:

% & '

( )'*

"# $

$2

(1390/4/1 [! uC n = 1389/6/7 H) + n =)

2# -E
X DV 6 N +

< "D=

5/[

!@) \) + ! + F { A
#

V 6

G,

:59

+ +H +# #G <

d &

5l ! #0 H

c%A
V 3

& +!C S !1 #Db

6 ^C % + .H # )!F Y@/ !9 %@
\ "D= @ G 3 I# ^_ H %/ ! #,(& I# - S +

iG * + T

HA l/ d/ !

.H # )!F !* - +

!@" #

!* - + !9 + !@"
6 6 + !@" !A % D0 FB
Q+ `
y5 6^C + %5 %V * V 3 ! + 3 :6 % S lV AHA l/
H # )!F
# A F

!U H G `) Y < + # A F

D V H G `) HG , +!)

Ad50

5l 6 6 2 & !
+HD V6
+ H& 5/ H + %- + !) 6 != !)

3 "N 5` # 6 `
5V#
H + V %

+! 0
0g

6 8 A!C

U5 #

+ +H +#

! [(= H

! f1

+ 5: C < "D=
5/[
+ 5 Q,
8 A AHA l/
. !F l
y F#
Ad !C # n C + Q ,
#G < H * !& + .% + + Y@/ 8
6 c%A ( & 5/[ S 8G )
5l
# TU

! .% # )!F !*
+ #0 H

%/

y`G j

%5 S ,

9 9E
!x= +

5V P = J

bahare.arvin@gmail.com
1390

> * 2G

+ HF < G

V 3 X DV Z 1

V 3 y`G j { X $
ATU V 3 X DV Z 1

95A!) !U
% 4 67 8 5'F

5/#` 3 ! 0+ .

1390

> * 2G

0 # ! + F ! l`= #
! l`= # ATU

+ HF < G

P =

c :@

5l ! + %-

% 4 67 8 5'F

:59

! l`= #

A 5 d C + +H +#

#)

5| A # D0 ! + F - !F% A

Z1

5l ! H

.H # )!F !* - +
%5 %V *

6 { A ! l`=

V 3 y`G j { X $ 6 c%A

X $ & 5/[ S 8G c%A

6 6

P =J

.+ %-

5 d C c :@

%/

5V c :@

V 3 y`G j {

6 H5 [ 3+ & TU :"# '3

95A A

@ = 5 !A +

xP/

,'[> Y Z
H

V 3 X DV 6 N + < "D=

.H # )!F Y@/ !9 %@
#E !

< "D=

i= @
f)

x<

#Db

.H

#Db

V 6

G , + +H +# #G <

!@) \) + ! + F { A

5/[
+

5/[

! #0 H

5/[ 6

y" D) 6 N + + 3

#0 H

X DV

5/[

A 9F+#

6 TA

f" #

A 9F+

- + + 3
6 #3 { #

& Q%

5A A

9 A #3 = X%V !U5 6

S+ <

#@ 6 d #Db
Q%
#3 =

v =%V * .TU /n =

! dP + #G < y + + .%lDI

! +

5/[

6 N + + 3

!1 N yG <
#

5A A

D0 P C +

9 A #3 = ! 0

+ &

!=T

T:E #

V 3

.% # )!F % + !9 + #3

l= /T ) V 3 ! /+!) H 5 V /H 5AW

5/[ 6 N + + 3 ?D P i= @ Yx" %<

!9 +

,!) - +

%/ # & +!C ?D P i= @ y

0 Yx" a!I

& +!C S !1 +

S * !F + %/ ! uC @ + 3
H [(= + #0 H

5l

X6r !U H "0 V 3 X DV

5/[ i= @ iD2

9 F + 6 % S lV A 9 F +

V+

G v =%V *

i= @ % 9 F% + 6 H"F % Q h
5/[ -

%/ # "F #0 5E

a!I Y * d !C

G , + +H +# c%A

% .% + V 3 X DV

S +

5l ! #0

+ + P:=

#0 5`

l V / 5`

d &

X %0 % 9 vr , !9 + S lV # # )!F Y@/

# n C

+ + Y@/ < "D=

S !1 v

:59

c%A

+!@

{ #3 =

5/[ ?D P i= @
+ S * #@5
i= @
5V#

A 9 F + # 6 TA

+<

F %lDI
0

!9 + G $

& Q%

+ 5: C < "D= +!@

0% -

iG * +

H <) ; +

% & '

yG Q, y

( )'*

6 ^C f* + .+6

$ S ,# #@D + 3
#

i= @

"# $

# "Fd C

A 9 F+#

lD %< S ,# t<) #

3 #

6TA g S 3 = X %0

6 TA

9 A #3 =

+ 5: C

5/[ 6 N + + 3

6 TA 5A A

+ 5: C

5/[

5/[ ! 0 + +

?D P i= @ + #0 H

.+ % + 3 A
\ "D= 6 % 9 # "Fd C yDb
# v !A T0H +

!@"

# n C + H

.H # )!F !

A+!@

S "=

6 { !A #0 +!0
! l`= 6 + "

T 50 + "

5E

:59

6 H5

H5 # { A #0 G N +
%3

: !C !@"

A+!@

%< 5

5| A .H

`*

#
6 %/ +

+!@

5l ! .+ / #
% D0

A"

A 6 # - +

!@" 6 { !A H5 ! + F
! .+ +

+!0 6 +!C# !U

* y" D) H5

+ ! +F

$ 5

# !F z xP .%

# !U

5V# #E
#3

+ + !* TA

AHA l/ !1 N yG < + H

+!0 `

% H
#0

%5

AHA l/

"\ "D=

@ "H -

&

%5

Q%

!9 + yG < + T

+ = 0 - 1 = !0W # t<) 3

#0

# F# H

#0 H
3

% :0

6 %50 !

AT + C
< "D= # D0
5E # #3 =
A+!@
uF

G 3

6 + # %N 6 d

%/ " 0 %/ V+

+<
!@"

%/ X $ - +
.H

?D P

A ! + / #3 = T A "

I # %5E!A %5 A \ "D= " @ " %550TA !) #0 - +

# Fd/

!U # Y o=Y *
50 + v =% V + /

F% + 6 #0 H 5l

!U y U5 iG * + %

+ 5

% %< ` #0 T 50 #3 = < "D=

A}!)d C # #@

%< 5

+ < H (<V

\ "D= " @ " 6 d !C #0 H

F6

! 0

!@"

!U # 5l

S+ <

!U

- +

#0 G N + %

A+!@

& 5/[

5` #

!@"

iG * +

5l ! .+ + \D`= @ = 5 !A H5 # ! + F H \D`

S !U 6

+#"

! - +

6 `

- +

:59

< "D= 8 E!A #" D) [

#E

a!I

= "

+ + \D`= D D-= y" D) H5 #

A

A+!@

#" D) 6 N + "D P i= @

AS "=

5| A .% \D`

!* , & P = J

AS "=

5/[

5V + #0 5E

5/[ 6 N + !@" #

+ & ! `= 6 T A P !F f* + .% \D`
!@"

% TA #G <

!@"

A+!@

AHA l/ 6 { !A +

1390

> * 2G

# #@ Q H

+ HF < G

!1 = %< y @ # !0W - Y, # +

.%/ %A & # & +!C V 3 X DV

+

:59

%5

6 { !A #0 H

!@"

X DV y" D) 6 N +

%3

A% C

f* +

+ +

< + { = 5 !A #0

& 5/

" D)

6 N + v xP: #0 H

#E!F H
:

!:=

! 6 %/ %A & + %0#

%5

) D)# H

!@"
S !U

U5 H

%/ # "F P

+ .H

#)

" D)

%5

!U +

#% V

{ !

