSk g`U^gffWdWV S`V iWdW `af iSef[`Y f[_W dWT^SU]^[ef[`Y fab[Ue Xda_ eZ[Xf fa eZ[Xf
:aiWhWd fZWdW SdW ea_W USeWe iZWdW S eZadfWd f[_Wd _S]We eW`eW,
% Zagde!* Zagde, GeW fZ[e Xad fab[Ue fZSf SdW UgddW`f^k Vgb^[USfW fab[Ue Tgf _Sk W_WdYW Se
cgS^[WV eWUa`VSdk fab[Ue
8kT`c_X- ?XUeba =T`Xf \f \a cXaW\aZ UXYbeX g[X fgTeg bY g[X 6TiT_\Xef ZT`X Uhg [X [Tfag WbaX Talg[\aZ
lXg gb dhT_\Yl Tf T eXT_ jbe_W XiXag! JX jTag gb chg [\` ba T f[beg g\`Xe gb `T^X fheX jX eX eXi\Xj TYgXe
g[X eXT_ jbe_W XiXag [Tf UXZha!
$& Zagde, GeW fZ[e Xad \g`] fab[Ue fZSf iWdW XS[d^k Ua`VW`f i[^^ `af TW dW^SfWV fa S fdW`V
8kT`c_X- FTaWj\V[ jeTcf. 7b[. EXiXef\U_X \a[\U\g\ba bY fcXe` haWXe Zh\WTaVX. 4ZX bY 8a_\Z[gXa`Xag
4^SU]^[efWV fab[Ue dWSbbWSd [` fZW bW`V[`Y cgWgW iZW` fZW[d f[_Wd Wjb[dWe FZWeW fab[Ue i[^^ SbbWSd
i[fZ S efd[]WfZdagYZ
4^SU]^[ef DWSea`e
IZW` T^SU]^[ef[`Y S fab[U fZW faa^ i[^^ Se] kag fa bdah[VW S dWSea` 5ZaaeW fZW Sbbdabd[SfW dWSea`
TSeWV a` fZW TW^ai VW`[f[a`e
;X kagd fab[U VaWe`f f [`fa S`k aX fZW TgU]Wfe fZW` UZaaeW fZW U^aeWef a`W
#
@af dWS^ iad^V WhW`f, IZW` fZWdWe `a SbbSdW`f Ua``WUf[a` fa S dWS^ iad^V WhW`f [` fZW XWWV
S`V!ad fZdagYZ afZWd eWSdUZ fSUf[Ue
6gb^[USfW fab[U, IZW` S fab[U [e ^[`]WV fa S dWS^iad^V WhW`f Tgf iW S^dWSVk ZShW S TWffWd
fab[U fa dWbdWeW`f fZSf WhW`f
>ai cgS^[fk ZSeZfSY, FZ[e [e Xad ZSeZfSYe fZSf SdW fS`YW`f[S^^k Ua``WUfWV fa dWS^iad^V WhW`fe
Tgf fZW ZSeZfSYe SdW`f Sdf[Ug^ST^W dWS^iad^V WhW`fe 8ad [`efS`UW [X [fe :S^^aiWW` S`V iW
YWf S aaV aX ZSeZfSYe egUZ Se US`Vk bg_b][`e fd[U]adfdWSf Uaefg_WeiSY WfU
&
EfS^W WjfWd`S^ fab[U, ;fe [` agd Yg[VW^[`We fa `af dWSbbdahW S` WjfWd`S^ fab[U g`^Wee fZWdW ZSe
TWW` S VWhW^ab_W`f e[`UW [fe ad[Y[`S^ SbbdahS^ ;X S` WjfWd`S^ fab[U dWegdXSUWe ad US` a`^k TW
Ua``WUfWV fa S` WhW`f fZSfe 0$ VSke a^V geW fZ[e dWSea` Xad T^SU]^[ef[`Y
'
;`egU[W`f eagdUWe, GeW fZ[e iZW` iW fZ[`] S fab[U [e Ua``WUfWV fa S dWS^iad^V WhW`f Tgf
