Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
/DSWRSVIRU$OO6WXGHQWV
"Y !LEJANDRA "ONIFAZ AND !NDREW :UCKER
4HIS PAPER IS A PRODUCT OF THE .ORTHEAST AND THE )SLANDS 2EGIONAL 4ECHNOLOGY IN %DUCATION #ONSORTIUM
,ESSONS ,EARNED !BOUT 0ROVIDING ,APTOPS FOR !LL 3TUDENTS WAS DEVELOPED BY %DUCATION
$EVELOPMENT #ENTER )NC %$# A PARTNER IN THE .ORTHEAST AND THE )SLANDS 2EGIONAL 4ECHNOLOGY
IN %DUCATION #ONSORTIUM .%)24%# WITH FUNDING FROM THE 53 $EPARTMENT OF %DUCATION
!DDITIONAL FUNDING WAS PROVIDED BY .ATIONAL 3CIENCE &OUNDATION GRANT 2%#
!NY
OPINIONS lNDINGS CONCLUSIONS OR RECOMMENDATIONS EXPRESSED IN THIS PAPER ARE THOSE OF THE AUTHORS
AND DO NOT NECESSARILY REmECT THE VIEWS OF THE SPONSORING ORGANIZATIONS
Ú #OPYRIGHT %DUCATION $EVELOPMENT #ENTER )NC %$# !LL RIGHTS RESERVED 0ERMISSION TO
COPY IS GRANTED FOR EDUCATIONAL USE
,1752'8&7,21 FORMER 'OVERNOR OF -AINE !NGUS +ING
SAID ABOUT THE LAPTOP INITIATIVE HE INITIATED
! GROWING NUMBER OF STATES ARE
SUPPORTING ONE
TO
ONE STUDENT
TO
h&OR MORE THAN YEARS -AINE
COMPUTER RATIOS BY PURCHASING LAPTOP HAS ALWAYS BEEN IN THE BOTTOM THIRD
COMPUTERS FOR ALL STUDENTS AND TEACHERS IN OF STATESIN PROSPERITY INCOME
PARTICULAR SCHOOLS OR AT PARTICULAR GRADES EDUCATION AND OPPORTUNITY FOR OUR
-AINE HAS BEEN A PIONEER IN THE UBIQUITOUS KIDS )N MY YEARS OF WORKING ON
COMPUTING MOVEMENT PROVIDING -AINE ECONOMIC ISSUES NO IDEA HAS
COMPUTERS AND WIRELESS )NTERNET ACCESS TO HAD AS MUCH POTENTIAL FOR LEAPFROGGING
ALL STUDENTS IN GRADES AND !BOUT ONE
THE OTHER STATES AND PUTTING -AINE
THIRD OF -AINES HIGH SCHOOLS WILL ALSO BE IN A POSITION OF NATIONAL LEADERSHIP
PROVIDING LAPTOPS TO THEIR STUDENTS IN THE AS THIS ONEGIVING OUR STUDENTS
n SCHOOL YEAR )NDIANA SUPPORTED PORTABLE )NTERNET
READY COMPUTERS
ONE OF THE EARLIEST ONE
TO
ONE INITIATIVES AS A BASIC TOOL FOR LEARNINGv #URTIS
-ICHIGAN .EW (AMPSHIRE .EW -EXICO A
4EXAS AND 6ERMONT ARE ALSO EXPERIMENTING
"ETTE -ANCHESTER DIRECTOR OF SPECIAL
WITH STATE
SUPPORTED LAPTOP INITIATIVES
PROJECTS FOR THE -AINE $EPARTMENT OF
AS ARE MANY INDIVIDUAL SCHOOL DISTRICTS
%DUCATION INCLUDING THE -AINE ,EARNING
THROUGHOUT THE 5NITED 3TATES INCLUDING
4ECHNOLOGY )NITIATIVE ADDS THAT hIF PEOPLE
(ENRICO #OUNTY 6IRGINIA THE LARGEST
ARE REALLY SERIOUS ABOUT SCHOOL REFORM AND
DISTRICT
FUNDED LAPTOP PROGRAM
LEVELING THE PLAYING lELD RAISING THE BAR
5BIQUITOUS OR ONE
TO
ONE COMPUTING FOR ALL KIDS THESE ARE TOOLS THAT CAN REALLY
ENVIRONMENTS ARE DIFFERENT FROM WHAT SUPPORT CHANGEv #URTIS B
ONE TRADITIONALLY lNDS IN MOST SCHOOL
!LTHOUGH ONE
TO
ONE PROGRAMS
SETTINGS BECAUSE THEY OFFER ALL STUDENTS
