Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
by the book:
An Effective Approach to
Indigenous Behaviour &
Classroom Management
Journey to Behaviour
Management
Lets have a yarn and come along on a journey
to learning about behaviour management
strategies (and some cross over to general
classroom management) in an Indigenous
context. This resource came about from our
search for answers about how best to approach
behaviour in an Indigenous setting. Or perhaps
more so, how is it different to what we already
know? What we came to understand, is
behaviour management is generally universal.
Who is in my Classroom?
et al, 2001).
The Western Australian Aboriginal Child Health Survey (WAACHS), conducted a study
into mental health and social and emotional wellbeing among Aboriginal children and
youth. The findings demonstrated a higher overall rate (26 % compared to 17 %) of
mental health incidents than Non-Aboriginal youth between 4-11. (Zubrick et al, 2005)
21% of Aboriginal 1217 year-olds are at risk statistically of developing a mental health
complaint compare to 13% of Non-Aboriginal youth.
High stress rates are recorded for Aboriginal students given the many life stressors
faced. (Zubrick et al, 2005)
Aboriginal youth generally have high resiliency levels and strengths however they are
more susceptible to behavioural and emotional problems (Zubrick et al, 2005).
These factors all play a role in increasing the stress and responsibilities of
THE STUDENT:
The life pathways for young Indigenous Australians are often fraught with behavioural and emotional disruptions.
These are caused not just from socioeconomic factors but also due to other factors such as demographics or clinically significant internalising or
externalising problems which are predictors for mental health difficulties in adulthood.4
These disruptions also predict:
high school non-completion;
physical health problems;
drug and alcohol misuse;
marital difficulties;
increased mortality; and,
involvement in the criminal and justice system.
It is imperative not to make biased assumptions or judgements based on stereotypes. The role of the teacher is not to
go in with a these kids needs saving attitude. Many communities do not form a part of these stereotypes. It is
considered an honour to work alongside and within these communities. Misconceptions can be easily made when
making generalisations. The best advice is to engage with research, create a generalised understanding of the factors
at play and go in with an open mind and attitude towards building relationships. Seek first to understand then be
understood.
THE TEACHER:
We have established the link between behaviour (and classroom) management to the wellbeing of the teacher. It is therefore important to consider the issues
impacting the students wellbeing which disrupts their behaviour and then finding strategies to mitigate this in turn benefitting the wellbeing of the students
and the teacher. Teaching is an altruistic profession requiring a commitment to constantly reviewing and building competencies and flaws and all the while
maintaining a healthy wellbeing. In order to provide a holistic education to students which supports the needs of the whole child not merely the academics,
requires the teacher to have a strong sense of identity and wellbeing in themselves. Coombs (cited in Collier & Donnelly, 1984, p 20) states your emerging
professional teacher identity (which is interconnected to your personal identity) will both influence and be influenced by your actual teaching. Zemblyas
(2003, p.223) adds emotions inform and define identity in the process of becoming. You need to be able to identify the things you do well, the qualities that
you possess and that you will need to develop. Teachers identity experiences are central to their practice and commitment as professionals (Day, Elliot &
Kingston, 2005; Gibbs, 2006). A sense of personal and professional identity are inextricably linked (Gibbs, 2006; Palmer, 1993) As Gibbs (2006, p.77) writes
teachers who have deep knowledge about themselves as people and as teachers show a sense of security in their personal and professional identities.
(Walker, Robinson, Adermann, Campbell, 2014; Harrison, 2011; and Hudspith, 1997)
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander history is fraught with horror stories
and pain such as that caused by the Stolen Generations. It is important
to acknowledge these events and promote reconciliation. However, this
should not allow students to misbehave. It is important for expectations
to remain high and to aim for a reconciled future (SMH, 2008).
Some families of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander heritage have ill
feelings towards school in relation to history. They also may not want
the Stolen Generations to be included in the curriculum due to an
ancestral connection and may prefer for this to be taught at home(Korff,
2015).
