Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract
Strapped between 20th century that’s marked with permanently engraved suffering, and
globally oriented 21st century, BiH continues to evolve. Throughout its recent history, Bosnia
went through one-party, unitary system as part of the SFRY, trubulent war, post Dayton state
of independency, up to its current status of economic, political and ideological transition –
not an ideal market for private business growth. In order the combat this situation, a vigorous
and dynamic economic injection is needed which will drive Bosnia toward economic
prosperity, political stability, and ultimately ease the process of European integration. One
way to support and encourage a sustainable economy is through SME sector, particularly,
through franchise model. More specifically, for start up businesses, franchises can be viewed
as an available instrument for encouraging, developing and nurturing entrepreneurial talent,
promoting corporate governance and transparency, as well as attracting foreign investment
resources and competencies – both tangible and intangible, to the country in transition. This
paper is aimed at analyzing and proving that investments through franchising model are an
excellent way of encouraging a sustainable regional economic development and can serve as
a mean of promoting and strengthening home country SME sector, with focus on BiH as a
country in transition within SEE.
Keywords
SME creation, franchising business, sustainable economic development
1. Short History and Current State of Bosnia and Herzegovina
1.1 Short History of Bosnia and Herzegovina
Bosnia and Herzegovina is a country with a very complex and turbulent past that continues to
evolve. Throughout its recent history, Bosnia went through unitary system as part of the
SFRY, four years of devestating war, post Dayton state of independency proposing quite
dysfunctional system of municipalities, cantons, two entities, one district and a distant central
government, up to its current status – which can perhaps best be described as transitional, with
constant atempts to regenerate its inert economy and move toward the European integration.
There is quite a consensus when it comes to admitting the importance that SME have in post
war economy reconstruction, and so is the case in BiH. They play a crucial part in stimulating
growth, generating employment, and contributing to capital generation and poverty
alleviation. One way to encourage the SME growth is through the franchise model.
Specifically, using franchisers as an alternative growth pattern can significantly enhance SME
sector creation and sustainability.
The word ―franchise comes from the Norman French word "fraunchise," which was derived
from the French word "frank" – free man, free to work something.2 The English word
"franchise" originally was used to describe liberation from any prohibition, permission, or
privilege – by which a company is allowed to do or not to do something for which it would
normally not have rights. Franchising, described as “granting or licensing of specific
intellectual property rights by one agent (franchisor) to another agent (franchisee)”3 provides
access to tangible and intangible benefits and privileges. As such venture, it is a business
strategy between business partners acting in symbiotic and complimentary relationship,
designed to maximize profits through increasing market share and minimizes risks to its
participants. In its recent decades, franchise model has shown a remarkable resilience and
continuity throughout the economic ups and downs – which is why it becomes an interesting
part of the economic development strategy for the countries in transition, BiH being a perfect
example. At the very root of the franchising concept lies the method of interlacing the
1
Shilling, S., (2003)
2 The Random House Dictionary of English Language, (1973)
3
Blair, R.D., Lafontaine, F., (2005)
2
franchiser's brand of products and/or services with reliable support systems and by self-
motivated franchisee owners. It is this high level of motivation, combined with a rigid
business format that has allowed franchising to thrive, even in economic recessions.
3
This affects both, the franchiser and the franchisee, and in most extreme cases might affect
world-wide reputation of the firm. This problem is usually more widespread in the
developing countries as quality control processes are not necessarily in place and work ethics
and culture may be very different from the firm’s home country.
The biggest indirect thread of the franchise model within the host country is a possibility of
building a large percentage of its economy around it. It is important to realize that although
the franchising model does imply the local ownership of the unit, it still holds the attributes of
a mechanism that makes it possible for foreign investors to exercise management and control
over host country firms and its economy. This includes various corporate governance
mechanisms that drive and maintain a particular business, where the local channels can be
excluded or marginalized. Thus, it is imperative to realize that the franchising model is not
necessarily a long-term development strategy for a country, but rather a short to medium term
strategy for a country in transition, during which the hindered economy in transition period
can build its capacities and benefit through the encouragement of the local SME sector.
“Franchising is not a gasoline but oil of economy’s engine”7: franchisers alone are not enough
to create and sustain the SME sector within the country and serve as the fuel for the country’s
economy.
Closely connected to the local economy development is the so called ‘absorption capacity’ of
the host country – BiH. In order to realize on the full benefits of a franchise model, the
inefficiencies of local market must be addressed, as the “positive effects of franchising
opportunities don’t happen automatically”10. Rather “it highly depends on local absorption
7
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
8
Nicholl, P., (2003)
9
Basic, H., Becirovic, M., Korica, S. (2006)
10
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
4
capabilities”11 and these capacities refer to socio-political and economic environment of a
host country – its existing condition of physical infrastructure, education and training resource
level, administrative and legislative framework, supporting industries and other factors
allowing for full exploitation of franchising model benefits. One of the most obvious
absorption capacities to mention is “human capital development”12, and thus, local R&D
development is necessary in order to increase competitiveness of a nation, and attract
franchisers – since “knowledge creation attracts foreign investors”13.
