Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
the Brown
vol. cxxii, no. 66
friday, september 14, 2012
since 1891
iNside
Page 2
A new leaf
Page 3
Salary increase
Ruth Simmons compensation rose in 2010 Page 4
79 / 59
72 / 49
The watson Institute for International Studies is implementing several pilot initiatives this semester to further the institutes integration into related University departments and student life. The pilot initiatives include undergraduate and graduate fellows programs, an internal faculty sabbatical program and three lecture series on global security. The institute will also expand its funding for faculty undertaking research in line with its goals and for international relations and development studies concentrators traveling abroad for research. Theres been a perception across campus that the institute has not been sufficiently linked up across various levels of the University, said Peter Andreas, interim director of the institute, adding that he hopes the changes will help make the watson Institute a more inviting place for students and faculty. Though the institute has always
involved students informally in projects, Andreas said, the Undergraduate Fellows Program will look to involve students more fully in the institute. Cameron Parsons 14, an undergraduate fellow, said this formal relationship is what sets apart the fellows program from his past involvement with the institute. noting that the institute was one of the motivating factors in his choice to attend the University, Parsons said the program will allow him to form a close relationship with watson. Colby Smith 13, also an undergraduate fellow, said the program will transform the institute into a new community for students, rather than just an office or event space, adding another dimension to the academic experience. Though the exact mission of the undergraduate program has yet to be solidified, the fellows have met each other and others affiliated with the institute, which fellow Kathy nguyen 13 said will help / / Watson page 2
the Watson insitute aims to gain a greater campus presence with several new initiatives that will involve more students and faculty.
The University will not take action against former Professor of Psychiatry and human Behavior Martin Keller, despite acknowledgment by pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline that Keller co-authored a fraudulent study advocating adolescent use of the antidepressant Paxil. In a recordbreaking $3 billion settlement this July, GSK pleaded guilty to selling the misbranded prescription drugs Paxil, wellbutrin and Avandia. According to the plea agreement, GSKs promotion of Paxil was largely based on Kellers false and misleading article, published in 2001 in the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.
Since the articles publication, the ethics of the study - commonly referred to as Study 329 have been scrutinized in a book, a BBC documentary and a Senate Finance Committee investigation. Critics have said the study inappropriately characterized the drugs effectiveness while downplaying the risk of adolescent suicide associated with Paxil a significantly larger number of patients treated with Paxil had a possibly suicidal event than patients treated with a placebo did, according to the government complaint against GSK. The complaint also claimed that Kellers article was ghostwritten by GSK representatives. Following allegations of research misconduct, the University conducted an internal investigation into Kellers article but has never publicly discussed its findings, citing confidentiality. The fact that Professor Keller has continued
to be chair and continued research and continued to get grants speaks for itself, then-Provost David Kertzer 69 P95 P98 told The herald in 2009. The University has fully reviewed this issue, and there is nothing that emerged from the recent announcement by the U.S. Department of Justice regarding (Kellers) research that would prompt any further reviews of the paper by the University, wrote edward wing, dean of medicine and biological sciences, in an email to The herald. Keller, who stepped down as chair of the psychiatry department in 2009 but stayed on as a professor, announced his retirement earlier this year and stepped down in July. Pending approval from the national Institutes of health, the University will transfer his grants to multiple investigators, wing wrote, calling this a standard practice at Brown. Keller did not respond to multiple requests
for comment. The governments charges against GSK came under the interstate commerce clause. According to a government official speaking anonymously, the government cannot charge the individual researchers who co-authored the study because the research was not funded by federal dollars, the Chronicle of higher education reported last month. when Study 329 was initially conducted, researchers found that Paxil did not perform better than placebos on the measures the researchers had outlined beforehand. In internal documents, GSK called the results of the study commercially unacceptable, according to the government complaint. After viewing the results, the company introduced additional measures on which Paxil performed better than the placebo. P a x i l / / Fraud page 3
to be held outdoors
By pAlAk WAliA
contributing Writer
FootBAll
After conquering the Crusaders 20-13 last year, Bruno hopes to set up the season with another win tomorrow in Worcester.
The football team will travel to worcester, Mass. tomorrow to kick off its season against a College of the holy Cross squad that may still be reeling from its heartbreaking 20-13 loss at Brown Stadium last season. Bruno conquered the Crusaders last october with a 99-yard touchdown drive in the fourth quarter, and a demanding preseason this year has the Bears looking to rise to the occasion once more and set their campaign in motion. our team is really, really fired up right now, said ross walthall 13, defensive lineman and co-captain. we had a tough preseason I think we all are just really ready to get it started. head Coach Phil estes said the season opener is the most important game of the year.
