Registeredon:07012008 Registeredon:07012008 Decidedon :13122010 Duration:Ys.Ms.Ds.

2116

EXHIBITNO.______ INTHECOURTOFCHIEFJUDICIALMAGISTRATE, BHANDARA. (PRESIDEDOVERBYDR.S.R.JAISWAL)

PH.D.(LAW)

REGULARCRIMINALCOMPLAINTCASENO.4/2008

Ku.Pragatid/oGhanshamGajbhiye, Agedabout22years,Occ.Education, R/oAmbedkarWard,Warathi, Tah.Dist.Bhandara. ...VERSIS... 1) 2) 3) 4) Sau.Damayantiw/oDayalBansod, Agedabout50years,Occ.Household, ShriKumars/oDayalBansod, Agedabout23years,Occ.Business, ShriSachins/oDayalBansod, Agedabout28years,Occ.Business, Ku.Yogitad/oDayalBansod, Agedabout27years,Occ.Household, .. Complainant

AllR/oAmbedkarWard,Warathi, Tah.Dist.Bhandara.

..Accused ..2.

OFFENCEPUNISHABLEUNDERSECTION323,354,34OFTHEINDIAN PENALCODE. Mr.A.P.Singh,AssistantPoliceProsecutorappearedfortheState. Mr.Saxena,Advocatefortheaccused.

JUDGMENT (DELIVEREDONTHIS13THDECEMBER,2010)

1.

Theaccusedarefacingchargefortheoffencepunishableunder

Section323,354,r/w34oftheIndianPenalCode.

2.

Thebrieffactsoftheprosecutioncasearethatthecomplainant

Ku.Pragatid/oGhanshamGajbhiyehasfiledcomplaintallegingthatthe accusedno.1to5areherneighbourersandthecomplainantislearningin B.A.IstyearatWarathi.On9/12/2007atabout4.00P.M.thecomplainant cameoutfromherhousetothrowthewastewateroutofherhouse,atthat timeaccusedno.2hasthrownwastematerialonherpersonandtherebythe complainanthasthrownwastewaterthere,thereforehusbandofaccused

no.2hasabusedherinfilthylanguageandthreatenedthathewillsenther injailandhewillsetheronfire.Theaccusedno.2hasalsoabusedherby sayingngk uojs djh jkaMhu vkgsl] ngk yksdkalkscr >ksirsl o rq uaxh] HkkslGh] dq=h] ukyk;dh vkgsl andstarted

..3..R.Cri.C.No.4/08(Judgment)

beatingheronhershoulderandotherpartsofbody.Thenaccusedno.3 camethereandhehasbeatenheronherchestandtornherclothes.Then accused no.4 came there and beaten to the complainant. At that time UjwalaBharatGajbhiye,NitaManishGajbhiye,RituWasnikandPranali Wasnikcamethere. Atabout5.00P.M.Thecomplainant withhersister Ku.Barlin went to Outpost Warathi for file complaint but police have refusedtoacceptthecomplainant,thereforeshewenttoP.St.Bhandaraand filedcomplaint.Policehavereferredherformedicalcheckupandpolice haveregisteredtheoffenceasN.C.No.746/2007underSection323,506of IndianPenalCode.Thereforethiscomplaintwasfiledbythecomplainant.

3.

Afterverificationofthecomplaint,mylearnedpredecessorhas

issuedprocessunderSection323,452r/w34oftheIndianPenalCode asperorderdated22/01/2009.

4.

AsperorderbelowExh.1dated15/06/2010afterrecordingof

examinationinchiefofcomplainantandhearingbeforechargewastaken,I hadpassedanordertoframethechargeunderSection323,354r/w34of theIndianPenalCode.AccordinglychargewasframedbymeatExh.57 dated15thJune2010.Afterframingofchargethecontentsof

..4..

thechargewerereadovertotheaccusedinMarathilanguageandafter understandingthecontentsofthechargetheaccusedpleadednotguiltyto thechargeandfacingtrial.

5.

FollowingpointsarisesformydeterminationandIhavegiven

myfindingsthereonforthereasonsstatedbelow:
POINTS FINDINGS

1 Doestheprosecutionprovethaton9.12.2007 atabout4.00p.m.atAmbedkarWard,Warthi, the accused in furtherance of their common intentionbeatenthecomplainantandcaused hurttoherandherebycommittedanoffence punishableunder Section 323 r/w 34ofthe IndianPenalCode? Inthenegative.

POINTS

FINDINGS

2 Doestheprosecutionprovethatatthesame date,time and place, the accused in furtherance of their common intention, torn thebrawandblouseofthecomplainantwith intentiontooutragehermodestyandthereby committed an offence punishable under Section 354 r/w 34 of the Indian Penal Code? Inthenegative. 3 Whatorder?......... Asperfinalorder.

REASONS 6. ASTOPOINTNO.1and2: Thecomplainanthasexamined

CW1Pragatid/oGhanshyamGajbhiyeatExh.54.Itappearsfromher

..5..R.Cri.C.No.4/08(Judgment)

evidence that on 9.12.2007 at about 4.00 p.m. she was going to throw wastewaterfromherhouse. Atthattime,accusedno.1Damayantihas thrownthewasteonherpersonandthereforeshehasthrownherwaste wateratthatplace.ThenDayalBansodcamethereandstatedhertoclean thelaneotherwisehewillsendhertoJail.Thereaftershehasstatedhimto callhiswife.ThenaccusedDamayanticametoherhouseandabusedher infilthylanguage.AccusedYogitahasstatedhertosetonfire.Thenshe hastakenalathiinherhandandstatedthemtogetridof.Thenshehad

tried and shouted ' Sodwa Sodwa'. Then the neighboring persons have gatheredthere.SimaDongreandShaliniNagdevecametorescueherand they have taken out lathi from her hand. Then everything was done peacefulfortwominutes.

7.

ShefurtherdeposedthatthenKumarcamethereandcaughther

braandtornit andbeatenherhairalsoandaccusedSachinhasstarted scufflingwithher.ThenshewenttoPoliceStation,Bhandaraandpolice haverecordedheroralcomplaint.Thepolicehavereferredherformedical checkuptoCivilSurgeon,Bhandara.TheMedicalOfficerhastreatedher and issued medical certificate. Her oral complaint is at Article A and medicalcertificateisatArticleB.PolicehaveregisteredN.C.asperExh. 55.Thereforeshehasfiledthisprivate

..6.. complaint. 8. In her cross examination she has admitted that her house is

situatedbehindthehouseofaccused.Shefurtheradmittedthatthereisone laneinbetweentheirhouseandshopwhichgoestoherhouse.Shefurther admittedthatsheherselfandtheaccusedbothhavefiledapplicationfor gettingpetrolpump.Shefurtheradmittedthatthereisapubliclanefrom

herhouse.Shefurtheradmittedthatherneighborers ShrikantRamteke, PrashantRamteke,ManishGajbhiye,LaxmikantRamteke,SeemaDongre areresidingthere.Shefurtheradmittedthatthisquarrelendedwithinone hourandimmediatelysherushedtopolicestationtofilecomplaint.She alsoadmittedthatshehasshownthetornclothestothepolicebutthey havenotseizedit.Policehavenottakenhercomplaintalso.Shehasnot filedanycomplaintagainstthepolicetotheirhigherofficialfornottaking complaint. Shefurther admittedthatinthelandofherhousesomany peoplesarewalkingtheretogototheirhouses.Shefurtheradmittedthat forgettingthepetrolpumptheaccusedpersonshaveappliedandshehas alsoappliedbuttheaccusedwasallottedwiththepetrolpump.Witness volunteersthatshehasfiledwritpetitiontocanceltheunlawfulallotment ofthepetrolpumptotheaccusedandshehasalsoadmittedthatthiswrit petitionwasdismissed.Shefurtheradmittedthatshehasfiledcomplaint against these accused that they have started their petrol pump by encroachingthelandbefore

..7..R.Cri.C.No.4/08(Judgment)

revenueauthorityandshehasalsocalledthepressconference.Shefurther admittedthattheirlanewasusebyShrikantRamteke,PrashantRamteke,

LaxmikantRamteke,BharatGajbhiye,ManishGajbhiye,KalyanDongreto gototheirhousesandthesepeoplesareusingthiswayforcommunication.

9.

The complainant has submitted to close the evidence of

complainantandthereforeasperorderdated7/12/2010,theevidenceof complainant wasclosedandstatement ofaccusedunder Section313of Criminal Procedure Code are recorded at Exh.63 to 66 in which the accusedhave deniedtheincriminatingcircumstancesandsubmittedthat falsecaseisfiledagainstthem.

10

Heardbothsidesandgonethroughtheevidenceonrecord.The

learnedcounselforcomplainantShriBhole,Advocatesubmittedthatthe accusedKumarhascaughttheblouseandbraofthecomplainantandtorn it and also threatened the complainant and her family members tobeat them, therefore N.C.was filedbythecomplainant. He further submitted thatthoughtheotherwitnessesarenotexaminedbythecomplainant,but the evidence of complainant CW 1 is sufficient to prove the guilt of accusedbeyondreasonabledoubtandaccusedbe

..8.. convicted.

11.

Heard the learned counsel for accused Shri Saxena,Advocate.

Hehassubmittedthatthereisnocogentorcorroborativeevidencegiven bythecomplainantinsupportofhercase.Therearesomanywitnesses presentthereandtheyhaveseentheseoffencebutthecomplainanthasnot examinedanyofthewitnessesfromSimaDongreorShaliniNagdeveor other persons from that locality, therefore adverse inference be drawn againsttheaccusedandthecomplainanthasfiledthisfalsecomplaintonly withtheenmityofgettingpetrolpumpandthereforecomplainantfailsto prove the guilt of accused or any incriminating of the offence and thereforeaccusedbeacquitted. 13. Heardbothsidesandongoingthroughtheevidenceonrecord.It

isadmittedthattherewereseveralwitnessespresent atthetimeofthis incidentbutthecomplainantfailstoshow whythecomplainanthasnot examinedanyofthewitnessinsupportofherevidence.Thecomplainant herselfhasstatedthatoneSimaDongreandShaliniNagdevehasrescued herandtheytakenoutlathifromherhandbuttheyarenotexaminedbythe complainant. In her cross examination, she has admitted that she has appliedforgettingpetrolpumpandaccusedhavealsoappliedforgetting petrol pump, out of which accused have been allotted with the petrol pump.Thecomplainanthasalsoadmittedthat

..9..R.Cri.C.No.4/08(Judgment)

she has filed writ petition to the Honourable High Court but it was dismissed.Shehasalsofiledcomplainttorevenueauthorityandalsotaken thepressconferenceonthesamesubject.Fromtheevidenceonrecord,it appearsthatthecomplainanthasexaminedonlyherselfbeforetheCourt and there is no corroborative or supporting evidence given by her in supportofhercase.Hence,itisheldthatthecomplainantfailstoprovethe guiltofaccusedandalsofailstoproveanyoftheingredientsoftheoffence under Section 323,354 r/w 34 of the Indian Penal Code beyond the reasonabledoubtandundersuchcircumstancestheaccusedaccusedare entitled for their acquittal. Hence, I answer point no.1 and 2 in the negative.

14.

ASTOPOINTNO.3:Inviewofmyfindingtoabovepoints,I

passthefollowingorder: ORDER (1) Allaccused(1)Sau.DamayantiDayalBansod(2)Shri Kumar

Dayal Bansod (3) Shri Sachin Dayal Bansod and (4) Ku.Yogita Dayal

Bansod are is hereby acquitted under Section 248(1) of the Code of CriminalProcedure,1973fortheoffencepunishableunderSection323,354 r/w34oftheIndianPenalCode,1860.

..10..

(2)

Thebailbondsoftheaccusedstandcancelled.

Date:13.12.2010.

(Dr.S.R.Jaiswal) ChiefJudicialMagistrate, Bhandara.