Sie sind auf Seite 1von 107

CENSORED MEDIA MEXICO, 2011

FUNDACIN MEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

WHY THE INVESTIGATION?


In the last six years, the Mexican media has come under sharp attack by organized crime. Forty-one journalists were killed between 2007 and 2012, coinciding with a government crackdown against drug cartels. Most of them were murdered because of their reporting on crime, according to the Austria-based International Press Institute (IPI). The trend made Mexico the most dangerous country for the media last year. In 2010, the Fundacin MEPI began monitoring self-censorship in local media. That first study was able to quantify black news holes throughout Mexico, places where media outlets had stopped reporting on most crime related to drug cartels. MEPI decided to launch a follow-up to the initial investigation. We monitored 14 out of 31 states in Mexico, covering 14 daily newspapers during 2011.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

THE RESULTS
Fear of retaliation by organized crime continued to influence news outlets decision on what to publish.
Regional coverage of organized crime rose 100 percent compared to the year prior. News outlets reported 7 out of every 10 incidents about organized crime. More reporting did not improve the quality of coverage. Eighty percent of the monitored dailies failed to add clear context to their reporting. MEPI found federal and local government agencies failed to provide the regional media with timely and accurate information about crime and security. MEPI also identified a troubling pattern in several states largely controlled by a single cartel. In those regions, anti-crime coverage often outweighed reports on criminal incidents. In contested territories, the opposite was true, likely because organized crime did not have the same stronghold on media in those parts.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

METHODOLOGY
We chose 14 online dailies with accessible archives.* We reviewed their crime stories during the year 2011. The articles were divided into two groups: stories that mentioned organized crime and those that did not. The content of each story was reviewed to determine state public safety trends and the hegemony of cartels. Factors considered were the use of official sources, narco language and how well the outlet explained the violence. Story content was also divided into two other categories: government anti-crime actions and organized crime activity. This review helped us understand how the news outlet portrayed drug-related violence to its readers.

_______ *In three states we only monitored six months of 2011 because of accessibility problems with the archives.
Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Government Anti-Crime Actions Tracked Arrests Police Operations Official Reports Seizures, Raids

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Organized Crime Activity Tracked Executions Extortions/Kidnappings Attacks on Government Offices/ Personnel Attacks on Police Threats to Schools Arson Home Invasions Shootouts, Heists and Armed Robberies Narco Paraphernalia Mass Graves Jail Breaks and Riots Attacks on Businesses Cartel-linked Female Killings Bombs, Grenades and MPG Attacks Cartel-related Corruption Road Blocks Known As Narco Blocks Attacks on Public Transport Attacks on Migrants Attacks on Drug Rehab Clinics Attacks Against Media Body Snatching Prostitution Tied to Cartels Messages in Banners, Graffiti

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

STATE
Coahuila Nuevo Len Ciudad Jurez Zacatecas Durango

MEDIA MONITORED ( 2011) MEDIA El Siglo de Torren El Norte Norte Imagen Zacatecas El Siglo de Durango

CRIME GROUPS NAMED IN NEWS STORIES


Sinaloa Cartel/Zetas Gulf Cartel/Zetas Juarez Cartel and Sinaloa Cartel Not named Not named La Resistencia, Zetas, La Familia Michoacana, Milenio Cartel, Jalisco Nueva Generacin Cartel
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Guadalajara

El Informador

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Sonora Tamaulipas Veracruz Morelia

El Imparcial El Maana La Jornada Veracruz La Voz de Michoacn

Arellano Felix, Sinaloa Cartel Zetas Zetas and La Familia Not Named

Morelos

El Diario de Morelos

Cartel Pacifico Sur, Gulf Cartel, Beltran Leyva Cartel, Sinaloa Cartel, La Familia, Zetas
Zetas, Gulf Cartel and Beltran Leyva Cartel Zetas Sinaloa Cartel
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Aguascalientes Hidalgo Sinaloa


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

El Sol de Aguascalientes El Sol de Hidalgo El Noroeste

TORREN, COAHUILA

El Siglo de Torren

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL SIGLO DE TORREN


140

120

100

80

60

40

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

800 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Government anti-crime efforts
Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS


Wrapped in blankets/With a bag over the head

Decapitated/Dismembered

Bound

Shootout

Executions

0 Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


120

100

80

60

El Siglo de Torren Government Statistics

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


400

350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Series1

Members of organized crime 62

Local government officials 19

Federal government Municipal/state/tran officials sit police officers 7 29

Teenagers/Youth 84

Not specified 354


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Siglo de Torren

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Torren is caught in the crossfire between two cartels battling for hegemony the Zetas and Sinaloa Cartel. There were a greater number of reports on activities by organized crime than government actions. El Siglo de Torren cited official sources when reporting on organized crime murders. When information is available, the daily publishes victims names and other descriptive characteristics that may help in the official identification of the bodies. Torren is a vibrant industrial center and the business sector has been greatly affected by organized crime. Changes in daily life: -Physicians did not make house calls. -Schools taught children, as young as 6 years of age, how to protect themselves during shootings.
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Cartel Attacks on EL SIGLO DE TORREN


*November 2011. Three armed individuals attacked the newspaper's subscription offices, setting fire to a car parked near the entrance. The assailants sprayed the front faade with bullets from AK-47 rifles.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

CIUDAD JUREZ, CHIHUAHUA

Norte

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS NORTE


350

300

250 Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention drug trafficking

200

150

100

50

January
*Only 6 months
Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

February

March

April

May

June

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS


450

400

350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Burned

Decapitated/Dismembered

Shootout

Executions

0 Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

50

100

150

200

*According to crime stories

250 www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


350

300

250

200

Norte Government Statistics


150

100

50

0 January February March April May June Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus **According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics. www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


400

350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Series1

Members of organized crime 20

Local government 18

Federal government 5

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 27

Teenagers/Youth 66

Not specified 357


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from Norte

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


The daily Norte only reports on Ciudad Juarez, a vibrant city center that was overran by drug violence in 2010. MEPI monitored the first six months in 2011 when violence peaked before subsiding by year's end when the Sinaloa Cartel took over the territory from the Juarez Cartel and several smaller gangs. There is a general distrust of federal police forces in the city and according to local journalists, citizens tend to believe more in the word of local drug leaders than officials, despite the drug-related violence. Changes in daily life: -Local government officials warn youth against attending house parties after a number of mass murders at private homes. -Threats on schools multiply. Parents keep children away from school. -Organized crime groups focused recruitment efforts on youth. Young women were selected to collect extorsion money.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Durango, Durango

El Siglo de Durango

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL SIGLO DE DURANGO


60

50

40 Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

30

20

10

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

400

350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Burned

Strangled

Decapitated/Dismembered

Shootout

Executions

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


250

200

150

El Siglo de Durango
100

Government Statistics

50

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the daily's crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Members of organized crime Series1 47

Local government officials 17

Federal government officials 5

Municipal/state/tra Teenagers/Youth nsit police officers 23 24

Not specified 321


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Siglo de Durango

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


The news outlet mentioned organized crime activity in its reporting but no specific cartels were named. In 2011 authorities in Durango found several mass graves with about 200 bodies in them. Security experts believe that the organized crime groups that buried the bodies were trying to hide them to avoid retaliation. The state is a contested territory among the Sinaloa Cartel and the Zetas. Organized crime used high-powered rifles and attacked state police forces in groups of up to 50 men.

During the first four months of 2011, the armed forces reported capturing 168 organized crime members, but the daily did not report on most of these arrests.
Changes in daily life: -Being a musician or lawyer became a high-risk profession. The Law College of Durango and the Musicians Conservatory reported high numbers of threats and kidnappings.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

ZACATECAS, ZACATECAS

Imagen Zacatecas

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS IMAGEN ZACATECAS


140

120

100

80

60

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Beaten

Executions

Shootout

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


35

30

25

20

Imagen Zacatecas
15

Government Statistics

10

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the daily's crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


120

100

80

60

40

20

Series1

Members of organized crime 114

Local government 3

Federal government 10

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 10

Teenagers/Youth 10

Not specified 72
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from Imagen Zacatecas

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Zacatecas is a state where the Zetas had considerable control in 2011. However, the stories in the daily quoted citizens expressing admiration and trust for the army units patrolling the state.

