Gauthier - The Logic of Leviathan

-h.
···
'
le·· -···
.. -
L --..
.-
The Moral a .d Political Theory of Thomas .'~'-'..bes
Copyri hted ma nal
'T"'
'H--'Ei:_ 'L"·O·:-"Gr'~·!I-C'. O·",'·F(I ',__:__ .. ) '_ ':' _.,..:__. :

._...:.... _
't' E,'lV',:": I'A" T~i::HA; '·'.'N:' '

• [ I ~ [ _,,_.~
Copy rig hted m ateri al
IT-II JH: I..

'__ _ l
' , .•
'_
LO
.' ','".'
.....
··,·:-:··,G·:-:IlrC·/.··':._.I.. '.. ' _ ~
,Q:I··:·:--:-·······'rFI I.:
". :. :.:'.' .' :_.
. 0--.:..... .:.
.~.!
L··· .'V', ~'-:--A'-'

,
~1
J .:'. L [' .::'
,
.'
T'
I •
"-H' -'A'" N'"

. I"
•
," ",
'. •
1· ....,··
.:.
'.
.._ ••••
"
~.:._
•••••
i1"::___"::
'D··'···A=V,il"'D·::
,_.. " '.',' ,~I~-
, __
'p,.')
)
l~
G-~A·UI'iT.·"H':I"?R·.
":'
'J'
..
"
JI
.••
~,.__:.;
m..,...t,---m ,...,; ,.rm:iI~~~' :nt.n;..;..~"; "rJ.'

~
U~6I'T~t:o
...< ~~: ' _I:~ OX-F-OR'D

_' ,---'
[
'J
"
Copyrighted material
... OI"'~1O(-JRDiiiiiii [~.1.}' ._1IlH'.tI.I__

t~l. __
,lIT.·.1
"_r._
••
'O_tl~,:~IDVCIrd!IIllC:t,"·
11:
[~n'
h
1.,1 _.,' _ .,.
IwliU.,,_:~,
:t'iLF'WI'i'!iIi~c~C:~
11'11, .....
r [l1~ 11 I~Pcihiili~iIi
I
.,;ufr,4-~ [~Ii' .~... F-....:ii'·~iIli~...;i1 , "",,J .UK;I1.i!JUI~II~t~1'!U'II; ! ~~
ti'at-~~~'~llot'CI(d._lia rc&1[niil! iliDliQWp;~. I-.diltdii.b :b',pilin'lII"lI"Olidwiilk"m ~ ,A.Ui4WI '......
I~""'''I':-~ ""'-~' II
II~
Oif:anJ '.I:'::' ,~~

~"'_ift
N ~. - __ ,
L
~.
K.. III,ll_.., IIbidddJ~: tnhiil ,r... '~:111_llk ii_1 'Sii -"paR! . '........ :iIL.+. l~ •• ~!111!!1!"" [~ .~~_ ~ __ II!!I"
_j_
~ ~" Dif.~ 18 ~1.,I.Ii'M"""'~,
...-Ii
I~~I ~
I~~-~ II"~"'~'
_
~·>h!CI
'1!III: - _OC;jjliii, '1'
~r~
~J
lMabI~
III' \i!j,-i1Iiii':IjI',,":,,~·~, ~1~'Y~I!I'iI!IH!IIi
:_......iIi]_......,._~,:j'!i'itliijIIi,~.IIII!Ii. -- iiI!!.~ ~WIII!
iiti:t...;..~ ]D.A:'iiti _I !IQIIIiII.Md
'''cbldlilf.
,!.,
-,r--iliiliil ~;..- ~ , Il~r~ Ln~ ....... .. ,

1111
M'lmIbI~
II",_..J~'·.I] ~.:awJlgg
OdQ_w iliIi·RP~'~·I"'ofIOllO'I!d]
jOJ
llic;:~K ml,_ilill Of_~iidUlo !1Qid
U~~~~
bJ~
11f .l~'_
'Nb1ilh::I] iiDI'kl'U~] S~taJ [U~ldbl[~"tliil;:~~ 6'5'''~

IIIIDlford.rtr~[~,
[1;.,1
c~
__ =__ ~ i
... ~"""" ~ ..Yi,iull 'lHr;O,luU!liul!'
lIINI,VC
~-.'b«n
n •••
·~-~"_"l )!IIIa1IaJ
i~tI~ ~~) jpU1dQrd
Wn_~'iji' llm!u;;"giar:-,
~:I)OO
:I!....
'~i:ind:L !Ii 11IiQ'~!IIII ~'l ,,_ . 1l1li ~I......
L __ ....
Qf.~I:~_tkr:::=l~~;=-:~;=~~
~_ ~
"'-L_-: ~, ' )"1-1 _1_._~
~I ~.
_-_J
'ii!.i·~1 iI[~
~1I!iIi,,,,,,rclF~t.I: [iii.o.I:oiI:.....~:...-Ii· ll.~~· ~I~J~; ~_n~ _.,_~_IIl1_.... _.._~ __ 'ffiI'i¥ [~ ~
:=-_,-i_ !Ii,,.,~
1 '·;I>--';:;..;;uJI. .....J!..I!~~_~~_~ ~
rta iaDIiI flH'ml eM'~'bI';J" ~ ~ ~ ~.~.~~ ~~
r.c:pn.1d.~
.I~ __
..
_~J
,iI-nv. ~_I' _~-'I# ---
,~~tlIitl~~II=~==,i::~~~~t::~
IOiJnij(lill"_:~'[D.aig"'-" EDqQi_lki:'~!(r~ru_DI',~IiMI:
I'~" ·.. .
lnQl;,~m
ud! ;ou'II[UII;'~!fMI~'I~I,gglll1J~U~
'[hil !~,
hil.~J
mba' &adIq; !lJr;'OO'~Ii'
.ISB'N 11)-.19"'!Ui(i]~·>: 9'

10g1 Iidd\.:~ :Pi;~'_1 ,1IHtIa :Sfimt;,.r~ I~
[~]id:G_,!BpUhl
K'W1iI,~g
(bJhP'lI~llna.:
- __ ·,-1 ~l~J ... ........ [~'1~..._ i!I!;llll ~-~ ~r~
'----I I~,
'A"-" -.-=lIiII·'~, 1~<~, •. ~_"-':"'I~I ~,~J,~IHlI~
~J
-"IIWII'
._l~
~..._·(.-liI!I'
~,~ndIU.-(1
~'jlM
Diil&1:iM'aIl~,~I,~dwi"~:~,~·
" ... ........__ i:lt.. ~~-"'---I~ ~IIII!I ~,,':
=~r
WlJ, .....
-~l~_
' ......... ,~..Ii.;.."iI'rom ~

~
~r-'~~ ...~lt"IiI.a·.....::1iIi ......... 't:L ..._L ·t.r.... ..~ ,m,!II,~JMI;~iI' '.'" .... _.'. '!!If,1II1~·1II'J!'I'.1!.'~1
ll.11 ::.
ii... t_~._~"H_.·_·
"'II ........ eii,.;,orrli']i;.·I"~-.!Ii,~ilijl~ h . ~I; ~_Iwql ~-~~~~~Irl
.•I~iliJg.,~I~. ·
:1:0, ,I:P' ,I' 'w:m!c :1, 'IlriR~,unp~'bH8'h.l :paper' on B~obbesi"ill : . aI, dmory:. Gtaduail, I beGame aware't'iDt a larpr 'pmJ;d . 'WU ~ ,ahlpe~ :BBd In :BtlmmeN [oJ 11g6,~ amd I tot, );. ' ._ ''''1 .' Irst dr.aft 'mf"'1ID 'P"i':mmmt wom ' [The' ,~r. ...~ 1\)-;-leHOtIdm~', in 'w:WclR, :aItno&t: ;aD.• f rdle ~',pan,tuis mmdu,em:, 'waa 'w:nttlUlm, tllCj '1,dD;I~ '~lf:':[[t'?' at IOidoEil!l1i
_i
I. _
l.'r
••
l_l
__
••
-.••
_~
1 __
•.•.
I.
__
J ••
__
~.-.
._~
'
..
III.AI
I[_I.
.~l~
_~ __
'.WEb" baa, oR'lmita! po'6til_,[Iluthon!iy' on yftHmited _tUvi:",

~tii:i'a1illll" g~- -- - . -.-Ii
'1i~v' ': ·"·.I)[l~1 '~iI;~lIAIlli v.~a·l 'III. .1 .Vlg._or. _ 'n"~_]I~-~ _ .1
[~~'IMr:s,;:l!! '1;I"'I"i~~~1 [nJu.u~
[~W(i,-=..,.,~~,Iii; ~"_~-UlIUI'L!!U'-
i''i! 'rnn'I~~I.~m~ '~~~iFQ g r~.I- ,u. __ I~JI:l~-u'~IJJ'

J
~,..~ll~ l.J
..~~
po'lJitiical Audlmrity:" BI1II' dte 'p'em;' :iI 'tOOl Atmng
~DIit1I, 1!1:I11I1m.~~,
'ii!'"
[~ll'-fl'ili<":"li1iiii~oa;iR~D' 'li"-M!uiRl ' g~~ n'ii'~j~40 i!I, ~1'iI','1;~:~jj:ntl' 'liiliiiAilil, ~v._.J.fI~~", _.' ,Ill "'!w.''; 1'._... ,rtl1!lW:1~1~1_~ IUL~:l--g-II-Il:.-~el tIi "',"=-.lll ,,. ..a;:....;::,d."ii ... I1!'" '11..:1 ,:1 :1"' '" ... ..:1
,Imt, i~~ Will ,t),Dtstandling' meriM~ Fimt ,of' aJ~~1HODbts :bs, .trodll,(~aa liJum' •• ' ~l"ftaDt: meral and plUi:i:ca1[ [ooKee"a[ 'w:h:id,\], dDe"~:'Out' aueBmn,!, ObJ~pti~a his, 'basi1: :moml is, mD""t :md, I know DO[ [oth&n"' pltilw.,:her' 'wBmis boU), :ta Illmlrina~II" d.lht, ;~_Rd 10 ilurnlmtin.:g1y 'w:mlt~ aooUIt, 'it.. , ,AuthomalioD :ia hlis bail; :p'~lli,ea1[a)aee~ptj amd I: :tno,w' en. tU'her ,.J~,tica'l,til.tid 'wilDt baa RQ1,plizcdJ ed, e~,loited :11:
j
1
oldy' :1Ilar.e1l,:fOU9W1~ 'Tbe: taco", ,q 3, :fa~~U'M~
Ct.i';~~~i~,;_t~~~_;l~~i~~, t~[~:*.;'~, (;i)~ In,d,t~id~ai~;n

(cur 'it'he mR ...
t:~r...F .... ,.~'rilil:UiJfmm, 'w~.ltu ,JU~"~,i 'OLU,Y .urotiru

l ~
,~~tl:-~
I.'
:.'i~'~,i~.~.. ,~;:,l"'v,n'l[li a-g_~J~-Ii~'J ,~_Il.

Vlli [1''!IIiI!~Ul
;10, ably'
,~iI,~
la, ia_fdm:I'
Um1~edJ:i[uliM.nlll~, I' 'vinita II_m~ 'IU\ ;:-" ClJ1! "', ~".}~!1.. DB ,~L, ,"'~W'II[I ,IHe Iltu£Bi, Dl~lp~ltr 'UlJC, ,6~""""w Df' ." ":n=--oii"lf.. ,~.~ men '!l.,Ill,eJr"~,[, ._Rg ;:.' :0_ 'm,[maIder' each. 'Mhr'la .t:erata for ,tbeir' 'GW;O :ake, Imd 'Dm :aa,:.aDI[ to ise1H~salwami.m;1 :I.or om,'tUe ,eiBmC:1 ,of' iuD!m-, 'dona, 81 '.e mems of' 'bol'A,reonce.ot:mtml ,and,:1Dni~I' polib~
'wol!lld _:
,'ii"
:"_,'~d ("~T: ::lIIlit ","""~"u ~H,lo1f.'besi 'has, semJn~"JJi''''

j '_"~~
'~1~;'Lc'~1,,1I''!IIiI!' ,I;JIl.Ii-1
~'m·.
L!I!"'!111'_
'Ae ,rmation be1!,weenIOv eRip and

l It __
'~'4.rt' ILlI_~~_ILlIr.
l_md :plltical ,au;tkority
m~:"chj to[ 'I~.",~~b'lIt'I·~'J(L us 'w1..,...,.., ~ f'""~~ ~~,gu _u~"~. ~eae~~ ~~~ose

GR
"'~i,
.•
;nl:"\"'~ '-'~Jt.~ _I~1U1
~iIt;""''''R, ~
'power' ..
,., .! _~[ :
'Ria ~ b, :r-e~:,~~ m'_[[~et~I' • ~~ I~P'L~"~[ me fw~ 0;: ~"~Lc,~U ~"'dii u [: ~ ~ ~~~ ~llaie tJte ~~~IJILre -~'f' U bil, ·theoJJ:~ :But :ilf we look '1.1'ft1), :hi8 alJumeD,t: ,0, ,a,:lRdtimg'
c,~,n~_ c~l~:
'1,I_ll_CSC
[I_~I
~ ~Il
...
,;!i;;;no, 'a.I_lIll
-~IIi.-~~ .._:g:r-'Ir.l
;jI'Ij~~nt,
,'Ila'i ';apprmiiate: :its wu:c",., For 10, lIn.de.lBm_ftl' :failtLR\,we :a'lso,'u'ftdemtaRiI, 'w~hai,:lllJ1Dt 'I.; :added tD [Dvcwum,cl .. t (alDIC.. We' ,ca'D, 't'lle'n :31.,6 :fmllll 8, :Mi&im1Jrm1~lime~ [00 lhumaft, ,coodwi~'1 ,aBd, itutimtiortl!1l
favYQumbfe' luu;mptblu"
'R'
_a: " '," IS ,_.A .'i./: :": ,~~-~, ...... 'I:""C iI!IfIi ~ " ~ ~"'·:d'~ '!!I!UruCllJ~, ft.ILIU,ull!lB ' ,mI :811J1ltu,'~1 PIQW,_t::" o.'~ ifeaS(L~"'_lJ~; 'tasII ;~-,'._e ~~"C"llalb-'ilel.':"_~_',
'-'..'~
i.
,.~ IUJ.!'
~'iiII6,~'Ii~ ~_'_WU1U_r"'i~
'I 'lr~~ ;i~~'11 IA'f,ACAiP' I'H'1I'I·:.. [_:' _IJ~_~~.I1 v,.~lJI{c~"_]
i!iOf!\!;
Y~II
.. ,L;iI]j;,
U_l_;-~
'I..
[-.J
••
_.-.~'
for
:1~i'!D;D'~'iIi,[('I['~ ' [111 w.6

~. [ftl~ ~I
,:p. :fig68
:u~r~,
ol7'~[Ol['fJ
'il
:~,
,...."."
If
4~
£iill
';i!'oi;
:gt..
1'8::1
"In 1;1['1[:[ C'At(.,
ic'o:!r\n;:~j'rlT;5,:::If('OIRM,A't, :Iiillnft~ tn[I'~lljU!i
'It;;,]:
llt~U
A"AJllllt'~uni'tMtriQD
~6
'l!l!_~_~' ~:Al.n··.
:lM
.J!!JJI~
'M,,1If
!!Ill
I", T:6:1 :N'tr.:'U'I.,~L :K,UtC:I>[Q'M [~~' (lH,l~,P

'''', ,ft"
1;10
"1'·8:1"
".[ ): 'I
B~ :DlriiH :uw'
t1i,t:i1 ;i."j:~··,(~1
~
I';'!ic,:l:~ II'"'~'jl~g~, J1 ifi'i","",,' ~!i
'~~illIl!!o
'.I~~':1;..~, ~[ [I!!o!l,i!!
I);\jilli·~"": ftgiU:
Ilil
2h, ~_.'"
.~' .l'1-l
~,iiJ!1ii[~[
'!;iIi ,"",!II.!!'
~':~:C ~ ~ !iiI!~B'i!!!!':Ii ~ 'irS!

'0"
ISS
:':'0:
:'M· : ['M' - I '_.~~.
3,', iCi :a'~'.

,~~,~~,
iIj'[;il'!'il'iI:,'-;>['""'i,iIi ,~,",~,.U·~ ~"'iI'"; ~ ~ V ~~i
"0·: :'~l"~Iil"~,.''', ,!L~ ~
la,81[~
'Ii['I.
,1'~"~' 11l:~ll
..
l:M[
,A~ Th~' N:atl!l~ :Kin,ld.Q.n ,~(' [GOO Hul, Comfl"H)frwftithl

m,
B"
:IH[
''!IftjJ
I~-~l
ifJ'"
,ii" ..> _ (_
·:M'D['~v J,tDJ4.
1"
I:
"1,_I~
'~M'~"iD~'H': , '0",' 'U----c, i __

J ••••• "
1'.' ~,[:
[Tb" aceourrt,.... Iulletta, ,I Datu~al!istit H:)R~amtiQn.[0;' ib ~ ~ '---~.!r"_' 11 - __ ~ ~ f' .WIJEIR I. .~._ ~--...i1k--""":~CaI ,,,,,~ '.:.'lil(· ~i':r~ [~~lir~t~:~hHiif~''FIL :ifll, ,:~[ 'f~~~ '~~~~ [I(' ~'!,",;@, ,~~qg=I_~-. -.._~ uJI.). '~lnIC Ul_ ~-. 'U_l~,
-11•
,l""_
.'.
_.
-_,-
•• _
••
--
I"
••
•.
[[
.•
'_
..
_~.
__
j-._,
i~._.~"'._
.~"_
,_:~-_._~
__
..
[Ail
~Ii
...
_I.-V,I:II U\·
[1!1i.
I"'"
ILI.1I1
.~-
...
,~WT klliJ~-""
[~H--:I"'~I' U',oI;'[T'-' .. n~"(2I ~'"!!!I.,~. _' U.""GI

.II ~
,iI]'Ii~'iC' ~~.
'M_'-
1',illLn',,',~,~,'
ill.,, ,'I ,.lll -H~' 'IL'L ,.I Ai, E' 'w:~o_;J;e", ~H'~' ',~~Q~;ues ...._A.....:Ii.. Pl, 1L" lrano 'Uestp '~tr' ,~~,[~ag, i'U,Cce~~ :uid[ a uruned, seieftct', "Utestiions, of mor,all and poIliti1:s, 'wfJufd, be; t]'mied, ill a, ,nre1,y' :SJA!t'betic: ItmliU'~er'~, deriMatinn, :~Nm 'du:: b:y Iilillpf'Cme; - 'mlat~6ms'ol-;C ~nl!leiii-;ln,'Mtab];~h~ -,' ,thmB~,:m arW~~-[ "" ~,,,_1 - - -[',F' P_ -, , ,,' -;1,"",18 II(f' booy~'1:0,1: :i'D biis,,poliiltial 'writi-nIP' €;I,per,i£:l:m Rpk_ thisi
[Tids, i~ ,thl!l HiSOIJu,ti~~fim,pos~)t;:VI~ :~oo, fir 'GalilI!oo,[ d~e;.,;, ~oped in th~' Sch::m~of:Pad ~,~We, ~3~~':" -:'~t~-~':~~~,"c~~:,II~'_'~' ,'~~~~U~'i''-'-~ 'reso:lve or' as HatJhftlOften , __ e, U ,'~ '~~:~:l~~~ p,-,~ ~~ '_'ID [sa,'J~, ll~_I~ys.e11,w.o~e~~J~~,.~ Of a 'COIDII.onwel!lJth, a : jtch:, .IU:II :ill, [CQnstlltI!i:CR': pans,[ diSCQIVer.img ae :f;leJtatu:nu[ :mfltll dlC: '-I'ds, 'w:hrie'h 'then Ifla'b'la us to r-0001ftposc~0r' :BYD'lhmiH:
:,t~,-'_~~]_"~~~-~~,~,-]
~,_:__j ~
m~.
"t
I~J
~~ue:
..:ib..
[II
h,
Billll,
'~--
[de_clgu.R~'T,h,e, Maim, cno,fC~''';/tJlUmi1[ r,ml a,Je,I/]Ji '(,B~l'W~ ii,[ 'P'[I' xii)1 'p.,1d~ ,anaj,ptic; D!Lllment: i~~mdmtt·to, ~\l1e [e&.&~, 't'g: :'riAei:pl. ,tll,.oral aDd 'poUltiad 'pMlmaopby~
" :H.o'b'bes[ ;rlletrates, 'du;~'mom,ellis, of :
st'ti()11 _ . -~~~'_ J~ ,_'U__;,
~;llr'i~,). ,.,lfin d~·]·~U~ U, L~