fZW ShS[^ST^W [`Xad_Sf[a` [e `af egU[W`f fa UZSdSUfWd[lW fZW fab[U i[fZ Ua`VW`UW FZ[e S^ea
Uag^V Sbb^k [X S^^ fZW eagdUWe SdW [` S`afZWd ^S`YgSYW
:aSj eagdUWe, IZW` S fab[U egdXSUWe TSeWV a` g`dW^[ST^W iWTe[fWe ad eSf[dW e[fWe
FZWeW fia eZag^V TW geWV hWdk [`XdWcgW`f^k 8WW^ XdWW fa Ua__W`f ZWdW ad WeUS^SfW fa S Uabk WV
[fad [X kagdW Ua`e[VWd[`Y dWSea` ' ad ( fa W`egdW fZSf kagdW bdabWd^k ZS`V^[`Y fZW fab[U ;VWS^^k [X
S ZaSj [e T[Y W`agYZ fa dWSUZ FdW`V[`Y ea_W ^WY[f[_SfW eagdUWe i[^^ ZShW UahWdWV [f S`V iW US`
geW fZaeW Xad agd UZSdSUfWd[lSf[a`
&
Kag^^ ^S`V a` S bSYW fZSf dWWUfe fZW W`f[fk [V Wj 7`f:SeZfSY, '%$"'+$%*)$%& fZSf efd[`Y aX
`g_TWde [e kagd ZSeZfSY ;6
*OKFDUJOH 5PQJDT
# FZW WV[fad[S^ fWS_ 53@ [`\WUf S fab[U fa dWb^SUW S`afZWd fab[Ue S^dWSVk SbbWSd[`Y [` fZW dWh[Wi
faa^ [` fZW eS_W eUabW fa Ua`ea^[VSfW S efadk!U^WS`gb SbbWSdS`UWe
7j , IW [`\WUf AV[^W fa dWb^SUW 4S\S BW`[`eg^S S`V 5STa ES` >gUSe IW [`\WUf ;E;E fa dW
b^SUW 8^S_We aX ISd
$ FZW WV[fad[S^ fWS_ 53@ [`\WUf S `WieiadfZk fab[U fZSf [e `af SbbWSd[`Y [` fZW dWh[Wi faa^ Tgf [e
SbbWSd[`Y [` fZW VW_a faa^ [` fZW UaddWeba`V[`Y eUabW
% FZW WV[fad[S^ fWS_ 53@@AF [`\WUf S `WieiadfZk fab[U [X [f [e `af SbbWSd[`Y [` fZW VW_a ad dW
h[Wi faa^e IW i[^^ fdSU] fZWeW [`efS`UWe ea fZW W`Y[`WWde US` j Xad fZW XgfgdW
:ai fa ;`\WUf S Fab[U,
9Wf fZW fab[Ue aT\WUf ;6 iZ[UZ [e fZW ^a`Y `g_TWd Sf fZW W`V aX fZW fab[Ue XWWV GD> 7[fZWd
abW` fZW XWWV Xda_ fZW dWh[Wi faa^ [X [f [e eZai[`Y [` S V[WdW`f eUabW bWdZSbe ad [X [f
[e`f [` fZW dWh[Wi faa^ kag US` Ya fa fZW 6W_a faa^ S`V eWSdUZ Xad [f Se S UadW^SfWV fab[U
?S]W egdW fa UZWU] fZW T^SU]^[ef TWXadW [`\WUf[`Y [` USeW fZW fab[U iSe dW_ahWV WSd^[Wd
A`UW kag ZShW fZW ;6 kag geW fZW ?S`gS^ FdW`V 5gdSf[a` faa^ 0 FdW`V ;`\WUfad
&
'
EW^WUf fZW [`\WUf[a` f[_W S^iSke eW^WUf #$ Zagde iZ[UZ [e fZW VWXSg^f S`V fZW bd[ad[fk S^iSke
eW^WUf `ad_S^
:[f fZW [`\WUf Tgffa` FZW fab[U eZag^V eZai gb i[fZ[` ' _[`gfWe
0O$BMM 1SPDFEVSFT