6 .H
5/[

H +#

! 0+ y

- uG H

% !

!@" #

< "D=

++ x * iG * +

! !9 +

5 N S !1 v

!5

!2

A% C

l=

1=

Y 0

#@D %$5F

& +!C

<j5

+ ) Y@/ 6

= H %A &
X$

H D0

+ 3!A #@ X +

- Q N v =% V #0 H

!@"

!&o

5V + "% +" B #@ H

P: HGr+ #G <

5` # !1 N - #0 5`

`* dA gC { !
C + % 9 iP 5
V 6 N + G N 5/[ { y

+%

T<

V 3 X DV y" D)

% 0o= # @

:59

& 5/[

#0 H)!F #$

6 N + %-

`*

V 3

!& ! (/

AdA gC

% + # D0

%: \lj5 %/X =
H

+!0 !U

#E!F + % 8

.+ : %/ #

D+

z & y !U 8

1 = #0 T 50

) H + 6 V - +

5/[

I#

V 3 X DV y" D) 6 N # t<) A
!:

$ 5 y !U [ m 6 { A

H,!) + t<) # A#l53 y A + A

+ & [(=

!) H

6 H != %/ # & 5/ V 3 X DV y" D)

$ 5

. V 3 X DV y" D) 6 N +

!0W

# / uF ! mo= V 3

6 +!C# !U # 9 { A !@" #

+ & S! / % V dP 8
!@"

3 P:

V 3 X DV y" D) 6 N +

#G <

6N

6 #@

+! F " D) 9 +

# % 50 9 Q M

6 N + #E!F 8 ! + F .%/ + %

!@" 6 { !A

!1 H 3

! #0 %5 A

#E!F ( V 3 X DV y" D) + 5

{ = 5 !A #

6 dC

5/[ 6 N + v )!, - +

!@" #

X DV #" D) 6 N +
+

% 4 67 8 5'F

5/[
5/[

% .H

# /+

50 = H

< "D=

5/[

#E!F

: yDN! # 6 5A 0u dA gC

+ D* %N M- a!I % + v )!, !1 N
.H # "Fd C

% & '

( )'*

"# $

\0 4
+ V 3 X DV c%A [
y" D) Sr h # + 3
#

Z1

An C ? I !

+i@

!=# 3! #0 5`

#E

% H i= @

% / 5`

! 5
!

!@"
+6

QN

!A
.+ /

6 #

Y G+ # #@ T2 DV .%
+ - +

!@"

`*

5` # Q % y

+!0 %A &

+Y 0
-

An C

I#

v `*

!@"

Ad !C # d, &

! #0 3
@

An C

{ +8 ? I

6 %/ # "F #0 5E

AS !1 \ "D= X " \ *%=

V 3 X DV 6 N + #
i= @

A Fg
+ !1 N

!={ +8 ! { # #@D H

H Dj

!U # #3

V 3 X DV

< "D= H A

V 3 X DV y" D)

a!I

!*

< +i@ +

V 3 X DV y" D) S +
+/

!U #

& 5/[ i @

% .% ! F

<D= != + !9 + ! 6

c%A \<-= # c j`
Q %

Y <= #

3 i= @

@ # v < *+ 5= #

6 # D0 !

% .%50 % C a!I
++

Ad !C # n C + %

+ + #0 + + + 3 8

6 %5

- 9 3 = % %/ a!I !9 %@
A

+ # F#

5/[ i= @ 6

A#

Q % HA

.%/ # / % Y 0 lj 6 N
S%N
& 5/

fl= # Z 1 H : # #0 Q y + !@"
A c%A

H:A iG * + % %< `

V 3

:+!0 #,(& ! 6
(

(H `*
V 3 X DV

`*

5V#

& 5/[
c!I

l=

? , = P:=

& 5/H)!`
.1

V 3 % %C HG , .2
ATU y`G j .3

& 5/H)!`
Y<

`* + 3 #

V 3 X DV + H 5 V #
? , = 6 !l ` /H +

` lI X DV

9E _@ ) V 3 % / !@=

` lI X DV +

!U #

& 5/[

5l ) AW 6 Y<

+ !) 6 Y<

H +

l # := .4
! [(= .5

! f1 + 3 #

.6

A ` +3 #

.7

!l ` /H +
V 3 H `* ; + 5 d C + +H +#
1. Ideal type

10

! [(= .8

l=

1390

X DV Z 1
V 3

> * 2G

+ HF < G

A S "= # #0

!@"

` lI X DV

S "

% 4 67 8 5'F

& 5/[ f1

& 5/[

& 5/H)!`

S "= #

& 5/

!U # Y < +

fl= #

A c%A

V 3

` lI

H:A iG * + % %< `
:6 % S lV #0 +!0

H
(H `* 6 ?D P !

"=

AW y & !

V 3 H `*

+ =) H `* # # !F6 % T:E F% + #

+ !)

Ad50 f 3 Y, N

5V#

+ 3 Y G+ #

` lI

V 3 X DV

& 5/[

d50

& 5/H)!`

!@"

N l

+ ]

l=

lV H5V

Y < + 5 dC
X DV

& 5/[ f1

!1 N -

< "D= H A

! [(= .6

! f1 + .7
!U # 5l

V 3 ! TU 6 H S lV

S "= # Y *
6

A F !x5V

"= + }!VTA .8

A B % D0 %

% + T A & # + + .T ) ! "= 5`

+ 5`

Y<

. l V -G # H `* 6 ?D P !
S%N

l S "= .5

!9:50 H 5AW T )
c!I

.3

P = ! y`G j .4

Ad50 +
5`

.1
.2

V 3 H `*

+!)# !x-5

!@"

& 5/[

N l + ]

A B % D0

P = ! n = :6 H S lV V 3

+ = !1 #E i @ +

A B % D0

` lI
+ #0

.H/ + %A &
#

9 3H

!U # .T 50
#

T !l
`

V 3 X DV

C#

- S +

V 3 X DV y" D)
5/[ y" ()

!@"

!@"

G 3

D0

?I +8
? I + !@" #

! #@ 6 d C
- +

!@"

9 3%

:%/ T != Y * ! 6 Y@/
& 5/[ S "=
` lI X DV
V 3

! +F

:59

11

{ A

& 5/[ S%N

` lI X DV
V 3

% & '

X DV

( )'*

"# $

& 5/[ S "= # Y * !@" ? I ! #

& 5/[ S%N ? I !@" #

#3 = #0 + + #

`1

.+! F !* ! "= +

?I !

+&

A +"

v( V

!F + !A

{ A Y < + H + { +8
.+!0 + % D* { +8

+!A

6 % =

+"

y F#

!@"

5/ #G <

= %<

5`

5`

T)

+ - +

5` # f*

{ y
# H

\ "D= v
!@"

+ !@) \)

` %N + 3
!F #0 H

!* ? I
5E

i@ {
- +

- +

AHA l/ G 3

@ N l
Q+ `
#: v l

!U +

!
-

AHA l/ .% %/

+ %

5l

!U # .T 50

! .
5E

5` v

%/# )! uC

! - +

!@"

FB iG * + ?D P

12

! l`=
AHA l/

- +
\ "D= % ! F
@ TA6

@/

+ 6 %N =

A+!@

T A"

!@" #

iG * +

5` + 3 #0 H + !9 + !@"
S "

:59

6 .H/ + %A P + 3 \ "D=

+!@

6 6

< Z !A #0 %5/ S " !9 %@

!U # .+ / 5

5 :59

# +! F
! "=

AS "=
Dx-

I# # + + H

HA l/ ?:0 %
V

!1 "\ "D="

FB #0 % %3

!@"