VARY FROM ONE ANOTHER THEY HAVE EACH
AND TEACHERS CONTINUOUS ACCESS TO A WIDE
DEMONSTRATED THAT A COMPREHENSIVE
RANGE OF SOFTWARE ELECTRONIC DOCUMENTS
SYSTEMIC APPROACH IS NEEDED IF THE INITIATIVE
THE )NTERNET AND OTHER DIGITAL RESOURCES
IS TO ACHIEVE THE DESIRED GOALS .O ONE
FOR TEACHING AND LEARNING 0OLICYMAKERS
COMPONENT IS SUFlCIENT FOR A SUCCESSFUL
GOALS FOR LAPTOP INITIATIVES INCLUDE
INITIATIVE AS REPRESENTED IN THE ILLUSTRATION
INCREASING ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS
ON THE COVER PAGE h)F ITS NOT GOING
,ESSONS ,EARNED !BOUT 0ROVIDING ,APTOPS FOR !LL 3TUDENTS
MISUSE OF LAPTOPS IT IS IMPORTANT TO NOT BRING HIS OR HER LAPTOP TO SCHOOL WHAT
,ESSONS ,EARNED !BOUT 0ROVIDING ,APTOPS FOR !LL 3TUDENTS
DEVELOP AND ESTABLISH A CODE OF CONDUCT HAPPENS ,APTOPS NEED TO BE CHARGED AND
THAT SPECIlES THE RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES OFTEN RE
CHARGED PRIOR TO AND DURING THE
OF STUDENTS WITH REGARD TO THE CARE AND SCHOOL DAY 7HERE WILL THIS OCCUR )S THERE
USE OF LAPTOPS !PPLE 0ROlLES IN 3UCCESS ADEQUATE POWER ANDOR SPACE AVAILABLE
(ENRICO 7ILL THE LAPTOPS BE COLLECTED AND THEN
REDISTRIBUTED DURING RECESS LUNCH GYM AND
s 3ET UP lLTERS AND OTHER CONTROL
EXTRA
CURRICULAR ACTIVITIES
MECHANISMS FOR LAPTOPS )N -AINE THE
I4UNES SOFTWARE A hDIGITAL JUKEBOXv WAS
NOT PROVIDED ON STUDENTS COMPUTERS
ALTHOUGH IT IS USUALLY PROVIDED WITH
75$,1,1* 352)(66,21$/ EFFECTIVE IN ADDRESSING THEIR NEEDS ,EMKE
-ARTIN /FFER TRAINING FOR BOTH
'(9(/230(17 CURRICULUM
SPECIlC AND CROSS
CURRICULAR
APPLICATIONS !T THE SAME TIME THAT TEACHERS
4RAINING AND PROFESSIONAL
ARE LEARNING ABOUT TECHNOLOGY INTEGRATION
DEVELOPMENT OF STAFF AT DIFFERENT LEVELS ARE
TECHNOLOGY COORDINATORS NEED STAFF
FUNDAMENTAL COMPONENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL
DEVELOPMENT ABOUT SCHOOL CHANGE PROCESSES
LAPTOP PROGRAM AND SHOULD BE PART OF THE
THAT SUPPORT THE KEY GOALS OF THE LAPTOP
INITIATIVE FROM THE START
PROGRAM
3URYLGHWUDLQLQJDQGSURIHVVLRQDO s &ORM A h4ECHNOLOGY ,EADERSHIP
GHYHORSPHQWIRUWHDFKHUVDQG 4EAMv &ROM THE ONSET ADMINISTRATORS
DGPLQLVWUDWRUVPDLQO\RQ AT 'ILLISPIE 3CHOOL IN ,A *OLLA RECOGNIZED
FXUULFXOXPLQWHJUDWLRQQRWRQO\RQ THAT hTHE LAPTOP INITIATIVE WOULD SUCCEED
WHFKQLFDOVNLOOV ONLY IF ALL TEACHERS RECEIVED ONGOING
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENTv !PPLE 0ROlLES
4EACHERS PARTICIPATING IN ONE
TO
ONE IN 3UCCESS 'ILLISPIE 4HEY THEREFORE
PROJECTS AGREE THAT IN ORDER TO MAKE THE FORMED A h4ECHNOLOGY ,EADERSHIP 4EAMv
TRANSITION TO UBIQUITOUS COMPUTING THEY WHICH TRAINED TEACHERS NEW TO CLASSROOM