!O ,l,l_iI __
,rCso:lwulm
:LRU,
,Iii
,III;
[n/if
'!lid;
'Q
'!A;.
passage ,of'De posluR ,,oliidm'l: ,dl!JCtrine::
:1tlJ1J!miu!tillg:
C." which
nn'll~I-~~"'QI !&,v!iJI~_ ., 1':""'"111 ,!Ii;!I,,,,"!Ao.. 'H~1f.'lpm·-,,i
~:i\'Ii[ il:n
~1i'!''''I:d'biniit' 1011., ,~I: IJ'~-,
mmpo-
:Stlgpsts, MUoh, 'Clf Ms,
enmumt
'oodem_dlro.I' w~.eb.isl :pow~,·'r·An. iMmedJlte ~~jec,tlmB'to , H:6'bba~lBl'IiAB.lmt [of',.Iilig, lsi miRd. by .ltichanl. pieters·::· ·
l~ =~!
.'. ',.J :,.':! '.. ,'''~.·,,'L.;':b,~::',~'··, ~'I'I'if!ol·;,·nz., H ,_,~.".1,~~:,.J")'_1_'-1 ;J'~n.,u'mn.I~'m~'~.·'S:. .....• .DiU", ,IS" ~ Ilua ,8 ~.,~ aB'D, ,llm~[fQe,Ug),:l,~~.~ ~~.;~ ::.;g:'IIi1\,.;i:i ... ,~~!!I!!i~iIi
'''rj1fr,~;io;. .",!Jlil.a,~
Filt' 'WII, .b, :Rdy' "N;poIin,S'- upMn. 'tm: IC'lll!JMI, Oof :1. ab.tCi ~t :di,[~' 'Wh~;",~I'AJII!iIrhat~'M"wi! en~--'i'l1e :Ihout b: .. ·1iJilatt-en in..... _. ..... 'huMan '~e,e:n. [Irl ,'-~:"_"~~~'~~~ilUJu~ ~__ ~~~, ~~' , __ .~ _ whim ~ :utune::q ta' to :mde! 'up • [a:w:l, pum~t; lind, how' :~I __ ,~ 'bel , .~I . ,'_~-,~iFK't, ,iiI:"1l. ......... ---'I'~, ,~lb :::-r--I:i;.iI.;iIi'"~~II...,.. ii!IWUIi.'.','.,', _:-'!liroc'p', '~;n"'~I;iI'j ~iI!jp~ __ " U--HiII",A_·I;..JI .. , .. :., ...':' llIq~~ 1;S-'~IW."_'_~ I.tt he.IIHvimul:,·ll 'PmpeBiin,B' '.' ,aw' :blW':1 :n.tionilltlt~0#111; '10' Dc: 'mJWNdei;, M "rOl' j', :oot U'tempDQIIU'I, ,.phLnltiOR oJ :ldQ.ll, :Mlttl" Rowl~r,'~:b p~ 18, :if.1b ~, (tAin~d.~,I':I, IGalilean. le~~-" mtti.ref' 'IJlu}:dgciat.iBg :aJ. Ntlvad. ,18, :'O'E :r.,Hf)08t['U,dma ..:i
I
ill
~~~.llli'l1Ulle~-~l
l ,
~-~
;I!;
.1I~l'_lI~II!HI~
'~I~.J'_·.-.'
'1.1,1;'
11I_"!I)IiW!IiI1 [MI!Ii::-gJ
i P-!!iml'l. .
ilil.
'!iol
r; I..:II ".1- ~ ~ I
sse8
,', ",'
.-iIi
Uvl._gbe~~p ean 'lbe~ efined '(}A'~, i'll. 't'e~.IUIof'a, motion [OOmRlOD d ,

'~~I ,-
~I'~nrt!b Q.l.' ~
~_~I
·U01l..,'L 'u··mA--:'''''' ... .:Ii- : _Jl_l,1_;:.·:.J~~~iILlI1V.\~~-~~-'~-w' -- ',: '~ u_~~.I;~~~I~1 '0;111"p"h; .;iIIOt!iIiftt!'ll!!ll~tliII,i"Ii '•• :iI!iII, IUi/.:Uue:t. ~ [~-Il
......
·1i-~,ll.I~I~I.a, JUt
_;a;
nir; '_~~';'~1ffi' : 1.~._lR!.r-.aW:_I_~_~1
.'iiI'Ii;-·~'·~1~,-, ,- .' - '1:..,.-;,. nD~e~11...-:- ,.,'L. -. I-l-: d; 'et":- "-.• '~D~~[ d ,m me ,_U:f'O,:__U_;:':ilUIl --. F .----Z.~;lil!.,......... , "' B_~~.. /;VI. we !l)W;ve, H,obb. 'IJieatsl :lfe·H· 1~1J1!It. :mouotm of .lbDbs:' J! asl :niimatio:IJa· H'o:we¥'t;r~, t~is ia Rot. 'mil caqid,ered 'v:i,e;w':, fQ;t ,elsewb~re~ · hI' po~ps together' [~t~b.e"tmIIH [!If''ike: t'be '_"r. 'Ike 1w:~41"'[jj tbe' ~~, ·rr.ulftmm~ t..-r,timJ~, .c".:~ [(,B~,'W~ 'Pl~, ,31) g. ~ ii~.
.c:j. ..-
'Iood~
:pmpe_~l;,'to 3, ~nd [daM· ·of' :n1od~nIS~ :H:o'bbes;,doos; :llot 'pmri.de·~, or does. he ,think. it neeeuaf'J' ttll , n ,-- _*'~".l'ei; iiI"I\ii"!li' '~-p'IJIO".d;·~lL.. 0-:£.' *ii'I ._ ,,01,:1;O' m~i:i, N"'-" 'nrc •...]._ ~ t.~ en ~ .:JI - _ :pm''''I~~t. ~. IW_~'m~•.: I.;~~l~; _~. t-· II: !J;':(Wi._I'( '-m~'" . >II." ',_,._;~'U~I .Jl'lC~Q.101\il.er 'whOa' the .. amc,les, of' 'vital ml*JtiO:D wh~eb.he dnt8 proVide do :[0, ~f,act~ ·ft,cha'tacJter&tics, esse.l'I!d.a'~,teo ft!ml 'motlon~ lr-~~ -N;odoubt, .Ws, conception of' n[~~ motinm does, :baVtC B, buD in as,
;j;'j,
.mtotio.n, the ,geaeric' mod.on of ,the living: 'world" These: :motions, ,are .um.Wfted, in :aI. ~i.ftacDem. 'WcilhoOJ1: .'tertup.. f"I 'I!.. hei d-I 'hA,.~;I~mali~lR. UCI'ODp' ,-,'.' ,., iL 'Il 'tlOft :rD. tt_tc~r' encmtion to, 'ilt_ ~el'r~mt~~~ g
yjim].
,I, ,.,
''iii'' ~
ft_!
the ob~J'¥IuQ:n [of bod~ly ptF~~,

[;i!'i'I~i~ ",-~llr.
'wfj,ch. ,contmuei ,thmlll_JIl'.•,

'''h··~'.·~;iB.~'"""
"",,.
r~
'1,.;, "L... ,_ tn:.C :~I_!iJ_i~"
cm_c_, .."O~. cIS, ,p.mpeJ.~y:__ me_~p\ ----:J9tC&.

li'il .~ . . -- ,--. - . - iI!
. ~oti
.~\~~~ ,IU:~
I""'l!llia-- ~~i!iD' [",_",_~_, ~~
h- :', -1 necesst"\'J~' ai, .~"eqil!iu:mm:fHl, 'D\ • .... .~.-~nr' ...lr - .".... ....-" t"·r . e .,,£, b~' 'L 'H~ 'b- 11.._ 'I :1.PJinewOi":IL,'We'-~t(l~" ,I•. o",~, em,p,~(fp, .. :li!1 L'~ J :~ I.m.••.. !lrtll,
.·tt
'!If ,!!Ir.I'
t~ a'
'~;"""~\iIiiI"!lilili;'~ ,P.II, Q~-.U-I!II! 'lJlj1.....,i!~~'-e:iI" ,IJ~,~·"ji~~!I!Io!!'!I!'~ll
~_A_~~_"_MiJ.~
:iIi'f'6.~' '!I!ii;;I~I'.1 wil' '''·II!-Lll:lJIJ,
bat wbil mouDa. 'm.ere;.Mat: be..

1I. 'Ii II ,lUI
·mnllrWmAii:li·-.That:I~·e··~r~.t·I·!...:~·m~.tJ~~~:a!~ I... I .I::.:_IHIi~l - "IU~ I-:t;a·I-·~i!i.li.v·b-~@·nllil.iiiliin-;-.!Ad·=~-~~'~~'~~-" '"' '~_~"'_ .~,~~~~Q:I-~, ~~~y, _~Y..!II1~ ;~_~ }!I!ti(-"~iI!
~~!!!~-_,
IDiDJagl
"'.\no
:p0sse88;; In I' ~ltton

1'0;,
.•,
d~..I1. .., ,
't'Ol
.. I .O,tl~lll" 'II ·"ttl~ .. 'VOI__ft-'
'tallt :moti\om
ID..,su.t'h
caa to
:ftl.a1DAGl'
as, is 'iM fao.cied :im.
to ",tik~ t·o
ml1W
any [of
0([1"'
1011_['
t
mimds (,]bkt.\ , J.
lim'h~
'H~~'.illUDa.D."O;~:I·ft ':~".: \~:;·I~ ' .."-:,-~-;,::::,.,, ~.~.~~~~ '~aebO~ .!II YGIU-DJt1i7 1--~'-:- -t~-li[''' .h~f;, .----c-:-:,-,; p.aa81.D, r-: '~1f~,: __ ; ~ mutlOm"III . JWD.aDI ,II IOI"C
'1~,,--~'1I11
is, :RQI .s.ptcl_ ·of·m,ot10D pHDli\ar' tal ~IU.D,~ woo1ldl [~m] '~,Ol :IG,I,QW ·that. I:t aD. ~kj ,~daI. dIIMn,ot~ IH'tWnn :man aad: the: ethtr' ;m_Jls~1 siinw ,01...... tw dileaNCO mR ·only· 'be a di8eremte; :m. species ·of IIl6000." 'We ml;J 'Raee ,thl: orjgjB of '''0111_1}' :.ot,lun 't. 'same pe"ep.tio:m-,i!tlellf~, Io:fl mll_m'~.131. t~ of' motion ia. Ho.b~b.:;];sl ~;t~ BItcDGd, d~;cdli ad .n, 'dle IO~ lof' ,R:~t set't"'1
vtJl~UDIbtq :.om~iiIJ~, 1lt,eQ
'"',"·).p-~: R p~,-~a--"'iilil~~I~i~Iet-;iI,al, ,giill ... gJIfU, '..~~, 'il~~ .~;L~,'-b,··~,···il~'D··.,.,. ,'!IOOCI! "", .~,;;a;.,; u ", ,g. "ljO~~!Ii.I. ,~~~,"'l'Iif:"f41 l'lll~tr--.,,iIi.'IiloD'.I"', ,,,," U_IIJJli,., ,'. iL'V_"!llliili.U, IUll,~ ,',1.,.11 " .••
I
llm~llo_f
'.~N; ~ft.
'a-'M;.JI ";h""f:e
~iR>~~[~Iit1ii!'i1il
~I~
~-~_IIQ."
,!ijj!I'O",
1",_,
,nU"~'i1~-41 1!Ii!i_~I__"~~,&~~I;~[J",i~,~·~_.-_ ;n'O--:-j'lln;Ii'.r...'-p'rea'!i1~· ;e ~_._~ _ _)~JLW"Jlg .._~_.JL~' ~l
:l1lotbm:iI :Hnse~,We a:~ppose'.e objreera: of ' t:o be 'wiIIIOl!Wt;, 'bceaHICl 111_., Ii1KltJlOR ,b, d lRetGd, IO:IiI)Wl.d~, IT,H!t'w'hidJ, :is '1. a.lion lCODtiaW., ~. '.1)tiOD 'uBti~. i~ered by' • a •• e Gaer' ,for«;~'Tb:1D 'the: :.&1100, [,11:Hnse mnt1fJ!U,CSI'BIRM
l
~~.J :seme:
iDA'"
.IIIII,-p·.·.
1~~:_.';'J(__~!!!!u' ~_~_~~l
.•;~ .... ,,,,:,,~~-,,","·II,.~ 'lUI£! ,iI:6U_m'¥"_~
IlitI'QdU~11~~' ~~,.....- "~,'I' dimrmmh:ed, ~~~~,~~,~~~ ~-
~il"•.~ .~I,U_IG ~~'T"""'""I[II [~L'~,~_ ',_ "-,~IDJ___gg, J~~!I!I ,-;'~I ':h~ln [:';"'Jt;~nl!!l"'"'-ri, ~ [lUIgi, ,,_18 OOB['L~~_lilU
'_o~li1l-n'~~~~'~~~-illl'
:[an,c;Yj'
~iji~d!. '!fI.-:- vilai~ 1ft -:--Iio_ .1 mQQ" l~i~i~o~~:=,_m~l_

c-
'iL-._-, wL~;il'!;'b-" .m] ·'IL. LlnL~l"', '·_-._J·H"J~ _; i. UI~~ ~

.'J~_C~~~,
I
:F:nnn. '6'1: ibram.

_~~_~~_aJ,
·.e 0_.'
:~:~
1';,_
bJl1 ~.J'
'A6er~RII111'IY~-". :u. ~~---'[~~~' ~~- ~- ,Dr ~ ~~~-~ p~~~_mJesJ! ~~ i.aldiB3iliOR ~,..
.moDoR
I.'
o£' ot-ri.. _:li .• l.lI~-"aU,Jjll: -.I; ·''tlJ~IIIJ'' •.
of i~ptimll p~
---C~if
[~-ii'~n+" l(u"
Imfftiidl .. '., .~~r~-< &1 cajl"",:~;J:""''l~'1L~_ -~ UC:•.

,~~
- iIIlt":h'-~' [e~=~e[ L.- .• or il.,:'""".;J: .. ,-- ":t,~ ne ~"',uer ~>;.
_'~~A_'--, '1- .~.,
'~O tho
~,I~IJ_f~'
,~1!lIiij;i'IJi~'
#'i~_:i:nD' ·i:ft;l,.", ~gll-~-~-:rI; ..· Inal~
.!ilC_- -
WgeD
/i.- - :~~,
.~JI;.
fteth_1
'iU:U,
01' .".'"
bgt~ -otiOD,
lt .~~--".'- --i'-_·"'·_ I;: --, ,JI",.,,~.f1RDje.!!I1 .,~~:.~:·~I "mJJ"~.:m-J;,tu!!!. Ill!' ·II .. ;--~'~', W,~U;:liIJ! :~.~ 18
's'oolll
the :ba~rt,1'81 [mncep,ti•.D, is

'!SI
'- 'R'["
'hJndDdh _~_'~~ ~.~~ '_,rfJ (B~]': p~3]')~ '[Y]'I'

~ --'~'--"'""."--'
:I'IQIIkiQl 'but, m~oti9il ~.
't'Ij~,1; :bud,:~."."~.trurtr. :
'wben such :mDlt\iuD~ 'Ihe:... .y'iml '.Q!~\11i1J. ·th~m :~t·.1.._ cailtm I_~_,.~ Ij__.~, .~~~·~,__I'~~'~11 ~~Je~_. ~J..., '~.~~~.~ ..~
'U_il: .•
QU,.,ard, OD~e:• ore-'i'lihriS Q.ntwlird, :m5o.tlt)D,:m 'th.c:mnt b.mt~--I .
.~,~ ...
-~"!;-- "·h~'(. - -, . ),II'" - - -" taRecl :•. 't'!~e II1.UI't uKrKU

jl
...'1:..
,'~"
DU,on D~.'~'=~_m111UD,
"I "'.'''.-
f~ --~.-
lof' 'VOlliO'tUy :.Ul:jOR caJ'~edm4ellUt!JjU:~:i'In 80 :fa:r aa ,tbe; :•• Ii:O'R [nfl·~tWll·helpB. vi,tal motiORif. e.nd,avDuII:m dlrrolal'lew8'[-d,
'.'h;" '~,~9~~,,-_,.:~[e-,---:-- ,-.- -. 'C"f' '-"-'.Ji ,-,~, ~"-" .......[I~.~,,.J1 1-"-" tth!'~' 'wb'-'!:h"I-II,ti;it... -, eause 0:: ~ ,~',--.-,.' ",~- ,."> 1u-.'JIi ,tmagm_a'~lull'l :aRu ISO '.IS 1~~.Jlu
c1
~ppaitc,
Q.r
,d_c~
:1., 10 farl
'IIlt, m,oUOIJJ,of i~jtitrn
'."»de.n,'_' 'V:ihl .000;0 'IDda~o'Ur'is, direeted I.BY' :froa tM ,1_- ,._. _, _.__ __.,,_ ,.. ,_", _ .... ..... :
,0''1-- ..'..... ~j]f~:~tl
"w ••
mD""".,j' ,!Oin..--:ftll·' j~l 'fII'1l~ :.vc:rII, pauiou ,of :ma.m Ire speci,es ,of Idesircl _:d, 'l,ve.Im .. 'ThUB, adl.n~ w:~,tch,consists in, Yl):hlfli,Wy :m,otiliR" , .'dees fDLmI, th;,1 :pauiOllSlf, :lmmm.a}, mJ,QltlOIll, ,Qf' d.ni'R: taB,. aVlff,6n,A ~c,. 1~~"U I~
'w". _-
"
,
g,lJ.i~I.I!i'-iJ.V'
.; :11
,iIiJ!~~ IIJ_!V.t_JIi.!11
and awa,,' :&0. dma ~ilj.. , wjh,~~ ,,,fleets: impede~ 'vimllJ :mmiom.~ :M,eR~d iRdecd. 1.1.11, a»i;nmllJ~3ire ,thus OOJ),ce:t.ved 11:, 'H;o':bbes as Klf~:mamtaiD~'DI
l,
,flam, '~Dllmmce'nJta~ '.otiom

-,~'J'it,'"'"~:i'iIli~G1~o;i!ftoi!iii:il ,1!!I' ..~!liWilJ.I-i:J.'I_ ~""'ll\ei"U~
~l~~=r._.'
A'~,'n"'d,',-I t'h" "
l~~_~
f~·.tI'1,",~~:A1Ili;
G'.~~y~~,
'~4J
d"-;'·l:~.dld-J t'i'J~"'!~{~'~.-ii >ii;'l;iIlH:Ii"i ,~b":(I'~-,,~~L~, .. ~~_l~,~ v_ 'J.li~-M w-H~

._,.~.~I~_"'__""_._w,
1~_v'QJgILy,
~~;'i':-.;"i-Ci!,oi!i! '~~~!;~~I ,i~ Wll~"" ~lil!1l;'UiJ,.I,VJ~III, ,~
~.",,~iIi~,
ifi'ill.i'!;'~1
t'hem 'tDl cM!tUtwe 'to :mov"it~~ 'long as '~fbl~;~ Jr--~;jI'li;I'lii ~~_"_iCI!-~1
19
lconUmwed, 'moti~oft g,
,t,~_n'I"U. ,!b. lOIioftdi~:'~\.or.a;, ~I\-,q,f' ,~'~, . """._DiL~
"10m, 'l'l'ds a,CCOlllo,t,01' 'v;i!ta~ and, \lO]Ullitary mollalllJ", :Iit "-Jlo,w!, ,·-'Ir'-f} 'e.afi'L ,!O;iI!Ii;iI!i,LII;. ;jI'Ijr~~i, iO~'I~;-, '~n·I~Y,It '~~ '-P':~.~iiiii,--.;JI, ':t'nl :iD'Ii"~_, _-I-Ul-~ ._._-.-._-1~11 ~_~:HH~'J a_~_.U ~~-~ v. __ lI[Jl I~V .', iU;1U '!LV !IiiII-~I~_~1I
1.;~ILL'Ij~
dllt~D, iMl-cdf~,,A 'OOD~q, h
'DHeS8liry :m,-a:~"'~IDI:~~~~~'n/tl'l""' ~~'U?:~'I~I"_~~': ,-' -" .~, --'"

'~ __ ~ _ll!!!!1
I
fhr' ooJtdnued, 'wc'U:"'bem-l :18'both, 'I'ne: :3!odthe :sm:lI.aent 'pound ,~f hu1D3.R ,adiDR~ 'Hem:oe:
,. '" ... " " . "~, ~-'" '-'~-~'I_JI~I'
_D
";.I.~-~
~_lIEQllj_IL!I
lefore 'e&atin1iJim~OUT' 'sk"etch, of' h',~ma'D,DttLR1 :it, will be; 'wc_1'l '10 'BlUet lUi H;obba dJoa~, nd. ~n;tnHI,u:c.e: tb,e;: bmc; 'tejj;;jQ, H
01 ev;a!liuati,oll!l' lI'ohbm 'treara the defiiniiiHo.ns ,of 'tl!.ae:
_1·.11, u;
It, :is ,~till,

.DEI ,~'" &~ m~lftilli' ;'_ Q~~~I_~
w, oo~c,that tam :a.eMumti! a;ldl.u'U(g,k, i!t, dmoa

,IS
ii.i'L!6; ,~:,:,,it'i; ~'L'!'_' ~ 'UIU~ wi gfJl~ll iU~l'~~L Ut:
i'\if··~·.l~,~,~~iI!'
j
:~~~~.~~ •• ~~~c~~~!:.,~·~·~·~~·~ ~ of Rabb padlcoolH pa,eltollopcal, tb,eory", ~. ThIS u~:I_re '~ 'i;'i~.' l_
J
eD'h8!nclDl·vijtal.mflt'io;El~'~ U: as a, mla!tt-er'
I~;~'"'"""cn, -~'~;I-l !W..~I!IJ_UIIll" .-_'.~'
''I'~~_
nllIi
I
l lIJI_~V. _ fV'tl~I~1 !Ij._llrlj1ir.-I~IJ
,~,~t" ",) ~~liIfI..l. ~1r.. ~ 'W:· :'D' ~utMlJ ..... ····b~-a-"t' 0',~7..::t1 II.'"
!_ __
j!lj.,
0" fiet w'e del... 'whit ·w ..

llj_~V.-t, 'p__
~'i..,~~
;11;
~:Il,
,doto!i,
~'L.~~ Wl~J-~~
:~~I~li· = ,~i .,"_ _-. ,;II;ft;~:-n"~·~ ~ ~.-~RB-
,.-"IlIaI, ... r:~:tl
":'
-T':U~~"E T~I II 'I., E-" ],:: 'P' 'M' 'A'N" ~N~A' -'=U~'R'" " 0" ,. I "./ '.1 •..• I ,',~ '':
I~I I" h~ 11
__
,_I
'..
.~I
.~.
I~
_.~
__
•••
,_r
[_-.-_"
'1_~
I
j
:rnOUOD"But, 'tam cone'~Lt18lO:Il,,ioa :o€tt :fo'Uow Dle.mly' :fWM, '.e·
deinimR
[_ [1,< ••
101' II1,I'{KMjJ~I,~, '('('"'~pDIC ':'1UiI 'I~O,,,.~~II:I~ '";"""1 , __ ~1IIi_~,UV'i~""1 IIi:V,~;.'" ...
~ipMJd,",ia, 'OOD,V~~ :aB, obJ;1d [of',dame~lc~ r1,1tC:'muRrial~~lof~:pod" ,m,mll1¥C:Jedl. I'll" '.C D.),DliVtailmcc:: [ildUa is M~ ~, :m, an o:~j'ccten~
1..'''''~~~n'Q' lRil~-~~JJI~' ....
ti_n.i.n~:1 ,&ka11
aa,' 'i'hat~IUf' :HucfJb:a~

~,~ tllG
11
,~:,i'
~L,~ lii\ft'·iI17,~;A.Q' '~Aaomil~-n'.,~'I~I~11 lUl,~ llllw-.ag~HI!·[""_~"l "~",~_~_I( __ v,I~;~~~,
diiB-~ ' __ ~.
Jfmi1QJ' MlDD_i_DiI'Clf' 'lly tDJlj 1a;t\liv;deDClI:: "'~~tDs pod:' :,......,. ,g, is ~lttbiB,
'tf[e
'J~ta:1 m"-.~'A.i", [V.-Mv.~-'. l~

'~r~_~ __
~J [ __
'iIi"'G;~'.t~--'~iiIII\' I!IIJ_w[Vll[liU~
mQ.LI_"
"-all tboc~'- , I~-'f'ID aDU'! ~'te ,- ~.;~.~~~:~ 'dull' ,a'i. 1IM. f"'~l' .' ,._~m"... . [~~l~~~:~a,pa'.)~l~ skaJI 'lnd I'~~', we. '10, dilt~pl8'k ,iownal :md, :ma1iedaJ), mUIlI", [of' :sev'Cral01' 'HubliHB'lll IJaalclmRapti H, ORI} ,of ,dle' priaei~, sourees of' Ib,. dla,,1I11' 8'(\,0.1, ,_ :RiB'ian,ce: 'of' hiB, :payttt.J,., '10 'hilS ,edlla~
l.jJ ,~~_;_'~I, I
1
1
~,' ~}:'~ '117-,~/ 'w,~ilil.It~,~--"'-'-~~~:~~l '~ appaR_II_1i,"'mi ~rmln,O~I.j~,I)IJ_. QllllIy ILe/
'~~-r' '~a~..i:-II'ii:'i:~'~'~~' ,~"1;fliiiil ll-.~.t~~~~JlI~-IIJC, IUlLUI ,~~l."":""",: '.'Den, we: :hljlli·,~,. '..~ "",-JJiu,~ III 'ljlillm ~ H:~',,'IrJ~,-,~'
,Jl}~t'
!rpb'jl.'iiliil ,J(, DIUG!,

~ ~ -
H,~:'''i'If:'~~'rii! ,u.,DU_,
~ ~ -
0
~
:a~~,'iiJ*'i'it ~.u","ul'"
~ ~ ~
~f,"~ I~':II
U good;, I .. '
.~ . .' -
.,
!nfi"~i ~,,~il! :~, :~~~,';-,';'Ii'I,l~; Iii.!! iILILl:lli, !!I:.r'.dl!l aD! l}uJj~U!"l, 'B~:D'~""
~ -~ ~ ~ -~ --~~ ,.J
I,
-
jdv~
-L"'_1.,,__ t
I
'bu;t Rot .lOh"

il ..
to ... 1._-
8omeoa,I: 'wbo, [CDmidercd,

18,
'.f' c.';I·oclI~rnll,iI.... w~tattV.i IcclJ",UI~lo~""u~, 'i'!ri'I""'~:~P,·~<.O_D.tI141'di~Pln_~' cilil'ili8'_Jt,-~~'II ,!Ii~".iI!.~~ 'iil~'~:I ,1'Wi_iI!_il.gilU!~~!IL~~:1'lI· \ifi["ii.' ~~,U' I~"",r""
The :mea&ur-elof Hobbes,". ;audacity,

'jL
'tu fil1ii&H IS :R0,: '~1t;
BIII_JocdTW: fowda-tiop 10" ,hiI, ,IUI1A1], IddAitio:f:lB~ but 'Ilhat :111:1 IUtLmp,ed it om. the: laelf-eemLred, f.,aodations; of' his, :matm,all
.._m-..iII ~ " 'ih" -" ,~ie;rI";~~~.t,.NlliOi9~~ ~1'18, 8:truetu'l'Ie
a, :mow mud. 'ipolillieal
:ruD, '''['i''Ifr~~~,~T:~;.::~'-'.-~I_ ,.l I!j,we 'umu_u ....O'Jl8l ..
...'I!.. ~ on 'wit«=!
'.nc'hected" resu'l,u :iiR :aWone" We aek, '~D' 'o'bbdD, w:ha,t we ca'U ,pod, :S1n,dl to a,wi.d what W~ [eaJ~,Mi Bu:t
Bndea,¥Wr[l1 :.
,~ '.... _ "'iI;
Chatad-erila,"'IU~.
I!~,~may DC "H.~hl~
;f
&,'tIl.. ...
'fttal mUUDm---\t!Ult, tlere g no tmnq,[!lm~U~'ty ,dt. U£~~ :IR '60'&_
I .~ .' ']11 ~ f~' '~'h':lt ~ ... ,1l....... '~j~' '.' ill.. .', "'.' ,-,'t ,unes .BOt liDuO'W •,:mm. 't, e ~:aCttYmt , U~ie ,0 [Dolt ~IlHJrIlOR,~,
aecept$), bf atQti~,ad~n~[N'cwtom'~:s, :fint: :Ia,w 'that D, d1Jjm ' OODtlnrues. in, ,tts, tta;te~,vihet'her Qf :rat Of' u;Dilf~flih:MotinD1, ''U_mle.ss :aflimui by I0me e!)tem_2'~ ((FlOe;; 'Henee :if' 'y;iUl :BloliDa mnti'RJlIes~, mcifher [e;Bba'nc~d B01"':hiDd"ed~,,trMIqu~~lity i8ibclU'~., be Qrtta1in;O-ct, ~ . BUrt if' 'W~ 'tDm fmm vita;1 11;:;, V\:'bLl'OU.'MI''motion.it we [.- _.,_,,_ :.~' ;0 .'0 . -- _ .1 . -, . . ,.., - ~~ eln a.: ... ...
, ... ,.. ~~"~I.'
,a.«I; the er-pns, ,of Hnse;; t'~,lI!I'the :mDtl.~M[of sense If!'e oon.... , 'bD!I\I"~~ ,aIn.d [ever 'wryimgr.' ImapnatlJ)o,t 'Ikeno, 'wbl~m,m [d~'_' : Hl'l8e~ 'mlllli; :dH' be [conltmluall IDd, ',~g,., .Burt :~tie~, ,on :reac'himg 'the· ,h~';., ,giv~[ ,rise to mdea,vour~,mel, o4ea;vw_r' :frt8tllts ,m "~'~twRtary'acdon~, Heaee endea:.,OUf and aebun, l'Dm,t, :&'1&0, be mll!tmual :3'lld,'v,ary,in,l:~' :and :$0' fe'lJiclt]f [con.smt.l :m, Mil,.... 'PFOI;pmin;g'!I mTIId, :not in perpewal ,tmnq,diUttr,~
l
,",n:iIiLl, , " ,~.I!IC!Ii,
'H::: !'.ijii'b-,:L'?'~'9'··' '~i~1 ,0i"'11-,~'ifiiif" ,1,'~iIi...... IBb:l!1l
,-,
~~ .,
".
-"' ,= ''',.
~ - -,.
- - .,
'~';Ii_
,~"
'll"'o:r. , UIi~iI.IliIIi_, '~7':rt:!;-1r~~-~~::-;I;lv, iDc;.~,-' .~.~~~~o;l l1'UU~~ ~""1i''UJi",D~J'
'~J_,
The'
'"," '~_ ~c'
c~~
,ever' new' 'o~ject8[of'desiee, a,voidi!ng' 'CV'CI' new d~jcds, of' a~'Ir~' :8bj)m~Thel ,.~ 0" ;su~eu, ,~n 'thisl uReeasiJlil' wi,v~i,'ty r. 'w::bii1:h, :HDhba limn. ,D ,a, m.',~s[ iI'pr-aent 'Means,';, '10 obtai'A ,(1(0;1) :~.R: a_pplRnit ,goodf (:8..W;, ii~~, '4)~ ' '[P~
j,
[6\ifi'~C~m'"",f'I':A~t'i'''I"R'i'iili;'a;i!!;fi1li!Pii;iFi[~[ '''ii.p~1;,0 ~:I!I"" '_~~!I,I!Iig, -!.__"_!Ic!!!l.t~, ""-~,iI'~t!"lI L_ ...... .; . 1.'1
,,",uli"1ldftl'ii;i.i''u' ",",U,I.liiCl!!i.GUJl:.il ,
Ji
a-'~=:iix.'[ii~L~~ • •
1W'~,i!f'l;;!J
~~.I
.i'Jii'
~),
rand, "lflJf.lIII1~ 'uJUji 'IHe" iii, MdUq tr-ut the :I'IRUlf ,of lQod, ~:~ '.~lIV~ fP'.' ,3~"',1) iv:f.
Q~r:',/~,
.an_,
t1R
"--r
~
'Il~, '~~"'I ~,~[~~t," ,_"iii, ,1Ii~ ~m~,~

D'"'"'
I, :~~~
:""'~,iiI'ii,",;i;,
~~I!~U)~
~f"~ v,~ '~'YI"II-;-;-:: .~

:10. .i;~p.'I~, '~. ~~_ ~iI!;I' :ia: ,!I!~ ".Q
'1"Ii';8;tfi!'i'li'ijjJ;l nvg,~,~ ,!!!,~I!!oIY!!~~

l!i;., ....
'UI,~'iIrb·:,-1 '~"r-:-~~, ,,,,~,am

,~IU, d ,"'--~,~
:. power ,o:f' 01n!) :_., :mfste&l

'~<liiiii"
"~jilil'~l"181eftu. __iY
;I,
"-~-~~--"!'._~-C"-~'""-I"~-C""' IIXUllfJallVlj 'qHDltfty'i
,.,~,,"",;jj,I~'.r,"",~~ , ,r'" ~''''' ~f"~' ~iI."Ulll!i,O~~, ~~'"

!!Ii;o_:li, "';l~
bindem.' the: e8ecu, lof"llhel

"~'re"~'CO! ",
lU..
mgl
1;8,lerJiaJb, 'il'h1Is: Rd.mOB 10'1' po,wttr 'to' ,I',4tIt' power is, oDIJ , :mgpd.dJ 'b,' :H:.:OIIJM~aI~DUII, of ~umml,ptWCf' u ldle lemiBeRcc .f 'I'le ~aw'lliea, ,of rlmliY:I' or' .~nd,~ ;W:~ilii.ll I(E~
:P'li' ,,)~
o!ii ,~.
,~'Ii;:~ .. IWlC 'I"~';--'W .,' IOlt' ~t,~1te :-~"""/~I ,~t'\-'tt~r.'.· ; I;~:~~ lIuuve, ~I.WiIio &1, aDQU1L:e:r,", '.. [. '., ~',;,?]~,!'!':':~. "'. \.ti[o;lP'lF ,L !!II
PO~~,'O. __
aa '.
Ig)l,l',~.... gg)':'. ~
~,'iJ~~,
teb·. ".~ ,.~, ~~ ''!!.'

'Ii
""~I ~f' v~,

'~:~~l p,"' ,3101,~, ..
'11.11111: :apitl, thll pmWKai af ,di.Dm!I~~Ddilvld!uals, :a.rrc'k_lm -"'i'littal~v' ~p-~ "";i"fIiii'~1 , ~ ,;A/1,-'iIb~ '~, ...",,". l"~~..:_,,~~, ~ ;I'~.'i!i' ,i11i1.~' 'jii..jii; ~ft-w; ~'I!~ ."~:;, u,~~,V""",~~~''I'-,,'j~i,'.~)lh~ ,!IlU18 descrJiIL .... ,liiIii'~"i ,iliiL~
'CUBI,'.
'I-n..
II.oa-l' ,them_.,
'11*:'
.f~~: ~i,~··d~~t~t~. '.;iq'~'lo,''b~, .~ .. ~.~_~

l!.'
muid_r'MI:iI'.,
[~Uil,l;lj,Ids 'bIBle: lmacem,
:m the: com;~ltiCIft
ilr~~
,.oiI11 'iU", 'bL,,--- ~ ",mil" nO' ,nO,:',mmrrs
~;£ .. ~.... ,R'~(';".a:im.taim:t~1£1'1\1106 Jileoasa1ni~ 'Iy lOO.~-
~'R~,~'e!"~,\¥~ '~ust~~~~:fl~C
mat'ica'f,V!-,tII&J:J;1F.alOn· For mUDna'~'i:ty'wil~ 'pmve ,teO 'he' die '~.~~~~-"~ll::l' '~'.~"~H]cl' e: '_~~~:;~, "-f~' 'L'~~~~~~~-~~--'"" ~:I":~' ~.~'~:l'~t,":''''_'II' ~iL~r'· .
asID'!U!U :if,fIWUDuiit1}10111l0 I: [
,~ .:
Itll,n.:~I~S
:lROoo, anu
:po.l~Lc~
'~~I~l~'
(TI ~ ~ ,g~
'. 1
'''Ift,~,
1i.:'I'.I;, "rIU,".,' (Ol'~'

'~I~
U~,
~,'F-
~Y\1L,n,.Ij;~
'ilciII:
,j;"
"""J'
:kIlOWf,em:. [of:consequel1,ca~·tll:a:t ~ftbm be, 'dial, UI'i]:if '.m, hu, been, '~'lt8i,t, nas, 'Htm~;, i.f thr_iS laban be, d)ait 8baJ~ be'~' (:ibi,d ..', )!1 'w:hlc'b, we' ,c;aill, 8clen,ce"
@_'_j~ ~-----
[Our' ,concern, :P Oldy 'w~hb. t'ba,t tY,pe [ai ~'al,ttf,lDJtifJnl[ lB, w;Hit'h the' 11:I:masinR of' o,pm1oD9:re:praenrts the slIem:saivc :It. in, lIJIUMlmti 8ath, [mseoume'j< wh~cb.iB Fe.UORUl:I,[ '.. , ''with, du~:: '[a"b", ,~;Ii)~,,~ ~ til"obg ,:'" #ilitil"' "~:Iii,===,~Jil,.::;",,"'b, 'ilr,~;e; __ C'~ii;~t'~.~: ~_,~~.~11~;0P: -~' ~~b"'W,iI,CUiCi["'" 'Y'J; l~:...,..,..t'-"i:1Ta"-lt" ,[:,:oiiI,.,.. ,!!i,:lil y., '!P'I!',~_',IQ~n '~'\-'. UI._I;I~1Ir. .._;_ P' "'~""~;D:r;_i(i; [~f' ~-~,~ 1 .._Il:~I~ :.;i!j;~) Vt. sense ~i~,d, iRemo~:~'Il'·.' and 'p['FOOCOOI '10 :2 --~ -1
L'
,HI!iJ[
,!I,:gI
~,g;'-:
JlJLU·"',~_ - ~~
,I ["""
---~
'V"iDoA'!iiiil')- ...AU.b
,bd,
_~j~~r"i ~_:I!: ,'£g' -...... :t'n,r He -,j"io'b,~,~~ I;;.._~j' ;~:""\, ,

A~
,II!:
L-
I ,,~
U!Ii;i!i:l!I,
'i-illi' 'r~tl"..:tl-.AI :iin..ll-li:-tl-.::nna; ll_~ [",,";V~,UC\l, illiI1l, ~la__l!I!_~'_~JV"W'"
~ tlons:
SO [&3",8 I!,'.....li..
l'te
that 'vihen [cUscomme'~bepmwith 'Ae dJmui),..,

,.:I
:pnual 'aBiffftlOOIW, :llld \If' these ~pin,i[tJt1!l' :SY~lfJ[gismJ";1tht; eld OJ:'l.t,I\'d. :il, cal'led, 'dl,e w1i,c:I"l!i;sio.n,:~ :S!nd Ihl: :dvJU;gh!l, ,.f't,litc'
[Of'iiiP' ga,
,01(''wo~~~tp,mu i
:p\l'rtie~
""-,"",.J",,,
'lou
;; ~y [OOll;o,m,o;n,
0:;: 'l.ill:
f'"
'l.,
., :UJiRe :in!tit
'~18":'-': ,~,~~~_gl '~iV ='~I -8--~I"~;~~~.ad[-'_ 'I;~'a-"i' [~fi4i~4t~'t>o!D-:-,iIii'l·._ •.l~rV "...,l~·"-D{~-II g~ [~l'~' [.-=drj~!!!!-lILQ~-'.--1!! '__ ._~1;1-~_~1 .• 'U_~~_~'u\ ~~!I _A_ I '~-:'n;jiliCW, ~;'~.i!id-~,_
'~l;;~'~
enuall~.,;; ~:iit,~~"';~.-ii[~ ,ized], ~in,a, :UteraUy' mom"~DaUsit 'mUl'11T:iie:r~ :fo,r' it ~'is,R,odwiq;' 'blllt; ,ruirnJing:, tbat ,q adding' 81~u:llmh:tractiRI:. of:'the ,crmmeq'UeD,ctSl ,ofl:paDI namal ¥lMd upon, for tile m.ki,.' md ,'_f1hJg ,af OUf' thu1lJ;,;hts" (8.. UiiJ, ,p.. ,3\0).. 'W~ 'WkCR BODbee, :spmb [()if ",amend :names~'il m.e :i9,'Df WUI'JSC aot, " ~"" [II, "NO: , , "" " , a'L......'"t" pnecnl 'thf"'n -, ~Jor!Id~IS, ," ,:': __...;~l~" ' ~J1m_g'·'ma-',","' ,r.eamcn~!D'\iJ-tI,c.,' "" .. '1- ,c _:__r_~_:~p~It, 'fL":: 'Rtltm_W_~WJlLUII'D, i;-l :n["'~ [~DiIi" . [.. ;, :" ' QCL_1lJI ,!,,'L_,. ,~I\ . ~, .. _: eh j);:-~,",:-[' he :0:, ,,~;'~nd'?< ,[,,'; H '~f'~--' ere are :l14CL, ~'~leT" ne IS ,m~ ,m.; U.m" all1t'bnIl.gJ],W~ :mamn, ,OOOD;t: p-arti~ular't'biio,p,,- we; do :nm :mama :abc:mt~ thB;ir :pamcu'lar,i~r';,,proper' names :lmN!I!:: ,~llO'[oo~,um,c_~ 'When. I, eollclude :from, 't'be: iap,pea:raaee O'f' the sky t'lU,! i,t, 'willI 1 'Rm'La'blv'mi I[ '~'liCUW'li';n!Cir':aiil...·'··",i'I,..' '.n..:l'-'Vii,S'[ ) ·";~'''V ;§:n.;ill "Iii ,,,.,._.-'.l!J _~[_ _j_"~e--[LHiI~,~ "'-v.~:J' !r!Ii&:J.i ~IL"1i.I,
~J ~~~]
:~al~[of' 'Ile [CO]1!~ueac:e' o€:'wurdsl~ 'wbi:C:h is [cornmoDl~'eaUId
'b_-ii!lL~''''' lMllv.'ip
~~_~]~~'~!I
~i"'"~~'~E"
l
I~
[f~~'_,'~·;r'=--J. ,r·lrl! n"-~ l"l"':'i~i- n::nl,
,;'16
[~""~j~'\I,
~.J'. 'R---;',~'Dfl:ml~. ~_=!III
'-_~]'~ _~~--~:I_:.'
~~~~~.-=
'I~~II _"
i__
I[
_I,
'Ii[ ",\
'.. '.. ' I____o_
I,
e;:'"
'!I!'~.!liJ.'
'~~Ii~,
i!:Ii'_,
,t~'~
..
iL~""
:aeUOrl'l:'Si
w;e.I[tlber:~ 'b:mt
iR t-enll9!
ll,
of
,9 mD_m~Dn,
~ft_D,
:1,
'.
[of'isly am.d, a 'ty,pe of' 'wa!tber,~ T,RI: '_:e~ ,o:f RaHall!' th:m 'p'lOvides 'UtS, 'wi!m, ;Kience'~,.. d i_nee :is power,", p:o;[ iJt: ~::isi lite ',knowled;ge o;f' ,oooequmiZl"
~inrAI .J1.l'Ul!n~''''-oI!YIi' ;~~UJ u-~r~~.IIiIJJI.~
IU;; [U-ll~l~ II.I~!L
nf;
n.~;iIIi, ,~~~
'iigt: 'we [tam,,pre.sen!ti~f d,o,~, kflOrW mOrW ,tv .do' som~g 'we
'u'nn:~,ft!n;ncili"b"a-r'.::~ Lv' ~ i-~~I-~ ~_.I~:~:I; ~ J~,j/

I.
Iii-.:h-' il~jlnll_lil w': "'~1l..-
A1ililil';'
~.l~.
I'll :]
;i"lif~'
'when 'Wie 'wDl(~,Of' the' ~i'e~ a.otber'time' (;RJ" .. :iiiii;, p, 3,5)" lA, ,t'bis, 'way' rmsnrllJ, :ai. d,eiB[beJ;l,tiuD. 'b;y show:i~1s' ,the 'MetJ1l8, 'III' u
"",'b- '+.p"'m-'[",'-IiG' I[
[else
1<,
Ai'" ;u,iIi. ';I;fi ,,,,.,,,,, ~li' [~& 'a-'vn'"I-:..J1
'w--'b"~.' '". i "i!i~,ri'..,."~,~~nrl'll

''111[1-
Jj,;,
:luII:
'Fa IOn,
:Rln-n,
dle.111ibemJttem :im, a, :~mrt~,.er a1~' Th,I: w
~I'; ;tIi;ftm.e_.,j':iI'-.iiia l-tnli~l'·~t'iIi, _ IVII_la,V. I 'Urr-!W-!Li-~_~l ~ .-U-.'.-. ~-_-_..
[~il~'j,.;il:L~1~"i~.!IMJi[!I!_~:~lU_~iQ!_U~_,: '8''''Ai'!a~~di ';:-n-Ai~i':i1),.@'ra---"i~nl 'li!''''''iiill~iI'I[ ... ~ gl: .. ~"!lV~~_,,~~lI!_~~J
,.;L, , .. ~_l_'_r~J
s.eta&loD, ,of' ~.ilniOD .• , di.smrune.., ,As, we dt;l:emll!_mc~ :lw_nh,iF,1 [mn_Rqwen,ca ml[seu., :ad;, our d,.IN: 'to penf,r,lJIj, :it" '0'[' not 'IU[ 'perform ,it. alters, Io.r' 'last mp.iom 'm '!w.m;,m.t'~''0-.1::' '\rl'~~
l
~·~f~~,~~·~m:~;~'~~~r
UIl\\l
1....... :~~il~~" ~ ~,r[r'~.~~l