Z $ 6 = %/ %A &

A+!@

@ #@ 6 d C v =%V *

+ H !@" !A
@

AS "= #0 3

- .3

- ! : X $

5` # v =%V * \ "D=

S !U

@
& 5/[

% .H

+ & %V *

!@" !F !9 + c!I 6

!@" #

y Fd/

\ "D=

+ v( V #0 %5/ # / + HA l/ !9 %@ #

+ / <D= "G f k * A

Ad5 6

9 )'*

6 6 # 6
@/ .H

f* +

!E .H

!U5 6 \ "D= ? !`= !F %

! + F ! l`= # !9 + !@"
+!0 u& !@" #

" D)

#0 5`

\ "D= .%

!@"

F+! F #

* !9 + + V 3 X DV ; +

+ !@" #

)0

:59

+ +H +# T A+ !* - +

!U y5 6^C X %0 +

X $ #G <

[ " D) 9 +

"

` lI

` lI X DV

+ + !* 6 Y@/

AH

V 3

V 3

% +!0

C +
B 6

! + F 5l

& 5/[ i @ + !A !@" 6 X %0!A H"F

! - +

.H) %A & ! :

:59

+ d T0 8

?I

\ "D=
- +

A#: % + !@" !A
6

!@"
FB

A 6 # \D`= Y G+ #

1390

m # +5

> * 2G

v(x"

+ HF < G

!9 + yG <

% 4 67 8 5'F

+ #0 !@"

A+!@

y Fd/

:6 % S lV % %/ %5
"

" : 35

+ %5 %V * V 3 !
#

.%50

# % 50 9

1_<

+ M-

6 H5

C #0 H }!)
!)

.H

5V

% (]7

5V

+ 5 y"Gh

+!)

5/[

! + F + (138-142 :1382

` T A"

% 0o= +

6 6

!@"

AH) +
:59

! +FX "

!U # .H

# F#

#) +

6 { !A #0 5`

F{ :

! !@"

y: % + V 3
6

:59

A 6

%5 %V *
2

3 !:=

[ 3+ & TU

% .%/ #3

Ad50 y5 6^C

5| A 214-216 :1381 ^ D F 44 30-33 :1381

yj %

#0 + +

A+3 v

>

y: % + # :

TA !) " V 3 " X DV 6 N + #

(195 :1382 ! G C # % 50 9
X " #

+ 3 }!) !@" #

6 6 ? !`=

# 2# N

Q%

!) P =
5V

z x&

{ A +

X V !9 %@

5` N 6 Q N V + + % + 3 !9 + !@" X " + Y`5G Y`5G \ I

.+ + : ! 6 Y@/ iG * + !9 %@

X " #

yj

% / f* + .H ~! :

6 6

6 H5
P =TU
[ 3+ &

,!

$ " U!

y: % 6 Y ,
8

+!)

H-= # + !)

76 / (
83

+!)

,!

$!

V 3 y5 6^C

%V * !j

76

7 = (`

Ad50 y5 6^C + %5 %V * !

Ad50 ! %5 %V * ( V 3 ) +!) !) !
Ad50 % V dP

'

1!)d C
H-= v lG 2 #@D

1. Language game
2. Spontaneous order

13

5E

! mo= F

+ 3 !F v =%V *
%/

!@"

.+ %A & P:= Y *
+!) A F

&

+ ! mo=

% & '

H A

( )'*

5` X + y"Gh

+ #0 + /
{ A

# #0 H

!$5 # A F

"# $

!j

#E ! mo=

A + %A & %5 = %*

!U H G `) Y < + # A F

T ) + %& iG * + ! + F

D V H G `) HG ,

+ 6 +! 0 iG * +
.H

T ) + %&

! 9 C Y * Z 8

:59

5A!) iG * +

6 +! 0
5A!)
Z8

C
A Fg
! A
yj

'

+ 6 #0 H T

%N #E =

#j

% a)W :"1 G 6
6

N #0 + + c!I +

H %5 %V *
#

>

&

5E #0 H

@/ .H

A 6 .H S "
HD V#

# % 50 9 ! + F
{ A

y: % + 6 `

+! 0

A #@ #D 3 6 .H !: y !$= + +!)# !x-5

= N T

5/ Z 1

%5 %V * S !1 5` ! & #3 +

iG * +

!@"

(V

+ 6 # l:= +! 0 +

%5 5/ yj

.H 5`

6TA #3 = S !1
+! 0 +

6% { #

5@ 6 + 3
&#

6 X$
g

% QN V +

!9 6 + 3 S !1 ! A

+) +6

6 `

+ 189-194 :1382 ! G C 33 :1381 !

.(19 :1381 + g 52 # % 50 9
#

1 *

, # 3

1 b$

>

3;

. 1 -) ,

V 3 !
! FY@/ # H + #0 %5 !) %5506 2 !@" # !A y: % +
V 3 !
#E!F #0 5` % .H
+!) Ad50 +!) + / T & %5 %V *
!U H G `) ! F + &
D V H G `) HG , H A 5`
<j5 y$
%5 %V *
!
! FY@/ 5l
+ + !@"
+
- d< F + &
+ Fg
6 # G Z(I ! ) H
+!) Ad50 +!)

AH G `)
Z(I ! 5| A 163-164 :1381 !F
A # % 50 9
:59 #: %
5l # #3 = S !1
.(309 :1377 X(0 l 6 # % 50 9 { A #: % +
:
+! 0 #0 5@ 6 + 3 S !1 # #3 = iG * + 8 6 `
+ # lG # !F+!)
14

1390

> * 2G

+ HF < G

% 4 67 8 5'F

# #3 =
! % 0o=

Q N V + .+ # )!F !* #3 = + %5A+ X $
6 ! T0 N %V *
5E #0 !9 + %5 : % # < + z xP # !F+!)
0g
5l
.+ /
% % +!) 6 6 2
% 0o= 5E vr ` H != * A + & # #3 = y 6 #0 %5 : % v xP:
.% % V 3 &
! FY@/ %5 !)
0g
# !F+!) 5l !
3=
A % %C Y D-= %5 !) 6 2 S "= + # A 6 != / % / = " #3 = % 0o= 5E
! !@"
+!A #0 G N + .%/
+ Y * !
0 + AH5 + V 3
+!) # % %C
! FY@/ 6 2 ! + %550 % 0o= +!) !) V 3 % %C HG ,
A% C"
5V
- X " iG * + ] %=# #0 H i 5
Ad50
#@5 # T 0 + +
+ / Y %l= X 8G V 3 % %C # "
d50 y &
H A #0 !E +! F
S , ! TA % 0o= !x= + / " Y0 # 6 2 5E
6 - + !@" # ! "F = !U5
6 .+ % V 3 % %C Y D-= + %5E
H5 # %5 %V * V 3 !
! FY@/
0g
# !F+!) 5l # #3 = !U
.% !={ +8
5/#` 3 + !
5/[
6 6
%5 %V *

S D0 + 5`
+! 0 k !
S D0 +! 0
+!)
6
P =-

[ 3+ & TU

6 H5

<D= 5l ! +!) d50

d A6
%V * 6

P = \)

%V * 6 +!) <D=
d A6

T)
!FY o=

15

% & '

( )'*

c ! de
+

y
A

5/[

:59

#5

5E y

<

\j5

6 6 {
Y %l=

+!@

A 6
:59

C +

! uC # 3!= !
6 Z(I

3 A #0 5`

% ) %5 A
( D V

+ T

A[(=

+!@

+!@

}!)

