The Center for Victims of Torture—New Tactics in Human Rights Project 1

“Why Strategy and Tactics?”

www.newtactics.org newtactics@cvt.org
“Why Strategy and Tactics?”

!"#$"%&', ($)"') *$&$$+ ,-#-&"-. &-/?

2000-!!" #$%$&' ()*()) +,(!"-' .)*/$&' 011( #!'#$' 23' 41: “!"#$%#&'(
)$*"$+&% ,-. /.".$"01 2'*&32 2"4&%(0 51""0 6"4. 7"*%0 )$*"$+&%&'(
$"#$%#551 08 /."&1.90 5*8$". :55&%"0 ;4” /)#)). 5') '6 3&% !#$%%!/!!/3&
(7%78%7%( 9*/3& :9909' ;3&%, (7%78%7/77/3& 3&% !#$%%!/!! 01.#-2 /)0)'()&
1(/! ')/ <=.
!"#$"%&' 342 56& ,'., 78 96,$2 3424,:& "4+4#,4.2+4&
2(*!(>/$! (9"9:9&%9:-' (1%" .!/ ;!8 /!*/!: '6 (!'- ;9*$%/9"99 :3*):
?9%9=#11" ?9%9' !=#$%( /!*/!: ?9%9=#$&/ ')=)/"33%")/ <=. 2(*!(>/$!
(9"9*:9&%0'99* (! 77*$&':77 7'77/$&' ?9"$( ?!&"!% ?9%99" ?$& ?9%/9:-/
:$@))# ?1& $*))"3& *33/)) :)*:)' 1*!/A%!' :7/#$# ?9%9:-/ $%33 0!&' 9&%/9#
!8'!.

!"#$"%&'
B%"!!(!&
2!&'
($)"')66+
<2033)33 ,'$3.&'($32 $"=%."0$"(
>3*2:33. ,-.-0 /14"& -*-.1.-&-
?4@%.$"01 2'*32 )"(0 ,-.-4@
7-*2-( 2'*&34 )'(*3.
“C'"0)'” 0(*!(>/$ ?9% ;9*$%/9"99 :)*:)' :3*):, ;9*$%/9" :3*/): ?9%9=#$(
'77.33"$&/ ( :3' :3@, )"$&' ;!0!/, 1%0 (7*, D0 01*(!:11', 9<1'- /): =)() :)*:)'
1"$*"!' ;9:$.11%#, !A$/%!: (!%!!* :!=/$&' 7*/7' 9&%/9%(-/ ?!/(!!0!'
?!&"!/. E9*$%/9" @$/%)0)' ?3:$& % ()=.%$&' :9D*"9: (38A$' "): ("!/!%"!:
A!(!'") (9"9*:9& ;9*$%(11"-/ ?$>%33%):$&' (1%" ?10!" :,;/!!*%!/"=!%
0(*!(>/$1"-/ :)*)/#33%): :)*)/()& ?9%"9/.
5') 3>" :!=/$&' /9%%9: A!('- !#%-' (7%78%7/77 )0 ?7/770 3'"0)' 0(*!(>/$&'
:3*))'" ,8!/"!: F!=G!'$( !#%-/ (9"9*:9&%'9. H!'- :30)# ?1& 3* "3'" @$'6
:3*/):))* '77. 01*8!%#11"-/ @$'6 :7(%7: $%33 0!&' 018!/ ?9%#

1
?9%980*11%0!' 0(*!(>/$ (!'6 (10!%'!. I7*@%7%( :$&:)" A!!*"!/"!: 7*(7/
=!A 7'"7* ?!&'!. 2!&' ?9"9# ?9%980*11%0!' 0(*!(>/$(!& ?!&: '6 :3' :3@'$&
/!*; :9:$*%-' ;)*)/.)) !=#$%(!'" :3*):)" A!!*"!/"!: ?10!" 7*(7/, ;9%$90-/
?11*11%# 7/'7.
J:!!%!/ 0(*!(>/$@$" 0(*!(>/$(!&, ?$>%):3&., (99.9# ?9%9:1&. ;9*$%(11"-/
(7%78%7"7/. H)" ?!0 77*0"$&' !=#$%(-/ 3')%#, ()=")/%)")/ <=.
<2 )5*=".@: A*&31%(0 ,-.-0 ?:&%(0 ,5) ,"(&55.."&90 B1%*1."&":
“CD*E.D.$%(0 '+133 ,5( ,"(&55.."&551"1 $5)."2 6D=.D4@” >+*%$ F3#%,
G-*@ F3#%, H-1 I"J%+*, G30%) H-,%0)-0
2(*!(>/$ '6 (7%78%7/77/ :)*)/#33%):)" @$/%)0)' 4247 A$&"%))0 ?3*"")/:
! ;42 <4#'2"66+ ?9%9' ;9*$%(9( ?3%/33")) ( :3=330, ?!&/11%%!/!, :11%6
#1*!= /): =)( ) 09'/9#, 0(*!(>/$&/ :)*)/#33%): ?9/$'9 :1/!.!!'- (10/!&
;9*$%/11"-' (!%!!* (9"9*:9& 9&%/9%(9'" :3*):
! =>>? 06#@$2/66+$$ "!:$' ',/(%!:: +9%?99('11" ?! 07*7/ ?!&*
011*6('11", ?9%9=#(9& ?! :)*)/.))()& '77.33")) =)")# !8!:
((1:!&%?!%: :3=330, .!/ :1/!.!!, =7'/7 /): =)().
! *A$# "$)"')66+:& :);)) !A$/%!:!! A$&"):.
! 29'/909' (!F($F11"!! ,-#-&/112-,.
! H!F($F11"-':!! 3* "3'" +17 B'7/'2&-- ,'./, 17-2-7 01*0!' ;3&%0))
"!*!!/$&' !%:=11"!! (7%78%7:7" :)*)/%):.