u ' ...
~~~11~11, _1J_:1I1 'I-'[~I ~ I~ WlJlHIL. [
,~i.ii.' '~: "_" lllla·Ii.J!iI!!lii! ~-'tl,.I1IL~-~-I.:.; i!iia: "J't~f~'tI_: ,~lh_lIi. ~ -",I L

'iI;~, ~n:il"" ~11\'11,~ ~:v iU,U!I,1~0,l"'~
... [_
.. ,~,,~ __
[Q'!Ill!!'
,~'Ij"P~"I~ !a~·d['~~U,""i·l'lv, ~ .IP_~U;"J

._1.1.1:, ~_
~J
fD;~ Lgj~
'~~~;~I ~~?b:a-iJ;: H,liliili . ill ~~'d)'iii~'~!

~.ilii&_"i~~
'C~
'~~ ,~iI!!IJ~"',
A::"'-"'o'.11R-iiI'i', ~ --;-I-~jtr' U' ' ~IiF~~:Ii.,
'1-,~'D'~ojji:!'ii[Iii,iF.~I1l_~_lllK
enables, 'w,iti '~D':bc: d[tin.a'l :a,ppeti,te .., :H~:o'b,m"- u,oeI ,0,0".cww,op. ,,;w'l!.,:!: ... ,!f.la3UJiM.,.u,p .. et.WHn·'. 'd'~ROHfiIi,',' ,.;Jt-.::""JIi,: ·~,[,t'·' "i;L,::-., b-····.-·~:-·;,,,,:;.,. -~ .. ',:-I~" "',.- ,'~', '.'--.,esc ;.. d[,deiUJbt~tlQn'!, Btl 100_1"1:8 ,tIl1imi iU m~l • ,;blllt~d.uaDtJt~ • llk.w ~pJliciidy' :kmw' ene IRf¥m, '~'." [otbe:r,'~,:But, '~\II~iism iso'rl'~,Y" : :iMP'II~,it :lo, :&11, le8_: ,aaDlIni: of' ,r.eaaoll;, a.d, li_D, :him iui&tence
~.;,.",>c..:.
,?,[:-,-!,,-, ,:fI;,
1L!!J1D1
'u;pom,,the :praaiGd, e=i•• mcanR of :.i:ml1G.~ ms€lll, lB,an IB8Hnda'~ R 'pm [ofthe [eqw_ipm,e_lI!t of' 'm,c: ~9;i~f"':m~m.iRi;Qg' I~D,P'9,I\t 'man,~
nr IU~~~l. r.,z~ ..,. ..:Ii;j;'t1i'Lam-,..;iiiND· ,it;...'~'I-l!!'iIl:~!iIIii ,~~: ~Jt'!li,;!I!_I_IU!lo;,[_[w.v,." ~'I!iP_',!;U",,"~ '4:nol: 'DB;t 'dat :rea.&nn irt.lf :u[ aiwapi :riigftl, :reaS1l\a" 'bot: RD'6nl1 ~1!mU'I,")1 falOl'l:~1 :.01'" 'the :trDSOll, lo",amy' IOrieoLD_btt, of :meH~['.U,t;,e81
,,---,~_,~, ~.'!I!I;'~~~~~12,[,
'lot
~~nl:;~ftD
..l~iiitifiiiA."iiI)~[
:;iIIi'
j'
~, ,"
'lbe I~edaimw'[ I(.~~.'~~~

!P.
", , -, d·C:iia~'IIIIIir:d;ilii;.be _~~_~I~I IU~

!II •.
~rig ![,' jnmM bi,ptb,er' :rnfi;J[ sJ~lo,gilmll then 'the: eJitd[ ••

~:1i11~'a:-;~~. ,~~,i;~, '~GI "~~I!IiII!,
'!I!oP- [...... ~~....,"',~;. ~
:~i[j[:pp~, 1)-J )1., OI' lIli;f 'Ille "Nt ,puand, ,of 3 P 'Il-:~~: [tI~i1"i:~~:~fti:ll[~.I~'" ,:J!" '~I'f...__ . : " lil=gIIItlIY,I=u:II '~-: _~.~ [- r"'~ UlitlllJ1~_QlU[V!l=~ t- ~~ [II ,,-~w d.,;l"!:~-rI~,"'~i~iI"iiii:lil•. 'O-itii'*c' IU!I!i"[
;iIIi;
In., D:I"jIIiin'.',' '.:0-_."'_ 1II1Ii.11'Il"Il1Iicr.·, '1IJli-,' ViIf,U;"!!!,[I;!!';;I!',t7'!!!,, ~~'I!~'Iio!"~'J
.idl~ thOll,I~'stUl1C:Umes, _ ,0w)I' ~F-~~---~-~~~-~,JJ sl" '~~~m'" ~lh-li'ili!JJm.de~·~·~T·..]Ill" W' u.,..~," 'I':'Ii[. [It"'] ):\l(:~ . II~, r'i .~-~' ~~e . "I, ~f/Klllnail 'r:"~D~ft~;.~, ,i'~la.~nz_""~1 '~\t~ft~m~~. : h-'~~l'~_'" 1,"IIlI;;;1"'" •• [.,~ ,uW ,ii<il
••• ~ _I
~~I-~. ~i'ifl ~"' t·[·:~."-'I~b[·1 I :ftf·~.; !DiAi_c'---: :.~" _ ~'I:-:'""'. 'Iio!!',I-~e ,~, @'Y_1l'leW,DiIj'l., :lusti'rd, a-md :~(esa '''''EO" 'witb~
F,'
10;['
00,0'"
I~~."
g,'_J,I)[Jj,
~_
.-~.~--.~.~~:~~I
\',Dl.I'_.I~
lli
__
1~~11:·~1
'_'
....
'.. '. _..
,,~'.IiIi!li~1
,ao;:,; ..
,_
"_ilhL[!i'
,_
'Fc~t~"iIIi\i)O"'i'ri1 'e~Jiili,
1'~ili-8.1~~' I~lil:
-rij1.,1
flrafml~to[
,0 [of: :mrlil __
"'~!j,i;
'M dG'mr,lfj~d.R,ed ["01:,8: concept ,of':r~lbj :r!G1MD, ~
el1)ta'~,
'l~hemlJ'~' :Ul 'Bata.e.lt: ,of':It el neither com,l&te :mOf 'mos1l''¥e'lt: 'i-.n~' 1I"n'~ ....... .tMii1 ,c-:;:_..__... he tIii""''r'!iiiitii71 '*'~'''lS': ,-L·...··m·~...;:;'i'II~~:Rn; ·o~ '::iiIt '. ,01'1:":1'f:' ,.Iou,
.ll!-""~I ,.·,")[UIi-Mir~1 ,., ,.
ILiU_ .'
,impo;rt
WI
:Hfi1:lbetl~[9 :111,0,[:311,,am. 'poliii,ea.11

~ILM .' !!'ii"_""',Ii,~Ii.lI.Mu,
,[,Ii, ,11: .. ".
'r;~;ri :IH.m ~ fha! :1ir.c.lfnmiJ :ind.li'W'liihIe: b;y [.iperi~~".[duc;,tiO:DI,af',MBM' andJI~,m~!OOI,uoof'W,f'j:m8 a,¥~ided~[ o 'w ,wnduam:1l. :M ma.ht:Q Is, ISaid, m' be tlr;&.hI'r4ing 10 '.It, :N'IWDt1: :;: blllt 'wla. :(rom, hiil [~~~O:fi I: 'mt~ may'~ ~ :b:y' mi~adoDI!1 d.;ril!G)'that: 'w-Mell, :iI ,«JffIta4Ultw:l 'm[ ,IDlr ImdUt t_NI~hwhtme¥Cf: dr.,en, 'he ,m ;gldl 'm :b.lvel mn,cl~. ,~.t, :rrftUQfl::: II!I,e~h.:1, ,~~n, q,d 'II a'illdl. ,cWwd19:" ,(I~W~,:, :'4' at) :11'
'I
.······.ow 'who a ..
I[
Til.: tat: lof ric.,! mamD wouibill :HCIR, '10: be '&e OOMiIDlRqt of [oondUtiOD 'W;[th, _ab~g;bld and. ,mdmt, tm:tb., And [tiN_):
'I".:
Bilkl: :rea&Im. hes :flO :n3!!wf,al. I)taudar,d, _~II.OI 'a;,peaI ·to '(.eY:i~ d~nt ·tmtL:i CWU~,S1!l•. OO~ ltat.hU'~, :~Ibtreason .11~st. be nUI!o,,] •. ·Imbed. ooa.¥mti.oa~ Just H :80 8uilt in carda ,is '~y nature: ·~/ij'1i~~'P-). liij'i.'n';~:J-': .1 It,~~ '~l~;~~, ~f,:' 'a~m~'-"' """"., ';rliilld";'mmil~~; '~GI, o"......_ ..._
h,
11!!o~'!!IIIiliit_I,-'" lUg.
·~I"lt'}.
Vi
_iI;,~,
'~fV' U.
,,",~IL,..,,1,11I:lI11~
l~~
V,,
'r'~'ifi!!i' II._U ....
iGi~1 'r:iI'~1 .J!IU. !DV ,iI=_~t~
'L['·fV· Jjlll_Ilili!ll.iWjl'~ 1~V.\~~_I.~~!i!',~L~'n:il.. o~!Ct! 1D:$ iliiQ-~·.:~
meia!~ :&l1ti~u:me., :nl, t:hc aiwcn,ce ,~f ~ie'ty:~ '£BC', ' prnumru '·b-:.,: ~IUuge ,!Lor '~':!r;'lf,'~~ ,~~, if, ..',. ,~, ,In._I' .l,Y .:"';~'r/ u_l_mse~. ""Ri _.easG__ ,IS:, ._ ..
"-"1'0,'(1: .'. '~'i'
'~n: Ir--;tr·:t..._~·1i"Jij[;a.afi'i;[li. ,~,fJll~

1J,~-MaVllJI~1
'~:U-i;i!; v~=111"i 'bl~".:.') ID. j~ ~'i"ii;~;-J"::-1'r
J'
Di~J'!IiO,I~I!!Ii.
,iLQ
~:L.~ ~-~ ,,*,_III~ ~;-~~I.
l~iIf.' ul;
:rmlift,
ILt~_ ~!P'
m-Ql':
. '~;I;..~: :n,1.1I1;'
'CoQllClt'ia;g ·tmeo.rics,of' ·tnlth. seem ito 'U.Rdcrl~ 'these ·t.w,gl a.eoourr. lof :"gJrut :reason .., I'D. Rrzman: N~' 'bvtb. 4.,..6 lOP. an. ltl~lkmI!tce8ppea~~. wlm~:s, ~ident ..in mnmJ of' con,oo.ptjnna 1:0 i d,eriVle.d, .from ~Dse:; :ill. .~ld." tru;t~b. d~ds, ,on m. :a,paJ),
"'IIifi;II". :-I~,:-,._,,-l-:-_d_·,-._ : :-_·'_"-.'-·lfi'i!!!i,'''_~I''''I·Jt-:_'~~:na,:·~._\i!'li:"'IIii1ii.,,·,d:l""Ii'\.-d~ !fI;.• i_ ~,:.,';-'I_"'·Iit"II'· ,-,,-:'::"i"i~lm- _I ~ ";0'., •.•1011,,,,,,,,,,lh,,'!U :,1' "";,' "'!'i-,t-} 'IHli_ ,·I__I·:'i~,'·. !LlJ CUi!,!; ,~!", ........ Illl!l! m.__ .""~~J! _!I!,"!,lI'.!I,ilL it ""'1~~~_i!!Ii!L'_ '" V'U~. ~iI!"'~.", ':--H-'': -jifl!liib(bes- _'!Ii B [~I~- -- "'-',' I~;ft; d-[ '_'~ _ioLiLI.~,'U'., ~"IUIU.-"!IOO' - '~'-- _ ., ........'iD, 'ptrm-'h't- ---_ - - -.. -' I . -I ,"-' ;~ - . ,-", ,1(I1ft· -I 'H'I~_ ~ijl"1llnl~_ - 'I; P?Ir~1~tI;nillli, ~ - -- - 1-' 'I -~. ,..,C~, -." ,~~~, ' : .,...;.t,~ ..~;a,-' ... ~:~_:.~.,Qi,I..I< ,_; \I:,UI_I .. ~cliilil.D
"":-.,'1
:ruson.~
t-':h'-- - -"\liM~h dtae tbeori.a ta'IIe·., :aa,tiJer'j' aI~'we em dOl :m 'm elJ;l :lttm!t'ioB t~,'chUB o:ppostWJ. 'vlews;of'tm'tb ad ,of.:r~lb!t.r.mJ.~u_~, . , so ttL:-t~ 'W-j0 ,may ·fiir·-.: ,ttilb:,.',' '-: ~_D, mut._ ",rh':I' we~'''l~i!i:~-I' 'iH:;;:b'-iIl;-:~iIi.l-l ~_"'" ,_ iIltilye ,,,_;em, :'-:":~i I,:d'l ..~cen, .. ''-i~m, ,.,0: .mea· • use of' 'the·concept of. ri,lht reason • ,d,evelo,pmc' ·tlc 'basal of
J' -...
J
-'logy-
--
;-'-,1
e-
'j I~ ;:.
~:j'
'j
to~1
:.;is. e,t'iu.ea ..,
-bb __!Ii' 'I,if te' ..J H I,O~: ~."I - :Ru:":maMm~I' empl,es :Ir.~ :IJIOfCe!il. iotO [(:OJlSta.lbt acU¥ity ~iy'the: :pr.alnftauom, [of' 'B;Vier-:Bew o~j:ecm,of d,esite md~ RRnloD, ., ~n:pe,dmoe.~ The 'w ttf]dl is :mi!1 of kelps, am'
,I,.. II, ,~ [~
,ii; _ _
_"
. ...::__.
I_I1I_ru~,,[~[~~1
'L.:r .... .4"i"'!li.iliin~
"m '!i',1,.-i~ ~~ :U_lI~'
=---..
'I'"
'Ilii'i;<i.=:111 ~Ul~~U'JLlI;g!j[" ,,,'lk,'~' a,~-dea, .' ·'iiiit~'MII_ii!" '1iiliI'iin* ~l<"'_""ii' ~ I"J~IiUH, ~iIl:~_~}i~~, ~_-.~;.'~
'ii;
~ll!Rdo :B\VDidl·th£: JDFtdmncea,. t :rower':m '1'11'1'means of IBcee8I, 'lB, 'dds -ornendimg',a:cti¥citJ,~ B:.t ,ROI [dgee Inl':p0wer' [can ever euUK ,a~~, 'TbG bin,~ dmnea, : . , pmv~ tDrJ],pml'~ [tke: JRe:lps,'~OO . :smaI][i CVitaj~,MOtioft :May;",_d 'l;v IDltuall:Y'I'DJut" 'bentt_iillmt, T~.U8 'w:keo.:HIo:11,b§l[com., '10 dese:riDe; 'the:mlnmen; of :meR~he wri~es::
hel"
J"''''~~I
'.~l
,6Aii"!\~llt'l li!I'ifIi; ,,,,;~,,,,
[~~:._lIl~
Li~I~[:v
,_te
TIle pndemr!t: ,em,gine' 'wlU, allway,s, :seek 'tOI ~IlIR: i.~lf11 te ,t'~ madmruM exl·ent 'pouible" alldl ~IOwa~,dmre ·po,wtr ,'"
pow_"
pow~r'
mR~ed
'by' :DiWml foree8 'would. ,al!tcmpt, ·~o, :fliu:r[~ jlM,power' :In.,relation, 'tol the.~ ,ooul,(I, R.C),t,'Ibe; Mid, t:QllOOll.l!pek: wl,d'i th.lID!p 'bot BUJI maa. is :mGt :1, sOltiltary' !bem.I~;,he: Ii"tes ,ootofr.on~ed:'~Y'lot'her . mea, :Bvm, thls, :d no,l: ~neeesaarilya 'conl!peb.tivl: simatioD,; :(o.r
j
illog ;•. ' ,¥~Jta1 :motiom. ooDtiDU .• Tbil ~ltrli.Vbl\l: :fOir :Y, ~nDt .~,. eompe;utiyer= -a, :so;ljmry be~"'lt [COD:;;,'
OSI
~1
t'bat. ,hi! plWUB, ,of' ·ditlerreDt. 'M9 should, [oppose' '., 'lbe: .po-wters of :na!m'fe', au:d :oot eaeh IQ'tb,e,'" Ihillt [once :a_lt: 'Ih,e; 'possiihl_iJt" 'dlitat (lilt; mloi';'s, power' [opposes :mother;,] and. the: aUl£em, fo_!' 'power ,afMr 'J'OIWct' '~Me8j
Sm,tTle'
iit, :m, [m~le
'=u.::;-l:.~~~:~o=::,~~=
to, Hatrre :m,self 'by' ~nere.uiRI' :.,' 'power in ,lmatioD, t. 'Joon~,'y,'o,U'J' :kQ1wwel;,] :mJust eq:ua'WI,,. strive:'10, :seeu:re;"youmlf' 'by'
inCRUl~II'
!II'
'10Ut
pow_ in. .Ja:ll0B. 'teo :mi'lle", ARd
:SOI
-the ~mcc
'iiBI~n-
~~.~:!I;
~"u,
... ;00....::11,
C' ,-
w:,· leaD,'~_t~V ','-' A:-"~~[~i'r,.. thus, see 'w'hy :Hobbes

eo.II\;,.._1.lIm .., "
JUJ_:IJ_tl)~
-' ~",:_ ,ill; ~~ ~'" n ~,.1 ,n ,Ii_~'" Tum,Iii!' N'·····~,I!'if'!I',u'mE' 'O,-'',1:",'(i!I 'M'" A,I ~N"'~'
I
:SU;pposes
"'-tIl,.,'
;L ... '~W!ltC'~L:,'£~~:".. ,t,.<"I" me ,:r_~JvnJ._J wli!j, [-. ,m.m,Ii .pm-wmw

,····--l~l_l
'I~ ""11'
mcn
'tB' be
ncc.a""·
I ~-
I~,
IDppgseEil. D.d J·W HfJ1Ut. adlttrit: the
·thal. 11i1iiS is th-e l~c of [aU :hluman,

,i, i,
~1I r- y'" 'iLb .. -b 'L'i' T:tb.:l[ u!etab [0.' ',I:~I'''lu' ,:a:"s. :a:rgume~;t 'J'~ears ou.t~'{jJlta aceouftl:; ,T,lIill :md.dc,:It ,~ftm ,t'be looe ,of comfl[et :~n,:3:. :RllrLEtU' bo6 IJuclJd. ..:i H-"' 'L ~_Ii'" ~allJ4 '-I )cpnt~., :"~' bt.._ b . IO.'i~' .;C,IPD8, ·WJt~~.t'.Ilitt esscoltmi..'. eq,u~ity [0".' a'i :"8- -am. eq~.\iJt.y,'whit:.; [Jestslon ,tb~ 'UDpl~,I; fa.d. ·tha:t '~\ul to' ,th.e ,ftU., of' hmJ",~, the 'w'eakmt bas stren.llh, ,enOQI~ to kjl~ ,tb8 IBtm:n,PBt '(B:.,W~ lU~,p, :~ IO'-)~ 'm:f' :lUniwil :m maD?!" U'llt_t:e :aOn;1 ·Ilme.n ,the abillit:,· 0,£ one: man, to' kill ,i'n;,OtRer :Lal 'the.
I~
cODli,a~
[of a,ItnJ[Ule ,".mlll:
1)..
,i,
'f"
"."
'
'u],timat:l; _Glure ,of :.an'iS ,eq,ua~i,ty'~. H~ob'be&,'dIeD :illues::
of'lour ,ernD ..ADd t'lll~fr~'f~u: :lmi)!" tw'Q :m~JiW :if' d.~~: 'llie :1I.Me -thing}, 'wb-i,cb, :n9-;enhe1ns, ,~,. C2'f1!DO\t; !oo.,th ~rdI1>J'~ th,e;y I~: I~a,;, 'an~dl 'i_o'~be: ,t'O th., ~md,t w'hb,~'h, :p:rl~dp:ally' their ·~wn '.. :r~~l~nl;" i~ IDd,
"tom, ddtl ~,unty ,of' ,a!I1l~I~IJ~, ,eq,uaitity ,Q;" :00,.: :ID'6c ,lti:Iini·.s ,amelL,
wa~, .m.~
,~ ~ll."~ .. (B~:W~, :p;o iU

i
'~r'
dJe.lemtiollIomIy'!' tndcarYOULIt'
I: I::~)I
'~O
d.a1n:r,·, ~r g'bmJuel
Qftc:
If MeD, w,e_re :ma;llif.d.y U'ru~:q1i,ud., ,tbe: weailet' 'would. ~r:~'~' :mrlze dteLir .uuibiiqr· '1':0,eoapae :i:n, 't~fe~ :pm'W~f'~8tmuleio, Tit.,' cou~d,rn:aimtam, 'tt.,emseJ,Ye8., not :b:y' ,iincrcsslng ·t·b.etr· POWI'l: in
1
Rla!tlun.
:fnr '.·is, 'would. :O,Qt, 'be: 'pHlilbJ,e;" but ,0n1l;y' 'Il" ~ '_ plw1e:r of :IO.~:-tmn,l,er penDlm.. ~Q dIcit, dcfm.ce~, s :io,:mmm, ior' '~'bGirbomage tOI :h_iimll' Bmnitv '--" - - -·'.D , - ,- "'J arDmfJf. ,(JUlit Qf' (iQ:.~tlt~Qm feads, lo'~mmtv' ,a:f.1Sm.b ,' ··.. ·-~,r"'" -'e,~. ~~I."..;,~·.;~~~i~'o' 91111: of [d,iIi.dmee;. .:0" you,_ are my' plt'C!ltial ~ompdiJtoT~ then :iJt , p in MV~ '~'Il~uat'~D f~ra;td~ '111'0..,f;-om 'dr:-: ~.~~-",~, 'H:b'bea~ "\~. ~ ~~.. .1_ , J .. ,F _ -:e ,outset As =~,Q , Jg:pll' .".
WI '~'I
I. .. ,-' -".'
t,
..•...
_ ..
',~I
..'~, ". _:.;0;11 ',"~ .. ,',"I!!Il', 'iI'.-·L~I· 'J' ,Alt.Q 1~,'!I!1-1!1!~ ~-g~~_
(.;s:,~m.;I""" .,;:.... -::.,.,~ : ......
'-b~ ,__:JI; &w,n mmRm
[IKCUR D-_ii~lr~ :1() ~ml'lilr!~, wl~, te, mut« dtI: ~F18, ,~f'IiU :.m nc: mii~ :~.0,n..g;" "D. h l~ ~ • ot~[' :pewel:J gtft.t: ,ee,u.p, tQ IlBda:np,' :him;' and dUal li3 00 mfi.' 'than,
W'
.==: ftQ ~.ulr~,ilii:!, ...... 'iL ....
.. ,... .:ii.' :i1it\li:d .......... iIIli 1'1' _,oj] ,IQ,~.,Y'1'.'.OWlig" ('IL~'..iI''\ ::>-,liKl~~
li' ~-~.~_~=I~ '~f, :,:-.: .'"!", '.-'
_Y.'-Iel~
'-1:"' [man l~ 'iI!U'I' '~,.'~. ) JII_O,I,-~iIi' '----;--ai, ,amrticlipaIHmI~, 'tut: b. Q f~~t or

df"!l"- , ~~!V,~-~-
·.,.jL-'""'lf.' ~. ,~111-~=!}~ ;=:., .~'l;.,~).'.: ..
l._~
.!p.!Il'_~
~,I~
IVI
;!
or :M.A1N' :I~' LThil :mem,ltnT' is, u_am;ermlJsl:y' slIggcs,ti¥e '01:' ,th'l 'view 'tbat :_.;"8, 'basic aim 'm 'to 'Obt,..do, :bil feU~lW8~.,tbat :h, :11'__ ,_. adJ ori_lilnal1,y' oomp;dtiv,¢~ Bu,t IS 'W1!: bav,e :Sb"OWllit COMpedOOJ tion is, d,ertvadve'~ 't~lein'lliat~and ,ar;igiBal, c~[u~'m 'wi. ~g]f~ maim.~,a: mam.'ifa,ts ~tse'l' c:o~pGdJtlonJ 'but ,ol\lily 'booaua as, em'C :ma:_O,~9 :po'w~r :ma,y' alwa,ys: 0P,pose anut'he.r nanj1;I .. lSimi:IIr::Iy:~, ·tke; :r~mo.WJ.f,' rolF' lev~ry' man;J aplut: ~~ry'
T'M E
'm": [~
:mt.N A.'T'U'I.
:l~'nl:iil'~~"I '~_''''~L ,~;,,: ~~,

I~"'r
I. ". 11'(
.• Il'Yhl!- YI!lol. ,!Il'~i=lIl"I~._
1I;'ii"~*'
,~ft
~fnlift"!llf"e' 'Ib'_;(YIj~~;I:::.v'_:'..b, ,:'If~,t···li/Iio~1 ,~,~ti'~ii~'~ l~eriiit,1-4: _lI!j~l~ I, 'U]. I ~111, [DWCi'-'-LilD_ .. ~· II,. I"j~
~~_Il
,J
:fmm, ,tb,e' ever""'possibW,e comtlid, [betwmo, :m,en,~'s 'POWlrs [oi' lIi~f ... 1-:0 ,~: 0',= 0 __ 1r.~hJi":ml8~nJIeD\UlOO, 'Wi'; : ]S the oommq,ue_.JJe [:I' :[ til;rf' i1'lal t .. '.' ,ar I ,_ ,e tttL __, ,lm&."CI~IL.lll,,:~~, ;ud ,tbe AINral. Idealrei 10 :presenrc: ODeself:~H:o,i'.ba?'II, :m,empllor
'j [I ,: [I'~' !Ii,
["1-:.'. "'
II .' .". ~,:
II
.~ ,;:-::-=;:- -:-(v ,_!I!iI:.J8U~!Iu(L,,! - "~ [pu18~J' ~II f;~-'-(I~,JI ~m''i'"1''~

~ii!j;,
m:afe'QI,e_~ md. twU~,

• " iil'ii;~' lUI!li.1 . "_'~'~I
'if~/~l"~L\n~u,g,![,iIJ~, ;g:By -,-. . ifi"iir~~~~'\"" 'il-I~:n.

:"'1"1 '~lB,
I,,];!,
[_.l~:
ri:liJl..II.i'!O'!IV
''''''
-1-'I-II;o'lj'll~i ,,:Ji:iII', II
!I!~~.!I;,.iC!'
'.~~':'''Yl!,'._, ;l"' M,'"",'' ' ' :~'ii'~

II
'W,:oi;p
'W"~"1;-;::oji'ib, a-'n~~:Ji:ii~1 [O~'llji" ",:~iQ,~_I:ll" _~.~~ ,'.l~
[eQad1$uon 'of ~,eoQtiiqua'l fear:i, :a;ruJ,dan:ger. of viulelliJt Idea•. ;, lAd. ,the; ~K" 'ma'n;~:snl,tary'" pOOI'~ 'nHtyi' brut.IlI, :;i'Rd. raho;n;'j' ,of'
(:B~ ij,i~,:p~.1 :13,)~ 'W~ 'TIlt, MIu'ral ,eo;Rditillm, 'Ulf mankind :q, linmer1end,y 'Uuta!blc.,
~TUid;;";;IIl". ,I [D~; 1~,g:~~r·~·~,Ul1l"~~
ifIi~III¥"·}i..
~.~~~-~.[IJ
cqtion,. :ts [of coum 't'he greB'e.it [ER~J ,of prese_lVa)tlQm.~, If: ld~. :m,en, aUk, to, 'be :filr.em,OSit~ :m,os,t l'fUlst :'I~l ~bim:d.,If' ain '10"10, b :ftght;t :"081: 'fDlBtt. be' ,l)fvm~ume~,TJ oondiiJtiou. of W;I'r Ui. ,tbl;
o~Jt:*'b.,;Q;~ ;i!i!'i!i;·d:-'';;''IlIiI'tf..i'!iii·UI"; J.tl 'iII~11~;"·1I"lr!Ser:,.., t~~ [~.Il r~.._...:.~ ~Jlt~ ~.IJ.It.~ ~al·"·v.l"lbll ',l.~·
ne
I'll"-.
c~,
'w:We'b tendl w, br:ml: on 't'hat [coidlid~,so :mea~,~~

1
~:.~~m:i,~~Q):;t~~~~.~;~~~~'~~ Bitt WIrth tlu~ .Md, rbemselves lOOked anns ,ra~

o,;h,ef1t
Ul m.
:fOW1C'-t
I,.,ds; o,nl,y' 'to'eV cr..,:mcreutnl· ,i~U;Fity;, Ie!: as,

1
t'BiI!" N!i.u,.,.,L. ,lI!';.'~ ,I}y(~- '1~'lI!'ilj,j""I',--,~-_j ~'!i''';;tv' ~l~J" 1._p_jIJ~~'~~1 '~;n,~!I!;.~~,~, ~.~.~
't'''"'
ttll
Itrenli'llen tkems:e[v e8, 'lUI 'pre'eo!Jt. bemll' evereome, SAd 'them.., HlvC$,~td. :m. a,raee viblcb, [f!:6!!lIres,(h~)t~ are (Fvftmme., I :mEt IThe' ~~al 3'od restJFess desire 0'1 powet afte[t' 'pJwm!i1 IradB lQ'Dt· tDI ._"po "_" __ '_'"___m.po;.ernce i-I .~-th ., .y "" ·iM,1emoo'. , And jj~:iJ::C; eence ~~ ~lla~ . _
[1'if"Ik.: .... '.' ,
JI,~Jiil1li .m
:In,4 '~lltiea'~, dteory'.. 'Tlte .actio., 'whlcil men, DBtu'rai, md~ mmDlll,JI ,ptrlOIlU i. order' 't.ol secure their ell/(ts :PiRlV1'C .. .~f , d\d_tm;I"~ 'We CQ!nnot suppose: 'mat OlM :m, H,obbes~;8, state: [of 'atom aN: :~n2lmRat Th~1 d,o,.Dot: ,eD,Ple • 'the' 'war of' ,all :a.piDst td~,:merely in lom@r' 'tD satisfy iMmlml31m: paUi.n81i 'O:f eva, tO SeeDR s;llort, ... t;elf,il~ i;IlIJter[n,t9~In, eompetrog 'wit'h 'tkmf'
I
Jl.L. me
~,~ 1:.... 'h _,'il p:rcWCInlelllt - 'W''';j'!lC~1_ d"' 11'· 'UDJerJlle5, 'H" bbee .':".ol:eIl,S, .• (h~~
Ih,.,· :s_~nl ~b.~iir.· ..a~1 ... are .¥ler.,. ·we~l ;'be_tlll:'" Fur tbe :mam. whol wOli(d opt, Otl,l: IQf' thei :mm~1 wou'ld put :nimself a~:the :MUCY
:f'CI~[fw'SI
.1.11 jnUolwa,,:~'
~llevtl'
~ - ,"",11!..·;; ~ ~
:m:1; :"Iir"~ft, ~ .ar'"II:ed Ij.a:t~ ~gst~... :Dalt~~O'I'Ul' as '~.~' ensure .~~ ~. ~ ~ ~~~~\I! ~ 'be .~ ~"..., ~ ~ ~~~~ ~!I!.Ii~ ~ ~ =~<I' ,r"""'"
J~ ~~J~'_'
it :seBJf~G' - :E'- ~ ~ •• ":~~I 'L. t'lu1iKI.I 'I~O:~DJ·eth.~Ic..'~ eac.l~~

oiIO,1!...
:ann_~D.g;, ·80
·~vft:
.to;~II'ID.
~. •
'ibv' '!Ii ~_Q, :.lg81 MiSUFG' ·datu, :RC'\I'I~l'tJ' 'by' aDa

.,.= .. I
1!I!I!_!Ii'IlIiJ,~Q;,"~: ... .~L~"!,":
ii'I:~)"ci~:i":Ii,*,b
:a.'ttiIJ~ft ·of ,legty~ ,then m:m :m~lht. :reflf;tln. fmm, kostUJtJ' ..~ButlivaR ·diat iai. , : mm]~ .in, ordef' tU 8un:r.'ljl
If 'tke
r~a"V' l.~'__ :,}' :$.•
·Ml!ti saJD,'t';: OO u.J~re i'"il~I' .~.1:'-III,-;~'''i'''~t~t~-: IIi;L~Ci •• ,uw_llI.IID
~'. i'
af;:' [.II~:uii("iIJ,!!Ii:li'!, q"I'liifjl~<i!i;i

~
,DUi~ ~lc.1S, I 'P,'0pDS3lJ 'O'iv.r!LOOM me 1'ltll' - 'Ii'!i.. I!.. ....... - ,IiTi.li; - el!iie;lD!la, llf1",~, ·fi: ,tioiL·-'J~ , -li'iii,':: ! -[L;j!i,,;j'!i":'iRU~;Cji. 11.I~lie.::,' i',~le"iIi. ~O",.;u,.i:
D;t.,
t~ 't.:"
'~I~;
'1._ ... L.
~-C'
,'1
1e 01 Rawrce'
as
'Ir ....... im~iIi;U.I,
1I1ri1'~·~1.'",.0 ~\;;;\,~, p!li'~r~1'au.oll~ ,), ·l,Iilil~lF. ~,-C~-~--::-'\," ~~":

I
'W'C['C
'R~41:D~'e: ,~-~~ ~~.~-I-_

"_,-
'~'~fi~) ·w~~,'L'~:ii:!Ob-::lli'l Y~~-~-1Ll .. l.. [I.~_:_ _ I

~o::il
l I__
j,_,~ •. _-_-_-
''''11II1ii\ii?: !iWi_~
\"11111]
·~a.a~,...._41 1~_lIi~-~-U~,
11--'-',., .. ~:~~ U,_I,J' 1~1I_1AJ! ,t'~'lil~~/la II~tLlvln'D:"1

1""".
then
._-~-~-_-
_.1
ImM1IV!"~:t1.on 'I'IHBlSlriliU') -I("!'III!!!P. ~-I-~-_.~ ;.__

[~i~1
"fil~fJ:'-,~,~A'~J;d~·~, 'H'~b'he8i.-{ilOW9_B,_, as _!IIJt ' "_-_ 9-~-~-~ ..~',.

I_f-_-_-_" '_"
r~'-Il
.:Ii!~m:d:'~:n~~ ,~1i~ln;w~· ~iftilil'ii-i":i~n, IUJl~rl._I~~I-I-w. ··~S·~~.~-!W!!~_!lUI~~1

_,'~i_~~~1 l .. )I_ 1
'6m t UW:IaJ" h.aW1!;'lel 'IlDlO:uabtle: 'd~,ey rna, bet! :a;r-e ,doomed, '1m 'Ihe 'war ,of' .m a.uios:t :all 'Rtlb:bn IlCife[llR: L ,.:I" ·iL '" 11.. ' ·iI!..·i: :Re..'; .~'9'~.e;WlR: :arr,rao_prmeDts ·w,!I1dCI~.·W;1"1 ,euaU,le _=:11 .. ~:o.tel"" •"•1_. -i.ll;t:tC· 'I'Ws, ·war:" Tlhe ~cll:"'~rOU:Dd!,ed, r&ttiite .is tbat ,mAdi.tion, !ilf bul'flaa d.:im, viaidaJ. ,enalbJcs, .• en '10 'Of~e:fOOme 'thei lomst;a,el. '10 ·tbJci'f ~ri!tt" ,,'hl,cb, mai.k~ t!belr oatu~m~~ loom,d;i,tiiulJ, Ollt) of
~:,~:eo, :awl.J
IDIl
1
l l~~'
'~lm;"J;lf!lli~lft r·-·~~ll __ -- IJJIIlIi!:JI~!~
·w"a~lr:, l..-~ .. ~
gL~~~ Il" .
!IIIl",
poam" ,:,
17-'iIr~~~'6i:'1 &iI!_w_",,'~'!I'!Ii!i~,
,· :llut is am,." :11.1011. of' state. :possi'ble'" p'ven 't'be· leom~i,ti¥'e~ ·ii'iOl' '~'O:IrL~::~;ft '_~I:~:11;* .:it!: . ···;"~'I ... ;1:0 O¥'_~M~ ;i;!L~ v~ ,n _ =~~~~~ J""
.J ~ .a:::d·~~ ~- .. 'U. ,"' ..
~ ~'h~'.-'h_ .........;~k - - ~. ~ _ - - _ '"_', ~ ~ - - ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~_ ~ -.;1,'"- ~~ - - ~ ~ 'u'lLnn:;' m.ce;' 'W~:~JCif['lIllll_Ns.alIl~nman, :anl:er.-cou:r:se ·an mBem.U:lK,g· een'I~\~~tf :~'l..,.b:;.~, '~I,a'el ;i'!iA,·~.····'T'~".~--:.,.",:,~.D,··j.~'ft.,l..iP_~~i;I! ""'-'~J""~.!I,'U~~~,~ .!I!.~ dis,~.,·r..v.,' t:~:'h'~.~'·iIlil ..ltIC!l" ~ J:~,'Y!U~ ~ if' ~,Ii_g~''Y\_~~,~ 1!lJ!. ~UT"
.
'
~ ~ .. ~ •.
t; ,
JW~~
__
~.
!I¥~~~~~
iU,[P;:
'!U.1.Ii
,"I~
L[
nit.:~Aii'"t~;~;i'!i;~II'
..
!Oiii:l!',
·~.·II~,'.'i~I·4;·1
c~·~-~'!:"""- !"., ICU8li[~u, IliIlill,
BUit :11:
:IDBwer Gild,
'~Ic'~' 16,1,
-----=----~
:m .not
.f..n;.
'~:A, ,ft.·
·R·:'~'i!if~:-~.· J.'£'¥l-ew~ ,-~.JI ,Bug.
~'-'iI"'o:'!i"I-I~-~'-«i'~'
~,Ii""'-'
'iI'_ ~~'. )1i.!IiSl'u-\Ii~ ,"v ;f'"~~,,""'oiIilL~ ~.'!'~II-~~ii.""'.:.fi!nA
'S'L,A'l"qG1
_U.VJn'D~
~,_.~
~ ~~,'C
loW
,~ii,
I""
·W~lIe~.1Cf -.cli.. -~. 11l....

'_'I)
....• ;·~;.'~~aI'lt. 'Iul 'OOJlltNd:. a '~lall!li$lh~e· ~RU.ma~ p r' ~ -~
:seuelMml' '~Itiol!.
more· 0'( :H,~b.ba·~·81 t'b,eorri,es'wiU, eDlcr:ge, lit: 'tile

,JI;:I...··~-I-'~-~-·
U_l'l~' :BtID!WIC'cf
-,"~
W1L W,l'Gm~_~'U. a
'-::-."~
,of OBI' ,s:tud;Y~1 'W'Ne':me.Dtl DDt :seII;"'m.arlln·.mimg· [lmillna~, 'but. oth.UIA~d.tm,.
condltioft of
..~_ _~U .• ~Uw.,_~, liliifl o:~i'b t~)'h:·"!i:·d:~l~~:~·~!~n··.q~ Yl~-R~-~,Q.-IJ blllDlilt
·~.-~iRa·Q;; d:!:d. ·tihew el~~,'·[ . Il~~~- , 'lmimt~ce

~J •• ~ •.
'••••
,t'b;iiCg, .~_g~_~__
'i.~Ir,
QI"_~I
"W~_J~-._I ·~-.,~i~ldi· ~:1!,.,.: .~;n~~I·taih·i~: 'Ir;i:i;; '~~I~I~ 1~_.2:.~'·lil Q~

... I
r.~
deaend ·n~l,., ·.r--· _ ....."~
OD. ....
.iatm.;!1 :Bn.t if~ 'by' morat;J ~pllillb3i~~ lOt"
.1"~
laJ-pa'bll of 'Mi.' ·tMllcd •. LtI1" '1.~lva 't'h~irl cnndirti.u, :m ,ORe[of' endla.[ ,mm:Bidi Dut. 'tmi'Rttl, ,mdI .r-eimed dl~" need. Dot: ·be· lcerditleil. 'iD[ aepual. lcaPS' :ia :1. :zoo; ,tk~ ~ :Iil.ye :in ·ncb.
j
'baim'h!JI~' m'~1,d~~l""t~ ==ru.

._.~~~_---. !I!
[~,L.~r.'.'I··~if"6'm··mtli'l'ilu'~ U-U_IEt 'IIIi-U-c ~ ~ ,r-~:

J •• '
~l
~HI:~b~,';~~_;I'1Ii 'B~'~'~~I JU!I-. ' .. :U~J

[' II Ul
,r,..t:lv.1Utl~;.I_1I_1I1
,~
·ja,
.~\ii'!i;,
~v.
[~I~~:iI:j~'""'.I:eUIi~~' U~·rtJ~ 'lDJJ ..', .-. _

11r.·~
~~g"'~1
·,.~i~,al .
llJ_]~lI:Qi_!I!
!!!'I"!1'Ei! 'C< Ii n,~
.i."",A
,il,T::C-.'~' 1'.--:- ~ [~: Pr' 'M-,'~,n,'l1iI;.;~1' ,a .... ~I _._,D. U,~j ]

~l !.J
'~T" ~~If~ 'N=' ,n' ","=U='QI IC" ~,~'.iI;:U~,,'" II. 'T_,'_::,!n.,~
[,.I'"
O"u'
'li,ji' jo, I P',~,.i!"i;'.N'" . :~
'whiCh deseri'be hocw' ,B'D ideal m;aD" 'wiu!lJi~d, bclJa,yc. 'b'lIt~'p~ :scribe,:how :a~a'l .en 'iihould, be-bavle~Amd ,tbis ",-ins, a qui!I,1
1~.j'ft'!liD_.jD; ~5:'J~Y~_~~_~'
'B~_.:ril-=[~
be: a, .iata'ke'to, conclude: ,that :Ho':ol•• dna, :aot, [H;n'~De: faotU!s'lamd IUlmHlltiive :issues.. Tite' 'COnm.iDB oceufl,~ ho.nleF~ ft,Qt ,in tbe d,eriw't:ttll1), af :mora'l amd, '~Itiad ICQR,_' dulou fr.-om. 'psymol~cl~,premia8ei, bu.t::iR, 't~,e:praniua,
alit, :11, would,
,rl_~L~-~U~.L~~~1
t.n,~.I~:I,i¥a
~'b~Iii\iiii'IL~,_~ , ..IL.' _ _
.. ,n.l]!lUI,
_AI ~-~~~ '......- 1 ~. ~~t',!IIlCtre
1..-,.'0 q;l!.llili~e
'u.mllfil:i1;";;;~ Ol;'Jlr~~:~"':""~~'
..JI":,-."'n.i"i!t'
~1"__1·:iiIo.F!Itt~;~nili!illi:!; '-""'_iIlIio'n;io
p~~ni!'"
...
t._I~I,'IjI_:.~._~_I·"'L~'1i
;d\ili'·~""_1
'~T['b'~,4'-0" r"'" Ill_'

I " I ::
1,_ .~
;j:g, ;;,j"i;, [' fI!IiiiII' I.i!-V
'H~ ;b~,~,:J,a: oii"i!'I-'l!:~m:iIf!i;b,-' W_: __:_~"

'I',w.
l -'~ ..
[~ ....
~'L..:ir •.
",J.;Lf_1Ilr
'-m;-'iIiiI.-t"i,
I:: ':_
:a"rPiiir ~~iJ_lal : __
1.,~1
'in",~""""",,, II::I_;J'
,...:!iv
RIf~Rl;dfttal~I'
@\II!~
'!!in'd ug~~, '-~~ __ ,~,,\~, """ ~1_
'L"',"l,., .ot:v- AI' hlitBlan

._._i~~~~~'_~, !J!ijO ~
~,i'ti~
'eDgiRQ1j
tiM;!·Hlf~'p,msemlJti,o;o, is, a, Rooau~'

,oii;~':~ I~Y_.y,_~~ ··~iit~~,ft "·,bJib~i:6,'il..,'I,olj:."'ifilitOi",' '1~I;l!li;"'''if!Ii"'i. ~iic~,-,':"I,_ ~r"".~';' , '!IioW ~.,. _, . ,I&V.U D."'"'e,,_lt«& ,IIIU,UI!I,,,,,"A
'QiIi .. ,
'W'\;,,",;","i
~ ~
'rrll'A
'",",
I~~~~._'~
~·p"·'.J'ai~ln .. ,~I'iR'!lri--i~I~I'lar ;j'Ii,~j;"'-m,'I I"""~' li!lil, 'IW-A:_:, _ v,]i, ~ _..~._~~-.r-~'~:.-~ :!ig.... I '~mm1 of g, 'namwl\a;r 'm0dlve', :WI~ft~rl.r ,,r _ _... _-_ ... r' .-.. _ P3!ni~r' ~D "arbon, eDlm, :not U_ftoomm.on'ly ~a,to:8'BCD, iltat-cmm1lts~r WI' _' ,..:I ...~. It, .iIi.',11~· .. I"' _'Iii Ii, ~ :~;Rq~mUry' a, poi:iJl.lOm!, to 'CBta!b'If-'b~ pn,c~·* :MOD,WIOO:JiOO ,'1: :m, ~,~I., :rta'tHDe9ta" ;. 'wb[CJi 'we lexplain mm,,' :amnM iOcl'mamy :pcl'lOll!, ':":n '~ .. ,~,~, .. J _~, ~ ~ ...,~ ..• ' ..,'f~'" ,'--'"~_'~'v'" :01,\',~. '. ,. ~. :"'~, 1,~ll":..(. ,. '.' .. __ Df'li .~emm type Q I,,MOtl~e~..,n~ la'PM~,UJJiIl'~P,rMlf' .. •..~"' I~~, I~~rms, ~ ·
IWuJiUl!li,
fIIi.j;;o,.,4!r~~~""i. D~Ii.,~_I_'liiL""'III~i!!'
e Ii,,., """'1i,,,",'Vc'_'li)"_,,I :- It!!Ii ~~,:,',._ "'l~'_iiI!!<IjIr:.I-v,·,' '';'~I
;g !r--"",IIU-Vlt_iI.
I~,
'~,:'::".'
,ijr.t 'W'-:-i'L~~J\-c~~~: IllIa ,.n!L"",lJiil, ,,"'~

Il."'~ __ •• -.::
!fA ~_"''Ii'L,'!I.ii!\iili
4M..!Ii,!,I,~.
!IIIi;
•~
I •••
1_.
-iii
_.
,ii
.........
~',,:,·o'Ii.·~:_iIf',"'!f'iI. ~ii'ii,V,',: '~s:.~n,"I.~,'.", '~'@oU'l!o!'~ ...~-~,iI-' :Jj~'''''LIIi,'!!ii!'
~'Il_.1
iJ_.= !Cf.l!;IIQJl
sueh
',i:Ji*:h•. ·~·\-:~m.-.··'~~I"'I"l-bI' ..., !ilI!~""e ,'!iii\Ii!I"-I<:lil.
:Motii,wtloDll :staJtemllllta em.8bJe us "(;-{) pnd1d '~ha,I';1 :im, ia,~"n :slw!tlon. :1,penoa d, Ylry . act,:m, a eenaM, 'way because· :be' 'wi~l'very '61:.11 the D'louwtm, b:y' ncb,...dl'"
IGemma),
:1 .'
'B~!io"~ [M~-_.-~_- __. W!i,~tr' P-'~I":"~II".t!if;, '1.:",.: :1··: :-~J:nw__ .. S-;"~h~.'· ,~:"~;-nr;'~.Ulf~J ~-;~ ,..It.D~lti~;I~·d;·1 _B~ __ s· ,1iI~-~\ w~ 11~~l _1I,r:w_IVI!- 1 PIiI~_i-~__ IJ"~_, ~
l ..
ll!l ,__ I
.
'pt.
I-~","'
.. __!l,
:Bmll,
:im :nfJfMail' :pih,si,o'ID,gi,cam and, ,~,yt~kof.o,gi,aiI, mD,dijtillUl~llot .INUred ROT h~ft,otmdt :[Uf' eDmp1.e~",w;, act in :a ,cutlin, 'wq' beealUt: 'he::m." be, mo,ti~;akd, 'by :BII~ll'"'aod,or\su~c'h :factor'., :11 'Yet ,t'~ ~,g. ,.J~_,~,,1",--,0_, i~ eDumv",:un,...• '''',', ,d,"",f!! ',[1_1:18, ,tiIol'L ..... ,.--: :raJ.~ra :~-I'wllat ""bJI~,,,,,,,,, -',iO,'" . .- ',: . ,,;;._,~~, ,:_.'.3_' .__ ..{t_o~, iIk:"", Il-Ilfdry\ dlat :1. ,mDnul, '~,D, must 'p,mD_, t:m,QH: amua' 'viwdi he' believes :~q,~:istt;GtUI hi, :p(['e8e:nra ti,oj), 'because he .ut be, -~::vr.eflU '.b···ri s, ·~'IIit':-· . ,1 £/, ....'I .' t '~""I"'{ .1" _ CO",~D!m, ,.fO\r,1iI'lUn;~IDll'I\g '[I!-':!'I ...• _'11;1/," IIlllmH,1 :B'mpu.iw1]y' tbis; is :m, 'unttlaib~I;' poailthlJlE COMid,eriul Illicl.de~ H,:c,b';oa, m, 'i);rad 't-OI D:J~; ~
,1,
I',
C-H'' '--::",
r'-;-'~
~'~A'~-~'
ll
.gw~,,_.,~
>,
'·1
·1"
'~l'''''T''>U","I'3"iD' T.-:'Ilil"rm' I~;~ . . ll;-;i.,D In. .ft,~
or
U[ ~
'!Il;,iI' !IJ,'N-'-.1 , .
j:Hfto
.adlquaqf' Io:f Hrm'Jil:bcsl'[a meehan_mTilie
[-~i
'it~;.., "'~
'l'ftiGl¥ .... :I'J
that ~·tb08C· ttitrJU aIle: a :.tat to 'm,G.Ef CD:d\5",~

·H'~'n·L.·h'..-~"'iiIIiiIIi,i'[1i;~-.111.~.~ I'!4I'q- C1I:1[i:iII"AoiIIi' ~·,:_:,VU\ I~
'I
'iI):,...~\'If~, '[ we: .nill.,!IIG!II; ~D_D:r~"1 ':"';iI;;-a., ,a.~~ .... :m'l;~-}. _ ;;:o_ .. U;v;1O 'l,!.!I!iL~ _I ~
:actO.UDlt [Df
:'i"f;· v. Ul~ ~.
j:r;t<!'I;iMf!U'-ID
~:~!l,.
~'1f.i"A'n_,~. ~~ft. ,~~"""~I : -)!lI~JUv-.UJ ~"'IiIW. .
~I~'
.D$I~ re~bll:~
;f~
that [aludul:e
('f!IAiI!'Ii'Iij, l~lYI'll
1
'iIr'L,~~, l&f_:: [i"if......:ld1l!" 1,,_I;1DJ. i:D' ~[I:U}~-~,
I~'V'
'p-~oa
~
_'._~I
[~j;-I-D-~' ,.--~_~.g_.'~._!_liD.l
::---:I#iI; W"'"
:S!OOUI 'wbat. iii]
B~essary
.~'~~iI.i!!
'19
secure a 'mao,t,8,
'Md 10 [Bat~mUli
-:::---;1;' !Ro1i.A;!e:p.~
;joi~
,~·ii~·~;~jlit, L...JI:.,U.b." ,iIl,,'I!... ... I~UUgl~,_ w,' "~-,~.
·~~il"_
tihia. :fmthCf' prem.. u a. :fa£1UaJ or d,meriptj.ve 1.ta;ne.:D~: ilbout. hUJU!S aature l

'~r-'I~I~
'l""IIil~:~n-"a';'I,'d~['i":u: .IUi.i, ..~_ ~.~ "jui~I~1 .. "".~!I!!I!_,~

.~~l
~'Ii:~,t· '~~iI!I"l .. ~1Ii. ~~
'~Dr~'
W"::th' ~ I . "".ll~.~"
'1JI1'[~b"t;.-iiIIoii'. r1"41,~"Q~1!I
.~.iUl~
B,l"r~4[ ,'i"I!'Ilf'
"4I!!~I.
'-tJ~·¥-~-~'~~~~-::
3,.~.-,t,
'~D
M:I!]
'~oi"f>t-'. ,1I_1.U'~J
l
m[ the .facitB~ 1\\~Io:r.al ction. is ,oJt:en. 'd1~ll---lht ·to a [OO:A~!\leeJI ln I,·.an,:':s· len,de" bru't'to tb,c ends lof adlerl :mell;i! 01'[ :not of aodetr~rOf of [G:od:;. yet. :m,QraOC am,on isl Rot: tl!tQu-I1t tor be; reasoR~ No,w i!t. :may 'be that, 'suc'~,a ·¥.imv' of :.omJliiity' .is, miati&cil, 'bUl,t. it: [cmnot: 'be mled. out of' OlD_it sl'mp.l,J' 'by- ,aD. aleged, 'aetua'~ [ciaim)' that: leaso,na!ble acti,{)u ate t:Aosew:hi~ch conduce '10 s, maa~s, eliJ;dl!~ bis 'cla.~m,mBlmdiies· a :Na4ammtall T I
.8ft a&lefllt:
l
isilm!ply'
'-t
:nQnDQi!tlve ,oomKndo:n~
O,~ aldn, '~ltn. 'we' .m.U8t~ modify our Ho\bbea ,caD derive ftom hia tlheo:ry 'illf bu ..
we.
'8.
aOOouDi1t of' whl: :utrtl'r-e;'l I &»II,.m:
~actiiUll' w:meb mndrl;ce;: to' tJm,e :apI'IJti'sends :a'Min ·t'bls m.peet . .r.-asnnmle:~I.,. la"'.~I· ,opeD. that ,othe-if :[actoq[ :18 'w'C'[( :ma, 'bear [if'I.~1 t~'LiIlII' ~~ :iiiinna-:I.;-·tl~ess ,~f:.'~' ;;jji.... ':n~~1 •• 'Hg~ ....... ,g. ~'QV Ji~~,.1 ,:':1ii1'1 a-i1i'm'i!!! .~:.D_ ~~. ride a, :man,~'I'10M, lelld!I~. E-V,en.dlb invol¥eI' I, :Dormat~lvi~ ,c'l\a:'m:t
'I!-;!"~~.
,~~"",,~~-~~;:,:itl,UQIIIi,J' '_" ,U'.uu~.,. .~~?'!;~~ -..~'[ori!t..~~::J:ilil.n.<~-m,tilliiCf, a-I'~.;"i:_n.ti'. '~li'-i.;"ii-nl-I'I.~\~ '~~: i-,·,~:·'d'. [.:.iIl~J~, .. rll"" ... ~ .. u.uU" 'ILGi~IV; IiU!I!!-;J' [",0 __
r--a "
~,"'~'Ji!L
.. __
U.
_ji;~~~ .. aiI:P.;,;',,"IL-'1.,#.I!I,.
g!y', __
",
~~. ~
[~Cf...-",,,",, V''J' ~
but ~~41y a [d[jplltabfc'
'111u8, (fUm ~'helpr-emiss *X. ~s I, Aeeessary ~mamJ ·to M'lf~
'OIl;,C..
'n~"'II"'I'[;"Ii,t'~:'f"..,~'il"!.~~~lillii'i";:'~"!Ii; t\[a,-' 'm:-, -.-,'''''(1''' m'I,,~iIIi~' [~l""" ,A, 'iiIi'~ lIiftil'!lio~re W.na!!l.:ti ... ~,,",,~,_ ,r~.'~~· ~~_~""-'~~'"'II;< !Ii.il~..... ' ,~.'!I!''Ii!r _ __II!IiI·. '"""g,-!!i., I;Jg " ~v ~~I~[,--;--::
'lIety
:pm'ba'bly:,.lbe w;mJt$[~'~ :fmm. ·thm 'wei-derive A'nd

~!liiO'li~
[.]'~~]~] I~
'668,11 :~":DJ)means :al·.ways,,a 9ufljcient~ [tastui, iot, ,die, :impcr;a,..,

''''~'Hai, 1~.lL!I"~'
n(~~~l'lr;-.·illv,-' [iIIi'""m.·.·!Ii< ~'~-, ~- - - ' .F,~,I~-U-DU~~iI1"I~~ I
4i~. ~u
[.'JI":"i'. .~. U..u
'y:t[ _ ~:~'1iIJ .~J,HIJJ. 'n-I ,JIL ,1I~g_~ .~;nlill r~l~·~,~Q-~

jiu'. -
[~a, man 'vc:ty

'a· . ~~'lf'iL . . _. '.JI~.~ll_:ll
I;./!U~;~[.
,jj!'D"-':t!i;
I 1",,,,,]
I ... ·~~ 'l~
X~!'~;~
II
~k loDeof d'le :.0 (lem, 'mmmenfa1o:ml :(0,1:' :H~b'bes',·,. m'oral 'taeoryi1 we':may' reeeii,'1e ID, Irmwer b~M~nl::; '~'H:«bbes,~:SI
BUlt:if we :
c$riwl Ich:ctnnc' :proper:t disenppd, 'from, aD, ~utb~'. :payocnu-, logy 'w,ith, 'wWell i,e: :haa 80 ~,o,liwlly'ftreoessary Im.nKUOO~:is, a, Ytry ,Itd,a dooRtology' ~,~,.. ~:~ : ,ADd,pr.-edJic~1Jl"~1 ;llUlwer ku thiB :nnt 'been, Ilmli,Cleat1lIy Idlrm1t'~n.dtl~,ed,1mI'D, '6c typel lfif' :answcf.'
H--n'~L"'_1 __ ,v!I;J.,~
\~~~Iii W",uilU
IMi.
r;i"T~"
,'.'~~.
'N. C':~-Il,~=" e
, , !i;i'- _ ,....
'i'~~' W!!liO
~;D~I', ~~~;i"'b-.~'i"'" dj !IIUU'I,. _ U. _

,,,",,:Ii
'1~~~~~~iI-~4i"1 l!Iii'!l;il':U'.iI!iI!iL~u!~~.Ii,
.! '. M''0-' HAL T"'U'-'!EOi""R'Y",'

• .!_
" I~:
-.1
I ".,
__'. 'I
' ..
:_', ," X: l':: ~
~.
I'~ :~ I I _' i 1: '_, '~" .....___'__. ...:_: ..,_._'

I ~
,I,
':A,bl, ,tb,c' ,[,.bt.
'CQI do
:X" = ~.A .may do :X,[jl",

t;1i.. tne . . '" -'Lit' r,I,III), . . ·f ".-,OJI' ftdJi'fII'l!:t
it
the eq;uiiv:alena:; • 'dt. WI"r::
~T;-I)C"~~:~ ,-'Il.fii'd" I~ ,9, ,re:!)1. ~~~ '.. . f'e I 10 .et~I~I: ~ ,~~~~rence~m
'. -.. Wit
' ..• ~ iY ~Ad:' 1R8;)/
,au;'I,.,.... lU'
..
,,
t ~
'I!:,A,
i;A ,It., 'the natuml right,
't(iJ1
OJ) X:
mar 'iHitia~U"do, :X~~,
"'11e :mI1tod.diOn oE' l~im,tiaUy' is 'm,t~Rdal,'tol :11'-3'1: the :fad .mail: io;r:HOil1bes.tke.r.ig.ilri.af '.Mlture.iS ,the riI&t: ~, '.iF
iiifi.tI;i'I!'\-, ~~_I
~!j.
TiI,e; '~.fli.' e
:II'Iift!!liiD_"_ 1 'A~·~r·'''~,M~1I1J.' ~-T~"~.}""_~l~_~_: _ 1 ltIii~1l':I!i':"f.ft~1 w'~:'lj~'b-~~....~~ '~~~'I:~--:~~i~'"Inj5.1J,IrJp_iIi ,~'L'iIIi*':~~I.;;'. ~-~.U_ r~I[I.Vl !Lv. ~ ·"j~1 iLW- I l_m_l~ ~_I;t_D.-Ll
of'
'tb;'e ,evjen'ta, w,iU
IdeaaJut,,ex~lmllin~ i~a,
due muae:~ m,D, 'OUl' smt-emmtl ,of I~uiy,alence we lIa"e: ,suppressed a!.I~, :ndemncc to, :'JteHrv;alioll~ Suein rceferemce' belo:l'I(gs~',~~, to' ,the::mdmia'l de_Ition lof' the f,~b~:of' n.ture~ Tio ·~nsHt:!t~:801 i 1M! die I'qllival!mce ,r.ead::
IA'~ _
IL· [ -~-~.-~.
:10['
i
'me' :~n'aliM
",,~~ UI~
iiI'fIi''lIi'''I~liI''!'lIil~ ~~~"~1~ ~~
I~'
'~~a-1t-4t, "tiil'i; Id-1iii'" X'?:i!1 ~ J!ltl!r'lIJ~1 .,~ .~-~ ~'".:' -
~A~'i~;:.~r~J.!· ,i'nII~II.I:l~-v' X\'~' ft':Il'iIl!V' 'H'~ do -_.-V

,~.~. J, ~ __ ~.~
i..
l" II
"J
,of b,m low,n, :nat1.rt'~'

I.' ~.
'woUlld, nmk~ rto 'ramitJJ' IdlJfere.n,t)e., h1llit, :it 'wGld,d, ,haJle;m,l: ,t~ -,~~_~,"~1]°0; ilL .~ .,mmLJtm__g H:' I{{b'~:~,.', UeDymlUUIlt!!l1 ,I. .' ' ;!';f~' ,1"W J1'fUf' mmm:q,_rL~".;I".' m .II'fit~t ,;(~'_'.'_ ~.;~ ,0 :.;111." }'j
;if1i.., ... ~;,.
£~" ~tb~·,~,~d,~ ~~ :d;'b, ~~~,: '~~;~,~i;;P~l.i~,~,~~:DI~~:,~~'~I~i~ t~~,',t~

',1?',:","",~,_..
:n,III "'IliIJn:::
11~~
L~~'~~Ii1
~,-_!lnli",
:f[em1>rced :io, n. Cia 'I>Y' 'ul'ing die'

-I"V,:
~~_"" __ "-IJ IQi ~;~L'lV~
iI!Ii1'iIlIll!!i'
"Whllt, is, :mat: iap~cnst;:rMmB~ :m [raI~ed dJ_btC4'
:iinltern.Id __t@, ,euD"'~e:pt;,of.'

~'il\"4"
Tbis, OOcmllCUUA :m,
',=iIIi,
,A,{::"-~~,'liJi-4!ll
ft,
.:vil .ot,
,(Ihc
cNefUt af mt~
JI.;
vii'~W'..~ut~,~ .,-,L_., '~iI'
~h 'w'm~'h 'it
,"".,, 15.'.~J ~_
~lM.l 'L::im_ L [I:U. -'
""Ii"'~
III_II_ILII
,_,'L,'I'II ••
II.I:L_.... I~
, \t,D
-,,'L~,t"" n.IJIJILo ,
1I~-"'
,
',~;~~,2.~
,,
,liIiI; .... ~; ~"U'~
lill}l;~:ndthcr :apiruI: 'dle .W:tal of 'tnJCi RUeI1[1 ,for I, nu_n "0, _ :18 ~b", CAd~,f8un, [to 'praorvt: ;-.,<1, def9d, biI, 'W,,' :md,'tH ~Hn, ,t~' fmm [death ,udI' IOJ'imWI CBLrt '~bt\~~k1:d1 ~ot, w-'trHY 'UI ,~<In .ftIUllm, ,~~nl;~~~f;~I""bGB~JHj:'~~ ·'fid.,~tb,~n,~ht N~\.;· word :~ !g, aj'tiln, c1lRl Il.. Uiftl~ 'thanl 'Iihal; 1:~HdJ' 'wmdl,~~ mal al ~_~_JU +~-~'If~'''''', ImIh tfJ! Mih; ~liliiUii 10;[' bi ~a..~'~,J):u;oI/J'Y!'!IX!I :-ooo:-r4iirr~; ~~I-:' -,;~,.; a._"_·;m,~-~,',,D, ~ _~__ __ ~~ ~~~ ~~ ~ _~ ~ a~,t!!i.il_n,g Ji'.~II'" [tE~,:W::,6~. ' I1JI
'iIjft<i!'IL~ ... c,,_~'!!'_
;..Jl_~~-T"'"'f~~~, utJIWllJ!_._~; iii" ,
'I,;t! l!.ll! 'tltl-~,;t~~ ~:.. , n£~GI,U
'i_'!'.,":-~C' , jIL.,,"r,;j:"',~ ... ~ .. ..,'Iii' ,O]ii'h.IIIC[' ,.IRIIWi(U, ;I!~.Ii
ep~Il-"~- ... , ~.CJl,
,tkat
't~11
'1.,-.
',iI"'
~""!'
'1i.!Oo!I
i,ft,
'~:A, my de X~I := c,A,d._in.' X, is, iR. ,atDlmaDCO 'with, '(Dgkt;~ n

:rea80n,~';o;,
,guidm,
Iii cA I~
'Cit¥J} 'we
I~:'~, 'me,
:ba,v@j::
'~r~
tast~ sen.~entt:'(Jfl 'the pusap :&um, ~,

X'::'~ ~ ~A'" :.~:~-~g_~: ~ d"In~~,i!t "-";'_::'
,~i'~
'L,~_ ,..!LA, "r=a'L,., .~ U~ ...'it.,.,. I~i 1~:I,~ ~'~-~~11IL"
',:_'~-~~ ~~:~ g"__ :: X' ",/ ,~ ~..,.,;, ~. ~ ~~ili'
-rnaR-
.'~I_'.~~:~;
'w,i. (:ri-Jbt)1 :reaso;o' ~

,a_lui;:
1....
_.
mtiwoa!ll 'ru!)r"~cl[~loiri'~I'I;I_-'1,~rb~~__ '.., 'W'~_-~~tliC,Ja::,I,~1i ",ftJ"o' '-~'!>~t [dl~,~,~~~ '-'}~-~~~_-;~-~~, ,~I~~,~, r~'~~~U~.'.B~i' ,!t.'~••••• C \.'~, II' ~~~u~ ,. l_') ,~~' aI-i-r.a.~:;nn .iI!..~n ~~_, ';~n;;!!!ft '.,~::~.-mt·' as ,~~~,M!I~-!J~ ... wi~L., IB''FR"b-L-,l!i'S~' '[L-'_!C~~, ~_' [ ,~~_J"""'..~'~j! [lt~J,~(I~ '~~,,~UIH[;V~'lliJgli'. ,; l~_> '
1
1U.I€m~ ,all)t
:aa 'Wi!~:8IJiI1 He\~ ~no.t'I'D defmld~ [Qnnelf' U
~aIliithe_r
~poeItIoJ'lJ~ II,
'I.. 'mroc:eedj~[t;,- '~~-~!l'J.mvl!i.iIi_ilD ~.Gl~I~I,:wr-=' q~'-U'-.iiI!j~nl'~w';'1hi~t., I:O~ r'__ ~ -~!II-G!I!' "~ :-iI!..~'ir~I'~~ ~Ii!:""; '-__ ~ ,\l&l!I..-c V"_~''''" ,~lJ!I,CJ111 OWl" a,QJDUllrt, ,c'luJ :lD[U,t.\., 'Wb:y €loa :Ho:b_ muit :fMID ,UiM_fb~, :b}m[ Bloat d,e;YiGlol_d, 3!.d, :m9!ltuIN :pQlitical WQD;~Itbe :~f'IU!rn•• ~~'~I~'j'1I;h' '~U:jIIj; 'L'a-',~~ , [~u'~r,:[til~I_I.L~ d,<~\-'ri~t:~~:~n,-", 11: ·HIl_I_I.~ '_[ [1;1_ _ u_~U ,~ [iii'"~'II[Ii'iIdo~:~'~' __
= ~, __ ''''''' ~ ~iIi~ I, "~"_"VJli_''''~~ ~_ l.~I.-_.~.~-ILlI~
j .. ,iIIl
nJ11Iw.
.·!I!J~I
'~'IIiG.~[
[jll'!iil
~-I~LD.1-_.I1I~~-!II.l
__
. __
I_~_'.JU"l
Is '~lh~m:no,t;the moat 'UlnC(U!D'rortab'te :pmsibi~~ty HolJb'bra 'rtlhat o.tmd, tbese, ar:gumeru:s, beeause 'be :80 ]Olt,pr:' a~tId, 'tImm,? I tbilmk :I,ot., nc' :ICOl,MI: in ~l as we m¥e~ :ReD :[."a, ·tIt,l, OllIlll,mpt [of' ,the rilbt [of' :natu'le: [e.gtirelY 'w,ltllou!t, ~rior ,~:Jjcauon.. A_ad .8um'l~ m~ iJ!lOlma[tloJl1)l, is, ,mHlim of' llJ :hDW it Ul tol he: ~fttnXluced :iD~O~a&,:I~mlt 'whftb;~'tD[ druw,
jl
Ir'.I._1
, ;:,:i!'c '[.'~ '~,puJS,!p'.~
... [
Jlo,thinlr :in, the ;ar.p.en.
-; ,: --·ftI : "',: OUt ,',,'IIDD
(,,_:I~
ilJl'l:I:.1'
~,'I U ~I ,&e,u' \RUllmttlUftq, I, ,-)ii~~., I' "~ [I("':~i [I,i',,)
,',- 1[""
":I'h;' I"'~' gtum ,ISIU,ADCU~ Ill' O'ell :r..S10", :md 10 'we~ aN n'Nl, [~mjded 'ltD' .m ,t~ like: ,_~I.i£r :(vt [lUI" dDiti,Ofli' 'We: Im_o;,.deed~, ;1I¥'e: :1Cl1Jle~aCOO1ll!Rt of tme' [omiui,OB .f the: denwtmn [6f' t [o:f :UIilIe; from ,LmiS1lumil I'n DI C~" ~I~J::~;', ': ~'-11 .~~ ",,"1VIJJ,1 H';' l'[;""~~!, t ,.~~~'l<;! ,.Ute ,.;, ,i~,-: [.'f" inaNR J ~,~MID ~,,~ , .€b;i!~ ,~O!U'uquces . L, ..~ ,n,lh'iilit. 0", ";~; prior to :lhia ,diseusliom. o.f ,tke sta)k~of ,ftaJtaR\~,and, tbLQ, :B1lmwlll
,e~I-,~",:~~ill ,mppotl!mD ,~~1f..,"";>r'tl'r-_: ~-~h~ ,-',";-'::-,;~ :~/>;:,_ I~Wit 'Ig~e ,~I~~e, Wlj~ t--,~e
n,:
,RaeJliJI: '~D,,~,_:
,:__It,
m, :inCDl'Il:pa
~ ...-.~
Rlllltt .. ,
[", L,....
'-I'-([
," , ,'""
[,-,-;-
"on.
~"1"
[~'~l,
iii .:'