% h !9 %@
:59

+!0 U
@

# % 50

P =J

H5 + &

+ 6 v )!,

DV) AH)!`

=#

<

F% 6 Y V 6

dP

& + #0 TA = D` 6

+!) !A #0

%A :

/ +#I N H

0 T <= + #0 H
0

@ !2 ! 8 % +

U ,"

5= H)!` #0

D V H)!` 6 H S lV #0 + +
! 6

+!) A #0 5| A .+ /

F F

& + #` 3 + !) #0

,"

A% C #

AxP=

f* (

5/H)!` + ! f1

! f1 A H !9 %@ 6 TA ?D P + !) H& 5/ !F f* +

+ + !) ?D P
.+

D<V H)!` # !x-5

+ %

A V+ T<

H-, ; + S * #

v =%V * H + 6 H + H& 5/ P:=

GN +

!&o

%< `

A 155-156 :1381

Y @:=

H& 5/ y5 6 + # !F l

#0 + % + 3

:59

DV S , # #0
.+!

.>! 1 A

H& 5/

5l

+ !) ! t - H5 8 ! + F y: % +

.(14-13 :1381 :+ g 52) H

% $

#0 + % + 3

! +!@

!9 + H)!` #@D H

3+

/+ # + *

= V(I

S !U # Z 3 .+6 H + %N

5 # % 50 9 )H

% H)!` T <= .%A+

+ !) X = S D` Z $ ! #I N # + * +!) A .% +

#5 +

5`

AH)!` X %0!A #0 %/ Y @:= + !) 6 #` 3 8 { A !U +

G +!0 %5 S ,
H

X%<

66

)!F !*

Y o= %V * ?:0

T 50 #3 = !F z xP H
+ 3 !=f

!F

.(33-34 :1381 !

!=T 6

H& 5/ H + %- }!) + + C

! ) H ! f1
% .H

H5 Y o= #@D + % + 3
z&

< #

6 # A 6 y A Y %l=

f1

A}!)

A !9:50 + % + 3

:59

.(116-121 :1381

+ %-

+ !U

; +

H5 6 &

#0 (2

y: % + .H ! f1 +

6 { # A 6 y 3!=

A% C #0 !@" #

! f1 A %

"# $

/ # ! f1 + }!) <j5 % C #
16

S ,
5/H)!`

)!F !*
+ H& +!C
!F l

1390

> * 2G

5/H)!`

!F l

X + + %/

+ ; ++ &

A A!

#
%V *

+ HF < G

% 4 67 8 5'F

)!F 6 8 A!C

:59

.%5A+ H + # H + 6 H + 8

A B H + 6 H + +! 0 P:=

Y o= P:=
[ 3+ &

! % +!0 ` !@" # !A #0

` %50

` + + `

ATU + 95A A + $ }!) { A

%/ # )!F }!) H `*

157-158 :1381

:59

9E _@
# % 50 9 )

f1

& 5/[

dC

S "= #

6 +! 0 +

N !@" # !A #0 %A+

s !) 6 ; 5 3

= lV#

[(=

\ "D=

9 A 95A A

S !U H"F

6 8 A!C

3 # #3 =

%/ #

/(=

+ Z 1 y`G j [
#@ H

+ +

D, c%A .H

+ .% +

H <)

[(= 6 %/ # "F #0 5E

* 5

:P X $

.4

+ ( V 3 X DV +
++ #

+&

A Fg #E H E V 3 X DV Z 1

v - D= V 3 X DV 6 N + %/# & 5/
8 !1 N yG <

# n C + "D P

y@
!@"

:P X $

5E ^" #@D A[(=

! - +

( )'*
V 3 X DV c%A v

)!F % +

t<) # % + \)

d !C

! T

.+ +

H # 9E

Yx" - %5 6

; + S * # !1 N -

H `* ?D P

/
0 #@ 6

#@5 .% + + X $ H `* * 5 v !A 3 #
%A / X %0!A #0 H

6 d C #0 !

\ "D= +%, + % 9 YM

# F %3

%< ` ? I !U

6TA + 3 .+

* 5 Y, +

X%V

# !F l

5/[ S%N #

AQr%

#0 H

: - S +
%

S * % h
H <)

ATU + 95A A { A +

A[(= + & %5 ! H `*

#@D H

:59

!U Q , 83 T & +!C

: A+!@

+ %N #E = A

9E _@ ! + F + (47-49 :1384 !=

)!I 6 .H #
%< `

AH& 5/ 9 "/ + 3 *

95A A }!) #0 T + +

H& 5/ H + %-

+ %50 #1!V H + 6 H +

6 d C .(80-83 :1381 + g 52 # % 50 9 ) [ 3+ &

9E _@

xP/

95A A !@" # !A y: % + v

(132-133 :1387 S!/ # % 50 9 )

Q , 83 H `*

@ = 5 !A + a!I ! + F .%A+ H + #
.H * 5

+) H

& 5/[

5/[ Z !A %
# F#

17

Ad !C

A}!)d C)
!U # H E

P C v N !,

% & '

( )'*

"# $

\ "D= 6 %/ # "F #0 5E #0 P C .H
d/ .H

% H +#

V 3 X DV

.%5 A + 5: C
X6r

5/[

52 + / -G A

S lV # H) %5A &
A% C

5` 6

+ !@" # !A
A

5/[

:P - +

V 3 X DV + #`G j +
6 H5

: +

+# :

Q, 6

!@"

Z1

ATU

!@"

0#

{ A ! l`= # TU S lV

+ #0 5`

# ! + F ! l`= #

:59

P =

+%` !, 5V

! l`= #

T A+ #
+3 A

#<

#0

6
=

A 6 # \D`

+ 5: C

5E TU 6

P =

5/[

F% + 6
FB 6 {

!@" 6 { !A

+ & ! l`= { A .H # )
I l=

+ 6 HP #0 T A+ X $

A .H/ + %A & + 3 %/
TU #0 H

% D0 T A "

.1.4

U %

U5
@

A 5 d C Y* %N

#` 3 !A #0 H 1

%/ + $ # % V #@5
% :H # "F # 3!

5E + S " Z

A 5 d C #V $ %5A+Y @:=
!

V
y`G j

+%$ ! "= H D * !9 %@

`1 ? , = #: A TU 6

%/ # / + 5`
X$

5/[

A # v xP: S lV

#0 %5 A !9 %@

+ - -,

% + 06 H +

vr ` #@5 8

5/H)!`

6 ([ 3+ & TU B % D0 iG * + g # )

+ #0 H

&! H& 5/ T

! l`=

!9 +

F6 # # + +

% H # / + +! 0 - +

:%A+
!, 5V 6

5/[ J #

V 3 X DV

V 3 X DV Z 1

A B % D0 iG * + #0 +

cuN

!A + H& +!C T A & #`G j X $ 6 c%A

% & ' g e
D,

#0 1 =

6 { !A

E 5`

.%5

:59

G , 6 P:= Y * 8 =

x< E+ Q ,

+ TA 50 + - +

!A .H P = J

P C + +H +#

* t<) Q ,

Ad !C # n C iG * + # Fd/ Q ,

# 9E #0 + + T A &
J

+ 5 Q , f* + d C dP + %/!0W HA l/

+3

y F#

Ad !C

5/[ 6 N + ! + F { A

.%/ %A &
+ - +

.+ +
5E

V 3 k 5/

1. L. S. Stebbing. A Modern Introduction to Logic (London, 1933), p. 228:When

we know how a set of elements is ordered, we have a basis for inference. See also
Immanuel Kant, Werke (Akademie Ausgabe), Nachlass, vol.6, p. 699: Ordnung ist
die Zusammenfugung nach Regeln.

18

1390

+&

> * 2G

A 0# H

+ HF < G

6 { A + l
1

6 ! 8F

A6

iD2

lj X8D
T A+
+

+ !

) %A %
Y@/
%A+

S + V #0

+
t

G v l !<= .H

U
#0 H
+6

Q+ `= +

= %*+
.H

@ A
= U
A

#E

F6
D`) y`G j

# !@"= @ )

C!

