Case 1:09-cv-00752-HTW Document 11-6 Filed 05/04/09 Page 1 of 7

Invoice Number Invoice Date

Dates Services Rendered

Specific Dates

Discrepancies Noted in Review of Sample of Invoices Original Non-Original Code for # in 4th and 5th Columns: Category 1: Deleted tasks but did not reduce hours substantially or at all Category #2: Included a task defending against Murtaghs claims or edited out such a task originally entered, but did not reduce hours at all or reduce them substantially Category #3a: Invoices with different numbers but many of the same entries Category #3b: Invoices with identical invoice numbers, but substantially different entries

1851357

3/31/07

Through 2/28/07 2/01/07 LAD #1 2/8/07 LAD #1 2/8/07 RPS #1 2/8/07 TDW #1 2/9/07 No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted outline issues for additional discovery we may want to pursue to establish damages) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted research on attorneys fees; nominal damages; and punitive damages) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review Emory e-mail filter account for relevant e-mails) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review new Internet postings) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted research

Case 1:09-cv-00752-HTW Document 11-6 Filed 05/04/09 Page 2 of 7

LAD #1 2/9/07 LCE #1

2/13/07 LAD #1 2/15/09 LCE #1

on nominal damages and punitive damages; research on republication of defamatory statements) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted Conduct internet investigation to identify whether Dr. Murtagh has made any recent postings on the Internet that would constitute a violation of the settlement agreement and telephone conference with T. Eichelberger regarding Duke Naiphons affidavit) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review witness files of Nancy Ellis, Leigh Strong, and Duke Naipohn in preparation for witness interviews) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted conference with Patuntas, Inc., to begin identifying source of disparaging postings.. and conduct online internet research to determine whether Plaintiff has posted any disparaging or defamatory comments. and witness interviews No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted compile summary of evidence supporting Emorys counterclaims) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted meet with L. Edelmann motion for summary judgment) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted examine various pleadings filed in state court and arbitration, draft section on Dr. Murtaghs misrepresentation of fact, false testimony, and use of spoiled evidence in his six pro se motions.. No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted finalize chart of Dr. Murtaghs perjured testimony) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review

1869508

4/26/07

Through 3/31/07 3/5/07 LCE #1 3/12/07 TDW #1 3/14/07 LCE #1

1887194

5/14/07

Through

3/29/07 LCE #1 4/3/07

Case 1:09-cv-00752-HTW Document 11-6 Filed 05/04/09 Page 3 of 7

4/30/07

LCE #1 4/4/07 TDW #1 4/10/07 LCE #1 4/12/07 TDW #1 4/16/07 LCE #1 4/22/07 LCE #1 4/24/07 TDW #1 5/11/07 LCE #1 5/14/07 TDW #1 5/15/07 LCE #1

New Criminologist archives to determine if Dr. Murtagh has made recent defamatory statements and to link Dr. Murtagh to additional postings) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted revise letter to R. Bard regarding . and review agenda for May Semmeilweiss program..... and review and revise letter to R. Bard.. No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review internet research to identify any recent defamatory or disparaging postings.) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review correspondence with J. Breen regarding Fowler e-mails and other document productions for spoliation proof issues. No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted research on the consultant/professional advisor privilege under Georgia state law) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted perform internet research to determine if Dr. Murtagh has many any new disparaging postings.) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review select e-mails caught by Emory e-mail filters) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted set up survelliance of Dr. Murtagh during WA Whistleblower week and telephone conference with M. Hallas regarding Sundays events and her responsibilities relating to same etc) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted meet with L. Edelmann regarding coverage for Whistleblower week) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted telephone conference with L. Watson regarding Dr. Murtaghs activities during WA Whistleblower week and analyze internet postings on websites.

Case 1:09-cv-00752-HTW Document 11-6 Filed 05/04/09 Page 4 of 7

5/16/07 LCE #1 5/17/07 LCE #1 5/22/07 TDW #1 5/24/07 LCE #1 1957981 8/28/07 Through 7/31/07 7/24/07 LCE #1 7/31/07 LCE #1 1831298 2/8/07 RPS #2 2/8/07 TDW #2 2/2/07 LCE #2 2/15/07 LCE #2

No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted telephone conference with L. Watson. No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted telephone conference with L. Watson..... and review L. Watsons memorandum regarding same. No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review memorandum regarding whistleblowers week) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted conduct Internet research to identify any potentially disparaging postings by Dr. Murtagh on the Internet) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted prepare chart of evidence in support of Emorys counterclaims) No reduction in hours but a reduction in tasks (omitted review Georgias abusive litigation statute and draft abusive litigation letter to C. Culotta) #2s: Defendant defending against Plaintiffs claims #2

#2

#2

1851357

#2

Case 1:09-cv-00752-HTW Document 11-6 Filed 05/04/09 Page 5 of 7

1869508

2/16/07 RPS #2 2/16/07 TDW #2 2/20/07 TDW #2 2/21/07 LCE #2 2/27/07 LAD #2 3/2/07 RPS #2 3/2/07 TDW #2 3/3/07 LCE #2 3/3/07 TDW #2 3/4/07 LAD #2 3/5/07 TDW #2

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

Case 1:09-cv-00752-HTW Document 11-6 Filed 05/04/09 Page 6 of 7

3/5/07 LCE #2 3/6//07 LCE #2 3/6/07 TDW #2 3/7/07 TDW #2 3/12/07 LCE #2 1997523 and 2007118 Invoice #: 1997523 Invoice #: 1997523 Invoice #: 1997523 Original

#2

#2

#2

#2

#2

Billing Date: 10/19/07 11 pages Total billing = $85,423.19 Billing runs from 10/1/0710/18/07

Billing Date: 10/19/07 11 pages Total billing = $85,423.19 Billing runs from 10/1/0710/18/07

Billing date: 10/19/07 12 pages Total billing = $85,423.19 Billing runs from 10/1/0710/18/07

#3a and #3b: Identical invoice numbers but different content and dollar amounts, and same invoice numbers with different content Invoice #: Invoice #: 2007118: Invoice #: 2007118: 2007118: Nonoriginal: Exhibit (Exhibit B-April Original B14 ( Exhibit D2008 Arbit.) September 2008 Arbit.) Billing Date: Billing Date: Billing Date: 11/6/07 11/6/07 11/6/07 16 pages Total billing = $101,239.38 10 pages Total billing = $72,271.50 4 pages Total billing = $12,880.61 Billings runs from 10/19/07-10/31/07

Billing runs from Billing runs from 10/1/07-10/31/07 10/1/07-10/26/07

Case 1:09-cv-00752-HTW Document 11-6 Filed 05/04/09 Page 7 of 7

Invoice submitted to Sup. Court (1017-07)

Invoice submitted to Arb (4-2908)

Invoice Submitted to Arb (9-14-08)

Invoice Submitted to Arb (4-29-08)

#3a: Different invoice numbers but many identical entries ) Invoice #: 285697 Original and Nonoriginal Invoice Date: 8/16/04 Services rendered through: 7/31/04

Invoice #289498 Invoice Date: 9/30/04 Services rendered through 6/27/047/30/04 Non-original Bill: $8,835.39 Original Bill: $8,845.49 Case: Henninger v. John Doe Matter #: 126005

Original Bill: $8,870.20 Nonoriginal Bill: $8,870.90

Case: Henniger v. John Doe

Matter #: 126005