Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
$
5
.
9
5
C
a
n
a
d
a
$
6
.
9
5
M E M B E R P O R T R A I T
Michael Chapman, ASC
W W W . T H E A S C . C O M
TO SUBSCRIBE BY PHONE:
Call (800) 448-0145 (U.S. only)
(323) 969-4333 or visit the ASC Web site
spent my early childhood in
the days before television.
Movies were everything to
us; cinema was truly the
church of the 20th century.
Through a series of
accidents, I stumbled into the
industry, and American
Cinematographer reassured
me that somehow I might
actually survive there. It
seemed to be written by and
about people like me, who
struggled and worried. It also
gave me access to the minds of
people Id met and respected.
AC is a generous
magazine. There are no
secrets. No matter what our
style or method, were all
cinematographers, and AC
expresses the insight that
comes with that unique
vantage point.
Michael Chapman, ASC
I
p
h
o
t
o
b
y
O
w
e
n
R
o
i
z
m
a
n
,
A
S
C
www.schneideroptics.com
P
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
e
r
:
J
o
h
n
H
a
y
d
e
n
B
u
s
c
h
B+W Century Schneider
I spend most of my working hours on
location so I need to know that Im carrying
the most reliable equipment. Thats why
I always travel with Schneider 4x5 and
6x6 filters. They give me the highest
quality look across all formats.
Recently, I did a shoot at 9000 in the
Poudre River Valley of Colorado. I found
that the ND Soft Grads, combined with the
Circular True Pols worked particularly
well. The Grads helped blend the dynamic
range in the sky, allowing our cameras
sensor to see what it needed. The Schneider
filters helped me create the crisp, contrasty,
artsy images that we were going for.
i E h i C
d i h S
B f f d i
i S
ww e d i e n h c s . w w w
c i r E r e h p a r g o t a m e n i C
n i k i r t s d e t a e r c s a h e H
c i n a h c e M e h T g n i d u l c n i
s s a h d n a e s a C d l o C n o
C S A n a r o ff d e t a n i m o n
m o c . s c i t p o r e : e o o h P
s a w t d i m h c S c
c i s u m r o f y r e g a m i g n
. u o YYo h t i WWi t l e M I d n a c
, s e r u t a e f l a r e v e s t o h s
k r o w s i h r o ffo d r a w AAw C
4 5 2 1 - 8 2 2 - 0 0 8 5 1 7 3 - 6 6 7 - 8 1 8
4
s a l G e h t h t i w s t r a t S t I
m t
s
s o D r o ffo s t o p s n a M g nng i t s e r e t n I
e h T e v i t c n i t s i d e h t g n i d u l c n i
5 r e v o t o h s d n a s r e t h g i F o o F
u r B m o r ffr e n o y r e v e r o f s o e d i v
B n h c S y r u t n e C W +
. s i u q E
t s o M s d l r o WWo
s l a i c r e m m o c 0 0
o t n e e t s g n i r p S e c u
r e d i e n
The International Journal of Motion Imaging
28 Cosmic Questions
Emmanuel Lubezki, ASC, AMC captures existential imagery
for The Tree of Life
40 Darkest Arts
Eduardo Serra, ASC, AFC brings a beloved franchise to a
close with Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
48 An All-American Hero
Shelly Johnson, ASC pumps up a super soldier for
Captain America: The First Avenger
58 Once Upon a Time in the West
Matthew Libatique, ASC mixes genres on Cowboys & Aliens
DEPARTMENTS
FEATURES
VISIT WWW.THEASC.COM TO ENJOY THESE WEB EXCLUSIVES
DVD Playback: The Outlaw Josey Wales Au Revoir, Les Enfants Scream
On Our Cover: Members of the OBrien family (Brad Pitt, Jessica Chastain, Laramie
Eppler and Tye Sheridan) are reunited in The Tree of Life, shot by Emmanuel Lubezki,
ASC, AMC. (Photo by Merie Wallace, SMPSP, courtesy of Fox Searchlight and Twentieth
Century Fox.)
8 Editors Note
10 Presidents Desk
12 Short Takes: The Arrival
18 Production Slate: Rise of the Planet of the Apes Femme Fatales
72 Post Focus
76 New Products & Services
82 International Marketplace
83 Classified Ads
84 Ad Index
86 Clubhouse News
88 ASC Close-Up: Tom Houghton
A U G U S T 2 0 1 1 V O L . 9 2 N O . 8
58
40
48
A u g u s t 2 0 1 1 V o l . 9 2 , N o . 8
T h e I n t e r n a t i o n a l J o u r n a l o f M o t i o n I m a g i n g
Visit us online at
www.theasc.com
PUBLISHER Martha Winterhalter
EDITORIAL
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Stephen Pizzello
SENIOR EDITOR Rachael K. Bosley
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Jon D. Witmer
TECHNICAL EDITOR Christopher Probst
CONTRIBUTING WRITERS
Stephanie Argy, Benjamin B, Douglas Bankston, Robert S. Birchard,
John Calhoun, Michael Goldman, Simon Gray, Jim Hemphill, David Heuring,
Jay Holben, Mark Hope-Jones, Noah Kadner, Jean Oppenheimer,
John Pavlus, Chris Pizzello, Jon Silberg, Iain Stasukevich,
Kenneth Sweeney, Patricia Thomson
ART DEPARTMENT
CREATIVE DIRECTOR Marion Gore
ADVERTISING
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Angie Gollmann
323-936-3769 FAX 323-936-9188
e-mail: gollmann@pacbell.net
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Sanja Pearce
323-952-2114 FAX 323-876-4973
e-mail: sanja@ascmag.com
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Scott Burnell
323-936-0672 FAX 323-936-9188
e-mail: sburnell@earthlink.net
CLASSIFIEDS/ADVERTISING COORDINATOR Diella Nepomuceno
323-952-2124 FAX 323-876-4973
e-mail: diella@ascmag.com
American Cinematographer (ISSN 0002-7928), established 1920 and in its 91st year of publication, is published
monthly in Hollywood by ASC Holding Corp., 1782 N. Orange Dr., Hollywood, CA 90028, U.S.A.,
(800) 448-0145, (323) 969-4333, Fax (323) 876-4973, direct line for subscription inquiries (323) 969-4344.
Subscriptions: U.S. $50; Canada/Mexico $70; all other foreign countries $95 a year (remit international
Money Order or other exchange payable in U.S. $). Advertising: Rate card upon request from Hollywood
office. Article Reprints: Requests for high-quality article reprints (or electronic reprints) should be made to
Sheridan Reprints at (800) 635-7181 ext. 8065 or by e-mail hrobinson@tsp.sheridan.com.
Copyright 2011 ASC Holding Corp. (All rights reserved.) Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles, CA
and at additional mailing offices. Printed in the USA.
POSTMASTER: Send address change to American Cinematographer, P.O. Box 2230, Hollywood, CA 90078.
4
our extended
family of lightweight
Optimo zooms
now includes
45 120mm.
973.812.3858
angenieux@tccus.com www.angenieux.com
The perfect portrait lens has finally arrived
45-120mm Optimo zoom lens joins our award
winning 15-40mm and 28-76mm family of
hand-held lenses to provide a combined focal
range of 15-120mm. They allow you to take
fewer lenses on location without any sacrifice in
performance and without the excess weight
of all the prime lenses they replace. Plus
Optimo 35mm Zoom Lenses deliver the
extremely fast apertures and outstanding
contrast and color reproduction that have
made them the optics of choice for DPs all over
the world. Take our extended family of Optimo
35mm Zoom Lenses on your next shoot and
experience the difference.
NEW 45mm - 120mm
Actual product image may vary
15mm - 40mm
28mm - 76mm
OFFICERS - 2011/2012
Michael Goi
President
Richard Crudo
Vice President
Owen Roizman
Vice President
John C. Flinn III
Vice President
Victor J. Kemper
Treasurer
Frederic Goodich
Secretary
Stephen Lighthill
Sergeant At Arms
MEMBERS OF THE
BOARD
John Bailey
Stephen H. Burum
Richard Crudo
George Spiro Dibie
Richard Edlund
Fred Elmes
Michael Goi
Victor J. Kemper
Francis Kenny
Isidore Mankofsky
Robert Primes
Owen Roizman
Kees Van Oostrum
Haskell Wexler
Vilmos Zsigmond
ALTERNATES
Michael D. OShea
Rodney Taylor
Ron Garcia
Sol Negrin
Kenneth Zunder
MUSEUM CURATOR
Steve Gainer
American Society of Cine ma tog ra phers
The ASC is not a labor union or a guild, but
an educational, cultural and pro fes sion al
or ga ni za tion. Membership is by invitation
to those who are actively en gaged as
di rec tors of photography and have
dem on strated out stand ing ability. ASC
membership has be come one of the highest
honors that can be bestowed upon a
pro fes sional cin e ma tog ra pher a mark
of prestige and excellence.
6
Its relatively rare these days to encounter a movie as philosophi-
cally and artistically ambitious as Terrence Malicks The Tree of
Life. The films bold, nonlinear structure serves up a series of
emotionally wrenching family memories, a mind-blowing
creation of the universe sequence, and a mysterious climax
that offers a surreal glimpse of the afterlife in other words, a
veritable smorgasbord for undernourished cineastes pining for
the heyday of headier fare from highminded auteurs like Anto-
nioni, Bergman or Kubrick.
Although he remains as enigmatic and elusive as Kubrick,
Malicks on-set strategies are, by all accounts, considerably more
freewheeling than those of the notoriously rigorous taskmaster.
In an interview with European correspondent Benjamin B
(Cosmic Questions, page 28), cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki, ASC, AMC and other
members of Malicks production team offer enlightening insights about the directors unique meth-
ods. Terry was incredibly well prepared because he had been thinking about this film for many
years, but he wanted the film to feel unprepared, says Lubezki. We couldnt really set up shots;
we had to find them.
This divining-rod approach produced a picture filled with unforgettably fresh and sponta-
neous images: a butterfly alighting on a womans arm, a luminous swarm of fireflies, and some
remarkable perspectives that show the world through childrens eyes. Winner of the Palme dOr at
Cannes, The Tree of Life will challenge viewers who prefer straightforward narratives, but richly
reward anyone who appreciates adventurous, beyond-the-box artistry.
A more structured magic was applied on Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, the two-part
conclusion to one of the industrys most beloved fantasy adventures. Waving the wand on both
installments was Eduardo Serra, ASC, AFC, who found himself conjuring images on massive sets
fashioned by production designer Stuart Craig. This thing is so huge, with so much space and so
many people, that there is actually limited freedom to determine a look on set, he tells London
correspondent Mark Hope-Jones (Darkest Arts, page 40). I must say, I was surprised by how dark
they were prepared to go with the visuals. Throughout my career, producers have argued that if
images are dark, the audience wont see them, but on this film it was the opposite, which was nice.
Shelly Johnson, ASC also found himself facing daunting logistics on Captain America: The First
Avenger, a production filmed on more than 115 sets and locations. In discussing the project with
New York correspondent Iain Stasukevich (An All-American Hero, page 48), Johnson notes that
as many as seven sets were up and running at any given time. This shoot was like a giant freight
train, he marvels. When it leaves the station, theres a lot of momentum behind it!