% 2 .H

!@"

+ HDV

++!F

+ %5 C +

!F % *

&

5` %/ HV I

A% !)

A ) + \ !I 6
5`

0!A

Q N!A#

( 6 ! ) X U 6 &

A ! \ !I 6

+ 6 # ) \<-=

G+ `= YM 6

6 H +

(66-67 :1382 { A) H

!9 +
+ #0 H

V TU

/ v( 0 TU X " y !F % *

V y !U #0

+ S 3

<G

\ j .H

l= ! #D D #` 3 Y0

+ TU X "
6

%50
v

F% 6
+6 +!_

#0 3

/ S U

%)!I iD2

5 l % #` 3 + TU ! l`=

d % C# +< V 6

5V#

5E d % C 9 9E ~ +

; l-

`= # A )

!=

F% 6 + .+ + %5A & X $ v `*

0 t = #E

"

V 3

F F Q @/ #

: ?D P + !) Q V 6

+ #0 H

! #` 3

%/ + + i =!=

.+ /

d= 3 N

AW { a!I %x* Y, N TU
x= H

!F .+ + + 3

y C! T + !9 + Q V

+ & TU

Z1

.%50 + !

0 !9C T

A# !

A S ,#

% 4 67 8 5'F

+ Q+ `=

/ 3+ & TU .+ %

+! 0 + +

%/ + $ TU { S , x&

S "

1=
= , x&

.(H { A 6 S % 0o=

A^ C )

V 3 #3 + t<) # #0 { A y: % + TU X " g S , x&

+

Ad50

A% C 6 #

&

5V

V 3 TU + 3 S , +" ! uC 5 d C l

#& !

A Y G+ #
5V#

@ " ! !x= Y G+ # #@D + /

!) 5= H5 X " #E!F T #

+ 3!

[ 3+ &

5V# H5 6 + & A { A + % TU X "

ATU 6

{ A ! l`=
H", #

* %x

!) 5= #@5
+

8 TU

!F g # H

! + F H5 X " #
+

%: !x=

%5 = %*

P =

X "

#0 H

6 Q N V + .+!

+ 5
X

! { A y: % + + % TU X " 6

1. E. E. Evans-Pritchard, Social Antropology (London, 1951), p. 49; see also ibid.,

p.19.
2. L. S. Stebbing, op. cit., p.229: Order is most apparent where man has been at
work.
3. J. Ortega y Gasset, Mirabeau o el Politico (1927), in Obras Completas (Madrid,
1947), vol.3, p.603: Orden no es una presion que desde fuera se ejerce sobra la
sociedad, sin un equilibrio que se suscita en su interior.

19

% & '

+ 5

I#

( )'*

"

A # - +

# #0 5| A % +

6 +

+ s 6 { !A

TU f*

+ .T %

x-

A ! + F #0 H
)!F % +

"# $

P =J

P =v A

!6

A Fg

- +

83 #@D TU

#0 H

+ 5

I#

AB

5`

6 TU S lV % 6

6v A
"
# .% +
!@"

x< E+ H `* 6

!@" 6 ! `=

,& 3

\ "D=

5l !

:+!0 !x= P = J
H)!` T <= k ! { A #0
! +F
6

Y o=

#0 5E .% +

FB #0

5`

H& 5/ 5l

P =J

5`

A#
Fg

- +

A+! 0 %3

% =

!@"

H& 5/ Z !A ! uC

Y 0 H& 5/ ! uC
! f1
F6

+ %5
E+

Fg
& 5/[

+ 5: C

.1

+ :F

:59

6 8 !F

)!`

!F l

6 ! 2 H& 5/
#

3=

{ A
A yj #

# v 8G Y 0 H& 5/

A Fg !9 +

5/[ X U

y: % +

! [(=

5` # Y 0 H& 5/

+ 5

=# 8F!A #0 H

!F l

Q N V + .H

F%50 !C

C H

ATU

! 5 .+ %A P ! uC @ #: A

}!) 8 !C C + #0 5E .%/ %A P !$5

X%V = lV#

Y 0 H& 5/ +

x= Y *

#0 % + T A & # + + #E!F .%/ %5A P ?:@5

! uC

+ ! t - TU H& 5/

+ %A P

+ / % %3

ATU

A# A

A B % D0 - +

.%/ %A &
+

:59

! +!)# !x-5 S % 0o= z & ! `= -G # A

+

P = J
#0

! uC

ATU

# F# H #

TA

.+!0 %A & * 5=
.( $ %= %50 S ! w= ! % 0o=
H G `)
! w= S @

+!

0 # { A #0

A 9G 6

<D= 6!I + !:= # Q -=

9G

l= + = " v( 0

:H %< `

%50

)!`

5` # ) +

HV 5, B % D0 + a!I { A

A ! F#$ #

G -= F% + # %< `

G -= .2

+ & .+ /

F% + 6 #0 +6 +!C
!$5 A

S + + #E 6 S " ( 0 5` + X "
{ A #0 H 1 =
/ :Construction .1
^ @= k
0 ATU
S 8 = iG * + ! : C #0 +!
0# H ]
5/#` 3
.H %/ / # # ) %/ ATU Z 5x ATU

20

1390

> * 2G

v l !<= =%

% +3 #

y ) TU HDx& #0 +
Q V

A+

# DV TA

#0

a!I

+!)

F% +

I # #@D H

!9 +

U5

A !F # #0 % %/ "N H 3

%50 6 l

F% +

% !@"= T )

# %/ N !I V %
1

D r+ # 6 2 + #0

6 5` TA%$A !* 6

%/ 6 2 + #0 + /

D V

6 %+
.% % :P

* "=

!=! % +

+!0

TU5

= ,

yNG+

S x= H <=

.(29 :1382 { A) %/ !x= a 1 # #0 + #" D)

%/

@ A

.% ! !U # :N H
# #@D TU
#0 5`

% .H

" iG * + #0 +

%/ !0W #`G j +
+

P =

+ #`G j +

% 0o=

#@D #l/{

:59

TA

#/ H V 6
; + + !)
.% +
#

A
0#

Y r+

I +

+ 5 # S ! w=

[ 3+ &

! uC

%3 83

ATU

ATU

P =

.%5A+

: !=d C #0 5E . + %5 %V * .3

A 6

&

V 3

%5 %V * !

#0 % +

:59

+!) !) A

Y ! 5 t<) # %V *

%5

`l= %5 A A
.H

1. Growth
2. Evolution
3. Practices

21

,&

( V 8 ) D0 %V *

%5 %V * 8

! l`= #

iD2 + #0

5`

.H

6 ! 8F A %V * #E!F #0 H X6r # @

% .H

F+ & +

GN +

P = J

ATU + 3 { A .% # / +
6

!9:50 +!)+!)
! w= + !) H

! % 0o= #0 H

5AW <D= + < V # s 5 + & H V

f1 + !) #0 5`
#@D %50

= ! w=

{ A TA %/ + +

A 83 #

$ %= %50 S ! w= ! !x= % 0o=

X " # ! #0 % + %5A & + & #

$ %= %50

5V + #0 P =

# X "

TU

+ G -=

G -= +%$ !x= H

Z1

%/ W P=

C ! # DV TA H

F% + f* + .% %3 y !F+!& y" D) ! mo= H-=

#3 =

I#

) r V #0 #` 3

%/ ? , = 2Q -= ^_

v( 0 S , #

# A #0

H/ + !* !Ff5, H 5AW Z `:G H-= Y 0

%5 !) 6 +! F

% 4 67 8 5'F

+ 6 ] %=#

/ t<) + /

! #0 %5 !) .H
W P=

+ HF < G

%V *
! % 0o=

HA

% /

%550 wD

6 H `l= 6 ! 8F
+!) y A F

P:

% & '

+ 6 `
TU

( )'*

+! 0.H

%5

# F#

.%/

iI P % =

%V * xP/

X$ 6

8F!A H

Hm

6 X " (I +

+ &! T2 DV + & H A
6 T$5C Fg #0 H #

% H

6 !