EWW fZW 7eUS^Sf[`Y BdaT^W_e i[fZ FdW`V[`Y ;` fZW Efadk ^W [` fZW FdW`V[`Y 7V[fad[S^ FWS_ Ydagb
5PPMT 8F 6TF
9dWW` _WS`e ea_WfZ[`Y `Wi ZSe ZSbbW`WV fZSf iW `WWV fa UZWU] W[fZWd S `Wi fab[U ad
baee[T^k S `Wi VWeUd[bf[a` [e `WWVWV
4^gW _WS`e fZSf fZW fab[U ZSe dWUW`f^k TWW` dWh[WiWV S`V!ad `a `Wi VWeUd[bf[a` egYYWef[a`e
ZShW egdYWV
FZ[e faa^ dWWUfe S^^ fab[Ue fZSf SdW fdW`V[`Y TSeWV a` UZSffWd a` 8SUWTaa]
4^SU]^[efWV fab[Ue SdW dWWUfWV ZWdW Se iW^^ Se fab[Ue [` BW`V[`Y S`V >[hW
FaYY^W TWfiWW` eUabWe Tk SV\gef[`Y fZW Vdab Vai` _W`g fZSf eSke FdW`V Tk >aUS^W
;X kag eWW S fab[U fZSf [e`f [` fZW fdW`V[`Y dWh[Wi faa^ Tgf eZag^V TW TSeWV a` ba^[Uk [`hWe
f[YSfW,
DWh[Wi fZW XWWV baee[T^k T^SU]^[efWV TSeWV a` S baad cgS^[fk XWWV fZSf Uag^V ZShW e[`UW [_
bdahWV
;X kag eWW S Z[YZ cgS^[fk fab[U S`V XWWV fZSf [e Ua_b^[S`f i[fZ ba^[Uk,
BSefW fZW fab[U ;6 [` fZW g`T^SU]^[efWd fST g`VWd ?S`gS^ FdW`V 5gdSfad S`V
Z[f G`T^SU]^[ef fab[U ;6e
BWdea`S^[lWV Xad WSUZ geWd bdah[VWe S Ugefa_[lWV ahWdh[Wi aX fZW VSfS 8SUWTaa] ZSe Ua`ea^[
VSfWV STagf kagd ^[]We!V[e^[]We [` adVWd fa V[eb^Sk fZW #" fdW`V[`Y fab[Ue fZSf [f bWdUW[hWe Se _aef
SbbWS^[`Y fa kag
(VJEFMJOFT
G[XfX TeX g[X WXgT\_XW Zh\WX_\aXf g[X 9TVXUbb^ aXjf gXT` hfXf gb TV[\XiX \gf ZbT_!
IW `WWV fa _S[`fS[` S UWdfS[` `g_TWd aX fdW`Ve [` WSUZ eUabW Xad fZW bdaVgUf fa bWdXad_ abf[
_S^^k I[fZ XWiWd fab[Ue fZW bWdea`S^[lWV dS`][`Y aX FdW`V[`Y fab[Ue VaWe`f iad] S`V WhWdka`W
eWWe fZW eS_W eWf aX fab[Ue :Sh[`Y _adW fdW`Ve ZSe bdahW` fa [`UdWSeW fZW 5FD U^[U] fZdagYZ
dSfW S`V bSdf[U[bSf[a` dSfW
:WdW SdW fZW TSeW^[`We iW 53@@AF ZShW XWiWd fZS` fZWeW `g_TWde,
:SeZfSYe SdW hWdTSf[_ bZdSeWe fZSf fdW`V 3^fWd[`Y fZW_ iag^V TW UZS`Y[`Y fZW adYS`[U Ua_
bae[f[a` aX fZW fdW`V :SeZfSYe SdW V[WdW`f fZS` fab[Ue iZ[UZ SdW [`ZWdW`f^k _adW egT\WU
f[hW TWUSgeW fZWkhW TWW` YW`WdSfWV Tk fZW fab[U fSYYWd iZ[UZ ZSe [fe ai` ^[_[fSf[a`e