NEED ASSISTANCE INTEGRATING TECHNOLOGY INTO TECHNOLOGY INTEGRATION AND PROVIDED
THE CURRICULUM NOT ONLY HELP DEVELOPING ONGOING TRAINING AND MENTORING TO TEACHERS
NEW TECHNICAL SKILLS /NE PIECE OF ADVICE AT ALL LEVELS AND SPECIALTIES 3IMILARLY $AN
FROM 'UNDERSON (IGH 3CHOOL 3AN *OSE %VANS FORMER 3TATE 3UPERINTENDENT OF
#ALIFORNIA TO OTHER SCHOOLS CONSIDERING )NDIANA ADVISES NEW INITIATIVES TO hPUT
ONE
TO
ONE COMPUTING IS hTHE SUCCESS OF TOGETHER A TEAM THAT BRINGS TOGETHER
YOUR LAPTOP PROGRAM DEPENDS ON HAVING EXPERTISE IN CURRICULUM LEARNING SCHOOL
TEACHERS WHO FEEL CONlDENT IN THE USE OF CHANGE AND TECHNOLOGY &OCUS ON GETTING
TECHNOLOGYv !PPLE 0ROlLES IN 3UCCESS TEACHERS READY TO USE THE TOOLS IN POWERFUL
'UNDERSON 3IMILARLY "ETTE -ANCHESTER WAYS FOR LEARNINGv ,EMKE -ARTIN
TOLD PRINCIPALS IN -AINE hIT WAS REALLY
CRITICAL THAT WE SET UP STAFF DEVELOPMENT
DURING THE DAY AND THAT WE BRING TEACHERS s 5SE A VARIETY OF TRAINING AND
TOGETHER BY CONTENT AREAv -ANCHESTER PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT FORMATS
4EACHERS VALUE BOTH FORMAL PROFESSIONAL
,ESSONS ,EARNED !BOUT 0ROVIDING ,APTOPS FOR !LL 3TUDENTS
%XLOGDQGPDLQWDLQWKHQHFHVVDU\ 0DNHWHFKQRORJ\VXSSRUW
QHWZRUNLQIUDVWUXFWXUH DYDLODEOHRQVLWHDVZHOODVRIIVLWH
2ELATIONS THIS INITIATIVE PROVED TO BE VERY )N LARGE LAPTOP INITIATIVES LIKE -AINES
EFlCIENT FOR ADDRESSING MINOR TECHNICAL STUDENTS AT DIFFERENT GRADE LEVELS USUALLY
PROBLEMS !PPLE 0ROlLES IN 3UCCESS RECEIVE LAPTOPS IN DIFFERENT YEARS /VER THE
(ENRICO LONG TERM AS COMPUTERS ARE USED MORE
ROUTINELY CHANGES MAY TAKE PLACE NOT
0$1$*,1*&+$1*( ONLY IN INSTRUCTION BUT ALSO IN ASSESSMENT
SYSTEMS EG ONLINE TESTING INSTRUCTIONAL
MATERIALS EG CLOSER TIES BETWEEN TEXTBOOKS
$OORZVXIÀFLHQWWLPHIRUFKDQJH
AND DIGITAL MATERIALS INCLUDING SOFTWARE
DQGPDNHLWJUDGXDO MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS INCLUDING DATA
DRIVEN
DECISION
MAKING AND COMMUNICATIONS
3TAKEHOLDERS NEED TIME NOT ONLY TO
WITH PARENTS EG THE USE OF PASSWORD
PROGRAM STUDENTS HELP LOCAL SENIOR CITIZENS
PROTECTED WEBSITES SUCH AS +0LANET INCREASE THEIR DIGITAL LITERACY ,EMKE
WHERE PARENTS CAN VIEW THEIR STUDENTS -ARTIN 4HEY ALSO ORGANIZE
GRADES AND ASSIGNMENTS ANNUAL PRESENTATIONS AT WHICH STUDENTS
USE TECHNOLOGY TOOLS 0OWER0OINT AND
)RVWHUDQGPDLQWDLQVWDNHKROGHU I-OVIE TO SHARE THEIR CONCERNS AND
SDUWLFLSDWLRQDQGRQJRLQJ PROPOSE SOLUTIONS TO PROBLEMS THAT THEY
FRPPXQLFDWLRQ HAVE IDENTIlED ,EMKE -ARTIN
(ENRICO INVOLVED STUDENTS FROM THE ONSET
7HEN ALL STAKEHOLDERS TEACHERS 4HEY CREATED hLEADERSHIP TEAMSv WHICH