U S ,

T0 N

83

) #0

5 dC
? !`= ! 5

TA #3 +

Y V + ! mo=H-= %A+

+8

c :@ #0 H X + Y V + 3 Y G+ #
(H

Y 0 c :@ #0 T +!0

C +

P =J

! uC @

+!)

& 5/[ S 8G
T +!0 + !

ATU

v =%V * .+ + ! A #
P =

ATU

Fg

T ) .5
TU ! T0 N
TU

Ad50 \ *+ 5 d C

% & '

3 TU 6

6 d C) #`G j +

" i : <)

+!0 #`G j

%5E

`= X%V 6

<D= V 3 X DV Z 1 # "Fd C Fg ]5C ! A #

!9 + S lV #

l 5

+! 0 + + !) S

.+6

#E!F.H

+ #0 + !) d50

%V *

A % %C

5 dCY *Y 0

6 #0 !E .H/ +

ATU

+ #0 !E)

@8 )

5E !F .+ %A P

A H

5V 6 !

A 6 y$

.+6
%V * :H

.4

ATU H A 1 =

6 ! T0 N TU + 3

! uC @

6 TU H A

!9 6 #0 5`

+ 6 %N =

! uC 5 d C

P =#`G j +

A P Q+ +! 0 # 6 $

5 dC Y*

H `j*

V 8 S - 1 = #-", A + % / #0 %A+

! T0 N TU ^53 6 Q N V + (+
TA %/

"# $

6 ! T0 N TU ^53 6

HA ~+ +

T0 N TU #@5

.2.4

P =J

# 9E #0 H

ATU !F

%` d !C T 50

& 5/[ S 8G #E ATU

6 TU T A " 6 #0 H

y`G j

, & ! `= 6 `l5 + &

:6 % S lV

+ & d50 6 A

5`

!@" # !A T "F
+ !) 6 != !)
S !1

+ !) # "Fd C

6 d C #0 5E .H # A F

5V#
%/ + +
.H

T 50

x= c :@

++ & %5

!) 5= #E!F #0 T A+

%550
: Yx"

ATU y`G j 6 2 yj< .1

%/

6 2 # !F+!)
I # s !

+
0g

!* % 0o= #3 = +
22

5l 6 - +

5V Y W + #0 5E 8 .%5

+!0 !:= !9 + 6 !=P: { A

S 83 !0W 6 N l

iD2 + #0 H

!@=
#@ %

& 5/[

!F+!)

X(0 yG I 6 8 A!C
!F+!)

5l

; %j<)

1390

> * 2G

#3 = Q N V + H
6 + !) S x=
t<) # 8

%: !x= A

6 T<

D`3

A# "F % #0 H
D<

Ad50 6

+6

5`

5`

c :@ #

# #@

.+ / i 5 d50

H/ 9 A

::50

5` ?:0

TU5 %A :

%5 6

H + A

# S

5/

! : a!I

+ 3 S x= S U

5` # %50

5` 6

! [(=

! 6

+ != !) D V S
D3

@ 0 v 8G

+ & !U + #E

Ad50

! !

iD2 + + & d50

Tl A

%: + %- S !1 T

# iD2 + !) #0 H
5` ?:0

x=

D3 %/

A}!)d C ! `=

+ !@) S 8G H 3 6 A
%/

v * "= #@D %50

A# "F + % ?*
A

F+ &

A 5` %50

G N S x=

+ + % { A

!1 !9 + !@"

d !C H

# %/? !-=

% 4 67 8 5'F

5` #@ Q .H

# + !) +!0 +
+ !)

+ HF < G

+ !)

F+ & S ,

j 6 H ! 8F

% + !) !U + #E

% :0 dG E #

.% H + %/
y`G j #0 5`
j

% .H # !F+!) j

+ +/

# #3 = .%
Y l* 6

<=

62

+ % ?*

::50 6 + !)

+!) !) P = J

= 3=

% =

x=

8F!A

!5

V 3 y`G j .%50 !x-5 Ad50 6

+) +!& j

6 ) ATU
# H + %-

!F

+ 6
]

6 TU 6 &
TU

# +

x=

?*

+) +

5` c :@ #

",=

+ & ( (0

6 ^C % v = !1 + & " V 3 " H A

Ad50 +!)

+!)

ATU !9 +
5` c :@ j

Ad50 Z $

N .%5/ # )!F Y@/

dI l=

E %5E

+ %/+ %-

5`

V 3 %5 !) + \<- H0 : S !1 .2
Av

+ % +3

6 ! 8F

P =J

P =J

l V % + T A & # + + #0 I
% H

ATU

# #@

5 l= Y <

N %A+ !* - +

6 ) \ <-= +

%/ ! : #`G j +

% #0 5`

+!)

%/ Y D-= a j !9 + + + 3

6 TU +
P =J

( +

@ "? , =" # !x-5 #`G j { !F

.H

+ #`G j

+!) !) TU c :@

!=+!& + ATU

#E!F + 3

V 3 y`G j #0 H 5`

+ #`G j Y <
& v lG 2

5` c :@

ATU j # % v = !1 %

j
6 #

! ! 8 # @

+ #`G j +

! f1

6 TU c :@

6 TU + 6

23

6 :( P =

! \<- H

! \<- S

A #0 !E .+ %A & !=!l `
P =J

#0 3

%*!A .H

y`G j 6 % H +#

6 TU c :@ 6 % H +# ]

% & '

( )'*

!=\ V ~ + #
! x=

#`G j ]

"# $

#@ # % !

! .%5 %

F% + 6 #`G j +

TU #

A# "F 6

) != !)

<=

# #3 =

%/

v )!, #

`*

=H

!1 #`G j +

! C TU

Y #`G j +
6
D P=

&! H

!9:50

#l !2 9 6

~ +# +*v

%5

%/!= /

.+

%A & :9A \ <-= %5 !) +

TU #

S lV #

F H"F V

# .H #`G j +
+

TU

F{=

TU + \<- y !A

& 5/#` 3

!1

ATU y`G j
B

A% C

#0 %50 P: %
H
.%50

f*

%/ + 3 TU +
Q V

y`G j !

P = J
!1 TU

\ <-= %5 !) + #0 5`

Ad< + % l #`G j

+ ! + F #0 5E \ <-= %5 !)
!FY o=
F H"F

D3

!1 #`G j

9 3 c :@ .3
+

+ + & 9 3 ; + \<-

AH + %- #E z & d<

!9 +

! FY@/ U5

6 TU + \<- H0 :

!9 6 6 { X %0 d< +

24

#E

6 TU + \ <-= %5 !) + \<+ .H

6 `

%/# & 5/

- +

#`G j +

1 f* + .+ /

TU ; + ~ +Y *! 2

5/H)!`

`* H0 : #0 H

6 : P =J

Ad5 8

+ v * "=

.%50
%5 + #0 3

\<-

!@" ! `= 6 T A P !F

/ Y o= %5 !) +

\<-

5/#` 3

!F H& % %A & %5& # HG N

y

%50

!1

9 !A

! - +

P =J

6 H ,

!9:50

/ #@ 6 d

5/#` 3 Y P= l V

TU + ! F + !9:50 #0 %/ %A & !$5 #`G j +

#@D % /

5 )! uC

:F! H) + %

`* c :@ #
=

.%5/

) != !) #0 H

S x=

V ~ + \<- y

\<- #

.H

! !9 + c!I 6 H

5`

A 6 +!C % #

#3 = T 50 + "