The daily reported on more anti-crime activities that on those actions carried out by organized crime, a trend that was common in states controlled by one cartel.
No cartels were named in the news stories. The daily described organized crime members as armed groups or armed civilians. In early 2011, reports on the kidnappings and release of state and municipal policemen highlighted cartel efforts to infiltrate the police. Changes in daily life: -Taxi drivers stopped night work out of fear for their safety. The Zetas often forced them to become lookouts and informants.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

GUADALAJARA, JALISCO

El Informador

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL INFORMADOR


50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

400

350

300

250

200

150

100

50

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Strangled

Wrapped in blankets/With a bag over the head

Shootout

Bound

Executions

50

100

150

200

250

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


100

90
80 70

60
50 40

El Informador Government Statistics

30
20 10 0

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the daily's crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


200 180

160

140

120

100

80

60

40

20

Series1

Members of organized crime 58

Local government 8

Federal government 1

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 14

Teenagers/Youth 62

Not specified 187


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Imparcial

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


El Informador, unlike other news outlets, benefitted from complete and timely crime reports from officials in Guadalajara, the country's second largest city. The news outlet provided context in their stories about public safety and organized crime as the city suffered, for the first time in recent memory, a bout of high-profile murder cases such as 26 bodies dumped in a city street. Guadalajara had been controlled by the Sinaloa Cartel until recently. The following cartels were identified in news reports as fighting for control in the state: La Resistencia, Zetas, La Familia, Nueva Generacin Cartel and Milenio Cartel. Executions often took place during parties and at restaurants, in the presence of many witnesses. Cartels blocked principal streets to protest government detentions of their members. Bodies were found hog-tied and with a plastic bag over the head.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

CIUDAD VICTORIA, TAMAULIPAS

El Maana

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL MAANA


1000 900 800 700

600
500 400 300 200 100

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

600

500

400

300

200

100

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Decapitated/ Dismembered

Executions

Shootout

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


300

250

200

150

El Maana Government Statistics

100

50

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

** According to the daily's crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


80

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

Series1

Members of organized crime 12

Local government 0

Federal government 1

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 0

Teenagers/Youth 0

Not specified 73
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Maana

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Tamaulipas is a state largely controlled by the Zetas Cartel, which enforced tight editorial restrictions on the media in 2011. Yet, the outlet rarely acknowledged organized crime. The handful of crime stories it did report on took place in the Texas Valley including extortions and shootings. This had not been prevalent in the 2010 MEPI study. For the second year in a row, El Maana, appeared to observe almost complete self-censorship. The few stories on organized crime reported in 2011 focused on the Zetas competing cartel, the Gulf Cartel. The daily frequently overlooked stories that did not reflect well on the Zetas. For instance in 2011, the daily did not write about the murder of blogger La Nena de Laredo who was presumably slain by Zetas for her critical reports on local crime. Tamaulipas is an international transportation hub. There are 16 bi-national bridges between Tamaulipas and the Texas Valley.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

MONTERREY, NUEVO LEN

El Norte

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL NORTE


120

100

80

60

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

1200

1000

800

600

400

200

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS


Burned

Bound

Decapitated/ Dismembered

Shootout

Executions

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


250

200

150

El Norte
100

Government Statistics

50

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

** According to the daily's crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


600

500

400

300

200

100

Series1

Members of organized crime 351

Local government 15

Federal government 16

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 84

Teenagers/Youth 218

Not specified 531


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Norte

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Monterrey endured a bloody year as two cartels, the Zetas and the Gulf Cartel, battled for control of this wealthy industrial and financial center. El Norte is considered among the country's best newspapers. Its reporting on the drug conflict is extensive and the outlet was among the few Mexican dailies monitored that provided context in news accounts and did follow-ups. El Norte enjoyed an engaged readership, which often commented at length at the end of stories on public safety. It also published a special section on deaths connected to organized crime. The outlet fully identified minors linked to organized crime activities. It reported on car accidents stemming from car chases between organized crime groups and the armed forces, which have taken over police duties. People supported and respected the federal forces which patrolled the city in 2011, according to the outlet. They were weary of local police, which were identified by readers as poliZe, tranZite and muniZipal, using the Z as a reference to the Zeta cartel.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet (continued):


The outlet reported on so-called body rescues by cartels that stole bodies at crime scenes before police could identify them. Between 2010 to 2011 female homicides nearly tripled. In 70 percent of the cases the women were decapitated. Cartels increasingly used children 10 to 15 years old as lookouts and drug runners. Cartels retaliated against individual enemies by killing their entire family.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

JALAPA, VERACRUZ

La Jornada

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS LA JORNADA


40

35

30

25

20

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

15

10

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

160

140

120

100

80

60

40

20

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus **According to crime stories