ADMINISTRATORS STUDENTS PARENTS INCLUDED STUDENTS TEACHERS AND PARENTS
TECHNICIANS ETC ARE WELL
INFORMED ABOUT FROM THE HIGH SCHOOLS TO DISCUSS THE LAPTOP
THE PROJECT AND COLLABORATE WITH ONE PROGRAM PRIOR TO ITS IMPLEMENTATION
ANOTHER EMERGING PROBLEMS ARE MORE EASILY !PPLE 0ROlLES IN 3UCCESS (ENRICO
IDENTIlED AND CAN BE ADDRESSED AT AN EARLY
STAGE 021,725,1* (9$/8$7,21
s 5SE VARIOUS APPROACHES TO REACH 4O MEET THE CHALLENGES OF
OUT TO THE BROAD COMMUNITY !LL -AINE IMPLEMENTING A LAPTOP INITIATIVE TO LEARN
SCHOOLS HELD PARENT NIGHTS AT AN EARLY STAGE MORE ABOUT ITS IMPACTS AND TO INFORM
OF THE LAPTOP PROGRAM AND MOST CONTINUE ONGOING DEBATES ABOUT THE VALUE OF THESE
TO HOLD ANNUAL PARENT NIGHTS (ENRICO INITIATIVES ONGOING MONITORING AND
#OUNTY CREATED A hKEY COMMUNICATOR EVALUATION ARE CALLED FOR
NETWORKv THROUGH WHICH STAKEHOLDERS
COMMUNICATE VIA E
MAIL TO LEARN ABOUT 0DNHPRQLWRULQJRQJRLQJ
ACCOMPLISHMENTS AND ADDRESS CHALLENGES
.EWSLETTERS COMMUNITY GATHERINGS 3OME CHALLENGES MAY BE FORESEEN AND
FORMALINFORMAL PRESENTATIONS AND ADDRESSED DURING THE PLANNING STAGE BUT
CONSULTATIONS WITH COMMUNITY LEADERS CAN OTHERS EMERGE AS IMPLEMENTATION TAKES
ALL BE HELPFUL !PPLE 0ROlLES IN 3UCCESS PLACE /NGOING MONITORING HELPS IDENTIFY
(ENRICO 4HE -ANATEE #OUNTY &LORIDA OBSTACLES AT AN EARLY STAGE &OR EXAMPLE
SCHOOL DISTRICT ADVISES OTHER PROGRAMS (ENRICO #OUNTY FOUND IT HELPFUL TO USE
TO FOSTER ONGOING COMMUNICATION WITH FOCUS GROUPS OF TEACHERS AND STUDENTS ON A
,ESSONS ,EARNED !BOUT 0ROVIDING ,APTOPS FOR !LL 3TUDENTS
PARENTS 4HEY DID SO THROUGH CONTINUOUS REGULAR BASIS TO IDENTIFY AND SYSTEMATICALLY
hPARENT NIGHTv GATHERINGS AND BROADCASTS ADDRESS UNFORESEEN PROBLEMS THAT OCCURRED
OF h4ECH 4IMEv A 46 SHOW THAT GIVES DURING IMPLEMENTATION OF THEIR ONE
TO
ONE
INFORMATION ABOUT THE PROGRAM AND INITIATIVE %DWARDS
GENERATES DISCUSSIONS VIA CALL
INS !PPLE
0ROlLES IN 3UCCESS -ANATEE -EETING &RQGXFWUHVHDUFKRUHYDOXDWLRQ
WITH 04! PRESIDENTS AND CREATING PARENT VWXGLHV
NEWSLETTERS CAN ALSO HELP
"ECAUSE LAPTOP INITIATIVES ARE NEW
s )NVOLVE STUDENTS )NDIANA ORGANIZES AND TECHNOLOGIES ARE CHANGING THERE IS
EVENTS WHERE STUDENTS ACT AS MENTORS STILL MUCH TO BE LEARNED 3OME USEFUL
TO PARENTS SIBLINGS AND THE BROADER EVALUATIVE STUDIES OF LAPTOP INITIATIVES HAVE
COMMUNITY 4HROUGH THE h4ECH $AYSv BEEN DONE SEE HTTPUBIQCOMPUTINGORG
FOR REFERENCES (OWEVER THERE IS STILL A PROlCIENCY
PAUCITY OF INFORMATION ABOUT COST ISSUES
IMPACTS ON STUDENT LEARNING IN MANY s ,OOK FOR WAYS TO EVALUATE THE LONG
SUBJECT AREAS AND OTHER IMPORTANT TOPICS TERM COSTS AND BENElTS OF THE TECHNOLOGY