`* H0 : v * "= + / 5 \<- S 5AW

6 TU !l `

!9 6

8 )

#@

TU + # !A

P =J

+!F+

= +6 $ A

Y P=

Ad50 6

-j

= v N(j, +!@

!9:50 +!) ~ + 6

%/ H

5l ! %

Ad50 + &

& 5/[ S 8G Q %5 + #0 %5 %

6 Y, N +!) !) TU c :@
Y P= + S

Ad50 6 %/? !-= *

5/[

y 6r

Ac!I y A

! C TU E %5E

6 Y, N TU

+ 5: C
#@

%/ ~ + Y * + 3 TU + ! F +
A

Z !A W P= 5l

Yl*
:% 6

!9:50 6 { X %0 9 3 +
9 3

!F 3

1390

Z #E v
.+ /

> * 2G

+/

A 9 3

i3 #`G j +

+ HF < G

% 4 67 8 5'F

Ad< 6 { X %0 #

@ +8

TU c :@ %

! uC ; 5 3

9 3 y l/ + +6 H 3 6 t<) # \ <-= %5 !) + \<P =J

ATU

Fg

?:0

%5

%/!= /

: % 6 %5 #`G j +

% .H ! + F

++ X $
H

% +

6 #`G j +

TU c :@

TA!

9E _@

` (%/

T)

T )Y * P =J
#`G j +
#0 +
6

! A# 8

A !F 6 % T:E

+ %A & !l `

+d C

uF!)

X$ #

TU + z & A 9 3 +

)!F !* 6

! +F

9G ! 5

3=

3 =

6 TU
!

9 3

l V .4

H + T)

A}!)d C
%50

H <

!={ +8 !=\ *+ T ) #

9 A ~ + ! % 0o=
% H

A T ) ! + F ! l`= # #0
lV

H + # + 3 TU 6

!=\ *+ T ) # + !) y A #0

25

\ <-= %5 !)

t<) vr N TU

! #0 %A+

P =J

G N

# v 8G %/?:0 TU 5l

+ %A & X $
V y A

/
+ \<-

+ %/?:0 P = 6 TU + /

%550 @/ % =

!U5 6 t<) #0 5`
6 c :@ +

(34

A) %

:A 9 3 + & 6
g

z xP

# @ .(

6 & + !) yD

6 TU

TU +

S%N #0 !, 5V $ %= %

+ -G #

+d C +!0 %3

: #0

%/ 6 2 d C : C #0 H ! uC @

V 3 dA gC

#0 5`

5@) !) %5 !) + & + t<) #@D

P =J

6 TU

AT )d C

Y o= y"
+ #@

.%50
!E) + /

#E

!9 6

AH + %-

H + T)!! +8 +3

:% 6

G $=

@ = 5 !A + #0 5E H

%5 6

! `= 6 T A P !F

+d C 6 -,
j& 6 -,

\ <-= %5 !) + & v * "=

.%/ ! uC ; 5 3

6 f

6 8 A!C !E %A+

+ \<-

! !

Y 0 H& 5/ #0 H

!@"

+d C ; + ! + F

Y o= + & #0 #V G \D&

!1 \<-

+d C y A +!0 0#:

<D= j&

D V !

:% 6

TU + dA 9 3 + & ; + \<- Y o=

#3 = Y * A

A !F

! - +

5 ) %50

#0 H

A !F

9 3 c :@

+ Y o= %5 !) + !FY o= ! uC ; 5 3 S lx`=

Y o= y" #@D % +
:1381 !

G N

6 d #@D H
.H

T 50 + "

+ V #0 5`

.%5

# F# .H
TU

%V *

# !F6 % T:E %/?:@5 TU

6 TU .%50 D3 !l ` TU + ! F + + !)

% & '

( )'*

"# $

%/ # "F #0 5E %/ ~ + Y * + 3

X+ 6

#`G j +

#0 H

TU #E

9E _@

}!) %/

%5A+Y @:=

{ +8

+ %5
+5 H

F6

6 ]5

GN +

9 + % / #0

! # ) 0#

V~+
S `G j

Q,

+ 5: C

5/[

5E

! # ) 0#

6 !9 + S lV #

%/#

+ l V \<-=

6 #0 !E .%5/ l

%N

6 6 6

T A" #

6 +! 0 ! % 0o=
:59

!&o

F6

5V Y *
.%lDI

%5

#`G j +
5l ! :

# 8

P =J

\ "D=

+"

TU %/

3 #

A ++ 6 + "

+ !)

6
+

x= c :@ 6 6 2 + 3

ATU

H A

y !$=

AB

/!

5/ T A "
- +

d50 ; +

!9 +

! # ) 0#

H `* %/? !-=

V a(j, #

,!)

Gr%

H +
#lN x

50 +

A{ 5@= !M@= # "Fd C

H \<-

6 6 H A

S 83 !:= #0 + +

! #`G j

Z1

xxP= a(j, #

& 5/[ S 8G

5l # lG #

A[

\ "D= .5

0 : %A : 6 + "
& 5/

& 5/[

!U # ! uC ; 5 3 A
26

AB

@ TU + ! F + !9:50

5` #`G j +

#0 !E .%

@ %N = %

! uC

!9:50
.H

6#

%/?:@5 TU

* y 3!= Y, N #0 %/Y`3

!6

TU + ! F + + !) y A

5E

6 +! 0 + s !) #,(& I # .+6
6 %/# &

5V

3! S `G j

xxP= %/Y`3

5E # + * v <Dj + & A

< "D= Fg
`*

% + uF

6 H #`G j +

=!C

5| A Fg

%/ { +8 TU + ! F + !9:50

T ) #0 H TU + &
vr `

! mo=

N l #0 + : # "F !9:50 # !F #0 %/ l

&6

D3 i 5

! #0 5`

6TA

)!F !* TA 50

!@" #

& 5/[

5/[

+ - +

! uC @

9E _@

/#

+ 5: C

A Fg

!@) H5

6!

s!/d C #0

A+

!F6 % T:E

.+

%< ` ? I #

l E! # !A + T0H +
+

!=\ V ~ +

!F l

.%A+
A+

= F% + 6 #0

:A 9 3 + & 6

+ l V #0 H

%/ ! uC @ !9 %@

Ad<

83 6 vr ` TU B % D0 ! A # S%N

& 5/[ S "= #

!U #

A 9 3

! + #0 5E H # " 8 TU B % D0 + & + # lG

P = ! # #3 = ! A #
.%50

Q N!A# .%50 #3

S%N }!) + +

/ - S +

S%N +!@

#@D

A Fg y A

S 8G \<-=
6 Y, N

U5
A# )

1390

> * 2G

% V dP #@ Y G+ #
5` ~ + j

+ HF < G

!9:50

+ %

A# "F j

?*

! !

0 : %A :
S 8G

+!)

?*

+!)

F+ &

Ad50

5`

d50

5`

%/

Ad50 ! T0 N +!) !) TU ?:0 d50 +!)

9 A

+ l V -

\ V ylN x X $

9 3

+ %

S !1 8

\<- H0 : S !1 ! A #
+! 0 #0 H

% 4 67 8 5'F

5=# { A

#`G j +

P =J

# d !C Y @= %5
ATU

6 TU +

{ 5@= { t<)

; @

- Y D-=

.+ %A P # "Fd C

& 5/[

% & ' j# .3.4

X $ 6 c%A

+ 5: C

5` # 3
(V H

:%

!F% A
1

% v m

y"

H 5`
! +!C6

Y V @/ !
% 5`

S ,

\D& %5 !)

