Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Christopher Ballantine
iii
Praise for the first edition
‘There are not many books like this, to which you can dance.’
— John Lonsdale, Trinity College, Cambridge
i
Contents
Acknowledgements ix
Author’s Note on Terminology xi
Abbreviations xii
Foreword by Sibongile Khumalo xiii
Introduction:
Memory, History and Context 1
Concert and Dance:
The Foundations of Black Jazz between the 1920s
and the Early 1940s 16
Music and Emancipation:
The Social Role of Black Jazz and Vaudeville
between the 1920s and the Early 1940s 54
Music and Repression:
‘Race’, Class and Gender in Black Jazz Culture
up to the Early 1940s 86
Looking to the United States:
The Politics of Male Close-Harmony Song Style
in the Later 1940s and the 1950s 118
Gender and Migrancy:
Jazz Culture in the Later 1940s and the 1950s 146
Afterword:
After Apartheid: Then and Now 193
vii
Appendix:
Accompanying CD: Notes on the Historic Recordings 201
viii
Introduction 1
Introduction
Memory, History and Context
Only that historian will have the gift of fanning the spark of
hope in the past who is firmly convinced that even the dead will
not be safe from the enemy if he wins. And this enemy has
not ceased to be victorious.
Walter Benjamin, ‘Theses on the Philosophy of History’
1
2 Marabi Nights
But the bands were not alone. Existing beside them – indeed,
in symbiotic relationship with them – were the vaudeville troupes,
companies usually specialising in a variety of musical and theatrical
routines. Not all groups worked to the same format but, taken as a
whole, vaudeville programmes included items such as solo or group
singing (usually with accompaniment), solo or group instrumental
performances, tap dancing, mime, comedy, recitations, character
impersonations, dramatic sketches, juggling and acrobatics. Historic-
ally, these vaudeville troupes were distant descendants of the minstrel
tradition, but now they took their place alongside the bands in sharing
the presentation of a genre of all-night entertainment known as
‘Concert and Dance’. Like the bands, their repertoire was derived
from both foreign and local sources and they also produced cultural
exemplars. The Palladiums and the Darktown Negroes in the 1910s,
the African Darkies and the Versatile Seven in the 1920s, the
Darktown Strutters, Harmony Kings, Pitch Black Follies and Synco
Fans in the 1930s and 1940s: troupes such as these set the standards,
dictated trends and created role models.
And so the exodus of jazz musicians for Europe and the United
States began; most never returned. Those who remained had to
find some way of adapting to the new situation; those who couldn’t
adapt, or wouldn’t, simply packed away their instruments. As if to
symbolise the new musical order, Mahlathini – one of the new
order’s first commercial products – appeared in animal skins and
sang of the virtues of tribal life. Music became inextricably tied to
ideology.
It is important to understand that one of the reasons jazz was
suppressed was that it aspired to (among other things) musical and
social equality: it was precisely the musical idiom in which and through
which urban black people were proving to themselves and to the
world that they were the equals of whites (without in the process
abandoning valued aspects of their culture, or of their history as
blacks who were assuming aspects of Western culture). The white
and racist South African state was devising an ideology and a
programme for fragmenting black South Africans, for turning them
against each other by reinforcing and artificially cultivating differences
of ethnicity and ‘race’; yet, at exactly the same time, black jazz
musicians and audiences were insisting not only on their necessary
unity as blacks and as South Africans, but also on their status as fully
fledged and equal members of the international society of human
beings. By adopting jazz, urban black South Africans were proudly
and self-consciously identifying themselves as actors on the inter-
national stage of world history.
But the identification went further. For jazz was not only
international: at times it was also, significantly, a discourse aspiring to
become the musical vernacular of the oppressed. Moreover, it was
a discourse with explicit and historic roots in the continent of Africa,
and it had been cultivated by people of colour – people who were
formerly Africans – in the United States, under conditions of
explosive capitalist development. The parallels with South Africa
were obvious.
Introduction 11
A philosophical reflection
This book is a story about marabi-jazz, a practice of seminal
importance in the history of South African popular music. But it
Introduction 13
hopes to be more than that: all stories – at least, all those worth the
effort of telling – are ‘about’ more than just the flows, tensions and
details of their own narrative. They also open upon broader
perspectives, provide ways of thinking about more general issues,
support or undermine related arguments developed elsewhere, in
other narratives. Because these wider or more universal concerns
help us to understand particular instances – because they have
explanatory value – they become our theories. They may challenge
other ways of making sense of the world or, in turn, be challenged
themselves.
Implicitly, the story told in this book is also in dialogue with
several such theories. One of these, most fully developed by
Theodor Adorno, is that we cannot seriously hope to explain the
features of any music, or explicate its meaning in history, without
precisely grounding it within a social context – including, importantly,
its political economy. Related to this is another issue that I engage
with here very centrally: the argument that popular music tends to
be fractured, in deep but complex ways, along lines having to do
with, for instance, class, gender and power. What this implies is that
music comes to be associated with particular identities – that, for
example, gender roles or stereotypes may become embodied in the
numerous practices that make the performance of music possible,
that give it audibility and visibility, that bring it to its audiences
and to other musicians. These practices include, for instance, the
music’s own microeconomics (patterns of ownership, power and
exploitation), as well as the discourses in which it is situated and in
which it participates (the media, the utterances of fans and, of course,
its own songs, compositions and dances). Thus the character of
music’s social relations at any particular time and place cannot be
accounted for by looking only at the music itself. Rather, we need
also to look beyond the domain of music, to a broader socio-
political history, a macrocosm against which the musical microcosm
becomes intelligible.
14 Marabi Nights
Notes
1. The appointment by Gallo (Africa) of the outstanding discographer Rob
Allingham to a newly created post of archivist in 1990 was a laudable – if
belated – attempt to make some amends. A significant number of reissues,
principally of music from the 1950s and 1960s, have appeared since his
appointment. These belong to the period in which, for the first time,
studio recordings were made directly onto electromagnetic tape – and it is
these that today constitute the earliest recordings in the Gallo archive.
2. The South African Music Archive Project (SAMAP) has since 2007 been
involved in digitising these collections, with a view to making them
searchable online; its plan – if funds can be found – is to do the same
with other collections of historical value, whether owned privately or
institutionally and, in the longer term, irrespective of where in the world
they might be. SAMAP is based at UKZN, where it is hosted by Digital
Innovation South Africa (DISA) and it has been funded by the National
Research Foundation. See http://www.disa.ukzn.ac.za/samap/.
3. The music discussed in the remainder of this chapter is, of course, the
central focus of this book. The chapters that follow deal with it almost
exclusively and the CD accompanying this book presents appropriate
selections chosen from the phonograph recordings of the time. A detailed
discussion of the music on the CD can be found in the Appendix.
4. For more on South African music, post-1994, see the afterword at the
end of the book.