Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Nelum Shehzade
BBA 2004-2008
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
All the praise is for Allah, the most merciful and beneficent, who
blessed me with the knowledge, gave me the courage and allowed
me to accomplish this task. I am especially indebted to all my
teachers for instilling in me enough knowledge to be able to carry
myself efficiently during my internship.
2
DEDICATION
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY...................................................................................................................................5
1. INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................................................6
CENTRAL BACKGROUND INFORMATION.........................................................................................................................6
1.3 TELENOR IN PAKISTAN...................................................................................................................................12
a) Vision and Values...................................................................................................................................12
b) Largest direct European investment in Pakistan....................................................................................14
c) Highest (ARPU) in the market................................................................................................................14
d) Fastest growing mobile network.............................................................................................................15
e) Infrastructure expansion.........................................................................................................................15
f) Employment opportunities.......................................................................................................................15
g) Social and corporate responsibility........................................................................................................15
h) Achievements .........................................................................................................................................16
i) Future Projects........................................................................................................................................17
2. COMPANY ANALYSIS................................................................................................................................17
2.1 OPERATION ANALYSIS.....................................................................................................................................17
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS..............................................................................................................................................20
2.3 HUMAN RESOURCE ASSESSMENT......................................................................................................................21
MARKETING ANALYSIS.........................................................................................................................................23
ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS......................................................................................................................26
INDUSTRY AND MARKET ANALYSIS..........................................................................................................................26
3.1.1. Major product lines ..........................................................................................................................26
3.1.2. Market Segmentation........................................................................................................................27
3.1.3. Growth Rate for Entire Industry.......................................................................................................29
3.2. COMPETITOR ANALYSIS.................................................................................................................................31
3.2.1. Major Competitors............................................................................................................................31
Market share of Competitors.......................................................................................................................33
Competitors Goals.......................................................................................................................................34
Competitors Strategies.................................................................................................................................34
TECHNOLOGY ANALYSIS.........................................................................................................................................35
Technical methods affecting industry..........................................................................................................35
Innovation ...................................................................................................................................................35
DEPARTMENT WORKED DURING INTERNSHIP....................................................................................39
IDENTIFICATION OF A MAIN PROBLEM..................................................................................................44
6. FINDINGS ....................................................................................................................................................45
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS...............................................................................................46
7. APPENDIX....................................................................................................................................................51
MONTENEGRO..........................................................................................................................................56
4
Executive Summary
5
that I performed. Last part of the report consists of some
recommendations and suggestions that I have given.
1. Introduction
a) What is Telecommunication?
b) Telecommunication in Pakistan
6
It promotes and protects the interest of end users of
telecommunication services. Pakistan under World Trade
Organization (WTO) commitment is now ready to deregulate the
whole of telecom sector. Deregulation policy is in final stages and
will be announced shortly.
In the year 2002 – 03, the PTA has stepped forward to encourage
the telecom operators and transfer of technology in Pakistan.
7
For the value added services, Pakistan Telecommunication Authority
has issued total 431 licenses including 177 licenses for card
payphone services and 121 for electronic information service.
For voice and data network services, 24 and satellite 8, trunk radio
services 12, store and forward fax service 9, video conference 1 and
25 data communication network services license were issued up –
till June 2003.
The license terms stipulate that by year 4, Telenor will cover 70% of
Pakistan's 297 administrative Tehsil headquarters. Telenor will fulfill
the license requirements and provide superior quality coverage.
8
1.1 Company background
9
at the turn of the century. The spread and use of telecommunication
was modest compared to later periods, but as entirely new features
they received a fair amount of attention.
e) International expansion
10
f) The Telenor Group 2007
g) Global opportunities
• Sonofon, Denmark
• Telenor, Norway
• Telenor Sweden
• Kyivstar, Ukraine
• Pannon, Hungary
• Promonte, Montenegro
• Telenor Serbia
11
• VimpelCom, Russia
• Telenor Pakistan
• DiGi, Malaysia
• DTAC, Thailand
• Grameenphone, Bangladesh
Telenor Vision
12
The key to achieving this vision is a mindset where every one of us
works together: Making it easy to buy and use our services.
Delivering on our promises. Being respectful of differences.
Inspiring people to find new ways.
Make it Easy
We're practical. We don't complicate things. Everything we produce
should be easy to understand and use. Because we never forget
we're trying to make customers' lives easier.
Keep Promises
Be Inspiring
Be Respectful
13
formula worldwide. We want to be a part of local communities
wherever we operate. We believe loyalty has to be earned.