On Cowboys & Aliens , Matthew Libatique was yet another ASC member in big-budget
mode, reteaming with Iron Man director Jon Favreau on a project that required the careful blending
of two distinct genres. We wanted to be as honest with the Western as possible, and the challenge
was how to mesh that with science fiction, he says in an exceptional overview penned by associ-
ate editor Jon Witmer (Once Upon a Time in the West, page 58). The question became, How
do we create the tension within the Western to graduate into the science-fiction thriller? That was
terrifying, but ultimately, as a cinematographer, its not my position to worry about the storys struc-
ture. I just have to worry about the visual language of it all.
Stephen Pizzello
Executive Editor
Editors Note
P
h
o
t
o
b
y
O
w
e
n
R
o
i
z
m
a
n
,
A
S
C
.
8
High-Speed
Phantom Flex
Digital Cinema
ARRI ALEXA
3D Cinema
Phantom 65-Z3D
Film
AATON Penelope
Optics
Zeiss, Canon, Fuji, Angx
Compact HD
AF100, Sony F3
Training &
Consultation
Applied Learning
for Professionals
Carl Zeiss
Warranty Service
Carl Zeiss Authorized
Service Partner
for the Americas
Digital Media
Services
Data Management,
Archival, Hardware
Integration Solutions
www.abelcine.com
New York
609 Greenwich St
New York, NY 10014
888.223.1599
Los Angeles
801 South Main St
Burbank, CA 91506
888.700.4416
Chicago
17 W662 Butterfield Rd #302
Oakbrook Terrace, IL 60181
877.880.4267
Advances in digital acquisition have
transformed our industry, empowering
filmmakers at all levels of production.
We fully embrace this transformation
and have expanded our services to meet
the changing needs of our clients.
Sales, Rental and Technical Services
and introducing:
As I begin my third and final year as president of the ASC, I find that thoughts about where the
craft of cinematography is going become more important, not so much in terms of what the ASC
can do to affect the future, but in terms of enjoying the discovery of new talent. There are very
few things that warm the heart of a seasoned cinematographer more than seeing a new and
unique vision discovering its place in this form of artistic expression.
Many people have asked me if the Society has a mentorship program. We do not have a
formal arrangement, but individual ASC members freely mentor young cinematographers on a
regular basis. One of the most valuable and rewarding things a veteran can do is pass his or her
knowledge and love of the craft to an eager apprentice. And as often as the veteran may jokingly
say, Now he/she is going to go after my jobs, there is a calm satisfaction in knowing that, in a
small way, youve helped pave the way for someone who may reach artistic heights that could
surpass your own.
Im always mentoring a few people at any given time. Sometimes I can get them onto sets
so they can experience the professional world of production, and sometimes their interest is in
the myriad ways post tools can affect the final image. I always try to see what truly sparks their
imagination, to see what makes them excited about cinematography. In those moments of inspi-
ration, I rediscover what makes this profession exciting for me as well.
I was recently interviewed for the Rising Stars department of Friends of the ASC about one
such person. Polly Morgan was a student of mine when I taught a semester at the Maine Media Workshops a few years ago. A native
of England, she made her way to Los Angeles to continue her studies here and began shooting student films. Two silent shorts sh e
photographed during that time convinced me she had a talent worth developing. As I became reacquainted with her ambition to
create compelling visual stories, I was drawn to help that quest. As we prepared to launch Friends of the ASC, I asked Polly to be the
director of photography on the promotional video. There are probably few things more unnerving for a young cinematographer than
being given the responsibility of lighting and filming Caleb Deschanel, ASC, and Nancy Schreiber, ASC, who were the spokespersons,
but Polly didnt show any sign of anxiety. She did her job, and today that video is seen all over the world.
Subsequently, when I was asked to shoot a feature and could not do so because of a schedule conflict, I asked Polly to step
in for me. I was able to be around during the first few days of filming to make the producers feel at ease, and to observe how Polly
worked. Her command of the set and the respect she received from the crew and the director spoke well of her ability to lead a
complex project with a team of professionals without ever raising her voice above a conversational tone. Her focus on the detai ls that
mattered during chaotic filming schedules was befitting a cinematographer with many more years of experience. The joy that Poll y
has in exploring visual styles for a project is evident in the careful way she approaches setting up every shot. There is a log ic and rhythm
to the flow of images, and it incites anticipation in the viewer for where the story will take you next. The capper was when the produc-
ers thanked me for introducing them to her. She was subsequently profiled in British Cinematographer as a cinematographer to watch.
Many cinematographers working today were given a boost of confidence and inspiration from an ASC cinematographer at
a crucial time in their careers. George Spiro Dibie and Vilmos Zsigmond did it for me, and I have tried to do so in return, as have many
other ASC members. Its part of our passion and our mission. It keeps us young.
I have said this many times about many talented, young cinematographers, and I love saying it: Now Polly is going to go after
my jobs.
And you know what? Im okay with that.
Michael Goi, ASC
President
Presidents Desk
10 August 2011 American Cinematographer
P
o
r
t
r
a
i
t
b
y
O
w
e
n
R
o
i
z
m
a
n
,
A
S
C
.
Family is very important to me. Being part of
the Clairmont family gives me this same
sense, feeling safe and secure wherever I am.
Tony Richmond ASC, BSC
www.clairmont.com
12 August 2011 American Cinematographer
Sonys F65 Makes Debut With The Arrival
By Stephanie Argy
Directed and shot by Curtis Clark, ASC, The Arrival is the first
project to be photographed with Sonys F65, the companys soon-to-
be-released 4K digital motion-picture camera. The movie is a modern
film noir set in downtown Los Angeles, and Clark describes it as an
effective test of the F65s performance in production.
Clark chairs the ASC Technology Committee, and he
confesses that prior to the committees involvement in the ASC-PGA
Camera Assessment Series ( AC June and Sept. 09), he was not a
fan of so-called digital-cinema cameras, even though hed been
following their evolution closely. For me, the issue was that most of
those cameras were too restrictive in their tonal latitude and color
gamut because of their reliance on HD-video parameters, he says.
The limitations were exacerbated by post workflows that frequently
took place in a Rec 709 environment that tended to accentuate an
HD-video look, he adds.
But Clark was intrigued by how closely Sonys F35, configured
with S-Log and S-Gamut, was able to match images from the film
cameras that were used as benchmarks for the CAS, and this led him
to more in-depth conversations with the Sony development team.
Eventually, he became a consultant for the company, advising on an
advanced motion-picture workflow for their next-generation high-
resolution camera. Sony, he says, was eager to get the input of work-
ing cinematographers, and Clark felt it was essential to help them
get it.
He was also becoming increasingly aware of the work the
Academys Science and Technology Council was doing on the Image
Interchange Framework/Academy Color Encoding Specification, a
workflow architecture whose components are designed to preserve
the widest possible image information from production through
post, exhibition and archiving, using a standardized, non-proprietary
set of transforms and file formats ( AC March 11).
Those two things started to converge, says Clark. I
became the focal point for the convergence in that I brought Sony
into the mix by making them aware of IIF/ACES. Sony became
committed to designing the F65 as a true digital motion-picture
camera that would support IIF/ACES.
Sonys major goals for the camera included:
Spatial resolution: Unequivocal 4K, 4096x2160, using a
single 20-megapixel CMOS sensor.
Dynamic range: The target is more than 14 stops without
the use of blended-exposure techniques or electronic-gain increase
to extend dynamic range. Its a single-frame exposure, just like film,
so there are no motion artifacts from shooting blended exposures to
get a wider dynamic range, explains Clark.
Color reproduction: The camera was to have not only
significantly wider color space, but also the emotional quality of
how film reproduces color and contrast, says Clark. It had to be
able to replicate a cinematic film look and feel.
Planning to introduce the F65 at this years NAB conference,
Sony wanted to present footage that would demonstrate how the
camera had reached all of these goals. So, in December 2010, Clark
began conferring with Toshitaka Ikumo, Sony Electronics business-
development manager of digital motion-picture production, about
what the NAB presentation should include. Clark recommended a
short, dramatic narrative that would not be based on a collection of
Short Takes
P
h
o
t
o
s
a
n
d
f
r
a
m
e
g
r
a
b
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
C
u
r
t
i
s
C
l
a
r
k
a
n
d
S
o
n
y
.
The climax of the
short The Arrival,
designed to
showcase the
capabilities of
Sonys F65 camera,
was shot at the Los
Angeles Theater.
The piece was
conceptualized,
directed and shot
by ASC member
Curtis Clark.
I
www.fotokem.com
It Starts & Ends Here
2011 FotoKem Industries, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Oapture F||e-Based Med|a
Transoode
Manage Oo|or
Mu|t|-Format Oompat|b|||ty
Syno Dua|-System Aud|o
Aooess & t|||ze Metadata
Aroh|ve to |TO
Oua||ty Oontro|
FotoKem`s next|AB
Left: Working on a breakaway prison set while shooting the episode Behind Locked
Doors, cinematographer Roger Chingirian (at camera) angles in on actresses Ana
Alexander (on bunk) and Kit Willisee (at door). Right: Actor William Gregory Lee,
portraying a bank robber, delivers his lines as Chingarian frames his shot.
28 August 2011 American Cinematographer
A
t a press conference after The Tree of Life premiere at the
Cannes Film Festival, it fell to the producers and lead
actors to explain the film. Not surprisingly, director
Terrence Malick, who is known to shun all personal
publicity, was absent. Brad Pitt, who produced and stars in the
movie, was asked about his experience working on the film.
Its changed everything Ive done since, he said. The best
moments were not preconceived; they were not planned. Ive
tried to go more in that direction.
The Tree of Life went on to win the festivals top honor,
the Palme dOr.
Emmanuel Lubezki, ASC, AMC
creates emotionally resonant
imagery for Terrence Malicks
The Tree of Life.
By Benjamin B
|
Cosmic
Questions
Cosmic
Questions
Malicks unique approach to filmmaking appears to
have left a similar mark on his other collaborators, starting with
director of photography Emmanuel Chivo Lubezki, ASC,
AMC. You learn so much by watching an artist like Terry at
work, says Lubezki. For me, he has been an extraordinary
film teacher and much more.
The cinematographer counts himself fortunate to have
worked on three of Malicks films; they first teamed on The
New World (AC Jan. 06), and after wrapping The Tree of Life
they embarked on another feature, as yet untitled, that will be
released next year.
The Tree of Life is a film whose scope and ambition rival
that of Stanley Kubricks 2001: A Space Odyssey (AC June 68).
Malick combines a poetic evocation of childhood in an
American suburb in the 1950s with plainspoken metaphysical
questions that echo the Book of Jobs inquiries about the
mystery of unjust affliction.
The main characters are the OBrien family: Jack
(played as a boy by Hunter McCracken and as an adult by
Sean Penn); his younger brothers, R.L. (Laramie Eppler) and
Steve (Tye Sheridan); their mother (Jessica Chastain); and
their father (Pitt). The story begins with Jacks parents learning
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 29
of R.L.s sudden death at the age of 19.
This tragedy leads the mother to ask,
Why, Lord? and the whispered ques-
tion calls forth a dazzling, 20-minute
history of the universe, including the
birth of stars, volcanoes, dinosaurs and a
meteor crashing into the Earth.