Korff (2015) states effects of the Stolen Generations still have
implications on each students life. When teaching about this chapter,
teachers need to protect students privacy and not expect them to talk
about their personal stories
It is important strategies are arranged to strengthen relationships in the
community an establish a safe learning environment including
promoting reconciliation and setting expectations. Key ideas for
implementing this can be found on the website. This is about teaching
students to walk in two worlds
(Walker, Robinson, Adermann, Campbell, 2014; Harrison, 2011; and
Student Responsibility
Give students more chances (Korff, 2015)
Many behavioural problems can be managed by
taking the time to listen and giving students a
second, third and forth chance (Korff, 2015).
Aboriginal students are more autonomous by
nature. As the teacher, an understanding and
tolerance of such factors can assist in firm
boundaries and also realistic expectations.
(Korff, 2015).
Story Sharing
Community Links
Deconstruct/Reconstru
ct
Non-Linear
Land Links
Non-Verbal
Learning Maps
Consider the example
application on the
following page.
REFLECT ON HOW YOU
COULD USE THIS IN
YOUR CLASSROOM
Strong Relationships
Know about and get interested in culture! The key word here is to be authentic.
Find out about your new community, network and investigate. There will no doubt be a wealth of new experiences and knowledge and rich cultural understandings to seek out. In teaching you are
also learning and students have so much to say. Taking a student centred approach to behaviour management means knowing the students. No learning can occur without a sense of trust and
rapport. Content students makes a content teacher. Support your wellbeing (and your students) by creating an environment where the students recognise themselves and want to be there.
Strategies:
Behaviour management should be firm, fair and consistent
Be aware of harmful interactions (teasing, crying, etc). Aboriginal students can reduce another student to tears by just a look and teachers need to be consistent and firm with their rules and
instigate change if it persists or is hurtful to others.
For the first few weeks students may be very shy and apprehensive asking and answering questions. Give them time to warm up and become accustomed to your presence and mannerisms.
Telling stories or sharing yarns is much more familiar than asking questions and expecting answers
Avoid becoming annoyed or angry towards behaviour. Remain calm and work within the framework of the school to effectively address concerns appropriately, professionally and consistently.
Provide regular positive encouragement, reassurance and feedback especially towards behaviour which you would like to see repeated.
Appear confident, present and happy as opposed to tired or stressed.
Use small group techniques. In many cases group responses to questions during lessons are advisable, unless individuals volunteer.
Use real-life analogies when explaining something to provide a context. Telling a story is one of the 8 Ways of Learning identified for Indigenous students.
Set high expectations to motivate students to succeed and know that you believe in them.
Aboriginal students often avoid direct eye contact as a sign of respect and in line with culture. Failing to understand such cultural mismatches can result in soft racism.
Students have a greater sense of autonomy which should be considered in conjunction to behaviour management. They are often raised to be autonomous individuals with a right to express their
needs and opinions and have them taken seriously. But a strong character can get them into trouble in a classroom.
Be mindful of social factors and life stressors (see earlier description) when addressing behaviour. Treat behaviour on an individual need basis. Providing pastoral care lets them develop trust and
feel safe and valued.
Model and discuss expectations for behaviour with clear, explicit examples (do not get students to role play unless appropriate. Individual students should not be called upon until a safe, inclusive,
participatory, trusting environment has been developed over time specific to the cohort needs). If teachers spend half an hour teaching basic norms they get much more control over their students
(AUSEINET, 2008).
There is a lack of positive role models for Aboriginal students, especially boys who have no father figures in their lives through death or separation. They need basic strategies for their immediate
needs, for example extra attention, food or a talk about what happened the previous night at home.
Provide more chances (Many behavioural issues can be dealt with by providing time , listening and respecting students by providing a choice and providing a second, third and forth chance)
Include community spirit. Aboriginal students are more used to working for the collective good rather than focusing on individual achievement. Eg. Looma Remote Community School, about 120 km
south-east of Derby, WA, uses a high level of community involvement and togetherness as a crucial factor to its success in education. Every morning, students, and often parents, play heads and
tails in morning assembly. Parents and carers often join sack races and tugs of war at sports carnivals and eat lunch with children.