!"#$"%&'.7 7C&"2$2

(>2>@2>&>>
E9*$%/11"!! (9"9*:9&%#, ;9*$%(11"!! ;78A$%.7:
($)"')66+$$ "4+4#,4.24,
H!F($F!! (9"9*:9&%#, 09'/9:
($)"')66+$$ ,-#-&/112-,
K3&.)(/): !#$%('11" ?9%9' :)*)/#$%($&' ',/(%!:
D17 B'7/'2&-- ,'.,
E7-2&--
C* "3'/ 9&%/9#, 01*/!=#11"!! 3')%#, :)*)/#33%):
D$,'7 7C&"2$,
L77. 01*8!%#11", :9%?99('11"/07*7/ ?!&* 011*6('11", '7:.7% ?!&"!%,
?9%9=#$( ?!&'11"!! A$'#$%#, 3')%):

2
!"#$"%&' C$&$$+ 96,$2 &-/?
2(*!(>/$(!& ?!&: '6:
! 2!'!!@%!/!(!& ?!&"%-/ @$'6 !%"11%!:/3&;
! M9%9=#11"-/ 9%# :!*!: @!"8!*-/ (!'6 ')=)/"33%');
! +3@ @!"%!! :!=/$&' 0!&' "!811 ?!&"!%" :3*/)' !A$/%!#,
! 21% (!%!! ?!/!0/!:!" (!'6 (10!%'!.

!"#$"%&' ()* +'*,'-&..

!"#$"%&' /0*&0-"
!"#$"%&'1* 2.#.&,'-"

T34564 &., 78 9.?:

“!"#$%#” ,-. D&D&1)D0 0D2KD. ,"(1".1 0D.DD.D2 6-*%.&--* 2%(&113& $5)&"(,
,-1%$ '(. "@%.."&"" ;4.
! H1:!&' (!F($F$&' !=#$%( '6 :)*:)' ?10!" (!F($F11"(!& 1,%"!'
:)*)/#33%0)'))0 '6 $:)8@%)' :!=!!*"!/.
! H!F($F ?9% "0:0020* /"#$"%&'1* ?3*)%"):33' ?9%9: 3&%
!#$%%!/!!'- :)*)/0)% <=.
H! ;78:7' !%: :)=)): ?!/!#(!& ?9% ?3: !011"!% (!'" :!"!!0 =)( :!*!/"!'!.
“;'*.”5$<"'<88(
C')'")) “A$')” (!F($F11" ?9% ?$"'$& 9%# :!*# @!"!: 0!'!!, '77. 01*8!%#,
@!"8!* ?9%9' (1:!&' '7:.7%" ?$"'$& :)*)/#33%): @!"!8:$&' "110!A/3& 9%9'
,';-' :18$%?!*11" <=.
“L01)30 $"="0 D0&DD) (2D2, :"*, 5.""0, K"&""0, 2"*) DD* -.-0 D0&D ,"(1"&&'(
E $31 2-).-2--*-- 2"*"&1"@ ,"(&""&"") E %.'' -.-0 D0&%(& ,%( ,-.&-1-&.
!5.".1""01 :551 ," :551 ,5) 1-=$-.&--09 2-M* "*&"") DD* -.-0 "*&"
,"(2&'( E 303 2-M*9& 2-).55."2 ;4 ,-. 155)":&'( -.-0 "*&" 432%(& '')&3@
,-.0-. N551 ," :551 ,5) 1-=$-.&-- 08 '*&3.@%1 03& 03&033 33.@.30
E%&.''.@ ,"(1"&. <03 08 /& . 3K3) $D&)&D.&'( $-(*-& 43$. !31&33*%(0
2-).-2 ,-.-4@%(& 230 E :"=2"@ E"1":&'(.”
!17 F6
5*('$& :,(!"-' .)*/$&' 011( #!'#$'