It tells you a lot about your team, he said. It tells you what your strengths are, it tells you what your weaknesses are and how teams are going to exploit you. The Crusaders, who hold an all-time 32-23-3 record over the Bears, will test Bruno on both sides of the ball. Quarterback Patrick Donnelly 13 said he is confident in his squads offensive skill and its ability to mix things up by gaining yards with both running and passing plays. A balanced offensive strategy would contrast with last seasons matchup, where both teams relied heavily on aerial attacks the Bears passed for 229 yards, and the Crusaders passed for 243. But this year, the Bears hope to wield a double-edged sword on offense. on the ground, the Bears have Mark Kachmer 13, a two-time All-Ivy tailback who carried the ball 124 times for 569 yards / / Bruno page 5 last season, and
Punk band titus Andronicus will perform on ruth J. Simmons Quadrangle Sept. 15, preceded by opening act toKiMonStA, at this years Fall Concert. The concert will officially be held outside, the Brown Concert Agency announced via its blog wednesday. we bring people that we know will put on a good live show, said emma ramadan 13, BCA Booking Chair. The purpose of the Fall Concert is to reach out to people who cant be catered to in Spring weekend. BCA chose these two acts after circulating a poll of five different acts on BlogDailyherald. neon Indian and Black Lips came in first and second place, respectively,but after both declined, BCA booked titus Andronicus, which came in third in the poll. BCA members selected DJ Jennifer Lee, also known as toKiMonStA, for the opening act. her music is relentlessly fun experimental electronica, the BCAs blog reads. rajan Mittal 13, BCAs administrative chair, said toKiMonStAs name came up previously in the groups discussions. toKiMonStA has said she wants to play at Brown, ramadan said. we thought it would be a good balance between electrical and punk music, ramadan said. Its going to be a really good show. Its the best lineup for the Fall Concert in a while, Mittal said. BCAs budget for the event was $20,000, but since this years acts are / / BCA page 5 more expen-
2 campus news
c alendar
TODAY 12 P .m. Places for the Living and the Dead Giddings House 212 8P .m. Nudity in the Upspace TF Green Hall 4P .m. A Reading by Paul Legault McCormack Family Theater SEPT. 14 TOmORROW 1P .m. Providence Walking Tours Swearer Center SEPT. 15 By sArAh perelmAn
contributing Writer
menu
SHARPE REFECTORY VERNEY-WOOLLEY DINING HALL
lunCh
Tuna Noodle Casserole, Tilapia with Provencale, Vegan Tofu Veggie Ravioli with Sauce, Magic Bars Breaded Chicken Fingers, Vegan Nuggets, Vegetarian Baked Beans, Peanut Butter Sandwich Bar
Dinner
Eggplant Par mesan, Grilled Cilantro Chicken, Pound Cake with Strawberries and Whipped Cream Grilled Turkey Burger, Spinach Pie Casserole, Tortellini Italiano with Sausage, Foccacia with Rosemary
Sudoku
the stephen t. olney herbarium will move to the Biomedical Center later this semester, taking a step toward digitizing the specimens it houses. students to assist with research in the herbarium and said she wants to open it as a working herbarium for local botanists throughout Providence to collect and document new specimens. Professor of Biology Mark Bertness said he hopes the increased activity and research at the herbarium will support the growth of phylogenetics the study of evolutionary relations among different species of plants at the University. In addition to its role as a historical resource, the new herbarium will provide enough space and the proper equipment for scientific research, including in areas of DnA sequencing and global climate change, edwards said. McCauley said the airtight metal cases and temperature controlled environment will prevent future damage to the collection, a third of which was ruined by bugs in the old wooden cabinets in the basement. I think the scientific world is going to blush at so many treasures stowed away here that nobody knew about, McCauley said. Since she began working at the herbarium in 2009, McCauley has taken on the daunting task of sifting through the materials in the herbarium, which has had no curator since 1930. Though she started the project without a computer and with overhanging pipes blocking access to some of the cabinets, she has now made some rewarding discoveries. She said she found the first specimen ever documented of Castilleja guadalupensis, a species of Indian paintbrush, which is now extinct, and said she is excited to see what else is hidden in the cabinets.