14
d) Fastest growing mobile network
e) Infrastructure expansion
f) Employment opportunities
The company has created 2500 direct and more than 25000 indirect
employment opportunities with 100,000+ retail outlets and 200+
franchises in addition. 99.9% of these employment opportunities
belong to Pakistanis.
15
special focus on bringing the telecom promise within the grasp of
the most disadvantaged sections of the society.
h) Achievements
16
• Lahore Chamber of Commerce & Industries’ Appreciation Award
for the Largest FDI and Rawalpindi Chamber of Commerce &
Industries’ Achievement Award 2008
i) Future Projects
2. Company Analysis
17
and the balance over the next ten years. Additional fees for Telenor
include 2.5% of the annual gross revenue. The license covers the
operation of Global System for Mobile Communications (GSM),
General Packet Radio Service (GPRS) and Enhanced Data Rates for
Global Evolution (EDGE) technology for the network.
Nokia supply the GSM Base Station Subsystem (BSS) solution, GPRS
core system and Network Switching Solution (NSS) DX 200i series,
which is easily upgradeable to 3G Wideband Code-Division Multiple
Access (WCDMA) technology in the future. In addition, Nokia also
provide turnkey implementation of the network including project
18
management, network planning and design, site acquisition, civil
engineering and supply and installation of hardware and software.
They also provide software maintenance, emergency support,
hardware services and maintenance and training for Telenor
Pakistan personnel.
c) Management of Telenor
19
The top management of Telenor comprise of versatile and highly
educated people to cater the need of company. Under the
supervision of top management, employees are highly motivated
and perform sophisticated and day to day operations.
Financial analysis
20
Most financial indicators of Telenor Pakistan are good: Revenues
have soared, subscriber share is steadily increasing. The EBITDA
(earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization) is
positive for the first time, though the EBITDA margin is only 7%.
Another thing which needs to be noted that Telenor’s operating
losses have reduced in 2007. The company also grew its revenue by
18% in local currency from Q3 2007 and improved its EBITDA
margin by 17% from Q3 2007.
The average revenue per user (ARPU) has stabilized around Rs 280
per month for Pakistan - its low but that’s the reality of the market.
The company has created 2500 direct and more than 25000 indirect
employment opportunities with 100,000+ retail outlets and 200+
franchises in addition. 99.9% of these employment opportunities
belong to Pakistanis.
21
Telenor offers exciting and challenging careers with competitive
pay, excellent benefits and exceptional advancement opportunities.
Telenor care about its employees and provide them with a relaxed
and enriching working environment. Telenor training and further
education programs ensure a high professional standard amongst
its employees. Telenor believe that a talented and loyal workforce
plays a crucial role in the organization’s ongoing business success.
22
--Empower people
--Integrity
HC at Telenor Pakistan
Marketing Analysis
23
variables known as the “four Ps”: product, price, place, and
promotion.
PRODUCT OR SERVICES
PRICE
PLACE
24
source: www.telenor.com.pk
PROMOTION
• Personal selling
• Public relations
• Sales promotion
• Advertisement (print,electronic,direct marketing and out of
home advertising)
25
Before it’s starting of services commercial ads were aired through
electronic and paper media. Initially their ads gave the people an
opportunity to understand the company’s profile. Then after
launching it started its mega advertisement campaign.
There are different types of banners and billboards all across the
country on important public places. Telenor is distributing
pamphlets through service stations and big super stores.
Telenor uses every media to promote its product and value added
services.
Environmental Analysis
26
Telenor group has major product lines including, mobile telephony,
fixed line, broadband TV networks. But currently in Pakistan
Telenor’s only product is mobile telephony.
The two product lines according to product segments are:
27
Demographic segmentation
It offers value added services such as WAP, ring tone downloads etc.
to attract the youngsters. Further, it offers no maximum time limits
for recharging which is attractive for lower income group people.
Concept of easy load was very first time being introduced in
Pakistan to cater lower income strata and students.
Behavioral segmentation
28
• Strong youth culture with needs similar to other markets
• Private postpaid almost non-existent
• Small but profitable (high ARPU) Corporate/SME segment
• Women a largely untapped segment
29
more than double at 1,366,698 employment opportunities. An
intense competition is seen in the telecom sector and all the
companies are trying to take edge on each other, which is helping
the subscribers as they are getting advanced and new packages at
low prices. Here is a table depicting cellular subscribers in Pakistan.
