Indian Islamic group attacks BBC film for Bin Laden link

Author Randeep Ramesh

October 29, 2007
Publisher The Guardian
http://www.guardian.co.uk/india/story/0,,2201026,00.html

· Claim that Deobandism linked to extremist groups

· School fuelling divisions in UK, says presenter

A BBC documentary shown last night came under attack from one of India's largest
Islamic groups for linking their movement to Osama bin Laden and "extremist" Muslim
groups around the world.

The Deoband school, whose main madrassa Darul Uloom (House of Knowledge) lies 90
miles north-east of Delhi, said it had allowed a television crew making a three-part
documentary called Clash of Worlds into its grounds to explain its "message of peace and
historic role in Indian affairs".

The seminary is a global centre of Muslim learning with 15,000 schools worldwide
adopting its sparse and dogmatic version of Islam. One report last month said almost 600
of Britain's nearly 1,400 mosques are run by Deobandi-affiliated clerics.

However, Muslim scholars in Delhi became alarmed to hear the programme's presenters
talk of their part in the anti-British uprising in the nineteenth century being similar to "the
role played by Osama bin Laden today". Mohammad Anwer, a spokesman for the
Deoband school, said he had protested to the film's producers about the link with Bin
Laden and "many other mistakes". "We protested at the time but it made no difference.
We do not advocate violence nor are we asking others to do violence," said Mr Anwer.
"We did fight against the British in the nineteenth century but so did Hindus. Deoband
has a long, proud history of being part of the independence struggle. But this is not
comparable to Osama bin Laden." Clerics in Delhi have also been incensed that their
creed has been termed an Indian version of Saudi Arabia's Wahhabi school, seen as a
hardline, revivalist form of Islam.
Charles Allen, a historian and one of the documentary's presenters, said: "I don't feel bad
about condemning Deobandism. In India it set the Muslim cause back by a couple of
centuries by turning its back on the west. In Pakistan and Afghanistan it has helped to
promote extremism, intolerance and violence, and in Britain today it is helping to drive a
wedge between Muslim and Muslim and between British Muslims and the rest of
Britain."

Mr Allen's book, God's Terrorists, advances the theory that the "hidden roots of modern
jihad and the Wahabi cult" spring from the subcontinent.
However, this goes against the grain of contemporary thinking on the subject. Many
accept the Deoband school as a strict but essentially law-abiding. "The Taliban took
(their) beliefs to an extreme that the Deobandis would have never recognised," writes
Ahmed Rashid in his book Taliban: Islam, Oil and the New Great Game in Central Asia.