how, ,tlllte :flgb!t, [01' naltore'~ m.eei~ed as liD, ,~nIDa1, uDlm_lRd, :ri,lbt'" l•• , 'to' 'ti&,C';' \V'aif ,of all I.pin_sl: all" In, I~,O ute of :El'.r~ :Ruon, :0 'tl1,l: sJJave ,of ~he' aMiom:;: henee 't'Ol :ref.r 10' I, ,rilh,l~ p 't.
'to do :Is, OtJ'~i' In ,lAtIaIJltttn; 'ttJ)Jm~,'H,gb:bcs, ~ntrodllcea lIu , liatiDJITiil1it;y" :1.1 'nmBi(e. in, SmODt. Qul,y' wh,eo, hre: ram. 'dmt: s:t\ap ,in his,
'~l~ll~_ILlaJ_~._I]~
~1'N'I'Iii!Mi;illifti"
;iii!.
dOl 'viut, 'O:m~:nam'ral~~, (Hlldea:VOOfS,
jg-~,
~~-'1k~;i!'!!'b ~DAi'i
begbu 10 mmidt!, :bow :mam can r"a.gl:ilmll, [~pc, :£1'0., the im___pgse: 'Gtu,ed], ., bis ~pga.igD_ate g!ture" 'TihiB, [Qrd~rJ ,of '., .. ,', I-"~ ,., 'L__ 'IL.. 'I'·' aposlliOO, :m lceatllJJ~ :smpertol' to 'tL~,t lin t~jeearJ]b~t\'¥ld,UI\.~
<ii' i .. '
W~lIl~~iII~.~!l ;./~~-~~.l
;"IrnA
~L~iU
~Giin~ d'- ~ 'r~-~~j!-~",. : '1''lih!io:t':t!i~~,'I-v':J ;L~'~-~'D'~~~~_'
,~tiL.~,
·njl.~L~I~l I;i~:
~ ..
lut
..11..11'· '" [Wvorc., -maoalOQ
in, RCGm.dmC'tiDa his ,lilJlll!me'Jlt: iR tlkis, wa,y'~,Ho'b'RaI

,:"" .. t.~ 'c.' e: -'L. '.' ;;;......::..lII'~ :R8I.Q'D :I~rom,'tldl ~D~U,dtOD, '0 ,;':111111
'b,.,
',b,e: n,)lit [of

U~I._:1 . __
O~;
~'
:""'d'-I! ..riALU'!!'Ii,'I:ll"I~lrUL . -._

!II[ ~-
:nabJ'fe'" fot, IRe' ;ftli,-IU,er i\9 paR of: MI, aecollft~: €If
~'m-~~*'i:i!1 a"d"-'I J -,n'-fimD ti-n .:l~: [Q ~ _I;~ ·~[_u :._-:_:.U~ ~.:U_J.L~_~_~;
I~
'ft~, ni:lih'lii-~' A;" ... ..:Ii .1l:tll_I.~U.&lhtl, :'~ _aj~uI[e.l n);IUI

'~il··;~~ __ ~~ ~---
:Im'ics, 'wWc'h WQ,uJd

--=
mason md, 'die, :rigbt, of' ,Rature'~M. 'mls ¥la," his ,~pmved, orde,r
-f'','[~~-~g_r~Jf~.... 'L,~_ -nnilt1i .:-~-,~,
nn,.JiiillO_:fo<'!li'o.:l-'bI~A'_Q~~;~~~:~_:-'
:rmIlke: e~rU~~t: 'IDe c;:[I!f:I~~n:;f' ------;p- ,.1, ..-~.. ~O",._"O,"

- ~;v
0"
;o;"""e)&ll
~~1\..it
[~~
'm~G ~iI/ :~.~ 11_.l] ~w\l~
Ci'nim.~l ~
1:1
'-.iIII,
~
:,:;
o:i' 1;
..
: ~l~
h-' i4 [~'\i!-il'~,.J -- .....:1le.._,
Bj' LtG' 't!!1 N~
[~f~'H::~~~'~:~:_:"~:':m-:~~'~' ~'~~':'~-IO~:j~;-: ,_,_)!I!";~:~ B ~'_'~'~~'mn:~~~'i ,U\lllua:_"':JiiLllH.I, ,.~~.'CIiil ._~,~_~~_,~,,,_ur ~tplent • ,thiS ~on, w,i~,be :l~,~".e :~ d.... lic; 'W~ is'baU 'pMtPOIlC untH, 'the t'blr.-d, 'part [of ,tnm 'Gba_pter a :fl!"~1 ld&cuwoR, 'of:~I60rne[of 'tiel najnF' :pftJbleftUl, 'iDlmlvc~t,A, j_;.. , in'ii'iii [n-f~·t~:1l..@ '''-n_~'I'II' I d" ~-nl=i~:n~, iiZ'iI..,£I'I"I·.m-;I :!1[1IJI'8,.l~ft,J ....[ ~IIII ID~-~_~V~_1l Ut· . li-:v,...ll_~_Wl_IJJ '. III:I:Ii_ .; rn-~I DIl:I_A: - I 'UJ~F-~~~~'UII 'ti'liAnil d 1l.. Ii. 'H'.... - .;lL , £tDl,IDIOq t~telema 'I., se to, 'w.~UCJj, 'L'iIJ..""""", 'P,lIta II~et€tDR<Pt~[ u,~'-JW~' ,ami 'dlis ,cam 'be :[oIllDd omy' :m the oonduliofta, 'w:llitfi Hobha, II_mal 'abo"l),t 'th-e ~nfttent: ,0£ • :lawa, [ai Daiw're :iu~d meir
"",,"111:1,1' ';"""~_ .. 1Ii,lI'_,
I~~~[,~.~[
The [OOflC-ept of' a 'laDw' of' Ubrr.-el is 'petmarp&, t.e~ Imo&t [d~Ii-,
_°.li.,IJ"~ ~
'£;j'i;oj; ...
-:_I;L~I
~
_I;UrVjLlIl
'ii.'i.t,i:i;,
~}-I-LJlI~.
'gc~-~-~
;0;0,
iI),.,:
'pmmcal :rel'e¥:lnee:" [nat: eonseq~.ces

nat :p81n; of' the eJmp~m'., .
'It,!;, '~~ill ,'0, ,~'_~:"'''I:iL.~, jD'-:;~'~.. Qo~Ua i , ..'
[depend
[00,
'nmt~r.iDil.d.einiltinn, [of 'tlOe: lOOm,OOcPt~,'w:hl~k'we leibatl state
,r.
'.e
'iI1h;e:
p\~g
1-:-'';'-'--,
:~a:lf, :,~pt Ol' pD,t'rai :Nk]'~:(~uhi.foot by :HlIIOH;il b,,' wrum 'iI, ~ b ,rodddd~ ,to ,ao ,tlhlftjl wWCh, ii, d\cdN,ctllvl of :IUJ 'l'i'[!:J.1 or tJiklt.h, away' dlC m9llli '0:1' :preae".llli' me: :s.a.1B;; and '~Q
,A,:tAW
[0" Hilc\mMJ', h
v:I_~~_"J!lil
:L,.
~. '~, UI '~~~"-'jb. ,01;,1-.1~'''' ,~;:::£'';i~;~;.:, ,[;;,' W[llln, u~ uemD'bOD,,.,
~i'.'
~-:-~.'. :~."",.;Ii..~#;'1:- ~h'i~I '~'~=:iIli"~· t'~, h ... ~~ 1-_1l"I!_gl-[I! ~,.1 _L::IiIJr~_'_'J ' Iij ~-~-~{d~~~·~-I-I
ift'Ii"'V' '~ ... ~--'; f~~J lYe, l~~
Ip.:~i!Ii~~,.
I.
~'~-~"!I!'~_~'
liii'iE'!.'IiI~_ '·I~·I:t ~G;i@i"~' ,~~,.
Lr,r- '1 '!I::I:~I~"Ji'~'['1'/1

'••
liii.JII."!'~' , __ A ,.,"
Ueg,Yl.iII~,
·~·f'~· lB, 'iI::jL~ ,~ ,,'~ ~~A0., 1r"' .....J' IUIB: WDF;tu ~~,
l\tfOIB.A,L T'UJEOll,'1"
,i,,'l.atJ,
,tJBn;p~1
(::ilhid~,)~ 'Tbisl aCOOuR't

-"'
b-,~'~'~"'bi c-ftmfMftdetlD 1~"~'J 'r:II_J_(,~~~I_I~~~~ ~~ ~~~~--,I_i, Mil

'_~_~I
'"
:IUJ-IFS"t!;0, ,a]ltunaU'VIi' 'lqmJ_tVli:1"'1
:ie:~:: 1!:I\a,w ,of n.ature:tl
~command,d,e~iv,ered, :m, 'th,e 'wurd ,of 'GOdJ~l~
[b:d 'tblS:,.~11IJ!rHt~'le 'will ,.ee:t dl,e' Irst [o;~jtcti~g;:; Y' G,od. 'COIDMIad!s by' :ril-ht~, 'the» iI:is, eom_aDds, are pfoperl,' :ta,,"I.,
,A, :.UusessnKD!t of' 'these objecltimmSi 'w:iI be pos;t,pone~:t Bg,t i!t: is pos&iJb],e' 'to 'p~llJt :a'o ~ni,tlalde(e:llCf; of' ,d~itit)n by loo:uidtrim:1 'the ,f~n :passap ,from, ,",'bie'h 'we: ha¥e qnol'ld, 'tke'two uarpls u~pKBSiiDI',tbe: ,obj:ectlOI1lS", It ,Rads::
,0."
'T,~' dl(ctaw, 'Bf :feMOD:. m~-tl, u~Rd to, call by ,the :1iIi8l1UJ of :la,W8~,btlit im~'NJed;)!': :mr' :lhey',Irel 'but mlI!KIJU.l.iO'Jl'l~, till.fenll (i(f mnm~j~1 w~1m: ,m:m;ducelh,,to the ~o:n.RLn"'Sti~:A I~d, dief9cc 'ff 't_b'cmHl¥a,;', W;b~M;!lll,"~, pmper~y:~I'lM '~.1-d I~fbiroJ, di.a!~ dg:tl!t, :br_athI~~~ I by '~¥ef:' [Mhos., :iB14t. )I'm H ~' M_.f~r' b lBamt:: ,th~t'-ems!,g, Id~tjYfiM~ lOI'tJ'he:'WOJ:d, [G:f (Jod~'cIW:, by'qiht _m.and.h[ 1):1 ,tbjqs j, :lbenl ,1M tlr!'o¥ :~r:~' atI~ faM" (,Ibi~jt,)
- "~ ~ ~ ~ - ~~" ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~...Jt......., ~ ~ "''''tilt I'~" - 'I T11.·::.... passa:ge 'SUIICS.:D \~'~" t IB, w:aJrrQ~,UJZ~ 'Wl~. ,gur ~.rilll~~ , ,1M, [defi.itIO:R; '(_me law,s of ,naluJle" as, ~_Dtf-odumW 'hy :Hokb.~ ~lR :not laWS,., Ine rseGUDJd defiBiltiOB 'm 'baed Oil:, ,m m!tmnati,ve WI,' Af: oiIi;:L~ p~,'~'p-iiD iDlndj 'fM'ilin ,,,,;'11..(= .... 'p1~"'~inll" ilfliIf: '''/.:·''w ,.1I.lI!I'" ; .~. 'v., m~ '.iJ!,"'w cl..!..~,~~~", [~IHI1U.'!il ~.'~Ii.,
hi
;jj:.it.. ... ,jii~-~~"" '~'1" '-~
~ ..'
I."'~ "~,
::~:.
"~.
~ .•
.:,
'_l
,~,
;'.'!iOQ'j,
-
~",2__,
V, .''',
~';'c,'
:H,flb'IH8~:s,:iiftlda1l :ICQlUDt", then

a 'UJe:r;PJl!lbnm:
..J
I
-"--;~~;~,,.-_:; '~,....,::--~,DiU.~ '''f?-,~.''-' ';_ PI\ .."""""1I"'--- R_!Fe :M:'W'S., '~f'~~' n our
c..... ~
'tt,'wad, 'be: :mmta1keD :[or' it 'to '1M!
:~d[l[i")~:, UJ. _AlluO,D[I
:!'I II
'~F,-;
~u
~""'"': lUI;
'iIf"'"''''~~: ~,
Ie; Q,I),
The: 'quetl,ti;on, ,then, .i. 'whi~. of' dle8e 'tlYO[ '~,JSI ,of ,1OO___~_g' ,lIjt~ 'tile: :kws O'f :Da)tUJ-e is 'ba8i~ 'to ,H,ob':bes,i'. moml, 'diooliY:i T,Ida, qUe81tiriD '(3I1l, 'he: :sett1ed, [on'l, b,' CQD8id~g' dte~mAlmt, 0,1' 'Wl '~'JkmlJ""'b1ll,1; we, ;eihall :ftad, 'that tille, '1m: wa;,' :pltO¥eI bali~~~
,n.J~U .~.
.1iIIi. -~
'0.' ~,.,
t!: .ir~
'-'," ,'/,~, WC-""

'I'. ~
'''ib~'a,~~"';~;I "'rilliiift"~'11i-~ ~ ~~ ~ t'A~-~.~I' ..l' - £:-... ~'. 'II ~ ' 'iI,Q 'WliJl, J'~Ul;y' '01!JE' ,1IlN.i:nna , 'ueJl!lilll.,]l'Om~
'iI¥Ii;!i'liV ,I'_ .... ~~
'hliI'lOH'~ili" -[
,I
}!Ll'll'I""'"It'IIlid"if
'n--''''
,t"';Ii.'1.'.a!~i ••niJ.,
~~. '~I;
"
..1
..
id ~I'Ii;DiI"';_ ~UD.
."",[IIIi!li.i[:v.ll.
~,~~~'li!iG!:
'I'
h"' ~,A~~·I .
:IU,PPOd[of '0lB" ,!biro 'dial, ~Hobbel~isl :lmt dei-doll ~is'hule~ 'The :iat :is, taken, ,f[om, :hIs, eM,er' of ex~iti1>R;o 'Tile: :6mt [r--~~ d~ti.u., :RfVe8, '1,0 :iinb'oduce tbe lcom.eep,t:~!, :Rob'bes, 'theJil PlIO-I
[d•I~-l~[1~' 'O"'~' . ,.,~~Je, ,their [CG:nlelllt, fuJ~" OR. ,tbe !bum of :~.
~I
'"-'~IC,
,m
'I'
~--:-.
~ ....1i""'"
'i"r [~~,~-~'I\i::o"~ II.IQ Ui.'!Iiii,,,eILv,,,,

~
,111~""","J"nn,~
'~~'i:i[
",11-..-,
,~,WS ,-:;~" 'i'i'i'i"I,ib-i"f[".-. UIl: ,iI!.... ~~~:Ii

'~~""'~~,~:
I""'~~~~['" .
,;;!I!~",,~~il;a;
~I
~(Lr
'whm 'be: :Itas, ,completed :bill esp08iaon does, :hJc: :intrudIU" dae
ilmtftldtl:ctinD~, 'Oftl:.,,? ~ ..
dJ:o ,tlHolJ'~ :(0, 'the: leW.d, ,.. Hu'b'bul ,eq,lIa~es :hg, [orife,' 01' [expDOOJ isilla. 'w,ilh, ~e ~'~iU1D_PO~, ,om. 1m: 'wbi:llh BIiTIi, :.38 '~.~' '~.
'U~·'~ '1l~41iili!n~4t)'i;j~d,' , __,~U~L",gUU_iL,
'f,'!'Ij...a;
wb~·h:'. he ,d·\tAn,.l-1 ,~olU;'ni,';"'.:Ii_!LII!" ... ;if ~~,oii.l.l_~ :R,£a~m;ll" ~'L'iIIi '1·~~~-;LAnl'8 nLii-+.j'_'Il!iill! 'L,. ".' '_ . ,~_I:'; C.b~i'..","iIi''''''_~Jua ,,,U~', '.UIilI,uit.'" : J 'uUJ~UIJlII.ali' ,lli.llli!' N:J9": '''1 'Iho~"t,it :itDat :iin, 'Ib' :last : [o~ee :f~r',aI~1 ~say _ duty 'weM'.c bws afllGmJ~ 'w:hIn, 'w_ Id~li~"erid!' ~IA,
[LlII!]L.....
'~[a'~']id! ~ ~ 11:. ,'nii:llJ "'11!1
'ii'fi;~~iii~
,iI,",,!I!o-'lIi,"!!Ii;"~
'1["'1 '1kr."",!,At .. __ l.e.lli, ,IDa ,.l1H01,~,1'
4J.n[
_
Ike: wHd, [of' 'G,oo,:;,b.mil bc(u~

th~Rp)' b·L,.,•., ,i;;\'i!..eir '.'0:11111;, AtHi'iiIi _~~'I~': iI~"; 10< ..'
'.0, , '.ma
Dot b;,Qw., '~,

,;iIi't!...v
'waPA _"';j,'>'~:1'",",
p_. m.y'
:~llJtIII;QlJ ~';:n, "I',_ .,.,._.. .,
,iii 1.'111,
min, :f&r:m,'
,.jL'~~iiiiil
'ii!\'Iill~hlilll--'1 , ..... OAn ,ilil\.,\iulai , ~.iliil!;, ..
'i.e.'ift··
lUg ~ IUlL~.Ji,~"'IiMJ';Ii'
teR,d~n~to Lr'~~' '~ai

~:~J
~~i!"Ii1iii
~~"""'"i'
,.f···~'u;~-rj·~·~"I,jB~1 ~l!'Iiir'~ ,~~'i\'Ii'fI!tr..... an~I;:"':=·~;·1 nrlL~;·nAIl'mra:--iV' IS'~~, :t,~: ~_, ,11I""",O,~ ~ '~'::'@'"",,"L~ru, J_iliY~~, r~H~iIlI~~~"";r~1I!~,~ '~
'm'll
,ntm
~"'_dlig~_"v.....
~'fIi;l:=~j~
wa, out
l~fl v,
,
[~'E,.,;W..- :'Vi*, ~Ijj _ lr"r

iIIU~i&g
2[~:~1~~~~ tliiJlQe: U1r [~I
dte: 'vilele:
,WIl"",
D,UU=
r..,;L"'[",W,
of' 'llRe:war [of' aU
to,f' hia, ,pm~~'~ AI,d, :m the th.rd 'p'la~~, if B:Oh'ba, dtOII_1 that: 'the •• ad, dminitiGR, 'was, batie, he: w·ould, '1;I!~1"Y'haYi: gi:ven, lea.l, ,alll.tlon, 'm :Iihowbtg, Itat tim laws of aaturee am 'me:
l
:U,ob!bu 'tlita ,t'be :I.t, ,d~ltion, 'ta[ be '''RtiaJ~ adl t'be :~nd, de6lliJiuD, '10 'be :indad, ,accoltdary[il ;and, not, leqilllmd
~~. Ir~;t
il~tt: '18"1 ~I-,'~Ii:~, ~",~~ ...JI" lIi~,"",liiliili, 1""'1f'~Gl ,lI.r~~""" ;il!fftt;': '~~I ,_'~'_.. :iIU'.'ii'!JIi'if"" ,~~~i,d,~ l~iI!~ 'ngjUi1i~j
,ftpit&t
ralJ :Ifld, i~.'tie

,jjj'iI;.c .....
""IiUII ..
J,
lOODUUB,~
..J\.., .....~
bIml ,_~vm;~1~-.~..;11..,... ' 'Ia~ :0011, 'i~UI!t -~',>_i'!~~

:SM: in, Chap_
thac' lIke' 'laws, ------, -~- '-'-- -
dle :laWl" 0.1 :u'w're are eoatained, 'HI Std,,mrre,., 80 thaI: hel MA,' mat, :rol_prQ, Obj~ectiOO8 '1:0':mll t'l'eor.y,~ BUlt 'chis :sb.wa .1~J'
'-bL'UJr,' 'uOO~ 1I."IOw' ,pO ~,~

iiii""" ..... .l, lIii.:'m' 'U'
g,OM '~
..:I
;iI;,_JL.,...
ill. pMU teD' IlllflW'

Iii
:.d_,
'--, ,as
.;L .... ~ ..... in.cI
,Q" ',nall'U_['C ~~, -,~ [.-~~H~,,:~Be

"fj;JIi2iq'
'l'~
'~'~·:·di ,mB :C·.·.•··.t;.j..J ....':~·'·i-, '~':' IJtIDJ_mc_~~,·_~UibaU

.~ _'I!
.,11..
'V"e.b';ba, baa, DOl 8'lJUmcBtI ,im, ,11!I:ppod, of 'me ,c'llIim, '~~~at :IBWi of nam. fiN :IUJtuml1,' dlu',eRd, II ea"'-I 'At, :manO, ,of [Gmt 'Wi: :ma, lsugpat '6e; 1,,10.1' ooAct.ioB .. If oar' '."1111 ,
MnitiDD -,of ~1~faW'01' ' 'mUta'len .boun 'w'L.~> '~-l '. _~ ~~~_~_ _I:'j~ ,~[t ,IS ~
.~•• .-._ I •• -._
,arc,
DIU_IlI.
b - '1 ~ , -.~. ~L._.'n, L~~WI'i' .1'0 ~act~, ,UI WG :rlJl~
&D;P"'
,_(;~i\.)\.,
'~_"L
.J
1_
'j
••
' __
>
,aM '1:0 ,r i/r" tbe~r'Mle '~:la~1' :
'MIDR 'miIbJk~a -:Ii] ._. " 'Y:cJb'bal :h, .:____., i',~~':IT'ind ,Rq8 " :T'f,';'h~~~ UL '0-4fi'1i~·,:.:: rfi' 'i;i~~1 __ 0, C.e 'Il"';-~-'If'': JlaI!Ju_r'C ~-" I~~J ,.M
1 __
-,.r.
,._
m,'_._"
,.
.-_-
'men
.~!II!II'
,.,_'_,1_.-,
__ .•
I.
in bia,••
Nj~, :Ind '~I'iai~, ,s~I~.~ T\bJ [r'~-
'ist
_'
,pr~"_'.'~
'i'-iil'O';-'::R"il, 'jI'Lc '~'~E,·:O',:I!i!"-';I''' ~"~ IIJI,~-~_ , "_",ftl I
',.'
~.~J
',n., , ;
:mistake:D~
~ mn'~r~
[of ,coune~ [r·~ '~~bl~~ Bot we &haJJ~ :sbow' 'thlt, H~bb.· is[
:1.9t
'W.. :luml ~u'r ,"ol,ma], a~u'[lt; ,of' I, :lJaw' of :UtllRl 'we :s!hould [coui,cmr.~ 'ljrid, the foma,l re.tbJ1Uli,p ktw,HD,
'h;;-' ~ ,'i~""h!ii--'
'. E nd !t;ik"" 1""" ,.:i .: 'f';i;'L ~~,_g)~: :~JgY:rle :au'" 'I,,~~m,M, '!llll, :na",~m_• .n1IlilM 'iYilC .J~ ... OJ): here a d,IRClli~lY'imtmda~. 'Glve.ft our :(nf1nm'~ .defi'l'IIition8~,it wou~d Hera ·tbat. tike 'k:wa : of M!m-e are· 'preeepa _:truetiQI' ·us in '~'b~e: cx-c~ ,(tf 'thel 'rillt of' 'biJtu[~ [That is we 'may" no w'~mer amams witb
,~.......
'.C
ired ~. .~,,~, 'Hence ,actin.' [DB die", ·taws. ,of' "'" ,,~' :"1' '.". , , ,"', , , . ~"\~ ',' ., ,,' , ... " ":naNre: is .actta~:~Ihd", ,~efC.ml tilt! riI;bit of D.ltu_r.~ but:iln ·thOle 8~ial( clr.cunu:tao£a in 'whioh, iacd_g' 'otHrwise: 'would
" ,!dl 1a.I(MI" Wl~
hl'c't '=. __ ....,~~,
~~;' ~~ ...~',.~ .. ",. ~

_ill", ''.m, '~[i .. ~-,~
.~~ ;"~.;;~fl1J.~
be :amt.ii~l:WmD,lly.~
:PurdmlR'dlrc), b: :laws, Qf' :natmm 'woul!d. IilDt tbmBltl~fJSJ bn__pose: ·iknltarti.0D8 'Oil, IRe :rigbt of' Dam·m',.. lB. 'I~I~~I' 'U 'w:llmt: gl :mdQmatl~1nquiRd~,'they wuuld se"e~dle U'smw: role of 0:.'"
~J, .-.-.='
~A~· ....a... =v ....'iv· I~V [~~, :t~-~ a~m ...~l ...,.....,.."""Ln'L,jUfl.,~l~ __1l 0·,'1[' ,~ ..1l.., ~*A;1Ii UD_l.!_~1 u' _ '~.V~~l [mjl~~lW:,~}GI;~.' 'lrA ,iIi_ 'I~'B ·~~~._-".~I~_~ 1~·lj..i;::'!H7'..._'0 m---:.._[ ~"",,,.',,,~, ,"tlL., ~LiIi;l!1i c "",[ I, ,;Ii_'Ii.U.I,'....,. lUlu c· ,~it..A'J'c· '!dJI'O--:-1iii;~ld,' "_,,.v" ·u~~ .. [L'ii'iiit;' IUil",,;, P !!IiIIill." W .-*_i:a<lli, Ub.~;,;Pll' ,-;~,t> :nf' lII'iIIA'th"¥
'Chat .,.blt in prili1,eipl~!,

Ptlt
l~~11
n~.""~~
,1 __
~~Q'~~I
~Int. 'Utlll_f~lrimLdtCly:,1 'w:bat H:ob:bc8; sa;Pi :m .f8 dUff' Mere-nJt

l
~Ih;
""' ...
~J
.il'...... ,
,,,.l'!---'iIl..;j.
.~
.AI ~~
[' ••
~'lImt:
jl~ I~[~~I
'UR c~.· a:pcD ,of' fml :.~·bJed,~ 'to ,QmfQuM"jJa~, :Md, ','i_ ·R""I"""'.'~
·ii7k~--.'~II];~ rI_l~lIJ~'
''C ,,' .... ,,-,
l~
L""" [g~~_~I~I_la.iIl~t. A~ .. ~Ii'iIO'i!ijliil'L...AI~ 'il............ UG

'fI'&,W:;-';',
,iW"I;.,.
,~c-~~~I1!.1 ~1I1;Il""l;ni
~- '1"I,",b~~. ,,'0 ~''il"L !liQ "uc;: .•"..~' ~-::-I t1,'!o'lII,

'ii"", ,iilIii ...
1Ii-~ .~~_~~
[.,'b'Rptil)n~,and, U}~;
rtJiI.t..
" "
:lft~1 ~~r,;,~_"~ ' __~_Ir~ :1iIt'_~_~~~~J!:~J

'/i':E'-[
ift~
~-I
1,. .. In' ';' !l1!I~.,'" .Cl
[1"1'
·.b~,: ~, 'ii!"~:""~ 1~IW" ~ai~ft .d'ili:d'.I1!'· ,idHIi, ~g.~'iL" 1!J,," ;__ 1._ .'.~~ ~'~I:f.J_'~ ,~~~~,~, ~ Ig_1 ·w.hJ,~h. on.l! and, ,the PAle; maltier ue i\geogg!O' :illl
~._~I~~~, ~ ~~,~~ .d!iI!ii,ii ~_I-g, L'_I_',.
j
1
'l!;I!\l.
~iI:"
,~,~,
I,,,,,,
.t'h~d.~r~~r>~' 'w1b.~~~~; ,I'-"'(~,.~ ""ri~
_I
it!.
4~~~:~ilJ.L, !Ii.iII."~,iI'''':U'I'IIII~:t:Pi1i'
,,'.'OJ
:!'r:17:~'
~ . ' 'iN;
'PaIU,pa .BlIJIUt ,the (u:llowil'ljI' Idoctrimut. To, ,Imn;t ,;rway 'oBe:~:I'.rig'hl: '1:0, ~PI'dorm,,80:[fll ;_Qn~" or 'to possess' IMme: ~
[n'Ir,li~I'~:I-!iD:ID"~)I ,,iI;L'3'" ~'!iJi'~;r' uUl iIJ~-~_au"'U"J : .__I 'U~I ,Ii. ':.-~~-~l __
=:=-one~~ed.. ::~':!:a '::; e:

[object:;, lB,
'to
l
u~ndatal:e
;a.
o'bUaadoll
flD! to'
:pedtUnfll, that:
I iIIl
J
AU 'o'b9ti,omli. 'rdt9.., 3:Hl' KlI~,iMposed.. T,nne :ne nOI , ,'tuw ~ltlr~ f ~~~ ~ W""U~:.L!ImIi_:.'.' ~~ "t~,~,---'II" " :nl,.: _:"'~;,"II , o,"_~~I!PLlg_~, miD 'te ~ '01~'L, D_a~m~~,,'" '1:....... ~,I, ~ue: aJiI:: WI., ·n:IQ:.::o, DOl,.h:Ip:W!u, loutBide the area Ql the: ,ript: of' :DiWIJ:; if on;,C, has, ian, ,~h:lip'mR,:ut '10 do .me actinm, then,'previo,uly' 0ldJ: bad, a, :Uituai .riabt: ·to ldo 'C'hM :_0Ri, "
rw.tBc_ _;iB
'WJ-il' 'IUJJ~.~VII __I ;.. ~~ [N:~_~-o.w·';IJ~: Hi'L:v jL:ll~I<~iti~ ~MiIi ·i!n'lil~~1 .,r~jM:lj ,.••
·a qJ),Mtioa,
faD,,' 'wi,tIUa 'dlc' IllitmaJ,
n'i_nli ~c~""* :l.l~:I.~~:~, ,&L~_M~"_~!L.,
.;L.: 'ID~-' •
pad [of
'lib ..... ", " '~.: 'UiIj] .. .~~_ ~'.~
~A'
"·t· ,'"' '_' mil n~~~:al,-v. .···n X"Ii-'Ii _"I.~ h' ....n. d'¥ .... [~ . '. ';~.
-.. & :0.. ~I:il
'0;
J '_',' '~
~ :3!ft ·0b·itt'-bon ~111'·' ~__~._ -'-'_.~D"'!""!'!"!I_._'~'~.II _~.
~A- ~w,wu. ..Jlt... · .. II.. not. ,to d~ 'X"" .= '~" iL __ 'I·_~.:I, uu,wn "OiLe o,<'~
-~~. ~ ._"~. _
I.~. '~_'
__
r •••
-"
.~._l
__
-,.
:·pr.omiM-;kapm.l,o'b~ipmry'r" .And:lo.vlt:e· (h.e quatbntm. ,e'Wb;,'be '.1' ·tbII· .... G-nt:w((uld simplY' the ill 'In thiS _usl
;a'll5w;~r
'P"~:~'~I!i'p' '.r.-,,,,.:I'Ii'l!'~'. b~•.. "'I~. '~'~S~IIII~ ,.,'~;~ ·t'tr~ ; ~.. .~~,,_.J~ iII"lm".. u
'J'~ ,~"'" _'W
'~:&cauepmmlllttgis ',u.ttlmg 'on~$i'lfuodu If('bruipllon.~I!! T.hc:

iI! ~1,iL ~~_IIi,iI!I!!Ii~.'"
:Q'iIli,"f"'ii"·d: I_·~ft: ',iIi!.~,!l,!lill~ OlI!!UIJ!lL , .~u, :'fo', "i"l ;ii;L~ pl"'3':~~-~ ~.;._ ,rl~,
,.I,",£~.:."..;::;i!!i,~ II: u~tlum'W,V'il_"~1
D_md,:iIldepe;ndtDt ,of our' :IClts of :pmumc;f 'we :.uat ha¥c the 'tf!«J~"1"b11ob~ip ,o1Jael.'e8,. ~r", "~~ ]'tI;t, .IS :IIJi)t :"'-' '-I:{', m~ 0 ~,~fi;· : "'I~~ .' l,"\ II I', iIt'~_~) '". '.,,,' I, , "', o·-·~,,:, } JL .JJ_~JS ca__paa""J i' " ':'I:~ ~me.,. j~~tlo:n~ ,. ~.c Clli. 'UJ_ftllli. men ma. 'Obl~~: .ems::I~CI§' :b·l1' L:. \rom&o;:-;CiC~'U ROt ,II.,", _ . 't'tl:l poTm.d ' '~lYlf' -_ '_ , ..D., . .... . - ..1A5''!Iii! .~, ,v ',/1 . lElI . of anv' ,old~:imt;~r'llw'il~fjJj~ve~~OD:l~ an~d ,of' p',,-;:.I_~~I!·n~' :lU, ,.r~, ":gi ,,' a,.. ,., fU ,11.",g, \~i'~~1 WI, :pfOduee an. attu~d.obl~pjtion., :S:iurri;la'r):y'" :Hdbba MiU$,tiUP:po8e 'that MeR .[ha~I·.C capacity,
't-OI
I ;.' '.'
We' :81hnu'[~. Dote 'that. 'priO!'
,'I '....:' h'
t,
p-;"
0000
o'
•••
.,'
':~
"_~j_
000
'0
.,'
,,Co
dUlt iSli to cmnt iaway mrtarl_n of' ·~.mr.' :rlIBb\j' W:e ahd~. see laeer 'I'h;w!t, 't'b_m :s'W(p'position, ([-altUI r;miJ] 'nmbfmm [ . ~V1e:D ,r" ."'_. .------' ('or.' 'I)'fihh.· [!:if" ... _. his, .,.~~~wei' the 'DIr_m IQf. &8'11 VII,... ~ .1".: it. does, :no,t, ft:VeM amIy' j:madeq.uaq' ..... ltD· amual dmniition'i 'llli:fC: mJ' .h'0!we1Ie.r:.ome :posIlble ;Radeq,uacy :~o~ dmlJlbi.on; ,tbe:
'm ooUgc themse'~~;,
."L.
I _
t.
...
"'.
.."L
I.
.-. _
I.
_.
.•
~,
~J
mL.·~:...,;:L ~""A, "·I~I_II~~.In~l.~ l
'm---'1'16J; 'k~'-m:v '~'~'i'!.'~li:Ii~:~';i!i'" ·~}.o-ft~·~ I:: !!Ii.I_Ii:f'-1 'lJt~'ll.e-'~Jl[/· ~-IL&..:I!{~U~~ll~' [~Ulr,r~J
~.iifi'-'-M~oi!ioiil la. 'i'1R~,fi ,IL~I_lL~-m_.::.}'ii~'~ [.~.~I_g_.~Ii,
[III]
01
.ri!)lJt, 'but dlJe81 8D lcon,if,,,,' 'to :r'~lblt:[1ea8DII .. :D·0t81 .Rethereb, :pUiIlt :~~f' un.der ob:l~pltLOD ~hba, IlUl:N'er ,wuidefS -dds, que&tiofl., .fg(f' bis· concern is 'wi~ ;siim_lilmm io cwhlcll1 m~Jl haJ.\,·e: :r-eMOLR '!Co RQlO1!!lftCC: th.elr .rights" BUit. ~if weR' tD' SUJppose 'that. be 'would lJi:vc ·1,:n~ti,ve ·we· ih. ·11.... ··'.;iI1 ~ ..n',,," f: IilUlS\¥U~, IUBtI~l: '1illtilt ;a. '\\';mnl~,Oll M'~_O.I (IOWA '0[: :F:I.i9:lit: 'Will O_' no, efttet~ 'fnen lour' CO'R'le:XIJUld defiDittioo. should. .read::
,'l
,II
,.,
t;
.~
liI li;A'-",Jas _. 1001U',!I!II~lw~,_;':' IL', .- ''_O . 'X•.':: '-b·'·, .'.'.,' 'L~I"',-.'';:0:0 . 'fI'" ~' 'd", .:::_' 'e:' ·11~~ili-:.-;~I~·;':c '~r ~JU .Ail: ,m. a,~...,.ru. .~·t· ' ' L7:' ,"-:;-,~~':...'il .iRa:!!i;~.rail!. .·b' I~U n:g",',
~\C;,
~:
;i:A""
'1..,__ , 'I'~d ,~~ Ji~1iU ,112..

"o'~
;-,:~'JIi;bl Wl"uI.
~ :h'~'~'-~ ,...-;-lI ·l".lIr,JI!I., re.asOtD ~,

l
.~l·,:· '. ~!i.... uOw:n~ln'~
;5~.·~;;·:;;;;~~ "','Fe o:r

Whr, H' we
ht .~: .~; ~ .~
tftdI;
.~: f'~: O
.~:
'"iiJ1 [!I!~'~,~
i:~llIR
,~q.w
,iLutiDal.
.~1.
W'.':f
·dbll.n;c·'~n.e~va ,. Fcn~ UIlIti_fU.nj .. ~

:~ :~.
b)
UIC .~~
Juri,'
the, ·c;i:bt.~~
a~.nl.
~I'},Io~ ' .o
- -I~·.' ~._
,- :c... ~1,,"i~.iGl _lil.--V,IH&a L.,:,::_. ~ - --~-
'~~I"J
.,
'1Uscd"
.~ ~-_.__.~
l'~' ", I'. ~ ~-
~II"); _,I;a ,~ I.. ~ _. ~
I,'. '. Jw-" , D--: .....
. ~·.·~I .~..I~~ .~ / __
'0' ~"".,
.. ;
iI! .',
.~
~ ~M" ~~.
I ,'.~
__ :!!I ','.:.'...
..
'L"
~.
~
~ ......
_ .
~' ,~
...
- ....
' ',.,. ......
~ ......
' .. _.'
,-,
~_~~
11,1;,- ,.
~_ .1..
~" ...... ",-, ,'.' !Mil!'! .. _ .. -
"
__ ,'
:'[' iii
(b:""
",'.: -~_.~~.
Il~Ord~1 ·1ii1i'!liiC:.1C'
l'_~l
'~'''~~\~l
lr-'''I!
-1-' 'n ID'

[I~ -
_:!II!]
H,o.bbes'~9,8:tat~mellt,t;t ~1!h,edeinllJtiiom, ,of
'~Djust"is iwt' [('B,;W" i~;[I' , :1,3'1), p '1'hm gives ~I ,the. 'equ:i,vajlmee',:

'I,X is, B, Just ,act" ,-- ?[ dwca not:
o~1~1~~~.fl'rll"lil.' ~ _ JJl II_::~1r. II
~·!If.·~-~~-. __
than ,tile
:nt;J." ,fJtd~'
'~f ,~'i;,.
And 'wba~.'
LNl]USII:CB,r;.. :g: D'e' odJ.
:m :80'1:
~il,Yohrt:thoe :1,0,1,
p«i~~
-:X, bt
:8.,
jiu8t Qd:" =, '~X,dees
DOtt,
invu:lve the, breald~I'[of'
mveftlAl,~
l~
.>IIiiCi,
[mdlnL, :BuJt 0" natu"." um:ltke: i,ta

'~-~'r":~~U~.:~ .Q='Ui~;r·~-.l"I~
J~'~jI'~t
l!;;I'g",l.~
I~:~~!~:.)" ~.lju.w,~iI![ ..
'~.,t_'_~i.:~n, '~~~~~·d,'.njt:, .w'

=
and :its [mnm.eci:"loll. ·with. J -~ -~~ :isl ..-d...... '!uti~ .~ ~~ ..-I w:hart IS ,of i'll!!tf:crnt t'O us' :Ilefe D, tim: 'dda, 'rdUDJ,
,.-~ - -,--- - -- -,. - -~-
:[e[1oW8jl
J
I~f'
~
1
: ~~~,,~f~~I,~f~,~~,"~~~,,'~or iQ@:,ill'"' I~~_,_,. _ il' '~~c~;~~~~ ~~~ H"'~'b~ bi"',11!"~ ~. 1~!ljP:: ,1,_, .'. '.' = _'_'.~~I'I~;~j;, '~h~t'~~:~';l~~'i1
l"
llaa :1,DlBkriaJI, :in!t-C!premtioo,1 of' [cou'me" W:hl£-L W~ iBllJa'U, be co;DSidtring' :in, tJ.Ie ~l1ext :pm: 0," ,tha [chIcP,t.~, 'The 'f-o;r;ma~ in1llerpi[[ertation is sWD,ested 'b 'rtDe d\elcn'cc
" ,', "iV~ "'~
=Hi :,T·Iji;'LI~'¥,~I;i:I!1DR:"f:i'i!i'b~tnQV _,uDD~~ 1t~:I~ul~I~[~J

.~
:18 ,give•. ,I,

Q
',um"
~~,
:fwu];'I,
'[ .1'': 1 1!Ii
I ·~ ''!'[ ... ..
~[WII!.!'!!I.'1i~,
.~ "iii! _ "","~~~l!l;lO;
'10, ,au' thin., It-mMoifllg;. we ;a't'e: :1tI1, ,m 'the' matiinDD, ,of 'WIll"
~~_~J ' __ ~
,~~~ 'm"'--:-I 'i'.fJIlII-I/.·'Il1Ii,--;;II~ ,;i:I;~'--:l1'~:ii:"'~'""!m':;'p-;:'~' ~J$ ·~~,~.t"!iPr41"['~1 llIIUl ,~;I,.'iIii; .!I!"~J~Hlt""l u~ :a' ';1':1" :a'Ii!f'i,~1 l"l'~ iii'~_L,!,!, ~ .if __~.~ ' I l!Jl"'_~;jI1 ~l.Ul 'R'W;~~"
1j1_1". '-'
~;
'me~ .-H
,:~_. _Y.II,.'''
'b" :',:. ·A/'", '~" ": ;-it~:111 ...:~~. '~f: "'", " : .!I)_wt'!i .. e'en lRiauC: .. "". OOVeJiBDt. ,II Vi_lu, QU.I:1 ,I, ~!t, 'tmmd~18 :QlbbJI 'but ,it tm'ufem, :ri:I~blold, :if 'tbe'~partiea [amAfI,t~ RSUM1!: 't1lm, :rig'bts at their p:[euu:m·... ,b,t, :partln, ,caRRot mUlDe! T 'du~ir :Qsbltl Of.~J if they ;Rre'~b:I:~.d, 'tD\il 'but: ,t~:J ,Rei [QD:IJWed, not,
,,:-Ilr'd,~ CByamm~J •. ,['.'... " ,,'".' ~ "_1,
[I~' ~",", ... , [I' : 11["
't1meB ,-__I'--_.,'--
[~"".: ~.-~ U,lllltsa ,-,' r . '~'''''' ("~Ib~"i""")' !Jlilih, 18J" .[:1,....;1::, .men.ec~1H ;i;i'\-,~~--;;-;-~~}IV,.-,,'~I~: ::I'~:.r~ ,!,I.. UJl:eJDK-J~~es I~Ouc Q;u.lI:5~ ~, dlroK 'WiVeooots 't-o :periflRft 'wla!t: they b.a¥c oov NmntdI"
~I .~ ~"."~>~,-~~; _; [,;I.,v'
A.n U:;UlI!. ';L\:I~L__;, .. ....... ·11 tll"'!"ljns·le··· r _
V~,
Af· 'fII'iI\D~1i, ,lliUI! ,aot::a1;.,t, ~"'I'"

r.~' .. ,::,
, .....
W1Iio~iI:,
11._, 'in'l:a"~' .IF"

'~11
,! '.,
,III .. U
'111'1",'.;1;
. .Iil",,:ai~~
~oiOI_[i'!ig,
.....•
mii'ili
~\iI[
:ROt. WI [Ojl~Y
,~r' are so',ub:lised IIR~:Y

J
'li':Iilnzt1!~_i!I(ft'if' ':t'\-..~''''~~~ [_.I[e.!,J._~:iJ_.I~.~.J~, ilJ.G.H~U1V.-.IJ.[ ..- -.-...
j'joiililf' l
Yul ]
'iiiji''''I'@iiI!i!i''
...
I ~-"'
iJl
'~"'"''''''''iI II.'-~[~
by' the uo~etmDt..,Htn,co 'dds,

'~m"'~1 ,.o:,lt... 'n....-,lIil!iii\n'IAJ I iWII.~i ~"-,I-~'~
-! _'
,thll, HdiO:I)~1tba1;:~ovmmnts [o:bUp Il~'ril,,~,
lr'_
'l;~_~~' ,rfiO'f:' pa" ':n'l'~l U" ~ _
ITWa, ,CfjRel_da ·OUf' [~ltloll, 'oftle fomaal d_tiDfiS, [Df' Hul/bel1'l m(u'a'~ comcepu'O, J~f' oU:1" definidmma :PiRJVlC' ,ncmpitLg'~
,[~md 'lfuID'Rf:. 'But

''''''fj''''"'.' ....
-e-
,-:;:",;;:,-'j¥',
CDI1.,_
c,_
,D"b·,,·'it .... ,.LAM 'iIIU~ 1A.' '~-iJ I~Jlll-~-~_1I
~""'!llii'a, ;aili'iIi~~-~'''''..i ,I~UI,"Q~;!I&~_~_~~
'~I''D 8.I1~·"IUl~ ,;;;'il-a"j, ,~,_~.o;'b·'~.i~J ..... -,l!...cft,fiji1l':ll,p lll._r~.· 11, 'H':::·' 'iIl..
_!_
I]
Ji~ '!i'ftiAi .. ...'1 ~, '~J ,!I;~II~

"I'-,C",A~Ii-:-
;;~I' I.Ri iIlnu~=,,_,~, all L"",:. 'I' '1;-;'1leqt1:'.of:o'fi

'."J'" , ....
[a1Dions, ant b_ ,da,wn, fmm, tllJe d.efinitioMI we havle 19ivm'lt 'Hflo'ba's mom)] aad 'polidcal doctrines are mdaiDlty' DDt [ I" J: c"I~1 .":I::['·,~",':,·· "~>.],,[I .[:~~G-;I ~•. 'I·•• ';~Ii';i,1 ;~.~,~: mgjl~. by the OOJlC ~,P _, ._e~ed ,lleR,", To show ,bow ,aMJ'bea1 ,~. ~ Rae'htl :lds,,tollclrtlsifJDS, 'we: .list tum. to ,die :Kmimnal dmmi ....
:,: •.... ::, .,~,~':;[ ..• ,: '
Pl:JaiL" ',iJ. ,is etllual!I'v clear' thai:.o . ,,_\.I:s~.-'hI'bDtf'~~l;:'-;" e. , ,. . ." ._, . ',1: .'. ''_.' .,' _... .~. _'. . ".~_~,,,,eCOR ..,
c,·"th··"lilt WlL_Ol.lL
'[f:-''':; ;'.:;':~~ to ,IllS ='~I}(tr:cnce: ["" ~;~.
.:~~~.~'~:·,aa,i[~',;~
,l, _:
timm"
Yi~J:,
~!p" '."~~~
,oU.w' :fhlm,
"""]'_[~ .... .I. ,.~.~
:Iiuht ~t. :m 'w_mh, notm~ 'Wit certain lornla~,Qn~,u,e_nca,

[OWl.f'
,defimiltloM" ITIlese h3i~1e'beeq,

l
i~~
:pre-,
bUlt:
~n!'Jig
irmpo:rtl!nt: on.",
,~I"'Ii.'ii-m;',
l"ll~jI_I-"
it, .may be 'wonh ,eo,lecting "~er'

',,",_ i'i".f··;
:"i1"""II... ''iIIIir,Q.'~.'' .T • .1.,;.
'tile: 'moat
fi:~\-it:f';:' '~'ltiili.Ii'r~~' .A v
1 1~_I.IIIiIUJI1~"1
o ~~. ,_~l"~_~,~ 'U-~ net
~i-m:,:. 'pose''-:.'' ' .. ".-=:.' ,~~=w'~it,;ft!b·;~;iI"ii.ln., '1":"1..".' ,~.~'nl ~,~_~~l~_-fy~,~ V-Jll!~ lUI-v.
Jj
~."_
""',.",:.'.'1I.,1l.C [~ ... ,iIIO
n.e)li~~, ma,:r.e 01;

}tiil1it;'r'I~'II'W':-··'II,;:,,~
I ,logl~~y ,19'i"~~:~I~l~/
,~,-;:~', ,prKlf
.,[ ... ..0 _
:'~:I[T'tf'li;~- ·tt·~-:C·':I, ~_:.p_JJP--",
'~:CC;OrW' [I
moe 'lite n:rim.dnail end [of' a 'mati 'm, the: ~[:~ ,·:~:-~ti~~f:~;f"hm .:~~~' [ab'b:lis'btjb~',iiJJ~ft'l~~~ "raenaDD_=
mDRnJr,a!ttOD [01
'~ ,.,_~,,~~
=_
~~,:'r,"~~' ~~~~'
et)ruitvalemR:
~¥lD
~~-,~~.-~tl
~~~~,~
.~~
,~~~ ..;;,
~~~ .. ~~~~ ...
[~'A, the: :,.ht: to do X:, &.11 [j!,A, [doi.~ X~,is, eo.dltlel¥e~,to, :l1a8 A,~I['p~tiQII:'[, ..
,:II.
[~
5.
:MO':RA1;; TiH:EOR:Y
:p~tio8.,
18,De C"" wbttn, he saPI 'ma,t, '~H.cama'W:b~i a, man 'w,ouJdl~ :il, 'therela [--.s, ,good '10, :kiM, lbic;_j :.1::
,~*,,..... [~tl[-II.UIU 1_'1 ,1~~;lJ" gg-~, 'V~: -.".11" ,~',iI;IL",,,, ,'~iIV"A" ....oI:.','Il., Rr-' I_I-;, IU~,
,l'ij., ,...........
" ,,"~i~l ~jn"'l ..Jo~ '1'1 •.......'- Af"' 'iI!iIi,i"iiihl~l_ 't!n ,_""'~' •. lAIi~; •. ,iIi_~qili''''''ili' 1~~1 ~""'U_ ,iU!JI!-oj1 ,~~U U I ii:UI_1 :Ii .W r....
hi'm +~ _~, WJJlIil,~ trilmRi ,~o\Wftls his, presuwmon:. ,"'"' ,.,:if :f.l&"WlJ, ,bat ,m, '.e:
n,t\ '1'~ii:i;iilIiGit'~.I ... _~-.~~ ;:rj __
!~'~l~~l
iIi
Ii ....
l~l
'W.,
iii
.~_:~~_.
PpI'i ICFI·I:).
'the; ·FlI,bt of' :namre

p~amnn." am~d.
la:w~' .iIi!_II-, ~ ...;~ln '("HI ·1J'!.r ,"u':!\ --'_".- ~~;~'£'~r' irl, ,AWl, aetU>1l81perfoRmed .m, dliie sm.' ,of ,mm_tl 'WbIR' '
.~'Ii;
,~~_!...;,
19a.
,,:,:'__c___ji,
I' I ~I
'm ,hm :pNServa!tioD~1.Moh, 'S ,he ,hkue1f Idu't1B, 00,1;mlBide:n.dy

bClm¥~'
> "., _' _'-~:L~)l~,
l
But H~(ib'bel :seeJU, 'to ,eontdd: this hi. ,a·:foot~, DOle::: ':lu.t, :1' Ilny mara :,Htend somewh.t ·to 'IInd :~ru,
etA ~j '~, O'HeD~ .: ~_.~ '~,gV' ll.~~~,,· [~ ~_ _:___I_~_~
I~~'
BOimmediatel;" ._~.Il,
there 'ean, be
:0.01
S,
:~P,:ti.1 :(u'~l":arc; 1l1dlp" m,
08, 'tke;
oom:d.,clve t-o
:r~g't'~,
he'
d'
i 1 '~~~_~'
,.. <idL, l!;iiogiIRDUle' ._j~_-.___
'Ill...
__ .\
",1,
!..tHiPit---S ~.nama' 0.'f'

',_)[ ) [ __ " ~~. _ '.~
I.":"_j
as : __
~~!I!~
'i;n P'"l
~
iO'
1.. 'iwG I. -:-__! _~)

.... !I! ~
,~L:~i~ :~b.0!Ii~~ IUll_~_1"U ~aRf."-~_ljl
p, :1:,0:0,.,:),""~J~w'Ithe laM, ,or :namRJ '
:~:;~~!m~~~O:==
aslwe :ba¥l: Int-eqrr.eMd '.em;;
matm.ry '101 R.lsom in acou:rdlain.oo: 'witit the :ri.I~lIM .mitrl)_rc~ HeneI; 'H~lJbm HeMSI'., bel :.""1: 'lmal 'tXe :9i. of :nam'm is
vJl.
,~'\-l~'a: l~Il_lI_~ U~._~
\~ki .;:Dl, :~B~ :lrt: '~a;~ ~ ~tJ~~~I~ -~ =~'Iar~"'''
,d~:",,'1L"'red,I' ~.~-~ ~_
til.'W~, i .
to' 'i'Woh " 'the!','~:b:t II:f' :1'1~~lHr-e:m 'OF.~~~;qi1~~ mflin:ite.d~.'; D~ ad••-, -"'~ ~· ,,' w" '. .. ,I n:1I~~tL m.a~-- ~ - - - ~~;,W -~.~, ~ -,I ,,_, '1llI, ·tiat. leerula, :actiQUI'M: ·wm.J 'c-onUa'ry te :r.camn~ I
'1' ll,
.n",
[__ ....
UIltimitat A 'lDa'D, might a.md against the laws lof' D11mR :im. the: state' of :mtW'R';t land. 8'ueh.of~: are .mDt. :~tted, 'b" die rlrht. of :natllre~,'Note: 'rdtal: 'tDls pcmltmn :m m._padh~e;w,ith ,(l:1IWIC1lHn. 'that ... :IiaM ICJf :uture d,ol.not. ' 'Iim;pose' n.i'.II~,ns, 'H;POIl, riPt of' .RBt&R,~:F1o,r 'the, ,qu,ao,on, ,die' ,heR lal :no:t Iwhelk tho: :laWI, of' ,utI!lIr-ti ,IN' la,WI fe8'triW.g· 'OUf' ,dgb!M., lRadUUf ~tt,is, wlLdhef' 'die laws ,MrttlIre :show',.~. I~_t. ,
:001
wdBH\r'
"m.
'0"
l~
,pyI!"r~J"'~tt
'LcAtiiJffjH)':A'I"
'~~n;i!'!i'~;~ __ .:Iii
1~lbl..~.U:.~I~'
,mtulie: the
11
'Wle'
mnsi,dued lcon.d:u,cblt:: 'io, pr.eaervaUou, :amI :80 done 'with. ,right" To reeDne:iiI,l: the ,appaKDt~ oaniim: ~m, ~b'bes"1:stakmmm, we :1E9 QO,tce 'at 'rdJe H Mfe.rea'Ce Ua. the foo,motG t'O 'dic t1JiBIlti~ptetli' 11.1mB :~,8U-lP't,
,as,
1
do in, 'that: state' is to 'be takm.
riIh!t lof' :Mmfe isl ;stricdy
*_ ."L~_L, UlUJla.
'1J,U1
..'~""'t> ~n, th'.',

,
'~~J
'-_,~~J
'.'
'~b!!'lll~' ,_,e Dtr-'O'I;,t.__ 'u'-I.iRL~J [UJ,

._' ..
wI,l~
_'I ~
:!-;~8ted,-,'dllt
'whatever
'UI,
:"i'I'!!'i, "'~''''" BpRlBt.
;"'j :b-' ,.: ,0' 11:'(.':Pll~WlDJa t'J!K!. ~""~'"'\I :'1--'('.... Im ~~;'"i 1.:I"'1':'"'II),'L_,~ gWl ~L II(~III' I~' llIi., uulBl W,I1~'I.\ ,I_BY · I~-'~~'-: .~ be IcoadBmv1e'to :pr__ rntm., a,~ lal~G:r;. ,aRd. aee Dot to
'timt du: loonditi,oAl 'ondel' 'WW~, a
Na'D
:IRaY c,ftead
.~
...w
IU,ppcttHd 1Pcdlfil\t, ia 'dlJe I(L::_:,:~~', .am)te .iJ.
be'
10" ,Damle~
,iIii'~ __ .'iiIIi!' '9.1,-;ib'~~l:!~'j"!~, ~ '=;3; ;ftiinll '1i~::J:t;ii~tj!i '~O'....'iI'l~'iL-.,Ac.. lml.....I, t1t~:it' illlili,ili;'"i"'ii"4Iu,_..ii1 ,::""I ,I!J'~-'-"~-~-"l J' ~~lI~~1. -UWIWI~,,~~.l~_ lL_~;I~ Vlll~I .. ljl~ll~_~_1!1 _ ~~U;-U~JlkB,,'
.1 ~w.m,
'14.8,
iHC~lld
If tJhr.iB BYapsuo,n, ,m aC¢Cpied" thea 'w,e :may' ifilarp,m

[Pill ~:~
I.
'lite
[~
I~J
IIpD1m.~, Rub'lla warms 68 reader .mo:l; su,,.. '10 'that '~use :bl ,dIe bare :1.1e of ,aafJ(UR :aiJ, ,ad1imm :aftl dome 'willi, ,right.~ it, :f~'IDfWB;'dmt milder all condidoJmI :10 ldiimu, eaR, be: :mp".al '~Q 'be :mb.nded, 't,o ooRdilOl: to 'pmsenlli~ ,n, :10 muld be dODe 'Mt'b, :rilbit~ Tn, support ,dds, :int:erpmtatiJJn 'we: must tmm 'lite muru: of 'the :.p.eQt _, ,Dl CiW'~As we: have:at-:)f' :nottdtJ '~ihil: mD_ec: ,diflea, fmm tJmt~,0., ,~tltail: in that ,the 'baSil: :mtfdl,
1
:Laflo, rdllti,OD* as, l~l'I!}te:n,dedto, :mticiplt.t: lID, lOOj'IC"'" ,tb,e; ,Rad,ef mi,.blt:,mise In tke l~lbt I~f.1Ibecq~mt
Dlncep,.
eeeds :D f'oUows::
mrmmadq in
,aR
,mtnxbaad, "r.lor 'to t'be· auJ:ysia, of'

t!hCj WIlE
,of id~ :Ipt
amt t,1,'be: :aqJlment
lOO.~
'pre-
8··LmD
~
. ~ ~ _" "-~.
fi"N~1
~'", '--~ ---.j .~.
IThe: ,ooJlJifent,of' the :~alWi'lof' nature :m :H,obbes",$, :posiJtiive 'UUirali, dootriR£~ naJ.e: :p~m" [derived :1[0., : • UOOlmt of • hUJ'&Ift ,.atuH~,a;,' d.• l ,w:l.1: :m ,aKUSary' :i!f mm 'is, to aeMevc;" 81 fir' u :g, :poIiib:l:c\,. w 'pMc~pal'eftd~hi9, 'O'WD :praenamn" 'ad, '''Rith :i1:,,1 :Ws wci.(betogi
[~.
.!I,J;l,C IWiL~JI!_I.'Iiif.Uil4U
'--::,
~.::,~Ci~:'I-i11~:"""mr"~.·lriir''''''
'~l ...~-_;,~f':'.HI1;ijj-,'hl~I~' '~:D -W IV, .;loUII!"~_'!!iiii,._,,~
'~,;,!;I._-'-<,.;: ~,.- ,."., ,_-,::,'1.' '"~''' ~'~'''"'~'J ,~.,~
,tw;fl_ -,
.. I.,~:",',' :l~,[ ~~IIU' !II.~
[mil.,.,,' ,",~:'I .',1.' [til h ,,.. "~t:t/' ,alJlaiu", ;irJ:~[or. :I!ru:n~e [ simalv' ,it is ri:;Q[ _A /r!--···-· tmd :(iJJlOtD 'it" '('B-W:, 'iii- n\~l'I~[l ~B£', '~'I·"·I"·J
",----I,1r\,I,z'-J
TIDI, :Ia,w is, 'dre:muetpn~nd [oonc'luioll, :maD, [(bln:w. (NBl

iU;l_g~
lH_'
._.
,"',
.. _.....
~l
.-.~.,.-.J[!
..,.-,.-., ..
'..-.
1~=.Ii~~. ..
l __ ~l
Ir"1i
[expuience ,.f,ttffiu!'war' &f all. ap.insit ;aU., Clearly It [.nda OD,

,...\'il..~,*,
,w
,wly' :a,mam Inligtrlt ,co8c'~u:detbat 'war W,Qi :n,eeeuariQ" ,~mmiw

t'
[~n-_"'iIilI{n'~' ~:r'!lii'_
[r"'_:
~-1J1
'i,tiLA'~;I'I!.'Q-
n' .Il11~v!li._I:I~~.IL~_1 1
'iI'i,i:!l;~11~~, .I~~'~l"-'.I1_ .; elI,~ A",·_t'i.lHI~Y,5.~_ill' ,;'j[~-~_&~Ii_&rl V.r '~;-m-~ OI,c:-:""n,-=~1 Il ~16iL~'ij~ 'h~"t'~~:"~j:-I _
·~o:human, :lite [(tlilil,y :m,3Mit,sm, ,of' ':the: ,hufR1Im, mn&tinn 'Mlth alJ[ 'soc g), boodsl :remG1ved :sbo:w;s 't'balt peace' :m 'dle ,~ :requilit'e lOr' ',reserva)uo:n",
j
'b!i~19[ ''II'' 'w:ha,t:t,o dQ~,'to] better' [O,H' dWtaa of' :og' ;'Iri,';h-'-r-,tJiI'I,_ I't- ,~~~, 'n'A:". ~'t,~", 'I~im.'. l~iit: ,iIi')'lril'If' '-n'·~,,~,., 'nd:""I~[_ ~l" 'L1 :-Ili)~~ ~JI;1io vI; 'iO'Q,.J"~"I" ,pJ:iC8Cnuat 'h:~~"i~,_... ~,plO"[. ~ ~,~,~,gJJi,",. . _,~ wane!!!, iI'Ii'~~AIi'ii ~"~,~~'~l:-~! ~[~~!lil~:.!, 'r;~i ~~'" ,.~,, om:'r~;11:; J~~''i"'L1;II:t" r-'".:.;I,.,·· [:f-:';-i.-'[~~<;'~ .. e~~ _ .u ~!lj.lV-u!This, :p~,t:
T~_j~'R._1! •..
~" __~l
l.=-'V~-~l
~~I~I::.lli
[ ..1. __ ,-~""
YU_IJJ
I.
"::aA~-Y_IIi'Y"1
lDull!
:0.···••
;~;~iin'at ,~,is, 'n~t: '""'Ie--'_'.' .... ' ,r-'""'''''-,i,f''

C -U!luu.-~ ..
bmish, [ooA ,t'hlit 'RO] ORe: c:m'tioorna a 'w,ar' [of :aU a ... ,aD " ~ ~ '10 ;~~,.00, for' hb'" aDd~,t'bat-~'ev~ry' -'~.·~brJ .~a_r;d 8~ity [deal,r., thrat whll.1:h is unnd 'for 'b-im~ ~E[ RJ:. i~·P-:", 1"2)", 'I't follows that :mo :IRm" [Oil' :00 ;samc:man, 'wiltin:gI,' 'vi:.o]atm tID :,~I';[
• ,._-_-_-_1._-_, '__ -__I_I _ •••• _._._.• -_-_
l"""!_' ~,~-~ .. __ • '_'_.'"'
·~'8=~,fi-:'~itt;\0'
~IUJ.l·
l
'~::(f-Ui, W
li[!d , .
lit-
he
e-e- ..
;-~~mn-;-;:' 'But~ 8H'f'm w". -'··"\I~ '. ~ '~' . ,~,
~_::
J
:...........;'t.~;nD
~_~_._~
'~!!'I'i]r~,~'~~.. ra~[~ 'O,A_ l"_D~"
her
acmn- can . "~.'~' '.' .. -,
;~;fli-;-lijln~'~·'''iIi~'ifI,~ 1l._1_I_M_:: '

I
lr'-~-,'
, \''"\'"~'H~.I;i!'(Ii'iI!o.jL~1 ....
BiJHlJ ' ·:__;uU.ug
l.'::
__
i.=.o.
__
ill_'
!Ii
I_
-~J
J"'!II'
I].
_Jl'.~'
Il_'
["
..
,:
I._,
l._ _ ..
:m, 10, cfar IS :1I;e:'u'ndler:amnds,

'lUJ'iiI;
L1mIr'~ I _ ']
;lin,w-----~' ;:'n--c-,;i;,'Le~ niNi!"'~~\n;U,a ,g!~-~L:,,,,,, ,Q.Q1U Bi~~".nn- 'D ""JL,'b' 'h-_it..J:a; [Ug__ I W -_~ ~ .,~~¥~U~l ,&,'Ii.. .....t~·· A,S-, :lnm.Q' :18 m.en '~ ",~, - -~-~~ r-~"""""" ;anil], ,ad: ,an the u_~~~_~~~ 'r17Rt .:[f' 'I-m~[;,~\ ~~~~~~-~~ - ~~ ~~~e'~n'Hrn·jjte:d, =~I-~-(L na~Rl! ~~ 'WIf' :auist ,nsu'lt,~, H:en,CC,,:
~r· ...... [~:
J
,it,"
:tja-~··!IFI.c:Ul!1J1Gl
Ijl
-;iRj,
~I •• ~
,~l
;aD
'I
0.1' ,Batu~'~ b, wm,eb, :men He oonun.uuled, ,~~ [,~n~v,~~'r.~.-:,ll,,~~~~ ~~~ ~~_~~,~~la:':~~ ~i~t~[~~[, ~t.'[~ wim, MM,' ,~ w J~l[ Qj JW! ~fml~ [QI_f1J'T ,~~ ,(DUj 'i4tJf(~'OJ ~ ,IN ,.. ~tIid:il:'~:il ;'0 'w dbwJt tmJ ~I# :m] ,11;[_,; [_[[lJ;[[~ ,mljlll!l[~' 1IWr~, "_,·q.fm ~'~ ~',b wuMmlQW'~'~ntfjj,.m"'dl ~, .. [("B~'•• , :W~, :1 J):"'''-'1:8[)1
'P:~, [lAb iU!lJJ~tall\a;w
"P.I
,la,rime dOwn
the 'im~ laW'l' :it is a, 'mtbloal pr.-uept, 't_lt., us :how 'beat 10' :HeUr.-e lour':,rceerwJu.on", In ]iltRlf it don Rot, limit 6,1' aerdle! [~_'.e~ ,ngbt, mi':nato:re', BUT' :i,11:,tIlie,~1a us' t,o' ,tmpMe' IlIldh, a lmit~ 'ThUI, :in acting [OJ], :'it we: ex;er-c~se. [01!Jr' pIevioual,' umlimited, dJ~i: of' ,urtur-e) 'W' :pedorm, an I.ebloml 'w'm;ich ,has 'the eiHt [of' :lbDi:Un,I' [ou[" ,ri[.ibt of ,~)tUR,.
:~.r.e~[ is' 'Vlhieh
The: ~Jld
lOme patt [oil'the iniluaUy 'URI~w1!ed

'ft}]~J,
law'of' .;mft,1 'meR; provides
'.1' ior 'tak~,g,~~~~~~rta,iR-[obwiPti~;~~i1

'Ibt~ mt1,oAB11: fOf'
[of'
,~~ :~::~ 1~
Mt ";bave' ,l1li,
,of'~
I~
'bc~l
'IhI-t
'~~ i' b,:_ on lwi'tl!l 'wddng' '•• ' :nlamiAl:., bu,t~I' ,d\o .... to"do iii., ~ ~ ~
'Q~'
'~'GQlbt',~'ua~llI
Iilm::
:m:K
~Ye1
dIat 'du~:,ncomd, llaw Of'Dailtnrn l-m;posa aD, If:l!idal tab,imBeR 8n tb,e~:~,! [of' naWR~ [ob'~;ps ai -(tt 'UI[ tiem, ,Ill, :RmaiDm, :femlail [~mml~ [(m:e UOOlld, [QDJe:)18 g,1leo1 mjeoledi : ,Nlow iit: 'woulitl be' dlamgeauou .mot w[ a_I 'nt. :lIo'b[IJea[ b~lIl is[ Rot [m[t.ireJ,,' ,liee &Om, [comJutlMl, ,with ,~ ., 'dlel rolc of thCi '8ec~lld, :Iaw'of' :nattu~e'..m·n. pa;mttlb:r~:hc d~, 11pd, -~ __ n'b'II~MinD" ~~i\ll!.,.~ [_~_~' ,!IiUIi"_,,,, ~ [~;i" ~ln,A 'W'" [mal '~"'M.'-_ [U.I. ,.. ',1!.... 'la' ''!W8 Af' "'l'lIi;oj;h~ll' J)a..Qi-''ID'~ ia 'the ,Red section ef 'du~,chapter.' 'whet'llfJ" 'wh;a[t, .he~,up [cam,'Ibe , Ralnciled, 'widll QUii' [llcfiRi,~imB8, ,11I1d 'their' m0R4ll1m'CCI.. ,At tlUB· .. inil! let [me [.cIatim [onliv that ,our accournti' ,of Tthe; '~Ie' [of 'the; seoomd, :l\aw' &fl'ma)turce is eon&mtent, 'wilb'what HoJJ" apidllJ'
1 ~~l
l
iU_!l~_:__.',_,~_,
.,"
,iIi~''''U,c_I.~:·igQ
~iII'
""",_:,
1_,
~~~II_
,'.'
'._- __ " lr-~~-
_~ I _-_-,_,I_ ._-_. _.~.~~ ~~ "_'_' _;/ __
.__-~._ ~ _.-__-._, _ ..' .. - _... ~-_] ~
~ = ~_'_-_. '='_-=r_.
'~_'
l_
~-_.
"I'd:'
[1It~ '-~~Ca'1111,"" I,t""~~~.::__'_~,y
.mll:rpmatiou, emables, us'
dootdlte"
atated
1 ...
[~Uetm1e::p~dm ',be' condusinu, ,:H[obba draWl [II, :far' 18 'iIi!lioo-,,":: ,~~ ... i!'L'1I11ii1l! 'n·~ ... 1~ ~,,-~~JL~ -v.~~ .. !IIi~t ;1-__ .~.rU '. ' ,~:t" ,"'II"", 'H~;Ab-'~'""""'iaD ;~~I .u._ .. ~ ~
:Dmidilj", au,u !!:!I,r-"""'"
I ... _1 _ .•.. ~
m
t
'lkat;
impartan,t, :pasaa.gal im ILlb'ba':s. 'wGr.b.~ that 'the

