Search CNET

Reviews

News

Download

CNET TV

How To

Marketplace Log In | Join

CNET News Privacy Inc.

Facebook's FTC settlement won't change much, if anything

by Declan McCullagh | November 29, 2011 4:15 PM PST

CNET Blogs
comments

Like

38

72

Share

19

More +

Federal Trade Commission officials spent the day touting a new settlement with Facebook, with FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz saying the company now will be "obligated" to keep its privacy promises.
But in reality, the agreement is likely to have little, if any, actual impact on Facebook users. One reason is that Facebook won't have to roll back any changes to its default privacy settings, which have grown more permissive over the last few years. Photos, wall posts, and lists of friends were once visible by default only to people you were associated with; now the default settings include everyone on the Internet. The proposed settlement "does not rectify the original problem," Marc Rotenberg, executive director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center, told CNET this afternoon. "Our concern was with the change in the default settings--that's the part that was clearly unfair" and therefore unlawful, he said. Rotenberg, whose group complained to the FTC about Facebook in late 2009, says he'll ask the FTC to order a rollback to previous default settings before the settlement becomes final. If that happens, of course, Facebook could withdraw its agreement and the entire deal would be off. Another reason for the limited impact--in other words, the difference between what Facebook could do yesterday and what it can do once the agreement is finalized--is that the deal largely formalizes what are already viewed in the industry as best practices. "It doesn't create any new or unusual obligation," says Jules Polonetsky, director of the Future of Privacy Forum think tank. Polonetsky says that "any reasonable lawyer advising a client" already would have told them to follow what the settlement specifies. EPIC's letter (PDF) to the FTC noted that Facebook previously defined a user's name and network as "publicly available information." That changed in late 2009 to also include lists of friends, pages users are "fans" of, gender, and geographic regions. (Here's a visualization of how the defaults have changed since 2005.) In a Twitter post today, FTC attorney Laura Berger indicated it would be infeasible to restore the default settings from late 2009 because the "current site no longer maps" to the previous one.

Intel to help more companies build ultrabooks Nanotech - The Circuits Blog Kepler 22-b: NASA confirms another Earth? Crave Carrier IQ analysis finds no evidence of 'keylogger' Privacy Inc. Apple's secret code names for iOS revealed Technically Incorrect Sexting far less prevalent than previously reported Safe and Secure

What's Hot
Shared

Discussions

comments

161

Judge denies Apple request for U.S. ban on Samsung gadgets Are you finished with physical media?

comments

151

comments

124

The sad self-obsession surrounding NASA's Kepler-22b discovery

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com

But, she said, Facebook has implemented privacy controls since. Those privacy changes, including ones that gave users more control over how information was shared, happened in May 2010 and August 2011. And that was sufficient to appease the FTC. When asked what Facebook will be newly prohibited from doing under the proposed settlement, Justin Brookman at the Center for Democracy and Technology said: "I don't think there's any difference. The order is very consistent with what the FTC has done for a number of years." The proposed agreement does specify that biennial audit will be performed by an "independent third-party professional" to evaluate Facebook's "privacy controls." That's "not going to substantively change much," said Brookman, who heads CDT's Project on Consumer Privacy. "At the margins it might help." While Facebook does have to pay for the cost of an annual audit, one benefit is reputational. It now can tell users: "Trust us with your data--we're government approved!" "Their No. 1 asset is their reputation," says Berin Szoka, president of TechFreedom, a technology think tank. "They work very hard to preserve that." All of which explains why the only change that Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg announced today was that his company would now have two chief privacy officers, Erin Egan and Michael Richter. There was no mention of restoring defaults to make Facebook user information as private as it was before.
comments comments

122

Gaming PCs: How much is too much?

107

Why Chevy Volt sales matter less than you think

About Privacy Inc.

You've got personal information scattered all over the Web and in company databases. But how private is your private information, and how much does everyone else know about you? CNET's Declan McCullagh and others keep you in the loop.

RSS
Subscribe

my Yahoo
Add this Feed

Update 7:45 p.m. PT: EPIC's Marc Rotenberg sent me e-mail a moment ago saying he thinks
the FTC's order is flawed but nevertheless important: "My objection was not to the obligations placed on Facebook going forward; they are sweeping and comprehensive. My objection is that the FTC failed to require Facebook to restore the original privacy settings."

Google
Add this Feed

MSN
Add this Feed

Topics
About Declan McCullagh
Declan McCullagh is the chief political correspondent for CNET. Declan

previously was a reporter for Time and the Washington bureau chief for Wired and wrote the Taking Liberties section and Other People's Money column for CBS News' Web site.
Like 733

Topics: Privacy, Policy, Social networking, Corporate and legal, Advertising and marketing, Personal communications | Tags: ftc, facebook, federal trade commission, privacy

Popular headlines Latest Tech News

Senator presses wireless providers for Carrier IQ answers Carrier IQ analysis finds no evidence of 'keylogger' Carrier IQ verbatim: Answers from company exec, researchers How Carrier IQ was wrongly accused of keylogging WikiLeaks files expose surveillance-industrial complex Carrier IQ: More privacy alarms, more confusion Verizon blocks Google Wallet on Galaxy Nexus Intel to help more companies build ultrabooks Google adds graphing calculator to search The sad self-obsession surrounding NASA's Kepler-22b discovery Man behind XXX domains says they'll help parents protect kids Global industry CO2 output rises even in weak economy Galaxy Nexus to cost $299 at Verizon, report says T-Mobile deploys Carrier IQ on BlackBerry, others

Advertising and marketing Censorship Cloud computing Content and publishing Corporate and legal Fourth Amendment Gadgets Internet Law Miscellaneous Personal communications Policy Politics Privacy Search Security Social networking Software

CNET on the Go

comments

Join the conversation! (Log in or

register)

Add your comment

Why should he? The public is stupid enough to keep giving away their information to this shady, evil network.

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com

Once people educate themselves (and delete their Facebook accounts) this might actually come to an end.
Like

RSS Subscribe

Newsletters Subscribe

548966 likes. Sign Up to see what your friends lik

Posted by Droid101 (299 comments )

November 29, 2011 4:47 PM (PST) Like (1) Reply Link Flag E-mail
CNET 143K followers

This makes me glad that I've never made a Facebook account.

Posted by Wrong_Number (128 comments )
November 29, 2011 6:57 PM (PST) Like (1) Reply Link Flag E-mail

Join the conversation

Log in or create an account to post a comment, or quickly sign in with:

Comment

Add your comment

The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our Terms of Use.

Ads

Over 30? Meet Singles Now

Date Upscale Orlando Area Singles Guaranteed To Meet Someone!
MatureProfessionalSingles.net

Install Google Chrome

A free browser that lets you do more of what you like online!
w w w .google.com/chrome

3 Bureau Credit Report

View your latest Credit Scores from All 3 bureaus in 60 seconds for $0!
w w w .FreeScoreOnline.com

Inside CNET News

New Opera tweaks its threads, mail client
The latest version of Opera takes the stage with updates to its look and quicker load times for secure pages. Meanwhile, the company takes note of the fact that Justin Bieber is not a fan of the browser as a marketing win.
The Download Blog

1-2 of 12

Renewable energy on Indian land (photos)

Gallery

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com

 2011 CBS Interactive. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy | Ad Choice | Terms of Use | Mobile User Agreement | Visit other CBS Interactive sites:

Select Site

Reviews
All Reviews Camcorders Car Tech Cell Phones Digital Cameras GPS Laptops TVs

News
All News Business Tech Crave Cutting Edge Green Tech Security Wireless

Downloads
Add Your Software All Downloads Mac Mobile Software Deals Webware Windows

CNET TV
All Videos Apple Byte Buzz Report CNET Top 5 Loaded Prizefight

More
About CBS Interactive About CNET CNET Deals CNET Forums CNET Mobile CNET Site Map CNET Widgets Corrections HelpBecome Center

Follow us via...
Facebook LinkedIn Twitter YouTube Newsletters RSS

free! Permissions

close [x] a CNET member for

Join CNET to get access to exclusive deals, connect with other members, and automatically keep your software up-to-date. get started

Recently Viewed Products

My Lists

My Software Updates

Holiday Gift Guide

Follow:

Log In | Join CNET

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com

converted by Web2PDFConvert.com