In addition, there are also “other favorable conditions, mostly related to market size, the levels
of urbanization, literacy and corruption and proximity to larger franchising nations”.14 Level
of urbanization and market size both have a positive correlation with the development of
franchise business. Within emerging SEE markets, the market size and urbanization factors
are certainly present (in some cases not within the single country such as BiH, but within the
region as markets are combined). Also, its proximity to larger market – larger franchise
nations of EU is significant as it introduces the regional proximity and consequently provides
exposure to number of factors that stimulate franchise development.
11
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
12
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
13
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
14
Parker, G.W., (1995)
15
BiH Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper, (2001)
5
The country has open access to European markets, which are very close to the
country and has very strong human capital.” 16
b. As a potential candidate country for EU accession, the main goal of BiH is EU
membership. BiH has started its process of negotiation to join the WTO and it
has signed all the Free Trade Agreements foreseen by the Stability Pact’s
Memorandum of Understanding on trade.
2. Financial stability
a. BiH has the most stable currency in SEE (directly linked to Euro) and the
lowest inflation rate in the region. “Stable currency and low inflation rate are
important elements for macro-economic stability and for continuous increase of
foreign investments in the country”17 and this certainly includes the franchise
business opportunities.
3. Privatization
a. Privatization process is very important for any business, including franchise
opportunities, and in BiH it has been continuously improving – especially over
the last year. State owned capital in the enterprises dealing with electricity,
public traffic, telecommunications, water supply, mining, forestry, public
media and other enterprises of strategic importance, is also being privatized
with accordance with the Law on Privatization of Enterprises and under special
Government privatization programmes. This is very interesting for the
franchise business as it expands the market areas that can be pursued.
At the same time, the overall improvement within BiH economy is certain. The extreme
poverty is not noted in BiH, while 17.8 % of population is considered to be poor18. Although
the overall economy of BiH is improving, it is important to realize is that the economy of
Sarajevo canton is growing faster then the rest of the BiH territory and is responsible for large
percentage of these positive statistics. One of the indicators of economic power in Sarajevo is
the fact that Sarajevo Stock Exchange measured 283,923,277Euros in 2005 (more then
doubling in value from 2004) while the second largest Bosnian stock exchange – Banja Luka
Stock Exchange measured 142.194.184Euros – half the value of the one in Sarajevo19.
3.3 The Effect of Franchises on the Transition Economies: OBI Case Study
In order to better understand the impact that franchise business can have on the local
economy, concrete results from an actual example of the franchise company that operates in
BiH were researched: OBI – a “Do It Yourself” home improvement company that originated
in 1970 in the Alstertal Shopping Centre in Hamburg Poppenbuettel.
16
Reinnerman, D., (2005)
17
Kozaric, K., (2006)
18
Preliminary report on poverty in BiH, (2001)
19
Basic, H., Becirovic, M., Korica, S. (2006)
6
by means of which the franchisor frees them from a large number of administrative tasks, and
offers them the advantages of bulk purchases as well as the opportunities of large-scale
advertising campaigns under a well-known brand name.
Perhaps the most important benefit of the franchise model is that each store opened up
remains in the hands of independent entrepreneurs situated in the local context, who can react
to the specific regional and local market forces. For the customers, this means a favorable
price / performance ratio and considerably more intensive service – because of the brand
name standards and continued support. “All business is local”20 principle has been the
success factor for the rapid growth of OBI: growth as a group of companies, rather then trying
to grow centrally.
20
OBI Web Site, (2005)
21
Avdagic, E., (2006)
22
Nabel, Schulze, Wessels, (2001)
23
Avdagic, E., (2006)
7
opened up in Sarajevo are connected to the main centrally controlled centre where all the
requests and transactions are registered, and where the main supporting statistics are produced
that are shared back with the OBI stores. With these refined statistics, the strategic
development planning for each store is crystallized – through round tables with local owners
and OBI headquarters.
8
association would provide accurate information about BiH market capacity and its economic
power: supply most recent information on the business climate, and micro and macro
economic indicators, legal updates in the relevant fields etc. To do this successfully, the ‘one
stop shop’ franchise center must have access and continue developing marketing channels for
both – internal (franchisees) and external (franchisers) investors involved, and constant focus
on improving the international image of BiH and acting as a match-making organization i.e.
providing match-making services between interested entrepreneurs in BiH and potential
external franchisers.
Looking ahead, such franchise center can serve as a more compact and all-encompassing
organization, which will extend its services – further capitalizing on the idea of a ‘one-stop
shop’. Consequently, it can offer various consulting services for the first time franchise
owners that need specific pointers on how to own and run a business. Providing practical
assistance related to the establishment of business in BiH, and drawing the right correlation to
already existing government and non-government institutions is beneficial. This is closely
connected with the idea of fostering the learning culture and economy, as well as overall
improvement of the favorable business environment, which is something that can help greatly
and make quite a difference for the developing country without abundance of resources. By
addressing these concerns, this ‘one stop shop’ can serve its overarching purpose –
improvement of local economics, and with it, bettering of living conditions and improved
standard of living including social and environmental richness.
5. Conclusion
Perhaps the best way to summarize the idea of international business and its impacts is by
quoting Bernard Shaw “wise man adjusts to the world, unwise tries to change the world
according to his ideas”24. It is evident that the globalization is a fact in today’s world, and
thus “adjusting is the rule of the day”25. Therefore, the question is not weather to adjust to
globalization or not, but “how to adjust”26?! “Design a strategy and unlock internal resources
in order to enhance and keep competitiveness.”27 One of the possible strategies is the
franchise model. With SME market being acknowledged worldwide as a powerful economic
sector that enhances economic growth, decreases unemployment, and generally elevates
poverty, franchise model is an excellent way to better the success of SME sector
establishment in the transition countries such as BiH. Due to the economic, political and
social environment within BiH, the franchising model becomes particularly attractive as it
offers favorable starting conditions for countries that lack specific skills and know how for
establishing and running a business; it offers starting point and guidance in a country where
people do not know where to start and are afraid of having a sole responsibility for running a
business.
For BiH, the inevitable strategic, political, economic, administrative and legal change are an
anticipated reality – though it can not be forced. It is now at a turning point of its existence.
Political and administrative reforms are indeed necessary for country’s prosperity and
inclusion to EU; however these same reforms require political negotiations that often seem as
an endless, vicious circle where the average citizen does not feel the benefits. Nonetheless,
BiH is hungry for new vigor that would boost up its inert and administratively complicated
economy and inject energy in its people; franchising opportunities can help, serving as a
24
Shaw, B. (1999)
25
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
26
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
27
Svetlicic, M., (2006)
9
catalyzer for administrative and legal resolution, pushing the country toward a solidified
political and economic environment. The basic preconditions for the success of the franchise
model exist within Bosnia, especially within Sarajevo region, and can serve as fertile grounds
for franchise development. Furthermore, the franchise business initiative development can be
bettered with an organization responsible for supporting the process of franchise business
establishment by offering guidance to interested local entrepreneurs and external investors.
Finally, the political and economic progress must be based on the platform of common
interests – providing a country wide approach with government, public and private sectors
involved, toward a political stability and economic prosperity. If succeeds, BiH will leave
behind the ideas of extreme nationalism and economic destructions, and steer toward
democratic, economically prosperous, stable, safe and contributing nation of NATO and EU.
10
References
Avdagic, E., (2006), Interview, Business Magazine.
Basic H. (2005), Interview, Business Magazine.
Basic, H., Becirovic, M, Korica, S., (2006), FIPA Handbook.
Beaver, G., (2002), Small Business: Entrepreneurship and Enterprise Development.
Bernasconi J.L. (2005), The Country Economic Memorandum.
Blair, R.D., Lafontaine, F., (2005), The Economics of Franchising.
Dalal-Clayton, B., Bass, S., (2002), Sustainable Development Strategies.
Dayton Peace Accord in Bosnia, (2005) http://www1.umn.edu/humanrts/icty/dayton/daytonaccord.html.
Kozaric, K., (2006), Governor of BiH Central Bank.
Kuczi, T., Lengyel, G., (1995), The spread of Entrepreneurship in Eastern Europe.
Lipsey R.E. (2002), Home and Host Country Effect of FDI.
Memic, F., (2004), Preliminary report on poverty in BiH, 2001 – 2004.
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, (2003), BiH: Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper
http://www.prizma.ba/external/english/documents/prsp_12_01.pdf.
Murray, I., (2003), How to Choose a Franchise, Express Newspapers.
Nabel, Shulze, Wessel (2001), Das Franchise-Systems: Handbuch fur Franchisegeber und Franchisenehmer.
Nicholl, P., (2003), Bosnia and Herzegovina: Progress and Partnership
http://www.bis.org/review/r031223d.pdf.
OBI Holdings, (2008), OBI Company Structure
http://www.obi.cz/cz/company/en/Unternehmen/OBI_Unternehmensstruktur_/index.html.
Parker, G.W., (1995), Structured Problem Solving.
Random House, (1973), Random House Dictionary of English Language.
Reinnerman, D., (2005), World Bank Country Manager.
Sexton, D.L., Landstrom H., (2000), Handbook of Entrepreneurship.
Shaw, B., (1999), The Wisdom of Bernard Shaw.
Shaw, B., Shaw, C., (1999), The Wisdom of Bernard Shaw: Being Passages from the Works of Bernard Shaw.
Shilling, S., Kim, J., (2003), CRS Report for Congress
http://www.usis.it/pdf/other/RS22324.pdf.
Storey, D., (2000), Understanding The Small Business Sector.
Svetlicic M. (2001), Small Countries in a Global Economy: New Challenges and Opportunities.
Svetlicic M. (2003), Facilitating Transition by Internationalization: Outward Direct Investment from Central
European Economies in Transition.
Svetlicic M. (2006), FDI and Regional Development: Impacts.
Svetlicic M. (2006), Regional Development Theory.
11