Promote Aboriginality .For Aboriginal students to have a full and productive life, they need to receive an education that enhances and promotes their Aboriginality. Teachers can encourage cultural
pride through programs such as music and dance. Incorporating such programs should see a significant improvement in engagement, behaviour and attendance at school. Consider the following
example:
Students who have poor attendance rates and attitudes to school are less likely to participate positively with
expectations set in the classroom . They need to see value in what they are doing . Encouraging positive school
experiences is central to the process of lifting both achievement andretention rates among Aboriginal students.
Aboriginal students need to view school as rewarding, enjoyable, and as a learning environment encouraging
active engagement in ongoing educational opportunities (WAPPA, 2012).
Non-attendance at school remains perhaps the most severe manifestation of the dysfunctional relationship
between school and Aboriginal students. Non-attendance becomes a pattern that is hard to break, especially if
triggered by school-based confrontation (WAPPA, 2012).
The home school disconnect has a significant impact on a students positive identity of themselves and their
prospects. Development of positive self-identities as students beforeimproved participation and
retentioncould be achieved. This requires a school environment where students from a supportive home
environment had a sense of belonging, where teachers have positive expectations of student success and where
curriculum is perceived by the students to be relevant (WAPPA, 2012)
When considering the wellbeing of the teacher and the risk imposed by unsuccessful behaviour management, the
following quotes provide some food for thought:
The impact on educational and behavioural management outcomes in schools of the inability to engage Aboriginal
students into the learning process, can be attributed in large part to the lack of success enjoyed by Aboriginal
students. The inability to read and participate fully in academic activities by a significant number of Aboriginal
students, is an inhibiting factor to Aboriginal education participation, success, school attendanceandretention
(WAPPA, 2012).
Clearly, the initial focus in developing strategies for maximising the potential educational opportunities for
Aboriginal students, is linked to engaging in regular attendance. Schools should have consistent behaviour
High Expectations
Case Studies
I want them to reach for the stars, (Principal Paul Eaglestone from Looma Remote
Community School in WA). Were all about student gain. I prefer high targets, even if
sometimes students do well but dont quite get there (ABC, 2016).
I give the students examples, explains Len Yarran from Balga Senior High School (WA). I
tell them there are people who came from alcoholic households, suicides in their family,
backgrounds where there was no hope, and they have changed their lives. Some of them are
in really influential positions (The Australian, 2014).
I dreamt big, says Aboriginal gold medal winner and politician Nova Peris. Most people
would have looked at an Aboriginal girl from the Territory, with its statistics of alcohol abuse,
youth suicide, domestic violence, imprisonment rates and substandard education, and point
to every reason why I should not succeed. But I was determined to be successful (Koori Mail,
n.d).
Sky News international editor and Wiradjuri man, Stan Grant, remembers: Aboriginal kids
like me were too often denied opportunity, ignored or held captive to the low expectations of
others. Indeed at age 14 I, along with my black cousins and mates, was encouraged to leave
school, our principal said there was no meaningful place for us (The Australian, 2014).
Tips to Remember!
d
ors
ern
End n Gov mende
ia
tral y recom
s
u
A
ighl use in s
h
d
t
an
for
ntex
o
c
ALL
This flowchart provides a quick overview and ready reference guide for
managing challenging behaviour.
SOURCE: Ian Christie (HOD) from Urangan State High School
Classroom Management is a
Balance
Teachers can have two types
of conversations with students
in class. In the ideal situation
the most potent conversation
is focused on learning, with
minor support from the
managing conversation.
However, when teachers
experience lessons where
conversation about managing
dominates, the learning
agenda can disappear and
poor outcomes are much
more likely (Richmond,
2007).
(Richmond, 2007).
Despite their
individual styles,
when teachers are
effective they
typically do three
things within the
management
component of
their work.These
teachers clearly
establish
expectations with
students,
generously
acknowledge prosocial and on-task
behaviour, and
discretely correct
anti-social and
disruptive
behaviour
(Richmond, 2007)
Behaviour Management
Style
(Villegas 2016)
Be cool, calm, firm, fair and consistent. Invest time into setting up a safe, harmonious
learning environment.
Quality relationships are equally important as quality pedagogy (learning wont occur until
these are firmly established between the teacher, students, parents/carers and the
community)
Avoid disengagement by being mindful of triggers and have strategies in place. Dont allow
students to disengage due to behaviour and ensure high expectations are maintained for all
students.