Know Yourself - I7*$&/77 (!'$# =)"

3
H!'- ;9*$%/9, "!811 (!% ?9%9' :,;/!!*%!%(11" <1 8)?
+)' (!'- :9%?99('11" 8)?
N1"!*/! 3')%/)) :$&: '6 =!A @1:!%. I7*$&' ?9"9%"99 $(/)#, ?33 ?!*$/".
O!811 ?9%9' 01% (!%!! 3')%):")) !%6 ?9%9: ?9"$(9& ?!&.

Know Your Adversary – I*07%"7/@ (!%!! (!'$# =)"

+)' (!'- 7*07%"7/@ 8)? H)"'$& ;9*$%/9, 0(*!(>/$, "!811 ?9%9' 01% (!% <1 8)?
27*7/ (!%-':!! 1:11%/!" @ ?33 $(/).

G>#'.7 >#0>2+>&9 - -0-#&11?-&9'+ 34247 ,42344"766+$$ A-+-/, ,19--

<>@ ,6@$$#'2$,
I*07%"7/@77 3')%#, (99.9:-' ;)*)/.)) 0(*!(>/!!0 (!'6 :!=!!*!' /!*@
342<4B&1. :9%?99(9', )0)*/33.)/@$" ?!&/!! )0):$&/ 3')%#, (99.:
! B%?!' (1A!!%
! N$&"8)* /!*/!: @!"8!*
! L)* :3'"
! L$&/=$&' '7%77

Know the Terrain – K!;!* 9*@'99 (!'$# =)"

(62$2+$$7 ,$$7$ 3424, @-?
! L7:.7% ?!&"%11"-/ (99. (1%0 (7*, '$&/)=, 09D%-')
! K!;!* 9*'- "!811, 01% (!%-/ (99.
! O!811 ?!&"%!!* !A$/%!# ?9%9: ?9%9=#$&' '))%(33"$&/ (99.
! B<1%(!& /!;*11"-/ (99.

;$<$# 4#7:& <4#'2&4+44 ,1#-, <$.2B&1. -2%A%7" ,-A--7 "44?4/ 17-2.

J1%!'" !8$*!/@$&' !"$%:
! K!;!* 9*'99 01"!%
! E9*$%/9" :3*): ;!=!! (9"9*:9&%
! L7:.7% ?!&"%-' (!%!!* 9"99/$&' A$&"8)*)) /!*/!.
;$<$# 4#744 A-+– !6+2$, &$<#66+ ("$7: $066+2$$0 ,$A$$#9)
2(*!(>/$" 3;33%): '7%77, :3@ ((!F($F11"-' 09'/9%(-' (!%!!* A$&"8)*%):)
J%0 (7*$&' (9/(9%.99

4
L$&/=$&' ?3()./ H9/(9%.99
5"$&' ;!0/$&' (9/(9%.99
M10!" :3@$' ;3&%
L$&/)=/29D%-' G*!F($F (A!A$', /)* ?3%, $*/)'$& G*!F($F$&/ 9*9%.11%!')
M9%980*9%-' (9/(9%.99 (!%?!' ?! !%?!' ?10)
E!0/$&' /!;*-' (9/(9%.99 (:11%6 "3*)=, ?9"%9/9, ")" ?3().)
I7*0"$&/77 ?9%9' 77*$&' :9%?99('11", )0)*/33.)/@"$&/ ',/( ',=?!& 3')%#,
=)"): '6 @1:!%. 2!&' 0(*!(>/$&/ ?$& ?9%/9#, (9:$*9: (!F($F11"-/ 09'/9: '6
?9%9=#(9& :9%?99('- (99/ :!=/$&' $:))* ')=)/"33%#, )0)*/33.)/@"$&' (99/
:!=/$&' ?!/!" :3*/)# @!""!/. 5'):33 3&% ,8. '6 .!/ :1/!.!! ?9%99" ?10"-/
09'09: @!"8!*, =7' 1/ !011"!% ,!/!!" :)*:)' @1:!% ?9%9:-/ (10!%# @!"!: 77*
:3=330( 9&%/11%!:-/ A!!*"!'!.
I7*$&' 1* @!"8!*, .!/, '77. ?9%9=#99 1/ !011"!%" ;9*$1%!' 3')' 0)(/)%))0))
9*9%.9:9" '6 :)' ')/'$&/ <1 :7"7%/7# @!"!: 8)? H)"'$&/ :7"7%/7/@ :3@, 0)")%
()"'$& ;3*: 0)(/)%$&' 3') .)'))0 '6 /!*"!/ 11? (;!*@=11", $(/)% 3')=A%$&':
'6 :3@, '7%77) )08)% 1/ !011"%-' !A$/(!& (!%-/ :!*0!' !A$/ 09'$*:%990 '6
/!*"!/ 11? (O$!/*!== 3;') 33)