IZW` XSUWV i[fZ fZW UZa[UW TWfiWW` S ZSeZfSY S`V S `ad_S^ fab[U fZSf SdW TafZ SbbWSd[`Y adYS`
[US^^k 7jS_b^W, EfSd ISde 6Sk he ?SkFZW&fZ4WI[fZKag UZaaeW fZW a`W fZSf i[^^ Y[hW fZW TWef
geWd WjbWd[W`UW S`V W`ST^W fZW U^WSdWef g`VWdefS`V[`Y aX iZSf fZW fab[U [e STagf
7jUWbf[a`, ;X S FWS_@S_W fab[U [e fZW a`^k ShS[^ST^W fab[U Xad S ebadfe YS_W iW eZag^V ef[^^ Xa^
^ai agd Yg[VS`UW VWfS[^WV TW^ai faa, B[U] fZW adYS`[U fab[U i[fZ fZW TWef XWWV S`V dWid[fW fZW
fab[U `S_W fa [`U^gVW TafZ fWS_e Agd bdWXWddWV efk^W [e FWS_ he FWS_
5:1&4 0' 501*$4 50 3&83*5&
FZWeW SdW ea_W fkbWe aX fdW`Ve fZSf iW^^ id[fW Ugefa_ fab[U `S_We Xad,
Ida`Y!5a`Xge[`Y Fab[U, DWid[fW fab[U `S_We fZSf SdW ^WY[f[_SfW^k fdW`V[`Y Tgf i[fZ a
fab[U `S_We
7jS_b^W, Ad[Y[`S^ fab[U `S_W!VWeUd[bf[a`, @[U] 5^WYY 6Wbgfk Bd[_W ?[`[efWd 8WSfgdWV
I[fZ AfZWd G= BSdfk >WSVWde [` @Wi EbaaX H[VWa
DWid[ffW` fab[U `S_W!VWeUd[bf[a`, 9dWW` BSdfk G= 9dagb DW^WSeWe EbaaX H[VWa Bad
fdSk[`Y AfZWd BSdfk >WSVWde Se 4ak 4S`V
>a`Y Fab[U @S_W, DWid[fW fab[U `S_We fZSf SdW ^a`Y ad Si]iSdV^k Xad_S^
>aUSf[a`e, DWid[fW S ^aUSf[a` fab[U iZW` fZW ^aUSf[a` [e `af fZW _S[` XaUge aX fZW fdW`V
7jS_b^W,
Ebadfe 9S_We, DWid[fW fZW fab[U `S_W fa [`U^gVW TafZ fWS_e Agd bdWXWddWV efk^W [e FWS_
he FWS_
IW eZag^V a`^k dWid[fW ebadfe YS_W fab[Ue [X fZWdW SdW `a 9S_Wf[_W ad he ZSeZfSY fab[Ue
7jS_b^W,
G E Ebadfe
3[_ fa [`U^gVW fZW fWS_e ^aUSf[a`e S`V `[U]`S_We [` fZW fab[U `S_W GeW \gef fZW
fWS_e `[U]`S_We [X kag dWcg[dW ebSUW fa [`U^gVW [_badfS`f [`Xad_Sf[a` [` fZW VW
eUd[bf[a`
4aefa` DWV Eaj he BZ[^SVW^bZ[S BZ[^^[We, FWS_e AbW` EWSea` Sf 5[f[lW`e 4S`]
BSd]
KS`]WWe he DWV Eaj, FWS_e 4WY[` EWd[We Sf 8W`iSk BSd] I[fZ #ef B^SUW [` 3>
7Sef Sf EfS]W
3XfWd fZW YS_W UZS`YW fZW fab[U `S_W fa fZW i[``[`Y fWS_ [X [f _S]We eW`eW fa Va
ea
;X fZW ad[Y[`S^ fab[U [e fZW ^ae[`Y fWS_ UZWU] VW_a fa _S]W egdW fZW i[``[`Y
fWS_ [e`f fdW`V[`Y adYS`[US^^k
BdWYS_W, @Wi Kad] KS`]WWe UZS`YWV fa @Wi Kad] KS`]WWe he 4aefa` DWV Eaj