CELLULAR SUBSCRIBERS
Growth
Mobilink Ufone Zong Instsphone Telenor Warid Total
Rate
2000 114,272 80,221 112,000 306,493 15.39
2001 309,272 116,711 96,623 220,000 742,606 142.29
2002 800,000 350,000 218,536 330,000 1,698,536 128.73
2003 1,115,000 550,000 319,400 420,000 2,404,400 41.56
2004 3,215,989 801,160 470,021 535,738 5,022,908 108.90
2005 7,469,085 2,579,103 924,486 454,147 835,727 508,655 12,771,203 154.26
2006 17,205,555 7,487,005 1,040,503 336,696 3,573,660 4,863,138 34,506,557 170.2
2007 26,466,451 14,014,044 1,024,563 333,081 10,701,332 10,620,386 63,159,857 80.70
2008 32,032,363 18,100,440 3,950,758 351,135* 18,125,189 15,489,858 88,019,812 39.4
July-2008 32,056,336 18,368,074 4,446,024 351,135 18,329,428 15,774,299 89,325,296
* Revised
Note: Including AJK & NAs
SCO Cellular Mobile Subscribers in AJ&K and NAs for Mar-08 are 172,531
Source: PTA 2008
In 2004 there were less than 2000 cell sites installed by all mobile
operators for provision of mobile services. Today total cell sites of all
mobile operators are more than 17,500.
30
• Forward looking telecom policy
• Investment friendly climate
• Good regulatory execution
• Acceptable political and economic situation
CELLULAR MOBILE
DENSITY
Year Mobile Density
2000 0.22
2001 0.52
2002 1.16
2003 1.61
2004 3.29
2005 8.30
2006 22.21
2007 39.94
2008 54.70
July-2008 55.62
* Revised
Note: Including AJK & NAs
Source : PTA 2008
3.2. Competitor Analysis
Direct:
• Mobilink
• Ufone
31
• Warid
• Zong
Indirect
• PTCL
• Calling card providers
• Wateen Telecom
• Worldcall wireless
• PTCL wireless
• Go CDMA
• Smaller WLL operators
32
Market share of Competitors
zong
4%
warid
17%
mobilink
37%
telenor
20%
ufone
source: PTA may,2008 22%
Mobilink
Ufone
Warid
33
Warid currently holds almost 17.29 percent market share in
Pakistani cellular industry, with 14.76 million customers as of April
2008.
Zong
China Mobile has injected more than $800 million into Pakistan’s
telecom sector after a landmark takeover of Paktel’s operations late
February 2007. Zong has been growing at a brisk pace, it has
captured a market of 4% in first few months of its launch with 5
million subscribers.
Competitors Goals
The collective goal of all the competitors of Telenor is to:
• Increase their market share by increased subscriber base.
• Increase network reliability and premium connectivity.
• Excellence in customer service
• Customer retention.
• Brand building.
• Seamless migration to the 3G technology.
• Ensure low cost operations
Competitors Strategies
34
The competitor’s strategies to compete in market and attain their
goals are as follows:
• Accuracy in billing
• Extensive coverage.
• Competitive pricing.
• New products for more market segments.
• Marketing initiatives.
• Expansion of high quality value added services.
• Strengthened GPRS/EDGE network.
• Use of a more contemporary style to give a more
approachable image
• Leveraging group knowledge building
Technology Analysis
Innovation
35
One of the competitive edge of Telenor is its innovation. Telenor
has work on the different innovative ideas for improving its services
and brand image in Pakistan. Following are some of the innovative
steps Telenor took:
Easy load
With entry into Pakistani market , Telenor was market leader in
introducing easy loads from rupees 10 to 1000 .
Mobile TV
36
PixSense Multimedia Management Solution for Mobile
Subscribers
For the first time in Pakistan, Telenor’s PicShare service gives users
a unique new way of sharing their memories online and through
their mobile handset.
Telenor Pakistan, which has taken the leadership role in the industry
by offering a platform which helps its subscribers manage their
media transparently and also allows building of mobile user
communities thereby building a more lasting relationship with their
subscribers.
Environmental benefits
Crisis interventions
37
• Telenor Pakistan made a sizable donation to Shaukat
Khanum Memorial Trust in order to support the cause of
treating cancer patients.
• Telenor Pakistan contributed to a fundraiser for the
restoration of the historic Rohtas Fort.
• Telenor Pakistan, continuing with its efforts to provide
relief to the flood-affected people, has distributed food and
drinking water to almost 10,000 families in the badly-hit
areas of Sindh and Balochistan.