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Executions

Shootout

0 Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

10

15

20

25 www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

*According to the police stories

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


140

120

100

80

La Jornada
60

Government Statistics

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


160

140

120

100

80

60

40

20

Members of organized crime

Local government

Federal government

Municipal/state/transit police

Teenagers/Youth

Not specified

Series1 86 Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

10

**With data from La Jornada

148 www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


The year 2011 was among the most violent for the southern state of Veracruz and for its journalism community. Four journalists were targeted and killed by alleged organized crime hitmen. In 2010, MEPI monitored the daily El Dictamen based in Jalapa, Veracruz. For the second study, that daily had limited online reporting of crime. So for 2011 MEPI chose to monitor the regional version of the national daily La Jornada. During the first three months of 2011, the daily reported on an alarming growth in organized crime activity. According to journalists, the Zetas had held tight controls over the state for the last few years. But the arrival of the Mexican Navy, challenged that group's power base. The outlet reported that transit police colluded with the Zetas, and that human trafficking and livestock theft generated income for organized crime. The daily warned readers that criminal groups were recruiting youth as lookouts and campesinos to grow marijuana.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

CUERNAVACA, MORELOS

El Diario de Morelos

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL DIARIO DE MORELOS


160

140

120

100

80

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

60

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

***According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

439

438.5

438

437.5

437

436.5

436

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

***According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Strangled

Wrapped in blankets/With a bag over the head

Decapitated/Dismembered

Bound

Executions

20

40

60

80

100

120

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


35

30

25

20

El Diario de Morelos
15

Government Statistics

10

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


120

100

80

60

40

20

Series1

Members of organized crime 10

Local government 2

Federal government 1

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 10

Teenagers/Youth 56

Not specified 98
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Diario de Morelos

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Morelos is a state that until 2010 had been controlled by the Beltran Leyva drug cartel. But with the takedown of the cartels top leaders, the organization lost hegemony. Several other groups began fighting for control of the state. Morelos was one of the states where the MEPI study found that the presence of competing cartels benefitted press coverage. Without a single cartel exerting control, the media was able to operate more freely. El Diario de Morelos attempted to provide context to crime stories. It always quoted authorities in their articles. The daily explained turf battles among crime groups. The outlet published the content of narco messages, unlike most other dailies, and often detailed gruesome killings. About nine out of 10 executions included a narco message, commonly used by cartels to send messages to other organized crime groups. Organized crime lookouts developed sophisticated techniques such as the use of surveillance cameras to monitor drug territories. The daily wrote stories about organized criminals mocking authorities.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

AGUASCALIENTES, AGUASCALIENTES

El Sol de Aguascalientes

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL SOL DE AGUASCALIENTES


60

50

40

30

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

20

10

January
*Only 5 months Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

February

March

April

May
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

80

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Strangled

Executions

10

12

14

16

18

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


16

14

12

10

El Sol de Aguascalientes
8

Government Statistics

January
Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

February

March

April

May
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


25

20

15

10

Members of organized crime

Local government

Federal government

Municipal/state/transit police

Teenagers/Youth

Not specified

Series1 10 Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Sol de Aguascalientes

21 www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


El Sol de Aguascalientes named the Zetas cartel in their stories and said the group was fighting with another criminal organization. La Familia Michoacana has been identified by Mexican federal forces as having some control in this state. But the daily never mentioned them. As in other states where the Zetas or the Familia Michoacana wielded some control, the press reported more on government anti-crime efforts. The daily included narco messages in their stories and employed language used by narcos to describe guns and types of crimes, such as levanton, which means kidnapping.

The daily reported that organized crime often recruited children as young as 15 years
old.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

PACHUCA, HIDALGO

El Sol de Hidalgo

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL SOL DE HIDALGO


300

250

200

150

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

100

50

January
*Only 5 months Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

February

March

April

May
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

100 90 80 70 60

50
40 30 20 10 0

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS


Shootout

Burned

Wrapped in blankets/With a bag over the head

Executions

10

12

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


12

10

El Sol de Hidalgo
6

Government Statistics

January
Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

February

March

April

May
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


18

16

14

12

10

Members of organized crime

Local government

Federal government

Municipal/state/transit police

Teenagers/Youth

Not specified

Series1 0 Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Sol de Hidalgo

16 www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Hidalgo is a state where the Zetas held control of most drug trafficking routes. The outlet did not use narco language, such as levanton (kidnapping) but preferred the word desaparicion. The daily wrote about prostitution rings, which they downplayed by identifying them as escort services. Prostitution is largely controlled by the Zetas, according to national sex workers union. The outlet also wrote about contraband and piracy, important revenue generating activities for organized crime.