;X fZW DWV Eaj i[` UZWU] VW_a fa eWW [X DWV Eaj [e fZWdW ;X ea S`V fZW[d dS`]
[`Y [e Ua_bSdST^W [` VW_a _WS`[`Y fZW i[``[`Y fWS_ [e dS`]WV Z[YZWd ad U^aeW
fa Se Z[YZ Se fZW ^ae[`Y fWS_ ei[fUZ fa fZW i[``[`Y fWS_
;X `af ]WWb TafZ fWS_e Se fZW fab[U ad ei[fUZ TSU] fa fZW ^ae[`Y fWS_ [X fZW ^aee
iSe Ua`eWcgW`f[S^
@Wi Kad] KS`]WWe he 4aefa` DWV Eaj, 4aefa` FS]We AhWd #ef B^SUW [` 3> 7Sef
I[fZ %$ I[`
@Wi Kad] KS`]WWe, FWS_ 7^[_[`SfWV 8da_ B^Ska 5a`fW`f[a` I[fZ %$ >aee fa
4aefa` DWV Eaj
8ad Va_Wef[U eaUUWd U^gTe ?>E ^WShW 85 VWeUd[bf[a` S`V 8 5 eg__Sd[We [` fZW
`S_W aX fZW U^gT
;`fWd`Sf[a`S^ Ebadfe
3[_ fa dWXWd fa fWS_e [` fab[U `S_We Se fZWkdW dWXWddWV fa [` `Wie efad[We a` def
dWXWdW`UW dSfZWd fZS` fZW ea_Wf[_We ^a`Y S`V Ug_TWdea_W aU[S^ Xg^^ fWS_ `S_We
fZSf SdW dSdW^k geWV E[_[^Sd^k fS]W UgWe Xad eWUa`V dWXWdW`UW Xda_ `Wie efad[We
STagf fZW YS_W :WdWe S dg``[`Y ^[ef aX Ua__a` WjS_b^We,
BdW_[Wd >WSYgW U^gTe 6a`f geW 85 ad 8 5 S`V Va`f geW G`[fWV WjUWbf Xad
?S`UZWefWd G`[fWV,
5ZW^eWS he Efa]W 5[fk, 5^gTe ?WWf Xad BdW_[Wd >WSYgW ?SfUZ Sf EfS_XadV
4d[VYW
AfZWd [`fWd`Sf[a`S^ eaUUWd U^gTe 6a`f geW 85 ad 8 5 S`V Va`f geW kWSde [`
fWS_ `S_We 7jS_b^W, 85 EUZS^]W "& / EUZS^]W
4SkWd "& >WhWd]geW` / 4SkWd >WhWd]geW` 4afZ 4SkWd S`V >WhWd]geW` US`
baee[T^k iad] a` eWUa`V dWXWdW`UW 5ZWU] iZSf afZWd `Wie agf^Wfe SdW Va[`Y
A`Ya[`Y @Wie 7hW`fe, Id[fW S Ugefa_ fab[U `S_W Xad TdWS][`Y ad b^S``WV `Wie WhW`fe fZSf
SdW WjbWUfWV fa bWde[ef Xad eWhWdS^ VSke
7jS_b^We,
Fab[Ue fZSf SdW`f gbefk^W, 8ad Ua`e[efW`Uke eS]W S^^ fab[Ue eZag^V Xa^^ai agd gbefk^W Yg[VW
^[`We
FkbW fZW `Wi `S_W [`fa fZW 5gefa_ Fab[U @S_W W^V
S 5gefa_ fab[U `S_We eZag^V Xa^^ai agd gbefk^W Yg[VS`UW
T FZWdW [e `a UZSdSUfWd ^[_[f Tgf fZWk eZag^V `af WjUWWV fZW def ^[`W aX fZW D:5 V[e
b^Sk
5a`eg^f i[fZ S 5abk 7V[fad Xad Yg[VS`UW a` dWid[f[`Y eW`e[f[hW ad Ua`fdahWde[S^ fab[Ue
S 7jS_b^We, 6[eSefWde!fWddad[ef SffSU]e ba^[UW eZaaf[`Ye ba^[f[US^!eaU[S^ [eegWe