croSSWord
/ / Watson page 1
them take advantage of networking opportunities at the institute. Unlike its undergraduate counterpart, the institutes Graduate Fellows Program has been more fully developed. The program provides its fellows with office space, research funds and travel support. There are currently seven fellows from the anthropology, economics, sociology and political science departments, all at various stages in their graduate studies. The program allows graduate students to be engaged in the life of the institute in a more systematic way, said Angelica Duran Martinez GS, a graduate fellow and doctoral student in political science. Duran
Martinez said the program will support her writing process, while also allowing her to exploit the potential and take advantage of the human capital at the institute. watson is also sponsoring a sabbatical program that enables professors to spend their sabbaticals at Brown away from their departments while engaging in policyrelevant research in international studies, Andreas said. esther whitfield, assistant professor of comparative literature, will be the first faculty member to take part in the program this spring. The institute will also focus on bridging the gap between itself and related University departments, such as the william r. rhodes Center for
daily herald
the Brown
www.browndailyherald.com 195 angell st., providence, r.i.
Claire Peracchio, President rebecca Ballhaus, Vice President Danielle Marshak, treasurer Siena DeLisser, Secretary The Brown Daily herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serving the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement and once during orientation by The Brown Daily herald, Inc. Single copy free for each member of the community. PoStMASter please send corrections to P.o. Box 2538, Providence, rI 02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, r.I. Subscription prices: $280 one year daily, $140 one semester daily. Copyright 2011 by The Brown Daily herald, Inc. All rights reserved.
editorial
bUsiNess
International economics and Finance, the Center for Latin American and Caribbean Studies, the India Initiative and the Middle east Studies Program. The goal of the Latin American center is globalized area study, which will be better facilitated by the center sharing a space and partnering with watson, said richard Snyder, professor of political science and the centers director. Ashutosh Varshney, professor of political science and director of the India Initiative, said that housing the initiative in the watson Institutes facilities allows the two to build bridges and create synergy within the University. The India Initiative is at the intersection of policy and research, Varshney said. our goals connect well with watson. As part of the efforts to better integrate with institutional partners and the student body, Andreas is also trying to revitalize the institutes global security profile by supporting three new speaker series related to global security, which he hopes will also help bridge the policy-academia divide. For watson to function meaningfully it has to connect better with Brown, Browns research and Browns pedagogical aims, Varshney said. Though these initiatives have garnered much support from watson affiliates, Andreas said, any initiatives continuation is up to the next director. There is no long-term commitment.
campus news 3
Simmons base compensation rose from $549,158 in 2009 to $606,306 in 2010. The number is less than the $611,139 Simmons made in base compensation in 2008. the list of highest-paid employees included not just administrators, huidekoper said, but employees who are considered to have substantial influence on the University. The employees on the list are considered disqualified persons, which means they would be imposed with sanctions if excessive compensation occurred, according to the Internal revenue Service. The process the Corporation undertakes to determine the salaries for employees that make more than about $120,000 relies on a number of determinants, huidekoper said, including comparative salaries at other universities. This differentiates the decision-making process from the one for administrative salaries, which may be influenced by fluctuations in the capital market, she said. Cynthia Frost, vice president and chief investment officer, made $1,098,265 in total compensation in 2010, an $86,914 increase from the $1,011,351 she made in 2009. rajiv Vohra, former dean of faculty, made $570,333 in 2010, an $80,338 increase from $489,995. Its about the IrS looking for transparency and to ensure that were operating efficiently and with integrity, said Marisa Quinn, vice president for public affairs and University relations.
Former President ruth Simmons total compensation rose to $863,684 in 2010, a jump from $656,683 in the year prior when Simmons took a voluntary salary cut following the 2008 economic downturn. Simmons compensation in 2010 was closer to the levels seen in 2008 when her total compensation reached $884,771. Salary and compensation figures for 2010 appear in the most recently released Internal revenue Services Form 990, which all nonprofits are required to file in order to maintain their tax-exempt status. The filing includes a list of the base salaries and total compensation for 14 of the Universitys highest compensated employees in addition to the Universitys endowment values. Due to salary freezes and voluntary salary cuts in 2009 as a result of the financial crisis, the fluctuations between 990 filings for 2010 and 2008 do not represent any significant change in compensation trends, said Beppie huidekoper, executive vice president for finance and administration. It is important to look at the base salaries as well as total compensation, she said. total compensation can include health insurance, deferred compensation, previously reported compensation and other benefits, such as the Presidents house.
