Criteria to evaluate

Contents (8 points) 7-8 points
Show knowledge and
understanding about
contents that were excellent
searched show evidences in
searching various
documents
Having important essence of
contents clearly with details
to support
Show comparisons by
referred to factual evidence
Organize documents in a
nice language
5-6 points
Show some knowledge and
understanding about
contents that were searched
Show evidences in searching
various documents
Having important essence of
contents with details to
support but not clear
Show comparisons by
referred to some factual
evidence
Organize documents in a
good language
3-4 points
Show knowledge and
understanding about
contents that were
searched with limitations
Show one or two sources of
evidences in searching
documents
Having important essence
of contents with details to
support but limited
Show comparisons by
expressing personal
opinions
Rarely organized
documents searched
1-2 points
Rarely show knowledge
and understanding about
contents that were searched
Show one or two sources of
evidences in searching
documents but lacks of
important essences and
details to support
Show comparisons by
expressing personal
opinions and not organized
documents searched at all

Usage of Language
(4 points) 4 points 3 points 2 points 1 point
Use vocabulary grammar and Use vocabulary grammar and Use some vocabulary Use many mistakes of
punctuation correctly and punctuation correctly or grammar and punctuation vocabulary, grammar and
completely or having not having 4-5 mistakes correctly or having 5-8 punctuation
more than 3 mistakes mistakes