• The Corporate Responsibility unit recently teamed up with
Pakistan Red Crescent Society to help collect blood
donations from Telenor employees.
38
Department worked during internship.
Departments in Telenor
The finance department was very small and looks after the
daily expenditures and sales of franchise. Payroll of the
employees is also made by this department. At the closing of
everyday the manager reports to Telenor Business centre on
mall road, Rawalpindi for the profits or losses.
39
During my six weeks of internship I performed many duties in
Telenor customer care department which added to my experience
and learning. All the tasks that I executed gave me a sense of
responsibility. Sometimes there was too much responsibility on me;
too much burden was there. At times things were slow, yet I wanted
to work more because I had blurred the lines between work and fun.
I performed following tasks and duties during my Internship:
40
Telenor customers deserve quick response when they first order
their services. Therefore to, assure that I filled the new connection
form by verifying information from customers NIC and the
customers ordering prepaid connections can have service activated
within a few minutes of fulfilling all the ordering requirements.
Easy load
At Telenor I did easy load for customers in the first few days of my
internship. Every transaction generates a number and I keep record
of all the transactions of the day. This information was used for daily
closing accounts of franchise.
Dispute Resolution
Billing Information
41
Telenor make every effort to protect customers’ privacy and to
assure a secure network for the confidentiality of their information.
In addition customers’ personal information is safe with telenor and
be strictly guarded as per laws of Pakistan. For this purpose I was
given special lesson and I signed un undertaking for not disclosing
and misusing information.
Data Entry
The customer care department daily receives different types of
forms and data including Sim registration forms, Sim replacement
forms, feedback forms, complaint forms etc. My task was to enter
the data in Telenor database.
Dispatching Letters
Telenor is a centralized organization in which every decision has to
go through the head office. So a lot of letters, applications and
recommendations were dispatched daily to Telenor head quarters to
Lahore, and Karachi. My supervisors only mentioned the city and it
was my job to write the postal address of Telenor office on an
42
envelope containing the document and deliver it at the reception to
be dispatched.
Managing Visitors
Many people came to visit the customer care department for
solution of their complaints. I gave information to the customers
and solve the problems by providing them effective and sufficient
guidance. In customer care department, customer is always given
more priority and respect, and we listen to them with all ears. It was
my duty to satisfy customers on their all queries regarding calling
call rates, package conversion, VAS, compatibility of handsets and
enabling GPRS on their number according to their requests.
43
Identification of a main problem
I was appointed for internship at a Telenor franchise at bank road
sadder .This franchise is also carrying out distribution activities for
the Telenor business centre mall road sadder.
44
given to people who are serving the customers directly. Staff at
customer care department was also not enough. Franchise is
dealing with so many customers each single day but due to small
place , no of employees is also few. This adds extra burden and
stress to the employees serving to customers. Some times this lead
to demotivation of employees. Also the shift timing is 8 hours which
makes customers representatives very tired as there are no official
breaks in between.
6. Findings
While working with Telenor , I learned practical knowledge of the
business world. I find it interesting to relate my bookish knowledge
with the practical things.
Following are my findings regarding Telenor :
45
• Telenor believes on good governance and corporate
responsibility.
• Telenor focus on reaching masses with extensive
distribution strategy.
• The Telenor outlook for 2010-2011 is :
SIM penetration above 70%
Market share above 25%
EBITDA in mid thirties
The company has created 2500 direct and more than 25000 indirect
employment opportunities with 100,000+ retail outlets and 200+
franchises in addition. 99.9% of these employment opportunities
belong to Pakistanis.
Telenor is a place where one can live his dreams and pursue a
career that reflects his skills and passions. Telenor gives flexibility
for change, the opportunity to learn, and providing career options
with endless possibilities.
46
Some of the recommendations for Telenor according to my
understanding are:
47
There was a fine line between employees and internees, and
though that is understandable, the system seemed much
closed at times.
The fact that there were two sales offices in the building (one
on the 2nd floor and one in the ground), led to work related
confusion and hence mishaps. Proper communication and
planning should be there.
48
All the employees in the customer care department are over-
burden with work and responsibility. The customer care
department requires more employees.
49
Special thanks to:
References:
www.telenor.com
www.telenor.com.pk
www.pta.gov.pk
50
7. Appendix
51
Annexure
52
Annexure
53
Annexure:
54
55
Annexure
Mobile operators and the markets in which
Telenor operates.
Bangladesh Denmark
Hungary Malaysia
Montenegro Norway
Pakistan Russia
Serbia Sweden
Ukraine
Thailand
56
Annexure
Jon Eddy Abdullah has more than 15 years of experience in the telecommunications
industry. He has been working with both infrastructure vendors as well as several mobile
operators, most recently as Chief Operating Officer in Maxis Telecommunications,
Malaysia, and Chief Technology Officer DiGi Malaysia. Jon holds a Bachelor of Science
(Electrical Engineering) from Montana State University, USA.
Irfan Wahab Khan, Executive Vice President Corporate Affairs & CEO LDI
Irfan heads the Corporate Affairs & CEO LDI Division and supervises the Regulatory &
Interconnect, Legal Affairs, Public & Government Affairs, and Corporate Communications
departments. He has extensive international experience of working in the mobile cellular
industry having worked with Orange UK, T-Mobile USA, Telecordia Technologies USA,
Nortel Networks, Ericsson Philippines, and the Ministry of IT & Telecommunications
Pakistan. Irfan has served as a Director on PTCL's Board and was Vice Chairman of GSM
Alliance, North America. Irfan Wahab Khan has an MSc in Mobile Communications from
the University of Westminster, UK.
Lars-Christian Iuel rejoins the Telenor Group following a two-year stint with Cell One,
Namibia's well-known mobile operator. He was appointed Cell One's CEO in 2007 from
his previous position as the company's CMO. Lars was Senior Executive Vice President,
Private Products, Telenor Nordic when he left in 2006. He joined Telenor ASA in 1996.
With 12 years management experience Lars has a wide range of knowledge of the industry.
He has a Cand. Merc (MBA) from University of Aalborg, Denmark, an MBA from
University of Sheffield, UK, and can speak English, Norwegian, Danish and German.
Peter heads the Technical Division which comprises the Network Planning & Design,
Implementation, Operations & Maintenance, Real Estate & Site Acquisition, Technology
and Strategy, and E2E QA departments. He was previously responsible for the
development of the Real Estate & Site Acquisition department. He has been Operational
Advisor to CEO Telenor Pakistan, and has worked on a broad range of commercial and
technical operational issues. He has also been responsible for managing the CEO's Office.
Prior to joining Telenor Pakistan, Peter was the Chief Operational Advisor for Promonte,
57
Telenor’s operations in Serbia and Montenegro. Peter began his career with British
Telecom (BT) in the UK where he worked for nine years. He spent the next 10 years on
various international assignments including working with StarHub in Singapore and
Ericsson in Malaysia. Peter Dindial has an MBA, and a BA in Business and Finance from
the University of South Bank, London.
Khalid heads the Information Technology Division and manages the Business Support
System, IT Operations, and IT Security departments. Before joining Telenor Pakistan as
CIO in June 2004, Khalid worked in Tanzania as a CIO for Celtel International which
caters to both mobile and fixed line customer needs. Khalid has the distinction of being
noted as IT Director of the Year for Western Wireless International in 2000, and Employee
of the Year at Millicom International in 1996. He began his career 14 years ago, and has
worked extensively in the international telecom sector with companies such as Motorola,
Millicom, AT&T Wireless, Western Wireless, Celtel Intl, and with Ufone. Khalid Shehzad
has a BSc in Computer Sciences from UCLA USA and an MBA from IBA Karachi.
Peter heads the Finance Division and supervises the Business Planning & Finance,
Accounts, Procurement, Treasury, Financial Operations, Revenue Assurance & Fraud
Management, Credit Control, and SOA departments. Peter comes from a CFO / CIO's
position from Star Foods S.A. Poland, an FMCG company, where he worked from 1996 to
2006. He held the position of Controller Procurement and IT Project Manager at Bahrain
Telecommunications from 1987 to 1996. Peter also has experience in the building
materials, electronics and pharmaceutical industries. He is a member of the United
Kingdom Chartered Institute of Management Accountants. Peter Kuncewicz has an MSc in
Business Planning and Finance from the University of Salford, England, and a first degree
in Biology from the University of Sussex, England.
Nayab heads HC Division and oversees the People Excellence & Business Process
Improvement, Safety and Security , and Organizational Support Services departments. He
has extensive human resource management experience having developed performance
planning, management and evaluation systems in addition to introducing developmental
activities at Packages and Unilever Bestfoods in the past. He has headed the HR
departments of Packages Ltd., Unilever Bestfoods, SHV, and Avari Renaissance Hotel.
Nayab Baig has an MA in Human Resource Management from the University of
Westminster, UK.
58
59