Sie sind auf Seite 1von 72

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 14 PageID #: 4382

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA,
INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
MEDALLION FOODS, INC. and
RALCORP HOLDINGS, INC.,
Defendants.

Case No. 4:12-CV-00074-ALM

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER


This cause came before the court at a pre-trial management conference held on February
8, 2013, pursuant to Local Rule CV-16 and Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.
A.

COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES


Plaintiff Frito-Lay North America, Inc.: Timothy S. Durst (State Bar No. 00786924),

Russell J. Crain (State Bar No. 24045717), Susan Cannon Kennedy (State Bar No. 24051663) of
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.; and Clyde M. Siebman (State Bar No. 18341600) of SIEBMAN,
BURG, PHILLIPS & SMITH, LLP.
Defendants Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.: David W. Harlan, B.
Scott Eidson, and Mark A. Thomas of ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP; T. John Ward, Jr.
(State Bar No. 00794818) and Wesley Hill (State Bar No. 24032294) of WARD & SMITH LAW
FIRM.

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 1

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

B.

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 14 PageID #: 4383

STATEMENT OF JURISDICTION
This Court has concluded that it has personal jurisdiction over Defendants. See Order

Denying Defendants Motion to Dismiss (March 30, 2012) (Dkt. 42). Defendants have disputed
personal jurisdiction.
The Court has subject matter jurisdiction under 15 U.S.C. 1121 and 28 U.S.C. 1331,
1332, and 1338 over causes of action that arise under federal law and supplemental jurisdiction
under 28 U.S.C. 1367 over the state law causes of action.
C.

NATURE OF ACTION
Frito-Lay asserts claims in this action for trademark infringement, trade dress

infringement, unfair competition and dilution under the United States Trademark (Lanham) Act,
15 U.S.C. 1051, et seq. (as amended); for willful patent infringement under the patent laws of
the United States, 35 U.S.C. 271 et seq.; for trademark dilution under Texas Business and
Commerce Code 16.29; for trademark infringement, misappropriation of trade secrets, unfair
competition by simulation of appearance of goods, misappropriation of time, labor, skill, and
money, and unjust enrichment under common law; and for misappropriation of trade secrets in
violation of Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code 134.002(2).
Defendants bring counterclaims for inequitable conduct in the prosecution of the patentin-suit and for declaratory judgments that Frito-Lays asserted registered trademark should be
canceled as functional and/or abandoned, that Frito-Lays asserted patent is not infringed, that
Frito-Lays asserted patent is invalid, and that there has been no federal or Texas common law
trademark dilution, trademark or trade dress infringement, unfair competition, unjust enrichment,
or trade secret misappropriation.

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 2

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

D.

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 14 PageID #: 4384

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES


The parties set forth below a summary of their contentions for trial. The parties do not

necessarily agree with each others contentions and reserve all objections.
Frito-Lay contends:
1. Defendants have misappropriated Frito-Lays trade secrets under common law.
2. Defendants have misappropriated Frito-Lays time, labor, skill, and money under
common law.
3. Defendants have misappropriated Frito-Lays confidential, proprietary, and trade secret
information by unlawfully appropriating property. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code
134.002(2).
4. Defendants have committed theft of trade secrets as defined in the Act and Texas Penal
Code 31.05(b).
5. Defendants infringed Frito-Lays federally registered TOSTITOS SCOOPS! product
design in violation of 15 U.S.C. 1114.
6. Defendants trademark infringement has been willful and in bad faith, making this an
exceptional case under 15 U.S.C. 1117.
7. Defendants overall chip design and BOWLZ packaging constitute trade dress
infringement and unfair competition in violation of 15 U.S.C. 1125(a).
8. Defendants trade dress infringement has been willful and in bad faith, making this an
exceptional case under 15 U.S.C. 1117.
9. Defendants overall chip design constitutes a likelihood of dilution of the distinctive
quality of the TOSTITOS SCOOPS! shape in violation of 15 U.S.C. 1125(c).

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 3

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 14 PageID #: 4385

10. Defendants have infringed Frito-Lays U.S. Patent No. 6,610,344 (the 344 Patent) under
35 U.S.C. 271.
11. Defendants patent infringement has been willful, entitling Frito-Lay to enhanced
damages under 35 U.S.C. 284.
12. Defendants overall chip design and BOWLZ packaging constitute trademark
infringement under the common law of Texas.
13. Defendants conduct constitutes trademark dilution under the common law of Texas, as it
is likely to dilute, blur and/or tarnish the distinctive qualities of the TOSTITOS
SCOOPS! product design in violation of Section 16.29 of the Business and Commerce
Code of the State of Texas.
14. Defendants acts constitute unfair competition by simulation of appearance of goods
under common law.
15. Because of their unlawful conduct, Defendants hold in constructive trust for Frito-Lay all
issued patents, patent applications, trade secrets, and other assignable intellectual
property that were derived, in whole or in part, from Frito-Lays technology, trade
secrets, or other proprietary information. Frito-Lay asks the Court to order Defendants to
assign to Frito-Lay any issued patents, patent applications, trade secrets, and other
assignable intellectual property that were derived, in whole or in part, from Frito-Lays
technology, trade secrets, or other proprietary information.
16. Defendants have been unjustly enriched at Frito-Lays expense.
17. The Court should enjoin Defendants from using or licensing or authorizing others to use
Defendants Design and Trade Dress or any other mark or trade dress that is confusingly
similar to Frito-Lays TOSTITOS SCOOPS! product design and/or packaging in

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 4

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 14 PageID #: 4386

connection with the promotion, advertising, manufacture, distribution, offering for sale,
or sale of any tortilla chips, including any further manufacture, sale, or distribution of
BOWLZ tortilla chips. Frito-Lay also asks the Court to enjoin Defendants from using
manufacturing processes that infringe the 344 Patent.
18. Defendants should be preliminarily and permanently enjoined and restrained from using,
licensing or authorizing the use of, or seeking to register any mark or dress that is
confusingly similar to the TOSTITOS SCOOPS! product design or packaging, or any
other symbols or indicia associated with Frito-Lay and/or confusingly similar to the
TOSTITOS SCOOPS! product design or packaging, or likely to dilute the distinctiveness
thereof, as, or as part of, a trademark, trade dress, or other identifier, including any
further manufacture, sale, or distribution of BOWLZ or CUPZ tortilla chips, regardless of
the packaging.
19. Defendants should be preliminarily and permanently enjoined and restrained from using
manufacturing processes that infringe the 344 Patent.
20. Defendants should be ordered to file with the Court and serve upon Frito-Lays counsel
within thirty (30) days after entry and service on Defendants of an injunction, a report in
writing under oath setting forth in detail the manner and form in which Defendants have
complied with the requirements of the injunction.
21. Unless enjoined, Defendants will continue to infringe Frito-Lays trademark-in-suit, trade
dress, and patent-in-suit, and misappropriate Frito-Lays trade secrets and an injunction
to prevent Defendants continued infringement and misappropriation is warranted.
22. Frito-Lay should recover actual and punitive damages from Defendants.
23. This is an exceptional case entitling Frito-Lay to enhanced damages.

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 5

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 6 of 14 PageID #: 4387

24. An equitable accounting should be directed to determine Defendants profits resulting


from their infringement and other activities complained of herein, and that such profits be
paid over to Frito-Lay, increased as the Court finds to be just under the circumstances of
this case.
25. Frito-Lay is entitled to submit and recover its reasonable attorneys fees as well as the
costs of this action upon the conclusion of the jury trial.
26. Frito-Lay is entitled to recover pre- and post-judgment interest and such other and further
relief as the Court may deem just and proper.
Defendants contend:
1. Frito-Lays product shape trademark is functional and therefore unenforceable under 15
U.S.C. 1115(b)(8) and subject to cancellation under 15 U.S.C. 1064(3).
2. Frito-Lay has abandoned its product shape trademark, and it is therefore unenforceable
under 15 U.S.C. 1115(b)(2) and subject to cancellation under 15 U.S.C. 1064(3).
3. Medallions sales of bowl-shaped tortilla chips and its use of the BOWLZ packaging are
lawful and do not constitute trademark or trade dress infringement (willful or otherwise),
trademark or trade dress dilution, unfair competition, unlawful simulation of appearance
of goods, or unjust enrichment under federal and/or Texas law.
4. Medallions manufacturing process for bowl-shaped tortilla chips and the chips it
produces do not infringe Frito-Lays 344 Patent, willfully or otherwise.
5. Frito-Lays 344 Patent is invalid, in whole or in part, because the invention claimed in
the patent is not patentable under 35 U.S.C. 102 and/or 103.
6. Frito-Lays 344 Patent is unenforceable because Frito-Lay engaged in inequitable
conduct before the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office by withholding material

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 6

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 7 of 14 PageID #: 4388

information about the patentability of the invention claimed in the patent with the specific
intent to deceive the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
7. Frito-Lay has not properly disclosed a protectable trade secret.
8. Defendants did not misappropriate or use a protectable Frito-Lay trade secret, nor did
Defendants engage in any conduct that constitutes misappropriation of Frito-Lays time,
labor, skill, and money or a violation of the Texas Theft Liability Act.
9. None of Defendants intellectual property was derived unlawfully from Frito-Lays
technology, trade secrets, or other proprietary information.
10. Defendants are entitled to recover reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
11. Defendants are not liable to Frito-Lay under any cause of action or legal theory asserted
by Frito-Lay.
E.

STIPULATIONS AND UNCONTESTED FACTS


1. The 344 Patent, entitled Process for Making a Shaped Snack Chip, was issued by the
United States Patent and Trademark Office on August 26, 2003.
2. The asserted claims of the 344 Patent are claims 1, 5-8, 12, and 16.
3. Frito-Lay practices at least one claim of the 344 Patent.
4. United States Trademark Registration No. 2,766,278 (the 278 mark) was issued by the
United States Patent and Trademark Office on September 23, 2003.
5. Defendants BOWLZ and CUPZ tortilla chips are sold in Texas.
6. RALMED 287328-337, RALMED 290973, and RALMED 291057-065 are photographs
Defendants' counsel took during an inspection of a bag of chips from 1997 like the bags
of chips Frito-Lay sold in a BehaviorScan test market in 1997 and made with a process
disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 6,129,939.

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 7

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 8 of 14 PageID #: 4389

7. RALMED 290985-291056 are photographs Defendants' counsel took during an


inspection of two bags of TOSTITOS SCOOPS! reference chips on December 19, 2012.
F.

CONTESTED ISSUES OF FACT AND LAW


The parties set forth below their contested issues of fact and law. The parties do not

agree that each contested issue listed may be properly raised. The parties reserve all objections.
1. Whether Defendants infringed Frito-Lays 278 mark.
2. Whether Defendants alleged trademark infringement was willful.
3. Whether Frito-Lays 278 mark or trade dress is functional.
4. Whether Frito-Lays 278 mark has been abandoned.
5. Whether Defendants infringed Frito-Lays trade dress.
6. Whether Defendants alleged trade dress infringement was willful.
7. Whether Frito-Lay has protectable rights in its trade dress.
8. Whether Defendants infringed Frito-Lays 344 Patent.
9. Whether Frito-Lay may argue that Defendants infringed the 344 Patent under the
Doctrine of Equivalents.
10. Whether Defendants alleged patent infringement was willful.
11. Whether Frito-Lays evidence of alleged willful patent, trademark, or trade dress
infringement is sufficient for submission to the jury.
12. Whether Frito-Lays 344 Patent is invalid, in whole or in part, under 35 U.S.C. 102
and/or 103.
13. Whether Frito-Lays 344 Patent is unenforceable as a result of any inequitable conduct.
14. Whether Defendants misappropriated any trade secrets of Frito-Lay.
15. What information Frito-Lay claims is protectable as a trade secret.

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 8

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 9 of 14 PageID #: 4390

16. Whether whatever information Frito-Lay claims is protectable as a trade secret is


protectable as a trade secret.
17. Whether any of the acts Defendants are alleged to have committed constituted
misappropriation of Frito-Lays time, labor, skill, and money, unfair competition, theft of
trade secrets under the Texas penal code, trademark dilution, unjust enrichment, or any
other cause of action or legal theory asserted by Frito-Lay.
18. Whether and to what extent Frito-Lay is entitled to actual, punitive, equitable, enhanced,
or other damages.
19. Whether Frito-Lay is entitled to injunctive relief.
20. Whether Defendants are entitled to declaratory relief.
21. Whether Frito-Lay is entitled to recover pre- and post-judgment interest.
22. Whether Frito-Lay is entitled to recover reasonable attorneys fees and costs and, if so, in
what amount.
23. Whether Defendants are entitled to recover reasonable attorneys fees and costs and, if
so, in what amount.
For purposes of narrowing issues for trial, Frito-Lay does not intend to assert that Defendants
misappropriated the following information: (1) the percentage of moisture of Frito-Lays tortilla
chips going into the oven; (2) the information discernible from the nutritional panel of
TOSTITOS SCOOPS!; (3) how Frito-Lay sets the cook times for its tortilla chips; (4) the type of
process control sensors used by Frito-Lay to make tortilla chips; (5) the vendor that supplies
Frito-Lays process control sensors; and (6) that Frito-Lay uses near infrared technology on its
corn processing lines. The parties dispute whether Defendants may introduce evidence and

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 9

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 10 of 14 PageID #: 4391

cross-examine witnesses concerning Frito-Lays change of position regarding the foregoing


items.
G.

LIST OF WITNESSES
Frito-Lays witness list is attached as Exhibit A and deposition designations are attached

as Exhibit B.
Defendants witness list is attached as Exhibit C, their deposition designations as Exhibit
D, and their designations of discovery responses as Exhibit E.
H.

LIST OF EXHIBITS
Frito-Lays exhibit list is attached as Exhibit F.
Defendants exhibit list is attached as Exhibit G.

I.

LIST OF ANY PENDING MOTIONS


Defendants Motion for Leave to File Daubert Motion (filed January 9, 2013) (Dkt. 190).

J.

PROBABLE LENGTH OF TRIAL


The probable length of trial is 10-12 days.

K.

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE LIMITATIONS


The following limitations were agreed upon by the parties and are reflected in the Joint

Conference Report (filed May 14, 2013) (Dkt. 61).


Exhibits: Each side is limited to designating 250 exhibits for trial absent a showing of good
cause. The parties recently agreed to change this limitation to 275 exhibits per side for trial
absent a showing of good cause.
Deposition Designations:

Each side is limited to designating no more than 10 hours of

deposition testimony for use at trial absent a showing of good cause. As trial approaches, if

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 10

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 11 of 14 PageID #: 4392

either side needs to designate more than 10 hours, the party may file a motion for leave and show
good cause.
Witness Lists: In addition to identifying witnesses as will call, may call, or probably will
not call, each side shall identify the witnesss employer and topic the witness will address, e.g.,
John Doe, Acme Corp., invalidity.
L.