~Ii~
;It,... :
_ribe ,t-D ·H[g.b'ba ,a, e(IlW.stml 'VIldou ,am 01' ais, d.ooIIine' :BC; [QpWdy
~D
~AiDi~IIIO'f;~"D:+;:
,says m,
I:"C",;-, ,"':1
,'t-:"'-11 ,-"; ." 4i'il!.. [--r~ ,~'L_}t· ,O'il: ,m.cfU\:.liU,Clll(gwuC. ,'IL-W ,UI~,~. [WlJ&U UJi.1_", .:.or
,"',
,'' ' '~,.:I ~['lP!'

:~,J'
- ....••..•....
::E'!' " ,~
1111'IO~I·
~,---~~~II:I!.~
__
.IIi,
'~_.'
1_.
'~
I....
_~l
t-"'b':a"~ ~ln~ :11 " .. " .'!LI il:1IIJCI!l.!!! I,

-.
II!]
~.iiI:ii,<ii'nl ~iliil~"',
I I.
'fol" RIf;..,·.t~raI_ ,HCUlar, 'rational 'men ".-'·'1 _... -....
'~'I~:'"*: .~;. '11 n '1-~iIi!'Ef>i'i~;~1~~r:J'-~ 'I!!oillili,\;· .1", ..~, I, .raJdy.~it'Ai!l! [ U.~I!.[Ii.,IIHI;1I!iO

