i

++J
I

L I dG I

pGIA~I J !
~

.v I j C " J 1 4 1 L
: F U l
J 2 k j
&A - &

dy ~iI& Y hg i f j hi >i 'y J ~ !J 9 &

~+l+l
& G 2 b sU

Jd\ 2 G \ A d \?Is ;\A\" + j ~ t 22 ++ A41 & JpJ1 I =

I A d l ,+U J3i d&Yl
I I

>
I

I
; ; i2

+ *u 9
,,&l+l',

+ j d J 8 '+ l d

'

A &

JXI

&dlAIL

J>~I & d l
> .LG

d2u\

+&!

'++L l &d LC u+>>I '";i_jL9' .. *i! &$I) lib & > -91 $L 1 6 5 9
. L L& l & U + d j

i ; b

+ j3 ' ( " + I ~ I !

~ 3 1 , d -$I , + l

- I U
2 -

, I ;

ek >

j i i ~&I
+&Yl

+\-I p u l

:JL ;1WI + M I

+ .-

2 s s d l %+I
2;Ul

9 21L Y I $i ;' 3 ~ 2) ~l>;jL >,A

/Y&

Pctrr Bcrger. "On the Obsolesccncc o f thc Corlccpt o f Honour". in Michael Sandel ed.. I~iherolisrnandirs Crirics, iNr!%'r'ork: N c n York University Press. 1984). p.149.
b$

'LlAxr

'Y 1 i U &$I

A'L$Y

?*

ubl$x
. 2 L U I

- . +

.
@1 > p

LL+ + , l ' L+

""l$I"
4 j $1

L i .(kratia + 'demos = 4) . 1 + " I $ kP 2 .q u i - L &p . rliber : z ~ J - ' & & i a ~ j &

I 4 (&I ;

d~ U) "*\&dY

a Jy2

. a L

4 ."d~
G

j L y
+ I

-L2

+A

. JI-YI

>GYLYI
~ s

4 > b y .ci
" 4 1

$1 +Y UI

liberalis '"p"
GG,~II

' L ~ L ~ J ~ I , +&I

+J.L~Y) -+ji A Y (Alexis de -3 4' 3 w? Y cI LU c 1 j & "(~oh11 Stuart Mill) L&>Is?;--'j j *ill

88q~&~88 > "+~&dr J PIJIG & s & j j i -41 d-141 +&sji u

&j

V~ocqueville)

> ~ l ~ L ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ( i i j l ) 4 l + J & i t j J _ > ? i &

hp

~
C &

+ ;J JH
.+ (I

& Y (&HI L & *i>) WIqi

c-3

>ki;lJl

J J M Y I pUiill

u & J&!dl I l

&w d l & i e & ! I 5s .L >>i > &? + L ' ! Q L Y L ' t U Y I> + & I > @I & p &a +dl + I & '4 >dl U >h J > ' L L i l l + i I 1p
O +

>&

& l j

c(\ V

t - \ Try)

(John Locke) 4p-l

j~ 4 A Y l

h W I

+LYI
1 -

>LI>>

'-IA~I,

$91~a??,I, L L & ! .
&

- l d
I
,

+WI > $1 L+L ,i

3~
.iI>YI
+ I
L+

+YI

3 i i , d + " &! UL , >I+ ~1I&, 2& hUI, ; > d l 1

J,L

L ! %

& I LIL Jj i+" ,

291-L

I++ ~
J2,

Ll i +I&'

LL E I 2 , &I
@I

jG, 2
&i
&I $1

>4 ,"

2 .ASYI
:A,*)

>

j113YI
$ +k I>+

++ LG
fr? ~i i, I +
:$i

&+,

*LCI ,$ . i ~ l l + d l
& . =
i l &*

& JA
4~

L"GI+ j L Y l Lli j

c"&J

j?ij _I!
+y

i+,Ixl?l

,&Aibd isp 2 b , , ~a ,~ \ ;

,JWl-, ."&I 1 >'(lqAY 1.$' I,

jl j Y l i
<I , Y

.!YY-1Yl

'Alexis de Toequevillr. Denzocrocy in Aniericn, (New York: WashingLon Square Press, Inc.. 1564). p. 96. '~ohn Stuart Mill. On L i b e r p , in E.A. Burtt ed.; The English Philosophers >om Bocon l o .Mill. (Ncw York: Random House. 15391, p. 55 1 ' ~ e o r g eH. Sab~ne.A H i x t o ~ ofPolitica1 T h e o ~ (New York: Holt. Rinzhalt and . Winston. 1561). p. 669.