Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Year 2011
neutrality transparency physician and patient choice open standards collaboration privacy
2012 2011
90,000or36%ofoffice-basedphysiciansnow 1 e-prescribe. urescriptsannouncesnetworkexpansionto S allowclinicianstoexchangealltypesofclinical messageswiththeirpeers. heU.S.DrugEnforcementAdministrationallows T theoptionofissuingprescriptionsforcontrolled medicationselectronically. atientProtectionandAffordableCareActpasses. P
RxHubbeginsnetworkoperations.
RxHubfounded. SureScriptsfounded.
introduction
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
contents
introduction TheEvolutionofE-Prescribing........................................ 1 AletterfromthePresidentandCEO................................... 2 ExecutiveSummary .................................................. 4 E-PrescribergrowthintheU.S.20082011 .............................. 6 part 1: electronic prescribing use TheThreeComponentsofE-Prescribing ................................ 8 ImpactofE-Prescribing:MedicationAdherence .......................... 9 PrescriptionBenefitInformation .......................................10 ThevalueofPrescriptionBenefitInformation............................11 MedicationHistory ...................................................12 PrescriptionRouting .................................................13 HowtoImproveUseofPrescriptionRenewals...........................14 EHRvs.StandaloneE-PrescribingSoftware .............................15 CollaborationDrivesQualityImprovements.............................16 FutureofE-Prescribing..............................................17 part 2: electronic prescribing adoption TheClassof2008:TrackingthegrowthofMeaningfulUse.................18 Prescribers........................................................ 20 E-PrescribingPhysiciansbySpecialty..................................21 E-PrescribingPhysiciansbyPracticeSize .............................. 22 PharmaciesCommunityandMailOrder.............................. 23 Payers............................................................ 24 part 3: about surescripts AboutSurescripts................................................. ibc Acknowledgments................................................. ibc
introduction
Executive summary
national progress report Year 2011 at-a-glance Thisreportprovideshealthcareindustrystakeholderswithauniqueviewofe-prescribingintheUnitedStates.The reportgoesbeyondtheremarkablesustainedgrowthseenin2011totellacompellingstory,throughgraphicsand analyticaldataaboutthestillgreatpotentialofe-prescribingandcollaborativecareforpharmacies,prescribers, pharmacybenefitmanagers(PBMs)andotherhealthcarestakeholders.
more than one in two office-based physicians e-prescribed in 2011, up from one in ten in 2008 E-Prescribing entered the mainstream of health care technologyintheUnitedStateswith317,000office-based physicians, or 58 percent, now actively e-prescribing (Figure 1).Bytheendof2011,morethanoneintwoofficebased physicians used e-prescribing, versus one in ten threeyearsago.
75%
NewPrescriptions PrescriptionRenewalResponses
570 million prescriptions were routed electronically By the end of 2011, an estimated 36 percent of prescriptions dispensed were routed electronically, up from 22 percent at the end of 2010. More than 570 million were routed electronically in 2011, versus 326 million in 2010. This represents a 75 percent increase in just one years time(Figure 2).
2010
Figure 2: PrescriptionRoutingUse20102011
74,000 80 76% 156,000 134 Before e-prescribing 234,000 196
2011
With e-prescribing
Numberpickedupoutof100 writtenprescriptions
Abandoned
10%
INCREASE
Abandoned
Pickedup
Abandoned
e-prescribing is Helping to improve First Fill medication adherence. savings are estimated up to $240 billion over 10 Years Surescripts collaborated with pharmacies and pharmacy benefit managers on a study comparing electronic prescriptions with paper, phoned and faxed prescriptions. The data showed a consistent 10 percent increase in patient first fill medication adherence among physicians who adopted e-prescribing technology (Figure 3). One findingwasthattheimprovedmedicationadherencefrom e-prescriptions can lead to 10-year estimated savings of between $140 billion to $240 billion, measured in health carecostsavingsandimprovedhealthoutcomes.
Figure 3: E-PrescribingIncreasesFirstFillMedicationAdherence
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
Total High and lowest meaningful use estimates by specialty (Highest) Family practitioner (lowest) ophthalmologist eHr vs. standalone e-prescribing eHr standalone e-prescribing
39,893
12,416 1,082
69%to74% 27%to27%
close to 60 percent of physicians who started e-prescribing in 2008 meet the stage 1 meaningful use e-prescribing measure. 38 percent would meet the proposed stage 2 e-prescribing measure Surescripts analysis of 39,893 prescribers who began e-prescribingin2008showsanestimated54to60percent of active early e-prescribers would have satisfied the stage1meaningfulusemeasurefore-prescribingbythe end of 2011. The second finding from this data set indicatesthat38percentoftheseearlyuserswouldmeetthe proposedstage2meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasure.* This analysis also showed that physicians use of e-prescribingincreasesovertime. Eightypercentofphysicianswhoadoptede-prescribingin 2008 used an integrated electronic health record (EHR). The data showed that prescribers using EHRs had significantly higher utilization levels (+53 percent) than prescribersusingstandalonee-prescribingsystems.