All students should be participating, involved and provided with attention and recognition
Work to boost attendance by strengthening relationships, rapport and classroom climate
Always avoid shaming
Be sensitive of the past and promote reconciliation through practice
Avoid confrontation , heavy discipline, being controlling or authoritarian and backing
students into a corner. Return to a situation after providing cool down time.
Provide positive praise and encouragement as much as possible
Identify harness and encourage students strengths
Involve parents wherever possible and provide good news regularly about student learning
Invest time in preventing misbehaviour
Dont expect or demand immediate conforming or compliance. Expect to develop this over
time in collaboration with the needs of the students (many experience differing levels of
control, compliance or autonomy outside of school it is common for these traits to be
encouraged or expected which will then translate into the classroom)
Encourage group rewards rather than individual
Be mindful of autonomy and non-compliance outside of school and make allowances and
What are your ideas so far? Write a reflective statement on how you think
behaviour management can be a risk or protective factor to teacher wellbeing
and why?
What do I know about each of the students in my class?
Am I differentiating for the needs of all of all students?
Are the students engaged and actively participating?
Is the work at an appropriate level for all the students in my class?
Have I set high expectations underpinned by a supportive environment?
Do my students understand what I am asking?
What have I done to establish a safe learning environment and is it effective?
Identify what steps I am undertaking to ensure my pedagogy is culturally appropriate and
sensitive.
Is my approach to behaviour management firm, fair and consistent?
Are my expectations achievable and realistic?
Am I providing options and choice?
Am I happy with my classroom management?
Is my classroom somewhere my students would want to be?
Can my students recognise themselves and their identity in my classroom?
Do I know where to seek assistance or find information?
Am I developing and nurturing relationships within the classroom and community?
What could I do to improve any of the areas mentioned in this presentation?
Is what I am doing the best I can do?
Have I considered the links between my wellbeing and behaviour (or classroom)
Further Information
Website and Resources
Check out the free resources
and regular webinars
with experts available on our website:
Beyondteachers.weebly.com
Live Chat
We offer a live collaborate style on-line chat everyThursday evening
between 6:00pm 9:00pmwhere an experienced Indigenous teacher
will be available to assist with any further questions or queries that you
may have in relation to Indigenous learning styles and pedagogy
Source: http://www.cherbourss.eq.edu.a
Source: http://www.cherbourss.eq.edu.a
Source: http://www.cherbourss.eq.edu.a
Source: http://www.cherbourss.eq.edu.a
Source: http://www.cherbourss.eq.edu.a
Source: https://
Source: https://
Source: https://
Source: https://
Source: https://
Source: https://
Source: https://
Source: https://
Source: https://tagaisc.eq.edu.au/Pages/default.a
Source: https://tagaisc.eq.edu.au/Pages/default.a
Source: https://tagaisc.eq.edu.au/Pages/default.a
Source: https://tagaisc.eq.edu.au/Pages/default.a
Source: https://tagaisc.eq.edu.au/Pages/default.a
Reference List
Australian Network for Promotion Prevention and Early Intervention for Mental Health (AUSEINET) (2008). Mental health promotion and illness prevention: Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People.
Ausinetter. 30(1):22-27.
Boon, H. (2016). Why and how to use different teaching methods with Indigenous students. Australia Association for Research in Education (AARE). Retrieved via the web on April 2016
http://www.aare.edu.au/blog/?p=1449
Brunsvold GL, Oepen G, Federman EJ, Akins R (2008). Comorbid Depression and ADHD in Children and Adolescents. Psychiatric Times. 25(10).
Burney, L. (2000). Not Just a Challenge, an Opportunity. In M Gratton (ed). Reconciliation: Essays on Australian Reconciliation. Bookman Press, Melbourne, pp. 65-73.
Cherbourg State School. (2009). Positive Rewards System. Department of Training and Education. Retrieved via the web April 2016 from http://www.cherbourss.eq.edu.au/Rewards.html
Collier, G. and Donnelly, K. (1984), Self Esteem, Sydney: N.S.W. Education Department
Day, C., Elliot, B., & Kingston, A. (2005). Reform, standards and teacher identity: Challenges of sustaining commitment. Teaching and Teacher Education, 21(5), 563-57
Gibbs, C. J. (2006). To be a teacher: Journeys towards authenticity. Auckland, New Zealand: Pearson Education.
