Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
FACULTY OF MEDICINE
DEPARTMENT OF HYGIENE, PUBLIC HEALTH AND PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM
SOCIAL-HYGIENIC PROBLEMS
OF PUBLIC HEALTH
AND PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM
IN COUNTRIES AROUND THE WORLD
(INDIA)
Name of
student - Deepankar Srigyan
Group-
ML 511
Name of
teacher- Ph.D. S. S. Kupov
Submitted in
Dep.:
1
MOSCOW 2008
2
there, while Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam arrived in
the first millennium CE and shaped the region's diverse culture.
Gradually annexed by the British East India Company from the early
eighteenth century and colonised by the United Kingdom from the mid-
nineteenth century, India became an independent nation in 1947 after
a struggle for independence that was marked by widespread nonviolent
resistance.
CONTENTS
Snapshot …………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………. 3
Preface ……………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………. 5
MAIN CHAPTERS:
3
1. Population statistics …………………………………………………………
………………….. 37
2. Population dynamics ………………………………………………………
……………………..41
• Mechanical population movement ………………………………………
…………………....41
• Brain drain problem …………………………………………………………
…………………….. 47
• Infant mortality ………………………………………………………………
……………………… 49
• Birth rate ………………………………………………………………………
……………………….. 52
• Average life expectancy ……………………………………………………
……………………... 54
• Fertility and contraception …………………………………………………
…………………….58
• Morbidity …………………………………………………………………………
……………………...59
• Physical growth ………………………………………………………………
……………………….67
• Disability …………………………………………………………………………
………………………69
IV. ORGANIZATION OF THE PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM ………………………
……………. 70
V. MOTHER AND CHILD HEALTH CARE IN THE COUNTRY …………………
……………73
VI. PUBLIC HEALTH PLANNING, FINANCIAL AND ECONOMIC PROBLEMS
IN THE COUNTRY …………………………………………………………………
………………………………..87
VII. MEDICAL STAFF …………………………………………………………………
……………………...95
VIII. RELATIONS BETWEEN INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS AND
PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM IN THE COUNTRY ………………………………
………………………….. 98
IX. PUBLIC HEALTH DEVELOPMENT PERSPECTIVES …………………………
…………..106
X. ANALYSE AND SUGGESTIONS …………………………………………………
………………. 113
XI. CONCLUSIONS ……………………………………………………………………
Motto:
Republic of India 116
…………………...
"Satyameva
XII. BIBLIOGRAPHY ……………………………………………………………………
Jayate"
…………………..117
सतयमेव जयते
"Truth Alone
Triumphs"
Snapshot : National Song :
Anthem: Vande Mataram
Jana Gana Mana I bow to thee, 4
Thou art the ruler Mother
Flagof National Emblem
the minds of all
Capital New Delhi
Largest city Mumbai
Official languages Hindi,
English
Demonym Indian
Government
Parliamentary democracy
Federal
republic
- President Pratibha
Patil
5
Independence from British
colonial rule
- Declared 15 August 1947
- Republic 26 January
1950
Area
- Total
3,287,240 km² (7th)
1,269,210 s
q mi
Population
- 2008 estimate
1,147,995,904 (2nd)
- 2001 census
1,027,015,248
- Density
349/km² (33rd)
904/sq m
6
Calling code 91
PREFACE
This report explores the social conditions of the population, public
health problems and public health services of India. This report
captures the knowledge and experience of public health system in
India. The level of social conditions of the population of India
depends on the level of national economy. The social, political and
economic problems worth today in front of India are complex.
Therefore, it is important to pay attention on structure of economy
of India, which is completely depend on agriculture, the industry,
an infrastructure and foreign trade of India. It helps to define
principles of the accelerated economic development and to plan
economy of India which in turn can support development of social
hygiene in the financial attitude.
The tremendous accelerating population of India is the main barrier
in the way of development of this country. The improved level of
social condition of the population of India and the decision of tasks
in view, planning and the organization of public health services to
veil from the analysis of the present condition of the following
areas of demography: parameters of the population, statistics of a
life, social parameters, water supply and conditions hygiene, a
level of a feed of children, the organization of services of public
health services, management of public health services, protection
and hygiene of work, a professional training in the field of public
health services, financing and distribution of the humanitarian
help, disease and death rate, care of patients and research activity
in the field of public health services. Therefore, in the given work
pays the big attention to the parameters, describing the present
7
level of social hygiene in these areas. It helps to define in further
principles of development of social hygiene and to plan and carry
out actions on improvement of public health services in India.
MAIN CHAPTERS:
Government
National Symbols of
The Constitution of India, the longest and the India
most exhaustive constitution of any
Flag Tricolour
independent nation in the world, came into
Emble Sarnath Lion
force on January 26, 1950. The preamble of
m Capital
the constitution defines India as
Anthe Jana Gana
a sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic rep
m Mana
ublic. India has a bicameral parliament
operating under a Westminster- Song Vande
Mataram
style parliamentary system. Its form of
government was traditionally described as Anima Royal Bengal
l Tiger
being 'quasi-federal' with a strong centre and
weaker states, but it has grown increasingly Bird Indian Peafowl
federal since the late 1990s as a result of Flowe Lotus
political, economic and social changes. r
The President of India is the head of Tree Banyan
Fruit Mango
Sport Field hockey 8
Calen Saka
dar
state elected indirectly by an electoral college for a five-year term. ThePrime
Minister is the head of government and exercises most executive
powers. Appointed by the President, the Prime Minister is by convention
supported by the party or political alliance holding the majority of seats in the
lower house of Parliament. The executive branch consists of the President,
Vice-President, and the Council of Ministers (the Cabinet being its executive
committee) headed by the Prime Minister. Any minister holding a portfolio
must be a member of either house of parliament. In the Indian parliamentary
system, the executive is subordinate to the legislature, with the Prime Minister
and his Council being directly responsible to the lower house of the
parliament.
The legislature of India is the bicameral Parliament, which consists of the
upper house called the Rajya Sabha (Council of States) and the lower house
called the Lok Sabha (House of People). The Rajya Sabha, a permanent body,
has 245 members serving staggered six year terms. Most are elected
indirectly by the state and territorial legislatures in proportion to the state's
population. 543 of the Lok Sabha's 545 members are directly elected by
popular vote to represent individual constituencies for five year terms. The
other two members are nominated by the President from theAnglo-
Indian community if the President is of the opinion that community is not
adequately represented.
Politics
9
political party a majority, the INC formed a minority government under Prime
Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao and was able to complete its five-year term.
The years 1996–1998 were a period of turmoil in the federal government with
several short-lived alliances holding sway. The BJP formed a government
briefly in 1996, followed by the United Front coalition that excluded both the
BJP and the INC. In 1998, the BJP formed the National Democratic
Alliance (NDA) with several other parties and became the first non-Congress
government to complete a full five-year term. In the 2004 Indian elections, the
INC won the largest number of Lok Sabha seats and formed a government with
a coalition called the United Progressive Alliance (UPA), supported by various
left-leaning parties and members opposed to the BJP.
In recent years, India has played an influential role in the ASEAN, SAARC, and
the WTO. India has provided as many as 55,000 Indian military and police
personnel to serve in thirty-five UN peace keeping operations across four
continents. Despite criticism and military sanctions, India has consistently
refused to sign the CTBT and the NPT, preferring instead to maintain
sovereignty over its nuclear program. Recent overtures by the Indian
government have strengthened relations with the United States, China and
Pakistan. In the economic sphere, India has close relationships with other
developing nations in South America, Asia and Africa.
10
India maintains the third-largest military force in the world, which consists of
the Indian Army, Navy and Air Force. Auxiliary forces such as the Paramilitary
Forces, the Coast Guard, and the Strategic Forces Command also come under
the military's purview. The President of India is the supreme commander of the
Indian armed forces. India maintains close defence cooperation with Russia,
France and Israel, who are the chief suppliers of arms. The Defence Research
and Development Organisation (DRDO) has overseen the indigenous
development of sophisticated arms and military equipment, including ballistic
missiles, fighter aircrafts and main battle tanks, to reduce India's dependence
on foreign imports. India became a nuclear power in 1974 after conducting an
initial nuclear test, Operation Smiling Buddha and further underground
testing in 1998. India maintains a "no first use" nuclear policy. On 10 October,
2008 Indo-US civilian nuclear agreement was signed, prior to which India
received the IAEA and NSG waivers, ending restrictions on nuclear technology
commerce with which India became de facto sixth nuclear power in world.
Subdivisions
• Climate-geographical particularities
Geography
11
India's defining geological processes commenced seventy-five million years
ago, when the Indian subcontinent, then part of the southern
supercontinent Gondwana, began a northeastwards drift-lasting fifty million
years—across the then unformed Indian Ocean. The subcontinent's
subsequent collision with the Eurasian Plateand subduction under it, gave rise
to the Himalayas, the planet's highest mountains, which now abut India in
the north and the north-east. In the former seabed immediately south of the
emerging Himalayas, plate movement created a vast through, which, having
gradually been filled with river-borne sediment, now forms the Indo-Gangetic
Plain. To the west of this plain, and cut off from it by the Aravalli Range, lies
the Thar Desert. The original Indian plate now survives as peninsular India, the
oldest and geologically most stable part of India, and extending as far north as
the Satpura and Vindhya ranges in central India. These parallel ranges run
from the Arabian Sea coast in Gujarat in the west to the coal-rich Chota
Nagpur Plateau in Jharkhand in the east. To their south, the remaining
peninsular landmass, the Deccan Plateau, is flanked on the left and right by
the coastal ranges, Western Ghats and Eastern Ghats respectively; the
plateau contains the oldest rock formations in India, some over one billion
years old. Constituted in such fashion, India lies to the north of the equator
between 6°44' and 35°30' north latitude and 68°7' and 97°25' east longitude.
India's coast is 7,517 kilometers (4,671 mi) long; of this distance,
5,423 kilometers (3,370 mi) belong to peninsular India, and 2,094 kilometers
(1,301 mi) to the Andaman, Nicobar, and Lakshadweep Islands. According to
the Indian naval hydrographic charts, the mainland coast consists of the
following: 43% sandy beaches, 11% rocky coast including cliffs, and 46%
mudflats or marshy coast.
Major Himalayan-origin rivers that substantially flow through India include
the Ganges and the Brahmaputra, both of which drain into the Bay of
Bengal. Important tributaries of the Ganges include the Yamuna and the Kosi,
whose extremely low gradient causes disastrous floods every year. Major
peninsular rivers whose steeper gradients prevent their waters from flooding
include the Godavari, the Mahanadi, the Kaveri, and the Krishna, which also
drain into the Bay of Bengal; and theNarmada and the Tapti, which drain into
the Arabian Sea. Among notable coastal features of India are the marshy Rann
of Kutch in western India, and the alluvial Sundarbans delta, which India
shares with Bangladesh. India has two archipelagos: the Lakshadweep, coral
atolls off India's south-western coast; and the Andaman and Nicobar Islands, a
volcanic chain in the Andaman Sea.
India's climate is strongly influenced by the Himalayas and the Thar Desert,
both of which drive the monsoons. The Himalayas prevent cold Central Asian
katabatic winds from blowing in, keeping the bulk of the Indian subcontinent
warmer than most locations at similar latitudes. The Thar Desert plays a
crucial role in attracting the moisture-laden southwest summer monsoon
winds that, between June and October, provide the majority of India's
rainfall. Four major climatic groupings predominate in India: tropical
wet, tropical dry, subtropical humid, and montane.
12
The Bengal tiger, threatened by poachers and
smugglers, faces declining population levels and
possible extinction.
Economy
Del
hi Metro. 13
With an average annual GDP growth rate of 5.7% for the past two decades, the
economy is among the fastest growing in the world. India has the world's
second largest labour force, with 516.3 million people, 60% of whom are
employed in agriculture and related industries; 28% in services and related
industries; and 12% inindustry. Major agricultural crops include rice, wheat,
oilseed, cotton, jute, tea, sugarcane, and potatoes. The agricultural sector
accounts for 28% of GDP; the service and industrial sectors make up 54% and
18% respectively. Major industries include automobiles, cement, chemicals,
consumer electronics, food processing, machinery, mining, petroleum,
pharmaceuticals, steel, transportation equipment, and textiles. Along with
India’s fast economic growth comes its growing demand for energy. According
to the Energy Information Administration, India is the sixth largest consumer of
oil and third largest consumer of coal.
Although the Indian economy has grown steadily over the last two decades; its
growth has been uneven when comparing different social groups, economic
groups, geographic regions, and rural and urban areas. Income inequality in
India is relatively small (Gini coefficient: 36.8 in year 2004), though it has
been increasing of late. Wealth distribution in India is fairly uneven, with the
top 10% of income groups earning 33% of the income. Despite significant
economic progress, a quarter of the nation's population earns less than the
14
government-specified poverty threshold of $0.40 per day. In 2004–2005,
27.5% of the population was living below the poverty line.
More recently, India has capitalised on its large pool of educated, English-
speaking people, and trained professionals to become an
important outsourcing destination for multinational corporations and a popular
destination for medical tourism. India has also become a major exporter of
software as well as financial, research, and technological services. Its natural
resources include arable land, bauxite, chromite, coal, diamonds, iron ore,
limestone, manganese, mica, natural gas, petroleum, and titanium ore.
In 2007, exports stood at US$145 billion and imports were around US$217
billion. Textiles, jewellery, engineering goods and software are major export
commodities while crude oil, machineries, fertilizers, and chemicals are major
imports. India's most important trading partners are the United States,
the European Union, and China.
15
1999 and 2008, the best performing states grew at over 8% annualized rate
compared to under 5% in the worst-performing states. Further reforms have
proceeded slowly amid political debate.
Two-thirds of the Indian workforce still earn their livelihood directly or indirectly
through agriculture in rural villages. However, non-agricultural jobs and towns
are playing an increasingly important role in India's economy. More recently,
India has capitalised on its large pool of educated, English-speaking people,
and trained professionals to become an important outsourcing destination for
multinational corporations and a popular destination for medical tourism.
Other sectors like manufacturing, pharmaceuticals, biotechnology,
nanotechnology telecommunication, shipbuilding, aviation and tourism are
showing strong potentials with high growth rates.
Agriculture
India is the largest producer in the world of milk, cashew nuts, coconuts, tea,
ginger, turmeric and black pepper. It also has the world's largest cattle
population (193 million). It is the second largest producer of wheat, rice, sugar,
groundnut and inland fish. It is the third largest producer of tobacco. India
accounts for 10% of the world fruit production with first rank in the production
of banana and sapota.
16
and Information Network, and Development / Strengthening of Agricultural
Marketing Infrastructure, Grading and Standardization.
Industrial output
34 Indian companies have been listed in the Forbes Global 2000 ranking for
2007. The 10 leading companies are:
17
Reliance Oil & Gas
258 18.05 2.11 21.75 42.62
Industries Operations
Steel Authority
800 Materials 6.30 0.91 7.06 10.16
of India Limited
Tata
Software &
1047 Consultancy 2.98 0.67 1.93 26.27
Services
Svcs
Services source :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/in.
India is fifteenth in services output. Service industry employs 23% of the work
force and is growing quickly, with a growth rate of 7.5% in 1991–2000, up from
4.5% in 1951–80. It has the largest share in the GDP, accounting for 53.8% in
2005 up from 15% in 1950. Business services (information technology,
information technology enabled services, business process outsourcing) are
among the fastest growing sectors contributing to one third of the total output
of services in 2000. The growth in the IT sector is attributed to increased
specialisation and availability of a large pool of low cost. Highly skilled,
educated and fluent English-speaking workers on the supply side and on the
demand side, has increased demand from foreign consumers interested in
18
India's service exports or those looking to outsource their operations. India's IT
industry, despite contributing significantly to its balance of payments,
accounts for only about 1% of the total GDP or 1/50th of the total services.
19
Currently, India has 88 scheduled commercial banks (SCBs) — 28 public sector
banks (that is with the Government of India holding a stake), 29 private banks
(these do not have government stake; they may be publicly listed and traded
on stock exchanges) and 31 foreign banks. They have a combined network of
over 53,000 branches and 17,000 ATMs. The public sector banks hold over
75% of total assets of the banking industry, with the private and foreign banks
holding 18.2% and 6.5% respectively.
Oil
India had about 5.6 billion barrels (890,000,000 m3) of proven oil reserves as
of January 2007, which is the second-largest amount in the Asia-Pacific region
behind China. Most of India's crude oil reserves are located in the western
coast (Mumbai High) and in the northeastern parts of the country, although
considerable undeveloped reserves are also located in the offshore Bay of
Bengal and in the state of Rajasthan.
Sector organisation
As a net importer of oil, the Government of India has introduced policies aimed
at growing domestic oil production and oil exploration activities. As part of the
effort, the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas crafted the New Exploration
License Policy (NELP) in 2000, which permits foreign companies to hold 100%
equity possession in oil and natural gas projects. However, to date, only a
handful of oil fields are controlled by foreign firms. India’s downstream sector
is also dominated by state-owned entities, though private companies have
enlarged their market share in past recent years.
20
Natural gas
As per the Oil and Gas Journal, India had 38 trillion cubic feet (Tcf) of confirmed
natural gas reserves as of January 2007. A huge mass of India’s natural gas
production comes from the western offshore regions, particularly the Mumbai
High complex. The onshore fields in Assam, Andhra Pradesh, and Gujarat
states are also major producers of natural gas. As per EIA data, India produced
996 billion cubic feet (Bcf) of natural gas in 2004.
India imports small amounts of natural gas. In 2004, India consumed about
1,089×109 cu ft (3.08×1010 m3) of natural gas, the first year in which the
country showed net natural gas imports. During 2004, India imported
93×109 cu ft (2.6×109 m3) of liquefied natural gas (LNG) from Qatar.
Sector Organization
As in the oil sector, India’s state-owned companies account for the bulk of
natural gas production. ONGC and Oil India Ltd. (OIL) are the leading
companies with respect to production volume, while some foreign companies
take part in upstream developments in joint-ventures and production sharing
contracts (PSCs). Reliance Industries, a privately-owned Indian company, will
also have a bigger role in the natural gas sector as a result of a large natural
gas find in 2002 in the Krishna Godavari basin.
The Gas Authority of India Ltd. (GAIL) holds an effective control on natural gas
transmission and allocation activities. In December 2006, the Minister of
Petroleum and Natural Gas issued a new policy that allows foreign investors,
private domestic companies, and national oil companies to hold up to 100%
equity stakes in pipeline projects. While GAIL’s domination in natural gas
transmission and allocation is not ensured by statute, it will continue to be the
leading player in the sector because of its existing natural gas infrastructure.
21
expenditure
General gov't final 12.3 11.4 10.3 1
consumption 0.1
expenditure
Imports of goods and 7.1 12.1 25.1 2
services 4.4
Legal environment
Working conditions
22
Standards for working conditions in India depend on state and federal laws as
well as whether the workplace is a “specified establishment.”
Factories, mines and plantations are usually put in this category. When in effect,
regulations set standards such as 19 days of annual paid leave; a working day
not less than 12 hours; and double pay for overtime above nine hours a day or
48 hours a week. In addition, governmental permission is needed for female
employees to work at night, though this is usually granted in service sectors.
Managerial staffs are almost always excluded from regulations on working
conditions. While managers usually receive the same leave terms, they do not
receive overtime pay.
The standard hiring practice in India is for employers to provide new employees
with a letter of appointment, which serves as a binding contract, though legal
requirements take precedence. The letter usually includes the terms of salary,
starting date, position, workplace, transfers, ethics, confidentiality, probation
and termination.
Terminating a worker in India can be difficult. By law, a number of procedures
must be followed, involving just cause, notice and arbitration. But, while the
procedures are not applicable to managerial staff, it is important to observe the
termination process with non-managerial employee because if they are not
observed a firing can be challenged in court. The possibility of a terminated
employee raising a court challenge increases the need to document the
circumstances surrounding a termination, but HR departments need to
remember that although misconduct is accepted as a cause for termination,
inefficiency is not always accepted.
23
Salaries in India vary sharply by education quality and experience. An entry-
level information technology (IT) hire may earn as little as $2,000 annually,
while an engineer freshly graduated from a reputed university will easily make
$12,000. In some of the highest-demand sectors, salaries for particularly
experienced staff have even risen to surpass American levels, IT managers with
15 years’ experience, for example, command about $220,000. However, IT is an
exceptional sector as department leaders’ pay in most other industries is
generally about 25 percent of American levels. But wage levels are changing,
and overall salaries are increasing annually by from 10 percent to 30 percent.
The most prominent social security program in India is the “Provident Fund.”
Although it is mandatory only for employees making under about $141
monthly, it is used almost universally because of its tax benefits. The Provident
Fund deducts 12 percent from an employee’s wages, which the employer
matches. The funds collected are earmarked to a retirement pension or to make
lump sum payments for worker death or disability.
There is also the Employees State Insurance (ESI) program, mandatory for
employees in specific industries making under about $163 monthly. The ESI
pays benefits for worker death and disability as well as sick pay and maternity
pay.
Types of employees
Expatriates are less common in India than in most Asian countries, except for
top positions, with the pharmaceutical, hospitality and airline industries among
the leading companies that most often hire expatriates. Returnees are
becoming more common but are still limited overall, and they rarely command
higher salaries than locals. In addition, work visas are generally tied to a job,
thereby preventing most foreigners from moving easily from job to job on the
same permit.
Recruiting methods
Like the United States, India has a wide range of recruiting methods, but most
recruiting is fairly informal, with walk-in interviews common below the
managerial level. In specialties like finance, engineering and marketing, on-
campus recruitment is often used to find entry-level candidates.
24
Advertisements and recruitment agencies can be effective and even necessary
to recruit for managerial positions. Internet job sites like Monsterindia.com and
Naukri.com are coming into wider use.
Emerging issues
Child labour
There are more children under the age of 14 in India than the entire population of the
United States. The great challenge of India, as a developing nation, is to provide
sufficient nutrition, education and health care to these children. Children under 14
constitute nearly 3.6% of the total labor force in the country. Of these children, 9 out
of every 10 work in their own rural family settings. Around 85% of them are engaged
in traditional agricultural activities. Less than 9% work in manufacturing, services and
repairs. Child labor is a complex problem that is basically rooted in poverty. The
Indian government is implementing the world's largest child labor elimination
program, with primary education targeted for ~250 million. Numerous non-
governmental and voluntary organizations are also involved. Special investigation
cells have been set up in states to enforce existing laws banning employment of
children (under 14) in hazardous industries. The allocation of the Government of India
for the eradication of child labor was $10 million in 1995-96 and $16 million in 1996-
97. The allocation for 2007 is $21 million.
Corruption :
The chief economic consequences of corruption are the loss to the exchequer,
an unhealthy climate for investment and an increase in the cost of
government-subsidised services. The TI India study estimates the monetary
value of petty corruption in 11 basic services provided by the government, like
25
education, healthcare, judiciary, police, etc., to be around Rs.21,068 crores.