1 __ I."
'The~'dlhd,
(ll"""
',iMi'ft..i'_' ~.(jJC
'~n!')f'(LUILIB U_g;p"er~nere we are [-:-[I-;;-;--:::[-;;-~~I i'!'!i[ftl r-'~' ;iIi;,~r-: ~~"''''i~j;;~:"I)~~ 117-:","~ ',",;:' ; 'j I,~~ CDBlZmcu. c, /~~\-! ',-;-"-teri'I[li W1u_~ ,b" ,BaH " _
dismssi,OD .. W:I' uarmiimoo :1&, .rQ!~D-mi :ioWpFef8UOn. in, 'the :Iat ,

H,o'b,",." ~. _~ ~.e91 ~
,;b,
,.u... '~~i~'" ,~,.. "',J'I~1 ~

ilVl'
'iDl~l',:~
'~I~iill~""'I"", : i:
,of naku:e'"
1"
'1'" :,'
t:,,,.,
_ •.. __ ,
:11,.'
"0'\1 I" 1-..:'"''''''
,a·li,Ra.J,-" ' been. '~:~~,1',~<;'ILiD'- .....41 ;~:~~I '_' ",~~, ,!J!Q..--- _.~u/ _.'P!'I,~
'IIWJ·
,J1et/Orm tlu!iI' ~
_~J
['!'U,'I(~,i"'" "~!Ii,
intc!p.RtaltiOJ1=-- 'tDat
:m" 'M;dl: :ib; rol@ as ;1.[amdinmD, [0:1peace.,

iY~'~
,~,~,~ LUI"· ,~il'lil ~"';~',al V'~IUI] 'UI~
[cUlClDIi.m, [of ~ltB ,De ,Cl/N':: i
1~,,!i"WI!n..:l:""1fLI~G, U~I~~::I!ru.a
:~\n{.~:Ifft~~~=nn. 11_. 'iliri:-, ",- ~'_ ." Ilnll" n ~1~_"'rilll~-l4Ill!Li:&v..:
[Th-e HDJ:nd, ~law'mU9 0 Qlv1mmm- :i. D.OOtaal}'

oI
'rnat paodng .&W[II,·

tol
:peace:;, 'me: tlii.Td law' adttl, 'dwt
:.!~
51 .
--..'~
dis.play pti.1I.1~~ .he ~lIi isboul.d :if I.,M· ,of' nature 'wert; ,1£-01]:O,ds lf [ob.doo~, My' e ~ f.ig~'t Qf' :natuN :19 :1101: fSlmcted. :S!.hou~d,'yIO'U cooler I8m.e Idad,... ·
IJa,geaWI
[tbat .mm. .e· [ • "d •
*1'
'lO'
,mm 'D~POn,m,e .. '1~ne:.RWJth, :at1 ,t~ •. laws ~m,~, ;0, mndi!uoH[ [9f :~~,~, lu)t men aokmoJw~edp; [eaeb ,omer _ [eq.om;t, .ad :~, equail, :~lhts •. establmm'QI' eooditioM, [of peace (,I:~ :ii;t ~,p~, Jf:~ ~1'4~1)\~ The :marn, 'WllO dml:lands, mo;le for :hii~F_[' tJiIm. J],c alUM tu[ othem .is ,arrop'lJit .. [TiRe ar.fO,prd: man dees :o.ot "f~lDl8t"C:Ws, [o'b'~~PU,QItS,;, 'ins.tad;;.] he felnses 'til' [aceept ,obtlpdons 'whldl, he
,not lIRjilU;t'~,arJ ,an m;m'lJr't'o ,peace he 'mB:Y 'be: ailed, 'by' o,tbcn~~
Wi.tlmcnllt: b~j1!listite.,
.nl-r~Jer
he ,PreYeD
~~~~.~.~_f1IMDlent _I pea<:e,[_~ __~-' ~~,a;.:.ce~o:.~f.~;h:~h~Z tile, .. ~eu· e _

l•
8011 -----
,",,r. --~ "~"jj~htt'i,j!ji [t.'O·· ',~ . ,~[m-~~~~;l~:;;. n.t'i'.D
i""'JU'_flfli'
[U1;H'~
Oil.
t, :1l.~14re·t,u'L.iIi ... 1i:.. ft!i!loilii "n'II~Li_~~~t_1I ilWll~

iIjj,'.-~ ~~-
~-\ii'!i'd'~!:I:iAftO
~VtI2l ..'~_~JUtVIIJ_:~ g'

i
;i!'i.'f~·
:ptactr[ H;obbe.s :.eDtitum ~:[ol.ef',t.ni'n,p tendilil!l' 'to' die d!ettm'c~' 'n(,D, [~f''nanicu1lar _~n:~aB, [ruu:o'kenneas. ,and aD. [oth~r nli.l'tl [of' m_,' -~- --- -~---~----t, ---" -~-- - ---.-~ ir" ....- -,lnt:empermct::; wb~c;hm~'J 'tbererQ~e also be :r_tlJlcd, amompt
._.... ,.. -~ ,r,"'-- -- ... -._- .. __~..
f-- .... ' :', [I~~' -:d····]',-n; '-j ,:.-:; '~[iI~ilrt-:-:ou'~~'h, ,~oIIJC: ,menuO;De!!, nor - He ,~~,_Hem en_j_~,I__'~( '1;'0 ,dis 'p10«' (:B~'WI' iii" P['"I ]:[M'.1,. Hobbes, oftcm apaW, as, ,if' he
'),,+ ',' ,110',"<' ecessary n .. : - -; "I
'~:.
'th,08e t-hi.p, 'wbtc:h 't'he 'law' of' nl)tUF.[e :had], :f(u~bjddar; 'b.t: ,are
[eq[waLl~U~l,,",
-;;-il"i,~~~.J1
,;i;'ii..ii;!Ii
1ia~~--[
:u:jsl pnemJl.
"W,'j"fO!liclli
,~_'WI! v'
~f;'~;~'Ii'~~"i,liIL!l! ;w'",'!',,!'i)..
,I!!I!A'Ii.!J.U,'!W~,.
!~J
...,1i..;6 Ul"",
dmDj'!ti,oD~ d~OH,net QOnlta;'D,tho :rmtD,cd:onct w:hit;!J ,

n~!p.joQ lrlIJ~·~:,.
'ti"I~~'=1 ["III~'
~"I'"i""'1f'-:__' ,-,
.i"!iO'."Iw1i;"I:t-=~-~:"'[f= ~~ '[~. :r-~jl 'I 'I;,I.v,~.1\U_ ;!.'iLv,lw
~iIi~:j;
,iD'!oII1I.
.,~. ug~IU:','. ' ~lIc~
,i-411
'ru~,-,;'~I;6A'Ii'~~' V.-Lll~
dl,eolJ'~ .Perb~pswe :rm-l~tlabel them mlies, 'of :penlOllSii .pn.~

dtmee"
"owner:, ,:Ii;U_~, ",I];e:r. rm'!.ulie Pliilf :no '::n . [,,;:V_C"~[ " _ 'V\rL4I, ,t;h-AQn' ~ili-_' neae at' all ~D m.Q' r.... .~.~'ii '!'ll'l'ili,d~~1 '~~. ml[I~~=~I'1 ,ililu: H' n'b'L- ... 's m "'~!IIA!I'...!',J':;,
'0, ;:;;---c~'~F:-:_-~ [-,--j"'I"'~~-:__
,~_,'c---'_
'~'a'c::·."If01 ILWS
'~u'~'J'L '!!:IiiCl' -~~Il

,~. _ ...... '~l
th~'~:··a+·am::l11i."...... ,~_I~m!L,
','~ _ ". _ :-~
[d·,!--,~-'IL.;"'"';D';iIIi:!IIi;a, '. ~I-Ullft;~-J£~ ~

,~-ioI'
~,'II~C';. 'i:';
'_ ~,
!-;O;-~--;-':~[~~TIit SIPilim;:Bih,.,
,[~,;"'~l-:_,fQ.L~
'c
.. "
,~_---,_, ,I___,__!
u~iJ!lj,I,~----'
c~[OI,IJigfltiln:
[DIJ:llpu,o;l),", 1m'I'ke :p(R.v.io1!Jl :setJtion 'we ,kavle '01JtUned], 'dl,l; :mdormle ,iur ~IJ'''I' dO'Nft :righu and :hence' Io.r 1.~mliDgo'bJip tioR8\" ,AldtOillgB,
~o,
,iay
[d«W.ifi ,3
F"igll.,t is bJ' 'omldenak,e

,[Ile
.'J~ _
-.
I~;
:H"bbes, [dOlIB,ot
~,II
:_j
,,,,L_ oo···-n"""ep· ','~,~, . ~-~ :.I-.-.IJI~.~-.~ -'..
Af~'n'L1!ii;p,~'·r;": U.I:!II~t -t"'I~oii"iIin !UUI_~

-
{aei: .pro~.de I, mal_.

,,,"'b~;£[.::.,U'y·;.rV ..:_.~ l'-_:'- -. o--]1l..~ii!liiU'·S
'J I
".ti~i'J',liii!'li; """"J!A(;/ I~J
d_dOI;
fo,I"
~iI'Iii~'h·"tf.' ~L.a~L'l~~~l
'iil'L1~~I;I,I1
de8.nitlo., :b t:O ,add.

J
:ripts '10, ,the ~f9DM'"Icq.btaJ~t11lce.,nUl· we [~b:tam:::

!I'A~' II
'-'.' '.
. ~,_:.. ~'= _U.I;I
:blt""~ ~~.I w[ d.o X", namrallJ. :riI~,t,

[-·ld~ ....
.e~
I_ I ..: ~
'MI'~'IO,C:;.'iDI· "II; '~' - lf1ItIij~"~,O" ··'R-:"'Il!'" r: D_,ft.-';'l

~,rgl'~"-=,__ ~ ~
:Ma.dal mllditio., :iur Ia"i'-. d.nwo,

dol
,'c,
,_'_ .,'__ ,1:.[
0"-
-j 1.,1,/ .1 ..
~I~~~'-UV,.~1i iI_l&:v-~, I~v.l
-:i:!iI:rd,tin"lIIi;, nftilt ''"n
:H
II!!iiiii." d u:Pn""C· 'b~ .~,.... X' "A' h '~'"'d-I [_~yJ" ,~l,.~~ a loond·id,(uiiJ. of p:resen;ltiom~:;
.- .- •.,~ .. • 'I~ ",
", I_.I'~'··I·~
'
.. ,......., '~', ,
I c.ij;ii:i, '__: ..:_:_.,~AQI
,_:'!~ig;.__:______
;i;' ~'A
,,~_, '.r\~'.
ftc'r- .....-IJt,.;m· "'a~t.:!~I~·I~ · ~'l'~ ~_Ii:I·

I~ __ ,I; [Ii'
.ric-
'by 'whi\eb, .en. obl~le· ·.emseJ,,~~ 8im.pl~:rm,o;nc~au.oB. o;r :Iu~: ,tr.a'MI~r'of' d,fit, ~lsi,i,t; leat: ,theoftdeaia,' :pOssiimle., TIte· [diI'elii.·, enee 'betw·HD. :fen1DidauoQ, :and, ,traufer :is,thiI::, .n I' reneunee :My:,: -~~ '10 ,lOIRe lo'bieet" :1 o'IlBp: m,yaeif :nu't 'to ~m~.I,:}C, am~' [ ~.;ht ~ ~_ ~ i' Mm. em, the Itxer-eisel of' .We .ri~ghtteO 'dmt. ID'~jCc:t::;,:i( I ,tmmJlcr' .my' ' t' 'CD 80:.1'. object, I ,ob:U_gc my. ,e_, :no.l:10, ,impede the pH80D to whom I 'Imnder' '•• ' riBo)t in, the !Demise ,of' 'his, u_Jh)t to 'rllat [~)~jeet!,(:B:~ :it~1 p.,~,:11E:;~':119~)'" W~ 'Nut ~dIriI;bJU" or' aI~,:pads ,of 'die right '0:1 nature~ lean, be : of' o[bl~lptiGnjj' Q,fte CIlJAot .,\1\'0' '~p :lB, :iinuBedialtely and, dlred]y n.~' · . e rig'Bt •
:M,
'W:e "vie:
m:lUId, :liUJ~cdbit; [mv~nt:
iSI 'tke usual
.mq~1l8,
hid, dOW,H~1and, ,hence 'tbeR
aT4!: :~imw)m om the
[OR~·I' ,dgh!t: '101

J
:possibl,e! ,alecDt
do 'W.Mt
:RSbt 'thraits ,ad ,assaults ,on, ,oRe~:8:lfe pGrwer:11 ;and. OJf'PGni~, :libut;r, ':B~, Hi, p, IL20]),., 'T:h~R!s~Ikcn an :ind.i~na'ble mfC ID] w~ i
({Jr''pfeurvadon,~
gb~iptiBD.:mJt, 'to' delelld, :m:Y:seK, tlds, of :imc]_f' im,posa, DO 'oh1.iptioo, 08 ,o,t'flus, not to .attack.• e, In :addi!dDII, tD t.ls :prim~ry:1le8;,u.imffn; en 'ltjfte exlm~of' 01lJ:F ~b~igati~ ,illeR: :Ire 'ce.rtain. ~oJl.dar.y' ,r;mmctiomJ! QB, the dialmslal"lca, URdu w_c'h 'we :M4J 'be ,obJipd.. ;and ,the ob.... , ,j;GdI, '1:0 'w;mcS,'we! 'be ,o'bllged;l 'w.eIl. a_rite fro. ,1m~,tarm.oD.8 on the~valicliity [oi eoft-DIDlcl!~:I: [O,ml, 'WlIO of '.eae ,rettriemou
1
,ofu_-e~ Bult '.ote :agalft~that~,,~tlun~gb'1:

j
caBROt:
:have
&la,'
:tie~"'~~J=!n c:.-::;: ~o,:,

,gf,~C:=:'-':::"~T~,:;=,:: ~i.
:IM,
amDt: IdJMluaim,
'pedtu'U~ :p~otl", :bu,t: tlUlt: onc'_her';, :in, t'hc [c.n,diJdnn 'I:f' _, ,n$~, 'w:lltdJ :i8, :1 oom.d:fdon, [of war at cYeIl" :iWlf1l .insl, IVery ngnijl 'ujpon, ,lDy ~1U8OA"" :lble [lllIlpid.o,n~ iiI :il, v::Qid,::,~ : The RUg' [nf' ,rm.~\¥,hie.b, -abth, IU~ ,a, my. n IiDI: tl1i'¥,dd-,[mun b!i
If
iii [~'e'I(t1.ql:
be Madt:' .. w,hOR'~n :~)t'h.el' Qf th~
'p4inifi
,!I "',
:m~:; 'For' 'tkll: 'w:IU,., [mu'id '._t, :Wndcr. 'SI 'mm f-mDJ 'pmmiling' [ought 'Iilot teo, bri~ admiB~ 'hfmd:~:-~~,'~~f~<~:L~::~),~~,W~ I:~",----, -- - -----~----'----'-- 3i,:I __' ~lii--~---~t~~~':-·-~'~!
:aiw,ap :~'hin:g'
'-'-'-'-'------~
~- -~- ~
~'~~ ~
11_:,.['
\'~.'-
----~ -~-
~~-- -~-~~- - - ~-~ -
- - ~~---~--
--
-----I'
------
--
dB: ~~,~
'I' ~, ~
O'~ 1~,--,,-l11IiUng~,
- ,. '---~,
pp., -"If
,jJ,!'i
1"'110-1;:'8 ,A r. m'll31 t:!iIIQ"';':-Rv' L~".'. IftA,~ &.lg,Ei!·.·.,J. _'ll;
As, 'wi)tb. o'bl~PbiG." ~HottJOes, aoa, :not ~ploV:ide :1, mater.ial dGllJiuUEi of' di.c~ mil~pt lli)fJusdR'~, 'the ,ceut.ttiUD. of GRC :.uII: :isi eaMt,' ,earried, I()\J:I;.. UMmI d~e same; :method H 'befQr-e"o, 'I'X, is a,jius:t :ad"'-,> I= ;I,X, oes ,not mvill"t~ '.e~ bi-alk;i~I'of' a, d '~~'~:IFi''''''ii''i,. iii~r-~.~......o:-",,1\..;ijriffi, In :a''COO'~d~'idi;i"'i;'C"A ,~~;iIO"L ,~"1!.._ ,~'Ii!i'.Ji ~'I",-n' ~V!l!.~~L"''!.iiIi!l'ltb~~~I~, ,iI ., ,_c-,i'['iflI'!II •• ,C~, IW~
_t '_ ffilll 'W~ ...... UI rl~"~,U-1; [Ii 'W""~~~'-:::" ..... .. if: ne .,l, ,_.~~
I-',;~,it ,n~i\o ,,-,~~• ttIL,,"oi:i;', ~'~:-m, ,""'""'I, '~,".~r~1Il!> ',~'\s\l!, 'IA',..-,'.., 5~iA!,"", ~u.... QI__ .~i"I" ~U~, finiU'. ~:!I~\",,;I'.iIIi!_""'<IIi;, ~l''''' '.
.;ii,
D'~"","'
iNIi'
'"':1)1.1[1,
'CI'IiiI~.Ii~~,
~,,,'iI'f
'~!D',
,iIiIi:!!
'a'
I,.'
:m.an,~'~ Ho'b:bes, :~~ in 'C(UlftCCti,oq, w,idl, jitl!;ti~·~, :prohlem whrlc'h a h_as,:ID, :iImpo;~t 'beariin;G' on 'dI,1 q,uesti,~n,.raised, IIMa,t o'bl.~ 'lion, :~Ad1tc: ~at, ,seetion, A,:rath.' leapy 'qH'0\tatima 'WI( sene ..
'~n,"i "g .Aj~", •
6~·
"~'.'
.... 6i
... ---L_,."
h., IU~lv . 'pRUBI 'powu '[II.)] :f:RQ¥" :., ".C!j 'wa"i if &nul 10m, if it em. ~' :~~~-; m:!i'~,~\·-;t··:.'~aw' :;rij~:~c:-;il ~~_I;[I;_IinJ ,~~nid~:I~:"~.~:Q_. '['II~Ithis, IU:N._ HDSe: 'lite: weli. mia" 'hBt _t1mr ·dte: '[bound, :mm :nmT '.~: :B~d,
''T'1.,I,·t~~_i.l·"•.. ,oi;l-_Jrll.."_ ..• _..~ ..~._., ... _~,, ~ , [nJnl~L~ [II IUI'lU...
:di 'p,~-.a~ •. _,"

'::
~~.I_~~~
'pm.:
I ..
'.',
-W"l~I!" !!iiI_~II..
• ,-,
Ai'.
lll_li_~&
'iIfiIliii:i!iIin YdlJ :'f"'i"'
'~:!nrl~;} UIDJI _'

'_ .'
,~I\..~,
Q4!~I"j~
Lnl __
~j
'~i~;~.,iI,,::,-. llllJU_a.m.'
iIM\i-!Ioi~-., ~:~\ifijm-::"';~
~U"~.
_~~~V.l~~
~ AI:~1 __.
-~
:MlDit
w1lllt·~, LibeRJ~ ROW" .mDt 'be: d..eo!. as po,te.Dda'~. G1wer U~ ~ p .... :ped,ed, ~fJ =t;,emal, oo:m1iirmDnsli ,A, m_, or a ,t:biQII lias, die. ,~_iberty "'a m~'-,~., :if~:\ n.4i '-'MV' il.\v .I_. ,~_iI,U. 1!U~'~1 ·l:f\ 't", ~u'ld nOW' Hi.love I. mat' -i way under aeDlail IUtuftIJ, eoftdignDS,~'T,nus *e: 'WeD mm. ud,
;jftftU", l ,1l.1oPJ!o'~1 .... , . ,.
'~_~.iI,,,,,,.
:.11, 'lkl: :POWIf '.
''iml!'.lV' 'g'iAi~j!ji'
'iI'i'
.I_: •. ~.,
~~_.~_.
'-h ".' ..".
'
,.. " .. ".~'
.I_I I"
._- ....
'.;t...... lliij:.-!I., n'iII;iiiil'ili, 11_.ow _ ~~_1I;.

[~I~'
'ijj,n~~Il-~,.- IW d~-Aifil [~rJ l~-'';~-~~'~'l "n-a 'iL .... ~E. :'~I~_~ ~-~I._A~ Aali;;~n'l~.~
Ro'bba~'1 aeeooot, 'e' ·,II.UblmticR.. :FO!1 :11.e' .'S':: ~:And,'~ isl it, ca'U~. ik.l1Iiim; '~. it :bla·,Dim. ,Bll .dJ '10'the: -"'1'
,~.I-UI_r':1
'm:1:s W-~7.,\1j,.] :~I 1·~~il1-: :~~~mg:. ~ _ _ IU!I!, Ii, UII.I~e ~""""""'~~~ II! l~~.
ib,'iii:t 'nA.'
1_I,_.U} ...
~~v.-Ir
;ilj;1l.'iIiIi,
1~"'J ~.~.J~ltJ_~'
·iJ.."l!"-uC-·t!iIi"d, I
'R'iii!iifi
,~l-;-Jf)~~:':'i-D·. ·~·'-I:l!I;iI.~I~J~. T!U, .,
~~~,.
·h·-~~a~'ii;~A. ;idLeR. ._~~:'~ 'UI~i

.l~J~
j;::LA:Ii"tv, +\i"!i; '!Oi!Oi_I'~fL, QlUIII!!!ii-~'~I' ~ 'W;"'_~

"'''''
;ii=Ii_~~
~:Ii,
'rt'''I"Io'
,~
l.-.vip.'·ll~;ii~B: VA! ..lilA - .
M~.....Alm'":
"1- '11ft A'l~l'rw'o',iHI, 'i!iIip~ifi\iili ~:;ll~~l U-~_I', ~.~>.lt~:H~'·r'li--J.1

A'IUiI::Ii,
lOr
:;~i;. :p,r-eve~~I'uJi~"'eh~Jb~t;_,-'~":~~,:IlO,t~I"" aC,dft-l

~«1l1tka mat action 'oRows :Hnmdatel:,' 00 d.mibuatiOD~ If it· did .P,ot",,dieD, IOUf :~iberty wiQuld, :oo,t be lat. an '1I.d;i ((It the a.cm.al limiter.ftaJ ein:umstanca wtltll.d. still 'penmt 'HI, to ,audse· 4.' ,mpadqr' 1:0' ohDDH-' ,assum~ft~'lhat. 'the ,cReumammce8, per,rrtiu.i t'hiS :uuua1l,,~,,A'Rd ' c:1D·,'J;.I~-, t'l1at actinD HI ___Ulgg ~iftilllli~~,. '~;~Il"~"-~ "J~_~. ,i:m·nn~-"ii'f~~'I-;aMJIJ8t: foluw :i!mmediatmy· en ,detilber-atloa, :lftd,:~b mr..lllin)U" 'w:i'D~,
'we lrel :RQ :fOOprl :at Ineny '10 :act. 'or :Bot to ,act..AltbnBI~' out ~paeiti_ are nne",--" Jet 'tltG '·.iIlema·~ mrcuM&tamcult mf
1
;avemioR~'(B~,W~ 'P'~l4B;)t~ :." D,dhuadon. 'lel1Nna:ta· :h1 ,aenmm :Iut. w:.m 'we ,acct. 'Ihm ...
t.
:~~:o,le:thac: drl" explanatiOIl ·
"~-.uJi~
1~_I!~~
'~!'~
~'lII(I'V'
I.L--,r"lll!'tl~UI~lnlllr.' [~
.,. ~__ ~~
_~-_~_~
:N;ow let:
hl"t;
natIlR'~
IH,', l'nJli~'i~"~:!![S" [ P'iflft;iiqJ"" :''" , " ,v,!llI!~"" ~._Mwi,"' ~

[~I_,
Ho/bb_al ,ddnibiBn, [(.1:'1 W~[ i~" :1: 1'6[)'~,'dmit: 'Ike: to'tloiwmg ,eqrl!d~aleRec'"ttl.:~ ,pl.,
W:e'~m;_ ·:A ,~~'Ule 'L,........ ;iIi;;1!.." ,~,'~
~l
*' [~f'~1~IL_~yi" '~it;_t" ':"iit' 'm'"!Ii'ls't"" 'L,C 8"'pp":_.,'~.L~ ,~L;oo,~'w'_' ["'I[-iIi" ,,W""iliL!i:I!>'t!i' 1I.t~:lJ miaco~~t¥ed :H[o'bbes,"s :a~~:UDt [m Ute :riPt of
Vi, :lililiPC_il.,'';',
E,
d)_ra,'w t'ne [cnmequen,ees

~
[of
00"
' ,,'
['J
[di.ecuaiOD of
UW,iJ;.,
',,!!Iiil'
.iL"", ••
i\.I,",
D"
DOW' :saJ'~[ ,lo:llfomng'
-~" mi' .," d"" :-X'-;':i' 'C-M-' '~A h the ,Uj~JI'~J' nIJ~'~'I~O"D' ,;,,' ,_,:,0 I ,-~:,~:~, ""'h 'I~~" =1&
,.:I:" 'CD IU'O y ,~
H:i;~~fiIIi, l.::.~l,~_~
to
l'-V
as,
[[
A,"J:u[. n~:Diii'~~a-r"~I",~~'i!i '~: G! r·&·~I.·!I!J. J!I._._V"~IJ J.i
[~A
r.r;;'~,
'ifio'br .nl~,lt.. .fr" ·d':'l.: :"~~~"" ~'";1!..t, ~'L '.".",."", '~n' ~~~:_e~ !l/.Ul .'~~Q ,'!i!' '~M"~"-- iiiA.'' '. 1!.. __ 1_~_le pamj~~.,'~ ~ .. ,IIBIR, peded by' ,actual [Dltenml, ,conditions;, t'Ol do 'Xiii :U :1 meau
,~~l
'l.........
I:
'X"·-'
,v",~'
~;'w:'I~:
~;~'"
.~_~l
olD !Le,'
A:",,\ ~ '~".~ "rIi" ,[:,"'\,~:Ii
'P"I:r"¥·trn.'a"'~~:o"I)'" .. ' " ""',-"Y",",\.,

I __
[~~ ~11.ft)ld"~ [n." -n:"'Iii"'I'iI'ii'lg.~ ,~,t."" '~'~'~ll\i, 'D;:~'iii~'_ has 11...IlJlf~ ~;•.'I~~: uJ; a!"U~IJI~,. 1"';'\I:.IIIl,liog ~.Ul'_~l _~
,I. _
~;f][t<~'~iI1i[~ "'DIIi-~~i"j~ ~_lJ.cV ~Jlll!!I_~1

:_...~
'~~~i~-~"l~r,' .~[ !l-W
,Aloflo~ ;lijw' ." ilLW'1l. W!I!o!" '~i~L,··\-""'iit:
,-~atim-, whaf[~he ,~,-"": [€I:, tl!L_~_lI '."__~,,[!f., ne C1ln~,Q" ~

[Qu:r
;0'1, _ " nmy,,[).A!;i('io, '111't~' .': _ :~;jI'Ijrn" .. , _ i1J_1o.1R \!I,v.~ '"' .S' " ' '."
::'.'
a:o'b'bes: ;says':' [fPro.mists, 'drH-efor1:~ 'l],pom,mnsid__:emr[tlon [of :r«.;~prooal beamt_t :I_R mvmaall :01(1 8!'~1:1 _:1,~.._ ,of the, d:H" o:r ~·--,t,act' of' de]~'bemfClD 'wberei1!J,:' the: '"'"' ..~ ,a8_,"_,_,"_, .. "1_"" "-"t,~,,,".t '."_-_""'"_,:, '_"'_
'wV1e'!liaot
't'~J be"[I:~-"c:~--Jl -'.~" ~. o ~' rt)r"'
, ,.,.'" ":J.'
Beoollld~1 muld,ef ,the ,dm 'of tWI d,octdn,c:
:'\"li::,(L.,er I~O ',>""::"">::--,~"' '~::~ ...,... I' 1ft :rd~~"~"~ ,praltfYe ,LQI1JJ_UlCD..~
:__.:.
p[ I
,U_.,'!!Iiii_,
.~'I'~'I"'J,i..lI~j'!in~'p,::~~~:"'" ~.b9":_~-'I--I;"~ . u~_" ,"'1''''
:aceount: of
0' :Ibmy'
~.liil, "
"l~~
'_,
'."
I,'
ua,
[oomRqumd,' iam o'tll~ptory,,, For 'w:ber.e :Ihuty, c~"

'~~~I~@~'L
",""",, , " " "
f'~''1'1-:m~'~' .. ?:tr (, ~r-I}Mn'pl ..'''Ja-'

_"~~'~-I
H
'W1-~i!1 [r".": :lU', " -
VlI:,
l-D-":~~'
,. _".'
I~~-
,F"-'"
ft)' ~ ~, D'" • :Or-ID~D'.

'''!.!', " _. ..
lia,
,100
mH' :"[ 'l ~~-~l ,- " - .,
-·>=-':0" !~W-J,~".I. •• "dI, ~ft;n-~, _,'!I"" "';:"1.' ,', !&II!II
1Oj't'b":.'I~~I"[I7i.l~:~n,~1 ,~~,np:.. [nn-'I"C):1 I'~ 'lit' \1,BJjI.,· tt r,~," ~:~m'_, '1";!!iI!...~~ ''''~I,.... ~l'~ ,;:~~~Afi ...'n..' 'oit'!\~ ,oitL~ ~'1 .~. m~~ftlii" .. O~~,,",,~ ,~~II.H:+~ [DJ W-v'.....,..~.jll." 1~1"'_"_iIIJ HI."" ~ Y_iMU_lIi,'\;, must: '1IIBOrYG 'I_itlhm' the, oovenmte.rs[il apaciqr' n,ot;'to' pDu,.~~, or, 'l)).,.~e···· [lik),"·J1lv'. 'm:-,"iiI'iiiOl,:f' e:".~.. ~~,U~g ·:;1". ,~;_~:i~~I~, ~t~11"r'L~,'w'.", i",C." ~;,,,,, * ,' ',-[a' n O'L:!![ Hb~~,,~ ="~m.i!i' ,_[~"" ~ ,P"I.~~"'~"'iI!~ ~i1i"', [I!olll~
1J-~1~~_I~.I_~~.~U~11 .1_~Cfl'll.J"U : Ut!
["':J"
I Ii
,.~,
[Ii''''
iii
~'!tII!"
1.,/11
@'_[!'nn,." .... ,I;;;JI!I ~.'\O!~"III .... ~l-I>Rill;~,
I,-""_", ~[~",
[~i-~,
•..•"".
,their :not; peaoJ1BiRg;~ ~It:rvl~SWIjthml!~~ Bt.' [aJVienlndn-l'~ : ,that :1,mB:O is 0.0 'lnnrpr' :ab'l~ net [talpmrfarmi .A:fty.": '.U.L~,,wirth ,iii!!:
,,~,\ ,.;iiIJ"'.' -, - '; "'I';&" !lrll~rU, ,B,W Of
ti "','
~Y' IOOqMlmJ, iniptdimmbi,~' m. 'Iit&t rIIl11fJ11m;: 'which :riaa, fmm, CODtdCt' (:B~ iiit. '[p.. :1-CMJ:')\t ,'or 'the, :Iatler' 'W~ blkem
3W1l"
fjtmmlJy .at.al betweem;t"fwtll' [abllJfIIitm ,.'.. 'w:hm, :Ulmtty'

I ,"
l ,na",~rell,
''''''''ili'-',:t ",
A'~",~·, . /"'.:L, lUll; ~UIi~VUon, :-H"~",~~",- ..... ",:\WIry \Wi,IUI,,~,'il.." [11:""';:.~: .__,o,u.ua, ,.~,.: eonI~"·'
e .•
rcdllftiS,
to
;1, ~ea
[of ,die :fmmer.:1 .AW,I¥j ":lndeed", 'wi,tn, :aD
1'IIDIttd 'Ie.rms 'whiarDM;vmJ
...~~~~.~... ,g BlOObals mncept,..(If ,lberqr"J WI1iIt,,,,,1; ~~.~~.~ .. ~.~J:,.~. ~ ~. OilvtO,lU cu:ulidatej, r'eqmlre" :in addition 10 the :BeDRI of :6ben~r e: :~e' d".ed,~ w :d,
19
In, ICif.v~~~ s~iielty' t'bc'law'S, of :oatlu~~'C booo,me civilIaw.B~, Bu;t :it ~is t;ndeat dla1t, :il: is :n,(lt as ci"U ~a:WI; ~ha!t,they' eOJt1eJ' :init1l1 :H:O',bhes,~'8
:m~ra1,'dte~lry'~
,i;!J ,:
'D. ,-'L.A~i'iiPA :I1J;I~~.J.I~II;.,~ilJ ~',
Hobbes;
I ::DI ,1'1" ,.Dlilll,... II·
u-
,.;L,~ ~'atlfllll' l":_I;I~'It _:'gi~
'n-'ii!t;ii;;olii'~ [~.; [','__ I;~;
;i!'iif"~
of' OO'lr' ObU,PltiOO; 'to ,obe,' IGoelL We Ido' nlit: Ide-DY tihal: :Hilllba
!Ii ,ii, 'E' '''jI"'!.,.J-I'o- -p. ;iI!Wii ~ ,iillL, lEI., ,il '''"\J' - -""II :~., I
.',;.
:iSi dLiv,ilnc:ta,W$lJ, ~:deli"cr-ed'b,' 'God, hi, :hol,' :~pturcS' ~~' P" r';iI'!i;':)'" ,~ -..jl A'L.;~i:,(!J'\iIii; n, :>\11 ~U;~.J~ LftI-~~U.iliiii:l;.J:r""iinl!i:IIl '~-lla'liI-1 '!to·... n' [~-UJ-"e'~-"'~:n''liri~'.';iIIi; :~I [LU1"";'LlI_~~ lll_:"~Jg lli_llr~:J/ ~_I;.J ",J~a~lIll~~U~w
n.iiiOli -~'I!' ,it" ~~,
'i•.
t,
8"'i!I-oifi; JI~,l~
;il"iiif-~ ~'U' _IJl~ l.r~_~_l14cml 'Lv' ...oJl,"",~ [u~: IW" -jill'!d\A '~I U:,i
"~la-""'i;!1i'
~IL_l,"
D,
i!I
~.·-W'~Iv.--'ll~IJf
·.Iiriil,t:'
~:I'V'
1'IA._ ..
".~! .. ,
'n~,
"'iI~;ILA a-II".,
'n',~~\I'
._r_~,~,
the 'l!-iiIIo'ft ... Cc:'a~A-iZl1 I .n~ I)·~."[II,,-=~D,.~-~. ,!It~, ~

1['~ -
ft£' UIt5 'f- ~1I"i!11i1i'!Ii •. 'i:n,t!'Ii1 vll: ,.J1!..,. r~,~·,,·luJVU:U_~~

1
~1l1Ii1-II"1 '--:--:-. ii:"ii~.~ ;'11" ...

~:liiliili
iII.,·' __, ,m.V,r.i!dllt 'Il!!IW!~·d:'

- ...... _.i
-~!l
,f;" .... ,~
-,~I~.~:eaiI. lii'!\ii!'io_·,_··i"Ii."~n-~~II!i;. '!I1U'I!...:. r"'·:~t.I'· T.~ -~r.[n.I'\.'~ ..- ...._ 'I, :u!l.i&---- ~U, ... ~.ir"~ nJiU.~iI!iL n"""UUg"t
~" '.'
·~iftl!!l.la.ttu111 :u·e: ilJ.a·poIlttDD to uiF.:I,Weli.r,IlY 't :e U :' ·uri,*J1l,.., ,wc_'IL~:""b''-': I"H~'Jv,DUG:I I.:IIU1~HlJ]~~ j',n!1I...'k----1 ,a,'i;-'iICfD"·~ ·1!'lf-.~~1~1, _-,11I}l-~ ,~ .. _II
,~ ;';1:.'" j,
".lll
h loo.neepm~,1 ~_l_ll. , ..... jii'
.amiij'L'l'iUP.
--W""~l
n.·.,·-,;~fh.6ft1!,-· "" !!I;!I!1i,~""~,~)
'We: rna,' add, f1Jrtbe.;r. 'd\at,t Goo :3)9, iau.tkor ·of 'tlll; m'm,~UIl!:-. · • st: 'be~:lwIlU(f' abo, of' ·tbe·eoadJi,t-1Qlls, of' <JUII' p~tion.!, • 10 thJs, sensei, ·tbCD1!wle :ma.,' ,t'bl-nk ,of die: :P(F,iteq,to: IU_ ,those, eondiitltlmS :3Si :~_rt 10:£·the aaltu~a1 .law of' jGoo~ 'th!lu_'b f'JawJ
'b iL ,~,I,e:re' ...., ,rr:13.'I1: -;~' -.. lil~; [oonnecuO;n. wu ~'I ,10Ii.
"'b -"....::"
iI!Il-1
j!i&'Ij." ~.
-- "-- ·~it;L.~; " ,.r A.·'; c,'
SCDse ·~'ha!ttt.e' :la!.w!1 ,of .,~brfSl:,cs,are ri3ltu:ral dietcrip;tm,¥~ .principOOea:!, t :Ho(b'ba:t.:1 use af' 'tlile label, :1)8,"" [o;f m:atUII.t :0.0' mnlibt :reftGdi,
','~.·,I"1>.-11"a~." ~. ..,....!: ~~[I!."I·. Olld. ,8_ "~'i_'iI" 'CW.lUi. )!l,oYU!.
b"'."• -
_~
'"_"1 ~I'ii'--, .·1'. . ,l!L,,!l,)Y!I"iiII.~,~

a·' .
p,.... ~~J.~"t"u.,., ~ ·[;i"!i:';'Ii:l.iI'."~ii~'1!.
'W~t!';tl, "Ioo:mmanu,'
"--=-.'. "\~'n_' ,PIi ..Yt!!~,~~ !
-- """ - -.Jjji
,i:~1
'~'p;:-.'1".' .
,I'
~"
JIl.
...-,~-tC·~I ,wws
U',I! ..
'lii'ftl-liili~l~~1 -.' "
''-1'-~ ~.~g,~iIi. I ,;i;.I·;~·L, IUt"",·
thne '0011sild,em!tfODS
~i'~Ai.iIUIl
as;
;6,,,,..,;;1..-
We 'tum. :now' 'ro t'blose~Passel., in which. :H~bb'es .adiOd~;,.

[;i"i;,f'? ,;;.'ii... '=-'_I~
U.IJ
wen. ..
'~,t'Ii;i_~ """'~' 'i'II1~*ii'iIi'ii'P .drilll L~~g·"·~, [U'II.::lhCil~,IJ.~U~.l~ ~ ,-.-'IJ·~II~I~~,
oonvmlen.Ily
w:b!ch. IOO,:I.eer.l,[OilI' ,ob:l:iptiom

:[~r~ :Ilwl teo ,emrm
!P.' !P. !I!
be ,d~.ridoo,.;10
na,t'u_fC1," '" ~ ~.:
nassa;ga,m [1:1.-.1.-1 .... ,.V r- ,hr.; .marin. :IWI!PS~, Ike 'irat: ml'
I 'lll~II.'· _ _ .-_~
·~··i.~'_!~l
o'b-, "i11~,iiil~D' T·:i...~
'lO
:keecp le.o"em".~
:P.~f·'I_b,e':~aw of'
__ , '1I'J:1l-'~~ ;11;1 ["l[ltirliY'"-if,oiI1 Il.~,~ ,~;jl~ ~~~,2!~~Jf~~~~

~",.~.~,~
, , _ 1.lIIO:· [.,.~ ...... ;l1 ,j;-.,n, ~iIi,.-;;.,-. 1!!1 ~ y.~. ~'~·~""-@w.t~ I!! ~~ ry.'~'.'.:
~""
o'btdi~n,ee~, 'w:nen: we
j
w· '10 iup ,«mbw/tj~, land ,th~

i':--~.,[~-~~_~~~-. .. ;, w~ ~"'I"'!"'~""-r- ...iII ~ __
IH,I
w:
b,.", mve_ted ,,'(mIUa.. ,

-e-.._"~~
:~~
11.'...... '"',
~~~~
4f1i'~~","'riIIi' !I;lIM(r"'·""!I!i!'l!"'"
,~;=-!'!p.l~~,!!!!~~~~~.~
POWlrf' titll..~t: I,' .....- - ~[I' [!Iio_~_t_g._

:"!-~"i'
iili
''-!L'":. ~_lI_m1
'i""'" u.~tl',~'If-~1~.Y,~n~ " ...... -~ Ii""" - -']' I' ~,I1_'J_ ""',I! _ ~~ ~a!.'W'S
,~j~, ,~
~:Ii" '.\.' !!I;U,'!I.ii ''V.. ~' ,,!!iii"~,J'
rn~~m.oiii~ii;'.
iL'"":t~~ ~l~~,~
~iit, .j:.:. llr-,..-~_·IJ,I~ 1rnIti':'iirl~:Il;'II~
'!i"ii' :t,'7""'",J'L, l~~ Ut~,

@ '"
'it'Ii;'~I"
~~~~1
~~I"lIirrjj~~":'I" [iiil"f' _,U_;my,. '!iiI[Y,'!.:I!',IiI. ' ' ","",, 'F;oIjjI;i!'" ..iW.-~ , ,~.~:"' ,ii!:i<,'" •. 'L .. ¥~,
,~l ~.,
'I'~I!UJ'
"
iIiIatuft· dJd [~'b:Qge:in ~,1!tt~bJt~ o:E'.DltUirc:~ ';'

: :,"
_~j~ __
.... ,iI!!iiil!t
.~~~
.•'
~' i":
~
__
,~~~. ~l~~~\~·~
.•. 1"":'1""'" :;:io,'h'!I"' ~y.~, ~ __ :o~it-i",,""

•.~
.II,~.{!!,!!_II •.I:V.~=-'!] ,"~
.~ +-"1"1 [olI:;,
.
"'" ~._,._.]
"
.... ' .~. ".
'!I!;_.h_~ '"':i '!""'~! iI"', .... ' ,_i!II!!lp'n!J~
~ ~'"
~
,......._~. 'iIIi'ftfi.cil'liit"·· l~'~ ...8~ [~_I~,~"_IIJI!·._1

~=-~ ..•
~t:--riil!i!I;':If.- n~!II!II[lDa!.;jn'i[li l~"1~ "I.'. lr,lJl~-.l.LL'~_~~~"",,iV
n~ ,.'~~ II_R'n]fII! '~h·"~"'nl1~ii:ir;CiIc ~"\1lii.~1 V"tli, 1I.II1~ tJ. _~~IH~.~J]·~Jl~CI!