The primary narrative focuses on
Jacks childhood, which is evoked in a
series of powerful vignettes that begin
with his birth and end roughly a dozen
years later, when his family moves from
the home where he was raised. Images
of the brothers playing, fighting and
exploring their neighborhood are beau-
tifully and simply lit with natural light
through windows, doorways and tree
canopies. The scenes are often brief but
telling, often jump cut, and feature little
dialogue. Fluid Steadicam and hand-
held camerawork follows the children
through the house, yard or woods, or
U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
b
y
M
e
r
i
e
W
a
l
l
a
c
e
,
S
M
P
S
P
.
P
h
o
t
o
s
a
n
d
f
r
a
m
e
g
r
a
b
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
F
o
x
S
e
a
r
c
h
l
i
g
h
t
a
n
d
T
w
e
n
t
i
e
t
h
C
e
n
t
u
r
y
F
o
x
.
Opposite: In The Tree of Life, an enigmatic coda finds Mrs. OBrien (Jessica Chastain) traversing a
limbo-like desert. This page, top to bottom: Mr. OBrien (Brad Pitt) examines his newborn son;
a butterfly lands on Mrs. OBriens arm; cinematographer Emmanuel Lubezki, ASC, AMC meters the
light on a church organ.
30 August 2011 American Cinematographer
frames a family fight at the dinner table.
After the family moves out of
Jacks childhood house, the narrative
returns to the adult Jack for a mysterious
epilogue. The story concludes with Jacks
mother delivering a memorable answer
to God.
When they began planning The
New World, Malick and Lubezki sketched
out a set of rules that, over time, evolved
into what the crew called the dogma.
However, Lubezki observes that rules
have always been a mainstay of his own
work. In all the movies Ive done, I always
worked with a set of rules they help me
to find the tone and the style of the film,
he says. Art is made of constraints. When
you dont have any, you go crazy, because
everything is possible.
He says his previous movies were
dictated by rules such as using only one
lens, or shooting the entire film at T2.8.
Although there is no written version of
the Malick-Lubezki dogma on Tree,
interviews with the cinematographer
and some key collaborators suggest
some parameters:
Shoot in available natural light
Do not underexpose the negative
Keep true blacks
Preserve the latitude in the image
Seek maximum resolution and
fine grain
Seek depth with deep focus and
stop: Compose in depth
Shoot in backlight for continuity
and depth
Use negative fill to avoid light
sandwiches (even sources on both
sides)
Shoot in crosslight only after
dawn or before dusk; never front
light
Avoid lens flares
Avoid white and primary colors in
frame
Shoot with short-focal-length,
hard lenses
No filters except Polarizer
Shoot with steady handheld or
Steadicam in the eye of the hurri-
cane
Z-axis moves instead of pans or
tilts
No zooming
Do some static tripod shots in
midst of our haste
Accept the exception to the
dogma (Article E)
With a laugh, Lubezki notes,
Our dogma is full of contradictions!
For example, if you use backlight, you
will get flares, or if you go for a deep
stop, you will have more grain because
you need a faster stock. So you have to
make these decisions on the spot: what
Cosmic Questions
Intimate
close-ups place
viewers in the
midst of the
OBriens most
emotionally
revealing
moments.
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 31
is better in this case, grain or depth?
The most important rule for me
is to not underexpose, he continues.
We want the blacks; we dont like
milky images. Article E does not apply
to underexposure! The cinematogra-
pher concedes that there is a single
underexposed shot in Tree, an amazing
accomplishment for a film shot in such
free form.
Lubezki appreciates the com-
plexity of natural light. When you put
someone in front of a window, youre
getting the reflection from the blue sky
and the clouds and the sun bouncing on
the grass and in the room. Youre getting
all these colors and a different quality of
light. Its very hard to go back to artificial
light in the same movie. Its like youre
setting a tone, and artificial light feels
weird and awkward [after that].
Lubezki shot Tree with two tung-
sten-balanced Kodak Vision2 negatives,
500T 5218 and 200T 5217, going to
the faster stock when the light was low.
He did not use an 85 filter because it
homogenizes the complex color.
Instead, he prefers to color balance in
the timing.
The picture was shot in standard
1.85:1, in 4-perf for maximum resolu-
tion and low grain. Lubezki explains,
Even though anamorphic has more
resolution, we decided on 1.85 because
the close focus was going to be extreme
we were so close to the kids, their
faces, hands and feet. And we didnt
want the grain of Super 35.
Lubezkis camera team included
operator Joerg Widmer, who often shot
Steadicam, and 1st AC Erik Brown.
Underwater footage was shot by Pete
Romano, ASC, and second-unit
photography was done by Paul Atkins
and Peter Simonite. Principal photogra-
phy ran for 12 weeks. The main location
was the Texas town of Smithville, with
other scenes shot in Austin, Houston, on
the Texas coast and in Utah. (Additional
photography was done in New York by
Ellen Kuras, ASC; in Versailles by
Benot Delhomme, AFC; and in Italy
by Widmer.)
Although Tree was shot single
camera, Brown prepped three cameras
every day: an Arricam Lite on the
Steadicam, another Lite in an EasyRig
Top: Tensions
mount during a
family dinner.
Bottom: Operator
Joerg Widmer
(center, wearing
black shirt) moves
into position for
an over-the-
shoulder angle.
32 August 2011 American Cinematographer
configuration, and an Arri 235 for run-
and-gun work. All three cameras were
outfitted with Arri wireless focus controls
so that the assistant could quickly switch
from one to the other. Brown maintains
that 90 percent of the movie was shot
without a tripod.
Lubezki chose Arri/Zeiss Master
Primes and wider-angled Arri/Zeiss
Ultra Primes. Brown says the lenses most
often used were the 14mm, 18mm,
21mm and 27mm, and that the camera
was usually very close to the actors, often
between 1 and 2 feet.
Its the most difficult thing Ive
ever done, Brown continues. There were
no marks, and I had to guess what the
operator was about to do because he was
reacting to what the actors were doing. I
developed this wonderful partnership
with Chivo and Joerg that became a
dance where they led and I followed.
Production designer Jack Fisk, who
has worked with Malick since Badlands
(1973), notes, I often tell people when
they start working for Terry that he asks
for nothing and expects everything, so
they have to be prepared. Terrys very
humble and very passionate. You end up
doing more for him than you would do
for anybody else because the film is so
important to him.
The shooting rhythm on Tree was
exceptionally fast. Widmer would often
Cosmic Questions
Despite
their initial
no flares rule,
the filmmakers
incorporated
backlight as
a consistent
visual motif.
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 33
start filming a scene with the Steadicam
with Lubezki at his side riding iris, and
when the magazine ran out, they might
trade places, with Lubezki shooting hand-
held. Ive never been on a set where the
crew was so tuned into the movie, says
Lubezki. At one point while we were
shooting, somebody suddenly screamed,
Oh, my god! The fireflies are out! because
hed heard six weeks earlier that Terry
wanted to shoot fireflies. The crew
immediately rushed out to shoot the fire-
flies.
Serendipity is another key feature
of Malicks approach. His collaborators
are always open to shooting the acciden-
tal and the unexpected. One morning, a
butterfly flew by as the crew was prepar-
ing for the day. Lubezki grabbed the Arri
235 and filmed it as it landed on
Chastains outstretched arm. The shot
then follows the butterfly onto the grass,
where a cat shows up in the frame.
Usually on a film set, you wait
more than you shoot, but in our case we
shot more than we waited, says Widmer.
Sometimes we didnt wait to reload; we
simply took a different camera and
restarted the scene. Everything happened
so quickly, and the kids energy was lost so
easily if we didnt continue immediately.
The concept was to change, to
always vary things, he continues. Malick
would alternate between Steadicam and
Top: The
OBrien boys
climb skyward.
Middle and
bottom: Mr.
OBrien enters
a cathedral
of trees,
where viewers
experience his
POV from
the ground.
34 August 2011 American Cinematographer
T
he 20-minute creation sequence in
The Tree of Life depicts the birth of
stars, the beginning of life on Earth, a
memorable interaction between two
dinosaurs, and a meteor crashing into
the Earth, among other cataclysmic
events. The sequence begins with the
formation of early stars and ends over 5
billion years from now, when the sun
will, according to scientists, shrink to a
small white dwarf.
In creating the sequence, artists
led by senior visual-effects supervisor
Dan Glass worked with an array of
material, including 65mm and 35mm
motion-picture film; digital footage
captured with the 4K Dalsa Evolution,
the Red One and the Phantom HD
high-speed camera; and large-format
Canonstills. Real and virtual elements,
like the CGI dinosaurs, were layered
and composited in 5K (5,464 pixels
across) and recorded as 32-bit floating-
point EXR files. The finished images
were exported to EFilms DI suite as
10-bit log DPX files.
The greatest challenge of this
project is that Terry Malicks approach
is the opposite of the way we commonly
work in visual effects, say Glass. The
director, he explains, wanted to avoid
defining the imagery ahead of time and
often used the word Tao to convey an
organic search for unpredictable images.
Terry objects if theres a sense of
the human hand [in the image], of
someone interfering with the process,
says Glass, so our work involved a lot of
experimenting. The goal was to create
glimpses of natural moments.
To get these images, Malick
organized a series of shoots he called
Skunkworks over three weekends at a
studio in Austin, Texas. A small group
led by visual-effects pioneer Douglas
Trumbull (2001: A Space Odyssey) exper-
imented with liquid tanks, flashlights,
glass paperweights, dry ice, pinhole
flares and sundry objects to shoot
elements that were then layered to
represent cosmological images. The
material that came out of those shoots
was really rich and fantastic, says Glass.
We tried to create interesting visual
imagery first, and then figured out how
to shape it and where to place it in the
film.
A shot of light lattices in the early
universe was primarily constructed with
layered light leaks recorded with a Red
One without a lens flashlights were
shone through glass objects like paper-
weights. Theres an organic core to the
image, a kind of natural beauty, says
Glass.
A dark eclipse image was shot
with a polystyrene planet on a pole in
front of a light shining through dry ice.
In post, the colors were finessed and
tiny details of planetary fragments were
added.
A cloud-like nebula beginning to
form was a 4'-wide pool of half-and-
half poured into a water tank and shot
| Big Bang Theory |
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 35
handheld, go from an 18mm to a
27mm, from low mode to high mode,
putting the actors in different positions,
and sometimes he would redo the scene
in another way the next day, perhaps
with a different child or in a different
setting.
Terry was incredibly well
prepared because he had been thinking
about this film for many years, but he
wanted the film to feel unprepared, says
Lubezki. We couldnt really set up
shots; we had to find them.
Mornings in Smithville started
with Malick meeting with the crew,
reading from index cards that bore type-
written notes about things to find.
They could be shots, emotions he
wanted to capture or specific angles he
wanted to get, says Lubezki.
Sometimes he had a little picture
clipped to the index card that he wanted
to show me. Or he might talk to Jack
[Fisk] about changing colors in a room.
Every morning he had information to
share, and then everybody knew what
to go for during the day.
The filmmakers were constantly
talking behind the camera, trying to
steer the shoot into a place that felt
unrehearsed, he continues. The scenes
had to be found, like in a documentary.
He adds that Malick would often
surprise the actors and crew by intro-
ducing unexpected elements, a tech-
nique referred to as sending in a
torpedo. Sometimes it was another
actor, sometimes it was a dog, or some-
times it was the operator running
through the scene without telling
anybody! Its like pulling the rug from
under your feet. What happens is that
you suddenly get something unexpected
that feels more natural. For example,
As OBrien bonds with one of his younger sons, R.L. (Laramie Eppler), over their
shared affinity for music (top), his eldest son, Jack (Hunter McCracken, bottom) lashes out
at a neighbors house.
in slow motion, with stars added and
colors shifted to auburn later.
Another reference for imagery
was scientific visualizations. For
instance, an intricate, reddish image of
early Pop III star formation was
based on a simulation by astrophysicist
Volker Bromm that he ran at the
National Center for Supercomputing
Applications in Illinois. With the
scientists approval, Glass asked a
concept artist to illustrate up the
image and render it as a cavern from
which light emerges, incorporating
nebulae-like elements. We then fed
that data to Double Negative in
London, and their team mixed in addi-
tional elements and artistry.
The Hubble telescope was
another image source, providing the
shot of the Carina nebula, a tiled
assembly that was 27,000 pixels across.
The visual-effects team added depth
cues, tamed the arbitrary coloring and
added a slow push in, according to
Glass.
Background plates for the
creation sequence were shot in 15-perf
65mm Imax. They are perhaps most
prominent in the dinosaur scene, the
longest segment of the creation
sequence. Terry didnt want to feature
the dinosaurs more than necessary, so
sometimes theyre almost in silhouette,
notes Glass. Once Malick and a scien-
tific adviser vetted 4'-long maquettes of
the dinosaurs, the maquettes were
scanned to form the basis for CG
models.
Malick asked the visual-effects
team to listen to music as they worked,
and he often tested the imagery with
different music as the team watched.
Thats highly unusual visual effects
is a silent world, says Glass. Working
on this movie was a wonderful, all-
encompassing experience.
Benjamin B
36 August 2011 American Cinematographer
during a scene that shows the father and
mother arguing, Malick sent in one of
the boys, and it immediately changed
the way the adults acted. If something
felt intentional to Terry, be it in a camera
move, a performance or a sound, he
would react against it [in the edit], says
editor Mark Yoshikawa. He didnt want
that feeling of manipulation. He wanted
to feel as if things were found and not
presented. We ended up just cutting out
anything that felt false, and that gave
way to the jump cuts, which give the
movie its elliptical feeling. Terry said, If
its a 10-second shot and five of the
seconds feel false, then just take it out
and see what happens. A lot of the time
it didnt work it was a horrible cut.
But sometimes it did work, and we went
with that feeling.
For Lubezki, the greatest chal-
lenge posed by Malicks emphasis on
naturalism was obtaining a good expo-
sure and extended latitude. Part of the
solution came from his collaboration
with Fisk. In the dining room of one of
the houses we used, we replaced wall
space between two windows with a third
window so that the whole wall was glass,
and it faced south, says Fisk. We also
put in a new back porch with a plastic
ceiling so it would let light into the
kitchen. To avoid light sandwiches,
Fisks crew would often darken the
backgrounds as much as possible and
T1.3 in the same take. You have to
think really fast: does it work?
One scene where Lubezki kept
the exposure constant is a beautiful
moment that shows R.L. playing guitar
in a doorway in changing sunlight.
In other scenes, like family
dinners at the table, the challenge was
filming people with a range of exposure
values. Lubezki notes that he does not
use white bounce boards or white cards
to help the exposure because they will
show. At one meal, for example, Brad
was 2 stops darker than the boy sitting
next to the window. You can only
capture that with film; I had to expose
for Brad, and those closer to the
window were many stops overexposed.
Lubezki marvels at films latitude.
Looking out from inside the house, we
were sometimes shooting at T2, and you
can see detail in the curtains, you can see
the grass outside, you can see the sky
and you can see the clouds, which were
maybe T64. Theyre overexposed, but
you can see them!
In day exteriors, the cinematogra-
pher would often reposition the actors to
shoot them in backlight for continuity.
We can ensure that shots will cut
together if the actors dont have direct
light on their faces, because that tells you
the time of day and what kind of light is
there, he notes. Backlighting is very
important because it helps the editing
add drapes to opposing windows.
Thomas Edisons small film
studio, the Black Maria, was built on a
giant turntable that allowed him to turn
the building to follow the sun. The film-
makers on The Tree of Life adopted a
similar strategy by shooting in three
separate houses with different orienta-
tions to the sun. Fisk explains, If we
had a room that faced east, we could
shoot early in the morning, and if it
faced west, we could shoot later in the
afternoon. Terry took that to the
extreme by having the same room repre-
sented in several houses so that we could
shoot at different times of the day.
According to Yoshikawa, the
editing team described Malicks
approach to continuity as being like
Cubism, shooting the same scene in
different locations. Wed mix and match
them with no continuity and worry only
about the feeling. We jumped around
the three different houses, but you dont
really catch on because youre accepting
the house as Jack remembers it.
In day interiors, Lubezki often
placed the actors near the windows,
riding the iris to keep the negative
healthy, he says. It sounds easy, but its
incredibly scary! Lets say the sun is out
and its bouncing into the room. You
start the scene at T8 and follow the kids,
Brad comes into the shot, and then
clouds suddenly drop the exposure to
Cosmic Questions
The Steadicam was used in low mode to capture action close to the ground.
CONGRATULATIONS
TO ALL CANNES FILM FESTIVAL AWARD RECIPIENTS ESPECIALLY
Thank you for using our equipment and services.
www.arri.com
THE TREE OF LIFE
DIRECTOR TERRENCE MALICK DP EMMANUEL LUBEZKI, ASC, AMC
SHOT WITH ARRICAM & MASTER PRIMES
FOOTNOTE
DIRECTOR JOSEPH CEDAR DP YARON SCHARF
SHOT WITH ARRIFLEX 535B & ULTRA PRIMES
THE KID WITH A BIKE
DIRECTORS JEAN-PIERRE & LUC DARDENNE DP ALAIN MARCOEN, SBC
SHOT WITH ARRICAM & MASTER PRIMES
DRIVE
DIRECTOR NICOLAS WINDING REFN DP NEWTON THOMAS SIEGEL, ASC
SHOT WITH ALEXA
MELANCHOLIA
DIRECTOR LARS VON TRIER DP MANUEL ALBERTO CLARO, DFF
SHOT WITH ALEXA
ONGR C
ANNES FILM FESTIV O ALL C T
THE TREE OF LIFE
TIONS A TUL A ONGR
CIPIENT ARD RE W AL A ESTIV VA
THE TREE OF LIFE
TIONS
Y CIALL LY S ESPE CIPIENT
THE TREE OF LIFE
THE TREE OF LIFE
H T I W T O H S
THE KID WITH A BIKE
THE TREE OF LIFE
I R P R E T S A M & M A C I R R A H
THE KID WITH A BIKE
THE TREE OF LIFE
S E M I
THE KID WITH A BIKE
THE KID WITH A BIKE
H T I W T O H S
THE KID WITH A BIKE
I R P R E T S A M & M A C I R R A H
DRIVE
THE KID WITH A BIKE
S E M I
OO F
TE TNO OO
DRIVE
H T I W T O H S A X E L A
TE
OO F
MEL
TE TNO OO
ANCHOLIA
TE
ANCHOLIA
MEL
or using our equipment and ser Thank you f
ANCHOLIA
or using our equipment and ser
om .arri.c w w w
A X E L A H T I W T O H S
ANCHOLIA
es. vic or using our equipment and ser
without requiring silks and so on. If both
characters in a scene are backlit, you can
cheat the audience no one will know
that one was shot in the summer and the
other in winter. In the scene where
Jacks father teaches him to fight, both
characters are backlit, a physical impos-
sibility that intercuts well.
We also used backlight because
it gives a sense of depth, whereas front-
light is flat, adds Lubezki. However,
we didnt backlight all the time because
that would be boring.
Another important tool for exte-
riors was negative fill, provided by a bead
board or other black surface. This was
often used to eliminate a light sand-
wich of two similar sources on either
side of an actor, and it also added a sense
of depth.
Lubezki admits that some simple
lights were used on night interiors, but
we never put a single light stand inside
the house. A single lightbox with
Photoflood bulbs was rigged overhead
for evening dinner scenes, supplementing
a practical. Night interiors in the boys
room were lit with a mobile light with a
hand dimmer, a 2K with a Chimera that
was held by Lubezki or Widmer,
whoever wasnt shooting, says the cine-
matographer. We didnt want to tell the
kids where to go; we wanted them to tell
us where to go, so we followed them with
the light. I dont think the audience can
tell the light is moving.
One scene in the bedroom was
played with real flashlights that were held
by Lubezki or Malick. In another scene,
Cosmic Questions
The adult Jack (Sean Penn) encounters his loved ones, including his deceased brother,
in a dreamlike beach setting.
38
Lubezki gave one of the boys a practical
desk lamp to play with in frame.
In a remarkable dusk exterior
sequence, Jack walks around his neigh-
borhood, peering into the houses and
catching glimpses of families. This scene
was shot over several evenings during a
15-to-20-minute window when the
deep blue sky was still luminous enough
to register. The house interiors were lit
with practicals on dimmers.
According to Lubezki, Malick
originally intended to color time the live-
action portion of the picture photo-
chemically, but this plan changed when
the print dailies came back with less
detail than the filmmakers wanted. The
dailies were very well-printed, says the
cinematographer, but they didnt
capture the wide latitude of the negative.
We lost detail in the whites, for example.
Ive been printing film for a long, long
time, and I can tell you that todays print
stocks are too contrasty. Thats because
theyre not made to print film anymore;
theyre made for the DI process.
Lubezki subsequently worked
with colorist Steve Scott and his team at
EFilm to create a look-up table that
would enable him to retain the detail of
the negative by making the values fit in
the tonal range of the prints and also the
DCP (which was prepared at
LaserPacific). Comparing the print and
DCP, Lubezki notes, You could almost
say they are two slightly different
versions of the movie. The DCP is
more sparkly, whereas the prints (from
4K filmouts) have better blacks.
Looking back, Lubezki reflects
that he could not have worked on The
Tree of Life without the deep trust he
had in Malick. He remembers the
director telling him early on to work on
the edge of catastrophe my words,
not his on the edge of exposure, of
framing. He told me to experiment and
try anything. And he said, I will never
use any shot that will humiliate you or
make you feel bad. You can come to the
editing any time you want, and you can
take anything you want out of the
movie. In that moment, I felt I could
truly try anything I could shoot
without lights, I could make mistakes
and I would have Terrys support. He
is a true artist and a true collaborator.
CookeOpticsLimited
British Optical Innovation and
Quality Since 1893.
The Cooke Look
Darkest Arts
Throughout
Part 1, Harry, Ron
(Rupert Grint) and
Hermione (Emma
Watson) hide out
in a tent as they
attempt to both
evade Voldemort
and find a way to
destroy him. The
top image is a
unit still; the
bottom image is a
frame grab.