India still ranks in the bottom quartile of developing nations in terms of the
ease of doing business, and compared with China, the average time taken to
secure the clearances for a startup or to invoke bankruptcy is much greater.
The Right to Information Act (2005) and equivalent acts in the states, that
require government officials to furnish information requested by citizens or
face punitive action, computerisation of services and various central and state
government acts that established vigilance commissions have considerably
reduced corruption or at least have opened up avenues to redress grievances.
The 2006 report by Transparency International puts India at 70th place and
states that significant improvements were made by India in reducing
corruption.
Environmental Degradation
About 1.2 billion people in developing nations lack clean, safe water because
most household and industrial wastes are dumped directly into rivers and
lakes without treatment. This contributes to the rapid increase in waterborne
diseases in humans. Out of India's 3119 towns and cities, just 209 have partial
treatment facilities, and only 8 have full wastewater treatment facilities (WHO
1992). 114 cities dump untreated sewage and partially cremated bodies
directly into the Ganges River. Downstream, the untreated water is used for
drinking, bathing, and washing. This situation is typical of many rivers in India
as well as other developing countries. Globally, but especially in developing
nations like India where people cook with fuelwood and coal over open fires,
about 4 billion humans suffer continuous exposure to smoke. In India,
particulate concentrations in houses are reported to range from 8,300 to
15,000 μg/m3, greatly exceeding the 75 μg/m3 maximum standard for indoor
particulate matter in the United States. Changes in ecosystem biological
diversity, evolution of parasites, and invasion by exotic species all frequently
result in disease outbreaks such as cholera which emerged in 1992 in India.
The frequency of AIDS/HIV is increasing. In 1996, about 46,000 Indians out of
2.8 million (1.6 % of the population) tested were found to be infected with HIV.
Future predictions
It has been estimated by the economists that the domestic political scene will
be dominated by the upcoming general election, which is due to be held by
May 2009 but might be held sooner. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI, the
central bank) is most likely to maintain a bias towards monetary tightening
during the remainder of 2007 in order to keep inflation under control.
Monetary policy will move to a more neutral orientation in 2008 to 2012,
provided that the wholesale price inflation remains within the RBI's medium-
term target range of 4 to 4.5%.
26
improve living standards outside the country's fast-growing urban localities.
Also, the strong economic growth will increase tax revenue, allowing the
government to continue to reduce the budget deficit. The real GDP growth (on
an expenditure basis) is forecast to slow from 9.4% in fiscal year 2006/2007
(from April to March) to an annual average of 7.7% in 2007/2008 to
2012/2013. Information technology (IT) and IT-enabled services (ITES) output
will grow rapidly in the upcoming period, owing to India's cost advantages in
these sectors.
The strength of the Indian rupee against the US dollar will mitigate inflationary
pressures by limiting import-led price rises. However, strong domestic
demand, together with supply-side bottlenecks, will keep consumer price
inflation at an average of nearly 5.1% a year in 2008 to 2012. For the years
2008-2010, India, is the second largest destination for Foreign direct
investment, after China.
• Urbanization
Rural Population which Migrated to Urban Areas.
25% of the country's poor live in urban areas,
31% of the urban population is poor.
27
Table – 02.
Economic trends :
Gross national product (GNP) per capita increased from Indian Rs. 6340 in
1991/92 to Rs. 13,193 in 1997/98. The annual growth rate of the GNP increased
from 0.5% in 1991/92 to 7.0% in 1995/96, but declined to 4% in 2000/2001.
The percentage of poor in rural areas increased from 20.5 in 1991/92 to 22.9 in
1992/93 and to 37.3% in 1993/94. Since the early 1990s, overall economic
growth has been faster. The situation regarding balance of payments has
strengthened considerably, and the central government's fiscal deficit as a
proportion of the gross domestic product (GDP) has declined significantly.
Social trends :
From the 2001 population census, the literacy rate for males is 75.85% and for
females is 54.16%. The changing economic situation created by urbanization,
industrialization and new economic liberalization has transformed the Indian
social structure and values from a traditionally agrarian economy to a modern
industrial order. The emerging nuclear family is exposed to severe economic
and social constraints and changes. The traditional mechanisms for social
security and adjustment in times of crisis and conflict are fast disappearing.
This transformation has resulted in the creation of several social problems for
individuals and groups such as older persons, the disabled, drug addicts, street
children, child labor, HIV-infected populations, etc. There has also been
increased violence - individually as well as collectively - especially towards
women and young girls, which has assumed a national dimension. The problem
of drug abuse is no more confined to a particular section of society but has
infiltrated all strata. The large uncontrolled influx of rural migrants to urban
areas in search of better earnings and job opportunities leaves them totally
vulnerable, particularly the children of these migrant families. The negative
influence of the electronic media appears to have resulted in an increase in
juvenile delinquency, vagrancy, robberies, murders and kidnappings.
28
Data from the 2006-07 National Family Health Survey also reveal a wide gap
between SCs and other castes in health status and access to public services
(Table 2).
Infant and child mortality is much higher in SC households than in others, and
women’s health and childbearing are much worse (perhaps a contributing
factor). The extent of malnutrition and undernutrition among children of SCs is
also much higher than among children of other castes.
Conclusion
While the purpose of this brief has been to highlight the direct and indirect
effects of economic discrimination on poverty and the need for socially
inclusive policies, above all, the brief draws attention to the current paucity of
knowledge on the full impact of discrimination and how this knowledge gap can
be effectively addressed. Studies on these issues, as outlined above, are a
necessary foundation for the development of appropriate policies to combat
discrimination and reduce poverty.
Reference:
• A. de Haan, “Extreme Deprivation in Remote Areas in India: Social Exclusion
as Explanatory Concept,” presented at the conference on Chronic Poverty
(Manchester, April 2003);
• A. Sen, “Social Exclusion: Concept, Application, and Scrutiny,” Social
Development Papers No. 1 (Office of Environment and Social Development,
Asian Development Bank, 2000);
• S. Thorat, A. Negi, and P. Negi, Reservation and Private Sector: Quest for
Equal Opportunity and Growth (Jaipur, India: Rawat, 2004).
• http://www.ifpri.org/2020Chinaconference/pdf/beijingbrief_thorat.pdf
»The World Bank Group: This graph was prepared by country unit
staff; figures may differ from other World Bank published data.
9/24/08. Figure :01
29
Source : https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/in.
»The World Bank Group: This table was prepared by country unit staff;
figures may differ from other World Bank published data. 9/24/08. ,
https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/in.
30
II. SOCIAL-HYGIENIC PROBLEMS OF THE COUNTRY
31
• Characteristic of nutrition
Food supply and nutritional status :
The proportion of newborns weighing less than 2500 grams at birth was
reported as
23% in 2006/07. The proportion of children under 3 years whose weight-for-
age was less than minus 2 SD below the median was 47% (2006/07). It is
estimated that 200 million people are exposed to the risk of iodine deficiency
disorders (IDDs) and that 63 million suffer from goitre. Surveys conducted in
275 districts have revealed that 235 districts are endemic for IDDs. In 2001,
87.5% of pregnant women were found to be anaemic (haemoglobin <11g/dl).
The National Institute of Nutrition in Hyderabad reported that 56% of children
under five years of age had iron deficiency anaemia. The contribution of
vitamin A deficiency to blindness was estimated to be 2% in 1975 and 0.04%
in 1990.
A national IDD control programme was launched in 1992, which covers all
states and union territories. The strategy is the use of iodated salt and all
aspects of programme implementation are being addressed. Anaemia
contributed to 20% of maternal deaths in 1991. An intervention programme
that commenced in 1992 prioritized pregnant women for iron and folic acid
administration. During 1994/95, 85.8% of pregnant women were covered with
the recommended daily dose of iron folate tablets.
The most susceptible group for vitamin A deficiency blindness is preschool
children. The child survival programme seeks to administer five doses of
vitamin A to all children under three years. During 1994/95, 72.6% of infants
and 54.8% of 1-2 year old children were administered vitamin A.
Other actions include the Integrated Child Development Service (ICDS)
programme that provides a package of services to 54 million beneficiaries
comprising preschool children, pregnant women and lactating mothers, and
the mid-day meal programme for primary school children. The following goals
have been set to be achieved by the year 2000: reduction by 50% of moderate
and severe protein-energy malnutrition (PEM) in preschool children,reduction
of low birth weight to less than 10%, elimination of blindness due to vitamin A,
reduction of iron deficiency anaemia among pregnant women to 25%, and
reduction of IDDs to less than 10% in endemic districts.
Rural children :
Several studies including NNMB surveys show that the heights and weights of
rural children are lower than ‘well-to-do’ Indian children or NCHS standards.
Longitudinal data are also available from special studies of linear growth in
Indian children. In a study conducted by NIN, Hyderabad, a cohort of 700 rural
children were followed from the age of 5 years to 20 years. They were classified
into different nutritional grades, based on their height at the age of 5 years,
and their growth rate was compared with that of ‘well-to-do’ children of Delhi.
Peak height velocity was similar in all groups, while the peak weight velocity
was lower in undernourished Indian children. Another interesting feature is the
age at which the growth spurt occurs. The well-nourished Indian children had a
32
growth spurt around 14 years, similar to that observed in Western children,
while among undernourished boys the growth spurt is delayed by about 2
years. The total height gain between 10-20 years is around 40 cm in both
Western and Indian boys. However, the rural children are shorter than the ‘well-
to-do’ group at all ages, with the deficit in height being noted before puberty
and then carried through to the adult stage. Unlike height gain, the increase in
weight from 10-20 years was found to be lower in rural boys. If the rural adults
are compared with the well-to-do group, the differences in heights and weights
are about 7 cm and 10 kg respectively.
The heights and weights of rural girls were also found to be lower compared to
the well-to-do group at all ages. The growth process in rural girls continued for
a longer period and in fact, the increments in this group were much greater
between 14-18 years. This is because the menarche, and consequently the
adolescent growth spurt is delayed by 1-2 years in the case of poor rural girls.
The mean age of menarche is around 12 years in well-to-do girls and 13-14
years in rural girls. If the rural women are compared to the well-to-do group the
differences in heights and weights are about 6 cm and 7 kg respectively.
Table 04: Percentage distribution of children (1-5 years) according to Gomez classification and NCHS
weight-for-age standards
33
Clinical nutritional deficiency signs :
protein-energy malnutrition
Birth Weight
34
The incidence of low birth weight is highest in low-income groups. A number of
factors have been identified as risk factors: maternal age, weight, height,
parity, literacy, income, infections and pregnancy-related complications. Even
within low-income groups, a gradual increase in birth weight is evident with
rising income, the differences between the poorest and the less poor being 100-
150 gm (NIN 1983). Differences of a similar magnitude have been recorded
between infants born to illiterate and educated mothers. With increasing
maternal height from below 145 cm to 160 cm, differences in birth weights are
of the order of 200-400 gm. Similarly, with increasing maternal weights from
around 35 to 55 kg, differences in birth weights are of the magnitude of 100-
250 gm.
A recent study showed a good correlation between birth weights and BMI of
mother. The mean birth weight in women with BMI less than 16 (severe CED)
was 2.50 kg and it showed a progressive increase with increase in BMI status of
mothers. The mean birth weight was around 2.80 kg in women with BMI 18.5-
25. The incidence of low birth weights was highest (53%) in severe CED and
gradually declined to about 15% in those with normal BMI.
One of the goals of the National Health Policy is to reduce the prevalence of low
birth weight to 10% by 2000 AD. There is an urgent need to strengthen health
care services so as to reach all pregnant women in need and to improve their
nutritional status to achieve this goal. In the current programmes, women
receive attention only after the onset of pregnancy. The preceding years of
adolescence are crucial and special efforts are needed to reach girls at this
stage.
Studies in Indian women of a high-income group have shown that their dietary
intakes range between 2000-2500 kcals per day during pregnancy. In this
group, women generally do not perform hard physical labour and there is a
35
reduction in activity during pregnancy . The average weight of this group
ranges between 45-55 kg and the mean weight gain during pregnancy is about
11 kg - observations similar to those reported in women from developed
countries.
Studies in urban women of a low-income group have shown that their dietary
intakes range from 1200-1600 kcals per day. The average pre-pregnancy weight
of these women is around 43 kg and they gain 6 kg during pregnancy. In rural
India, dietary intakes of women are slightly higher (1600-1900 kcal). However,
rural women have to spend more energy in daily household chores. For
instance, they have to fetch drinking water from sources which may be 1-2
kilometers away from home, and gather and bring firewood from forests miles
away. Most rural women from low-income groups are heavily engaged in
agricultural activities. It is therefore not surprising to find that these women
weigh less than the urban women. The NNMB surveys showed that the average
weight and height of rural women are 42 kg and 152 cm. About 33% of 18 year
old women have body weights below 40 kg and 15 percent have heights less
than 145 cms (NNMB 2001). These women fall into high risk category as they
are likely to suffer from obstetric complications and give birth to small babies.
Micronutrient Deficiencies
Vitamin A deficiency
36
corneal xerophthalmia among preschool children is 0.05% The estimates based
on these figures suggest about 30,000 cases of corneal xerophthalmia per year,
of which nearly half would result in permanent blindness.
37
ranged from 3-26%. The number of children covered was also negligible. The
reasons for poor coverage included inadequate supplies of iron folate tablets,
poor supervision, and poor compliance of women due to lack of knowledge and
ignorance. More than 80% of the pregnant women had haemoglobin less than
11 gm. Thus there was no impact on the prevalence of anaemia. There is an
urgent need to strengthen the national anaemia prophylaxis programme with
better control over actual delivery of tablets. Adequate supply of iron folate
tablets, involvement of village-level workers in the distribution of tablets and a
greater motivation of health workers and the community will be important for
the successful implementation of the programme.
Goitre has been recognised as an endemic problem in the Himalayan and sub-
Himalayan regions in the past half century. Surveys between 1945-53 in sub-
Himalayan belt, stretching from Kashmir in the North-West to Nagaland in the
East indicated a prevalence of goitre ranging from 26-90% (ICMR 1981).
Surveys carried out most recently by the Directorate General of Health Services
and other agencies indicated the presence of goitre even outside the
conventional goitre belt of Himalayas. ICMR conducted a survey covering 14
districts of 9 states with diverse geological, metrological and geochemical
characteristics (ICMR 1989). The study confirmed a high prevalence of goitre in
all the areas. In some districts like Dibrugarh, which lies in the Himalayan belt,
the prevalence was as high as 66%. In the extra-Himalayan regions the
prevalence ranged from 24% in hilly districts to 19% in coastal districts and
12% in the plains, with prevalences higher among tribals than non-tribals. The
prevalence rates in each of these districts were well above the level recognised
for endemicity. More alarming is the prevalence of endemic cretinism in all the
14 districts surveyed, though in varying proportions, with Manipur having the
highest prevalence of 6.1%. Apart from cretinism, children in endemic areas
show varying degrees of thyroid deficiency and developmental defects. A study
conducted by the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Delhi revealed a high
prevalence of neonatal chemical hypothyroidism (NCH), as defined by thyroxine
<30 ug/dl and TSH >50 ug/ml. In one particular district (Gonda) of Uttar
Pradesh, the prevalence rate of NCH was as high as 15%. Without treatment,
these infants are likely to develop physical and mental defects. In the villages of
Uttar Pradesh and Bihar where goitre prevalence was high, deaf-mutism, mental
retardation and other clinically detectable problems of environmental iodine
deficiency were found in 4% of the children. It is estimated that, today, more
than 54 million people in India are suffering from endemic goitre and 8.8 million
from different grades of mental/motor handicaps. The magnitude of the
problem is thus far greater than hitherto believed.
Although the national goitre control programme has been in operation for the
last three decades, it has gained momentum only recently. Initially, iodised salt
production was managed by the Hindustan Salt Ltd., a public undertaking. The
production was grossly inadequate and could not meet the demands of even
38
the endemic areas. Transportation of salt from production centres also posed
serious problems, as did poor supervision and the lack of quality control.
Subsidies for asset acquisition range from 25% for small farmers, 33.3% for
marginal farmers, agricultural labourers and rural artisans, and as much as 50%
for scheduled castes and tribes. Block-level staff select potential beneficiaries in
consultation with the village council (Gramsabha), help them select viable
investments (such as animal husbandry, agriculture, horticulture, weaving,
handicrafts etc), and provide back-up support when needed.
In the sixth Five Year Plan, IRDP coverage (including coverage of scheduled
castes/tribes) exceeded targets. However, resource allocations between states
were not based on incidence/intensity of poverty, and even the investment per
beneficiary varied tremendously among states - partly as a consequence of
inadequate credit mobilization in many cases. While both Andhra Pradesh and
Tamil Nadu performed slightly above the national average in credit mobilization,
states with large tribal populations performed poorly.
39
Table 05: Impact of IRDP on beneficiaries
40
on-site low cost sanitation has not been given priority. Though the 8th plan
envisaged conversion of all existing dry latrines, the final result is nowhere
near the target.
The main constraints with regard to water supply are inadequate maintenance
of rural water systems, lack of finances and poor community involvement.
Most municipalities do not have any system for monitoring the quality of
water, with contamination causing episodes of water-borne diseases even in
metro cities like Delhi and Calcutta. Most of the people in rural areas are not
aware of the health and environmental benefits of improved sanitation.
Future actions include phasing of the rural water supply programme, more
financial support
from the state finance commissions, more responsibilities given to local bodies
and village
panchayats, water supply and sanitation agencies to have full autonomy in
declaring tariffs,
improving manpower and equipment support to municipal authorities, and
creating public
awareness regarding safe water and sanitation.
• Working conditions :
Due to an increase in unplanned urbanization and industrialization, the
environment has deteriorated significantly. Pollution from a wide variety of
emissions, such as from automobiles and industrial activities, has reached
critical levels in many urban and industrial areas, causing respiratory, ocular
and other health problems. Monitoring of the urban environment in selected
cities in recent years by the pollution control authority has identified 21
critically polluted areas in the country.
Agricultural activities including widespread use of fertilizers, pesticides and
weed killers also alter the environment and create health hazards. Water
stagnation and the consequent multiplication of vectors has increased the risk
of vector-borne diseases. The risk associated with disposal of hospital wastes
has added to the overall unhealthy situation.
India is a party to the UN Conference on Environment and Development
(UNCED) held in 1992. In the same year, a national conservation strategy and
a policy statement on environment were formulated. The policy addresses
issues related to sustainable development including health. Thrust has also
been given to management of hazardous waste, adoption of clean
technologies by industries, establishment of effluent treatment plants, criteria
for environmentally friendly products, phasing out of ozone depleting
substances, and creating mass awareness programmes.
A very far-reaching notification by the Ministry of Environment and Forests
gazette in 1994 makes it obligatory for almost all development projects to
conduct an environmental impact assessment study which has to be evaluated
by an impact assessment agency. A Government constituted group at the
highest level has identified six priority programme areas, namely urban low
cost sanitation, urban waste water management, urban solid waste
management including hospital waste management, rural environmental
sanitation, industrial waste management and air pollution control, and
strengthening of health surveillance and support services. These areas have
41
been addressed in the Dayal Committee Report that forms the basis for a
comprehensive national programme on sanitation and environmental hygiene.
There are many constitutional provisions and laws pertaining to the
environment and its protection and improvement. However, the level of
enforcement has been extremely poor.
Besides, there is no comprehensive legislation on environment and health. In
view of the current situation and the Dayal Committee Report, it was proposed
that action be taken by the concerned ministries/departments to prioritize the
areas and activities that should be included in the 9th plan. During the 9th FYP
the Ministry has proposed the following actions:
1. Strengthen environmental health and health risk assessment in the country.
A division of environmental health will be established in the Department of
Health for this purpose.
2. Establish a hospital waste management programme.
3. Initiate drinking water quality surveillance as a part of disease surveillance.
42
activities with intensified IEC, and capacity building at the central and grass
roots levels
through training. The progress of filariasis control is constantly under review
and a strategy
of selective treatment, vector control and IEC is being implemented. A revised
strategy of
mass drug administration has been initiated in some districts in Tamil Nadu
and Maharashtra
states. In view of the seriousness of visceral leishmaniasis, the government
has accorded
high priority for its control. Strategies involve early diagnosis and treatment of
patients and
interruption of transmission by DDT spraying.
Treatment of common diseases and injuries
The national tuberculosis control programme has not achieved the desired
results. In 1992 the programme was reviewed and a revised control
programme formulated with short term course chemotherapy using the DOTS
strategy. The problem of protein-energy malnutrition (PEM) and micronutrient
deficiency disorders are quite significant and are being dealt with through a
number of national programmes with well defined goals. Diarrhoeal diseases,
which are still a major cause of morbidity and mortality in infants and children,
are being addressed through the promotion of exclusive breast-feeding, good
child feeding practices, and the timely use of ORT during episodes of
diarrhoea. Acute respiratory infections (ARIs) are a leading cause of death due
to pneumonia in children under five years. A strategy aimed at early
recognition of the signs of pneumonia and timely referral has been very
effective in reducing mortality. HIV/AIDS is predicted to be a major problem in
India. A total of 22,529 seropositive cases were reported up to March 1996,
but this number does not convey the actual magnitude of the problem. Almost
4 million HIV cases are estimated as of June 2000. Of the noncommunicable
diseases, cancer and cardiovascular diseases are emerging as major health
concerns that will require considerable financial resources for case
management.
43
III. CHARACTERISTICS OF POPULATION’S HEALTH IN THE COUNTRY
Demographic indicates
1. Population statistics
Demographics
Over 800 million Indians (80.5%) are Hindu. Other religious groups include
Muslims (13.4%),
Christians (2.3%), Sikhs (1.9%), Buddhists (0.8%), Jains (0.4%), Jews,Zoroastria
ns, Bahá'ís and others. Tribals constitute 8.1% of the population.
India's literacy rate is 64.8% (53.7% for females and 75.3% for males). The
state of Kerala has the highest literacy rate (91%); Bihar has the lowest (47%).
The national human sex ratio is 944 females per 1,000 males. India's median
age is 24.9, and the population growth rate of 1.38% per annum; there are
22.01 births per 1,000 people per year.
44
Demography is the scientific study of human population. A slogan for
family planning- “Delay the first,postpone the second and
prevent the third”
India is the 2nd most populous country in the world,next only to China,whereas
7th in land area.With only 2.4 % of the world’s land area,India is supporting
about 16.87 % of the world’s population.India’s population is currently
increasing at the of 16 million each year.India’s population numbered 238
million in 1901,doubled in 60 years to 439 million(1961);doubled again,this
time in only 30 years to reach 846 million by 1991.India’s population to
crossed 1 billion mark on 11 May 2000,and is projected to reach 1.53 billion by
the year 2050.This will then make India the most populous country in the
world,surpassing China.