!Il,~...
:;n;CI1 iL"""~.I;:~D.· l- __ ..... lUlil .~~. ~~!.~.
~ta5n~d' __
'1':ii'I; l'~il,~i ,_.~'J,jLoij;;
:."1~~'c.jll ~~~ .'..i!!t'U' ~"··I-'~j~tn'-n··nt, .;1;:'1"" [~'hf"~ '~v ..","-U~~ . ..I v_Ii toJJ1.... ....I,~,J '!' ~.~
{~mi. 'biNI.
'tille clwl. kW!~(B;•.W~:hitt. :1111. :1'90') :

iliiiBv' [;ijOI\1Ii:~tr::;"'n" '~iri'i' ~~I]~ w-~-.I.~~r-~.n..I! .•~1-11 Uy~]
lU:~'
of'el)ven.t~ the :~aw' nature: oommm6i olf'

~:~, ,~~llllr.'·!IiI'-' V-!ll~~ll~
IIl~_U.·_',~.~,~.:p.'
·t'~~,'t.:I~·'~ Af;' ,I,f!;:ul, u..
·~I'l. ~n.-Ij;oi·""'-;I .. ~IJ,... iI!'~.f!!.'!!i.I!~,
'~:_U1"
'i... ~'i!.'i~• ~''n''l''fl!b~Q.
'It M, ~
a'll
:P:'QT. 'ai. dv~1.11!~'~ dIal: .,~ba:1Jl f~~dr~id. :~Kn~O:lltj .," " b" D0.t'~.&1 a ,ei.WJ ~8iW'I' ,' Y~I-t'l~"" ~.,.~v ,l'io,~ .~!",jii;~"w' ,ul; ~;iiii-"'i~" n-~ ~;I!."'!i' ,~';"_..'I;;--~I···~I~·"7'I-·L, Vii. !Ii.~lll~ ll_ ]~,~ .. l~~.=-~_~_~.~ 'It'b.~i ~'Ia~n, [0;(' [all'b:~ whi~'h 'nam~'i Qh1i---.P'DH~, if ~ :me.n.:kn,~,w :nm~1''lht;y ~mlDOt know t!h,e~dgiht of' 9imy' :!;Q,W t:h,i@; O'v,cmp ~lh,;. 8 (B;,'W~.I[~~,
l~.~.~l
'pp.. 323'~--4f) ,
,~".~,
_;ilia .~,'~,..-"'j", .1..~.~___1[ ,lJj,nIl!IIII
flipS,
'Il;v '1"'1;-., '~fii~ ~,~ ._.1.1_1Ir. ~ __
lLod.miiimcl~
1,"
'had
.
f~F
'iIi~fil!i;11,oi+i=[ncttil' 1!'I.-U,-t.• _w.~:~ l~~lt!

[~~
~ti\... '.:'~#,V '~·.L~·' ~ ·n l~blj1l" ~_I,'~~ b.IN'iN!i' ..iljI1

~.~~~.!IiI_"''!Ir.""lfi
I~'it--'I"l~ ·WSJ~'
!IIf!',~
Vii,
il'fii!i~fll~.
:(,':!(!'" '[frl'~ ,:;ijl~" lr-r·'·] .. -....,-----./:I' ni:1li "i!I~,Iiji~~\ ~ ,[G,., p.r.

l. l~_"_~~~'
~od ·~o:p~;R; fai~thi'fi.0t: '1)0:1lHp ~n"": D.. . ,..=ii\':~' ,iif.,....··~ ~1h-iIj;· ,_._.~~-n, le ~,,~ . 'M.,iIiL-;- a .--;--:'!WI1 _ ~ ·"'-~!liJJl ,I'lli, l~Lv.'III] l"',~
l'~~''''\l
'~'_"~I A """I .• _ .RlJ ,~, [,;.;:'--:-~l~'
more pen,emU:7;) ~ .ald.~ [cenal. ri,lhm",

~,,"" .nJ:Ii.Js··
1"!.Oi:\l';IiCI, I I!i""I,U.aiill
.1
iI· " ".'
<"0'111 Cl , :,'" a mnJ.;!li~t(CJm,1','fT, '~'[
...~.
h~'"
'wr" .M_81..~~ ,1:-1. l .,:,'IV: i, '~.' II"II; C m:~c m.
11'.'nil!l""! _a_~IL!iO ;,_,ll . al:IIU~
na~)~;~..b:6p:~~~
1
:lflglhli., lob~al,e~ 'It, 'Ut t~p'm;I' 1'0 ~dM 'rbis, up[ '~11the ,elMnl rlta't the, laws of H;,o~~b,~-~.~lii~~1 . of' 'c(a;~~h".[ 'it~'~'~mJ;,t i~,
:ri•• ta~ 3.,";:,a'~ld 'CORIUU1Lt8 and'
m,llr.re ,br~ .R_'fl~'r. il :1;-,[ f.rcl'l 6r :huld, '10 ODI' :la~.tnrQ~ J til ,uid!e of
J
--d"; i:tHAn, ~; 'p/.-.:.~Ai!'""·~ '-·u~'C"o"'· '~"'ee,p --':~oi!I!D~ii1Ii*'",~.dl~1 ftf··~· -..ea,ce ''"''''al nil!::__ig~, .~:>~, ~i[ _~,M[
I~''''~.
i!iii'ii~l
,More
geae.raj~~,~ la[y,i).. , aside of
,c;~ml:':~i
[I,
fCIi'f,~;?i"v' ~-~_~ll~~Ujf
[
'I~i~~""__ .~_~-~~II!J[.-'~~l
I ~-~[,.
.A/~lln'~1 'I:'I~I _'~.rUj ''Ufi!\i,i '~:~;';Ir~, V·~ U ~~v

l lUil.~.
d.eflll~R' isl . 'b,cilTlu ~H~ohbes'[9 oonduaioMS .. e :aR-ected~1:if''we

... "' .·.'tl ..,....... ,....... :rCl,p~: 'l..:t:. ~. ,...,.......... ~ C--'cc .~)i"",, 'L.lJi] CoW-,.'.~;I:___" 'w~:a Ig~iL'!I! ,miS] ~JgUJ WQIi~ U'i '..~ 'La"oj, I.. /~i -'I~i~~, ItaiGenteflt~ ,And]' eletlF.ll,' his 'OOlLlmEioB1J, are
comeilBS1Dui amJd :ROI mati'~I' [WDtZpt¥ail ,di'9t~n,ctiiFJIlI~1 I'OJ 'b" ,,",~'.'n,QIQ.I, lOr. CilIGU, 3JJUUJ" ,WJe .l.ll.l.CClllmfJY,"'.'WfL, ..... 'W -. ,.us~ '.' -'-"_..1 .... , .- '".' ·,..... AI··il.·..,.,~·("., ... ....-. L '-'~n'. ~.,~~~, , ,Je ,"., I'~·-·+, ,_.ave· ,_i '~';".
,!I;',-,-·.c
w/hoae 'P;D~'
:~DI:e.~I.
:m in, IdldwiQ'I.~.': ~.Grai[ :3!od,',r,r'~ltdlta'i W'!, ~
iIi"~;jj~n ~_Jl~t.~
·fio;fl[ 1~:PI:~~ ,,-~. ~,']' ~I
'8:' 1'~\'~7-1 . [~~,tUIllW~,
,;:~ ~ m-" 'n~b s··~~ic - ~:It ~'. ,IK!! ,a, I.• v,r.~ , ~,~rale
::;bl:!I~UDI'I
ubt~ptillm :nDt: 'to ;e'bem alm[ ltans .(i':0o), 't'b8i!t. OOiV1C'nlJ4tt~,A'n.d, 'we ma'ke '~kat 'eDVUUID!t in, :mII16~1' ,t~lIIt! .mdoJi1a~ :r-cqtd1f1eIU,eolts;, of 'the :~ar.w,(d' na)tu;rt,~,
.0'1:-.
~ ~ia~ in~d! ;;.;.~Jeh ~

I.: ,"'." '..'ur
tmt. d~ml ,Our '1'0'·.B~B ciYi~, 'iDws[ isl ',finl' tOI th:-' ]a,ws ·thmms,e!l.v_~, wUrlWtes die~ 0;
~..y.
uses, 'ml draw :iUi 'OOmCbI9iD1JJ~[ aa we :ba,¥e :saidil ~u ,aRd, iii: 'wijldl.ut IIddU~I' bwmwiltb 'd1Ie~n!ipM9 ba~, 'ID' 'm,e o:b.... ,
~""tl!Iil ·f!n IUIV!l~iiJ, ll_~l ~~.
tl'--;';'~~~"'~I""~.~.'~'.";~'ifii., ·,t~ "1·~~.I~ifi" .~!';rr., ... :' L ,~Rtl!pl.fWtI'''"J''~~,lII if~~J!~,] ~
AA~.;Mj," ~ug:~J O .... ;JI
;_1
~[·"·-n._;~: 'N pa_ ,_"_'Y'~,!lJ~

·-:C~.. '~:iii;
·.·'~.,n.·I·-,.'L.I~.~1
,gU. ,Jilt! '~~.~ 'Ik.}I··-;::, U'. 'iiii~~,,";, ._~.
:'~,:"',:
Uf
~Iii'i:;m;
l'l
,"IIl~l
·w. ,A ·d,:"liI'j'i[ =- ;U. -:. ;lll_~~llIl '-D·~.t·" ;C;nA ';:-0'

I" I~ ._" ~ I I~- _-
,~'i,.;;i!iI.D;Iij;
'r_[I~
massages lr~' ._>::_ ,
_.IEIIJ~I
lunv
real. ,gb~:miDn,'1:0 ,ou'r :imil~J:ir(retaJtiocm;~ 1-, .l r,r.' ~l'J: ~nd, I«Ulpl of' :paa.sages[ eo seems· t'ke ,o'lIliptioms ,(Jl'
.~c,m¥Cmpi.
cWO
'6r.t [elccled,; 'ttim has ,hel :pN!U~[,0:)1" hi. 'm, [oltdia;ed, Ill:J' '.,~ l-~:' 'oltul'e' m..'···.·m¥ide. 'bv' ettail)l~dt~na' biI[ :1U~ftSIQ;f'· 'l~' '~HtA '~lme ~IW [~f ~~~-_-_~,,~-.. _-_' _"_ --'-,F~ ~-_- ,_-,_,
him, tH,t;
~_~_j
. ~:Bu~~1'~lh ,n~ji't.hat[~. ,gj,~~ 'I.U:MW~,t;y~l~r
~'Ih!-[d~o,f'
of,
~'.l.'""'t' IIl_'lIQIl ,:t'~~,_c-.ill 'If-,-.:I [~_Il~_~ I£U_tj._~

",~I:
'~·,:."'i..;t: : \i-~ ,--:-> l'lUIUIu&1! ... ';-:"'-d'l~:'~1 [mf:-;-'!'-::,~"I DDL.~bOn~~, .yg WIt" ,IEfW:~ -~~~ a \:~ ... '" iii~. ,PO,'
:~~:~I
I
1-
•.
,.,
_"i:'~.,dt~
••
tljl
",~
...
- - _- - - - - '.
'
-__
~. _
t ....
- _- _ -
,.
I~.l
ee
~-U_~
_~
[m1iI'¥~-r-.-tt. B~ ~ ~!!!!'~~_~~IIIr.,.
'WII,
'uutal wi.1} 'the .vmip, ~pGw~rl"[ :n~l:y tb,e 'pfKI!J~mti:Qnl ,of ," [lqJ~ [oj' .',~lt/~; 'ID 'wJl.i~. ,k :iI Qultigal l)cr '11mIllY; [.f' _Nrc,,[ :.d. '~JDI
~n.d~I,'I-_ ~=nt '~r tQl' ICi,~j[ 'W 1,1lI,60:r'lo:f 'tbt: :lilW'~,and,C~0[:gnll¢i ~--' IlUm~. 'iDf' [iiL'~ ,3j~, f~l':~ '~&.; R . I,DI uu:t p., ~-"~l)""
ii' ~,
ITile a&laB at: 'thI;
"Rip~,..CG~m.moth:io ·w [cnd;~M:r wlridh he: '~ . ,~
,~'9,.
'i[ ",'[\
fmll'!l' 1~'II·nU~I·'~ l_I~I-~ l:'li~ ~-__ ~'~-~l ~"iII~'_',~_~IEI."

-
,.'Ii...,., ~_I[m
'.>I! I.!J,~'
,other :haDd~,o:b:lplioD, ~iI, mplumlzed;1 but in, eoD,~ex!U,w'W.c~h, e :dlg,gm: ''tHt, nJftO'.aI, nh:ttptinn. :UI in "uatioo.'1 'rile. key p.~'
:81,&1:
,.1:::
,'I
,«,.. as :8'pl-Cf,. of ranDa, 'o'bJiptiDni~ ,t'hftl,

l,';OW
~If 'we
:IM)!' '[treat. [ublpliim
:m, ,'6IfJ :idmtOl Huil

'WIt'
[cJim:hmlte
o:bl~tilln :10 th_ :passqUI 01 jD,esamt~ 'dilL ~P;CII '•• M:J' ,that~'we M,ve: a :mliunail obl'igalluD l'Ol [dD '~ il[ 10m;, 101laJ 'I&.t HDDcR, [cUna,tcs [Of' :lueS(ul&es ,d.l: x~:~'~o'
luuemeIJ t-o[
'~I~:~:i~iI!j;~~1 v _;, riiiD'.7IL," ';~iQ,cIItilli,'J"!, :1·\'4'~;I. ;i~i~O···. ~." ,Lili..QLU!.'~;~"¥~'1i, I~H,,\~U!I,~,~ ell!'
'1" -'i" _iplJJen ,~,,,, ".~ ,,-;:1f..
I
I _.~.;~ II _
mil:, 1II~~y
iI~ I_'ll
:'!'if';
~~tr"": ''''I'~''I<iIom·,-;~:t li'lI',4i !ii~,~ [~u~.Ju ,~~~ llliu~IU V~ II_~_I.-Ul iI~IL~J ~JI.i~
:t,ent
:ku 'two Dlaom,p i[nl~~Lrtw,~Ded:=

l
_~?:,~~I
,... 'l-Jtiil7il4;.,.~ J llJIU'p--o-~~,~",~1
'~.&jiIi1
~-~l'!lll!~_"
; . '~'~Ii ,[lIi.cUlfll,
I.'
.-,',
lAO [ ,,,'~,~ "iliI,e
:A~*'6.m·:';if!i;,~I -H':,4!,·., '\Va, ;fI'.ii'~'" ..

l_
:~! .. r:'1[-~-"" '''iii[ of' ---~ nl~::",ilim'e'r~U·"!ii!llli.a",U11l!!I!_'~,it'~

IU
iii
I. I .~•• , ~ ~,,_,~ ~-. _'. ".", 'j'.
nhrasM '''in ,iih,e_ ,~~l ... u-_ ~~~.

E;"'-------'"
--~
~J-~ 'p~[O',ided, ~~
'b1i"'Wmtf.lduI~ 'wb,ol :S'lIGW18 that Ho't,:bes,

'I~
pe.a~'" ~'~\;;I ':"~'--""'I\[ :i.1 ~ ,~.iii"f""-'~~ I __ _,~ "~J'!lO!'.~W [1_iII.IIi1!"'~1 '!IL.iY.liI.U-,UtcU, ,.th, an ulllQpikm, to, pWbrm, 'speciii~:IU:te.f,rud, :dmu WLhiCh 'ddl law. «f' DlN_R! ,~~1!I,RlIi~d~~ c~__J_me • am :btdi~.uat,[~:itI:.;r"~"B~.:~\o' [ !J' ,Ir-~'~=~ '\] .J~ i'i' [Ohl~n; itO a :IJIltml,[C!lf'II,~t l'lt:f!irp.mted :and 'Id_m:_'_~~' :b:y' thCi
1'I_,ii.,-. ,~[., ,~
1,'I,:;I! ~[""'Iiji;d.mffil"'iI~:ii" !I!!'~!I! _,,~'~~,

,~!
,loG!
L!l
:iMlltddl.la!, ~
L~ '.: . ,-.,-. " LV.
J
[.',,mmn fl'Lf::",~J,..,tiiIi:i!, 'I-~~i, -[" .~~,~,~,

gn.!II
llal,U a'U-'nll~_.l
'(_'/Oto tIm'IJUD)~,:~; m'tuat~, w.itb,

~~c.Q' ii'li'i(i[
QlIU.-._n"
'to' III
'tIRd, 'bf~ m .. ----,iI'~

:IIM,~bJ"
JQ.f'OI~I
~:~
uteml1 :11;, I'.. --[:~'~!l4[~.., (T·~T!~hril"mntr.af;:MB~'~ aid,:to 'n..,¥\iR1 ----~--~ ~1U'DlU1I'~[~I"'" '\- -~-- --~~- --~ -"-.~ he -. - ,. ,r-
lEl!.I'
~,'.'-;-:-".iI:"!'ii'i.. :!1I, 'If"iiil~~!ii'io ~ltill""',~,,~, ',dJ IIii !II..I:I ~111~li~L'JIJ_._iU 11_1;1I_IfI:Y'III_I, l~M! 1!!~'.~J'J1f~lIIl ~rU
.';'"'~-i:'"
AI, ~ ;,_.'-,JlI.':ft'd,_-" ~_~
I amRa' mUnin.l' ,mr' 'b [~Rlli41i1;'1 [mbUptHUllit: [t~lh HOO.~, ~ :nM: Q. dl\fiCi ~ :b!~IU~, Ill,
't-t"l!~
[.n-
'men~'i' wat; ,t'hey ·o~ghtt:t[ [d'ot iDt1! w:h1: to[ I,Nij in rqard: 0'1".01 didl!'. 'th,1; ~ '~O ·00 MaO:nrwultJlI;" 'that :b~'m 'til' m~, :~~l :pfillCM :.d 9Qve~lfiJ,:a~'l]dles.:;: 'lbN: 'bd~IJ'fi~'
iI!Ii]
,j:nd
dle
l~
:l.w'~~hli. diaat,ah. ·t:o· mfll: that :u.ve> no, ~
p,vef;iD~·
:UlOI'b,tr;t ~d:
[Ii)l!gi~,
.I~.M~ .lQdh,~f':thm~ . '~hligG :.lnlhi[(l~ ml m.~ ·.1 .. g • [God!,![ 18, .he :11:'I'ihl; Il~lt!hJo:r of :n:l:litUl~'~ "[e' __ .and, in, l~: ,of' the' I'IIT:Ic: God;~:18, h :g, Kin_. of :.;It1-P~~r['C I:~J"~ (,E.,'iV@ ti.j' 'pp'~3p\5JJ
,~1;II,l!I'~,~1
....... ~_,,'
~'i'li
~.' ;~!'~"
. '. ~~!!
'~~~I+'
.dh:~ 'W:~·
~~!',
'~,...,~" '.,
.~
!,"'~'~n~""!I!~~' l""'IifiI;,'I~~,.,''ijj.'~, Oiir!~.. ' [~- '.,..,; ..... !I;,I'.~d.:y II' '!!"'.U..,Ii,,,,", ...,., "'I'll,
4'~,
!I!~""~ ~.~
,~d' [a!
1i'",·i'O..t'. ',-,' i- ':'" il...[.~.~ •. ... ~

i
n:.~:~.~.,[.:.I'I]
U~,
as di.v,in~~aW8t 'the IIWI, (If [du~:Kl~1 ,of ki'Q;p~:r. ,the' absence of ,ciril sOOety' '1'111: '081" w;ay' of iftterpretimg dl.e ~a',ws01:' :Qa.re as, :Ia;,ws, iI[ to' COD;.... , aida:' ·them di:mru.~' :11a'\VS(j'Q'b:Ugi'D,g' as the ,oomrun6 of' 0,00" and, ,mffJreed :iD, ,the eoaseienee o~'t11u~; ind_itv,idual~ 'Iwbere: :mot~ :rIlIR" 'brut IGod, '!~gne1!D':"i'T:o say d:l1s, is D,ot, to, dleml" '~m.)t,in 'Ib,ei :sta~e' ,of :maJtD;re ttJlte :[laws Illf :rultJllfe are :pr'I'mariJ, [al~(JJ1al :pmcepb" 'Tlmt: 'lihey' ,a'l!o o'il:lige as, 'Godl's ,coMmandl :ml, feiMoree 'Ik.,,]
Tile la,\VSof
:I1lfltlJjrf'e' o'b~ig~~n CO(fiSC[enee
!!!H'!I!' .#' 'I'
the matErial :IJevt'~dlfJ~ p~-nblem, :is bJI shaw ,t'bart '.len 'Hve su.ci_~: 'mmc!:WboD 'to'-adhe-lle tto 'the OO,l'enmUJi 'whidl .~' ::!~'~-:! ~-:'-I'~I ----- ~':"n'- ,~,-~ -,< ,-~--~~-:~ ,-~ ~ ~-\I ba,_~ IUil[~u~nJtmD'U,~,atlnll,,for.!lJfU~~l_~g'l ' ,Just ~ua,~; ,I,IBam, , has coftflmted ~:o pedorm ,$om,e' :=!lc[ti~Ull\t.it (10m; :not :fo~llow
~~I~ ~ ~~ [~'~
I~"\~'~~' ~~~~ ,~~--~

'r;I,." U_;_le
'~I
,-:
-1-·
""b-'-Ia~~ ~Ur.rna· , . _. !Ii.JJ[ ~~C1Jj~'I':r~i[iii _,IIlb.''':I!.iL '~1f;Q' '.C~lm:I-~' '1i.11","" W - - ~ :1"0[-- ,v _r~b\,
[u, ,
,cDii\~~: v ~['"~
[tDVIHmlt
'w1I~ be 'fu_~I~b!d~ 31Dd, to thls eJ:,imt. 'IDe;:,:n:J'hlaJ. [of iIli~'I![~m' I'['f' '!·t-' ~~-~-U_~lll~~I/ ·w-"'I-. ~l ... met ··".<'~l.lllif... .1,.:~.1,', ~a'~ll b . -:,~. [iIIi,'i..'ii':'iInir.u-·' ,;t;"b-~:" 'm--n' A!I!'.IIIio [.~J./. tIf~'~ ~II~',"" ~ l~~;JR. R",~l ... ,'Ilwdl;-a ~ :mutj,V;lJte;J. to' !w:l:II: ,tbe' (;ov,tumts·they :ha;ve 'been, im.d~dr'
,1;1; '~":~I I;
1-, ':'~';:I '0 ,pef,l,ln:'ftl
I-DIIIf"~ '~m::-: ~'<I!ii wilil-, be m44!~\. ~J[ :liI.~ ,.'.' . !I:Mi ,-:l 'I ~IR~~e is :-.:.,-;~,*jva;,'~~ ,_mJ. '~\'!--e ,iilCittU'D.,,"~, h:; '~~ so nUlu~, '~,1[ ~J1Jr~-;;-1 lUlL ~
- - . - "'""~
!!I;.--'I,o!', -
,iliiliiL'U'P
"'"~''ii'i,
-';6
,I ~I ~ ~_
~1
:m,otl,WYIJ'm
tffm;,
ulu:lertake', then, tb,e pr-ablem, of' ~ri~ WlI be Idly RU!II'~At tJm'lS level, ~hf.ni''we :~a;ve 'tlle~'prlfib:I:em. ,of' 'llWm.~
'to:
:Hfilb'llCS presellb
.e ,eov'&:_mUI hj,e;b ,tbe,'" rn;l,Ye ~luli,ciemt:r~m. w

dl,l~ :p(F.o:blem, :if1l;
Co
dllS :i'D &tiSI d_IIion. of iii 'ill.. ,I; ilJtIi Il:llIl ~~.", ~ 'L.·'~·b ~ "",,,.III 'tl~' 't~e ~,'OO~,[ [~,.G li1" :iU~, ppl> 1:,3:2F'3_)\~wll~dlL',we','aMm, .r~u'~ 'I' •.[~,.~ ,UlIt we :Ib:,()uld r.1I6b!~iimm,ed-ialJllel~y' dl!lt~,ilmpo,dID,t. :as I, foatlll l'tal:enu.t [of'dlle :pl}ubl:cm, :is, :in,:m.-m,gc'lea;f' ,the' :istlle8, .voJ.ed~,
(u,rRY'~anli~y[!is, itt8elf
'ws.,.
[tD'
uftdertakeJ..,
:lmTI,~ '~'
'W'it'. ,this a11¥9t 'in 'mUnd- 'W~''piroceed
:p~-o¥"idesno s(Jlg,tion~
't-Dl
[covenant'" 'there ,a'Fe ,then, :£ou:r' pouiDlte~ outooma,:,
rmso~:~"9~~~t;:~':Pe~~s~~ 'IB;'~BJt«' :i~~~a, ~ ,A,~~;d.
dt;¥lfJ:O,'
the pr:~b_...
,4'" III but: not: ,A~keeps fhe ,oo'veDJam;t.,
:~:~ tB. ,A ,and D, keep th,e oo¥emant:. & a, 'Neither It ner D, .l~eps,t[hie mven8D!I.:; ],.. ,A.,but: nut: B~ :k~ the 'oo¥eJ1t"llnt;;
'W['e' :now' aoo,l,)t a fH!' ,rn,~talti,o.u~ [derica~'w:b,*, '~R; :is -l~ifici,enJdli1' _~ ~~"~ ~~ ~ ~~~ ~_~~ .... ,L~_ ~_ ~""[i._1",\1l:9 ~ St~~ ~~~~~~~~~; ,m,dlj~rted :;'0 't'h~~ ''!m:Itn1~:'I"--:-, ~"~
~~R(A&B,)e':;8:r.md '~iit:is,f'lmsoilab~,e :ror A, an.d :1, ,to mlef' "he

OOlf.'enaDJt' ~,
';'R~' i,_, '-....k-' ,~' ("A-' )' . " -<.] "

-' .' i .,
1,: _.
Ii '~j:'j; ..
~I
i;\ri)-'....~.'!(~r· ~'L'a··'·D·· _tCt*__ - i,~,;~~ \I[~l,, ~l·~.U~I~ IU~I='_~ V-u.:-.l.r-~JI!_I~.e. ~~;/I!i' ..

I,
1
[~'R/Ai')~"~'tIi' I = -"-,~ \ ,III,
d- ~~ '~iO! 'i'lii!!ft'iciifiiinq 'b~~' J~\_ A··.·' ~,~'~ :_'J1IiiIw.r' ·WIl.I~ .. ~.~.!CW;I!-~~.=.-.,:_ ~~r-:' ~-v .1 .._.~ :_).~ ~~I:\!'::DI'rail [~~;t· ,.~~j~QiIj},!I.""" ;j31'~~-:Ijj'A~'~'["" ~n,iIl" A[r, '4f~i~Iii"i'Il.~ 0
,L~H.
r'j;i;jj;, C.~'il. i
[II
!lit,
IIJijII
<'I
,~
"
c.
;l;11i.. ..
,;;:"i.i'Hii.'~[j'j;n.!' ~fl"~.I.I.aIJI.~ [iifi."I[-;iI:o--:-:-:-;-·-_
. ii·
tl
,~}
J:g"
.....
11_
,Iii!;!!
1:,['I;,t!!\Ii,
'"
,1 ..
!!I.-:t(}!.!J!'\;RJ!'!li'.
v1jjl"wmC
78
,
~1 I
~'~""\ P'I'~QiilR;:~:.ei:r;t'~;~iNl~ .1, ,111m ;;-'.'Vlr·~~)~'V"J" ,P".F-~-~·

l
=:!:=::r;.:.=~~~~
[~~:ilof~~~'iiiiI!~ Vgl~~l._:_:f~"~ [~~' ~I,
'~I\-~''~I~~U_~J - ""1I~IJt:b~~~: [~_I_Iw. ~~'~~:b~~i!iA.1 .~ the . - ..N
wve
Md;t~tCOD9i:dc_r'~'kae [ :pmpoai;t[o.:~
:RBt iSO"~the. '
'tlte'
CO.eDaDt,
wo'U'~d mt!'rely IlQi'nrd£iS~ 'he~
If' R(A:)e ,dlen, R(~;)I (,2" +)~,

I:f' ~I(B)e'tken :R(A)I «'I., 3,)~
the ctlRdli:tinn 'tha[t :1, find, '.ni .., _'I "" 'L IiU_~ , _. mi1l,,~~ 'ft[lL~ 'Ilan - ~ .. ,I_;:J i_ll.i19 _I,IIIF. ...:iIL'~l ,~~:o:n J'f' .,.., I~" ,I,~nClemce ,las,:reaaonau;'I"e 'U...L,_....[.UiJj~,
'1;w1'lin'~1 ~~'.' ~
TBe~lime: of thlsl pwr' :~I

Dot :90JI 'thttn, B:
l_' __ ~-_~_ . _~.~' L J •• '._~ ••• ~. _ r.~
wue
L~_f..~ ._ •.••.
'WOl1idd,
I .. I. J _
I, _"
perl('t\l',m~,dilC adi,o;n Mq1!ii!f[ed, 'hy'

Of
",1
l
I [_ I. ,',
'~e mVlmmt 'w'h.emer.' A did
'l1iIot,~__ .; ,-_ so A wrndll, have 'flO '-JI :md, ,,'_' , feas(JA, 't., [eDlm' 'the rOOv,en.m* The IUCORd m,emhef' IOf.' ,the pair' .. :imposes a, simIfatr [ooadtitiom [on r6Q~:uD;bJclless, ofl B ,el1ta~, :il_lft-l' 'IDe; eov,enalJit~ These 'tJtree pftJcpositioftl,. 'we :IUgpl~. PVIC aiD, malJs_is, [llf' :RL(A&.)e'~ ITb., we :"1'1::' D'I']I, Gi""U'b :h: Imu, om~j; ,h' 'R/,A I!L'D) ( 't~il' ~~ '\ d w(n,,~[l 'Oil ~a ,..III ~~:~".·}fo~ ~'i£' ,.l ,,:~'{~~Jp:::':,I:~ 2'j- iln~, l\ 'Ni [(:I, J;~I nu
'_"= _'~_' ~_ ,~,_ , .. _~,
'-J '~' '_-_ ~
me
R(,I:) (:I~ '4)[~

ft!r~~... u 'a'"le v.:~.~ I R~'A&;"~' ljl
,I:
Tite' imt
J
r ,;
I!~I in, die ~,r

jl
••
:ua.am~i~, o~f ~A&B'lkis ~~Il~el 'to,\tIhat R ~l IwJ IIr-1'J ~
~I
I~
p.\.-.
J._ •• \~:~
'~':,,~_~.:['.:
'If " ,J~'C',
,~, i!Q'ieft, 'D" A&t'B'c)" ''.~~'~'>J.~~~ ,At~".':,I.,,:
'R\'kl~1l.."_,
"Ic
,(/. 21}1I 1:"1 '\
11tc um~: la5flmq

loo¥maaD
;88 :fo.l'
esmbUs'hes ,the CfJaditlOD, 1011

l
'.aiding' 'COY e_t8,!, Now' ~QMilda' I_hen: :pro.posit-i,oms,: If ,R(A)lI, ,t'b~n.B(B) (.1,) 3.)~
'"'I-l~ I J"~'Rtl']~'L:1l11~ll '",,;" ,C),,\1. ,4\.,.. 'il.,;:::-- nitA:_"' (~/IC)', ..
1
:1Ii,_,,,
The '._lSt of timl paii:!' iimpM\eSthe eo,ll(Utlon, ,thlt B ,find :m,ut:Uil

,...iL~ ~ - -_-_--~~ ~ - ~- -'11..'~ aL~I!.IiJ(.,re.I1t,ce ~ --~ :~HaU\lie .Ui\C
.11."",.-.. "IIi.Jl'iiiUll --- '·'~'~if1~'i v'~'--iii _.~~ " '~!llt~jajlJ!C-J;,iU, '~',ltbaIfIDm~, J,_
I
w"cre ,Ro,t :St)I~,,tll,en ,I,'would, :6tld it f.\mso[iJa'b~B :mnt to' ,adlillM' :if' A
'~I"f~' , ~L~, 'Hlil8i
,adbaedl~, BUlt: Ihm,
,ldha9ee~ reaBQuble., Tbe ,sooond ,mem,beJ' of'Ilie::pair kaposa

-I : i~'~~I'~' ,a, ~,~ii'ft'!;~I"',,:,,':;:--'dr~.~~i1i ~iU_~_yg: ooJ1. ~11,,1; ~!t ,~-n', ~t.~. ..... ~,~.J .. Yle 'i!lAQ'D~~;ioli;b-:-:11~.,~ ~,I~H._:_
m 'viltue
of' :R(,A,) (2;, 3,)" ,A,would
Bet:
'nnt);
,*,1.,,,,, II.~U~
IA~' '''~:'''h'''e,;.~Q' u'J: '"0, 'iUilU ,-iI< H~I ~ .g
.~I
m,~,lCB_mt~
:J:,t,
~lloo.Mrw: 'ba:w,een, O1J:t:comes ('I:) 3'IlO '(',l;l~,lor ,A, 'benv:·een, aut,.., Wines ,(I) 'and 1(4)~'80 ,that 'd~ieseeOIl,di,tioM,MaJ 'be :ii[l,opeN~l,e'~, Tid!, ID!3;Y' hufeed be: SOl' and '"fie ;sbaU hay~ 'to 'OOmM'clfi' tile
leliixtsl of' :IU,eh. Si!t1!i'IBO.,!, I,'u;t at I'D'is :poig,t ,in our ::mal:ysBl''W~ amme '~'~Ijt, ,tbm! o,p,tiuM,do ,exts;t,~nd ,sowe: propose :Inr OHr A :anal~t8, ~rR(,A&Blk': :R(AllI,)k i[' arnd o~~yif R(A".,) I():~I ) :md, R(,A,), fl:" 4Jl 'andj, 2
,~~I;~,A 1]""
_.gllt be objiect~d, ,tblt~ :1, :•. 1" nat: have' ,the 6:ptio:J), lof
.-:-:'l, R"(II-,--r\t" ,3J!'.'

I'
~---auncral-
..
~~,
'D' .g
- ..~jit .... ~,A ,,1iIU!1Q;:1,_ I ,;;, 'V'i'a]at-ea,
:~
1l:'1' .'
';V,.' ,_'
[~I::.I.
Af~'adiberenc.e' '
c; ",'
"lp_,"
e,l
'Lv ~t.'iiIlIi' [",0-(%;'.,.. n;&'L.. lU,J/ ;U_~}!Iii;'

~~_jl
,A,'~l....""'""""iPib-'-', .i ,BlIi,U_WU. '_,
AtiII;ifi!;'1I ji.!']jf:li' ~__II_I. !lLt;~

'!t;A
';:"'10--."'11~1!_1I~:a;~"Iii'ilWlirJj..', ~t.~ lIMe! • a mlla_ of' ldisarmameDl'",~'
'n. mthll'
c."
~}~li,~_~~J!I._11
~iII"'li.. /••1'11.... "'" . ~
'h::t'Ii~ ~~illiii'ji.'fi"II1 ~ "~oI"l,
Bh-Itrac-t :amai:"I18
...,,.. tlmt,~ ,.e, o:ml~1' nYu, mttions;r :Iod, 'we :s!&an ;SD:ppole: 'that!: an outcome :is feasoaal1fe ,fot, a 'uarlo 'tn ,the 'al~.t, '10 'wWe'. ,it :m ':;me:rmd h~I' ,tbat: na,titlJl., -,,-- -------
pm:IJI,C., [Qf' 'POI' Ttllte' p:urpmles, ,af' ,discusailoA we shal,
:.3:, 'be ,the :PJ'fte_OJt

--'-
'iill,u&tmt8d 'by mc.r'-' 'thR~e pH'ulaB,
.u
'ii"~Q.fin,~~c
c_
'• .A _ .._ lli;v '!!IiP:.a!ilUliiI,
,~i\n'L •• W!!;, ~;~, '"'·,iIi~tUlJ~~
~!I!!=ilJ
'H:~:r~i:IiI~~ ;I;I:_ I~.~,i'~:~n~ :"' llJJ_:_~1 '~;\l~' liro:<' ,~:-~'.,_ ~IJJ¥ ~~r,-"iI~ : . ',.4 :k~btg a, d~ell!t . .f.\eeM~D!t: is, m,d:; bot' •••
'~.'~ftBiiI!ii' .,..-IJU 'R~.: d,-niijii6t~'. ~;F·--~-IIJII-~.~ [!e'~'~;' . ~_UIH'el~-.ll~J
r
uau
'How 'we
-- ---
--
---
-~
-- ---
--"
--------
--
81!Wppose!'dial
'ti'le8e
,.j~-.~ ••~~
,gee :is. Id;sa,d,vm,ita_geous fO(f eaehl ,~n:~nlVj]~G' 'both ,.JeSt
:nauaos, asree that

gllil ~~~~IY~_'_:_1Ii
,1\
'mllI,mail
,;jIj[.~
LlIm~t_II,
that it, wewld 'M' .tefe-mb~e:Iorleu'll, '10 :keep ,sueh, am,,Q;I'''eJlJt

...L ....... ;iI!'V'Ii, '[1--'""'''';1.. ' !l£1_MlI I 'CAPc luu-Uii
,if!'A c'i''''':fi'~la--'t-'\D; ,;:..
1.:;,U,,,,wl:.
,;,..:
J..!L;, !i!liift.l r'Atol'ii'Il'I'iIi, 'M 'lU_l A oIl:~D iWil,U.:' 'lWL\u;.;~~~, iL¥ ."li.. ....' ~~_.;_~~
neimer' ,oo.ll1dden, uni~atetial [dlsanuammt, r.:eastL.a!ble~';: eadh, p,!dm, ,dIe:anna ,race 'be-ml' I)t: ,die m,ercy of' til!: ,othu'~,
'IOOR~
'R-- -- th -- 'COD.,.i· ~Ql&, Ji'-'~ ,!t~ ,re3SCl3l1lW,e,ucs.s 0;'f JMaik'" --; - - b~ - --- - ~~Il..;g , '; I.CDCC: ... ~C - - -(lD -- - .01:' ~Je
.1
r~n;a; ,i_I[g:~i'
IF'Ur!ll'nclli.P '_':_,.:,l~~"
__c:
th . I:~C
[~
B ~ y eheese 'm' ,adibe,c (llr' 'liO[ '~iQJ.le·iR. ,die ~.bt:of '\,rRat ,A, .. dees, ,AAd sin~e:'wn:is)tloll, :iD, dlCSl: oond;idilDS, IS, alwa,'S ml1M
reaaa-na~-Ic~
.~~'~l""~\iei[ · ·1;U,_~.1 .. '_
[.: .....[fi:r~ ·~l~i~;u·[;~i,i~·,~~· [~U"ii"' . 'b~·.~' DIG 1"':J:lr'~' '";J:" ~,-~,
'To :Maike 'I_
,.-'."~~-Ij.-~,.-~~ IIO~~ D
l~ 1 '_' =
ev[m, c·tea:Rr~',.S'1lr:Ppose ·t"ht: [t'ke 9~Jtua!tiuft, :is·of~

·m[I··[:··a·I~;~'. al'I~~: Ai~·'.. :~ , ~-- - _':lll4_~ o.,__=I~
l_ I
is
I -~
,~,'fIO.
l~I'" ,r·~;[,lJj,~
·~~olit.m lIlRJ"-I'
~~i;.
_11_-~
-,., .... ,." ~,'L,ili., ,£1_,,.. 'D
'I~'rf}r, A
,;Ii.~b ,...... a-A'l.D~;i'!io.D .... ~IHIiUIJ, ~_~UJ:I-~(~~I.~l

'~~:~, ,p g!
'D[
Ul '1.~~.JJ11~-U,I:y
'~iOCoAfta'
.1l,.,~L.'C ,"'I..~:DC
,i~ [_~;'p~~_~ Iu~_ 'a'~'I:~'a~ifilllii"",f",,' ~
,s':iih;;a·~"!i;-i~~I' ~. ~ jll_IAiir
~_~_~-~ f~"'UiJ.U.IJ_~1
eheiee .prior 'M,m3i:iDI :111& 'OrWD, dmsio~,

,£~A Uij\'i,l'[~i":A'I!iii' 'ii"-A;"IoGA'IilIi,ft,'b,:1!.[ ~1l..A ,~~IIIUI "-I~V _g""v.l_iIll lil~~I_iML ·..I~ioIl l~JIH1~
[ii"irA,Van''''iI'!Ii/iI~~l_.·l~~_~~,
,:_..:_l
omlY OBG: [of'die oofl£ilitiom, wbich,
[Couide:radDn of ,die' tmnporal, dlmentl(u)~, then, ellmiiaatal

p:r1CV,eoD,
m ':t'~HSi ~m'"i'i:'I:AjDo. ~111,~_.'

r-~\,_)"'~r~lf.'
ean__ 'p-:~~ iWllIIJ_~ .. ~ltl~;i!l4i·~·'if"i'. ~ :and,:80 he too :ma:t

I ,~_,~_ ~I~
~.J1f~
"'n, !l.V
m;iU_ng R(Akl[):k .. 'Wha:t: :is 'w;SB!tiKI, :m mme 'way' [of elimimsrtIDmg' , 'boA, Colutii.QDS~'1 For dt~il,,gi.Veft. :8(,&&B) (',I~[2)j w hieh. mat
R(A&IJe, :£roM [en,-·
'~M'IO-:"D ,i" iii ~ =-TI"H .'~' . '-.' A,iJ"'Ib

lL!.lii l 1 _:
~.~
~'IO'C:'~''!Q'' Rl JI.
-.,_.
be ,.amtt~ if A and B are 'to :hav,er :Iumdellit. :rea!Q1ll,fOoreDterin;g' l inm '.e [OOr,leBIDit, 'eachw,iU [CllOOSf~'~O 'pennm~~ BI~ltB:Obbes,~utmd alittleks the pro:blftD in :a· IiJfermt 'way'", < In tb'e ~aua~' [~'I)o1;,ed. dOH :m;!)t actualll~' 0-11: 'hiilruJ@lf w[ he ro;~ , irJ" tb,e :po:ssibi~ity·that: :R(B) (3'~ :~.)~ ' I:nstead, he [ef~A)[ '10 cenairn. ,iPHS1Q~ 'wh~c~h, lead ,t[ke seeond :petfu,Pller' tol 'viola!'" :bis,
,co~enmllti' :H~,e' • ,•
--~
'.J
,9 ~IltDlikiBp'
~I
,a'bo.t the :reuonahlme.M, ofl the

-
'v,ivlawil.OJ ),t~ 'may' seem, obv,louSI

!Ii'I"iIi['iI~IGi,t~~, ~_~_~u~." _l!L1,
a-'tt '~';im.l,<'JI~'~-III.e: d I:!i;i!!i>it'"~:::,

~_I_~I.-_~~ .
,th_J;1:~ r-ason· as Hobbes, 'OOBmelVe5, ilil ~J~;;i('L'I'idf'JoIi":ii~, 'Ii~~~,I~'r'~"n"!... D,',Ur. _, ~,l···~~~n~~lilt;l~. 'iUe: Jid,.;~:. een... ll:U[ ' ~u; _,
t 'J'il JUt _UI"'_:_iI~I::.}iI l_ 11=lllI_DI~, _iI:II_
,si.dlerlatlolill to tike :pufe'ly,f,oruuJJ'l eaes 'we bav'e. [oomid.e_nd. '.111, ,Car:,'we note that :reastlb, is taken by H:obbes, 'to' :p:tieseribe:
'~'~,~4li1 Uil.~iI'i:J'
.'0"
~.l.'
"m--';j1j;..,,:fID
, ••
mil,
'iW',I!_il.U!:!ii]!i' [_I,ll.
~,...i,","
'don .. (AlcIDlBBO sense ,
:..
etimes: :a, .D. staods 'to ,p'irm,

1f/"I"~GiiIIi'ltt.' 'b':v' '~~"I'o'li~t'-"I"n--:'Q"-~ II;l_~~J.JIQ~.!Q·lloJ 'iii i-V-clhlilj -_- -;~ II
IRa,' &Gem.[mlOUlgb
,o'li;'i;'i,~
~'iI:..:~~'A,~. '~~;iiI"C""'.'~~· ~'b~,'!;d~--c,..I
""~lle.JI:c/ ,mp_iIl. IS,
[""'.~~~
eUII;ili!!',~~!l"~nra~
'P' ·......,.6~~,~~
'me'
'ni"'~~i.'~y.'~ lr·1.1~1Il1
'h.·~~al ~;?;j'~~,p]il';'ii;~nl
</, "
m. 'temll
".':
tOI
,convi:m,m:
,~~t,',tA, :jll!l:: ,go '_-_~'1
..
us 'tllat,
of' :hia, power' .'