&

?:@5

! ? , = .(24 :1381

.+ / @/

%/C H

?:@5

#
A

5`

6 Y< 25 :1962 :!F% A) %/

V 3 X DV c%A #0 H

5V
%/ X $

1. Givenness
2. Covered up - ness
3. Phenomenon

27

#0

) + Y o=.H Y o=
@

#0 3

@ = 5 !A

6 .%50

5/

k! + +
#`G j +

5/ % %C
5`

TU

AH 5

- # d C: C

! H X6r c :@ X " 6 ! l`=

V8

F+ " & +

%/C

% / C!

" & + #E

@ = 5 !A !F% A

&

! +F

5/

6 vr :H

+ +6

%/

0 #

% %C Y < X "

!5A !m { %5 !5A v(M #0 I

?:0

V 3 y`G j

+ x< #0

!U # #0 T 50 % 0o= # @

{ X$

# / ! # + / 6 2 A 6 Y o= H

.(24 :1381 !

@/

5` 6 d !C v =% V) H

5C ! a " !

+ + 6

ATU c :@

A - ) A % %C ? , = v )!, !F% A

H "0 H " & + #E

il

+ + & # lG #0 T !

6 Y< # 60 :1962 !F% A) .H

! 5 .%50

!F

F+ +

! # "Fd C N l 6 #0 5E

P =J

" k

( !<=

!F% A .+6 +!C

F% + 6 %

+ c :@ X " .H

#@ 1 = .H
!

5/[

5l !
V 3 \<-

V 3 \<- #@D %50

6 z xP #

<

.%50

% & '

!U # # :

!5A !m \D&

\ !I 6 H

V 3

) A
!5A !m

!5A c%A

+3

ATU c :@
%

! l`= #

"! w="

%50 !C

83

% # :=

TU 6

+ 5
+

P =J

!9 + #

5/[

@ Y -=

#0 %5 A 8 E
.H

5 )! uC k
@

5l ! !=

.%

6 d C #0 5E # lG .+ /

!U #

6 d C J %V *

A 5 d C + +H +#

+3

TU

@ 6 8

0#
8 #

+ T GM
6

+!@

+T A"

+ 0 G
+ +!@
6

FB #0

5E k !
#0

6 H5

+ ) %A iG * +

5| A

A %5 %V * k ! + %?,=

! TU X " +! 0
/ TA

!9 + TU ! T0 N %V * @ J +! F

c :@ X + Y V + 3 Y G+ # #0 %/
3

+ +6

! uC @
.H

6 #,(& ! ;
# % 50 9 %5 !5A

!U5

I # .% +

+ + !) d50 T ) #@ Y G+ # %/

+! 0 + + !) S

\ *+ 5 d C #`G j +

C j

TA !) V 3 X DV Z 1

Y@/ Y V + ! mo= H-= ATU

5/[

/" + % # : !9 %@

6 { !A 5 89 3

6 % %/ # )!F 0#

A 5 d C + +H +# c :@

6 6 # !={ +8

5l ! 8 E!A 6 d % # )

FB

" /"

6 H5 !:= Q N V +

A 83 #@D T A " Q <

% c+ ! !A % FB

ATU !9 + d5 !)

0 !) 6 f #0

FB #0

+ 5 }!)

= " #E

+ 5: C
"

ATU

ATU !9 + "d5 !)

A " !5A

H + "[ "

+ & z & "[ "

" :P

6 TU c :@ %5

!1 N

5l ! z xP

D0 + +H +#

" @ "

#E

V 3 X DV #E!F

= "= c %A
.+ /

{ !A H A 6 %/? !-=
# +3

) != !)

!= (0 + !5A

P =

+!0 + 5`

dG E # %/ # / + + 3 "H

.%:0

TA !)

V 3 y`G j

. + 5`

H + (0 c%A

+3

I # .%

!9 %@

# #3 =

!= (0 +

3 + # ) H +6 + 5` H D0 %3 #0 @

c %A j

.%550

c %A j

D0 + l H 36 H + 3

# { !A %

"# $

* 5

!5A %

< + + 5`

V 3 X DV #0 G N + .%/ %A & i3

\D&"

6 #,(&

S "= # #3 =

"c :@ "
#

( )'*

~.
* %x

28

%
!

+!)

/ 8
Ad50

%/ # "F P + %-

3 + !5A d< ; + !=Yx" - ! .1

5| A 188-169 :1377 W ~. S !U
. % 0 ( S !U
m

1390

> * 2G

A 5 dC ! A#
+!F+
`

P =J

!9:50

/ uF

5 V !x5V # Y %l=

F+ :F t<) # #0 H

Yx" -

!)

k ! \ *+
%

+
`

#:

AF

6 TU 6

@ #0 H #`G j +
6

83 #
A

(244-247 :1382

+ & d50 % /

#3

5 l + %-

+ & TU

5l ! .%5

TU

! + F ! l`= #

A 5 d C + %&

!9:50 #0 !E +6

6 H A H 3 6 z xP

Fg
@

% /% o=+ &

#3 = Y * y @

a!I

TU

ATU

Y 0 H& 5/ +

A 5 dC X$
#

V 6 N +

P =J

P =J

(V #@D + + + 3 A

% 4 67 8 5'F

6 TU c :@ Z !A #0 H

.+!0 %A & Q% + 3

6
!

+ HF < G

+ %%V *

%/TA !)

# % 50 9
%V *
! C TU 6

.%5A+

9: A

! w=

TU c :@
83

5V#

5l ! % %3

5/#` 3 +!& (1377) ?

W
D + !& ! (/ A#" D) + Y o= y !U ) { = 5 !A TDV (1382) . + | ! G C
.^ !A : ! = X + > E / 0 5N % ` y 3!= (! + F !F% A
. : ! = H !C
6 5 / y 3!= V 3 TDV T ) (1384) !3 !=
y h : ! = X > E [ ! T !@G %lV y 3!= V 3 X DV y" D) (1382) G
. a!I : ! =

.s !, 95A!)
+ :A gC) %50 H `l= ` lI X DV [ 6 %

X DV

(1377) % `

X(0 l 6

.296-329 :17-18 [ !U %< ({ A d % !) y: %

6 : + < y !U

* V 3 X DV y" D) (1387) S!/

. : ! = D D3 + A y 3!= (T@ H
!* =
.!, ` 9 :A gC y h : ! = { A + (1381)
+ g 52
:T*/ ! =
%
N y 3!= T
!* + TDV y" D) (1381) %G + ^ D F

/H

5/ l= { = 5 !A)

.#I 95A!) y
.

: !=

* ! y 3!=

" D)

AdA gC

1. SELF - Validating predictions

29

:59

(1382)

h
F{

% & '

( )'*

! F + ! + F

: ! = X + >E

I)

!)

"# $

+ y !U

5
" D) { = 5 !A (1381) Y 3 !
.k 5<* : ! = DV + ` y 3!= ({ = 5 !A
:59
% !) y 3!= " D) AdA gC (1381) + G
.80!

.!@) a G : ! = % +r ) S8V y 3!=

: !=

A 06 ! ) % - y 3!=

:59

+ 6 !95 + (1382) ) d % !) { A
+ G (1381) !F + 3
3
A
. 6! /

Evans-Pritchard, E. E. (1951) Social Antropology, London.

Gadamer, Wahrheit und Methode. 1st ed.
Hayek, F. A. (1979) The Influence of Natural Science on the Social Science
in The Counter-Revolution of Science, Liberty Press, Indianapolis (first
published:1941)
Heidegger, Martin. (1962) Being and Time, trans. John Macquarrie and
Edward Robinson, New York: Harper and Row.
Stebbing, L. S. (1933) A Modern Introduction to Logic, London: Methuen.

30