CERTIFICATIONS
The undersigned counsel for each of the parties in this action do hereby certify and

acknowledge the following.


(1)

Full and complete disclosure has been made in accordance with the
Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the Courts orders;

(2)

Discovery limitations set forth in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the
Local Rules, and the Courts orders have been complied with and not
altered by agreement or otherwise;

(3)

Each exhibit in the List of Exhibits herein:


(a)
(b)
(c)

is in existence;
is numbered; and
has been disclosed and shown to opposing counsel

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 11

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Date: January 22, 2013

Filed 01/22/13 Page 12 of 14 PageID #: 4393

Respectfully submitted,

/s/_Timothy S. Durst
Timothy S. Durst
State Bar No. 00786924
tim.durst@bakerbotts.com
Russell J. Crain
State Bar No. 24045717
russ.crain@bakerbotts.com
Susan Cannon Kennedy
State Bar No. 24051663
susan.kennedy@bakerbotts.com
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 600
Dallas, Texas 75201
Telephone: 214-953-6500
Facsimile: 214-953-6503
Clyde M. Siebman
SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS
& SMITH, LLP
Federal Courthouse Square
300 N. Travis St.
Sherman, TX 75090
Telephone: 903-870-0070
Facsimile: 903-870-0066
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA,
INC.

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 12

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 13 of 14 PageID #: 4394

Respectfully submitted,
By: /s/ David Harlan (by permission)________
David W. Harlan LEAD ATTORNEY
dharlan@armstrongteasdale.com
Jennifer E. Hoekel
jhoekel@armstrongteasdale.com
B. Scott Eidson
seidson@armstrongteasdale.com
Daniel E. Sakaguchi
dsakaguchi@armstrongteasdale.com
Mark A. Thomas
mathomas@armstrongteasdale.com
Timothy D. Krieger
tkrieger@armstrongteasdale.com
Zachary C. Howenstine
zhowenstine@armstrongteasdale.com
ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP
7700 Forsyth Blvd., Suite 1800
St. Louis, Missouri 63105
(314) 621-5070 (telephone)
(314) 621-5065 (facsimile)
and

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 13

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196

Filed 01/22/13 Page 14 of 14 PageID #: 4395

T. John Ward
State Bar No. 20848000
tjw@wsfirm.com
T. John Ward, Jr.
State Bar No. 00794818
jw@wsfirm.com
Wesley Hill
State Bar No. 24032294
wh@wsfirm.com
Claire Abernathy Henry
State Bar No. 24053063
claire@wsfirm.com
WARD & SMITH LAW FIRM
1127 Judson Rd., Ste. 220
Longview, Texas 75601
(903) 757-6400 (telephone)
(903) 757-2323 (facsimile
ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS
MEDALLION FOODS, INC. AND
RALCORP HOLDINGS, INC.

This Joint Pre-Trial Order is hereby approved this _____ day of ______________, 20__.

__________________________________
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

JOINT FINAL PRE-TRIAL ORDER

PAGE 14

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-1

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 6 PageID #: 4396

EXHIBIT A

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-1

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 6 PageID #: 4397

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA,
INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
MEDALLION FOODS, INC. and
RALCORP HOLDINGS, INC.,
Defendants.

Case No. 4:12-CV-00074-ALM

FRITO-LAYS WITNESS LIST


NAME

EMPLOYER

DESCRIPTION

DESIGNATION
Will
Call

Scott Allen
Janelle
Anderson
Bruce Atkins
Scott Batson

Rudy
Bazaldua

Tim Bender

Medallion
Patent infringement
Foods, Inc.
Frito-Lay North Trademark/trade dress infringement and
America, Inc.
validity; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition
Armstrong
Willful patent infringement; trademark
Teasdale LLP
validity
Frito-Lay North Trade
secret
misappropriation;
America, Inc.
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
trademark/trade dress infringement
Frito-Lay North Trade
secret
misappropriation;
America, Inc.
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
trademark/trade dress infringement
Ralcorp
Trade
secret
misappropriation;
Holdings, Inc.
trademark/trade dress infringement; patent
infringement; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment

FRITO-LAYS WITNESS LIST

May
Call

Depo
Test

9
9
9
9

PAGE 1

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-1

NAME

EMPLOYER

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 6 PageID #: 4398

DESCRIPTION

DESIGNATION
Will
Call

Charles
Brown

Medallion
Foods, Inc.

Colin
Cahoon
Steven
Chandler

Carstens &
Cahoon, LLP
Self-employed

Mike Ferris

Timothy
Fink
Dr. John
Floros
Deb Gibbins

Jaclyn Green

Earl Justice

Rusty
Karschner

Richard
Koulouris

FRITO-LAYS WITNESS LIST

Depo
Test

Simulation of appearance of goods;


dilution;
unfair
competition;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment;
trademark/trade
dress
infringement;
trade
secret
misappropriation
Patent validity/enforceability

Misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust


enrichment; patent validity; trade secret
misappropriation; unfair competition
Frito-Lay North Trade
secret
misappropriation;
America, Inc.
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
trademark/trade dress infringement
Frito-Lay North Patent validity
America, Inc.
Kansas State
Patent infringement
University
Frito-Lay North Trademark/trade dress infringement;
America, Inc.
damages; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition
Ralcorp
Trade
secret
misappropriation;
Holdings, Inc.
trademark/trade
dress
infringement;
simulation of appearance of goods;
dilution;
unfair
competition;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; patent infringement
Ralcorp
Trademark/trade dress infringement; trade
Holdings, Inc.
secret misappropriation; simulation of
appearance of goods; dilution; unfair
competition; misappropriation of sweat
equity; unjust enrichment
Self-employed Trade
secret
misappropriation;
trademark/trade dress infringement; patent
infringement; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment
Ralcorp
Patent
infringement,
trade
secret
Holdings, Inc.
misappropriation; misappropriation of
sweat equity; unjust enrichment; unfair

May
Call

9
9
9

9
9
9
9

PAGE 2

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-1

NAME

EMPLOYER

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 6 PageID #: 4399

DESCRIPTION

DESIGNATION
Will
Call

Ryan Lane

Jennifer
Loge
Michael
Mazis
Robert
Monteforte
Dr. Martin
Okos
Daniel Orr

Scott Phillips
Alexander
Pier
Jackie Price

Dr. Adriana
Quintanar
Guzman
Richard
Ruegg

Joshua
Stimson

competition
Ralcorp
Trademark/trade dress infringement;
Holdings, Inc.
simulation of appearance of goods;
dilution; unfair competition; trade secrets
misappropriation
Ralcorp
Trade dress infringement; simulation of
Holdings, Inc.
appearance of goods; dilution; unfair
competition
Self-employed Trademark/trade dress infringement;
simulation of appearance of goods;
dilution; unfair competition
Frito-Lay North Trade
secret
misappropriation;
America, Inc.
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment
Purdue
Trade secret misappropriation; patent
University
validity; misappropriation of sweat equity;
unjust enrichment
Frito-Lay North Trade
secret
misappropriation;
America, Inc.
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
trademark/trade dress infringement
Charles River
Damages
Associates
Quality
Trade
secret
misappropriation;
Fabrication &
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
Design
enrichment; unfair competition
None
Trade
secret
misappropriation;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment
Consultant
Patent infringement

Frito-Lay North Trade


secret
misappropriation;
America, Inc.
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
trademark/trade dress infringement; patent
validity
Medallion
Patent
infringement;
trade
secret
Foods, Inc.
misappropriation; misappropriation of
sweat equity; unjust enrichment

FRITO-LAYS WITNESS LIST

May
Call

Depo
Test

9
9
9
9
9

9
9
9
9
9

PAGE 3

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-1

NAME

EMPLOYER

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 6 PageID #: 4400

DESCRIPTION

DESIGNATION
Will
Call

Michael
Trowbridge

Ralcorp
Holdings, Inc.

Dr. Kent Van NERA


Liere
Economic
Consulting
M. Kent
Medallion
Vickery
Foods, Inc.

Steve Visser
Andrew
Westervelt

Purdue
University
Self-employed

Bryan
Wheelock
Dr. Alexa
Williams

Trade
secret
misappropriation;
trademark/trade dress infringement; patent
infringement; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment
Trademark/trade dress infringement

Trade
secret
misappropriation;
trademark/trade dress infringement; patent
infringement; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; trade secret misappropriation
Trademark/trade dress validity

Depo
Test

9
9

9
9

Trade
secret
misappropriation;
trademark/trade dress infringement; patent
infringement; simulation of appearance of
goods; dilution; unfair competition;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment
Willful patent infringement

Harness Dickey
and Pierce PLC
Frito-Lay North Trade
secret
misappropriation;
America, Inc.
trademark/trade dress infringement and
non-functionality;
simulation
of
appearance of goods; dilution; unfair
competition; patent validity
James Young Self-employed Trade
secret
misappropriation;
misappropriation of sweat equity; unjust
enrichment; unfair competition
Joseph
Reading
Patent infringement
Zaleski
Bakery
Systems, Inc.
Mike
Frito-Lay North Simulation of appearance of goods;
Zbuchalski
America, Inc.
dilution;
unfair
competition;
trademark/trade dress infringement

FRITO-LAYS WITNESS LIST

May
Call

9
9

9
9
9

PAGE 4

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-1

Dated: January 22, 2013

Filed 01/22/13 Page 6 of 6 PageID #: 4401

Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Timothy S. Durst________
Timothy S. Durst
State Bar No. 00786924
tim.durst@bakerbotts.com
Russell J. Crain
State Bar No. 24045717
russ.crain@bakerbotts.com
Susan Cannon Kennedy
State Bar No. 24051663
susan.kennedy@bakerbotts.com
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 600
Dallas, Texas 75201
Telephone: 214-953-6500
Facsimile: 214-953-6503
Clyde M. Siebman
SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS
& SMITH, LLP
Federal Courthouse Square
300 N. Travis St.
Sherman, TX 75090
Telephone: 903-870-0070
Facsimile: 903-870-0066
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA,
INC.

FRITO-LAYS WITNESS LIST

PAGE 5

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-2

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 7 PageID #: 4402

EXHIBIT B

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-2

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 7 PageID #: 4403

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA,
INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
MEDALLION FOODS, INC. and
RALCORP HOLDINGS, INC.,
Defendants.

Case No. 4:12-CV-00074-ALM

FRITO-LAYS VIDEO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS


Witness
Scott Allen

Bruce Atkins

Tim Bender

Designations
6:1-10; 6:20-7:10; 9:25-12:17; 9:25-12:17; 14:1-15; 21:11-22; 22:1-8;
22:16-23:9; 24:23-25:6; 37:18 (begin at "It's") - 24; 52:5-10; 52:25
(begin at "Are") - 53:14; 61:13-15; 65:10-14; 69:10-17; 70:12-71:2;
71:4-9; 71:11; 72:13-24; 73:24-75:7; 75:22-76:10
8:1-10; 8:20-11:3; 12:2-9; 18:16-20:9; 21:22-25; 22:2-14; 22:19-22;
40:21-25; 45:11-14; 45:20-25; 47:21-48:7; 48:17-22; 49:5-9; 51:2-8;
51:23-52:8; 52:11 (begin at "How")-19; 54:9-15; 55:9-12; 56:11-57:4;
81:4-15; 81:21-83:9; 86:7-87:10; 96:3-97:4; 104:21-105:5; 114:1-16;
116:11-117:19; 118:18-24; 121:13-122:1; 122:4-23; 123:1; 123:10-15;
130:9-14; 131:3-134:22; 144:20-145:25; 146:9-147:8; 147:20-148:5;
150:5-150:18; 153:25-154:6; 157:3-5; 160:5-19; 163:1-13; 167:19169:1; 170:4-171:15; 172:10-16
9:1-22, 10:1-21, 15:7-14, 17:7-20, 17:22-18:9, 18:11-19:22, 19:2420:19, 20:21-21:10, 23:18 (start - w/your) - 24:1, 25:21-26:7, 29:3-5,
29:7-10, 30:24-31:7, 32:2-4, 32:17-33:7, 33:13-34:7, 36:9-37:1, 40:1218, 42:2-6, 43:2-11, 45:2-8, 45:10-46:11, 46:17-24, 47:18-24, 48:2049:6, 49:23-50:1, 50:4-6, 50:18-51:24, 53:16-18, 55:18-56:2, 57:1361:11, 61:23-63:15, 65:16-20, 66:18-67:4, 67:23-68:1, 68:13-25,
74:24-76:10, 79:3-15, 81:2-19, 83:11-20, 87:17-25, 89:15-22, 91:892:3, 97:8-97:14, 97:20-23, 100:9-15, 101:20-25, 103:3-8, 106:13-21,
109:5-11, 115:8-21, 116:13-15, 117:4-7, 118:22 (start with there)119:13, 122:8-14, 125:10-13, 127:8-10, 127:12-18, 129:4-8, 131:25132:13, 133:5-10, 140:19-25, 158:24-159:14, 161:15-162:3, 165:4-18,
171:23-172:15, 173:25-176:11, 179:17-22, 181:16-20, 188:2-7, 191:7194:1, 195:8-17, 195:22-25, 196:12-23, 198:5-9, 200:7-201:7, 202:20207:19, 213:11- 215:4, 221:14-21; 222:5-7; 226:3-11, 230:21-231:5,
231:11-21, 232:7-21, 234:4-8, 238:21-239:4, 240:2-12, 241:8-25,