31,902 6,976
60%to67% 44%to50%
Figure 4: MeaningfulUsebySpecialty,Classof2008
Internist
Internist
Internist
Internist
* eferencestomeetingthestage1meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasureorthestage2meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasure,asproposedbutnotcurrentlyineffect, R alsoassumethattheusermettherequirementforparticipatingasaneligibleprovider.
e-prescribinge-prescribing
45% 45%
e-prescribinge-prescribing
81% 81%
E-Prescribing Adoption Rates Register Significant Growth by Physician Specialty and Practice Size
Family Practice Family Practice Family Practice Family Practice
Solo Solo Solo Solo
e-prescribinge-prescribing
Internist
Internist Internist Internist Family practice physicians and cardiovascular disease physicians were e-prescribers
e-prescribinge-prescribing
Solo
the three smallest practice sizes led 31% 31% e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribing adoption in 2011 Solo Solo Solo
e-prescribinge-prescribing
45% 45%
2010
e-prescribinge-prescribing
81% 81%
2011
specialty Internist
Solo 2 to 5
e-prescribinge-prescribing
31% 31%
2010
Solo 2 to 5
e-prescribinge-prescribing
internist
Family Practice Family Practice
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
+80%
Family Practice Family Practice
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
solo practitioner
2 to 5 2 to 5
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
31% 31% 42% 42% 42% 42% 42% 42% 44% 44% 44% 44% 44% 44%
+48%
2 to 5 2 to 5
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
46% 46% 53% 53% 53% 53% 53% 53% 55% 55% 55% 55% 55% 55% 46% 46% 46% 46%
FamilY practice
Family Practice Family Practice Cardiovascular Cardiovascular
e-prescribinge-prescribing
+59%
Family Practice Family Practice Cardiovascular Cardiovascular
e-prescribinge-prescribing
2 to 5
2 to 5 6 to 10 2 to 5 6 to 10
e-prescribinge-prescribing
+26%
2 to 5 6 to 10
2 to 5 6 to 10
e-prescribinge-prescribing
cardioVascular disease
Gastroenterology Gastroenterology
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
+55%
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
6 to 10
6 to 10 6 to 10
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
Gastroenterology Gastroenterology
+25%
6 to 10 6 to 10 11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing
6 to 10
e-prescribinge-prescribing
Figure 5: E-PrescribingAdoptionbySpecialty*
e-prescribinge-prescribing
38% 38%
e-prescribinge-prescribing
76% 76%
Figure 6: 2011E-PrescribingAdoptionbyPracticegroupSize**
6 to 10 11 to 25 6 to 10 11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing
6 to 10 11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing
Gastroenterology Gastroenterology
Gastroenterology Gastroenterology
e-prescribinge-prescribing *Samplesizeis314,616,whichrepresents99%ofallactiveoffice-basedphysicians. 34% 34% e-prescribinge-prescribing **Estimatedbasedonsampleanalysisof292,658or92%ofallactiveoffice-basedphysiciansovertheSurescriptsnetworkasofDecember2011. to 25 38% 38% 76% 76% 11 to 25 11 to 25 11
e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing
Cardiovascular Cardiovascular
Cardiovascular Cardiovascular
e-prescribinge-prescribing
49% 49%
e-prescribinge-prescribing
76% 76%
11 to 25 26 to 100
11 to 25 26 to 100
e-prescribinge-prescribing
34% 34%
11 to 25 26 to 100
11 to 25 26 to 100
e-prescribinge-prescribing
introduction
2008
2009
2010
physicians e-prescribe
1 in 10
1 in 4
physicians e-prescribe
1 in 3
physicians e-prescribe
2008
he Centers for Medicare and Medicaid T Services (CMS) issues Medicare Part D e-prescribingincentiveregulations. he Drug Enforcement Administration T (DEA)proposesruleallowinge-prescribing forcontrolledsubstances. edicare Improvements for Patients and M Providers Act (MIPPA) passes; includes e-prescribingincentives. xHub and Surescripts merge to form R Surescripts-RxHub.
2009
mericanRecoveryandReinvestmentAct A provides$19billiontopromotetheadoptionofhealthinformationtechnology. MS releases proposed regulations C defining meaningful use of electronic health records (EHRs). E-prescribing is a keycomponent. edicare launches MIPPA e-prescribing M incentiveprogram. hodeIslandannounces100percentofits R pharmaciesareenabledfore-prescribing. urescripts-RxHub is re-launched as S Surescripts.
2010
90,000or 36%of office-based physi1 cianse-prescribe. urescriptsannouncesnetworkexpansion S toallowclinicianstoexchangealltypesof clinicalmessageswiththeirpeers. heDEAallowstheoptionofissuingpreT scriptions for controlled medications electronically. atient Protection and Affordable Care P Actpasses.
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
more than 1 in 2
physicians e-prescribe
2011
urescriptsannounces58%ofalloffice-basedphysicianse-prescribe. S 6,900+pharmaciesnowconnectedtotheSurescriptsnetwork. 5 fficeoftheNationalCoordinator(ONC)announcesproposedcriteriaforMeaningfulUseStage2. O NCannounces123,921EligibleProfessionalshaveregisteredforEHRincentives. O
medication HistorY
Ambulatory&Acute
beneFit inFormation
PrescriptionBenefitforAmbulatory; EligibilityServicesforPharmacy andMedicaid
electronic routing
ProcessNewPrescriptions andRenewals
Healthcareprovidersandprescriberscanaccessallthreecomponentsofe-prescribing throughvendorcertifiedsoftwareontheSurescriptsnetwork.
8
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
With e-prescribing
Numberpickedupoutof100writtenprescriptions
Abandoned
10%
INCREASE
Abandoned
Pickedup
Abandoned
E-Prescribing should be considered a powerful tool in the health care systems efforts to address medication adherenceandimprovepatientoutcomes. Ken majkowski, pharmd,
vicePresidentofStrategyandInnovation Surescripts
$140$240B
william H. shrank, md, msHs
SpecialistinMedicationAdherence HarvardMedicalSchool
Inhealthcaresavingsoverthenext 10yearsduetoe-prescribing
The Surescripts research is an important contribution...In a huge study, they have shown a clear link between e-prescribingandfirstfillmedicationadherence.
* 2011 study found that every dollar spent on improving patient adherence to medication can result in three to ten dollars of savings from reduced downstream medical costs for A certaindiseases. 9
KeY statistics lectronicresponsesforprescriptionbenefitinformaE tiongrew87percentin2011. n average, the response rate to requests for preO scriptionbenefit(therateatwhichinformationforthe patientcanbereturnedtotheprescriber)wasapprox pproximately 62 percent* of patient visits involved A imately80percentin2011,upfrom69percentin2010. oneormoreoftheseresponsesin2011.
125%
422 million
248%
188 million 54 million
2008
Contributing Factors:
Active Prescribers (pg. 20) Number of E-Prescribing Applications Certified for this Service (pg. 15) 74,000 43 156,000 78 234,000 137 390,000 157
2009
2010
2011
10
* ccordingtotheAugust2010NationalAmbulatoryMedicalCareSummary,anestimated1.037billionvisitsweremadetooffice-basedphysiciansin2010(datarelated2011). A
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
patient encounter
q re
t ue s
o sp
for
n
p atie
o se t
est f requ
or inf or mation
r&
s ent
pha
hy s
rm
to p
ac
re
ici
an
1 2
pHYsician
DrugTherapyDecisionMade ReviewsBenefitandSelectsTherapy E-Prescriptiongenerated
pbm/paYer
provides patient:
PrescriptionBenefit PrescriptionHistory
4
pHarmacY
6
pre
pre s
cr ip tion
r o u te d to p h a r
mac
s cr ip
tion ren
ew al and reque s t r
e spo
nse
benefit information enables: Accurateprescriptionsforeligibledrugtherapies Improvedpatientsafety Potentiallylowerco-paysforpatientsresultinginimprovedadherence IncreasedefficienciesforPBMs,pharmaciesandprescribers Improveddrugspendmanagementforpayers Nearly253millioncovered-livesareconnectedthroughPBMs,payersandstateMedicaidagenciesontheSurescriptsnetwork whichisopentoallpharmacies,payersandhealthcareparticipants.Patientscanhavemultipleprescriptioncoverage. Therewere789millioneligibilityresponsesin2011ontheSurescriptsnetwork.Thesebehindthesceneselectronicconnections toprescriptionbenefitinformationadduptoamorecomprehensivelevelofcarefromprescribertopharmacy.PBMsandpayers gain from the strong compliance generated when benefit information is used. Benefit information also helps create positive outcomesanddecreasehealthcarecosts.Thatshowe-prescribingcandrivedownthecostcurve.
11
MEDiCaTion HisTorY Was aVailaBlE For onE in THrEE oFFiCE VisiTs in 2011
KeY statistics I lectronic medication history deliveries increased 72 n 2011, more than 15 million medication histories E were delivered to clinicians working in acute care percentin2011. environmentstosupporttransitionsincare. pproximately 31 percent of patient visits generated A anelectronicallydeliveredmedicationhistoryin2011.
600
72%
500 400 300 200 100
395 million
184%
230 million
395%
81 million
0
2009
156,000 76
16 million
2008
Contributing Factors:
Active Prescribers (pg. 20) Number of E-Prescribing Applications Certified for this Service (pg. 15) 74,000 42
2010
234,000 133
2011
390,000 154
* orinformationonSurescriptshandlingofpersonalhealthinformation,pleasereviewourPrivacyPolicyonhttp://www.surescripts.com/about-us/commitment-to-privacy.aspx. F 12
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
prescription routing
Prescribers are e-prescribing in record numbers. In 2011, e-prescription routing on the Surescripts network increased75percentto570million.Morephysiciansare exchanging prescription information electronically and bi-directionally with pharmacies using vendor software certifiedbySurescripts.
MorE THan 570 Million prEsCripTions WErE ElECTroniCallY roUTED in 2011, a 75 pErCEnT inCrEasE oVEr 2010
KeY statistics y the end of 2011, an estimated 36 percent* of pre- orethan570millionprescriptionswereroutedelecB M scriptions dispensed were routed electronically, up tronicallyin2011versus326millionin2010,a75perfrom22percentattheendof2010. centincrease.** fthese,approximately24millionelectronicprescripO tionswereroutedtomailorderpharmaciesin2011,a three-foldincreaseover2010.
75%
96 million 474 million
2009
2010
2011
13
prescribers
take advantage of the efficiency of electronic prescription renewal requests. Efficiency is a key benefit of e-prescribing connectivity, which significantly reduces the number of faxes and phone calls pharmacies needtomake. respond to electronic renewal authorization requests promptly. Prescribersshouldrespondtorenewalrequests within 24 hours. In an emergency, a follow-up call in the event of a delayed response is appropriate.
pHarmacies
report issues with electronic renewals or e-prescriptions to your pharmacy software vendor. Provide the following details when reporting errors: transaction date, name of prescriber, messageID,prescriberSPI,pharmacyNCPDPID. ensure that information in your pharmacy system about local prescribers is up-to-date.
Pharmacy software vendor should keep prescriber files up-to-date as new prescribers become activated for e-prescribing. Store-bystore data updates in each store should be consistent.
14
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
KeY statistics ighty-twopercentofactiveprescribersusedEHRsfor ome standalone e-prescribing software vendors E S e-prescribingin2011,comparedto79percentin2010. license the use of their products to companies that provide EHRs. At the end of 2011, 228 EHRs used or t y-seven percent of cer tified and deployed F embedded standalone e-prescribing software that EHR software was used for all three ambulatory was certified for connection to the Surescripts nete-prescribing servicesprescription benefit inforwork,comparedto148EHRsin2010. mation, medication history and electronic routing attheendof2011.*
40 264
35 22 28
0
22 27 110
20 40
161 25
60
132
135
20 127
80 100
105
95
2010
2011
2010
2011
2010
2011
2010
2011
Medication History
Prescription Benefit
Prescription Routing
* ertificationforallthreee-prescribingservicesiscomprehensiveofcertificationforprescriptionbenefitinformation,medicationhistoryandelectronicroutingservices.Routing C servicesincludeconnectivitytoretailandmailorderpharmaciesandtheabilitytomanageprescriptionrenewalselectronically. 15
QualitY tip 2: most drug descriptions should typically include the complete drug name, strength, strength units and dosage form (if applicable). In the United States, lovastatin is commercially available in three strengths.Prescribersshouldidentifytheproperstrength. e.g.:lovastatin40mgtablet
10
20
40
QualitY tip 3: Quantity qualifiers must be correctly associated with drug descriptions. where possible, quantity along with the quantity qualifier should reflect the actual metric quantity. example of improper use: Amoxicillin 250mg/5ml, 1 EA. In this case,thepharmacistdoesnotknowwhetherprescribermeant1fluid ounce or 1 bottle. Even if the prescriber meant a bottle, sending a nonmetricqualifiermightstillresultinconfusionbecauseAmoxicillin 250mg/5mloralsuspensioncomesinthreebottlesizes:80,100and 150ml.UseinsteadAmoxicillin250mg/5ml,150ml. ThecorrectQuantityQualifiermakesitclearthat the prescriber wants the pharmacy to dispense 150mlbottle: use amoxicillin 250mg/5ml, 150 ml
Surescripts clinical quality program team of pharmacists, pharmacy technicians, prescribers, technologists, and Six Sigma BlackBelts(TrainedQualityleaders)arefullyengagedinqualityimprovementsthatincludeincreasingefficiency,valueand theuserexperience.
For more information about surescripts efforts to raise industry quality, contact the surescripts Quality office (quality@surescripts.com) and visit our blog at www.surescripts.com/eprescribingquality.
16
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
Future of E-prescribing
E-PrescribinggrowthDrivesIndustryCollaborationonNewStandardsandCapabilities
Surescriptshasbeencollaboratingwiththenationspharmacies,PBMs,prescriberandpharmacytechnologyvendors, andgroupsinvolvedincreatingindustrystandardsonimprovementsandinnovationsthatwilldrivethefutureofe-prescribing.wearecommittedtoexpandingsupportforandenablingelectronicexchangeofalltypesofclinicalinformation.
InSeptember2011,SurescriptsbegantheinitialdeploymentofEPCSinstateswhereEPCSislegal.Progresswillbedrivenby anindustry-widecollaborationbetweenpharmacies,technologyvendors,pharmacybenefitmanagers,Surescriptsandother networkstoplanandimplementsupportforU.S.DrugEnforcementAdministrationandstatepharmacyboardrules. TosupportthedeploymentofEPCS,networkparticipantsmustadheretomajorDEArequirements: prescribers must: Useane-prescribingapplicationthatisauditedandcertifiedforthispurpose. Completeacompliantidentity-proofingprocess. Useasecure,two-factorauthenticationprocesstosigne-prescriptionsforcontrolledsubstances. software vendors and pharmacies that have developed their own software systems must: ompleteSurescriptscertificationandDEA-requiredthird-partyauditsbeforeconnectingtotheSurescriptsnetworkforEPCS. C pharmacies must: ApplyupdatestotheirsoftwaresystemstoensureDEAandSurescriptsNCPDPSCRIPTadherenceforEPCS.
Electronic prior authorization (ePA) is viewed as a way to address the need for prescribers to obtain approval for prescriptions that are subject to closed formulary, step-therapy regimen, off-label use or other plan benefit parameters and eliminate the inefficiencies of paper-based prior authorization processes (PA) that create significant administrative burdens forprescribersandpharmacies. In October 2011 the National Council for Prescription Drug Programs (NCPDP) reactivated its Prior Authorization workflow-to-Transactions Task group. In addition, industry pilots were initiatedandcollaborationthroughNCPDPcontinues to date. Humana, Agadia, CvS/Caremark, Surescripts, CoverMyMeds, McKesson and Ibeza are reviewing draft standards, collaborating on enhancements, and should soon produceanePAstandardthatwillbeusefultoall.
Collaboration on Standardized Procedures and Proper Use of ePA Needed for all Stakeholders
Provider
Standardizedproceduresforrequesting PA.Implementation areneeded.
Pharmacy
Standardizedinformationandimplementationguidelinesare neededforconsistent communications.
Payers
ModifiedPA processing;Minimize frequencyof unnecessaryPA.
Theabilitytocommunicateelectronicallytootherhealthcareprovidersbetween(orwithout)EHRs,andacrossregionalnetworks and health systems means that health care providers can exchange clinical information more quickly and efficiently whileimprovingpatientcare.Clinicalinteroperabilitysolutionshelpbyallowingphysiciansandotherhealthcareprovidersto securelysendandreceiveclinicalinformationelectronicallywithpeerslocally,regionallyandnationally.Surescriptsandmany otherorganizationshavecollaboratedwiththefederalgovernmenttocreatethestandardprotocolsneededtomakethistype ofelectronicclinicalcommunicationpossible.TheSurescriptsnetworksupportsallfederalandstatepoliciesandstandards forhealthinformationexchange,includingprivacyandsecuritystandards(suchasHIPAAandstatelaw),technologyinteroperabilitystandards(suchasDirect)andmessagetypes(suchasHl7).
17
summarY Arecentanalysisofacohortofphysicianswhoadoptedandbeganusinge-prescribingin2008producedfourfindings.Summaryoffindings:1)Estimatesshow thatthemajority,asmuchas60%,ofthoseprescribershavesuccessfullymetthe stage 1 meaningful use e-prescribing measure*; 2) 38 percent of these early userswouldmeettheproposedstage2meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasure* if it were now in effect; 3) physicians use of e-prescribing increases over time (see Figure 2) 4) that e-prescribing was utilized at a higher rate by prescribers whousedEHRsoftwarecomparedtostandalonesoftwareusers. bacKground Inordertospurwidespreadadoptionofcertifiedelectronichealthrecord(EHR) technology,thefederalgovernmentthroughtheHealthInformationTechnology for Economic and Clinical Health Act (HITECH)is providing up to $30 billion in incentives for prescriber adoption and meaningful use of certified EHR technology. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) is responsible for administering the EHR incentive program and developing objectives and measurementcriteriathateligibleprovidersmustmeetinordertoqualifyforanEHR incentivepayment(s). E-Prescribingisoneofthecoreobjectivesforstage1ofmeaningfuluse,which requiresmorethan40percentofaneligibleprovidersprescriptionstoberouted electronically. Todate,CMShasmadecloseto$4billioninpaymentstoeligibleprovidersand hospitalsthathavemetthemeaningfulusemeasureofcertifiedEHRtechnology. CMSisprovidingreportinginatransparentmanneronpaymentsmade,towhom, andwhichEHRvendorstheyuse. metHods SurescriptsanalyzedprescriberadoptionandutilizationdatafromtheSurescripts network.PrescriberdemographicdatawasmatchedtoSK&Aprescriberdatain order to segment by specialty and practice size. we used aggregate IMS Health data about prescriber volume to create models of estimated average total prescriptionvolumeperprescriberbyspecialtyandmatchedthattoourlistofprescribers.Thedatashowedacountof48,993prescriberswhoadoptedandbegan using e-prescribing between January 1, 2008 and December 31, 2008. The data was further segmented by e-prescribing system (EHR versus standalone) and specialtytypefor39,798activee-prescribers(Figure1).Prescriberspracticedin 50statesandninedistrictsandU.S.territories.Modelsweredevelopedtoanalyzeactivee-prescribersuseandthenumberofearlye-prescriberswhowould havemetthestage1meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasureandproposedstage 2measure(notineffect)byfourthquarter2011. results ByDecember2008,Surescriptsestimatesthatbetween6,927and8,129prescribers (17.4 percent to 20.4 percent of active e-prescribers) met the more than 40
Q1 2008 Q2 2008 Q3 2008 Q4 2008 Q1 2009 Q2 2009 Q3 2009 Q4 2009 Q1 2010 Q2 2010 Q3 2010 Q4 2010 Q1 2011 Q2 2011 Q3 2011 Q4 2011
49 78 82 94 125 132 139 153 160 160 163 178 198 197 200 213
18
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
ESTIMATED PERCENT OF EARLY USERS OF E-PRESCRIBING BY PHYSICIAN SPECIALTY WHO HAVE SUCCESSFULLY MET THE STAGE 1 MEANINGFUL USE E-PRESCRIBING MEASURE
specialty Family practitioner internist pediatrician general practitioner cardiovascular disease obstetrician/gynecologist ophthalmologist psychiatrist gastroenterologist obstetrician/gynecologist other eHr vs. standalone e-prescribing eHr standalone e-prescribing 31,902 6,976 222 144 60%to67% 44%to50% number of prescribers 12,416 6,474 2,627 2,293 1,994 1,453 1,082 822 771 762 9,104 average utilization
(monthly)
69%to74% 67%to72% 55%to67% 33%to43% 58%to70% 59%to70% 27%to27% 38%to45% 38%to54% 51%to59% 33%to36%
Figure 3: EstimatedStage1MeaningfulUseE-PrescribingMeasureMetbyEarlyUsersfrom2008*
percent stage 1 meaningful use program measure. By December 2011, these numbers increased to 21,392 to 23,877prescribers(53.8percentto60.0percentofactivee-prescribers),Figure3.Themodelsalsosuggestthat 15,146prescribers(38.1percent)wouldhavealreadymettheproposed65percentthresholdintheproposedstage 2meaningfulusemeasure(notcurrentlyineffect). Theresultsalsofoundthate-prescriptionsperactivee-prescriberincreasedovertime.Infirstquarter2008,they wereanaverageof49permonth.Byfourthquarter2011,theyhadreachedanaverageof213permonth. Familypractitionersdemonstratedthehighestindividualutilizationlevelswith316e-prescriptionspermonth.They alsoappearedtohavethehighestlevelofsuccessfullymeetingthestage1meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasure ofanyspecialtywithanestimatedspecialtyutilizationrateof69percentto74percent.Theywerefollowedbyinternistsat303e-prescriptionspermonthandaspecialtyutilizationrateof67percentto72percent(Figure3). Themajorityofprescribers(80.2percent)whoadoptedandbeganusinge-prescribingin2008didsousinganintegratedEHRsoftwaresystem.ThedataindicatesthatphysiciansusingEHRsoftwarehadsignificantlyhighere-prescriptionutilizationlevels(+53percent)thanprescribersusingstandalonee-prescribingsystems.Upto67percent ofthee-prescribingphysiciansusinganEHRweremorelikelytomeetthestage1meaningfulusee-prescribing measureversusanestimated44percentto50percentofe-prescribersusingstandalonee-prescribingsystems. discussion Therequirementsforstage1meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasurehavebeenwidelycommentedonanddebated by healthcare stakeholders, as they have significant implications in terms of provider adoption, use, and reimbursement.TheEHRincentiveprogramisaprimarymechanismthegovernmentisusingtoinfluencetheuseof healthinformationtechnologytoimprovehealthcareoutcomesandlowercosts. Thisanalysisofadoptionandusedatasuggeststhatamajorityofproviders*whobegane-prescribingin2008(54 percentto60percent)areinapositiontomeetthestage1meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasurewhile38percent ofthisgroupwouldmeetproposedstage2meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasure.
* eferencestomeetingstage1meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasureorstage2meaningfulusee-prescribingmeasure,asproposedbutnotcurrentlyineffect,alsoassumethatthe R usermettherequirementforparticipatingasaneligibleprovider. 19
KeY statistics y the end of 2011, 390,000 prescribers routed pre- fthese390,000prescribers,317,000werephysicians. B O scriptionselectronically,upfrom234,000attheendof urescripts estimates that approximately 58 percent S 2010. This represents about 54 percent of all officeof active office-based doctors nationwide are basedprescribers.* e-prescribing.
50%
234,000
109%
156,000 74,000
2008
Contributing Factors:
% of Active Prescribers Using EHR (pg. 15) 63%
2009
70%
2010
79%
2011
82%
* ased on total count of 718,193 office-based prescribers, per SK&A data. Surescripts counts of active e-prescribers represent those that used ambulatory prescription routing B serviceswithinthelast30daysof2011.Asmallproportionoftheseprescribershavebeenregisteredbyhospitalsandotherorganizationsthatdobothambulatoryandacutecare. 20
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
top three specialty groups have e-prescribing47% 47% adoption and use rates at or above 75 percent. 75% 75%
Internists, family practitioners and cardiovascular disease specialists have adopted e-prescribing at the highest Internist Internist Internist Internist ratesin2011.Elevendifferentspecialtieshaveachievedadoptionratesof60percentormore. specialties with Highest rates of e-prescribing adoption e-prescribinge-prescribing
specialty
Internist Internist Gastroenterology Gastroenterology
e-prescribinge-prescribing
45% 45%
2010
e-prescribinge-prescribing
81% 81%
2011
internist
Family Practice Family Practice
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
+80%
Family Practice Family Practice
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
FamilY practice
Family Practice Family Practice Cardiovascular Cardiovascular
e-prescribinge-prescribing
+59%
Family Practice Family Practice Cardiovascular Cardiovascular
e-prescribinge-prescribing
cardioVascular disease
Gastroenterology Gastroenterology
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
+55%
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
Gastroenterology Gastroenterology
Specialty Group
dentist/oral surgeon dermatologist endocrinology & metabolism Gastroenterology Gastroenterology gastroenterology general practitioner general surgeon nephrologist neurologist Cardiovascular Cardiovascular non-alleo/osteopaths obstetrician/gynecologist oncologist/Hematologist optometrist/ophthalmologist orthopedic surgeon other pediatrics Cardiovascular Cardiovascular other specialty other surgery otolaryngologist pediatrician podiatrist psychiatrist psychologist urologist
e-prescribinge-prescribing
38% 38%
% E-Prescribing in 2011
44 62 78 Gastroenterology Gastroenterology 69 43 36 67 57 Cardiovascular Cardiovascular 39 52 58 67 43 43 Cardiovascular Cardiovascular 34 31 61 59 55 35 68 68
e-prescribinge-prescribing
76% 76%
e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
49% 49%
e-prescribinge-prescribing
76% 76%
* stimatedbasedonsampleanalysisof314,616or99%ofallactiveoffice-basedphysicians. E 21
Solo 2 to 5
Solo 2 to 5
e-prescribinge-prescribing
31% 31%
Solo 2 to 5
Solo 2 to 5
e-prescribinge-prescribing
46% 46% 46% 46% 53% 53% 46% 46% 53% 53% 46% 46% 2011 53% 53% 55% 55% 46% 46% 53% 53% 55% 55% 53% 53% 55% 55% 46% 46% 53% 53% 55% 55% 46% 46% 55% 55% 46% 46% 35% 35% 55% 55% 46% 46% 35% 35% 46% 46% 35% 35% 27% 27% 46% 46% 35% 35% 27% 27% 35% 35% 27% 27% 35% 35% 27% 27%
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
42% 42% 31% 31% 42% 42% 31% 31% 2010 42% 42% 44% 44% 31% 31% 42% 42% 44% 44% 42% 42% 44% 44% 34% 34% 42% 42% 44% 44% 34% 34% 44% 44% 34% 34% 31% 31% 44% 44% 34% 34% 31% 31% 34% 34% 31% 31% 22% 22% 34% 34% 31% 31% 22% 22% 31% 31% 22% 22% 31% 31% 22% 22%
Solo 2 to 5
Solo 2 to 5
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing Physicianpracticegroupsthatrangefromsolopractitionersuptoofficeswith11to25physiciansaretheleaders Solo Solo Solo Solo intheadoptionanduseofe-prescribing.Solopractitionersincreasedtheiradoptionby48percentin2011.Practices e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing 2 to 5 2 to 5 2 to 5 2 to 5 with26to100physiciansincreasedadoptionby13percentin2011.
6 to 10
6 to 10 Solo 2 to 5 6 to 10
6 to 10
6 to 10 Solo 2 to 5 6 to 10
practice size
Solo 2 to 5
Year-to-Year Solo
2 to 5
solo practitioner
6 to 10
e-prescribinge-prescribing
2 to 5 6 to 10
2 to 5 6 to 10 11 to 25 2 to 5 6 to 10 11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
+48%
2 to 5 6 to 10
6 to 10
e-prescribinge-prescribing
2 to 5 6 to 10 11 to 25 2 to 5 6 to 10 11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
2 to 5
11 to 25 2 to 5 6 to 10 11 to 25
+26%
2 to 5 6 to 10 11 to 25
11 to 25
6 to 10
6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100 6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100 6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100
+25%
6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100
6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100 6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
11 to 25
6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100
+35%
6 to 10 11 to 25 26 to 100
e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
26 to 100
11 to 25 26 to 100 100+ 11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
+13%
26 to 100 100+ 11 to 25
11 to 25
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
100+
26 to 100 100+
+23%
100+ 26 to 100 100+
26 to 100
26 to 100 100+
26 to 100 100+
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
26 to 100 100+
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
26 to 100 100+
26 to 100 100+
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
26 to 100 100+
26 to 100 100+
e-prescribinge-prescribing e-prescribinge-prescribing
e-prescribinge-prescribing
* stimatedbasedonsampleanalysisof292,658prescribers(or92%ofallactivee-prescribersovertheSurescriptsnetworkasofDecember2011). E e-prescribinge-prescribing 22
e-prescribinge-prescribing
100+
100+
100+
100+
e-prescribinge-prescribing
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
KeY statistics T inety-one percent of community pharmacies in the hereare62,461communitypharmaciesintheUnited N States represented by both chain and independently UnitedStateswereconnectedforprescriptionrouting owned pharmacies.** Of these, about 64 percent are in2011.* chain pharmacies and 36 percent are independently orethan98percentofchainpharmaciesand79perM owned(includingthosethatarepartofbuyinggroups). centofindependentpharmacieswereconnectedtothe Surescriptsnetworkforprescriptionroutingin2011. S ixofthelargestmailorderpharmacieswereableto receiveprescriptionselectronically.***
16,000
17,600
39,600
39,300
36,000
2008
Contributing Factors:
Community Pharmacies Connected Independent Pharmacies Connected 76% 46%
2009
85% 62%
2010
91% 73%
2011
91% 79%
TWEnTY-FoUr sTaTEs sHoWED inCrEasEs in aCCEss To prEsCripTion inForMaTion in 2011 WHEn sElECTing MEDiCaTion THErapY
KeY statistics ore than 66 percent of patients in the United States M nearly 253 million member records (patient-lives) attheendof2011wereprovidedaccesstoprescription fromparticipatinghealthplans.** benefit and medication history information (on behalf n 2011, Surescripts provided access to more than I ofpayersandpharmacies).* 30,000 formulary files, including formulary status, y the end of 2011, par ticipation by payers in B coverage, co-pay and alternative medication lists e-prescribingallowedprescriberstolocateandaccess maintainedbyparticipatinghealthplans.
percentage oF patients For wHom paYers can proVide prescription beneFit and medication HistorY inFormation
91100% 8190% 71 80% 6170% 5160% NV 4150% 31-40% 21-30% CA OK AZ NM AR SC MS TX LA AL GA UT CO KS MO OR SD ID WY NE IA IL IN OH WV KY TN VA NC DC PA NJ DE MD
WA
MT
ND MN WI
MI
VT
NH ME
NY
MA RI CT
AK HI FL PR
24
WWW.SURESCRIPTS.COM
tHe national progress report on e-prescribing and interoperable HealtH care Year 2011
about surescripts
The Surescripts network supports the most comprehensive network of health care organizations in the United States. Pharmacies, payers, pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), physicians, hospitals, health information exchanges and health technology firms rely on Surescripts to securely share health information across the healthcarecontinuum. guidedbytheprinciplesofprivacy,security,neutrality,choice,transparency,collaborationandquality,Surescripts operatesthenationslargesthealthinformationnetwork.Byprovidingpatientmedicationinformationforroutine, recurring and emergency care, Surescripts is committed to saving lives, improving efficiency and reducing the costofhealthcare. Formoreinformation,gotowww.Surescripts.comandfollowusattwitter.com/Surescripts.
acknowledgements
SurescriptswouldliketothankCircleSquareInc.,theNationalAssociationofChainDrugStoresEconomicsDepartmentandSK&Afortheirexpertiseandsignificantcontributionstothe2011ProgressReportonE-Prescribing. For more information about surescripts, visit www.surescripts.com and follow us at twitter.com/surescripts.
www.surescripts.com
FOllOwUSONTwITTERATTwITTER.COM/SURESCRIPTS