H066+266+:
M$")'" <1 @1:!% ?7/77" ?$" <1/ :7/#33%):

I$+$@,'
M$")'" ,=!* '77. ?9%9=# ?!&/!! (1* @!"8!*, !8P,!0, !%?!' (1A!!%, '7%77,
.!/ :1/!.!!, =7'/7… /): =)()

E7- ?-7-:
M$"'$&/ 0)")% ()=33%%$&/ :7"7%/7# ?1& ;!*@=11" ($(/)%, 3')=A$%, /): =)()

HB'& 047'#,42:
M!*6.!!'" <1 ?!&'! 8)?
B011"%!!0 ?$" <1'" :3*): 8)?
J/ !011"!% ?$")'" :)* !A$/(!& 8)?

J4#'62$2":
C&% !#$%%!/!!'" 9*9%.9: ?$"'$& :30)%, ?)%)' ?!&"!%

5
M$>%33%0)' <1 ?!&/!!
<2 )5*=".@: Wellstone Action!
O3.&3*30&'( 43133..%(&: http://www.wellstone.org/
G>#'.7 A-+2-&-- +$.9'2
O!*!!: :30')/( '6 (!'- !011"!%(!& :9%?9/"9: :3=330, ?!&/11%%!/!,
$'0($(1($&/ :!!'! ?!&%/!: (!%!!* ?9"9:9" (!'6 (10!%'!. “+9%?99('11"-'
0G>F(*”-$&/ !A$/%!' 77*$&' ?3%)/ ?9%9' ?!&/11%%!/!!*!! "!0/!% :$&/))*)&.
5'):33 "!0/!%-/ Training for Change website-$&' “tools” "9(*990 9%# 3;)#
?9%'9:
http://www.trainingforchange.org

K42344"766+ 3$ L0-#&11?-&9+-- A-+-,

M'.+@-# &$#&$,
N+'#+$, K42344"766+
N+'#+$, L0-#&11?-&9'+
+!&:*!=#/3& (78$&/ 0!:$/@$"
O!&0!/'!%( (78$&/ 0!:$/@$"
L7:7*07/ (78$&/ 0!:$/@$"
Q")8:/3& )0)*/33.)/@$"
Q")8:/3& :9%?99('11"

ODLPK(LQ KRSTRR(=NND
ODLPK(LQ L!LU;EEFL;IOD
H)"'$&/ 77*(77 (!(!: )0 ?7/770 ,"!# (78$&/ 0!:$/@$" :)8))* ?!&%/!#, !%6
')/)' (!%" 9*11%!:/3& ?!&%/!:
50*)/ (!%-':'- "1'" )*/)%;)), =7*/7%"77' 330/):
O)=#$/@"$&' ')/"=)% ?!&"!%, 3&% !#$%%!/!!/ ')=)/"33%):
<2 )5*=".@: "Spectrum of Allies“: http://www.trainingforchange.org
4!!0!' "))* "$!/*!== ;1*!!" :$&# ?9%'9. M3%/))* !#$%%!: ?! (9=
:)=#))'$& .!!0!' "))* :$&'). I7*0"$&' 0!'!!/!! ?$@$#, ?!&*%11%!:"!!
'!!#, 0!%/!# !8@ ?9%9:99* .!811(!& .!!0'11"-/ :)*)/%): '6 (10(!&.
Q'/)0'))* :!!'! ?!&*%11%!: '6 :!=/$&' (9:$*9=#(9&/ :)%)%.)' ;77#
?!&*%11%'!. H!8!' :)0)/( :18!!0!' 0G>F(*$&' :,%?!*A11%0!' ;!/8!*-/

6
!A$/%!' "$!/*!== ?!&/11%'!. H33' "))*)) "!*!!: )%>=>'(33"$&/ ECCL552 '6
MBRJJL ($&A ?!&*%11%!' :!*11%'!.
+ ($2
1. Q")8:()& +9%?99('11"
2. Q")8:/3& +9%?99('11"
3. HISQTK 2B+QKUQO: 5') :)0)/ '6 3 (10"!! :)0/))0 ?3*")').
- ($2
4. Q")8:/3& 50)*/33.)/@$"
5. Q")8:()& 50)*/33.)/@$"