Harrison, N. (2011). Teaching and Learning In Aboriginal Education. Second Edition. Oxford Univeristy Press. Australia and New Zealand. Victoria.
Hudspith, S (1997). Visible pedagogy and urban Aboriginal students. In S Harris & M Malin (eds). Aboriginal education: historical moral and practical tales, Northern Territory University Press, Darwin, pp.
96-108.
Koori Mail. (n.d). 'Kids' brains 'need help', 511 p.54
Korff, J. (2015). Teaching Aboriginal Students. Creative Spirits. Retrieved via the web on April 2016 from
http://www.creativespirits.info/aboriginalculture/education/teaching-aboriginal-students#axzz47RPfhKqL
Malin, M (1990a). The Visibility and Invisibility of the Aboriginal Child in the Urban Classroom. Australian Journal of Education, vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 312-29.
Malin, M (1990b). Why is Life so Hard for Aboriginal Students in Urban Classroom?. The Aboriginal Child at School, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 9-29.
Ministerial Council for Education, Early Childhood Development and Youth Affairs (MCEECDYA). (2013). Retrieved via the web May 2016 from: http://www.mceecdya.edu.au/mceecdya/.
Munns, G. (1998). They Just Cant Hack That: Aboriginal Students, Their Teachers and Responses to Schools and Classrooms, in G Partington (ed). Perspectives on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
Education. Social Science Press, Katoomba, New South Wales, pp. 171-87
NSW Department of Education, (2016). Behaviour Management. Retrieved via the web on April 2016 from http://8ways.wikispaces.com/Behaviour+management
Richmond, C. (2007). Teach More, Manage Less: A Minimalist Approach to Behaviour Management. Australia: Scholastic.
http://www.etfo.ca/Resources/eResources/ResearchForTeachers/Lists/Research%20List/DispForm.aspx?ID=8
Sawyer. M, Arney. F, Baghurst. P, Clark. J, Graetz. B, Kosky. R, et al (2001). The mental health of young people in Australia: key findings from the child and adolescent component of the national survey of
mental health and well-being. The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry. 35(6):806-14.
SMH, (2008). 'The school of tough love. Good Weekend. pp.26.
St Vincent's Hospital Sydney Limited. (2016). This Way Up. Retrieved via the web on April 2016 from https://thiswayup.org.au/how-do-you-feel/stressed/
The Australian. (2014). 'Where are all the indigenous faces?', Dated 28/7/2014
Koori Mail. (n.d). 'Education, recognition hot topics at Garma', 482 p.3
ABC, (2016). 'Newcastle academic slams 'Eurocentric' education for indigenous students', Newcastle. Dated 19/1/2016
Villegas, T (2016). Donald Trump is Bad for Students With Disabilities in America. Retrieved from
http://www.thinkinclusive.us/tag/special-education-2/http://www.etfo.ca/Resources/eResources/ResearchForTeachers/Lists/Research%20List/DispForm.aspx?ID=8
Walker, R. Robinson, M. Adermann, J. Campbell, M. (2014). Working with Behavioural and Emotional Problems in Young People. Chapter 22 Part 5. Pp383-398. In Working together: Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander mental health and wellbeing principles and practice - 2nd edition. Telethon Kids Institute, Kulunga Aboriginal Research Development Unit, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet (Australia).
Retrieved via the web on April 2016 from http://aboriginal.telethonkids.org.au/media/673991/wt-part-5-chapt-22-final.pdf
Western Australian Primary Principals Association (WAPPA) (2012). Online Aboriginal Education. Department of Education retrieved via the web from
http://www.wappa.asn.au/oae/module4/mod4_part3.html
Zembylas, M. (2003). Emotions and teacher identity: A poststructural perspective.Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice,9(3), 213238.
Zubrick, S. Silburn, S. Larence, D. Mitrou. G, Dalby. B, Blair. M, et al. (2005). Western Australian Aboriginal Child Health Survey. The Social and Emotional Wellbeing of Aboriginal Children and Young People.
Volume 2. Perth.