:UCKER ;= PROVIDES AN EVALUATION INFRASTRUCTURE "OTH COSTS AND BENElTS ARE
FRAMEWORK AND AN AGENDA FOR STUDYING ONE
DIFlCULT TO QUANTIFY BUT UNDERSTANDING
TO
ONE PROGRAMS 3OME NEEDED STUDIES ARE THEM IS IMPORTANT ,ITTLE HAS BEEN WRITTEN
INEXPENSIVE AND COULD BE DONE IN
HOUSE ABOUT THE COSTS OF LAPTOP PROGRAMS AND
FOR EXAMPLE IT WOULD BE VALUABLE TO HAVE ABOUT THE RELATIONSHIP OF THOSE COSTS TO THE
MORE DESCRIPTIONS OF CREATIVE TEACHERS USES BENElTS
OF LAPTOPS DURING A SEMESTER OR A YEAR )N
OTHER CASES EXTERNAL GRANTS FROM FEDERAL s ,ET THE RESEARCH QUESTION DRIVE
STATE OR PRIVATE SOURCES MAY BE AVAILABLE FOR THE CHOICE OF METHOD 4HERE ARE TOO
RESEARCH -AINE FOR EXAMPLE IS CONDUCTING MANY INTERESTING QUESTIONS TO ASK ABOUT
A RANDOMIZED EXPERIMENTAL TRIAL OF ITS LAPTOP PROGRAMS FOR YOU TO STUDY THEM ALL
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT INTERVENTION IN $EPENDING ON THE RESEARCH QUESTIONS YOU
MIDDLE SCHOOL MATHEMATICS USING RESEARCH CHOOSE SURVEYS CASE STUDIES EXPERIMENTS
FUNDS FROM THE 53 $EPARTMENT OF OR OTHER METHODS MAY BE APPROPRIATE .O
%DUCATION ONE METHODOLOGY IS BEST FOR ANSWERING ALL
QUESTIONS
!UTHORS OF A NEW BOOK ABOUT
EVALUATING EDUCATIONAL TECHNOLOGY IN &21&/86,216
SCHOOLS -EANS (AERTEL SUGGEST
THAT THERE ARE A SMALL NUMBER OF IMPORTANT !S COMPUTERS AND WIRELESS NETWORKS
EVALUATION PRINCIPLES THAT WILL HELP GUIDE BECOME MORE CAPABLE AND LESS EXPENSIVE
FUTURE WORK EACH YEAR MORE STATES AND DISTRICTS ARE
PROVIDING ALL STUDENTS WITH A COMPUTING
s ,OOK FOR CRITICAL INmUENCES AT DEVICE 4HESE INITIATIVES ARE COMPLEX AND
MULTIPLE LEVELS OF THE EDUCATION SYSTEM CHALLENGING 3TATES AND DISTRICTS THAT ARE
4HERE ARE MANY INmUENCES ON TEACHERS NOW BEGINNING TO IMPLEMENT ONE
TO
ONE
AND STUDENTS USES OF TECHNOLOGY 3TUDY COMPUTING SHOULD TRY TO BENElT FROM
THOSE INmUENCES THAT ARE MOST IMPORTANT THE MANY LESSONS THAT OTHERS HAVE LEARNED
IN YOUR CONTEXT STATE OR DISTRICT POLICIES THROUGH EXPERIENCE !MONG THE MOST
SCHOOL LEADERSHIP DEMOGRAPHICS OF SCHOOLS IMPORTANT OF THOSE LESSONS IS TO FOCUS
TEACHERS TRAINING AND EXPERTISE ETC $ONT ON THE DESIRED GOALS !CCORDING TO "ETTE
,ESSONS ,EARNED !BOUT 0ROVIDING ,APTOPS FOR !LL 3TUDENTS
WWWCICONLINEORG
,ESSONS ,EARNED !BOUT 0ROVIDING ,APTOPS FOR !LL 3TUDENTS
3ILVERNAIL $ , ,ANE $ -
4HE )MPACT OF -AINES /NE
TO
/NE ,APTOP 0ROGRAM ON -IDDLE 3CHOOL
4EACHERS AND 3TUDENTS n 0HASE /NE 3UMMARY
%VIDENCE -AINE %DUCATION 0OLICY 2ESEARCH
)NSTITUTE 5NIVERSITY OF 3OUTHERN -AINE
/FlCE 2ETRIEVED /CTOBER ST FROM
HTTPWWWUSMMAINEEDUCEPAREPDF
MLTI-,4)0HASE/NE%VALUATI
ON2EPORTPDF