Ll-'''-'-
'rho ',pcr,..;~L..!,""~ "6::0-' Wh,~, 'H'oiL.['i!.." [[m,. " seeB1B1 ':0 ~l "'dJ [s:'O,ppoft "." '"· '.;' ,~~~~~, rDnm:~1 nrsr, .. ,~-~a[, ,..!.'_j':"!UW!CS' ~~) ile.l'IL_
~-U~I!fi1ir_I"I_Il,.JM
iIjr't··i1tiiii"i" [~t:+u. 'YIl_n~!Il. ,v~-~~~,.
'to, ,t';is, view',.
It
,
M:O'R,A,L T,11:]B,OR,'V
,I...
I~
I,
- .dl- - -, - 't;!lC!t -'-n;i;:l'~ ,a\f,va:D,',eQ, ~ua' C'-:' ~ ,niC'f!W'ii~'~ __.. 'c;o''':~''''..J,!Ue~~u~' ~

'I;
lIasoJ1l11 HU,I~' 'U;.aIt 'WiOmbOR IQ ;' leo'¥~Rmt J

ii
,,;I
...'1.,
'~1,_
'f'
-, H, 'm' l~ -,;_:all,
his ~pfttHni1Ditio:n,~,A'DrrJj, SOl 'VJio'tltioa

'than, ;adhaeJloo.,
1,,-,'_ -, I - ,'~-~,
... ~ti~1 'IL lOOIllwi!lliC: tol 'w;ilII~ 'tm~,' JI
- __ ca '0-I;fOi;.rriit~-' ~iJV'_"
'il,~:t~.'Ib, 'ft'~<n,
'-""Db-.' :n,~,i~,
,C3'DBOrt
'be mnri:: reasenable

1_I,v.\~,,~ -
'~ W,,:', """laWC,-, ,Rcn _e b' ';--:-,
R(,A&'I)'k"
I~J,,\\&"'-" A-'Ui""'11~~
'R-I,t'A", '~\...'~)--- ,_J!~: ,~,-~-*,"~m.aJ~bY 1~.!Ia!Q ifrn';i;. .... ::i~ cc~,,,_""~D,e u~ I~'.. :8:1I't:Ho'bbes, ,arpLe9 tib.a,t if 'w.-e 'talk,e 'mal~e:dal, ooll,'"
4",\.""",,. ~!I!!lQJ"', .
JiJlQ!i,
1
1i!!i~~I;ilHl'!;lliikA.iIiii' j,
:IIlJ:tds txea, tAo ,m.d~,tiollS, ,R(,A) (I:" 4) and :R(BJI [(1,1 ,3)1 must:
,"'.ii.!.., lliwn§" ,
',"'t!ii'!i.-fti!i!311"lv' iI:!lIJ"':c L "1I:'Ur,,",,,IL 'J ·;'ftlltio
R~.v!Y!~Il_~I!!i;-,
,"-,'~L\llltltn;.'
we
'__ ,
-'
~;ft~i ,.:L'3't' ,,_,_,._JJ!IoO..U CO"("A,'~" 'iiI!'' :IBf1Iiiilii, W'L';i!li'ft ,fti:" E_':J!iX.\ "-,}~ '~-~IU, i\;U_
'because ,the person, :Is: 'UMble te [choose bdlveeo, ,the 'two [Ollnl:..., comes!., A~nd,SOl R(A,&Blk ho1u.,
I, ,.am
"", ~I ,0,
'[L ......I1l., 1W'\lP:,Wt
,.
b-"',0, iiI' "'Id·~ '-", ;

'~I
'" h'~,..iII... ana t~~e '!ll~'h'," ~i;,~~_oell,'~ a o;....i ~'b :'.t.',_:e:cr ta, ~: ,'1'1' laDJk;1 "'iI' 'Olle, ,~~OI!U:zIj
H~b'ha, does :oot (I,eny' tbaJt~:from, 3), :sh,On:-l-efilb :poi:HLt mf'~,ew ~

'L L, '. 'L 'I~.AI ,"' 'I~ ma,' ,J:u~ 'wlib~,reason iil;lat,~~CS\li~O:,lll~' 'nD\aIlt~:so.e oiEiiI ~L~_~_\~ ,
R"ti:i:I'h 'er ,~L~: lnsiil+. ,c_U __,~, ti!l!iie' ito'lll'ii,f)' iii... ~.. 1!.. 11:., d,.' ,~:~'~bJ~~ :.:~ ~c._t_-: 01 :Itl,e:h 'WQiJartb~D.i1liiSt: ;alwa;Y8 be 'expooted], to' 'be' s:u:lle'iemdy .dvem: 'to o.ul:wm~~ :lboJilt...'I~nn,ben,efiJM~ Thu, 'Wli :a_.y . BaJ 'dmt BJlth01!l1,ril :1 ,si'nuatiom in the ,sibort"':ND maJ' 'be I'lepr., by'~ :l1lS1t~: ,of'~:b}e:t'~ bavlc~a~~ild~mtl '\V~ ::In,-,tb,~ :NIl ,t"lhe CQ;O\ed, :rep"esen;t2Uo.n, (:igmDring' m,t, [compliealJOMI introduced, D:J' discussion, [of the :Gmt petfuf.iner)1 :mjDS~: = 'bei
'b'" ""~~
-IiDI
cI'Vlu~~mr"ft ~'J',..,':~Ji~~,
t-'JLI!3'I'
1111 ,it<~ ,~~~~.""'l~~~;~
"C ,,-' '~. [~~'~~"'"
m,,'
~mted
lo~~-
'YiQla1\u
,r;11 "
,I,
:I
'i'Ii!_ ,~,. or.
.4~1
j
-'
:1.081' iii tho oUter adfhues" 'the 'parties, .' :a,lOOV'GIULt. :[0, a. :slh!~ ti.om.[of't'he .type dacriDcd [by' ·~mu='Dilit'Dx 9~h(Juldhave ao difl..., cu~t!IY'in ,co-otdJinadDI 'rdiJ:ir [cho:Ee: 01' aetteR_91 to 'briB_g':a'boul:
l
Haibbes :haSi QOW' pRn".ided a partial 801!oti,on. ~l)' 'the p:fub~mn. of mQd,,,,adom~.StOOl: ad'beR'I1:Cei t'O [CQ;Vtftl'll:ts, must :alw,IYs, be ·apwal. '1:0 [Ullldiuc:e:'tD pJeSrenati,g'.[j :IJ :ma. wb.Q ,r~nl
1
mll!tuail. :adherc.ee~,
Ci:-A] W,IlO ,,;,~,;~'L.-c:l[~~[~[I-.Ji ··,'t~: mD'~uy~ ,aou, .~--c'l.-:;; ,[I 110" O'Vm'l'lu:e_tJm,~. 'b~-:'io,;"rr .. pa!SS1JDB;~ ~,.,_ccu~=en_ ·I,i "':';,,; :":~. 'will :ind ~lfwi~., :IIUmeicRf; m.od,·e~'10 :kttp,:Ws ·OOV1manm~
'~:';·~i~'l-,:};'Jl~;_
,!-, i-;[,..
'bo:dlJ, :~adm.6a Htr.,arJ'~,A:.anJ :f;U},t*, t;h.en~, e actua:l~",.m,t~,b : '"aim:! to ,.dfi~, lOO¥l!mnrca~, :hi's [Tbusl Hob':b. ·Ita :001:'yet:: :solved. I~he· mh:~em,of sec,udt:r'~,:Em, p [C~'~ld-::~~ [~_:~-:I[~liR!' '~bt:;- .. ,..~.. ,Icm:dh :Rlotlva1~ ,~11I1~ftI, tt_ 'tD '10 'lil:-ir or m',~ BHUf m,en ,are . ~.__ ,m¥m.μt ~ke mmi4em tbat: tber.e must be an eartJd,' ,power
_j~ _~ _ ~_ •_ ~.. _.
B, f,·t iCtUflI8 :~II[ i~'----. c ~;~a~l. :aJ)d ·t1he·'rur:ce "',~ .~ , _o_ I~ .~:; -, •. !fca8Cl~~*, ~ ~~,.~.. ., .1,.... _.
8M,
,o,f ·",~.·r1T;;cular' ·miustons·. ,,.,..,...,!IrIoJ -, ,r - ""

..e'
= _ _ __ ___
is,.s;.cf.emt.to knItl, men itO these cov-mmts\t and, :10 ,he 'e, :11:4 'dLe::0_101 ari~ :~ie1y' :•. 'w:N.d1I, 'di.er.-e is a :SDyt:tmpl. 'w,i;tb, tim
l
'.1
~uired. p6,werr,., 'We ,m3:Y [oo-mldal the: ,ef~lt:,af '.ie [eI,rtJhly ptl';we:f'
poui'bi.lty of' au' o.lItiD_.a saye: ,(I). :M:eo must,

theii:r
(OV ermft!b,;,,tRey'
1
,,':.--",'~':" ~~--:c-',~' two waYS"""
'W,'>,:'_::,-,~,i e
1B8, [suppose
., ,,,',~ 'it1n
'i:' 1lr-J"'1fi" Ug;!j"

I
c.....' __ J,a;.,g:~e_iJ ml ~~_] Ol~i~' .-J1,., ... , ,1,", leG'~-:~tf~~~'~~· ._.[_~I__:e:s_iUl', ~,
i[l. ,e~lt'hcr,of'
'that it :iln_poRS1 '&u8i:cle:mt :pena'l:ti,es. lar 'vlo~atlCln. ,of [ooveumt", tHat~ ,fatr' of 'tmese: :peJtalda, :i.s isulieigl'liJt~1 wifJ~b.t}»!t
IUpplR:
IIl~U_f.lg_lIJ~~ [g-CII,~"~.~,.'-"'~-~ IJlj
b8!,y.re'ltD[c'holvc.~n,the matter,., Or 'we :ma,'

1~...:iI'di
~
toelJ;
Leepl
,E."'_ILoiII.,~:_'liiib~I···;iIIi·r"'i*;iio-n
",v.]
"~
1a..L~J~Jll
'!I'¥I;~,
'~n liIl'iiP-:;·j. t'~[~~, ..-:J'd·"b·Cppj!ii",",~;F\,p;. [L-u] ~,~.. J;u I]

"i~ ,Q_. _'~ .; ~JIj,I~il~I/~~~
aC'In-:-.A1 1!g_yJ iDEIi Ul

: .;
101' 'Ol!l!t'CO.e ,(J:).., [Tbe o'dUl!r.',o,u,toomcs 'wi~~ then be '~flllSi.deredl 'pRll!bl~:"'hilt fi,idencl, ~nritHO:l1a1ble"
'.
Ian .iSl '10 [CfillI'C' ·that. :men ,allbJaiUy peu-or:ru ttu~i;r.'[mV'l.lUtB[a~, [c.mid£RG, ,aba~I,:Y'~ ,18, ,3 pmbileta. ,a'ilodJt ·tmc, ,r[easomahfeaess,
1
'lj ......'Ilia] '8-'~t;'m-"_! 'U"n, ,:""'L~ lii!'"~U'rojjl" ., ...; 16i:~'I"~~ 'H ... u;a [.~.-~_ ~ . \t, g.~ ~,.-_.&l~' v._ Vg,~, giil",mlm~,-,-·r/tiin·~·~ ~1'~1t'iIF~i"B' 'n~b:~ .1"b~J ..,~,·~t~;LJ.l~ ,_.I Ir~:Y~~"
l~-~I
~l~·~'-·_,~r~
[l·:f;' adl'li<~~~~i~'['~)[;>~~-'.:~',-'n·,-!. O~,_~~_W,'CflB:l:>~'I wveo.au.rIB",
leaao~b~,e~ {UI" mm lUI eo!tG:r'81 OOrV:emrllfit. did DOt. mf i,_'ll' eJl,mi~ that ill: 'was reamma:ble: :[0' '~'hem,'~O- keep the [e&'lmaD!t~1 :Iu[t" 'W13 :1llD,lm" Hobhcs, :~es dlat :1£' a OOrVfe:l'lmRt :19 made .f'OI' the sd;ft ,of :pr~tioltt '~'len, ~_UII: ,1~.waJS'Iu;peet 'leRr~ W
'WIS
':'':',-
we
,~''''~,'~ r Umc:O~('L~.
-r:-~ ~~1f..IIl~,,th:~' '_~ fi~'-~' t~; ~U_ ~)t e (a';~:1!j,!J~t II Jilt.
'RdOg,
_['I ',',,',
."JI
to be~,fUnlke.fed'b, _piD,I' ,die [oov,ena~[I]t'~1 nd so[ we: 00 a 1,. .... '~'~< fl'U ..eep UUi,ve ,nasDD, 'iIi\~ ,'lk::':~'1 I~·t·'.~'~..~ ,,,,,:'~lrh-:;:I';-''It {d~:"!'_1 ,p:._ ,_, _~_~ ,-: .. ,_u~.. ~["L-'Oug_~ ~ , _.~_ r:-mvldM I, ._
1
I'~'
' ,--::
Slll:~jee,tive :pmdence :faHs

cAv\A:~c~:iiIi\iili;
~.VII1L~:~
'''''il!..;iIioi'f ;U_II~_il._
ill:il~:~'~cft'iii;if;,",~
'J'
"ii!' ,~:iI'!ii LU_lI}.tlD_II~lr~iI"_CL1 'ft'It.ii~U"~[~tH IiYl_l:-.· -:~I .. ~'~.~.~':~ l"l.,o;~ .... ",.Al"'~""'" ,~",Jt.. '_- ,~_~_I:~-~,I.-.J.lI:I!_lil~: J~, L~·~lL~.IHi .;L,;iiij;r:, Ig~11w.:_ '
[Di\lID,
:ljlUJ~~~::-lmt~ '.~' - - - ,J- -gem-~!p,--~",,~,

-'-ct~ clll,~_-
, .. . ;i~1LTba ,__ iit!l~liiii' ,:,____:,~"" )'!'l'!"!Q!'
'ta~HtQ'o,~' nr§hr""r-A '-.r,~~_I__II__,b, I!n~~;i!ftD' '(3g_6~~
~Ih" &tel Ttthem.se'lv., ~m,a 'w;a;r [of a4'~--;--(\[-t ~ __~u______ --- -.1_81
_h __ --
:a8,
:3),
:guide; 'to iC,tioft", )" :mm

'it,n
,"vi
.'I_Il_c ..... r:Ai!iliQon IJ;iIi,

1 ... ,'--',~'::_,_---"L[,
o'r'
----
_'Iil[ ,_1'[_"""'I-;I!' ,i:Ii!U '.- -,.1'11,
:r-eq,uin ,.E1ft to 'Ii.it th,eif' namra1, :ri_ght~ ac.c:epu1al' IClJtain, ,oblptioH Olle, to ,moth"!:,, Thus Hobhes, clams ,~, ,ered, an,
I(lh!mn, --., '.o:~,ai!,iil~, ,___ 'me: 'milns aI' S'tdl'~'eaiv{el:'-p.·rrudertTe 'G' - _I[ -l~,,:r fm. ·~··9L-' .. , -" ., ;~l ' .. ,_." .. , .'..ID.!, AI: RO' sta.ge of bl:s, Hg!IJD\~mIt~d,oes, ,H:,obbes; ,I,ose sig)lt of ilIte:
of 'the :~fu:&~:lduat. ldlQ1lJ~~1 :Lis ma(r"aI [s.~t£m '~(m)lii A ,r ,,'f,des a ematnoa yii,ewpoil!ll: fOf' ;~I '.,e-A, :"et each :"0, :.1W9't see;
'Yi~il"tt r"~i
L~
'~'!lj
~fI_J.I.';J!II!P.'
~tlb.~:., ~ii:li: [~iU'-J!I_J~~.LI,u:.,HI. ,;L.'l-';A, ~'iltiAi1Iil ro'i.;ti 'R'll~l_a~1!1J 1-1i;I ~l P;I~J

,~.j;
A,Fi'i+~~.l
~-"'I~,~UJb.='~1
;i'i;;f"~JIHIJ_1Ja ilkl~a, U _.
oi"iIiii'~n ~'iPif~;jfi"IIi'iiJ~[o'Iii'.
u'n' .•:_ ,It.~jl
~_I.:.'-r.-.. :: .... .
I
~'i'i~;@o'~ [~--'U__':oI~-~.~.b.1
wi;., D,OWI'I :presorV'luon, ,and ·we'l... beiml~ T,hu8 each new:9t1ep .. t,'~b r:t;t"t.... 'i,t:;""",.,1 'I.e ,i, '1:8 --, - -'D-'nmeDt~9,cUSU:~~w -", 'a to nell 'maR ,_1,'te:nns__-,it '~b'" ,OIW;1l liD '€l(' ,---- ",,".• 18, ,-. - '--!'-,JI- -"-'--'" ---,--, ,----. good,., ,Fo.I' at; 8:tep[ ,tile a1j~erDartIve :18,the :same;!: co~tl_, '1,0 t'be. :taWl,'of l\2!W'I"e\,1 't-o :restric,D.Dn, ,of' :naw'w, ~Ib,tj 'io ei,,,,i~,
cam,
;societ,y'~te uwimtilai, 801'''CFCip;t,- ;or

, ,_
as -W\'~·/;;o:II~.D_"dIO!li!'i'" U~-1!' ,'":'!L~*r' '~,(:I:)'.e ,of':lIa.[~ ,~,~~ &,Ill' :nol ,molnm ~fQrperIORal suocess~ :IBWi8 n.or ,evren. ,penw,ma] nwles .fori k.,iin; ,aI:,yye.~ ,they' afe, gell.mI, ~,~, :p;dnc~plea :falf 'I_he ,ples;en,artiQIll, at bU'D'WlltJ'j,.,:~ ,Fo,l" ,tbe ,a~'t-ema'~ 'tive iSi 'W,[rOn:I~Y PmJt, Tboti laws of nature: ,I_r-e,III1BiMS fur '.0: '-;-reserY;Btio.u Q, _. ,e ~[B_. v, ' __.. ' ..,' "r ··· .. ,p _-_, , __ '~'fthe :!rlldi;c~~duai ,ll__il'b'lllt' tb,@;1l1',..hold "b~-e~re"'if'··' 'indi;,~,. ,. ',~ __ ,
':IC"t~· ,~;L,~:ti'i.:f~,t:'I'D' ,iI;il-iIi.I_::IJ.,~, .iliIHIi,. .!I.~ CJi_AD_iI;l" ~,~ '~:.iiIi1 'm,i""!'II~dJ~i'fiIi:o'Ji'ii:~:I;olIii~:'I')i"I',. ,iMJi U[I,~iIi,!!Iiio_iLIU\.,'''''''
U;I,iIi,,,",, _,
perm'..,
,!,
~:Ii,
[~ljiac:l',
W_CIIIL~
111 .;:;JU.... 'I',t' 1~!IL!t, ._.·,~~.u._,__mi',~,iIl. p,gpiL
;ft;;;§iI:':i;, 'p,'_;iilit:"i!r-..aQ ~"uP~ , ," ~-li, 'I' 'I!IiQ'
'jIr.::-';'I;ji;'lf·''j; ~UlUA'!II-f~
'~'""'11:I
1_---'~~__iII!, ,iWU ,c__Il_Il_.
_en~i;~~ ~--='.~---~"''!II!'''''J
-.
is; pr.acl'V~~, 'BUltthe hasle Olms:ideRt1nn :is all,ways, 'the, :plIKrvab:OJJ'l or tne ,iI)Bw,",J!um"~
...., r,' .. \L "', . l:'::
'•. ..:Ii.
_'~I
:inilli,,",idulWiit :poJilt~ieal, pbiiloso,pher[f' ,pa'r lex~~enenee~ doc :EUs, trin,e :may seem, straDae 1'O['dU.I' 'who eenneet bUU'lIeois
elli'
H:obh. :nmy 'widi,
rc8SDID,
be :r,egarded, as, 'me: bOllrgool5;t
UJ;
:at,ttmd,a, w'~!t.,,lah8~~i-/m",,;~, w])~h the 'Vciiftw' 'tD_at ,tb,e !bat, an,d, :gcTvlcmaent: :i.a 'that: \\rm'i1:h :IDV'CnlS least, awn!: :H'o'htu~8,I"S, :ar.-gu,.... 'L __ _,,",,1!.. ~ ,-' ~' 'meAt, :l8, lP, :ma'P,,' :ra,peeu, m,o,re [MftI.t~e:Dt t.MI'l ',in/It,'G_ ~ 'man,' 01:'
,i, ,~ ..
'L.
£, '111 "' 'D H' h'L... .. ,uiS :1~~lDiW ..1~ ~...1 ....:I'~ :~ftd_i,"':~Q)llJ)~Bts;" ,ItJ'OI' ,~JO,~~,- .,~l,
ii
:~u:ppositiOD, ,tbs!t; all ,~Qdi,QdulhBJre,tqul, BRd dt,el'~,e:w:I'~mp:lbdt,
'iI<nsI Ib ;II;,~l.. - 'L. ·~es 8emll~!~,,'10ui tne i
~m' :~y
oou:r-gools: tb~nkelSj,'dta!t: ,aill =mem,,afe :nauu:alJ,,' :se'lfislll~ Th'l; rau1ta8t [~,haml,Q~,y01' iRt-U§isi1' is, ,i).posed, :not 'by ;UI 1 :iI<-,'Y_:"~'~hl-~ D1L Wl __ e "and~ ,I b:ll-llt: 'br7.~)'VC"" visJl,b:le huid of ,tile absalIuJie: . _ fJ ,~e __
~,;J _ __ __ __ ___ _ _ _
~ H'~~
'W~~
~,~ 'e-it'.:., ,,; ~'7','
'M''O~' 'RA'L
.-~"L
'
:::
__
l'~
',.:,.••
'.
Jl
I I"
mu'iE'O- 'D'V '~J!,·U..!ri/',ftli:

~ _
,I,pe.e 't'illJt :peace Is :pod.l1 'blit ooily 3, nn~!Ue_i!!',~~~ 'M~ri,:-1i~lv' ,~n~', '---~~'en ean "'~'iIr.~I~' '~d\-.~~~t'lJ;, r-,n" 'iliUiJ~''''',~_:,;/ ~-- ;_111 m !i:!YJi, I~:I~ ,lr--'"
8OVer~s~~
:Ii,
'P:o;r Idl m,m,

;0
'!I;.;oQ_U O'-1~U,.!!I.>
'••
11:
iMp,I_ve'
,iIJIi:!!
:H;ubbes's, SiJstan :i.s, 'we :may questin,Ii,

~
'~'I'r,~J,",~_;-: II",,- ~B ,-I ,.!~:nI!Ii, iilI!, ,'Iii",":liiLil!l! ~,p"Ii;~~ W~~I!j,!I!ite.r '!:.. :i_ al, 'liI)~7:"':~1
1_'
,111.-1
i'fl'lil,t:'1T,;ifi!' ~~~ ,U,IW
sense
,;IIi,I!I.I
~iI!i'l'wtl~j!!;~,
. . ""~..
.lijJ~iI: _~ ,Ii.li... ~:Ii~~
'W-~: ,ii!l;'i;~cPlp!tBI:'~' !OI!'!IiiI, ~~' ~ "~

e ~ ""
.:i.._,.-,. ,'.ill,jr::",~~;~·~ '~~. '&iI",",:-Jllll'iI~lb~~' "r,~" 'P-l,(Ii"II' '1-'>dJe,',-,n.~';(!IjII;_::_, '~~. "'1-11il,. Ula" .. Olw~J!IO;:1 '~'CI ,!I!~'\!II''', ",'aJl!!oII,",'1i Ji,~ ~.~ ,11,1, ':.:, U,I~l!iii '.'\'-'1" 'I,Ina~ ,R~:"b:bca'~'8 8.'J81eJn, 'UUllSteBdS w~'~jeet;~,Vie ,pmdence.'~ g,ut 'WG _ay' :aIk, w:b ;t'b-I':' :~;~: (L~~ can, 'be' _Ollie, '11m.m, cammnn, 'p':N\demoo~ ,"~, ... ~ ~~_JL._.c;~ ,IS~I:,~lr' __ 1_ ~-----~ O,llee a,l~dD~ :neOOl,nlot suppose tllftat our 'flu.muoD, is, ODIC we fbact 'would, :batw'e: been of' :great i'n'tel}est~ t'O, a,oo'o.. :hilRiH'tf:~,AI,
,a!OI!!
'+1
'=
~L
-]1--
_ -.~
._
---
'~~'"
!'i"'1i.-.: .• ·Rj~ V'L [~,~r\.'U-.,I~ Q.v 1"-_- ~_~-_ [~f'V:U:ti1 ·~V.J!~D ,~i!ji'l:!ll, 'ILQ~ '~l,,",~~, It'iof" '~"';l-inilil'i~ '~'4 '~'b~:~;;[': > ~
'-1'-1"rll ~ ,:,(,-,~~-,'n" ,.~-,>.~." m,'I!4I'Ji~~, ~;,~,'I.~.-- n,':,",r~·,' m,-,::-, pn_~~~p,:les" 'Y' _' _' ~_,~~
' ' ','1:'-('':,'' '!JJ\_. ~Ji~I'iUil~",
'ii:\;~
W.,,~--;'bII_ ilt~:: ~:it' '~''''''iifiir·r--:c,if>; ,t>'~ .. w' ~"f~~ ~. [ __ JI_~_"~!'~ . [_ _I~lr~rI' !III. ,.v. ~
> ~> , •
'-,'::::>W(~'
~O," "p',"'nI', :I_"l~n~~ :1' II.,D,>: : iI;i[,.. •• \;i~" ,~l",:'... 'a-'--:-,' _,_.u~I' ,f ',_8,
,appeal' tol 'b'Ble: - bl!te1\lest, 01' Ill'vantagD :is, IHref:,' dle :_,t effeCll,Ve ,~ppeal f' a~I,----cand, ~f' it: 1(8;0> be apr.sod ,~n tcRnS, o 'w~bicJl, ba'te :mora'~ 100rm,Oflt'i<n:ls1,so :m,len, '~Jlteibetler, .. IdM:1Dgy' :iis ~nter-es't .i$gu:ised, .' mara'Utr~
«(~~~_~~~
the: :[laDCI is, ,RU,t '.w~poda.t if 'Olle: ;s:upposes, '''t:,m, :a:p,peaJ, tiD ~mQ:Nl oonsidetati1J~ a';t ~eas,t~m,som'6 :me-asu:re~ladq>e'l,dml, ,o;f' :
,~ .• ~. • ., ·~I ' ~ - _1
=~t, ~,.
the. d.QCtnl"u! ~s m,Ol}e ,ID'l!pclftamt tbaD, t~~e,~aJDe:I, ~t car,n.!, Yet, ,
dle.~ew:atlt~e~~
'~'nl~RlIb:, ':~.'nfac:e' fie'D ..,--~-"' . .ir----- .-~-'s,m.helt'e' Po:r w~~~' :"1 _, ,iii. - .' ,t", ~_. '.- '.. ~,~" lim 'me'Mliitlca'l -i["--" ,..• Ie, 'ma~i - ..
su~
"H-"'~n'LL-!~iI; a;1'laft·I-'iI'!ii~'fi [ :.,·~~Ul~:1:1 iI1ilr:'l!rnr~m·.· Anih, A- iIIIl '\VtiIi; _,1..,,,;,;'1'11liIII'boii.iJr •. 1i..,:'_, :~YQ.f~ r~&~II~ll ~-lle;~~; ~',~Ii~I)~1i \-j~: IPJ'.J. ~~~·~.t";;. u~ .·'l.··~~
1"1,1:
:so.,et'hiimg distbl1:tiive:~y m.0:nd :is, ~dilnl: :fmm
~G!, :m 'or 'II 'nje_~~
f1JUlldml", Wba!Jt :is,mere, we ,shal~ 'trat?t 'W:Ralt :is iaddinl' 'tD :Rob''beait:s :ps"cltoltl:D'~ t~b'Us,rlf1l ti'D,g' ,the: 'v,itM', ,tba!t, :Ws; : 8;Jlt=m\ cam; betreated IS 'q,U'~,te'indepemden.t of' :b_lS! 'y:le,w' 0,' :man~
1
mmm.
"What 1!J,la'~liDI':is 'fii,otto 'be disooyered I_ ,. Ilttl2i1,I~tO;n,'~O t.e :f1Jrrnal deln~ti.oIl8, of' Ho'bbes~t:!I :mlo(r,a) Co,ll,tepts\~ 'W:e :Id¥t'e, ~a'_UJ' HUD'bai':S,oon,cep;tioD O'f 'obl~iatiom,., Thu ~.
,C<iDf\1ses
:;rn.dcxd~1 IUllI.d, mu,c'h to pn&e ralther ,t:ban. 'tUI ,tridnSe~, GS,peei.ii'
'tw'll qullte d:lstb;u~t~ tS'aJUi~'w:b,e:o, he :M'I~ '7~1,e, w,[hB ~" ,tbat 'tHere is, ,no, :plaee~ ,lor oblil;ati!tlD :i;n ,tke sysll:[u ,of' Hobbes 'wamt 1'01 d~y 'rJMtt: Whalt :he caj[ls~by tbat name is;'wbalt:
"!ii-al
L!If.J'"
rJ~uneftab
,iIfii;i""11::n-i'!iIIi'!''".-:'iv' '~u~"n'd.:~~if-a-',n'~' 'b~ll1' '~m,,\il't'if"a·11 Ab:-'.'I;:I!Bm'''~:iiI'i.TiJ !!I.I.~f1lIJ~_ ~ :J' '. -"'J' ,:: =1~A'L_"'Vtll.[Ii'
~g_lill : ::I,r:rf. t1ir.'iI,~!11._.::: Ul . 1 tV-JJ,[ __~I Vl ,.',
'~A'I!!" [I. ,~~I~JJ
:j;~a.-"n(t .. eo "'[~_'=I!j.)
l~_::.,
11:,' Bit: 1.8t dlis .u~bJ' this m,uoA irsl S;'i.!J.re]:J't:m£;,~~' I~d, The' 'q,l!Ie8t'[on 'wbedler' wblt Hobbes, lU'l,d,efS,tmds, 'b:y t'he 'lam'i,o'b:lffiptio1l is 'w'bat we 'Unders,tand by' :i,t;, :b, q.ldJte Idill3F. enJt
1
1
,I:
)'0'l1n .P1.&men •• ~,op.
,dt:..!,
,p.. ':5:.

Gauthier - The Logic of Leviathan

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Gauthier - The Logic of Leviathan

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

-h.

The Moral a .d Political Theory of Thomas .'~'-'..bes

Copyri hted ma nal

'H--'Ei:_ 'L"·O·:-"Gr'~·!I-C'. O·",'·F(I ',__:__ .. ) '_ ':' _.,..:__. :

't' E,'lV',:": I'A" T~i::HA; '·'.'N:' '

Copy rig hted m ateri al

IT-II JH: I..

··,·:-:··,G·:-:IlrC·/.··':._.I.. '.. ' _ ~

L··· .'V', ~'-:--A'-'

"-H' -'A'" N'"

m..,...t,---m ,...,; ,.rm:iI~~~' :nt.n;..;..~"; "rJ.'

...< ~~: ' _I:~ OX-F-OR'D

... OI"'~1O(-JRDiiiiiii [~.1.}' ._1IlH'.tI.I__

1.,1 _.,' _ .,.

.,;ufr,4-~ [~Ii' .~... F-....:ii'·~iIli~...;i1 , "",,J .UK;I1.i!JUI~II~t~1'!U'II; ! ~~

ti'at-~~~'~llot'CI(d._lia rc&1[niil! iliDliQWp;~. I-.diltdii.b :b',pilin'lII"lI"Olidwiilk"m ~ ,A.Ui4WI '......

Oif:anJ '.I:'::' ,~~

~ ~" Dif.~ 18 ~1.,I.Ii'M"""'~,

III' \i!j,-i1Iiii':IjI',,":,,~·~, ~1~'Y~I!I'iI!IH!IIi

:_......iIi]_......,._~,:j'!i'itliijIIi,~.IIII!Ii. -- iiI!!.~ ~WIII!

iiti:t...;..~ ]D.A:'iiti _I !IQIIIiII.Md

-,r--iliiliil ~;..- ~ , Il~r~ Ln~ ....... .. ,

llic;:~K ml,_ilill Of_~iidUlo !1Qid

'Nb1ilh::I] iiDI'kl'U~] S~taJ [U~ldbl[~"tliil;:~~ 6'5'''~

... ~"""" ~ ..Yi,iull 'lHr;O,luU!liul!'

i~tI~ ~~) jpU1dQrd

"'-L_-: ~, ' )"1-1 _1_._~

~1I!iIi,,,,,,rclF~t.I: [iii.o.I:oiI:.....~:...-Ii· ll.~~· ~I~J~; ~_n~ _.,_~_IIl1_.... _.._~ __ 'ffiI'i¥ [~ ~

rta iaDIiI flH'ml eM'~'bI';J" ~ ~ ~ ~.~.~~ ~~

,iI-nv. ~_I' _~-'I# ---

mba' &adIq; !lJr;'OO'~Ii'

.ISB'N 11)-.19"'!Ui(i]~·>: 9'

'A"-" -.-=lIiII·'~, 1~<~, •. ~_"-':"'I~I ~,~J,~IHlI~

" ... ........__ i:lt.. ~~-"'---I~ ~IIII!I ~,,':

' ......... ,~..Ii.;.."iI'rom ~

"'II ........ eii,.;,orrli']i;.·I"~-.!Ii,~ilijl~ h . ~I; ~_Iwql ~-~~~~~Irl

Copy rig hted m ateri al

Copy rig hted m ateri al

'.WEb" baa, oR'lmita! po'6til_,[Iluthon!iy' on yftHmited _tUvi:",

'1i~v' ': ·"·.I)[l~1 '~iI;~lIAIlli v.~a·l 'III. .1 .Vlg._or. _ 'n"~_]I~-~ _ .1

[~~'IMr:s,;:l!! '1;I"'I"i~~~1 [nJu.u~

i''i! 'rnn'I~~I.~m~ '~~~iFQ g r~.I- ,u. __ I~JI:l~-u'~IJJ'

po'lJitiical Audlmrity:" BI1II' dte 'p'em;' :iI 'tOOl Atmng

oldy' :1Ilar.e1l,:fOU9W1~ 'Tbe: taco", ,q 3, :fa~~U'M~

Ct.i';~~~i~,;_t~~~_;l~~i~~, t~[~:*.;'~, (;i)~ In,d,t~id~ai~;n

t:~r...F .... ,.~'rilil:UiJfmm, 'w~.ltu ,JU~"~,i 'OLU,Y .urotiru

:.'i~'~,i~.~.. ,~;:,l"'v,n'l[li a-g_~J~-Ii~'J ,~_Il.

:"_,'~d ("~T: ::lIIlit ","""~"u ~H,lo1f.'besi 'has, semJn~"JJi''''

'Ae ,rmation be1!,weenIOv eRip and

l_md :plltical ,au;tkority

m~:"chj to[ 'I~.",~~b'lIt'I·~'J(L us 'w1..,...,.., ~ f'""~~ ~~,gu _u~"~. ~eae~~ ~~~ose

;nl:"\"'~ '-'~Jt.~ _I~1U1

'I 'lr~~ ;i~~'11 IA'f,ACAiP' I'H'1I'I·:.. [_:' _IJ~_~~.I1 v,.~lJI{c~"_]

Copy rig hted m ateri al

:1~i'!D;D'~'iIi,[('I['~ ' [111 w.6

Copy rig hted m ateri al

"In 1;1['1[:[ C'At(.,

ic'o:!r\n;:~j'rlT;5,:::If('OIRM,A't, :Iiillnft~ tn[I'~lljU!i

Copy rig hted m ateri al

I", T:6:1 :N'tr.:'U'I.,~L :K,UtC:I>[Q'M [~~' (lH,l~,P

I';'!ic,:l:~ II'"'~'jl~g~, J1 ifi'i","",,' ~!i

~':~:C ~ ~ !iiI!~B'i!!!!':Ii ~ 'irS!

3,', iCi :a'~'.

iIj'[;il'!'il'iI:,'-;>['""'i,iIi ,~,",~,.U·~ ~"'iI'"; ~ ~ V ~~i

'H--'Ei:_ 'L"·O·:-"Gr'~·!I-C'. O·",'·F(I ',: .. ) '_ ':' _.,..:__. :

rta iaDIiI flH'ml eM'~'bI';J" ~ ~ ~ ~.~.

['IMr:s,;:l!! '1;I"'I"i~1 [nJu.u~

Ct.i';~~~i~,;_t~_;li~~, t~[~:*.;'~, (;i)~ In,d,t~id~ai~;n

m~:"chj to[ 'I~.",~~b'lIt'I·~'J(L us 'w1..,...,.., ~ f'"" ,gu _u~"~. ~eae ~ose

'I 'lr ;i'11 IA'f,ACAiP' I'H'1I'I·:.. [_:' _IJ~_~~.I1 v,.~lJI{c~"_]

,nU"~'i1~-41 1!Ii!i_~I__",&I;~[J",i~,~·~_.-_ ;n'O--:-j'lln;Ii'.r...'-p'rea'!i1~· ;e ~_._~ _ _)~JLW"Jlg .._~_.JL~' ~l

IlitI'QdU~11' ,.....- "~,'I' dimrmmh:ed, ,,~ ~-

'A6er~RII111'IY~-". :u. ---'[~' ~~- ~- ,Dr ~ ~~~-~ p~_mJesJ! i.aldiB3iliOR ~,..

;'i':-.;"i-Ci!,oi!i! '~!;~~I ,i~ Wll~"" ~lil!1l;'UiJ,.I,VJ~III, ,~

'DHeS8liry :m,-a:~"'~IDI:~~~'n/tl'l""' 'U?:~'I~I"_~~': ,-' -" .~, --'"

~,' ~}:'~ '117-,~/ 'w,~ilil.It~,~--"'-'-~:l '~ appaR_II_1i,"'mi ~rmln,O~I.j~,I)IJ_. QllllIy ILe/