FRITO-LAYS VIDEO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

PAGE 1

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-2

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 7 PageID #: 4404

Witness

Charles Brown

Steven Chandler
Jaclyn Green

Earl Justice

Designations
242:15-19, 248:3-6, 249:11-22, 250:12-251:10, 253:22-254:2, 255:1012, 256:9-16, 259:7-261:10, 262:2-5, 263:23-265:8, 266:13-269:23, 25,
270:4-13, 272:11-273:3, 274:22-277:22, 278:18-22, 280:12-17, 282:23283:13, 285:16-24, 286:3-7, 286:19-287:4, 287:22-290:18, 291:3-17,
292:10-20, 297:22-298:6, 299:23-300:17, 302:22-305:11, 307:18309:20, 313:24-314:6, 314:25-315:4, 315:17-316:15, 318:17-319:1,
320:6-320:25, 321:8-322:12, 323:9-325:23, 327:5-328:15, 329:13330:2, 330:21-331:1, 332:7-333:18, 335:15-336:22, 337:15-338:14,
344:23-346:13, 353:3-354:4
6:1-8:20, 9:10-23, 14:10-15:2, 15:11-14, 22:15-23:1, 23:16-22, 27:18
(starting with Have)-21; 42:11-14, 45:3-14, 45:17-46:8, 48:21-24,
56:24-57:3, 60:2-9, 60:23 (starting with why is)-61:3, 71:18-72:2,
72:14-15, 72:17-19, 74:13-15, 74:23-75:21, 76:11-16, 82:7-10, 82:2383:3, 85:15-20, 85:24-86:6, 100:1-10, 103:9-11, 103:20-104:5, 107:11
(starting with Kroger)-16, 109:21 (starting with so)-24, 110:25111:13, 133:23-134:10, 134:12-20, 148:23 (starting with you charge)
149:9, 163:10-165:13, 165:17-167:17, 175:23 (starting with if we
look) 176:14, 186:22-187:3, 188:10-18, 203:10 (starting with So
you) 204:4, 204:16-205:18, 210:24-211:2
6:1-7:8, 104:17-25, 156:25-157:18, 189:6-190:2, 190:7-191:13,
191:18-192:18, 192:25-193:24
6:1-7:15, 9:20-25, 19:21-20:6, 21:19-23, 28:9-13, 28:20-22, 29:11-19,
30:21-31:17, 33:19-25, 36:16-37:2, 39:8-9, 39:15-19, 43:14-44:1,
46:16-25, 52:24-53:6, 57:20-24, 60:2-6, 62:24-63:10, 63:18-20, 70:1971:1, 71:9-21, 72:5-11, 74:2-18, 77:2-11, 77:15-78:1, 78:3-79:13,
100:16-21, 101:1-102:10, 106:1-12, 108:1-14, 109:3-9, 111:4-17,
111:20-21, 111:24-112:1, 112:4, 112:7, 112:21-23, 112:25-113:5,
113:7-8, 113:10-15, 114:2-10, 116:11-18, 116:20-117:13, 120:25121:4, 121:7, 121:9-10, 121:18-21, 122:2-123:19, 129:22 (starting with
was there)-130:7, 132:7-133:5, 133:21 (starting with All)-133:25,
135:7-25, 140:11-141:5, 142:3-16, 143:1-13, 143:23-145:14, 145:1724, 146:8-147:7, 147:13-21, 148:5-8, 148:10, 148:12-14, 150:15151:15, 155:12-21, 155:24-156:8, 156:15-158:11, 168:10-11, 168:16169:3, 169:5-6, 169:8-11, 169:24-170:1, 170:3-172:18, 172:23-173:8,
177:5-15, 177:25-178:19, 188:6-10, 196:19-197:21, 204:10-13, 207:19208:20
5:1-25; 6:5-9; 7:8-15; 8:1-22; 9:20-22; 16:12-14; 19:25 (starting w/ the)
- 20:21; 21:6-12; 21:25-22:3; 22:22 (starting w/ to meet) - 23:2; 23:3(do you know, sir) -24:2; 24:5-10; 24:12; 24:15; 24:16-26:14; 26:16;
29:18-30:12; 31:11-12; 31:11-32:1; 32:9-34:21; 36:4- 7; 37:7-:22;
38:1-5; 38:8-39:1; 39:9-:11; 42:13-43:2; 43:21-23; 43:25; 44:2-17;
44:19; 47:8-11; 47:14-50:9; 51:7 (start w/ at)-51:11; 74:14-75:15;
75:19; 81:11-17; 81:22-82:7; 83:10 -84:10; 84:13-25; 85:3-7; 85:9;
86:10-12; 86:20-87:11; 87:13- 14 (ending at line); 87:17-90:18; 91:2
(start w/ it was a) -91:19; 92:9-11; 92:13; 92:17-93:6; 93:8-93:9; 93:12-

FRITO-LAYS VIDEO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

PAGE 2

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-2

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 7 PageID #: 4405

Witness
Rusty Karschner

Rich Koulouris

Ryan Lane

Jennifer Loge

Designations
13; 93:15-16; 94:2-6
5:1-6:7, 40:8-12, 43:17-23, 44:18-45:18, 47:17-48:2, 48:12-22, 68:2225, 78:8-12, 80:11-19, 82:2-5, 84:11-22, 84:25-85:6, 97:8-14, 105:1420, 107:14-17, 119:3-121:2, 123:18-124:4, 124:15-22, 134:12-135:11,
138:21-139:2, 153:1-154:23, 155:6-156:11, 159:2-5, 159:23-25, 160:17
6:25-7:1; 7:6-8:5; 19:15-19; 20:12-15; 25:1-17; 27:19-28:5; 28:9-23;
29:3-13; 30:7-31:8; 34:19-24; 36:2-14; 39:3-14; 40:3-8; 41:1-8; 42:1618; 45:25-46:11; 46:18-47:16; 48:3-50:1; 51:19-52:2; 53:17-24; 54:819; 57:19-58:23; 62:17-63:3; 64:9-12; 64:17-18; 64:21-65:12; 73:2474:2; 83:18-84:4; 96:14-97:2; 98:5-24; 103:7-105:25; 107:5-109:5;
113:8-10; 113:13-114:7; 115:21-118:5; 120:10-121:24; 122:8-10;
122:25-123:4; 123:6-10; 126:1-5; 126:14-17; 126:20-127:6; 128:16129:13; 129:24-131:22; 132:14-133:25; 134:6-15; 140:13-15; 141:922; 142:16-143:4
6:1 - 6:23; 7:1 - 7:9; 7:14 - 7:17; 9:4 - 9:8; 9:9 (starting w/give) 9:13;
9:14 (starting w/What) - 9:25; 10:3 (starting w/What) - 10:18; 10:23
(starting w/in) - 10:25; 11:1 - 11:3; 15:2 - 15:5; 15:7 (starting w/are) 15:14; 15:19 (starting w/There) - 15:22; 15:24 - 15:25; 16:1 - 16:3;
16:5 - 16:25; 18:14 - 18:19; 1822 - 18:25; 19:1 - 19:4; 20:2 - 20:5;
20:24 - 21:8: 23:4 - 23:6; 23:8 - 23:10; 23:23 - 23:25; 24:7 - 25:11;
25:12 (starting w/what,) - 25:23; 26:7 - 26:19; 28:16 - 28:19; 28:20
(starting w/thats) - 29:3; 29:8 - 29:9; 29:21 (starting w/Is) - 29:24;
30:5 - 30:10; 30:14 - 30:17; 30:21 - 30:25; 31:8 (starting w/Do) 31:17; 31:19 - 31:20; 32:12 - 32:17; 32:23 - 34:11; 34:16 (starting
w/Do) - 34:20; 37:15 - 38:1; 39:15 - 39:24; 40:4 - 40:15; 40:24
(starting w/What) - 41:2; 41:3 (starting w/What) - 41:16; 41:18; 41:20
(starting w/If) - 42:12; 45:24 (starting w/are you) - 46:3; 47:21 - 47:22;
47:24 - 48:3; 48:6 - 48:13; 51:6 - 51:10 ; 51:22 - 52:17; 56:7 - 56:12;
56:14 (starting w/Is) - 56;21; 61:22 (starting w/do) - 61:24; 62:1 - 62:4;
62:5-65:6; 65:17 - 65:25; 66:2 - 66:5; 66:8 - 66:12; 67:14 - 67:24;
71:19 - 72:17; 72:20 - 72:23; 74:2 (starting w/the) - 74:6; 76:18 - 77:8;
77:19 - 77:23; 79:20 (starting w/Do) - 79:23; 81:22 - 81:25; 82: 9 82:12; 84:6 - 84:8; 84:10 - 84:11; 84:22 - 84:25; 85:4 - 85:11; 85:18 85:20; 85:21 (starting w/there) - 86:6; 86:8; 86:10 - 86:11; 86:19 87:6; 87:8; 87:13 - 87:23; 88:3 - 88:16; 88:18; 88:19 (starting w/have) 88:20 88:23 - 89:11; 89:14 (starting w/read) - 89:19; 90:6 - 90:8; 90:10;
90:12 - 90:14; 90:19 (starting w/in the) - 90:21; 90:23; 90:25 - 91:2;
91:4 (starting w/Mr. G) - 91:8; 91:13; 91:21 - 91:24; 92:1; 92:3 - 92:8;
93:21 - 93:22; 93:24 - 94:1; 96:16 - 96:17; 96:19 - 96:20; 96:22 - 97:3;
97:9; 99.7 - 99:8; 99:10 - 99:12; 100:24 - 101:24; 102:1 - 102:2; 102:10
- 102:15; 102.21 - 102:24; 103:3; 103:25 - 104:1; 104.2 (starting
w/What) - 104:13; 106.2 - 106:7; 106;15 - 106:16; 106:18; 117:19
(starting w/Who) - 117:23
6:1-23, 17:22-18:11, 34:14-35:20, 54:19-55:12, 66:23-67:7, 106:14-

FRITO-LAYS VIDEO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

PAGE 3

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-2

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 7 PageID #: 4406

Witness
Michael Mazis
Jackie Price

Adriana Quintanar
Guzman

Joshua Stimson

Michael Trowbridge

Designations
107:18, 110:14-111:6, 120:6-123:4
6:1 - 7:5, 7:9 - 7:10, 7:19 - 7:24, 38:9 - 39:23, 39:25 - 40:12, 165:9 166:12
8:1 - 8:25; 9:3 - 9:17; 22:5 - 22:9; 23:6 - 23:11; 24:5 - 24:10; 25:6 25:8; 25:12 (starting w/What) - 25:23; 26:2 (starting w/What) - 26:8;
26:12 (starting w/Can) - 26:24; 29:9 - 29:20; 38:9 - 38:15; 68:14
(starting w/could) - 68:9; 69:2 (starting w/Mr. V) - 69:4; 69:6 - 69:8;
71:21 - 71:23; 72:5 - 72:10; 73:13 - 73:16; 81:4 - 81:15; 81:18 (starting
/what) - 81:20; 82:16 - 82:23; 83:8 - 83:12; 86:3 - 86:5; 87:3 - 87:14;
88:9 (starting w/Were) - 90:6; 91:14-19; 91:25 (starting w/How) - 92:2;
92:16 - 92:20; 92:25 - 93:2; 93:8 - 93:10; 93:13 - 93:25; 94:22 - 94:24;
95:1 (starting w/they) - 95:2; 96:20 - 96:25; 97:9 - 97:18; 103:18 103:24; 104:1 - 104:8; 109:6 - 109:18; 122:3 - 122:13; 127:1 (starting
w/And so) - 127:4; 157:22 - 157:23; 157:25 - 158:7; 160:5 (starting
w/If) - 160:12; 160:19 - 160:21; 161:18 - 161:21; 163:6 (starting
w/from) - 163:13; 163:20 - 163:23; 191:3 - 191:5; 191:14 - 191:19;
210:21 - 211:1; 211:7 - 211:9; 211:13; 211:15 - 211:21
4:1-14; 5:2-10:15; 11:13-22; 18:14-18; 24:9-15; 25:2-18; 28:25-30:20;
31:19-23; 49:21-25; 50:18 (begin with "Dr.") - 51:3; 61:6-9; 110:1016; 124:24-125:1; 127:9-22; 143:2-11; 176:24-177:18; 178:17-179:4;
180:18-181:10; 187:3-189:3; 192:5-12; 199:13-20; 200:4-5; 200:9-20;
209:23-211:6; 221:11-17; 222:1-15; 223:6-13; 224:1-225:9; 228:11229:20
8:1-10; 9:8-9:10; 10:1-6; 11:4-17; 12:13-22; 14:6-14; 16:19-19:21;
21:13-22:10; 28:5-15; 28:23-29:7; 29:11-30:5; 35:9-18; 45:20-46:6;
46:19-47:12; 50:18-21; 51:1-10; 52:21-53:18; 55:15-25; 56:11-57:14;
57:15-58:12; 60:18-61:16; 79:19-21; 96:10-97:5; 97:10-99:8; 99:16-20;
99:21-100:19; 101:5-11; 102:11-16; 102:24-103:8; 103:17-104:7;
105:1-105:20; 105:21-107:12; 107:13-109:3; 109:8-17; 109:25-110:2;
111:24-112:16; 112:24-113:1; 116:22-117:3; 118:11-14; 118:20119:18; 120:4-8; 120:17-121:2; 122:8 (begin at "By") - 124:21
9:1-10:20, 13:7-17, 18:22-19:12, 37:14-25, 38:10-13, 40:20-23, 41:811, 43:13-44:22, 45:5-9, 50:18-51:24, 57:22-58:25, 62:6-17, 64:2465:3, 68:24-69:14, 70:12-17, 71:25-72:3, 80:12-19, 81:10-82:5, 87:1688:24, 90:3-91:7, 93:4-16, 93:20-96:16, 97:12-15, 100:14-103:22,
104:7-14, 105:5-9, 106:8-108:7, 109:1-9, 110:25-112:20, 114:24-115:1,
116:9-118:12, 120:3-12, 121:12-122:15, 123:3-124:21, 125:11-22,
127:1-9, 127:16-129:1, 129:12-14, 130:24-131:7, 131:23-132:12,
133:14-134:10, 135:20-136:8, 137:3-9, 141:13-23, 143:12-144:2,
145:14-146:5, 147:10-24, 148:18-23, 149:22-150:1, 151:5-7, 151:1921, 151:25-154:3, 158:11-19, 158:24-159:1, 160:8-11, 163:14-19,
169:21-170:10, 171:23-172:8, 174:18-24, 175:4-177:2, 177:10-19,
180:12-23, 182:20-22, 183:23-184:4, 188:18-22, 189:14-191:8, 192:10194:10, 195:24-196:18, 197:13-15, 198:16-199:10, 200:3-204:4,
206:19-25, 209:20-24, 211:18-212:11, 216:17-217:9, 217:25-218:18,

FRITO-LAYS VIDEO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

PAGE 4

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-2

Filed 01/22/13 Page 6 of 7 PageID #: 4407

Witness

Designations
221:23-224:25, 225:16-235:9, 237:2-244:25, 245:17-251:12, 252:2-23,
253:5-16, 261:4-14, 262:22-263:2, 266:8-14, 268:1-270:2, 270:14-18,
271:22-273:12