The daily rarely quoted officials in their crime stories.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

MORELIA, MICHOACN

La Voz de Michoacn

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS LA VOZ DE MICHOACN


160

140

120

100

80

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

60

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

600

500

400

300

200

100

0 Government anti-crime efforts Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus Organized crime activities www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Stab

Bound

Shootout

Executions

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


90

80

70

60

50

40

La Voz de Michoacn Government Statistics

30

20

10

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Michoacan is state that is widely controlled by La Familia Michoacana and its splinter group the Knights Templars. However, La Voz de Michoacan, never named either group in its daily crime stories. It did not provide context to crime incidents or draw obvious conclusions about crime patterns. Like other states where one cartel dominated the territory, most crime stories focused on government anti-crime efforts. The newspaper based its reports on military and federal police bulletins. Few stories cited local or state police. Extortion had been a serious problem in this state for the last few years. However, the extortion antics seemed to have escalated and victims were now forced to hand over titles to land and other real estate property. The state is considered dangerous by the Mexican Red Cross, which employed conflict zone procedures while operating in the state. All stories had bylines. Photographs were graphic.
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

HERMOSILLO, SONORA

El Imparcial

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL IMPARCIAL


250

200

150

Police stories that do not mention organized crime


100

Police stories that do mention organized crime

50

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

900 800 700

600
500 400 300 200 100 0 Government anti-crime efforts Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus Organized crime activities www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS

Bound

Shootout

Executions

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

*According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


60

50

40

30

El Imparcial Government Statistics

20

10

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 Series1

Members of organized crime 11

Local government 3

Federal government 1

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 11

Teenagers/Youth 0

Not specified 17
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Imparcial

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Sonora state is controlled by two organized crime groups, the Sinaloa Cartel and remnants of the Beltran Leyva Cartel. The daily El Imparcial provided context in news stories on organized crime. It quoted official sources who consistently identified victims as members of organized crime. However, in stories where government representatives were the victims, officials did not provide immediate information on the cause of death. The outlet used narco terminology to refer to specific crimes and even weapons.

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

CULIACN, SINALOA

El Noroeste

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

2011 CRIME STORIES-GENERAL ANALYSIS EL NOROESTE


180

160

140

120

100

80

Police stories that do not mention organized crime Police stories that do mention organized crime

60

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to crime stories

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

DRUG-RELATED VIOLENCE AS PORTRAYED TO READERS

1200

1000

800

600

400

200

Government anti-crime efforts


Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Organized crime activities


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

**According to crime stories

TYPES OF CARTEL-RELATED MURDERS


Decapitated/Dismembered

Wrapped in blankets/With a bag over the head

Shootout

Bound

Executions

0 Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

100

200

300

400

*According to crime stories

500 600 www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT HOMICIDES LINKED TO ORGANIZED CRIME


180

160

140

120

100

80

El Noroeste Government Statistics

60

40

20

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**According to the dailys crime stories and government homicide statistics.

www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

VIOLENT CRIME VICTIMS


350

300

250

200

150

100

50

0 Series1

Members of organized crime 63

Local government 14

Federal government 5

Municipal/state/tra nsit police 64

Teenagers/Youth 197

Not specified 308


www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

**With data from El Noroeste

Public Safety Trends Reported by the News Outlet:


Sinaloa, the seat of Mexicos oldest organized crime group, the Sinaloa Cartel, experienced unprecedented violence in 2011 as the Zetas tried penetrate their territory. The Zetas incursion was in response to the Sinaloa cartels involvement in Veracruz the same year. The Sinaloa Cartel has controlled this region for the last 30 years. El Noroeste and other media in this state operate under a sort of dtente with the cartel. The media knows its limits. It does not publish names of cartel leaders, nor logistics about drug operations. Narco messages printed by the outlet often identify the victims and give the reason as to why they were killed. The daily had access to crime scenes and official investigation documents. The daily wrote stories that warned citizens of organized crime antics. One activity they wrote on described how criminals posed as couples with children to rent residential properties that were used as stash houses, or to hide kidnap victims. Readers demanded that the daily do more investigations.
www.fundacionmepi.org @FMEPI

Tecnolgico de Monterrey, Mexico City Campus

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen