News, Quotes, Companies, Videos

Tuesday, April 21, 2009 As of 12:00 AM New York 82 | 65

SEARCH

OPINION
U.S. Edition Home World U.S.
Today's Paper People In The New s Video Blogs Journal Community Subscribe Log In

New York

Business

Markets
Leisure & Arts

Tech

Personal Finance

Life & Culture

Opinion

Careers

Real Estate

Small Business

Book Review s

Letters to the Editor

Political Diary
2 of 12

Colum ns
3 of 12

1 of 12

TOP STORIES IN

Opinion
OPINION

Guy Sorman: Why Europe Will Rise Again

Garry Kasparov: When Putin's Thugs Came for Me

Jenkins: Facebook Faceplant

If Only They Had Li

April 21, 2009

Why Capital Structure Matters

Companies that repurchased stock two years ago are in a world of hurt.
Article
Comments
MORE IN OPINION

By MIC H AEL MIL KEN

Thirty-five years ago business publications were writing that major money-center banks would fail, and quoted investors who said, "I'll never own a stock again!" Meanwhile, some state and local governments as well as utilities seemed on the brink of collapse. Corporate debt often sold for pennies on the dollar while profitable, growing companies were starved for capital. If that all sounds familiar today, it's worth remembering that 1974 was also a turning point. With financial institutions weakened by the recession, public and private markets began displacing banks as the source of most corporate financing. Bonds rallied strongly in 197576, providing underpinning for the stock market, which rose 75%. Some high-yield funds achieved unleveraged, two-year rates of return approaching 100%.

Available to WSJ.com Subscribers

Chad Crowe

Communities Fight to Break Cycle of Killing

The accessibility of capital markets has grown continuously since 1974. Businesses are not as dependent on banks, which now own less than a third of the loans they originate. In the first quarter of 2009, many corporations took advantage of low absolute levels of interest rates to raise $840 billion in the global bond market. That's 100% more than in the first quarter of 2008, and is a typical increase at this stage of a market cycle. Just as in the 1974 recession, investment-grade companies have started to reliquify. Once that happens, the market begins to open for lower-rated bonds. Thus BB- and B-rated corporations are now raising capital through new issues of equity, debt and convertibles. This cyclical process today appears to be where it was in early 1975, when balance sheets began to improve and corporations with strong capital structures started acquiring others. In a single recent week, Roche raised more than $40 billion in the public markets to help finance its merger with Genentech. Other companies such as Altria, HCA, Staples and Dole Foods, have used bond proceeds to pay off short-term bank debt, strengthening their balance sheets and helping restore bank liquidity. These new corporate bond issues have provided investors with positive returns this year even as other asset groups declined. The late Nobel laureate Merton Miller and I, although good friends, long debated online.wsj.com/article/SB124027187331937083.html

Economy Notches Fitful Gains

Caterpillar Union Bows to Demands

Egypt's New Leaders Target Judges' Power

1/5

whether this kind of capital-structure management is an essential job of corporate leaders. Miller believed that capital structure was not important in valuing a company's securities or the risk of investing in them. My belief -- first stated 40 years ago in a graduate thesis and later confirmed by experience -- is that capital structure significantly affects both value and risk. The optimal capital structure evolves constantly, and successful corporate leaders must constantly consider six factors -- the company and its management, industry dynamics, the state of capital markets, the economy, government regulation and social trends. When these six factors indicate rising business risk, even a dollar of debt may be too much for some companies. Over the past four decades, many companies have struggled with the wrong capital structures. During cycles of credit expansion, companies have often failed to build enough liquidity to survive the inevitable contractions. Especially vulnerable are enterprises with unpredictable revenue streams that end up with too much debt during business slowdowns. It happened 40 years ago, it happened 20 years ago, and it's happening again. Overleveraging in many industries -- especially airlines, aerospace and technology -started in the late 1960s. As the perceived risk of investing in such businesses grew in the 1970s, the price at which their debt securities traded fell sharply. But by using the capital markets to deleverage -- by paying off these securities at lower, discounted prices through tax-free exchanges of equity for debt, debt for debt, assets for debt and cash for debt -- most companies avoided default and saved jobs. (Congress later imposed a tax on the difference between the tax basis of the debt and the discounted price at which it was retired.) Issuing new equity can of course depress a stock's value in two ways: It increases the supply, thus lowering the price; and it "signals" that management thinks the stock price is high relative to its true value. Conversely, a company that repurchases some of its own stock signals an undervalued stock. Buying stock back, the theory goes, will reduce the supply and increase the price. Dozens of finance students have earned Ph.D.s by describing such signaling dynamics. But history has shown that both theories about lowering and raising stock prices are wrong with regard to deleveraging by companies that are seen as credit risks. Two recent examples are Alcoa and Johnson Controls each of which saw its stock price increase sharply after a new equity issue last month. This has happened repeatedly over the past 40 years. When a company uses the proceeds from issuance of stock or an equity-linked security to deleverage by paying off debt, the perception of credit risk declines, and the stock price generally rises. The decision to increase or decrease leverage depends on market conditions and investors' receptivity to debt. The period from the late-1970s to the mid-1980s generally favored debt financing. Then, in the late '80s, equity market values rose above the replacement costs of such balance-sheet assets as plants and equipment for the first time in 15 years. It was a signal to deleverage. In this decade, many companies, financial institutions and governments again started to overleverage, a concern we noted in several Milken Institute forums. Along with others, including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, we also pointed out that when companies reduce fixed obligations through asset exchanges, any tax on the discount ultimately costs jobs. Congress responded in the recent stimulus bill by deferring the tax for five years and spreading the liability over an additional five years. As a result, companies have already moved to repurchase or exchange more than $100 billion in debt to strengthen their balance sheets. That has helped save jobs. The new law is also helpful for companies that made the mistake of buying back their stock with new debt or cash in the years before the market's recent fall. These purchases peaked at more than $700 billion in 2007 near the market top -- and in many cases, the value of the repurchased stock has dropped by more than half and has led to ratings downgrades. Particularly hard hit were some of the world's largest companies (i.e., General Electric, AIG, Merrill Lynch); financial institutions (Hartford Financial, Lincoln National, Washington Mutual); retailers (Macy's, Home Depot); media companies online.wsj.com/article/SB124027187331937083.html

Don't Miss

Powered by Taboola

Opi n i on Jou r n a l : Oba m a 's T r a n scr i pt -St eph en s on wh 03:47

Mi ss Ph i l i ppi n es Bea t boxes a t t h e 2012 Mi ss Wor l d Pa gea n t 03:45

Opi n i on Jou r n a l : It 's t h e Econ om y , St u pi d -- Cr owl ey pi cks a pa r t Ga l l 05:13

Most Popular on Facebook

Miss China Crowned Miss World 2012 38 people recommended this. Future of Data: Encoded in DNA 271 people recommended this. In Turf Tussle, Die-Hard Skateboarders Diss Scooters 9 people recommended this. Facebook Investors Cash Out 130 people recommended this. Are We All Braggarts Now? 405 people recommended this.

F acebook social plugin

More in Opinion
Guy Sorman: Why Europe Will Rise Again Garry Kasparov : When Putin's Thugs Came for Me Jenkins: Facebook Faceplant If Only They Had Listened The Energy Subsidy Tally

Most Popular
Read Emailed Video Commented

1. 2. 3.

Miss China Crowned Miss World 2012

Facebook Inv estors Cash Out NBC Cuts Staff at 'Tonight Show'

4. The Panic Ov er Fukushima 5.

SEC Shuts Down ZeekRewards as Scam

Most Read Articles Feed

Latest Headlines
Communities Fight to Break Cy cle of Killing Cantaloupes Linked to Salmonella Cases Fannie, Freddie Bailout Receiv es Rev amp School in August Gets Low Grades Saltwater Creeps Up Mississippi Charges Against Kansas Abortion Clinic Dropped White House Frees Up Funds for States Thirst for Y ield Driv es Munis Moody 's, Seeing Default Risk, to Rev iew Ratings on Calif. Cities

2/5

(CBS, Gannett); and industrial manufacturers (Eastman Kodak, Motorola, Xerox). Without stock buybacks, many such companies would have little debt and would have greater flexibility during this period of increased credit constraints. In other words, their current financial problems are self-imposed. Instead of entering the recession with adequate liquidity and less debt with long maturities, they had the wrong capital structure for the time. The current recession started in real estate, just as in 1974. Back then, many realestate investment trusts lost as much as 90% of their value in less than a year because they were too highly leveraged and too dependent on commercial paper at a time when interest rates were doubling. This time around it was a combination of excessive leverage in real-estate-related financial instruments, a serious lowering of underwriting standards, and ratings that bore little relationship to reality. The experience of both periods highlights two fallacies that seem to recur in 20-year cycles: that any loan to real estate is a good loan, and that property values always rise. Fact: Over the past 120 years, home prices have declined about 40% of the time. History isn't a sine wave of endlessly repeated patterns. It's more like a helix that brings similar events around in a different orbit. But what we see today does echo the 1970s, as companies use the capital markets to push out debt maturities and pay off loans. That gives them breathing room and provides hope that history will repeat itself in a strong economic recovery. It doesn't matter whether a company is big or small. Capital structure matters. It always has and always will. Mr. Milken is chairman of the Milken Institute.

Life Partners Dodges Seizure

More Headlines

Oklahoma Oil Well Already Drilled, Tested and Analyzed. $7500 min. IRA ok. OklahomaOilInvesting.com Business Insurance Find Business & Commercial Insurance Companies in Your Area. yellowpages.com Business Insurance Effective Small Business Solutions. Find Ideas, Resources & Financing. www.business.com

From Around the Web

Content From Sponsors

Powered by Taboola

T h e Wor st Mi st a ke I Ma de Pl a n n i n g for Ret i r em en t Fiscal Times

T h e Esqu i r e T h e Sca r i est Gu y 's Ir r ev er en t A ppa r i t i on Yet Scripps: Travel Channel Ru l es for t h e Per fect Bu si n ess Entrepreneur

Please add your comments to the Opinion Journal forum.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION MORE IN

Be the first to comment

Opinion

Don't Miss
BUSINESS

Powered by

Taboola

OPINION

Fa cebook In v est or s Ca sh Ou t ; Zu cker ber

02:59

Opi n i on Jou r n a l : Bi den Lea ds Ch a i n of Fool s --

05:30

PERSONAL FINANCE

BUSINESS

Mi l l i on a i r es Fl eei n g T a xes
02:41

Googl e Sl a sh i n g 20% of Mot or ol a Mobi l i t y St a ff

02:20

President Lowers Mortgage If you owe under $729k you probably qualify for the Govt Refi Program. www.MortgageRatesExperts.com Full Color Business Cards 14 -16pt Glossy, Matte, Recycled or Uncoated. Satisfaction Guaranteed! www.gotprint.com Restaurant Insurance Guaranteed Low Cost Restaurant Insurance www.allunitedinsurance.com Easy 90% Stock Signals 90% Accurate. Fast Daily Scans. Buy&Sell Chart Signals $99Yr 30DayGntee www.MarketTrendSignal.com

You Might Like

Tom Morello Rages Against Paul Ry an

From Around the Web

Content from Sponsors What's this?

online.wsj.com/article/SB124027187331937083.html

3/5

The Worlds Richest Country A Look Inside the Feds Balance Sheet Melbourne Remains Most Liv able City Why Falling Bond Y ields Are Raising Y our Auto Insurance Premium

Economist: "I Don't Think Our Civ ilization Can Surv iv e This" (Money Morning) Economist Warns Its Going To Get Worse For The Av erage American (Moneynews) Buy or Rent? Y ou'd Be Surprised (Daily
Finance)

How Long Before TV and Internet Are Completely Merged? (Yahoo!) In Pennsy lv ania, a shipy ard is back to life due to U.S. energy dev elopment
(ExxonMobil's Perspectives)

Add a Comment

JOURNAL COMMUNITY

Com m unity rules To add a comment please

Log in

Create an Account
Your real name is required for commenting.

Track replies to my comment CLEAR POST

Editors' Picks

Did Y our Ancest or Dat e a Neandert hal?

The Panic Over Fukushima

Parking by t he Numbers

In Sy rian Village, a Sheik's Word Is Law

Why Mega-Event s May Not Mean Mega-Bucks

BACK TO TOP

Custom er Center: My Account My Subscriptions Create an Account: Register for Limited Access Subscribe to WSJ.com Subscribe to WSJ Weekend Print Edition Help & Inform ation Center: Help Customer Service Contact Us Global Support

About: Content Partnerships Reprints Advertising Place a Classified Ad Classifieds Advertise Locally Conferences About Dow Jones Privacy Policy - UPDATED 10/18/2011 Data Policy - NEW Your Ad Choices Subscriber Agreement & Terms of Use - NEW

WSJ.com : Site Map Home World U.S. New York Business Markets Market Data Tech Personal Finance Life & Culture Opinion Autos Careers

Tools & Form ats: Today's Paper Video Center Graphics Columns Blogs Topics Guides Alerts New sletters Mobile WSJ Social Tablet Edition Podcasts RSS Feeds

Digital Network
WSJ.com Marketw atch.com Barrons.com SmartMoney.com AllThingsD.com FINS: Finance, IT jobs, Sales jobs BigCharts.com Virtual Stock Exchange WSJ Radio Professor Journal WSJ U.S. Edition WSJ Asia Edition WSJ Europe Edition

online.wsj.com/article/SB124027187331937083.html

4/5

Print Subscriber Services

Copyright Policy Jobs at WSJ.com

Real Estate Small Business Student Journal Corrections SafeHouse - Send Us Information

Journal Community WSJ on Tw itter WSJ on Facebook WSJ on Foursquare WSJ on Google+ WSJ on YouTube My Journal Portfolio E-books

WSJ India Page Foreign Language Editions: WSJ Chinese WSJ Japanese WSJ Portuguese WSJ Spanish WSJ Deutschland

Copyright 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved

online.wsj.com/article/SB124027187331937083.html

5/5