M. Kent Vickery

Andy Westervelt

Bryan Wheelock

9-28-12 / 6:1-7:20, 8:17-9:9, 16:18-17:15, 26:17-24, 27:9-24, 29:1430:6, 39:8-12, 43:25-44:2, 44:12-45:6, 46:11-20, 47:21-49:24, 52:1822, 53:19-24, 55:3-8, 57:1-4, 60:12-19, 66:2-9, 66:16-20, 67:4-9,
67:12-18, 69:5-10, 75:22-76:6, 77:12-78:18, 78:22-80:11, 80:20-24,
81:5-11, 81:25-82:12, 83:5-85:1, 86:3-24, 98:5-19, 104:23-105:7,
107:20-108:1, 112:2 (starting with what)-112:5, 115:25-116:16,
120:6-11, 121:14-18, 124:5-125:13, 126:2-4, 126:24-127:1, 144:1-16,
148:18-149:7, 149:13-18, 162:17-23, 164:15-165:2
12-7-12 / 7:1-8:20, 15:22-19:14, 20:13-21, 24:7-25, 27:17-28:15,
28:23-29:25, 30:8-15, 31:12-16, 37:16-38:16, 39:25-40:5, 42:10-19,
45:5-48:1, 49:17-52:22, 55:11-57:1, 57:22-60:18, 62:5-66:17, 67:1268:7, 69:4-70:9, 70:15-72:18, 73:12-74:5, 74:18-24, 79:23-82:19, 83:613, 84:4-25, 86:16-25, 87:1-90:7, 91:7-11, 97:25-98:18, 102:10-15,
110:22-111:15, 118:17-121:12, 122:10-12, 123:17-126:11, 127:10-22,
128:23-129:19, 131:6-13, 133:9-134:7, 134:14-135:3, 137:3-138:15,
139:25-140:11, 142:2-12, 143:25-144:4, 144:15-149:9, 150:19-25,
152:11-17, 153:16-19, 154:14-158:24, 161:6-9, 162:8-17, 163:17164:24, 172:11-177:4, 179:6-180:13, 181:18-24, 183:14-184:8, 190:14193:3, 193:12-194:19, 195:23-196:2, 198:16-25, 199:19-200:16, 201:521, 202:1-7, 202:20-203:14, 209:7-211:23, 217:12-14, 224:5-8, 230:1013, 231:6-13, 238:24-239:25, 243:13-260:10, 260:22-261:22, 262:5-8,
264:21-265:17, 267:11-268:17, 270:18-272:5, 275:8-19, 276:13-279:4,
280:5-282:9, 283:1-286:6, 287:6-295:24, 296:7-300:4, 300:18-306:1,
306:14-310:2, 310:17-23
5:1-6:6, 16:10-18:17, 49:2-50:3, 52:16-53:13, 53:20-54:6, 55:4-56:10,
56:19-57:17, 59:12-60:19, 64:18 (starting with who) 65:3, 67:22
(starting with Does) 68:18, 68:20, 69:3-6, 70:3-71:22, 72:7-74:1,
74:18-75:1, 75:24 (starting with And when)76:3, 76:13-19, 77:580:2, 82:11-16, 82:20-83:5, 85:5-8, 85:10-15, 95:1-12, 96:16-98:7,
98:9-99:8, 101:24-102:20, 106:18-107:20, 110:12-16, 114:14 (starting
with who) 114:25, 119:9-19, 120:16-20, 122:18-20, 122:24-123:14,
123:18-124:5, 124:18-20, 125:19-22, 141:18-22, 141:25, 142:10-24,
143:21-144:15, 145:3-146:18, 147:3-148:13, 148:25-149:11, 151:1524, 152:13-153:11, 156:4-157:11, 158:7-19, 162:8-18, 162:24-163:12,
165:16 (starting with would)-165:18, 165:20, 178:23-179:11
7:1-9; 7:19-8:12; 9:9-15; 15:5-6; 15:12-16:21; 23:1-20; 28:1-20; 30:2131:3; 31:9-25; 32:13-33:5; 34:3-35:4; 35:15-21; 39:2-10; 40:17-41:8;
41:17-19; 45:3-46:5; 46:13-18; 47:1-10; 49:18-24; 50:1-22; 51:10-15;
52:4-14; 63:7 (begin with "Did")-11; 63:21-64:2; 64:11-17; 64:21-65:7;
65:16-66:6; 69:5-12; 70:17-18; 71:1; 71:14-18; 74:13-16; 89:16-19;

FRITO-LAYS VIDEO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

PAGE 5

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-2

Filed 01/22/13 Page 7 of 7 PageID #: 4408

Witness

James Young

Joseph Zaleski

Designations
90:3-5; 91:18 (begin with "In")-92:2; 92:16 (begin with "So")-19; 94:57; 94:23-25; 96:24-97:3; 98:11-25; 99:21-100:3; 100:8-13; 100:25101:1; 101:3-10
4:1-17; 5:3-21; 7:2 (begin with "Can")-6; 7:13-17; 9:3-5; 21:9-22:5;
24:8-13; 25:3-14; 26:14-27:10; 29:17-20; 30:12-32-7; 34:14-36:4;
36:8-16; 40:7-17; 43:5-23
7:3-7, 42:24-43:10, 43:23-44:20, 51:4-20, 65:20-23, 74:3-7, 77:2580:1, 80:7-11, 82:10-23, 84:10-17

Dated: January 22, 2013

Respectfully submitted,
/s/_Timothy S. Durst_______
Timothy S. Durst
State Bar No. 00786924
tim.durst@bakerbotts.com
Russell J. Crain
State Bar No. 24045717
russ.crain@bakerbotts.com
Susan Cannon Kennedy
State Bar No. 24051663
susan.kennedy@bakerbotts.com
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 600
Dallas, Texas 75201
Telephone: 214-953-6500
Facsimile: 214-953-6503
Clyde M. Siebman
SIEBMAN, BURG, PHILLIPS
& SMITH, LLP
Federal Courthouse Square
300 N. Travis St.
Sherman, TX 75090
Telephone: 903-870-0070
Facsimile: 903-870-0066
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA,
INC.

FRITO-LAYS VIDEO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

PAGE 6

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-3

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 5 PageID #: 4409

EXHIBIT C

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-3

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 5 PageID #: 4410

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA, INC.,

Plaintiff,

vs.

MEDALLION FOODS, INC. and RALCORP

HOLDINGS, INC.,

Defendants.

No. 4:12-CV-00074-ALM

DEFENDANTS WITNESS LIST


Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(3) and this Courts Scheduling Order,
Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc. (Defendants) hereby identify the following
witnesses:
WITNESS

TOPIC (generally)

Will
Call

May
Call

Depo
Test.
Will

Scott Allen (Medallion)


Janelle Anderson (Frito-Lay)
Bruce Atkins
Scott Batson (Frito-Lay)
Tim Bender (Ralcorp)
John Bischoff (Ralcorp)
Charles Brown (Medallion)
Steve Chandler (Frito-Lay)
Timothy Fink (Frito-Lay)
Deb Gibbins (Frito-Lay)
Jackie Green (Ralcorp)
Woodrow Guinnip
Rusty Karschner
Terry Klockenga (Frito-Lay)
Rich Koulouris (Ralcorp)
Jennifer Loge (Ralcorp)
Jeffrey Martin (Ralcorp)
Michael Mazis
Terry Midden (Wolverine)

Product development/operation
Scoops marketing/pricing/sales
Opinion of counsel
Trade Secrets/Scoops manuf.
Product development/operation
Corporate overview
Product development/financials
Scoops process/invention
Scoops products/Fink process
Scoops financials
Product development/operation
Product development/operation
Product development/operation
Product/process development
Corporate overview
Packaging
Product development/operation
Absence of confusion
Product design/development

May

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-3

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 5 PageID #: 4411

WITNESS

TOPIC (generally)

James Nawrocki
Harvey Norman (Quality Fab)
Philip OKeefe
Martin Okos
Jackie Price
Adriana Quintanar-Guzman
Boyce Sherrill (Frito-Lay)
Triveni Shukla
Josh Stimson (Medallion)
Mike Trowbridge (Medallion)
M. Kent Vickery (Medallion)
Andy Westervelt
Bryan Wheelock
Alexa Williams (Frito-Lay)
James Young
Joseph Zaleski (Reading)

Damages
Equipment used in development
Invalidity
Trade Secret
Product development/operation
Non-infringement
Scoops products/process
Trade Secret
Product development/operation
Product development/operation
Product development/operation
Product development/operation
Opinion of counsel
Scoops development/trade secret
Product development
Product design/development

Will
Call

May
Call

Depo
Test.
Will

May

X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X

X
X
X
X

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-3

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 5 PageID #: 4412

Dated: January 17, 2012

Respectfully submitted,
By: /s/ B. Scott Eidson
David W. Harlan LEAD ATTORNEY
dharlan@armstrongteasdale.com
Jennifer E. Hoekel
jhoekel@armstrongteasdale.com
B. Scott Eidson
seidson@armstrongteasdale.com
Daniel E. Sakaguchi
dsakaguchi@armstrongteasdale.com
Mark A. Thomas
mathomas@armstrongteasdale.com
Timothy D. Krieger
tkrieger@armstrongteasdale.com
Zachary C. Howenstine
zhowenstine@armstrongteasdale.com
ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP
7700 Forsyth Blvd., Suite 1800
St. Louis, Missouri 63105
(314) 621-5070 (telephone)
(314) 621-5065 (facsimile)
T. John Ward
State Bar No. 20848000
tjw@wsfirm.com
T. John Ward, Jr.
State Bar No. 00794818
jw@wsfirm.com
Wesley Hill
State Bar No. 24032294
wh@wsfirm.com
Claire Abernathy Henry
State Bar No. 24053063
claire@wsfirm.com
WARD & SMITH LAW FIRM
1127 Judson Rd., Ste. 220
Longview, Texas 75601
(903) 757-6400 (telephone)
(903) 757-2323 (facsimile
Attorneys for Defendants Medallion Foods, Inc.
and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-3

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 5 PageID #: 4413

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that on January 17, 2013, the undersigned served the foregoing
Witness List, via e-mail, to:
Timothy S. Durst
Susan Cannon Kennedy
Russell J. Crain
Jonathan R. Mureen
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 600
Dallas, Texas 75201
(214) 953-6500 (phone)
(214) 953-6503 (fax)
tim.durst@bakerbotts.com
susan.kennedy@bakerbotts.com
russ.crain@bakerbotts.com
jon.mureen@bakerbotts.com
/s/ B. Scott Eidson

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-4

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 6 PageID #: 4414

EXHIBIT D

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-4

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 6 PageID #: 4415

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION

Plaintiff,

vs.

MEDALLION FOODS, INC. and RALCORP

HOLDINGS, INC.,

Defendants.

FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA, INC.,

No. 4:12-CV-00074-ALM

DEFENDANTS DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS


Witness

Designations

Video

Batson, Scott

10:3-10:22; 11:3-11:10; 39:1-39:25; 43:8-43:22; 44:23-45:1;


46:1-46:8; 50:20-51:13; 53:16-53:22; 54:9-54:23; 55:1-56:3;
63:14-63:21; 65:23-66:6; 70:14-70:23; 79:23-81:5; 81:2281:24; 91:22-92:4; 92:16-94:2

Yes

Chandler, Steven

7:2-7:5; 9:12-9:15; 10:1-10:14; 10:22-11:1; 12:2-12:3; 12:8Yes


12:12; 12:17-12:20; 14:7-14:13; 30:12-30:20; 38:19-38:23; 38:2539:1; 39:5-39:12; 39:20-40:4; 40:8-41:8; 42:8-42:14; 67:24-68:8;
71:1-71:22; 72:4-72:7; 83:4-83:14; 135:17-137:24; 189:6-189:24

Fink, Timothy

6:24-6:25; 8:8-8:12; 10:8-10:9; 16:23-17:12; 42:16-43:15; 43:1643:18; 49:1-57:22; 114:1-114:21; 114:23-114:24

Yes

Gibbins, Deborah

5:2-6:5; 7:18-7:22; 10:11-11:11; 16:1-16:11; 17:7-17:22; 23:223:13; 39:23-41:13

Yes

Green, Jaclyn

7:6-7:15; 9:20-9:25; 12:18-13:6; 13:20-14:8; 14:15-14:23; 15:1215:22; 16:13-17:2; 32:23-33:10; 33:19-33:25; 35:22-36:3; 36:1337:9; 39:8-39:9; 39:15-39:19; 40:18-41:13; 50:1-50:13; 53:1256:1; 56:16-57:5; 57:25-58:3; 58:5-58:7; 66:1-66:23; 67:1567:20; 68:8-69:6; 81:20-82:8; 82:13-83:7; 85:24-86:8; 87:787:23; 88:5-88:20; 90:4-90:11; 90:13-93:21; 94:1-94:16; 96:196:11; 96:13-97:13; 104:9-104:23; 105:11-106:17; 107:15108:18; 108:20-109:15; 109:17-109:23; 113:16-114:4; 115:9115:15; 115:23-116:188; 116:20-116:24; 122:2-122:10; 123:22124:11; 124:22-125:8; 125:11-125:12; 125:14-125:25; 126:1127:4; 128:3-128:21; 128:25-129:12; 131:12-132:6; 141:16142:22; 142:3-142:16; 158:22-159:2; 183:17-184:12; 187:19188:5; 190:4-190:8; 190:10-191:20; 191:22-191:24; 192:16193:23; 195:11-195:22; 198:19-198:21; 198:23; 199:1-199:22

Yes

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-4

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 6 PageID #: 4416

Witness

Designations

Video

Karschner, Rusty

6:9-6:10; 13:6-14:6; 14:12-14:18; 16:3-17:5; 33:1-33:25; 34:1935:7; 39:10-41:23; 42:7-43:20; 44:6-44:13; 48:12-48:22; 53:654:18; 80:20-82:5; 82:10-83:2; 89:11-91:1; 95:21-96:21; 97:897:14; 98:1-99:6; 99:16-100:19; 102:7-102:13; 103:24-104:15;
104:25-105:5; 106:21-107:4; 108:19-109:9; 111:20-112:25;
113:1-114:22; 115:5-115:9; 115:15-116:21; 117:1-117:19;
117:24-119:17; 121:7-121:17; 124:23-131:9; 135:23-137:16;
143:16-147:6; 147:12-148:13; 151:17-152:23

Yes

Klockenga, Terry

6:22-7:2; 9:7-9:10; 35:3-36:18; 54:8; 54:9-54:25; 56:23-57:1;


57:3-57:4; 57:18-58:6; 101:20-102:5; 104:20-106:12; 106:14106:20; 106:22-107:12; 107:14-107:21; 116:8-116:12; 116:21117:1; 117:8-118:10; 118:12-118:15; 118:17-119:12; 127:11127:12; 133:11-133:23; 133:25-134:1; 134:17-135:2; 135:7-135:9

Yes

Midden, Terry

5:8-5:14; 7:4-7:9; 7:13-7:18; 12:19-14:22; 15:7-17:24; 18:320:13; 20:19-22:5; 26:2-26:4; 26:9-27:4; 29:2-29:3; 29:8-29:10;
30:18-30:19; 30:21-31:1; 34:20-35:12

No

Okos, Martin 11/2 6:2-6:4; 22:17-25:25; 26:15-27:23; 29:1-30:3; 30:13-35:15;


35:21-35:25; 36:5-38:3; 39:7-40:21; 40:23-47:23; 47:25-48:4;
48:6-49:10; 49:12-49:25; 50:1-50:11; 51:4-60:7; 60:9-60:20;
60:22-61:10; 61:12-61:17; 61:19-62:9; 62:11-62:13; 62:15-62:24;
75:17-79:4; 79:6-82:19; 82:21-84:7; 84:9-85:2; 85:4; 85:6-86:7;
86:9-86:10; 86:12-86:21; 93:4-94:14; 94:18-100:10; 100:12100:15; 109:18-113:7; 132:25-136:7; 136:11-139:21; 139:23139:24; 140:25-141:18; 148:3-159:9; 159:15-160:14; 160:19164:3; 164:5-164:10; 164:12-164:14; 164:16-167:5; 167:7-167:9;
167:11-167:21; 167:24-169:16; 197:13-200:25; 201:2-201:3;
201:15-202:20; 202:22-202:24; 203:14-203:22; 211:4-212:6;
212:8-212:25; 213:2-214:6; 224:10-226:11; 227:7-227:10