Cities by population
45
R Core State Pop. R Core State Pop.
ank City ank City
1 Mumbai Mahara 13,66 11 Jaipur Rajasth 2,997
shtra 2,885 an ,114
2 Delhi Delhi 11,95 12 Luckno Uttar 2,621 Mumbai
4,217 w Prades ,063
h
3 Bangalo Karnat 5,180 13 Nagpur Mahara 2,359
re aka ,533 shtra ,331
4 Kolkata West 5,021 14 Indore Madhy 1,768 Delhi
Bengal ,458 a ,303
Prades
h
5 Chennai Tamil 4,562 15 Patna Bihar 1,753
Nadu ,843 ,543
6 Hyderab Andhra 3,980 16 Bhopal Madhy 1,742
ad Prades ,938 a ,375
h Prades
h
7 Ahmeda Gujarat 3,867 17 Thane Mahara 1,673
bad ,336 shtra ,465
8 Pune Mahara 3,230 18 Ludhia Punjab 1,662
shtra ,322 na ,325
9 Surat Gujarat 3,124 19 Visakh Andhra 2,845
,249 apatna Prades ,938
m h
10 Kanpur Uttar 3,067 20 Vijaya Andhra 1,961
Prades ,663 wada Prades ,152
h h
source : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/in.
Country INDIA
46
Population 1130 million
Area 3 million sq km
Population growth rate 1.4 %
Population density 363 persons per sq km
Urban / Rural distribution Urban-30 % , Rural- 70 %
Health and Education: Life Male-62 yrs ; Female-64 yrs
expectancy(average)
Infant mortality rate 56 deaths per 1,000 live
births
Population per doctor 2500 people
Population per hospital bed 1300 people
Literacy rate 70 %
Number of students per teacher, primary 41 students / teacher
school
Sex Ratio: Sex ratio is defined as “the number of females per 1000 males”.
One of the basic demographic characteristics of the population is the sex
composition. In any study of population, analysis of sex composition play a vital
role. The sex composition of the population is affected by the differentials in
mortality conditions of males and females, sex selective migration and sex ratio
at birth. The sex ratio in India has been generally adverse to women, i.e., the
number of women per 1000 men has generally been less than 1000.Apart from
being adverse to women, the sex ratio has also declined over the decades. In
1901 the sex ratio of India was 972 females per 1000 males and after wards the
ratio is continuous decreasing and in 2001 the ratio was 933 females per 1000
males. Kerala has a ratio of 1058 females per 1000 males in 2010.It is only state
with a sex ratio favourable to females.
Dependency Ratio: The proportion of persons above 65 years of age and
children below 15 years of age are considered to be dependent on the
economically productive age group(15-64 years).The ratio of the combined age
groups 0-14 years plus 65 years and above to the 15-65 years age group is
referred to as the total dependency ratio.It is also referred to as the societal
dependency ratio and reflects the need for a society to provide for their
younger and older population groups. The dependency ratio can be subdivided
into young age dependency ratio (0-14 years); and old age dependency
ratio (65 years and more).These ratios are, however, relatively crude, since they
do not take into consideration young persons who are employed or working age
persons who are unemployed.
Density of population: One of the important indices of population
concentration is the density of population. In the Indian census, density is
defined as the number of persons, living per square km. Density of population in
India in 1901 was 77 persons/sq.km. but in 2001, 324 persons/sq.km.
Family size: It refers to the total numbers of persons in a family. The family
47
size depends upon numerous factors, like, duration of marriage, education of
couple, the number of live births and living children, preference of male children,
desired family size, etc.
Total fertility rate in 2004 was 3.1 in India.
48
everyone has a right to education. Education is a crucial element in economic and
social development. Spread of literacy is generally associated with
modernization, urbanization, industrialization, communication and commerse.
Higher levels of education and literacy lead to greater awareness and also
contribute to improvement of economic conditions, and is required for acquiring
various skills and better use of health care facilities. It was decided in 1991
census to use the term literacy rate for the population relating to 7 years age and
above. A person is deemed as literate if he or she can read and write with
understanding in any language. A person who can merely read but cannot write
is not considered literate. The national percentage of literates in population
above 7 years of age is about 66% with literate males about 76% and females
lagging behind with about 54%.State Kerala has occupy the top rank in the
country with 92% literates. Government of India has made education compulsory
upto age 14 years in the country.
Life expectancy: Life expectancy - or expectation of life – at given age is the
average number of years which a person of that age may expect to live,
according to the mortality pattern prevalent in that country. Life expectancy at
birth has continued to increase globally over the years. Most countries in the
world exhibit a sex differential in mortality favouring women – females live longer
than males. Contrary to this biological expectation, the life expectancy of women
in Nepal and Maldives is lower than that of men, while in Bangladesh and India it
is almost equal. Life
expectancy(average) in India for Male-62 yrs and for Female-64 yrs .
2. Population dynamics
• Types of mechanical Public movement:
Mechanical Public movement can be Internal or External or both. Migration from one
area to another in search of improved livelihoods is a key feature of human history.
While some regions and sectors fall behind in their capacity to support
populations, others move ahead and people migrate to access these emerging
opportunities. Industrialisation widens the gap between rural and urban areas,
inducing a shift of the workforce towards industrialising areas.
In some regions of India, three out of four households include a migrant. The
effects of migration on individuals, households and regions add up to a significant
impact on the national economy and society.
49
figure : 04 source -
http://www.census.gov/ipc/www/idb/
Short duration labour migration
Our special interest is in temporary, short duration migration, because such
migrants lack stable employment and sources of livelihood at home and belong
to the poorer strata. These migrants find work in agriculture, seasonal
industries, or are absorbed in the amorphous urban economy, either as casual
labourers or as selfemployed. They may move from one type of job to another
or even from rural to urban areas. There is another category of poor and
destitute migrants who
have virtually no assets in the areas of origin and have lost all contact with their
origin. Thus not all poor migrants would fall in the category of seasonal/short
term migrants. But as discussed earlier, for one reason or another, all these
categories are likely to be underestimated in data.
TRENDS AND PATTERNS IN INTERNAL MIGRATION
The two main secondary sources of data on population mobility in India are the
Census and the National Sample Survey (NSS). These surveys may
underestimate some migration flows, such as temporary, seasonal and
circulatory migration, both due to empirical and conceptual difficulties. Since
such migration and commuting is predominantly employment oriented, the
data underestimate the extent of labour mobility. Furthermore, migration data
relate to population
mobility and not worker mobility, although economic theories of migration are
primarily about worker migration. It is not easy to disentangle these, firstly
because definitions of migrants used in both surveys (change from birthplace
and change in last usual place of residence), are not employment related.
Secondly, migration surveys give only the main reason for migration, and that
50
only at the time of migration. Secondary economic reasons could be masked, as
in the case of married women, who would cite other reasons for movement.
Another problem is that migration data relate to stocks of migrants and not to
flows, although different policy concerns relate to
stocks (of different ages) and flows. Many of these concerns can be handled
only by micro surveys,
which have their own problems.
Causes of migration
Given the diversity in the nature of migration in India, the causes are also
bound to vary. Migration is influenced both by the pattern of development
(NCRL, 1991), and the social structure (Mosse et al, 2002). The National
Commission on Rural Labour, focusing on seasonal migration, concluded that
uneven development was the main cause of seasonal migration. Along with
inter regional disparity, disparity between different socioeconomic classes and
the development policy adopted
since independence has accelerated the process of seasonal migration. In tribal
regions, intrusion of outsiders, the pattern of settlement, displacement and
deforestation, also have played a significant role.
Most migration literature makes a distinction between ‘pull’ and ‘push’ factors,
which, however,
do not operate in isolation of one another. Mobility occurs when workers in
source areas lack suitable options for employment/livelihood, and there is some
expectation of improvement in circumstances through migration. The
improvement sought may be better employment or higher wages/incomes, but
also maximisation of family employment or smoothing of employment/
income/consumption over the year.
The migrant labour market
Migrants at the lower end of the market comprise mostly unskilled casual
labourers or those who own or hire small means of livelihood such as carts or
rickshaws and are self-employed. We focus in this section primarily on migrants
who work as casual labourers, although several of the conditions discussed
below are also common to other categories of migrants.
Migrant labourers are exposed to large uncertainties in the potential job market.
To begin with, they have little knowledge of the market and risk high job search
costs. The perceived risks and costs tend to be higher the further they are from
home. There are several ways in which migrants minimise risks and costs. For a
number of industries, recruitment is often done seeking jobs independently may
still find the labour processes in the destination dominated by contracting
and sub-contracting relationships. Workers have to depend upon advances and
irregular payments. Migrants often get lower wages than local labourers.
International migration from independent India
Two distinct types of labour migration have been taking place from India since
independence:
• People with technical skills and professional expertise migrate to countries
such as the USA, Canada, UK and Australia as permanent migrants (since the
early 1950s).
51
• Unskilled and semi-skilled workers migrate to oil exporting countries of the
Middle East on temporary contracts, especially following the oil price increases
of 1973–74 and 1979.
52
Source: Country’s migration report, Nayyar, 2004
Table : 08, source - http://www.census.gov/ipc/www/idb/
53
Y
ear
Net
mi
gra
tio
n
rat
e
(mi
gra
nt(
Definition of s)/
Net 1,0
migration 00
rate: This po
entry includes pul
the figure for ati
the difference on)
between the
number of
persons 2
entering and 000
leaving a -0.0
country during 8
the year per
1,000 persons
(based on 2
midyear 001
population). -0.0
An excess of 8
persons
entering the
country is 2
referred to as 002
net -0.0
immigration 7
(e.g., 3.56
2
003
-0.0
7
2
004
-0.0
7
54
2
005
Figure : 05 , India - Net migration rate (migrant(s)/1,000
population)
source -
http://www.census.gov/ipc/www/idb/
Impact on labour markets
The labour market impact of international migration depends on factors such as
size of outflow, employment status before migration, skill composition of
migrants and, in the case of temporary migration, on the size of the return flow.
The labour market implications of migration from India may be examined both
in relation to permanent emigration to the industrialised countries and to the
outflow of temporary migrants to the Middle East countries. From the discussion
on the
magnitude of permanent migration from India to the industrialised countries
taken up earlier, it is abundantly clear that they form an insignificant proportion
of the total workforce in India. Even though a large proportion of those who
migrate to industrialised countries are fairly highly educated, the absolute
number of migrants is small and their proportion of the total educated
population of graduates is insignificant. In fact, total emigration to the four
industrialised countries (USA, UK, Australia and Canada) constituted a mere
0.13% of the population of graduates in 1991. Similarly considering the large
reservoir of educated unemployed in India, it may be reasonable to presume
that permanent migration to the industrialised countries could have hardly
created any supply shortages in the labour markets. In such a situation it may
be prudent to assume that the aggregate labour market effects of permanent
migration is negligible in the Indian context.
55
fees far in excess of authorised placement fees and illegal recruitment. Delayed
deployments are often caused by factors beyond the control of the recruitment
agency, such as visa delays or when the employer requests a postponement.
Non-deployment is however a serious case and the magnitude of its
implications are amplified if an excessive placement fee is collected from the
worker. Overcharging is a serious offence and is prevalent in all labour-sending
countries in Asia. What makes overcharging doubly serious is that the workers
end up paying huge amounts equivalent to many months salary (Sasikumar,
2000). Minimising, if not totally eliminating, overcharging poses a serious
challenge to overseas employment administrators. Illegal recruitment is
another serious violation of the rules as workers get recruited and deployed
overseas without the government knowing about them. Being unlicensed,
illegal recruiters are beyond the reach of the normal regulatory machinery of
the national overseas employment policy. They are and should be the concern
of police and other enforcement agencies. Some major problems encountered
by the migrants in their countries of employment include:
a) premature termination of job contracts,
b) changing the clauses of contract to the disadvantage of the workers,
c) delay in payment of salary,
d) violation of minimum wage standards,
e) freezing of fringe benefits and other perks,
f) forced over-time work without returns and
g) denial of permission to keep one’s own passport.
Migrant labourers seldom lodge any complaint against the erring employers for
the fear of losing their jobs. In cases where migrant workers decide to complain
against the erring employer, they have two options. First, the employee may
inform the home embassy in the country of employment. This is mainly done by
people lacking the means to return home. Embassy officials
sometimes seek the help and assistance of the local government to take
actions against the erring employers.
Apart from that, the Embassy also passes information about the complaints
made to it to the Protector of Emigrants (POE) offices in India. If a registered
recruiting agent recruited the complainant, then the POE refers the complaint to
the concerned agent seeking explanation.
In most cases the agents maintain that it was the foreign employer who
committed any violation.
However, if the POE office finds the explanation unsatisfactory it proceeds with
further action.
Secondly, the employee registers the complaint after he/she reaches India. To
facilitate the lodging of such complaints, a system of public hearing is
conducted at the POE offices, where emigrants, recruiting agents, project
exporters etc. can meet the most senior officer on duty to obtain information
and voice their grievances. When complaints are received against foreign
employers, the POE office forwards them to the Indian embassy in the
concerned country of employment for taking necessary actions. As in the case
of first option, if a registered agent has recruited the complainant, the POE
office seeks the agent’s explanation. If the agent does not provide satisfactory
explanations, a case is registered for the violation and the case is referred to
56
the police for investigation. In some instances, the POE officials themselves
conduct the inquiry.
Apart from this, generally no action can be taken against foreign employers as
they are governed by laws of another nation state.
Suggestions and recommendations
Some specific suggestions relating to international labour migration are:
1. Developing migration information systems:
One of the areas requiring immediate policy intervention is the creation of an
appropriate information system on international emigration. This would enable
closer surveillance and better management of emigration.
The status of out-migrant data can be improved by making the registration of
entry by migrant workers mandatory in the Indian missions operating in labour
receiving countries. The nature of outflow data at home can be strengthened by
a fuller utilisation of the data already available with government departments
and recruitment agencies. A chief requirement in this connection would be the
strengthening of the statistical wings of the concerned government
departments.
International experience suggests that it is possible to extract labour outflow
and return flow data on key variables from embarkation/ disembarkation cards.
An essential first step to make use of this source is to redesign the existing
arrival/departure cards to yield required information. To obtain further
information, periodic airport surveys could be resorted to.
Data on migration are as much essential at the state level as they are at the
national level. Apart from relevant disaggregation of national data sources, it
would be desirable if the National Sample Survey Organisation (NSSO) conduct
detailed surveys on international migration periodically, say once in five years.
To strengthen the information base abroad, an identification and networking of
Indian associations
operating in different Middle East countries is necessary. The Gulf crisis of 1990
had highlighted the vital role played by various Indian associations and bodies
in safeguarding the interests of Indian migrants in the Gulf at a time of
emergency (Sasikumar,1995). Discussions with evacuees from Kuwait revealed
that the majority of Indian migrants maintained very close liaison with
community organisations even in times of stability.
57
In a forty-seven-country ranking of brain drain arrived at on the basis of a
survey whether "well-educated people emigrate or do not emigrate abroad,"
and presented in the World Competitiveness Yearbook 2000, India has been
placed at position forty-second from the top, sixth from the bottom. India has
also been assigned a significance score of 3.291 calculated on a ten-point scale
between 0 and 10, using a special standard deviation method (SDM) to assign
each country a standardized (STD) value or score.
The low ranking and score both mean that India has a high degree of brain
drain in terms of well-educated people emigrating abroad. The USA is at the top
with a score of 8.524, meaning very few educated Americans emigrate UK's
ranking is thirteenth with a score of 6.343, meaning that some people emigrate.
India is better off, relatively speaking, than Venezuela, Philippines, Russia,
Colombia, and South Africa, but worse off than Argentina.
Traditionally, the U.K. has been the main recipient of Indian migrants - both
skilled and unskilled until the end of the 1960s. This was mainly due to the
colonial ties between the two countries and the advantage of the English
language as medium of education in India particularly at the higher,
professional and technical levels.
The fact that emigration of skilled labour to the US comprises a significant
proportion from the UK - a country which also receives emigrants from
developing countries including India - makes Britain's emigration more of a
'brain exchange' than 'brain drain', if one were to make use of a specific
distinction. Keeping this in view, it may be said that not only to UK, Indian
migration of skilled labour to other developed countries like Canada, Australia,
New Zealand, Western Europe (mainly Germany, and France in the EU), and
now also Japan, and Singapore (relatively substantially more developed than
India, though small in size and economy) too is largely a function of some kind
of derived demand' for skilled labour from the United States. Given that the
emigrating Indians' preferences and priorities too are in favour of the United
States as compared to each of these countries, the migration to these countries
may perhaps be described as a stopover 'intermediate' supply rather than a
terminal one. This kind of 'hopping migration' has a negative effect on retention
of migrants in the labour markets of Europe, particularly the recipient countries
in the EU.
Apart from the 'external brain drain' of skilled people leaving India for taking up
jobs abroad, there is also an 'internal brain drain'. For example, the selection of
the IIT engineering graduates, and doctors in the Civil Services Examination
(CSE) is called the 'internal brain drain', because the professional skills acquired
by the selected ones are obviously wasted when they join the Indian
bureaucracy for undertaking administrative job responsibilities. There is also a
high social opportunity cost of a wasted seat because, like selection in the CSE,
admission to public engineering and medical colleges is highly competitive in
India. A recently conducted study based on a sample survey in two premier
institutions of higher education in India - one general, and the other
professional, by the author (Khadria 2001a/UPSC 2001) estimated that over
Rs.10 billion (US $1= Rs.45 approximately) are being spent by all the
examinees (i.e., their families) put together (on an annual average number of
125,000 examinees) every year for aspiring to enter into the Indian Civil
58
Service. Only 500 out of the 125,000 examinees are finally chosen. Many of
these are engineers, doctors, managers trained at great public costs. Their
entry into the civil service is also considered a brain drain so far as the
application of their skills or the usefulness of subsidies sunk in their education is
concerned - an 'internal brain drain'. A substantial number amongst those who
fail to make it into the Indian Civil Service emigrate to other countries in search
of jobs or higher education because they simultaneously keep trying that route
to 'success' as well - leading to the 'external' brain drain.
Student migration
Professionals holding post-graduate degree or diploma from Indian institutions
of tertiary education are not the only ones who are considered of value abroad.
Many of the Indian immigrants in the United States who fuelled Silicon Valley
were educated in America at the post-graduate level after they emigrated with
a first engineering degree (B.Tech/B.E.) from the Indian Institutes of Technology
(IITs)/Regional Engineering Colleges/ Banaras Hindu University - all institutions
of excellence.
Similarly, scientists with M.Sc/M.Tech from universities like the Jawaharlal Nehru
University or the University of Delhi, or doctors with MBBS from the All India
Institute of Medical Sciences, and managers with Post-Graduate Diploma in
Business Management (PGDBM) from the Indian Institutes of Management
(IIMs) have emigrated for the purpose of pursuing higher studies abroad and
then entering into the labour market there.
Impact of Migration on India
The issue of impact of brain drain on sending home countries, most of which
are also 'developing' countries, needs to be examined in the light of the
shifting paradigms of the phenomenon of skilled labour migration. There are
three types of paradigm shifts that are discernible, and one of them pertains
directly to the subject of impact. But there are backward and forward linkages
to this particular shift of paradigm with the other two shifts: a geo-economic
shift of paradigm for brain drain to become more of a demand-determined
phenomenon from a supply-determined one (i.e., employers determine
immigration, rather than employees; in other words, pull factors become more
important than the push factors), and the other, a geo-political shift of
paradigm in terms of looking away from temporary, short-term and ad-hoc
remedies (of the malaise of brain drain) to more sustainable long-term solutions
(towards developing immunity against the negative and very negative effects of
the malaise) through policy.
Perceptions and Debates on the ‘Brain Drain’ in India
On the exodus of Indian talent abroad :
Today, India is almost at the top of the list of countries so far as emigration of
the
"brain drain" category is concerned - to developed countries like the USA,
Canada,
Australia, Germany, France, Japan, and of course the UK.
59
• Infant mortality :
Infant mortality rate: total: 32.31 deaths/1,000 live births
male: 36.94 deaths/1,000 live births
female: 27.12 deaths/1,000 live births (2008 est.)
Table : 09
Source: CIA World Factbook - Unless otherwise noted, information in this page
is accurate as of May 16, 2008
Definition: This entry gives the number of deaths of infants under one year old
in a given year per 1,000 live births in the same year; included is the total
death rate, and deaths by sex, male and female. This rate is often used as an
indicator of the level of health in a country.
Thirty percent of the world’s newborns die in India: India, which is home
both to the highest number of births and neonatal deaths of any country in the
world, faces a bigger challenge than any other country in improving newborn
health and survival. Each year, 20 percent of the world’s infants—an awesome
26 million—are born in this vast and diverse country. Of this number, 1.2 million
die—almost 30 percent of the world’s neonatal deaths—before completing the
first four month of life.
60
1980s, from 69 in 1980 to 53 in 1990, an unprecedented decrease of almost
one quarter in a single decade. In recent years, however, the rate has been
static; between 1995 and 2000, there was only a negligible decrease of four
points, from 48 to 44 per 1,000 live births. This tapering off in the rate of
decline is a cause for concern—and also for decisive action.
The rate of neonatal mortality varies widely among the different states, ranging
from 10 per 1,000 live births in Kerala to around 60 in Orissa and Madhya
Pradesh. The states of Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, and Bihar together
contribute over half of all newborn deaths in India, or roughly 15 percent of the
entire global burden. There are also significant rich-poor and rural-urban
differences: The rate in the poorest 20 percent of the population is more than
double that of the richest 20 percent , and the rate in rural areas is over one
and a half times that in urban areas.
source : http://www.census.gov/ipc/www/idb/
61
reduce the NMR from the current level of 44 to about 20 per 1,000 live births.
There is a consensus to incorporate a comprehensive maternal and newborn
health strategy into the next five-year phase (2005-10) of the Reproductive and
Child Health program Better health system and mortality data is required to
manage these programs and to recognize if goals have been met.
source - http://www.census.gov/ipc/www/idb/ Table : 10
100
Post neonatal
90 Late neonatal
80 Early neonatal
70
44
60
35
50 29
40
16
30 12 8
20
28 25 5
24
10 2 1
1
9 1 1
6 4
0
1980 1995 2000 1980 1995 2000
Figure 07 Time trends in infant mortality between 1983 and 2000, split by
62
early neonatal, late neonatal, and the post-neonatal period, contrasting
high-income and low/middle income regions. Source: State of India’s
Newborns, Government of India. Based on Sample Registration Survey data for India.
80
69 70 1980-1990
70 67
67 66
60 60 25%
60 58 57 56
53 1990-2000
51 50
50 47 48 48 47 46 45 15%
45 44
NMR
40
30
20
10
0
1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
Conclusions
• Darmstadt GL, Lawn JE, Costello A. (2003) Advancing the state of the world’s
newborns. Bulletin of theWorld Health Organization.:81:224-225.
• Lawn J E, Cousens S N, Wilczynska K and the CHERG neonatal group.
(Submitted) Estimating the causes of four million neonatal deaths in the year
2000. • Saving Newborn
Lives. (2001) State of the World's Newborns. 1-44. Washington DC, Save the
Children. Available at
http://www.savethechildren.org/publications/newborns_report.pdf.
• Birth rate :
63
Definition: This entry gives the average annual number of births during a year
per 1,000 persons in the population at midyear; also known as crude birth rate.
The birth rate is usually the dominant factor in determining the rate of
population growth. It depends on both the level of fertility and the age structure
of the population
source -
http://www.census.gov/ipc/www/idb/
The population clock in the Union Health Ministry, Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi,
now ticks at the rate of 31 persons per minute. The clock shows that about
44,640 babies are born in India everyday. Hence the population of India
increases by 16.29 million every year, which is equivalent to the total
population of Australia. Here are some more facts about our motherland.
The present population of India is around 1.4 Billion (1400 Million). The billionth
baby is a girl. Her name is ASTHA (which means Faith). Her mother's name is
Anjana Arora, and her father's name is Ashok Kumar Arora. She was born in
Delhi at Saftharjung Hospital at 5.50 a.m. on Thursday, May 11, 2000.
India with about 2.4% of the land area in the world contains about 16% of the
population of the world.The density of the population in India has climbed up
from 261 per square kilometer in 1981 to 267 per square kilometer in 1991.
This is ten times greater than the density in the United States (26 per square
kilometer) and 2.5 times greater than the density in China (109 per square
kilometer).
The birth rate in India (31 per thousand people) is greater than that of China
(20 per thousand people). If this trend continues, India will beat up China by
2025 A.D., making India the most populous nation in the world. In 2025 A.D,
India will have 1591 million people and China 1554 million people.
64
Only five countries in the world - China, USA, Brazil, Indonesia, and United USSR
have more population than Uttar Pradesh (145 million), which is one of the 28
states in India.
The total population of the South Indian state of Tamil Nadu was 55.6 million as
of 1991. About 4,478,000 people die every year in Tamil Nadu, or to put it
another way, 1,227 people pass every day into eternity without knowing Christ.
The death rate in India is 8.39 million per year. This means that 23,000 people
everyday, 958 people every hour, or 16 people every minute, pass into a
Christless eternity. Are we "moved with compassion for them because they are
weary and scattered" like Jesus Christ said in Matthew 9:26.
65
• Life expectancy :
For the period 1996-2001, the life expectancy at birth is estimated to be 62.36
years for males and 63.39 years for females. In 1991 the sex ratio was 927
females per 1000 males which increased to 933 in 2001. To ensure the
continued improvement in life expectancy, the health care delivery
infrastructure is being expanded, MCH care is being improved, specific
programmes such as the expanded programme on immunization (EPI),
introduction of oral rehydration therapy (ORT), etc. are being strengthened, and
efforts are continuing to contain locally endemic diseases. There is also an
increased thrust in other development and poverty alleviation programmes. The
main constraints are the diverse population groups, low literacy and income
levels, and sociocultural beliefs and practices which adversely affect health.
Definition: This entry contains the average number of years to be lived by a
group of people born in the same year, if mortality at each age remains
constant in the future. The entry includes total population as well as the male
and female components. Life expectancy at birth is also a measure of overall
quality of life in a country and summarizes the mortality at all ages. It can also
be thought of as indicating the potential return on investment in human capital
and is necessary for the calculation of various actuarial measures.
66
Life expectancy at birth: total population: 69.25 years
male: 66.87 years
female: 71.9 years (2008 est.) Table : 12, source -
http://www.census.gov/ipc/www/idb/
Source: CIA World Factbook - Unless otherwise noted, information in this page
is accurate as of May 16, 2008 Figure : 11.
67
Gujarat 61.53 63.12 64.60 65.76 62.77 64.10 65.49 66.45
Haryana 63.87 64.64 65.50 66.03 67.39 69.30 70.00 70.00
Karnataka 61.73 62.43 63.10 63.73 65.36 66.44 67.43 68.35
Kerala 70.69 71.67 72.00 72.00 75.00 75.00 75.00 75.00
Madhya
56.83 59.19 59.20 60.70 57.21 58.01 59.80 61.40
Pradesh
Maharashtra 65.31 66.75 67.89 69.02 68.19 69.76 71.13 72.00
Orissa 58.52 60.05 61.44 62.70 58.07 59.71 61.23 62.63
Punjab 68.39 69.78 70.88 71.74 71.40 72.00 72.00 72.00
Rajasthan 60.32 62.17 63.79 65.21 61.36 62.80 65.22 66.84
Tamil Nadu 65.21 67.00 68.45 69.64 67.58 69.75 71.54 72.00
Uttar
61.20 63.54 65.48 67.10 61.10 64.09 66.60 68.72
Pradesh
West Bengal 64.50 66.08 67.42 68.57 67.20 69.34 71.11 72.00
India
62.30 63.87 65.65 67.04 65.27 66.91 67.67 69.18
(Pooled)
India 62.36 64.11 65.63 66.93 63.39 65.43 67.22 68.80
68
in India, where as in United States, it is as high as 2300. The scarcity of doctors
can be addressed if we allow greater private participation in setting up medical
colleges and hospitals. Only when we address these issues can we hope that
our people will be healthier while the country is getting wealthier. Figure :
12, source - http://www.census.gov/ipc/idb/
• State-wise data are included below; more indicators can be found in the
"FACTFILE" section on the homepage for each state. Average life
expectancy Table : 13.
• ===========================================
• STATE TOTAL MALE FEMALE
• Andhra Pradesh 63.1 61.6 64.1
• Assam 57.2 57.1 57.6
• Bihar 60.2 60.7 58.9
• Gujarat 62.8 61.9 63.7
• Haryana 64.5 64.1 65.0
• Himachal Pradesh 65.6 65.1 65.8
• Karnataka 64.0 62.4 65.5
• Kerala 73.5 70.6 76.1
• Madhya Pradesh 56.4 56.5 56.2
• Maharastra 65.8 64.5 67.0
• Orissa 57.7 57.6 57.8
• Punjab 68.1 66.9 69.1
• Rajastan 60.5 59.8 60.9
• Tamilnadu 64.6 63.7 65.7
69
• Uttar Pradesh 58.4 58.9 57.7
• West Bengal 63.4 62.8 64.3
• India 61.7 60.8 62.5
===========================================
Source: Registrar General of India (2003) SRS Based Abridged Lefe Tables,
SRS Analytical Studies, Report No. 3 of 2003, New Delhi: Registrar General of
India.
India
70
urban India. While the total fertility rate decreased from 5.2 per woman to 3.2
during 1971-1999 (a decrease of 2 births per woman or a decrease of 38,5
percent), that among adolescents decreased from 0.5 to 0.3 births per
adolescent (a decrease of 0.2 births or 40 percent) [total fertility among
adolescents in the age group is obtained as 5 x adolescent fertility]. Comparing
the share of adolescent fertility to total fertility, it can be seen that contribution
of this age group declined only marginally; during the 28 years from 1971, the
percentage of adolescent fertility to total fertility rate decreased from 9.7
percent to 8.1 percent. This decline became visible only by 1996 till when there
was an increase in the share, possibly due to the younger age structure of
women consequent to high fertility in the previous years.
As contraceptive use is important for a better reproductive health in adolescent
years (when pregnancy and child birth should be avoided as far as possible),
the paper tries to examine the factors associated with contraceptive use in
India. Logistic regression analysis shows that the most important variables
affecting contraceptive use among adolescents are education, age at marriage,
media exposure, standard of living and experience of physical violence. Those
who are literate have chances 1.7 times higher to use contraception, those
married after completing 18 years have a lesser chance to use contraception,
those with some exposure to media have 1.8 times higher chance to use, those
from high standard of living strata have 1.7 times higher chance to use, and
those have had experience of physical violence have 1.2 times chances higher
compared to others.
Given that the age at marriage in all Indian states is increasing, the high extent
of adolescent pregnancies among certain Indian states needs special attention;
the higher extent of adolescent fertility among some of the states with low
fertility is certainly disturbing.
A finding from the analysis indicates that a second demographic transition is
unlikely to happen in the near future in Indian states which are nearing the
completion of first transition.
• Morbidity :
The number of reported cases of the following diseases were: leprosy 560,000
(2000),
malaria 2,276,788 (1999), measles 26,986 (1991), neonatal tetanus 1896
(1995), polio 142
(2000/2001), and tuberculosis 1,223,127 (1999). The vaccine-preventable
diseases (referred
71
to in Section 6) have declined significantly since implementation of the EPI. In
India about
14 million people are estimated to be suffering from active tuberculosis and
about 0.5 million
die of the disease each year. Currently, short term chemotherapy using DOTS
has been
introduced and accessibility to tuberculosis treatment centres improved. The
prevalence of
leprosy has declined from about 39 per 10,000 population in 1985 to about 7
per 10,000 in
1995 and further down to 3.7 in 2000. The spectacular reduction in this disease
has been due
to the new regimen of multidrug therapy. The number of new cases detected
annually has,
however, remained more or less the same, at about 0.5 million.
Morbidity
There is limited experience in collecting morbidity data from population-based
demographic
sample surveys. NFHS-1 collected data on five major morbidity conditions—
partial and
complete blindness, tuberculosis, leprosy, physical impairment of the limbs, and
malaria—
among all persons in the sampled households. The results were found to be
generally plausible
and useful. For these reasons, it was decided to include similar morbidity
questions in NFHS-2.
In NFHS-2, questions on blindness, leprosy, and physical impairment of the
limbs were replaced
by questions on asthma and jaundice. The questions on tuberculosis and
malaria were retained,
and a question on medical treatment of tuberculosis was added to get a better
measure of the
prevalence of tuberculosis. The household head or other knowledgeable adult in
the household
reported morbidity for all household members, and no effort was made to do
clinical tests for any
of the disease conditions.
The prevalence of asthma, tuberculosis, jaundice, and malaria in the household
population by age, sex, and place of residence. There are several reasons why
the results of NFHS-2 may understate the prevalence of these conditions.
Respondents may underreport diseases carrying a stigma, such as tuberculosis,
due to intentional concealment. Underestimation may also occur because the
household respondents are unaware that they or other members of the
household have the condition. It is also possible that the respondents know that
a household member suffers from a given condition but fail to report it because
they do not recognize the term used by the enumerator to describe the
condition. On the other hand, a factor contributing to a possible overestimation
of prevalence without clinical verification is that some other disease can be
72
mistaken by the respondent as one of the listed diseases; for example, chronic
bronchitis may be reported as asthma or tuberculosis, or common flu may be
reported as malaria.
Asthma
Asthma is a chronic respiratory disease characterized by sudden attacks of
laboured breathing,
chest constriction, and coughing. There has been a rapid increase in asthma
cases in recent years
in many parts of the world. In India, 2,468 persons per 100,000 population were
reported to be
suffering from asthma at the time of the survey. The prevalence of asthma is
considerably higher
in rural areas (2,649 per 100,000 population) than in urban areas (1,966 per
100,000 population),
and is slightly higher among males (2,561 per 100,000) than among females
(2,369 per 100,000).
Age differences are marked, with the prevalence of asthma increasing from 950
per 100,000 at
age 0–14 to 10,375 per 100,000 at age 60 and over.
Tuberculosis
Tuberculosis, which is also resurgent worldwide, is an infectious disease that
affects the lungs
and other body tissues. Tuberculosis of the lungs, the most commonly known
form, is
characterized by coughing up mucus and sputum, fever, weight loss, and chest
pain. According
to NFHS-2, the overall prevalence of tuberculosis in India is 544 per 100,000
population. This is
16 percent higher than the prevalence recorded in NFHS-1 (467 per 100,000),
indicating that
tuberculosis may be on the rise in India. The prevalence of tuberculosis is much
higher in rural
areas (600 per 100,000) than in urban areas (390 per 100,000). The prevalence
rate is much
higher for males (624 per 100,000) than for females (460 per 100,000). The sex
differential in
the prevalence of tuberculosis is about the same in urban and rural areas.
Probable reasons for
the much higher prevalence of tuberculosis among males than females are that
men are more
likely than women to come in contact with people who suffer from active
tuberculosis and that
men in India smoke more than women. The prevalence of tuberculosis increases
rapidly with
age. It is substantially higher among persons age 60 and above (1,374 per
100,000) than among
those age 15–59 (675 per 100,000) or age 0–14 (153 per 100,000).
73
Medically treated tuberculosis is expected to give a more reliable measure of
the prevalence of active tuberculosis than the measure based on all reported
cases considered in the preceding paragraph. As expected, the prevalence of
medically treated tuberculosis is considerably lower (432 per 100,000) than the
prevalence based on all reported cases (544 per 100,000). Differentials in the
prevalence of medically treated tuberculosis by residence, age, and sex are
similar to differentials in the prevalence of all reported cases.
Jaundice
Jaundice is characterized by yellowish discolouration of the eyes and skin, fever,
liver
enlargement, and abdominal pain. NFHS-2 asked household respondents if any
member of the
household had suffered from jaundice at any time during the 12 months
preceding the survey. In
India as a whole, 1,361 persons per 100,000 population were reported to have
suffered from
jaundice during the 12 months preceding the survey. People living in rural areas
were somewhat
more likely to have suffered from jaundice (1,410 per 100,000) than those living
in urban areas
(1,225 per 100,000). Males were 42 percent more likely to have suffered from
jaundice than
females. Jaundice is the only condition measured that decreases with age. The
prevalence of
jaundice was highest for the age group 0–14 (1,515 per 100,000), followed by
the age groups
15–59 (1,339 per 100,000) and 60 years and above (826 per 100,000). The age
and sex
differentials in the prevalence of jaundice are similar in urban and rural areas.
Malaria
Malaria is characterized by recurrent high fever with shivering. NFHS-2 asked
household
respondents whether any member of their household suffered from malaria any
time during the
three months preceding the survey. In India, 3,697 persons per 100,000
population were reported
to have suffered from malaria during the three months preceding the survey.
Since the prevalence of malaria is known to vary considerably by season, the
NFHS-2 estimates should not be interpreted as representative of the level
throughout the year. It would also be misleading to
compare this estimate with the lower NFHS-1 estimate because the months of
the year comprising the reference period for the malaria estimates from the two
surveys are different.
Rural residents are almost twice as likely to suffer from malaria (4,254 per
100,000) as are urban residents (2,156 per 100,000). The reported prevalence
of malaria is slightly higher for males than for females. The prevalence of
malaria during the past three months increases with age, from 3,552 per
100,000 in the population under age 15 to 4,146 per 100,000 in the population
74
age 60 years and above. The steady increase with age occurs in rural areas but
not in urban areas.
Comparisons by State
The prevalence of asthma varies considerably by state, from a low of 1,204 per
100,000 in Delhi to a high of 5,995 per 100,000 in Meghalaya. Other states with
relatively low levels of asthma prevalence are Punjab and Himachal Pradesh,
and other states with relatively high prevalence rates are Nagaland, Kerala,
Sikkim, and Andhra Pradesh.
State variations in the prevalence rate of tuberculosis are also large.
Tuberculosis prevalence ranges from 207 per 100,000 in Punjab to 1,654 per
100,000 in Nagaland. All states in the Northeast Region except Assam have
prevalence rates above 1,000 per 100,000.
Tuberculosis prevalence rates are also noticeably high in Bihar and Orissa.
Variations in the
prevalence of medically treated tuberculosis are generally in line with the
variations in all
reported cases of tuberculosis.
State differentials are also substantial for jaundice. Jaundice is most common in
Nagaland, but it is also a substantial problem in most other northeastern states
and in West Bengal and Goa. The prevalence of malaria varies widely across the
states, at least partly because of seasonal variations in the timing of the survey
fieldwork. Malaria was most often reported in Meghalaya, Nagaland, Arunachal
Pradesh, and Madhya Pradesh, where 10–17 percent of the population were
reported to have malaria during the three months preceding the survey. On the
other hand, there were very few reports of malaria in Kerala, Himachal Pradesh,
and Tamil Nadu. Four states (Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya, Nagaland, and
Andhra Pradesh) have a higher prevalence of all these diseases than the
national average, and six states (Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Jammu and
Kashmir, Punjab, Karnataka, and Tamil Nadu) consistently have a lower
prevalence than the national average.
Vitamin A Supplementation
Vitamin A deficiency is one of the most common nutritional deficiency disorders
in the world,
affecting more than 250 million children worldwide (Bloem et al., 1997). The
National Programm on Prevention of Blindness targets children under age five
years and administers oral
doses of vitamin A every six months starting at age nine months. NFHS-2 asked
mothers of
children born during the three years before the survey whether their children
ever received a dose
of vitamin A. Those who said that their child had received at least one dose of
vitamin A were
asked how long ago the last dose of vitamin A was given. The percentage of
children age 12–35 months who received at least one dose of vitamin A and
who received a dose of vitamin A within the past six months by selected
background characteristics. In the country as a whole, only 3 out of 10 children
age 12–35 months received at least one dose of vitamin A, and only 17 percent
75
received a dose within the past six months. This indicates that a large majority
of children in India have not received vitamin A supplementation at all and even
fewer children receive vitamin A supplementation regularly.
Children living in urban areas, children of more educated mothers, and children
living in
high standard of living households are considerably more likely than other
children to receive
vitamin A supplementation. Children of birth order 4 or above are much less
likely
than children of birth orders 1, 2, or 3 to have received any vitamin A
supplementation. Muslim,
Hindu, and Christian children are less likely to receive vitamin A than other
children. Similarly,
children from schedule castes, schedule tribes, and other backward classes are
less likely to
receive vitamin A than other children.
State variations in the percentage of children who received at least one dose of
vitamin A and the percentage who received at least one dose within the six
months preceding the survey are shown. The percentage of children age 12–35
who received at least one dose of vitamin A supplementation ranges from 7
percent in Nagaland to 78 percent in Goa. In addition to Nagaland, Bihar (10
percent), Uttar Pradesh (14 percent), Assam (15 percent), Tamil Nadu (16
percent), and Rajasthan (18 percent) stand out as having very low proportions
of children receiving at least one dose of vitamin A. In addition to Goa,
Himachal Pradesh (71 percent) and Maharashtra (65 percent) stand out as
having relatively successful vitamin A supplementation programmes. State
variations in the percentage of children receiving at least one dose of vitamin A
supplementation within the past six months follow closely the variations in the
percentage of children receiving at least one dose at any time in the past.
Child Morbidity and Treatment
This section discusses the prevalence and treatment of acute respiratory
infection (ARI), fever,
and diarrhoea. Mothers of children born during the three years preceding the
survey were asked
if their children suffered from cough, fever, or diarrhoea during the two weeks
preceding the
survey, and if so, the type of treatment given. Accuracy of all these measures is
affected by the
reliability of the mother’s recall of when the disease episode occurred. The two-
week recall
period is thought to be most suitable for ensuring that there will be an
adequate number of cases
to analyze and that recall errors will not be too serious. The percentage of
children with cough accompanied by fast breathing (symptoms of acute
respiratory infection), fever, and diarrhoea during the two weeks preceding the
survey and the percentage with acute respiratory infection who were taken to a
health facility or provider, by selected background characteristics.
Acute Respiratory Infection
76
Acute respiratory infection, primarily pneumonia, is a major cause of illness
among infants and
children and the leading cause of childhood mortality throughout the world
(Murray and Lopez,
1996). Early diagnosis and treatment with antibiotics can prevent a large
proportion of
ARI/pneumonia deaths. NFHS-2 found that 19 percent of children under age
three in India
suffered from acute respiratory infection (cough accompanied by short, rapid
breathing) at some
time during the two-week period before the survey. A comparison with NFHS-1
ARI data is not meaningful since the two surveys took place at different times of
the year and rates of ARI are affected by the time of the year when the
measurements are taken.
ARI is somewhat more common among boys than girls and among children
living in rural areas than urban areas. Children of mothers who have at least
completed high school have a lower occurrence of ARI than other children. The
prevalence of ARI is higher among scheduled-tribe children than among other
children, and children living in lower standard of living households also have a
higher prevalence of ARI. Children living in households that use piped drinking
water and in households that use a water filter for the purification of water have
a lower prevalence of ARI than do other children.
Sixty-four percent of children received some advice or treatment from a health
facility or health provider when ill with ARI. This percentage, as expected, is
relatively low for children whose mothers are illiterate or who live in households
with a low standard of living. The percentage is relatively high for children
whose mothers do not belong to a scheduled caste or scheduled tribe. Notably,
boys, urban children, and children of birth order one are also more likely than
other children to have been taken to a health facility or provider for advice or
treatment.
There is considerable variation in the prevalence of ARI by state . The
percentage of children under age three who suffered from ARI during the two
weeks preceding the survey ranges from 8 percent in Karnataka to 30 percent
in Sikkim. Interstate variations in the prevalence of ARI, fever, or diarrhoea
should be interpreted with caution, however, because these conditions vary
throughout the year and the fieldwork was conducted at different times of the
year in different states.
Fever
Fever is the most common of the three conditions examined, with 30 percent of
children suffering from fever during the two weeks before the survey. The
prevalence of fever is lower among children under age six months (21 percent)
than among older children (28–34 percent). In general, the prevalence of fever
does not vary widely or in a predictable way with most of the remaining
demographic and socioeconomic characteristics. As with acute respiratory
infection, fever tends to strike young children irrespective of their demographic
and socioeconomic background. The prevalence of fever varies from 21 percent
in Gujarat to 42 percent in Kerala.
77
Diarrhoea
Diarrhoea is the second most important killer of children under age five
worldwide, following
acute respiratory infection. Deaths from acute diarrhoea are most often caused
by dehydration
due to loss of water and electrolytes. Nearly all dehydration-related deaths can
be prevented by
prompt administration of rehydration solutions. Because deaths from diarrhoea
are a significant
proportion of all child deaths, the Government of India has launched the Oral
Rehydration
Therapy Programme as one of its priority activities for child survival. One major
goal of this
programme is to increase awareness among mothers and communities about
the causes and
treatment of diarrhoea. Oral rehydration salt (ORS) packets are made widely
available and
mothers are taught how to use them. NFHS-2 asked mothers of children born
during the three
years preceding the survey a series of questions about episodes of diarrhoea
suffered by their
children in the two weeks before the survey, including questions on feeding
practices during
diarrhoea, the treatment of diarrhoea, and their knowledge and use of ORS.
The 19 percent of children under age three suffered from diarrhoea in the two-
week period before the survey. There are seasonal variations in the prevalence
of diarrhoea, however, so that the percentages cannot be assumed to reflect
the situation throughout the year.
Among children age 1–35 months, those age 6–11 months are most susceptible
to diarrhoea (as is the case with ARI and fever). Differentials by sex of child,
birth order, place of residence, and caste/tribe are small. Sikh children are
considerably less likely to suffer from diarrhoea than children belonging to other
religions. As expected, children of mothers with high school or more education
and children in high standard of living households are somewhat less likely to
suffer from diarrhoea than other children. Also consistent with expectations,
diarrhea is somewhat less common among children living in households that
boil water or use a water filter for purification of drinking water than among
other children. Children living in households that use surface water for drinking
are more vulnerable to diarrhoea than children living in households that use
other sources for drinking water.
Three percent of all children age 1–35 months (14 percent of children who
suffered from diarrhoea in the two weeks before the survey) suffered from
diarrhoea with blood, a symptom of dysentery. Children under age six months
had the lowest prevalence of diarrhoea with blood (less than 1 percent).
Children of birth order four or higher, children living in rural areas, children
whose mothers are illiterate, scheduled-tribe children, children living in low
standard of living households, children living in households using surface water
for drinking, and children living in households using ‘other’ means of water
78
purification or using unpurified water for drinking all had an elevated risk of
having diarrhoea with blood.
The 62 percent of mothers with births during the three years preceding the
survey know about ORS packets, up from 43 percent among women who gave
birth during the three years before NFHS-1. Knowledge of ORS packets is
somewhat lower among mothers age 15–19 and among mothers age 35 years
or older than among mothers in the middle age groups. As expected,
knowledge is considerably higher among urban mothers (76 percent) than rural
mothers (59 percent), and among more educated mothers, especially literate
mothers as compared with illiterate mothers. Knowledge of ORS is higher
among Sikh, Jain, and Christian mothers than among mothers belonging to
other religions. Mothers belonging to scheduled tribes are less likely to know
about ORS packets than mothers belonging to other caste/tribe groups. Among
all the groups shown in the table, knowledge of ORS packets is lowest among
mothers who are not regularly exposed to any mass media (48 percent).
In order to assess mothers’ knowledge of children’s need for extra fluids during
episodes of diarrhoea, all mothers of children born in the three years preceding
the survey were asked:
‘When a child has diarrhoea, should he/she be given less to drink than usual,
about the same
amount, or more than usual?’
In India as a whole, only 29 percent of mothers report that children should be
given more to drink than usual during an episode of diarrhoea and, contrary to
the standard recommendation, 34 percent report that children should be given
less to drink. This suggests that mothers in India need much more education in
the proper management of diarrhoea. The proportion reporting correctly that
children with diarrhoea should be given more to drink is particularly low among
rural mothers, illiterate mothers, mothers belonging to a scheduled tribe, and
mothers not regularly exposed to any mass media. The proportion reporting
correctly that children with diarrhoea should be given more to drink is much
higher among Sikh and Christian mothers than among mothers belonging to
other religions. Mothers age 15–19 and 35 years or older are less likely to
answer correctly than mothers age 20–34. Literate mothers and mothers
exposed to mass media areslightly more likely to know the danger signs.
Notably, however, knowledge of two or more signs of diarrhoea that suggest
the need for medical treatment is universally low across all demographic and
socioeconomic groups. This suggests a need for further educating mothers with
regard to children’s diarrhoea so that they are better able to recognize the
danger signs of diarrhoea for which a health provider should be consulted.
HIV/AIDS
Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) is an illness caused by the HIV
virus, which weakens the immune system and leads to death through
secondary infections such as tuberculosis or pneumonia. The virus is generally
transmitted through sexual contact, through the placenta of HIV-infected
women to their unborn children, or through contact with contaminated needles
(injections) or blood. HIV and AIDS prevalence in India have been on the rise for
more than a decade and have reached alarming proportions in recent years.
The Government of India established a National AIDS Control Organization
79
(NACO) under the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare in 1989 to deal with the
epidemic. Since then there have been various efforts to prevent HIV
transmission, such as public health education through the media and the
activities of many nongovernmental organizations (NGOs).
NFHS-2 included a set of questions on knowledge of AIDS and AIDS prevention.
Evermarried
women age 15–49 were first asked if they had ever heard of an illness called
AIDS.
Respondents who had heard of AIDS were asked further questions about their
sources of
information on AIDS, whether they believe that AIDS is preventable, and if so,
what precautions, if any, a person can take to avoid infection.
Knowledge of AIDS
Sixty percent of women in India have never heard of AIDS. Knowledge of
AIDSvaries little by women’s age, but it is somewhat higher among women age
25–34. Urban residence, education, and the standard of living all have a very
strong positive association with AIDS knowledge. Seventy percent of urban
women in India have heard about AIDS compared with only 30 percent of rural
women. Knowledge of AIDS increases from only 18 percent among illiterate
women to 92 percent among women who have at least completed high school.
Similarly, knowledge of AIDS increases from 20 percent among women in
households with a low standard of living to 74 percent among women in
households with a high standard of living. Jain (83 percent), Christian (78
percent), Buddhist/Neo-Buddhist (69 percent), and Sikh (54 percent) women are
much more likely to know about AIDS than Hindus, Muslims, or women
belonging to other religions (28–39 percent). Only 17 percent of scheduled-tribe
women have heard about AIDS compared with 32 percent of scheduled-caste
women, 42 percent of women belonging to other backward classes, and 48
percent of ‘other’ women. Exposure to mass media increases women’s
knowledge about AIDS substantially. Eighty-five percent of women who read a
newspaper or magazine at least once a week know about AIDS compared with
only 10 percent of women who are not regularly exposed to any mass media
(newspapers, magazines, radio, television, cinema, or theatre).
State variations in the percentage of ever-married women who have heard
about AIDS. Knowledge of AIDS ranges from a low of only 12 percent in Bihar to
93 percent in Manipur and Mizoram. Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, and
Madhya Pradesh all have very low levels of AIDS awareness (below 23 percent).
On the other hand, Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Delhi, Goa, and Nagaland (in addition to
Manipur and Mizoram) have relatively high levels of AIDS awareness (above 72
percent). However, in all of the 12 states with comparable information currently
available, awareness of AIDS increased substantially between the two surveys.
Particularly dramatic increases in AIDS knowledge have taken place in Tamil
Nadu (from 23 to 87 percent), Delhi (from 36 percent to 79 percent),
Maharashtra (from 19 to 61 percent), and Goa (from 42 percent to 76 percent).
Source of Knowledge about AIDS
As part of the AIDS prevention programme, the Government of India has been
using mass
80
media, especially electronic media, extensively to create awareness among the
general public
about AIDS and its prevention.
Television is the most important source of information about AIDS among ever-
married women in India. Seventy-nine percent of women report television as a
source of their information about AIDS. Other important sources are the radio
(42 percent), friends or relatives (31 percent), and newspapers or magazines
(27 percent).
Only 4 percent report that they received information about AIDS from a health
worker. Television is the most important source of information about AIDS in
both urban and rural areas, followed by the radio. Rural women are more likely
than urban women to have learned about AIDS from the radio, a health worker,
or a friend or relative. On the other hand, urban women are more likely to have
learned about AIDS from television, cinema, newspapers or magazines, or
posters or hoardings. More educated women are less likely than less educated
women to have learned about AIDS from a friend or relative, but they are more
likely to have learned about AIDS from each of the other sources. Scheduled-
tribe women are less likely than other women to have learned about AIDS from
television or cinema, but are more likely than other women to have learned
about it from a health worker or a friend or relative. Women in households with
a high standard of living are more likely than other women to have learned
about AIDS from television, cinema, newspapers or magazines, or posters or
hoardings; they are less likely to have learned about AIDS from a friend or
relative. Finally, women who are not regularly exposed to mass media are much
less likely to have learned about AIDS from any media sources, but they are
more likely to have learned about AIDS from a friend or relative, as might be
expected.
Among ever-married women who have heard about AIDS, television is the
primary source of information in most states, followed by the radio. Newspapers
and magazines are also important sources of information about AIDS in most
states. The percentage who received AIDS information from a health worker is
much higher in Mizoram, Sikkim, Himachal Pradesh, and Goa than in other
states, but even in those states only 10–13 percent of women mention health
workers as a source of information. Friends and relatives are a relatively
important source of AIDS information in the northeastern and southern states,
as well as in Orissa, Goa, and Maharashtra.
Knowledge of Ways to Avoid AIDS
Respondents who have heard of AIDS were asked if a person can do anything to
avoid becoming
infected. Those who reported that something could be done were asked what a
person could do
to avoid AIDS. The percentage of ever-married women who know of no way to
avoid AIDS and the percentages who report that AIDS can be avoided in specific
ways, by selected background characteristics.
Among women who have heard about AIDS, 33 percent do not know any way to
avoid infection. As expected, this percentage is higher among rural women than
among urban women and among women not regularly exposed to mass media
than among other women. The percentage who do not know any way to avoid
81
becoming infected with AIDS decreases sharply with increasing levels of
education and household standard of living, as expected. This percentage is
also considerably higher among Muslim women (40 percent) than among
women from almost all other religious groups. Scheduled-tribe women are less
likely to know any way to avoid AIDS than other women.
Among women who report that something can be done to prevent AIDS, the
most commonly mentioned ways of avoiding AIDS are having only one sex
partner (40 percent) and avoiding injections or using clean needles (30
percent). Avoiding sex with commercial sex workers, using condoms, and
avoiding blood transfusions are also mentioned as ways to avoid AIDS by
substantial proportions of women (25, 20, and 19 percent, respectively). Only 7
percent mention abstaining from sex, 3 percent mention avoiding sex with
homosexuals, and 2 percent mention avoiding intravenous drug use. The
percentage reporting each means of avoiding AIDS is lower among rural than
among urban women and among women not regularly exposed to mass media
than among other women. The level of education and the household standard
of living are strongly and positively associated with women mentioning each of
these ways of avoiding AIDS.
‘Having only one sex partner’ is mentioned more often than ‘avoiding injections
or using clean needles’ in 16 out of 25 states.
‘Abstaining from sex’ is mentioned much less frequently as a way to avoid AIDS
in the southern
and western states than in other states.
The lack of knowledge of AIDS, its modes of transmission, and ways to avoid
infection among women in India is a major challenge to efforts to avoid the
spread of AIDS. Most evermarried
women in their childbearing years have never heard of AIDS, and many of those
who have heard of AIDS do not know even one way to avoid infection. It is clear
that AIDS prevention organizations need to strengthen the educational
components of their programmes, in addition to trying to reduce high-risk
behaviour, since even basic information about AIDS is seriously deficient, at
least among women in India.
• Physical growth
82
Growth Problems
The term growth problem is a common occurrence in households having small
children. But most of the time this is basically a misconception and a result of
over-anxious parents. Growth problems in children can arise due to a number of
causes, one of them being the inability of a child to put on weight or if the child
is putting on extra weight than that is needed.
There might be other disorders in the growth and development [pattern of a
child, but before striking a panic attack, it musty be studied whether the child is
genuinely having a growth problem, or he or she is just having a normally
delayed growth. Generally
the growth and development of children have their own patterns, which are
different for girls and boys. The normal cycle of growth in any child is
demonstrated throughout his or her growing years, but is especially apparent
by his or her attaining the puberty. The age of attaining this puberty is also
somewhat different for boys and girls. While girls have their puberty between 8
to 13 years of age, for the boys it is often between 10 to 15 years of age.
This growth in girls are manifested through the development of their rounded
hips, breasts, growth of pubic hair, and their menstrual cycle, whereas in boys it
is the growth in the size of the testicles and the penis, growth of facial hair, and
changes in the voice. Though this
growth is early for some, and somewhat late for others, this cannot be marked
as a growth problem. But for some children there is a constitutional growth
problem that needs to be treated.
Symptoms of Growth Problems
The symptoms of growth problems are generally not very apparent till a certain
age, and if some problem in the growth pattern is suspected, then the doctor
must be consulted immediately. These symptoms differ from one individual to
another according to the causes and their individual growth pattern, but some
more general symptoms are as follows:
» Failure to put on weight for babies
Fig.
» 13. Calculation
Excessive weight gainof Target Height and Target Height Centile. Measure the
parent’s heights and
» Disproportional length makeanda head
note of their heights on the chart. Calculate the
circumference
child’s
» Belowtarget
normal height
height(TH)
andand plot it
weight at 18 years and mark it with an arrow on
ratio
the growth chart. This
Causes of Growth Problems represents the child’s projected height and the target
range are
There is produced
a number byofplotting
factors two
thatpoints
lead to7.5 cms above
growth and below
problems. Some offorthem
a boyare
and
6 cm above
as follows: and below for a girl (representing
» Premature babies the 10th and the 90th centile for
that
» child).
Babies of In the parents
small example shown above, the 50th percentile for the general
population
» Failure to is theweight
gain 90th centile for the child measured and the 10th centile for the
child
» is below
Physical the 10th centile for the population.
illness
» Improper feeding
Source:
» Cowell
Emotional CT. Short Stature. In: Clinical Pediatric Endocrinology, 3rd edn.
neglect
Ed.
» Coelic diseaseLondon, Blackwell Science, 2002; pp 136-172.
Brook CGD.
» Cystic fibrosis
» Crohn's disease
» Infections
» Eating disorders, like anorexia
» Not getting adequate amounts of protein, calories, and other nutrients in your
diet » Number of other chronic medical conditions such as
kidney, heart, lung, and intestinal diseases » People with
sickle cell anemia
» Hormonal imbalance, like hypothyroidism, hyperthyroidism, or Turner’s
syndrome » Genetic causes
83
Diagnosis of Growth Problems :
Disability
Disability prevalence rates per 100,000 population estimated in 1994 are as
follows: physical disability 3574, visual disability 827, hearing 806, speech 510,
and locomotor disability 2041.
The incidence rates per 100,000 population of these disabilities are: physical
173, visual 45, hearing 27, speech 10 and locomotor disability 105 (national
sample survey).
The main cause of blindness is cataract (80.1%), with about 6.5 million (2000)
persons blind due to cataract. The national blindness control programme is
centrally sponsored with a four-pronged strategy to strengthen service delivery,
develop human resources, promote outreach activities and develop institutional
capacity. Due to changing lifestyles, mental disorders are likely to increase in
the future.
The total number of mental disorders treated in specialized mental hospitals
was 48,396 in 1991 and 38,323 in 1992. The majority of cases have been
diagnosed as suffering from psychosis (85.7%).
84
Health expenditure, insurance and human resources :
Household expenditure on various services of health was assessed for one
month prior to the
survey. A household in India on an average spent 118 rupees in the previous
month for health
treatment. Of this, the households on an average spent 52 rupees on drugs,
seven rupees on
traditional medicines and 18 rupees on other expenses related to treatment in a
month. The
amount spent on in-patient treatment was five rupees and out-patient
treatment was 35 rupees.
A major share of health expenditure is on drugs and out-patient care.
Household health expenditure on in-patient treatment, out-patient treatment,
drugs and other related expenses rose with increasing income quintiles.
However, health spending on traditional medical treatment declined for higher
income quintiles, suggesting the dependence of poorer respondents on
traditional medicines. Average household health expenditure is the highest of
203 rupees in Maharashtra and 138 rupees in West Bengal. Household health
expenditure is the lowest 90 rupees in Karnataka. Eighty percent of households
reported that they paid their health expenditure through current income
followed by 16 percent from borrowed sources. Health expenditure paid through
savings (bank account) is nine rupees and income from outside the family
(family members or outside) constitutes about 11 percent each. About seven
percent of the households financed their health expenditure through sale of
assets such as furniture, cattles, jewellery etc. Less than one percent of
households relied on health insurance for their health payments.
85
rupees followed by 49 rupees for out-patient fees.
Households spent 22 rupees for in-patient fees, 40 rupees for other treatment
and 14 rupees for
traditional medicines. Catastrophic health expenditures rise with increasing
levels of income quintiles. At the lower income quintiles, on an average, the
catastrophic health expenditure is 151 rupees compared to 260 rupees at the
higher income quintile. Higher income quintile households on an average spent
12 times higher for in-patient treatment compared to the low-income quintile
households in India.
Impoverishment
The proportion of households with catastrophic expenditure in the first and
second expenditure
decile is 13 percent and 25 percent respectively. About 30 percent of the
households had
catastrophic expenditure in the third decile. Households in the middle
expenditure decile e.g.
fifth and sixth deciles experienced highest impoverishments. Both households
of catastrophic
expenditure and impoverishment due to catastrophic expenditure are
concentrated in the
middle health expenditure decile categories. As economic status improves that
is in very high health spending categories, the catastrophic expenditure and
impoverishment levels come down.
Insurance
In India, only two percent of the population are insured and the rest 98 percent
of respondents are
uninsured. Of the two percent insured, 1.5 percent are covered under
mandatory insurance
and 0.5 percent are covered under voluntary insurance. Both voluntary and
mandatory insurance coverage exists at a minimum scale, but mainly in urban
areas. Rajasthan and west Bengal have slightly higher levels of insurance
coverage than other states. Overall, the poor insurance coverage indicates that
it requires a serious policy intervention to develop it as an important source of
health financing.
Human resources for health(2004) :
The World Health Survey indicates 60 physicians, 135 nursing and
mid-wife and 245 other health related support staffs per 100,000
population in India.
All these professionals are trained in a health related areas or they ever worked
in health related occupations. The highest ratio of health professionals such as
physicians, professionals in nursing-midwifery and other health personnel per
100,000 population is reported in Maharashtra.
The availability of health professionals per 100,000 population is greater among
males compared to females, urban compared to rural, higher income quintile
compared to lower income quintile. Males dominate in physician category while
females dominate in nursing profession with 218 female nurses compared to 57
male nurses per 100,000 population of the respective sexes.
86
Physicians are three times higher in urban areas compared to rural areas.
Physicians and nursingmidwifery professionals are concentrated in higher
income quintile whereas the professionals in other health and support
occupations are evenly distributed in income quintiles. Among the health
professionals, 14 percent are physicians, 31 percent are nurses and mid-wifery
professionals and 56 percent are other health and support staff.
All physicians, 17 percent of nursing and midwifery personnel, 42 percent of
health and support occupation professionals have university degrees. More than
90 percent of health professionals in nursing-midwifery and other health and
support occupations have secondary or less than secondary education.
Among the three categories of professionals in health occupations, physicians
have the highest
participation in the health occupations in the last one year. Eighty eight percent
of the physicians
have worked in the last one year and the rest 12 percent did not work not
because they could not
find a job or for other reasons. About 71 percent of the nursing and the
midwifery personnel have
worked in the last one year and 27 percent did not work for other reasons.
Three percent of nursing and midwifery personnel could not find a job in the
last year. The primary work location of the health professionals indicates that
three fourth of the physicians (79 percent), one fourth of professions in other
health and support occupations (26 percent) and 31 percent of nursing and
midwifery personnel are working in the private health facility. 21 % of
physicians, 54 percent of nursing and midwifery professionals and 25% of
health and support occupation professionals are working in public health facility.
The proportion of professionals in non-health services is 20 percent among
nursing and midwifery professionals and 44 percent among other health and
support occupations.
The nature of work reflects that direct patient care is the major activity of the
physicians (90 %). About 43 percent of nursing/mid wives and five percent
other health professionals are involved in
direct patient care. Those who are engaged in health education/research are
more among other
health staff (56 percent) and 10 percent from physicians. About 53 percent of
nursing and
midwifery professionals are involved in health education, research and other
health related
activities. Twenty percent professionals in health and support occupations and
four percent of
nursing professionals are involved in non-health activities.
Table : 15
Country INDIA
(2006)
Population 1130 million
Population growth rate 1.4 %
Population density 363 persons per sq km
Urban / Rural distribution Urban-30 % , Rural- 70 %
87
Health and Education: Male-62 yrs
Life expectancy(average) Female-64 yrs
Infant mortality rate 56 deaths per 1,000 live
births
Population per doctor 2500 people
Population per hospital bed 1300 people
Literacy rate 70 %
Number of students per teacher, primary 41 students / teacher
school
88
measles immunisation. Immunisation of three doses of DTP is unfavourable to
female and rural
children, indicating a gender and residential gap in immunisation coverage.
Maternal and child care, along with household food security, adequate health
services and a healthy environment is a third necessary (but in itself
insufficient) precondition for adequate nutrition. In fact, ‘care’ may be
considered as a pivotal link between these two other conditions, representing
the behavioural component of intra-household decision-making and resource
use. It refers to the provision in the household and the community, of time,
attention and support to meet the physical, mental and social needs of the
growing child and other family members. In the child nutrition context, most
importantly it involves the optimal use of household resources for child feeding,
protection from infection, and care for the sick child. While the issue of ‘caring
capacity’ refers to all the household members -- male and female -- who are
potential caretakers of children, in practice in India, the main responsibility for
child care lies with the mother (who often also has a major role as an income-
earner). Her capacity to manage the many competing demands on her time will
govern the degree to which she can maintain a clean household environment,
feed her children, care for them when sick as well as providing and preparing
food for other household members.
In turn, this capacity will be governed by the quantity, control and use of
resources such as food, income, time and knowledge. The control of such
resources at a societal level may be influenced by factors such as her socio-
economic and educational status. We thus start with an examination of the
feeding and caring practices in the household before examining the possible
basic causes relating to the role of women in Indian society and their
educational status and literacy levels relative to men.
This integral precondition for adequate nutrition may not be as well
89ecognized by policy-makers, compared to food and health. Partly this may be
as a result of its many linkages with the areas of food and health, and partly as
little data is routinely collected to reveal the gender dimensions of nutrition
problems. These are discussed in the concluding section.
Mother and Child Health Care:
The type of care received at child birth is often critical for the health and
survival of both infant and mother. A significant proportion of neo-natal deaths
is attributed to poor birth practices. During 1987, only about 32% of births in
rural areas and 74% in urban areas were in institutions or attended to by
trained personnel (Registrar General of India 1979-86). Traditional birth
attendants are unable to attend to complications and health professionals are
contacted too late. Both these factors point to the need to identify mothers at
risk during the prenatal period.
89
coverage however masks variations between states ranging from 16% in Assam
to 99% in Kerala.
Even though abortion has been legalised in India since 1972, mortality and
morbidity due to illegal abortions and birth attention by incompetent persons in
unhygienic conditions remain a major problem, mainly because of ignorance of
the law and inaccessability of professional services in rural areas. Only around
half a million pregnancy terminations were performed through the health
services in the fiscal year 1987-88 which is around 9% of the induced abortions
likely to have been performed during the same period. Since the inception of
this formal facility in 1972, 5.8 million abortions have been performed under it;
less than the total number of induced abortions likely to happen in one year
(UNICEF 1990 p15). Induced abortions in fact reflect an unmet need of women
for family planning, and highlight gaps between demand for family planning on
one hand and availability, accessibility and actual use of services on the other.
90
Source: GOI Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
The four-state ICDS study undertaken by NIN (Sarma et al. 1990) has indicated
that nearly 50% of the mothers did not alter the diets of their children when
they were sick. Quality of intranatal care is another important indicator of
health service availability and utilisation. The ICDS report shows that 76% of
the deliveries in ICDS areas were conducted by trained personnel compared to
49% in non-ICDS areas. The immunisation coverage of children between 12-24
months also showed that the ICDS children in most of the states were better
protected. In the states of Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra, however, the coverage
was more or less similar in ICDS and non-ICDS areas. Similar results were
91
observed in the four-state ICDS study undertaken by NIN where immunisation
coverage, antenatal care, massive dose vitamin A administration, folifer
distribution etc., was two to three fold better in ICDS areas.
Education
Resource allocation
The total expenditure on education increased from 1.2% of the GNP in 1950-51
to about 4% in 1986-87, against an optimal target level of 6%. The real per
capita expenditure also increased steadily, particularly in the late 1980s, from $
0,68 in 1975-76 to $ 1.64 in 1989-90.
The share of education as a proportion of plan outlay in the public sector has
shown a declining trend through the plan periods. Within the education sector,
the share of elementary education has been falling from 56% in the first five-
year plan to 29% in the seventh plan; higher education has benefited at the
cost of primary education. There is a need to step up the resources for formal
and non-formal education. Assuming that 70% of the 6-14 age group will be
92
provided education through formal and 30% through non-formal channels, the
annual per capita cost for universal elementary education has been estimated
at Rs. 103 and Rs. 54 (informal) by the year 2000.
Infrastructure development
The new educational policy adopted by the Government in 1986 accords a very
high priority to universalisation of education to ensure essential minimum
education to all children up to the age of 14 years.
Changes in literacy rates during the 1980s are impressive for both males and
females (Registrar General of India 1991). According to the 1991 census, about
52% of India’s population is literate. At the time of independence in 1947, the
female literacy rate was a mere 6%. Over the years however, there has been a
steady improvement in the rate, although the absolute number of female
illiterates has increased from 215 million in 1971 to 242 million in 1981. This
backlog is estimated to have further swollen to 253 million in 1988,
notwithstanding the rise in the female literacy level reported by the 1987-88
National Sample Survey. Of the 340.5 million illiterates above 5 years in India in
1981, as many as 200.3 million were women. Of them 170.7 million live in rural
areas. In other words, more than half of the total illiterates in India in 1981 were
rural females, and this proportion remained throughout the 1980s. The female
rural literacy rate in the 10-14 year age group was 36.4%, but it declined
progressively with increasing age and is only 8.6% in the above-35 age group
(UNICEF 1990 p88).
Overall, female literacy rates improved threefold from 1961 to 1991 (from 13.3
to 39.4%) while for males the level has gone up from 34.4% to 63.8% during
the same period. Clearly however the female rate is still much lower than that
93
of males (Registrar General of India 1991) - in fact the female rate in the early
1990s can be seen to approximate the male literacy rate of a quarter a century
ago.
The regional variation with regard to female literacy is striking. In the 1981
census, the highest female literacy rate (5 years and above) of 78.9% is
registered by Kerala (UNICEF 1990 p102). By contrast, among the 14 most
populous states, four states viz., Rajasthan (28.4%), Madhya Pradesh (32.3%)-
Uttar Pradesh (31.4%) and Bihar (30.2%) ranked the lowest. These states
accounted for half the illiterate rural women in India (as well, in fact, as the
majority of India’s poor).
There have been efforts to correlate female literacy with age at marriage,
fertility rates and child mortality. In rural areas, a higher proportion of married
women are illiterates as compared to urban areas. Further, among illiterates,
around two-thirds of women got married before reaching the age of 18 years,
suggesting a positive correlation between age at marriage and level of
education. Available data also suggest an inverse correlation between a
woman’s level of education and her fertility.
Child mortality rates are about five times higher among illiterate mothers
compared to graduates (Registrar General of India 1989). Better child survival
among the educated group may be due to several factors such as better
hygiene, improved nutrition and feeding practices, and timely medical
intervention. A study conducted by NIN (Brahman et al. 1988) showed that,
controlling for income, the energy content of the diet of children whose mothers
were literate tended to be better than those whose mothers were illiterate.
There are other case studies showing that maternal education has a significant
influence on the nutritional status of the children (Walker and Ryan 1990).
Women’s literacy and their use of health facilities go hand in hand. Krishnan
(1985) examined overall death rates in terms of literacy, doctor, hospital and
bed population ratio, per capita income and % per capita expenditure on
medical and health services. He observed that literacy was the most important
factor while health services also had some explanatory power.
Socio-economic Status
The capacity of a mother to care for her children depends on her social status
and economic activities. In many poor societies patriarchy is likely to be the
main obstacle in securing a fairer distribution of work and decision-making
power between adult household members.
94
her little time for child care. It is a complex situation and women’s problems are
difficult to capture in national surveys. There have been a few case-studies to
assess the impact of women’s work and income on child nutrition. The analysis
of women’s work and child survival undertaken by Rosenzweig and Schultz
(1982), whose two-stage regression analysis of an all-India sample of rural
households demonstrated that female employment had a significant influence
on the survival of the girl child. A case study undertaken in Kerala (Gulati 1978)
indicated that the nutritional adequacy of households dependent on agricultural
labour was more related to women’s employment than men’s. A study
undertaken by the Maharashtra Employment Guarantee Scheme (Walker and
Ryan 1990) indicated that in households where women exercise control over
their wages, more money was spent on food and other basic needs while men
tend to spend more on liquor, cigarettes etc. These studies suggest that
women’s gainful employment and decision-making power in the family
influence the child health and survival (see ‘Gender Issues in Child Care’ section
below).
Data on gender differences in child care and access to food and health care are
contradictory. While recent NNMB data fail to show evidence of gender
discrimination in food consumption (and by implication, in food access and
allocation), anthropological and other evidence to the contrary has been
reported from numerous studies. Miller (1981) has collated evidence from thirty
one ethnographic studies from several regions in India on allocation of food,
medical care, and love and affection. Of the 13 studies that report on food
allocation among young children, only two studies indicate no gender
differentiation in feeding practices, while 11 studies indicate caretaker bias
against female children.
This bias is most often exhibited during early infancy in breastfeeding, weaning
and supplementation practices, and in later years in apportionment of quality
foods such as milk, butter, snacks and sweets. Most studies conclude that
gender biases are small (which may be one of the reasons why these are
unlikely to be picked up by generic surveys), but as one study states "in an
emergency...[a daughter] is more readily expendable than a son". Twelve other
studies that document gender-related food practices during adolescence
present evidence for allocation of special foods to girls for periods ranging from
a few days to a few months at/around the time of menstruation. Of the ten
95
studies that report on allocation of medical care, all but one infer better medical
care for boys.
Only two of the studies reviewed address the issue of sex differences in
nutritional status, and both present evidence for consistently higher
prevalences of underweight girls than boys. Many of the studies also suggest
more pronounced gender differences in northern India, and among the less
privileged classes. The report presents further evidence that sex ratios at birth
are similar in all regions of the country, while juvenile sex ratios
(females/males) are significantly low in North India - the region where evidence
for gender discrimination is most strong (sec Table 13). While some evidence of
female infanticide may explain this differential, the implication is that overt or
covert marginalization in child care in North India translates into greater female
mortality in the early years and a consequent rise in the sex ratio.
Table 16: Sex ratios in Indian regions (females per 1000 males)
96
the 12) were female infanticide was practised, this was the outcome of 9.7 per
cent of all female births!
These are frightening statistics, even more so when research has shown that
the problem is much worse in the north of the country. The question of why it is
that all the Indian states with IMRs higher than the national average (of 94) are
concentrated in the north of the country demands investigation from this
perspective? While the relative incidence of poverty in the north vis-a-vis the
south may explain some of this, the findings above suggest that research into
the degree of female infanticide in other parts of India, particularly the north, is
urgent.
Cultural factors on the other hand determine not only the gender division of
waged tasks within which market mechanisms may operate, but also systems
of property owners. In a tribal south Indian population, for example, increased
income from female wage work was not associated with an increased female
control over household food allocation decisions. The impact of the concurrent
decrease in capacity for child care was disproportionately borne by girls under
the age of one, a bias that was reflected in excess female child undernutrition.
Material factors in this case appear to have been less important than cultural
factors in influencing gender-differentials in child care and nutrition. The
process of Hinduisation which is diffusing throughout tribal societies in South
India, with the practice of dowry becoming increasingly widespread and the
costs of the dowered increasing, may here be reflected in the relative neglect of
the nutritional and health needs of girls vis-a-vis boys.
97
Table 17: Selected Socioeconomic characteristics of Households in
Sample
All India N=85091
Variable Mean
Age of Mother 31.17
Urban Household (%) 31.46
Rural Household (%) 68.54
Mother’s Education in single 4.02
years
Father’s Education in single 6.59
years
Religion (%) 78.44
Hindu 11.12
Muslim 5.54
Christian 2.38
Sikh 2.46
Other
Caste (%) 17.01
Scheduled Caste 12.30
Scheduled Tribe
Read Newspaper once a week 24.70
(%)
Watch TV once a week (%) 50.70
Mother Working (%) 34.90
North India (%) 69.15
South India (%) 16.87
Live in Big City (%) 11.29
Living with Mother in Law (%) 1.6
It is estimated that out of half a million maternal deaths in the world each year
about 20% are in India. Maternal deaths are caused either by direct causes
arising from complications of pregnancy, delivery or their management; or
indirect causes due to aggravation, by pregnancy or child birth, of an existing
abnormal condition.
India’s maternal mortality rate, estimated at 3.4 per 1000 live births, on
average between 1980-87 (UNDP 1990 pp.148) compares with an average of
2.9 for ‘all developing countries’ and 0.24 for industrialized countries. There is
no figure for the maternal mortality rate of the country which can be considered
as reasonably conclusive, more so because levels as high as 13 have been
noted in certain rural areas. The actual life-time risk of an Indian woman dying
from a maternity-related cause is far greater than comparative rates between
India and the industrialized countries would suggest owing to the higher total
fertility rate (4.0 in 1990 according to the World Bank 1992). Maternal age and
98
number of births have a strong effect on maternal mortality. A woman giving
birth to children at 20-35 years of age faces a much lower risk than women
below 20 and over 35 years. An estimated 8% of the 26-27 million annual births
in India are to mothers below 19 years, whose growth and maturation may be
retarded. Maternal illness and death rose significantly with the fourth pregnancy
and reached a high level after the fifth. Some 35% of live births in rural areas
and around 29% of live births in urban areas are of the fourth birth order and
above (Registrar General of India 1984). In India, as in many developing
countries, maternal mortality accounts for the-largest, or near-largest,
proportion of deaths among women in their prime years (UNICEF 1990 p14).
The trend in the percentage distribution of deaths by causes related to child
birth and pregnancy in rural India is given in Table 7.
Specific causes 2 2 2 2 2 2
001 002 003 004 005 006
Abortion 13.7 10.1 10.7 10.8 11.5 8.0
Toxaemia 8.0 12.5 12.1 10.8 6.7 11.9
Anaemia 17.7 24.4 18.9 23.3 23.1 17.0
Bleeding of 23.4 26.2 23.5 18.8 15.9 21.6
pregnancy
Obstructive labour 9.2 7.2 8.3 6.2 7.7 6.2
Puerperium sepsis 13.1 8.3 11.6 10.8 13.9 13.1
Non-classifiable 14.9 11.3 14.6 19.3 21.2 22.2
Total 100. 100. 100. 100. 100. 100.
0 0 0 0 0 0
Sample number of 175 168 206 176 208 176
deaths
Percentage of total 1.0 1.0 1.2 1.0 1.2 1.0
deaths
Source: Registrar General of India, Survey of Censuses of Deaths (Rural) 2001-
07
In 1997, deaths related to pregnancy and child birth accounted for 13.2% of
deaths among rural women aged 15-45 years; and 14.0% of those in the 15-24
years age group. Most of maternal deaths are associated with malnutrition,
particularly anaemia. Other major causes such as toxaemia and septicaemia
reflect the inadequate health care available to women during ante-natal, intra-
natal and post-natal periods. The share of deaths from toxaemia and puerperal
sepsis is higher in the 15-24 year age group which also faces a considerable
threat from abortion, anaemia and bleeding (the latter two are inter-related).
These young women are thus particularly at-risk, in addition to their greater
propensity for delivering low-weight babies and to infant loss.
99
Structure of School Education System in India:
In India the kinds of Schools are - public schools, private school, girls schools,
boys schools ...etc.
The minimum age for starting scholing is 4-5 yrs, initial standards are LKG(
lower kinder garden), UKG( upper kinder garden).
Higher
Pre-Primary Primary Middle Secondary
Secondary
School School School School
School
Length of Age level Age level Age level from: Age level from:
program in from: 6 to 11 from: 11 to 14 14 to 16 16 to: 18
years: 2
Source : http://www.spice.org/htm/Schooling/Schooling/EducationStructure.htm
The Grade 10 and Grade 12 examinations are very important in India. These
two exams are usually conducted by an external examination body that is
different than the school. The student performance in these two examinations
is vital for seeking admission to a University program in India. In India, this
schooling system is commonly referred to as “10+2” (Ten Plus Two) schooling
system.
Advantages:
Youth behavior changes drastically at about 16 years of age. By separating the
schools for less–than 16–year olds from the 16+ year olds in 11 th and 12 th
100
grade, the less–than 16–year olds get a better chance to stay away from the
influence of the 16+ youth.
Immunization coverage
101
Note
- The BCG vaccine to prevent TB (tuberculosis) is no longer routinely given to
children. It is now only recommended for children at high risk of the disease
(e.g. those living in areas with a high rate of TB or whose parents or
grandparents were born in a country where TB is highly prevalent).
- Scares over the MMR vaccination have meant that some parents have not
had their children vaccinated against measles, mumps and rubella. There have
consequently been reported surges in the number of children with measles. If
you’re concerned about this vaccination, it’s possible to obtain some of the
vaccines individually and privately.
102
high estimates for Kerala).
As direct investigations require a huge sample, several indirect methods have
been
proposed for the estimation of maternal mortality. One of these is the so called
'sisterhood
method' developed by Graham and others (Graham et al., 1989). This method
makes use of the
data collected from female respondents in a sample survey on the number of
ever-married
sisters they had, the number who were not currently alive, and the number who
died while
pregnant, during childbirth or within six weeks after delivery. The procedure of
estimation can
be made more direct by adding a few more questions on siblings, as done in
some Demographic
and Health Surveys (See Rutenberg and Sullivan, 1991). The sisterhood method
cuts down the
required sample size drastically because women generally have several sisters
who could have
been exposed to the risk of maternal mortality, each time when they were
pregnant. The method
has been used to estimate maternal mortality with some success in African
populations. In India,
opportunities for using the sisterhood method have been limited owing to
paucity of data.
An indirect procedure of estimating maternal mortality from the sex differentials
in
mortality at reproductive ages has been developed by Bhat et al. (1995).
Basically, it involves
the regression of sex differentials in mortality rate on fertility rate, by age. The
method can be
applied to any source that provides estimates of mortality rates by age and sex,
and fertility rates
by age. The main advantages of this method are that it requires no special
questions to be
canvassed, and provides estimates for more recent times than the indirect
version of the
sisterhood method. Comparisons made with the estimates from other sources
indicate that this
approach gives quite plausible levels of maternal mortality for India. However,
there have been
few applications of the method to data outside south Asia.
The objectives of this paper are two fold. First, it presents estimates of maternal
mortality derived from the sisterhood questions asked in the Human
Development Profile
Survey (HDPS) conducted by the National Council of Applied Economic Research
in 1994
103
(Shariff, 1999). As the relevant data have been collected from about 37,000
ever-married
women, it is possible to derive from the survey data reasonably stable
estimates of maternal
morality for broad geographical regions and by socio-economic characteristics.
The second objective of this paper is to update the estimates of maternal
mortality
derived using the indirect procedure developed by Bhat et al. (1995). The
original paper carried
estimates of maternal mortality for India and its major states for the period
1982-86 using the
data from India's Sample Registration System. In this paper, estimates are
presented using this
method for the period 1987-96. An attempt is also made to compare the
estimates derived from
the two indirect methods to judge their relative performance.
Indirect Estimates from Sisterhood Method
The HDPS covered about 33,000 rural households spread over 1,765 villages
and 195 districts
in 16 major states of India. Table 1 shows the application of the sisterhood
method to the all-
India data for rural areas. Nearly 37,000 women 15-49 years at the time of the
survey have
reported on an average 1.9 married sisters. Among them, 2,671 sisters were
not alive at the time
of the survey (i.e., 4.3 percent). The data available for 2,102 dead sisters
indicate that 32
percent died around the time of childbirth. From this information, following the
procedure
developed by Graham et al., the lifetime probability of dying from maternal
causes for a female
baby has been calculated as 2.5 percent (see Table 1). This estimate of lifetime
probability
refers to, on an average, 11.8 years before the survey, or roughly to 1982. For
computing the
more conventional measure of maternal mortality rate, an estimate of average
number of
children born to women in their lifetime (i.e., total fertility rate) is required. The
most
convenient approximation to this is the average number of live births reported
by the surveyed
women of age 40-49 years. According to HDPS, the average number of children
ever born to
women of the age interval 40-49 was 4.4. But the reported sex ratio of 118
males for 100 female
births suggests that women had underreported the number of daughters born
to them. If a
104
correction is made by assuming a sex ratio at birth of 105, the total lifetime
births to an average
woman rises to 4.7. This figure is close to the total fertility rate of 4.9 reported
by the Sample
Registration System for rural areas of India in 1982. With 4.7 as the estimate of
lifetime births,
the sisterhood data from the HDPS imply a maternal mortality rate of 544 per
100,000 live
births in rural areas of India in 1982. With 4.9 as the estimate of TFR, the data
imply a maternal
mortality ratio of 518. As only the survey can provide estimates of lifetime
births for various
population groups, for the sake of comparability, the former could be adopted
as the estimate of
MMR for rural India from HDPS.
105
slow progress in the 1990s in health status improvement, as several of the
above indicators show a plateauing.
Moreover, the improvement in health status has been very uneven across the
country, where states such as Kerala have health indicators comparable with
the middle-income countries and other states such as Uttar Pradesh, Madhya
Pradesh, Bihar and Orissa are at the lower end levels comparable to Sub-
Saharan Africa.
Photo: 1, Medical college students explaining how to prevent from Dengue fever
spreading.
106
health sector endowments but also by its efficient use. An empirical study in
Cote d’ Ivoire found that health care utilisation at the lower end of the income
spectrum was much more sensitive to distance when compared to their richer
counterparts .
• SHARE OF PUBLIC AND PRIVATE HEALTH CARE FACILITIES
The Government of India and the states spend less than one percent of the
nations Gross Domestic Product, or about three percent of all government
spending, on health. Although not quite as large as the world average of 5.5
percent of GDP spent on health, it is still sounds significant. Ninety percent of
the health finance is routed through the state (provincial) governments since
the Indian constitution specifies that a large number of health related activities
belong to the ambit of individual states (GOI, 1996; Reddy and Selvarajau,
1994).
Also, the central government spends most of the remaining share, with local
governments such as municipalities accounting for about 2.5 percent (World
Bank, 1995).
The public sector plays an important role in the rural health delivery system in
the country. In
urban areas the public and private health systems complement each other. The
public sector does a offer a source of subsidized health care to the majority of
India’s underprivileged, but this benefit comes at the price of subsidizing the
richer groups out of proportion to their share in the population (NCAER, 2000).
Rural health system performance determines the overall health outcome of the
states and the country. Thus, the performance of public health system is of
great significance in rural areas.
In India, patients from both rural and urban areas overwhelmingly choose public
facilities (Government hospitals, Community Health Centres and Primary Health
Centres) for inpatient
care. The reliance on public hospitals for in-patient care was greater in hilly and
backward
states, among Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and those belonging to
the lower monthly
per capita expenditure quintile (Shariff, 1995; National Sample Survey
Organisation, 1998). In the public sector, 70 percent of hospitals and 85 percent
of hospital beds are located in urban areas. These facilities are used more often
in cases of severe and catastrophic illness, which the private practitioners are
either reluctant or unable to handle.
Poor patients depend heavily on public health services because the cost of
treatment of illness is
higher in private health care facilities. The patients with higher levels of income
use private health care facilities because of better quality. However, other
studies suggest that only 35 percent of the patients seek care from public
facilities for major illness and largely depend on private health care facilities,
irrespective of their level of income (Selvarajau, 2003). In the public sector, 70
percent of hospitals and 85 percent of hospital beds are located in urban areas.
In India, the total health expenditure was 5.3 percent of the Gross Domestic
Product (GDP) in 1997 and 5.1 percent in 2001 (World Health Report, 2003).
This indicates a marginal decline in the proportion of health expenditure as a
107
percent of GDP. Private household health expenditure as a percent of total
expenditure on health was 84 percent in 1997 and 82 percent in 2001. On
average, a household spends 250 rupees per capita per annum on health
services. Health expenditure is 40 percent higher in urban households than in
rural households.
Health expenditure is also positively related with overall household expenditure
. Private health spending out of pocket expenditure in India is one of the highest
in the world and indicates an inefficient way to finance healthcare that leaves
people highly vulnerable. Studies in less developed countries in general shows
that subsidies on public health are not necessarily targeted well to those most
in need, the poor. Government expenditure on health as a percent of total
government expenditure was 3.2 percent in 1997 and 3.1 percent in 2001. Also,
the share of health budget in total revenue budget of the 16 major states has
come down from 6.7 percent in 1987-88 to 5.4 percent in 1996- 97 (Selvarajau,
2003). Studies have shown that the use and availability of health care system
varies between states, gender, and residence and by different socio-economic
groups (NCAER, 2006).
Table 19. Trends in health expenditure in India, 2000-2004
2000 2001
2002 2003 2004
Total expenditure on health 1(as a % of GDP) 5.3 5.0 5.2 5.1
5.1
General government expenditure on health 15.7 18.4 17.9 17.6
17.9
(as a % of total expenditure on health)
Private expenditure on health 84.3 81.6 82.1 82.4
82.1
(as a % of total expenditure on health)
General government expenditure on health 3.2 3.5 3.3 3.1
3.1
(as a % of total government expenditure)
External resources for health 2.3 2.4 2.2
2.2 0.4
(as a % of total expenditure on health)
Out of pocket expenditure 100 100 100
100 100
(as a % of private expenditure on health)
1 Includes all public and private expenditure on health
Source: World Health Report, 2006
Private health facilities are greatly used in urban India. However, private
practitioners are well
spread even in remote and backward areas, and they are usually contacted for
day-to-day health
care needs before availing distantly located specialist public facilities. The
growth of corporate hospitals is due to the demand for development of a health
care market in which investment in state-of-the-art medical technology can give
a good return. Although the private sector accounts for a significant portion of
the health system facilities, human resources and expenditure in India, no
108
adequate mechanism has been developed for monitoring and regulating the
private health sector. In most countries health sector reform involves a change
in the respective shares of tax revenue, social or private insurance, user fees
and external aid in financing the health sector. Services provided in the public
and private sector tends to differ.
Hospital subsidies are distributed much more evenly in urban population in
comparison to the
rural population (NCAER, 2000). A shift takes place in the role that the state
plays in the regulation and provision of health care services and the
development of various types of
public-private partnerships. Decentralisation, integration of services, including
sector-wide
approaches and reforms in logistics occur. The reform process is also affected
by the geopolitical context in which a health system is embedded. This includes
the bargaining position
of the country in the international setting, the level of external debt and
financial stability of the
country and the impact of the past political structure on the health care system.
HEALTH SYSTEM GOALS
Health for all by the year 2010 AD is a national goal set by the Indian policy
makers over Alma
Ata. Since then, a lot of planning, efforts and public expenditures have been
focussed and
concentrated to improve the human health both in rural and urban parts of
India. Supply of
medicine has also improved. Despite concentrated efforts, India is one of the
many developing
countries, which faces a high level of morbidity, especially among the infants,
children, women and the elderly. Also high incidence of infectious,
communicable diseases are associated with low levels of sanitation, public
hygiene and poor quality drinking water.
The main goals of the health system are health system responsiveness and
fairness in financing.
Health of the population should reflect the health of individuals throughout the
life course
and include prevention of both premature mortality and non-fatal health
outcomes as key
components. Responsiveness has two key subcomponents: respect of persons
and client
orientation (WHO, 2002).
Respect for persons involves elements of dignity, autonomy and confidentiality
and captures aspects of the interaction of individuals with the health system
that often have an important ethical dimension. Client orientation includes
prompt attention to health needs, basic amenities of health services such as
clean waiting rooms or adequate beds and food in hospitals, access to social
support networks for individuals receiving care and choice of institution and
individual providing care.
109
There are also cross-system goals to evaluate how much the health system
helps or hinders education, democratic participation, economic production etc.
One of the more important cross-system goals that should be emphasised is the
contribution of the health system to economic production and social aspects
like education.
NATIONAL HEALTH POLICY OF INDIA :
In the broader context of health system goals, a new National Health Policy was
formulated
in 2002 to cater to the changes in the determining factors relating to the health
sector since the National Health Policy of 1983. The old health policy was
revised and restructured based on the United Nations Millennium Development
Goals.
The main objective of the National Health Policy 2002 is to achieve an
acceptable standard of good health amongst the general population of the
country. The approach would be to increase access to the decentralised public
health system by establishing new infrastructure in the existing institutions.
The National Health Policy (2002) of India has noted that improvement in health
status in terms
of indicators such as the infant mortality rate, morbidity prevalence, life
expectancy etc. has been very uneven across the rural-urban areas. The
statistics also bring out wide differences between the attainments of health
goals in the better performing states (Kerala, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu)
compared to the low-performing states (Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Orissa, Bihar,
Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand). So, the national average of
health indices hides the wide disparities in public health. Given a situation in
which the national averages in respect of most indices are themselves at
unacceptably low levels, the wide inter-state disparity implies that for
vulnerable sections of society in several states, access to public health services
is nominal and health standards are grossly inadequate.
GOALS YEAR
Eradicate Polio and Yaws 2005
Eliminate Leprosy 2005
Eliminate Kala Azar 2010
Eliminate Lymphatic Filariasis 2015
Achieve zero level growth of HIV/AIDS 2007
Reduce mortality by 50 percent on account of TB, malaria and other
vector and water borne diseases 2010
Reduce prevalence of blindness to 0.5 percent 2010
Reduce IMR to 30/1000 and MMR to 100/lakh 2010
Increase utilisation of public health facilities from current level of <20 to
>75 percent 2010
Establish an integrated system of surveillance, National health accounts
and Health Statistics 2005
110
Increase health expenditure by government as a percent of GDP from the
existing 0.9 percent to 2.0 percent 2010
Increase share of central grants to constitute at least 25 percent of total
health spending 2010
Increase state sector health spending from 5.5 percent to 7 percent of the
budget 2005
Further increase state sector health spending to 8 percent of the budget
2010
Source: National Health Policy, 2004, Government of India, Delhi.
111
• Creating sustaining cross-Government and intercostals partnerships to
improve health reduce inequalities
112
SOCIO-DEMOGRAPHIC PROFILE OF INDIA
The data from Census, Sample Registration System and National Family Health
Survey (1998-99) are used. Population in the six states constitute about 47
percent of the country’s population. Uttar Pradesh has the highest share of 16
percent of population followed by Maharashtra with nine percent and Assam the
lowest proportion of about three percent of the population. The annual growth
rate of population in India was 1.93 percent during 1991-2001. The population
growth rates in Karnataka, West Bengal and Assam are lower than the national
average. Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan indicate the highest population growth
rate of 2.3 percent and 2.5 percent respectively in the country. West Bengal,
Assam and Uttar Pradesh have higher densities above the national average of
324. For the country as a whole, 28 percent of the population are in urban
areas. But, Maharashtra, Karnataka and West Bengal have higher levels of
urbanisation above the national average with 42 percent, 34 percent and 28
percent respectively. Sex ratio for the country is 933 females per 1000 males.
The sex ratio of the population for Maharashtra, Assam and Rajasthan are lower
than the sex ratio for the country, indicating greater deficit of females.
Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and Assam have literacy rates below the national
average of 65 percent. Assam, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan have crude birth
rates (CBR) and total fertility rates (TFR) higher than the national average.
Maharashtra, Karnataka and West Bengal are more advanced in demographic
transition than the country level average. The couple protection rate (family
planning methods) in India is about 45 percent. Among the six states,
Maharashtra and Karnataka have the highest proportion of couples protection
rates and also higher proportion of elderly population, which is above the
national average of 7.9 percent.
• The scope of public health :
Public health services are conceptually distinct from medical services. They
have as a key
goal reducing a population’s exposure to disease ⎯ for example through
assuring food
safety and other health regulations; vector control; monitoring waste disposal
and water
systems; and health education to improve personal health behaviors and build
citizen
demand for better public health outcomes. Thus they involve such disparate
activities as
improving slaughterhouse hygiene and cattle-keeping practices, cleaning
irrigation canals
to discourage vector breeding, and applying public health regulations.
Public health services produce “public goods” of incalculable benefit for
facilitating
economic growth and poverty reduction. Consider, for example, the long-term
growth
113
possibilities generated by draining the swamps around which Washington DC
was built.
And conversely, consider the global economic costs imposed by the avian flu
and SARS
epidemics, emanating from poor poultry-keeping and health practices in a few
Chinese
localities. In India, the 1994 plague epidemic following poor municipal
sanitation in
Surat is estimated by the WHO (1999) to have resulted in losses totaling $1.7
billion.
Poor public health conditions take economic tolls in various ways, including
reduced
attraction for investors and tourists; continued expenditures on combating
diseases which
should have become history; and labor productivity foregone. The poor pay a
high price
in debility, reduced earning capacity, and death. The rich suffer little mortality
from
communicable diseases, but nevertheless suffer repeated episodes of
morbidity which are
reflected in high rates of stunting amongst their children.
It has long been accepted that the most effective approaches to improving
population
health are those that prevent rather than treat disease. Moreover, they
account for a small
fraction of the total health budget in most countries. It is the norm for public
health services to be publicly funded, since the market has limited incentives
to provide them. This applies even in the US, where medical services are
largely privately financed. But in India public policies and programs have
focused largely on the provision of curative care and personal prophylactic
interventions such as immunization, while public health activities have been
relatively neglected. This helps explain why India’s health indicators are so
much poorer than in East Asia and much of the rest of the world.
Photo: 3, Public services in India: Rural health facilities and Urban health
facilities.
Abstract
Public health services, which reduce a population’s exposure to disease
through such measures as
114
sanitation and vector control, are an essential part of a country’s development
infrastructure. In
the developed world and East Asia, systematic public health efforts raised
labor productivity and
life expectancies well before modern curative technologies became widely
available, and helped
set the stage for rapid economic growth and poverty reduction. The enormous
business and other costs of the breakdown of these services are illustrated by
the current global epidemic of avian flu, emanating from poor poultry-keeping
practices in a few Chinese villages.
For various reasons, mostly of political economy, public funds for health
services in India have been focused largely on medical services, and public
health services have been neglected.
This is reflected in a virtual absence of modern public health regulations, and
of systematic
planning and delivery of public health services. Various organizational issues
also militate against
the rational deployment of personnel and funds for disease control. There is
strong capacity for
dealing with outbreaks when they occur, but not to prevent them from
occurring. Impressive
capacity also exists for conducting intensive campaigns, but not for sustaining
these gains on a
continuing basis after the campaign. This is illustrated by the near-eradication
of malaria through
highly-organized efforts in the 1950s, and its resurgence when attention
shifted to other priorities such as family planning. This paper reviews the
fundamental obstacles to effective disease control in India, and indicates new
policy thrusts which can help overcome these obstacles.
Sources:
1 Office of the Register General and Census Commissioner, Census of India,
2001, Provisional Population Tables, New Delhi: Office of the Register General
and Census Commissioner.
2 Registrar General, India, 2005 Sample Registration System, 2003.
3 Family Welfare Programme in India year Book 1997-98, Department of Family
Welfare, Ministry of health & Family Welfare, Government of India, New Delhi.
4 International Institute for Population Sciences (IIPS) and ORC Macro. 2000,
National Family Health Survey (NFHS-2),2003-04: India. Mumbai: IIPS.
115
the public sector. With near doubling in the number of medical colleges over the
past 15 years, it would be interesting to see whether the human resource in the
form of medical college teachers has kept pace to fulfil the criteria of adequate
staffing norms of the MCI. Gross shortage of teachers promotes unhealthy
practices during inspections. The MCI is aware of these facts and has taken
important measures to minimize, if not eliminate, these unhealthy practices. It
has, however, not always been successful. Of the 260 medical colleges in
existence, 181 are recognized by the MCI and 79 are MCI permitted; 26 of these
260 colleges admit 50 students per year, 146 admit 50–100 students per year
and 88 admit >150 students per year. The total intake of medical students in
these colleges is 29 072 (20 842 in MCI recognized institutions and 8230 in MCI
permitted institutions). The annual student intake is a critical factor in assessing
the requirement for teachers for various subjects.
Photo: 4, The top most Medical institute of India- All India Institute of Medical
Sciences (AIIMS), New Delhi.
116
for 50 admissions, 90 for >50–100 admissions and 125 for 150 admissions per
year. This manpower requirement is only for the MB,BS course.
With these norms nearly 26 000 medical teachers are required to adequately
staff 260 colleges for the MB,BS course alone.
This number has been arrived at by multiplying the faculty required per college
based on student intake by the number of colleges with that intake of students
and summing up the total.
Using the existing norms, the total teacher requirement for different disciplines
for all medical colleges in India has been calculated (Table II). For the MB,BS
course alone, over 2000 teachers are required for Community Medicine,
General Medicine and General Surgery, 1600–2000 for Anatomy, Physiology,
Pathology and Anaesthesiology and 1000–1500 for Pharmacology, Paediatrics,
Orthopaedics, Obstetrics and Gynaecology and Radiodiagnosis.
However, teachers are required not only for undergraduate but also for
postgraduate courses. The available seats for postgraduates are highest for
Medicine and Surgery and progressively decline in the pre- and paraclinical
departments with the lowest intake in Forensic Medicine and Tuberculosis
and Respiratory Diseases. However, many seats in the pre- and paraclinical
departments remain unfilled for want of takers. Hence, the actual annual
numbers available after postgraduation in various specialties is likely to be only
about 75% of these numbers because of vacant seats, dropouts and attrition
due to Acute shortage of teachers in medical colleges: Existing problems and
possible solutions
Human resources for health(2004) :
The World Health Survey indicates 60 physicians, 135 nursing and
mid-wife and 245 other health related support staffs per 100,000
population in India.
• Medical training :
Asian centres just as good, No one can argue against the fact that exposure to
clinical material is far greater in third world countries than in the West. Medical
information now flows freely over the Internet and doctors now have myriad
ways of gaining access to ‘globalised’ knowledge, whatever that may mean.
Globalised medical practice is not synonymous with Western medical practice.
It is also somewhat patronising to insist that critical thinking skills are
accessible predominantly via Western training traditions.
They should remove their reflexive biases and examine the options of more
cost-effective centres with high standards that can be found in India, Taiwan
and even Thailand and the Philippines.
US healthcare statistics may say something about the quality of some of these
Asian medical schools. For example, in 2004 there were about 38,000
physicians of Indian origin practicing medicine in the US.
About 12,000 Indians and Indian-Americans are medical students and
residents (doctors in specialty training in teaching hospitals) across that
country. Indians make up roughly 20 percent of foreign-trained doctors in the
US and added to this number are Filipinos, Taiwanese, Pakistanis and other
Asians. UK stats may convey a similar message.
117
EXISTING PROBLEMS
1. Considering the large number of faculty required, there is an acute shortage
of teaching manpower in medical colleges both in the long standing and newly
started ones.
This shortage is in the region of 20%–25% in most departments and as high as
33% in some departments (based on personal observations and discussions).
The shortage is mainly attributable to non-availability of qualified personnel
willing to take up employment in medical colleges on the current terms and
conditions.
2. In addition to the existing vacancies, there is an annual decrement due to
superannuation, resignation, etc. of 10%–15% of the existing faculty strength. If
one matches the current shortfall in teacher strength in various departments to
the actual number of newly available qualified teachers
in that discipline, one can conclude that the current shortage in terms of annual
requirement of teachers in different disciplines is more than two-thirds in most
departments and is likely to increase by 10% every year due to superannuation
and other losses.
For example, the required number of anatomy teachers for undergraduate and
postgraduate courses is 1888. A 25% vacancy rate amounts to a shortage of
472 teachers. The actual number of teachers qualifying in anatomy per year is
about 170, which is 36% of the requirement. The shortfall at present is
therefore 64% on an annual basis. The shortage particularly affects faculty
posts at the senior level.
3. MCI norms require a 1:1 ratio to be maintained between students and
postgraduate teachers. This is excellent in an ideal situation. Unfortunately,
what it does is to create-
• Departments with more teachers at present will get more postgraduate seats
and more teachers for future.
• Departments with shortage of teachers at present will get less postgraduate
seats and less teachers for the future.
The current policy is therefore a vicious circle likely to lead to an increasing
shortage.
REFERENCES
1 List of MCI recognized and permitted colleges and list of postgraduate courses
and
colleges conducting them.
http://www.mciindia.org/apps/search/show_colleges.asp
2 Minimum qualifications for teachers in medical institutions, Regulations, 1998.
Medical Council of India, New Delhi.
3 Minimum standard requirements for the medical college–For 50 admissions
annually,
Regulations 1999. Medical Council of India, New Delhi.
4 Minimum standard requirements for the medical college–For 100 admissions
annually,
Regulations 1999. Medical Council of India, New Delhi.
118
5 Minimum standard requirements for the medical college–For 150 admissions
annually,
Regulations 1999. Medical Council of India, New Delhi.
119
• reform and reorientation of medical education;
• advocacy for equity, and social justice;
• the role played by WHO in highlighting the vital role of health in
development ; • the role played by WHO
in getting health on the Human Rights agenda;
• the role played by former WHO staff on their return to their own countries.
• the effect on national institutions of being designated as WHO Collaborating
Centres and working to develop approaches and tools for other countries to
use.
the new and dynamic relationships between WHO and its Member Countries,
working as partners in health development.
» Priority Projects
Polio Eradication
Rollback Malaria
AIDS
Tuberculosis
Women’s Health
» FUNCTIONS.
In order to achieve its objective, the functions of the Organization shall be:
120
• to stimulate and advance work to eradicate epidemic, endemic and other
diseases;
• to promote, in co-operation with other specialized agencies where
necessary, the prevention of accidental injuries;
• to promote in co-operation with other specialized agencies where
necessary, the improvement of nutrition, housing, sanitation, recreation,
economic or working conditions and other aspects of environmental
hygiene;
• to promote co-operation among scientific and professional groups which
contribute to the advancement of health;
• to promote co-operation among scientific and professional groups which
contribute to the advancement of health;
• to promote co-operation among scientific and professional groups which
contribute to the advancement of health;
• to propose conventions, agreements and regulations, and make
recommendations with respect to international health matters and to
perform such duties as may be assigned thereby to the Organization and
are consistent with its objective;
• to promote maternal and child health and welfare and to foster the ability
to live harmoniously in a changing total environment;
• to foster activities in the field of mental health, especially those affecting
the harmony of human relations;
• to promote and conduct research in the field of health;
• to promote improved standards of teaching and training in the health,
medical and related professions;
121
WHO has a crucial role to play in providing technical support to India in Human
Immuno Virus / Acquired Immuno Deficiency Syndrome (HIV/AIDS) prevention
and care.
The hazards of tobacco use have been proven and highlighted worldwide. Its
use has increasingly been reported among women and youth. In the South-East
Asia Region, tobacco poses tremendous health, economic and social challenges.
Protecting vulnerable groups such as women and children and reducing the
health and economic burden of tobacco use is a priority. WHO has, intensified
its advocacy with India for more stringent tobacco control measures.
122
In recognition of the substantial proportion of burden of disease and disability
related to reproductive health as well as prevailing high maternal mortality in
many countries of the Region, WHO identifies Reproductive Health with life
span perspective as a priority area with safe motherhood, family planning,
prevention and treatment of complications of abortion, Reproductive Tract
Infection /Sexually Transmitted Diseases (RTI/STD) and adolescent health as
essential interventions.
WHO is putting increased emphasis on prevention and control of non-
communicable diseases (NCDs).It is estimated, in 2006, about 3.7 million
deaths out of 11.8 million total deaths (45%) in SEAR countries were due to
NCDs.
UNICEF is one of the specialized agencies of the UN. It was established in 1946
by the UN to deal with rehabilitation of children in war-ravaged countries. In
South Central Asian Reagan which covers Afghanistan, India, Sri-Lanka, the
Maldives, Mongolia and Nepal. In the
early years, UNICEF and WHO worked together on urgent problems such as
malaria, tuberculosis and venereal diseases. Later, its assistance to countries
covered such fields as maternal & child health, nutrition, environmental
123
sanitation, health centers and health education and programs which would
directly or indirectly, benefit child health.
More recently, the tendency has been for UNICEF to turn away from campaigns
for the eradication of specific diseases unless they are of direct benefit to
mothers and children. Greater attention is been given to the concept of the
“whole child” meaning that assistance should henceforward be great not only to
health and nutrition, but also to their long term personnel development and to
the development of countries in which they live.
» CONTENTS OF SERVICES …
1. Child health-
- UNICEF has supported India’s BCG vaccination.
- Assisted in the erection of a penicillin plant
- UNICEF has also assisted environmental sanitation programs
emphasizing safe and sufficient water for drinking and household
use.
- Providing primary health care to mothers and children.
2. Child nutririon-
- aiding “applied nutrition” program in India.
- Encouraging the development of national food and nutrition policies
that make provotion for child health.
3. family and child Welfare-
-to improve the care children, both within and outside their homes
through such means as parent education, day-care centres, child welfare and
youth agencies and women’s club.
COMMUNICABLE DISEASE
Environmental and social factors impose severe constraints on two of the
communicable diseases, malaria and tuberculosis that pose a special threat.
India accounts for a third of global tuberculosis cases.
According to the available estimates about 2.2 million people are added each
year to the existing
load of 15 million active TB cases. Of these new cases, about 800,000 are
infectious and about
450,000 die (WHO, 2003). India has been identified as a hotspot for multi drug
resistant (MDR) tuberculosis, which is both difficult and expensive to treat.
The resurgence of malaria and tuberculosis indicates the difficulty to control or
treat along with the exponential rate of development of HIV/AIDS. It shows a
new sense of urgency for disease control.
The Government of India is seeking to reduce the burden of the most significant
endemic diseases through projects to control the spread of AIDS, leprosy,
cataract blindness, malaria and tuberculosis.
The Indian Ministry of Health and Family Welfare first tested this revised
approach through pilot projects in 15 rural and urban sites, curing more than
15,000 patients over a period of 16 months, with a very successful 80 percent
124
cure rate. Given the above background, the evidence from the World Health
Survey on coverage of communicable diseases is presented below.
TUBERCULOSIS AND HIV/AIDS
Tuberculosis and HIV/AIDS are the two most important communicable diseases
in India.
Tuberculosis, which is resurgent worldwide, is an infectious disease that affects
the lungs and other body tissues. Tuberculosis of the lungs, the most commonly
known form is characterized by coughing up mucus and sputum, fever, weight
loss and chest pain. The overall prevalence of
tuberculosis in India is 544 per 100,000 population (National Family Health
Survey, II). This is 16 percent higher than the prevalence recorded in NFHS-I
(467 per 100,000) indicating that
tuberculosis may be on the rise in India. The prevalence of tuberculosis is much
higher in rural
areas (600 per 100,000 population) than in urban areas (390 per 100,000
population). The prevalence rate is also much higher for males (624 per
100,000 population) than females (460 per 100,000). In India, six percent of
respondents in ages 18-49 have reported that they are using condoms.
The highest proportion of respondents using condoms is in Assam and Uttar
Pradesh with about 10
percent each and Karnataka shows the lowest two percent of respondents using
condoms.
About seven percent of males and six percent of females reported using
condoms. The use of
condoms is higher in urban areas (10 percent) compared to rural areas (six
percent). About 13
percent of insured respondents are using condoms compared to six percent
among the uninsured. Use of condoms is three times higher among the
respondents in the highest income quintile (12
percent) compared to respondents in the lowest income quintile (three
percent).
MALARIA AND DIARRHOEA
Table 5.3 presents the percent of children with a reported episode of malaria
and its treatment in the last one year in India. Also, information on the
prevalence of diarrhoea is collected. The
information on both the illness is collected from the respondents who have
children less than five years of age. About six percent of children had an
episode of malaria in India during the five years prior to the survey. Of them, 93
percent of children were treated. Rajasthan, the state with highest prevalence
of TB also has the highest prevalence of malaria followed by Maharashtra (six
percent). The lowest (less than one percent) prevalence of malaria is reported
in Karnataka. Ninety four percent of male children and 91 percent female
children with malaria received treatment. Significant urban rural difference is
observed in terms of treatment of malaria is concerned. Sixty five percent of
insured and 93 percent of uninsured received treatment for malaria. The
proportion treated for malaria declines slightly with increasing income. The
reported prevalence of diarrhoea is 30 percent in the last one year for child
under 5 years in India with the highest prevalence in Rajasthan and the lowest
125
in Assam. The prevalence of diarrhoea is higher in rural (31 percent) compared
to urban areas (23 percent). Prevalence of diarrhoea is 19 percent among the
insured compared to 30 percent among the uninsured. The proportion of
children reported with an episode of diarrhoea also declines with increasing
income.
MATERNAL AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
Improving maternal and reproductive health has been a major thrust of the
1994 International
Conference on Population and Development Conference in Cairo. All the
countries of the
developing world initiated programmes to promote reproductive health status
of women.
The Government of India took certain steps to strengthen maternal and child
health in the first
(1951-55), second (1956-60) and fifth (1974-78) five year plans.
Several programmes have been implemented for better maternal and child
health. With regard to maternal and reproductive health, the government
programmes seek to integrate maternal health, child health, and fertility
regulation interventions with reproductive health programmes for both men and
women. The coverage with respect to maternal and child health care are
presented in the following sections.
SCREENING OF WOMEN FOR CANCER
Cancer of the cervix is the second most common cancer among women
worldwide, with about
500,000 new cases diagnosed and 250,000 deaths each year (WHO, 2004).
Almost 80 percent of
the cases occur in developing countries; in many developing regions cervical
cancer is the most
common cancer in women. The only available treatments for the disease are
surgery and
radiotherapy, and these are not accessible to the most affected women in
developing countries. The primary approach to control cervical cancer is
therefore through prevention (WHO, 2004).
Cervical cancer takes many years to develop, and changes can be detected in
the cervix some
time before the appearance of cancer. In principle, screening of women for
these changes can
allow treatment of these with early signs of developing disease, preventing the
development
of cancer.
Screening programmes have been in operation in most developed countries for
a number of years. While in some of these countries there have been significant
reductions in the incidence of invasive cancer, overall the impact has often
been less than expected. In middle income countries, the success of screening
programmes has generally been even more limited.
In urban areas, 25 % of women reported having had cervical cancer screening
and nine percent of women had breast cancer screening. Compared to this,
fifteen percent and four percent of women in rural areas have had cervical and
126
breast cancer screening The proportion of women screened for cervical and
breast cancer increases with income.
MATERNAL AND CHILD HEALTH
Questions were asked to women in the ages 18-49 about maternal health care
services availed for
births during the five years prior to the survey. Of the total 1452 women who
gave birth in the last five years, 48 percent had received full antenatal care and
34 percent had received care at the time of delivery. Amongst the states, full
antenatal coverage (66 percent) and care for delivery (46 percent) are highest
in Maharashtra.
Sixty-two percent of insured women and 34 percent of uninsured women
received delivery care.
The proportion of women receiving care at the time of delivery is about three
times and antenatal
care is more than two times higher in the highest income quintile compared to
the lowest income
quintile. Mother’s education shows strong positive relation with antenatal and
delivery care. About 85 percent of mothers with high school or higher level of
schooling received antenatal care compared to just 30 percent of women with
no formal schooling. COVERAGE FOR CHILD
HEALTH CARE
The coverage of three doses of DPT and measles immunization corresponds to
children less than 5
years in the household. Overall, 43 percent of children received DPT
immunization and 32
percent of children received measles immunisation.
Among the states, Karnataka has the highest coverage for DPT3 (59 %) and
measles immunisation (55 percent) followed by Maharashtra with 50 and 45
percent respectively. The reported coverage of DPT3 immunisation is the lowest
24 percent in West Bengal. Also, Assam (16 percent) and West Bengal (17
percent) have shown the lowest coverage of measles immunisation. About 40
percent of female children received three doses of DPT compared to 46 percent
of male children, indicating a gender gap unfavourable to female children.
Coverage of measles immunisation does not vary much between sexes.
The proportion of children receiving both DPT3 and measles immunisation
increases
with mothers education. The information on child immunisation was collected
only from respondents who could show the immunization card.
NON-COMMUNICABLE DISEASES
The burden from non-communicable diseases in developed countries remains
stable at over 80
percent in adults aged 15 years and over, the proportion in middle-income
countries has already
exceeded 70 percent.
Almost 50 percent of the adult disease burden in the high mortality regions of
the world is now attributable to non-communicable diseases. Population ageing
and changes in the distribution of risk factors have accelerated the incidence of
non-communicable disease in many developing countries.
127
ANGINA, ARTHRITIS, ASTHMA, DIABETES, DEPRESSION AND PSYCHOSIS
The World Health Survey gathered data on need and coverage of non-
communicable diseases such
as angina, arthritis, asthma, diabetes, depression and psychosis in India. The
need refers to
population diagnosed with morbidity and coverage refers to population treated
for the morbidity. The reference period in the analysis for noncommunicable
diseases is one year prior to the survey.
The reported prevalence of asthma (seven percent) and psychosis (four
percent) are highest in
Rajasthan. Except psychosis, the reported prevalence of all the above non-
communicable
diseases is the lowest in Assam.
A greater proportion of females have been diagnosed and treated for arthritis.
There is no significant gender difference within diagnosed cases for major non-
communicable diseases except angina. However, the percentage of treatment
for angina and asthma are higher among males, whereas treatment for
depression, psychosis and arthritis is higher for females.
The proportion of respondents diagnosed with arthritis, asthma and diabetes is
higher among the
insured compared to uninsured respondents. Prevalence of depression is
highest among the
uninsured respondents. However, a higher percent of insured respondents have
been treated for all the non-communicable diseases except psychosis.
The proportions diagnosed with depression, psychosis, angina, arthritis and
asthma and are
inversely related to income and that of diabetes is positively related to income.
But, the diagnosed
cases of depression are high in the higher income quintile (Q4) compared to
lowest income quintile.
COVERAGE FOR VISION CARE
Cataract is a disease in which the lenses of the eyes become cloudy and
opaque, causing partial or total blindness. If the cataracts become too thick, the
eye lenses can usually be removed with laser surgery and replaced with clear,
plastic lenses. The coverage module of the World Health survey asked the
persons above ages 60 if they had cataracts in their eyes and if they had any
access to appropriate medical treatment during the one year prior to the
survey.
Questions were asked to the respondents to determine whether the
respondents were
diagnosed by a physician or other health professionals in the last five years as
having cataracts
in one or both the eyes, and if they had the cataracts removed.
The proportion of respondents diagnosed with cataract is 31 percent in urban
areas compared to
15 percent in rural areas. There is not much variation between the insured and
uninsured respondents in terms of cataract diagnosis. Among the insured, 66
percent had cataract surgery
128
compared to 52 percent among the uninsured. Both the proportions diagnosed
and treated for
cataract are higher in the higher income quintiles compared to the lower
income quintiles.
India is an under developed country and 50% of the population live in urban
areas in an extremely below the poverty condition. As they are lured by
massive industrialization, economic and educational opportunities in cities like
Chennai, Mumbai, Kolkatta and Delhi are over crowed and the statistics says
about one fifth live in slums Most of the health problems in India are generated
from these slums only.
Drainage system is poor in Chennai, Kolkatta and Mumbai which cause high
incidence of infections disease and epidemics. High densities of dwellings and
lack of internal roads cause poor accessibility for emergency and life saving
services. New squatter settlements come up on the periphery often on
inhabitable lands because of their low values and cause environmental hazards.
In the recent Bhopal gas tragedy, around 3000 persons mostly from the
peripheral slums were killed and it clearly revealed the vulnerability of
squatters.
Central council of health was formed as per the constitution to check all health
problems in India. Health survey and Development Committee was the first
committee to be formed in India which laid foundations for several activities in
all five year plans to attend to all health problems attaching the millions in
India.
The ministry of health and family welfare is handled by secretary of the govt. of
India. He is directed by the cabinet minister of state or by his deputy. The
ministry is concerned with 1) maintenance of international health relations with
other countries of the world and coordination among them 2) adoption of family
welfare measures concerning population stabilization and family planning.
129
Photo: 7, Smoking prevention program Photo: 8, Patient consultancy with
a doctor
At the District level we have the District health office that is in charge of all
activities concerning medical, public health and family welfare and district
health administration. To lay more importance to family welfare programmes, a
separate family welfare officer has been appointed.
In urban areas we have local self governing bodies having three tier
administrations.
Among the major public health programmes, the Maternal and Child Health
Services constitute an integral part of the family welfare programmes and
occupy an important place in the socio economic development planning. It also
plays a crucial role in human resource development and in improving the
quality of life of the people. The Government has sponsored immunization
schemes for infants and children against nutritional anemia among mothers
and children and prophylaxis against blindness due to vitamin ‘A’ deficiency are
also in operation. Programme for oral rehydration therapy is another important
child survival scheme. Diarrhea disease is a major health problem in India
especially among children below five years of age.
130
1978. The objectives of the programme are to reduce morbidity and mortality
due to diphtheria, pertussis and tetanus, poliomyelitis, tuberculosis and typhoid
fever by making vaccination services available to all eligible children and
pregnant women.
Urban Malaria Scheme was initiated in November 1971. The main objective of
the scheme is to control malaria transmission by eliminating aquatic stages of
vector mosquitoes by weekly application of larvicides in breeding sources. The
scheme has at present been sanctioned for 133 towns distributed over 17
states and two Union Territories.
National Filarial Control programme was taken up in urban areas from 1955 in
order to contain the diseases. Anti-larval and antiparasitic measures are being
taken in 199 towns distributed in 13 states and four Union Territories.
Leprosy control programme has been in operation since 1955 but it was only
after 1980 that it received a high priority and it was redesigned as National
Leprosy Eradication Programme (NLEP) in 1983 with the goal of arresting the
disease in all known leprosy patients by the year 2000.
131
coordinate all activities pertaining to AIDS control. At present, 40 surveillance
centers and four referral centers are available in the country.
Apart from the above national health programmes, there are programmes like,
National Programme for Control of Blindness, National Mental Health
Programme, Sexually – Transmitted Diseases Programmes and National Goiter
Control Programme.
Overcrowding, poor housing, choked drains, high density of insects and rodents,
lack of garbage disposal facilities, poor personal hygiene, and hygienic
conditions are hall marks of urban slums in India. Unplanned and rapid
urbanization put a strain on the already dwindling civic amenities. Under such
conditions gastroenteritis and other infectious diseases are rampant. Children
affected by serious diarrhea diseases are likely to spend 20 percent of their first
two years of life suffering from serious diarrhea with a median number of 4.9
episodes per child per year. Studies from urban slums of Ludhiana show that
children under two years of age had 3.8 episodes of diarrhea per year.
Health Care System in India in the last 45 years has focused on increasing
coverage in the rural areas. There has been little or no development of
organized health care services for the vast urban areas. The 3,600 odd cities
and towns of India with some 40 million people living in slums have to depend
largely on private practitioners (mostly quacks) for their health care needs. Out
of the 3,000 plus urban local bodies in India only about 100 have been some
semblance to a health care service while the rest have only a sanitary inspector
or even a lower functionary to look after the health care system.
Slums vary greatly from each other. But the universal characteristics refer to
overcrowding and congestion, extremely poor sanitation, lack of civic amenities
and deviant behavior. It is reported that in Delhi slums, 400,000 people live on
one square mile. In Bombay it is common for ten persons to live in a room-ten
132
by fifteen feet. However, slum cannot be defined only by housing. In India,
temporary structures raised with the use of material such as rags, plastic
pieces, rusted pieces of iron, pieces of canvass cloth, and places where there is
almost total absence of tap water, latrines and roads are identified as slums.
There may be very high density of population per square mile but if people are
staying in multi-storied permanent structures sharing inadequate civic and
sanitary facilities, these are not popularly identified as slums. Slums culture is
marked by apathy, insecurity, social isolation and disease.
In India, more than nine million people live in slums of which 12,50,000 are in
Bombay, 11,00,000 in Calcutta, 9,00,000 in Madras and 7,00,000 are in Delhi. It
is no wonder that slum dwellers should be the victims of air—borne and water-
borne infections, and should suffer from nutritional deficiencies as also from
undiagnosed mental illness. The disorganizations in various aspects of life
breed apathy and psychology of defeat which is manifested in fatalism, crime or
lack of enthusiasm about preventive aspects of health, although offered free of
charge.
Urban areas continued to develop being the seats of power, money and
intellect. They also became the first places to experiment with ideas. As a
result, various agencies of health representing municipal, provincial and
national levels developed simultaneously with voluntary, private and
philanthropic institutions. However, curative aspect got precedence over
preventive and promotional aspects. Health care system continues to veer
around doctors, drugs and patients. Piped water supply and modern sanitation
also developed but in selected urban localities. However, the water supply is
almost always intermittent, and in most of the cities / towns drainage often gets
clogged for one reason or another.
133
It is not uncommon to see medical colleges and hospitals belonging to various
medical systems such as modern, ayurveda and homeopathy in one Indian city.
India provides an excellent example of medical pluralism. People follow home
remedies, spiritual remedies and treatment from various medical systems
simultaneously or one after another. Metropolitan urban areas provide medical
facilities which are available in developing countries such as cardiac surgery,
treatment of all kids of cancers, or in brief, for the diseases which are
associated with affluence. The major diseases identified in South – East Asia
Region under WHO are malaria, filarial and other mosquito – borne diseases,
diarrhea diseases, leprosy, tuberculosis, sexually transmitted diseases,
poliomyelitis and other children diseases, tetanus, nasopharyngeal and cervical
cancers, visual impairment and blindness, etc.
It is often said that a large proportion of population suffers from protein calorie
malnutrition. However, the range of nutrition in which people can function
efficiently without getting nutritional deficiencies is wide and what are
commonly given as recommended quantities for intake of nutrients are much
higher than what are required.
Urban poor are unfortunately use bottle feeding and baby feeds under the
influence of commercial advertising on radio, television, and through other
popular media like films.The revolution in drugs coincided with freedom from
colonial rule. The drug industry has developed out of proportion in comparison
with basic amenities like potable water and sanitation.
Primary health care is available to the whole population, with at least the
following:
134
- Safe water in the home or within 15 minutes walking distance, and adequate
sanitary facilities, in the home or immediate vicinity;
- Trained personnel for attending pregnancy and child-birth, and caring for
children up to at least one year of age.
- At least 90 per cent of new born infants have a birth weight of at least 2000
gm;
135
risk for HIV infection prior to any possible engagement in HIV prevention
efforts.
International cooperation to accelerate sustainable development in
developing countries and related domestic policies :
• Combating poverty
• Changing consumption patterns
• Demographic dynamics and sustainability
• Protecting and promoting human health
• Promoting sustainable human settlement development
• Protection of the atmosphere
• Integrated approach to the planning and management of land resources
• Combating deforestation
• Managing fragile ecosystems: combating desertification and drought
• Promoting sustainable agriculture and rural development
• Conservation of biological diversity
• Protection of the quality and supply of freshwater resources: application of
integrated approaches to the development, management and use of water
resources
• National mechanisms and international cooperation
• Promoting education, public awareness and training
» Article Source: http://EzineArticles.com/
• The population density is 363 persons per sq. km., population density
is much higher than other developing countries.
• Morbidity rate is higher than other developing countries.
• Literacy rate is approx. 75 % estimated at the end of 2008, it is lower
than other developing countries.
• Birth rate is 22.22 births/1,000 population (2008 est.), stands 87th
rank in world, is higher than other developing countries.
• Infant mortality rate is 56 deaths per 1,000 live births, is much higher
than other developing countries.
• Life expectancy(average) is for Males- 62 yrs and for Female- 64 yrs,
is lower than other developing countries.
• Fertility rate in India is 3.1, is quite high than other developing
countries.
• Very high external and internal migration.
136
Analysis of morbidity and mortality of population :
• Morbidity at all groups of diseases is decreased except AIDS (HIV inf.) and
tuberculosis.
• Indirect estimates suggest that 272,000 South Asians died from AIDS in
2004. This study will be the first to provide direct evidence of AIDS
mortality in India.
• About one in two male tuberculosis deaths and one in four of all male
deaths in India may be attributable to smoking.
• Anemia, trauma following severe bleeding and ischemic heart disease give
high risk of mortality in hospitals.
• Rare causes of death are food poisoning and ulcer diseases.
• Mortality from all diseases is decreased except infant mortality due to
anemia.
• One in five of the world’s child deaths occurs in India, i.e. over 2 million
deaths every year.
• Childbirth is still a leading cause of death for women in India: more than
100,000 women are estimated to die each year from causes related to
pregnancy.
137
The Government of India has adopted various schemes and programs for
accelerating the rate of economic growth, eradication of rural poverty
through wage employment and self-employment, redistribution of land
and security of land tenures, enhanced purview for Minimum Needs
Program, protection of minorities and availability of opportunity for socio-
economic uplift, and infrastructural development for uplift of urban poor.
India has a three pronged strategy for poverty eradication:
i) Economic growth and overall development;
ii) Human development with emphasis on health, education and minimum
needs, including protection of human rights and raising the social status
of the weak and the poor; and
iii) Directly targeted programs for poverty alleviation through
employment generation, training and building up asset endowment of the
poor.
» The Government of India has so many good policies and these policies are
issued on time when needed but those do not work properly and sufficiently
because the fast growing population and illiteracy fails them.
» Public Health Services in India are depending on some factors like Politics;
economical conditions; quantity and quality of medical personnel’s; fast
growing population; literacy; regional conflicts; tragedies like flood,
earthquake, tsunami etc.
• Political condition is very bad in India, I don’t know why?, may be it
due to some mistakes in Our Respective Constitution or may be due to
nature of our politicians. So, on respective to political conditions,
public health services face major problems like not get proper money
at time or not issue at due date.
• Economical condition of our country is not well too because fast
growing population and morbidity pull back it.
• Quantity and quality of medical personnel’s is low here because lack
of medical colleges again due to fast growing population.
• Literacy is low again due to fast growing population and lack of
schools.
• Regional conflicts in Jammu and Kashmir or any other part of country
stops its development and proceeds towards poverty.
• Tragedies like flood, earthquake, tsunami etc. also disturbs our
development.
Suggestions :
• At first we have to control the ultimate cause of all withdraws i.e. Fast
growing population. For this, need people should be literate and
government should advertise the methods of contraception and
methods of family planning. In India medical termination of pregnancy
138
is prohibitory, so government should allow the safe medical
termination of pregnancy on parent’s will.
• Need to increase the quantity of primary and secondary schools,
colleges, medical institutions and universities.
• For controlling the infant mortality and abnormality, there should be
some aims :
Primary aims
To identify children with growth deviation i.e., under nutrition and
over nutrition and to identify diseases and conditions that manifest
through abnormal growth. Secondary aims
1. To discuss health promotion related to feeding, hygiene,
immunization and other aspects of the child’s health and behavior;
education of parents to allay their anxiety about their child’s
growth.
2. To sensitize pediatricians to use growth charts.
• For controlling morbidity at HIV infection and Tuberculosis, need to
advertise in public the prevention and prophylaxis measures.
• For controlling morbidity at other diseases need to improve sanitary
conditions and utilize the full support of WHO. Need some of the
Programs like: National Malaria Eradication Program, national
Tuberculosis Control Program, national AIDS Control Program,
national Blindness Control Program.
• There is need to strengthening of rural health infrastructure through
provision of buildings, equipment drugs and vaccines and training of
all levels of Personnel.
• For facing the ‘’Brain-drain problems’’, need to control the external
profession and student migration. For this, have to open the
opportunities inside the country.
• For decreasing maternal mortality and increasing safe delivery,
need to increase the number and improve the conditions of ladies
doctors and nurses.
• Full sanitary and hygienic control of all communities, food products,
drinking water and well canalization system can decrease the
epidemics and morbidity.
• We can’t stop the tragedies like flood, earthquake, tsunami but for
facing them we should prepare well always with extra med
personnel’s, drugs and other objects.
• I don’t know what should do with our political conditions but at least
need to elect well literate and active politician who can understand
and solve these problems.
XI. CONCLUSIONS
139
This report has reviewed the different ways public health, the Indian healthcare
sector can be viewed as a glass half empty or a glass half full. The challenges
the sector faces are substantial, from the need to improve physical
infrastructure to the necessity of providing health insurance and ensuring the
availability of trained medical personnel.But the opportunities are equally
compelling, from developing new infrastructure and providing medical
equipment to delivering telemedicine solutions and conducting cost-effective
clinical trials. For companies that view the Indian health care sector as a glass
half full, the potential is enormous.
India is one of the leading developing countries, the term “developing
countries” encompasses very different countries, which experience different
levels of economic development and disease burdens. In order to design
solutions that have relevance in different national and local settings, relevant
macroeconomic and institutional features need to be taken into account.
At present, one sees a greater political will to address public health needs via
the National Rural Health Mission. This affords a good opportunity to innovate
and experiment with a restructured healthcare system, but such restructuring
will be possible only if certain conditions are met:
• The healthcare system, both public and private, is organized under a common
framework.
• The financing mechanism of healthcare is pooled and coordinated by some
single-payer system.
• Access to healthcare is organized under a common system which everyone is
able to access without any barriers.
• The providers of healthcare services have reasonable autonomy in managing
the provision of services.
• The decision-making and planning of health services is decentralized within a
local governance framework.
• The healthcare system is subject to continuous public/community monitoring
and social audit, under a regulatory mechanism geared to ensuring the
accountability of all the stakeholders involved.
All resources, financial and human, must be transferred to the district level
governments that will need to work out detailed district plans based on local
needs and aspirations. An appropriate regulatory and accreditation mechanism
must be put in place to facilitate the inclusion of the private health sector.
Private health services, both ambulatory and hospital, must be contracted in on
appropriate terms. Detailed bottom-up planning must be undertaken with
regard to budgeting and the allocation of resources appropriately to different
institutions and providers. Finally, all stakeholders must be trained to
understand and become part of this restructuring process.
Public healthcare services should be organized and regulated, using both public
and private resources, for social benefit. Furthermore, the delivery of healthcare
should be decentralized at
an appropriate community level rather than (as at present) planned at the
central or state level. The role of the centre and the state should be to
formulate strategies, mobilize and disburse resources, and monitor outcomes.
Such is the global experience where healthcare is universally accessible with
equity. Why should it be different in India?
140
So, we should follow the steps of the public health systems of developed
countries and make the complete command on services of healthcare system,
population, poverty, maternal health, medicine distribution, fatal diseases like
AIDS, TB, malaria, plague and leprosy. India's government must open more
public medical schools. These steps bring the country in a new era of
development.
XII. BIBLIOGRAPHY :
141
19.A. Sen, “Social Exclusion: Concept, Application, and Scrutiny,” Social
Development Papers No. 1 (Office of Environment and Social
Development, Asian Development Bank, 2000);
20.S. Thorat, A. Negi, and P. Negi, Reservation and Private Sector: Quest for
Equal Opportunity and Growth (Jaipur, India: Rawat, 2004).
21. http://www.ifpri.org/2020Chinaconference/pdf/beijingbrief_thorat.pdf
22. India, Census of India 2001 : Provisional Population totals, March 2001.
23. India, Sample Registration System, Statistical Report 1998, October
2002.
24. India, Sample Registration System, SRS Bulletin, April 2007.
25. India, National Family Health Survey (NFHS-2), 1998-99, October 2002.
26. India, Health Information of India 1998 & 1999, July 2002.
27. Adapted from “WHO Geneva, The World Health Report 2001 : Mental
Health, New Understanding, New Hope”, October 2001.
28.India, Press briefing by the Minister of Health, 23 October 2007.
29. India, Sample Registration System, SRS Bulletin, April 2004.
30. Darmstadt GL, Lawn JE, Costello A. (2003) Advancing the state of the
world’s newborns. Bulletin of theWorld Health Organization.:81:224-225.
31. Saving Newborn Lives. (2001) State of the World's Newborns. 1-44.
Washington DC, Available at
http://www.savethechildren.org/publications/newborns_report.pdf
142
41. Darmstadt GL, Lawn JE, Costello A. (2003) Advancing the state of the
world’s newborns. Bulletin of theWorld Health Organization.:81:224-225.
46. Lawn JE. Cousens SN et al. (March 2005) Lancet neonatal series. Paper 1.
49.Yinger NY, Ransom EI. (2003) Why invest in newborn health? Policy
perspectives in Newborn Health. Washington DC: Save the Children and
Population Reference Bureau.
50. http://www.personal.psu.edu/~saj169/MyWebpage/index.htm.
143