Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ªï∑’Ë ÒÙ ©∫—∫∑’Ë ı °—𬓬π - µÿ≈“§¡ ÚıÙ¯ Vol. 14 No. 5 September - October 2005
Histopathologic Features of
Human Infection with Avian H5N1
Influenza Virus
Yavarace (Vongsivavilas) Young*
Tawetong Koanantakool**
*Pathology Department, Chest Disease Institute, Department of Medical Services
Ministry of Public Health
**Cardiovascular and Thoracic Division, Chest Disease Institute, Department of Medical Services
Avian influenza (AI) or fowl plague (FP) is AI, subtype H5N1 viruses were first discov-
defined as a disease of viral etiology that ranges ered in domestic geese in Guangdong, China in
from a mild or asymptomatic infection to an acute, 1996(4). In May of 1997, human infection with
fatal disease of chickens, turkeys, guinea fowls, and this virus was detected for the first time during
other avian species, especially migratory water- the simultaneous outbreaks of H5N1 in poultry
(1- 3)
fowl. The term FP was first used in 1878 to in Hong Kong(5,6). The boy died 5 days after ad-
describe a serious disease of chickens in Italy(1-3). mission. Approximately 6 months later, 17 addi-
In 1955, it was discovered that FP was actually tional confirmed cases with 5 deaths were reported
(1-3)
caused by one of the influenza viruses (IV) . from Hong Kong(5, 6). These cases acquired the
There are 3 types of IV, designated as A, B, or C infection directly from chickens, without the in-
according to the antigenic character of the M pro- volvement of an intermediate host. The outbreak
tein of the virus envelope and the nucleoprotein resulted in a territory-wide slaughter of more than
within the virus particle. IV is classified into sub- 1.5 million chickens at the end of 1997. H5N1
type according to the serologic identity of the two infection in humans is a classic example of emerg-
surface antigens, hemagglutinins (HA) and ing infectious disease resulting from transmission
neuraminidases (NA). There are now 16 HA and of a known causative organism to a new host.
9 NA antigens described among influenza type A In January of 2003, human disease caused by
viruses and only 3 subtypes circulating among influenza H5N1 re-emerged for the first time since
humans (H1N1, H2N2, and H3N2). Therefore, the 1997 outbreak(7). Two cases of H5N1 infec-
they are also known as human influenza viruses. tion occurred among members of a Hong Kong
˜ÙÒ
Histopathologic Features of Human Infection with Avian H5N1 Influenza Virus
family who had visited Fujian in Mainland China. H5N1 disease were reported with 62 deaths. In
The diagnosis was confirmed by cell culture and Thailand, there were 17 confirmed cases with 12
by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction deaths during the 2004 outbreak. Indeed, it is the
(RT-PCR) from their nasopharyngeal aspirates. largest and most lethal H5N1 virus outbreak in
One of them was a 33-year-old Chinese man who humans to date.
presented with a 4-day history of influenza-like It has been thought that AI viruses have wild
symptoms and a right lower lobe consolidation. waterfowl as their natural reservoir and they
Despite a heroic treatment, he deteriorated and usually do not infect humans. However, the 1997
(7)
expired 6 days after admission . A complete outbreak has changed our view regarding the po-
autopsy was done. Prior to his illness, his 7-year- tential for cross-species transmission and virulence
old daughter had high fever and respiratory symp- of AI viruses for humans. Genetic analysis showed
toms and died of a pneumonia-like illness 7 days all genes of the H5N1 human isolates were of avian
after the onset of symptoms. The exact cause of origin. In addition, the 1997 H5N1 virus, the an-
her death could not be ascertained since no clini- cestor of all H5N1 human isolates was the reas-
cal specimen was available for tests and no autopsy sortant of multiple co-circulating AI viruses in-
was performed. The second confirmed case was cluding genes from 1996 Guangdong goose
his 8-year-old son who was admitted with a 3-day H5N1, a quail H9N2 virus, and a teal H6N1 vi-
history of influenza-like symptoms and a left rus(6, 12-17). This indicates that it is possible for avian
lingular lobe consolidation. The boy was the only H5N1 viruses to jump species from chickens to
one who recovered from his illness. Since mid humans without using an intermediate host or a
2003, lethal outbreaks of H5N1 viruses among mixing vessel for reassortment and they may not
poultry have been reported to occur in several have to combine with another variety of mammal
countries in Asia and Eastern Europe. In spring influenza in order to spread among humans.
of 2005, more than 6000 migratory birds were The outbreaks of H5N1 not only cause eco-
found dead due to H5N1 infection at the Qinghai nomic losses for poultry producers but also ignite
Lake in Qinghai, China. The death of wild birds global fears that the devastating ‘bird flu’ pan-
is frightening because it suggests adaptation of demic is imminent. It was once predicted that in-
H5N1 virus. Later on, H5N1 expanded in a north- fluenza pandemic was likely to originate from
west direction and both Russia and Kazakhstan Southeast Asia. However, the recent outbreaks of
have reported outbreaks in poultry as well as in H5N1 and other subtypes of AI in various parts of
wild birds. H5N1 infection was not limited to poul- the world indicate that the next pandemic may
try and wild birds but expanded to tigers, leop- start anywhere on earth and at anytime.
(8-10)
ards, cats, mice, ferrets, pigs and dogs . More Of all these years, great interest has been fo-
than 100 million birds either died of the disease cused on molecular biology technique and a
or were culled. The outbreaks were followed wealth of information has been acquired from
by cross-species transmission of H5N1 from numerous researches in this area. However,
chickens to humans with a case of probable hu- merely genetic sequencing would not have been
(11)
man to human transmission . As of October of adequate because the virus’s genes could react in
2005, more than 100 confirmed human cases of the live virus in ways no one predicted, resulting
in protein changes that help the virus enter cells. replication in the respiratory tract might trigger
Histopathology would be another area to study to hypercytokinemia resulting in reactive hemo-
see how the virus behave inside the cells and cause phagocytic syndrome(6, 18).
damages to the host in real life. So far the publi- The findings of autopsy in case 5 also sug-
cations on pathological findings are very limited. gested cytokine dysfunction contribute to the
Systematic reviews of research data with emphasis pathogenesis of H5N1 disease(7). H5N1 antigen
on pathology of AI (H5N1) infection in human was also detected in the lungs of case 5, 6 and 7.
were carried out. In contrast to the other cases, hemophagocytosis
This study includes 2 cases of complete is not seen in any organs of case 6. It is not clear
autopsies, 1 case of paramortem biopsies and 1 whether this is due to prior treatment with corti-
case of postmortem necropsies from the 1997 costeroid or the young age of the patient. In case
(6, 18-19)
Hong Kong outbreak ; 1 case of complete 6, tumor necrotic factor-alpha (TNF-α) was de-
(7)
autopsy from the year 2003 ; and 2 cases of com- tected in the lungs only. This finding concurs with
plete autopsies from the 2004 Thailand out- previous observations that human H5N1 isolates
break(11, 20-22). Clinical data and histopathologic initiate the production of cytokines, most promi-
findings of the 7 proven cases of H5N1 virus in- nently TNF-α, in cultured human macrophages
fection are shown in Table 1 and 2. Photomicro- in vitro(23). Both viral mRNA and TNF-α are found
graphs of hematoxylin and eosin (H & E) section in the lungs of case 6. The simultaneous pre-
of the lung of case 7 are shown in Figures 1 to 3. sence of viral antigen and cytokine TNF-α in the
All patients were of Asian descent, 4 being Chi- same organ suggests a direct induction of cytokine
nese, 1 Filipinos, and 2 Thais. in the viral infected cells. However, the possibility
The clinical spectrum of human H5N1 infec- of Aspergillus induced cytokine in case 6 cannot
tion ranged from asymptomatic infection to fatal be ruled out.
(6)
pneumonitis and multiple organ failure . The The most consistent histopathology findings
postmortem examination of the 1997 outbreak in these cases are in the lung. Although, DAD
showed reactive hemophagocytic syndrome as the and interstitial pneumonitis are non-specific le-
most prominent feature. Other findings included sion, they are typical lesions of pneumonia of vi-
diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) with interstitial ral etiology. The diagnostic tests such as cultures,
fibrosis in the lungs, extensive hepatic centrilo- electron microscopy, molecular diagnostics, and
bular necrosis, and vacuolation of renal proximal immunohistochemistry are required in detecting
tubules in case 1 to extensive acute tubular necro- the causative agent. So far, human autopsy cases
sis in cases 2, 3 and 4. No viral antigen was found have not shown viral spread beyond the lung ex-
in any organs except case 3 in which H5 antigen cept case 6 in which H5 specific RNA was detected
was detected from the lung only. Elevation of solu- in the lungs, spleen, and intestine and evidence
ble interleukin-2 receptor, interleukin-6 and in- of viral replication was found in lungs and intes-
(6, 18)
terferon-γ was demonstrated in cases 2 and 4 . tine(6, 7, 11, 21). Viral spread beyond the lungs in
Secondary bacterial pneumonia was not observed case 6 could be related to corticosteroid admi-
in any case. Therefore, it was postulated that in nistration or virulent strain of the virus. The
fatal human infections with H5N1, initial viral damages seen in the lungs along with the finding
1 1997 3/M No May 11, 97 Acyclovir started at late stage Died 5 days after admission
Hong Kong Chinese of disease (10 days after the onset of illness)
Paramortem biopsies were done.
2 1997 13/F No Nov 20, 97 Amantadine plus intravenous Died 25 days after admission
Hong Kong Chinese Ribavirin on day 7 after A complete autopsy was one.
admission
3 1997 54/M Old Nov 24, 97 Amantadine on admission Died 7 days after admission
Hong Kong Chinese myocardial (6 days after the onset of illness) (11 days after the onset of illness)
infarction
4 1997 25/F No Dec 17, 97 Amantadine on day 3 after Died 24 days after admission
Hong Kong Filipino admission A complete autopsy was done.
5 2003 33/M No Feb 7, 03 Intravenous cefotaxime and oral Died 6 days after admission
Hong Kong Chinese clarithromycin on admission A complete autopsy was done.
add oseltamivir on day 3
6 2004 6/M No Jan, 04 Multiple broad-spectrum antibiotics Died 6 days after admission
Thailand Thai Granulocyte colony-stimulating (17 days after the onset of illness)
factor then oseltamivir and methyl- A complete autopsy was one.
prednisone on day 15 until death
7 2004 26/F No Sept 11, 04 Antibiotic Died 4 days after admission
Thailand Thai A complete autopsy was done.
Brain: mild edema otherwise unremarkable. No viral antigen was detected in any organs.
5 Right lower lobe pneumonia Lungs: edema, hemorrhage, intra-alveolar fibrinous exudates, pneumocyte type 2 hyperplasia with in-
ARDS, MOF creased expression of TNFa in these cells. No viral antigen was detected in these cells prominent CD68+
H5N1 was detected by cell macrophages in alveoli, CD3+T-lymphocytes in interstitium Bone marrow, bronchial and hilar lymph
culture & RT-PCR from nodes: reactive hyperplasia with hemophagocytosis Other organs: unremarkable. Lung was the only
nasopharyngeal aspirate organ that showed positive influenza A antigen by culture and RT-PCR techniques.
6 Right lower lobe pneumonia Lungs: proliferative phase of DAD, interstitital pneumonia, focal hemorrhage, bronchiolitis, type2 pneumocyte
ARDS, pneumothorax hyperplasia and superimposed aspergillosis Bone marrow, lymph nodes and spleen: slight histiocytic hyperplasia
Pneumomediastinum but no hemophagocytosis Liver: mild fatty changes, activated Kuffer cells, and slight lymphoid infiltrates in the
MOF portla areas Brain: edema, small foci of necrosis. Other organs: unremarkable H5 specific RNA was detected in the
lungs, spleen and intestines by RT-PCR. Immunohistochemical stain revealed influenza A viral antigen in pneumocyte
type 2. Electron microscopy: viral particles in pneumocytes and macrophages
7 Pneumonia A complete autopsy was done after the body had been preserved with formalin infusion. Lungs: exuda
Respiratory failure tive phase of DAD, interstitital pneumonitis, hemorhage, reactive pneumocyte hyperplasia, bronchiolitis and pleuri-
tis. Immunohistochemical stain: influenza specific antigen in the desquamated epithelial cells. Lung tissue was
positive for H5N1 by RT-PCR. Liver: cholestasis, congestion, and hemophagocytosis
Spleen: congestion and lymphoid depletion
Patient numbers in this table correspond to those of table 1
Abbreviations: ARDS = Acute respiratory distress syndrome, DAD = Diffuse alveolar damage, MOF = Multiple organ failure, RT-PCR = Reverse transcription polymerase chain
˜Ùı
reaction, TNFa = Tumor necrosis factor alpha
Histopathologic Features of Human Infection with Avian H5N1 Influenza Virus
Figure 1 Section of the lung shows diffuse alveolar Figure 2 Section of the lung shows non-specific pleuri-
damage, interstitial pneumonitis, and intra- tis, subpleural blebs, diffuse alveolar damage,
alveolar fibrinous exudate and hemorrhage, intra-alveolar fibrinous exudate and diffuse
(H & E section × 100) hemorrhage, (H & E section × 100)