You are on page 1of 3

c 


    
Patrick McAtee| Thermodynamics | 25 October 2010



 

According to thermodynamics, thermal radiation is the electromagnetic radiation emitted by a body as a


result of its temperature [1]. What is of interest in this lab, however, is that the thermal radiation
emitted by different objects at the same temperature can be of different values, although this is not
always immediately obvious. The purpose of this lab will be to show quantitatively that the radiation
emitted by four different surfaces is not equal to each other

 

mÊ Ohmmeter
mÊ Millivolt meter
mÊ Thermal Radiation Cube
mÊ Radiation Sensor
mÊ Westward Infrared Thermometer




The procedure can be found in Instruction Manual and Experiment Guide for the Pasco Scientific
Thermal Radiation System, pages 5 and 6, which is available online [2]. After taking the measurements
with the radiation sensor, the infrared sensor was also used to find the actual temperate for the surface,
whereas the radiation sensor gave a value in units of millivolts. This was the only addendum to the
methods described in the lab manual.



Power Setting - 5.0


Thermistor Resistance ʹ 11 Ñ
Temperature - 79.5 C

  
 c   
 0.008 81.1
ð  0.006 82.1

 ! 0.000 24.8
! 0.002 35.2
Power Setting ʹ 6.5
Thermistor Resistance ʹ 8.6 Ñ
Temperature - 87 C

  
 c   
 0.009 89.0
ð  0.009 91.0

 ! 0.000 27.6
! 0.002 37.8

Power Setting ʹ 8
Thermistor Resistance ʹ 4.7 Ñ
Temperature - 105 C

  
 c   
 0.014 108.9
ð  0.014 112

 ! 0.000 28.3
! 0.003 44.1

Power Setting ʹ 10
Thermistor ʹ 2.9 Ñ
Temperature ʹ 121 C

  
 c   
 0.018 123.7
ð  0.018 128.1

 ! 0.001 29.4
! 0.004 47.0



From the results it can be seen with relative ease that the radiation emitted by a surface being
warmed by the same light bulb is not the same. The ohmmeter was allowed to reach thermal
equilibrium in each of the above cases, yet the sides did not match up in temperature, hence
they were not emitting the same amount of thermal radiation





Although each of the four surfaces of the cube (polished aluminum, dull aluminum, white, and
black were exposed to the same heat source for the same amount of time, the sides did not
emit the same amount of thermal radiation, meaning they did not have the same temperature.
It is not immediately obvious why different surfaces exposed to the same amount of thermal
radiation will not have the same temperature. However, if you think of a mirror, for a moment,
what is a mirror's purpose? To reflect light; So by extension, it should reflect thermal radiation
to at least some degree. Thus, it will not get quite as hot as something that does not reflect
light. However, everything reflects radiation to some degree; it just comes down to a matter of
how much.

Albedo is what best describes how much radiation a surface reflects. Something with a high
albedo will reflect more radiation than a surface with a small albedo. Thus, if two surfaces are
exposed to the same amount of radiation for the same amount of time, the surface with the
highest albedo will have the lowest temperature. This is confirmed by the data as the polished
aluminum side of the radiation cube is approximately a mirror (it has a very high reflexivity).

One paradox inherent in the above data is that in every trial, the white side of the cube is
warmer is than the black side of the cube. White would seem to have a higher albedo, thus
reflecting more thermal energy, though that does not seem to be the case. Instead, since the
object is white, that means it is absorbing radiation of all visible light, and then must be
absorbing more thermal radiation than the black side. Black is the lack of color, so thus it is not
absorbing any radiation of the visible wavelength. This may not in fact be the case, though it is
an adequate explanation for the observed number.





Different materials exposed to the same heat source for the same amount of time will not
come to the same temperature. It is not immediately obvious from the experiment why this is.
This experiment opens up an odd paradox of thermal radiation. Why is the white hotter than
the black? How can this be explained?

[1 ]c  
. Wolfram Research. http://scienceworld.wolfram.com/ physics/ Thermal
Radiation.html Accessed ʹ 26 October 2010. (Shortlink - http://goo.gl/4vg2)
[2] Instruction Manual and Experiment Guide for the PASCO scientific Model TD-
8553/8554A/8555. Thermal  
 
.
ftp://ftp.pasco.com/Support/Documents/English/TD/TD-8554A/012-04695D.pdfTD/TD-8554A/012-
04695D.pdf (Shortlink - http://goo.gl/XDKh)