$863,684
$606,306
$826,428
$327,001
$614,067
$561,222
$570,333
$416,157
$545,920
$409,901
$404,278
$361,222
$397,452
$308,395
$256,001
$207,666
$251,705
$208,306
science-fiction author paul tremblay reads a passage representing the dystopia of his novel, swallowing a Donkeys eye.
By sorA pArk
contributing Writer
In a reading of his newest novel, Swallowing a Donkeys eye, science-fiction author Paul tremblay described the process of writing the book as an oddly personal journey, although not biographical in any way. tremblay addressed a small crowd at the Brown Bookstore wednesday evening. tremblay, who has been nominated
for two Bram Stoker Awards, has also authored two mystery novels, The Little Sleep and no Sleep till wonderland. But Swallowing a Donkeys eye, a dystopian political satire, is a different work altogether. Its narrator is trapped at a mega-conglomerate farm simply called Farm. Farm is the sole food provider for the technocratic City for the next six contractual years.
/ / Fraud page 1
would soon become one of the 10 most prescribed drugs in the country, according to the plea agreement. As part of its promotion of Paxil, GSK would regularly invite physicians to conferences in resort locations, providing fine dining and expensive forms of entertainment, according to the government complaint. Keller acknowledged in 2006 that
over the years, he had received tens of thousands of dollars from GSK and its affiliates. In recent years, groups such as the Project on Government oversight have written to the University requesting that action be taken against Keller. The global nonprofit healthy Skepticism wrote to administrators last year, requesting the Universitys help in an effort to have the article retracted. wing
responded that the University would not support a retraction, adding that the University takes allegations about faculty research very seriously. healthy Skepticism plans to write the University again this year, in the hopes that a new president might be more inclined to support its efforts, said Jon Jureidini, a professor at the University of Adelaide in Australia who co-authored last years letters.
/ / Digs page 8
between the Phoenician and nuragic cultures on the Mediterranean island of Sardinia, aiming to answer the question, how can we gauge transfer of knowledge between different cultural situations? The research centered on two different ways of attaching a handle to a piece of pottery. In the traditional Phoenician manner, the handle was attached directly to the outside of the piece, while nuragic potters first made a hole in the pot, inserted the handle and attached it from the inside, he said. Though this might seem like a mundane detail at first, van Dommelen said, it turns out to be important in that different traditions of attaching handles reflect cultural choices. For example, this summer Phoenician-style ceramics with handles attached in the nuragic way were discovered on the central west coast of Sardinia. Van Dommelen concluded this indicated a high level of interaction between the two cultures, a reflection of long-term working and living together, because pottery depends so much on apprenticeship and the sharing of knowledge. Ceramics traditions are about cultural traditions, he said. A very different type of investigation took place in France, where Sheila Bonde, professor of archaeology and art and architecture, engaged in what she termed rescue archaeology, which in-
Julie Gearans exhibit, which draws from a historical art theme, explores human experience and the connection between past, present and future. the exhibit will be on display in the sarah Doyle Gallery until sept. 29.
/ / BCA page 1
sive, tickets which were free last year will cost $12. The ticket revenue will help BCA pay back their production loan to the Undergraduate Finance Board, ramadan said. Dana Goplerud 15 said she listened to titus Andronicus after Fall Concerts lineup was announced. Im super excited, she said. There are really good bands Ive never seen
Stepping into the Sarah Doyle Gallery to see work created by painter Julie Gearan is comparable to watching ones own dreams. The exhibit features familiar landscapes in paintings that are offset by mysterious subjects. Gearans palette is composed of soft, cool pastels and deep, nebulous blacks and grays. Subject matter varies from pensive dancers with dark eyes to beached whales, and many paintings have Providence landmarks lurking in the background. The exhibition, now Again: Paintings by Julie Gearan, includes quiet metaphoric still lifes as well as large narrative compositions, Gearan said. It has a wide scope and covers many different themes. Its popular right now to have thematic shows, Gearan said. But even to title my show seems kind
of funny. Gearan said that unlike some artists, she does not paint to meet a deadline for an exhibition. I paint until the painting is done, she said. Gearan said she draws from a historical art theme or from her own life for inspiration. Usually these things come from moments in time as a seed, and if they stay there for long enough I start painting them, she said. her recent work has been most heavily influenced by winslow homer, a 19th century American painter best known for painting oceanside scenes, she said. other artists who have inspired her include Guido reni and Balthus. Gearan said she hopes those viewing her art draw their own conclusions and create their own narratives. her artist statement reads, I expect the reading of my work to be open allowing a sense of mystery and stirring
curiosity. She said her work is rooted in human experience and added that she often dwells on the connection between the past, present and future that looping that happens. A wide range of patrons came to experience Gearans work. Local resident Don Schim said he was particularly impressed by Gearans artistic talent. This is better than most (shows), he said. I love what she does with color and light, said Shelby wilson 15, who said she was inspired by Gearans work to improve her own art. The Sarah Doyle Gallery itself is unorthodox. Gearan called the colonial house-turned-gallery domestic and intimate. Gearan has been a member of the rhode Island School of Design faculty since 2010 and also teaches at roger williams University. her paintings will be on display until Sept. 29.