Yes

Price, Jackie

9:5-9:17; 20:21-21:7; 23:6-23:12; 26:12-26:21; 28:8-28:23;


28:24-29:4; 31:13-31:15; 31:20-32:1; 32:6-32:7; 34:4-34:24;
47:16-47:24; 49:18-49:25; 51:3-51:7; 52:1-52:5; 52:21-52:23;
54:19-54:25; 55:1-55:3; 55:8-55:15; 56:10-56:25; 56:21; 59:159:8; 59:17-59:20; 60:1-60:19; 60:24-61:2; 61:8-61:22; 62:2063:13; 64:1-64:25; 80:5-80:13; 80:23-80:25; 81:1-81:9; 81:1682:1; 84:9-84:17; 84:22-84:24; 88:8-88:19; 88:23-89:23; 91:1191:19; 105:16-106:9; 106:19-106:22; 107:23-108:1; 109:19110:11; 111:16-113:1; 113:20-116:15; 131:3-131:22; 132:2132:22; 133:11-133:23; 136:23-137:8; 146:15-146:20; 174:15175:18; 177:1-177:15; 177:19-178:20; 186:7-186:17; 186:19186:20; 186:22-187:8; 187:12-188:6; 188:8-188:14; 203:14204:10; 204:13-204:17; 205:25-207:21

Yes

Sherrill, Boyce

5:20-5:21; 6:17-7:7; 16:2-16:4; 62:18-63:4; 67:4-67:22; 72:572:12

Yes

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-4

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 6 PageID #: 4417

Witness

Designations

Video

Stimson, Joshua

9:3-9:5; 11:4-11:13; 12:16-12:25; 16:22-17:16; 19:7-19:15; 24:224:9; 28:5-29:13; 32:11-35:15; 35:19-35:21; 36:7-37:1; 37:1937:24; 38:3-38:12; 49:5-49:8

Yes

Young, James

4:6-4:13; 9:6-12:9; 17:7-17:18; 17:22-19:24; 20:16-20:21; 37:737:22; 38:21-39:2

Yes

Zaleski, Joseph

7:3-7:7; 9:11-9:22; 11:8-11:17; 11:24-12:5; 12:12-14:4; 14:814:9; 14:10-17:8; 17:9-18:1; 18:24-19:4; 19:5-21:8; 21:12-23:3;
24:6-26:16; 26:22-27:3; 27:6-28:8; 28:16-30:3; 30:11-31:11;
32:20-35:2; 35:3-36:10; 36:17-37:25; 38:3-40:17; 41:12-45:3;
45:9-47:21; 47:24-47:25; 48:4-51:20; 51:22-54:4; 54:6-55:15;
55:18-55:19; 55:21-56:12; 56:14-56:22; 56:24-58:6; 58:11-59:2;
59:13-59:21; 60:18-64:8; 67:9-67:14; 67:21-68:7; 69:8-70:9;
70:10-71:19; 71:22-72:2; 82:10-82:23; 84:10-85:6

No

Dated: January 17, 2012

Respectfully submitted,
By:/s/ B. Scott Eidson____________________ _
David W. Harlan LEAD ATTORNEY
dharlan@armstrongteasdale.com
Jennifer E. Hoekel
jhoekel@armstrongteasdale.com
B. Scott Eidson
seidson@armstrongteasdale.com
Daniel E. Sakaguchi
dsakaguchi@armstrongteasdale.com
Mark A. Thomas
mathomas@armstrongteasdale.com
Timothy D. Krieger
tkrieger@armstrongteasdale.com
Zachary C. Howenstine
zhowenstine@armstrongteasdale.com
ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP
7700 Forsyth Blvd., Suite 1800
St. Louis, Missouri 63105
(314) 621-5070 (telephone)
(314) 621-5065 (facsimile)
and

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-4

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 6 PageID #: 4418

T. John Ward
State Bar No. 20848000
tjw@wsfirm.com
T. John Ward, Jr.
State Bar No. 00794818
jw@wsfirm.com
Wesley Hill
State Bar No. 24032294
wh@wsfirm.com
Claire Abernathy Henry
State Bar No. 24053063
claire@wsfirm.com
WARD & SMITH LAW FIRM
1127 Judson Rd., Ste. 220
Longview, Texas 75601
(903) 757-6400 (telephone)
(903) 757-2323 (facsimile
Attorneys for Defendants Medallion Foods, Inc.
and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-4

Filed 01/22/13 Page 6 of 6 PageID #: 4419

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that on January 17, 2013, the undersigned served the foregoing
Deposition Designations List, via e-mail, to:
Timothy S. Durst
Susan Cannon Kennedy
Russell J. Crain
Jonathan R. Mureen
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 600
Dallas, Texas 75201
(214) 953-6500 (phone)
(214) 953-6503 (fax)
tim.durst@bakerbotts.com
susan.kennedy@bakerbotts.com
russ.crain@bakerbotts.com
jon.mureen@bakerbotts.com
/s/ B. Scott Eidson___________

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-5

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 6 PageID #: 4420

EXHIBIT E

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-5

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 6 PageID #: 4421

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
SHERMAN DIVISION
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA, INC.,

Plaintiff,

vs.

MEDALLION FOODS, INC. and RALCORP

HOLDINGS, INC.,

Defendants.

No. 4:12-CV-00074-ALM

DEFENDANTS DESIGNATIONS OF DISCOVERY RESPONSES


Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(3) and this Courts Scheduling Order,
Medallion Foods, Inc. (Medallion) and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc. (Ralcorp) (collectively,
Defendants) hereby designate the following discovery responses:
1.

Plaintiff Frito-Lay North America, Inc.s (Frito-Lay) Response to Medallions

Request for Admission No. 1 of Medallions First Set of Requests for Admission.
2.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 8 of Medallions

First Set of Requests for Admission.


3.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 44 of

Medallions Second Set of Requests for Admission.


4.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 45 of

Medallions Second Set of Requests for Admission.


5.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 46 of

Medallions Second Set of Requests for Admission.


6.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 47 of

Medallions Second Set of Requests for Admission.

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-5

7.

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 6 PageID #: 4422

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 48 of

Medallions Second Set of Requests for Admission.


8.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 55 of

Medallions Second Set of Requests for Admission.


9.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Request for Admission No. 60 of

Medallions Second Set of Requests for Admission.


10.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Interrogatory No. 4.

11.

Frito-Lays Response to Medallions Interrogatory No. 10.

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-5

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 6 PageID #: 4423

Dated: January 17, 2012

Respectfully submitted,
By:/s/_B. Scott Eidson___________________ _
David W. Harlan LEAD ATTORNEY
dharlan@armstrongteasdale.com
Jennifer E. Hoekel
jhoekel@armstrongteasdale.com
B. Scott Eidson
seidson@armstrongteasdale.com
Daniel E. Sakaguchi
dsakaguchi@armstrongteasdale.com
Mark A. Thomas
mathomas@armstrongteasdale.com
Timothy D. Krieger
tkrieger@armstrongteasdale.com
Zachary C. Howenstine
zhowenstine@armstrongteasdale.com
ARMSTRONG TEASDALE LLP
7700 Forsyth Blvd., Suite 1800
St. Louis, Missouri 63105
(314) 621-5070 (telephone)
(314) 621-5065 (facsimile)
T. John Ward
State Bar No. 20848000
tjw@wsfirm.com
T. John Ward, Jr.
State Bar No. 00794818
jw@wsfirm.com
Wesley Hill
State Bar No. 24032294
wh@wsfirm.com
Claire Abernathy Henry
State Bar No. 24053063
claire@wsfirm.com
WARD & SMITH LAW FIRM
1127 Judson Rd., Ste. 220
Longview, Texas 75601
(903) 757-6400 (telephone)
(903) 757-2323 (facsimile
Attorneys for Defendants Medallion Foods, Inc.
and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-5

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 6 PageID #: 4424

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned certifies that on January 17, 2013, the undersigned served the foregoing
Designation of Discovery Responses, via e-mail, to:
Timothy S. Durst
Susan Cannon Kennedy
Russell J. Crain
Jonathan R. Mureen
BAKER BOTTS L.L.P.
2001 Ross Avenue, Suite 600
Dallas, Texas 75201
(214) 953-6500 (phone)
(214) 953-6503 (fax)
tim.durst@bakerbotts.com
susan.kennedy@bakerbotts.com
russ.crain@bakerbotts.com
jon.mureen@bakerbotts.com
/s/ B. Scott Eidson_______

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-5

Filed 01/22/13 Page 6 of 6 PageID #: 4425

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 10 PageID #: 4426

EXHIBIT F

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 10 PageID #: 4427

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS - SHERMAN DIVISION
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA, INC.
V.
MEDALLION FOODS, INC. AND
RALCORP HOLDINGS, INC.
Presiding Judge: Amos L. Mazzant
Trial Date: February 11, 2013

EXHIBIT LIST
CASE NUMBER: 4:12-CV-00074-ALM
Plaintiffs Attorney: Timothy S. Durst, Clyde Siebman
Court Reporter: Susan Simmons

Defendants Attorney: David Harlan; John Ward, Jr.


Courtroom Deputy:

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

Offered

P-1
P-2
P-4
P-5
P-6
P-7
P-8
P-14
P-19
P-22
P-25
P-26
P-29
P-31
P-32
P-34
P-35
P-36
P-38
P-39
P-40
P-41
P-42
DAL01:1223221.1

Trademark Registration 2,766,278 - (278 Mark)


U. S. Patent No. 6,610,344 - (344 Patent)
CR11-01 Project Backhoe - Capital Appropriation Request
Email from Bischoff to Ken van Ooyen, re: Project Backhoe Update
Project Backhoe PowerPoint for financial meeting
Customer Sales Analysis
Medallion Sales Plan 2013
Medallion 2011 Sales Plan spreadsheet
Medallions fiscal year budget 2012 v. 2011 August Projection
Project Backhoe Invoicing Summary
Category Reviews: Tortilla Chips, Cheese Snacks, Corn Snacks
PowerPoint
Introducing an Exciting Addition to Your Private Label Salty Snack
Program PowerPoint
Medallion Purchase Order: Reading Bakery - Project Backhoe
Medallion Foods, Inc. PowerPoint
Project Backhoe PowerPoint
Email from Martin to Moore, re: Vision System
Medallion Backhoe Vendor Questionnaire
Medallion Backhoe Vendor Questionnaires w/ handwritten notes
RBS Formed Tortilla Oven Concept - April 19, 2010 diagrams
E-mail exchange between Bischoff, Bender, and Vickery
Email exchange between Trowbridge and Bender, re: Wolverine
Email from Bischoff to Bender, re: Project Backhoe Evolution
Quality Fabrication Proposal: Corn Production Line

N/A
N/A
RM228623-53
RM019348
RM019349-58
RM228396-412
RM228347-68
RM284805-957
RM014045-065
RM228514-606
RM199313- 355

09/23/2003
08/26/2003
11/12/2010
11/19/2009
----08/22/2011
---

RM018009-022

10/12/2010

RM000929-934
RM017815-26
RM10952-962
PINN000177
RM010777
RM284980-991
RM009837-38
RM019129-30
RM019187-88
RM017972-73
RM010984-87

05/03/2011
--10/13/2012
--04/19/2010
08/12/2009
08/06/2009
06/17/2010
03/16/2009

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 10 PageID #: 4428

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

Offered

P-43
P-44
P-45

Email from Trowbridge to Bender, re: Project Backhoe


Email from Trowbridge to Westervelt, et al., re: Quality Fabrication trip
Photos

P-60
P-61
P-63
P-84
P-95
P-111
P-112
P-114
P-117
P-118
P-120
P-122
P-123
P-124
P-125
P-126
P-128
P-131
P-132
P-133
P-134
P-135
P-139
P-141
P-146
P-147
P-150
P-151
P-152
P-153
P-154
P-163
P-164
DAL01:1223221.1

07/13/2009
07/24/2009
--

Inventors Assignment of Patent


Patent Application
OKeefe Curriculum Vitae
Email from Bischoff to Bender, re: Project Backhoe
Frito-Lay Corn Specification
Rusty Karschner Email to Bender and Trowbridge, re: Oven Design
Karschner Report, re: Quality Issues
Handwritten Diagram - Alignment
Medallion Foods Background and Overview
Medallion PD Meeting Notes
Introducing Medallion Cupz! PowerPoint
Swivel photo
Hand Written Diagram- Air Assist System
Medallion PD Meeting Notes
Opinion memo from Bryan Wheelock to Walbert.
Email from Walbert to Bender re Project Backhoe
Email from Trowbridge, re: sales call action items
Email from Jeff Martin to Bender, et al, re: vision system
Email from Jeff Martin to Trowbridge, et al, re: RBS oven automation
Email from Gottshall to Bender re: Medallion Update
Email from Bischoff to Bender, re: Project backhoe - RBS participation
CUPZ Tortilla Chip Manufacturing Procedure
Drawing by Jackie Green -- alternative shape
Summary report of sensory panel
Product Attribute Statistical Process Control Chart for CUPZ
Email from Bischoff to Koulouris re: Reading Bakery
Email between Walbert and Atkins re: Project Backhoe
Armstrong Teasdale invoices

RM021101
RM019819
RM000793-802
RM000876-880
RM001129-1134
RM001210-91
N/A
RM018348
RM287280-81
RM019604
RM128931-34
N/A
RM189894-97
RM159818-24
RM018455-77
-RM290203-363
RM285392-393
RM285371-373
RM285385-86
RM018134
RM019799
RM019820
RM019502
RM019155-56
RM14258-67
N/A
RM131802-04
RM289908-11
RM019226
RM285063-064
RM289872-900

Preliminary patent clearance summary


Armstrong Teasdale patent opinion
Reading Bakery System schematics
Email between Walbert, Bender, and Fitzgerald re: Belt Drawing Revision
Email between Walbert and Atkins, re: patents

RM285077-079
RM285012-022
N/A
RM285138-144
RM285164-165

12/09/2010
05/02/2011
06/03/2011
09/10/2010
10/21/2010

03/23/2012
--01/24/2011
12/20/---02/11/2011
01/02/2010
--02/23/2009
09/00/2010
-06/21/2011
04/06/2009
03/26/2010
03/25/2010
06/25/2009
05/27/2011
05/03/2011
11/01/2011
01/29/2010
02/20/2012
-05/29/2012
-02/01/2010
11/18/2010
--

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 10 PageID #: 4429

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

P-165
P-171
P-172
P-173
P-175
P-176
P-178
P-179
P-180
P-181
P-182
P-186
P-187
P-188
P-191
P-193
P-198
P-200
P-201
P-207
P-209
P-210
P-211
P-213
P-235
P-236
P-237
P-239
P-240
P-241
P-242
P-243
P-244
P-245
P-246
P-247
P-248
P-249

RM020915
RRDON000349
RRDON000601-06
RM290435
RM057200-16
RM290974-75
RM120420-25
RM119155-7
RM290942-45
RM290960-69
RM290946-47
RM290982
RM019400
RM019148-54
RM290508-535.
RM289351-289411
RM011922
RM011929
RM011871
RM017726
RM139810
RM132869
RM132967
RBS000206-278
QF000001-24
FL00896071-75
FL00847479-86
FL00896088
RM017987
RM21710
FL00845347
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A

Offered

DAL01:1223221.1

Email from Vickery to Schulte, re Project Backhoe


Black and White Photo- Tostitos SCOOPS!
Email chain, re: Tortilla Bowlz: Design Sample
Tostitos Blue Corn Nutrition Facts
Required Documentation Manual
Customer Comments on Bowlz/Cupz
Email re: Cupz specification - Delhaize
Email re: chip breakage
Email from Vickery to Lane, Lethcoe, re: Cupz issues
Email from Lane to Vickery, with Cupz product specification
Email from Vickery to Achauer, attaching Backhoe flats response
Theres a New Chip in Town Presentation
Email from Knight to Koulouris re: GV Bowlz Sales- Last Week Results
Project Backhoe PowerPoint
Kent Vickery Resume
Documents designated as Kent Vickerys handwritten notes
Revised Discharge Roll Stand Schematic
Quality Fabrication & Design Schematic
Quality Fabrication & Design Schematic
Quality Fabrication & Design Schematic
Email from Stimson to Vickery re: Oil Pipe Labeling
Email from Stimson to Trowbridge re: Alignment Conveyor Belt Jumping
Email from Stimson to Marlin, et al., re: Backhoe Sheeter Platform
Reading Bakery Systems schematic binder
Quality Fabrication & Design Purchase Orders
Quality Fabrication & Design equipment list, contacts and purchase order
Quality Fabrication & Design Agreement
Processing Diagram
Piping and Instrumentation Diagram
Email to Koulouris
Ralcorp 10-K, FYE September 30, 2011
Curriculum Vita of Dr. John D. Floros
Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Martin R. Okos
Dr. Kent Van Liere Resume
Dr. Kent Van Liere Questionnaire and Instructions
Dr. Kent Van Liere Photographs of controls
Mr. Steve Visser Curriculum Vitae
Mr. Steve Visser USPTO Registrations

05/09/2011
-10/27/2011
---03/05/2012
05/11/2012
10/12/2012
10/16/2012
10/12/2012
-02/13/2012
12/10/2010
--07/21/2011
06/20/2011
06/20/2011
02/00/2011
08/30/2011
11/28/2011
02/01/2012
06/03/2011
03/23/2011
02/19/2009
10/28/2002
04/15/2007
04/002011
03/00/2009
12/14/2011
--------

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 10 PageID #: 4430

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

P-250
P-251
P-253
P-254
P-255
P-256
P-257
P-258

N/A

--

N/A
RBS000054-57
RBS000087-89
N/A
N/A
N/A

10/10/2000
03/05/2010
03/05/2010
----

N/A

--

N/A

--

N/A

--

FL00000001-102
FL00000412
FL00000597-611
FL00000678-689
FL00002499-649
FL00002942-59
FL00003100-09
FL00003421-2
FL00003440-2
FL00003552-71
FL00003799-807
FL00004249-55
FL00004319-24
FL00004567
FL00004597-99
FL00005140-46
FL00005432
FL00005527-29

-02/00/2000
-04/00/2010
05/10/2001
06/07/2000
11/02/2000
01/20/2000
12/22/1999
-12/05/2000
03/19/2002
11/21/2000
04/00/2000
03/29/2000
01/12/2001
01/19/2000
02/18/2000

FL00005898-99
FL00008012-25
FL00009788-801
FL00010106-16
FL00010186-98

07/19/2000
08/17/1998
05/15/2002
---

Offered

P-259
P-260
P-261
P-262
P-263
P-264
P-265
P-266
P-267
P-268
P-269
P-270
P-271
P-272
P-273
P-274
P-275
P-276
P-277
P-278
P-279
P-280
P-281
P-282
P-283
P-284
DAL01:1223221.1

Mr. Steve Visser Photographs of bowls


Frito-Lay memo, re: Nutrition/bag sizing/trade call test run
U.S. Patent No. 6,129,939
Summation of results test trial of 3/24/2010 to 3/26/2010
Summation of results test trial of 4/13/2010
Photo Bowlz package
Photo Tostitos SCOOPS! package
SCOOPS! bags - Plaintiff intends to exhibit bags of chips and/or individual
chips to the jury
Bowlz bags - Plaintiff intends to exhibit bags of chips and/or individual
chips to the jury
Cupz bags - Plaintiff intends to exhibit bags of chips and/or individual chips
to the jury
B-scan chips bag - Plaintiff intends to exhibit bag of chips and/or individual
chips to the jury
344 Patent File Wrapper
Proof of Principle 2/2000
Tostitos SCOOPS! History
Successful Innovation PowerPoint
Tostitos Scoops Project Frankfort East Plant Startup Plan
TAB report of SCOOPS!
Scoops startup plan
Memo from Williams to Chandler and Gold, re: Period 1 Report
Period 13 Project FIESTA Report
Tostitos SCOOPS! Technical Review
Kern Tostitos SCOOPS! Startup Plan
Kern TC SCOOPS! Equipment List
Plunge/Mold System - Report and Recommendations
SCOOPS! Update
Email from Chandler, re: Kern Frito-Lay SCOOPS! Team Members
Corn Washer Specifications
TC SCOOPS! Project Overview
Memo from Mensch to Basantes and Williams; re: final report Tostitos
SCOOPS! CLTT Final Report
SIG proof of principle
Project Fiesta Process and Product Performance Specifications
Lynchburg TC SCOOPS! Equipment List
Tostitos SCOOPS! Consumer Proposition Presentation
Tostitos SCOOPS! The Next Step

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 6 of 10 PageID #: 4431

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

P-285
P-286
P-287
P-288
P-289
P-290

SCOOPS! Design Review


Email from Chandler to Farabaugh, re: SCOOPS! project update
Email from Robinson to Chandler re: Period 8 Project Fiesta Report
Tostitos SCOOPS! Project Briefing
Sensory Testing Documentation
Sensory Testing Documentation

FL00011489
FL00011940-46
FL00011953-54
FL00011955-2049
FL00014158-167
FL00014191-204

P-291
P-292
P-293
P-294
P-295
P-296

Sensory Testing Documentation - SCOOPS! OMT


Tostitos SCOOPS! Proposition Fiesta Bowl 2001
Email from Williams to Chandler & Santana, re: SCOOPS! 4th Table
TC SCOOPS! Sequence of Operations
CAR/ESR Completion Instructions
344 Patent Certified Copy of File Wrapper

P-297

Introducing Scooped Tortilla Chips Presentation

P-298
P-299
P-300
P-301
P-302
P-303
P-304
P-305
P-306
P-307
P-308
P-309

Product Research Strategy


Directions Research Tostitos CTS - Presentation
Tortilla Chip Equipment Audit
Tostitos Is Delivering Profit Growth in 2001
Email from Ruegg to Jason Audley, re: Borescope SOP document
E-mail from Trick to Bone; Re: TC SCOOPS! Flat Qualitative Testing
Kern TC SCOOPS! Phase I Kickoff Meeting Agenda
Trademark Assignment - certified copy
Patent Assignment - certified copy
Kent Vickerys complete Frito-Lay Personnel File
Kent Vickery Personnel File - Kent Vickery Agreement
Kent Vickery Personnel File - Kent Vickery Signature Pages

P-310
P-311
P-312
P-313
P-314
P-315

Reading Bakery Systems Agreement


Frito-Lay Employee Handbook
Tostitos SCOOPS! Weak Link Quality Evaluation
Jonesboro Tostitos SCOOPS! Startup Phase Transition Criteria
LBCSS Corn Cook & Soak Commissioning Protocol
Bscan chip pdf

FL00014375-386
FL00014670
FL00015056-058
FL00353094-168
FL00359273-92
FL00363802-4213
FL00363214-670
FL00850956-1026
FL00851027-484
FL00365257.005012
FL00365258
FL00392347-54
FL00486583-721
FL00489527-60
FL00498167-172
FL00533245-47
FL00843297
FL00846443-454
FL00846455-457
FL00846458-7302
FL00847053-55
FL00847093,
FL00847095-96
FL00847355-57
FL00848673-739
FL00848977
FL00848978-9010
FL00849011-17
FL00849140

Offered

DAL01:1223221.1

-09/09/1999
08/04/1999
08/05/1999
05/04/2000
01/07/2000
01/12/2000
10/05/1999
03/18/1999

10/00/2001
03/27/2001
07/00/2000

03/25/2003

10/26/2004

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 7 of 10 PageID #: 4432

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

P-316

Certified copy of patent 853 File Wrapper


Certified Copy of 853 Patent

FL00849782-50025
FL00851485-703
FL00845343-346

P-317
P-318
P-319
P-320
P-321
P-322
P-323
P-324
P-325
P-326
P-327
P-328
P-329
P-330
P-331
P-332
P-333
P-334
P-335

Foster Miller Agreement


Wolverine Agreement
PepsiCo Policy
Frito-Lay Facility Photos
Presentation: Maximum Acceptable Toast Points
Tostitos SCOOPS! Product Attribute Evaluation
Corn Purchase Agreement
Medallion Plant Inspection Photos
Kroger Cupz Source of Volume
TC Equipment Audit
Jonesboro Handbook
Email from Gold to Ruegg, re: Kern status
Kern SCOOPS! Start Up Report
Email from Chandler to Robinson re: period 9 Project Fiesta Report
TAB meeting notes
Hand drawn diagram - chip ejection concept
Tostitos SCOOPS! Chip Release Task Force; conference call notes
Agreement Recot and Frito-Lay
Photos of molds and plungers from SCOOPS! development
FL may show the jury the original molds and plungers depicted in the
photos
Great Value bag pictures
Dr. Kent Van Liere Survey Materials

FL00852608-16
FL00852732-33
FL00880303-304
FL00880306-56
FL00880401
FL00880403
FL00880533-40
FL00880541-2
FL00880604
FL00880608-13
FL00880614-50
FL00883421
FL00884506
FL00889822-23
FL00889896
FL00890714
FL00890715-16
FL00895933-41
FL00895942-970

Offered

P-336
P-337
P-338
P-339
P-340
P-341
P-342
P-343
P-344
P-345
P-346
P-347
DAL01:1223221.1

Corn soaking mechanical schematic


Corn cleaning mechanical schematic
Agreement Recot and Frito-Lay
50th Anniversary Innovation poster - timeline
FL may show the jury and/or offer the original poster
Westervelt Employment Spreadsheet
SCOOPS! Historical CAPEX Summary
Topeka Plant Photos
Portion of USPTO 278 Trademark File
Iowa State Transcript OKeefe
Soak tank schematic

FL00895971-973
FL00895984-993
FL00895994
FL00896134
FL00896172
FL00897208-210
FL00900932
FL00901164-165
FL00901023
FL00901218-258
FL00901338-348
FL00901349-350
FL00896079

05/27/2009
06/00/2005

08/01/1998
02/09/2001
01/04/2011
09/02/1999
-02/05/2001
02/06/2001

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 8 of 10 PageID #: 4433

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

P-348
P-349
P-350
P-351
P-352
P-353

RM017551
FL00851989-2092
FL00378789-889
FL00895974-979
FL00901306-324
JY01-14; 16-19

Offered

P-354
P-355

P-356
P-357
P-358

P-359
P-360
P-361
P-362
P-363
P-364
P-365
P-366
P-367
P-368
P-369
DAL01:1223221.1

Gottshall Email to Albers, et al., re: Backhoe


278 Trademark File Wrapper
278 Trademark Prosecution File
Team Awards Pictures
Frito-Lay - Quality Fabrication & Design Agreements
E-mail exchange between Young and Trowbridge; re: confidentiality
agreement; signed confidentiality agreement
E-mail from Trowbridge; re: conference call
Mr. Scott Phillips Exhibits 1-12:
Spreadsheet Medallion Profits
Spreadsheet Medallions Incremental Gross Profit
Spreadsheet 2013 Sales Plan Profitability
Spreadsheets Medallion 2012 Wal-Mart Bowlz Profit
Spreadsheets Medallion 2012 Kroger Cupz Profit
Spreadsheets Unflavored Tortilla Chips
Spreadsheet 2012 Sales Plan
Spreadsheets Scoops Profit
Spreadsheets Scoops and Tostitos P&L Wal-Mart Sales
Spreadsheets Scoops and Tostitos P&L Kroger Sales
Spreadsheets Scoops and Tostitos P&L
Medallion P&L
Spreadsheet Summary of Patent Royalty Rate Research
Trademark registrations from Tums, Kikkoman and Elmers Glue
E-mail from Jeff Martin to Mark Moore
Project Backhoe Schematics

Reading Bakery Systems Drawing


Cupz Tortilla Chip Manufacturing Procedure
Quality Fabrication & Design Purchase Order
Lime Slurry Purchase Order
Reading Bakery Systems estimated pricing for Project Backhoe
Reading Bakery Systems Operation and Maintenance Manual
Defendants Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs First Set of
Interrogatories - Interrogatory Responses 2, 4, 6, 7
Manufacturing Agreement
Lime Slurry System and Corn Cooking System
Test Plan

JY15
N/A

11/04/2011

--

N/A
PINN000173-74
RM000388
RM000387
RM000391
RM000397
RM000463-472
RM000943-45
RM001027-31
RM009774
RM010169-336
N/A

-03/23/2012

FL00848932-941
RM013391-419
RM013457

12/28/2003

09/02/2011
04/19/2010
06/28/2012

03/24/2010

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 9 of 10 PageID #: 4434

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

P-370
P-371
P-372
P-373
P-374
P-375
P-376
P-377
P-378

RM013620
RM013908-11
RM013969
RM013985
RM014397-409
RM017656-7
RM001771-72
RM018030
RM018034

Offered

P-379
P-380
P-381
P-382
P-383
P-384
P-385
P-386
P-387
P-388
P-389
P-390
P-391
P-392
P-393
P-394
P-395
P-396
P-397
P-398
P-399
P-400
P-401
P-402
P-403
P-404

DAL01:1223221.1

Finished Bowlz Specification


Medallion PD Meeting Notes
Medallion PD Meeting Notes
Medallion PD Meeting Notes
Project Backhoe Presentation: Under Construction
Email from Klanac to ORourke, re: Backhoe/Cupz Project with attachment
Project Backhoe product specifications
Email from ORourke to Vickery et al., Cupz rollout schedule
Email from ORourke to Vickery et al., re: Cupz Sample Order for
Presentation
Terry Midden Email to Kent Vickery
Email from Vickery to Bischoff, re: CHC Capital and Investment Strategy
Email from Meehan to Bender, re CHC Medallion Meeting with attachment
Email from Mary Knight to Darren Baker, re: Great Value Bowlz Launch
Email from Mike Trowbridge to Tim Bender and Kent Vickery
Email from Mike Trowbridge to Kent Vickery
Email from Mike Trowbridge to Tim Bender
Email from Mike Trowbridge to Tim Bender, re: oven manufacturers
Reading Bakery Systems cost breakdown for trial run
Email from Joe Mehan to Charlie Brown
Email from Kent Vickery to Tim Bender
Email from Bischoff to Bender, re: Project Backhoe Meeting
Email from John Bischoff to Rich Koulouris
Project Backhoe Presentation
Tortilla Training Topic
Medallion PD Email
Medallion PD Email
Project Backhoe Test Plan
Medallion PD Meeting Notes
Email from Gettinger to Vickery, re: Corn Contracts
Email from Kent Vickery to Michael ORourke
Introducing an Exciting Addition to your Private Label Salty Snack
Program PowerPoint
Email from Kathleen Clark to Kent Vickery, re: GV Bite Size Production
Email from Kent Vickery to Michael ORourke
Medallion PD Meeting Notes
Medallion PD Meeting Notes

01/11/2011
02/22/2010
08/19/2009
07-08-2010
09/01/2011
09/09/2010

RM018111
RM018384-87
RM018397-417
RM018578-79
RM019415
RM019416
RM019417
RM019610
RM019700
RM020711-13
RM021096-97
RM021326
RM021710
RM022244-62
RM022899-916
RM057425
RM071569
RM096975-77
RM117480-81
RM120011-13
RM120094-96
RM120286-306

05/01/2009
03/19/2009
10/20/2010
01/20/2012
01/12/2010
01/06/2010
01/21/2010
07/07/2009

RM124768-75
RM130072-73
RM013939-42
RM159812-14

09/09/2010
02/01/2012
09/20/2010
05/18/2009

11/30/2010
08/19/2009
05/01/2009
03/09/2009

02/10/2009
01/27/2009
04/13/2010
12/13/2010
09/24/2010
10/04/2010
10/15/2010

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-6

Filed 01/22/13 Page 10 of 10 PageID #: 4435

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.
Date
Marked
Admitted
Description
Ex # Ex #

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM


Bates
Date

P-405

Email re: SCOOPS! sales

P-406
P-407
P-408
P-409
P-410
P-411
P-412
P-413
P-414

Medallion Foods Trip Report


Email from Bischoff to Lane, Re: Bowlz Factory Trial
Meijer PowerPoint
E-mail from Bruce Atkins to Daniel Fitzgerald, re: alignment system
Bischoff email
Corn washing equipment photograph
Email from Woloszyn to Vickery, re: Project Backhoe Update
Sales and Distribution Agreement
Photographs from Quality Fabrication

P-415
P-416
P-417
P-418
P-419
P-420
P-421
P-422

Jonesboro Photos and Videos


Email re: Kroger Cupz flats
R&D Lab Notebooks
Medallion facility photographs
Mr. Scott Phillips Spreadsheet - 1.1S Patent Reasonable Royalty Damages
Email from ORourke to Loge, re: Cupz Roll-out
Email from Wheelock to Mullen
Ralcorp Standards of Business Conduct

RM019400
RM019916-17
RM207688-700
RM213539-44
RM284958-65
RM285220
RM285387-8
RM287903
RM289271-72
FL00848942-951
RM290439
RM290445
FL00901369-70
RM290954 -59
FL00013163-3440
RM000399-461
N/A
RM012182-85
RM285378
RM091994-99

Offered

DAL01:1223221.1

12/21/2011
03/00/2011
12/07/2010
05/25/2010

12/28/2003
-----09/20/2011
04/17/2009
--

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 1 of 18 PageID #: 4436

EXHIBIT G

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 2 of 18 PageID #: 4437

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS - SHERMAN DIVISION
FRITO-LAY NORTH AMERICA, INC.,

Defendants Exhibit List

v.
MEDALLION FOODS, INC. and
RALCORP HOLDINGS, INC.,
Presiding Judge: Amos L. Mazzant
Trial Date: February 11, 2013

Case No. 4:12-CV-00074-ALM

Plaintiffs Attorney: Timothy Durst, Clyde Siebman


Court Reporter: Susan Simmons

Defendants Attorney: David Harlan, John Ward Jr.


Courtroom Deputy:

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

D-001

Dip It Video

SCRIPPS0001

D-002

Wolverine and Frito-Lay Proposed Contract for Plunger


System and Molding Conveyor (1999)

FL00001418FL00001433

Scoops Frankfort East Plant Startup Plan (2001)

FL00002499FL00002649

Project Fiesta Frito-Lay Proprietary Equipment & Process


Learnings & Enhancements
Project Fiesta: Alignment System Equipment Specifications
Addendum (6/11/2000)

FL00002933FL00002941

Tostitos Scoops! Weak-Link Quality Evaluation form

FL00003770FL00003792

D-007

Fluor Daniel Equipment List Kern TC Scoops Capital


Equipment (3/19/2002)

FL00004249FL00004255

D-008

Fluor Daniel Equipment List Lynchburg Line 3 TC Scoops


(5/15/2002)

FL00009788FL00009801

D-009

11/14/2000 Memo from S. Chandler to A. Williams.

FL00014555

D-003
D-004
D-005
D-006

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

FL00003379FL00003382

Depo Ex. #

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 3 of 18 PageID #: 4438

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #
D-010
D-011
D-012
D-013

Ex #

Date
Offered

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Description

Bates Range

11/13/2000 Memo from S. Chandler to A. Williams.

FL00014556

TC Scoops (2002), Commercialization Stages diagram

FL00014683FL00014694

Tostitos Scoops! Product Evaluation Manual

FL00015200FL00015218

U.S. Patent No. 6,129,939 (Fink, et al.)

Depo Ex. #

O7

T10

CAD image of Reading Bakery Systems Oven

RM 000396RM 000398

Tostitos Scoops History presentation

FL00000597FL00000611

10/19/2010 Frito-Lay Quality Bulletin. Subject: Temporary


TC Fried Scoops Control

FL00483389FL00483390

F1

March 24-26, 2010 Project Backhoe Test Plan

RBS000054RBS000057

Q3

2/24/2000 TC Scoops ELT Project Review

FL00010039FL00010049

K6

D-019

12/13/1999 Tostitos Scoops CAB Review Follow-Up

FL00889893

L7

D-020

Sample Scoops Bags from Jonesboro Inspection

D-021

03/26/2010 Memorandum from B. Wheelock, Esq. Subject:


Project Backhoe.

RM 00285371RM 00285373

125

Tostitos Scoops Technical Review

FL00003552FL00003571

D-023

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000399

D-024

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000401

D-025

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000402

D-026

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000404

D-014
D-015
D-016
D-017
D-018

D-022

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 4 of 18 PageID #: 4439

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Description

Bates Range

D-027

Photograph of Medallion Sheeter Cutter

RM 000405

D-028

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Sheeter)

RM 000406

D-029

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Sheeter)

RM 000407

D-030

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000408

D-031

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Inside Toast Oven)

RM 000410

D-032

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000411

D-033

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Chip distribution/bagger


machine)

RM 000412

D-034

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Medallion cutter detail)

RM 000416

D-035

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Corn wash)

RM 000417

D-036

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000420

D-037

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000421

D-038

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000422

D-039

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000429

D-040

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000430

D-041

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000431

D-042

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000432

D-043

Photograph of Backhoe Process (even ranks sheeter belt)

RM 000434

D-044

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000435

D-045

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000437

D-046

Photograph of Backhoe Process (air assist)

RM 000439

D-047

Photograph of Backhoe Process (transfer to mold belt)

RM 000440

D-048

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000441

D-049

Photograph of Backhoe Process (oven)

RM 000445

Depo Ex. #

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 5 of 18 PageID #: 4440

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Description

Bates Range

D-050

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000446

D-051

Photograph of Backhoe Process (oven)

RM 000449

D-052

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000450

D-053

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000451

D-054

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000452

D-055

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000453

D-056

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000454

D-057

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000455

D-058

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000456

D-059

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000457

D-060

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000458

D-061

Photograph of Backhoe Process

RM 000459

D-062

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Medallion mold detail)

RM 000460

D-063

Photograph of Backhoe Process (Medallion molds)

RM 000461

D-064

Photograph of 2013 Tostitos Scoops Packaging

D-065

Reading Bakery Systems Operation & Maintenance Manual for


Medallion Project Backhoe

RM 000473RM000592

D-066

CAD drawing of proposed Backhoe process

RM 001798

D-067

CAD drawing of proposed Backhoe process

RM 001799

D-068

11/12/2010 Ralcorp / Medallion 2011 Capital Appropriations


Request (C.A.R.) Project Backhoe Tortilla Cupz

RM 002866RM 002872

D-069

Reading Bakery Systems Budgetary Proposal for Project


Backhoe Pilot Conveyor System

RM 009639RM 009644

D-070

Photo of BOWLZ package

D-071

Photo of Tostitos package

Depo Ex. #

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 6 of 18 PageID #: 4441

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #
D-072
D-073
D-074
D-075

Ex #

Date
Offered

Marked

Admitted

Description

Bates Range

Depo Ex. #

Photos of product packaging

FL00365262FL00365297

Tostitos Packaging Review QT 2012 presentation

FL00264179FL00264187

07/29/2011 Excomm Tostitos Core Product Upgrade

FL00192125FL00192126

Photo of 2012 Tostitos Scoops package

D-078
D-079
D-080
D-081
D-082
D-083
D-084

F
G

Scoops Commercials

FL00083935;
FL00272346;
FL00272347;
FL00272358;
FL00272359

Tostitos Invoke Ad Test results 12/22/2011

FL00254029FL00254051

06/19/2001 Press Release Frito-Lay Launches

FL00378770FL00378771

05/11/2010 Tostitos ABP Presentation

FL00084324FL00084465

Product Design Brief

FL00717755FL00717760

Good Scoops

FL00314895FL00314897

Scoops presentation Introducing scooped tortilla chips

FL00365257.005
FL00365257.012

03/25/2003 Tostitos Scoops! Update

FL00311237FL00311282

03/28/2005 Tostitos Scoops Shape Improvement

FL00343490FL00343498

A1

D-076

D-077

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 7 of 18 PageID #: 4442

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

Depo Ex. #

02/23/2010 TC Scoops Quality Update

FL00315647FL00315654

C1

April 2010 Successful Innovation presentation

FL00000678FL00000689

D1

07/16/2010 Tostitos Scoops Flats Update

FL00314640FL00314643

E1

05/04/2011 Tostitos Scoops Flat Defects Qualitative Research


Summary

FL00314812FL00314820

G1

Ignite Our Selling Spirit presentation

FL00265841FL00265872

H1

February 2011 UTC Strategy

FL00271669FL00271693

I1

D-091

04/18/2011 Email from J. Lambeth. Subject: Tostitos Pricing


POV

FL00451364FL00451366

J1

D-092

04/26/2011 Email from D. Petite. Subject: ILT presentation


discussion

FL00724095FL00724096

K1

7/16/2011 Email from J. Anderson. Subject: Connecting.

FL00451747FL00451748

M1

D-094

07/29/2011 EXCOMM: Tostitos Core Product Upgrade (full


presentation)

FL00192136FL00192141

N1

D-095

08/22/2011 Email from D. Petite. Subject: Scoops CPU Deck


Size Reduction

FL00451816

O1

Scoops is the Product That Could Step Change Our Business

FL00014711FL00014748

P2

D-085
D-086
D-087
D-088
D-089
D-090

D-093

D-096

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

D-097

09/14/2012 Plaintiffs Response to Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.s


Second Set of Interrogatories

D-098

09/18/2012 Email from J. Young. Subject: Case 4:12-CV00074-ALM, e-mail string: Ralcorp-Jim Young

V2
JY00000001JY00000014

H3

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 8 of 18 PageID #: 4443

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Description

Bates Range

Depo Ex. #

D-099

09/18/2012 Email from J. Young. Subject: Case 4:12-CV00074-ALM, e-mail string: Ralcorp-Jim Young (2)

JY00000015

I3

D-100

Frito-Lays Supplemental Interrogatory Responses to


Medallions Interrogatories 6 & 7

F4

12/02/2009 Email from T. Bender. Subject: CA Agreement

RBS000046RBS000049

O3

02/01/2010 Email from T. Bender. Subject: Project Backhoe


RBS Participation

RBS000066RBS000067

P3

04/13/2010 Project Backhoe Test Plan

RBS000087RBS000089

S3

D-104

04/15/2010 Project Backhoe Test Trial April 13th. Trial


Notes Lessoned [sic] Learned

RBS000078

T3

D-105

06/07/2010 Pilot System Estimated Pricing for Project Backhoe

RBS000009

V3

04/19/2010 Formed Tortilla Oven Concept

RBS000010RBS000011

W3

December 16-17, 2010 Project Backhoe Test Plan

RBS000093RBS000096

X3

Medallion Project Backhoe cost estimates spreadsheet


(handwritten bates)

RBS000043

Y3

U.S. Patent No. 6,638,553 (Bell, et al.)

RM 000371RM 000383

B6

December 6-7, 1999 Tostitos Scoops CAB Review. Review


Summary and Project Risk Assessment.

FL00011534FL00011545

G6

U.S. Patent No. 6,610,344 (Bell, et al.)

RM 000357RM 000370

D7

07/17/2000 Project Fiesta (TC Scoops) Bullet Scope

FL00000532

L9

D-101
D-102
D-103

D-106
D-107
D-108
D-109
D-110
D-111
D-112

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 9 of 18 PageID #: 4444

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

Depo Ex. #

D-113

Tostitos Scoops Process Options and Recommendations


presentation

FL00011910FL00011931

R9

D-114

Photo - Detail of product in bag

RM 287336

U10

D-115

Photo Detail of product in bag

RM 287337

V10

D-116

Photo of bag of product

RM 290973

W10

03/16/2009 Quality Fabrication & Design Equipment Proposal

RM 010984RM 010987

K11

Medallion Purchase Orders

QF000001QF000024

L11

D-119

8/10/2009 Email from J. Morgan. Subject: New Multi Grain


Formula

RM 116606RM 116607

82

D-120

Tostitos Scoops Shape Improvement Testing Strategy

FL343423

J2

D-121

02/11/2011 Email from R. Karschner. Subject: Oven design

RM 019604

111

D-122

Project Fiesta TAB Assessment & Recommendations

FL337384

R2

D-123

02/20/2012 Ralcorp Cupz Tortilla Chip Manufacturing


Procedure

RM 014258RM 014267

135

Cupz Tortilla Chip Newport Line 6 Manufacturing Procedure

RM 289438RM 289449

136

05/02/2012 Product Specification Cupz Tortilla Chips

RM 289849RM 289850

137

D-126

Jackie Green email and attachments of chips from different


molds

RM 105043-46

138

D-127

Hand drawing of bowl with crinkled edges (no bates)

D-117
D-118

D-124
D-125

D-128
D-129

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

139

Compusense Summary Report on Cupz tortilla chips

RM 131802RM 131804

141

Project Backhoe Readiness Items

RM 013504RM 013505

143

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 10 of 18 PageID #: 4445

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

Depo Ex. #

Product Attribute Statistical Process

RM 289908RM 289911

146

02/07/2011 Quality Fabrication & Design TC Line quote

RM 010993RM 010995

234

D-132

Piping and Instrumentation Diagram

RM 017987

240

D-133

Project Fiesta (TC Scoops) Kern, California Phase 1


Preliminary Scope of Work and Estimate from Fluor Daniel

FL00000291FL00000328

D-134

06/23/2000 Schedule A to Wolverine Proctor & Schwartz and


Frito-Lay, Inc. Agreement for Services

FL00001978FL00001985

D-135

4/19/2010 Estimated Pricing for Project Backhoe

RM 009774

D-136

09/01/2009 Formed Tortilla Oven Concept

RM 009839

D-137

03/12/2012 Medallion Foods Cupz Oven Control System

RM 010337

D-138

Cambridge Mold CAD drawing

RM 010346

Medallion Foods, Inc. Presentation

RM 010347RM 010358

Cambridge Mold CAD drawing

RM 010363RM 010368

12/19/2011 Cupz Tortilla Chip Manufacturing Procedure

RM 010377RM 010386

Project Backhoe Notes Update from 4/30 call

RM 010966RM 010967

Backhoe cooked corn capacity planning

RM 001522RM 001523

Project Backhoe estimates

RM 001528RM 001537

D-130
D-131

D-139
D-140
D-141
D-142
D-143
D-144

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 11 of 18 PageID #: 4446

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

Ralcorp, Inc. Capital Appropriate Request Summary

RM 012108RM 012160

Backhoe 2011 Process specifications

RM 013420RM 013430

04/06/2010 Project Backhoe Trial Notes & Follow-ups March


25, 2010

RM 014482

Project Research Proposal Test date 07/16/2003

FL00312110FL00312120

Project Fiesta Product / Process Spec (2011)

FL00338065FL00338442

D-150

Tostitos Scoops Fried / Baked Wing Line Commissioning /


Startup Phase Transition Criteria

FL00351609FL00351645

D-151

Excerpts from Snack Foods Processing, ed. Edmund W. Lusas


& Lloyd W. Rooney. Publisher: Technomic Publishing
Company, Inc. (2001)

RM 015439RM 015618

04/27/2001 Frito-Lay Press Release

FL00378772FL00378773

D-153

Tostitos Scoops! The Ultimate Dip Chip Fact Sheet

FL00378781

D-154

01/18/2011 Email from R. Strothkamp. Subject: Approval


Snacks, Sauces & Spreads Project Backhoe Newport, AR

RM 017513

01/18/2011 Notification of Approval

RM 017514RM 017515

D-156

01/07/2011 Email from K. van Ooyen. Subject: Back Hoe

RM 017525

D-157

06/17/2010 Email from J. Bischoff. Subject: Confidential


Project Backhoe Evolution.

RM 017972RM 017973

D-145
D-146
D-147
D-148
D-149

D-152

D-155

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

10

Depo Ex. #

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 12 of 18 PageID #: 4447

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

D-158

05/25/2010 Email from J. Bischoff. Subject: Confidential


Project Backhoe Update

RM 017974RM 017975

D-159

12/17/2010 Email from M.K. Vickery. Subject: Project


Backhoe Test Trial

RM 021271

D-160

03/09/2009 Email from J. Bischoff. Subject: Scoops


Overview.

RM 021710

D-161

08/23/2010 Memorandum from M. Klanac. Subject: F11 &


Beyond Summer Planning Session

RM 105971RM 105974

D-162

Alliance Consulting Group presentation The Threat of


Retailer Brands

RM 273201
RM 273305

D-163

Symphony IRI Group presentation Private Brands Threats &


Opportunities

RM 274737
RM 274800

D-164

08/13/2010 Email from R. Brown. Subject: Thought


Leadership Presentation

RM 274734
RM 274736

Medallion PD Meeting Notes 4-06-09

RM 287054RM 287055

D-166

Backhoe Throughput Calculations.

RM 208425

D-167

04/19/2010 Proposed Project Backhoe Milestones Schedule

RM 214612

Frito-Lay Scoops Product and Process

FL00389490FL00389580

D-169

08/08/2008 TC Equipment Audit. Tortilla Chip Equipment


Audit

FL00486583FL00486721

D-170

09/08/2011 Invitation with Email string. Subject: Doritos


Innovation Meeting Healthier Doritos & Dipping Chips

FL00498703FL00498704

D-171

Doritos Innovation presentation

FL00498705

D-172

10/13/2011 Invitation with Email string. Subject: Low cost


Scoops Ideation Session

FL00498718FL00498721

D-165

D-168

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

11

Depo Ex. #

241

J10

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 13 of 18 PageID #: 4448

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

Performance for the Long Term. Ralcorp Holdings 2010


Annual Report

RM 227225RM 227319

Project Backhoe Invoicing Summary

RM 228514RM 228606

Tostitos Scoops Startup / Commissioning documents

FL00848978FL00849010

Scoops Capital Appropriations Request

FL00849128FL00849202

D-177

09/24/2012 Compusense Summary Report. Project: Tortilla


Chips Cupz

RM 284969RM 284979

D-178

Toast Point Demo

FL00880401

D-179

Tostitos Scoops! Specifications chart

FL00880402

D-180

Tostitos Scoops! Product Attribute Evaluation

FL00880403

FL710 Module Installers Manual

FL00880429
FL00880448

FL710 Configuration details

FL00880454FL00880458

D-183

04/04/2007 Approved Variety List 2007 Illinois

FL00880459

D-184

04/05/2007 Approved Variety List 2007 Nebraska

FL00880460

D-185

03/04/2008 Approved Variety List 2008 Illinois

FL00880461

D-186

04/01/2010 Approved Variety List 2010 Illinois

FL00880465

D-187

04/01/2010 Approved Variety List 2010 Nebraska

FL00880466

D-188

Frito-Lay Tostitos Scoops Engineering Check-Out and Test


Run Plan

FL00003631FL00003697

U.S. Patent No. 5,761,883 (Pruett, et al.)

RM 016743RM 016768

D-173
D-174
D-175
D-176

D-181
D-182

D-189

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

12

Depo Ex. #

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 14 of 18 PageID #: 4449

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

Backhoe CAD drawing

RM 141687

Scoops Line CAD drawings

FL00848788FL00848804

The Andersons, Inc. Corn Purchase Agreement

FL00880533FL00880540

Kroger Cupz Kroger Fiscal YTD Sales by Division

FL00880543

Frito-Lay Scoops Financial Spreadsheet

FL00880591FL00880603

08/01/1998 TC Equipment Audit Washing

FL00880608FL00880613

D-196

Purchasing documents regarding Wolverine Molding Conveyor


& Oven Components

WOLVERINE
000419-544

D-197

Frito-Lay Performance Specifications for Project Fiesta,


Molding Conveyor & Impingement Dryer

WOLVERINE
000696-891

Frito-Lay Purchase Orders from Wolverine

WOLVERING
001399-1544

Armstrong Teasdale Non-Infringement Opinion

RM 285002RM 285370

Project Backhoe Pilot Line Video

RM 287904287917

D-190
D-191
D-192
D-193
D-194
D-195

D-198
D-199
D-200

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Depo Ex. #

D-202

Medallion Edited Full Sequence.wmv (produced April 24,


2012)
Email from A. Williams to S. Licker

FL365504

I9

D-203

Email from T. Johnson to K. Trick

FL4835571

J9

D-204

Scoops Concept Insights Research Summary

FL250800

N9

D-205

Scoops Product and Package Upgrade

FL251652

O9

D-206

Appearance Defect Definitions

FL347928

W9

D-201

13

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 15 of 18 PageID #: 4450

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

D-207

Data from Product Taste Test

FL315667

X9

D-208

Consumer Test Results and Analysis

FL311829

Y9

D-209

Product Research Proposal

FL490014

Z9

D-210

Scoops Shape Improvement TOPPS

FL495675

A10

D-211

Email from T. Johnson to J. Kelly

FL389436

D10

D-212

Jonesboro Fried Scoops Boost PSA Test

FL348253

E10

D-213

Tostitos Scoops WWTC Conference

FL315824

H10

D-214

11/19/2012 Compusense Summary Report. Project: Bowls


Tortilla Chips

RM 289831
RM 289834

D-215

05/21/1999 Schedule A to Wolverine and Frito-Lay Agreement


for Services

FL00361282FL00361297

Medallion Purchase Orders

RM 019483RM 019487

Agenda Item No. 10 Request for Capital Budget Item


Approval of New Line of Tortilla Chips Capital Project at the
Newport Arkansas Facility

RM 290453RM 290464

1997 Fink Chips

RM 290970RM 290973

Bowlz / Cupz feedback

RM 290974RM 290975

D-220

Photo of product detail

RM 291061

D-221

Photo of product detail

RM 291062

D-222

Photo of product detail

RM 291063

D-223

Photo of bag of product

RM 291064

D-224

Photo of bag of product

RM 291065

D-216
D-217
D-218
D-219

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

14

Depo Ex. #

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 16 of 18 PageID #: 4451

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #
D-225

Ex #

Date
Offered

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

Description

Bates Range

Frito-Lay Financials regarding Scoops!

FL00015805FL00015814

Depo Ex. #

D-226

U.S. Pat. App. Publ. No. 2009/0017178 (Desai, et al.)

B4

D-227

U.S. Patent No. 7,303,777 (Baas, et al.)

C4
D4

D-228

Food Quality of Corn, L. Rooney and E. Suhendro, Chapter 3


of Snack Foods Processing, ed. Edmund W. Lusas & Lloyd W.
Rooney. Publisher: Technomic Publishing Company, Inc.
(2001)

E4

D-229

Alkaline-Cooked Corn Products, C. McDonough, M. Gomez,


L. Rooney, S. Serna-Saldivar, Chapter 4, Snack Foods
Processing, ed. Edmund W. Lusas & Lloyd W. Rooney.
Publisher: Technomic Publishing Company, Inc. (2001)

D-230

Great Value Bite Size Tortilla Chip Manufacturing Procedure

RM 105272

G4

U.S. Patent No. 5,060,783 (Chenevard, et al)

RM 016411RM 016422

V7

U.S. Patent No. 5,652,010 (Gimmler, et al.)

RM 016664RM 016678

X7

U.S. Patent No. 6,467,401 (Caridis, et al.)

RM 017015RM 017031

Z7

D-231
D-232
D-233
D-234

WO 00/08950 PCT/US99/16444 (Fink, et al.)

64

D-235

UK Patent Application GB 2 211 391 (Hopper)

72

D-236

Photos of Medallion Plant Inspection May 25, 2012

RM 291105

D-237

Video of Medallion Plant Inspection of May 25, 2012

RM 291106

D-238

Frito-Lay Jonesboro Plant Inspection photos and video

RM 287279

D-239

Frito-Lay Specification Corn Washer

FL1379

D-240

U.S. Patent No. 5,580,583 (Caridis, et al.)

15

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 17 of 18 PageID #: 4452

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

Depo Ex. #

Medallion Foods, Inc. Presentation

RM 017815
RM 017826

31

Project Backhoe presentation

RM 010952RM 010962

32

CR11-01 Project Backhoe, Medallion Foods Newport,


Arkansas project

RM 228623RM 228653

08/12/2009 Email from J. Bischoff. Subject: Project Backhoe

RM 019129RM 019130

39

08/06/2009 Email from M. Trowbridge. Subject: Project


Backhoe status

RM 019187RM 019188

40

01/29/2010 Email from J. Bischoff. Subject: Project Backoe

RM 019155RM 019166

134

D-247

02/01/2010 Email from J. Bischoff. Subject: Reading Bakery

RM 019226

147

D-248

Ralcorp Holdings, Inc. Annual Report for FY ending


September 30, 2011

FL00845347FL00845364

242

D-249

U.S. Patent No. 6,592,923

D-250
D251

278 Trademark file history (certified copy)

D-241
D-242
D-243
D-244
D-245
D-246

D-252
D-253
D-254

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

A6

U.S. Patent No. 7,037,546


Alexa Williams memo

FL00014556

UTC Value Strategy Presentation

FL00771055

Supporting Materials for Expert Report of Michael Mazis

97A-97D,
98-101

D-255

Video of PAS

FL00352037

D-256

Email from M. Nebra to B. Rooke

FL394263

I10

D-257

Email from A. Williams to T. Johnson

FL365389

K10

16

Case 4:12-cv-00074-ALM Document 196-7

Filed 01/22/13 Page 18 of 18 PageID #: 4453

Frito-Lay North America, Inc. v. Medallion Foods, Inc. and Ralcorp Holdings, Inc.

Ex. #

Ex #

Date
Offered

Description

Bates Range

D-258

Email from D. Jones to R. Ruegg

FL498733

D-259

Tostitos Scoops Technical Review

FL10150

D-260

Chip Shape Distribution

FL12941

D-261

Tostitos Product Process Specs

FL14603

D-262

Tostitos Scoops Design and Consumer Data

FL14669

D-263

Tostitos 2011 Campaign Brief

FL168418

D-264

August 15, 2005 Tostitos Scoops Quality Review

FL314821

D-265

Tostitos Scoops Line Boost: Larger Chip Cutter

FL315559

D-266

International Competitive Dipping Tools

FL337947

D-267

TC Innovation Shapes Optimization

FL343590

D-268

Tostitos Scoops Flats Defect Level Specification

FL388163

Reference Chips

RM 290985RM 291056

Photos of 1997 Fink Chips

RM 291057RM 291065

High Noon Entertainment Documents

FL0090135152; 0090135556

D-269
D-270

Marked

Admitted

Case No: 4:12-cv-00074-ALM

D-271
D-272

Summary ChartExhibit C to Expert Report of Triveni Shukla


(summarizing sources previously produced)

D-273

IN RE WOLVERINE, PROCTOR & SCHWARTZ, LLC


447 B.R. 1 (2011)
United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Massachusetts.

D-274
D-275

17

Depo Ex. #

L10

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen