Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Fernandez
GR No. L-1278 January 21, 1949
Feria, J.
FACTS:
• Jimenez and Barrioquinto were charged of the crime of murder. Barrioquinto
has not yet been arrested while the case proceeded against Jimenez.
• After trial Court of First Instance of Zamboanga sentenced Jimenez to life
imprisonment.
• Before the period for appeal had expired, Jimenez became aware of
Proclamation No. 8, which grants amnesty in favor of all persons who may be
charged with an act penalized under the RPC in furtherance of resistance to
the enemy or against persons aiding in the war efforts of the enemy and
committed from December 8, 1941, to the date when each particular area
where the offense was committed was liberated from enemy control and
occupation.
• On January 9, 1947, the Amnesty Commission issued an order returning the
cases of the petitioners to the Court of First Instance of Zamboanga, without
deciding on the case saying that since the Barrioquinto and Jimenez deny
having committed the crime, they cannot invoke the benefits of amnesty.
ISSUE:
• W/N Barrioquinto and Loreto should be given Amnesty.
HELD:
Pardon Amnesty
Granted by the Chief Executive, Proclamation of the Chief Executive
private act which the Court takes no with concurrence of the Congress,
notice. public act which the Court should
take judicial notice
Granted after conviction Granted to classes of persons or
communitie who may be guilty of
political offenses generally before or
after the institution of the criminal
prosecution and sometimes after
conviction.
looks forward and relieves the looks backward and abolishes and
offender from the consequences of an puts into oblivion the offense itself, it
offense of which he has been so overlooks and obliterates the
convicted offense with which he is charged
*doesn’t restore right to hold public *as though no crime committed.
office or right of suffrage, unless
stipulated in the pardon
• Admittance of having committed the crime is not a condition precedent in
order to be granted Amnesty. It is enough that the offense committed comes
within the terms of the Amnesty Proclamation.
• The Commissions should conduct summary hearing of the witnesses both for
the complainants and the accused, on whether he has committed the offense
in furtherance of the resistance to the enemy, or against persons aiding in
the war efforts of the enemy, and decide whether he is entitled to the
benefits of amnesty and to be "regarded as a patriot or hero who have
rendered invaluable services to the nation."
• The court ordered the 14th Guerilla Amnesty Commission to hear and decide
the application for amnesty of petitioners Barrioquinto and Jimenez.
Separate Opinions: