Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
EDITORIAL
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Stephen Pizzello
SENIOR EDITOR Rachael K. Bosley
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Jon D. Witmer
TECHNICAL EDITOR Christopher Probst
CONTRIBUTING WRITERS
Benjamin B, Douglas Bankston, Robert S. Birchard,
John Calhoun, Michael Goldman, Simon Gray, Jim Hemphill,
David Heuring, Jay Holben, Mark Hope-Jones, Noah Kadner,
Jean Oppenheimer, Jon Silberg, Iain Stasukevich,
Kenneth Sweeney, Patricia Thomson
ART DEPARTMENT
CREATIVE DIRECTOR Marion Gore
ADVERTISING
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Angie Gollmann
323-936-3769 FAX 323-936-9188
e-mail: gollmann@pacbell.net
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Sanja Pearce
323-952-2114 FAX 323-876-4973
e-mail: sanja@ascmag.com
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Scott Burnell
323-936-0672 FAX 323-936-9188
e-mail: sburnell@earthlink.net
CLASSIFIEDS/ADVERTISING COORDINATOR Diella Nepomuceno
323-952-2124 FAX 323-876-4973
e-mail: diella@ascmag.com
American Cinematographer (ISSN 0002-7928), established 1920 and in its 93rd year of publication, is published
monthly in Hollywood by ASC Holding Corp., 1782 N. Orange Dr., Hollywood, CA 90028, U.S.A.,
(800) 448-0145, (323) 969-4333, Fax (323) 876-4973, direct line for subscription inquiries (323) 969-4344.
Subscriptions: U.S. $50; Canada/Mexico $70; all other foreign countries $95 a year (remit international
Money Order or other exchange payable in U.S. $). Advertising: Rate card upon request from Hollywood
office. Article Reprints: Requests for high-quality article reprints (or electronic reprints) should be made to
Sheridan Reprints at (800) 635-7181 ext. 8065 or by e-mail hrobinson@tsp.sheridan.com.
Copyright 2013 ASC Holding Corp. (All rights reserved.) Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles, CA
and at additional mailing offices. Printed in the USA.
POSTMASTER: Send address change to American Cinematographer, P.O. Box 2230, Hollywood, CA 90078.
4
OFFICERS - 2012/2013
Stephen Lighthill
President
Daryn Okada
Vice President
Richard Crudo
Vice President
Kees Van Oostrum
Vice President
Victor J. Kemper
Treasurer
Frederic Goodich
Secretary
Steven Fierberg
Sergeant At Arms
MEMBERS OF THE
BOARD
John Bailey
Stephen H. Burum
Curtis Clark
Richard Crudo
Dean Cundey
Fred Elmes
Michael Goi
Victor J. Kemper
Francis Kenny
Matthew Leonetti
Stephen Lighthill
Michael O'Shea
Robert Primes
Owen Roizman
Kees Van Oostrum
ALTERNATES
Ron Garcia
Julio Macat
Kenneth Zunder
Steven Fierberg
Karl Walter Lindenlaub
MUSEUM CURATOR
Steve Gainer
American Society of Cine ma tog ra phers
The ASC is not a labor union or a guild, but
an educational, cultural and pro fes sion al
or ga ni za tion. Membership is by invitation
to those who are actively en gaged as
di rec tors of photography and have
dem on strated out stand ing ability. ASC
membership has be come one of the highest
honors that can be bestowed upon a
pro fes sional cin e ma tog ra pher a mark
of prestige and excellence.
Backstage Equipment, nc. 8052 Lankershim Bl. North Hollywood, CA 91605 (818) 504-6026 Fax (818) 504-6180 backstaged@aol.com www.backstageweb.com
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
We are the largest retailer specializing in Magliner customized products and accessories for the Film and Television Industry in the world
New York Showroom C.W..H. 364 W. 36th St. New York, NY 10018 (877)-Mr-CASTER (877-672-2783) backstage@cwih.com www.cwih.com
e are the largest retailer specializing in Magline WWe
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
e are the largest retailer specializing in Magliner customized products and accessories for the Film and T
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
elevision Industry in the world m and T Te
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
o
E n 2 h o H h tt rr oo NN
h
. l B m i h s r e k n a L 55 00 8 . c n e , t n e mm p i u q E ee
N
g a t s k c a B
. t S tt 66 33 . WW 4 6 3 . H . . W . C m o o rr w oo hh S k r o YYo w e N
T
9 4 C a b
c
0 8 1 6 - 4 0 55 8) 8 1 88 (( x Fa F
6
6 2 0 6 - 4 0 5 ) 8 1 8 ( 5 0 6 1 9 AA
8
C , w d o o w yy
Y
l l o
c a b ) 3 8 7 2 - 2 7 6 - 77 ( 7 8 ( RR E T SS AA CC M - r M - ( ) 7 7 8 11 00 00 11 YY NN , k r o YYo w ee NN
o
b m o c . b e w e g a t s k c a b . m w w w m oo a c . l o a @@ d
m
e g a t s k c a
w o cc . h i w c . w c w w m o c . h i w c @ e g a t s k c
6
My visit to the set of Hitchcock was a bit unnerving. Upon
arriving at Red Studios, I found myself sitting in a directors
chair with Hannibal Lecter and Ed Gein lurking directly behind
me. Who scheduled this visit right before lunch? I joked,
glancing back at actors Anthony Hopkins (this time portraying
Alfred Hitchcock) and Michael Wincott (as Gein). Wincott
took the bait. When I go to the craft-services truck and they
ask what I want, I say, Scarlett Johansson. (Johansson co-
stars as Janet Leigh.)
Hitchcock is laced with gallows humor that leavens the
drama as Hitchcock struggles to make Psycho while worrying
that his wife, Alma (Helen Mirren), is having an affair. Cine-
matographer Jeff Cronenweth, ASC offers his insights to Jay Holben (An Auteurs Angst,
page 78), while director Sacha Gervasi provides his own perspective (Dramatizing the
Master of Suspense, page 82).
Robert Richardson, ASC is no slouch when it comes to cinema history, but he has met
his match in Quentin Tarantino. Before the duo began work on Django Unchained, Tarantino
screened a wide variety of titles for Richardson and other key collaborators, including Sergio
Corbuccis The Great Silence, Dario Argentos Suspiria, Lucio Fulcis Dont Torture a Duckling,
Mario Bavas Black Sunday, Max Ophls The Earrings of Madame de , Brian De Palmas
Carrie, Sergio Leones For a Few Dollars More and Howard Hawks Rio Bravo. Thats by no
means a complete list, Richardson notes wryly in his interview with Iain Stasukevich (Once
Upon a Time in the South, page 32).
Though Tarantino probably trumps almost anyone except Martin Scorsese in terms of
the sheer scope of his movie mania, he wisely defers to Richardson when it comes to areas
of technical expertise. My input [on lighting] is so minuscule that it really doesnt exist,
Tarantino concedes. I love Bobs look. I love his atmosphere. I love his hot pools of light. I
love all that shit. Its taken my work to a different level.
Andrew Lesnie, ASC, ACS and Peter Jackson achieved a similar serendipity while work-
ing together on the Lord of the Rings trilogy, a triumphant marriage of technology and visual
design. With The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, the two have upped the ante by adding
high-frame-rate 3-D to the mix. Peter has been talking about 3-D and high frame rates for
years, Lesnie tells Simon Gray (An Unlikely Hero, page 50). It goes back to seeing a
Showscan event in New Zealand when he was young and watching 70mm films in his child-
hood, and it goes all the way up to the King Kong ride he created at Universal Studios, which
involves 60-fps projection.
Not to be outdone in terms of ambition, Danny Cohen, BSC and Tom Hooper set
Les Misrables to music in a sweeping adaptation of the hit Broadway production. In tack-
ling Victor Hugos epic saga, they opted for naturalistic visuals that ground the spectacle in
gritty period realities. Its a story about social issues wealth, revolution and social change
but the story is told through song, Cohen tells John Calhoun (A Musical Revolution,
page 66). By making it as naturalistic as possible, we thought the fact that everybodys
singing wouldnt create a wall between the story and the audience.
Stephen Pizzello
Executive Editor
Editors Note
P
h
o
t
o
b
y
O
w
e
n
R
o
i
z
m
a
n
,
A
S
C
.
8
We wish all of you a Happy New Year. We hope for peace and prosper-
ity all over the world. This is a big January in the United States, as many
new faces have been elected and will be taking federal or state office this
month. Many of us watched the campaigns and elections closely and
noted the advances in polling and polling analysis.
Nate Silvers FiveThirtyEight blog in The New York Times was
quite informative. (The title comes from the total number of electoral-
college votes that can be cast: 538.) Silver made clear his methodology
as he gave new projections every day. Most readers were aware that hed
had a remarkable degree of accuracy in predicting the 2010 election
results. Ultimately, he had a near-perfect record of predicting 2012s
winners. That some candidates lost and were surprised by their losses
makes one wonder what information they were getting. If Silver could
predict the outcome of the election with a great degree of accuracy the
day before the election, why werent the candidates able to do so as
well? Simple: wishful thinking and assumption, the mother of all mess-
ups. Some candidates made assumptions about who would vote, and
many of those assumptions were wrong.
In cinematography you knew I would get back to cine-
matography we see lots of wishful thinking and mistaken assump-
tions, but what concerns us is the misinterpretation of numbers. When
discussing cameras, numbers have become a faddist sort of sloganeering
by the uninformed. We hear constant reference to 4K as the best
camera, but that might not be the case if the camera is 4K with 4:2:0
compression. And what exactly does 4K refer to: sensor size, individual recorded frame size, etc.? There is also frequent
reference to raw camera files, and many assume these files are uncompressed and unaltered. In fact, there are several
variations of raw that are processed and compressed. Manufacturers often clearly explain that a given raw file type is
compressed, but the uninformed chatter often does not take these various and reasonable compression schemes into
consideration. I say reasonable because as we make the welcome move toward 4K capture, we are going to be handling
enormous amounts of data, and well-made compression systems will be necessary.
In cinematography, what matters is the quality of the image. One camera might have better numbers, but the
image must serve the story and move it forward. The chatter about numbers distracts from the real purpose of images and
demeans the role of the cinematographer. Yes, we know our numbers, but numbers do not tell the whole story either in
elections or in storytelling.
Stephen Lighthill
ASC President
Presidents Desk
10 January 2013 American Cinematographer
P
h
o
t
o
b
y
D
o
u
g
l
a
s
K
i
r
k
l
a
n
d
.
WWW. WARNERBROS2012. COM
F O R Y O U R C O N S I D E R A T I O N
BEST PICTURE
BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY
WALLY PFISTER, A. S.C.
K E N N E T H T U R A N ,
Bullet Train
By Alec Ernest
When the Barbarian Group asked director/cinematographer
Andrew Wonder to capture 36 hours of time-lapse photography that
could be slowed down to a drop at any point, he recognized it
would not be a conventional job. The project was Juice Train, part
of an online campaign to revitalize General Electrics website, and the
subject was the train that makes a 36-hour journey to transport
550,000 gallons of Tropicana orange juice from Bradenton, Fla., to
Jersey City, N.J., for distribution in the Northeast.
Wonder had caught the agencys eye with his visceral docu-
mentary short Undercity, for which he followed urban explorer Steve
Duncan through New York City subway tunnels and sewers, and to
the top of the Brooklyn Bridge, with his Canon EOS 5D Mark II. The
video became a viral sensation. All I wanted to do was make some-
thing I had never seen before, says Wonder.
The potential to achieve that, he continues, can only be real-
ized by todays digital cameras. I could never move a film camera the
way I can move my 5D. Getting that camera was like finding my
paintbrush. With todays digital tools, we can make films no one has
ever seen before.
It used to be a real technical challenge to achieve time-lapse,
but DSLR technology has made it easy, he continues. The challenge
now is to do it in a way that creates a new experience for the viewer.
Juice Train, which presents the Tropicana trains 36-hour trip
in 156 seconds, offered such an opportunity. Prep was a six-month
journey to get all the tools we needed from vendors around the
world, and my producer, Alon Simcha, was instrumental in that
process, says Wonder.
The first challenge was finding a camera that could record
1080p at 60 fps. I wanted to use the Sony F3 because it offered
broadcast controls and a very cinematic image, but the specs said the
camera was only capable of 720p/60p, says Wonder. I hoped there
was a workaround and contacted Cinedeck about its recorders to see
what was possible. They pointed me to the Cinedeck RX recorder,
which was able to take the dual link out of the camera and record it
as 1080p/60p ProRes. Once we discovered the Cinedeck RX, the
whole shoot came together. It also allowed us to record directly to
two eSATA drives and provided full-screen waveforms, eliminating
the need to offload footage with a computer, change SSD modules
or use scopes. We couldnt have done the shoot without it.
Next, with help from Panavision New York, he tracked down
a JDC 32mm anamorphic lens, thinking that by shooting 2x anamor-
phic on a 16x9 sensor, he could achieve an aspect ratio of 3.55:1. I
wanted the image to be like a proscenium stage, he says. I wanted
the audience to look around the frame and find different details each
time they watched the video.
Short Takes
For Juice Train,
part of an online
campaign for
General Electric,
director/
cinematographer
Andrew Wonder
and his
collaborators
mounted two
Sony F3 cameras
to the front of a
locomotive and
recorded the
trains 36-hour
journey from
Florida to
New Jersey.
I
12 January 2013 American Cinematographer
A
l
l
i
m
a
g
e
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
t
h
e
f
i
l
m
m
a
k
e
r
s
.
BEAUTIFULLY PHOTOGRAPHED
BY FRANK GRIEBE AND JOHN TOLL AND ELEGANTLY CRAFTED.
JOE MORGENSTERN,
20 January 2013 American Cinematographer
and key grip, Cyril Kuhnholtz, would
propose something by saying, This is truer.
Michael would say to me, for example, The
lighting you did here is pretty, but I cant
read a book in this light; therefore, it isnt
true. I want them to be able to read with the
light of the practical. Sometimes I would
add a fixture in the direction of the practical
to extend its effect, and he would tolerate
that, but he would say, It cant only be
pretty. It must also be functional. Some-
times, in the moment, it was frustrating, but
it led me to enter into another lighting
approach that is magnifique. I loved it. I
learned a lot on this film, and on the films
Ive worked on since then, I have striven to
work on the truth of the lighting, which has
made it more beautiful to me.
This movie has a lot of depth-of-
field. There are only a few scenes in the
living room where you see a focus shift.
Khondji: With Michael, you always
need more sharpness and more depth-of-
field, so we shot at T4 almost all the time.
With another director, I might have shot
more open, but in this case I had to
compensate for the lack of depth-of-field of
the digital sensor. I found T4 with the Alexa
to be the equivalent of T2.8 with film. With
film I would have shot between T2.5 and
T2.8, but there I was at T4, and sometimes
even at T5.6, trying to give more roundness
to the depth-of-field. I mixed Cooke S4 and
S5 primes, which I often do. I started with
Top and middle:
Georges is
alarmed when his
wife suddenly
seems incapable
of speech during
breakfast.
Bottom: Georges
informs the
couples daughter
(Isabelle Huppert)
of Annes
deteriorating
condition.
22 January 2013 American Cinematographer
the idea of shooting fairly open with the S5s
during my tests. I like the S5s because you
can open them up, and theyre very beauti-
ful between T1.3 and T2. Their lack of
depth-of-field makes the image very beauti-
ful and fragile. Its almost like shooting with
a large-format negative.
Part of the films sobriety comes
from its limited focal lengths. What
focal length did you use most often?
Khondji: 35mm. Robert Bresson
shot everything with the 40mm. Michael
Haneke shoots everything with the 35mm,
which isnt available in the S5s yet.
Almost the entire film takes place
in the apartment, a set built on a sound-
stage. What was your lighting
approach?
Khondji: Michael created a detailed
lighting framework, which he started by
himself and we then refined together. In
defining the orientation of the apartment,
we decided the windows of the bedroom
and living room would face north so that
there would be no direct sunlight. Those
rooms are lit by the bounce off a big build-
ing across the street that is visible through
the windows. The kitchen is the only place
where sunlight enters directly, in the morn-
ing. Whats more, its never the same light-
ing from scene to scene. There are sunny
days, cloudy days, rainy days and so on. We
followed Michaels directions like a musical
score, continuously changing the lighting
according to the moment in the day, the
weather and the season. Because we knew
everything in advance, we preset the light-
ing settings ahead of time, and we could
determine the proportion of daylight to
practicals. We had everything on dimmers
to define the light intensity. I wanted the
lighting to be very true. I wanted you to feel
the light coming in from the outside, and
for the light to be very spatial, to really be
part of the dcor, just like the colors of the
walls. Many people have told me they cant
really tell its a soundstage, not a location.
What was your lighting setup?
Khondji: All the fixtures were tung-
sten. For daylight I wanted very big sources,
so as to light the entire window. We put
24Ks with heavily diffused Chimeras 5 or 6
meters [16'-20'] away from the windows,
shining directly through them, and we hung
sheer curtains on the windows that also
diffused the light. Above each window we
installed 4-by-4 Kino Flos with diffusion
similar to tracing paper; these were skirted
and channeled to extend the window light
inside. Underneath each window outside
were soft lights shooting up, because
daylight does that: it doesnt just come from
above, it also [bounces] up from the ground
and lights up the window and the window
edges. When the street windows were in
shot, we lit the greenscreen outside. [Visual-
effects supervisor] Julien Meesters from
Mikros Image did a wonderful job of [comp-
ing in] street footage behind the sheers.
Did you have any lighting above
the set?
Khondji: All the rooms were lit from
above with space lights gelled with CTB
and going through very thick, unbleached
muslin. These top sources were played very,
very low. Depending on the scene and the
moment of the day or evening, they had
almost no impact, or a little more. They
could provide fill to offset the contrast from
the window light. The big vestibule and the
little hallway leading to the kitchen also had
toplight, but it was much more tungsten-
balanced so that when the practicals are on,
there is more fill coming down from the ceil-
ing. But I found that the toplight could
quickly become fake looking, so I dimmed
the ceiling lighting a lot.
There are few close-ups in the
film, but you present the characters
faces beautifully with a very natural
look. An example is the kitchen-table
scene in which Anne has her first
stroke.
Khondji: That scene was shot with
two cameras, so it was very complicated
because I had to light the two actors and
the two backgrounds at the same time in a
very tight spot. The only source of light was
through the window. The key on each actor
was provided by a 10K, and it was more
heavily diffused on him than on her.
Tell us about the DI.
Khondji: We actually did two
passes. I did the first with [colorist] Didier
Lefouest at Digimage, with very specific
notes from Michael, and Michael did the
second in Austria. He wanted to see my
version and then do his own because he is
so meticulous. We graded in 4K, and I must
say that the 4K DCP we saw at Cannes was
much more beautiful than the 2K DCP I saw
afterwards. There really is a big difference.
For me, there was something very
musical about this film. The lighting varia-
tions felt like a musical score that incorpo-
rated the time of day, the weather and the
season. I felt like a violinist working with a
very, very good orchestra conductor. Its true
that I had less freedom than Ive had with
other directors, but it was a fascinating
experience nevertheless. You know, I would
have loved to have had the opportunity to
work with Bresson and Bergman, and work-
ing with Michael Haneke on a film like this
felt like the same level of filmmaking. He
has the same rigor and desire for truth.
TECHNICAL SPECS
1.85:1
Digital Capture
Arri Alexa
Cooke S4, S5
Director of photography Darius Khondji, ASC, AFC (center) and director Michael Haneke (third
from right) confer with their collaborators on the set.
W W W . WA R N E R B R O S 2 0 1 2 . C O M
B E S T P I C T U R E
B E S T C I N E MAT OG R AP H Y
ANDREW LESNIE ACS, ASC
F O R Y O U R C O N S I D E R A T I O N
A Conscience Decision
By David Heuring
To present the rural setting of the
drama Promised Land with the richest
detail and greatest clarity possible, Swedish
cinematographer Linus Sandgren, FSF and
director Gus Van Sant brought an unusual
format to the big screen: Super 1.85:1
achieved with a 4-perf Super 35mm nega-
tive and Hawk 1.3x anamorphic prime
lenses. The format, which boosts image
size on the negative, is made possible by
the combination of DI techniques and the
1.3x lenses. It has been used in some
commercials, but never in a feature film,
Sandgren attests. By shooting 4-perf
Super 35mm in a squeezed ratio of 1.42:1,
we worked with a negative area that was
70 percent larger than Academy 1.85:1
and 30 percent larger than 3-perf Super
1.85.
Promised Land follows Steve Butler
(Matt Damon), a salesman for a natural-gas
company who arrives in a small, economi-
cally depressed town in upstate New York
with his work partner, Sue (Frances McDor-
mand), and tries to talk the locals into sign-
ing over the drilling rights to their farmland.
It isnt an easy sell, and as he spends more
time talking to the townspeople, Butler
struggles with whether he is doing the right
thing.
In prep, Van Sant and Sandgren
discussed their mutual admiration for
photojournalism of the latter 20th century,
particularly images captured with Leica
cameras, and decided to try to capture a
similar level of detail in Promised Lands
rural locations (in Avonmore and Apollo,
Pa.). Sandgren tested a range of formats to
determine how best to deliver this look.
They took inspiration from large-format still
photography, especially the work of
Stephen Shore, but also the reportage-style
images of Steve McCurry, Mitch Epstein
and Eve Arnold. There were conversations
about shooting 65mm, but that format was
deemed impractical. Anamorphic 2.40:1
was considered, but Van Sant decided he
wanted a 1.85:1 aspect ratio to make the
images feel more natural, says Sandgren.
Gus thought these Kodachrome stills shot
in the American countryside in the 1970s
and 80s were perfect. You see a lot of
detail, not much grain, and everything has
nice latitude, with nothing really blowing
out. Theres exposure everywhere, but its
still contrasty.
The images they were viewing had
faded slightly with age, and Van Sant also
liked that quality. Sandgren found that a
combination of overexposing and pull
processing the negative helped. By overex-
posing
1
3 of a stop and pull processing 1
stop, we got even exposure and great,
strong contrast. The blacks are dense but
soft. (Deluxe Laboratories in New York
processed the productions negative.)
He shot most of Promised Land on
two Fujifilm Eterna Vivid negatives, 250D
8546 and 500 8547. For bright day exteri-
ors, he occasionally used Fujifilm F-64D
8522. I wanted to get a lot of saturation
so that we could perhaps mute it later [in
post], he says. I wanted everything to
have color. In window highlights with white
curtains, the Vivid stocks seemed to register
those subtle tones of cyan or yellow that
exist in the world. Those reportage photos
we were referencing blow most peoples
minds because they make you feel like
youre there, and the Vivid stocks helped us
[achieve] that same effect by capturing even
minimal saturation. By pull processing, we
maintained even exposure and maintained
highlights, and I found that the mid-tones,
where most of the important information is,
maintained contrast, while the blacks and
the highlights were softened. The blacks
dont develop enough to be completely
contrasty, and the highlights dont process
enough to burn out. White clouds are
24 January 2013 American Cinematographer
P
r
o
m
i
s
e
d
L
a
n
d
p
h
o
t
o
s
b
y
S
c
o
t
t
G
r
e
e
n
,
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
F
o
c
u
s
F
e
a
t
u
r
e
s
.
Upon arriving
in a rural town
to pitch the
locals on a
fracking plan,
Steve Butler
(Matt Damon,
left) finds
retired
engineer Frank
Yates (Hal
Holbrook) to
be a very
tough sell.
I
detailed, and blacks are deep yet dull. Faces
get a beautiful shine. Our testing showed
we couldnt achieve this look any other way,
even in the DI. (The final digital grade was
done at Technicolor Hollywood with colorist
Mark Gethin.)
The Hawk V-Lite 1.3x anamorphic
lenses, which he teamed with Arricam
Studio and Lite cameras, are just great
very well manufactured, contrasty and
beautiful and they contributed signifi-
cantly to the look as well, he continues.
They have their own unique characteris-
tics, like out-of-focus highlights in the back-
ground that are not quite circular. In combi-
nation with the rich detail of the negative,
the lenses gave us an image thats just
amazing.
Sandgren notes that the pull-
processed material looks less grainy than
the material that was processed normally,
even at night, and he attributes that in part
to the increased resolution of the 4-perf
squeezed image. I didnt pull process the
first night exterior [a dialogue between
Damon and John Krasinski in a parking lot]
because I was afraid it was going to get too
dark, he says. Later, we shot in a similar
environment and did the pull processing,
and it looked so crisp. It was very successful.
The pull processing doesnt bring up the
grain; you can lift it up with the gamma
curves in the DI. In the end, there were only
two scenes that we didnt pull process, and
they were both from the first day of the
shoot.
Van Sant values simplicity, and Sand-
grens in-camera techniques, as well as his
lighting and framing, were in harmony with
that aesthetic. We could move fast and
capture things quickly with confidence, and
because we were already using the right
technique, what was happening in front of
the camera could give us some cool
surprises, says Sandgren. That was nice.
Most mornings during the shoot,
Van Sant spent the first hour or so devising
the blocking for a scene. Then, the actors
would retreat for wardrobe and makeup,
and Sandgrens crew would go to work.
Lighting was minimal, and clean sets
were encouraged no cameras, dollies or
lighting in the spaces until after blocking.
Blocking and shot selection, like most of
26 January 2013 American Cinematographer
Top: A farmer
(Scoot McNairy)
gives Butler the
cold shoulder.
Bottom: The
salesman enjoys
a warmer
welcome from
a local
schoolteacher
(Rosemarie
DeWitt) in the
town bar.
2012 Sony Electronics Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission is prohibited.
Features and specications are subject to change without notice. Sony, CineAlta, and the make.believe logo are trademarks of Sony.
HD, 2K, 4K and beyond.
With Sony 4K, your future is bright. Even if youre distributing in HD, Sony 4K gives you beautiful, super-sampled pictures
with higher contrast and greater sharpness. The F55 camera upgrades your imagery with true color, on-board 4K
recording and electronic global shutter, while the F5 offers a 4K sensor and super-sampled HD recording. They join the
8K-sensor F65, not to mention a full spectrum of Sony 4K tools to create the ultimate in immersive viewing. Experience
incredible Sony 4K recorders, monitors, digital cinema projectors, a nonlinear editor, a home theater projector and even
a home television. Sony 4K: delivering tomorrows performance, today.
sony.com/35mm
PMW-F5
PMW-F55
the future
ahead of schedule
28 January 2013 American Cinematographer
Van Sants decisions, were always based on
character and on the actors instincts. Sand-
gren and his gaffer, Patrick Murray, usually lit
the room rather than the shot, with some
minor adjustments after blocking. Most
scenes were filmed with two cameras.
Gus wanted the sets to be very
open for the actors when it came to block-
ing, the cinematographer recalls. If we
didnt need to use movie lights, that was
preferred. Sometimes we needed light, but
only on interiors and night exteriors. We
used sodium-vapor and mercury-vapor
streetlights sparsely and randomly in the
town. We didnt use very big units, but we
had a lot of small units on Condors so we
could fill [night exteriors in town] with dirty
mixed light.
Nothing was too planned out, he
continues. We didnt want the light to
look as if it was meant to be in a space in
that perfect, filmic way. I wanted it to be a
little off. Our plan was to kill any light source
that didnt feel authentic. I was also very
allergic to wide squares reflected in the eyes
of the actors. I hope you dont see any!
Key grip Bart Flaherty and costume designer
Juliet Polcsa collaborated to create 8'x8' and
4'x4' frames with a variety of fabrics in
shades of yellow, blue and white. The
frames were used to soften faces and
reflected abstract, less noticeable patterns
in eyes.
For a day-interior scene in which
Butler appeals to the locals at a town meet-
ing in the high-school gymnasium, the film-
makers switched off the existing mercury-
vapor practicals because they were too
noisy, and Sandgrens crew rigged a combi-
nation of diffused ArriMax M18s overhead
and 18K ArriMaxes and ArriMax M40s
through windows to emulate sunlight.
Van Sant wanted Sandgren to
emulate the reactive style of camera
movement he admired in certain films from
the 1970s. Gus was concerned that we
might not be able to move the camera
much in some of our locations, says Sand-
gren. We found an Elemack Jib that the
operator rides, and we used it extensively.
Early on, Van Sant asked Sandgren if
he could work without monitors or play-
back. I said, Sure, that would be fun!
says the cinematographer. I operated the
A camera, and I trusted my B-camera oper-
ator, Davon Slininger, completely. Of course,
it took a few days to get used to this
method, but when we saw dailies, it was all
good. Working without monitors saved us a
lot of time. It eliminates a lot of discussions.
Gus encouraged all of us to trust our
instincts. It was like an organized pledge to
work together. Everyone felt included.
TECHNICAL SPECS
Super 1.85:1
4-perf Super 35mm
Arricam Studio, Lite
Vantage Hawk V-Lite 1.3x
Fujifilm Eterna Vivid 250D 8546,
500 8547; F-64D 8522
Digital Intermediate
Top: Butlers work partner, Sue (Frances McDormand), questions his strategy.
Bottom: Cinematographer Linus Sandgren, FSF.
Built on revolutionary Thunderbolt
!
You also get Photoshop
and Nuke
. No other editing
solution supports more software on Mac OS X, so now you have the freedom
to build your studio your own way!
Learn more today at www.blackmagicdesign.com/UltraStudio3D
UltraStudio 3D
$
995
www.red.com
2012 Red.com, Inc. All rights reserved.
The smallest camera makes the biggest images.
This still frame was pulled from 5k RED EPIC
motion footage. Hitchcock 2012 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation. All rights reserved. Not for sale or duplication.
The visions always clear in my mind but the trick on every project
is to get it up on the screen, fully realized. No excusesI absolutely hate
compromise. After shooting The Social Network, The Girl With the Dragon
Tattoo, and Hitchcockal l on REDI came to the conclusion that
compromise has been removed from the equation. With RED, my vision
becomes my reality. For what its worth, I feel much better now.
TECHNICAL SPECS
2.40:1
Anamorphic 35mm
Panaflex Millennium XL-2
Panavision Primo, E-Series
Kodak Vision3 500T 5219,
200D 5213
Digital Intermediate
49
50 January 2013 American Cinematographer
J.R.R.
Tolkiens The Hobbit, or There and Back
Again tells the story of how diminutive and
reluctant hero Bilbo Baggins finds himself
far from home on a perilous journey. The
Hobbit wrests himself from hearth and home when he is
hired by a company of dwarves to steal a vast treasure from a
dragon. The Hobbit is a classic heros journey that continues to
resonate because it reminds us to get out there and take part in
our amazing, richly divergent world, says cinematographer
Andrew Lesnie, ASC, ACS, who is shooting a trilogy of films
based on the novel for director Peter Jackson. The themes and
subtext of the book drove my theories about the films visuals,
and the character I focused on was Bilbo [Martin Freeman].
Through interaction with a variety of people and creatures in
faraway lands, he wrestles with self-doubt and finds courage
and inner strength. He returns home wiser, more compassion-
ate and forgiving. The novels storyline also involves the 13
dwarves, led by Thorin Oakenshield (Richard Armitage), who
enlist Bilbos services.
The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey is the first movie in
Jacksons trilogy, and he and Lesnie have broken new ground
in using 3-D digital capture at 48 fps to make the picture.
Peter has been talking about 3-D and high frame rates for
years he has always expressed an interest in more image
clarity, says Lesnie, who also shot Jacksons Lord of the Rings
trilogy (AC Dec. 01, Dec. 02, Jan. 04). It goes back to seeing
a Showscan event in New Zealand when he was young and
watching 70mm films in his childhood, and it goes all the way
up to the King Kong ride he created at Universal Studios,
which involves 60-fps projection.
We tested 3-D rigs for King Kong [AC Dec. 05] and
digital cameras for The Lovely Bones [AC Jan. 10], and both
times we decided to stay with 2-D and film, Lesnie contin-
ues. But developments in 3-D and digital technologies that
began to surface in 2010 specifically, 3ality Technicas
TS-5 3-D camera rig and Reds Epic camera combined
with Series 2 projection systems capable of projecting at
higher frame rates, made Jacksons desire to shoot The Hobbit
in high-frame-rate 3-D achievable. I undertook to embrace
that vision when I started prep on the movie, says Lesnie.
The first step was assembling the veritable armada of
equipment for R&D to determine how best to integrate the
An Unlikely
Hero
An Unlikely
Hero
Andrew Lesnie, ASC, ACS
pioneers high-frame-rate 3-D
capture for Peter Jacksons The
Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey.
By Simon Gray
|
www.theasc.com January 2013 51
new and existing technologies. In the
second half of 2010, Lesnie and Jackson
appointed New Zealand-based second-
unit cinematographer Richard Bluck,
head of technology Dion Hartley and
3-D camera supervisor Gareth Daley to
assemble, refine and combine prototype
Red Epics with 3alitys 3-D rigs and an
array of other gear, including motion-
control and motion-capture tools.
Throughout this period, Lesnie kept in
touch with fellow ASC members John
Schwartzman, Dariusz Wolski, Jeff
Cronenweth and Newton Thomas Sigel
about the teams progress and findings.
During ACs visit to the produc-
tions Wellingtons Stone Street Studios
last year, Daley noted that both Red and
3ality were extremely supportive during
all phases of the production. The Red
Epics [recording on 128GB SSD cards]
and 3ality rigs were still works in
progress, with software and design
upgrades that covered everything from
the cameras to rigs to wireless systems
coming in on a regular basis. Red was
incredibly responsive, often making
firmware changes on the same day [we
discussed an issue].
Preston Cinema Systems worked
with 3ality to create controller software
for its handsets, allowing the stereogra-
phers to use familiar equipment to
control the 3-D. For the TS-5s use on
the Steadicam, 3ality replaced non-
structural metal components with
Delron, changed the mirror-box to
molded carbon fiber, and removed any
steel screws that werent absolutely
necessary. At the same time, Red
continued to develop the Epics hard-
ware and software at such a rate that
Bluck, Daley and Hartley often needed
to retest their workflow, sometimes going
back to the beginning of the process.
The production ultimately
acquired three TS-4 (side-by-side), four
TS-2 and 10 TS-5 (beam-splitter) rigs
from 3ality. According to Daley, the
TS-5 became the preferred rig for its
versatility, ergonomics and low profile for
camera operators Cameron McLean (A
camera/Steadicam) and Simon Harding
(B camera/Steadicam). Unlike 3-D rigs
where one camera is essentially fixed, the
TS-5s two cameras move equally with
interaxial changes, so the Steadicam rig
remains perfectly balanced no matter
what the stereographer does with inter-
axial and convergence during the shot,
says Daley.
All of the equipment had to be
able to withstand New Zealands rugged
U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
b
y
J
a
m
e
s
F
i
s
h
e
r
a
n
d
M
a
r
k
P
o
k
o
r
n
y
.
P
h
o
t
o
s
a
n
d
f
r
a
m
e
g
r
a
b
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
W
a
r
n
e
r
B
r
o
s
.
P
i
c
t
u
r
e
s
.
Opposite page:
Bilbo Baggins
(Martin Freeman)
races through his
rural Hobbit
homeland, the
Shire. This page,
top: The great
wizard Gandalf the
Grey (Ian
McKellen)
commiserates with
the royal elf
Galadriel (Cate
Blanchett). Bottom:
Cinematographer
Andrew Lesnie,
ASC, ACS lines up
a shot.
52 January 2013 American Cinematographer
locations and accommodate Jacksons
style of filmmaking. The camera
systems were to be wireless and on small,
light, mobile rigs so they could be taken
anywhere to do pretty much anything,
Lesnie explains. I wanted to be as flexi-
ble as possible to enable Peter to have
ready access to any and every piece of
gear to make the film he wanted.
Lesnie and Bluck also managed
the crewing of the department, includ-
ing the stereographers. Each unit
required A-camera and B-camera stere-
ographers; those roles fell to Sean Kelly
and Angus Ward for the main unit, and
Phil Smith and James Rua for the
second unit. Most of them had been
first or second camera assistants, and it
was important to Andrew and I that
they had worked with Peter before, says
Bluck. Gareth and 3ality trained them
for their new roles.
With prep deep into camera
development, Lesnie and Jackson began
testing high-frame-rate acquisition.
Their eventual decision to capture the
entire picture at 48 fps doubled the
already huge amount of data; Lesnie
estimates that over the course of 266
days of principal photography, The
Hobbit amassed the equivalent of 26
million feet of film. This was my first
3-D shoot, my first major digital shoot,
and certainly my first at a higher frame
rate, so the learning curve has been enor-
An Unlikely Hero
Top: Bilbo hosts a gathering in his cozy Hobbit-hole at Bag End. Middle: The dwarves in attendance
include Bombur (Stephen Hunter), Ori (Adam Brown), Dori (Mark Hadlow), Nori (Jed Brophy) and Gloin
(Peter Hambleton). Bottom: Freeman holds the door as director Peter Jackson discusses a scene with
Graham McTavish, who plays Dwalin.
www.theasc.com January 2013 53
900Mhz spectrum, eliminating inter-
ference when the two shooting units
were next to each other, Daley says.
Each of the productions 17 rigs was
assigned a permanent individual
frequency. We then had a completely
wireless rig: picture, time code, gen-
lock, focus, iris and stereo control. We
were even able to rebroadcast metadata
and footage to other departments,
including video village.
We really put the Epics through
the wringer, and they performed
mous, he notes. The increased picture
clarity that comes with shooting 5K
images at 48 fps brings joys and horrors
simultaneously. The need for attention to
detail pervades every aesthetic aspect,
including hair, makeup, wardrobe and
art direction. One of the joys is creating
frames that are reminiscent of paintings
by Pieter Brueghel or Heironymous
Bosch.
Focus becomes even more criti-
cal, and we were blessed with great first
assistants: Colin Deane and Brenden
Holster on main unit and Dean
McCarroll and George Hennah on
second, continues Lesnie. They often
had to work in spontaneous situations.
Peter and I like moving the camera, so I
aimed to give them a fighting chance by
creating a working aperture of T4 for
most of the shoot thats T4 at 48 fps
in 3-D.
The first challenge for us was
keeping the cameras recording in sync at
a base speed of 48 fps, says Daley. He
and Hartley worked with Babak
Behesheti of Standard Deviation to
create a wireless sync pulse generator
that sent a constant, locked time code
and sync pulse to every rig, automatically
spot-checking back to the master with-
out the need for re-jamming or cabling.
A phase bar was also created that sat
beneath the slate. When cameras rolled,
the LEDs sequenced, allowing for
instant sync sign-off at the data-wran-
gler station. 48 fps doubled the chances
for things to go wrong, but shooting 1
petabyte [1,000,000 GB] of footage is a
testament to both the cameras and the
system setup, says Daley.
Achieving wireless rig control
over and above the competing din of
on-set wireless systems including
location sound, second-unit feed, light-
ing, Internet and Prestons required a
custom-created RS-422 controller.
This allowed utilization of the
Top: Thorin Oakenshield (Richard Armitage), Elrond (Hugo Weaving), Gandalf, Bilbo and Balin (Ken Stott)
confer in the Elven outpost of Rivendell. Bottom: Gandalf (far left) stops for some rest during his journey
with Ori, Oin (John Callen, behind tree branch), Dori, Kili (Aidan Turner), Bifur (William Kircher), Bilbo,
Dwalin and Gloin.
54 January 2013 American Cinematographer
admirably, reports Lesnie. [Red
founder] Jim Jannard and his team went
into overdrive for us. We resolved the
sync issues early in the project, and they
never came between the story and me.
The footage from the cameras has given
us a lot to work with in post. I still have
some issues with electronic shutters, but
the Reds dynamic range has been good,
and I think the next generation of
sensors will eliminate any complaints
anyone has about them currently not
having the range of film.
In December 2010, Lesnie staged
a series of comprehensive tests at Stone
Street Studios. I wanted to shoot 3-D
on a 2-D schedule, and I was keen to get
things sorted before we started principal
photography, he explains. The reality
was that we never completely locked off
the tech development in the cameras
and rigs. We lived in a world of perpet-
ual upgrades!
Shooting in the sets for Bag End
and Gollums cave, the crew tested
cameras and rigs, slave motion-control
rigs, and on-set motion-capture systems.
Some of the issues were unique to The
Hobbit, such as cameras needing to be
synchronized at 48 fps, let alone 72, 96
and 120 fps! says Lesnie. We were also
looking for the most comfortable 3-D
viewing experience, so we tested every
speed at every shutter angle, while Park
Road Post struggled to accommodate the
massive influx of data. We shot a range of
material so we could study motion-blur
and strobing, amongst many other
things.
Shooting stereo at 48 fps with a
270-degree shutter, which provided an
equivalent film speed of ISO 250, was
determined to be the most viewable
combination. During ACs set visit, stere-
ographer Sean Kelly used a break
An Unlikely Hero
Gollum, a Stoor-hobbit of the River-folk, eventually loses the One Ring to Bilbo during their
famous Riddle Game. He was played once again by Andy Serkis, shown at far right in his
performance-capture suit.
56 January 2013 American Cinematographer
between takes to describe the key differ-
ence between 24-fps 3-D and 48-fps
3-D: [With 24-fps 3-D,] the conver-
gence point is usually on the subject, but
the viewer remains aware of the envi-
ronment in the background and fore-
ground, and the brain subconsciously
attempts to fuse these two images
together while viewing the focused
subject. This is a major reason for
discomfort. By contrast, the smooth
motion-effect of 48-fps 3-D provides
for a much more comfortable and
appealing viewing experience; the lack
of strobing and movement artifacts
helps the viewer relax into a more
immersive experience. This meant I
could concentrate on creating shape in
the scene knowing that many of the
surrounding discomfort cues were all
but negated. The 3-D eye fatigue is
minimized without sacrificing depth.
Bilbos story begins at Bag End,
where the Hobbits peaceful life is shat-
tered by 13 rambunctious dwarves and
a wizard. Whats great about Bag End
is you meet every pivotal character thats
going on the quest, but whats not so
great is that they were all stuffed into
one set! laughs Lesnie. Even if youre
jammed in a closet, if its the shot you
need to tell the story, you just have to
work out how to light it. Finding hidey-
holes for small lighting units was a big
deal in Bag Ends curved wooden
tunnels.
A variety of Kino Flos, zip lights
and 1K nook lights from low angles
created the impression of candlelight
and firelight. A lot of the newer units
dont have the throw compared to a 1K
nook light, Lesnie observes. At the
same time, I wanted to maintain mood
and shape, keeping the blacks and
whites clean and the warmth in the mid-
tones. I also didnt want any extraneous
light because the combination of 3-D, a
5K sensor and 48 fps required so much
attention to detail.
As the night deepens and the
mood becomes somber, talk turns to the
dangerous journey, which will take the
characters through dark forests and over
inhospitable mountains. The banquet
at which the dwarves eat and drink
Bilbo out of house and home is high key,
but when the tone becomes serious, I
transition to lighting from low angles to
create a clandestine and covert feel,
Lesnie explains. But because there was
a large dining table and 15 characters
An Unlikely Hero
Top: CG technology was used to create trolls William, Tom and Bert (performed by Peter Hambleton,
Mark Hadlow and William Kircher), who fancy a spit-roasted feast. Bottom: A view of the set on a
greenscreen stage.
angenieux@tccus.coms www.angenieux.com
With the range of 16mm to 80mm at T:2.8, Optimo DP
series zooms are lightweight and feature Angenieuxs
exclusive guiding mechanism and high quality glass, all at
a cost effective price. Theyre a perfect choice for todays
large format digital cameras and variety of applications
including hand-held, steadicam and 3D productions.
t he r t of di g i t al opt i c s
58 January 2013 American Cinematographer
with their backs to the walls, the only
way to get from one end of the room to
the other was an undignified crawl
down the table! Removing the ceiling
allowed four Source Four Lekos to be
positioned overhead to create a strong
bounce off the table. Lesnie notes, I
have a great relationship with our visual-
effects supervisor, Eric Saindon, and he
was very supportive of my ideas for the
look of sequences. Knowing that the
banquet would be filmed with slave mo-
co rigs, and that most of the shots would
be visual effects, I bounced light off the
table to create the right mood. The art
direction that was overexposed was digi-
tally restored; some props and table-
cloths had burned out.
Not only did the Bag End scenes
require complex lighting, but there was
also the issue of scale namely, how to
make Bilbo and the dwarves appear
smaller than Gandalf (Ian McKellen).
Motion-control supervisor Alex Funke,
ASC says, Peter requested a scaled,
slaved motion-control system that was
silent, fast and, most important, able to
film all the actors in the scene at the
same time. Development of this system
continued right up until shooting
started. (General Lift in El Segundo,
Calif., was the principal contractor for
the system.)
Funke defines scaled motion-
control as a dual-camera, real-time
process to create a complete scene in
which the apparent sizes of characters
have been changed. Achieving this
required key grip Tony Keddy to set up
a greenscreen stage, with details scaled
up or down to provide the apparent size
difference, near the live-action set. The
actors playing the dwarves and Hobbit
were on the Bag End set, which was
built at the Hobbit-world scale, while
McKellen was placed in the small-scale
greenscreen set. The crane on the Bag
End set was operated as normal. Kuper
motion-control software took the
encoded positional data from the crane
move, creating a scaled-down but
geometrically identical move that was
sent to the slaved crane, which
performed in sync simultaneously. The
scaled move, coupled with the camera
on the slaved crane, which was propor-
tionally closer to McKellen, resulted in
Gandalf appearing larger than the other
characters.
To assist McKellen with the
complexity of 14 different eyelines, 2nd
AD Emma Cross devised a simple but
effective system. Photos of each charac-
ter were attached to light bulbs, which
were then positioned in the appropriate
eyelines around McKellen. The bulbs
were individually wired to a control box,
and when an actor on the actual set
spoke, his corresponding photo would
light up.
Scaled motion control provided
for instantaneous changes to any aspect
of the scene, including eyelines, perfor-
An Unlikely Hero
Closer views of the trolls at their campsite.
60 January 2013 American Cinematographer
mance, lenses and composition. With
the use of a specialized video assist
developed by Glenn Anderson, Jackson
and Lesnie could see a real-time
composite of the entire scene with the
scales exactly represented in stereo.
Funke reports that the director
and cinematographer deliberately
designed complex master shots with the
dwarves, Bilbo and Gandalf to persuade
the audience to easily accept the scale
relationships. Other shots in the scene
that were created with more rudimen-
tary techniques, such as using scale
doubles, or by putting one actor on a
riser, then went unnoticed.
For sets constructed in the studios
at Stone Street, Lesnie decided to create
ambience with Kino Flo Image 85s,
which were rigged under the gantries
for easy access, rather than space lights.
One of the main reasons for using
Images 85s was the comfort of the actors
playing the dwarves, notes gaffer Reg
Garside. Although they wore cooling
vests under their fat suits, prosthetics and
heavy costumes, they could have become
dangerously overheated under space
lights. The Image 85s also put out more
light, used less cabling and consumed
less power. In the long run, it was a
cheaper system. Each unit contained
four tungsten and four daylight tubes,
dubbed fruit salad, allowing quick
changes from day to dusk, morning, late
afternoon or night scenes. The 1,000-
plus Image 85s spread across several
studios were all DMX-controlled.
Garside also built G-Lights four
Image 85s banked together and run
through 9'x6' frames of Silent Grid
for soft fill.
For a sequence in which the
dwarves and Hobbit get caught up in a
boulder-throwing, lightning-inducing
game between rock giants in the Misty
Mountains, Garside operated Lightning
Strikes, while Image 85s were used to
create the effect of sheet lightning. Board
operator Reuben Morrison assigned
groups of Image 85s to flash keys, creat-
ing six minutes of random patterns that
were then looped and recorded to disc.
The Kinos flick on at 50 percent on the
dimmer, which suited the look perfectly,
explains Morrison. We essentially
An Unlikely Hero
Top: Bilbo takes in the sights along his path. Bottom: Middle-Earth sculptures adorn a greenscreen stage.
62 January 2013 American Cinematographer
dissolve between one tube at a time, so
the ambience shifts without being too
apparent. We can also fade between
whole sections, so the backlight moves
around with the shot.
During their journey, the
company comes upon a hoard of treasure
and weapons stashed in a troll cave. The
cave entrance was lit as white but not
cool daylight, and as Thorin led the way
in with a flaming torch, Lesnie faded up
ground rows placed around the set. The
ground rows have a very low profile, and
four 1K bulbs in each unit meant that we
could gel them with various levels of
CTO and have them flickering to keep
the flame effect alive in the cave, he
says. We also had some Kinos as
extremely low ambience.
One of the items found in the
cave is Sting, the small sword Bilbo gives
to Frodo in The Fellowship of the Ring.
The blade glows blue when goblins or
Orcs are nearby, and for this effect,
Lesnie sought to use as much interactive
light as possible. Practical electrician
Rick Pease designed Sting Mark 2 to
generate its own light. A Kino tube plas-
tic housing cut to size contained a tightly
packed spiral of 5600K LED tape lights
that threw out a strong level of light. The
color was altered as desired by gel
sleeves, and a battery and wireless
An Unlikely Hero
Top: The crew sets
up a complex
move. Middle:
Bilbo makes his
way across a
rickety bridge.
Bottom: The
bridge setting
onstage.
control were built into the hilt, enabling
the sword to be turned on and off or
dimmed as required. (Pease also created
LED versions of Gandalf s staff crystal
and the famed Arkenstone jewel.)
The companys penchant for
landing in tight spots is again demon-
strated when they find themselves
stranded high in pine trees circled by
slavering wargs. Gandalf s response is to
arm the company with flaming
pinecones and bombard the creatures, a
tactic that sets fire to the surrounding
flora and further endangers the
company. The CG pinecones were
created by Weta Digital, and for the
interactive light that was needed on set,
Pease created wireless, battery-powered
pinecones out of conical, plastic spray
bottles purchased at a discount shop.
With the trigger mechanism removed,
the bottle was packed with a wireless
receiver, and AA batteries powering
LED tape lights wound around the
outside. Each LED was daubed with
heat-resistant orange paint for a warm
color temperature. During the scene,
the actors threw the cones with much
gusto, while down below, the crew
valiantly attempted to catch as many as
possible, Lesnie chuckles. It was a
sight to behold.
The productions largest set was
the forest home of Radagast the Brown
(Sylvester McCoy), a wizard who is at
one with the natural world and cares for
the flora and fauna of Middle Earth. In
a high-speed chase sequence filmed on
the set, he escapes from The
Necromancers fortress of Dol Guldur
on a sleigh pulled by large rabbits. At
400 feet long, Radagasts forest set was
much bigger than any of our stages, so it
was built in an old car factory outside
Wellington, says Lesnie. For ambi-
ence, Reg rigged space lights down the
length of the set. I wanted a strong
An Unlikely Hero
64
Fearsome goblins spring into action.
dappled effect of the sun penetrating
through gaps in the forest canopy, so we
ran 18Ks, 4K Molebeams, and 4K and
7K Xenons down one side of the set
aimed back through camouflage
netting, creating fractured beams of
light.
Smoke, which is not ideal for
either CG effects or 3-D, was also
added. The smoke, which was
augmented by Weta Digital, was put in
so the chase would repeatedly go
through bright beams into quite deep
shade, accentuating the impression of
speed, says the cinematographer.
The second unit, under Richard
Bluck with gaffer Giles Coburn, also
undertook a large section of the chase
sequence. Key grip Jay Munro mounted
Flight Heads operated by Peter
McCaffrey on Polaris six-wheelers and
tracking vehicles.
When AC visited Park Road
Post, senior colorist David Hollings-
worth explained, SGOs Mistika was
used for alignment, color grading and
dual-stream playback for our tri-weekly
3-D 48-fps screenings. The Mistika has
very strong stereoscopic tools, and we
worked with SGO to expand the color-
grading toolset to give us maximum
control of the image while operating in
real time at dual-stream 48 fps. Head
of technology Phil Oatley added,
Removing the artifacts of 24 fps and
shooting at 48 fps improves the viewing
experience with more clarity and
temporal resolution. There are only
advantages to combining a higher frame
rate and 3-D.
Throughout the shoot, Park
Road Post received 6-8 TB of data each
day; this was sent directly from Stone
Street Studios via fiberoptic links.
During the location period of principal
photography, LTO tapes were the
normal delivery method.
Regarding the final color timing,
Lesnie acknowledges that he has a
certain mandate to remain faithful to
LED Conversion Filter Tungsten Cool White LED
622
624
626
628
LED Con
nversion Filte
O Digital LED CT TO
One and One Eighth
622
O LED CT TO
ull Digital F
624
.leelter www
O Digital LED CT
en Eighths v Se
626
s.com .leelter
O Digital LED CT
ter ee Quar Thr
628
the look of Middle Earth we created on
film for Lord of the Rings. The 48-fps
picture is so clear and sharp, I tended to
light more gently. To maintain the look
he established on 35mm, he continues,
he and the grading team have softened
the curve of the Epics footage, rolling
off the shadows and highlights as well as
providing for a gentle, textural finish.
65
TECHNICAL SPECS
2.40:1
3-D Digital Capture
Red Epic M
Zeiss Ultra Prime,
Angenieux Optimo
66 January 2013 American Cinematographer
A Musical
Revolution
www.theasc.com January 2013 67
P
h
o
t
o
s
b
y
L
a
u
r
i
e
S
p
a
r
h
a
m
a
n
d
J
a
m
e
s
F
i
s
h
e
r
.
A
l
l
i
m
a
g
e
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
U
n
i
v
e
r
s
a
l
P
i
c
t
u
r
e
s
.
Danny Cohen, BSC
reteams with director
Tom Hooper on Les
Misrables, a grand
adaptation of the
Broadway sensation.
By John Calhoun
|
V
ictor Hugos epic novel Les
Misrables has been filmed at least
two dozen times, but it has taken
more than 30 years for the wildly
successful Broadway-musical adapta-
tion of his story to reach movie screens,
which finally happened last month. In
making the picture, director Tom
Hooper chose a daunting project for his
follow-up to The Kings Speech (AC Jan.
11). Cinematographer Danny Cohen,
BSC, who earned ASC and Oscar
nominations for The Kings Speech and
eagerly reteamed with Hooper on Les
Misrables, describes some of the chal-
lenges: This is a movie of a musical
thats been seen by 60 million people, so
its got that heritage. The musical
condensed Hugos thousand-plus-page
novel into a three-hour running time,
and the film had to be shorter than that.
So instantly, youve got to decide how to
strip the story down to the most impor-
tant stuff. I think what interested Tom
the most was the prospect of making it
as real as possible. Its a story about
social issues wealth, revolution and
social change but the story is told
through song. People dont talk to each
other; they sing to each other. By
making it as naturalistic as possible, we
thought the fact that everybodys
singing wouldnt create a wall between
the story and the audience.
All of my work to date has been
governed by almost obsessive levels of
cinematic realism, says Hooper, whose
credits also include The Damned United
(shot by Ben Smithard; AC Nov. 09)
Opposite: Inspector
Javert (Russell Crowe)
rides through Paris in Les
Misrables, directed by
Tom Hooper. This page,
top and middle: Jean
Valjean (Hugh Jackman)
takes pity on Fantine
(Anne Hathaway) and
her daughter, Cosette
(Amanda Seyfried).
Bottom:
Cinematographer Danny
Cohen, BSC keeps his
balance while taking a
meter reading in the
Parisian sewer set.
68 January 2013 American Cinematographer
A Musical Revolution
and the telefilm John Adams (shot by
Cohen and Tak Fujimoto, ASC). I did
wonder whether the form of the
through-sung musical would give me
permission to loosen some of the some-
times-rigid constraints of being a realist;
yet, at the same time, I felt very much
that the key to making a musical work is
to ground it in the real world. That
tension between the desire to make it
feel compellingly real and the desire to
be more of an expressionist in some
choices was a key dynamic that I navi-
gated with Danny in the shooting.
Published in 1862 as a five-
volume work, Hugos novel has many
characters and plotlines, but its main
protagonist is Jean Valjean, a reformed
thief who is pursued for years by the
relentless Inspector Javert. Opening in
1815 and culminating with the Paris
uprising of anti-monarchists in 1832,
the novel is substantially set amidst
poverty, in grim streets and sewers with
stronger ties to medieval Paris than to
the modern city. Despite its beautiful
score, the Claude-Michel Schnberg-
Alain Boublil musical attempted to
preserve that grittiness, and so does the
film. As the title suggests, its not an easy
ride, says Cohen.
One of the major choices the film-
makers had to make was how to handle
the unique demands of narrative song,
and they chose a highly unusual
approach. Instead of recording music
tracks before the shoot and having the
actors lip-sync their songs during the
shoot, Hooper had the actors includ-
ing Hugh Jackman (Valjean), Russell
Crowe ( Javert), Anne Hathaway
(Fantine) and Amanda Seyfried
(Fantines daughter, Cosette) record
their numbers live on set. We did a few
tests early in prep where we shot a song
to playback and then shot it to live
music, and the difference in impact was
massive, says Cohen. You just get so
much more emotion from the live
performance.
But this choice had ramifications
that trickled down through the entire
production. Every take became a gig,
says Cohen, and anything the camera
crew could do to make the music and
song work was key, really. This led to the
consistent use of three cameras, often
handheld, to capture the action, and to
the practice of shooting entire sequences
without cutting. We didnt want to
sacrifice a good performance to some-
thing technical, explains the cinematog-
rapher. The idea of doing long takes and
working handheld was about creating
maximum flexibility so we could go with
what happened in the song. We didnt
want to tell the actor, You have to be on
this mark and in this light.
This kind of freedom meant that
the performers, who were accompanied
by a live piano on set, could vary tempos
between takes. Early on, recalls
Hooper, my musical supervisors pointed
out that if each take was a different
Top: Early in the film, an imprisoned Valjean endures his sentence of hard labor. Bottom: The sequence
was filmed in a dry dock in Portsmouth.
www.theasc.com January 2013 69
tempo, I couldnt necessarily cut one
take with another. Adds Cohen, The
beauty of having three cameras on the
main unit was that every single take was
treated as a live performance. We could
get the coverage in as few takes as possi-
ble. Hooper says that in Hathaways
number I Dreamed a Dream, for
example, We did six takes, and each of
those six takes could have been the one.
It honored the live performance,
because it was likely wed pick one
particular take all the way through.
Prep was vitally important. The
rehearsal period stretched over several
months, and Cohen was there most of
the time partly so I could sit in on
rehearsal and get an idea of how things
were blocked out. This definitely fed
into the set designs and the lighting
designs; for example, we knew that at a
certain point in a certain song, a shaft of
light would come through the window.
A-camera/Steadicam operator Zac
Nicholson also sat in on rehearsals,
learning the songs so as to coordinate
many of his moves with the musics
time signature.
But part of the prep, naturally,
involved normal cinematography
duties, like choosing a format. We
started out testing 3-D with the idea
that it might help create the sensation of
a live performance, Cohen recalls, but
in the end, 3-D fell by the wayside
because of the scale of the film. We had
to use three cameras in spaces that were
quite small, so the logistics didnt quite
add up. Also, we found that when
people have their mouths open for a fair
amount of time onscreen in 3-D, it
really feels like youre going to disappear
down into their stomachs!
The filmmakers also tested
65mm, but that was rejected as too
expensive, particularly for a multi-
camera shoot. Spherical and anamor-
phic 35mm were also tested, as was
digital capture with the Arri Alexa.
Anamorphic was rejected partly
because of Hoopers propensity for
using wide lenses and the close focus he
likes to achieve. Also, says Cohen, We
decided to go for a 1.85:1 aspect ratio
Top: The crew films
Jackman outside of
a church in
Oxfordshire as the
actor performs
Valjeans
Soliloquy. Middle:
The song continues
as Valjean
determines to
break his parole
and make a new
life for himself in
Paris. Bottom: Years
later, Javert catches
up with the
reformed Valjean.
70 January 2013 American Cinematographer
because a lot of our locations had great
ceilings. Why throw that away?
So it came down to digital vs.
3-perf Super 35mm. In the end, we
decided that for a period film, the sharp-
ness of digital was not ideal, Cohen
says. We could have done something
about that in post, but our release date
had already been set, and there wasnt a
huge amount of time [for post]. The
more we could do in-camera, the better.
So film was the best option.
Hooper agrees that speed and
economy were key considerations, but
notes, The other reason I chose film is
that it matters hugely to me that I have
latitude in the capture. On location, I
didnt want to deal with digital burnt-
out skies, and in candlelit situations, I
didnt want the flames clipping out.
Cohen used four Kodak film
stocks: Vision2 50D 5201 and Vision3
250D 5207 for day exteriors on location,
Vision3 200T 5213 for night exteriors
on location and some studio day exteri-
ors, and Vision3 500T 5219 for most
studio work. Production started with an
Arricam Studio as the A camera and
Arricam Lites as the B and C cameras,
but as the shoot progressed, the A-
camera operator often switched to the
Lite as well. Handheld is just easier
with the LT, Cohen observes. On top
of that, when three camerapeople are
working in a small space, they can fit
easier if theyve all got the cameras on
their shoulders. He adds that the movie
has its share of Steadicam, dolly and
crane shots, and a number of compli-
cated setups, such as the opening
sequence, shot in a Portsmouth dry
dock, which involved a hydroscope
crane and underwater camerawork.
Overall, though, handheld
cameras and wide lenses were judged to
serve the narrative best. I didnt want to
abstract the characters from their envi-
ronments when they were singing,
Hooper explains. So we generally shot
close-ups on shorter prime lenses the
25mm, 27mm or 32mm. A full range
of Arri/Zeiss Master Primes was
employed, as were 17-80mm and 24-
290mm Angenieux Optimo zooms. But
A Musical Revolution
Top: When
Fantines
coworkers
discover she has
an illegitimate
child, they
demand she be
thrown out of the
factory in disgrace.
Middle:
A-camera/
Steadicam
operator Zac
Nicholson frames
the action as A-
camera 1st AC
Peter Byrne (in
plaid shirt) keeps
it in focus. Bottom:
Fantine reflects on
her tragic position
in the song I
Dreamed a
Dream.
72 January 2013 American Cinematographer
A Musical Revolution
the A camera generally stayed wide.
Its weird, in a sense, not to be back on
long lenses making everything feel
fantastically beautiful, with soft back-
grounds, when people are singing, says
Cohen. But it just felt like the way to
tell this story was to be right there in
peoples faces, getting every bit of
emotion and energy in frame.
A-camera focus puller Peter
Byrne notes that the close-in camera
style was sometimes problematic
because camera noise could interfere
with the live recordings of the songs. He
recalls, I asked the tech at Arri, Andy
Taylor, to go through all the LTs and
STs to find the quietest ones. Once they
did, they tweaked them to make them
even quieter. In testing, we went a step
further and covered the camera bodies
in Tesa foam tape. Our sound recordist,
Simon Hayes, is a double black belt in
Jiu-Jitsu, so I knew it was in my interest
to do so!
The problem was amplified
during shooting of On My Own,
sung by ponine (Samantha Barks) in
the rain. There was polyethylene cover-
ing the camera and plastic rain gear on
the crew. All they could hear was the
sound of the rain on our waterproofs,
says Nicholson. We ended up wearing
white sheets, and Danny used us for a
bit of bounce as well!
The crew became quite adept at
disguising the cameras, as well as them-
selves. Because we shot three cameras
the whole time, we were often getting in
each others shots, says Byrne. Wed be
halfway through the shot, and Tom
would say, We can see the B camera.
Maybe you should just put a costume
on. From that moment on, the
wardrobe department would bring us
our long coats and hats in the morning,
and when we were outside, wed use a
roll of brown waxed cotton to cover the
camera instead of plastic. Though these
tactics helped hide the cameras and crew
during long takes on sequences like a
melee involving several hundred extras,
the costumes occasionally caused some
confusion. Halfway through take two,
when the students were throwing tables
and chairs out of windows and everyone
was running around shouting, I
suddenly realized the man I was running
next to wasnt my operator, says Byrne,
who was using a Preston remote focus
system. We were all dressed up so well
that Id lost him! There was nothing to
do but put the lens at 6 feet and hope for
the best.
The production was a roughly 50-
50 split between stages at Pinewood
Studios and locations in England. We
ended up doing just a weeks shoot in
France, says Cohen. There are almost
no medieval buildings left in Paris. The
filmmakers also wanted the control the
studio would facilitate, particularly for
large-scale setpieces like soldiers storm-
ing the barricades erected by students in
the streets.
That climactic sequence, along
with much of the other studio work, was
shot on the brand-new T stage at
Pinewood, a 200'-long, 50'-high space
that was filled with production designer
Eve Stewarts detailed 19th-century
Parisian street set. It was built diago-
nally across the studio and went all the
way up to the ceiling, says Cohen. It
was redressed for different periods and
lit for every possible lighting situation.
Lighting was facilitated by Caf de
Lumiere (formerly Light by Numbers),
a remotely operated lighting-control
system that was used to control 350
overhead space lights and at least a
Above: The
Greenwich Naval
College doubled for
the Place de la
Bastille. Right:
Nicholson and Byrne
show off some of
the period garb
they wore in case
they were caught
in another
cameras frame.
T
o
p
i
m
a
g
e
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
D
o
u
b
l
e
N
e
g
a
t
i
v
e
a
n
d
U
n
i
v
e
r
s
a
l
P
i
c
t
u
r
e
s
.
B
o
t
t
o
m
p
h
o
t
o
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
Z
a
c
N
i
c
h
o
l
s
o
n
.
74 January 2013 American Cinematographer
dozen 24-light Dinos installed on the
stage. The system included roughly 900
2.5K and 150 5K dimmer channels and
could be run remotely from anywhere
on the stage by owner/operator Chris
Gilbertson, under the supervision of
Cohen and gaffer Paul McGeachan. I
could stand next to Paul and Chris and
say, I want those 50 space lights at 50
percent, that chunk at 10 percent, and
now bring up the Dinos , says
Cohen. Anything I could visualize,
Chris could literally do at the press of a
button. We could go from day to night
in seconds.
Id do a plan, and Chris would
do a CAD drawing with all the channel
numbers, explains McGeachan. Chris
could just walk around beside me with
his remote and tap in the numbers.
During the storming-of-the-barricades
sequence, which starts at dusk and
moves through night and into day,
Gilbertsons system was employed to
make changes nearly effortlessly. A
sunrise sequence was created with four
24-light Maxi-Brutes rigged up on a
gantry, some with spot bulbs and some
with wide bulbs, run at 35 to 40
percent, says McGeachan. The sun
covered the whole length of the street.
Cohen adds, We could create a cloud
rolling across the sun by fading the space
lights and then bringing up a big Dino.
The set also included the interiors
of spaces, such as the caf at the end of
the street. Because these interiors had
ceilings, lights had to be hidden in the
set to suggest period illumination, which
in the early 19th century would have
been confined to torches, candles and
other fire sources. On night exteriors in
the studio, says Cohen, it was basically
a few lanterns knocking around and
some space lights. The darkness defi-
nitely adds to the feel of the period, and
it also helps create mood, especially
when the soldiers assault the students
its a firefight in the darkness.
In the caf, says McGeachan,
There is a big fight sequence, and
action was running up and down stairs,
so there were cameras upstairs, down-
stairs and on the stairs. To light that, we
used about 40 No. 1 275-watt
Photofloods that we hid in the thick
beams on the ceiling and softened with
spun. Where we could, we hid Chinese
lanterns on the floor.
During this sequence and the
storming of the barricades, the three
camera crews were plunged into the
action, covering as much as possible
with the handheld LTs. As the soldiers
were advancing, we did a few takes from
behind and in front, traveling with them
and in different directions, Nicholson
recalls. A lot of it was quite freeform
and very different every time. By
contrast, a sequence that follows Javert
picking his way through the length of
the street and the resulting carnage was
A Musical Revolution
Top: Hooper surveys a scene on the massive T stage at Pinewood Studios; behind him, Cohen checks
the light on a fallen soldier. Bottom: A crane arm extends down the stagebound street to capture an
angle during the storming-of-the-barricades sequence.
Film & Digital ARGO-ing Together!
Michael Condon, SOC
VP Digital Division
Andree Martin
VP Technical Services
Film and Digital do go together; just ask Rodrigo Prieto, ASC, AMC.
For shooting Argo, Rodrigo chose Clairmont Camera to fulfill his
diversified camera needs. Rodrigos extensive package included
Arricams in both 4-perf and 2-perf configuration, Arri BL4 2-perf, Arri
435 2-perf, Arri 235, Alexa Plus, and a wide assortment of anamorphic
and spherical lenses. Kudos to Rodrigo and his creativity; thank you for
choosing our tools!
www.clairmont.com
a Steadicam shot, a kind of calm after
the storm.
Locations included Greenwich
Naval College, where an exterior space
doubled for the Place de la Bastille;
14th-century buildings at Winchester
College, which were lit with 4K Lunix
balloons, four Genie booms, three
Spiders with 10Ks and ulcers (a.k.a.
large gobos), and a cherry picker with
two Wendy Lights; and interiors and
exteriors at Boughton Hall, an English
country mansion where several
sequences were shot, including the
Beggars at the Feast number. After
shooting at these sites, the production
returned to Pinewood, where T stage
had been remade into the Thnardiers
inn (where Master of the House is
performed) and a nighttime frost fair
exterior. Balancing the cold night exte-
riors in the snow with the warmth of the
tavern has been quite fun, says Cohen,
who was in the midst of the final 2K
digital grade at Londons Company 3
when he spoke to AC. Cohen and
colorist Adam Glasman were pushing
the look into a realm I dont think youd
associate with a musical, says the cine-
matographer. Its quite rough-and-
ready, messy and grungy.
In the number Lovely Ladies,
shot on Pinewoods M stage, even
Hathaways beauty is dimmed down.
She looks amazing at the beginning of
the film, but not for very long, because
Fantine is a fallen woman, and she falls
quite a long way, says Cohen. By the
time shes on the Lovely Ladies dock-
yard set, shes had her hair shaved off,
and shes incredibly gaunt.
A Musical Revolution
Cohen takes
stock of the set
on T stage. It
was built
diagonally
across the
studio and went
all the way up
to the ceiling,
he explains. It
was redressed
for different
periods and lit
for every
possible lighting
situation.
76
And, of course, a long sequence
toward the end of the drama occurs in
the Paris sewer system. Built onstage
from the template of a Victorian-era
London aquifer, this set had the tiniest
bit of lighting from overhead Par cans
and angled 1Ks bounced into the brack-
ish water for a ripple effect.
The thematic importance of light
touching the characters at certain
moments is crucial, notes Hooper.
Danny and I were fascinated by the
idea that light represents the presence of
God, he says. The existence of God is
presumed by all the characters, and a lot
of the songs I chose to stage as sort of
prayers, which contextualizes why
people are singing alone. I thought a lot
about the paintings of Turner, where
the presence of something greater than
us is represented by rays coming down
from an extraordinary sky. In this
framework, light anoints the charac-
ters, and puts them in contact with the
sublime, he says.
Cohen observes that light has the
same function in Hugos novel, wherein
its not passive, but brings power and
emotion to the story. This is preserved
to a great extent in the motion picture,
especially in Valjeans Soliloquy,
which is a moment of self-realization
and conversion for the character. The
song starts in a church interior (shot on
location in London), proceeds to the
church exterior (a location in
Oxfordshire), and culminates with
Jackman on a French Alp,
photographed by a handheld camera.
We were going to do the shot with a
Technocrane, recalls Cohen, but on
the day, we kind of turned it on its head
and ended up doing it handheld. The
camera operator leads him out of the
church, jumps onto a crane that pulls
back, and then heads towards the heav-
ens, towards the sun.
TECHNICAL SPECS
Super 1.85:1
3-perf Super 35mm
Arricam Studio, Lite
Arri/Zeiss Master Prime,
Angenieux Optimo
Kodak Vision2 50D 5201;
Vision3 250D 5207,
200T 5213, 500T 5219
Digital Intermediate
77
Hitchcock, based on Stephen Rebellos book Alfred Hitchcock
and the Making of Psycho, tells the story of the production and
chronicles some behind-the-scenes drama involving
Hitchcock (Anthony Hopkins) and his wife, Alma (Helen
Mirren).
Director Sacha Gervasi, a documentary filmmaker
(Anvil: The Story of Anvil) making his first foray into drama-
78 January 2013 American Cinematographer
A
lfred Hitchcocks Psycho (1960) was the directors most
commercially successful film, but also one of the most
difficult for him to make. Studios refused to finance it, so
he paid for it himself, using the crew from his television
show, Alfred Hitchcock Presents, to shoot quickly and inexpen-
sively. He also chose to shoot black-and-white, even though
color had been in vogue for more than a decade. The new film
An Auteurs
Angst
Hitchcock, shot by Jeff Cronenweth, ASC,
dramatizes the pressures the filmmaker endured
on and off the set while making Psycho.
By Jay Holben
|
www.theasc.com January 2013 79
tization, teamed with Jeff Cronenweth,
ASC to make Hitchcock. Cronenweth
recalls that when he first heard about
the project, I was working on commer-
cials and actually wasnt looking to do
another feature so soon, but my agent
sent me the script. It was so well writ-
ten, and Sacha had lined up such a great
cast, that I decided to meet with him
and see what it was all about. I was so
taken by Sachas passion and his intu-
ition about the script that I was inspired
to shoot the film. The fact that we
would be shooting in L.A. on a short
schedule made my decision that much
easier!
Much like Psycho, Hitchcock was
shot quickly, in 35 days, on a modest
budget. Initially, Gervasi was keen to
shoot 35mm, but after testing film and
digital workflows, production deter-
mined that digital capture would yield
considerable financial savings. Digital
was a real lifesaver for our budget,
says Cronenweth. However, Fox
Searchlight and Montecito [Picture
Co.] had never financed a digital
feature, and they were both a little
nervous about it.
In addition to the financial
considerations, I pointed out that this
was Sachas first feature, and we were
going to be shooting very quickly, he
continues. I thought digital would be
extremely beneficial in streamlining our
decisions on the set, because Sacha
would be able to see exactly what we
were getting on the monitor.
I also made the argument that
Hitchcock embraced new technology,
and I presume he would have been an
early adopter of digital because he
would have seen it as an exciting new
tool for storytelling.
Cronenweth chose the Red Epic,
which he had used on a number of
commercials and on part of David
Finchers The Girl with the Dragon
Tattoo (AC Jan. 12). I framed Hitchcock
in 2.40:1 to create that Scope feel, but
without using anamorphic lenses. We
cropped 2.40:1 out of a 4K frame within
the 5K chip to give ourselves a little
room for repositioning and stabiliza- U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
b
y
S
u
z
a
n
n
e
T
e
n
n
e
r
,
S
M
P
S
P
,
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
F
o
x
S
e
a
r
c
h
l
i
g
h
t
.
Opposite page:
Legendary
director Alfred
Hitchcock
(Anthony
Hopkins)
addresses
viewers during
the opening
scene of
Hitchcock. This
page, top:
Director Sacha
Gervasi and
Hopkins analyze
the Master of
Suspense.
Bottom: Jeff
Cronenweth,
ASC (wearing
glasses) eyes a
setup while
camera operator
Dan
McDonough
checks the
frame.
tion. The release was made from a 2K
file. He teamed the Epic with Zeiss
Ultra Primes. I thought some slightly
older glass, with older coatings, would
help with the period look and the pros-
thetic makeup, which was extensive on
Anthony, he explains. The Ultra
Primes are a little softer [than Master
Primes], and they tend to pick up more
flares.
Prosthetics are always a chal-
lenge, especially when youre working
quickly and dont have the budget for a
lot of time in post, he continues. I
knew we would have to spend a certain
amount of time in the DI smoothing
out issues with the prosthetics that just
couldnt be fixed on set. That isnt to say
that [makeup artists] Howard Berger
and Julie Hewett and their respective
teams did a bad job. On the contrary,
they did phenomenal work, but there are
always some issues with prosthetics that
have to be fixed in post. There are always
changes in texture over time on the day,
and you have to blend lines [between the
prosthetic and the actors skin] that
become more noticeable as the day goes
on.
To help hide some of these
imperfections, Cronenweth chose to
capture a more compressed image.
After a lot of testing, we decided to
shoot at 6:1 compression [instead of 5:1,
the Epics lowest compression rate].
Left, top to bottom: Hitchcock responds to author
Robert Blochs horror novel Psycho; the directors
wife, Alma (Helen Mirren), is less enthused; Alma
enjoys a friendly flirtation with her writer friend
Whitfield Cook (Danny Huston). Top right:
Cronenweth and Gervasi confer between takes.
80 January 2013 American Cinematographer
An Auteurs Angst
www.theasc.com January 2013 81
That slight additional compression
actually helped to soften the image
details and smooth out the imperfec-
tions a bit. In addition, I decided to use
[Schneider] Classic Soft Frost on
the lens most of the time. I typically
dont use any diffusion on the lens at
all; I tend to wait till post to decide
whether something is too sharp. But
we couldnt spend a lifetime in post.
Psycho was shot in 1959-60, and
to help suggest the period, the film-
makers strove to tailor their camera-
work to the era. We tried to stay with
[camera] moves that were possible
within that world, says Cronenweth.
To that end, we tried to stay away
from using Steadicam for most of the
movie and kept the moves as classical
as we could. Theres a lot of dialogue in
the film, not a lot of action, so we tried
to impart some energy through move-
ment and create coverage with camera
moves rather than separate shots.
Of course, when youre making
a movie about one of filmmakings
pioneers, its very tempting to steal
some of his concepts, he continues,
but we decided that we would only
tip our hat a couple of times. Viewers
who are looking for it will appreciate
those moments. One such shot
evokes the famous crane shot in
Notorious that ends in a close-up of
Ingrid Bergmans hand holding a key.
In Hitchcock, the director is haunted by
dreams of serial killer Ed Gein
(Michael Wincott), who presents
himself as Hitchcocks conscience.
When the filmmaker begins to suspect
that his wife is having an affair with a
novelist, Whitfield Cook (Danny
Huston), Gein points Hitchcock
toward evidence that confirms his
suspicions. The moment of discovery
is presented in a sweeping shot from a
high over-the-shoulder to a macro
close-up of the evidence.
Similarly, when Hitchcock
makes a phone call to Cooks cottage,
a shot reveals Cook and Alma outside
on the porch facing the beach, with
the ringing phone framed large in the
foreground. Its a classic Hitchcockian
Top: As crewmembers dress a Bates Motel interior set, Hopkins chats with Scarlett Johansson
(portraying Janet Leigh) and James DArcy (as Anthony Perkins). Middle: Johansson and Jessica
Biel (playing Vera Miles) rehearse as Cronenweth (reflected in mirror) observes. Bottom: Water
heaters and a crane-mounted remote head were employed to re-create the filming of Psychos
infamous shower scene.
82 January 2013 American Cinematographer
shot that exaggerates the elements of
the narrative to emphasize an emotion.
Cronenweth used period-appro-
priate lighting fixtures as much as possi-
ble, but its really hard to find any
rationale for using arc lights today! he
notes with a laugh. Theyre hard to
maintain, theyre expensive and theyre
unreliable. I really couldnt justify going
that far. For the most part, I stuck with
tungsten fixtures, mainly Fresnels, units
that would have been used at that time.
The filmmakers also had to
tackle the challenge of re-creating a few
of Psychos key scenes. However, notes
Cronenweth, this movie was never
about replicating Psycho like, say, Gus
Van Sant did [with 1998s shot-for-shot
remake]. I was conscious of achieving
the same kind of feel as [Psycho] in my
lighting of the scene being shot, but
really, once you have your actors in
period makeup, period hair and period
wardrobe, and the set is dressed in a
period feel, there isnt much more you
have to do to re-create that look. In one
situation, it was really easy: when Vera
Miles [played by Jessica Biel] goes into
the basement to find Normans mother,
and the source is just a swinging light-
bulb no real challenge to match the
look and feel of the lighting there!
Some of the scenes in Psycho
have become so iconic, so seared into
peoples memories, that we had to get a
little closer to how they really look in
the film, he continues. I think the
closest we got in that respect was shoot-
ing Janet Leigh [played by Scarlett
Johansson] driving to the Bates Motel.
We replicated the rear-projection-
process scenes of her driving, and that
was fantastically fun. We used classic
projectors provided by [ASC associate]
Bill Hansard and acquired stock footage
of driving in the desert to play on the
screen. I tried to light Scarlett the same
way John Russell [ASC] had lit Janet
Leigh, and I ended up using a 1K
straight on. We cut off everything else,
making the hard beam very narrow; it
was pretty common back then to use
hard light in that manner. We used a
variety of 1Ks, 2Ks and 5Ks to light the
M
aking this movie was a rapid-fire
process. Our production schedule
was 35 days, and we went from the first
day of principal photography, on April
13, to locked, colored, scored and done
in six months. That only happens when
you get really lucky. We were on location
with two hours of prosthetics every day,
so it was very intense. But Hitchcock
only had 30 days or so to make Psycho,
with no money, and we were sort of in
the same position. If you want to make a
robot movie, they give you $100 million,
but if you want to do this kind of film,
they dont!
Fortunately, I came to this project
from a documentary that I made and
paid for myself [Anvil! The Story of
Anvil]. Obviously, a documentary is
different by its very nature because its a
real story, and production can unfold
over a couple of years. But in terms of the
energy of it, and the feeling you have to
create within your crew and around your
actors, its actually exactly the same.
Before starting Hitchcock, I thought, My
god, its such a big thing working with
actors, but after youve directed Lips
[Kudlow] and Robb [Reiner] from
Anvil, trust me, Tony Hopkins and
Helen Mirren are a walk in the park! It
was a madness making that film, just as
it was a madness making Hitchcock, but
in a good way, because creative people
thrive on that. Sometimes when youre
under pressure, you come up with your
best ideas. We were all in it together, and
no one was doing it for the money. We
were doing it because we loved the script,
we loved the subject, and we loved the
idea of telling a unique story about a
partnership in a marriage that no one
really knew about. We were trying to get
behind Hitchcocks mask. The notion of
doing a really emotional story about such
a central part of his life really intrigued
everyone.
Jeff Cronenweth [ASC] really
responded to the script, so we set up a
meeting. I had a very specific idea of
what I hoped the movie would look like
in my mind, it had three or four very
distinct visual worlds and Jeff brought
along some color references that
matched mine. So from our first meet-
ing, we were thinking about the film in
exactly the same way.
There is the world of the studio,
which is very lush, rich and romantic. To
Hitchcock, that was the only reality that
really mattered, so for him, it should be
the most exciting place to be. We
wanted to lend those scenes warmth,
scope, scale and color, and thematically
that approach worked well for the story
we were telling. Psycho was shot in black-
and-white, so showing that studio real-
ity in color created a really interesting
counterpoint.
Then we have the austere nature
of the Hitchcock home, which is a little
pocket of England in the middle of Bel
Air. Those scenes are very Merchant
Ivory, with dark wood, big staircases and
halls.
California during that era was
very distinct, so that became our third
[look]; we wanted to capture the purity
and the slightly surreal feel of the
California dream, with its beautiful blue
skies and sunlight. My references for
those scenes were movies like Betty Blue.
Finally, theres the world of the
serial killer Ed Gein. He represents
Hitchs dark side, so those scenes had to
be very moody and brooding.
From day one, Jeff and I agreed
we wanted a really dynamic range of
feeling in the film. This isnt just a movie
about Hitchcock making Psycho. Its
about his relationships with women, its
about his marriage, and its about his
obsessions. Above all, its about an artist
whos struggling and risking everything
in order to feel fully alive, not insulated
by his own success.
Sacha Gervasi
| Dramatizing the Master of Suspense |
An Auteurs Angst
www.theasc.com January 2013 83
stage, which we see around the car, and
we used a 2K as the projector light
behind the screen after the film loop
breaks, revealing Hitchs silhouette as he
walks by.
The shower scene was a whole
different beast. Because we shot in color
and Psycho is, of course, black-and-
white, theres a discernible difference in
the looks. Again, I just tried to emulate
the feel and let the actors, makeup and
set dressing sell the rest. Above the
shower, he bounced two Inkies into a
large beadboard that was further soft-
ened with a layer of Lee 129 Heavy
Frost. We also boxed [the beadboard]
in to keep the light off the walls. The
tiles of the shower were a much brighter
white than I hoped for, and Scarlett has
fairly pale skin. The two elements
together really lacked contrast, so the
toplight felt best.
I used a separate bounce source
when we turned around to see Hitch
sitting by the camera, and we used a Big
Eye 10K in the background to backlight
the stairs where the crew was standing.
Top: As Hitchcocks
stresses mount, his
dreams are invaded
by serial killer Ed
Gein (Michael
Wincott), the
real-life model for
Norman Bates.
Bottom left:
Hopkins and the
crew shoot scenes
in the Hitchcock
bedroom set built
on a Red Studios
soundstage in
Hollywood. Bottom
right: A bank of
fluorescents
illuminates a shot
of Gein in
Hitchcocks
bathroom.
84 January 2013 American Cinematographer
We also had some makeup mirrors and
smaller practical fixtures in the back-
ground to give some texture.
When Hitch comes to the
shower and starts working with the
knife, I used a covered wagon on the
floor to uplight him a bit. We used
[covered wagons] several times on this
show; theyre correct for the period,
they have the right kind of color and
tone, and theyre very convenient, espe-
cially in small locations. They also have
a great feel.
Hitchcocks shooting schedule was
divided among practical locations in
Pasadena, Altadena and Beverly Hills
and sets built at Red Studios in
Hollywood. Additionally, two movie
theaters in downtown Los Angeles
were tapped for scenes involving movie
premieres; the Orpheum stood in for
the theater that hosted the Chicago
premiere of North by Northwest, a scene
featured at the beginning of Hitchcock,
and the Palace Theatre served as the
host of Psychos L.A. premiere.
The production utilized a house
off Bellagio Road in Beverly Hills for
many scenes set in the Hitchcocks
home, making use of the kitchen,
breakfast nook and study. (The
bedroom and bathroom were both
constructed onstage.) The study was
an old-school, mahogany room with
lots of shelves and a big, mahogany
desk, says Cronenweth. Night scenes
in there were really a challenge. I had to
be careful not to overlight the actors but
still bring all that dark wood out of the
blackness. That particular palette
presents so much contrast, and we
werent onstage, where I could have just
brought in large, soft sources.
I also strangled myself a little bit
by always trying to combine several
shots into one, which makes lighting
more difficult, he adds. I ended up
using covered wagons for wider shots or
shots that had a lot of movement. We
tucked them high against the ceiling,
and we used practicals as accents
around the room. Then, I tried to clean
up the close-ups when I could.
After collaborating with Light
An Auteurs Angst
A lighting
diagram
illustrates the
crews approach
to a scene that
replicates the
rear-projection
process used for
Janet Leighs
driving sequences
in Psycho.
Introducing
The Cineex ELITE
YOU ASKED, WE LISTENED...
Combining the proven stability and versatility of Cineex camera systems with the image quality
of the ARRI ALEXA M camera, the Cineex ELITE allows Super 35 format digital production
to reach new places and ensures a cinematographers only limitation is their imagination.
The Cineex ELITE features a compact, lightweight design to facilitate quick transport and
easy rigging onto a variety of platforms.
530.271.2500 | info@cineex.com | www.cineex.com
Experience the
Cineex ELITE
Iron Digital on both The Girl with the
Dragon Tattoo and The Social Network
(AC Oct. 10), Cronenweth advocated
working with the facility again on
Hitchcock. Light Irons involvement
started with providing the production
with the Pix dailies system and a Lily
Pad on-set color-correction cart
equipped with ColorFronts Express
Dailies software. The Lily Pad was
manned by DIT/colorist Brandon
Lippard. We set looks together for
each scene, and that encoded informa-
tion would follow through to editorial
and all the way into the final grade,
says Cronenweth. Between the Lily
Pad and Pix, I knew the executives at
Fox Searchlight and [co-producer]
Montecito [Picture Co.] were seeing
dailies properly. Thats always a relief.
Pix is another amazing piece of
technology, he enthuses. It allows me
a lot more control over how I see my
images. I watched dailies every day with
[gaffer] Harold Skinner and [camera
operators] Peter Rosenfeld and Dan
McDonough, but we did it on our own
time. I use my laptop. Ive had it for
years, and its my litmus test for
whether things are working; if some-
thing is off, I can tell immediately.
When youre looking at dailies in some
random screening room, you never
really know what youre seeing. How
many footlamberts is the projection? Is
the projector lens good and clean? Ten
different screening rooms can show 10
different images. With Pix, everyone
was seeing our dailies in a consistent
form, and that really helped ease the
executives minds.
Light Irons involvement contin-
ued into post, when Cronenweth
reteamed with Social Network and
Dragon Tattoo colorist Ian Vertovec for
Hitchcocks final grade. We were
initially scheduled for a 10-day session,
but we wound up going 15, he recalls.
A good half of that time was spent
matching skin tones, smoothing out
prosthetics and makeup, and fixing
some things that might not have been
so challenging on a bigger movie. Items
that were not of the period, unwanted
An Auteurs Angst
Top: Hitchcock
attempts to save
potentially
controversial Psycho
scenes while
negotiating with
Geoffrey Shurlock
(Kurtwood Smith),
administrator of the
Motion Picture
Production Code.
Middle: Shurlock and
studio executives are
dismayed by a rough
version of Psycho.
Bottom: The married
collaborators finesse
their final cut.
86 January 2013 American Cinematographer
Cronenweth notes that digital
grading is much more time-intensive
for the cinematographer, who is typi-
cally not paid for such work. With
photochemical timing, youd donate
88 January 2013 American Cinematographer
reflections, and any bits of our own gear
that could not be kept out of frame were
masked or eliminated with color
changes, defocusing or power
windows.
Top, left and
right: During a
screening of
Psycho,
Hitchcock
awaits the
audiences
expected
screams of
terror. Middle
and bottom:
Hitchcock and
Alma enjoy
their moment of
triumph at the
movies
premiere.
An Auteurs Angst
your time when you were called to the
lab for a screening with the color timer,
youd give notes as the film was played
in its entirety, the timer would apply
those notes, and then, a couple of days
later, once the lab had struck a new
print, youd donate another couple of
hours to watch the film again. But in
todays world, youre sitting in the color
suite 12 hours a day, coloring every
frame. [Production] usually books the
room for two weeks or so, so you basi-
cally have to take two weeks off from
any other jobs to finish the movie. It
requires full days and full weeks, and its
a real liability to do it gratis. Luckily, I
was paid for this work on Hitchcock, but
thats not the norm in the industry, and
that has to change. Its up to the cine-
matographer to protect the image and
get the best image possible for the direc-
tor and producer, but thats becoming a
much bigger job than it used to be.
TECHNICAL SPECS
2.40:1
Digital Capture
Red Epic
Zeiss Ultra Prime
Never Stop Learning.
Never Stop Networking.
Guarantee your seat by
Registering Online Now
at www.studentfilmmakers.com/workshops
Intensive
Filmaking Workshops 2013
Presented and hosted by
Venue: StudentFilmmakers.com Workshop Studio Manhattan, New York City.
StudentFilmmakers.com & HDProGuide.com 1123 Broadway #307, New York, NY 10010 TEL: +1 212.255.5454
t HDSLR 2- Day Workshops:
1/26~27, 3/23~24, 5/25~26, 7/13~14, 8/31~9/1, 10/5~6, 11/9~10.
tNAB Classes: April 8 through 11, 2013 at the show.
t3-Date RED Production Workshops: TBA.
t Private Team Training: Call us to arrange for a group of 15 or more.
+'3UR*XLGHFRP
90 January 2013 American Cinematographer
Another Trip Down Sunset Blvd.
By Robert S. Birchard
When Sunset Blvd. was released on Aug. 10, 1950, Para-
mount Pictures touted it as another motion-picture masterpiece
from director Billy Wilder and the most unusual motion picture
in many years. Audiences were urged to come out to see the
film that reaches a new milestone of dramatic daring. The movie
tells the story of Norma Desmond (Gloria Swanson), a 50-year-old
silent-screen star who has been shunted aside by the advent of
sound and ageism on the part of Hollywood producers, and who
takes up with a man, Joe Gillis (William Holden), 20 years younger
than she.
Sunset Blvd. has indeed become an iconic picture, but the
film itself the original nitrate camera negative survived just
over a decade before it was lost or destroyed. The best surviving
film elements on Sunset Blvd. are a dupe negative and a fine-grain
master positive, both made in 1965, says Andrea Kalas, vice pres-
ident of archives at Paramount Pictures. Strangely, these
elements were not generated from the same source material, and
there are different issues and anomalies in each.
Although Paramount digitally restored Sunset Blvd. only a
decade ago, the studio decided to revisit the picture with the
latest 4K tools at Technicolor Hollywood. As we approached the
100th anniversary of Paramount, says Kalas, we felt this was
not only an iconic film, but also one that offered a vivid and
historic portrait of Paramounts Hollywood studio, with footage
shot all over the lot. We also wanted to revisit the imagery of the
films cinematographer, John Seitz, ASC.
According to Laura Thornburg, Paramounts executive
director of restoration and preservation for archives, the restora-
tion team consulted an original 1950 print in the Library of
Congress, as well as some other surviving 1950 print sources, to
get a feel for what Seitz was trying to achieve.
Tom Burton, executive director of restoration for
Technicolor Creative Services, says the Library of Congress print
provided the cornerstone for the look of this restoration. Unlike
some projects, where we have to cobble together the picture
from many sources, Sunset Blvd. was relatively straightforward,
with most of the image coming from the dupe neg. We only
resorted to the fine-grain in the transition scenes between the
golf course and Schwabs there was significant damage to
the dupe negative in that area and even a missing frame. The
scans from the fine-grain matched quite well in grain and image
quality.
The actual work took about four months, he continues.
Danny Albano was the lead restoration artist, and he supervised
the image-repair work done by the rest of the team. Our goal was
to get back to how the film looked on the screen the day it was
released. The repairs were rather subtle in the sense that there
Post Focus
S
u
n
s
e
t
B
l
v
d
.
f
r
a
m
e
s
2
0
1
2
P
a
r
a
m
o
u
n
t
P
i
c
t
u
r
e
s
,
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
T
e
c
h
n
i
c
o
l
o
r
.
I
Above left: An enlargement of a pre-restoration frame from Sunset Blvd. exhibits multiple vertical scratches and printed-in dirt.
Right: The restored frame in full.
were no torn frames or major damage in
the elements we worked with, but there
were massive amounts of printed-in black-
and-white dirt, scratches and repeating
emulsion digs that had to be cleaned up.
Because we used the dupe negative for
most of the picture, we were seeing dirt
and abrasions from the original that had
been printed into the fine-grain, which in
turn had its own dirt and abrasion issues
before the dupe negative was generated
from it. And the dupe itself had seen
significant wear through the years.
Tim Peeler was our colorist on the
project, and he has a great deal of experi-
ence working with older black-and-white
elements, adds Burton. He brought
back the incredibly rich blacks and amaz-
ing gray-value range Seitz achieved.
The restoration, which was
conducted entirely at 4K resolution,
produced several deliverables, including
HD masters for Blu-ray, DCPs for theatrical
projection and two new 35mm negatives.
Burton explains, The dupe neg and fine-
grain elements were scanned via Scanity
to create 4K 10-bit log DPX data. Image
restoration was done on the 4K data with
a variety of both commercially available
and proprietary processing solutions.
Color grading was done at 4K on a
DaVinci Resolve. The DCDM [Digital
Cinema Data Master] and DCP were both
created at 4K, and two negatives, one
archival and one for printing, were filmed
out at 4K via Arrilaser recorders.
We filmed out to Fujifilm [Eterna-
RDS] 4791, which makes a very good
archival negative, and then printed on
Kodak 2302. Weve found this combina-
tion yields very good black-and-white
results that match the DI data extremely
well.
We could have made the DCPs
directly from our restoration files using
look-up tables, but we instead opted to
make a 4K DCDM, which provides better
long-term storage and allows us to further
refine the XYZ curves in our outputs,
adds Burton. We used Rec 709 color
space for the Blu-ray, and [Technicolor
color scientists] Josh Pines and Chris
Kutcka developed custom LUTs for the
filmouts.