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 43
site, which was nice. Of course, as the
cinematographer, I had to make sure
there was enough detail on the negative,
and we knew the final level of darkness
would be determined in the digital
grade.
Supervising digital colorist Peter
Doyle had been with the Potter franchise
since the third film, and was actively
involved in shaping a look for Deathly
Hallows from the very beginning. I was
sitting down with Eduardo from the
moment he came on board, says Doyle.
We worked through what he had in
mind and explored how the grade could
help that. One of the luxurious aspects of
the production was that we had a fully
equipped DI theater with a 50-foot
screen set up at Leavesden. It was avail-
able for the cinematographer to use from
day one, so tests could be carried all the
way through a DI workflow in order to
determine what might best be done in
post and what could be done on set with
lighting.
Serra worked closely with Doyle
throughout the shoot. He notes, What
can I say about Peter? Hes just incredi-
ble. At 7 each morning, I would meet up
with him and look at rushes on the big
screen, describing what I wanted before
going to set. Then, at lunch, about 30 of
us would meet in the theater and watch
the graded rushes together.
Our philosophy was that the
rushes grading was almost the first pass
of the DI, so these studio screenings
gave everyone an idea of what the final
would look like, adds Doyle. Another
important function was that we could
give Eduardo feedback about the neg.
We werent printing dailies, so wed look
at the proposed grade and then switch it
off so Eduardo could see what was
happening with his exposure and light-
ing. Then wed go back to the grade and
make any decisions required before it
was sent to editorial. If it was a green-
screen shot, we would look at it with the
grade applied but actually deliver it to
visual effects with the grade off.
In order to maintain consistency
across the long shoot and the multiple
units, Doyle devised a grading database
so that Serra could call up color refer-
ences from any shot on any day. He also
set up the facility to print calibrated
frame grabs on A3 photographic paper
so that the grade could be assessed on
set. The printouts allowed a much
easier handover from first to second
unit, says Doyle. They were also useful
for being able to go back to sets, and for
the art department to refine the set
decoration based on how it was being
read by the neg and the grade. You just
have to be careful that you dont start
chasing the grade on set, rather than the
grade following whats on the neg. With
Top: A-camera
operator Mike
Proudfoot lines
up a shot of
Radcliffe and
Watson in the
tent set. Bottom:
In this Part 1
frame, the heroic
trio lands in a
London caf, an
urban setting
that marks a
visual departure
from the rest of
the movie.
the oil lamps to lift the back of the tent.
It was almost always a real flame in the
lamps themselves.
The practicals were oil lanterns
because there is no electricity in Potters
magical world, so lighting these sections
of the story could sometimes be like
working on a period film. Serra notes,
Ive done a lot of period lighting in my
career, on Girl With a Pearl Earring [AC
Jan. 04] and Wings of the Dove [AC June
98], as well as earlier films in France and
Portugal, so Ive been working with
flame-based sources for a long time.
The result was exactly what Yates
desired. The tent scenes were beautiful,
as was the lighting at Grimmauld Place,
another location where Harry,
Hermione and Ron hide out, says the
director. I think Eduardos real gift is
that he can light a scene incredibly natu-
ralistically and believably, and yet it can
still have this wonderful, painterly qual-
ity to it.
For scenes that take place in the
non-magical world of Muggles (i.e.,
humans), which does have electricity, a
more contemporary approach could be
taken. At a moment of extreme danger
in Part 1, Harry and his friends magi-
cally transport themselves to central
London and take refuge in a dingy caf,
which provided Serra with an opportu-
nity to utilize more gritty, urban lighting.
44 August 2011 American Cinematographer
Darkest Arts
Eduardo it worked very well, because
hes so disciplined with his lighting.
On occasion Serra had to be flex-
ible with the simple, natural lighting
style for which he is renowned. I dont
like using backlight, but if youre doing a
night scene with 1,000 people and a lot
of visual effects, then you might not
have a choice, he says. For the night-
time courtyard scene hes describing,
which takes place during the battle for
Hogwarts in Part 2 , the unavoidable
backlight came from two full Wendy
Lights on 150'cranes. These were
combined with four soft sources over-
head, each comprising 18 space lights in
a box with the sides blacked off and a
30'x10'silk positioned underneath.
It was the more intimate scenes
that gave Serra a chance to express the
natural look Yates had envisaged.
Examples of this include interiors of the
magic tent in which Harry, Hermione
and Ron live while on the run from dark
forces in Part 1. Most of the tent scenes
were done with practicals, although I
had some soft light coming down from
above the set as well, says Serra. I tried
to keep the lighting to a minimum.
Finch adds, We hung China
balls wherever we could, just above the
practicals, and put peanut bulbs behind
Top: In a
frame grab from
Part 1, the
Snatchers
prepare to nab
Harry and his
friends and turn
them over to
Lord Voldemort.
Bottom: The
crew captures
Radcliffe on
the run in
the woods.
The caf scene was refreshing, he says.
I was one of the first cinematographers
to work with fluorescents, a long time
ago, and I still use them when I get the
chance, so that scene was fun. Finch
adds, We built fluorescents into that
set, and even the fill was fluorescent it
was all Kino Flo tubes. It was pretty
simple and felt a bit more like working
on a normal film.
A recurrent challenge for Serra
was the tendency toward lenses of
shorter focal lengths, a decision moti-
vated by cavernous sets and large-scale
action. Often we were on a 16mm or
18mm, so positioning the lights could be
a challenge, he says. With a 16mm
lens in a forest, it gets quite tricky. We
had to work on some trees in the grade
because it was impossible to get the
levels consistent. The DI was the only
way.
Whereas wider lenses were the
norm in Part 2, Yates notes, For Part 1,
I suggested that we sometimes go for a
more compressed feel with a 50mm or a
65mm because it was different from
what wed done before and felt right for
the story.
Close-up shots of Harry contem-
plating his situation in the quiet of the
forest were an instance when longer
lenses seemed appropriate. Yates
describes this scene as a moment where
we wanted to bring the central character
into real relief. It was all about being in
his head and the intimacy that lens
brings, the way it abstracted the forest
behind him. We also used long lenses
for a chase through the woods with the
Snatchers [bounty hunters]. Its a well-
trodden path for filmmakers, the frac-
tured dynamic that long lenses can give
you when youre rapidly cutting between
multiple handheld and fast-moving
shots. Eduardo was very willing to
accept that the story had to dictate the
tools we used at any particular
moment.
Even less kinetic sequences were
frequently shot with two cameras. We
often had two Arricams set up on the
same angle, with different lenses, Serra
explains. I prefer to avoid having
cameras at different angles because it
has a big impact on the lighting, and
always, at some point, the angles wont
be correct.
However, Serra never felt
restricted in how he could use the
camera, even with the extensive visual-
effects work. Aside from all the green-
screens, we shot normally, he says.
There were no limitations on the
camerawork. In fact, we were so free
that it was quite hard to find Tim
Top: Steadicam
operator Alf
Tramontin
captures a close
shot of Radcliffe
for Part 1. Bottom:
Director David
Yates (pointing at
right) preps a shot
for Part 2 as
camera operators
Tramontin (with
Steadicam),
Proudfoot (center,
placing camera on
ground) and B-
camera operator
David Morgan (in
background, with
eye to camera) get
ready to film.
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 45
Burke, our senior visual-effects supervi-
sor, on the set. We generally just saw
each other at the dailies!
In the digital grade, the filmmak-
ers worked to convey a sense of journey,
which meant developing multiple looks
rather than just applying one look
throughout. For a memory sequence in
Part 2, Yates was keen to communicate
the impression of past events without
resorting to familiar techniques.
Flashbacks have been done ad infini-
tumin the movies, and there are all sorts
of clichs, says Yates. Peter is incredi-
bly proficient technically, but he can also
grade emotionally, and we ended up
with a very beautiful look that actually
feels nostalgic without pushing all those
familiar buttons. Peter can make you
feel things without using the traditional
palette none of his choices come off
the shelf.
Doyles great challenge was to
create a feeling of darkness without the
image actually getting too dark.It was
almost like an intellectual exercise of
figuring out how to get darkness on the
screen that you can see, he says. I built
a few tone-mapping and micro-contrast
tools into the grading pipeline to put
detail back just in the black areas. In the
process, I researched what solutions had
been found in other image-reproduc-
Darkest Arts
PANTHER GmbH
Raiffeisenallee 3 | 82041 Munich | Germany
T +49.89.613 90001 | F +49.89.61 31 00 0
contact@panther.tv | www.panther.tv
Camadeus Film Technologies
7358 Radford Ave. | North Hollywood, CA 91605
T +818-764-1234 contact@panther.us
www.panther.us
Lowest column dolly due to 3-stage column
Equipped with the new High-Low Turnstile
New Limit programming
New high-low-platform concept
Crab, Front and Rear steering
See more about the Panther products at www.panther.tv
e.g. The VacuRigg, a camera vacuum tripod and rigg system
Panther Dolly
www.panther.tv
The new dolly generation
Panth
her
w
y l l o D
w w
g y l l o d w e n e h T
v .t ther .pan w
n o i t a r e n e g
o 3-stage c olumn dolly due t est c w o L
w o igh-L quipped with the new H E
amming r og New Limit pr
ept onc m c or tf -pla w New high-lo
ing eer ear st t and R on r , F ab r C
g y l l o d w e n e h T
ing options: eer t S
olumn o 3-stage c
nstile ur T w
n o i t a r e n e g
v t . r e h t n a p . w w w | v t . r e h t n a p @ t c a t n o c
0 0 1 3 1 6 . 9 8 . 9 4 + F | 1 0 0 0 9 3 1 6 . 9 8 . 9 4 + T
m r e G | h c i n u M 1 4 0 2 8 | 3 e e l l a n e s i e f f i a R
H b m G R E H T N A P
0 0
y n a m
c a t n o c 4 3 2 1 - 4 6 7 - 8 1 8 + T
o N | . e v A d r o f d a R 8 5 3 7
o n h c e T m l i F s u e d a m a C
s u . r e h t n a p . w w w
s u . r e h t n a p @ t c
5 0 6 1 9 A C , d o o w y l l o H h t r
s e i g o l
ts a oduc ther pr an e about the P ee mor S
he T . .g e igg acuR V ipod and r acuum tr a v , a camer
- aut
- ba
- v
- e
- pa
t ts a v .t ther .pan w w w
em st igg sy ipod and r
em st acuum pump sy tic v oma - aut
ed t a y oper er tt - ba
tion pads ious suc ar - v
id ig emely r tr x - e
o 100 kg/220 lbs yload uo t - pa
46
The crew prepares a night exterior for Part 1 in which Harry and Hermione return
to Harrys hometown in search of clues.
tion industries. In the late Seventies and
early Eighties, when the print industry
was at its zenith, they had some fantas-
tically elegant techniques to get around
the same problem. They would build a
contrast map by making a black-and-
white negative of the image, inverting it
and using that to control the blacks. You
can reproduce that digitally in about five
minutes, which is what we did. We
slowly built up an array of tools that
were focused around working in the
dark areas of the image.
This work was further compli-
cated by Warner Bros. decision to
convert Part 2 to 3-D in post to facili-
tate a simultaneous 3-D and 2-D
release. Yates opted for a very conserv-
ative approach to the stereoscopic
conversion and took pains to prevent it
from breaking the audiences involve-
ment in the story. Serra points out,
Because the 3-D work was done later
on, we didnt pay much attention to it on
set. In fact, we didnt even know it was
going to happen until near the end [of
the shoot].
Given that 3-D presentations are
by nature darker than 2-D, Doyle found
that he had to develop two different
grades. He notes, Im still not
convinced by 3-D grading packages, so
I graded the film in 2-D and then built
a color-conversion model so that the
grade would work in 3-D. In simple
terms, I made it darker for 2-D rather
than brighter for 3-D, which goes
against the prevailing industry method
at the moment. It meant operating in a
YUV color space as opposed to RGB;
this allowed me to work on the lumi-
nance and density mapping when we
went from 2-D at 16 foot-lamberts into
3-D at 3.5 foot-lamberts.
Having just wrapped the post
process, Serra reflects on the unique,
two-year Potter experience: Sometimes
I would look around on set at all these
thousands of people and wonder, How
did I come to be here? It was a great
The most comprehensive
Digital Lab for on-location
dailies.
Scene from Derrire les Murs Stphanie Dupont
All popular RAW camera formats
Unlimited shots, takes and versions in
one view
Fast, accurate conform
Powerful sound sync
World-class color grading
Multiple simultaneous delivery outputs
Mac or PC: $4,995
DIGITAL INGENUITY
www.assimilateinc.com
Unlimited shots, takes and versions in
W All popular RAAW
Unlimited shots, takes and versions in
W camera formats
dailies.
ab for on-location Digital L
The most comprehensive
.assimilateinc.com www
ab for on-location
The most comprehensive
.assimilateinc.com
Multiple simultaneous delivery outputs
orld-class color grading W
owerful sound sync P
Fast, accurate conform
one view
Unlimited shots, takes and versions in
Mac or PC: $4,995
Multiple simultaneous delivery outputs
orld-class color grading
owerful sound sync
Fast, accurate conform
Unlimited shots, takes and versions in
Mac or PC: $4,995
thing to do, but straight after we
finished, I went off and did a much
smaller movie with a Brazilian director
who was making his first film. It was
nice to go back to that kind of film-
making!
47
TECHNICAL SPECS
2.40:1
4-perf Super 35mm
Arricam Studio, Lite; Arri 235
Arri/Zeiss Master Prime,
Ultra Prime;
Angenieux Optimo
Kodak Vision3 500T 5219
Digital Intermediate
Stereoscopic Conversion
48 August 2011 American Cinematographer
An
All-American
Hero
An
All-American
Hero
Shelly Johnson, ASC
brings a super soldier
to the big screen with
Captain America:
The First Avenger.
By Iain Stasukevich
|
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 49
I
ts the height of World War II, and
the U.S. Army is recruiting soldiers in
the fight against the Axis forces, even
as a greater threat looms on the hori-
zon in the form of Hydra, a shadowy
organization led by Hitlers villainous
head of advanced weaponry, Johann
Schmidt/Red Skull (Hugo Weaving).
Steve Rogers (Chris Evans) has the
makings of a good soldier hes loyal,
honest and brave but he is also a 98-
pound weakling who is summarily
rejected by every recruitment office.
Finally, he volunteers for Project
Rebirth, a top-secret military program
designed to create super soldiers.
Rogers emerges as a taller, stronger,
nearly perfect being: Capt. America.
Director of photography Shelly
Johnson, ASC says he eagerly signed on
to Captain America: The First Avenger
because it offered a chance to reteam
with director Joe Johnston, a favorite
collaborator, and because the story
offered a lot of cinematic appeal.
Part of that appeal, he continues,
lay in the parallels between Captain
America and another action-adventure
film set in the same period, Raiders of the
Lost Ark , for which Johnston was the
visual-effects art director at Industrial
Light & Magic. One of the things the
two films have in common is that they
take you on a long journey, and youre
rarely in the same place twice, the cine-
matographer observes. It has a cumula-
tive effect and really helps immerse the
audience in that world. U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
b
y
J
a
y
M
a
i
d
m
e
n
t
.
P
h
o
t
o
s
,
f
r
a
m
e
g
r
a
b
s
a
n
d
c
o
n
c
e
p
t
a
r
t
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
P
a
r
a
m
o
u
n
t
P
i
c
t
u
r
e
s
a
n
d
M
a
r
v
e
l
E
n
t
e
r
t
a
i
n
m
e
n
t
.
L
i
g
h
t
i
n
g
d
i
a
g
r
a
m
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
S
h
e
l
l
y
J
o
h
n
s
o
n
.
Opposite: A
military
experiment
transforms the
diminutive Steve
Rogers (Chris
Evans) into Capt.
America, a secret
weapon of the
Allied forces, in
Captain America:
The First Avenger.
This page: Nazi
officer Johann
Schmidt (Hugo
Weaving), a.k.a.
Red Skull, shown
here in a frame
grab (top) and
two unit stills,
seeks the Cosmic
Cube, whose
mysterious power
he wants to
harness for the
Nazis.
50 August 2011 American Cinematographer
An All-American Hero
All told, Captain America was
filmed on more than 115 sets and loca-
tions. Principal photography took place
in the United Kingdom, with various
locations standing in for sites in the
United States, Iceland and Europe. Stage
work was shot at Shepperton Studios.
The schedule was so packed that
as many as seven sets were up and
running at any time, according to
Johnson. This shoot was like a giant
freight train: when it leaves the station,
theres a lot of momentum behind it! he
says.
Seven months before the shoot
commenced, Johnston and production
designer Rick Heinrichs began sketch-
ing out every scene in great detail.
Preparation is the one ingredient you
cant have too much of, says the direc-
tor. I think of prep as having two
phases. In the first, anything is possible.
In the second, which I call the wake-up
call, you have to compromise, to rein-
terpret your ideal version of the film as
something you can actually put on the
screen.
While the director concentrated
on building his world, Johnson concen-
trated on giving it light. The cine-
matographer starts every production by
making a reference book containing
camera lists, lighting lists, orders, inven-
tories, diagrams, photos and production
art. The book is a constant presence on
set, and its an evolving record, with
Johnson updating it almost daily.
On these types of films, a large
part of the cinematographers job is
being organized, he notes. Its the best
way to manage the technical side of the
job, and you can then be free to focus on
the creative side of things.
Johnson and Johnstons collabora-
tions have been diverse Jurassic Park
III, Hidalgo (AC April 04) and The
Wolfman (AC Feb. 10) are among them
but the director maintains that his
visual style has a certain consistency. I
love letting the camera help tell the
story, but I hate fatuous camera moves,
he says. In terms of my visual approach,
most critics would probably consider me
a traditionalist, or even, God forbid, old-
fashioned. The camera is more mobile in
Captain America than in any film Ive
made, and the shots are designed to
continuously reveal new information, to
shift focus from one character to
another, to change dramatic emphasis.
Johnson maintained maximum
flexibility by keeping the A camera on a
30' Technocrane (operated by Gary and
Paul Hymns) as often as possible, but
we used it more as a moving platform
or a dolly, not as a crane, he notes. Joe
would watch a scene play out and ask
for changes while we were rolling, and
we could make adjustments on the fly,
sometimes without even cutting.
Shooting digitally was another
stage in Johnstons metamorphosis. The
director became fascinated with digital
cinema after seeing George Lucas Star
Wars prequels, but Captain America
marked his first opportunity to explore
it. When Joe started talking to me
about Captain America , [the format]
wasnt even a question, says Johnson.
He asked me to shoot it, and I dont
think he even took a breath before
adding, And were shooting digital.
I find the flexibility of digital
technology really liberating, says the
director. The time the camera is rolling
is less precious, so I dont have to cut in
order to discuss changes with the actors.
But the real advantage is in post, where
I can recompose or enlarge shots with-
out degrading the image. Sometimes
well reframe a shot to look like its from
another camera. We can even make
close-ups out of two-shots or three-
shots if we have to.
Top: Dr. Erskine
(Stanley Tucci)
prepares to
administer the
experimental
treatment to
Rogers. Bottom:
Director of
photography
Shelly Johnson,
ASC adjusts a
source for
the scene.
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 51
The filmmakers chose Panavisions
Genesis for their A and B cameras.
Johnson felt comfortable working with
the Genesis after operating it on the
ASC/PGA Camera Assessment Series
(AC June and Sept. 09). On that project,
he used the Genesis with a waveform
monitor and without a digital-imaging
technician, recording to Panavisions
SSR-1 digital recorder.
He used the same approach on
Captain America . We wanted to keep
things simple, so we worked with a
single look-up table on set, says
Johnson. Using the custom viewing
LUT in the Genesis Display Processor,
he slightly desaturated the image and
added a contrasty film look by zeroing
out the blacks and lifting the highlights
to just below clip. Exposure metering
was performed on a waveform monitor,
and at the end of each day, the uncor-
rected DPX files were delivered to
Deluxe Laboratories in London, where
colorist Russell Coppleman graded the
dailies according to Johnsons notes.
Working off one LUT helped us
out a lot, because I could clearly see how
the camera was performing, says the
cinematographer. But all you really have
to do to make it work is protect the
values you want to print, and a lot of my
exposures came from lighting the values
below the highlights.
A Schneider Optics Black Magic
filter was used to give slightly clipped
values a more organic feel, and a Filter
Gallery Blue Streak Filter masked hot
practicals with long, anamorphic-like
flares.
Despite Captain Americas period
setting, Johnson didnt hesitate to use an
arsenal of modern lighting fixtures,
tapping Vari-Lites, Martin Mac
computerized lights, space lights, wire-
less dimmer controls and LEDs. They
all had to be used judiciously so as not to
tip our hand, but at the same time, we
wanted this movie to have a modern
edge, he explains.
This was particularly true of the
lighting for and around two characters,
Red Skull and inventor Howard Stark
(Dominic Cooper). Those men repre-
sent the pinnacle of modern technology
for their time, maybe even beyond, so
we used a lot of modern lighting around
them, says Johnson.
A variety of LED lights, includ-
ing RGB-mixable and the new
MoleLED (which Johnson tested for
Mole-Richardson), were employed.
Initially, Johnson thought they would
enable him to quickly dial in colors by
eye, but the first time he checked the
calibrated HD monitor after lighting a
shot by eye, he noticed a discrepancy
between his eye and the cameras sensor.
We were in a circular corridor in Hydra
headquarters, and I had set the overhead
color-mixable ribbon LEDs balanced to
a very pale blue, he recalls. But on the
monitor they appeared deep purple.
When he adjusted the color mixture
Top: As the
film begins,
modern-day
explorers
discover a
mysterious
object in an
Arctic cavern.
Below: The art
departments
concept drawing
for the scene.
52 August 2011 American Cinematographer
while viewing the monitor to achieve
the cool blue he desired, the fixtures on
set actually looked green.
The camera was either adding
red to our desired color or not seeing a
lot of this green, he surmises. The
color-temperature meters we use are
made to read fluorescents, gas arcs and
tungsten lamps, and all those lights
occupy very specific areas of the visible
color spectrum. LED light occupies
enormous areas of the color spectrum,
including some not visible to the eye but
visible on film.
Despite requiring some extra
time at the monitor, the LEDs worked
out so well that the filmmakers used
them to achieve the effect of the
Cosmic Cube, a mystical energy source
sought after by Red Skull. The cube was
designed as an intense, blue light source,
small and self-contained, so that
Weaving could walk around with it
without being tethered or constrained.
Johnson and his gaffer, John Biggles
Higgins, decided on high-output blue
LEDs, and Higgins crew built a five-
sided cube with about 64 bare LEDs on
each side. Inside the cube were two 4.8-
volt battery packs and a wireless DMX
dimmer module to control the sources.
It was blindingly bright and just
punched through the warmer tones,
says Johnson. He explains that the films
heroes and villains are delineated in part
by color: the heroes world is rendered in
warm colors, whereas the villains envi-
ronments feature blue and green tones.
An All-American Hero
Top: A frame
grab of the
Modern Marvels
Pavilion exterior.
Middle and
bottom:
Stark Industries,
led by Howard
Stark (Dominic
Cooper), occupies
the pavilions
main stage.
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 53
When the Allies gain possession of
samples of the cube technology, the
signature blue source has an other-
worldly presence in their warm environ-
ment, says Johnson.
Captain America s period setting
keeps the action rooted in reality, allowing
the story to go to impossible places and
still feel real. One particularly impossible
place that had to feel real is the frozen
wasteland where modern-day explorers
discover Rogers encased in a block of ice.
It was a scene that could never have been
achieved in reality, says Johnson.
Theres an intense blizzard. Its a day
exterior with a midnight sun sitting on
the horizon. All the warm sky colors had
to pierce the cool ice colors. Its an image
constructed of primary elements, and if
any part of the execution had failed, it
would have been unsuccessful.
The team briefly considered shoot-
ing the scene on location in Iceland, but
they soon determined that Sheppertons
Stage H was a more viable option. Only a
handful of elements were required to
create the necessary illusion: skylight,
horizon light, and a sun projected onto a
muslin cyclorama behind a forced-
perspective glacial landscape.
We rigged 15 4K Fresnels over-
head to bounce up into 12-by-20-foot
UltraBounces and go through Rosco 251
Quarter White diffusion, which gave us
a soft, ambient toplight, explains
Johnson. For the sun ball, we used a
Vari-Lite 3000 spot on a dolly track
This frame grab
shows the
Arctic sunset
scene that
Johnson and his
crew created
onstage at
Shepperton
Studios. Below
is Johnsons
lighting
diagram for the
scene.
54 August 2011 American Cinematographer
behind the cyc, and we moved the light
as we tracked with our characters so it
looked like a believable sun in the
distance. Higgins adds, We put up
about a hundred 5K cyc strips circling
more than half the set, which was about
250 feet by 150 feet. We were at about 25
percent on the dimmer, and that gave us
a nice, red glow around the setting sun.
The snow and smoke really sold it.
Another set created on Stage H
comprised several elements of the
Modern Marvels Pavilion, where Stark
shows off his latest technologies. Only the
foreground elements were built: the main
floor, six exhibit platforms, monorail
pylons (the CG train was added later) and
the main stage. A greenscreen cyc fully
surrounded the set to facilitate views of
the outside, all CGI added in post.
Johnsons crew rigged hundreds of
lights in the pavilion, most of them Kino
Flo Image 80s that were illuminating the
360-degree greenscreen. Six of the 4K
HMI bounces created for the frozen-
wasteland set provided cool ambient
light, which was punctuated by Vari-
Lites spotlighting exhibits on the main
floor. Battens of low-profile 55-watt
MR-16s, Biggles Strips, were placed
along the base of the main stage to act as
footlights.
The main stage is the jewel of this
whole set, so we concentrated on
surrounding it with a more refined light-
ing style, says Johnson. Above the
revolving platform were three spinning
Vari-Lite 3000 spots and a 12' light box
with a space light wired to 2-3-5 behind
Light Grid and
1
2 CTB. Sixteen Par 36
spots were installed in the upper soffit
that ringed the stage.
When Im working with a large
set or complicated lighting task, I try to
simplify it down to its basic elements so
that every light is serving a single
purpose, says Johnson. One of his goals
with this set, he continues, was to faith-
fully translate Heinrichs concept art.
The pavilion has a spectacular look, and
Rick designed a lot of the exhibits, he
says. There is also an incredibly stylized
CG set that extends into the background.
Our lighting doesnt interact with that,
An All-American Hero
Top: Rogers
begins to shape
Capt. Americas
signature shield.
Below: The super
soldier and his
shield go into
battle in this shot
of some second-
unit action, which
was captured by
2nd-unit director/
cinematographer
Jonathan Taylor,
ASC. Most of
Captain America
was shot digitally,
but many fire and
explosion scenes
were shot on film.
The problem
with
photographing
pyrotechnics
[digitally] is that
you get clipping
in the flames
and explosions,
notes Taylor.
but it carries out the same design idea.
One of the productions largest
locations was an old Royal Navy
Propellant factory in Caerwent, South
Wales, which was transformed into
Hydras headquarters in Germany.
Rogers steals into the facility at night to
rescue his sidekick, Bucky (Sebastian
Stan), who has been captured by Hydra.
Rogers and Bucky escape with the aid of
some Allied POWs, but not without a
fight. That was a large installation the
buildings were about 200 feet apart
and there was an enormous amount of
light around it, says Johnson. It was a
totally artificial night exterior. I mixed
color temperatures uncorrected
mercury-vapor, daylight and tungsten
lamps.
He knew some of his sources
would have to be in frame, so he had his
crew position four scissor lifts holding
two SyncroLite 4K Xenon spots gelled
with
1
2 CTO around the location, and
then asked visual-effects supervisor Chris
Townsend to replace the lifts with CG
guard towers.
It took Higgins, rigging gaffer
Wayne Leach and their crew about two
weeks to pre-rig the four staging areas in
Caerwent. There were so many lights
spread over the area that the only way to
control them all was through a DMX
dimmer board. Most of the action takes
place in one spot, in front of the main
Hydra building, and Johnson lit the area
with Vari-Lite spots and washes, Xenon
lights, roving 20K and 5K lamps, and
three crane-mounted 20'x20' softboxes
with solid sides. Inside the softboxes were
2-3-5 modified space lights rigged to a
scaffold arm with jubilee clips and rigid
metal bars, allowing the lights to be
angled.
Higgins explains the 2-3-5
configuration: U.K. space lights come
with six bulbs in two circuits, so we take
one bulb out. With the five left, we can
turn on two or three, or all five, and that
gives us three different light levels at the
same color temperature.
Once Rogers gains access to Hydra
headquarters and attracts Red Skulls
attention, the ensuing battle was captured
by 2nd-unit director/cinematographer
Jonathan Taylor, ASC. After walking
through the sequence with his gaffer,
Steve Costello, Taylor designed the
shots. He and his crew then spent five
nights following stuntmen and extras
with dollies, Technocranes, Ultimate
Arms and Steadicams, dodging explo-
sions as the base went up in flames.
The problem with photograph-
ing pyrotechnics with digital cameras is
that you get clipping in the fires and
explosions, notes Taylor. Special-
effects supervisor Gareth Wingrove
worked with me to darken the pyro by
adding more cork and dust to the explo-
sions, and different gas mixtures were
used to create a richer flame. My gaffer,
Steve Costello, increased the exposure,
allowing me to shoot at a deeper stop.
When cameras had to be placed
very close to explosions, Taylor used
Arri 435s and 235s in crash housings,
shooting 4-perf Super 35mm. We also
used a film camera, a [Panaflex]
Millennium XL, to shoot fire and
explosion plates that were beyond the
dynamic-range capture capability of the
Genesis, says Johnson. He adds that
underwater cinematographer Pete
Romano, ASC used an Arri Alexa for
his portion of the action.
Another memorable second-unit
sequence shows Capt. America chasing
a Nazi spy through the streets of
Brooklyn. (Manchester doubled for the
location.) Film and digital were mixed,
with Taylor favoring the 435s and 235s
for the car-mounted 15' Technocrane
and the quad-bike-mounted wireless
Libra head ridden by stunt rider Jean-
Pierre Goy. The Libra head was
mounted to a Rise and Fall rig (designed
by key grip Kenny Atherfold and
Camera Revolutions Ian Speed) that
could take the camera from ground level
to a high angle. Jean-Pierre is so good
with the camera on the motorcycle that
hes actually like an operator, Taylor
remarks. My operators, Tim Wooster
and Peter Field, had to make a few
adjustments, but Jean-Pierre always put
the camera in the right position.
The chase covers about nine
blocks, but Taylor only had access to
three blocks of downtown Manchester.
To complicate matters, streets could
An All-American Hero
The crew preps a night exterior on location in Caerwent, South Wales, where an old factory
was transformed into Hydra headquarters.
only be blocked off at certain times of
day, and there were rain delays.
Fortunately, Manchesters soft, overcast
daylight made it easy to match shots
captured on different days, and Taylor
made the most of the location by shoot-
ing the available streets from every angle
and redressing store fronts.
Taylor used a Canon EOS 5D
Mark II to capture the moment of
impact when the Nazi spys taxi is hit by
a truck that sends it flying into the air.
He hid two 5Ds with kit lenses in small
Pelican cases that each had a hole cut
into one side. The holes were sealed
with clear Lexan polycarbonate, and the
cases were painted to match the detail-
ing on the front bumper of the truck
and the back bumper of the taxi.
Another 5D was rigged inside the taxi
to get the drivers POV. As the moment
of impact approached, Taylor also had
two Genesis cameras tracking alongside
the taxi on a winch-drive remote rail
system (built by Jason Leinster).
Second units really shine when theyre
given authorship over a large piece of a
sequence, Johnson observes, and
Jonathans work is just dazzling. He
understands what action is and how to
make it exciting for the camera.
Although Johnson desaturated
the dailies on Captain America, he says
that once he started the final color
correction with colorist/ASC associate
Steven J. Scott at EFilm, I found
myself doing almost no desaturation.
On the big screen, with our color
choices being so simplified, desaturating
the image takes the life out of it.
Johnston trusted Johnsons judg-
ment completely. Shelly is an artist
with paint and brushes as well as lights
and lenses, he says. I dont hesitate to
hand over to him all technical and
creative responsibilities for capturing the
image, and I know hell deliver some-
thing above and beyond what I had in
mind.
One of the most gratifying
aspects of Captain America , the cine-
matographer notes, was Joes ability to
integrate human moments into an
action film. Now that Ive seen it all put
together, I think its quite masterful.
BRILLIANT HMI LIGHTING SOLUTIONS AVAILABLE FOR RENTAL AT THESE PREFERRED LOCATIONS:
ADORAMA RENTAL CO
distributed by www.bronimaging.com (800) 456-0203
COME SEE THE LIGHT
WORLD CLASS HMI
TECHNICAL SPECS
2.40:1
Digital Capture and 4-perf
Super 35mm
Panavision Genesis,
Panaflex Millennium XL;
Arri 435, 235, Alexa;
Canon EOS 5D Mark II
Panavision Primo, Canon EF
Kodak Vision3 500T 5219,
Vision2 200T 5217
Digital Intermediate
Stereoscopic Conversion
57
of the desert. Broken glass and debris litter what used to be
the ceiling of the boats grand interior, and rain pours through
the splintered hull overhead. The night sky alights with light-
ning, sending shadows dancing across the boats interior.
Theres an unsettling sense that the searchers are not alone,
and their dogs sudden barking seems to make the inkling a
certainty.
From out of the darkness, director Jon Favreau calls
Cut! The rain stops and work lights come up inside Stage
27 at Universal Studios in Los Angeles. Cinematographer
Matthew Libatique, ASC joins Favreau at video village,
where the two discuss whether to go again or move on to the
next setup in Cowboys & Aliens. As the title suggests, the
project is a genre mash-up that pits cowboys in the American
West against an alien invasion force.
58 August 2011 American Cinematographer
T
he year is 1870. A band of frontiersmen has set out from
the town of Absolution in search of family and friends
who were abducted by an unknown enemy in an explo-
sive show of force. The mens search has brought them to
an inexplicable site: an upside-down riverboat in the middle
Once
Upon a Time
intheWest
Once
Upon a Time
intheWest
Matthew Libatique, ASC blazes a
creative trail for the sci-fi Western
Cowboys & Aliens.
By Jon D. Witmer
|
w ww.theasc.com August 2011 59
The production is nearing the
end of its 75 shooting days when AC
visits the set, and Libatique acknowl-
edges that the experience has been far
different from his last feature, Darren
Aronofskys Black Swan (AC Dec. 10),
which earned the cinematographer
ASC and Oscar nominations. I get re-
energized when I go from a small
project to a big project, or big to small,
or from features to commercials, he
says. If it was a different director,
maybe it would have been a little
crazier, but Jons like family.
I was never one to want to do a
Western, continues Libatique. In fact,
when Jon first told me about this
movie, it sounded kind of ridiculous to
me. But after two movies and countless
conversations, I trust him. He said, Its
good, and I thought, Okay. I trust Jon.
I did embrace [the Western
genre] as soon as I got into it, he
continues. I liked the references, the
John Ford films that we watched, and I
got into the pace of a Western. I was
inspired by The Proposition [AC May
06] because its patient, and a contem- U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
b
y
Z
a
d
e
R
o
s
e
n
t
h
a
l
,
S
M
P
S
P
,
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
U
n
i
v
e
r
s
a
l
P
i
c
t
u
r
e
s
.
A
d
d
i
t
i
o
n
a
l
p
h
o
t
o
s
p
r
o
v
i
d
e
d
b
y
M
i
c
h
a
e
l
B
a
u
m
a
n
.
Opposite: Jake Lonergan (Daniel Craig) takes aim at alien invaders in Cowboys & Aliens. This page, top:
Col. Woodrow Dolarhyde (Harrison Ford) and his men ride to the town of Absolution in search of
Lonergan. Bottom: Cinematographer Matthew Libatique, ASC (at camera) and director Jon Favreau
(right) find their frame on location in New Mexico.
60 August 2011 American Cinematographer
porary film with patience is a very rare
thing.
We wanted to be as honest with
the Western as possible, and the chal-
lenge was how to mesh that with
science fiction. We looked at Alien [AC
August 79], and we were taken by how,
structurally, it resembles a thriller. The
question became, How do we create
the tension within the Western to grad-
uate into the science-fiction thriller?
That was terrifying, but ultimately, as a
cinematographer, its not my position to
worry about the storys structure. I just
have to worry about the visual language
of it all.
As preproduction got underway,
the possibility of shooting 3-D arose.
Libatique recounts, I did the best I
could to absorb as much [3-D] infor-
mation as possible, and we tested for
three days with the Pace system. The
tests were very telling; they looked
stunning, but it terrified me how big
and cumbersome everything was. We
had so many cables we had to dig
trenches so the horses wouldnt trip.
When we showed the tests to
DreamWorks and Universal, they were
unsure about it, he continues. Jon
asked me what I thought, and I just had
an instinct it wasnt going to be good.
Cinematography is about action and
reaction, and I didnt think [shooting
3-D] in the middle of New Mexico was
going to be conducive to any type of
momentum.
Once 3-D was off the table,
Libatique quickly shifted gears. Out of
10 weeks of prep, we spent seven prep-
ping for 3-D, he says. Those last three
weeks were a whirlwind, but we had an
amazing team, including [production
designer] Scott Chambliss and
[costume designer] Mary Zophres. All
the elements that didnt have anything
to do with 3-D were in place. But it was
hard on the crew wed squandered
valuable mental energy trying to figure
out how 3-D was going to work.
The filmmakers ultimately
decided to shoot anamorphic 35mm.
Anamorphic is the language of the
classic Western, and it was a creative,
aesthetic and technical draw for me,
says Libatique.
The production carried Panaflex
Millennium and Millennium XL
camera bodies from Panavision
Hollywood. Ive had a long relation-
ship with Panavision Hollywood, and I
really wanted to use the G-Series
[anamorphic lenses], says Libatique.
We used them in combination with
the C-Series. My first AC, Mark
Santoni, literally walked through the
lens room and built the package lens by
lens.
Within the range of primes,
Libatique gravitated toward the 50mm
and 75mm. We would go up to
100mm from time to time, but rarely
did we go wider than 50mm. We had a
collection of Primo zooms as well, and
C
i
n
e
m
a
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
i
n
t
h
e
D
i
g
i
t
a
l
A
g
e
p
h
o
t
o
b
y
G
r
e
g
H
a
r
b
a
u
g
h
,
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
A
M
P
A
S
.
From left: Associate member Rob Hummel; Bill
Kroyer; John Bailey, ASC; Adrian Seery; Chris Sanders;
Guillermo Navarro, ASC; Dean Semler, ASC, ACS; and
Dean DeBlois.
88 August 2011 American Cinematographer
When you were a child, what film made the strongest impres-
sion on you?
The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957) and Lawrence of Arabia (1962),
epic stories unspooled on the large canvas of an exotic location
enhanced by spectacular photography.
Which cinematographers, past or present, do you most admire?
One of the first I noticed was Conrad Hall, ASC, for
his ability to do stunning black-and-white work with
an emotional impact within the constraints of a TV
schedule. More recently Ive admired the work of
ASC members Roger Deakins, Rodrigo Prieto, Caleb
Deschanel, Vittorio Storaro and John Bailey, and
Christopher Doyle, HKSC.
What sparked your interest in photography?
My uncle, an economist for the Federal Trade
Commission, was a serious amateur photographer
who took his 16mm Bolex all over the world. I was
captivated by the way he was able to entertain
people by setting up a projector in his basement
theater.
Where did you train and/or study?
At age 12, I began helping out on weekends at the radio station KVIP
in Redding, Calif., and later at their TV station. When I was in high
school, they hired me to shoot, develop and edit news film. In Septem-
ber 1963, I had the privilege of filming President Kennedy dedicating the
Whiskeytown Dam and Reservoir. I spent a college semester at the Slade
School of Fine Arts, University College, London, and received my MFA
from New York Universitys graduate film program.
Who were your early teachers or mentors?
I learned an enormous amount from George Abbott, my journalism
teacher at Shasta High School; Doug Watson, a cameraman at KVIP-TV;
and Jim Vestal, an award-winning local newspaper photographer. As an
undergraduate at Mackinac College, I was greatly influenced by my
professor Jack McCabe, a Shakespearean scholar and film buff.
What are some of your key artistic influences?
I look at the Dutch masters for their shadow and luminosity, and Im
always influenced by foreign travel for the distinctive types of available
light everywhere on the earth: on the Alps, on the plains of Central
Africa, on the sands of Egypt, against the ochre walls of Tuscan villas, on
fishing boats in Vietnam, gleaming up from rivers in Laos, and illumi-
nating jewel-toned saris in India.
How did you get your first break in the business?
I was called in to take over Fire Down Below, which became my first
credit on a major studio feature.
What has been your most satisfying moment on a project?
The Rescue Me Season 5 premiere at Radio City Music Hall. You dont
often get to see TV in a room like that.
Have you made any memorable blunders?
We make mistakes all the time, but the important thing is to try to keep
them small and take corrective action the next time around.
What is the best professional advice youve ever
received?
I received early encouragement from Woody Omens,
ASC; and Walter Lassally, BSC taught me many crucial
concepts over the course of several projects. I also
appreciated the opportunity to be on the set of Fat
City, where Conrad Hall was executing innovative
ideas like using 8K (4x2K) umbrella lights for the fight
scenes. In dailies, John Huston would just put his head
down and listen, trusting Conrad to deliver their visual
plan.
What recent books, films or artworks have
inspired you?
I admire The Kings Speech, Black Swan, Biutiful, True Grit and 127 Hours
for their innovative approach to drama. Im also deeply affected by the
blend of modern and historic architecture my distant relations have
created at our Lancashire family seat, Hoghton Tower. Running a 16th-
century estate in todays economy takes monumental effort, but the de
Hoghtons have managed to preserve the Banqueting Hall, which is lined
with 2,000 panes of Flemish glass, and drawing rooms where William
Shakespeare worked as a tutors assistant.
Do you have any favorite genres, or genres you would like to try?
Ive always been a fan of film noir, and after getting to know one of its
masters, John Alton, ASC, I studied his films even more intensely. I also
enjoy filming music, and it was great fun to shoot the musical segments
for Rescue Me in Busby Berkeley style.
If you werent a cinematographer, what might you be doing
instead?
Ive never really thought about it, because being a photographer and
cinematographer has been my quest since childhood.
Which ASC cinematographers recommended you for member-
ship?
Steven Poster, Ron Fortunato and Dean Semler.
How has ASC membership impacted your life and career?
Its a great experience to be able to commune and compare notes with
my friends and heroes and attend events where I can pass on what Ive
learned to others.
Tom Houghton, ASC Close-up
P
h
o
t
o
b
y
K
e
n
O
r
t
i
z
.
R OGI E R S TOF F E R S , AS C, NS C
ONFILM
To order Kodak motion picture lm,
call (800) 621-lm.
Eastman Kodak Company, 2011.
Photography: 2011 Douglas Kirkland
I love to make images. I believe that you need
to know the technical aspects so well that you
dont need to think about them anymore. Its
about the story and the characters, and along
with the ideas of your collaborators, your
approach is built out of that. I like to get one
or two images in my head that represent the
movie for me. As a director of photography,
my place is at the camera, in the middle of the
set, close to the actors, in the midst of all the
craziness and creativity. Then, when I put my
eye to the eyepiece, I enter my own world. At
that moment, nobody is concentrating on the
movie as much as I am. Thats the moment I
really love in lmmaking.
Rogier Stofers, ASC, NSC grew up in the
Netherlands and studied lmmaking at the
Nederlandse Film en Televisie Academie in
Amsterdam. His work on Character earned
the Golden Frog at the 1997 Plus Camerimage
International Film Festival of the Art of
Cinematography, and since then his credits
include School of Rock, Quills, John Q, Enough,
The Secret Life of Bees, No Strings Attached,
and The Vow, among others.
All these productions were photographed on
Kodak motion picture lm.
For an extended interview with Rogier Stofers,
visit www.kodak.com/go/onlm.