/ / Bruno page 1
Spiro Theodhosi 12.5, a strong rusher who sat out the last two seasons with an injury. Though the receiving corps lost valuable seniors including All-Ivy wideout Alex tounkara-Kone 11.5 veteran receivers such as tellef Lundevall 13 and Jonah Fay 12.5 will be ready when Donnelly takes to the air. Leading the Crusaders offense will be senior quarterback Kevin watson, who made his college debut two weeks ago in a season-opening 38-17 loss to the University of new hampshire. he registered 271 yards and two interceptions and will be looking to rebound and throw his first touchdown of the year. (watson) is a big, strong kid that has a great arm, and we certainly want to make sure that we put some pressure on him, estes said. walthall said the Bears defensive line is eager to shake up watson. were fired up at any opportunity to get after a quarterback, walthall said. But watson will have a capable group of Crusader receivers from which to choose. Senior wideout Gerald Mistretta caught six touchdowns last season and racked up 723 yards, and junior wide receiver Mike Fess had 417 yards and two touchdowns. In contrast to the Crusaders season opener they ran for only 75 yards against Unh and last years matchup against the Bears, estes said he foresees an emphasis on the holy Cross running game Saturday.
were going to have to do a good job of shutting the run down, he said. That will mean bottling up senior running back eddie houghton, who led the Crusaders in rushing last season with 506 yards and four touchdowns. he faces a daunting Bears defense with plenty of experience, including co-captain A.J. Cruz 13, a three-time All-Ivy and preseason All-American defensive back, as well as a veteran defensive line. But even with these strengths on the Bears side, stopping the Crusaders attack will take mistake-free football, walthall said. They always have a good quarterback, and theyre a really balanced team, walthall added.we just have to be on top of our game and do our job. estes underscored those goals. Its not about holy Cross its about what we do and how we execute, he said. My main concern is just us playing together as a team and executing, doing our job. the stakes at tomorrows season opener are high, estes said the game will set a tone that will affect the teams outlook not only on the Sept. 22 harvard game, but on the season as a whole. our challenge is to establish ourselves as a football team, he said. to make that happen, Defensive Coordinator Michael Kelleher said the teams aspirations for now will have to begin and end with the battle against the Crusaders. The first game is holy Cross. The only game, he said. The only one that matters.
comic
Join the Club | Simon Henriques
editorial cartoon b y a l e x y u ly
t h e b row n da i ly h e r a l d
Editor-in-chiEf claire peracchio ManaGinG Editors rebecca ballhaus nicole boucher GEnEral ManaGErs Siena delisser danielle marshak sEnior Editors tony bakshi natalie Villacorta BUSINESS officE ManaGEr Shawn reilly EDIToRIAL Sarah mancone Arts & Culture Editor Joseph rosales Arts & Culture Editor elizabeth carr City & State Editor amy rasmussen City & State Editor aparna bansal Features Editor Jordan hendricks Features Editor lucy feldman News Editor Shefali luthra News Editor alexandra macfarlane News Editor Sahil luthra Science & Research Editor Jake comer Sports Editor lindor qunaj Sports Editor Sam rubinroit Assistant Sports Editor dan Jeon Editorial Page Editor annika lichtenbaum Editorial Page Editor lucas husted Opinions Editor garret Johnson Opinions Editor Jared moffat Opinions Editor greg Jordan-detamore Special Projects Graphics & photos emily gilbert Photo Editor Sam kase Photo Editor tom Sullivan Photo Editor Photo Training Manager rachel kaplan Jonathan bateman Sports Photo Editor olivia conetta kyle mcnamara Julia Shube brisa bodell einat brenner neal poole production Copy Desk Chief Design Editor Design Editor Assistant Design Editor Assistant Design Editor Web Producer
dirEctors Julia kuwahara Samuel plotner nikita khadloya angel lee Sales Finance Alumni Relations Business Development ManaGErs Justin lee kaivan Shroff gregory chatzinoff luka ursic alison pruzan elizabeth gordon david Winer Human Resources Research & Development Collections Finance Operations Alumni Engagement Fundraising Marketing
facebook.com/browndailyherald
@the_herald
thebdh.org
CorreCtIonS PoLICy The Brown Daily herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication. C o M M e n tA r y P o L I C y The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of The Brown Daily herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only. LetterS to the eDItor PoLICy Send letters to letters@browndailyherald.com. Include a telephone number with all letters. The herald reserves the right to edit all letters for length and clarity and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may request anonymity, but no letter will be printed if the authors identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed. ADVertISInG PoLICy The Brown Daily herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.
BLoG DAILY HERALD matt klimerman meredith bilski Editor-in-Chief Managing Editor
taking sides 7
yes no
would resemble the real world much more, but your math skills, and your grasp on luCaS HuStEd theoretical be nearly asproblem solving would not good. Similarly, opinions Editor Brown should arm you with the tools to understand the world for yourself, not just the ability to follow directions. Given the amount of money people I would like to start by saying that I do pour into their education, the pressure not oppose the idea of pre-profession- to seek high-paying jobs after graduaalism. I think that it is critically impor- tion becomes even greater. But colleges tant to train individuals for the real would do well to continue to promote world, whether this means careers in the arts and the humanities. As Claire business, law, medicine or anything Gianotti 13 pointed out in a column else. I staunchly believe, however, that this week, these fields put ideas in conBrown is not the place for this out- text and help people think more broadside of the standard ly (A humanists set of pre-profescall to arms, sional programs that forget latin and Greek we Sept. 10). prepare students for while chalwill soon learn the finer skills lenging congraduate study. Simply put, a preof how to be an effective ventional ideas professional atmoisnt a skill that sphere is antithetiMorgan Stanley desk monkey. cal to what makes values in its apBrown so appealing, plicants, Brown namely, our open curriculum and our would fail you if it didnt teach you how non-competitive environment. these to formulate your own opinions. If we noble attributes of our community do change our courses to fit the needs of not just emerge from thin air. they ex- employers, and thus move away from ist because we, as a school, strive to our spirit of open inquiry and discovserve the community, the nation and ery, then we pay the price of having big the world by discovering, communicat- corporations engineer our curriculum. ing and preserving knowledge and un- Forget Latin and Greek, we will soon derstanding in a spirit of free inquiry. learn the finer skills of how to be an efthese words might not be familiar to fective desk monkey. Brown is a wonmany of you, but they are the central derful place, after all, and I would hate tenet of our mission statement. If our to see it offer classes that amount to litschool promoted, instead, a commit- tle more than training programs. ment to making students employable at all costs, something would seem just a little wrong. lucas Husted 13 doesnt hate the to those of you who are good at math, other Ivies as much as his first two imagine if your high-school teacher had columns of the semester indicate. let you use a calculator to do all of your He can be reached at lucas_husted@ work. your method of solving problems brown.edu.
Husteds Rebuttal
I agree with some of the arguments my opponent has made. She stresses the need for pre-medical students to learn more about diagnostics to help with medical school. As far as training for continued schooling is concerned, I am in full support of preprofessionalism. This edification is fundamentally different from the pre-professionalism encouraged by the crux of her argument, though that Brown should offer more career-focused classes. In my opinion, Brown should not encourage the use of class time for learning business leadership. In fact, we have resisted the temptation of having a business school altogether, and this is quite intentional. This defines Browns identity and makes it a truly wonderful place. So what is wrong with business or preprofessional programs? As a wall Street Journal article pointed out in April, undergraduate business degrees focus too much on the nuts and bolts of finance and accounting and dont develop enough critical thinking and problem-solving skills through long essays, in-class debates and other hallmarks of liberal-arts courses. According to the same article, many companies that used to look for business majors are now looking for candidates with a broader academic background. This sounds like the education that Brown tries hard to foster. Indeed, Brown stresses creativity, problem-solving and collaborative work. These are qualities that make our students happy, flexible and open-minded members of society, people that can come into a new experience and find great success. Though many Brunonians may find themselves mildly ill-prepared for mundane office work right after college, they will surely be well suited for greater life challenges, where creativity and critical thinking are stressed. So my fault with Fuerbachers argument is that it is too myopic. Could Brown students be a little more prepared for the first few years after college? Perhaps. would Brown students be ill-prepared for graduate school, higher levels at companies or more creative fields if they wasted class time learning things you can pick up in training? Absolutely. At the end of the day, the numbers dont lie. Brown has no trouble placing kids into medical schools or law schools. Applied Math-economics graduates have no trouble finding finance or consulting jobs either they will in fact have faced a much more rigorous math and economics curriculum then their business counterparts. Thus the Brown curriculum should continue to remain informed by research and discovery rather than by the needs of companies.
Fuerbachers Rebuttal
At first glance, Browns academic ethos and pre-professionalism might seem incompatible. Lucas husted 13 highlights a compromise whose virtue I myself questioned. yet upon further consideration, I reaffirmed my conviction that our University would be an ideal host for classes that expose undergraduates to pointed concepts they will face in their careers. Beyond our scholastic liberty, I would argue that Brown students are most distinguished by our robust passion for our interests and our drive to deeply explore those affinities. hence, furnishing students with more pre-professional options would only help accelerate our journey into the occupational realms that we Brunonians commonly lead and expand. I want to note that pre-professional does not mean anti-intellectual. Learning concepts applied on the job does not signify a total rejection of the theoretical underpinnings of those ideas, nor does it preclude students from questioning the material they absorb. even in my securities regulation class at wharton, which was pre-professional insofar as we examined specific statutes related to cases such as the lawsuit over Facebooks founding, the class professor, Andrea Matwyshyn, entertained thoughtprovoking discussions concerning the applicability and jurisprudence of financial regulations. we also hypothesized the fading relevance of existing SeC mandates regarding high-frequency trading. you might think this example only constitutes deep thought in the minds of Gordon Gekkoaspirants, but it nonetheless illustrates how pre-professional courses are not devoid of the intense scholastic inquiry that Brown encourages. Furthermore, to argue that preprofessionalism in and of itself signifies cutthroat competition is a misplaced attack on the educational approach. Browns classes are often curved anyway, so a latent competitiveness does exist. Given Browns aptitude for attracting talented, dedicated professors and motivated, inquisitive students, I do not doubt Browns prospects for success in the pre-professional realm. Paxsons term constructive irreverence is part of Browns DnA, and I am not advocating its temperance. I love Browns respect for individualism and the curricular liberty we enjoy. I believe the open curriculum should remain intact but should include more opportunities to take specialized classes. If anything, this expansion would sharpen our interests and add another dimension to our already multi-faceted characters. would taking corporate valuation, constitutional law or physiology drastically diminish your chance to read Pliny with classmates? I think the answer is no.
VolleyBAll
The womens volleyball team topped Providence College (1-13) in straight sets during the squads home opener wednesday, improving to .500 on the season. It was nice to beat the PCs because theyre our inter1 city rivals, said Pc 13 Alexandra rieck- Brown hoff 14. we get pretty fired up for our home games, and we always try to get our best friends out there in the stands. wednesdays showdown came after two tough match-ups for the Bears (3-3) at the yale Invitational Sept. 7 and 8. The squad fell to both northwestern University (8-0) and Villanova University in straight sets. nonetheless, head Coach Diane Short said she was happy her team rose to the competitions level and used the tournament as a learning experience. we played some top teams, and we competed well against them, she said. we can really hit against any team we play, which is one area we really improved on. rieckhoff noted that while the Bears were clearly outmatched in height at the
yale Invitational, she was impressed by how competitive they remained. (northwestern and Villanova have) big, tall girls, rieckhoff said. In the Ivy League, were just smaller teams than they are. Playing northwestern and hanging in there, even though we lost, was actually a big confidence boost for us because they got some votes for top-25 in the nation. with the momentum from their victory over the Friars behind them, the Bears look to improve their record as they head to Southern California for the Fullerton Classic Sept. 14 and 15. with 16 of the 20 girls on the Bears roster hailing from California, the trip will be a sort of homecoming. The girls played a part in planning the trip and helped to raise money for travel and accommodations. we pushed really hard for this one, rieckhoff said. we fundraised as a team, and were excited because we have friends (that well compete against). Venturing westward may have an extra benefit for the team: a boost in supporters. Most of the team is from California, so its like going back home for them, Short said. well actually probably get more fans out there just because of family, friends and alums.
the Brown womens volleyball team beat providence College during the home opener after losses to northwestern and Villanova last week.
Mens soccer team defender Dylan remick 13 has been named this weeks Athlete of the week for his strong play so far in the Bears young season. remick,
a unanimous selection for last years First team All-Ivy squad, was named Most Valuable Player of the ocean State Soccer Classic over Labor Day weekend, where the team (4-1) won with a pair of 1-0 victories. remick also scored the game-winning goal in Browns 2-0 win
against Cleveland State (5-2) last week. For his stellar play, remick has been named The heralds first Athlete of the week for this fall season. Herald: Whos your all-time favorite soccer player? remick: I really, really like David Villa and Gareth Bale. David Villa plays for Barcelona, and Gareth Bale plays for tottenham. do you support any professional soccer teams? yes. I sort of support teams in each league. I support tottenham in the ePL (english Premier League), which is what most people watch anyway. And then I support rayo Vallecano in the Spanish league. Whos your all-time favorite athlete? Id say Michael Jordan. I grew up in Chicago. his willingness to compete and win is just unlike any other Ive ever seen. do you have any superstitions or game rituals? yeah, Ive got a few. I like to listen to some taylor Swift before the game, and then I have a lucky pair of socks that I wear for each game. Whats your proudest soccer-related achievement? Id have to say winning the Ivy League last year was probably my proudest, just because we hadnt won it in so long. The seniors last year really, really wanted to win one because each Brown class has won one for mens soccer. So, they really wanted to continue that tradition. So, being a part of that winning
my first Ivy League was a big accomplishment for us all. Whats on your ipod? I like a lot of country taylor Swift. I listen to her before the games (thats) the reason why I really like her. I also have some hip-hop on there, a little bit of some jazz music for relaxing days. But I like pretty much everything. Ill sort of listen to anything. What are some of your favorite movies? It sort of depends on the genre. Let me think. Miracle is obviously a great inspiration movie of course Shawshank redemption is a great movie. I like all the classics Godfather, Scarface. How did you get into playing soccer? My familys a very athletic bunch. Both my mom and my dad played sports in high school. I have a twin brother, so we pretty much grew up playing every sport imaginable: baseball, soccer, basketball, tennis, golf. And we both really enjoyed playing soccer. So, I just continued to play and as I got better, older, it became more enjoyable. So I just stuck with it from there and havent looked back since. if you werent playing soccer, what would you play? well, I ran track in high school and I ran for my freshman year at Brown. So, Id assume that itd be running track. Its always fun to compete and run in the races in track. Its a different kind of sport because its more individual, whereas soccers a team, so I sort of like a little bit of that aspect as well.
Athlete of the Week Dylan remick 13 scored the game-winning goal against Cleveland state for the mens soccer team last week.
From measuring fragments of monasteries in Paris to performing some of the first archaeological explorations of the tiny Caribbean island of Montserrat, professors inBrowns archaeology department has had a busy summer. Speaking to a packed audience in rhode Island hall wednesday, six archaeologists presented the work they and their teams completed this season in an attempt to concisely answer the oft-asked question, So whats the best thing you found? Answers to this question were numerous and highlighted the diversity of projects undertaken by the department. A high point of the talk was a presentation by Stephen houston professor of archaeology, anthropology and social science on his fieldwork at the Mayan temple of the night Sun. Many of the projects continued work from past years. Professor of Archaeology, Anthropology and Classics John Cherry and his team completed year three of the Survey and Landscape Archaeology on Montserrat (SLAM) project this summer. The people of the small island of Montserrat in the west Indies have shared a home with an active volcano since 1995, when the Soufriere hills volcano came out of dormancy and began erupting, causing a mass evacuation of the southern half of the island and burying the capital city of Plymouth under 40 feet of ash. The volcanic activity and relocation of people and infrastructure to the north of the island have threatened the islands archaeological sites, many of which are undocumented. The aim of the SLAM project is to find and catalogue these sites and decide how much risk is posed to each site by the mass relocation of people and the continually erupting volcano, Cherry said. The team spent the summer trekking around the accessible half of the island cataloguing and exploring sites. Thus far, the team has found and explored about 45 sites and several hundred cultural landscape features, finding pieces like a 17th century Dutch pipe stem. An exciting discovery made by the team, Cherry said, included a site with artifacts dated from 2000-800 BC, making Montserrat one of only five islands in the eastern Caribbean on which artifacts from this period have been found. Prior to SLAM, the island had seen few archaeological projects and had no basic inventory of historical and prehistorical sites and cultural resources. to that end, the team also set up a temporary archaeological exhibit of artifacts in the island museum, taught archaeology in grade schools and represented archaeology at the islands career fair. Another cross-section of artifacts and culture was embarked upon by Peter van Dommelen, professor of archaeology and anthropology, who spent the summer studying knowledge and cul/ / Digs page 5 ture exchange